Volume 1 Part 2 (Land Use)
Volume 1 Part 2 (Land Use)
Volume 1 Part 2 (Land Use)
Land Use
Volume 1
Part 2
1
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Vision
Makati shall lead the Philippines in the 21st century; its global and national
enterprises, leading the creation of a new responsible and sustainable
economy; its citizens, productive, empowered and God-loving.
Mission
The Makati City Government will be the model for world-class local
governance: providing for the well-being of its citizenry through the delivery of
the highest level of basic, social and economic services with breakthrough
technologies, sustainable financing, and competent, responsible and
professional civil servants.
2.2.1 Goals
c. Innovative Infrastructures
d. Imageable City
3
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
2.2.2 Strategies
4
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
5
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Diverse urban culture and arts. Makati has several areas with
distinct characteristics and cultures (e.g. heritage, business, riverside,
entertainment). These areas have to be preserved and even
strengthened so that the City will remain a multi-dimensional and
cosmopolitan city.
1
A cosmopolitan city is a city populated by people from several countries living together with
different customs, cultures, and languages that all contribute to enrich the city’s economy and
urbanity.
6
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
The Fort Bonifacio area that has been converted into a Special
Mixed-Use Zone and other areas such as Rockwell, Century
City and Picar Place among others have the potential to
complement the development in Makati. The prospect of
creating a “super CBD” is enormous by efficiently linking MCBD
and other areas in Makati. The challenge will be to connect all
these areas as seamlessly as possible. Adjacent to the MCBD,
the residential villages will likely retain its low density residential
land use in the immediate future, noting that these villages have
been instrumental in attracting the business leaders and
decision-makers that allowed the MCBD to maintain the
premium it has enjoyed over the rest of the country (Figure 1).
8
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
There are many ways to allocate the resources of the City and at the
same time deeply involve the marginalized sector in city-building. Aside
from providing the skilled manpower and services that support Makati
City’s economy, residents also have to be involved in the community to
help improve its condition. For example, providing open spaces in
densely populated areas can significantly enhance the air quality, cool
the climate during the summer, encourage social interaction, upgrade
disaster preparedness, and improve the health of the community.
9
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Many affluent and highly urbanized cities in the world where cost of
land has become very expensive have resorted to high-rise buildings to
maximize the value of their land. The IRR of the NBC (PD 1096)
defines high-rise buildings as sixteen (16) storeys or taller in height (i.e.
from 48 mts. above established grade height). Singapore and Hong
Kong, two cities that are trying to overcome the scarcity of land, have
already moved on to developing extremely tall buildings (40 to 60
storeys) because of the efficient use of their limited land. Makati’s
expansion is similarly constrained by its limited land area. To ensure
that demand for office and residential space can be met, high-rise
buildings are becoming increasingly necessary. High-rise buildings as
a strategy for development have many virtues but they are not without
their detractors.
Criticisms range from the tall building’s high energy use to their
residents’ lack of community spirit. High-rise buildings, however, seem
to work well in the CBD and other Special Mixed-Use Developments as
they are better connected with their surroundings (i.e. ground level and
adjoining buildings). Clustering tall buildings especially if they surround
a mass-transit station is widely regarded as more efficient in terms of
transport. The City’s skyscraper-filled skyline is also a recognizable
image that exudes economic vitality and contributes to its cosmopolitan
brand. (Figure 2)
10
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
11
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
An assessment of the City’s natural hazards has shown that there are
areas exposed to geological (Figure 3) and hydro-meteorological
hazards (Figure 4). Since all of these high-risk areas are built-up and
inhabited, there should be redevelopment efforts to deal with the
hazards present.
12
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Livable City
13
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
The City’s built up nature and high daytime population density also
makes it a compact city that is quite suitable for more sustainable
Transit-Oriented Developments (TODs). Mass transit systems should
be complemented by efficient and pleasant walking environments to
provide seamless pedestrian mobility. The Makati CBD and the other
Special Mixed-Use Developments have state-of-the-art pedestrian
facilities (elevated, at grade level, and underground walkways) but
these have to be expanded to further improve mobility. Transportation
and communication systems have to be constantly upgraded to
maintain the city’s competitive edge. (Figure 9)
14
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
15
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
16
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Green Environment
18
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Iconic buildings and civic spaces have the power to create a positive
and indelible image of a city. Many cities have achieved instant
recognition with the introduction of new spectacular architecture (e.g.
Marina Bay Sands in Singapore, Taipei 101 in Taipei, Petronas Towers
in Kuala Lumpur) and green projects (e.g. Cheongyecheon River in
Seoul, High Line in New York City). Since the City is in need of civic
buildings (e.g. performance halls, museums, convention centers),
these new structures have to be designed in the most modern,
innovative, and unique manner that would help portray the city’s
international importance. Landmark urban design proposals can also
be educational and informative elements that provide geographic
reference (e.g. gateways, relief maps) or educational value (e.g.
history, environment, geology, biology).
19
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
20
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Makati’s physical development goal is to manage the growth of the City such
that the resulting built-up environment, including the type, extent and location
of land uses:
21
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
The Land Use Plan should also take into consideration risk reduction
measures to improve safety and increasing resiliency of the
communities.
22
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
The Land Use Plan should allow for sites to improve their efficiency to
perform their new functions as business and commercial villages. For
example, development guidelines will provide bonus Floor Area Ratios
(FAR) for parcels that consolidate to form bigger lots or for lots that
give up portions for the widening of streets. The introduction of a new
special zone that will improve the urban environment in these
neighborhoods and promote shared growth wherein more people can
participate in the city’s economy is another new intervention to induce
growth on strategic locations.
24
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
The Makati CBD has played a major role in making and sustaining
Makati’s role as the country’s financial capital. It is therefore, expected
that the MCBD will be the main driver in City’s push to become a
global center for business and finance. To sustain the primacy of the
MCBD, density controls have to favor the provision of a working
environment, including its necessary support spaces that will meet
future demand and fulfill the City’s role as a global business and
financial center.
Defining density limits will also allow the planning of infrastructure and
other projects needed to address deficiencies in services and utilities.
Properly applied density controls also help achieve preferred urban
design forms (e.g. such as higher densities in the center, reduced
building heights adjacent to parks).
25
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Pasig River is also a viable inter-city channel for a river ferry that
provides direct access to Metro Manila’s core city of Manila. The city
has two existing Pasig River Ferry stations located in Barangays
Guadalupe Nuevo and Valenzuela. In addition, there are two stations
that provide river ferry crossing (tawiran) to/from Mandaluyong City at
Barangay Poblacion and to/from Pasig City at Barangays Cembo-
West Rembo.
26
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Apart from the potential loss of lives and injury to families living in
vulnerable communities, natural calamities also strain the city’s
financial resources. Limited budgets meant to fund basic services can
easily be taken away and realigned to reconstruct and rehabilitate
calamity disaster-stricken areas. Mainstreaming “Disaster Risk
Reduction and Climate Change Adaptation” in development planning
27
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
28
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Makati City’s has an uneven distribution of parks and open spaces with
gated villages enjoying community parks and facilities while many
densely populated barangays have little or no open spaces at all.
Development of new parks for areas that have limited access to open
spaces should be one of the priority projects.
2
Douglas Farr, Sustainable Urbanism, John Wiley and sons, Inc. 2008
29
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
The Land Use Plan for 2013-2023 is a detailed translation of the Physical
Framework/Conceptual Plans. The resulting land use distribution of the 2013-
2023 Land Use Plan is summarized and compared to the 2001-2011 Land
Use Plan in Table 1.
The Existing Land Use as of 2012 (Figure 12) shows that Residential Zone
comprises 35% of the total land area of Makati, followed by Roads with
23.6%, and Commercial 14.8% and SMU accounting for 14.6%. Very few
Industrial uses remain; there is also relatively small amount of Parks and
Open Spaces.
For the Proposed Land Use Plan for 2013 to 2023, (Figure 13) Residential
Area will still be the dominant land use (30.8%) although its share declines
compared with the 2012 Existing Land Use owing to conversion of some
residential lots into low density commercial/mixed use development. There is
minimal change in Commercial Zone but several blocks of the Commercial
Zone are now rezoned into special precincts for redevelopment.
Three new land use zones are introduced in the 2013-2023 Land Use Plan as
a strategy to redevelop areas that either have not reached their full potential
or in most need of enhancement (due to significant City assets they contain),
or restructuring because of their vulnerability to geological and hydro-
meteorological hazards. Urban Redevelopment Programs for underachieving
areas are designated as SPUR which account for 0.85 sq.km. (3.1% of the
City’s total land area) while for communities in critically hazardous areas are
called DRIVE. The total land area for DRIVE sites is 0.23 sq.km. (0.8% share
to total land area of the City). A Heritage Preservation Zone (HPZ) is also
introduced to spatially designate the area within the Poblacion that is home to
history, arts and cultural facilities. The said Zones are additional to the
existing Special Development Zones which are already established in the
CLUP 2001-2011 namely: Government Center Zone (GCZ), Riverside
Development Zone (RDZ), and Planned Unit Development (PUD).
Note that most of the decreases or increases in the land areas and
corresponding percentages share to total land area of the Proposed Land Use
for 2013-2023 can be attributed to the delineation of several neighborhood
blocks into SPUR, DRIVE, or HPZ.
30
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
31
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
32
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Similar to the CLUP 2001-2011, the new Land Use Plan features the
application of building density limits in medium and high density commercial
areas of the City. The Density Model (Figure 14) graphically presents the
maximum allowable densities for the entire City. In order to appreciate how
the City has grown and is expected to grow over the years, it is useful to
compare the Existing Built-up in 2012 (Figure 15) with the Projected Densities
(Figure 16) and the maximum densities prescribed in the new CLUP and
Zoning Ordinance.
The Existing Densities by the end of 2012 in CBD alone is only about a third
of what is theoretically and legally possible in the previous CLUP and ZO
2001-2011. The highest densities in the City, which basically retain existing
limits, are found in core commercial/ mixed-use zones (CBD). The Makati
CBD and Fort Bonifacio area combined has the largest concentration of office
and commercial spaces, accounting for 68% of traditional office space in the
entire Metro Manila and 41% of total BPO sites nationwide. Currently, this
mega CBD is also home to the most number of local, multinational and
international headquarter offices, think tanks, deluxe hotels and premier
residential units. It is also the preferred location of global retailers, embassies
and consulates. Adding to its vibrancy are quality higher education and
specialized institutions (e.g. top business schools, arts and design schools),
architectural/design firms and creative agencies, and excellent medical
facilities. Despite the emergence of newer business districts in Metro Manila,
Makati and Fort Bonifacio continue to enjoy the highest capital values in the
entire country.
In line with the City’s thrust to expand economic opportunities, the CBD is
expanded to include the already bustling growth corridor of Sen. Gil Puyat
Avenue and the commercial blocks along Chino Roces Avenue and Extension
where further growth is anticipated. The density limits in this expanded CBD
shall be defined carefully so that future growth is accommodated without
sacrificing the current advantages enjoyed by the City by ensuring that new
development will not conflict with adjacent uses, hinder movement, or strain
utilities to the detriment of the whole. These densities taper off into adjacent
commercial areas for more efficient urban form and scale. The densities in
these adjoining low-density commercial/mixed use districts have been slightly
increased to accommodate additional commercial/mixed-use spaces.
The lowest density limits are still in the existing low and medium density
residential villages in the form of height and setback restrictions. The density
33
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
For the other uses that have unique or minimal vertical developments (open
space/park, riverside, cemetery, utility zones), density control is defined by
maximum lot occupancy to control and regulate growth.
Assumptions on growth rates and where these may likely occur are made for
planning purpose. With a steady stream of new constructions (3% additional
growth per annum from previous), in ten years’ time, the building densities in
the CBD are estimated to be closer to the 2023 Maximum Allowable. As was
the case in the 2001-2011 CLUP, transport conditions and planned
infrastructure improvements as well as macro-economic prospects will remain
to be the major determinants of actual growth. The road network in the City is
already nearing its maximum threshold level. Utility system and support
services (e.g. water supply, sewerage, power supply, telecommunications) on
the other hand are mostly provided by private service providers and are in
step in terms of projected demands by the end of the planning period.
Aside from the intensified growth in CBD (using constant 3% annual growth
rate forecast based on continuing service-oriented demand), much of the new
developments in the next ten years are anticipated in the areas that were
converted such as SMU (underutilized strip along Chino Roces Avenue), Fort
Bonifacio, SPUR, HPZ and DRIVE. It is expected that these newly designated
special zones will catalyze development within the vicinity. Moreover, large
blocks recognized as having high real estate potential will likely contribute
significantly in the shaping of the urban form (e.g. former military area along
Lawton Avenue, Santa Ana Racetrack, expansion of Rockwell, former
International School (IS) site, Nicanor Garcia Avenue strip). Even as these
new areas develop, the traditional commercial areas in Poblacion, and along
JP Rizal Avenue will also likely experience intense development as the City
pours investment in infrastructure and utilities upgrade and landscape
enhancement in these areas. The various transit and infrastructure projects
that the City will invest in and lobby for are also expected to serve as impetus
to expand economic opportunities along transit corridors and nodes, and
seamlessly integrate development in different parts of the City.
With a Master Plan that shall guide development in special districts, the HPZ
and RDZ are envisioned to add to the City’s diversity, distinction and
prominence. Enhancements in these areas are expected to trigger
subsequent redevelopment of surrounding neighborhoods catering to a wider
residential market segments and cultural and recreational offerings.
In all these areas, the City shall ensure that the mix and scale of land use
activities are organized and developed in an efficient and sustainable manner.
34
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
35
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
The Land Use Plan shows the different land use zones of the City,
based on the Physical Framework Plan. Most of the zones feature a
mix of uses, with a dominant character (e.g. residential, commercial,
central business district, institutional, recreational, government center
zone, etc.) that is reflected in the zone classification. Zones within each
major classification are differentiated by density and/or by specific land
use characteristics that need to be accounted for and are described in
greater detail in the accompanying Zoning Ordinance. The following
are the major zones and subzones in the City:
Residential Zones:
o Low Density Residential Zone
o Medium Density Residential/Mixed-Use Zone
o High Density Residential/Mixed-Use Zone
36
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Commercial Zones
o Low Density Commercial Zone
o Medium Density Commercial Zone
o High Density Commercial Zone
o Central Business District (CBD)
Institutional Zone
Recreational Zone
Open Space
Cemetery
Utility
PRINCIPAL USES:
duplex
government facility
multi-family dwelling
37
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
ACCESSORY USES:
day care center
home office
place of religious worship
pre-school/kindergarten school (maximum of two
classrooms)
utility installation for use of zone/lot occupants
PRINCIPAL USES:
principal uses allowed in low density residential zone
boarding/pension house, dormitory/apartment
community/village association office
daycare center
fire/security station
library, museum, exhibit area, art gallery
place of religious worship
pre-school, kindergarten school elementary school, high
school (maximum of 12 classrooms)
public utility facility
residential inn/apartelle/condotel/condominium
townhouse
utility installation for use of zone/lot occupants
welfare/charitable institution/rehabilitation center
ACCESSORY USES:
accessory uses allowed in low density residential zone
club house, multi-purpose hall/room
computer/information technology-related activity
convenience retail / food store/cart/kiosk/stall (neighborhood
service only)
dance/voice/music, other specialty studio
general service/repair
hardware without lumber, gravel and sand
38
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
PRINCIPAL USES:
government facility
hotel
office/embassy
parking structure
parks, pocket parks, parkway, promenade, garden, playlots,
playground, sports field/court
residential inn/apartelle/condotel/condominium
ACCESSORY USES:
club house, multi-purpose hall/room
convenience/ retail store/food store/cart/kiosk/stall
day care center
health center/clinic/sports club, gym
personal service/repair
place of religious worship
restaurant, canteen or food-serving establishment
sports/recreation facility
telecom station
transit station/terminal
utility installation for use of zone/lot occupants
PRINCIPAL USES:
principal uses allowed in medium and high density residential
zone
auditorium, theater, performance/civic center
39
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
40
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
PRINCIPAL USES:
principal uses allowed in low density commercial zone
shopping center
PRINCIPAL USES:
principal uses allowed in medium density commercial zone
except lumber, gravel and sand dealer
PRINCIPAL USES:
auditorium/theater/performance center (not commercial
cinema)
auto related shop
auto-related shop (parts, sales, service, repair)
bank, ATM, finance, insurance, money exchange service
boarding/pension house/dormitory/apartment
cinema
club/multi-purpose hall/room
cocktail lounge, disco, dance hall, KTV/music bar
college/university
community/village association office
computer/information technology-related service activity
convent, seminary and related uses
convention/meetings facility
convenience/ retail store/food store/cart/ kiosk/ stall
cultural and educational center
dance, voice, music and other specialty studio
daycare center
duplex
elementary, high school
embassy
entertainment/amusement center
fire/security station
41
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
general service/repair
general/specialized hospital, medical center
government facility
hardware without lumber, gravel and sand station
health center, clinic, sports club, gym
home office
hotel
library, museum, exhibit area, art gallery
machine/metal/welding/junk/furniture shop
multi-family dwelling
nature center/aviary
nursing/convalescent home
office
office support service
park, pocket parks, parkway, promenade, playlots,
playground, sports field/court, garden
parking structure
pawnshop/one-stop payment shop
personal service repair
petrol filling/service station
place of religious worship
pre-school/kindergarten school
public utility facility
radio/television station, media service
residential inn, condominium/condotel/apartelle
restaurant, canteen, other food serving establishment
shopping center
showroom/display store
single detached family dwelling
small scale home industry
specialty school/training facility
sporting goods/souvenir shop
sports stadium
sports/recreational facility
supermarket/grocery
telecom station
townhouse
transit station/terminal
utility installation for use of zone/lot occupants
warehouse/storage facility
welfare/charitable institution
wellness center
wet/dry market
wholesale store/distributor
42
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
ACCESSORY USES
club house/multi-purpose hall/room
community/association office
convenience/retail store / food store/ cart/ kiosk/ stall
dance/voice/music, other specialty studio
day care center
fire/security station
health center/clinic/sports club, gym
office support service
personal service/repair
petrol filling kiosk
residential unit at penthouse level only
restaurant, canteen and other food-serving establishment
showroom/display store
sports/recreation facility
transit station/terminal
wellness center
PRINCIPAL USES:
principal uses allowed in medium density residential zone
auditorium, theater, performance/civic center (not
commercial cinema)
club house /multi-purpose hall/room
college/university, cultural/educational center
computer/information technology-related activity
convent, seminary, and related uses
convention/meetings facility
general/specialized hospital, medical center
health center/clinic/sports club, gym
nature center/aviary
nursing/convalescent home
office support service
parking structure
parks, pocket parks, parkway, promenade, playlots
playground, sports field/court, garden
radio/TV station
specialty school/training facility
sports stadium
sports/recreation facility
transit station/terminal
43
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
ACCESSORY USES
convenience/ retail store/ food store/ cart/ kiosk/stall
restaurant, canteen, other food serving establishment
showroom/display store
PRINCIPAL USES:
principal uses allowed in institutional zone
ACCESSORY USES:
accessory uses allowed in institutional zone
auto-related shop (parts, sales, repair/service)
bank, ATM, finance, insurance, money exchange service
funeral/memorial service
general service/repair
office
pawnshop/one-stop shop
personal service/repair
PRINCIPAL USES:
club house /multi-purpose hall/room
dance/voice/music, other specialty studio
health center/clinic/sports club, gym
nature center/aviary
park, pocket parks, parkways, promenade, playlots, sports
field/court
specialty school/training facility
sports field/recreation facility/ court
sports stadium
ACCESSORY USES:
auditorium, theater, performance/civic center
club house, multi-purpose hall/room
community/village association office
day care center
fire/security station
government facility
library, museum, exhibit area, art gallery
44
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
parking structure
personal service/repair
place of religious worship
public utility facility
restaurant, canteen, other food-serving establishment
sporting goods/souvenir shop
sports/recreation facility
utility installation for use of zone/lot occupants
wellness center
a. OPEN SPACE. This zone shall be used as open space for parks and
playgrounds.
PRINCIPAL USES:
bikeways
parks, pocket parks, parkway, promenade, garden
playground and playlots
PRINCIPAL USES:
principal uses allowed in medium density/mixed-use zone
auditorium, theater, performance/civic center
auto-related shop (parts, sales, repair, service)
bank, ATM, finance, insurance, money exchange services
cinema
club house, multi-purpose hall/room
cocktail lounge, disco, dance hall, KTV/music bar
computer/information technology related activity
convenience/ retail store/ food store/cart/ kiosk/ stall
dance, voice, music, other specialty studio
daycare center
entertainment/amusement center
general service repair
health center, clinic, sports club, gym
hotel
machine/metal/welding/junk/furniture shop
nature center, aviary
45
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
office
office support service
parking structure
pawnshop/ one-stop payment shop
personal service repair
petrol filling/ service station
radio/TV station
restaurants, canteen, other food serving establishments
showroom/display store
small scale home industry
specialty school/training facility
sports/recreation facility
transit station/terminal
warehouse/ storage facility
wellness center
ACCESSORY USES:
accessory uses allowed in medium density residential/mixed
use zone
club house/multi-purpose hall/room
health center/clinic/club, gym
library, museum, exhibit area, art gallery
c. CEMETERY ZONE (CEM): This zone shall be used primarily for burial
and related activities.
PRINCIPAL USES:
cemetery
columbarium
crematorium
mausoleum
nature center, aviary
park, pocket parks, parkway, promenade, garden
place of religious worship
ACCESSORY USES:
fire/security station
parking structure
public utility facility
utility installation for use of zone/lot occupants
UTILITY ZONE (UTL): This zone shall be used primarily for utility
functions.
PRINCIPAL USES:
46
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
ACCESSORY USES:
fire/security station
petrol filling kiosk
2.5.1. Introduction
It has been acknowledged that natural disasters throughout the world have
occurred with more frequency and severity in the last twenty years, resulting
in the loss of economic, humanitarian, and ecological resources in the areas
struck by them. Many areas in the Philippines, whether urban or rural, are
known to be vulnerable to natural hazards such as typhoons, floods,
landslides, volcanoes, earthquakes, and tsunamis.
In 2010, it was estimated that about 66.40 % of the total population in the
Philippines was living in urban areas.3 Many of the old cities in the Philippines
developed with little consideration for the geo-physical and hydro-
meteorological hazards of their settlement sites and therefore were not able to
avoid or mitigate the potential risks brought about by earthquakes and floods.
The difficult tasks of disaster management and response in cities have been
made all the more challenging by rapid urbanization and the increase in the
number of densely populated informal settlements. The marginalized sector is
often the most severely affected by natural disasters largely because of the
poor location and lack of physical planning of their communities.
3
www.indexmundi.com, accessed in April 5, 2012
47
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Quezon City.4
Climate change is another recent concern that refers to significant and lasting
changes in the statistical distribution of weather patterns in the world that is
currently being experienced and is expected to further occur in the
succeeding decades. In recent years, more frequent typhoons and
unprecedented rainfall have resulted in destructive floods throughout the
Philippines. In September 2009, Metro Manila was hit by typhoon Ketsana
(PAGASA name: Ondoy), considered the most devastating typhoon since
1970. The flooding caused by the typhoon, however, yielded valuable
information that could be used to mitigate potential floods in Metro Manila in
the future. Such actual experiences and projected weather conditions in the
future that are attributed to climate change have to be considered in the
formulation of all development plans including the Comprehensive Land Use
Plan. It is imperative that cities make use of the latest geophysical and hydro-
meteorological data to identify areas that have to be redeveloped taking into
consideration disaster risk reduction5 and climate change adaptation6.
In 2005, the Hyogo Framework for Action (HFA) called for worldwide
implementation of DRR initiatives to substantially reduce by 2015 the loss of
lives as well as socio-economic and environmental resources brought about
by disasters. In response to HFA’s call, the National Economic and
Development Authority (NEDA) Regional Development Office prepared a set
of guidelines in 2008 to mainstream risk reduction within development and
land use planning.
49
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
The Climate Change Act of 2009 (RA 9279) defines ”Climate Change” as a
change in climate that can be identified by changes in the mean and/or
variability of its properties and that persists for an extended period typically
decades or longer, whether due to natural variability or as a result of human
activity. 7 “Climate Change Adaptation” is the response to climate change that
aims to reduce the vulnerability of biological systems to its effects. Adapting to
climate change is particularly important in developing countries like the
Philippines where the severe effects of climate change are expected to occur.
Adaptive Capacity8 is closely linked to social and economic development as
the economic costs of climate change adaptability will cost billions of dollars in
the next few decades. The most common and widespread climate change-
related disaster in Metro Manila will be floods. For the cities adjacent to
Manila Bay, they will also experience sea level rise and storm surges. Other
7
Republic Act No. 9279 – Climate Change Act of 2009.
8
Adaptive Capacity – is the capacity and potential for humans to adapt to Climate Change.
50
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
problems that may arise that is related to climate change are typhoons,
climate-related illnesses and diseases, and hot and humid summers. It should
be realized that the adaptation challenge grows with the magnitude and the
rate of climate change.
According to the Mainstreaming Disaster Risk Reduction (National Economic
Development Authority, 2008), Disaster Risk Assessment (DRA) is the
process of studying risks caused by natural hazards and their effects on
elements at risk (e.g. people, buildings and structures, infrastructure,
economic activities, and public services).9 Risk assessment is the process of
quantifying and evaluating risk. The quantification of risks may be presented
as the number of elements lost (e.g. loss of lives), proportion of elements
affected (e.g., 30% of buildings), and monetary value of damaged property.
DRA involves:
In the process of formulating the New Makati Comprehensive Land Use Plan
(2013-2023), hazard characterization/frequency analysis was completed. The
other steps (i.e. consequence analysis, risk estimation, and risk prioritization)
have to be completed in a more detailed undertaking involving more experts
and consultation with the communities in all the barangays in Makati. Such a
consultative process will require more time and resources to complete.
Through characterization/frequency analysis and analysis of available
information, however, several critical areas that require immediate
intervention can be identified. DRA was incorporated in the land use planning
process in the:
a) analysis of the planning environment;
b) identification of issues and problems;
c) formulation of goals, objectives and targets;
d) formulation of development strategies; and
e) identification of programs, projects and activities.
Disasters can disrupt social, economic, and physical development and even
set back gains. Deaths, injuries, community dislocation, damage to
infrastructure, destruction of industries, and disruption of economic activities
as a result of disasters can increase poverty. Because of the limited
resources of both national and local governments and the unpredictability of
9
Mainstreaming Disaster Risk Reduction, National Economic Development Authority (NEDA), United Nations
Development Program (UNDP), European Commission Humanitarian Aid, VJ Graphics Arts, Inc. (2008)
51
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
52
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
With a total land area of only 638.55 square kilometers (0.2% of the
Philippines’ total land area), Metropolitan Manila accounts for about 13% of
the national population and 33% of the National Gross Domestic Product.
Makati is one of 17 Local Government Units (LGUs) that comprise Metro
Manila. In spite of Makati City’s limited land area of 27.36 square kilometers, it
has consistently been in the list of top five richest cities in the country. As the
financial capital of the Philippines, Makati hosts the biggest banks and
53
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
For the New Makati Comprehensive Land Use Plan (2013-2023), the City will
have the opportunity to utilize more scientific data (hazard maps) and
integrating Disaster Risk Reduction in the land use planning process. It is with
much expectation that the updated CLUP will effectively improve the disaster
resiliency of its communities.
The poor and informal settlers are considered the most vulnerable to disasters
as they have the least resources and are often given the least attention by
local governments.10 Urban low-cost housing are often located in areas with
narrow roads and congested conditions, while informal settlements are
situated in the most hazardous locations close to where there are livelihood
opportunities (e.g., along railroad tracks, creeks and rivers, underneath
bridges)
10
Christine Wamsler, Managing Urban Disaster Risk, Chapter 1, 2007
54
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
55
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
susceptible to liquefaction. Ground shaking will cause the sand to behave like
a liquid with an upward flow towards the surface which would consequently
lead to differential settlement. The potential for liquefaction in Makati City
ranges from low to none in areas that have Guadalupe Tuff as subsurface and
moderate in areas that have Quaternary Alluvium underneath.
Lifelines are infrastructures that are essential for a community to function (e.g.
roads, water supply lines, sewage lines, power lines and telecommunication
systems). The MMEIRS report (2004) presented estimates of impacts of an
M7.2 earthquake originating from the West Valley Fault (WVF) on Makati
City’s lifelines. Earthquakes can just as easily damage underground systems
(water supply, sewage, power, communication) as much as surface
infrastructure. Based on the report, most of Makati City will experience very
minimal damage to underground pipe systems in the event of an M7.2 tremor
originating from the West Valley Fault. The pipe systems in Barangays
Comembo, San Lorenzo, San Antonio, Santa Cruz, Tejeros, La Paz, Palanan,
San Isidro, Bangkal, and Dasmariñas are slightly more at risk of damage,
although considered manageable in a post-disaster scenario.
Figure 21. The West Valley Fault and Areas Prone to Liquefaction
in Makati City
Four barangays on the east side of Makati City straddle the West
56
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Valley Fault Line. There are also large sections on the west and north
sides of Makati City that are “moderately” prone to liquefaction (areas
in brown).
The lack or inadequacy of disaster response may result in more deaths and
injuries after an earthquake rather than during the occurrence of the event
itself. Emergency response is crucial in the saving of lives and property. Apart
from the quality of equipment and trained personnel, accessibility is also a
consideration in reducing loss of lives and property damage. Areas have to
be permeable (can be accessed through several routes) which means there
should be no dead-ends and roads have to be wide enough for emergency
response teams to get through.
In Makati City, most of the flooding occurs in areas adjacent to rivers and
creeks especially if they are low-lying (downstream) and have gentle slopes.
Based on the flood hazard map of the Mines and Geosciences Bureau (MGB)
of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR), areas that
are prone to 2-to-10-year flood cycles are the areas along creeks, along Pasig
River and with low elevations. The 50 and 100-year flood cycles, on the other
hand, affect areas along Pateros River and in areas where it joins Pasig
River. The volume of rainfall during Typhoon Ondoy (Typhoon Ketsana) in
2009 was considered a 150-year extreme rainfall event.
Floods in the city by and large occur in areas surrounding rivers and creeks
with the exception of some western barangays where floods are more
widespread over very low and flat topography. In the western barangays,
flood levels range from 1 to 3 meters along the creeks and 0.15 to 1.0 meter
for residential areas alongside these creeks. The extent of residential areas
affected by floods stretches to almost a kilometer in certain sections. In the
eastern part of the city, flood levels reach from 1 to 3 meters along the
Pateros River and 0.15 to1.0 meter for a narrow area adjacent to the river. 13
The eastern barangays (Barangays East Rembo, Pembo, Comembo, Rizal)
and the northwestern barangays (Barangays Kasilawan, Tejeros, Singkamas,
Olympia) have some of the highest population densities in the city which
means that more people are affected by floods in these areas.
13
Alfredo Mahar A. Lagmay, Geohazard Assessment Report for Makati City (Preliminary Report), 2012
57
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Since most parts of the barangays that belong to the Eastside Cluster
developed in a spontaneous manner, geo-physical and hydro-meteorological
hazards were simply overlooked or ignored when informal settlements started
to develop. After several years since land tenure was finally granted, many of
the settlers have transformed their houses into permanent structures in spite
of the presence of the natural hazards. The communities in these barangays
can be characterized as having narrow streets, small lots, and practically no
open spaces. Many of the families in the densely populated Barangay Rizal
belong to the lowest income group in Makati.
58
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Maricaban Creek has areas adjacent to the creek and other drainage
channels also prone to flooding. The Eastside barangays (areas in
blue) are susceptible to 50 to 100-year cycle floods.
Since physical planning is mainly concerned with the first two categories, the
land use and urban design proposals presented here will not dwell at all with
the last two categories. Land use interventions which fall under the “Risk
avoidance or elimination” category will also be limited in terms of application
considering that practically all the land in the City have been built up. It would
be easy to designate or zone a fault line area as a green belt or a flood plain
as a wetland reservation if the areas being planned are “greenfields” but not
when these areas are already occupied by communities.
Knowing about the existence and the location of the West Valley Fault (WVF)
has given the city government the following levels of physical planning
response:
59
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Figure 23. The West Valley Fault Figure 24. Easement of the
Line in Makati City West Valley Fault Zone
The West Valley Fault (red broken The drawing shows the
line) cuts across Barangays East buildings including a public
Rembo, Comembo, Pembo, and school that have been built
Rizal. above the WVF line easement.
60
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
To cope with the frequency and rising levels of floods in Makati City, flood
prone areas such as residential areas have been considered for increase in
Building Height Limits. Such a provision will allow existing and new buildings
in these flood-prone areas to raise floor levels that would prevent or reduce
the damage caused by floods. Such Climate Change Adaptation measures
that allow increases in Building Height Limits will be reflected in the Zoning
Ordinance.
Flood hazard maps have shown that most floods in Makati are in areas
adjacent to drainage channels such as rivers and creeks. More frequent and
extreme rainfall attributed to Climate Change will put areas adjacent drainage
channels at risk to floods especially if the waterway easements are illegally
occupied by informal settlers. One of the first tasks is to strictly enforce the
standard easements of these drainage channels as they increase the volume
of water that can be conveyed. Furthermore, constant programs of preventing
the throwing of trash into creeks and dredging will allow these channels to
continue doing their job of draining the run-off in Makati. All of the rivers and
main creeks of Makati are actually the natural boundaries with adjacent cities.
This only means that all programs that aim to improve the drainage channels
should be planned and managed in collaboration with the adjoining city.
It would also be a good idea for the bigger buildings and residences to install
individual rain water harvesting systems that store rainwater on site rather
than discharging into the city’s storm drainage systems. This sustainable
practice of water management will relieve the pressure on the rivers and
creeks during extreme rainfall events. With new mixed-use developments
anticipated along Chino Roces Avenue, rainwater harvesting systems may be
imposed on the new developments before they are allowed to construct. Huge
lots along Chino Roces Avenue are transitioning from warehouse-type
buildings to high-rise mixed-use developments. The new developments along
Chino Roces Avenue are mostly in Barangays Pio del Pilar, Bangkal and
Magallanes. Barangays Post Proper Southside and Post Proper Northside are
areas where new high-density developments are also taking place. Barangays
Pio del Pilar, Bangkal, and San Lorenzo have creeks that eventually drain in
to Estero Tripa de Gallina while Barangays Forbes Park, Dasmariñas, Post
Proper Northside, Post Proper Southside, and Magallanes drain into
Maricaban Creek. Barangay Magallanes is situated downstream of Maricaban
Creek and is the southern natural boundary with Pasay City.
61
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
offered.
The 10-meter easement of the West Valley Fault Line if it is ever cleared of
structures is an excellent opportunity for conversion into a strip park.
62
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
63
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
An assessment of Makati’s natural hazards has shown that many areas are
exposed to geological and hydro-meteorological hazards. Since all of these
high-risk areas are built up and inhabited, there should be some kind of
redevelopment efforts to deal with the hazards present. The vulnerability of
communities occupying the hazardous areas should be a compelling enough
reason for their redevelopment. A vulnerability-focused urban renewal
program called “Disaster Resiliency Initiative for Vulnerable Enclaves” or
DRIVE is proposed to focus on highly vulnerable communities. Based on the
presence of natural hazards and other vulnerability factors (shown in previous
64
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Away from Makati’s Central Business District and plush residential enclaves
are some of the most congested and blighted areas that are vulnerable to
disasters. In such areas, urban renewal and disaster risk reduction are only
possible if the community comes together and lot owners pool their lots so
that an efficient layout that is more disaster-resilient may be drawn. Such a
voluntary urban renewal initiative in a highly urbanized area has never been
successfully executed but should still be attempted if a natural disaster is to
be averted. Other means of consolidating lots include expropriation by the
local government (eminent domain) and land banking through purchase.
Concept plans have been prepared for three pilot DRIVE sites which
demonstrate urban design interventions that would deal with specific hazards
present in a site. The three demonstration sites are as follows:
65
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Barangays Pembo and Rizal are two of the more congested and inadequately
planned areas in Makati City. The two barangays have predominantly medium
density residential land uses (2-3 storeys), narrow roads and hardly any open
spaces. The narrow roads will slow down any emergency response teams
during disasters and the absence of open spaces deprives residents of safe
refuge during evacuation. The West Valley Fault cuts across the barangays of
the Eastside Cluster which includes Barangays Pembo and Rizal. Structures
along the West Valley Fault are considered as “Highly Vulnerable Enclaves”
(See Hazardous Areas Map). Since several buildings are already at risk of
structural damage because they are sitting on faults, some kind of urban
renewal has to be undertaken in the area that involves removal of households
situated on the West Valley Fault as well as other vulnerable areas and
relocation to a new in-city housing development. The five meter easements on
both sides of the West Valley Fault have to be gradually cleared and
converted into a linear park (See Drive Site 3). It was estimated that there are
about 115 parcels (11,560 square meters) in Barangay Pembo and another
115 parcels (11,030 square meters) in Barangay Rizal traversed by the West
Valley Fault.
Barangay Tejeros
Several areas in Makati have also been identified as flood prone areas with
severity ranging from the 50-100 year cycle to the more frequent 2-10 year
cycle. Many of the flood-prone (2-10 year flood cycle) barangays are located
in the northwest cluster. The entire areas of Barangays Kasilawan,
Singkamas, and Tejeros, for example, are considered flood prone. A DRIVE
project for Barangay Tejeros has been conceptualized which consists of
redeveloping entire blocks including a BLISS Housing Project. The project will
involve housing, complementary commercial spaces and the provision of
66
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
open spaces. To mitigate the flooding in the area, it is proposed that the open
space be designed as a sunken park which will also function as a detention
pond during extreme rainfall events. The sunken open space can temporarily
impound excessive run-off to prevent the flooding of streets and homes.
Some of the recreational/ community facilities that can be introduced include a
skateboard park (X-Park or extreme sports park), amphitheater or outdoor
performance venue, and a children’s playground.
A portion of Barangays West Rembo and East Rembo, there is an area prone
to landslide either by earthquake or heavy-rain induced. This Area is another
pilot for disaster risk reduction for landslide. A development template will be
formulated in a form of Master Development Plan and development
guidelines.
The prepared concept plan for Barangay Rizal under Makati Risk-Sensitive
Urban Redevelopment Planning Project (MRSURP Project) should
considered the provisions of the New CLUP and Zoning Ordinance such as it
entails the prohibition of building new structures along the identified 10-meter
wide West Valley Fault easement (5.0 meters on both sides of the fault). Lots
sitting on the fault also have to be acquired so that no households are put in
67
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
harm’s way. The goal is to recover the ten-meter easement so that it can be
converted into a linear park that also increases the inventory of open spaces
in the barangay. The linear park will improve the environment, provide a safe
walking and bicycling path and increase the mobility of the residents. The
linear park should terminate in a bigger park on the western part of the
barangay beside Circumferential Road 5. The recovery of lots that are on the
West Valley Fault to convert into a strip park is expected to take several years
but each household removed will mean one less family at risk. The DRIVE
project can be piloted in Barangay Rizal but can also be undertaken
simultaneously for all the barangays crossed by the West Valley Fault.
68
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Figure 31. The sunken open space Figure 32. A new open
can have an amphitheatre and a space with flood mitigation
skateboard park. provisions will improve the
neighborhood environment
and help generate
economic opportunities.
Figure 33. The West Valley Fault traverses five Figure 34. A
barangays in the eastern part of Makati City proposed linear
including Barangay Rizal in the foreground. park will cut across
9 blocks and
terminate in a
bigger park along
C-5.
69
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
70
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
2.5.7 CONCLUSION
The national government has made Disaster Risk Reduction-Climate Change
Adaptation (DRR-CCA) a national priority and made the necessary measures
to empower the local governments to prepare development plans that take
into account Disaster Risk Reduction. National agencies that are entrusted to
gather and analyze geological, hydro-meteorological, and volcanic data have
also been instructed to make information available to cities and municipalities.
Like most cities in the Philippines, the City is complying with the national
policy of mainstreaming DRR-CCA in the formulation of its Comprehensive
Land Use Plan (2013-2023).
Makati has completed its disaster risk assessment and has mapped most of
the identified natural hazards. Appropriate land uses and urban design
interventions have been proposed to reduce the identified disaster risks.
The Hyogo Protocol calls for “disaster preparedness for effective response at
all levels” and Makati City has taken the initiative of upgrading its disaster
response capabilities, medical centers, and facilities for emergencies.
However, it should be realized that when a natural disaster occurs, the
nearest place where the assistance and rescue will come from is the
community itself. A strong sense of community has to be sustained by the
community members in order for them to help themselves. Much of the
success of the land use and urban development proposals depend on local
communities’ participation and willingness to carry them out.
71
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Transit Projects
o Monorail Project
A proposed project to connect vital locations and improve
the mass transport system in the City.
72
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Airport Access
o Bikeway Network
There is a proposed bikeway network that aims to
promote use of non-motorized bikes for travel by way of
delineated bike pathways.
o Parking Buildings
Construction of Multi-storey parking buildings outside of
the CBD to decongest the streets of illegally parked
vehicles and ease the traffic flow.
Ferry System
Linking the City through the river by improving the City’s
connection to river terminals.
73
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
Traffic Signalization
Installation of traffic lights to all strategic intersections to Improve
traffic flow and safety.
2.6.2 Housing
Housing Component of DRIVE and WVF Relocation
o Retrofitting and disaster proofing of communities
o Relocation of communities in danger zones
Redevelopment of Guadalupe BLISS Housing Project
Redevelopment of Tejeros Garden BLISS Housing Project
Community Development Program- relocation sites outside of
City
o Makati-Gawad Kalinga – San Jose del Monte, Bulacan
o Calauan, Laguna
74
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
75
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
76
Volume 1: Part II – Land Use
78