Nuovo Pignone: Gas Turbine Compressor Washing
Nuovo Pignone: Gas Turbine Compressor Washing
Nuovo Pignone: Gas Turbine Compressor Washing
Nuovo Pignone
Gas Turbine Compressor Washing GEK 103623B
These instructions do not purport to cover all details or variation in equipment nor to provide for every
possible contingency to be met in connection with installation, operation or maintenance. Should further in-
P. 1
formation be desired or should particular problems arise which are not covered sufficiently for the purchaser’s
purpose the matter should be referred to the GE Company.
© 1995 GENERAL ELECTRIC COMPANY
P. 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
I. SCOPE ................................................................................................................. 3
LIST OF TABLES
P. 3
I. SCOPE
The scope of this document is to present the methods of compressor washing approved by GE.
Two methods of liquid washing are employed - on line and off line. On-line washing is the proc-
ess of injecting water into the compressor while running at full speed and some percentage of
load. Off-line washing is the process of injecting cleaning solution into the compressor while it is
being turned at cranking speed. The advantage of on-line washing is that it can be done without
having to shut down the machine. On-line washing, however, is not as effective as off-line wash-
ing; therefore, on-line washing is used to supplement off-line washing, not replace it.
This document applies to all gas turbine models offered by Gas Turbine Division and addresses
units operating with DLN systems.
NOTE
It is recommended that a unit-specific procedure and checklist be created by each
customer. The procedure and checklist should include configuring the unit for water
wash, performing water wash and restoration following water wash. These proce-
dures should conform to the enclosed general guidelines. Technical assistance can
be provided by General Electric in preparing the unit specific procedures and check-
lists.
II. INTRODUCTION
A loss of gas turbine performance is indicated by a decrease in power output and an increase in
heat rate.
Often a loss of performance is a direct result of fouling of the axial flow compressor. Fouled
compressors result in reduced air flow, lower compressor efficiency and a lower compressor
pressure ratio.
Compressor washing will remove fouling deposits and restore performance. It should be noted
that full power may not always be regained once significant fouling occurs. Regular compressor
washing will help maintain performance. Specific intervals must be determined based on cus-
tomer performance. Compressor washing may also slow the progress of corrosion, thereby in-
creasing blade life and reducing the contribution of corrosion products to the formation of fouling
deposits.
P. 4
Turbine Compressor Operating Environment and Material Evaluation", discusses the factors in-
fluencing compressor fouling and corrosion.
P. 5
A. Visual Inspection
Visual inspection involves shutting the unit down; removing the inlet plenum inspection hatch;
and visually inspecting the compressor inlet, bellmouth, inlet guide vanes and early stage bla d-
ing.
If any deposits, including dust or filmy deposits, can be wiped or scraped off these areas, the
compressor is fouled sufficiently to affect performance. The initial inspection also reveals
whether the deposits are oily or dry. For oily deposits, a water-detergent wash is required.
Location of the source of the oil and correction should be accomplished before washing to
prevent recurrence of the fouling.
If only dry deposits are found, water alone may be sufficient.
B. Performance Monitoring
A second method for detecting a fouled compressor is performance monitoring. Performance
monitoring involves obtaining gas turbine data on a routine basis, which in turn is compared to
base line data to monitor trends in the performance of the gas turbine.
The performance data is obtained by running the unit at steady-state BASE load and re-
cording output, exhaust temperature, inlet air temperature, barometric pressure, compressor
discharge pressure and temperature, and fuel consumption. The data should be taken carefully
with the unit warmed up.
GEK 28166, "Field Performance Testing Procedure," can be used as a guide for assessing
machine performance both before and after cleaning the compressor. The purpose of this par-
ticular document is to establish the performance of generator drive machines. The appropriate
portions can, however, also be used for all machines, both generator drive and other applica-
tions, for assessing cleaning effectiveness.
Output and heat rate can be corrected to a standard condition using the turbine performance
curves, and an analysis can be made of compressor pressure ratio and efficiency. The current
performance levels can be compared to base line data and will aid in determining the problem
area.
If performance analysis indicates compressor fouling, it should be verified by a visual inspec-
tion.
P. 6
for on-line washing than off-line washing. The water specifications for off-line and on-line clean-
ing are given in Table 1.
It is recommended that on-line water washing be performed without the use of detergent. The
detergent effectiveness during on -line wash is limited as there is no soak time as there is for off-
line wash.
Except for the pH, the restrictions in these specifications are concerned with deposits and corro-
sion of the hot gas path. The pH restriction is concerned with corrosion in the water-handling sys-
tem. High-purity demineralized water after contact with air will have a pH in the range of 5.0 to
6.0. Thus, allowance has been made in the pH provided this is the reason for the low pH.
If a detergent is used, additional restrictions are required to ensure no harm will result to turbine
components. These are given in Appendix 1.
In general, deposits will contain some water-soluble material and oils. The latter will be more
amenable to removal by detergent, but the deposit may be removable by water washing alone,
depending on the amount of water-soluble material present. Hot water at 150 to 200°F (66-93°C)
is generally more effective than cold water.
There are a number of detergents commercially available for this purpose, some of which, along
with the deposits that have been removed, may constitute a hazardous solid waste (as defined by
the US Environmental Protection Agency) when used for an off-line wash. Because of this pos-
sibility, local regulations should be considered for the storage, handling and treatment of the water
wash effluent when the drain and containment system is designed.
P. 7
Off-line compressor water wash is required if compressor performance degrades 10% due
to fouling.
P. 8
a. Preparation
1) Off-line washing solution must meet the requirements of both Table 1 and Appendix
1.
2) The cooldown procedure must be continued until the wheelspace temperatures are
within 120°F (67°C) of the wash water temperature.
CAUTION
3) If a unit is equipped with off-base atomizing air compressor, the compressor should
be deenergized during the wash and rinse cycles.
4) Open inlet guide vanes, if applicable.
5) Close flame detector valves or blank-off. Water will foul the flame scanners and
make starting difficult.
6) When regenerators are present, the gas-side face must be covered and kept dry dur-
ing compressor washing to prevent wetting regenerator deposits. These deposits
may change form when wet and become extremely difficult to remove. Leave ac-
cess doors open while cranking to provide an air exhaust path.
7) Fuel manifold drains are to remain closed during wash to prevent water from enter-
ing. Open during dry cycle.
8) Manually isolate systems, open drains and divert drains as follows:
a) The flow through the false start drain valves (VA17) must be diverted from the
sludge tank to a wash water effluent tank on turbines that operate on liquid fuel
or have the capability to.
NOTE
The false start drain flow or any flow that goes normally to the sludge
tank must be diverted from its "normal" path into the sludge tank, into the
wash water effluent drain to prevent an overflow of the sludge tank. In
addition, the false start drain effluent should be visible to evaluate the ef-
fectiveness of the wash cycle. On gas-only machines, there will be no
sludge tank; only a wash water effluent tank.
b) Arrange valves in the exhaust plenum drain piping to divert effluent from the
sludge tank to the waste water tank. Open the main wash water drain valve at
the bottom of the exhaust plenum.
P. 9
NOTE
This step is necessary to prevent water wash from entering the exhaust
frame cooling system during the wash cycle.
The atomizing an system (if provided) is isolated in the following manner:
f) Close valve on inlet side of atomizing air system from AD-8 line.
g) Open all low point drains in the atomizing air supply lines.
h) Open the atomizing air separator drain valve (if provided).
i) Open vent line on inlet side of CA2, booster atomizing air compressor (if pro-
vided).
j) Open switch at the motor control center for 88AB; the drive motor for the
booster atomizing air compressor, CA2.
The cooling and sealing air circuitry is isolated in the following manner:
k) Close valve in the bearing sealing air supply line AE-5 from extraction air (if pro-
vided).
l) Close valve in all compressor discharge pressure transducer supply lines (AD-4).
m) Close AD-1, AD-3 and if provided, AD-6, AD-7 and AD-10.
n) Close valve in the bleed air line (AE-##) from extraction air (if provided). If iso-
lation valve is not provided, isolate with a blank-off plate.
o) Open separator drain valve on bearing sealing air line, if provided.
p) Open needle valve upstream of WW9 connection for drainage during the wash
cycle (low point drain on AD-3), if provided.
q) Open low point drain on bearing sealing air line, if provided.
r) If the turbine has a self-cleaning inlet filter, dose the block valve and open the
drain valve on the self-cleaning inlet filter air line.
The inlet air bearing system is isolated in the following manner:
s) Close VM15-1 manually, or if motorized valve is provided, ensure it is closed.
t) Open all low point drains in the Inlet Air Heating System.
b. Washing Procedure
P. 10
c. Washing Effectiveness
The effectiveness of the wash and the rinse can most easily be evaluated by observing
the runoff from the drains during the rinse and visual inspection of the compressor inlet
at the end of a wash cycle.
1) The compressor should be rinsed until the drain water appears clean.
2) The runoff water may also be checked for the amount of impurities it contains by
measuring its electrolytic conductivity. The conductivity value will decrease as
washing continues and the runoff water contains fewer dissolved impurities.
3) Another method of testing is to use an atomic absorption spectrometer if one is
available for checking the level of trace metals.
NOTE
The detergent wash may need to be repeated depending on the amount
of fouling and detergent effectiveness. Multiple washes will be required
if the compressor is heavily fouled.
P. 11
1) Allow the gas turbine to drain and dry for about 20 minutes including coasting down
time.
2) Open fuel manifold drains and open all low point drains in atomizing air system, fuel
system and purge system.
NOTE
The interconnecting piping is often the low point trap and this piping
must be drained by removing drain plugs or parting pipe flanges. The
low point can be in the inter-connecting piping or the manifold itself de-
pending on the piping design and location of the gas valves. Additionally,
lower combustion can flexible hoses may trap water and may require
flange disassembly to remove water at these locations.
Following water wash and rinse cycles, the dry-out crank cycle should
continue until no water is observed draining from any low point drain.
Following restoration of the piping, the subsequent turbine restart should
be carefully monitored and any operational abnormalities during restart
that might indicate that all wash water has not been drained should result
in an operator trip of the unit and further draining and purging of the pip-
ing to insure all water is removed.
3) After the turbine has stopped, and drying time is complete, initiate a turbine START
signal with the master operation selector switch in the CRANK position.
4) Allow the turbine to accelerate to crank speed.
5) Allow the turbine to dry for at least 20 minutes or until low point drains are dry at
crank speed.
6) Initiate a turbine STOP signal.
e. Restoration
1) If applicable, dose inlet guide vanes.
2) If applicable, reenergize off-base atomizing air compressor and remove regenerator
cover.
3) Close fuel manifold drains.
CAUTION
It is important that the line that allows waste fuel to drain to the sludge tank
be kept open after water washing and during normal turbine startup and op-
eration, so that fuel or water which may accumulate in the exhaust plenum
can continuously drain out of the plenum. Accumulation of waste fuel in the
exhaust plenum is potentially hazardous.
P. 12
a) Return the three-way false start drain valve, combustion system and turbine shell
valves from water drain to fuel drain (if installed).
b) Rearrange valves installed in the exhaust plenum drain piping to divert effluent
from the wash water tank to the sludge tank (if applicable).
c) Close the inlet plenum drain valve (if provided).
NOTE
This is important to prevent intake of dirt etc., into the compressor.
d) Open valve installed in the AD-2 line supplying compressor discharge air to the
false start drain valves.
e) Switch the motor controller for the turbine exhaust frame cooling fan motors
88TK-1 and 88TK-2, into the "AUTO" mode (if provided).
The atomizing air system is reenergized in the following manner:
f) Open valve on inlet side of atomizing air system from AD-8 line.
CAUTION
CAUTION
l) Open valves in all compressor discharge pressure transducer supply lines (AD-
4).
CAUTION
P. 13
CAUTION
n) Open valves or remove blank-off plate in the bleed air lines (AE-##) from ex-
traction air.
CAUTION
o) Close separator drain valve on bearing sealing air line (if provided).
p) Close needle valve upstream of WW9 connection (low-point drain on AD-3), if
provided.
q) Close low-point drain on bearing sealing air line, if provided.
r) If the turbine has a self-cleaning inlet filter, open the block valve and dose the
drain valve on the self-cleaning filter air line.
The inlet air heating system is reengaged in the following manner:
s) Open VM15-1 manually, or if motorized valve is provided, ensure it is opened.
t) Close all low point drains in the Inlet Air Heating System.
6) Press the Off-Line Water Wash OFF soft switch on the water wash control display.
NOTE
When the OFF-LINE WATER WASH OFF is selected, the permissive
is in place to allow the turbine to fire and the permissive is removed to
allow the 20TW-1 valve to be opened.
P. 14
Adding water for wash will increase the compressor pressure ratio and thus reduce the
surge margin. Under normal circumstances, there is ample surge margin to allow for wash-
ing and steam or water injection for NOx control or power augmentation. However, the
following steps are recommended prior to performing an on-line wash.
a. Preparation
1) On-line washing solution must meet the requirements of both Table 1 and Appendix
1.
2) Turbine must be running at full speed and not in the process of shutting down.
3) Compressor inlet temperature, CTIM, must be greater than 50°F (10°C). Refer to
TIL 1153-3 for information on cold weather on-line water wash. On-line water
washing should not be per-formed while inlet bleed heat is operating for any reason.
Do not force inlet bleed heat off to satisfy this restriction
4) Set the inlet guide vanes to 81° or greater. For units operating with DLN Systems,
full open position occurs only at base load.
5) Reduce load by 5% if operating at base load. Units operating with DLN systems
need not reduce load and must perform compressor wash at base load to achieve
full open IGV's.
6) Units operating with water or steam injection for NOx control or power augmenta-
tion must reduce water or steam injection to 3% maximum of compressor inlet flow.
7) For units operating with DLN Systems, washing is to be conducted while in Ex-
tended Lean-Lean or Premix combustion modes.
NOTE
Operating in extended lean-lean will result in increased emissions over
premix operation.
b. Washing Procedure
1) Apply water at the rate specified in Table 2.
2) Continue to apply solution for 30 minutes.
3) On-line wash is most effective when performed on a regular basis.
4) If inlet bleed heat turns on for any reason while washing, the water wash procedure
should be suspended.
NOTE
If using a detergent solution for on-line washing, it is recommended that
the wash be followed by enough rinse water to remove the detergent
residue from the wash nozzles at the spray manifold. This will prevent
the detergent solutions from drying and clogging the nozzles.
P. 15
B. Results of Washing
After cleaning, there should be a noticeable increase in performance. Increase in performance
is a function of how fouled the compressor was initially. An increase in BASE load power of
10% is not uncommon following an off-line wash. This can be confirmed by comparing re-
stored performance data to levels of performance before washing, utilizing the procedure in
GEK 28166 for generator drive machines and the appropriate procedure for other applications
as previously described under Performance Monitoring. It should be noted that full power may
not always be regained once significant fouling occurs. Regular compressor washing will help
maintain performance. Specific intervals must be determined based on customer performance.
P. 16
TABLE 1
QUALITY SPECIFICATION*
OFF-LINE WASHING
ON-LINE WASHING
P. 17
TABLE 2
P. 18
APPENDIX 1
1.0 Scope
1.1 This specification is for cleaning compounds for use in compressor washing. It is required
that these compounds will not cause harm to gas turbine components. Thus, their purity
and composition must be such that they do not cause aqueous corrosion or stress corrosion
of compressor materials. Also, it is required that they do not cause hot corrosion in the tur-
bine. Furthermore, they must not lead to compressor fouling. With regard to the cleaning
agents themselves, they must be chemically stable in themselves and in their mixtures with
water. Also, they must not form combustible mixtures and they should satisfy all local
codes relative to health and safety requirements. Compliance with this specification does
not imply a cleaning compound improves the cleaning of a compressor over and above
what can be obtained from water alone.
2.0 Requirements
2.1 The cleaning compound when mixed with water in the manufacturer's prescribed concen-
tration shall satisfy the water washing specifications for on-line and off-line water quality
given in Table 1. In the pure state it shall satisfy the specification given in Table Al.
2.2 The residue or ash content of the cleaning compound shall not exceed 0.01%. See test 4.1.
2.3 The storage stability of the cleaning compound shall show no marked color change, shall
not separate and shall not corrode or stain the steel specimen when tested as specified in
test 4.5.16 of MIL-C-85704A. This test is given in 4.2.
2.4 The cleaner and its mixtures with water shall not form gums under compressor conditions.
2.5 The Pensky-Martens flash point of the cleaning compound shall be above 1400F (600C)
(ASTM D93).
3.1 Use of the cleaning compound shall not have adverse effects on engine system materials
such as compressor or turbine materials.
4.0 Tests
P. 19
P. 20
Following this, the crucible and its contents shall be carefully ignited over a Bunsen-type
gas burner. The crucible shall then be placed in a muffle furnace at 1,900°F (1,040°C) for
2 hours. The crucible shall be transferred to a desiccator, cooled and weighed until con-
stant weight. The ash content shall be calculated as the percentage of the initial weight of
cleaning compound.
Procedure. The capped bottle containing the steel strip shall be placed in a water bath and
heated at a uniform rate to a temperature of 140° ± 4°F (60° ± 2°C) over a period of five
hours. It shall be held at this temperature for three hours. No heat shall be applied to the
bath overnight. The above heating procedure shall be repeated each day for five days.
(This test need not necessarily be attended if an interval time is used to regulate the tem-
perature automatically. The test may be started on a Wednesday, Thursday or Friday and
still have the pressure bottle removed on a normal workday.) On the morning of the sixth
day, the bottle shall be removed from the bath, uncapped, examined for separation and the
steel strip carefully withdrawn from the cleaning compound. Separation into layers shall be
cause for rejection.
The portion of the steel strip which had been immersed in the compound shall be examined
for evidence of pitting, corrosion and uneven darkening. The open bottle shall be capped
and the two bottles shall be thoroughly shaken for one minute, then allowed to remain un-
disturbed for one hour at room temperature and then examined. Any marked change in the
color and uniformity of the aged sample shall be considered as showing unsatisfactory sta-
bility properties.
P. 21
TABLE Al
CHEMICAL CONTENT OF WASHING DETERGENT
P. 22