Study On Implementation of Lean Tools
Study On Implementation of Lean Tools
Study On Implementation of Lean Tools
Chapter 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1INTRODUCTION
The project work is being carried out in VST Tillers Tractors Ltd. (VTTL), Mysuru.
This project is focused on implementing lean practices viz Value Stream mapping,
kaizen, 5S, layout optimization, etc. In VTTL (Mysuru) precision components are
manufactured. VWH crankshaft is one of them, which was not able to meet the customer
demand. Using the above lean tools the team focused to reduce manufacturing lead time
and to achieve the customers demand.
During the overall study of VTTL our team recognized that company is failing to
meet the customer demand. As on company’s advice we studied VWH crankshaft process
which was nearly taking 22 days of manufacturing lead time to complete the order of
2500-3000 components per month.
The following wastages were identified in the current system of crankshaft production
process:
1.3 OBJECTIVE
The main objective of the project is to reduce the manufacturing lead time using
Value Stream Mapping (VSM) tool.
In order to remain competitive, waste from the value stream must be identified
and eliminated so to run system with maximum efficiency.
1.4 METHODOLOGY
VSM is a tool to visualize and streamline work processes using the techniques of
LeanManufacturing.VSM help to identify, demonstrate and decrease waste in the
processes. Waste being any activity that does not add value to the final product.VSM can
serve as a blue print for Lean Manufacturing.
Generally VSM has four major steps as given by Rother and Shook (1996):
The first step is selection of critical part family. After study of all part families,
one part family was selected over all the product families.
Collect relevant and necessary data to draw current state map. Data is collected by
preparing the checklist, observing the activities that are performed in the shop floor using
stopwatch and measuring tape. To create a current state map following steps are followed.
threading 90sec 1
Takt time is defined as the ratio of net available time to customer demand. The net
available time is the total operation time during a specific period, meaning the total
amount of time, which adds value on value stream. Customer Demand can be determined
on customer forecast or based on the currently customer order.
This step involves various processes to complete the product. In addition, measure
the relevant data to add on to value stream mapping box.
Step-4: Map the material flow
The flow of material from raw material to finished goods is given by supplier to
customer. In addition to analyze Work-in-process(WIP) between two process.
By analyzing the current state map, the lead time and amount of inventory are
more between processes. Supermarket is used between two processes to reduce inventory
wastage during process and convert the process from build to stock (push) to make to
order (pull).
Chapter 2
COMPANY PROFILE
V.S.T.Tillers Tractors Ltd was promoted by VST Motors, as a joint venture (and
Technical collaboration) with Mitsubishi Heavy Industries Ltd, Japan. The company is
now the largest manufacturer of Power Tillers in India. From the time of inception in
1967 by the founder Managing Director, Sri V.T.Velu, the company has had a steady
growth. Today the VST family holds 51% of the equity in the listed company that has
recorded consistent growth and has given excellent returns to the shareholders. With the
growth in business, the manufacturing facilities for Power tillers has been retained on the
Whitefield Road in Bangalore, while that of Tractors has been shifted to Hosur in Tamil
Nadu.
Department of Industrial Production & Engineering SJCE MYSURU Page 5
Study on implementation of lean tools
This is keeping in mind the growing demand for compact tractor for small farmers
in the country. The manufacturing of key components for the Engine for both Power
Tiller and Tractor takes place in the Precision Components Division located in Mysore.
The company has a network of about 200 dealers and 300 vendors all over India
most of whom have been associated with the company over several decades.
While the company continues to be the leader in the Power tiller industry with
about 45% market share, its pioneering efforts for introduction of compact tractors have
been recognized all over India under the brand name of VST Mitsubishi Shakti. The
company has since introduced mechanized Rice transplanter and reapers.
The company also exports its products to Africa, Russia, Myanmar and other
countries while component parts are exported to UK and Europe.
The close knit and committed human resources have been the strong edifice of the
company. The continuing need for growth in Agriculture and the scarcity of rural labour
will be the key drivers for the future growth. With four decades of experience in the field
as well as its competitive edge, the company has limitless opportunities to expand the
business and as such is poised to take a big leap forward.
VTTL has ISO-9001 certification for quality management system since January
1998.
VTTL follows ISO 9001-2008 quality system requirements to satisfy all customer
needs.
Certified to ISO/TS16949 certificate, best supplier award.
Manufacturer of power tillers, Tractors, Rice Planter, Power Reaper, Engines,
Precision/ Auto components, Agriculture Implements.
2.3 VISION
V.S.T. Tillers Tractors Ltd. believes that the foundation of its business is to
provide excellence in its products through:-
In order to achieve these goals and attain market leadership, it shall be the objective of
every employee to strive to be "'The Best in the Field".
Power tillers.
Power tractors
Rice planter
Power reaper
Precision auto components and light engineering components
2.5.2 TRACTORS
VST tillers tractors ltd. Is the pioneer and largest manufacture of compact four
wheel drive tractor in India. The state of art technology of Mitsubishi, very low weight
and inbuilt rotary fined exclusive application in wet puddling, inter cultivation, spraying
for all crops and horticulture requiring less than 5 feet of row width planting. The
attachments used are cage wheels, chaff cutter, seed cum fertilizer drills, spring loaded
cultivator, reversible plough, fertilizer and laying machine.
VST tillers tractors ltd. Power reapers are mechanized units powered by a light
weight diesel engine which assists in harvesting rice, wheat, barley, etc with rotating
blades. Depending on the number of blades on the reaper, the unit can cut up to 8-12
sections on a single walk.
VST tillers tractors ltd. Is the pioneer in the introduction and leader in mechanized
rice planter. VST deals with both 8 row ridding and 6 row walk behind rice trans planter.
This is a high labour saving machine, eliminates drudgery, increase productivity and
gives very high return on investment.
The precision auto components which are being manufactured at VST Tillers Tractors
ltd, Mysuru are Diesel engine components and light engineering components. The
functions of these precision components is as described below.
In a reciprocating piston engine, the connecting rod connects the piston to the
crank or crankshaft. Together with the crank, they for a simple mechanism that
converts reciprocating motion into rotating motion.
A camshaft is a shaft to which a cam is fastened or of which a cam forms an
integral part.
A crankshaft is a mechanical part able to perform a conversion between
reciprocating motion and rotational motion.
The crankcase is the housing for the crankshaft.
Transmission case is a jacket usually of cast iron for the transmission of an
automobile.
Caliper brake uses “short pull” brake levers, for drop handlebars or upright
handlebars.
Brakes yoke is used to slow or stop a moving vehicle.
Brake shoe is a piece of metal that supports the brake pad.
Suspension is a system of tires, tire air, springs, shock absorbers and linkages that
connects a vehicle to its wheels and allows relative motion between the two.
A hydraulic actuator consists of cylinder or fluid motor that uses hydraulic power
to facilitate mechanical operation. The mechanical motion gives an output in
terms of linear, rotary or oscillatory motion.
All these are manufactured using quality S G iron castings, alloy steel forgings
and various other inputs under the expertise of professional engineers. Moreover,
advanced technology and high performance machines are used in the production process.
The perfect combination of premium inputs and modern machines assist in providing a
quality output to the market. Our Engine are highly appreciated by the clients for
their dimensional accuracy, high tensile strength, minimal, maintenance and durability.
Chapter 3
LITERATURE REVIEW
Crankshaft was manufactured in a single piece flow system with the low cost
machines developed indigenously and the results are that the crankshafts have passed the
testing, validation and approval by the customer to produce any variant in the company.
After implementing lean manufacturing system, the manufacturing lead time reduced,
defects were reduced, higher process capability achieved, quick response to customer
demand small lots were achieved.
Nowadays in a competitive market, companies require small lead times, low costs
and high customer service levels. As such, companies pay more effort to reduce lead
time. Value Stream Mapping (VSM) techniques are used in almost all companies. Value
Stream Mapping (VSM) is the one of the lean manufacturing tool. Value Stream mapping
aim is identified waste in terms of non-value added activities. Current State Map is
prepared to give details about the existing position and identify various problem areas.
Future State Map is made to show the implementation action plan.
1. Process level VSM – In process VSM, material and information flow with in a
particular cell or production line.
2. Factory level or door-to-door VSM –In factory level VSM, material and information
flow within a four walls of a factory
3. Extended level VSM – Focusing material and information flow of several companies
Value Stream Mapping is used to identify the current process of small scale
industry. The current state map is used to identify the wastes and non-value added
activities in the production process. A future state map is created with the waste activities
eliminated and improve process cycle time and reduce work in process inventory. The
current and future state map was developed with the objective if improving productivity
according to customer requirements. Draw and analyze the current state map found that
the large inventory between two processes, and big difference between total lead times
and value added time. Then draw a future state map with providing a supermarket pull
system and one work cell and reduced a lead time.
VSM is a special type of flow chart that uses symbols known as “the language of
Lean” to depict an improve the flow of inventory and information. Value stream mapping
is a lean manufacturing or lean enterprise technique used to document, analyze and
improve the flow of information or materials required to produce a product or service for
a customer.
A value stream is all the actions (both value and non-value added) currently required to
bring a product through the main flows essential to every product:
(1)The production flow from raw material into the arms of the customer.
Taking a value stream perspective means working on the big picture, not just
individual processes, and improving the whole, not just optimizing the parts.
A value stream map takes into account not only the activity of the product, but the
management and information systems that support the basic process. This is especially
helpful when working to reduce cycle time, because you gain insight into the decision
making flow in addition to the process flow. It is actually a Lean tool. The basic idea is to
first map your process, then above it map the information flow that enables the process to
occur.
+ + Lean Basic =
Provide optimum value to the customer through a complete value creation process
with a minimum waste in:
The basic purpose of value stream mapping exercise is to identify all possible
opportunities for ensuring that the time taken to produce items and have them ready and
transported out in as short a time as possible. This ensures the there is no stop sitting
around waiting to be dealt with. It also ensures that there are no finished items also
awaiting transportation. Once the components or items are received there are used within
production, then once the production cycle has finished, the goods shipped out.
Diagnostic tool
-Reveals hidden symptoms of larger problems
Strategic Planning activity
-Helps to prioritize opportunities for improvement
-Results in an implementation plan
Macro-level-Visual Representation
-Information flow
-People and material flow
-Each process block represents a hand off or a break in the time line
Contains relevant Metrics
-Lead time-Through put/Turn around/Flow time
-Cycle time-touch/process time.
Current State:
Visualize the “Ideal state” and design the future state map.
Identify value added and waste from current state
Reconfigure the process to eliminate waste or add value
Implementation Plan:
It helps you to visualize more than just the single-process level that is assembly,
welding, etc. in production.
It helps you to see more than waste. Mapping helps you to see the sources of
waste in your values stream.
It provides a common language for talking about manufacturing process.
It makes decisions about the flow apparent. Otherwise, many details and decisions
on the shop floor just happen by default.
It ties together lean concepts and techniques, which us to avoid “Cherry picking”.
It forms the basis of an implementation plan. This helps us to design how the
whole door- to- door flow.
Value stream maps become a blue print for lean implementation.
It allows the linkage between the information flow and the material flow.
It is much more useful than quantitative tools and layout diagrams that produce a
tally of non-value-added steps, lead time, distance travelled the amount of
inventory and so on.
It is tool that allows seeing waste, and planning to eliminate it.
Provides important descriptive information for the Operation and Storage icons in
the standard Flow Process Charts used by IE’s.
Forms the basis for implementation of Lean Manufacturing by designing a
manufacturing system based on the complete dock-to-dock flow time for a
product family.
Provides a company with a “blueprint” for strategic planning to deploy the
principles of Lean Thinking to facilitate their transformation into a Lean
Enterprise.
Fails to map multiple products that do not have identical manufacturing routings
or assembly process flows.
Fails to relate Transportation and Queuing delays, and changes in transfer batch
sizes due to poor plant layout and/or material handling, to operating parameters
(ex. machine cycle times) and measures of performance (ex. takt time)1 of the
manufacturing system.
Lacks an economic measure for “value”, such as profit, throughput, operating
costs, inventory expenses, etc. unlike the Flow Process Charting technique used
by IE’s.
Lacks the spatial structure of the facility layout, and how that impacts inter-
operation material handling delays, the sequence in which batches enter the queue
formed at each processing step in the manufacturing routing/s, container sizes, trip
frequencies between operations, etc.
Tends to bias a factory designer to consider only those strategies2, such as
continuous flow, assembly line layouts, kanban-based Pull scheduling, etc., that
are suitable mainly for high-volume low-variety (HVLV) manufacturing facilities.
Fails to consider the allocations and utilization of an important resource – factory
floor space – for WIP storage, production support, material handling aisles, etc.
Process Symbols
Select shape and Data Table This data box is placed under other icons
type text. Yellow
that have information required for
handle adjusts line
spacing. analysing the system. It typically includes
Cycle Time (Process Time, Lead Time),
Changeover Time, and other processing
information.
Information Symbols
Database A database.
Material Symbols
the icon.
Inventory examples:
Un-Transmitted faxes
3.3 5S
3.3.1 ABOUT 5S
improvement at the operation level.5S is a process designed to organize the work place,
keep it clean, and maintain effective and standard conditions. It instils the discipline
required to enable each individual to achieve and maintain a world- class environment.
The use of this tool was started in 1972 by Henry Ford, in the United States as the
CANDO program: Cleaning up, Arranging, Neatness, Discipline and Ongoing
improvement. The technique was popularized as ‘Japanese 5S’ in 1980 by Hiroyuki
Hirano.
Many enterprises have practiced the 5S and derived significant benefits from it. In
particular, this technique has been widely practiced in Japan. Most Japanese 5S
practitioners consider 5S useful not just for improving their physical environment, but
also for improving their thinking processes too. In Japan it is also called ‘Work place
Management’.
5S will be needed if the work place is messy and unorganized. It will also be
needed if employees spend extra time in searching tools, papers, information, etc
5S was developed in Japan and was identified as one of the technique that enabled
just in time manufacturing. 5S is the name of work place organization method that uses a
list of five Japanese words seiri, seiton, seiso, seiketsu, and shitsuke. Transliterated or
translated into English, they all start with a letter “S”. The list describes how to organise a
work space for efficiency and effectiveness by identifying and storing the items used,
maintaining the area and items, and sustaining the new order. The decision-making
process usually comes from a dialogue about standardization, which builds understanding
among the employees of how they should do the work.
Sorting(seiri):
Eliminate all unnecessary tools, paths. Go through all tools, materials and
so forth in the plant and work area. Keep only essential items and eliminate what
is not required, prioritizing things per requirement and keeping them in easily-
assessable places. Everything else is stored or discarded.
Straitening or Setting in order to floor or stream lining(seiton):
Arrange the work, workers, equipment, parts, and instructions in such a
way that the work flows free of waste through the value added tasks with a
division of labour necessary to meet demand. This is by far the most
Department of Industrial Production & Engineering SJCE MYSURU Page 27
Study on implementation of lean tools
misunderstood and incorrectly applied S and has been responsible for much lean
transformation failing to produce the benefits expected. When applied correctly
with flow established this step eliminates the majority of the non-value added time
and allows the rest of the zero philosophy to be enabled. Put simply, until you
have an orderly flow, you cannot have an orderly floe of problems to solve and
notion of zero defects is impossible.
Shining(seiso):
Clean the work space and all equipment, and keep it clean, tidy and
organized. At the end of each shift clean the work area and be sure everything is
restored to its place. This step ensures that the work station is ready for the next
user and that order is sustained.
Standardize(seiketsu):
Ensure uniform procedure and set ups thought the operation to promote
interchangeability.
Sustain(shitsuke):
Make it a way of life. This means commitment, ensure disciplined
adherence to rules and procedures of 5S to prevent back sliding and maintaining
the standards.
These are some of the benefits that improve the quality culture at the work place.
The work place becomes cleaner, safer, well-organized and more pleasant.
3.4 KAIZEN
Kaizen also applies to processes, such as purchasing and logistics that cross
organizational boundaries into the supply chain. It has been applied in health care,
psychotherapy, life-coaching, government, banking and other industries. By improving
standardized activities and processes, kaizen aims to eliminate waste. It has spread
thought out the world and is now being implemented in environments outside of business
and productivity.
It’s important to note that kaizen is a way of thinking, not a project to complete.
To implement it, all employees should receive training on the concept of kaizen and
should have some guidelines in terms of what the need to do before implementing a
chance. For example, it may be fine for an office worker to change his/her handling of
paper work without any discussion. A change in the production process, though, may
impact multiple teams and should be discussed with all impacted parties before
implementation.
It is also important that management is trained and be behind the effort. Kaizen
will result in many more suggestions for improvements and changes and will take away
from a rigid focus on moving items quickly through the existing production process.
Management must be ready to accept some time away from current work to focus on
changes with longer-range impact.
MUDA:
MUDA is about “every factor which does not contribute to the manufacturing
process but only raises cost”. Or kinds of thing which do not add any value to products
are called MUDA. This includes waiting, rearranging or transshipping materials although
there is no need for doing them. TPS is the system to thoroughly eliminate MUDA.
MURA:
MURA means unevenness, irregularity and inconsistent it refers to uneven
resources utilization or variation in loading from time to time or from resources to
resources.
MURI:
MURI means unreasonable and over burdening. It refers to the reduced output
because of over loading and over burdening, but sometimes it can also be caused by some
abnormality, hence creating congestion or bottle necks.
It is important to set standard for every work, to do so the work must be in stable
condition which affects the work sequence and time required. To achieve JIT, the total
efficiency will be increased only when all the process is consideration of single process.
Standardized work is not a fixed and it is improved to the change in conditions of the
company.
Chapter 4
DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS OF VWH
CRANKSHAFT
Marketing department creates customers and generates income, guides the future
course of a business and defines whether it will be a success or a failure. For a sustained
marketing effort, the organization requires a dedicated marketing department team. These
are the main section of the market departments
Sales department is responsible for the sales and distribution of products to the
different regions.
Research and Department is responsible for market research and testing new
products to make sure that they are suitable to be sold.
Promotion department decides on the type of promotion method for the
products, arranges advertisements and the advertising media used.
Distribution department transports the products to the market.
The quality control department has many responsibilities, with quality of the end
product being the main objective. This task, however, is not a simple one, because it
entails a number of checks before it can offer the product for sale, the responsibilities for
QC are as follows:
Review all production records for accuracy and completeness before approving
for distribution.
Establish procedures for revising procedures, formulas, etc.
Approve changes to procedures, formulas, etc.
Ensure that the latest revision is being used at all times.
Procuring materials
Evaluating price
Paperwork and Accounting
Policy Compliance
The human resources department provides the organization the ability to meet
business needs through managing your company’s most valuable resources its employees.
There are several HR disciplines, or areas, but HR practitioners in each discipline may
perform more than one of the more than six essential function.
Recruitment
Safety
Employee Relations
Compensation and benefits
Compliance
Training and development
Production and planning: They will set the standards and targets at each
stage of the production process. The quantity and quality of products coming
off a production line will be closely monitored.
Purchasing department: This department will provide the materials,
components and equipment required. An essential part of this responsibility is
to ensure that stocks arrive on time and are of good quality.
The stores department: The stores department are responsible for stocking
all the necessary tools, raw materials and equipment required to service the
manufacturing process.
The design and technical support department: They are responsible for the
design and testing of new product processes and product types, together with
the development of prototypes through to the final product.
The works department: This department is concerned with the manufacture
of products. This will include the maintenance of the production line and other
necessary repairs. The works department may also have the responsibility for
quality control and inspection.
4.2 CRANKSHAFT
The crankshaft is designed to convert the up and down motion of the pistons into
horizontal rotation. The shaft is one solid piece made from cast iron or forged steel. Oil
passages are either cast or drilled into the crankshaft to distribute lubricant to the main
and rod journals.
VSM is a special type of flow chart that uses symbols known as “the language of
Lean” to depict an improve the flow of inventory and information. A value stream is all
the actions (both value and non-value added) currently required to bring a product
through the main flows essential to every product.
There are several important steps involved in getting started in value stream
mapping. They are:
The process flow regarding the VWH crankshaft in the production line is studied
in detail. With the help of process flow we designed routing (movement of component
from one process to next process)
Each numbers in the present layout represent the specific processes are mentioned
below:
The detail study regarding each process in process flow is studied. The time study
and the distance between the processes calculated helped us to find out the non-value
added activities carried out in the production line.
Raw material in the form of forged components of the crankshaft are received,
these forgings under goes initial inspection as per the inspection checklist before being
sent to workshop floor.
Oil from the main oil gallery reaches each individual main-journal and bearing.
Oil is fed through a central circumferential groove in the bearing and it completely
surrounds the central region of the journal surface. Diagonal oil hole drills are provided in
the crankshaft which pass through the webs for lubrication of the journal. For effective
lubrication of these oil holes emerge from the crankpin at about 30 degrees on the leading
side of the crank’s TDC position.
The drilled oil passages should not be close to the side walls of the webs or near
the fillet junction between the journal and the webs to avoid high stress concentration,
which may cause fatigue failure. Also the oil holes on the journal surfaces must be
chamfered to reduce stress concentration, but excessive chamfering can destroy the oil
film. Both 30 degree and 35 degree oil holes are drilled in the same machine
simultaneously but in two different stations.
Critical characteristics: Hole of 60mm and 110 mm, check for hole clearance.
Gauges and Instruments: Double ended plug gauge and drill bits.
13 345 37 5 1 33.1
Cycle time=395seconds
12 240 12 5 1 -
Cycle time=264seconds
After oil hole drilling components are then here chamfered in the way to remove
the burrs is known as chamfering. It is the industrial standard in deburring crankshaft oil
passages.
10 10 10 5 1 7.4
Critical characteristics: Case depth of 1.5mm, surface hardness (53-63 HRC), specified
voltage.
Machine and Tools: Induction coil, water –oil ratio act as a coolant.
Gauges and Instruments: Metallurgy lab. (For every 5000 component) Destructive form
of test.
29 93 21 - 1 20.5
26 87 12 - 1 -
Critical characteristics: Temperature inside the oven and duration of time for which the
component has to keep in the oven, hardness.
Grinding operation is carried out on the pulley end of the component. This gives
smooth surface finishing to the component. This is one of the most important steps in the
remanufacturing process crankshafts. This step involves removal excess material from the
rod or journals and is known as crankshaft grinding. On the rod there are various mains
that need to be reground to proper specifications. These rods are spun grind to the next
undersize using the pultrusion crankshaft grinding machine.
15 145 10 36 1 5
Grinding operation is carried out on the flywheel end of the component. This
gives smooth surface finishing to the component.
21 288 21 35 1 1
Grinding operation is carried out on the pin of the component. This gives smooth
surface finishing to the component.
15 436 45 21 1 5
After the grinding process, a crank shaft is tested for cracks on its surface in a
magnetic particles inspection machine. Here the part is smeared with oil containing
magnetic flux is magnetized and put under UV light so that if any cracks present on the
surface are visible in green colour.
However all components are subjected to crack detection after all grinding
operation are over. After the inspection the components are demagnetized.
Critical characteristics: Cracks, special care must be taken to check for cracks.
Gauges and Instruments: visual inspection with the help of ultraviolet light torch.
6 33 6 6 1 15
After demagnetization the crack-free components are face drilled on the web of
crankshaft. Four similar holes position are guided through a jig. These holes are of 15mm
depth. Once the drilling operation is finished, it is then chamfered to remove the burrs.
41 218 30 15 1 6.4
Critical Characteristics: Width and depth of the flat keyway, length and position of the
flat keyway, cutter diameter.
Gauges and Instruments: Ring gauge, Slip gauge/Keyway width gauge (pin gauge).
Threading is done on the journal end of the crankshaft. This is done according to
the design specification as mentioned in the drawing. Threading operation is done at
journal end to assemble the crankshaft in engine case
Before reaming drilling operation is done. Then reamer tool is used to increase the
quality of the already drilled hole in CNC machine, where there is a option for two
component to be reamed.
Once finishing all the machining process, lapping process is done as lapping is a
finishing operation. Here the surfaces are rubbed using abrasive belt by hand movement.
40 46 5 - 1 3.7
Process 16: Counter weight assembly and balancing process of VWH crankshaft
To maintain the uniform weight throughout the component counter weight are
assembled to web by using nut and washer. After assembling the counter weight the
component is subjected to inspection which determines the part where the weight is in
excess ratio. Once it is determined, the unbalanced portion is subjected to drilling to
obtain uniform weight. The drilling operation is done on the counter weight assembled.
This process is continued till it achieves uniform distribution of weight.
Time required for this process depends on quantity of stock from the previous
operation. For a component it takes about 6 min to deburr as well as polishing
manually.
In this stage finished component arrives at the inspection department for final
inspection. Before receiving the component it is must to ensure visually whether all
operation are completed or not. Then the component undergoes inspection as per the
inspection plan. Once the final inspection is over, accepted quantities are handed over to
stores with accepting the tag on the component. Rework work component and rejected
components are kept in yellow and red bins respectively.
Gauges and Instruments: snap gauge, woodruff keyway gauge, flat keyway gauge,
Vernier caliper, internal width gauge, double ended go no-go gauge, thread ring gauge.
All the accepted components undergo cleaning operation and rust preventing oil is
sprayed on the component to preserve it for longer duration. Then the components are
packed, labelled and stored at designated place.
The methodology used to create current state VSM for crankshaft is carried out by
following steps,
Although it is convenient to use value stream mapping for visually displaying the
whole process, drawing the value steam mapping by hand is kind of difficult. By
using “EDRAW MAX” software, you can easily draw value stream mapping with the
help of value stream mapping maker.
This is a step by step guide to creating a current value stream map, the first step in
working towards your ideal state value stream and a truly a lean system. Current state
value stream mapping allows an organization to identify waste and sources of waste. The
current state provides a waste line from which people can work to create a future state
VSM.
By following these steps the current state value stream mapping is presented as in figure
1. Inventory:
2. Transportation:
Each time a product is moved it stands the risk of being damaged, lost, delayed,
etc. as well as being a cost for no added value. Transportation does not make any
transformation to the product that the consumer is willing to pay for.
3. Motion:
4. Waiting:
Whenever goods are not in transport or being processed, they are waiting. In
traditional processes, a large part of an individual product's life is spent waiting to be
worked on.
5. Defects:
Whenever defects occur, extra costs are incurred reworking the part, rescheduling
production, etc. This results in labor costs, more time in the "Work-in-progress". Defects
in practice can sometimes double the cost of one single product. This should not be
passed on to the consumer and should be taken as a loss.
Takt Time is the rate at which products or services should be produced to meet the
customer demand. It is derived from the German word, Taktzeit, which is often referred
to as the heartbeat or drumbeat of production in Lean Manufacturing.
Where
T = Takt time, e.g. [work time between two consecutive units]
Ta = Net time available to work, e.g. [work time per period]
D = Demand (customer demand), e.g. [units required per period]
Net available time is the amount of time available for work to be done. This
excludes break times and any expected stoppage time (for example scheduled
maintenance, team briefings, etc.).
4.6 5S
Proper arrangement of the waste is not managed. This may consume more amount of time
while identifying the waste.
Yellow line system is not maintained properly. Since it is not visible for the
workers, they may cross the line and tend to affect with accidents unknowingly.
Chapter 5
RESULT AND DISCUSSION
Each numbers in the present layout represent the specific processes are mentioned below:
Replacement of chamfering machine in the layout, beside the oil hole drilling
leads to the reduction of unnecessary movements, work- in-process inventor and
operators.
Interchange of induction hardening machine and tempering oven reduces half of
the movement done by operators.
Placing pin grinding machine next to flywheel machine reduces the zig zig
movement of inventory.
New machine for both keyway and reaming is introduced at the position of 12th
process there by high reduction of inventory movements and achieving all the
process within the crankshaft module.
Processing time=4455seconds
Kaizen burst-1
In future state value stream mapping oil hole drilling and chamfering process are
replaced by cellular layout. The time taken for operating oil hole drilling was nearly 4
minutes and time taken for the whole process of chamfering is 30 seconds. Therefore
instead keeping the oil hole drilling machine operator idle, operator is made to work
the chamfering process. The production lead time can be reduced by 0.5 days in future
state VSM. After implementing cellular layout in process1, cycle time will be reduced
by 30 seconds and in-process inventory is eliminated.
Kaizen burst 2
As the result of future plant layout,” line balancing” has been achieved. Due to
this the incoming parts can be operated either by A and B grinding operators or by pin
grinding operator and machine place have been shifted with A and B journal grinding.
Kaizen burst 3
Kaizen burst 4
By introducing new CNC machine, both keyway and reaming operations can be
performed in a single machine. As a result of this, inventory movements can be
reduced by 69 meters and since this take much time to finish the process the same
operator is subjected to operate tapping machine. Hereby, one machine and two
operators are eliminated.
5.4.2 SUPERMARKET
Supermarket 1
A supermarket is proposed after receipt of forging and inward inspection is done
which will ensure a smooth flow of goods materials as required and according to the
processes.
Supermarket 2
After the tempering operation inventory should be provided because both A and B
side pin grinding is carried out in the same cellular in order to achieve the line balancing.
Supermarket 3
Another supermarket is proposed after the packing end as well. All the finished
and packed substrate would go to the supermarket where they will be retrieved and
shipped accordingly; his system will ensure a smooth dispatching of finished goods
materials.
Activities carried out during the course of project imparted strong theoretical and
practical knowledge about the following aspects.
Department of Industrial Production & Engineering SJCE MYSURU Page 60
Study on implementation of lean tools
Pre-production such as preparation of process flow chart, control plan and standard
operating procedures.
Learning the techniques involved in the processes.
Manufacturing process of precision components such as crankshaft was explained
in detail.
Use of various precision measuring instrument tools.
Studied about the critical characteristics of each process in the manufacturing of
precision components crankshaft.
Organizational behavior and the structure of work carried out in the firm.
Overall working of the company and coordination between different departments.
Time management.
Value stream mapping.
This concept of time management and improvement is new approach to VST Tiller
Tractor Ltd, Mysuru. By proposing the current state and future state value stream map for
the component crankshaft the company can overcome problems and increase its
efficiency, kaizen bursts i.e., improvements and some other changes are done in the future
state value stream mapping.
Chapter 6
CONCLUSION
6.1 CONCLUSION
Major problems which were hindering the production were unnecessary material
movement; production line layout is not continuous according to sequential process flow
and unnecessary time delay in inspection areas where quality parameters are not
important.
So we used lean manufacturing tools like Value Stream mapping, Line Balancing,
Kaizen, Cellular layout, Plant layout which company is starting to adopt in their work
environment.
After our analysis with all the data we proposed new plant layout and value stream
mapping which helps in reducing the manufacturing lead time and unnecessary material
movement in manufacture of VWH crankshaft at VTTL, Ltd, Mysuru.
The major outcome of this project is developing a plan/mapping to achieve line balance
with short lead time to meet customer demand on time, machine and labour movements
can be minimized to use multi tasking works in the shop floor which helps to attain the
specified cycle time and to reduce in process inventory.
REFERENCES
1. http://courses.washington.edu/ie337/Value_Stream_Mapping.pdf
2. http://www.isixsigma.com/dictionary/value-stream-mapping/
3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Value_stream_mapping
6. Value Stream Mapping: A Case study of Assembly Process by Soniya Parihar , Sanjay
8. Getting Started With Value Stream Mapping Anders Nielsen Gardiner Nielsen
Associates Inc.