Chapter D
Chapter D
Chapter D
Aristotle 384-322 BC
Rest is the natural state. The problem of physics was to explain why a body had a velocity.
It is a matter of common experience that after giving a body a push, it will eventually slow to a stop. When a body is pushed it is given an
impetus; it continues to move until it loses that impetus. This notion is now known as incorrect.
Aristotle was a philosopher and physics was, for him, just natural philosophy. This perspective led to a de-emphasis of experiment.
Physics was a subject one thinks about and writes about, but there was no need to test ideas with experiment. The history of science is filled
with mistakes; what made Aristotle's mistakes so serious was that by de-emphasizing experiment no one found his errors for almost 2000 years.
As an example of the absurdity of Aristotelian physics, Aristotle claimed that heavier bodies fall faster that lighter ones. This seems
intuitive at first; a brick falls faster than a feather. But he took it a step further by saying that the rate is in proportion to a body's mass. This was
a precise mathematical statement and verifying it was as simple as dropping two objects of different mass. It is remarkable that for almost 2000
years no one thought of performing that experiment to test Aristotle's hypothesis.
Motion with constant velocity is the natural state. The problem of physics was to explain what caused changes in
velocity, or what caused acceleration.
The reason why a body, when given a push on a horizontal surface, slows to a stop is due to friction. One can create motion with less friction
and can imagine motion without any friction. In that case the body will continue to move indefinitely. Naturally bodies move with constant
velocity unless some net force causes it to have an acceleration.
Galileo was a transitional figure. He demonstrated the inadequacy of Aristotelian physics. He also asked the right questions. The problem
of understanding motion was no longer to explain why a body moves but to explain what caused changes in the motion.
Newton with his first law summarized what Galileo had done. The idea is that motion with a constant velocity is the natural state.
An object at rest tends to stay at rest. An object in uniform linear motion tends to maintain that motion. The
word "tends" should be taken to mean: unless acted upon a net force.
2 Chapter D - Newton's Laws and Applications
An object at rest tends to stay at rest. An object in uniform linear motion tends to maintain that motion. The
word "tends" should be taken to mean: unless acted upon a net force.
The first sentence sounds more Aristotelian than Galilean. Uniform linear motion implies motion in a straight line at a constant speed, that is:
constant velocity. Rest should only be viewed as a special case of constant velocity; it is a constant zero velocity.
A force is anything that pushes or pulls on an object. We will see that forces are vectors.
False Forces
Recall that a frame of reference is some coordinate system used to study motion. In an accelerated frame, for example inside an accelerat-
ing car, one feels one's self pushed opposite the direction of acceleration. When moving in a car in a straight line and braking, the acceleration is
backward and one feels a false force pushing forward. When turning to the left, the acceleration is to the left and the false force is to the right.
Generally, in any accelerated frame there is a false force opposite the acceleration.
What is the nature of these false forces? The point of the first law is that all bodies will tend to move with a constant velocity. When
braking in a car, a person in the car will tend to keep moving at a constant velocity but the car slows around him. Relative to the car he is thrown
forward. Similarly, when turning to the left in a car the person tends to continue in a straight line and the car moves to the left.
An inertial frame is a rest frame or a non-rotating frame moving at a constant velocity with respect to a rest frame.
Basically, an inertial frame is a non-accelerated frame. The equivalence of inertial frames means that there is no preferred absolute rest frame.
Moving with a constant velocity is indistinguishable from being at rest. Suppose some experiment is performed in a van moving at a constant
velocity. (We assume the road is as smooth as possible.) The result of that experiment will be give the same result as if the van were at rest.
Einstein's Special Relativity eliminated the notions of absolute space and time.
Although relativity had been a well-established principle of classical mechanics, it became clear in the middle of the nineteenth century that the
laws of electromagnetism, which were summarized by Maxwell's four equations, violated this principle. It appeared that Maxwell's equations
were valid in only one absolute rest frame. In 1905 Einstein realized that Maxwell's equations were valid in all inertial frames and he put
relativity back into fundamental physics. To do this however he had to modify the notions of absolute space and time that were implicit in
Galilean relativity.
In special relativity, lengths and times are different frames but, it turns out, that the length-squared minus the time-squared is the same in all
frames, where we multiply time by the speed of light c to make the units work out.
Δ x2 + Δ y2 + Δ z2 - c2 Δ t2 = Δ x′ 2 + Δ y′ 2 + Δ z′ 2 - c2 Δ t′ 2
One can state the second law with words, as in the case of the first law, but it just becomes a complicated sentence dictating a simple
equation. It will then be given as an expression.
Chapter D - Newton's Laws and Applications 3
F net = m a (D.1)
The net force F net is the vector sum of all forces acting on a body. m is the mass of the body and a is its acceleration. Newton's first law may be
viewed as a consequence of the second. If F net = 0 then a = 0 and this implies v is a constant.
F a
F0 = m0 a0 and F = m0 a ⟹ =
F0 a0
Newton's third law is crucial for a proper understanding of force. If F 12 is the force of body 1 on body 2 and F 21 is the force of 2 on 1, then
F 21 = -F 12 (D.2)
This is often stated in the language of action-reaction pairs: to every action there is an equal and opposite reaction. Equal and opposite means
that one vector is the negative of the other.
At first glance the third law is counter-intuitive. When a small car gets in a collision with a large truck the force of the truck on the car is
the same, in magnitude, as that of the car on the truck. The same force on a smaller mass has a larger effect, meaning that since F = m a the
acceleration is larger. For an extreme example, the gravitational force of the Earth on a person is equal in magnitude to the force of the person
on the Earth. Since the mass of the Earth is much larger the acceleration of the Earth is negligible.
Free-body Diagrams
The left hand side of the second law, F net , is the vector sum of all forces acting on a body. To help with this we draw a free-body diagram;
this is a vector diagram showing all forces acting on the body. To draw a free-body diagram we must include contact forces and action-at-a-
distance forces.
It follows from the second law that the normal force equals the gravitation force on the person, his weight.
Fnet = m a ⟹ N - W = 0 ⟹ N = W.
A bathroom-type spring scale, which is compressed, reads the normal force. This, in this stationary case, is just the weight.
For the hanging mass it is the same but there is a tension force pulling up instead of the normal force pushing up.
Fnet = m a ⟹ T - W = 0 ⟹ T = W.
Tension is read by the other type of spring scale, one that you stretch. Think of a fish scale or a hanging produce scale in a grocery.
When and object is in free-fall, the only force acting on a body is its weight. As we established in Chapter B it has a downward acceleration
of g. Choosing downward as positive the second law implies that the weight equals the mass times the acceleration due to gravity.
Fnet = m a ⟹ W = m g
This expression applies generally to give the weight of a body of mass m in a gravitational field. The strength of that field is g, the acceleration
due to gravity. Do not think of g as an acceleration but as the proportionality between weight (a force) and mass, which is dimensionally an
acceleration. If gravity is the only force acting on a body, as is the case of free-fall, then the downward acceleration is g.
Fnet = m a ⟹ N - m g = m a ⟹ N = m g + m a
The normal force here, which can still be read by a spring scale, is called the apparent weight. Similarly, a mass being lifted by a rope an
upward acceleration will experience the same apparent weight, but the express would be for the tension instead of the normal force.
Note that for an object in free-fall a = -g, so its apparent weight is zero. This is called weightlessness.
a
N
m g sin θ
m g cos θ
θ
∥
mg
Since surface forces split naturally into parallel and perpendicular components, it is typically best to choose the coordinates to be parallel
and perpendicular to the surface. The normal force is already resolved along the perpendicular direction. Whenever there is an inclined plane at
angle θ resolving the weight into parallel and perpendicular components always gives:
6 Chapter D - Newton's Laws and Applications
Anything hanging in a vehicle can be used as an accelerometer, meaning it that can measure acceleration. Relate the hanging angle, as
measured from vertical as shown, to the acceleration.
Solution
Here we will choose our perpendicular axes to be horizontal (in the direction of the acceleration) and vertical. Note that the
forces do not balance here; they should not balance because there is an acceleration.
ver
T cos θ θ
T
hor
T sin θ
mg
a
After resolving the tension into horizontal and vertical components, we apply the second law to each direction and get:
Atwood's Machine
An ideal pulley is frictionless and light. The approximation of a pulley being frictionless is often appropriate. For a pulley to be light its
mass must be small compared to the other masses in the problem. With an ideal pulley the tension is the same on both sides of the pulley.
Atwood's machine is a standard example. It consists of two masses m1 and m2 connected by a string over an ideal pulley. Here we take
m1 < m2 . It is clear that m1 will accelerate upward and m2 will accelerate downward. We make the assumption that the string is ideal; this
means that it has negligible mass and does not stretch. In this case, the ideal string assumption implies that whatever distance m1 moves upward,
m2 moves downward. Since the acceleration is the second derivative of the position we can then conclude that two accelerations are equal in
magnitude.
Atwood's machine is a standard example. It consists of two masses m1 and m2 connected by a string over an ideal pulley. Here we take
m1 < m2 . It is clear that m1 will accelerate upward and m2 will accelerate downward. We make the assumption that the string is ideal; this
Chapterthat
means that it has negligible mass and does not stretch. In this case, the ideal string assumption implies D - whatever
Newton's distance
Laws and m1Applications
moves upward,7
m2 moves downward. Since the acceleration is the second derivative of the position we can then conclude that two accelerations are equal in
magnitude.
m1 m2
T T
a a
m1 g
m2 g
We now apply the second law to each mass. It is usually easiest to choose the direction of the acceleration to be the positive direction.
Doing that here we will choose up to be positive for m1 and down for m2 . Using this convention we get:
Fnet,1 = m1 a1 ⟹ T - m1 g = m1 a
Fnet,2 = m2 a2 ⟹ m2 g - T = m2 a
In these two expressions the tension and acceleration are the unknowns. The easiest method for solving for the acceleration is to add the two
expressions, eliminating the tension. This gives:
m2 - m1
a= g.
m1 + m2
A System of Pulleys
5T
a=0
To find the net force lifting on the weight look at all the ropes pulling upward on the object. As a rule when pulleys are attached to a mass
always consider the pulleys as part of the mass as shown. There are five ropes leaving the object. Assuming all pulleys are ideal, we get that
there is a total force of five T pulling upward.
W
Fnet = m a ⟹ 5 T - W = 0 ⟹ T =
5
This is an example of a mechanical advantage. With this pulley arrangement a heavy weight can be lifted with a force that is 1/5 the weight
of the object. One is not getting something for nothing here. The assumption that the rope doesn't stretch implies that lifting the weight a certain
distance involves pulling five times the distance on the rope. This is generally the case with a mechanical advantage and is the basis of simple
machines. One can apply a smaller force but it must act over a larger distance.
Show Translation
Interactive Figure
Solution
The assumption that the string does not stretch allows us to relate the accelerations. Whatever distance m1 slides down the incline, m2
moves upward by half that amount. To see this notice that when m2 moves upward that length comes out of the string twice. (See the
Interactive Figure above.) It follows that the acceleration of m2 is half that of m1 . Since the problem asks for the acceleration of m1 we
will call that a and this then gives a / 2 for the acceleration of m2 .
⊥ m1 m2
a N
T 2T
a
m1 g sin θ
m1 g cos θ 2
m2 g
θ
∥
m1 g
Since there is no friction and we don't need the normal force we can avoid the resolution of forces on m1 perpendicular to the surface.
The second law applied to the parallel direction gives:
Fnet, 1, ∥ = m a1, ∥ ⟹ m1 g sin θ - T = m1 a.
Applying the second law to m2 gives:
Fnet,2 = m a2 ⟹ 2 T - m2 g = m2 a / 2.
The simplest way to find a is to eliminating T by adding the first equation to half the second.
m1 sin θ - m2 / 2
a= g
m1 + m2 / 4
T T
W T W +F W
T F
F W W
F
F
W W W -F
F F
F F W
T =W + F T =W - F
Interactive Figure
The interactive figures above illustrate tension as a force of constraint. Both show a weight W hanging from a string or rope. On the left an
applied force F pulls downward on the rope. The larger F gets the larger T = W + F gets; the tension T will take on whatever value is needed to
maintain the constraint. The figure on the right shows the same hanging weight but now the applied force acts upward. As the applied force F
gets larger T = W - F decreases. It is clear that if F is larger than the weight W, then the string will lost its tension and the mass will accelerate
upward. To maintain the constraint the tension would need to be negative, but it cannot. The tension force satisfies a simple inequality
T ≥ 0. (D.3)
This is equivalent to saying: "You can't push with a rope." Note that negative tensions are possible for rigid objects, like a stick.
N N
N W +F
N F
W W
F F
F W -F
W W
F F
W F W F W
N =W + F N =W - F
Interactive Figure
Consider a block sitting on a floor as in the interactive figures above. Without an applied force, the normal force is the weight of the book W. If
one pushes down on the book with an applied force F, as in the left figure, then the floor pushes up with a larger normal force of N = W + F; as
F gets larger, N gets larger. If a small force F lifts on the block, as described by the figure on the right, then the normal force N = W - F
decreases as F increases. If the lifting force exceeds the weight the normal force the book will lift; N would have to be negative to maintain the
inequality. A surface can only push away from it
Consider a block sitting on a floor as in the interactive figures above. Without an applied force, the normal force is the weight of the book W. If
one pushes down on the book with an applied force F, as in the left figure, then the floor pushes up with a larger normal force of N = W + F; as
10 F Chapter D - Newton's
gets larger, Laws and
N gets larger. If a Applications
small force F lifts on the block, as described by the figure on the right, then the normal force N = W - F
decreases as F increases. If the lifting force exceeds the weight the normal force the book will lift; N would have to be negative to maintain the
inequality. A surface can only push away from it
N ≥ 0. (D.4)
A negative normal force would describe suction or glue.
Because the normal force is a constraint it is always found by solving the second law perpendicular to the surface.
Fnet, ⊥ = m a⊥
One does not just insert a value of N into a problem solution; it is something you calculate using the above expression.
Static Friction
N No Sliding Sliding
f = fs f = fk
a=0 fsmax
fk
F fs F
W F
W
F
F fsmax
fs = F
Interactive Figure
The interactive figure above shows a horizontal pushing force F acting on a block of weight W. The force of static friction fs will keep the
block from sliding. It must then act opposite to F and must have the same magnitude, fs = F. As F increases, so does fs . It should be clear that
if F is large enough the block will slide. There is a largest value of the force of static friction fsmax . When the block slides then there is no longer
static friction and we get kinetic friction fk .
Static friction is a force of constraint; the constraint is that there is no sliding. No sliding implies that the accelerations of the two surfaces
are the same. Since it is a constraint we always solve for its value by using
Fnet, ∥ = m a∥ .
There is an upper limit on static friction. The constraint is that the maximum value is proportional to the normal force.
fs ≤ μs N (D.5)
μs is a dimensionless constant called the coefficient of static friction; it is a property of the two surfaces in contact. At the critical point between
sliding and not the inequality is saturated; that is it become equal: fsmax = μs N.
We will demonstrate static friction with two examples: one with no acceleration and another with acceleration.
Solution
First we draw the free-body diagram. All that is touching the block is the surface, so the surface provides the only contact
forces. Perpendicular to the surface is the normal force N. Now that we have friction we also must include the parallel
component, which is static friction fs . To find the direction of the static friction force ask what will happen without it; fs must
act up the incline to prevent it from sliding down. We break up the weight mg into components as is typical for problems
involving inclined planes. The condition that the block is not sliding implies, since the surface is stationary, that the
acceleration is zero.
⊥
N
a=0 fs
m g sin θ
m g cos θ
θ
∥
mg
Applying the second law to our pair of perpendicular directions gives expressions for the static friction force and the normal
force.
Fnet, ∥ = m a∥ ⟹ m g sin θ - fs = 0 ⟹ fs = m g sin θ
Fnet, ⊥ = m a⊥ ⟹ N - m g cos θ = 0 ⟹ N = m g cos θ
We then use our constraint inequality fs ≤ μs N, which is the condition for the block not sliding. We then insert the above values
for fs and N. (Be careful when doing algebra with inequalities; multiplying or dividing by a negative changes the direction of
the inequality. Here we are diving by only positive quantities.)
fs ≤ μs N ⟹ m g sin θ ≤ μs m g cos θ ⟹ tan θ ≤ μs
At θmax , the largest angle without sliding, we saturate the inequality and get our result.
A truck with a forward acceleration of 2.5 m s2 carries a crate inside. If coefficient of static friction between the crate and the floor is
0.30, will the crate slide?
12 Chapter D - Newton's Laws and Applications
Solution
The only thing touching the crate is the truck’s floor; the only contact forces are the two surface forces, the normal force and,
assuming no sliding, static friction. The direction of the static friction is forward. Without friction, the crate slides backward
and friction prevents that. The only other force to include in our free-body diagram is the weight.
ver
a
N
fs
hor
mg
Again, applying the second law to our pair of perpendicular directions gives expressions for the static friction force and the
normal force.
Fnet, ∥ = m a∥ ⟹ fs = m a
Fnet, ⊥ = m a⊥ ⟹ N - m g = 0 ⟹ N = m g
The constraint inequality fs ≤ μs N, is the condition for the block not sliding. Inserting the information above gives the condition.
fs ≤ μs N ⟹ m a ≤ μs m g ⟹ a ≤ μs g
?
a = 2.5 m s2 , μs = 0.30 and g = 9.80 m s2 ⟹ 2.5 ≤ 2.94
The question mark above the inequality is used because it is a test, not a mathematical statement. Since the test is satisfied the
crate will not slide.
Kinetic Friction
Kinetic friction is the dissipative force when there is sliding between two surfaces. Its direction opposes the direction of the sliding. The
magnitude of the force of kinetic friction is fixed at the value
fk = μk N. (D.6)
μk is the coefficient of kinetic friction. Like the static friction case, it is a property of the two surfaces.
Chapter D - Newton's Laws and Applications 13
Solution
Applying the second law the direction perpendicular to the surface gives the normal force.
Fnet, ∥ = m a∥ ⟹ m g sin θ + fk = m a
We then use our expression for kinetic friction (D.6) fk = μk N. Combining this with our expression for N gives fk = μk m g cos θ.
We can then solve for a.
a = g sin θ + μk g cos θ
(b) When sliding down the incline what is its acceleration? Take an acceleration down the incline to be a positive a.
Solution
This part is identical to the case above except the kinetic friction is now up the incline and thus comes in with the opposite sign.
14 Chapter D - Newton's Laws and Applications
Friction in a Medium
When an object moves through a fluid, a liquid or a gas, it experiences a friction force with a magnitude that varies with the speed. This is
in contrast to kinetic friction which has a fixed magnitude independent of the speed. There are two simple ways to model friction in a medium:
viscous friction, which is proportional to the speed and quadratic drag, which is proportional to the speed squared.
Viscous Friction
Typically, at low speeds when the fluid flow around the object is laminar (smooth) the friction behaves as viscous friction.
f =bv
v is the speed and the constant b depends on the viscosity of the fluid and the geometry and surface texture of the object.
Quadratic Drag
At speeds higher than where the fluid flow around the object becomes turbulent the friction force becomes quadratic drag.
f = c v2
The constant c depends on the viscosity of the fluid and the geometry and surface texture of the object.