Analisis Termico Motor 1fase
Analisis Termico Motor 1fase
Analisis Termico Motor 1fase
Abstract—A procedure for thermal analysis of a run-capacitor if the procedure can be applied to a motor of any number of
single-phase induction motor characterized by two different wind- different windings, the common case of two (main and auxil-
ings is presented. The procedure allows for the computation of the iary) windings is considered. The proposed analysis procedure
average winding temperature rise, and the temperature rises of
the two different windings separately. The proposed thermal anal- is based on a lumped parameter network that is solved two times,
ysis is based on a lumped-parameter network commonly used for each of them using equivalent copper losses as heat sources.
the three-phase induction motor. The paper illustrates how this The procedure presents three main advantages. Firstly, it al-
network is adaptable for analysing the run-capacitor single-phase lows the two different winding temperature rises to be computed
motor temperatures. In order to test the procedure, the predicted separately, in transient and steady-state analysis, too.
results are compared with those obtained from finite-element anal-
ysis and experimental data. Both comparisons show an appreciable As a second advantage, the lumped parameter network is the
agreement, confirming the validity of the analysis. same of a symmetrical three-phase motor, simply solved more
times. Therefore, it is not a difficult task to adapt the thermal
Index Terms—Computer-aided design (CAD), electric machine
CAD, finite-element (FE) analysis, induction motors, temperature analysis procedures commonly used for the three-phase motor
measurement, thermal analysis. to the single-phase one.
Finally, this analysis technique is very rapid, because it allows
the different temperature rises to be computed without using FE
I. INTRODUCTION method or more complicated networks, such as those consid-
ering circumferential heat flows.
I N AN EFFECTIVE design of an induction motor, a critical
analysis concerns the computation of the temperature rises in
the different parts of the machine. This computation is generally
To verify the thermal network results, two two–dimensional
(2-D) FE models have been developed and used for the thermal
done by means of lumped-parameter networks or finite-element analysis of a single-phase motor [9]. In the first model, the total
(FE) methods [1], [2]. winding losses have been equally distributed among the slots in
In the past, three-phase induction motors were deeply order to compute the average motor temperatures. In the second
analyzed by different authors [3]–[5]. Conversely, the thermal one, the different winding distributions have been considered
behavior of single-phase induction motors was not completely such as to show the different winding temperatures. In both
investigated [6]. The single-phase motor is often considered cases, the lumped-parameter analysis and the FE method pre-
as a particular case of the three-phase motor, and the average sented similar results.
winding temperature rises are only predicted. However, unlike At last, a commercial single-phase induction motor was
the three-phase motor, the single-phase motor does not exhibit tested. The transient and the steady-state temperatures were
winding symmetry and, consequently, different temperatures measured and compared with those obtained from the thermal
in the different parts of the machine. Thus, the prediction of an analysis. The experimental and the predicted results are very
average winding temperature rise only is not enough. close, confirming the validity of the proposed thermal analysis
For an accurate analysis, two strategies could be applied procedure.
merely: the analysis by means of the FE method or by means
of an involved thermal network, including circumferential heat II. LUMPED-PARAMETERS THERMAL NETWORK: A BRIEF
flow components. However, both strategies require complex DESCRIPTION
models and considerable preprocessing and solving time [7], In the past, several thermal networks using lumped param-
[8]. eters were developed to analyze the temperature rises of the
This paper describes a new thermal analysis procedure for the induction motor. Exploiting the analogy between electric and
single-phase induction motor with different windings [9]. Even thermal phenomena, the networks include resistances, capaci-
ties for the transient analysis, and current sources that represent
Paper IPCSD 02–070, presented at the 2002 Industry Applications Society the internal losses of the motor.
Annual Meeting, Pittsburgh, PA, October 13–18, and approved for publication
in the IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS by the Electric Ma- A. Model of the Thermal Components
chines Committee of the IEEE Industry Applications Society. Manuscript sub-
mitted for review July 26, 2002 and released for publication December 11, 2002. An induction motor is generally subdivided into different
This work was supported by RIELLO BURNERS S.p.a. components [10], [11]. For the sake of generality, the cylinder
The authors are with the Department of Electrical Engineering, University shown in Fig. 1(a) represents each component of the motor [2].
of Padova, 35131 Padova, Italy (e-mail: bianchi@die.unipd.it; bolog-
nani@die.unipd.it; tonel@die.unipd.it). Then, to obtain practical equations for thermal parameters, the
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TIA.2003.808923 following assumptions are made.
0093-9994/03$17.00 © 2003 IEEE
458 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRY APPLICATIONS, VOL. 39, NO. 2, MARCH/APRIL 2003
TABLE I
COMPONENTS OF THE MOTOR
(a)
(b)
Fig. 1. (a) Cylinder representing each motor component and (b) corresponding
thermal network.
TABLE II
WINDINGS DISTRIBUTION
Fig. 5. Actual motor with main and auxiliary winding: average total losses
Fig. 4. Single-phase motor, one pole.
equally distributed in the slots.
“ ” at the instant and , respectively, where conduction factor results in for the main winding and
is the time step selected in the transient analysis. Referring for the auxiliary winding. The weighted average value is
to the simple network sketched in Fig. 3 the behavior of each almost 4.2.
temperature rise can be expressed by the equation (1), where P The frame of the motor is composed only by two caps
is the heat source due to the losses, is the thermal resistance with length mm, and thickness mm,
between node “ ” and “ ” and is the “capacity-equivalent” the external part of the stator core is directly in contact
resistance given by with the external air. In the lumped parameter network
convection coefficient of the end-cap air is assumed to be
(1) W/m K, and coefficient of the air gap is assumed
to be W/m K.
TABLE III
TYPICAL VALUES OF MATERIAL CONDUCTIVITY
The results obtained with the test motor using the lumped-
parameter network are reported in the following sections,
comparing them against those obtained from the FE model and
against experimental results.
TABLE IV
MOTOR LOSSES
(a)
TABLE V
TEMPERATURE RISES ( C) OVER TEMPERATURE FRAME: FE ANALYSIS
AND MODIFIED NETWORK
(b)
TABLE VI
TEMPERATURE RISE ( C) WITH FE ANALYSIS AND MODIFIED NETWORK
TABLE IX
MOTOR CURRENTS UNDER MEASURE AND Eta Tau PREDICTION
TABLE X
COMPARISON BETWEEN MEASURE AND Eta Tau PREDICTION
APPENDIX A
In this Appendix, the equations of the capacity and of the
thermal resistances of Fig. 1 are reported
(a)
(b)
Fig. 13. Interactive windows for thermal analysis.
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The authors also thank Dr. R. Gobbo for his help during the
thermal test.
REFERENCES
[1] G. Cannistrà, G. Cannistrà, and M. Silos Labini, “Thermal analysis in an
induction machine using thermal network and finite element methods,”
in Proc. IEE EMD Conf., 1991, pp. 300–304.
[2] P. H. Mellor, D. Roberts, and D. R. Turner, “Lumped parameter thermal
model for electrical machines of TEFC design,” Proc. Inst. Elect. Eng.,
VII. CONCLUSIONS pt. B, vol. 138, no. 5, pp. 205–218, Sept. 1991.
[3] A. Shenkman and M. Chertkov, “Heat conditions of a three-phase induc-
A new procedure using a lumped-parameter network was tion motor by a one-phase supply,” Proc. IEE—Elect. Power Applicat.,
described. It allows us to quickly analyze the temperature rises vol. 146, no. 4, pp. 361–367, July 1999.
[4] M. S. Rajagopal, K. N. Seetharamu, and P. A. Ashwathnarayana, “Tran-
of a single-phase induction motor with different auxiliary and sient thermal analysis of induction motors,” IEEE Trans. Energy Con-
main windings. The simple thermal network of a three-phase version, vol. 13, pp. 62–69, Mar. 1998.
motor is used. Equivalent losses for the auxiliary and main [5] M. R. Feyzi and A. M. Parker, “Heating in deep-bar rotor cages,” Proc.
IEE—Elect. Power Applicat., vol. 144, no. 4, pp. 271–276, July 1997.
windings are used, then the thermal temperature rises of the [6] J. H. Johnson, J. D. Lloid, A. M. Nystuen, and S. D. Umans, “Design and
motor and in particular of the two different windings, are analysis of single phase induction motors,” presented at the IEEE-IAS
calculated solving the thermal network two times. The results Annu. Meeting, St. Louis, MO, Oct. 1998.
[7] A. Di Gerlando and I. Vistoli, “Improved thermal modeling of induc-
of the thermal network are compared with the FE results tion motors for design purposes,” in Proc. IEE EMD Conf., 1993, pp.
and experimental measurements. The agreement between the 381–386.
BIANCHI et al.: THERMAL ANALYSIS OF A RUN-CAPACITOR SINGLE-PHASE INDUCTION MOTOR 465
[8] A. Bousbaine, M. McCormick, and W. F. Low, “Thermal modeling of Silverio Bolognani (M’97) received the Laurea de-
permanent-split-capacitor single-phase induction motors based on ac- gree in electrical engineering from the University of
curate loss density measurement,” in Proc. IEE EMD Conf., 1997, pp. Padova, Padova, Italy, in 1976.
175–179. In 1976, he joined the Department of Electrical
[9] F. Tonel, “Thermal analysis of asynchronous single and three-phase mo- Engineering, University of Padova, where he is
tors by lumped parameter network and finite elements methods,” Laurea presently a Full Professor of electrical drives and is
thesis, Univ. Padova, Padova, Italy, 1999. engaged in research on advanced control techniques
[10] W. Schuisky, Berechnung Elektrischer Maschinen. Vienna, Austria: for motor drives and on design of ac electrical motors
Springer-Verlag, 1960. for variable-speed applications. He has authored
[11] E. Levi, Polyphase Motors. New York: Wiley, 1984. more than 130 papers on electrical machines and
[12] C. Mademlis, J. Xipteras, and N. Margaris, “Magnetic and thermal per- drives.
formance of a synchronous motor under loss minimization control,”
IEEE Trans. Energy Conversion, vol. 15, pp. 135–142, June 2000.
[13] N. Bianchi, S. Bolognani, O. Bottauscio, A. Canova, M. Chiampi, M.
Repetto, and F. Tonel, “A novel design platform for the automated design
of electrical machines,” in Proc. PCIM Conf., vol. IM, June 2000, pp.
361–366.