Research
Research
Research
1 | September 2022
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Abstract – Multitudinous disasters have crippled the country, leaving severe casualties and abundant
challenges among many citizens, especially among the vulnerable groups of elderly, who pose increasingly
physiological and immunological deficiencies in dealing with disasters, particularly amidst the pandemic. As
healthcare professionals, nurses carry crucial responsibilities in providing assistance and management among
them to help alleviate their suffering and distress from these circumstances. This quantitative, descriptive-
correlational study aims to determine the nurses’ roles among elderly during pandemic, the nurses’ disaster
preparedness among elderly during pandemic, the nurses’ disaster management among elderly during
pandemic, the challenges among nurses in taking care of elderly during pandemic, and the significant
relationship between nurses’ disaster preparedness, nurses’ disaster management and challenges among nurses
in taking care of elderly during pandemic. 170 public health nurses working on municipalities within the 30-km
radius around Taal volcano were purposively selected and surveyed via Google forms. Gathered findings
revealed that during pandemic, nurses always fulfill their roles in rendering essential health care among the
elderly; however, they often experience challenges in taking care of them. Furthermore, they often perform
measures for boosting their disaster preparedness and management among this group without being correlated
by the challenges they encounter. This study concludes that nurses still require continuous enhancement of their
disaster preparedness and management among elderly during pandemic thus, further provision of high standard
training programs directing to this is recommended for the supplementary sustainment of the elderly’s
significant health care needs fundamental in upholding their well-being.
Keywords – Disaster management, disaster preparedness, elderly, nurses’ roles, pandemic
63
Arce et al., Nurses’ Roles, Disaster Preparedness and Management among Elderly during Pandemic
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
65
Arce et al., Nurses’ Roles, Disaster Preparedness and Management among Elderly during Pandemic
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
Indicators WM VI R
1. I use the basic and continuing education to improve understanding of the need for
3.52 Always 1
competency in disaster response for elderly.
2. My institution organizes programs and trainings to promote a better preparation for
emergency response to vulnerable groups like elderly in times of disasters in the midst 3.34 Often 5
of pandemic.
3. I equip myself in acquiring practical experiences in providing care during disaster and Always 2
3.51
use this experience to facilitate proper interventions to elderly patients.
4. I attend in seminars about the appropriate ways of equipping the elderly groups and Often 10
3.02
their families for household emergency preparedness during COVID-19 pandemic.
5. I participate in emergency evacuation training for older adults that can be employed in Often 9
3.06
both natural and manmade disasters in the midst of pandemic.
6. I join in the infection prevention and control seminars that is particularly applicable Often 6
3.19
among elderly during disasters in the period of COVID-19 pandemic.
7. I participate in disaster drills at my workplace on a regular basis. 3.38 Often 4
8. I join in assemblies that address enhancement of skills in providing psychosocial
counselling and support for elderly people who may undergo traumatic experiences 3.18 Often 7
brought about by disasters during pandemic.
9. I attend in trainings that improve skills in providing first aid service specifically for
3.15 Often 8
older adults.
10. I develop mechanisms to increase rush capability, while maintaining expertise and
competence in handling emergency situations for elderly during disasters in the midst of 3.44 Often 3
pandemic.
Composite Mean 3.28 Often
Legend: 3.50 – 4.00 = Always; 2.50 – 3.49 = Often; 1.50 – 2.49 = Sometimes; 1.00 – 1.49 = Never
Nurses continue to seek for personal and There might be numerous seminars and training for
professional development by the enrichment of nurses to further enhance their knowledge and skills yet,
technical or customized knowledge and skills as health
it lacks assemblies mainly focused on equipping them
care professionals who assist in the resolution of issues
about the proper measures for household emergency
for service in their specialized area of discipline. As a
preparedness for the elderly and their families. People
result of this, nurses who are more prepared tend to can be equipped in a disaster if they are aware of and
provide better care to the elderly groups needing plan for the sorts of catastrophes to which they are most
support and management. vulnerable, establish a social interaction and evacuation
Disaster preparedness has been incorporated into the
plan in the event of a crisis, and organize a necessary
disaster supply pack [12].
nursing curriculum, emphasizing principles and patient
management in the event of a disaster [10]. Several Table 3 shows that nurses often perform the disaster
studies have highlighted the importance of disaster management among elderly during pandemic. with a
nursing education in enhancing disaster knowledge and composite mean of 3.43.
skills in preparation for their response. Nurses who haveThis relates to the results gathered from the table 2
in which due to the nurses’ curtailed attendance on
previously completed disaster nursing education have a
higher level of personal preparedness for disaster seminars and assemblies that can boost their disaster
response [11]. preparedness in responding to the vulnerable groups of
However, attending in seminars about the the elderly during disasters, they also often work on the
appropriate ways of equipping the elderly groups and principal measures for the efficient disaster
their families for household emergency preparedness management in assisting the elderlies during disasters
during COVID-19 pandemic, got the lowest mean value amidst the pandemic. Premise on this that being
(3.02). prepared leads to adequate management of a situation
even in times of crises.
Table 3. Nurses’ Disaster Management among Elderly During Pandemic
67
Arce et al., Nurses’ Roles, Disaster Preparedness and Management among Elderly during Pandemic
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WM VI R
1. I work with emergency planners and local government authorities in organizing
courses of actions for elderly for incoming disasters, evacuation and provision of care 3.28 Often 9
to elderly patients during emergencies in the period of COVID-19 pandemic.
2. I integrate the physiological, psychological, social, and family-oriented aspects of
3.37 Often 8
care during disasters while considering the special health needs of elderly.
3. I can educate the older adults and their families about emergency preparedness that
3.45 Often 6
is essential in the arrival of disasters in the midst of pandemic.
4. I inform and require the elderly people about the practice of infection prevention and
control measures in all phases of disaster especially within the period of COVID-19 3.51 Always 4
pandemic.
5. When disaster strikes, I work systematically to ensure that no one is abandoned, even
3.49 Often 5
the bed-ridden and physically disabled elderlies particularly in access of isolated areas.
6. I assist in seeking and providing a safe site for evacuation where equitable
3.54 Always 3
distribution of necessary supplies and services will be accessible.
7. I monitor the well-being and identify the signs and symptoms of injury or incident to
3.57 Always 2
older adults when responding to disasters.
8. I provide the advanced first aid to older adults when required to support the
3.44 Often 7
emergency services in the rescue efforts for disasters.
9. I deliver counseling and one-to-one support when required for elderly people who
have lost family members, homes and livelihood brought about by disasters within the 3.05 Often 10
period of pandemic.
10. I am able to work under pressure and remain calm, even the situation is difficult to
3.62 Always 1
handle.
Composite Mean 3.43 Often
Legend: 3.50 – 4.00 = Always; 2.50 – 3.49 = Often; 1.50 – 2.49 = Sometimes; 1.00 – 1.49 = Never
Among the items cited, working under environment to disaster victims while they perform
pressure and remaining calm, even if the situation is their interventions to the people affected by these
difficult to handle (3.62), monitoring the well-being of events, allowing them to focus on the demands of the
patients and identifying the signs and symptoms of situation [14].
injury or incident to older adults when responding to Nonetheless, delivering counsel and one-to-
disasters (3.57), and assisting in seeking and providing one support when required for elderly people who have
a safe site for evacuation where equitable distribution lost family members, homes and livelihood brought
of necessary supplies and services will be accessible about by disasters within the period of pandemic
(3.54) got the highest ratings. (3.05). Disasters are agonizing for those affected
Nurses are fortified with calmness and people. With that, psychological counseling is required
composure even when working under pressure in as they rehabilitate from these circumstances.
handling emergencies [13]. They may be troubled by COVID-19 has harmed the lives and health of over
the unsettling events happening within disaster millions of individuals throughout the world and
scenarios, but they manage to be unruffled to properly overwhelmed the healthcare system. Nurses
strategize about their subsequent management for the experienced significant challenges caused by the
elderlies and other community members in these pandemic, including a critical shortage of nurses and
situations. This is a fundamental characteristic, medical supplies, and the risk of infection, resulting
especially during these circumstances, as it may help them to be hesitant in providing one-on-one care to
alleviate the apprehensive feelings of the elderly clients. Aiding and addressing the needs of nurses will
patients brought about by the emergency and disasters. help them respond more confidently and appropriately
Nurses still manage to provide a comforting nursing to the needs of their clients amidst crises [15].
Table 4. Challenges Among Nurses in Taking Care of Elderly During Pandemic
68
Asia Pacific Journal of Allied Health Sciences
Vol. 5, No. 1, September 2022
Asia Pacific Journal of Allied Health Sciences | Volume 5, No. 1 | September 2022
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
WM VI R
1. I am hindered by the limited face-to-face interaction in providing home care visit to
3.11 Often 2
elderly people needing health assistance and surveillance.
2. I experience a shortage of nurses in my institution that impedes to meet the increased
3.09 Often 3
health care needs of the elderly in the community.
3. I encounter having insufficient personal protective equipment and medical supplies that
2.85 Often 8
help to reduce the spread of infection.
4. I fear of having increased risk of contracting the virus for myself and my family due to
3.46 Often 1
my exposure to different kinds of people in fulfilling my nursing roles.
5. I experience discrimination by the society as a health worker which affects my self-
esteem in interacting and providing care with the people especially the vulnerable elderly 2.88 Often 7
in the community.
6. I feel pressured in intervening with elderly patients as they require more complex and
2.92 Often 6
time-consuming care that may result to poorer health outcomes.
7. I have inadequate training in taking care of elderly people affected by the COVID 19
2.75 Often 10
due to lack of programs and facilities in my institution that supports it.
8. I experience an unfavorable atmosphere for elderly care brought about by stressful and
2.76 Often 9
emotional environment especially in times of disasters.
9. I encounter an inadequate allocation of medication, and health supplies provided by the
government for the elderly needing intensive care especially during disasters in the midst 2.95 Often 5
of pandemic.
10. I experience physical and emotional exhaustions caused by overloaded tasks that
3.04 Often 4
reduces my abilities to competently provide care for elderly.
Composite Mean 2.98 Often
Legend: 3.50 – 4.00 = Always; 2.50 – 3.49 = Often; 1.50 – 2.49 = Sometimes; 1.00 – 1.49 = Never
Table 4 presents that nurses often experience It affects their mindset while working as health care
challenges in taking care of elderly during pandemic. professionals, knowing how life-threatening the
with a composite mean of 2.98. It reflects that as health COVID-19 disease could be. Galehdar et al. [16] found
care professionals concern for the safety of the people out that nurses experience death anxiety due to
in the community, especially of the elderly, excessive exposure to the nature of the disease, fear of
encountering challenges in serving them amidst the unknowingly passing the virus to others, and emotional
pandemic has been inevitable because of the dangerous stress. However, the implementation and compliance of
circumstances the pandemic poses. Among the items proper protocols could mitigate the effects of anxiety on
cited, fear of having increased risk of contracting the the nurse's mental health. Job responsibilities and
virus for themselves and their family due to their attendance at COVID-19-related training were also
exposure to different kinds of people in fulfilling their discovered to predict anxiety of contracting COVID-19
nursing roles (3.46), being hindered by the limited among their nurse respondents [17]. Furthermore, a
face-to-face interaction in providing home care visit to greater fear of COVID-19 was connected to lower work
elderly people needing health assistance and satisfaction, increased psychological discomfort, and
surveillance (3.11), and there is a nursing shortage, organizational and professional turnover intentions in
which makes it difficult to address the rising health the workplace in the Philippine setting [18]. On the other
care needs of the elderly in the community (3.09) got hand, having inadequate training in taking care of
the highest rating. Nurses risk their lives to carry out elderly people affected by the COVID19 due to lack of
their nursing duties in promoting health wellness and programs and facilities in the institution with a weighted
preventing illness among their clients. However, as mean of 2.75 obtained the lowest rating. Nurses are
high-risk individuals, they are still concerned about given a variety of trainings to help them develop their
becoming infected or unintentionally infecting their psychological traits and firstaid skills. They can make
elderly patients and relatives. quick assessments and judgments in an emergency, take
appropriate measures, closely monitor disease states,
69
Arce et al., Nurses’ Roles, Disaster Preparedness and Management among Elderly during Pandemic
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
and accurately and timely follow doctor's advice [19]. afraid of contracting the disease than their fellow
Furthermore, nurses who had worked previously employees who had not, demonstrating that experience
through pandemic reported a higher level of competence can reduce fears.
to deal with such events in the future [20] and were less
Table 5. Relationship Between Nurses’ Disaster Preparedness, Nurses’ Disaster Management, and
Challenges among Nurses in Taking Care of Elderly during Pandemic
r-value p-value Interpretation
Table 5 depicts the association between nurses’ elderly during pandemic as they sustain their basic
disaster preparedness, nurses’ disaster management, and health needs; yet, uplifting their mental health status was
challenges among nurses in taking care of the elderly being disregarded despite experiencing traumatic events
during pandemic. It was observed that the obtained r- brought about by the disasters. During the pandemic,
values indicate an almost negligible correlation, and the nurses often experience challenges in taking care of the
computed p-values were greater than the 0.05 alpha elderly, wherein the fear of having increased risk of
levels. This means that no significant relationship exists contracting the virus for themselves and their family due
between the indicators and implies that the nurses’ to exposure to different kinds of people as they fulfil
disaster preparedness and management were not their nursing roles was mostly suffered by nurses.
affected by the challenges experienced. Nurses implement measures to develop their disaster
Cayaban et al. [21] reported that the past experiences preparedness and management among elderly without
of nurses and having disaster-related training helps them being affected by the challenges they encounter in
to increase preparedness response but sometimes shows taking care of this group of individuals during
a lack of confidence in doing so. With that, the findings pandemic.
of their study provide evidence that with proper training, Based on the accumulated findings, this study
sufficient disaster education, and adequate involvement sought to provide the following recommendations:
in assemblies and programs about disaster preparedness, Hospital administrators and Local
nurses will effectively manage and handle emergency Government Units, in coordination with the City Health
and disaster situations despite the shortcomings that may Office or Provincial Health Office and Red Cross
arise. Organization, must deliver high-standard training
programs to improve nurse's knowledge and skills in
CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION responding to disasters, taking note of the exclusive
After the results were analyzed, the following are measures to perform among the elderly while
therefore concluded: Nurses always fulfill their roles as considering their special health care needs during a
health care professionals in rendering care and service pandemic. Nurses must also be encouraged to engage in
to the elderly in the community, who are considered and seek out training opportunities in mock disaster
highly susceptible individuals during pandemic. Nurses drills and actual disaster events. Promote the
exploit their educational attainment, develop practical involvement of nurses in the meetings and assemblies
experiences, and join in different seminars and training with the local government authorities and other
to equip and prepare them in responding to disasters, emergency responders in organizing courses of action
especially amidst pandemic; however, institutions and for the incoming disasters, evacuation, and provision of
organizations have insufficient programs and activities care to the elderly groups to highlight the consideration
that particularly target and prioritize the needs of the for their essential health care needs and further engage
elderly groups during these situations. Nurses perform nurses in responding to disaster events. Boost utilization
the integral measures for disaster management among of telemedicine among nurses to maximize
70
Asia Pacific Journal of Allied Health Sciences
Vol. 5, No. 1, September 2022
Asia Pacific Journal of Allied Health Sciences | Volume 5, No. 1 | September 2022
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
communication between elderly clients and other health [7] Abrams, M. K., Hong, C. S. & Ferris, T. G.
care providers in monitoring their health condition while (2014). Toward increased adoption of complex
enabling them to stay at home, reducing the risk of care management. n Engl j Med, 371(6), 491.
transmitting communicable and infectious diseases http://ignacioriesgo.es/wpcontent/uploads/2014/
during pandemic. 08/NEJMp1401755.pdf
Additional research relating to this study must [8] Buenaventura, R. D., Ho, J. B., & Lapid, M. I.
further be done to support the measures in (2020). COVID-19 and mental health of older
accomplishing the nurses' roles, improving disaster adults in the Philippines: a perspective from a
preparedness and management, and overcoming developing country. International
challenges in taking care of the elderly during pandemic, psychogeriatrics, 32(10), 1129-1130.
for the benefit of both the older population and the [9] Flaherty, E. A. (2020). School nursing and public
nursing profession. This study may serve as a reliable health: The case for school nurse investigators
reference for other researchers who aim to further and contact tracing monitors of COVID-19
explore the nurses' roles, disaster preparedness, and patients in Massachusetts. NASN School Nurse,
management among the elderly during pandemic in 35(6), 327-329. 10.1177/1942602X20950670
different perspectives and practices of a larger scale of [10] Brennan, M. G. B., Labrague, L. J., Yboa, B. C.,
nurses in various fields and broader locales. McEnroe–Petitte, D. M., & Lobrino, L. R. (2016).
Disaster preparedness in Philippine
REFERENCES nurses. Journal of nursing scholarship, 48(1),
[1] Doran, K. M., Grudzen, C. R., Malik, S., Lee, D. 98- 105. https://doi.org/10.1111/jnu.12186
C., Worthing, J., Portelli, I., ... & Smith, S. W. [11] Tzeng, W. C., Feng, H. P., Cheng, W. T., Lin, C.
(2018). Vulnerability of older adults in disasters: H., Chiang, L. C., Pai, L., & Lee, C. L. (2016).
emergency department utilization by geriatric Readiness of hospital nurses for disaster
patients after Hurricane Sandy. Disaster medicine responses in Taiwan: a cross-sectional study.
and public health preparedness, 12(2), 184. Nurse education today, 47, 37-38.
DOI:10.1017/dmp.2017.44 https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2016.02.025
[2] McCombes, S. (2019). Descriptive Research. [12] Federal Emergency Management Agency.
https://www.scribbr.com/methodology/descripti (2014). Ready. Prepare. Plan. Stay informed.
ve-research/ [Cited 13 May 2016.]. http://www.ready.gov.
[3] Polit, D.F. and Beck, C.T. (2017) Nursing [13] Back, P., de Jong, N., Görres, S., Grochtdreis, T.,
Research: Generating and Assessing Evidence for & Harenberg, N. (2016). Nurses’ roles,
Nursing Practice. 10th Edition. Wolters Kluwer knowledge, and experience in national disaster
Health, Philadelphia. pre-paredness and emergency response: A
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.iccn.2015.01.005 literature review. South Eastern European Journal
[4] Magnaye, B., Muñoz, M. S., Muñoz, of Public Health (SEEJPH).
M. A., Muñoz, R. G., & Muro, J. H. (2011). The https://doi.org/10.4119/seejph-1847
role, preparedness and management of nurses [14] [14] Denier, Y., Dierckx de Casterlé, B., Mertens,
during disasters. International Scientific E., Steenacker, J. (2020). Nurses’ experiences of
Research Journal, 3(4), 269. working under time pressure in care for older
[5] Neuhauser, M., Puth, MT., & Ruxton, G. D. persons. Nursing ethics, 27(4), 979-990.
(2014). Effective use of Pearson's https://doi.org/10.1177/0969733019895797
productmoment correlation coefficient. Animal [15] Al Thobaity, A., & Alshammari, F. (2020).
Behaviour, 93, 183-184. Nurses on the frontline against the COVID-19
doi.org/10.1016/j.anbehav.2014.05.003 pandemic: an integrative
[6] Edvardsson, D., Nilsson, A., & Rushton, C. review. Dubai Medical Journal, 3(3), 87-92.
(2019). Nurses’ descriptions of person‐centred https://doi.org/10.1159/000509361
care for older people in an acute medical ward ‐ [16] Galehdar, N., Heydari, H., Kamran, A., Toulabi,
on the individual, team and organizational T. (2020). Exploring nurses’ experiences of
levels’. Journal of Clinical psychological distress during care of patients
Nursing. https://doi.org/10.1111/jocn.14738 with COVID-19: a qualitative study. BMC
psychiatry, 20(1), 1-3.
71
Arce et al., Nurses’ Roles, Disaster Preparedness and Management among Elderly during Pandemic
_________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
[17] de Los Santos, J. A. A., & Labrague, L. J. (2021). Scholarship, 46(2), 134-142.
Fear of Covid‐19, psychological distress, work https://doi.org/10.1111/jnu.12056
satisfaction and turnover intention among [21] Cayaban, A. R., Fronda, D. C., Gloe, D. S.,
frontline nurses. Journal of nursing management. Hammad, K., Labrague, L. J., McEnroe‐Petitte,
https://doi.org/10.1111/jonm.13168 D. M., Obeidat, A. A., Leocadio, M. C.,
[18] Abd-Ellatif, E. E., Anwar, M. M., AlJifri, A. A., Cayaban, A. R., & Mirafuentes, E. C. (2018).
& El Dalatony, M. M. (2021). Fear of COVID-19 Disaster preparedness among nurses: a systematic
and its Impact on Job Satisfaction and Turnover review of literature. International Nursing
Intention among Egyptian Physicians. Safety and Review, 65(1),
Health at Work. 41–45. https://doi.org/10.1111/inr.12369
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.shaw.2021.07.007
[19] Khalaila, R. (2014). Simulation in nursing COPYRIGHTS
education: an evaluation of students' outcomes Copyright of this article is retained by the author/s,
at their first clinical practice combined with with first publication rights granted to APJAHS.
simulations. Nurse education today, 34(2), 252- This is an open-access article distributed under the
254. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2013.08.015 [20] terms and conditions of the Creative Commons
Itzhaki, M., Kagan, I., & Melnikov, S. (2014). Attribution license (http://creative
Israeli nurses’ intention to report for work in an commons.org/licenses/by/4).
emergency or disaster. Journal of Nursing
72
Asia Pacific Journal of Allied Health Sciences
Vol. 5, No. 1, September 2022