Wall Morphology of Buildings in Puducherry by
Wall Morphology of Buildings in Puducherry by
Wall Morphology of Buildings in Puducherry by
net/publication/328017390
CITATIONS READS
0 4,886
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Arun Menon on 19 December 2018.
ABSTRACT
The city of Pondicherry located on the Eastern coast of India, is adorned with rich cultural heritage from
the pre-historic to modern colonial era. The monuments built during the French colonial rule still exist and
are in use. A considerable effort in the field of cultural heritage preservation has been undertaken by the
Government of Pondicherry, ably supported by organizations such as INTACH. Programmes such as Asia -Urbs
helped in preserving the architectural heritage of Pondicherry. The collapse of La Mairie de Pondicherry on 29
November 2014 brought forth issues related to previous conservation efforts. An overall understanding of the
structural typology, material deterioration and distress is essential in understanding the reasons for the collapse
of La Mairie de Pondicherry, and is crucial to ensure the structural health of similar structural typologies in
Pondicherry and for developing an appropriate structural conservation protocol for these buildings.
a b
Figure 2: (a) La Mairie de Pondicherry before collapse; (b) Condition of verandah before collapse
(Image Credits – NCSHS, IIT Madras)
was mostly residential. Bricks and timber for preservation of cultural heritage in
were the most preferred building material; Pondicherry. Preservation efforts such as Asia-
whereas stone had limited usage (INTACH, Urbs Programme4 has been able to etch the
Pondicherry, 2010). idea of built and cultural heritage preservation
among the stakeholders. Some notable
The structures in French town have load- outcomes of these efforts were the restoration
bearing walls with lime or mud mortar as of Hotel de L`Orient and Vysial Street
binding agents. The ceiling system comprises restoration – awarded the coveted UNESCO
of steel or timber beams and joists with Madras Asia Pacific Awards for Cultural Heritage
Terrace Roofing. Madras Terrace Roofing is Conservation- Outstanding Project in year 2000
a system in which brick on edge with lime and Award for Merit in year 2008, respectively.5
mortar is laid on closely spaced timber joists
(BIS 2119:1980, 1980). This system is popular The collapse of La Mairie de Pondicherry on
and most commonly used roofing system 29 November 2014, a listed heritage structure
here. Arches and pillars are constructed in undergoing restoration (TNN, 2014), brought
brickwork. The use of timber in French town forth issues related to previous conservation
houses is limited to the roofing system. A efforts. An overall understanding of the
similar structural system was incorporated structural typology, material deterioration
in Tamil town but the variation is in the and distress is essential in understanding
composition of spaces. the reasons for the collapse of La Mairie
de Pondicherry, and is crucial to ensure
Heritage Conservation Efforts the structural health of similar structural
The built heritage of Pondicherry is categorized typologies in Pondicherry and for developing
under un-protected monuments. Government 3
an appropriate structural conservation
of Pondicherry along with support from protocol for these buildings.
non-governmental organizations (NGOs) such
as Indian National Trust for Art Culture and This paper attempts firstly, to examine
Heritage (INTACH) has taken up the mantle and analyse possible causes of distress
Figure 3: La Mairie de Pondicherry after collapse (Image Credits – NCSHS, IIT Madras)
and collapse of La Mairie de Pondicherry collapsed while the work was in progress
specifically with reference to wall (Figure 3) (TNN, 2014).
morphology and secondly, to put forward
a case for a proper condition assessment of The structure of the La Mairie de Pondicherry
similar heritage structures in Pondicherry. was composed of load-bearing masonry walls.
The floor and roof were made of Madras Terrace
1. The Collapse of La Mairie de construction supported by timber and steel
Pondicherry joists. Steel joists were predominantly used in
Hotel de Ville or La Mairie de Pondicherry larger central rooms while timber joists were
(as it was called) dated back to 1870-71. used in other rooms.
This building was listed as Grade 1 heritage
structure (INTACH, Pondicherry, 2012). This For the masonry work, brickwork in mud mortar
building was located on the Goubert Avenue was interlaced with vertical and horizontal
in the French Town and it was used earlier bands of brickwork in lime mortar. The bands of
as Town Hall and subsequently it housed the brickwork in mud mortar were typically 70-80
Municipality of Pondicherry. The building cm in height, whereas those in lime mortar were
possessed architectural characters akin to 30 cm in height. The brickwork of the arches or
French colonial buildings in the precinct. at positions near floors and at the boundary of
openings was typically in lime mortar as bonding
This 147 years old structure showed distress material. The bands of masonry in lime mortar
due to improper maintenance. Most of the were possibly meant to provide confinement to
structural elements were distressed. The the weaker portion of the wall, i.e. brickwork in
distress was caused due to moisture and mud mortar. The masonry walls were originally
plaster had decayed severely. Cracks were plastered from the exterior and interior in lime.
observed on the masonry as well as on the The structure did not have a damp-proofing
Madras Terrace Floor (Figure 2). The structure course, which meant moisture from the ground
of historical and architectural landmark value would rise up through the masonry walls by
was taken up for repair and restoration but capillary action.
Figure 4: Load bearing masonry wall portions from the debris showing thick cement plaster.
(Image Credits – NCSHS, IIT Madras)
In past two decades when the structure was The Reasons for the Collapse of La Mairie
in service, renovation works were undertaken The collapse of the La Mairie de Pondicherry
by the Public Works Department (PWD) has been understood to have occurred after the
-Government of Puduchery in which the removal of the cement plaster on the interior
brickwork was plastered from the exterior and face of one of the primary load-bearing walls
interior with a thick layer of cement plaster.
The thick cement plaster was on
Figure 4 illustrates the presence of a thick
one hand trapping the moisture
cement plaster. For a structural masonry wall in
within the walls and on the other
brickwork with mud mortar and lime mortar,
hand, was playing a structural role
with no damp-proofing course and subjected
by confining the weakened walls
to rising dampness by capillary action, the
and sustaining the load-carrying
impervious layer of cement plastering is a
capacity of the wall.
serious hazard as it does not permit the rising
dampness to evaporate through the wall in the north-south axis. The removal of the
plaster. Original plastering in lime or mud cement plaster approximately 4 cm thick lead
would have permitted exit of moisture from to compression failure in the load-bearing
the walls, owing to the porosity of the plaster, walls. This is confirmed by the formation of
thereby keeping the masonry wall in good vertical cracks and bulging of plaster, which is
structural health (Figure 5). Moreover, regular a very rare phenomenon. Cement plastering
refurbishment of the plaster and repointing of being impervious, would trap the moisture,
bed-joint mortar are essential in such walls as and retain it within the masonry walls which
the cyclic process of escape of moisture leads were laid in mud mortar and lime mortar. Wet
to deterioration of plaster and bedding mortar, mud has poor or no compressive strength; wet
the sacrificial layer (NCSHS, 2015). compressive strength of bricks is also lower
than the dry compressive strength.
a b
Figure 5: (a) Illustration showing behavior of moisture in brick masonry with mud/lime plaster;
(b): Illustration showing moisture blocked in brickwork and plaster interface due to cement plaster
The thick cement plaster was on one hand Examination of the base and plinth of the
trapping the moisture within the walls and wall that collapsed first shows no discernible
on the other hand, was playing a structural signs of crushing at the base, implying that
role by confining the weakened walls and the crushing failure of the brick masonry at
sustaining the load-carrying capacity of the approximately one meter above the finished
wall. The use of cement plastering in such a ground level caused the collapse of the wall.
building can be described as the single-most This subsequently triggered the collapse of the
deleterious intervention that gradually led to floor and adjoining walls. The foundation of
the structural failure of the building (NCSHS, the structure in brickwork with lime mortar
2015). Thick rich cement plaster has clearly and random rubble masonry with lime
been observed in the load-bearing walls of the mortar was in excellent condition even after
Mairie building (refer Figure 4). Possibly, the the structural failure.
confinement provided by the cement plaster
layer to a highly deteriorated brick wall in mud Compression tests on brickwork in lime mortar
mortar was so critical as to lead to collapse on extracted from the collapsed structure, carried
de-plastering. out at the Structural Engineering Laboratory
of IIT Madras, showed that the compressive
There is some documentary evidence of 6 strength of the masonry was of the order of 2.0
structural failure of mud walls during removal N/mm2 (20 kg/cm2), which is a lower bound
of rich cement plaster from these walls. It is value for solid clay brickwork with lime mortar.
understood from the adobe structures in the The dry compressive strength of the brickwork
New Mexico region, that cement plastering with mud mortar would have been less than
adopted in these mud constructions (in place of 1.0 N/mm2 (10 kg/cm2); however, this was not
original mud plastering) had detrimental effects tested (NCSHS, 2015).
on the structural health of these walls (D`Ayala
& Benzoni, 2012).
a b
Figure 6:(a) Load bearing walls with partially removed plaster; (b) Delamination and bulging of plaster due to crushing
failure. (Image Credits – INTACH Pondicherry)
a b
Figure 7:(a) Distressed beam in upper floor of Pensionnat de Jeunes Filles; (b) View of Courtyard of Pensionnat de Jeunes Filles
(Image Credits – NCSHS, IIT Madras)
Figure 8:Masonry Core section from the school Pensionnat de Jeunes Filles.
Figure 9:Masonry Core section from the VOC Government High School.
a b
Figure 11:(a) Deterioration due to water seepage; (b) Verandah with later addition of Calve College
(Image Credits – NCSHS, IIT Madras)
Mairie. Wet coring process was followed for of drill bit. The biggest advantage is that it
these structures (Figures 8, 9 10). The core preserves the core section. The information
samples extracted were of 4 cm and 6.5 of wall morphology helped in analyzing the
cm. Core extraction is a powered process condition of masonry.
in which heat is generated. Wet coring is
preferred in order to keep the machine 2. The purpose of extracting core section
cooled and the blades clean when it is in was to identify wall morphology and not
use. However, the water jet is sufficient to for estimating strength of masonry. It may
wash out the mud mortar and could lead to be noted that for determining compressive
moisture ingress in masonry. This issue of strength of masonry wallettes are typically
binding mortar washing out is not noticed in extracted and not cores as in case of concrete
cement or lime mortar. structures. The extracted core is used to
identify the masonry typology, its constituents
Dry Core Extraction from Other Buildings and condition of unit and binder. Based on
Apart from these school buildings, Ecole Francaise this information on the masonry morphology,
d`Extreme- Orient (EFEO – Pondicherry Centre) correlation with existing databases of masonry
on Dumas Street and Old Lighthouse on Goubert is made to determine possible residual
Avenue were two other buildings whose condition strengths of the masonry for carrying out a
was assessed subsequently. Wet-core technique quantitative assessment of safety.
was employed in the three school buildings
as well as in the Mairie Building. A conscious 3. The information derived from core
approach in examining the wall section of EFEO extraction was helpful in decision making
and Old Lighthouse structures was adopted. A process for conservation of these buildings.
dry core technique was adopted in this case to As far as the three school buildings were
avoid washout of mortar (Figure 12, 13). Dry concerned, condition assessment along with
core technique is a time consuming exercise information of wall morphology helped
and it could result in quicker wear and tear of in deciding whether the schools were in a
machine. A core of diameter 7 cm was extracted serviceable condition or not. As regards to
from the masonry. The quality of masonry bed the EFEO building, based on the identified
joints was assessed thoroughly through this typology (similar to Mairie building) decision
exercise. It was observed that here too similar was taken not to load the structure further
intervention strategies as seen in other buildings with new additions. While in case of the Old
were adopted i.e use of cement plaster as render. Lighthouse this investigation helped us in
understanding different layers which existed
Inference in that building. It helped in clearly identifying
1. Wet coring process resulted in washout the historic layer and later additions.
of all loose materials and lead to moisture
ingress in the masonry. Dry coring process
is an appropriate method except being time
consuming and causing faster wear and tear
BIS 2119:1980. (1980). Code of Practice for Construciton of Deloche, J. (2007). Pondicherry: Past and Present.
Brick cum Concrete Composite (Madras Terrace) Roof and Pondicherry: EFEO Pondicherry and Institut Francais
Floor. New Delhi: Bureau of Indian Standards. de Pondichery.
D`Ayala, D., & Benzoni, G. (2012). Historic and Gupta, D. (2007). India, Conservation Briefs : Identification
Traditional Structures during the 2010 Chile and Documentation of Built Heritage in. New Delhi:
Earthquake: Observations, Codes, and Conservation INTACH (UK) Trust.
Strategies. Earthquake Spectra 28(S1), S425-S451.
Earthquake Engineering Research Institute. Nair, R. B. (2017). The Mairie: A lost heritage . The
Hindu. May 31, 2017.
Deloche, J. (2005). Le Vieux Pondichery (1673-1824)
Revisite d`Apres les Plans Anciens. Pondicherry: EFEO Philip, A. (2014). Restoring a stately legacy . The Hindu.
Pondicherry and Institut Francais de Pondichery. December 17, 2014.
Philip, A. (2016). Mairie poses challenge and
Express News Service. (2016). Mysuru’s 125-yr-old opportunity. The Hindu. January 27, 2016.
Devaraja market structure collapses, none injured.
The New Indian Express. August 29, 2016. Rajasekaran, S. (2015). Retracing roots of Puducherry
and knowing its culture. The Hindu. August 10, 2015.
INTACH, Pondicherry. (2010). Architectural Heritage of
Pondicherry. Pondicherry: Indian National Trust for Art Special Correspondent. (2016). Devaraja Market
Culture and Heritage (INTACH) Pondicherry Chapter. collapse: authorities prepare for dismantling
structure. The Hindu. August 29, 2016.
INTACH, Pondicherry. (2012). Listed Heritage Buildings
in the Boulevard Town of Pondicherry: French and
Tamil Precinct. Pondicherry: INTACH Pondicherry;
unpublished.
Additional Sources:
Chawla, N. (2012). A heritage, all at sea . The Hindu.
August 16, 2012.