Minor Hockey Association Coach Development Plan
Minor Hockey Association Coach Development Plan
Minor Hockey Association Coach Development Plan
Development Guide
Minor Hockey Association
Coach Development Plan
Recruitment, Selection, Training, Evaluation,
Retention, Conduct, and Ethics for Coaches
TABLE OF CONTENTS
RECRUITING COACHES.........................................................................................................................................2
WHO TO RECRUIT .......................................................................................................................................................2
COACH SELECTION PROCESS.............................................................................................................................3
COACH SELECTION TREE/TIMELINE ...........................................................................................................................3
JOB DESCRIPTIONS FOR COACHES ..................................................................................................................4
HEAD COACH .............................................................................................................................................................4
ASSISTANT COACH .....................................................................................................................................................4
8 STEPS TO COACH SELECTION .........................................................................................................................5
1. THE ASSOCIATION MENTOR POSITION ...................................................................................................5
2. COMMITTEE SELECTION.............................................................................................................................5
3. APPLICATIONS...............................................................................................................................................5
4. THE INTERVIEW PROCESS ..........................................................................................................................6
INTERVIEW QUESTIONS ....................................................................................................................................10
5. FINAL SELECTION .......................................................................................................................................14
6. CONTACTING CANDIDATES .....................................................................................................................14
7. FOLLOW UP...................................................................................................................................................14
8. EVALUATION ...............................................................................................................................................15
COACH TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT .......................................................................................................15
LOCAL ASSOCIATION SPECIALTY CLINICS.................................................................................................15
EVALUATION/ASSESSMENT OF COACHES....................................................................................................15
FORMS FOR PARENTS/PLAYERS TO FILL OUT.............................................................................................16
SELF ASSESSMENT – HOW AM I DOING?.......................................................................................................17
MENTOR OR PEER ASSESSMENT.....................................................................................................................20
COACH RETENTION .............................................................................................................................................25
KEEP THEM COMING BACK ......................................................................................................................................25
TIPS FROM THE FIELD........................................................................................................................................25
COACH CONDUCT AND ETHICS........................................................................................................................26
GUIDELINES FOR PLAYING SPORTS ...............................................................................................................27
1
RECRUITING COACHES
Before you start the recruiting process with your association should ask some key questions.
Who to Recruit
Quite often the obvious answer is parents, but are there groups or individuals beyond the
parents that would be a potentially strong group of coaches.
Players – this group may have the greatest knowledge of your association. Midget or Juvenile
aged players that have recently left the association or players playing college or university
hockey locally are quite often very interested in giving back to the program. They typically have
tremendous knowledge of the game, enthusiasm and a willingness to learn and grow in the
coaching position.
Service Groups – typically these groups are sponsors but may also have an interest in playing
an on-ice role.
2
COACH SELECTION PROCESS
2 Circulate Applications
4 Review Applications
5 Short List
6 Conduct Interviews
7 Finalize Selections
8 Notify Applicants
Assess/Mentor Throughout
10
Year
11 Final Report
3
JOB DESCRIPTIONS FOR COACHES
Once you have determined your hiring process it is imperative that you as a committee develop
a job description for each of the positions that you are hiring for. It is impossible to make
coaches accountable, give them feedback or help them develop if they are unsure of what their
purpose there really is.
The following 2 pages are generic job descriptions that can be used as guidelines.
Head Coach
Job Description
Assistant Coach
Job Descriptions
4
The following qualifications can be applied to both the Head Coach and the Assistant.
• Recruit coaches
• Contact person for prospective coaches
• Distribute and collect applications
• Create and chair committees for screening
• Interviewing and final selection
• Contact successful and unsuccessful candidates
• Provide new coaches with their initial instructions
• Ongoing evaluation of coaches
2. COMMITTEE SELECTION
It is suggested that the Association mentor form a committee to ensure fairness in the
screening interview and final selection of candidates. For simplicity and efficiency, the
committee should consist of no more than five people. Committee Members should
include a member of the executive, a person with coaching experience, and possibly a
neutral person unrelated to the association. Once the committee has been formed, it
should meet to establish its structure and procedure. The Association mentor should chair
the committee. Obviously, any conflict of interest on this committee must be avoided (see
disclosure form).
3. APPLICATIONS
All coaches, new or returning, should be required to complete an application form.
Initial Contact: The Association mentor should be available for all prospective coaches to
contact. This person will be responsible for the distribution and collection of coaching
applications.
5
The Application Form: A sample application form follows on the next page. Feel free to
use it, change it, or create your own. Make sure that applications include all the
information you feel you need.
6
• A written record of the interview should be retained by the MHA. This should include the
interviewers’ evaluation of the candidate. Evaluation may take the form of written
comments, or involve some sort of numerical ranking and written comments. Again, the
categories you use in evaluating should relate to the qualities the association is looking
for.
The following is a sample of a coach application. More can be found in the appendix to this
document.
7
Coach Application Form
EMAIL:______________________________________________________________
COMMENTS_________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________.
8
NAME OF ASSOCIATION: ___________________________________________
It is the intention of this pledge to promote fair play and respect for all participants within the
_____________ Association. All coaches must sign this pledge before being allowed to
participate in hockey and must continue to observe the principles of Fair Play.
1. I will be reasonable when scheduling games and practices remembering that young
athletes have other interests and obligations.
2. I will teach my athletes to play fairly and to respect the rules, officials, opponents and
teammates.
3. I will ensure all athletes receive equal instruction, discipline, support and appropriate, fair
playing time.
4. I will not ridicule or yell at my athletes for making mistakes or for performing poorly. I will
remember that children play to have fun and must be encouraged to have confidence in
themselves.
5. I will make sure that equipment and facilities are safe and match the athlete's ages and
ability.
6. I will remember that children need a coach they can respect. I will be generous with
praise and set a good example.
7. I will obtain proper training and continue to upgrade my coaching skills.
I agree to abide by the principles of the FAIR PLAY CODE as set by the Canadian Hockey
Association and supported by the _____________ Association.
I also agree to abide by the rules, regulations and decisions as set by the _____________
Association.
PRINT NAME________________________DATE________________________________
SIGNATURE: _____________________________________________________________
9
INTERVIEW QUESTIONS
These sample questions have been grouped into five sections. Some questions will not apply to
amateur levels or calibers of minor hockey. Thus, the interview committee must select which
questions are relevant and/or important. When interviewing a number of candidates for the
same position it is recommended that you first determine a bank of questions that will be asked
of all candidates.
1. Can you describe for us what you did in this situation… It was halfway through the 2nd period
and it was a tight game. You have a line that was not as strong as your other two. You
wanted to win.
2. For your last team what, if any team or individual objectives did you set?
3. You have outlined (assuming application form was completed) your interests in coaching the
coming year with this association. Outline your general philosophy and coaching objectives.
4. As a coach, it is necessary for you to have a standard for the management of your players
and support staff before a game, during a game, at a practice, on a road trip? Please
explain.
5. What is your attitude with respect to off-ice activities? i.e. Dry land training, school sports,
other social activities.
6. What is your philosophy o formation of lines?
7. What is your feeling about players playing more than one position?
10
II. TEACHING AND INSTRUCTION
1. What type of practice preparation would you do to ensure that you receive optimum
performance form your athletes in readiness for game play?
2. Tell us about a situation when it was important that one of your players learn a new skill.
Why was it important?
6. Why is sound yearly planning essential to the successful operation of a hockey team?
8. In tryouts, what skills are you looking for and how do you plan to evaluate them?
9. How do you organize your practices with respect to time for warm-up, cool-down, main
teaching time, fun activity and other coaches’ responsibilities?
10. Do you agree that to be a good coach you must also be a good educator? Specifically, how
is this true?
11
III. COMMUNICATION WITH PLAYERS
a. Tell us about a time when you had to discipline a player and either the player or his
teammates felt the discipline was unfair. How did you handle this situation?
b. Give us an example of when your discipline was proven to be unjust or inappropriate.
i. How did you handle this?
ii. What was the result?
2. Tell us about an occasion you are proud of when you were able to instill a sense of
motivation into one or more players.
4. How do you handle the player who does not get along with teammates?
7. What is your approach when dealing with players who have suggestions?
8. How would you handle a situation where there is jealousy between two players or where two
players dislike one another?
9. How do you handle behavior changes of your players at the specific age group?
12
IV. COMMUNICATION WITH PARENTS
1. Describe how you would handle a parent who has a different philosophy or game plan than
yours.
2. What is your approach when dealing with parents who have criticisms and/or complaints?
3. What is your approach when you hear that a parent is criticizing you “behind your back” and
hasn’t approached you on their own to discuss the concern?
4. How would you approach the parent who is excessively vocal and negative in the stands
knowing that it is affecting either their own child or the team?
5. How would you handle a complaint from a parent that his/her child does not play enough?
6. How would you handle complaints/accusations from a parent that the team’s budget isn’t in
order and that there may be money missing?
V. GENERAL QUESTIONS
1. If applicable: How do you feel about coaching your child? What are the advantages and
disadvantages?
2. What is it about coaching that you find most difficult or you need to work on the most?
3. Tell us about a situation that shows the most positive side of you.
4. Outline one coaching experience you think best characterizes you as a coach.
7. How would you handle dealing with your affiliate team throughout the season?
8. Should the coaching position not be available, would you consider accepting another
position at a different level? What are your preferences?
9. What is your opinion about coaches holding a position on a minor hockey executive?
10. Do you have anyone who would work with you as assistant, manager, trainer?
11. Have you ever been suspended under any hockey regulations as a player or coach? Explain
13
5. FINAL SELECTION
Once the interviews are completed, it is time to make the final selection. As stated
previously, it is strongly recommended that those who conduct the interview be
responsible for the final selection of coaches. All candidates should be made aware of
when decisions will be made and when all candidates will be contacted.
• There should be pre-set criteria for evaluating candidates. These criteria are based on
the desirable qualities outlined by the association. Previous experience, success, and
interview evaluation should all be considered.
• Before making a decision, the committee must decide how the final selection will be
made. Some questions to ask:
i) Who will vote?
ii) Will voting be open or by secret ballot?
iii) Is a majority decision required?
iv) How do you break a tie?
• Always allow time for discussion before making a decision.
6. CONTACTING CANDIDATES
All applicants, whether successful or not, should be contacted. The person contacting
them should have been involved in the selection process ideally the association mentor.
This will allow them to be prepared to answer questions unsuccessful candidates will
have. Unsuccessful candidates, or coaches who were not given their first choice, should
always be given reasons for the decision. It is also suggested that unsuccessful
candidates be sent written “thank you” letters for their interest in your association.
Always contact successful applicants first. Only after they have definitely accepted
the team should you contact unsuccessful applicants.
7. FOLLOW UP
The association mentor’s job is not done once all the coaches are selected.
14
8. EVALUATION
The evaluation of a coach’s performance can be valuable for future selection. Information
on the coach’s performance can be gathered from the players’ parents, coaches
themselves, other coaches, or by a neutral observer. Evaluations should always be
written. They may be ongoing, or may occur at certain times of the year (i.e. middle and
end of season).
For more information on the National Coach Certification Program (NCCP), please refer to the
NCCP section on this CD.
Local associations are encouraged to host specialty clinics (especially at the beginning of the
year) for all of their coaches. These clinics should cover – fair play code for association
coaches, parent meetings, association philosophy on player development, mentorship, tools
available to assist coaches, the association support mechanism for coaches and of course any
technical hockey issues that coaches want to discuss. Depending on the size of the association
these are best offered by grouping the Novice coaches together, Atom coaches etc.
EVALUATION/ASSESSMENT OF COACHES
There are three main areas of evaluation/assessment that will be covered in this section;
• Self-assessment
• Peer assessment
• Parent, player assessment
The first question you will often find come from coaches, parents and players is Why Assess or
Evaluate?
Most often you'll evaluate to learn. If there's to be no action taken as a result of the evaluation
then, unless you just want material for a paper, the effort is not worth pursuing. So, before you
embark on an evaluation, ask yourself "why bother?” Who is this for, what is it they want to find
out, and what changes will be made when the results are gathered? If the answer to the
question "why evaluate?" is that the results will lead to action to improve coaching within the
association, then all the effort will be worthwhile.
Sample forms can be found on the following pages for various assessments the
coach/association can undertake over the course of the hockey season.
15
FORMS FOR PARENTS/PLAYERS TO FILL OUT
The purpose of this form is to assist the coach in developing themselves and the program
for next season. Please be frank and honest in your responses to the following questions.
Your input is essential to improving the quality of the coaching next year.
no - yes
To be completed by the player:
1. Did you enjoy being on the hockey team? 1 2 3 4 5
2. Did you learn more about hockey? 1 2 3 4 5
3. Did your hockey skills improve? 1 2 3 4 5
4. Are you planning to tryout for a hockey team next year? 1 2 3 4 5
5. What was your favorite activity in practices? (back of form) 1 2 3 4 5
6. What was your least favorite activity in practices? (back of form) 1 2 3 4 5
7. Did you think playing time was fair? How could it have been better? 1 2 3 4 5
8. Did you think you had enough opportunity to ask questions? 1 2 3 4 5
9. What would you change to help next year's team? 1 2 3 4 5
no - yes
To be completed by the parent
1. Did your child enjoy the hockey experience? 1 2 3 4 5
2. Do you feel your child became a better hockey player? 1 2 3 4 5
3. Did your child gain a better perspective of teamwork? 1 2 3 4 5
4. Did the hockey experience help your child mature? 1 2 3 4 5
5. Did hockey help your child's self-confidence? 1 2 3 4 5
6. In your opinion, was playing administered appropriately? 1 2 3 4 5
7. Was the coach's public conduct at games acceptable? 1 2 3 4 5
8. Do you feel your child was treated with respect? 1 2 3 4 5
9. How would you rate the coach's organization skills? 1 2 3 4 5
10. How would you rate the coach's communication with parents? 1 2 3 4 5
11. Please suggest changes that you think would improve the program.
(reply on back of form)
12. Please list other questions that should be on this evaluation. (reply on
back of form)
16
SELF ASSESSMENT – HOW AM I DOING?
The following sets of questions can help you articulate your philosophy of coaching as well as
the atmosphere of your team and practices.
1. Using the following chart, assess how well you carry out your roles as a leader, teacher, and
organizer. For each statement, select the word that best describes you. This chart can be
used to assess yourself throughout the season.
Needs
Excellent Good
Improvement
As a leader I:
1. Establish Goals
As a Teacher I:
1. Teach the necessary hockey
2. Teach the skills using the proper sequence and
progressions
3. Teach skills using understandable language
17
Needs
Excellent Good
Improvement
4. Realize athletes differ in their readiness to learn a skill
4. Attend to details
5. Communicate effectively
2. Every coach should ask themselves the following questions each season.
18
I do a safety check of the facility before each practice and
game
4. Helping Athletes become Better People. Which of the following are parts of your coaching
strategies?
Yes No
I discuss my plans for the number and duration or practices with my athletes or their
parents. I am reasonable in my demands on their time.
I ask my athletes what they want from the sport experience. Studies have shown that
most children play for fun and would rather play for a losing team than sit on the
bench of a winning one.
I teach my athletes to treat the officials and other participants with respect.
I never criticize or ridicule my athletes. I offer constructive feedback and present any
perceived problems as positive challenges.
I have guidelines for behaviour in place and discuss these with my athletes.
I am a positive role model for the athletes I coach. Setting a positive example is the
best way to encourage positive behaviour in others.
19
MENTOR OR PEER ASSESSMENT
20
21
22
23
24
COACH RETENTION
Keep Them Coming Back
Finding volunteer coaches qualified to meet the needs of your association requires work. Once
you've successfully secured a volunteer's support, it's important to ensure that the benefits of
volunteering continue to outweigh the costs.
When volunteer initiatives are well managed and individuals are matched to service
opportunities that are mutually beneficial to the association and the volunteer, your recruitment
job becomes much easier. Satisfied volunteer coaches can be strong advocates for your
organization's mission and persuasive partners on your volunteer recruitment team.
There are many ways to foster volunteer coach retention. Just as people are attracted to
volunteer at your organization for a multitude of reasons there are many reasons why they
continue to serve. Oftentimes, these reasons are different than the ones that persuaded them to
give of their time in the first place. For example, a 1983 study of volunteer firefighters by Pearce
"found that these subjects stated that they joined the organization for predominately service
reasons, but friendships and social interaction were more influential in their decision to remain
with it" (cited in Brudney 1990, p. 162,)
Career Enhancement
Recognition
• showing your appreciation often, in many ways, and in ways that are individual-specific
Meaningful Work
• periodic orientations that link volunteer assignments to the broader mission of the
organization
• making the work meaningful and never wasting their time
• making good matches from the start - head vs. assistant coach.
Personal Growth
25
Respect
• treating volunteer coaches as staff* by inviting them to attend staff/board meetings and giving
them a voice within the organization/association
• accepting their recommendations/taking their advice
At the same time that you are listening for ways to keep them coming back, be sure to listen for
organizational barriers to continued volunteer involvement. Some of the reasons why volunteers
leave are out of your control; others may speak to program management, organizational culture,
or logistical issues that can be addressed. Just as positive word of mouth by volunteer
supporters can enhance your recruitment efforts, negative word of mouth by former participants
can undermine future endeavors to attract volunteers.
Once you've 'lost' a volunteer due to program or organization inadequacies, it is hard to get
them back.
To summarize, some of the keys to better, happier volunteer coaching that continue to come
back to your association year after year are:
• I will be reasonable when scheduling games and practices, remembering that players have
other interests and obligations
• I will teach my players to play fairly and to respect the rules, officials and opponents.
• I will ensure that all players get equal instruction, support and playing time
• I will not ridicule or yell at my players for making mistakes or for performing poorly. I will
remember that players play to have fun and must be encouraged to have confidence in
themselves.
• I will make sure that equipment and facilities are safe and match the players' ages and
abilities.
26
• I will remember that participants need a coach they can respect. I will be generous with
praise and set a good example
•
I will obtain proper training and continue to upgrade my coaching skills.
• I will work in cooperation with officials for the benefit of the game
Creating a code of conduct and ethics for coaches is a step in the right direction but
associations must also be willing to stand behind their code and use it has a measuring stick for
how their coaches are doing.
The cliché "in the heat of action" has frequently been used as an acceptable rationale for
harassing and abusive behaviour during competition. It is important that coaches and personnel
recognize that abuse and harassment must not be tolerated during competition under any
circumstances.
Codes of Behaviour for players, coaches, officials and spectators have been developed and
must guide and govern "the talk and the walk" or "the words and the actions" of all participants
during competition. It is vital that sport administrators create an environment for competition
where Standards of Behaviour are built on Respect:
The responsibility to PREVENT harassment and abuse during competition lies with sport
administrators, athletes and coaches. The responsibility to CONTROL harassment and abuse
during competition lies with coaches, officials and sport administrators.
• Sport Administrators implementing codes of conduct for coaches, players and officials
• Sport Administrators establishing quality rules and regulations for competition
27
• Sport Administrators providing coaches with clear expectations of appropriate and
inappropriate behaviours during competition
• Sport Administrators facilitating coaching Certification Programs
• Coaches providing athletes with clear expectations of appropriate and inappropriate
behaviours during competition
• Coaches being role models for athletes
• Athletes demonstrating respect for the sport, the rules, the officials, the opposition and
teammates and coaches during competition
"The Game/Sport"
• to coach for healthy competition
• to participate in coaching certification programs
• to teach players sportsmanship and fair play
• to be good role models
• to think and act according to the coaches code of conduct
"The Rules"
• to hear the rules of play
• to teach athletes fair play
• to promote sportsmanship
"The Officials"
• to support the officials
• to teach athletes to respect officials
"The Opposition"
• to congratulate the opposition in defeat and victory
• to avoid use of intimidating tactics
• to teach athletes to respect their opponent
The "Coach" is the most influential participant in preventing harassment and abuse during
competition. This can be achieved by "talking the talk" and "walking the talk" in teaching the
athletes that the concept of Respect is the most important aspect of the competition. The coach
must use every opportunity to reinforce this principle by being a role model and communicating
28
with athletes daily in practice, during pre-competition preparation, during competition and in
post-competition feedback sessions.
The Coach must teach the athlete that the concept of Respect includes:
"The Game/Sport"
• to play for healthy competition
• to play for fun
• to play for fitness
• to play for skill development
"The Rules"
• to play by the rules
• to play fairly
"The Officials"
• to ensure fair play in competition
• to ensure the safety of players
• to ensure the environment of healthy competition
• to ensure that the rules are applied consistently and fairly
• to eliminate intimidation, harassment or abuse
"The Opposition"
• to avoid intimidating tactics and discriminating remarks
• to avoid physically hurting opposing athletes
• to congratulate your opposition in defeat and victory.
During competition harassing and abusive behaviours must be addressed. This responsibility
lies with the officials, coaches and sport administrators. It is important to realize that prevention
of such behaviours begins with education during practices and team meetings - before such
behaviours occur.
The rules and regulations of sport are established to provide consequences for inappropriate
behaviours including harassment and abuse. Minor incidents are usually addressed during the
competition. Major incidents usually result in removal from the competition and a follow up
review by the sport association administrators. The officials have a responsibility during the
29
competition to apply the rules to ensure fair play principles. The coach has the responsibility to
point out inappropriate behaviors and discipline, where appropriate, athletes whose behavior is
inappropriate during competition. This is necessary even if an official did not see the
inappropriate behavior of the athlete.
The rules of play usually direct that major harassment and abusive behaviors be reviewed by
the sport administrators. It is their responsibility to ensure that the athlete is returning to
competition after a fair consequence and with the understanding that the inappropriate behavior
must not be repeated.
The athlete has a responsibility to participate without disrespectful behaviors. Athletes need to
be equipped with skills of how to respond when confronted by an opposing athlete of a team
who exhibits inappropriate behaviors, without falling into the trap of retaliation.
"Sport/Game"
• making obscene gestures to spectators
• damaging facilities or equipment
"Rules"
• using persistent profanity
• playing persistently with illegal equipment
• persistently violating of the rules
"Officials"
• arguing with an official over a call
• persistent heckling of an official
• intimidating an official through threats of physical aggression
"Opposition"
• trash talking
• purposely trying to injure an opposing athlete
• exhibiting racial or homophobic biases
• intimidating tactics
"Teammates or Coaches"
• using intimidation
• using isolation tactics
• making racial slurs
• displaying racial or homophobic biases
• being physically aggressive
• using name calling and put-downs
30
The coach has a responsibility to behave in a respectful manner. The following are examples of
inappropriate behaviors by a coach during competition:
"Sport/Game"
• coaching while under the influence of alcohol or drugs
• withdrawing a team during competition
• interrupting competition using illegal tactics
"Rules"
• using persistent profanity
• not controlling your bench
• encouraging athletes to violate the rules
• bending the rules to create unfair play
"Official"
• berating the official
• arguing with official over calls
• intimidating tactics
• trash talking
• gesturing
"Opposition"
• encouraging your athletes to injure an opposing athlete
• trash talking
• exhibiting racial or homophonic biases
• coaching using intimidation
31
Summary
It is important for sports leaders to develop programs which reinforce that competition must be
free of abusive and harassing behaviours by athletes, coaches, officials and spectators. It is
also essential for each sport to have playing rules that will discipline athletes and coaches for
harassing and/or abusive behaviours during competition. Codes of Conduct need to be
developed for athletes, coaches, officials and all personnel, and organizations must implement
policies and procedures through which they can determine when and if a breach of these codes
has occurred (see Section I, Chapter 1).
It is similarly important for sport leaders to develop guidelines requiring coaches to be certified
through coaching programs. Coaching education will reinforce the Codes of Conduct that
discourage abusive and harassing behaviours by all involved.
32