Physico-Chemical, Textural and Sensory Evaluation of Sponge Cake Supplemented With Pumpkin Flour
Physico-Chemical, Textural and Sensory Evaluation of Sponge Cake Supplemented With Pumpkin Flour
Physico-Chemical, Textural and Sensory Evaluation of Sponge Cake Supplemented With Pumpkin Flour
1
Food Science and Technology Research Center of East Golestan, Azadshahr Branch, Islamic
Azad University, Azadshahr, Iran
2
Department of Food Science and Technology, Science and Research branch, Islamic Azad
University, Tehran, Iran
3
Faculty of Food Science, Gorgan University of Agricultural Sciences and Natural Resources,
Gorgan, Iran
*Corresponding author.
Email: HosseiniGhaboos@yahoo.com
855 Hosseini Ghaboos et al./IFRJ 25(2): 854-860
fluidized bed and hot air drying are practiced for The combination of infrared with hot air provides
pumpkin (Sojak, 1999; Alibas, 2007; Nawirska et al., the synergistic effect, resulting in an efficient drying
2009). One of the ways to shorten the drying time is process. Energy and quality aspects were studied
to supply heat by infrared radiation. Their efficiency during combined far infrared and convective drying
is between 80% and 90%, the emitted radiation is in of barley (Afzal et al., 1999). A laboratory scale batch
narrow wavelength range and they are miniaturized dryer was used for this purpose. The total energy
(Sandu, 1986; Sakai and Hanzawa, 1994). Advantages required for the combination mode drying reduced by
of infrared radiation over convective heating include nearly 245% when compared with hot air drying at
high heat transfer coefficients, short process times 70°C. Combined infrared-vacuum drying of pumpkin
and low energy costs. Comparison of infrared drying slices was studied by Hosseini Ghaboos et al. (2016).
with convective drying of apple showed that time With increasing in infrared radiation power from
of the process can be shortened by up to 50% when 204 to 272 W, β–carotene content of dried pumpkins
heating is done with infrared energy (Nowak and decreased from 30.04 to 24.55 mg/100g. The rise
Lewicki, 2004). in infrared power has a negative effect on the color
Infrared radiation has some advantages over changes (ΔE). The optimum condition was selected
convective heating. In spite of these advantages, as power of 238 W and 5 mm slice thickness due to
application of infrared energy in food processing short time, high β–carotene content and bright color
is rather scarce. It is used for heating and cooking of the dried sample.
soybeans, cereal grains, cocoa beans and nuts, ready- Since pumpkin is a valuable micronutrients
to-eat products, braising meat and frying (Ratti and source, dried pumpkin could be processed into flour
Mujumdar, 1995). Pan et al. (2008) used sequential for foods to increase fibers, vitamin A and mineral
infrared and freeze-drying (SIRFD) to produce high- contents. Pumpkin flour is used because of its highly-
quality dried fruits at reduced cost. The products desirable flavor, sweetness and deep yellow-orange
dried using SIRFD had better color, higher crispness, color (See et al., 2007). It has been reported to be
higher shrinkage but poor rehydration propensity used to supplement cereal flours in bakery products
compared to those produced by using regular freeze- like cakes, cookies, bread, for soups, sauces, instant
drying. Infrared drying was applied before or after noodle and spice as well as a natural coloring agent
freeze-drying of shiitake mushroom to shorten the in pasta and flour mixes (Ptitchkina et al., 1998; See
drying time, to enhance the rehydration, and to better et al., 2007). Infrared-hot air method, when properly
preserve the aroma compounds and color by Wang et applied, can be used for achieving a high-quality
al. (2015). The results showed that the combination product. Therefore, the aim of this study was to
of freeze-drying (for 4h) followed by infrared drying determine the physico-chemical, textural and sensory
saves 48% time compared to freeze-drying while properties of sponge cake supplemented with five
keeping the product quality at an acceptable level. different levels (0, 5, 10, 15 and 20%) of pumpkin
The application of infrared drying also helps produce powder dried in an infrared–hot air dryer.
a more porous microstructure in dried shiitake
mushrooms. Materials and Methods
Ponkham et al. (2012) developed the mathematical
model of pineapple rings during combined far-infrared Infrared –hot air drying of pumpkin
radiation and air convection drying to investigate the Fresh pumpkins (Cucurbita moschata) were
evolutions of moisture content and qualities. The obtained from market. Slices of pumpkin with 5
diffusion coefficient was influenced by far-infrared mm thickness were prepared with the aid of a steel
radiation intensity and air temperature but was not cutter and were immediately placed into the dryer.
significantly influenced by air velocity. As expected The pumpkin slices were dried in an infrared –hot
at higher far-infrared intensity the higher heat air dryer (Infrared radiation lamp (NIR), Philips,
absorption resulted in higher product temperature, Germany) with 238 W power and 65°C with air at
higher mass transfer driving force, faster drying rate a velocity of 2 m/s (Hosseini Ghaboos et al., 2016).
and consequently lesser drying time. Hebbar et al. The dried samples were milled and passed through a
(2004) demonstrated that combination drying gave 125 mesh sieve. Then the milled powder was weighed
better results over infrared heating alone for drying and stored in an air-tight bottle till the experiments.
of carrots and potatoes. Moreover, infrared radiative
drying is able to give better qualities of product such Sponge cake preparation
as color, shrinkage, hardness, crispness, ascorbic The formulae of sponge cakes at five different
acid, and total phenol contents. pumpkin powder levels were shown in Table 1. The
Hosseini Ghaboos et al./IFRJ 25(2): 854-860 856
Table 2. Physico-chemical characteristics and crumb color of sponge cakes prepared with
pumpkin powder.
Means with different letter within columns are significantly different (P<0.05).
Sensory evaluation
The hedonic test was used to determine the degree
of overall liking for the sponge cakes. For this study,
trained consumers were recruited from the students,
staff and faculty at Gorgan University. All consumers
were interested volunteers and informed that they
would be evaluating sponge cakes. For the sponge
cake manufacturing study, 15 consumers received
five samples and were asked to rate them based on
Figure1. The β-carotene content of sponge cake prepared
degree of liking on a nine-point hedonic scale (1 = with pumpkin powder. Means with different letter within
dislike extremely, 5 = neither like nor dislike, 9 = columns are significantly different (P<0.05).
like extremely). Samples were placed on plates and
identified with random three-digit numbers. Panelists
evaluated the samples in a testing area and were and was in the range of 22.62-24.11%. The moisture
instructed to rinse their mouths with water between content of sponge cakes decreased significantly with
samples to minimize any residual effect. the increasing pumpkin powder level whereas the
protein and ash contents of cake showed a reverse
Statistical analysis trend. Increasing the level of substitution from 0
Each measurement was conducted in to 20% pumpkin powder increased the protein and
quadruplicate, except for the sensory evaluation ash content of cakes from 6.19 to 6.89% and 0.94 to
(n=15). The experimental data were subjected to 1.63%, respectively. The increase in protein and ash
an analysis of variance (ANOVA) for a completely content is because of higher protein and ash content
random design using a statistical analysis system in pumpkin powder.
(SAS 9.1 Institute, Inc.). Duncan’s multiple range A significant decrease in cake volume was noted
tests were used to determine the difference among with an increase in the pumpkin powder level. The
means at the level of 0.05. control sample had an average cake volume of 68.26
cm3, decreasing to 66.98, 63.08, 56.52 and 51.35
Results and Discussion cm3 for 5, 10, 15 and 20%, respectively. Masoodi et
al. (2002) reported that the cake volume decreased
Physico-chemical characteristics of cakes with increasing apple pomace levels. Increasing the
Bakery products like cakes, cookies, bread etc are pumpkin powder level from 0 to 20% increased the
very much liked by both young and old generation in density of cakes from 366 to 487 kg/m3. In addition,
rural and urban areas. So, an attempt was made to increasing the level of substitution from 0 to 20%
develop wholesome and nutritious cake by blending pumpkin powder increased the β-carotene content of
whole wheat flour and pumpkin, along with other cakes from 6.84 to 9.78 mg/100g (Figure 1).
ingredients. Changes in cake characteristics with The potential of carrot powder was evaluated
added pumpkin powder are shown in Table 2. The fat for production of fiber rich sponge cakes by Salehi,
content of sponge cakes was not significantly different Kashaninejad, Akbari et al. (2016). The density,
Hosseini Ghaboos et al./IFRJ 25(2): 854-860 858
Means with different letter within columns are significantly different (P<0.05).
Nine-point hedonic scale with 1, 5, and 9 representing extremely dislike, neither like nor
dislike, and extremely like, respectively. Means with different letter within columns are
significantly different (P<0.05).
ash, β-carotene and moisture content of baked cakes from 0 to 20% (Table 3). The hardness of cakes was
increased with increasing carrot powder levels from directly related to the density of the tested materials
0 to 30%, whereas the protein and carbohydrate (indirectly to its volume). The weight of samples was
content of samples showed a reverse trend. Sensory not significantly different among any of the cakes in
evaluation results indicated that cake with 10% carrot this study. Thus, the increase in hardness was mainly
powder was rated the most acceptable. Increasing the related to the volume of these cakes. Springiness
level of substitution from 0 to 30% carrot powder measures elasticity by determining the extent of
increased the β-carotene content of cakes from 4.98 recovery between the first and second compression.
to 19.94 mg/100g. The springiness values of sponge cake with pumpkin
were in the range of 0.87-0.92.
Color measurement Cohesiveness quantifies the internal resistance of
The results of color measurement of sponge food structure. Briefly, cohesiveness is the ability of a
cake supplemented with pumpkin powder dried in material to stick to itself. The cohesiveness values of
an infrared–hot air dryer are presented in table 2. sponge cake with pumpkin were in the range of 0.58-
The crumb colour of samples was affected by the 66. Gumminess is determined by hardness multiplied
replacement of cake flour with pumpkin powder. by cohesiveness. Chewiness is determined by
In general, as pumpkin powder level increased, the gumminess multiplied by springiness, and represents
crumb colour became darker. For crumb colour, as the amount of energy needed to disintegrate a food
the level of pumpkin powder increased, the L* value for swallowing. TPA results showed a increase in the
decreased but the a* and b* value increased, indicating cake gumminess and chewiness with increased level
that a darker, redder and yellow crumb was obtained of pumpkin powder from 0 to 20%. The gumminess
as a result of pumpkin powder substitution. The and chewiness values were in the range of 359.87-
sponge cake with 10% pumpkin exhibited a color, 521.16 g and 328.36-475.65 g, respectively.
with L*, a* and b* equal to 81.37, 312 and 70.91, Resilience is the ratio of recoverable energy as
respectively. the first compression is relieved. The results showed
not significantly different in the cake resilience
Textural properties of cakes values. Salehi, Kashaninejad, Asadi et al. (2016)
In texture profile analysis the hardness of improvement quality attributes of sponge cake using
samples measured showed that the cake became infrared dried button mushroom. TPA results showed
harder with increasing levels of pumpkin powder a decrease in the cake consistency with an increased
859 Hosseini Ghaboos et al./IFRJ 25(2): 854-860
level of button mushroom powder. The consistency Food Processing and Technology 4(9): 4-9.
values decreased from 4578.83 to 1797.03 g.s with Hebbar, U.H., Vishwanathan, K.H. and Ramesh, M.N.
increasing button mushroom powder levels from 0 to 2004. Development of combined infrared and hot air
15%. Overall, as the percentage of button mushroom dryer for vegetables. Journal of Food Engineering
65(4): 557–563.
powder increased, consistency, hardness, gumminess,
Hosseini Ghaboos, S.H., Ardabili, S.M.S., Kashaninejad,
and chewiness decreased whereas cohesiveness M., Asadi, G. and Aalami, M. 2016. Combined
increased. infrared-vacuum drying of pumpkin slices. Journal of
Food Science and Technology: 1-9.
Sensory evaluation Masoodi, F., Sharma, B. and Chauhan, G. 2002. Use of
For measuring product liking and preference, apple pomace as a source of dietary fiber in cakes.
the hedonic scale is a unique scale, providing Plant Foods for Human Nutrition 57(2): 121-128.
both reliable and valid results (Stone et al., 2012). Nawirska, A., Figiel, A., Kucharska, A.Z., Sokół-
Statistically significant differences evaluated by the Łętowska, A. and Biesiada, A. 2009. Drying kinetics
trained consumers were found in the crumb colour, and quality parameters of pumpkin slices dehydrated
using different methods. Journal of Food Engineering
flavour, texture and overall liking scores among the
94(1): 14-20.
control, 5, 10, 15 and 20% (Table 4). However, the Nowak, D. and Lewicki, P.P. 2004. Infrared drying of
sensory characteristics liking scores of 0% were apple slices. Innovative Food Science and Emerging
lower than those of the other cakes and the 20% was Technologies 5(3): 353-360.
slightly darker. The sensory characteristics liking Pan, Z., Shih, C., McHugh, T.H. and Hirschberg E. 2008.
results pointed out that a partial replacement of cake Study of banana dehydration using sequential infrared
flour with up to 10% pumpkin powder in sponge radiation heating and freeze-drying. LWT-Food
cakes is satisfactory. Science and Technology 41: 1944-1951
Ponkham, K., Meeso, N., Soponronnarit, S. and
Conclusion Siriamornpun, S. 2012. Modeling of combined far-
infrared radiation and air drying of a ring shaped-
pineapple with/without shrinkage. Food and
Infrared-hot air method, when properly applied, Bioproducts Processing 90(2): 155-164.
can be used for achieving a high-quality product. Ptitchkina, N.M., Novokreschonova, L.V., Piskunova, G.V.
In this study a novel formulation of sponge cake and Morris, E.R. 1998. Large enhancements in loaf
production with pumpkin was developed. Addition of volume and organoleptic acceptability of wheat bread
pumpkin powder to the cake formula led to increase by small additions of pumpkin powder: possible role
in the β-carotene of cakes. The protein and ash of acetylated pectin in stabilising gas-cell structure.
contents of sponge cakes increased significantly with Food Hydrocolloids 12(3): 333-337.
the increasing pumpkin powder level whereas the Puvanenthiran, A. Stevovitch-Rykner, C., McCann, T.H.
moisture content showed a reverse trend. For crumb and Day, L. 2014. Synergistic effect of milk solids and
carrot cell wall particles on the rheology and texture
colour, as the level of pumpkin powder increased,
of yoghurt gels. Food Research International 62: 701-
the L* values decreased but the a* and b* values 708.
increased, indicating that a darker, redder and yellow Ratti, C. and Mujumdar, A. 1995. Infrared drying.
crumb was obtained as a result of pumpkin powder Handbook of Industrial Drying, Ed Mujumdar, A S,
substitution. The gumminess and chewiness values Second edition, New York, NY, Marcel Dekker Inc 1:
were in the range of 359.87-521.16 g and 328.36- 567-588.
475.65, respectively. The sensory characteristics Sacilik, K. 2007. Effect of drying methods on thin-layer
liking results pointed out that a partial replacement of drying characteristics of hull-less seed pumpkin
cake flour with up to 10% pumpkin powder in sponge (Cucurbita pepo L.). Journal of Food Engineering
cakes is satisfactory. 79(1): 23–30.
Sakai, N. and Hanzawa, T. 1994. Applications and
advances in far-infrared heating in Japan. Trends in
References Food Science and Technology 5(11): 357-362.
Salehi, F. and Kashaninejad, M. 2014. Effect of Different
Afzal, T., Abe, T. and Hikida, Y. 1999. Energy and quality Drying Methods on Rheological and Textural
aspects during combined FIR-convection drying of Properties of Balangu Seed Gum. Drying Technology
barley. Journal of Food Engineering 42(4): 177-182. 32(6): 720-727.
Alibas, I. 2007. Microwave, air and combined microwave– Salehi, F. and Kashaninejad, M. 2015. Effect of drying
air-drying parameters of pumpkin slices. LWT-Food methods on rheological and textural properties, and
Science and Technology 40(8): 1445-1451. color changes of wild sage seed gum. Journal of Food
Bhat, M.A. and Bhat, A. 2013. Study on Physico-Chemical Science and Technology 52(11): 7361-7368.
Characteristics of Pumpkin Blended Cake. Journal of Salehi, F., Kashaninejad, M., Akbari, E., Sobhani, S.M.
Hosseini Ghaboos et al./IFRJ 25(2): 854-860 860