Unit Ig1: Management of Health and Safety
Unit Ig1: Management of Health and Safety
Unit Ig1: Management of Health and Safety
01
UNIT IG1
MANAGEMENT OF
HEALTH AND SAFETY
(Theory Paper)
ELEMENT 1
WHY WE SHOULD
MANAGE WORKPLACE
HEALTH AND SAFETY
Learning Outcomes:
1.1 Discuss the moral, financial and legal reasons for managing health and safety
in the workplace
1.2 Explain how health and safety is regulated and the consequences of
non-compliance
1.3a Summarise the main health and safety duties of different groups of people at
work
The Size of the Health and Safety Problem: Most organizations and individuals would like to manage
safety in their organizations, but sometimes they are not
The International Labour Organization (ILO) has released
convinced enough to take action. So now, we will try to
01
the following data to support the cause of maintaining
find out what are the prime reasons for maintaining and
safety in the organizations:
promoting good standards of health and safety. Though,
2.3 million women and men around the world expose somebody may sit down and come out with at least a
to work-related accidents or diseases every year. As a dozen reasons for managing safety, but all these reasons
result of this, over 6000 deaths have been reported can be summarized into the following three reasons:
in every single day
All Regions
Region Fatalities
Established Market economies 19,662
Formerly Socialist Economies of Europe 15,563
1.1 Morals and Money
India 36,740
China 68,231 Moral Expectations of Good
Other Asia and Islands 80,586 Standards of Health and Safety:
Sub-Saharan Africa 45,864
Organizations set up businesses and obviously make
Latin America and America and Caribbean 26,374
profits and earn money. To get the work done they
Middle Eastern Crescent 41,850
hire workers and contractors. Workers get paid for
WORLD 334,870
accomplishing the tasks given by the employer. The
employer provides everything to the employee to get
Work-Related Disease Deaths (ILO): the task done in the desired time with the desired quality.
No employer would want his employees to get injured
No. of deaths attributed
Causes of death or hurt while completing the tasks. The employer has a
to occupation
moral duty to take care of his employees. This moral duty
Cancer 30+years 456,240
can also be called ‘humanitarian’ or ‘ethical’. An employer
Cardiovascular and 200,025
pays the employees for the duties given to them and not
cerebrovascular disease 15
for getting injured while doing them. Hence the employer
- 60 years
has to ensure that employees who work for him do not
Chronic respiratory 275,000 get injured or suffer ill-health. This is the moral reason for
disease 15+ years managing safety.
Pneumoconiosis 36,000
(proportionalestimate
from US figures)
Nervous system disorders 12,080
15+ years
Renal disorders 15+ years 13,100
Total 992,445
The Financial Cost of Incidents Loss of staff morale, which impacts productivity and
quality.
(Insured and Uninsured Costs):
Cost of remedial action following an investigation.
Today the business scenario is changing and if a business
is not able to make profits year on year then it is difficult Compliance with any enforcement notice served.
to sustain it. Accidents cost money, and businesses realize
Cost of recruiting and training temporary or
that to maximize profits and to minimize costs, the costs
replacement labor.
associated with accidents either needs to be totally
eliminated or atleast minimized as far as possible. Let us General difficulties in recruiting and retaining staff as
now understand as to what are the costs associated with an indirect result of the accident.
accidents. Loss of goodwill of the customers following delays in
The theory of costs of an accident can be closely associated production and fulfilling orders.
with that of a floating iceberg. What we see above the
Activation of penalty clauses for failing to meet
ocean level is only 1/10th of the mass of the iceberg, while
delivery dates.
9/10th of the mass is hidden below the waters. In the same
way, we associate the costs of accidents only to costs of Damage to public image and business reputation.
hospitalization and compensation payments which can Damage to industrial relations, perhaps leading to
be easily measured, this is also known as direct costs, but workers unrest.
the majority of the costs is hidden like the iceberg and can
be many times the direct costs, these costs are known as Looking at the above it is proved beyond doubt that
indirect costs. accidents cost money and it is the indirect costs which cause
most of the damages to the companies’ performance and
Let us now define Direct and Indirect Costs and look at
hence it is worthwhile for businesses’ to invest in accident
examples of the same.
prevention (which some companies unfortunately look at
Direct Costs: the measurable costs arising directly from as costs) rather than face the loss making consequences of
an accident. Examples of direct costs are: the accidents.
First aid treatment
Hospitalization costs
Insured and Uninsured Costs: welfare of its employees. These legislations are made by
local governments in consultation with the society. The
To take care of any eventualities arising from accidents
societal expectations may increase as the living conditions,
01
employers are required to buy insurance by paying a
technology and awareness increases, and the law also gets
premium. In most countries it is a legal requirement for
amended to take care of these enhanced expectations.
employers to have insurance for their workers. Other than
To ensure that the law is adhered to, the national
meeting the legal requirements it also creates a sense of
governments also appoint the enforcement agencies,
comfort both in minds of the employer and employee that
who are empowered to enter workplaces, conduct
in case of an accident the insurance will take care of the
audits, interview people and verify records. During such
costs associated with it. But not all costs are covered by
routine inspections, if the enforcement agencies find any
insurance and generally the quantum of uninsured costs
violations with respect to the law then they may initiate
is generally much higher than the insured costs. Some
proceedings, which can range from a simple enforcement
examples of possible insured and uninsured costs are as
notice to prosecution in the criminal court, which can lead
follows:
to either fines, imprisonment or both.
Insured Costs:
Damage to plant, buildings, vehicles and equipment.
Medical costs.
Uninsured Costs:
Production delays of down time.
– Prohibition notice: This notice is given to halt ISO 45001 (Occupational health and safety
an activity which the inspector feels could lead to management systems (H&SMS))
serious personal injury. Whilst these are not legal documents they have been
Prosecution of the organization in the criminal adopted by many companies throughout the world
courts: Successful prosecution might result in since they demonstrate good management practice. The
punishment in the form of a fine. result is a common approach to managing quality and
Prosecution of individuals, such as directors, environmental matters. At a technical level, ISO has been
managers and workers: Successful prosecution responsible for developing safety standards to which
might result in fines and/or imprisonment.. machinery, etc. should conform, e.g. ISO 12100: Safety of
Machinery. Such standards are then commonly referenced
by national legislation on machinery safety, since
compliance with the recognized international standard
demonstrates safety.
member states, with almost all the countries in the world 2. … to ensure that .. the chemical, physical and biolog-
been part of it. Through deliberations of the member ical substances and agents under their control are
states the ILO regularly releases standards that regulate without risk to health…
health and safety laws across the world. These standards 3. … to provide… adequate protective clothing and pro-
or laws are known as Conventions and Recommendations. tective equipment to prevent.. risk of accidents or of
Once these conventions and recommendations are passed adverse effects to health.”
in the ILO through a majority vote it becomes binding on
R164 expands the above and provides more guidance as
each of the member states to convert these conventions
to how to implement the above requirements given in the
into their own national legislations by an act of their
convention.
respective parliaments so that they can be binding on the
businesses operating within their geo-political spread. Article 10 of R164 puts the following obliga-
Let us now look at the difference between a convention
tions on the employers:
and a recommendation and take some examples of the To provide workplaces and work equipment and use
same so as to reinforce our learning’s. work methods which are safe and pose no risk to health.
Conventions are legally binding international treaties To provide appropriate instructions and training.
that need to be ratified by member states, while
To provide necessary supervision.
Recommendations serve as non- binding guidelines.
Convention lays down the basic principles that need to To put in place health and safety arrangements adapted
be implemented by ratifying countries, while a related to suit the size and nature of the undertaking.
recommendation supplements the convention by providing To provide any necessary personal protective clothing
more detailed guidelines on how it can be applied. and equipment free of charge.
In 1981, the ILO adopted the Occupational Safety To ensure that the hours of work do not adversely affect
and Health Convention (C155). This is a goal setting employees’ safety and health.
convention and describes safety requirements at both the
To take measure to eliminate physical and mental fatigue.
national as well as the individual organization level.
To stay up-to-date with knowledge in order to comply
This convention is supplemented by the Occupational
with the above.
Safety and Health Recommendation 1981 (R164). It
provided detailed guidance as to how to comply with the Now let’s look at how the Indian government has
policies laid down in C155. implemented the above requirements in the national laws:
Let us now look at some of the requirements laid out in The Indian connection: The Factories Act, 1948 states
C155 and R164. the duties of the employer or here it is mentioned as the
occupier
Employers’ Responsibilities:
Section 7A. General duties of the occupier.-
1. Every occupier shall ensure, so far as is reasonably
practicable, the health, safety and welfare of all workers
while they are at work in the factory.
sure the health and safety of all workers at work; Section 111. Obligations of workers.-
d. the maintenance of all places of work in the 1. No worker in a factory - 01
factory in a condition that is safe and without
risks to health and the provision and mainte- a. shall willfully interfere with or misuse any appli-
nance of such means of access to, and egress ance, convenience or other things provided in a
factory for the purposes of securing the health,
from, such place as are safe and without such
safety or welfare of the worker therein;
risks;
b. shall willfully and without reasonable cause do
d. the provision, maintenance or monitoring of anything likely to endanger himself or others;
such working environment in the factory for the and
workers that is safe, without risks to health and
c. shall willfully neglect to make use of any appli-
adequate as regards facilities and arrangements
ances or other things provided in the factory for
for their welfare at work.
the purposes of securing the health or safety of
From the above it is amply clear that though the wording the workers therein.
may be different between the C155 and Factories Act,
2. If any worker employed in a factory contravenes
1948, the meaning generally remains the same.
any of the provisions of this section or of any
rule or order made there under, he shall be pun-
Workers’ Responsibilities and
ishable with imprisonment for a term which may
Rights: extend to three months, or with fine which may
extend to one hundred rupees, or with both.
Accident records National legislation Creating measureable aims and objectives towards
fulfillment of health and safety standards and statute.
Medical records Material safety data
Ensuring that the resources required to achieve the
sheets
Risk assessments set objectives are reasonably adequate.
Codes of practice /
Maintenance reports Ensuring that there are personnel with specific roles
Guidance notes
Safety inspection related to health and safety and these people should
Operating instructions be reporting to director level personnel.
reports
Trade association’s There are adequate numbers of competent persons
Audit reports
publications available to take care of the organizations health and
Safety committee safety obligations.
Safety publications
minutes
Workplace exposure Role of Supervisors:
limits
A supervisor means a person who has charge of a workplace
or authority over a worker. He must:
Ensure that equipment, protective device or clothing appropriate cases, the competent authority or authorities
provided by the employer are maintained in good should prescribe general procedures for this collaboration”.
condition and used as prescribed
01
(Source:https://www.ilo.org/dyn/normlex/en/f ?p=NOR
Instruct workers about any potential of or actual MLEXPUB:12100:0::NO:12100:P12100_INSTRUMENT_
health/ safety hazards; and ID:312502:NO)
Take every precaution reasonable in the Joint occupiers of premises are those that share a
circumstances for the protection of workers. common premise but have their own business interests,
employees, processes and equipment. In such scenario
the risks created by one of the business could affect the
employees of the other business. For e.g. there could
be pathological lab next to a garment manufacturing
company. The biological hazards and waste generated
by the pathological lab could become a hazard for the
workers working in the garment company and at the same
time the cloths and other raw material will create a fire
hazards for the workers in the pathological lab. To deal
with such a scenarios the individual business owners have
responsibility towards each other been joint occupiers of
How Top Management can premises. The following things can be done to ensure a
Demonstrate Commitment: proper coordination:
How Clients and Contractors should Procedures that he is going to employ and other
documents and records.
Work together:
In case of workers the following needs to be checked:
The duties they owe each other (as per Competence of the workers, for e.g. if welders,
‘Safety and health in construction’, ILO then their weld test qualifications; or scaffolders,
Code of Practice – chapter 2) then their relevant qualifications.
– (c) require those submitting tenders to make Whether the equipment meets the required
provision for the cost of safety and health measures national and the companies’ own standards.
during the construction process. Whether any statutory tests is required and has
In estimating the periods for completion of work stages been carried out (for e.g. lifting tools and tackles).
and overall completion of the project, clients should take
Whether the plant and equipment are suitable for the
account of safety and health requirements during the
task and the environment in which they are to be used.
construction process.
In case of documentation, the following needs to be
As the employer has the responsibility to protect own checked:
workers as well as contractors. To ensure that, contractors
The contractors’ health and safety policy.
have to be managed by the following steps:
Example risk assessments and method statements.
Effective planning and co-ordination of contracted
work Previous experiences of carrying out similar type
of work.
Pre-selection of the contractor
Accident records and legal labor permits.
1. Effective planning of the contracted
Any enforcement action pending or otherwise.
work
3. Co-ordination of the Contracted Work:
Client shall if required appoint a Project Management
Consultant (PMC) and plan the contract work as follows: This step is required because a project site is quite
complex with several contractors working side-
Decide on scale of contracting.
by-side executing several parallel or sequential
Scope of the work to be determined operations; even the clients’ own workforce may be
involved. To ensure that the activities don’t clash and
Decide on information to be shared
one contractor’s activities do not create a hazard for
Hazards posed by the site and work carried out others, proper co-ordination of the work is required.
The client can do this by having a control over the
Hazards posed by the contractor’s activities
work schedule and certain safety critical activities
Risk assessments of contractor’s job are carried out only under the Permit to Work system
Method statements authorized by the client.
Summary
Occupational health and safety is an organized system to ensure the safety, health and welfare of people employed at
01
different types of work premises
Three key reasons for practicing good standards of health and safety. They are:
– Moral: Employer or employee should ensure that the work which is undertaken should not affect others or put
others in danger
– Financial: Poor occupational health and safety performance influence additional costs to organization.
Employer should implement good strategies to effectively manage the costs of accidents, ill health events, and
environmental incidents
– Legal: Employer should ensure safe systems of work for all his employees and satisfy legal requirements with
respect to health and safety
Financial Cost of Incidents
– Direct Cost is a type of cost which can be easily identified to measure the cost of a product or service E.g: Labour
wages, equipment cost, worker compensation etc.
– Indirect Cost is a type of cost which cannot be easily identified to measure the cost of a product or service E.g:
Cumulative business loss, production delays, extra overtime payments, recruitment and training of staff etc.
Few of the above costs may be Insured and many be Uninsured. To summarize, cost of any accident would be: Direct
Insured, Direct Uninsured, Indirect Insured and Indirect Uninsured.
Most of the uninsured costs cannot be insurable due to the following reasons.
– Difficult to quantify
– Not readily measurable
Enforcement agencies responsible for enforcing health and safety practices at workplace
Some examples are: ISO 9001 for Quality, ISO 45001 for Occupational Health and Safety, ISO 14001 for Environment
International Labour Organisation (ILO) is an agency works for health, safety and welfare of labours across the globe
ILO standards refer to conventions, recommendations and also code of practices, guidance and manuals on health and
safety
ILO’s conventions (agreement) and recommendations clearly define the roles and responsibilities of employers and
workers to promote good standards of health and safety in a complex industrialised country
Example of ILO Conventions and recommendations are C155 Occupational Safety and Health and (R 164), 1981
ͫͫ Ensure appropriate control and protection of physical, chemical and biological substances
– Recommendation R164
ͫͫ Make sure workplace is safe and secure
ͫͫ Ensure frequent breaks and rests are given to workers
ͫͫ Provision of personal protective equipment and encourage the use of it
ͫͫ Conduct training and give necessary instruction and information with respect to the specified tasks
ͫͫ Stay up-to-date with health and safety knowledge
ͫͫ Ensure proper record keeping and documentation
Worker’s responsibilities and rights as per
Ensuring that the resources required to achieve the set objectives are reasonably
adequate
Ensure that equipment, protective device or clothing provided by the employer are
Supervisors maintained in good condition and used as prescribed
Instruct workers about any potential of or actual health/ safety hazards; and
Take every precaution reasonable in the circumstances for the protection of workers
– making resources available to design, implement and maintain the occupational health and safety management
system
– defining roles and responsibilities
– appointing senior managers with specific responsibility for health and safety
– appointing competent people (internal and external, including specialists) to help the organisation meet its health
and safety obligations
– reviewing health and safety performance
Requirements laid out in C155 Article 17, R164 Recommendation 11 with respect to sharing of workplace.
– Article 17 of C155 states that “Whenever two or more undertakings engage in activities simultaneously at one 01
workplace, they shall collaborate in applying the requirements of Occupational Safety and Health Convention
– Article 11 of R164 states that “Whenever two or more undertakings engage in activities simultaneously at one
workplace, they should collaborate in applying the provisions regarding occupational safety and health and the
working environment, without prejudice to the responsibility of each undertaking for the health and safety of its
employees. In appropriate cases, the competent authority or authorities should prescribe general procedures for
this collaboration”.
Duties of the clients and contractors when working together with reference to ‘Safety and health in construction’,
ILO Code of Practice
– Clients should:
ͫͫ co-ordinate or nominate a competent person to co-ordinate all activities relating to safety and health on their
construction projects;
ͫͫ inform all contractors on the project of special risks to health and safety of which the clients are or should be
aware;
ͫͫ require those submitting tenders to make provision for the cost of safety and health measures during the
construction process.
– In estimating the periods for completion of work stages and overall completion of the project, clients should take
account of safety and health requirements during the construction process.
As the employer has the responsibility to protect own workers as well as contractors. To ensure that, contractors have
to be managed by the following steps:
– Effective Planning of the contract work E.g. Deciding scale of contractor, information to be shared etc.
– Pre-selection of the contractor E.g. Check contractor worker’s competence, equipment effectiveness, reviewing
health and safety policy, accidents records, legal labour permits etc.
– Co-ordination of the contract work E.g. To ensure that the contractor’s work activities don’t clash with other work
activities