Prs Tu Cmc-Standard-Course Enu
Prs Tu Cmc-Standard-Course Enu
Prs Tu Cmc-Standard-Course Enu
Revision Table
Please use this document only in combination with the related product manual which contains several important safety
instructions. The user is responsible for every application that makes use of an OMICRON product.
OMICRON electronics GmbH including all international branch offices is henceforth referred to as OMICRON.
t/s
1,6
220 kV 1,2
Ssc = 15 GVA 0,8
0,4
ARC
0,0
Z Z
t 150/25 AI/St t 150/25 AI/St 150/25 AI/St
32.5 km 20.1 km 10 km
In this example, Siemens 7SA631 and Areva P435 protection devices are used to protect these lines in the
OMICRON network. These protection relays are equipped with the following protection functions for training
purposes:
These protection functions are to be tested within the context of the training with the test modules from the
OMICRON Test Universe.
To protect the transformer, either a Siemens 7UT613 or an Areva P633 is used in the following example.
Both transformer differential protection devices have been configured as "three-winding transformers". As
already mentioned, the tertiary winding will not be discussed further in this context. These protection devices
are equipped with the following protection functions for training purposes:
These protection functions are to be tested within the context of the training with the test modules from the
OMICRON Test Universe.
The start page of the Test Universe software (TU) is the central starting point for working with the CMC test
system. It is from here that you can access all of the elements within the software.
> Test Modules: These are programs which can be used to test individual protection or measurement
functions.
> Control Center: Complex test sequences comprising a series of test modules can be created here.
> Network Simulation: These are tools to model and generate dynamic/transient system events to test
the reaction of the device under test, to complement the test coverage of settings-based test modules.
> Data Management: ADMO provides asset management, including the free and unrestricted test set
management as delivered with Test Universe.
> IEC 61850: Use these modules for testing with signals according to IEC 61850
> Configuration Modules: These are programs that can be used to configure the test set features.
> Setup: You will find an option for connecting to a CMC test device with NET-x option, license
management, and various basic settings here.
> Support: You will find numerous options to assist you in the event of problems here.
Starting with Test Universe 4.00, all test modules are installed even if no related module license is
present. This allows you to explore all features of the modules, creating, modifying or reading test files
including Control Center documents and running offline (simulated) tests. The only restriction is that only
modules with a valid (permanent or non-expired timed) license can run online tests with a connected
CMC test set.
In the Control Center, multiple test modules can be combined in a single test sequence. This makes it
possible to create a continuous test sequence including all test modules that are needed to test a protection
relay. On completion of the test the Control Center generates one test report for all the test modules
contained in the sequence.
Click Open Protection Testing Library for direct access to the installed PTL packages. These packages
contain a predefined test sequence which can be used to test a specific type of protection relay. These test
sequences can be downloaded free of charge from the Customer Area of the OMICRON homepage. They
provide templates for possible test sequences. They can be modified and expanded by users at any time.
In Open examples of Use… you have the possibility to comprehend the testing of a certain protection
function based on an example. Every example of use includes a detailed instruction for testing and the
matching OCC-file.
Use the OCC Batch tool to run several Control Center documents sequentially.
The NetSim and Ground Fault test modules support the output of transient signals, e.g., to test the anti-hunt
device or a transient ground-fault relay with consideration of the physical characteristics of the network. For
more complex schemes and for parallel control of multiple CMC test sets from one test document you may
use the separate RelaySimTest program which can be launched from the Test Universe start screen.
Utilizing the GOOSE Configuration and Sampled Values Configuration modules you can integrate
IEC 61850 signals in your test. These two test modules map GOOSE messages to binary in-/outputs and
analog outputs to sampled values streams. Working with binary in-/outputs as well as analogue outputs
stays the same and you can use your testing templates also in digital substations.
With the module IEC 61850 Client/Server you can test control system communication based on IEC 61850.
You can set the mode of an IED (Intelligent Electronic Device). You can get information from the data model
and you can activate test reports.
The IEDScout is a general tool to test and troubleshoot communication based on IEC 61850. It can handle
many different services defined in the standard. You can associate to a device and check its data model,
control circuit breakers and switches, utilize setting groups, download disturbance recordings, activate test
reports and handle dynamic datasets. The IEDScout has also a sniffer function to visualize and capture
IEC 61850 network traffic.
The SVScout is a sniffer for sampled values streams and can visualize and record them.
2.5.1 AuxDC
This program is used to define the voltage at the AUX DC output. For example, you can use the voltage to
supply power to the relay that has to be tested.
The voltage can be set either to a predefined level or can be adapted individually.
Notice:
If a default starting value is set, this voltage will be applied after a short delay (blinking LED) when the CMC
test device is switched on, regardless whether a PC is connected or not. There is a risk of a relay being
inadvertently damaged beyond repair by a voltage that is too high.
The configuration module ISIO Connect is used to connect the ISIO 200 to the CMC. With this module a
maximum of three ISIO 200 can be connected at once using a default signal assignment. Every ISIO 200
offers eight additional binary in- and outputs. In total, the CMC can be expanded with 24 binary in- and
outputs. For more binary extensions or for custom signal assignment use the GOOSE configuration module.
TransPlay: This tool is used to play signal files (Wave or Comtrade format). These files can be read out
from a relay following an incident, for example, or simulated and saved in a test module.
EnerLyzer: The EnerLyzer test tool provides a means of using the binary signals from the CMC test device
to measure analog signals (current, voltage). It can be used with the CMC family 256 and 356.
EnerLyzer Live: The EnerLyzer Live is a test tool that allows to control the measurement capabilities of your
CMC 430 test set.
TransView: You can use this tool to display and analyze signal files (incident traces in Comtrade format, for
example) in the form of graphs.
Harmonics: You can use this program to generate electrical signals with more than one frequency (e.g., for
inrush).
Binary I/O Monitor: A clear overview of the states of all binary inputs and outputs from the connected test
devices is displayed here.
Polarity Checker: The Polarity Checker is a measurement tool (similar to a voltage tester) which can be
used for wiring checks. Use the Polarity Checker module for injecting the necessary voltage or current for
the test.
O/C Characteristics Grabber: In the absence of a formula for the characteristic for an overcurrent
protection characteristic, you can use the Characteristics Grabber to take the time and current pairs from a
bias curve which is available in digital form (e.g. scanned from an image in an operating manual).
4
2
1
If it is not possible to associate the test set to a PC, you might be able to rectify the problem by modifying the
IP configuration. You can specify whether the CMC test device should obtain its IP address automatically or
you can set an IP address manually (4). If the problems persist, please contact Support (see Start Page
Support).
Note: If the CMC test device is connected with an USB cable the step with pushing the “Associate” button
can be skipped.
The last possibility for assigning a CMC test device to the PC is via Wi-Fi. A Wi-Fi-adapter, a NET-2 (or
higher) interface board on the CMC and Test Universe 3.20 or higher is necessary. The module OMICRON
Device Link shows all CMCs that can be assigned via Wi-Fi in a list. The selected CMC can be connected
via an existing Wi-Fi network (1) or a new Wi-Fi network can be set up (2). For the new Wi-Fi network a
password has to be created and confirmed (3). After that the CMC test device has to be associated by
pushing the “Associate” button on the back of the CMC (4).
2 3
1 4
This is where you make the settings that are valid throughout Test Universe.
On the Default Values tab you define the parameters which are set by default for every Test Object. Please
note that only the values from the Default Values tab can subsequently be modified in the corresponding
Test Object. If a test file is opened and different values have been defined for its Test Object, these are not
modified. To make testing easier, the values you define here should be applicable for most of the tests.
1
1
This is where existing
license files are opened
(e.g., from CD) in order
to add licenses to the
Master License File.
2 2
All licenses for the
relevant PC are stored
in the
Master License File
(see the folder
specified).
3
3
4 These test modules
have been purchased
for the selected CMC
test device.
To be able to use a CMC test device with the Test Universe software, you need a corresponding license.
Information about which CMC test device may be used in conjunction with which test modules is stored in a
license file (omicron.lic). The CMC test devices are uniquely identified by their code (e.g., CH924H). This is
located on the inside of the handle. The license file for the corresponding device can be found on the
Test Universe CD supplied with the CMC test device. It contains the individual licenses for the test modules
purchased and is transferred automatically during installation. To add a license post-installation, click the
Merge into Master License File button.
It is possible to distribute all licenses to all PCs within an organization, so that every PC can work with every
CMC test device.
Newer CMC test sets may have their associated module licenses stored internally so some licenses might
not appear in the License Manager.
This is where you can change the user language for Test Universe. If a series of small squares is displayed
for a language, this means that the corresponding character set is not installed on the PC you are using.
Note: Manual text entries (e.g., text entered in the Comment field) cannot be translated when a
different language is selected.
If you have questions or problems, there are various ways of getting help:
> Getting Started: Here you find help if you are working with the Test Universe Software for the first time.
> Tutorials: Videos demonstrate how to get started with the CMC test device and some of the test
modules. (To activate this menu item, you need to install the tutorials from the Test Universe DVD or
download it from the customer portal my.omicronenergy.com.)
> Manuals: You will find all manuals (both for the software and for the hardware) in PDF format here.
> Help: The comprehensive help provides assistance in the event of problems. However, it is quicker to
call up the help directly from the window about which you have questions.
> Tips & Tricks: You can access tips to help you complete testing quicker and more efficiently here.
> Contacts: Click here to find everything you need to know about getting in touch with OMICRON. The
telephone numbers for Technical Support are a very useful feature.
> OMICRON Assist: Once this program has been executed, a variety of information about the operating
system, the PC, and the installed software is collected and sent to Technical Support via e-mail. This
makes it easier to provide assistance in the event of software problems.
> Diagnosis and Calibration: Click here to find tools for solving technical problems or calibrating the
CMC test device.
> What's New: The major new features of the current software version are listed in a PDF file.
You can share experiences with other users of OMICRON test devices on the User Forum. Members of our
Technical Support team also monitor events on the forum and answer questions posted there.
This test module has been designed for straightforward, quick and easy testing. It allows you to access all
the current and voltage generators of the CMC test device directly and also enables the state of the binary
input signals to be read out. However, in its basic function, the test module does not contain any information
about the protection function tested. This means that you have to calculate all the signals to be output
yourself. You then have to evaluate the response of the tested protection relay manually. Therefore,
although it is possible in principle to test virtually every protection function, this can be done more easily and
more quickly by using the test module designed specifically for that purpose in each case.
As such, the QuickCMC test module is best suited to straightforward wiring and commissioning tests. It can
also be used as a diagnostic tool for troubleshooting.
Although QuickCMC is the most basic of the test modules, it supports numerous setting options. All views
and their functions are described below.
However, before you can start to output currents and voltages, several basic settings have to be made.
In accordance with OMICRON's Ohm's law (Test Object, Hardware Configuration, Test Module), we start
with the Test Object. Click the button to open the test object.
Standard view
Advanced view
In the Test Object, you have to define various data relating to the protection device to be tested. These
parameters are used to set specific current, voltage, or frequency values automatically, for example, or to
add an entry to the test report indicating which protection relay has been tested. The RIO (Relay Interface by
OMICRON) functions are available to you for this purpose. You can find these functions under the block of
the same name. You need to make corresponding settings here as appropriate for the protection function to
be tested in this instance. However, the Device function is always available. It is described in more detail
below.
The Test Object can be displayed in two different modes. You can choose between these in the View
menu.
> The Standard View is the simpler of the two. It is used below.
> The Advanced View is designed for advanced users. The XRIO technology can be used to perform
complex calculations automatically.
The Default Values from the System Settings are displayed here.
You can enter various items of information to uniquely identify the protection relay on the left-hand side of
the screen. A variety of network and device data, such as nominal frequency, voltage, and current, can be
entered on the right-hand side.
If the relay has additional ground current or ground voltage inputs, you have to enter these scaled values
with the corresponding factors.
Maximum values for current and voltage appear under Limits. These values cannot be exceeded during
testing. This protects the protection relay against inadvertent damage beyond repair caused by electrical test
values that are too high.
Note: The debounce and deglitch functions are only available in conjunction with the
CMC 256/CMC 256plus/CMC 356 and CMB IO-7 test devices.
This RIO function supports numerous setting options for defining the characteristics of a distance protection
relay. However, only the System Parameters are required at this time. Enter the Line length in ohms and
the Line angle. You can also specify whether the PT connections are line or busbar connections. You also
need to define the direction of the CT starpoints for proper polarity of the currents.
This completes the entries for the Test Object. The File menu contains the Export and Import commands.
You can use these to save the Test Object and then reopen it later in a different test module. This means
that it is not necessary to enter all of the data again. (The Import Relay Settings command has a different
function and is not used for this purpose!)
You can now confirm all settings with OK. The software takes you back to the test module.
Next, we are going to open the Hardware Configuration by clicking the button.
In the Hardware Configuration you define how the connected test devices are to be used.
The first tab of the Hardware Configuration dialog box contains fields in which you can specify which CMC
test device and, if applicable, which additional amplifiers are to be used. You can then click Details... to
enter more detailed information.
In this window you can specify which voltage and current generators are to be used with which
interconnection option. You can deactivate individual generators or even connect multiple generators in
parallel or in series in order to generate higher output currents, voltages, or powers.
You can define the data for transformers connected between the CMC test device and protection devices
here. These transformers provide a means of generating higher output voltages or currents. The maximum
power that can be achieved by the CMC test device remains the same. For example, 4 x 900 V can be
generated with a 3V/V transformer, to test protection devices in wind power stations for instance.
Further settings affecting the analog generators are made on the Analog Outputs tab:
> Test Module Output Signal: Select which function is assigned to the analog generator for the test
module. The first three voltages are assigned to the phases. Each of the currents is matched 1:1 to the
phase currents.
> Display Name: You can enter a name of your choice here. This name designates the corresponding
signal in the test module.
> Connection Terminal: You can specify here which connection terminal in the cabinet or on the
protection device the corresponding analog output has to be connected to.
Note: Changing the assignment of the Test Module Output Signals also changes the physical
properties of the analog output signals (e.g., clockwise/counter-clockwise phase sequence,
etc.).
On this tab you define which binary input signals are connected. You also have to specify whether the
signals are Potential Free or not. In the latter case you have to specify both the Nominal range (e.g.,
110 V) and the Threshold (e.g., 77 V). A voltage above this Threshold is evaluated as a logic 1, a voltage
below it as zero.
If you want to use the Binary Outputs in this test module, as is the case with the binary inputs, you have the
option to define the signals used (e.g., CB position).
You can configure the DC Analog Inputs here. They are used to test the transducers.
This completes all the settings in the Hardware Configuration. You can export these settings on the
General tab so that they can be re-imported later for other test modules. This means that you only have to
enter the relevant data once.
6 5 7 9
1. You can enter the actual current and voltage values to be output by the CMC test device in this window.
Various input options are available under Set Mode. These include symmetrical components, line-line
values, and specific types. This option is known as the Fault Calculator. It makes generating the
necessary signals easier.
5. Press the Start/Stop button (F5/F6) to start/stop signal output. The signals can be changed during
output.
6. Press the Prefault button (F8) to output a prefault state with nominal voltages and selected current
magnitude prior to the output of the set values. Press F8 again to terminate the prefault; the defined
values are output.
7. Click the Hold Values button (F9) to freeze the values of the signals currently being output. As long as
this button is activated you can change the values in 1 without the changes being applied and output
immediately. Once the changes have been made they can be output by pressing F9 again.
8. The settings in this section can be used to ramp the signals output (in other words, to change them in
steps). This means that it is possible, for example, to increase the current in small steps until the pick-up
signal or a trip is triggered. You can see the corresponding time in 4.
9. Once the test has been completed successfully, the results can be evaluated manually by pressing the
Add to Report button (F10).
If an impedance option (e.g., Z-I const.) has been selected under Set Mode, the defined output values can
be displayed in the Impedance View. Conversely, you can define the output values by clicking the
impedance plane. In addition, the distance zones are also displayed here if they have been specified in the
RIO function Distance in the Test Object.
The signals can be displayed in any format (line-neutral, line-line, symmetrical components, fault values,
etc.) in the Phasor View. You can select the required format by right-clicking on the diagram.
Once the test is completed the report can be displayed in the Report View. Click on Report Settings in the
Home tab to define which settings should be included in the report. A predefined short form and long form
are available, which can be adapted accordingly in line with individual requirements.
Toggles the time unit between seconds (s) and cycles (cy)
A wiring test is a simple example of an application involving the QuickCMC test module. You should carry
out a test of this type at the start of every test in order to ensure that all analog connections have been made
correctly. During the test, currents and voltages are output with various amplitudes. The measured
secondary values or primary values can then be read off on the relay's display. If they match, the wiring is
correct. Using the different display options is very useful for this test.
This test checks for discrepancies affecting the directions of energy flow and amplitudes displayed. It can be
used to test the transmission of these signals via the control and instrumentation technology, for example.
This test is easy to run with the Set Mode Powers.
3.11.1 Tasks
> Wire the CMC test device to the OMICRON SIM box and run a wiring test.
> Work with the various input modes (direct, fault values, symmetrical components, etc.) and the Vector
View.
> Check the pick-up value and trip time of the definite time emergency overcurrent protection.
> After the test, export the Test Object and the Hardware Configuration.
Note: You need to activate the definite time emergency overcurrent protection function for the
distance protection relay used in this training.
Additional pause modules provide the tester with important information about carrying out the test.
This chapter describes how to create and adapt a test template like the one referred to above. It also
explains how to add existing and new test modules.
Start by clicking New Test Document under Control Center on the start page. This opens a blank OCC file.
The View tab contains the Report View, the List View and the Script View.
Use the Report View to customize your overall report. Test modules may be embedded in the report and
run from it. The header and footer can also be edited here.
In the List View, the objects embedded in the OCC are shown in a tree structure. For each object, the List
View shows specific properties, such as test status, whether or not it is ready for testing, or the assigned test
report form (short or long form).
The Script View allows you to write and run your own scripts using the Control Center script language.
We will now explain how to add a title, user-specific information, and a logo on the first page. "Fields" are
used to ensure that the text is updated automatically downstream.
You need to start by specifying several document properties, so that you can implement references to fields
later.
Next you need to add some delimiters. To do this, click the Test Object in the report to select it. Use the
arrow key to move the cursor to the left and press Enter. This adds a new line above the test object.
You can now add the first field right at the top. Proceed as shown in the screenshot. In the Insert Field
dialog box you can select which items from the list you wish to appear in the report (e.g., the title).
Two more fields are now added to specify the Test Person and the Date Tested.
A field works as a placeholder for certain information. This information will be acquired by the Control Center
and inserted into the document automatically (e.g., date tested, path of the test report, etc.). As we have
seen, some of the fields in the list can be defined and named on the Document Properties dialog (e.g., title,
subject, company, etc.). Therefore, if there is no information about a particular field (e.g., you have not run
any test yet so there is no test date) or no entry on the Document Properties dialog, "n/a" (not available) is
shown.
The area highlighted on the screenshot shows which fields have been selected (e.g., {Title}, {Test Person},
{Test date}, etc.). Activate the Field Names checkbox in the View tab to see this view.
The company logo is the next thing to be added. The easiest way to do this is to open the image file in an
image processing program and copy the image to the clipboard from there. The image can then be inserted
in the report using the shortcut key <Ctrl> + <V>.
The Filename, the Page Number, and the Page Count now just need to be added to the page footer.
The blank test template is now ready and can be saved. If you use this template for every test from now on,
all test reports will look the same. This is of course only a suggestion of how a template might look.
As explained above, the template already contains one Test Object. This is valid for all test modules
inserted below the Test Object. It means that you only have to enter the settings for the Test Object once
for all test modules. Double-click the icon or the text in the report to open the test object. Import and export
functions like those in QuickCMC are also available here.
The Hardware Configuration is very similar to the Test Object. It also applies for all subsequent test
modules. However, a distinction has to be made between the global Hardware Configuration in the OCC
and the local one in the test module. There is a difference between the two, which is explained in more detail
below. However, first, we are going to import the Hardware Configuration saved previously. This way you
will not need to configure any further settings, although we will revisit the configuration of the Analog
Outputs.
At first glance, there seem to be no differences between the two, but if you look more closely you can see
that the Test Module Output Signal column is missing. This is because the global Hardware
Configuration is not linked to a specific test module for which the precise application of the signals could be
defined. The column is also missing from all other tabs. It only reappears in the Local Hardware
Configuration of a test module. However, none of the settings made in the Global Hardware
Configuration can be changed there.
Note: Once a test module has been added we will look at this difference again in more detail.
All binary input signals which are required in the subsequent test sequence have to be declared in the global
Hardware Configuration.
All Binary Outputs, as well as DC Analog Inputs, can be deactivated, since they are not used for tests in
this training.
You can configure a synchronization of the CMC device to a connected time source. The available time
sources are GPS, PTP, NTP and IRIG-B. These additional settings enable multiple CMC test devices to be
synchronized. This is helpful above all in the case of the "end to end test", but it is not discussed any further
below.
You can now insert the QuickCMC test module you saved previously for the wiring test. The module
automatically adopts the Test Object and the global Hardware Configuration already available in the OCC
file. However, you MUST make sure that you insert the test module under the global Hardware
Configuration and not inadvertently between the Test Module and global Hardware Configuration.
Note: You only need to look at the Test Object of the test module inserted to check whether this does
actually contain the right data.
All that remains is to make some changes to the local Hardware Configuration.
In contrast to the global Hardware Configuration, the local Hardware Configuration for the test module
does contain the Test Module Output Signal or Input Signal column. As this column is specific to each test
module, you might need to make some local adjustments here. None of the other settings can be modified.
Once you have inserted a test module you need to check all tabs of the Hardware Configuration one more
time.
Close the test module to save all changes and go back to the OCC. You can rename the test module here
by double-clicking with the left mouse button or pressing <F2>.
As all tests associated with definite time emergency overcurrent protection have to be located in the same
subfolder, you need to create another group and rename it to "Emergency Overcurrent".
A Pause Module now needs to be added to the group created in the previous step. This test module can be
used to warn the user of the test template with an instruction to activate definite time emergency overcurrent
protection by tripping the voltage transformer circuit-breakers.
C.0047.AAX | v2.41
Page 66 of 215 © OMICRON Academy 2019
5 Ramping
5.1 Preface
You can use the Ramping test module to alter the currents or voltages to be output by the CMC test device
in stages (ramping). This is the same as the Step / Ramp function in the QuickCMC test module. However,
the signals are not changed manually in this case. Instead, you can define the shape of the ramp in detail in
advance. The analog signal outputs are then ramped during testing in accordance with the settings
configured in advance. In contrast to QuickCMC, where you had to evaluate test results manually, this
process is automated in the case of the Ramping test module. You just need to define the corresponding
measurements and tolerances.
Typical applications for the Ramping test module are testing the pick-up values of various protection
functions (e.g., I>, V<, etc.). The example below illustrates testing the pick-up value of the overcurrent
protection (definite time emergency overcurrent protection). The current is increased in steps until the pick-
up signal is triggered. It is then reduced so that the drop-off value can be measured. The reset ratio can
subsequently be calculated from these two parameters.
Pick-up Drop-off
I/A
t/s
The screenshot shows the standard view in the Ramping test module, with various different window views.
However, before you start to make settings in the test module, you need to double-check the Test Object
and the Hardware Configuration.
You have to configure the Test Module Output Signals in the local Hardware Configuration. As the
definite time emergency overcurrent protection function is to be tested here, the voltage outputs are not
needed. You can, therefore, set them to Not used on the Analog Outputs tab. However, as they are
needed for other tests (e.g., testing distance protection), they must be kept in the global
Hardware Configuration.
3
7
4 5 6
1. Here you can define the type of signal to be ramped. The available options are the same as those in the
QuickCMC test module. This means that in addition to currents and voltages, symmetrical components,
fault values, impedances, etc., can also be ramped directly.
2. What exactly the ramp is to change is set under Signal and Quantity. Two different signals can be
ramped at the same time. The possible settings are determined by the Set Mode. Examples include:
3. The start and end values of the signal to be ramped are entered here.
4. This is the step size, i.e., the magnitude, by which the signal is to change with each step.
5. You can set the output duration of a step here. It always has to be longer than the operating time of the
protection relay. This ensures that the protection relay will respond before the end of the step which
triggered it.
6. The settings result in a change rate, step count, and time duration for the entire ramp.
7. Every ramp can be assigned a stop condition. As soon as this event occurs, the next ramp starts or the
test finishes. This means that the set end value is not actually reached. This stop condition is configured
in the Detail View.
8. Use the Ramps tab to insert ramp states. This tab also includes the Ramp Navigation toolbar to go
through the sequence of ramp states by a simple mouse-click.
I/A
1.2 I>
I> + Tol
I>
I> - Tol
0.8 I>
Tol t/s
Delta I =
4
The first step (I>) of the definite time emergency overcurrent protection has been set to 1.8 A for this
example. The tolerance of the relay is 3%. In relation to I> this corresponds to 54 mA. The tolerances of a
relay can be found in the technical data of the relevant relay manual.
When setting the ramp parameters, you will encounter the problem of how to define the size of the individual
steps. One possible solution is to have approximately 4 steps between the limit of the tolerance range and
the set point. You end up with a step size of approximately 14 mA.
As a guide for the start and end values, use 0.8 and 1.2 times the nominal value. This corresponds to
absolute values of 1.44 A and 2.16 A.
The duration of each of the ramp steps must be longer than the operating time of the relay to ensure that the
pick-up ramp step is still active when the pick-up signal is coming, leading to a correct assessment. For our
example, therefore, 100 ms is sufficient.
You can now enter the required ramp parameters accordingly. Select a three-pole fault (I L1; L2; L3) as the
signal for our example.
Note: The settings in the Detail View have to be made individually for each ramp. The Ramp
navigation toolbar indicates which ramp is currently being processed. The ramps can also be
selected from the toolbar.
The characteristic for the ramped variables and the binary triggers is displayed in the Signal View.
Here you can configure settings for ramp measurements as well as for calculations with the subsequent
measurement results. Automatic assessment of the measurement results also takes place here. We will now
describe in detail how this works, based on the example of definite time emergency overcurrent protection.
Two measurements shall be performed. The first measurement is to determine the pick-up value while the
second is the drop-off value. In "Ramp 1" the pick-up value is determined by the amplitude of the current
output at the time at which the pick-up signal is triggered. You can make the corresponding settings in the
Ramp, Condition, and Signal columns. Enter the set value 1.8 A in the Nom. field. You also need to define
a permissible Deviation within which the measured signal has to be located. During the test the Actual
Value is entered automatically, the deviation is determined, and the test is assessed.
The same principle is applied to measure the drop-off value, although in the case of "Ramp 2" a
measurement is taken when the pick-up drops off. The setpoint is 95% of the set value. Please refer to the
relevant relay manual for this reset ratio also.
As well as taking these measurements, the actual reset ratio also needs to be calculated. You can select
various algorithms in order to do this. In this example you need X/Y. The results of the measurements taken
previously ("Drop-off" and "Pick-up") are to be used as X and Y. A Setpoint of 0.95 is entered and the
permissible deviation is set to 0.05.
Click the Start/Continue button (1) to start the test. The ramps then run until the set Stop Conditions and
the measurements and calculations are taken and made automatically. The test is then assessed. A green
check mark indicates "test successful", a red cross means "test failed".
Note: When carrying out the test, make sure that the distance protection function is
deactivated and the definite time emergency overcurrent protection is activated.
The Pulse Ramping test module offers an alternative solution. Instead of the pick-up signal, the trip signal is
used to assess the test. The trip times of the higher steps are always shorter than that of the first step. It is
possible, therefore, to test the faster trip via one of the higher steps (e.g., I>>) by injecting the current just for
a short time. If the CMC test device does not register a trip signal during this time, the current is reduced
until the pick-up is able to drop off. This avoids tripping in the first step. The sequence is repeated after a
short pause, but the current output this time is greater by ΔI. This continues until the I>> step picks up.
Thus it is possible to test all higher steps. In fact, the application range extends beyond overcurrent
protection.
In the Pulse Ramping test module the same Set Modes can be used as in the Ramping and QuickCMC test
modules. This results in numerous possible applications for testing the higher steps of all manner of different
protection functions.
Start by adding a Pulse Ramping test module to the existing OCC file.
The test module is displayed in the Test View. However, before you do anything else, you need to modify a
value in the Test Object. As the second step of the definite time emergency overcurrent protection is set to
6 A, you have to increase the maximum value of the current in the RIO function Device to 8 A.
You also need to configure some settings in the local Hardware Configuration.
As we are once again testing definite time emergency overcurrent protection, you can deactivate the voltage
generators (Not used).
Only the trip signal is used on the Binary / Analog Inputs tab. None of the other signals are needed.
We will now explain the possible settings for the module based on an example. The second step of a definite
time emergency overcurrent protection function with the following parameters is to be tested:
Settings Value
I> 1.8 A
t I> 0.5 s
I>> 6A
t I>> 0.1 s
6
4
1. The Set Mode works in the same way as in the Ramping test module. The available setting options are
also the same. This means that you can change currents and voltages directly or symmetrical
components, fault values, impedances, etc., automatically, in steps.
2. Here you can define which values are to be varied. The possible settings are determined by the Set
Mode. Examples include:
In the example we are considering here, the magnitude of a three-phase fault current is to be ramped.
You do not need to make any settings on the other two tabs, Binary Outputs and General. This test module
also features an option to synchronize the start of the test with a GPS or IRIG-B pulse.
As in the other modules, you can take a measurement here and run automatic assessment. In our example
the amplitudes of the generated signal are measured at the point in time at which the defined trigger
condition is met. The setpoint is the set value of the I>> step (6 A). The absolute tolerances can be
calculated using the values specified in the relay manual (3% of 6 A = 180 mA).
The defined pulse ramp is shown in the Time Signal View once the test is completed.
This module can be used to test much more than just non-directional inverse time/definite time overcurrent
protection functions. It also supports testing of protection relays with directional overcurrent protection,
unbalanced load protection, thermal overload protection, and zero sequence current protection functions.
Once the test module has been added to the OCC file and opened, the first thing you see is the predefined
overcurrent definite time characteristic.
However, this definite time characteristic does not conform to the application examples of this training
course. This has to be set in the Test Object first. A new RIO function called Overcurrent is available for
this purpose.
1. Here you can set whether a Non-directional or a Directional overcurrent protection is to be tested. If
you select the latter option, you have to define the position of the CT starpoint connection
(To protected object or From protected object). Examples are shown below.
To protected object From protected object
Protected Protected
Object Object
Busbar Relay e.g. Line Busbar Relay e.g. Line
Protected Protected
Object Object
Busbar Relay e.g. Line Busbar Relay e.g. Line
As VT connections also have to be included for Directional protection, the corresponding selection box
is checked. You need to define whether the PT connections are busbar or line connections here. In the
former case a voltage is output in the postfault state after the relay has tripped; in the second, a voltage
is not output.
2. As the test module is to carry out an automatic assessment, you need to specify the tolerances for the
currents and the trip times here. These can be found in the technical data section of the relevant relay
manual.
Use this tab to define the overcurrent elements (stages) of the relay:
1. The first step is to select the type of element. This refers to the type of overcurrent protection, the tested
relay uses. You can choose between Phase, Residual, Positive sequence, Negative sequence and
Zero sequence.
2. This list shows all defined elements of the selected type. There are command buttons available to Add,
Copy To..., Remove, Move Up or Move down the elements. Each element has different properties that
are shown in the list:
- Active: Use this checkbox to activate or deactivate elements.
- Element Name: A meaningful name helps to distinguish between the stages.
- Tripping Characteristic: Here you will find the name of the used characteristic type.
- I Pick-up: This is the pick-up current as multiples of the nominal current.
- Absolute: Here you find the pick-up value in amperes.
5
1
4
1. With the Characteristic definition you set the characteristic type, the I pick-up value and the Trip time.
Right to the characteristics name there is a browse button ... that opens the Manage Characteristics
dialog.
2. Within this dialog you can select either a Standard characteristic or a Predefined one from the list on the
left. All characteristic parameters are then shown in this dialog. To enter a custom characteristic, select
one of the predefined ones and click OK. Then you can change the parameters in the Define Elements
Characteristic tab (1).
The directional behavior for each element can be set in this tab.
1. This is only possible, if the Direction of the element is set to Forward or Reverse. This setting is only an
orientation for the user. The trip sector will be shifted by 180° if this setting is changed from Forward to
Reverse or from Reverse to Forward.
2. The trip sector can be defined either by using a Start and an End angle or by using the
Maximum torque angle and the Sector opening.
3. Also a Blinder can be defined. It can be set by using a complex current (active and reactive components)
and an angle. The blinder characteristic line will go through the complex current and will have the defined
angle.
VL3 VL3
Directional Line Directional Line
VL3
Directional Line
Fault Voltage Polarized: Here the voltage of the faulty phase is used as reference voltage. In this case the
relay characteristic angle (RCA), which is a relay setting, is identically with the test object setting
Maximum torque angle (MTA).
Quadrature Voltage polarized: During a fault close to the relay the voltage in the faulty phase can drop to
almost zero. In such cases the angle of this phase voltage cannot be measured. That is why many relay
manufacturers use the phase to phase voltage of the non-faulty phases as the polarizing voltage. In such
cases the Maximum torque angle can be calculated with the following equation: MTA = RCA - 90°
Zero Sequence Voltage Polarized: This method is typical for earth fault overcurrent protection. It uses the
zero sequence voltage as reference. The Maximum torque angle can be calculated with the following
equation: MTA = RCA – 180°
After defining the characteristic, you can use the tab View Resulting Characteristic to have a look at the
results. The characteristic of the chosen element type will be displayed.
If you have defined all the characteristics, which are used in the relay, you can close the Test Object by
clicking OK.
If you test a non directional overcurrent function you can deactivate the voltage outputs in the local
Hardware Configuration. Configure the binary inputs as shown.
You can define whether the Binary Outputs should be closed or open for testing. As no binary outputs have
been defined for our example, this tab is empty.
1 4
5
2
3 6
1. The Load current, which will be injected during the prefault, can be defined here.
2. Here you can set the Prefault time and the Postfault time.
Also you can specify how long the test module waits for a trip in two different ways. The first of these is
Absolute max. time and the second is Relative max. time. The relative time is calculated for the
relevant test point from the trip time setpoint. If, for example, you want to test the trip time of a high-
current stage with a setpoint of 100 ms, a Relative max. time of 100% means that the testing of the test
point will be aborted at the latest after 200 ms. To avoid damaging the relay, whichever time is faster is
active.
3. The voltages during the fault can be defined as well. Even if non-directional relays are tested, a voltage
output can be enabled.
4. For realistic fault simulation a Decaying DC can be set.
5. The CB characteristic is linked to the RIO function CB Configuration in the Test Object.
6. For testing thermal overload functions the reset of the Thermal image can be defined as well. This can
be done either manually or automatically.
After all the essential settings have been made, you need to define the test points for the characteristic test.
You can Add a new test point, or you can edit an existing one. The highlighted test point can be edited
either in the table on the left (1) or directly in the table of the test points (2). The resulting test points will be
shown in the expected trip time and directional characteristics (3).
Note: If two or more overcurrent protection functions are activated, they may interfere (e.g. a phase
overcurrent and a residual overcurrent protection). But if all of these functions are entered in the
Test Object, they will be taken into account automatically. The resulting characteristic will
individually be calculated and shown for each test point depending on its fault type and fault
angle, ensuring a proper assessment according to the expected overall relay behavior.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
1. For the fault Type you can choose between three, two or one phase faults as well as phase to ground
faults and zero and negative sequence faults.
2. It is possible to enter your test currents relative to the pick-up currents which you have defined in the Test
Object. The element, on which the test point will be referenced, can be set here.
3. Here you can enter the relative test current.
Note: If a test point is entered relatively, the absolute test current will be changed automatically,
whenever its pick-up value is changed.
4. The Magnitude can be entered as an absolute value as well.
5. For directional overcurrent protection, the test Angle has to be set additionally.
6. Here you can see the nominal tripping time of the test point.
7. Also the tolerances are shown for each test point.
8. The measured tripping time will be displayed here after the test.
1 2
3 4 5
Also there is the possibility to perform a Pick-up / Drop-off test. This is done automatically by ramping the
current. The start point, the end point and the step size of the ramp are calculated by the test module.
1. For a pick-up test normally a Relay with start contact is needed. But it is also possible to test an
electro mechanical (EM) relay without start contact. Digital relays without start contact can only be
tested, if they emulate the behavior of a disc-type EM relay.
2. If you do not want the pick-up test to be assessed automatically you have to clear this check box.
Note: The drop-off value as well as the reset ratio will not be assessed automatically
3. The fault Type can be defined similar to the characteristic test.
4. If you test a directional overcurrent relay, the test Angle can be set as well.
5. The Resolution defines the step length of the ramp. This value has to be set longer than the pick-up time
of the relay.
After the test the pick-up value will be displayed and assessed. The drop-off value and the drop-off ratio will
be displayed as well.
If the test point is indicated blue, the Absolute max. time is shorter than the upper tolerance tmax. In this
case the test cannot be assessed properly. Therefore you have to increase the Absolute max. time.
If the test point is indicated pink, the test current is too high. This means that the test current of this test point
is higher than the maximum test current I max which is defined in the Test Object.
The Report View is also available in the Overcurrent test module. It can be opened via clicking Report on
the View tab.
Settings Value
Characteristic type I> Definite
I> 1.8 A
t I> 0.5 s
I>> 6A
t I>> 0.1 s
Directional behavior Non directional
Settings Value
Characteristic type I> IEC Very Inverse
I> 1.5 A
Time multiplier 1.2
I>> 3A
t I>> 0.1 s
Directional behavior I> forward directional
Relay characteristic angle 45°
Numerous relays of the same type with similar settings (functional scope, pick-up characteristics, etc.) are in
use in a single transformer substation. To test one of these relays you have created a test template
containing the pick-up value and trip time tests for various fault loops. Following successful testing you now
want to use the same template to test the next relay. However, to do this, you have to recalculate and enter
a number of set values for the test modules due to the discrepancies between parameter settings. This can
involve up to 12 different settings for one ramp module alone. If this routine task could be carried out
automatically, you would be able to save a huge amount of time when adapting the test template.
In this chapter we will show you how to implement this type of automated testing.
RIO made it possible to map the behavior of a protection device regardless of manufacturer. However, it did
have certain limits, which were imposed by the content of the specific RIO functions used. XRIO does away
with these limits. Users can now create parameters at will in an XML file and use formulas to interlink them.
Settings Value
I> 1.8 A
t I> 0.5 s
I>> 6A
t I>> 0.1 s
You have to create these values as XRIO parameters in the Test Object. You also need two additional
parameters to configure the ramp for the pick-up test; these can be calculated from the parameters specified
above.
Tol/A = 3% ∙ I> = 54 mA
Delta I = Tol/A / 4 = 14 mA
These two parameters have to be created by assigning the corresponding formulas to them.
I/A
1.2 I>
I> + Tol
I>
I> - Tol
0.8 I>
Tol t/s
Delta I =
4
This is all done in an advanced view (View menu) of the Test Object. However, you have to create a new
sub-block first and add all the parameters to it.
A block of this type has various attributes. The most important of these are:
> ID: The ID identifies the block. This ID must contain only uppercase letters; not all of these letters can be
special characters.
> Name: The name can be selected at will.
> Description: You can enter additional notes here to specify the purposes for which the block is to be
used.
You now need to create the first parameter in this block. To do this, you have to select the data type first. In
our example, only the Real data type is used.
The first parameter is the pick-up value I>. Make the settings as shown:
> Foreign ID: If the parameter is a set value of a relay, you can enter the ID used to refer to it in the relay
here.
> Value: Enter the value of the parameter here.
> Formula: If a formula is to be used to calculate the value, it can be entered here.
> The Min. Value and the Max. Value restrict the range of values. An error message will appear if illogical
values are entered.
> You can specify a Multiplier and a Unit (e.g., MW or mA).
Proceed in the same way to define the remaining relay set values.
Complete the process by adding the two parameters Tol[A] and Delta I. You will need to use additional
formulas for this purpose.
Add a reference in the Formula field. This enables you to link the value of a different parameter. Once you
have added a reference you will need to specify the corresponding parameters.
Once the unit of measurement mA has been specified under Display Properties, a value is displayed
(54 mA).
All parameters are listed. However, so far these parameters have no effect at all on the test modules.
The screenshot shows the pick-up test in the Ramping test module. The inclusion of a link via
LinkToXRIO is also visible. In the window which is displayed you can now select the I> parameter. As the
ramp is to start at 80% of the nominal value, the Factor needs to be set to 0.8. When you click OK the field
turns purple to indicate that it has been linked. All settings are then linked in the same way, including the
parameters from the Assessment tables.
Nothing about the functionality of the test module has changed. However, if we now change the pick-up
value of the I> step in the Test Object, the test module is adapted automatically.
You have to proceed differently in order to adapt the trip time test automatically.
In the advanced view, the RIO functions are displayed as individual blocks with subblocks and parameters.
The different overcurrent stages are displayed as Timed Overcurrent Elements. The Pick-up Current and
the Time Multiplier/Trip Time are part of these elements.
As it was the case with parameters created by the user, a reference can also be added here in the Formula
field. In our example the pick-up current is linked to I> (I_G). This means that this value is applied
automatically. The same applies for the trip time.
As the Overcurrent test module uses these values and the test points have to be positioned relative to the
overcurrent stages, no further modifications need to be made there.
The LinkToXRIO function is supported in almost all test modules. It can be used to create complete test
templates where only the set values have to be entered. All test modules then adapt to these values
automatically.
The LinkToXRIO principle also provides the basis for the Protection Testing Library (PTL).
The Protection Testing Library is an extensive test template library of OMICRON. It includes test templates
of about 380 different relay types up to now. These so called PTTs (Protection Test Templates) exist of
OCC-files, which contain test solutions for a specific protection relay. The files are adapted to the protection
functions of the relay and linked with LinkToXRIO on many places.
The XRIO area of a PTT is structured in the same way as the relay software. Therefore it is easy to enter the
relay data in the Test Object. With the XRIO converter all entered relay parameters are calculated and
adapted to the RIO functions. This is done by formulas and the scripting functionality of the Test Object.
Note: All test templates provide only an example of how to test a specific relay. If you want or need to
change some test steps, all links, calculations or test modules can be changed, added or even
deleted.
You can find more details in the Customer Area of the OMICRON homepage (www.omicronenergy.com).
1. Download the desired PTL item from the OMICRON customer portal and install the files on your
computer.
2. Open the OCC-file. You will find it with the link on the desktop.
3. Open the Test Object and select the block Relay Parameter Section. You need to enter the relays
protection settings here. You can do this manually or with the Relay Settings Import Filter, if available.
4. Usage of the Import filter:
a. Export the relay settings in the relay settings software
b. In the Test Object select Import Relay Settings from the file menu
c. Select the right Import filter for the specific file type
d. You receive a message about the correct import of the settings. The imported parameters
are also listed in the lower part of the XRIO editor.
4c
5. Enter the necessary data into the Additional Information block of the Test Object (e.g. general information
about the substation or tolerances for the automatic assessment.)
6. Check the Hardware Configuration and connect the protection device to the CMC test set accordingly.
Take especially care about the configuration of the binary inputs (potential free or with potential).
7. Save the file with a new name.
8. In every test module, check all test shots, trigger conditions and additional test settings
9. Start the test!
A list of the protection's various distance zones appears on this tab. As no zones have been defined as yet,
the list is empty at this point. Click New to add the first zone.
1 2 3 4
3
Click the Edit... button to open an editor in which you can enter the geometry of the zone (e.g., polygon).
A zone comprises several elements, which define its limit. These elements can be lines and circles:
> Line cartesian: A point on the line with real and imaginary components as well as an angle specifying
the direction are required here.
> Line polar: The point is entered here with polar coordinates. An angle defining the direction is also
required here.
> Arc cartesian: In order to define the arc, its center point has to be entered in cartesian coordinates,
along with its radius, a start angle and an end angle, and a direction.
> Arc polar: The center point is specified here in polar coordinates. As was the case with the cartesian
arc, the radius, start angle, end angle, and direction also have to be specified.
The fundamental geometry of the zones is actually dependent upon the type of relay. Directional lines, load
blinding, etc., have to be taken into account in this context. In order to map the zones correctly, therefore,
you need a precise knowledge of both the relay settings and the parameter settings.
To avoid input errors, you should define the elements of a zone in a continuous sequence. We advise you,
therefore, to number elements consecutively before starting to build zones.
This screenshot shows the first zone with the corresponding tolerances.
The screenshot shows the tripping zones (1) and the extended zone (2). The starting zones (directional and
non-directional) are also visible.
You need to start by creating a new group called "Distance protection" in the OCC file and adding an
Advanced Distance test module to it.
The above screenshot shows the three most important views of the test module: the Test View, the
Impedance View and the Phasor View. The zones previously defined in the Test Object are displayed in
the Impedance View.
However, before starting the actual test, the Test Object and the Hardware Configuration have to be set
correctly. As the definition of the Test Object was described in the chapter before, you only have to
configure a number of settings in the local Hardware Configuration.
On this tab you can configure the trigger signal for the subsequent tests.
You can choose which simulation model is to be used for the Test Model. The following Test Models are
available for selection:
> Constant test current: To test distance protection relays with I> pick-up
> Constant test voltage: To test the underexcitation protection function
> Constant source imp.: To test distance protection relays with more realistic fault conditions
In our example we are using the Test Model, Constant test current with a test current of 2 A (2·In).
Under Fault inception you can specify the phase angle at which the fault is to be triggered. If DC-offset has
been activated, a transient event is simulated with a decaying DC element.
The Ignore nominal characteristics, Search interval, and Search Resolution settings are relevant for the
search test. These parameters will be described in more detail later in this chapter.
You can select the time to be assessed after the test under Time reference. This is either the time between
Fault inception and tripping (actual trip time), or the time between starting and tripping (trip time setting).
Set Extended zones active to define whether these zones are activated or deactivated during the test.
Deactivated extended zones will then not be displayed on the impedance plane.
The Switch off at zero-crossing function should always be activated. As a result, the CMC test device will
only disconnect the test currents following tripping in the corresponding natural zero-crossing, similar to what
is actually happening in a circuit breaker when the arc between the switch poles extinguishes, thus avoiding
current jumps.
You can define a Test Point either in polar coordinates (|Z|, Phi) or in cartesian coordinates (R, X).
Alternatively, you can use the cursor to place a Test Point anywhere on the impedance plane. Use the
ribbon to append the shot to the list. This procedure applies for each of the selected Fault Types.
In our example the reaches and trip times of the zones are to be tested. This is done by setting the points
relative to the zones on the line angle. The shots are at 94% and 106% of the relevant zone (outside the
tolerance range).
If you select the Follow line angle change option, the test points will be adapted automatically if the line
angle changes in the Test Object.
The Check Test is a more convenient option for testing zone reaches with respect to nominal settings and
specified tolerances. You can define a Check Line along the required test section. The test points are
automatically placed at the intersections between this line and the zone limits (1% outside the tolerance
range). The Check Line is specified by means of an Origin, an Angle, and a Length. Alternatively, you can
draw this line by pressing and holding down the left mouse button on the impedance plane. You then click
Append Check line in the ribbon to add the line to the list.
Click Sequence in the ribbon for a quick way to generate a set of Check Lines with common origin and
different angles.
As in the Check Test, you can define a Search Line in a Search Test. However, in contrast to Check
Lines, no fixed test points are defined at the intersections between the Search Line and the zone
boundaries. The boundary between the zones is determined automatically here, with a search algorithm
being used for this purpose. The accuracy required for this can be specified on the Settings tab under
Search Resolution. If Ignore nominal characteristics is selected here, the search algorithm is modified to
the effect that the search for the zone boundaries starts at the origin of the lines. The search is carried out
with the predefined search interval. However, the results of the search are not assessed.
Click Quick in the ribbon to define three search lines at once (0°, 90°, and line angle).
The tests carried out on the impedance plane can also be represented in a Z/t diagram.
However, please note that only one line at a time can be displayed after a Check or a Search Test.
To switch from one state to the next, you can define various transition conditions. These can be binary
trigger signals, for example, manual interventions by the user (pressing of a button in response to a prompt),
or simply the expiry of a set time. A trigger leaves the state in which it is defined.
The multiple configuration options supported by the State Sequencer test module will be described in this
chapter based on an example test of the "manual close" function of a distance protection relay.
A B
Although this function is known by many different names ("manual close" detection, "switch on to fault", etc.),
its technical function is always the same.
A grading factor of 85% ... 90% is usually used for the first zone in case of distance protection. This means
that the busbar in station B is already in zone Z2. Therefore, in the event of a fault at the end of the line, no
tripping would be possible in quick time t1.
Should it happen that the line between A and B was out of service and grounded, the following problem may
occur when the power supply is connected: High fault currents occur exactly at the moment of starting which
are not detected in station B. This is often attributable to a forgotten ground electrode in station B. However,
because the fault is outside Z1 it can only be disconnected at t2 subject to a time delay.
The "manual close" function can solve this problem: The "CB close" command activates extended zone Z1E
or Overreach (represented by the dashed line) for a time which can be set as a parameter in the protection
relay. This provides a means of disconnecting a fault of this type in quick time. In our example, the reach of
the extended zone has been set to 125% of the line length and the time during which the zone is active is
1 s. Once this time has elapsed the zone is deactivated again and distance protection is resumed with its
graded zones.
The seven states required for the test are shown in the diagram below. The transition conditions appear in
green.
1 CB Open 1 V = 0; I = 0
Manual Close = 1
2 CB Close 1 V = Vn; I = 0
t = 0.8 s
3 Fault 1 ZF = 100% · ZAB
Trip = 1
4 CB Open 2 = 1
Manual Close = 1
5 CB Close 2 = 2
t = 1.2 s
6 Fault 2 = 3
Trip = 1
7 CB Open 3 = 1
t=1s
Once we insert the State Sequencer test module in the OCC file, we have to look at OMICRON's Ohm's law
first. Then, we will describe the test module in detail.
All defined states are listed in the Table View. User-defined names can also be assigned here. The current
and voltage outputs to be applied during the test are also visible. You can use the buttons highlighted on the
screenshot to switch between the individual states. You can also add new states or delete existing states at
any time.
The Detail View is where you configure the signals (analog and binary) of the state selected in each case.
The available set modes are the same as those in the QuickCMC test module.
In the first state, the open line is simulated. The current and voltage outputs are, therefore, zero. The
"Manual close" command provides the trigger. An overview of all trigger conditions is shown below.
In the second state, the line is closed for 800 ms at no-load. In other words, a nominal voltage is output but
the currents remain at zero.
In this state, a fault is simulated at 100% of the line length. To do this, change the Set Mode to Z%-I const.
and configure a three-pole fault at 100% line length and line angle. The trigger condition is in this case the
open command.
You can define the four remaining states by copying the existing ones and modifying them accordingly.
However, you do need to increase the time delay for fault inception (state "CB Close 1") from 800 ms to
1.2 s.
The trigger conditions for each of the states are shown here. State 7, not shown here, is just a post-fault
condition (line disconnected) for 1 second.
The entire test sequence is shown in the Time Signal View. Once the test is complete, the binary signals
recorded are also displayed here.
The Autoreclosure test module provides a means of testing a sequence of this type. It supports two test
modes, each of which has up to 15 reclosure cycles (AR cycles):
> Unsuccessful Sequence
> Successful Sequence
The operative time, the dead time, and the reset time are shown in the diagram below. However, the actual
times are defined by the manufacturer of the protection device.
Fault
Start
Trip
CB-close
Dead time
Once the test module has been added to the appropriate group, it is opened automatically.
You have to start by defining the binary inputs in the local Hardware Configuration. The protection relay's
Trip command and CB CLOSE command in particular are required for this test.
Note: If both the Unsuccessful Sequence and the Successful Sequence tests are enabled, the
Successful Sequence test is carried out first.
On this tab you define the trigger conditions for the various measurements. Regarding the dead time, please
note that this will start with a rising or falling edge of the trip signals, dependent upon the relay manufacturer.
To benefit from the advantages of a common Test Object and a common Hardware Configuration, we
recommend to use these test modules in a single OCC file.
This chapter describes how to define the Test Object and the Hardware Configuration for a differential
test.
Precisely defined
protection zone with
D absolute selectivity
D Three-phase differential
protection (simplified)
D
D
≥1 Trip
(OR)
The principle of differential protection is based on current comparison. It can be used to protect
transformers, generators, motors, lines, or busbars.
The differential protection zone is located precisely between the current transformers. This ensures absolute
selectivity. Tripping only occurs in response to internal faults. Protection remains stable in the face of
external faults.
In the case of a transformer differential protection the protection system needs to introduce some
adaptations in order to properly compare both sides since the currents are transformed by the winding ratio,
the vector group may transform the phase currents from one side to other phases on the other side, and
usually zero-sequence currents on one side are suppressed (e.g. by a delta winding) thus ‘missing’ in the
CTs on the other side. This adaptation is controlled by related relay settings, and the test currents generated
by the test set must behave in exactly this expected way. This is achieved by settings in the related RIO
block, used by the Differential test modules
Idiff = Ip - Is
ID>> Characteristic
Sum
Tripping
Blocking
Saturation
Tap changer /
Leakage
ID>
Magnetization
Ibias = Ip + Is
The operating characteristic represents the ratio between stabilizing current (Ibias) and differential current
(Idiff), which causes tripping.
The characteristic has to be configured so that it is always greater than the total faults occurring (e.g.,
magnetization, scatter, etc.).
For a complete definition of the biasing behavior the formula which defines the generation of the biasing
quantity is relevant. This depends on the relay type or may be set in the relay, and therefore needs to be
selected accordingly in the Test Object.
OMICRON's Ohm's law stipulates that all data has to be entered in the Test Object as a first step. The fields
for the RIO function Device are completed in the usual way. However, the fields for the voltage and current
transformers are only needed to test additional protection functions (such as definite time emergency
overcurrent protection, for example) The Advanced Differential test modules use the RIO function
Differential in addition to the RIO function Device.
In the Function menu you can add the RIO function Differential by selecting Add.... Two options are
available but we are not going to consider the single-phase test module in our example, therefore, you
should click the Edit... button to call up the Test Object definition.
Note: The Edit (single phase)... button is used for single phase electro mechanical differential relays
only. It is used for the Differential test module. However, the following chapters refer to three
phase differential relays.
42 MVA
10.5 kV
160 MVA not connected
231 kV
118 MVA
115.5 kV
On this tab you need to make a number of data entries associated with the Protected Object. In our
example, this is a YYnD5 transformer. The corresponding data can be seen on the screenshot. The
following entry fields are listed:
> Protected Object: The protected object can be a transformer, a generator, a motor, or a busbar. This
selection determines the functionality of the subsequent entry fields.
> Number of Windings: If a transformer has been selected as the protected object, you can specify here
whether it has two or three windings.
> Winding/Leg Name: You can enter a name of your choice for each winding here.
> Voltage: The transformer nominal voltage of the corresponding winding.
> Power: The transformer nominal power of the corresponding winding. Make sure that the units are
correct for the rating of the transformer. If mega voltamps than use a capital M.
> Vector Group: Enter the vector group for the individual windings here using the letters Y (star), D
(delta), and Z (zigzag). You also need to specify the phase offset identifier for the secondary winding
and, if there is one, the tertiary winding.
> Starpoint Grounding: Specify which starpoints are grounded here. This is of course only possible if the
corresponding winding is star-connected (Y or Z).
> Current: The current of the relevant protected object is entered here. This value is calculated
automatically.
Note: If you wish to test a YY transformer, it is always assumed that the transformer has a
compensation winding, thus suppressing the transformation of the zero-sequence current.
600/1
Please refer to the relevant relay manual for information about which Ibias Calculation the protection relay
uses. A description of each type appears in the Help, as shown below.
Fault currents cease to be output for the relevant test point at the latest when the Test Max time elapses.
The Delay Time is the time between two test points.
The values of Idiff> and Idiff>> respectively are defined for the Diff Current Settings.
The Reference Winding is used to convert all measured quantities to a single winding.
The Reference Current is the current referenced by the Differential Current Settings and, subsequently,
by the characteristic also. This is either the CT nominal current or the protected object's nominal current.
You have to take the Diff Time Settings from the current protection relay parameter settings and enter them
here.
If Zero Sequence Elimination has been activated in the protection relay to be tested, you have to configure
the corresponding settings in the Test Object.
In our example, the tertiary winding is not connected, so the equivalent circuit diagram looks like this:
42 MVA
10.5 kV
160 MVA 2400/1
400/1 231 kV
not connected
600/1
118 MVA
115.5 kV
For nominal current on the primary side the currents will be:
42 MVA
10.5 kV
160 MVA 2400/1
400/1 231 kV
not connected
400 A
800 A
600/1
118 MVA
115.5 kV
1.00 A 1.33 A
D
For nominal current on the secondary side the currents will be:
42 MVA
10.5 kV
160 MVA 2400/1
400/1 231 kV
not connected
295 A
590 A
600/1
118 MVA
115.5 kV
0.74 A 0.98 A
D
2 3
1
IP 1 I0 IL1 IL2 IL3 IS 0
3
1 0
To stop false tripping of the differential relay in response to a single-pole external fault, you need to use what
is known as computational zero sequence elimination.
YD Interposing Transformer
This diagram shows how a YD interposing transformer works. Interposing transformers compensate the
effects of the zero sequence as well as the effects of vector groups. This makes the use of single phase
differential relays possible.
On this tab you define the operating characteristic for the protection device. The characteristic can comprise
one or a number of linear elements.
The values for Idiff> and Idiff>> are taken from the previous tab automatically.
Every line is defined by a Start point and an End point. These two elements have to be entered as a pair of
values comprising Ibias and Idiff. If the Auto-init Start point function is used, when a new line is created,
the end point of the previous line is automatically used as the Start point. The slope of each line is
calculated and displayed.
The start and end points have to be calculated based on the relay parameters.
IDiff
Line equations:
I : IDiff 0.25 IBias
I-Diff>> II : IDiff 0.5 IBias 2.5
P3 (?/6)
P2:
I II
5
0.
0.25 IBias 0.5 IBias 2.5
=
m
II:
0.25 IBias 0.5 IBias 1.25
1.25 0.25 IBias
IBias 5
Use Ibias = 5 in I:
IDiff 0.25 IBias
5
= 0.2 0.25 5 1.25
I: m P2 (?/?)
I-Diff>
P3:
P1 (0/0) 2.5 IBias Use IDiff = 6 in II
6 0.5 IBias 1.25
P2 (5/1.25) 7.25 0.5 IBias
P3 (14.5/6)
IBias 14.5
The graph shows the operating characteristic of the SIEMENS 7UT613. The characteristic is defined by two
line segments and the predefined set values "Idiff>" and "Idiff>>". The line segments are defined by
parameters which can be set in the protection relay. In our example, these are:
> Segment I:
- Start point: Ibias = 0 · In | Idiff = 0 · In
- Slope: m = 0.25
> Segment II:
- Start point: Ibias = 2.5 · In | Idiff = 0 · In
- Slope: m = 0.5
You have to use the line equations to calculate the remaining points defining the characteristic. The figure
shows the calculations you need to do this.
Note: When defining the operating characteristic you do not have to define any line segments for the
set values "Idiff>" and "Idiff>>". These parameters are considered automatically and shown in
the Test View when the operating characteristic is tested.
P1 put in I:
0.25 0.3 0.67 a
a 0.25 0.2 0.05
I: IDiff 0.3 IBias 0.05
P2:
P2 put in I:
IDiff 0.3 IBias 0.05
P1 (0,67/0,25) 0.3 2.5 0.05 0.8
P2 (2,5/?)
P3:
I-Diff>
P2 put in II:
0.8 0.7 2.5 b
0,67 2,5 IBias
b 0.8 1.75 0.95
P1 (0,67/0,25) II: IDiff 0.7 IBias 0.95
P2 (2,5/0,8)
Usage of I-Diff unres.:
P3 (9,93/6) I-Diff unres. put in II (here for
example 6):
6 0.7 IBias 0.95
IBias 6.95 / 0.7 9.93
The graph shows the operating characteristic of the SIEMENS 7UT86. The characteristic is defined by two
line segments and the predefined set values "I-Diff>" and "I-Diff unres.". The line segments are defined by
parameters which can be set in the protection relay. In our example, these are:
> Segment I:
- Intersection point: Ibias = 0.67 · In | Idiff = 0.25 · In
- Slope: m = 0.3
> Segment II:
- Intersection point: Ibias = 2.5 · In | Idiff = ? · In
- Slope: m = 0.7
You have to use the line equations to calculate the remaining points defining the characteristic. The figure
shows the calculations you need to do this.
Note: When defining the operating characteristic you do not have to define any line segments for the
set values "Idiff>" and "Idiff>>". These parameters are considered automatically and shown in
the Test View when the operating characteristic is tested.
P2:
.7
I: m =
=0
Use P1 in II:
m
0.25 0.3 0.125 a
III:
P3 (10.56/6)
IBias 10.56
The graph shows the operating characteristic of the AREVA P633. The characteristic is defined by three line
segments and the predefined set values "Idiff>" and "Idiff>>". The line segments are defined by parameters
which can be set in the protection relay. In our example, these are:
> Segment I:
- Start point: Ibias = 0 · In | Idiff = 0 · In
- Slope: m=2
> Segment II:
- Start point: Intersection of segment I and "Idiff>"
- Slope: m = 0.3
- End point: Intersection with Ibias = 4 · In
> Segment III:
- Start point: Intersection of segment II and Ibias = 4 · In
- Slope: m = 0.7
You have to use the line equations to calculate the remaining points defining the characteristic. The figure
shows the calculations you need to do this.
Note: When defining the operating characteristic you do not have to define any line segments for the
set values "Idiff>" and "Idiff>>". These parameters are considered automatically when the
operating characteristic is tested.
Here you seen the benefit of using test templates from the Protection Testing Library PTL: here, these relay-
specific characteristics calculations are already included as formulas in the Test Object (the so-called XRIO
Converter), so you only need to enter the native relay settings.
On this tab you define the characteristic for harmonic restraint. You have to start by specifying which
harmonic component this setting is to apply for. The characteristic is defined in the same way as the
operating characteristic for the differential function.
Stabilizing of the 5th harmonic prevents false tripping of the transformer differential protection in the event of
over-excitation.
Once you have defined the Test Object, you have to configure the settings for the Hardware Configuration
in accordance with OMICRON's Ohm's law.
Six currents but no voltages are required for the example selected here, with one three-phase system for the
primary side and another for the secondary side.
Current system A is configured for the primary side and current system B for the secondary side.
Note: Currents on the high voltage side of the transformer are named as primary currents and on the
low voltage side as secondary currents. But both current systems are injected as secondary
values by the CMC.
In practice the OPEN command has to be entered and tested for all windings here. However, for reasons of
transparency, only the Trip command is used in our example.
You need to add a Diff Configuration test module to the OCC file to test the differential function.
This screenshot shows the Test View. The protected object's single-phase equivalent circuit diagram is on
the right-hand side. In our example, an external fault has been set on the primary side, which draws power
from the secondary side.
The Binary Out tab can be seen on the left-hand side. However, as no binary outputs were defined in the
global Hardware Configuration, this list is blank. If binary outputs had been defined, they could be activated
and deactivated here.
1. The Test Time has to be set to leave the tester with enough time to check all relevant measured values
in the protection relay to be tested. In our example, set the time to 60 s. If no manual assessments are
made by the tester during this time, the test is terminated automatically and assessed as Failed.
2. In the event of an OPEN command while the test is running, the test will automatically be assessed as
Failed.
3. You can set the fault location and the infeed location here.
Note: In our example, the fault has to be set on the secondary side.
In our example, three times the reference current is defined as the fault current in phase L1.
The corresponding currents on both sides of the transformer are calculated automatically by the test module
and shown on the right-hand side of the screen.
Once the test has started, you have to read out the latest current values on the protection relay and enter
them on the Test tab. If these values are correct, you must assess the test manually with Passed.
If you need to, you can define a Prefault on this tab. It is also where you specify the necessary Trigger
Conditions. Under Test Method you can select whether the nominal characteristic should be ignored during
a Search Test. This function is similar to the corresponding option in the Advanced Distance test module.
With the Shot Test you can define the individual test points either directly by clicking with the mouse in the
operating characteristic diagram or by entering the coordinates in the Idiff and Ibias fields.
A characteristic can be tested by placing one test shot above and one below the tolerance band at the start
and the end of each segment of the characteristic. Also the tolerance overlapping of the different segments
of the characteristic has to be considered.
You also have to specify the fault loop to be tested under Fault Type.
When the fault loop is changed from L-E to L-L or L1-L2-L3, the shape of the operating characteristic
changes dependent upon the type of protection relay.
Because of this, the test points have to be redefined – best done using a copy of the module from 15.3.
With the Search Test you can add search lines which are defined by their bias current. During the test a
search algorithm will be used on every search line to determine the exact position of the characteristic. The
Resolution of this test can be defined in this tab as well.
On the Factors tab you can define current and time tolerances that differ from those in the Test Object. In
our example, however, the settings in the Test Object are sufficient.
You can define a Prefault on this tab. It is also where you can specify the trigger conditions.
A t/Idiff diagram will later appear on the Test tab. This diagram is defined by the test line on the Ibias/Idiff
plane. We advise you not to change the default setting for the Test line slope.
To test the trip times, place one test point above the Idiff> pick-up and one above the Idiff>> pick-up.
The General tab features an option to activate a Postfault without harmonics. It is also where you specify
the Trigger Conditions.
With the Shot Test you can set your test points either by clicking the test plane on the right hand side or by
entering the differential and the harmonic current manually.
You also have to specify the ordinal number of the harmonic to be tested. In our example, the 2nd harmonic
is to be tested.
With the Search Test you can set search lines which are defined by their differential current. During the test
a search algorithm will be used on every search line to determine the exact position of the characteristic.
The search resolution can be defined in this tab as well.
The RelaySimTest software offers simulation based application oriented testing methods. In contrast to a
parameter test such a system test focuses on the behaviour of the relay with respect to the power
system where it is used. For this purpose a fault scenario is calculated based on the grid simulation. The
resulting voltages and currents for the relay under test are used to find out if its behaviour fits to the power
system.
The voltages and currents can be calculated for different relay locations inside the grid. Hence it is possible
to test a protection system that consists of several distributed relays for example a line differential protection.
For this reason RelaySimTest can control several distributed CMCs at the same time.
The RelaySimTest software is independent from the Test Universe software but is present on the TU start
page if installed.
The System under Test menu of RelaySimTest contains the parameters of the bays and relays under test
as well as the submenus Protected line and the Protection concept.
To describe for example the Protection concept of a distance protection for an application oriented test, it is
not necessary to specify its zone shapes. It’s enough to define the trip times and the reaches of the zones.
These two parameters characterize the nominal behaviour of the relay in case of a line fault.
The time grading of the screenshot above fits to the distance protection of the training.
The Model power system tab of the Test cases menu offers the possibility to specify the grid where the
relay under test is implemented. For instance to perform a time grading test the infeeds as well as the
successor and predecessor lines of the protected line have to be modelled. This has to be done by drawing
the grid topology and defining parameters like line impedances, infeed power and so on. Afterwards test
points can be placed in the different distance zones to test the time grading.
You can add a fault to the grid with the Design test scenario tab and vary its parameters like fault type,
inception angle, fault resistance or its location.
The more details of the real grid are modelled, the more the test signals correspond to real signals. Hence it
is useful to model additional elements like additional infeeds, loads, parallel lines and whatever exists in the
real grid. All these elements and parameters influence the behaviour of the protection system.
With RelaySimTest you can analyse if your protection is able to deal with such influences, therefore it is a
powerful tool for system based testing.