Controls On Channel Sinuosity Changes: A Case Study Ofthe Tisza River, The Great Hungarian Plain
Controls On Channel Sinuosity Changes: A Case Study Ofthe Tisza River, The Great Hungarian Plain
Controls On Channel Sinuosity Changes: A Case Study Ofthe Tisza River, The Great Hungarian Plain
Abstract
The planform geometry of the Tisza, the trunk river of the subsiding Great Hungarian Plain is studied by reconstruction of the
last pre-regulation river course. The thalweg sinuosity has been computed for the main alluvial section of the river. Remarkable
sinuosity changes have been found to correlate with discharge and sediment load changes at the inflow of tributaries, as well as with
active deformation areas, like differential subsidence and wrench fault zones.
Analysing the change of the river pattern, a new discrimination line has been derived, which separates the meandering zone on the
classic slope vs. discharge diagram into two subzones. The first subzone (lower slope values) corresponds to a range of true, self-
organized meandering. The second subzone (higher slope values) corresponds to a range of ‘unorganized meandering’. This is a
range where river sinuosity decreases although the channel slope increases. In the case of the Tisza River, this subzone equals to the
wandering river pattern.
r 2003 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
0277-3791/03/$ - see front matter r 2003 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0277-3791(03)00145-8
ARTICLE IN PRESS
2200 ! / Quaternary Science Reviews 22 (2003) 2199–2207
G. Timar
Fig. 1. Shaded relief map of the Pannonian Basin. Dash-dotted line indicates national frontiers, the boundary of the Great Hungarian Plain is shown
by dotted line. MHSZ indicates the Mid Hungarian Shear Zone. The map is based on GTOPO30 global digital elevation data (GLOBE Task Team,
1999). The study section of the Tisza River is between the cities of Tokaj and Szeged.
presented in this paper, riverine seismic profiling and On the plain the longitudinal profile of the river
river planform analysis can be a useful tool to answer the has only minor slope changes (La! szloffy,! 1982)
questions of neotectonic activity and landform evolu- and due to the flatness of the plain, the channel
tion. slope is less than 10 cm/km everywhere downstream of
The Tisza, the trunk river of the GHP, drains Tokaj.
157,000 km2, and its catchment area covers the eastern The annual mean discharge of the river at Szeged is
part of the Pannonian Basin. It originates in the about 800 m3/s. Floods can occur in the spring season
Ukrainian part of the Carpathian Mts. and leaves its due to the snowmelt on the mountains of the catchment
narrow valley at Sighet (on the Romanian–Ukrainian area. The Tisza flows to the Danube and the local
frontier) changing from a bedrock to an alluvial river. erosional base of the whole Pannonian Basin is the Iron
Its real braided section ends up at Korolevo where the Gate where the Danube crosses the Southern Car-
river reaches the GHP (Fig. 1). From this point (the so pathian Mts. (Fig. 1).
called ‘Korolevo Gate’) till the estuary the Tisza is a The course of the river Tisza changed signi-
river without any bedrock control. ficantly during the late Quaternary (Ga! bris, 1998).
The section from Korolevo to Tiszabecs represents The river pattern was alternating between braiding
the alluvial fan, therefore the main fraction of the and meandering as a response to the climatic
river sediment is gravel and the river pattern is a changes during the Pleistocene (Vandenberghe, 1995;
transition from braided to meandering, which is Ga! bris, 1998). During the Holocene period the mean-
called wandering type (Miall, 1977, 1996). The dering pattern has been dominant everywhere down-
river starts the real meandering pattern at Tiszabecs stream of the alluvial fan section of the Tisza River
and it lasts till the estuary, along the whole GHP. (Ga! bris, 1987).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
! / Quaternary Science Reviews 22 (2003) 2199–2207
G. Timar 2201
Fig. 2. Important characteristics of the Tisza River between the cities of Tokaj and Szeged (see Fig. 1). (a) Confluence of the tributaries. The size of
the circles refers to the discharge of the tributary, in m3/s units under the circles. The percent data shows the discharge ratio of the tributary and the
Tisza River at the confluence. (b) Thalweg sinuosity of the Tisza River. Italic numbers and vertical dashed lines indicate the subsections (see text).
Capital letters show the discussed sinuosity anomalies. (c) Depth to the base of Quaternary strata (Frany!o, 1992), and a zone of tectonic deformation
derived from the seismic data of Toth ! et al. (1997).
Riverine seismic surveys were taken in 1997 along the 2. Method and results
major part of the Tisza River, between the cities of
Tokaj and Szeged. This was selected as a study section As the study section of the Tisza River has been
for river planform analysis. It is located between 250 meandering throughout the entire Holocene, the mor-
and 840 km from the estuary, measured along the phometric parameters of meandering rivers can be used
longer, pre-regulation channel. As there is only minor for planform analysis. For numerical and quantitative
variance of the valley slope along the study section, the approaches, Schumm (1963) suggested to define the
river planform is primarily controlled by the water and sinuosity of a section of a meandering river as a ratio of
sediment discharge of the tributaries. Fortunately, a the channel length and the geometrical distance between
long part of the study section is free of major its endpoints. The dependence of the channel sinuosity
confluences (Fig. 2a) which offers excellent conditions on the slope angle was studied by Schumm and Khan
for the analysis. (1972) using flume experiments. Setting a given dis-
The goal of this study is to find a correlation be- charge with constant sediment load, and increasing the
tween the known geological features (e.g. subsidence slope of the flume the flow was straight at low slope
centres, and other seismically detected deformation values and when a critical dip was reached, it started
features) and river planform changes and to show the meandering. The sinuosity of the thalweg increased with
applicability of river pattern analysis for neotectonic increasing slope to a point where it was maximum,
studies. beyond this maximum the sinuosity quickly fell and the
ARTICLE IN PRESS
2202 ! / Quaternary Science Reviews 22 (2003) 2199–2207
G. Timar
Fig. 4. Courses of the Tisza River around the subsection 11, plotted on a digital elevation model (derived from 1:10,000 scale topographic maps of
Hungary). Numbers indicate the following river courses: 1=present, regulated channel (black); 2=the last natural channel just before the river
regulation (continuous white); 3=a paleochannel (dash-dotted white), of about 5 kyr ago. Note the remarkable change of sinuosity between the
paleochannel (3) and the last natural channel (2).
tion induced by fluid extraction from the beginning of (E) The high sinuosity anomaly in the subsection 6,
the 20th century (Tima! r and Ra! cz, 2002). between 395 and 360 km.
Fig. 6. Derivation of the line (dashed) showing the slope resulting the maximum sinuosity at any discharge by the combination of the channel slope
vs. bankfull discharge diagram (Leopold and Wolman, 1957; Ackers and Charlton, 1971) with the chart of sinuosity vs. slope (after Schumm and
Khan, 1972). The vertical axis has no units because of the qualitative approach of the combination.
Fig. 7. Discharge vs. channel slope discrimination diagram (after Leopold and Wolman, 1957; Ackers and Charlton, 1971), and the plot of the
alluvial section of the Tisza River, showing the river planform change from braided, via wandering to meandering. For the determination of the line
of maximum sinuosity (dashed), see Fig. 6 (see text for discussion).
ARTICLE IN PRESS
2206 ! / Quaternary Science Reviews 22 (2003) 2199–2207
G. Timar
Mike, K., 1991. Paleohydrology and Surface Water History of Schumm, S.A., Dumont, J.F., Holbrook, J.M., 2000. Active Tectonics
Hungary (in Hungarian). Aqua, Budapest, 698pp. and Alluvial Rivers. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge
Mugnier, C.J., 1999. Grids & datums—Republic of Hungary. (Chapter 7: Lateral Response; Pannonian Basin, Hungary,
Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing 65, 423 and pp. 175–178).
425. St^lum, H.H., 1996. River meandering as a self-organization process.
Ouchi, S., 1985. Response of alluvial rivers to slow active tectonic Science 271, 1710–1713.
movement. Geological Society of America Bulletin 96, 504–515. Tim!ar, G., R!acz, T., 2002. The effects of neotectonic and hydrological
Partridge, T.C. (Ed.), 1997. The Plio–Pleistocene boundary. Quatern- processes on the flood hazard of the Tisza region (E. Hungary). In:
ary International 40, 100. Cloetingh, S., Horv!ath, F., Bada, G., Lankreijer, A. (Eds.),
Pinter, N.C., 1996. Active Tectonics. Prentice-Hall, Upper Saddle Neotectonics and Seismicity of the Pannonian Basin and
River, NJ, 338pp. Surrounding Orogens—A Memoir on the Pannonian Basin. EGU
Pog!acs!as, Gy., Lakatos, L., Barvitz, A., Vakarcs, G., Farkas, Cs., Stephan Mueller Special Publication Series 3, 267–275.
1989. Pliocene-Quaternary strike-slip faults in the Great Hungarian !
Toth, !
L., Monus, P., Zs!ıros, T., Kiszely, M., Kosztyu, Z., W!eber, Z.,
!
Plain (in Hungarian). Altal! .
anos Foldtani Szemle 24, 149–169. 1995. Hungarian Earthquake Bulletin. GeoRisk, Budapest.
!
Ronai, A., 1985. Quaternary geology of the Great Hungarian Plain !
Toth, T., Vida, R., Horv!ath, F., Simpkin, P., 1997. Shallow-water
(in Hungarian with English summary). Geologica Hungarica, single and multichannel seismic profiling in a riverine environment.
Series Geologica 21, 3–446. The Leading Edge 16, 1691–1695.
Schumm, S.A., 1963. A tentative classification of alluvial river Turcotte, D.L., 1992. Fractals and Chaos in Geology and Geophysics.
channels. US Geological Survey Circular V477. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 398pp.
Schumm, S.A., Khan, H.R., 1972. Experimental study of channel Vandenberghe, J., 1995. Timescales, climate and river development.
patterns. Geological Society of America Bulletin 83, 1755–1770. Quaternary Science Reviews 14, 631–638.