NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT No.

103 MAY 2013

UDC 621 . 983

Technical Report

Development of New Hydroforming Methods

Masaaki MIZUMURA* Manabu WADA
Koichi SATO Keinosuke IGUCHI
Masayoshi SUEHIRO Yukihisa KURIYAMA

Abstract
Hydroforming has applied for many kinds of auto parts in Japan since 1999. In
order to expand hydroforming market, increasing of hydroforming limit and joining
technology between hydroforming component and other component are important.
Therefore authors developed following five new hydroforming technologies, (1) high
branch forming technology with moving dies, (2) forming technology of two branches
with right angle each other, (3) large expanding technology by means of expanding
method with restricted expanding direction and crossing moving dies and counter
punches each other, (4) hydro-burring and nut-inlaying technology and (5) full length
flange forming technology.

formed in one piece, total manufacturing cost is reduced and fatigue

1. Introduction resistance and dimensional accuracy are improved through elimina-
Hydroforming is a method of forming steel tubes into desired tion of weld joints. Weight reduction, on the other hand, results from
shapes by setting them inside a set of forming dies and applying in- elimination of flanges or excessive sheet thickness required for
ternal pressure and axial feeding. The method was once called bulg- welding, and the use of thinner sheets made possible by increased
ing, and has been used since a long period for dividing work into strength and stiffness resulting from elimination of spot-welded or
pieces of comparatively simple shapes such as bicycle parts1) and similar intermittent joints.
piping joints.2) After the start of the ultra-light steel auto body proj-
ect 3) in 1994, the method began to be applied to manufacture auto-
mobile parts of complicated shapes, and it came to be known as hy-
droforming. It became applicable to manufacture parts of more
complicated shapes than before by, for instance, bending or flatten-
ing material tubes before setting them inside dies as schematically
illustrated in Fig. 1. It is also possible to pierce holes while applying
internal pressure4) (called hydro-piercing). The application of hydro-
forming to manufacture auto parts first spread in U.S.A. and Eu-
rope;5, 6) then, it was introduced to Japan in 1999,7, 8) and its applica-
tion expanded to cover a wide variety of parts.
Of many advantages of the application of hydroforming, unifica-
tion of parts and weight reduction can be cited as the most typical.9)
More specifically, unification of parts is advantageous because when
a part that was fabricated by welding two pieces or more can be Fig. 1 Hydroforming processes

* Chief Researcher, Dr.Eng., Forming Technologies Research Lab., Steel Research Laboratories
20-1 Shintomi, Futtsu, Chiba 293-8511

- 39 -
NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT No. 103 MAY 2013

Because of the above advantages, the application of hydroform-

ing expanded rapidly at the beginning, but currently the auto parts
formed by this method are limited to the cross and side members of
chassis,10) exhaust manifolds,11) etc. To further expand its applica-
tion, it is necessary to enhance the above-mentioned advantages,
namely to pursue further unification of parts and weight reduction,
and to this end, the authors have studied measures to advance form-
ing limits, and this paper reports the technologies the authors devel-
oped.
Decreasing or removing shortcomings of hydroforming is also
effective at widening its application. One of such shortcomings is
difficulty in joining hydro-formed parts to others;9) the authors stud-
ied measures to solve this problem, which are reported in this paper.

2. Advancing Forming Limits of Hydroforming

The principal modes of work by hydroforming are branching
and sectional expansion. It is possible to expand the application of
the method to parts that has been manufactured by other forming
methods and decrease the number of pieces if the forming limit of
each of these modes is reduced. With respect to branching, the Nip-
pon Steel Corporation developed a technique to form a high branch
using movable dies, and a two-way branching technique to enable
forming of two branches at right angles to each other. With respect
to sectional expansion, on the other hand, the company developed
cross-movable dies for expansion in restricted directions. The devel-
oped techniques are explained in the following subsections. It
should be noted that the said developments were performed under Fig. 2 High branch forming using movable dies 13)
joint work with customer companies.
2.1 High branch forming with movable dies
In general, a steel tube deforms little under internal pressure
alone, but it deforms significantly when axial feeding is applied to-
gether with internal pressure;12) in other words, feeding material to
deforming portions is essential for causing large deformation. How-
ever, by conventional practice, axial feeding was applied only from
the ends, and the friction in the straight portions hindered the mate-
rial flow into the branch to form. As a countermeasure, the authors
developed movable dies as a means to facilitate the material flow.
As illustrated in Fig. 2,13) by the developed method, the dies
holding the tube ends move toward the center to facilitate material
flow into the deforming portion (see Step 2). In addition, to make it
easier for the material to flow around the die shoulders, the tube is
bent slightly before the die is moved (see Step 1). Fig. 3 shows an
example of a high branch formed by the developed method;13) the Fig. 3 Example of high branch formed with movable dies 13)
initial material is a JIS STKM11A tube with an outer diameter of
31.8 mm and wall thickness of 1.0 mm. Whereas the maximum
branch height obtainable by conventional practice was approximate- direction at the sides of the branching node.14) Forming two branches
ly equal to the diameter of the initial material (1D) and a branch at right angles to each other, on the other hand, means forming a
height that is 2.2 times the initial tube diameter (2.2D) is achievable second branch protruding from the same position; this was very dif-
by the developed method. ficult by hydroforming.
The material flow into the branch facilitated by the movable dies Nevertheless, the authors developed a hydroforming method that
according to the developed method is shown in Fig. 4 in terms of enabled forming of two branches at right angles to each other as
the state of strain.13) Although by the conventional hydroforming shown in Fig. 5.15) In this case, two branches with a width WL of 140
method shown in part (a), the strain state near the end of the branch mm in the axial direction were formed from a material tube with an
is plane strain or equibiaxial tension, it is close to pure shear in most outer diameter of 114.3 mm, wall thickness of 2.9 mm, and tensile
part of the branch by the developed method. This indicates that the strength of 440 MPa. This was made possible by intentionally stag-
developed method is suitable for intensive deformation work. gering the centerlines of the two branches.
2.2 Orthogonal two-way branching Fig. 6 15) shows FEM analysis results of the states of strain in the
As stated in the previous subsection, pure shear strain is desir- cases where the ratio of the stagger K to the axial width of the
able for large deformation. In forming a T-shape part, the material branches WL is changed. The most critical portion where the materi-
fed in the axial direction from the ends flows in the circumferential al is likely to break under this type of forming work is the position

- 40 -
 NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT No. 103 MAY 2013

Fig. 4 FEM results of strain states after forming branch by hydroforming 13)

bulging work under axial feeding, buckling occurs and pure shear
deformation is prevented from taking place, and the uniaxial tension
in the circumferential direction would be best achievable.16) Restric-
tion by dies is effective at preventing buckling, and it is desirable
that the material to be in contact with the dies from the beginning.
Fig. 5 Forming of two branches in right angles to each other 15) Therefore, it follows that pure shear deformation is likely to result
from restricting a material tube in one direction by dies and allow-
ing it to expand in another at right angles.17)
between the branches marked with “a”. The smaller the ratio K/WL According to this understanding, the authors worked out the fol-
or the smaller the stagger, the more the strain at the portion “a” lowing method. First, sectional expansion in the vertical direction is
changes from pure shear to uniaxial tension in the circumferential applied while restricting horizontal deformation; then, horizontal
direction and the larger the absolute value of the strain becomes. expansion is applied while restricting vertical deformation. This en-
When K/WL = 100% or the branches are completely staggered, on ables large sectional expansion finally in all directions. Fig. 7 18)
the other hand, the strain at the critical portion is substantially the shows an example formed by the developed method; here, the cir-
same as that at other positions. This indicates that it is possible to cumference of a JIS STKM11A steel tube with an outer diameter of
form two branches from one tube by hydroforming and minimize 60.5 mm and wall thickness of 2.5 mm was stretched to approxi-
the strain at the critical portion by adequately selecting the amount mately three times the initial size. The rate of expansion (%), which
of stagger of the branches. In other words, it is difficult to form two is defined by convention as [circumference after forming – initial
branches from the same position of a material tube at right angles to circumference] / [initial circumference] × 100, of this example is
each other, but this becomes viable when the positions of the 200%. In consideration of the fact that the expansion rate of parts
branches are adequately staggered. formed by hydroforming is mostly approximately 10%, and at the
2.3 Cross-movable dies for sectional expansion in limited largest 40%,7) the expansion rate that the developed method achieves
directions is revolutionarily large.
As stated in Subsection 2.1, pure shear deformation is desirable Furthermore, in the above multi-step forming method, the au-
for large deformation, but when a steel tube is subjected to free thors developed cross-movable dies as a new forming technology.

Fig. 6 FEM results of strain states after forming two branches in right angles to each other 15)

- 41 -
NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT No. 103 MAY 2013

Fig. 7 Large-expansion-rate, multi-step hydroforming under restriction

of expanding direction 18)

When sectional expansion of a portion away from the ends is in-

tended, as stated in Subsection 2.1, it is generally difficult to supply
an amount of material sufficient for the deformation by axial feed-
ing because of the friction in the straight portions in between. To
solve this problem, the authors studied the use of movable dies.
However, when the initial distance between two movable dies is
large, axial buckling and fracture are more likely to occur in the
center portion than by the conventional hydroforming as illustrated
in part (b) of Fig. 8.18) Even, counter punches as shown in part (c)
cannot prevent the buckling or fracture because of the gaps between
them and the movable dies. The mechanism of cross-movable dies
was worked out to solve all these problems; as shown in part (d) of
Fig. 8, counter punches are provided so as to slide vertically in slits
cut in the movable dies. This configuration ensures that most sur-
face of the steel tube is restricted from an early stage of the forming
Fig. 8 Comparison of die structures for hydroforming 18)
process by the movable dies and/or counter punches, making it dif-
ficult for buckling or fracture to occur.
Taking advantage of the developed method using the cross-mov-
able dies, the authors developed single piece axle housings, which
had once been manufactured by welding of seven components, from
a single steel tube.19) Fig. 9 18) shows an example of the axle hous-
ings manufactured using a JIS STKM11A tube with an outer diame- Fig. 9 Axle housing formed by hydroforming at large rate of expansion 18)
ter of 60.5 and wall thickness of 2.5 mm. The overall expansion rate
is 180%. In consideration of fatigue endurance, this part was de-
signed in smooth spherical contours to minimize stress concentra-
tion. practiced widely in industries. On the basis of this method, the au-
thors developed hydro-burring, a technique to form a circular flange
3. Development of Joining Methods of Hydro- toward the inside of a formed piece by hole-expansion work. Fig.
formed Parts 10 20) shows the process: (a) after hydroforming according to normal
In the case where chassis parts, which are mostly joined to other practice, (b) a hole is made with a piercing punch while the internal
parts by arc welding, are formed by hydroforming, arc welding can pressure is maintained, (c) and then, by a burring punch, which is
be employed. However, in the case of body parts, which are joined driven forward by the shoulder of the piercing punch, the hole is ex-
mainly by spot welding or with bolts, since pieces formed by hydro- panded such that a circular flange is formed toward the inside. The
forming do not have flanges, it is difficult to join them to other parts. internal pressure is maintained throughout these process steps; the
To solve this problem, the authors developed the following seed higher the pressure, the sharper the hole edge, and the lower the
techniques: hydro-burring, nut inlaying, and full-length flange form- pressure, the larger the drop of the hole edge. However, it should be
ing, which are presented in the following subsections. noted that the risk of cracking at the edge decreases with lower in-
3.1 Hydro-burring and nut inlaying ternal pressure. Further details of the process are given in reference
As mentioned in Section 1, making holes during hydroforming literature.21)
while maintaining the internal pressure, or hydro-piercing, has been The part shown in Fig. 11 20) was made as follows. The center

- 42 -
 NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT No. 103 MAY 2013

portion of a steel tube with an outer diameter of 63.5 mm, wall cannot be obtained because of high strength. For such cases, a tech-
thickness of 2.3 mm, and tensile strength of 460 MPa was hydro- nique to inlay a threaded nut in a hydro-formed part was developed.
formed into a rectangular section at a rate of expansion of 50%, a Fig. 13 22) schematically illustrates the process. The method is basi-
hole was made using a piercing punch with a diameter of 10 mm, cally the same as the hydro-burring process shown in Fig. 10 except
and then hydro-burring was done using a burring punch with a d di- that a threaded nut is used instead of the burring punch and the nut
ameter of 20 mm. The part shown in Fig. 12 20) was obtained by ap- is left inlayed in the formed part. Fig. 14.22) shows an example of
plying M22 tapping to the hole of the part shown in Fig. 11. The nut inlaying in a part similar to that shown in Fig. 11; the material
tapped thread enables joining of the hydro-formed part to another tube is a little thinner here with an outer diameter of 63.5 mm, wall
piece with a bolt. thickness of 2.0 mm, and tensile strength of 440 MPa. This method
However, the above method cannot be easily applied when the makes it possible to join a formed piece of a thinner wall thickness
wall thickness of the material tube is too small for tapping or the to another with a bolt. Nuts of various shapes were tested, and in
hole expandability of the tube is poor and a sufficient burring height consideration of characteristics such as sealing with the base materi-
al, the resistance to falling in or out after inlaying, drawing load at
bolt tightening, and tightening torque, the nut shape shown in Fig.
15 22) was selected as the most suitable.

Fig. 11 Example after hydro-burring test 20)

Fig. 12 Bolting hydroformed component to other part after tapping at

Fig. 10 Process steps of hydro-burring 20) hydro-burring position 20)

Fig. 13 Processes of nut inlaying into hydroformed component 22)

- 43 -
NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT No. 103 MAY 2013

Fig. 14 Exsample of hydroformed component with inlayed nut by hy-

dro-burring 22)

Fig. 16 Hydroforming process with flat seal 24)

Fig. 15 Detailed sizes of the best nut for inlaying into hydroformed
components (dimensions in mm) 22)

3.2 Forming of full-length flanges

Hydro-formed parts do not have flanges for welding; for this
reason, they are unsuitable for conventional spot welding or bolt Fig. 17 Hydroforming loading path for flat seal 24)
fastening at a flange. Forming a flange by pinching the material tube
during the hydroforming process with forming dies seems to be a
viable solution, but when a material tube is pinched partially, wrin- in part (a). Then, the internal pressure P is raised to P1, and simulta-
kles or cracks are likely to develop near the portion. Uchida et al.23) neously, the pressing force F of the axial cylinder punches is in-
succeeded in forming a flange in a portion of a formed piece using creased to F1 to ensure the sealing. This condition being maintained,
dies to pinch and flatten a part of the piece, but the proposed method the upper die is lowered to form flanges at the same level of the up-
required a complicated die structure. To this end, the authors studied per surface of the formed piece as seen in (b). Hereafter, the internal
a modification of hydroforming to form flanges along the whole pressure P is increased further to P2, and simultaneously, the press-
length of a formed piece. Forming a flange or flanges along the ing force is increased from F to F2. Finally, as seen in part (c), the
whole length will eliminate the possibility of cracking or wrinkling internal pressure is increased yet further to obtain the intended
in the nearby regions, but since this means flange forming also at shape. The loading path in the above process steps is given in Fig.
both ends of the material tube, it is necessary to devise a sealing 17.24)
method that allows the deformation of the tube ends while the inter- Part (a) of Fig. 18 24) shows an example piece with full-length
nal pressure is maintained. A flat end sealing method was developed flanges; it was formed according to the above process steps using a
as a solution. steel tube with an outer diameter of 60.5 mm, wall thickness of 2.5
Fig. 16 24) schematically illustrates the procedures of the devel- mm, and tensile strength of 430 MPa. Part (b) shows an example
oped flat seal method. First, a material tube is set in the lower die. formed without applying the internal pressure. Although the upper
Here, the tube length must be longer than the die length, and the face of the formed part tends to droop without the internal pressure,
tube length extending from each end of the die is called sealing it is flat when proper internal pressure is maintained by the flat end
length LS. Axial cylinder punches having flat front faces are driven sealing during the forming process.
forward to seal the two tube ends and fill the tube with water as seen Besides the example of the photograph, parts with full-length

- 44 -
 NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT No. 103 MAY 2013

ing limits and facilitating joining of formed pieces to others, the au-
thors developed the following forming methods.
1) The height of branching was extended to 2.2 times the diame-
ter of material tube because of developed movable dies to fa-
cilitate the influx of material to the branch.
2) Forming of two branches extending at right angles to each oth-
er was possible by staggering their positions in the axial direc-
tion.
3) The rate of expansion was increased by restricting the direction
of expansion in a forming step, repeating such steps, and
changing the direction of expansion. Forming of axle housings,
the circumference of the center portion of which is expanded
approximately three times that of the material tube, was possi-
ble by the use of a set of dies consisting of movable dies and
counter punches moving in directions perpendicular to each
other.
4) A method of hydro-burring was developed, wherein a hole
Fig. 18 Hydroforming samples with full length flange 24)
made by hydro-piercing was expanded while the internal pres-
sure was maintained. It became possible to join formed parts to
others with bolts by tapping screw threads to the hole or inlay-
ing a nut there.
5) Flat seal method was developed, wherein sealing is maintained
at the tube ends against the internal pressure while allowing the
deformation of the ends, and applying the developed method,
it became possible to form parts having flanges along the
whole length.
The developed forming methods will certainly promote wider
application of hydroforming in the automotive and other industries.

Acknowledgements
The method of forming a high branch using movable dies de-
scribed in Subsection 2.1 was developed jointly with Toyota Motor
Corporation, and that of forming the cross-movable dies with re-
stricted expansion direction presented in Subsection 2.3 was devel-
oped jointly with Suzuki Motor Corporation. The authors would like
to express their deepest thanks for the cooperation of the two com-
panies in the development activities.

Fig. 19 Effect of seal length on flat seal performance 24) References

1) Takagi, M.: Journal of the Japan Society for Technology of Plasticity
(JSTP). 12 (120), 59 (1971)
2) Fuchizawa, S.: J. of JSTP. 30 (339), 473 (1989)
flanges were successfully formed by the developed method from 3) Kuriyama, Y.: J. of JSTP. 39 (453), 1009 (1998)
material tubes with a wall thickness of 1.6 - 3.2 mm and tensile 4) Leitloff, F.U. et al.: J. of JSTP. 39 (453), 1045 (1998)
strength of 300 - 470 MPa; the flat end sealing worked satisfactorily 5) Bruggemann, C. J.: Hydroforming 1999. 1999, p. 353
in all these cases. In this relation, the authors examined factors that 6) Vanker, R. W. et al.: IBEC’96. 1996, p. 118
7) Nasu, K.: Proceedings of 27th Conference, Japan Metal Stamping Asso-
exerted influences over the sealing performance of the flat end seal ciation. 2000, p. 1
such as the seal length LS, seal end properties, and loading path (in- 8) Majima, S. et al.: Proc. 2000 Jpn. Spring Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2000,
ternal pressure P1 and P2, pressing force F1 and F2). Of these, the in- p. 427
fluence of the seal length LS are explained briefly. Fig. 19 24) shows 9) Mizumura, M. et al.: Tool Engineer. 46 (10), 46 (2002)
the performance of flat seals when the seal length LS was changed. 10) Nasu, K.: J. JSTP. 46 (531), 321 (2005)
11) Katoh, K.: CAMP-ISIJ. 16, 1176 (2003)
When the seal length LS is too large, the tube end is likely to buckle 12) Mizumura, M. et al.: J. of JSTP. 44 (508), 524 (2003)
during axial feeding, leading to leakage from the seal; the critical 13) Satoh, K. et al.: Proc. 2006 Jpn. Spring Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2006, p. 1
seal length is approximately three times the wall thickness t, regard- 14) Yoshida, T. et al.: Proc. 49th Jpn. Joint Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 1998,
less of the steel strength. Note that, when the seal length is too short, p. 321
15) Wada, M. et al.: Proc. 2011 Jpn. Spring Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2011,
leakage occurs easily because the material is drawn inside during p. 59
forming. As a conclusion, an adequate seal length LS is slightly less 16) Mori, S. et al.: J. of JSTP. 29 (325), 131 (1988)
than three times the wall thickness t. 17) Mizumura, M. et al.: Proc. 59th Jpn. Joint Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2008,
p. 219
18) Wada, M. et al.: Proc. 62nd Jpn. Joint Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2011, p. 173
4. Summary 19) Kaneda, H. et al.: Proc. 62nd Jpn. Joint Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2011,
To expand the applicability of hydroforming by advancing form- p. 171

- 45 -
NIPPON STEEL TECHNICAL REPORT No. 103 MAY 2013
20) Mizumura, M. et al.: Proc. 56th Jpn. Joint Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2005,
p. 189
21) Mizumura, M. et al.: Proc. 58th Jpn. Joint Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2007,
p. 403
22) Mizumura, M. et al.: Proc. 2008 Jpn. Spring Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2008,
p. 231
23) Uchida, M. et al.: Proc. 2010 Jpn. Spring Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2010,
p. 181
24) Mizumura, M. et al.: Proc. 2009 Jpn. Spring Conf. Tech. Plasticity. 2009,
p. 421

Masaaki MIZUMURA Keinosuke IGUCHI

Chief Researcher, Dr.Eng. Senior Researcher
Forming Technologies Research Lab. Nagoya R&D Lab.
Steel Research Laboratories
20-1 Shintomi, Futtsu, Chiba 293-8511

Manabu WADA Masayoshi SUEHIRO

Researcher, Dr.Eng. General Manager, Dr.Eng.
Forming Technologies Research Lab. Forming Technologies Research Lab.
Steel Research Laboratories Steel Research Laboratories

Koichi SATO Yukihisa KURIYAMA

Senior Researcher, Dr. Professor, Dr.Eng.
Nagoya R&D Lab. Center for Risk Management and Safety Sciences
Yokohama National University

- 46 -