AsiaPacClinTranslNervSystDis1269-8564673 234726
AsiaPacClinTranslNervSystDis1269-8564673 234726
AsiaPacClinTranslNervSystDis1269-8564673 234726
154]
STUDY PROTOCOL
Department of Pediatric Neurological Rehabilitation, the First Hospital of Jilin University, Changchun, Jilin Province, China
*Correspondence to: Fei-yong Jia, M.D., erkekangfujia@163.com.
orcid: 0000-0002-8309-1395
Abstract
Background: Pointed foot deformity and mental retardation are common clinical manifestations in children with spastic cerebral
palsy. Comprehensive rehabilitation training is performed in cerebral palsy children with mental retardation, but its clinical effect is not
satisfactory. Acupuncture at acupoints related to the motor, sensory, foot-motor-sensory, language and equilibrium areas can promote
intelligence and effectively relieve local muscle tension. We propose that acupuncture combined with rehabilitation training mitigates
pointed foot deformities in children with spastic cerebral palsy and contributes to the development of intelligence. This prospective,
randomized, controlled clinical study will test the above hypothesis. Functional magnetic resonance imaging will be utilized to observe
the changes in acupuncture-activated brain regions and to elucidate the mechanisms of acupuncture in treatment of spastic cerebral palsy.
Methods/Design: This is a prospective, randomized, controlled clinical trial. Sixty children with spastic cerebral palsy, hospitalized
in the Out-Patient Clinic of the Department of Pediatric Neurological Rehabilitation, the First Hospital fo Jilin University of China,
will be recruited for trial participation. All subjects will be equally and randomly divided into a treatment group and control group.
Patients in the treatment group will be subjected to conventional rehabilitation training after acupuncture. Patients in the control group
will receive conventional rehabilitation training alone. The treatment will last for 6 months. Primary outcomes will be Gross Mo-
tor Function Measure, ankle range of motion, Gesell Developmental Scale and surface electromyography. Secondary outcomes will
be: modified Ashworth Scale of muscle spasticity, Fine Motor Function Measure, Gross Motor Function Classification System, and
functional magnetic resonance imaging.
Discussion: It is hoped that the experimental results can provide quantitative data for acupuncture combined with rehabilitation
training in the treatment of spastic cerebral palsy.
Trial registration: Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (registration No. ChiCTR-ONC-15007633) on December 24, 2015.
Key words: acupuncture; spastic cerebral palsy; Ashworth Scale of muscle spasticity; surface electromyography; intelligence; ankle
range of motion; randomized controlled trial
doi: 10.4103/2468-5577.181237
How to cite this article: Wang LL, Du L, Shan L, Dong HY, Jia FY (2016) Acupuncture combined with rehabilitation training improves
pointed foot deformity and mental retardation in infants with spastic cerebral palsy: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial. Asia
Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis 1(2):69-75.
© 2016 Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow 69
[Downloaded free from http://www.actnjournal.com on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
Wang LL, et al. / Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis www.actnjournal.com
growth retardation and abnormal posture, but also induce a visual disorder appears after corticospinal tract injury
contracture, deformity and pain. The gastrocnemius and (Nanba et al., 2007), anisometropia, strabismus, low
soleus muscle spasm often results in ankle plantar flexion visual acuity, dynamic visual acuity of eye movement,
and dorsiflexion insufficiency. The heel cannot touch the graphic perception, and visual memory may change.
ground normally, producing pointed foot deformity and These impact the development of intelligence, especially
reducing the stability of the support surface of the affected attention, memory and spatial thinking. Preterm birth and
foot. This affects the standing and walking abilities of these low birth weight are risk factors for visual impairment in
children (Li et al., 2006). cerebral palsy children (Zhao et al., 2010). Our previous
The total prevalence of mental retardation was approxi- research has shown that comprehensive rehabilitation or
mately 70% in spastic cerebral palsy children (Hou et neurotrophic drug treatment for cerebral palsy has a cer-
al., 2004). A higher Gross Motor Function Classification tain promoting effect on the development of intelligence,
System score was associated with a higher proportion of but we did not study the improvement in pointed foot
mental retardation (Hou et al., 2004). Krägeloh-Mann deformity. Moreover, the therapeutic effects and safety
et al. (1995) considered that the incidence of periven- considerations are different between comprehensive
tricular leukomalacia was high in children with spastic rehabilitation and drug treatment. Our previous studies
diplegia, occurring in 87% of premature infants. When are listed in Table 1.
Key to treating cerebral palsy is how to simultaneously there has been little comparison or assessment of their clini-
improve mental retardation and pointed foot deformity. cal effects (Wen and Dong, 2009). Therefore, the combined
The methods to lessen foot spasm consist of exercise application of other methods with rehabilitation training is
therapy, physical therapy, kreotoxin, surgery, brace, wax needed to gain satisfactory effects.
therapy and shock wave. However, none is effective alone, Acupuncture has been shown to completely regulate
so combined therapy is needed. Apart from neurotrophic the body’s activities, improve movement, intelligence,
drugs, comprehensive rehabilitation training is performed emotion, physical and mental health (Liu et al., 2010;
in cerebral palsy children with mental retardation, includ- Zhang et al., 2010; Zhang and Wu, 2012). Xie et al.
ing exercise therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, (2012) verified that acupuncture at acupoints related to
psychotherapy, education and social rehabilitation. So far the motor area, sensory area, foot-motor-sensory area, and
70 Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis ¦ April ¦ Volume 1 ¦ Issue 2
[Downloaded free from http://www.actnjournal.com on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
Wang LL, et al. / Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis www.actnjournal.com
language area could noticeably increase cell viability in brain regions that might elucidate the mechanisms of acu-
the brain and promote the development of intelligence. puncture in treatment of spastic cerebral palsy. This study
Acupuncture at Quchi (LI11), Chize (LU5), Shousanli aims to provide quantitative data for acupuncture combined
(LI10), Zusanli (ST36), Sanyinjiao (SP6) and Naoqing with rehabilitation training in treatment of spastic cerebral
(Ex-LE16) can effectively relieve local muscle tension palsy. This trial will observe the immediate effects and
and improve abnormal posture. long-term effects of acupuncture on pointed foot of spastic
We suggest that acupuncture combined with reha- cerebral palsy patients and identify any therapeutic effect
bilitation training can effectively mitigate pointed foot of acupuncture.
deformities in children with spastic cerebral palsy and
improve the development of intelligence. This prospective, Methods/Design
randomized, controlled clinical trial will test the above Study design
hypothesis. Functional magnetic resonance imaging will This will be a prospective, randomized, controlled clinical
be utilized to observe any changes in acupuncture-activated trial (Figure 1).
Primary outcomes: Gross Motor Func- Secondary outcomes: modified Ashworth Scale of Safety assessment: assessment
tion Measure, ankle range of motion, muscle spasticity, Fine Motor Function Measure, of adverse events
Gesell Developmental Scale and Gross Motor Function Classification System, and
surface electromyography functional magnetic resonance imaging
Data analysis
Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis ¦ April ¦ Volume 1 ¦ Issue 2 71
[Downloaded free from http://www.actnjournal.com on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
Wang LL, et al. / Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis www.actnjournal.com
Ethical approval • Failure to follow the protocol or desire to drop out of the
A family member of each patient will be informed of the trial
study protocols, and will sign with their informed consent. • Poor compliance, investigators determine that the
The study will be performed in accordance with the guide- patient is not suitable for the trial
lines of the Declaration of Helsinki, formulated by the • Severe adverse reactions or critical security issues dur-
World Medical Association. ing the trial
72 Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis ¦ April ¦ Volume 1 ¦ Issue 2
[Downloaded free from http://www.actnjournal.com on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
Wang LL, et al. / Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis www.actnjournal.com
day, 30 minutes each, 6 days a week. Physiotherapy includes card and follow-up record sheet, and then loaded into the
electrical nerve stimulation therapy and wax therapy, once computer for storage. The reasons why patients drop out or
a day, 30 minutes each, 6 days a week. Massage therapy have poor compliance will be recorded in the case report
comprises pressing, kneading and pricking, once a day, 30 form. We will as far as possible contact patients to gain
minutes each, 6 days a week. understanding and support, complete the evaluation, fill in
the follow-up record, record the time of the last treatment,
Follow-up and finally retain the electronic version of the data.
The sixty patients will have their own follow-up card, and
will be followed up by telephone at 6 months after treat- Outcome measures
ment. Follow-up results will be recorded on the follow-up Trial outcome measurement schedule is given in Table 2.
Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis ¦ April ¦ Volume 1 ¦ Issue 2 73
[Downloaded free from http://www.actnjournal.com on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
Wang LL, et al. / Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis www.actnjournal.com
• Admission rate bias: Tendency to choose hospitalized tionally recognized indicators to judge abnormal posture
children to reduce the loss of follow-up and improve and intelligence in cerebral palsy patients. The changes in
compliance ankle range of motion will be observed to further identify
• Nonresponse bias: Study subjects do not answer the the improvement in pointed foot deformity. In this trial,
survey content as required or conceal the truth acupuncture combined with rehabilitation training will be
• Measurement bias: A certain error will be induced by applied to treat spastic cerebral palsy in infants to gain a
subjective factors of different researcher’s measure- better therapeutic effect. Functional magnetic resonance
ment imaging will be employed to observe the activation of motor
• Confounding bias: Sex and age are common confound- area and language area after acupuncture and rehabilitation
ing factors training. This may point to the mechanism of action of
acupuncture with rehabilitation training on cerebral palsy
Bias control measures
in infants.
• Researchers receive uniform training
• Strict inclusion and exclusion criteria
Trial status
• Ensure the independence of samples
• Eliminate or reduce additional damage to patients to Ongoing and recruiting at the time of submission.
aid good compliance
• Reduce the withdrawal of cases, children who quit
Conflicts of interest
should be followed up
None declared.
• More than one member of staff could assess each Author contributions
patient. The same member(s) assess the same patient at LLW designed and participated in this trial, and obtained
each stage to prevent measurement bias final test data set. LD assessed indexes. LS collected and
• Independent variables in multivariate analysis will be analyzed statistical data. HYD retrieved references and wrote
discussed, such as cause, course and sex the paper. FYJ served as a principle investigator. All authors
• Reduce data loss. Data analysis will also be performed aproved the final version of the paper for publication.
in patients who had quit the treatment Plagiarism check
This paper was screened twice using CrossCheck to verify
Statistical analysis originality before publication.
Data will be analyzed with SPSS 15.0 software (SPSS, Chi- Peer review
cago, IL, USA). First, we will apply a statistical description This paper was double-blinded and stringently reviewed by
of the data. Measurement data that obey normal distribution international expert reviewers.
will be expressed as mean, standard deviation, minimum
value and maximum value. Data that do not obey normal
distribution will be expressed as the lower quartile, median References
and upper quartile. Numeration data will be presented as Badia M, Begoña Orgaz M, Gómez-Vela M, Verdugo MA, Ullán
constituent ratio. AM, Longo E (2016) Do environmental barriers affect the parent-
The baseline data of both groups will be analyzed with reported quality of life of children and adolescents with cerebral
non-parametric Mann-Whitney U test and chi square test. palsy? Res Dev Disabil 49-50:312-321.
The difference of ankle range of motion and developmental Bartlett DJ, Galuppi B, Palisano RJ, McCoy SW (2016) Consen-
sus classifications of gross motor, manual ability, and commu-
quotient will be compared between the two groups using
nication function classification systems between therapists and
non-parametric Mann-Whitney U test. McNemar’s chi parents of children with cerebral palsy. Dev Med Child Neurol
square test will be used to detect modified Ashworth Scale 58:98-99.
of muscle spasticity, Gross Motor Function Measure, Fine Dukes L, Buttery TJ (1982) Comparison of two screening tests: ge-
Motor Function Measure, Gross Motor Function Classifica- sell developmental test and meeting street school screening test.
tion System, and gait analysis between groups. Alpha will Percept Mot Skills 54:1177-1178.
be set to 0.05. Editorial Board of Chinese Journal of Pediatrics the Subspecialty
Group of Neurology, Pediatric Society, Chinese Medical Asso-
ciation (2005) Definition, diagnostic criteria and clinical types of
Discussion cerebral palsy in children. Zhonghua Erke Zazhi 43:262.
In strict accordance with a randomized controlled design, Hou M, Sun D, Shan R, Wang K, Yu R, Zhao JJ, Jiang YP (2004)
primary measures used in this trial, including Gross Motor Comorbidities in patients with cerebral palsy and their relation-
Function Measure, ankle range of motion, Gesell Develop- ship with neurologic subtypes and Gross Motor Function Clas-
mental Scale and surface electromyography, are interna- sification System levels. Zhonghua Erke Zazhi 48:351-354.
74 Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis ¦ April ¦ Volume 1 ¦ Issue 2
[Downloaded free from http://www.actnjournal.com on Sunday, May 10, 2020, IP: 190.238.16.154]
Wang LL, et al. / Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis www.actnjournal.com
Jia FY, Liang D, Chen YB, Hao YP (2010) Effect of levetiracetam Nanba Y, Matsui K, Aida N, Sato Y, Toyoshima K, Kawataki M,
monotherapy for epilepsy combined with cerebral palsy in tod- Hoshino R, Ohyama M, Itani Y, Goto A, Oka A (2007) Megnetic
dler. Shiyong Erke Linchuang Zazhi 25:943-949. resonance imagine regional T1 abnormalities at term accurately
Jia FY, Wang JT, Li HH, Hao YP, Li H, Liu B (2011) Effect of com- predict motor outcome in preterm infants. Pediatrics 120:e10-19.
prehensive rehabilitation on developmental quotient and intelli- Rosenbaum P, Paneth N, Leviton A, Goldstein M, Bax M, Damiano
gent structure of children with cerebral palsy. Zhongguo Fuyou D, Dan B, Jacobsson B (2006) A report: the definition andcla-
Baojian 26:2759-2760. sification of cerebral palsay April 2006. Dev Med Child Neurol
Jiang HY, Jia FY, Liu SC, Liang D (2010) Comparison of therapeu- Suppl 109:8-14.
tic effect of ganglion glycosides and Shi Pushan on cerebral palsy. Wang Z, Li J, Jia FY, Li YT, Li YK (2008) Clinical and intellec-
Zhongguo Fuyou Baojian 25:844-884. tual characteristics of children with cerebral palsy of ataxia type.
Kolind S, Seddigh A, Combes A, Russell-Schulz B, Tam R, Yogen- Zhongguo Kangfu Lilun yu Shijian 14:184-185.
drakumar V, Deoni S, Sibtain NA, Traboulsee A, Williams SC, Wechsler D (1939) Wechsler-Bellevue intelligence scale. New
Barker GJ, Brex PA (2015) Brain and cord myelin water imag- York: The Psychological Corporation.
ing: a progressive multiple sclerosis biomarker. Neuroimage Clin Wen YQ, Dong XL (2009) Advances of studies on acupuncture and
9:574-580. moxibustion for treatment of language disorder in children with
Krägeloh-Mann I, Petersen D, Hagberg G, Vollmer B, Hagberg cerebral palsy. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 29:772-774.
B, Michaelis R (1995) Bilateral spastic cerebral palsy: analysis Xie XS, Su AF, Su XH (2012) Scalp acupuncture combined with
from a representative series of 56 cases. Dev Med Child Neurol manipulation for treatment of children with cerebral palsy in 44
37:379-397. cases. Xiandai Zhongxiyi Jiehe Zazhi 21:1186-1187.
Li H, Ding JX, Zhou AY, Huang DF, Jiang Q, Yin YD (2006) Gait Zhang HY, Lu SF, Xiao N (2010) Effects of mild warming moxi-
analysis through plantar pressure measurement in children with bustion on acupoints Shenque (RN8) and Guanyuan (RN4) for
spastic cerebral palsy. Zhonghua Wuli Yixue yu Kangfu Zazhi prevention and treatment of recurrent respiratory tract infection
28:818-821. in children with cerebral palsy. Zhongguo Zhong Xi Yi Jie He Za
Liu L, Liu LG, Lü M, Ran WJ (2010) Clinical observation on infan- Zhi 30:935-937.
tile cerebral palsy treated with quick meridian needling therapy Zhang XJ, Wu Q (2012) Impacts on IEMG of gastrocnemius muscle
plus scalp acupuncture. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 30:826-829. for children with cerebral palsy treated with different intervention
Mishra C, Ganesh GS (2014) Inter-rater reliability of modified mod- order. Zhongguo Zhen Jiu 32:301-304.
ified Ashworth scale in the assessment of plantar flexor muscle Zhao JH, Hou M, Wang Q, Zhong ZB, Sun DR (2010) The clinical
spasticity in patients with spinal cord injury. Physiother Res Int features of visual dysfunction in child with cerebral palsy. Zhon-
19:231-237. ghua Wuli Yixue yu Kangfu Zazhi 32:915-918.
Mukhopadhyay R, Mahadevappa M, Lenka PK, Biswas A (2015)
Therapeutic effects of functional electrical stimulation on motor
cortex in children with spastic cerebral palsy. Conf Proc IEEE
Eng Med Biol Soc 2015:3432-3435.
Asia Pac Clin Transl Nerv Syst Dis ¦ April ¦ Volume 1 ¦ Issue 2 75