Jurnal MHCLN Peplau
Jurnal MHCLN Peplau
Jurnal MHCLN Peplau
KM
ERRITT Mental Health Consultation-Liaison Service, Lyell McEwin Health Service, Elizabeth Vale,
SA, Australia N
ICHOLAS
P
ROCTER School of Nursing and Midwifery, University of South Australia, City East Campus, Adelaide,
SA, Australia
ABSTRACT This paper examines the mental health consultation–liaison nursing (MHCLN) role and links
this to the interpersonal relations theory of nurse theorist Hildegard Peplau. The paper argues that, as
mental health nursing care around the world is increasingly focused upon meaningful therapeutic
engagement, the role of the MHCLN is important in helping to reduce distressing symptoms, reduce the
stigma for seeking help for mental health problems and enhancing mental health literacy among
generalist nurses. The paper presents a small case exemplar to demonstrate interpersonal relations
theory as an engagement process, providing patients with methodologies which allow them to work
through the internal dissonance that exists in relation to their adjustment to changes in life roles pre-
cipitated by physical illness. This dissonance can be seen in the emergence of anxiety, depression and
abnormal/psychogenic illness behaviours. This paper concludes arguing for considerable effort being
given to the nurse–patient relationship that allows for the patient having freedom to use strategies that
may help resolve the dissonance that exists.
Keywords: consultation–liaison nursing; interpersonal relations; mental health; Peplau
I I NTRODUCTION
n that contemporary community clinical consultation settings and it is liaison important ser- vices ensure
mental health patients have an active and meaningful voice in their treatment and care planning. This
means ensuring greater emphasis on the valued involvement of patients through dialogue and information
exchange with clini- cians. At the same time there is growing interest
158
NN
C Conceptualising the
functional role of mental health consultation–liaison nurse
C
NN
systems and structures as key drivers of contem-
de-personalised by the health system (Barker, porary
mental health care. There is a now a global
2009; Jones, 1998). The emphasis is, in this consensus
that mental health care should be
sense, on the physical, potentially reducing the
undertaken in partnership and collaboration with
patient to a collection of systems and ignoring mental
health patients – no matter where they
the holism and the person or patient’s journey are or
where they live – and in the least restric-
to this point in time. Australian studies have tive
environment (World Psychiatric Association,
shown that whilst depression, anxiety or psy- 2009). At
the same time there is a vision of a
chological distress is identified in patients with seamless
and connected care system which is con-
chronic physical illness, 75% do not receive sumer
focussed and recovery oriented (National
psychological treatment or counselling (Kelly & Mental
Health Policy, 2008).
Turner, 2009). At the same time there is evidence of mar-
Clearly, there is cause for examining the deeper
ginalisation, oppression and incarceration of
structures of engagement in mental health between people
with a mental illness in certain societies
clinicians and patients to advance recovery in (BBC
News, 2009) and in industrialised nations.
mental health. It is for this reason that the authors While
mental disorders represent 15% of the
draw upon the Peplau Model, as the underlying total
disease burden, people with severe men-
theoretical construct used by Hildegard Peplau tal
disorders in low to middle income countries
emphasises the crux of the therapeutic relation- often fail
to receive adequate mental health care
ships as a partnership between the nurse and the (World
Health Organisation/Wonca, 2008).
patient, and with it a notion of shared humanity A recent
UK Health Care Commission report
between the nurse and the patient (Peplau, 1952, (for
example) reveals that of 27,000 people
1991, 1997). Whilst the model has its genesis using
mental health services, 15% said they did
in psychodynamic and psychodramatic theories not have
enough say in care decisions and 44%
giving rise to looking more deeply at the reasons only had
a say to some extent. The Health Care
for individual thought and behaviour (Sullivan,
Commission quizzed 300,000 patients and found
1953), it has been long utilised by mental health that most
wanted more meaningful input into
nurses in clinical practice (Barker, 1993, 2009; their care,
especially those with mental illness.
Price, 1998). Barker (2009) in particular empha- Similar
sentiment has been expressed elsewhere
sised the person rather than the problem to be the in the
UK (BBC News, 2004) and in Australia
focus of mental health nursing. This underlines (Mental
Health Council of Australia, 2006). In
that, according to Peplau, the therapeutic rela- addition
and contrary to recommended national
tionship is a central platform of mental health standards,
less than half of mental health service
nursing practice. Shattell, Starr, and Thomas users
surveyed in the UK had access to crisis care,
(2007) adapted Peplau’s theoretical approach to and only
have had been given or offered a written
described patient’s views of the therapeutic rela- care plan
(Health Care Commission UK, 2008).
tionship as being expressed in three figural themes: Such
conditions are experienced by patients as
‘relate to me’, ‘know me as a person’ and ‘get to
de-humanising and de-personalising, placing
the solution’. The therapeutic relationship is by its
interpersonal relations at the fringe rather than
nature and scope primarily about the creation of a as
central interactions between patient, carer and
shared experience. mental health professional.
The next section outlines steps taken to review People
with co-existing physical and mental
literature pertaining to the functional role of the health
problems are also at risk of marginalisa-
MHCLN informed by Peplau’s nursing theory. tion.
People with chronic physical illnesses also
The utilisation of this theory in multi-morbidity
experience a sense of being de-humanised and
is then discussed.
Volume 34, Issue 2, February/March 2010
CC
NN
159
CC
NN
Michael K Merritt and Nicholas Procter
M
ETHOD
T
HE MENTAL HEALTH CONSULTATION
–
an emerging emergency mental health nursing model within emergency departments (Wand, LIAISON
NURSE
2004; Wand & Happell, 2001) alternatively The MHCLN
has become an established part
called the ‘emergency department mental health of
contemporary nursing in Australia (Sharrock,
team’. These roles show the advanced mental Grigg,
Happell, Keeble-Devlin, & Jennings,
health nursing development that has been accel- 2006),
the United Kingdom (Cullum, Tucker,
erating in recent years with some of these roles Todd, &
Brayne, 2007), Canada (Brinkman,
being developed into ‘mental health nurse prac- Hunks,
Bruggencate, & Clelland, 2009) and
titioner’ positions (Wand, White, & Patching, United
States (Yakimo, Kurlowicz, & Murray,
2007). Further, McNamara, Bryant, Forster, 2004). The
role is variously described as ‘psy-
Sharrock, and Happell (2008) and Sharrock, chiatric
consultation–liaison nursing’ (Sharrock
Bryant, McNamara, Forster, and Happell (2008) &
Happell, 2000; Yakimo et al., 2004), ‘liaison
describe the outcomes of a survey of CL nurses
psychiatric nursing’ (Cullum et al., 2007; Ryrie,
within Australia, which provides valuable data
160
CC
NN
Volume 34, Issue 2, February/March 2010
C
N
C
N Conceptualising the
functional role of mental health consultation–liaison nurse
C
N
about demographics, role description, prepara-
patient uses these strategies to provide a reduc- tion,
support and role satisfaction of these mental
tion of or resolution of the internal dissonance/ health
nurses. These show the developments that
psychological distress. have impacted upon the role
unfolding elsewhere
Within the development of the nurse– patient across
Australia.
or therapeutic relationship, the MHCLN provides many roles. Peplau emphasised six of T
HEORETICAL UNDERPINNINGS OF
these roles: MENTAL HEALTH NURSING MODEL
C
N
161
CC
NN
Michael K Merritt and Nicholas Procter
actions to be understood using the language and
to Emergency Departments and that total health
experience of the patient.
expenditure can be 4.5-times higher for these The utility of
this model has been in the cre-
individuals. Further, they can have longer hospi- ation of
a therapeutic relationship that allows for
talisations, increased symptom burden and higher the
identification of anxiety, depression and other
mortality and morbidity outcomes. An integral
psychogenic symptomatology by the patient in
part of this burden is associated with a worsening the
supportive environment provided by the
quality of life. The importance of the appropriate
MHCLN, and then the patient having freedom
psychological care of medical patients has been to use
strategies that may help resolve the disso-
emphasised by a report from the joint working nance that
exists. The overall aim is in a directive
party of the Royal College of Physicians and the approach
in which there is a ‘forward movement
Royal College of Psychiatrists (2003). of personality in
the direction of creative, con-
Recent Australian Institute of Health and Welfare
structive, productive, personal and community
(2008) data suggests that chronic respiratory illness
living’ (Peplau in Gastmans, 1998).
affects 4.3% of people aged 20–44 and 8% aged over 65. Chronic heart disease affects 7.3% of those A
FOCUS FOR MENTAL HEALTH
V
IGNETTE was 28%. A report by the Academy of
Medical
Jason1 was a 62-year-old man referred to the Royal
Colleges (AMRC) and Royal College of
MHCLN led clinic by a Cardiac Rehabilitation
Psychiatrists (RCP) (2009) indicates that patients
Nurse for assessment of depression and anxiety with
chronic diseases and a mental health disorder
after being admitted with angina. Jason and his such as
depression were twice as likely to present
wife Maxine had been touring remote and outback
1 Not his real name.
162
CC
NN
Volume 34, Issue 2, February/March 2010
C
N
C
N Conceptualising the
functional role of mental health consultation–liaison nurse
C
N
South Australia in a mobile home at time of his latest
Jason and his son had similar personality styles and
angina attack. They had been pursuing this lifestyle
problem solving methodologies – which followed of
roving and rambling for the past 10 years. He
a need to fix things and do it my way fashion – this was
initially medically assessed in hospital, where he
was also corroborated by Maxine who was included
reported a change in his sense of self, a feeling of
in all follow-up sessions. Over several one-to-one loss of
control and a general nervousness and inabil-
sessions with the MHCLN, Jason identified ways ity to
make decisions with a negative outlook on
of improving his relation with his son by exploring future
and a reduction in his quality of life. Further
different problem solving techniques – some of he
reported preoccupation with issues, increased
this through role play. Maxine was also provided
worrying, poor sleep and feeling ‘anxious, nervous
with support and encouraged to voice her own and edgy’.
His wife agreed with this self assessment,
anxieties around recent events and how she saw and both
felt that there ‘was no depression’, more
Jason’s progress. an ‘adjustment to life issues’. Further
assessment
At finish of follow-up, Jason and Maxine revealed that
Jason had recently had an argument
reported the resolution of anxiety provoking issues with
his son about his grandson’s birthday party
that had been identified and explored above, and which
had increased his anxiety and distress.
were just waiting for clearance from the cardiolo- The
MHCLN met with Jason. The conversa-
gist to resume their travelling. In using Peplau’s tion
focused on Jason’s reported anxiety feelings
theory, the MHCLN had fulfilled many roles and
provided education in verbal and written
including stranger, resource, teacher, counsellor, formats
about anxiety, causation and perpetuat-
surrogate, companion, advocate and leader in the ing
factors using his symptoms and self-story as
development, establishment and continuation guideposts.
Through further exploration of recent
to resolution of the nurse–patient or therapeutic events,
Jason identified three main areas which
relationship. The focus was on developing a shared
underlay his anxiety – his cardiac condition and
experience where the client was the centre of focus newly
diagnosed aortic regurgitation and cardio-
and maintained control of the relationship. The myopathy,
loss of control of and interruption of
ability for the MHCLN to provide support in current
lifestyle and relationship issues with his
both hospital and community settings, expands son. The
ability of Jason to identify the underly-
the vision of the role and provides a broader scope ing
causes for his anxiety/nervousness had a clear
for continuity of care, especially where services effect on
his outlook regarding current situation,
may not exist and where patients do not meet with the
development of a more positive outlook
entry criteria into existing community mental about the
future. Further follow-up appointments
health services. McNaughton (2005) highlighted were
organised at the caravan park they were stay-
the naturalistic use of Peplau’s theory in home vis- ing so
ongoing monitoring could be put in place
iting/community follow-up of patients. and future surgery
could be organised.
The MHCLN provided information and edu- Follow-up
in the community lasted 5 months
cation to ward and cardiac rehabilitation nursing until
after surgery. The MHCLN worked with
staff around Jason’s anxiety/internal dissonance Jason on
identified problems, providing further
and strategies in identification, exploration and education
and support regarding surgery and
supporting patient’s experiences. Through this outcomes
in conjunction with specialist cardiac
process, the MHCLN was able to support the
rehabilitation nurses, which included a likely time
patient’s transition through primary, secondary frame in
which he and Maxine could continue their
and tertiary healthcare systems through specialist lifestyle
and therefore the transition to being more
advocacy, collaboration and liaison with nursing, in
control of life. During exploration of relation-
medical and other allied health specialists as well ship
issues with son, it soon became apparent that
as the patient’s primary care general practitioner.
Volume 34, Issue 2, February/March 2010
C
N
163
CC
NN
Michael K Merritt and Nicholas Procter
C
LINICAL LEADERSHIP
C
ONCLUSION
measures specifically addressing phase specific treatments and strategies for the patient’s narrative
Peplau’s interpersonal relations theory is by its nature
to unfold. The emphasis of research should there- and
scope an engagement process that is about
fore be applied and interventionist to help ensure
164
CC
NN
Volume 34, Issue 2, February/March 2010
C Conceptualising the
functional role of mental health consultation–liaison nurse
C
NN
that the MHCLN is an enabler of interventions
depression: A randomized control trial. Age and to
prevent secondary disability associated with
Ageing, 36(4), 436–442. physical or mental health
problems. Over time the MHCLN can make informed evidence- based clinical decisions by ensuring that
previous research is critically reviewed and integrated into decision making and clinical education.
C
N DuBrin, A. J., Dalglish, C., & Miller, P. (2006).
Leadership (2nd Asia-Pacific ed.). Milton, QLD: John Wiley. Gastmans, C. (1998). Interpersonal relations in
nursing: A philosophical-ethical analysis of the work of Hildegard E. Peplau. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 28(6),
1312–1319. References
Health Care Commission UK. (2008). Health Care Academy of
Medical Royal Colleges (AMRC), &
Commission: Survey shows steady improvements in Royal
College of Psychiatrists (RCP). (2009).
community mental health services. Health Care No health
without mental health: The support-
Commission. Retrieved September 17, 2008, ing evidence
(Report by Academy of Medical
from http://healthcarecommission.org.uk Royal Colleges and
Royal College of Psychiatry).
Hicks, S. (1989). The psychiatric nurse in liaison London:
Academy of Medical Royal Colleges.
psychiatry. Australian and New Zealand Journal Anderson,
G., & Hicks, S. (1986). The clinical
of Psychiatry, 23, 89–96. nurse specialist-role, overview and
future pros-
Jones, P. (1998). Hodges’ health career – Care pects. Australian
Nurses Journal, 15(8), 26–53.
domains – Model, nursing – Art or science? Australian
Institute of Health and Welfare. (2008).
Retrieved October 4, 2009, from http://www.p- Australia’s
Health 2008, Cat no. AUS 99.
jones.demon.co.uk/holsci.html Canberra: Author.
Kelly, B. J., & Turner, J. (2009). Depression in Barker, P.
(1993, March 17). The Peplau legacy.
advanced physical illness: Diagnostic and treat- Nursing Times,
89(11), 48–51.
ment issues. Medical Journal of Australia, 190(7), Barker,
P. (2009). Psychiatric mental health nursing:
S90–S93. The craft of caring (2nd ed.). London: Hodder
Lipowski, Z. (1981). Liaison psychiatry, liai- Arnold.
son nursing and behavioural medicine. BBC News. (2004,
August 4). Psychiatric services
Comprehensive Psychiatry, 22(6), 554–561. failed me.
Retrieved September 17, 2008, from
MacHale, S. (2002). Managing depression in phys-
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/3531302.stm
ical illness. Advances in Psychiatric Treatment, 8, BBC
News. (2009, May 8). ‘Prayer camps’ chain
297–306. mentally ill. Retrieved October 2, 2009, from
McNamara, P., Bryant, J., Forster, J., Sharrock,
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/8040057.stm
J., & Happell, B. (2008). Exploratory study Brinkman, K.,
Hunks, D., Bruggencate, G., &
of mental health consultation–liaison nursing Clelland, S.
(2009). Evaluation of a new mental
in Australia: Part 2. Preparation, support and health liaison role
in the Rocky Mountain
role satisfaction. International Journal of Mental House,
Alberta: A Canadian story. International
Health Nursing, 17(3), 189–196. Journal of Mental Health
Nursing, 18, 42–52.
McNaughton, D. B. (2005). A naturalistic test of Chiplin, J., &
Geraghty, M. (1990). Psychiatric
Peplau’s theory in home visiting. Public Health liaison nursing:
Mental health needs in a burns
Nursing, 22(5), 429–438. unit. Nursing Praxis in New Zealand,
5(2), 15–18.
Mental Health Council of Australia. (2006). Time Crowe, M.,
Carlyle, D., & Farmar, R. (2008).
for service: Solving Australia’s mental health crisis, Clinical
formulation for mental health nursing
Canberra, ACT: Author. practice. Journal of Psychiatric and
Mental Health
Meredith, L., & Weatherhead, R. (1980, June). Nursing, 15,
800–807.
Psychiatric consultation liaison nursing: 18 Cullum, S.,
Tucker, S., Todd, C., & Brayne,
months later. The Lamp, 37(6), 19–20. C. (2007). Effectiveness
of liaison psychiat-
National Mental Health Policy . (2008). ric nursing in older
medical inpatients with
Australian Government Department of Health
C
N
165
CC
NN
Michael K Merritt and Nicholas Procter
& Aging (2009). Canberra: Commonwealth
Sharrock, J., & Happell, B. (2001a). An overview of Government.
the role and function of a psychiatric consultation Peplau, H.
E. (1952). Interpersonal relations in nurs-
liaison nurse: An Australian perspective. Journal of ing. New
York: Putnam.
Psychiatric and Mental Health Nursing, 8, 411–417. Peplau,
H. E. (1991). Interpersonal relations in nurs-
Sharrock, J., & Happell, B. (2001b). The role of ing. New York:
Springer.
the psychiatric consultation liaison nurse in Peplau, H. E.
(1997). Peplau’s theory of interper-
improved care of patients experiencing mental sonal relations.
Nursing Science Quarterly, 10(4),
health problems receiving care within a general 162–167.
hospital environment. Contemporary Nurse, Price, B.
(1998). Explorations in body image care:
11(2–3), 260–270. Peplau and practice knowledge. Journal of
Shattell, M. M., Starr, S. S., & Thomas, S. P. Psychiatric and
Mental Health Nursing, 5, 179–186.
(2007). ‘Take my hand, help me out’: Mental Prince, M.,
Patel, V., Sasema, S., Maj, M., Maselka,
health service recipients’ experience of the J., Phillips, M. R., et
al. (2007, September 8).
therapeutic relationship. International Journal of Global mental
health: 1. No health without
Mental Health Nursing, 16, 274–284. mental health. The
Lancet, 370, 869–877.
Sullivan, H. S. (1953). The interpersonal theory of Roberts, D.,
& Whitehead, I. (2002). Liaison
psychiatry. New York: Norton. mental health nursing: An
overview of its
Tunmore, R., & Thomas, B. (1992). Models of development and
current practice. In S. Regal
psychiatric consultation liaison nursing. British & D. Roberts
(Eds.), Mental health liaison: A
Journal of Nursing, 1(9), 447–451. handbook for nurses and
health professionals (pp.
Wand, T. (2004). Mental health liaison nursing in 43–63).
Edinburgh: Harcourt.
the emergency department: On-site expertise Royal College
of Physicians and the Royal College
and enhanced coordination of care. Australian of Psychiatrists.
(2003). The psychological
Journal of Advanced Nursing, 22(2), 25–31. care of medical
patients: A practical guide (2nd
Wand, T., & Happell, B. (2001). The men- ed.) (Report of joint
working party of the
tal health nurse: Contributing to improved Royal College of
Physicians and the Royal
outcomes for patients in the emergency College of
Psychiatrists). Salisbury, UK: Sarum
department. Accident and Emergency Nursing, 9, ColourView
Group.
166–176. Ryrie, I., Roberts, M., & Taylor, R. (1997).
Liaison
Wand, T., White, K., & Patching, J. (2007). Refining psychiatric
nursing in an inner city accident and
the model for an emergency department-based emergency
department. Journal of Psychiatric
mental health nurse practitioner outpatient ser- and Mental
Health Nursing, 4(2), 131–136.
vice. Nursing Inquiry, 15(3), 231–241. Sharrock, J., Bryant,
J., McNamara, P., Forster,
World Health Organisation/Wonca. (2008). J., & Happell, B.
(2008). Exploratory study of
Integrating mental health care into primary care – mental
health consultation–liaison nursing in
a global perspective (joint report of World Health Australia:
Part 1. Demographics and role char-
Organisation/Wonca). Retrieved October 3, acteristics.
International Journal of Mental Health
2008, from http://www.who.int/mental_health/ Nursing, 17(3),
180–188.
policy/en Sharrock, J., Grigg, M., Happell, B., Keeble-
World Psychiatric Association. (2009, April Devlin, B., &
Jennings, S. (2006). The men-
1–4). Treatments in psychiatry: A new update. tal health nurse:
A valuable addition to the
Conference Proceedings, Florence, Italy. consultation–liaison
team. International Journal
Yakimo, R., Kurlowicz, L. H., & Murray, R. B. of Mental Health
Nursing, 15(1), 35–43.
(2004). Evaluation of outcomes in psychiatric Sharrock, J.,
& Happell, B. (2000). The psychiatric
consultation–liaison nursing practice. Archives of
consultation–liaison nurse: Towards articulating
Psychiatric Nursing, 18(6), 215–227. a model for practice.
Australian and New Zealand Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 9, 19–28.
Received 04 February 2009 Accepted 21 October 2009
166
CC
NN
Volume 34, Issue 2, February/March 2010
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited
without permission.