Belghait May 2018

C. R.
Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Comptes Rendus Chimie

www.sciencedirect.com
moire
Full paper/Me
Semi-empirical correlation of solid solute solubility in

supercritical carbon dioxide: Comparative study and
proposition of a novel density-based model
Corr
elation semi-empirique de solubilite des solut
es solides dans le
dioxyde de carbone supercritique: etude comparative et proposition d'un
nouveau mod ele bas
e sur la densit
e
Aicha Belghait*, Cherif Si-Moussa, Maamar Laidi, Salah Hanini
Laboratory of Biomaterials and Transport Phenomena (LBMPT), Faculty of Science and Technology, University Yahia Fares of Medea,
Algeria
a r t i c l e i n f o a b s t r a c t
Article history: A comprehensive data set on experimental solubility of 210 solid solutes in supercritical
Received 2 October 2017 CO2 counting 5550 data points has been used for comparison of the correlation perfor-
Accepted 12 February 2018 mance of 21 empirical models. On the basis of the comparison results a new eight-
Available online 20 March 2018
parameter density-based model has been proposed. The comparison shows that the
three-parameter models are the least accurate. The results also show that models that
Keywords:
relate the logarithm of the solubility to the logarithm of solvent density and temperature
Solubility
are more accurate than models that include the pressure. When comparing the overall
Supercritical CO2
correlating performance in terms of average absolute relative deviation the proposed
Modeling
model is by far the best with an average absolute relative deviation lying in the range 0.17
Density-based models
e81.99% and an average value of 8.88%.
© 2018 Académie des sciences. Published by Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction new green biotechnological processes, and so forth [1,2].

The accurate knowledge of the phase behavior of the sys-
Supercritical fluid (SCF) technologies have been gaining tems involved and, in particular, of the solubility of the
an increasing attention in process engineering during the solid solutes in high-pressure scCO2 is crucial to the design,
past decades due to its various advantages. Carbon dioxide optimization, and operation of such processes. The solid
is the most commonly used SCF because it is environ- solutes of interest, such as dyes or pharmaceuticals, are
mentally benign, nontoxic, nonflammable, cheap, and generally high molecular weight complex molecules and in
readily available. As a green solvent, supercritical carbon their majority low volatile solids. This implies that very
dioxide (scCO2) finds applications in many conventional often their experimental physical properties, such as crit-
and novel emerging technologies such as dry dyeing pro- ical properties and sublimation pressure, are not readily
cessing techniques, which operate without wastewater available in the literature. The experimental measurement
emissions, efficient environmentally friendly and benign of the solubility of such compounds in scCO2 is laborious
and costly. To avoid expensive and tedious experiments,
flexible and robust predictive models are the ideal targets.
* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: belghait.aicha@yahoo.fr (A. Belghait). In the absence of such an ideal predictive model, however,
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crci.2018.02.006
1631-0748/© 2018 Académie des sciences. Published by Elsevier Masson SAS. All rights reserved.
A. Belghait et al. / C. R. Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513 495
simple and accurate enough correlative models are very densities are typically used. However, for the majority of
useful in engineering applications such as used in com- pharmaceutical complex chemicals such extended experi-
mercial process simulators. This is the reason why both mental data do not exist [18]. Most SAFT-type models
types of modeling have been and still remain a goal for require five parameters for each pure associating com-
many research works. pound (three for nonassociation ones). Three parameters
Three major modeling approaches have been used to for nonassociating fluids: the segment number, the inter-
model the solubility of a solid solute in an SCF for predictive action energy, and the hard core segment diameter. Two
or correlative purposes: equations of state (EoSs) and ac- other parameters for associating fluids are the association
tivity coefficient models, computational intelligence tech- energy and the affective association volume. These pa-
niques, and density-based semiempirical equations. It rameters are calculated using GC methods, such as pro-
should be mentioned that the three approaches rely more posed by Tihic et al. [19,20] or estimated from vapor
or less on experimental data and, therefore, their use pressure and liquid-density data over extended tempera-
outside the range of experimental data from which the ture ranges [21,22]. In the absence of such data for specific
models have been obtained is not safe. compounds, such as polymers and pharmaceuticals, GC
EoSs are the straightforward and obvious methods as methods, such as GC-SAFT [23,24], GC-SAFT variable range
the solubility is a phase equilibrium problem. Simple cubic (SAFT-VR) [25e32], and GC-SAFT-g [33e35], are used for
EoS with various mixing rules has been extensively used for the estimation of required properties. As regards modeling
calculation of solid solute solubility in scCO2 (to cite just the solubility of complex solid molecules in scCO2 using
few, see, for example, Refs. [3e12]). Detailed review of the noncubic EoS only few works are reported. This is due to
use of cubic EoSs in this context has been given by Yazdi- the lack of sufficient experimental data as this family of
zadeh et al. [10]. The use of cubic EoSs requires critical EoSs uses fluid-specific parameters that usually are fitted to
properties, acentric factor to compute fugacity coefficient, pure fluid experimental data [18]. Tsivintzelis et al. [18]
which is needed along with the sublimation vapor pres- have used nonrandom hydrogen bonding theory to pre-
sure, and the molar volume of the solid solute to compute dict the solubility of pharmaceuticals in SCFs. SAFT models
the solubility. In the absence of experimental values of have also been used to predict or correlate the solubility of
these solid solute parameters, they are estimated using solids in SCFs [36e38].
group contribution (GC) methods. Sublimation vapor Activity coefficient models, such as universal functional
pressure, which is very low, and experimental value, un- activity coefficient, the regular solution theory-based
available for many solids, may also be considered as an models, and more sophisticated models, such as
adjusted parameter to be fitted to solubility data as used in conductor-like screening model (COSMO), cannot be used
Refs. [8,13,14]. The accuracy of the correlation or prediction for high-pressure phase equilibrium calculations without
using the cubic EoS depends greatly on the method used to being coupled with another model, namely, an EoS [18].
estimate these solid solute properties [3,4,11]. The effect of COSMO-based approach has been used to predict solubility
mixing rules has been investigated by Yazdizadeh et al. of solids in scCO2 [39e42]. The only experimental data
[9,10] in two comparative studies. The first one [9] con- required for solutes are the melting temperature and the
cerned 52 solid solutes and compared two cubic EoSs melting enthalpy of the solid solute.
combined with four mixing rules and showed a global su- Computational intelligence techniques such as artificial
periority of EsmaeilzadeheRoshanfekr EoS [15] combined neural networks, adaptive neurofuzzy inference system,
with WongeSandler mixing rule [16] and a global average and least square support vector machine are considered as
absolute deviation of 9%. In the second one [10] 23 com- powerful modeling tools that can map complex highly
pounds were considered, five cubic EoSs combined with nonlinear input/output relationships of any systems. This
four mixing rules and the results showed a global best ability has made them suited for a wide range of engi-
performance of a modified EsmaeilzadeheRoshanfekr EoS neering applications. Applications of such techniques to
[17] with WongeSandler mixing rule [16] and a global correlate solubility of various solid solutes in scCO2 have
average absolute deviation of 7%. Sang et al. [8] considered been reported: Refs. [43e51] for artificial neural networks,
three cubic EoSs combined with five mixing rules where Refs. [52,53] for least square support vector machine, and
they used a modification of the calculation procedure by Ref. [54] for adaptive neurofuzzy inference system.
introducing some approximations. They proposed two- and The review of the EoS and computational intelligence
three-adjustable-parameter models for the calculation of approaches in modeling the solubility of solid solutes in
the fugacity coefficient. Accordingly, the only solid solute supercritical solvents reveals that both approaches,
parameter required was the molar volume. They showed whether used for predictive or correlative purposes, with
that the three-adjustable-parameter model gave a global the exception of the COSMO model, rely on experimental
average absolute deviation of 5.5% for the same data set data of phase equilibrium and the physical properties of
used in Ref. [10]. pure solid solute. As regards the EoS approach, phase
Despite their success for fluid mixtures, theoretical equilibrium data are required for fitting at least one binary
esound state of the art statistical thermodynamic models interaction parameter used by mixing rules, fitting other
have not been used for modeling complex molecules such required pure solute properties, or for the validation of
as pharmaceuticals. Statistical associating fluid theory models. Regarding computational intelligence methods,
(SAFT)-type models use fluid-specific parameters that experimental data are necessary for training and validation
usually are fitted to pure fluid experimental data. In com- of the model. Pure component properties for complex
mon fluids, experimental vapor pressures and liquid multifunctional solid solutes, such as pharmaceuticals, are
496 A. Belghait et al. / C. R. Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513
not always available and need to be estimated by GC solubility (y2), the fugacity coefficient (f2), and the equi-
methods. librium pressure P as follows:
Semiempirical modeling is used as a simpler alternative
insofar as it does not require any solute property, although f2SCF ¼ y2 f2 P (2)
there are few models that include some solute parameters
The fugacity of the solid phase is usually considered as a
such as temperature and enthalpy of fusion and infinite
pure phase and can expressed as
dilute activity coefficient [55], solubility parameter, and
molar volume of the solute [56]. In a very recent article [57], s
V2
we have presented an extensive review of semiempirical f2s ¼ P2sub fsat
2 exp P P2
sub
(3)
RT
models. Comparative studies [58e64] on the performance
of semiempirical models show there is no model that where P2sub , fsat s
2 , and V2 are the sublimation pressure, the
presents the best correlation for all the experimental data saturated fugacity coefficient, and the molar volume of the
of all solutes. In the present work, it is intended to carry a solid, respectively. T is the temperature, P is the pressure,
larger scale comparative study that includes all semi- and R is the universal gas constant (8.314 J mol1 K1).
empirical models on a more comprehensive data set. It also Because of sublimation pressures, fsat
2 is equal to 1 for
aims for the improvement of the quality of density-based most solutes that do not have a strong tendency of asso-
correlation of the solubility of solid solutes in scCO2. ciation. Furthermore, because of the incompressibility of
solids, values of V2s can be assumed to be pressure
independent.
2. Modeling solideSCF phase equilibrium Hence, y2 in SCF reduces to
s
The fugacities of a solid solute in the solid and fluid P2sub 1 V2
y2 ¼ exp P P2
sub
(4)
phases are related by the following fundamental iso- P fSCF
2
RT
fugacity relationship:
Note that fSCF2 is a function of y2, T, P, and ZSCF (the
f2S ¼ f2SCF (1) compressibility coefficient of the supercritical phase), it-
self a function of y2, T, and P:
in which f designates the fugacity and superscripts S and
SCF designate solid and SCF phases, respectively. fSCF
2 ¼ f T; P; Z SCF ; y2 (5)
The fugacity of solid solute in an SCF phase can be
written as the product of the solute mole fraction or
Table 1
Density-based models for the correlation of solid solutes in SCFs.
Model Equation Equation no. Reference
Chrastil ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 ln r1 þ a2
T
(10) [65]
Adachi and Lu ln y2 ¼ a0 þ ða1 þ a2 r1 þ a3 r21 Þ ln r1 þ a4
T
(11) [66]
del Valle and Aguilera ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 ln r1 þ a2
T þ a3
T2
(12) [67]
Kumar and Johnston ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 r1 þ a2
T
(13) [68]
Bartle et al. ln y2 P
P ref
¼ a0 þ a1 ðr1 rref
1 Þþ
a2
T
(14) [69]
Gordillo et al. ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 P þ a2 P 2 þ a3 PT þ a4 T þ a5 T 2 (15) [70]
Mendez-Santiago and Teja T ln y2 P ¼ a0 þ a1 r1 þ a2 T (16) [71]

Sung and Shim ln y2 ¼ a0 þ aT1 ln r1 þ aT2 þ a3 (17) [72]
Jouyban et al. ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 P þ a2 P 2 þ a3 PT þ a4 TP þ a5 ln r1 (18) [58]

!
Sparks et al. ða0 þa1 rr;1 þa2 r2r;1 Þ (19) [73]
c*2 ¼r r;1 exp b0 þ b1
Tr þ b2
Tr2
with c*2 ¼ rc2 ; rr;1 ¼ rr1 ; Tr ¼ T

Tc;1
c;1 c;1
Garlapati et Madras ln y2 ¼ a0 ln r1 þ aT1 þ a2 (20) [74]

Garlapati et Madras ln y2 ¼ a0 þ ða1 þ a2 r1 Þ ln r1 þ a3
T þ a4 lnðr1 TÞ (21) [75]
Jafari Nedjad et al. ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 P 2 þ a2 T 2 þ a3 ln r1 (22) [76]
Ch and Madras ðk1Þ (23) [77]
y2 ¼ PP* exp aT0 þ a1 r1 þ a2

Bian et al. ða þa r þa =ln TÞ (24) [59]
c 2 ¼ r1 0 1 1 2 exp a3 þaT 4 r1 þ a5 c2 ¼ Mw
r1 Mw2 y2
1 ð1y2 Þ (24a)

Keshmiri et al. ln y2 ¼ a0 þ aT1 þ a2 P 2 þ a3 þ aT4 ln r1 (25) [78]
Ali Akbar a0 þa1 =r1 þa2 =r21 þa3 ln Tþa4 ðln TÞ2 (26) [60]
ln y2 ¼
Amooey 1þa5 =r1 þa6 ln Tþa7 ðln TÞ2 þa8 ðln TÞ3
a2 r1
a1
Hozhabr et al. ln y2 ¼ a0 þ T þ
T a3 ln P
(27) [79]
Khansary et al. ln y2 ¼ a0 2
þ a1 P þ a2TP þ ða3 þ a4 PÞ ln 1 r (28) [61]
T
a2 r1
Bian et al. ln y2 ¼ a1
a0 þ T þ T þ ða3 þ a4 1 Þ ln 1 r r (29) [64]
Si-Moussa et al. ln y2 ¼ r r
a0 þ a1 1 þ a2 21 þ a3 1 T þ a4 rT þ
1
r a5 ln r1 (30) [57]
Table 2
Sources and ranges of solubility data of solid solutes in scCO2.
No. Solid solute Mw (g/mol) T (K) P (MPa) y2 104 Ni Reference
1 (S)-Boc-piperazine 285.3900 308.20e328.20 90.10e205.00 13.70e65.20 21 [81]

2 1,8-Dihydroxy-9-anthrone 226.2274 308.00e348.00 101.00e355.00 1.33e4.87 54 [82]
3 10-Undecenoic acid 184.2800 308.00e333.00 100.00e180.00 4.00e174.00 18 [83]
4 1-Chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene 202.5520 308.00e313.00 95.00e145.00 17.80e61.90 12 [84]
5 1-Hydroxy-2,4-dimethyl-9-anthrone 238.2812 308.00e348.00 101.00e355.00 0.24e1.06 54 [82]
6 1-Hydroxy-2-ethyl-9-anthrone 238.2812 308.00e348.00 101.00e355.00 1.08e9.78 54 [82]
7 1-Hydroxy-2-methyl-9-anthrone 224.2546 308.00e348.00 101.00e355.00 0.87e7.05 54 [82]
8 1-Hydroxythioxanthone 228.2660 308.00e348.00 121.00e354.00 0.99e4.24 45 [85]
9 2,20 -Oxybis(N,N-dibutylacetamide) 356.5432 313.00e333.00 88.00e131.00 15.20e86.00 15 [86]
10 2,20 -Oxybis(N,N-diethylacetamide) 240.2988 313.00e333.00 87.00e133.00 22.30e1171.00 15 [86]
11 2,20 -Oxybis(N,N-dihexylacetamide) 468.7558 313.00e333.00 90.00e164.00 10.60e53.60 15 [86]
12 2,3-Dimethylaniline 121.1800 313.00e333.00 80.00e200.00 3.30e95.20 18 [87]
13 2,4-Dinitrophenol 184.1100 308.00e348.00 121.60e483.70 12.40e140.00 41 [88]
14 2,5-Dinitrophenol 184.1100 308.00e348.00 121.60e486.40 19.10e94.40 45 [88]
15 2-Methoxybenzoic acid 152.1500 308.20e328.20 99.80e246.90 90.00e1110.00 23 [89]
16 2-Naphthol 144.1700 308.10e328.10 100.50e300.00 2.49e12.30 18 [90]
17 2-Phenyl-4H-1,3-benzoxazin-one 223.2270 308.15e328.18 651.46e951.27 0.80e4.50 26 [91]
18 2-Propenamide 71.0800 308.20e323.20 90.00e400.00 0.12e1.63 28 [92]
19 2-Trifluoromethylbenzoic acid 190.1190 308.20e323.20 93.40e226.00 13.70e85.50 21 [93]
20 3-Acetylpyridine 121.1400 313.15e343.15 100.00e260.00 69.00e1619.00 36 [94]
21 3-Aminobenzoic acid 137.1360 308.00e328.00 100.00e210.00 0.02e0.07 15 [95]
22 3-Nitrotoluene 137.1360 313.00e333.00 80.00e200.00 1.50e59.20 18 [87]
24 4-Aminoantipyrine 203.2400 308.20e328.20 100.50e220.40 1.16e3.67 21 [96]
25 4-Aminosalicylic acid 153.1350 308.00e328.00 110.00e210.00 0.04e0.36 15 [97]
26 4-Dimethylaminoantipyrine 231.2940 308.20e328.20 100.30e220.30 5.25e25.50 21 [96]
27 4-Hydroxybenzaldehyde 122.1200 308.00e328.00 110.00e210.00 0.07e1.38 15 [98]
29 5-Fluorouracil 130.0770 308.15e328.15 125.00e250.00 0.04e0.15 18 [91]
30 5-Hydroxymethylfurfural 126.1100 314.10e343.20 97.40e195.80 5.06e23.84 22 [99]
31 Acenaphthene 154.2080 308.00e338.00 121.60e354.60 23.95e47.37 36 [100]
32 Acetylferrocene 228.0680 308.00e348.00 77.00e221.00 2.50e79.20 18 [101]
33 All-trans retinoic acid 300.4351 308.20e318.20 102.00e303.00 0.01e0.18 15 [102]
34 Amical-48 (diiodomethyl p-tolyl sulfone) 422.0200 318.00e338.00 100.00e300.00 0.06e1.15 18 [103]
35 Ammonium benzoate 139.1520 308.00e328.00 110.00e210.00 0.02e0.05 15 [104]
36 Amoxicillin 365.4040 308.15e338.15 160.00e400.00 0.10e72.30 28 [105]
37 Anastrozole 293.3700 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.04e3.80 45 [106]
38 Anthracene 178.2290 308.10e328.10 100.00e300.00 0.42e1.13 15 [90]
39 Antipyrine 188.2260 308.20e328.20 100.40e220.40 2.09e7.17 21 [96]
40 Aspirin 180.1570 308.15e328.15 120.00e250.00 0.63e3.47 24 [107]
41 Atorvastatin 558.6400 308.00e348.00 121.60e354.60 0.17e14.46 45 [108]
42 Atropine 289.3690 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.60e16.70 45 [109]
43 Azadirachtin 720.7140 308.15e333.15 100.00e260.00 0.01e0.15 54 [110]
44 Azelaic acid 188.2210 313.15e333.15 100.00e300.00 0.01e0.08 14 [111]
45 Azobenzene 182.2212 308.20e318.20 91.00e253.00 36.40e98.40 10 [112]
46 Azodicarbonamide 116.0788 308.15e328.15 100.00e300.00 0.09e0.20 26 [91]
47 Beclomethasone dipropionate 521.0420 338.00e358.00 213.00e385.00 0.07e0.34 21 [113]
48 Benzamide 121.1366 308.00e328.00 110.00e210.00 0.02e0.16 15 [104]
49 Benzenesulfonamide 172.2050 308.15e328.15 110.00e210.00 0.65e2.90 15 [114]
50 Benzocaine 165.1891 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 10.30e121.20 40 [115]
51 Benzoin 212.2400 308.15e328.15 111.30e244.30 0.41e4.10 19 [116]
52 Bisacodyl 361.4000 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.36e5.83 39 [117]
53 Budesonide 430.5340 338.00e358.00 213.00e385.00 0.06e0.29 21 [113]
54 Caffeine 194.1900 313.00e353.00 199.00e349.00 2.83e11.30 24 [118]
55 Cannabinol 310.4299 314.00e334.00 130.00e202.00 1.26e2.17 34 [119]
56 Capecitabine 359.3501 308.00e348.00 15.20e35.40 0.08e1.59 40 [120]
57 Carbamazepine 236.2686 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.11e0.94 39 [109]
58 Carvedilol 406.4000 308.00e338.00 160.00e400.00 0.11e50.10 28 [121]
59 Cefixime trihydrate 507.5000 308.00e328.00 183.00e335.00 0.002e0.003 18 [122]
60 Celecoxib 381.3700 323.20e343.20 150.00e300.00 0.02e0.15 18 [123]
61 Cetirizine 388.8880 308.15e338.15 160.00e400.00 0.11e49.20 28 [124]
62 Chlormezanone 273.7000 308.20e328.20 119.30e239.90 0.05e5.45 21 [125]
63 Chlorothalonil 265.9100 318.00e338.00 100.00e300.00 0.13e2.68 23 [103]
64 Chlorpheniramine maleate 390.8600 308.00e338.00 160.00e400.00 0.15e4.26 24 [126]
65 Cholesterol 386.6500 313.15e333.15 100.00e250.00 0.02e1.45 24 [127]
66 Cholesteryl acetate 428.6900 308.15e328.15 90.00e240.00 0.044e10.40 24 [127]
67 Cholesteryl benzoate 490.7600 308.15e328.15 120.00e270.00 0.05e0.53 20 [127]
68 Cholesteryl butyrate 456.7400 308.15e328.15 100.00e240.00 0.22e8.93 20 [127]
(continued on next page)
Table 2 (continued )
69 Cinnarizine 368.5000 308.15e328.15 139.70e240.00 0.03e2.05 21 [128]

70 Climbazole 292.7600 313.20e333.20 105.50e398.90 6.20e48.80 24 [129]
71 Clobetasol propionate 466.9700 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.004e0.035 44 [130]
72 Clofenamic acid 247.6800 313.00e333.00 120.00e360.00 0.04e0.35 24 [131]
73 Clofibric acid 214.6000 308.20e328.20 100.10e220.20 2.57e8.56 21 [132]
74 Clotrimazole 344.8370 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.04e1.06 45 [133]
75 Clozapine 326.8230 318.00e348.00 121.60e354.60 0.04e0.42 27 [134]
76 Codeine 299.3642 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 1.00e12.30 45 [109]
77 Corosolic acid 472.7000 308.15e333.15 80.00e300.00 0.01e743.00 40 [135]
78 Cortisone acetate 402.4800 308.15e373.15 82.40e226.50 0.005e0.23 30 [136]
79 Cyproheptadine 278.4000 308.00e338.00 160.00e400.00 0.81e30.90 28 [137]
80 Cyproterone acetate 416.9380 308e348 122.00e355.00 0.13e2.61 40 [138]
81 Desoxycorticosterone acetate 372.4970 308e348 122.00e355.00 0.01e1.39 45 [130]
82 Dexamethasone 392.4610 308.15e328.15 151.10e348.30 0.013e0.028 30 [139]
83 Diazepam 284.7400 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 1.80e11.10 45 [109]
84 Dichlone 227.0400 313.00e333.00 70.70e325.80 0.07e2.51 23 [140]
85 Diclofenac acid 331.3400 308.15e338.15 120.00e400.00 0.40e19.80 32 [141]
86 Diflunisal 250.1980 308.20e328.20 93.00e246.00 0.02e0.08 21 [142]
87 Diheptyl-2,20 -oxidiacetate 330.4596 313.00e333.00 87.00e141.00 21.99e81.66 15 [143]
88 Dinonyl-2,20 -oxidiacetate 386.5659 313.00e333.00 91.00e142.00 14.86e67.10 15 [143]
89 Dipentadecyl-2,20 -oxidiacetate 554.8848 313.00e333.00 110.00e193.00 5.39e14.03 15 [143]
90 Dipentyl-2,20 -oxidiacetate 274.3532 313.00e333.00 85.00e125.00 22.31e125.05 15 [143]
91 Ditridecyl-2,20 -oxydiacetate 498.7790 313.00e333.00 99.00e156.00 5.57e18.22 15 [143]
92 Diundecyl-2,20 -oxidiacetate 442.6722 313.00e333.00 92.00e145.00 7.44e24.34 15 [143]
93 Diuron 233.0900 308.20e328.20 100.00e200.00 0.009e3.18 19 [144]
94 Docetaxel 807.8792 308.00e338.00 152.00e354.00 0.37e5.03 32 [120]
95 Dutasteride 528.5000 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.001e1.60 45 [145]
96 Epicatechin 290.2680 313.15e343.15 120.00e260.00 0.007e0.18 60 [146]
97 Ergosterol 396.6500 318.15e333.15 120.00e240.00 0.03e0.30 15 [147]
98 Ethanamide 59.0700 308.20e323.20 90.00e400.00 2.38e31.62 30 [92]
99 Ethylene glycol 62.0680 313.15e353.15 70.00e190.00 83.00e429.00 35 [148]
100 Exemestane 296.4000 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.13e18.76 45 [106]
101 Fenofibrate 360.8310 308.20e328.20 100.10e220.20 18.30e66.60 21 [132]
102 Ferrocene 186.0310 308.00e348.00 80.00e244.00 8.90e31.20 22 [101]
103 Ferulic acid 194.1840 301.50e333.50 120.00e280.00 0.02e0.12 18 [149]
104 Finasteride 372.5000 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.83e3.33 45 [145]
105 Fluoranthene 202.2506 308.15e328.15 86.00e249.00 1.13e9.30 28 [150]
106 Fluoxetine hydrochloride 345.7900 308.15e338.15 160.00e400.00 0.35e8.12 28 [151]
107 Flurbiprofen 244.2609 303.15e323.15 89.00e245.00 0.22e1.97 27 [152]
108 Flutamide 276.1000 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.05e5.09 45 [145]
109 Fluvastatin 411.4700 308.00e348.00 121.60e354.60 0.22e6.01 45 [108]
110 Gabapentin 171.2400 308.00e338.00 160.00e400.00 2.31e73.60 28 [153]
111 Gemfibrozil 250.3400 308.20e328.20 100.10e220.20 0.29e41.90 21 [132]
112 Geraniol 154.2500 308.00e333.00 100.00e180.00 27.00e252.00 18 [83]
113 Geranyl butyrate 224.3400 308.15e333.15 100.00e180.00 22.00e250.00 18 [83]
114 Hinokitiol 164.2000 313.20e333.20 101.40e358.40 5.91e24.90 32 [154]
115 Hydrocortisone 362.4600 308.15e373.15 99.00e226.50 0.0005e0.0073 26 [136]
116 Ibuprofen 206.2808 308.15e318.15 80.00e220.00 0.53e58.40 29 [155]
117 Imipramine HCl 316.8700 313.50e323.50 300.00e500.00 0.05e0.10 10 [156]
118 Iodopropynyl butylcarbamate 281.0900 308.15e333.15 87.60e341.50 12.00e47.00 27 [157]
119 Isoniazid 137.1393 308.00e313.00 130.00e185.00 0.005e0.06 18 [158]
120 Juglone 174.1528 308.20e328.20 92.00e244.00 0.20e15.90 18 [159]
121 Ketoconazole 531.4310 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.005e1.75 45 [133]
122 Ketoprofen 254.2806 313.15e328.15 90.00e250.00 0.03e1.88 15 [160]
123 Lamotrigine 256.0910 318.00e338.00 121.60e354.60 0.004e0.046 27 [134]
124 Letrozole 285.3100 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.01e0.83 45 [106]
125 Levonorgestrel 384.5000 308.00e338.00 12.20e35.50 0.004e0.03 36 [161]
126 Levulinic acid 116.1152 313.00e342.40 94.10e182.70 4.91e90.00 34 [162]
127 Lovastatin 404.5500 308.00e348.00 121.60e354.60 0.11e1.14 45 [108]
128 Mandelic acid 152.1500 308.15e328.15 101.00e230.60 0.27e29.04 21 [116]
129 m-Dinitrobenzene 168.1100 308.00e328.00 95.00e145.00 1.90e55.40 18 [84]
130 Medroxyprogesterone acetate 386.2460 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.40e4.13 40 [138]
131 Mefenamic acid 241.2900 308.15e338.15 160.00e400.00 0.83e59.40 28 [163]
132 Megestrol acetate 312.5000 308.00e338.00 12.20e35.50 0.03e8.70 36 [161]
133 Meloxicam sodium salt 373.3800 303.00e323.00 149.00e255.00 0.04e0.13 15 [164]
134 Menadione 172.1800 313.00e333.00 97.20e306.70 7.50e10.06 18 [140]
135 Metaxalone 221.3000 308.20e328.20 119.50e240.00 0.04e1.48 21 [125]
136 Methimazole 114.1700 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.54e18.99 40 [165]
137 Methocarbamol 241.2000 308.20e328.20 119.90e220.50 0.61e4.87 21 [125]
138 Methyl gallate 184.1500 313.00e333.00 100.00e500.00 0.001e0.042 27 [165]
139 Methyl salicylate 152.1473 343.15e423.15 90.00e310.00 5.10e753.30 44 [167]
140 Methylparaben 152.1473 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 1.08e12.13 40 [117]

141 Metronidazole benzoate 275.7600 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.70e45.50 40 [115]
142 m-Nitrophenol 139.1100 308.00e348.00 121.60e486.40 3.94e44.50 49 [88]
143 N-(4-Ethoxyphenyl)ethanamide 179.2160 308.00e328.00 90.00e190.00 0.09e0.43 16 [77]
144 Nabumetone 228.3000 308.20e328.20 100.00e220.00 0.39e26.80 21 [168]
145 Naproxene 230.2592 313.10e333.10 89.60e193.10 0.02e0.32 18 [169]
146 Nicotinamide 122.1246 313.15e373.15 55.00e305.00 0.10e31.40 24 [170]
147 Nicotinic acid 123.1100 313.15e373.15 45.00e302.00 0.003e0.104 22 [168]
148 Nifedipine 346.3350 333.15e373.15 126.00e296.00 0.05e0.71 29 [171]
149 Niflumic acid 282.2200 313.20e353.20 190.00e310.00 0.07e0.21 21 [123]
150 Nimodipine 418.4403 313.00e333.00 100.00e250.00 0.006e0.423 21 [87]
151 Nitrendipine 360.3600 308.00e328.00 80.00e200.00 0.01e0.63 15 [172]
152 Norfloxacin 319.3308 313.15e323.15 99.40e303.30 0.01e0.24 15 [173]
153 Ofloxacin 361.3675 318.15e323.15 101.50e300.60 0.004e0.013 10 [173]
154 O-Nitrobenzoic acid 167.1200 308.00e328.00 100.00e210.00 0.06e0.36 15 [174]
155 O-Tolidine 212.2900 308.00e328.00 110.00e210.00 0.05e0.48 15 [175]
156 Oxymatrine 264.3700 308.15e328.15 110.40e210.70 0.007e0.025 18 [176]
157 Oxymetholone 332.4770 308.00e328.00 121.00e305.00 0.16e1.49 20 [122]
158 Paclitaxel 853.9061 308.15e328.15 100.00e275.00 0.012e0.062 21 [91]
159 p-Dimethylaminoazobenzene 225.2890 308.20e318.20 91.00e253.00 4.37e12.50 10 [112]
160 Penicillin G 334.3901 313.15e333.15 100.00e350.00 0.04e0.63 18 [70]
161 Penicillin V 350.3800 314.85e334.85 79.90e280.50 3.24e4.26 24 [177]
162 Pentoxifylline 278.3000 308.15e328.15 119.80e2400 0.30e13.70 21 [128]
163 Phenazopyridine 213.2385 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 0.44e20.21 45 [165]
164 Phenol 94.1112 333.15e363.15 100.00e350.00 11.40e906.40 33 [178]
165 Phenylbutazone 317.4458 308.20e328.20 100.00e220.00 0.20e26.50 21 [168]
166 Phenylephrine hydrochloride 203.6660 308.15e338.15 160.00e400.00 1.01e28.90 28 [179]
167 p-Hydroxyazobenzene 198.2206 308.20e318.20 91.00e253.00 25.70e63.60 10 [112]
168 Picric acid 229.1100 308.00e348.00 121.60e486.40 0.22e26.50 50 [88]
169 Pindolol 248.3210 298.00e318.00 80.00e275.00 0.66e1.92 30 [180]
170 Piracetam 142.2000 308.15e328.15 120.00e240.00 0.08e0.37 21 [128]
171 Piroxicam 331.3460 308.15e338.15 160.00e400.00 0.12e5.12 28 [181]
172 p-Methylbenzenesulfonic acid 172.2020 318.00e328.00 80.00e210.00 0.20e0.74 15 [182]
173 p-Nitroaniline 183.1300 308.00e328.00 110.00e210.00 0.06e0.43 15 [183]
174 p-Nitrophenol 139.1100 308.00e348.00 121.60e486.40 2.23e19.70 49 [88]
175 Prednisolone 360.4400 308.15e373.15 82.40e226.50 0.00004e0.00099 28 [136]
176 Prednisone 358.4300 308.15e373.15 82.40e226.50 0.0001e0.0058 28 [136]
177 Propranolol 259.3434 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 3.58e239.61 45 [165]
178 Propyl 4-hydroxybenzoate 180.2010 308.15e328.15 94.10e220.20 0.19e6.12 21 [116]
179 Propyl p-hydroxybenzoate 180.2000 308.15e328.15 80.00e230.00 0.038e6.175 18 [184]
180 Protocatechualdehyde 138.1200 313.00e333.00 100.00e500.00 0.004e0.046 24 [166]
181 Protocatechuic acid 154.1200 313.00e333.00 100.00e500.00 0.0004e0.0259 24 [166]
182 p-Toluenesulfonamide 171.2200 308.15e328.15 80.00e210.00 0.05e0.51 15 [185]
183 Pyrocatechol 110.1106 333.15e348.15 100.00e350.00 1.22e38.47 22 [178]
184 rac-Boc-piperazine 285.3900 308.20e328.20 102.00e204.00 1.24e5.90 19 [81]
185 Racemic paroxetine 329.3650 308.20e328.20 88.30e242.00 0.73e11.84 24 [186]
186 Resorcinol 110.1100 308.15e338.15 120.00e400.00 1.10e9.73 32 [187]
187 Rosuvastatin 481.5380 308.00e348.00 121.60e354.60 0.23e2.44 45 [108]
188 Salicylamide 137.1360 308.20e328.20 100.00e220.00 0.09e2.10 21 [167]
189 Salicylic acid 138.1200 308.15e318.15 92.60e157.90 0.97e3.98 20 [188]
190 Simvastatine 418.5662 308.00e348.00 121.60e354.60 0.02e5.35 45 [108]
191 Spironolactone 416.5730 308.00e338.00 160.00e400.00 0.63e50.10 28 [189]
192 Sulindac 356.4100 308.15e338.15 160.00e400.00 0.37e86.90 28 [190]
193 Syringic acid 198.1700 313.00e333.00 100.00e500.00 0.003e0.127 27 [191]
194 TCMTB [2-(thiocyanomethylthio)benzothiazole] 238.3600 323.00e338.00 100.00e300.00 0.02e13.90 12 [103]
195 Tebuconazole 307.8200 323.00e338.00 100.00e300.00 0.04e18.57 12 [103]
196 Testosterone 288.4200 308.15e373.15 82.40e226.50 0.07e0.90 30 [136]
197 Tetramethylpyrazine 136.2000 318.00e338.00 100.00e300.00 100.00e1310.00 15 [192]
198 Theobromine 180.1700 313.00e353.00 193.00e344.00 0.09e0.47 23 [118]
199 Theophylline 180.1700 313.00e353.00 199e349.00 0.10e0.33 24 [118]
200 Thymidine 242.2286 308.15e328.15 100e300.00 0.01e0.08 25 [91]
201 Thymol 150.2176 308.15e323.15 78.00e250.00 8.37e147.00 17 [193]
202 Tolfenamic acid 461.7100 313e333 120.00e360.00 0.01e0.18 24 [131]
203 Triclocarban 315.5800 313.20e333.20 109.30e389.60 0.90e8.70 24 [129]
204 Triphenylene 228.2879 308.15e328.15 85.00e252.00 0.01e0.42 28 [150]
205 Triphenylmethyl chloride 278.7754 308.15e338.15 150.00e400.00 2.93e27 18 [194]
206 Triphenyltin chloride 385.4500 308.15e328.15 150.00e300.00 2.71e10.96 12 [192]
207 Uracil 112.0868 308.15e338.15 150.00e400.00 0.000769e0.0034 23 [195]
208 Vanillic acid 168.1400 313e333 85.00e500.00 0.0143e0.607 28 [191]
209 Xanthohumol 354.3960 328.15e358.15 350.00e950.00 0.012e0.17 15 [196]
210 Zopiclone 388.8080 313e333 100.00e250.00 0.015e0.219 21 [87]
Table 3
Estimated model parameters (ai) of the model proposed in this work (Eq. 32) for the 210 solid solutes considered.
No. a0 a1 a2 a3 a4 a5 a6 a7
5 5 3
1 105.07 0.083 4.48 10 6.59 10 1.32 2.08 10 24.58 1.85
2 1531.82 0.021 3.45 107 9.44 105 4.50 4.41 103 2.92 175,549.35
3 4084.36 0.060 1.46 105 1.38 104 12.65 1.32 102 2.92 437,823.79
4 0.97 0.073 6.70 105 4.56 104 2.89 5.14 103 80.05 0.44
5 8205.31 0.016 5.75 106 1.10 104 25.39 2.61 102 4.19 879,263.63
6 1982.72 0.013 1.33 107 5.77 105 5.95 5.97 103 0.40 217,476.69
7 573.76 0.010 7.18 106 4.24 105 1.91 2.14 103 5.20 54,779.81
8 546.60 0.012 2.81 106 3.79 105 1.59 1.58 103 0.82 58,878.77
9 374.66 0.219 1.10 104 2.37 105 1.19 1.91 103 43.89 1.06
10 525.74 0.357 2.08 104 1.38 104 0.15 9.85 105 101.71 5.43
11 382.66 0.163 9.82 105 1.12 104 0.64 8.50 104 53.66 3.04
12 1.66 0.006 1.44 106 9.60 106 0.06 2.26 105 2.16 2.23
13 11,328.33 0.018 2.33 106 2.17 107 34.56 3.52 102 5.74 1,234,124.05
14 392.25 0.001 6.50 106 7.90 105 1.32 1.41 103 8.26 46,727.41
15 85.82 0.061 1.76 105 5.13 105 0.07 1.37 104 17.55 7.53
16 83.09 0.050 1.15 105 6.50 105 0.53 6.75 104 5.92 10.79
17 885.78 0.689 2.25 104 7.63 105 2.30 3.56 103 244.70 4.01
18 262.35 0.001 2.34 106 2.89 105 1.63 2.56 103 1.91 1.69
19 1.84 0.044 1.76 105 1.18 105 0.78 1.35 103 19.53 2.52
20 251.12 0.064 1.38 105 1.28 104 0.53 4.15 104 5.66 30,058.65
21 95.39 0.002 9.40 107 3.53 106 0.43 5.89 104 0.48 0.15
22 11.28 0.007 1.23 106 1.35 105 0.02 2.87 105 2.62 2.48
23 133.12 0.021 3.05 106 1.31 104 1.66 2.97 103 15.94 15.54
24 74.34 0.058 1.49 105 8.87 105 0.31 3.33 104 2.11 0.85
25 25.71 0.019 5.32 106 2.56 105 0.18 3.73 104 6.14 1.78
26 360.01 0.190 1.32 105 5.80 104 1.24 1.19 103 12.32 0.63
27 141.29 0.023 1.67 105 6.03 105 0.09 8.10 105 17.82 0.78
28 598.29 0.080 2.73 105 4.44 105 4.58 7.28 103 22.11 6.32
29 2460.28 1.203 3.79 104 6.65 105 0.84 1.47 103 494.35 24.73
30 692.41 0.051 2.41 105 1.05 105 1.96 2.04 103 14.30 63,063.17
31 9800.68 0.0002 3.53 106 3.46 105 30.61 3.19 102 6.55 1,033,864.84
32 13,205.45 0.023 1.31 105 5.01 105 40.60 4.14 102 9.42 1,437,033.73
33 236.85 0.004 9.77 106 5.92 105 0.87 1.17 103 11.85 0.60
34 156.11 0.017 1.04 105 1.48 105 0.58 7.95 104 7.76 0.72
35 190.06 0.113 1.17 105 2.68 104 0.91 1.04 103 3.41 0.83
36 1954.65 0.088 2.45 105 5.31 105 5.82 6.02 103 9.43 223,043.77
37 2792.52 0.025 9.65 106 1.15 105 8.51 8.53 103 4.84 303,725.89
38 43.35 0.011 4.59 106 7.94 106 0.31 5.27 104 2.20 2.05
39 115.46 0.057 9.23 106 1.33 104 0.39 4.02 104 2.56 21.70
40 145.93 0.185 5.94 105 5.96 105 0.55 6.99 104 52.95 1.75
41 7678.04 0.075 1.73 105 1.27 104 23.47 2.37 102 9.28 847,146.30
42 852.15 0.030 1.00 105 1.22 105 2.55 2.63 103 4.10 98,485.91
43 1645.58 0.004 4.24 106 1.65 105 5.13 5.37 103 4.70 165,008.13
44 1.95 0.138 3.39 105 2.11 104 0.50 6.00 104 18.21 3.11
45 0.93 0.012 1.17 106 4.92 105 0.23 5.31 104 2.41 0.27
46 716.84 0.427 1.50 104 8.76 105 1.17 1.95 103 171.93 5.92
47 11,214.79 5.746 1.90 103 7.50 105 0.32 4.38 104 2179.38 93.76
48 227.10 0.121 1.59 105 2.37 104 1.37 1.72 103 10.71 1.82
49 107.14 0.006 1.81 106 7.24 105 0.62 9.96 104 4.78 4.22
50 2958.54 0.061 7.14 106 1.47 104 8.72 8.72 103 4.93 328,517.55
51 26.69 0.098 2.40 105 1.34 104 0.25 1.56 104 10.95 6.24
52 164.84 0.068 1.10 105 1.71 104 0.22 8.52 105 3.13 24,939.84
53 1060.66 0.514 1.82 104 8.90 105 0.35 4.70 104 198.27 8.60
54 34.68 0.004 3.01 106 4.46 105 0.11 1.64 104 5.71 5.29
55 1339.30 0.054 5.01 105 2.49 104 6.55 9.78 103 46.62 18.29
56 1164.46 0.181 5.51 105 4.82 105 2.69 2.71 103 51.34 110,426.70
57 3303.72 0.214 7.27 105 2.94 105 9.04 9.37 103 79.39 314,535.29
58 19,001.50 0.308 1.25 104 1.47 104 57.79 6.04 102 130.40 1,924,912.82
59 53.00 0.038 9.72 106 2.77 105 0.52 7.32 104 10.48 0.54
60 51.01 0.025 5.36 106 3.85 105 0.04 7.42 105 2.27 1.51
61 1138.32 0.108 3.25 105 1.40 105 3.90 3.89 103 30.78 132,743.12
62 50.19 0.107 3.55 105 2.14 105 0.19 1.32 104 24.43 16.81
63 12.49 0.012 1.32 105 7.90 105 0.11 1.88 104 8.57 1.40
64 1562.77 0.141 4.12 105 1.04 104 5.29 5.21 103 41.52 202,400.70
65 9228.66 0.009 2.13 106 5.99 105 28.64 2.96 102 0.64 995,613.08
66 119.60 0.070 9.87 106 1.75 104 1.03 1.53 103 7.48 3.78
67 237.86 0.042 6.03 106 1.26 104 0.69 8.09 104 13.81 1.24
68 40.73 0.124 3.66 105 7.46 105 0.88 1.20 103 27.01 2.77
69 671.21 0.654 1.88 104 3.30 104 0.89 7.66 104 180.49 2.74
No. a0 a1 a2 a3 a4 a5 a6 a7
70 101.91 0.110 3.27 105 6.30 105 0.05 1.91 104 24.39 1.91
71 2234.78 0.045 1.50 106 1.93 104 6.75 6.79 103 9.01 257,254.20
72 81.15 0.044 1.07 105 4.84 105 0.41 4.81 104 4.05 2.43
73 584.03 0.199 2.44 105 5.37 104 2.84 3.80 103 7.58 3.85
74 246.33 0.033 1.02 105 7.38 106 0.72 7.64 104 3.25 32,096.23
75 50.19 0.185 3.64 105 3.55 104 0.56 5.21 104 14.70 2.15
76 2563.28 0.078 1.94 105 1.34 104 7.57 7.63 103 8.38 279,924.96
77 51,417.64 0.049 2.31 105 2.93 104 160.07 1.66 101 3.75 5,507,449.07
78 11.31 0.032 1.59 105 2.13 105 0.21 3.21 104 6.31 1.26
79 717.56 0.144 4.74 105 7.99 105 3.17 3.27 103 61.25 106,770.33
80 452.85 0.085 2.19 105 1.64 104 1.55 1.55 103 4.99 46,538.55
81 350.16 0.026 3.00 106 8.53 105 0.83 6.91 104 1.57 42,383.68
82 2576.44 0.069 1.52 105 1.10 104 8.49 9.05 103 9.10 269,462.56
83 145.56 0.040 7.81 106 1.04 104 0.52 5.54 104 0.73 12,431.30
84 232.96 0.072 1.18 105 1.50 104 1.60 2.34 103 6.50 8.38
85 3580.56 0.036 7.25 106 7.43 105 11.12 1.14 102 6.73 395,352.20
86 240.50 0.055 2.89 107 2.07 104 1.39 2.02 103 3.65 5.82
87 243.80 0.179 8.83 105 1.77 105 0.11 1.94 104 46.11 1.30
88 659.43 0.171 8.83 105 2.60 104 0.89 1.12 103 94.34 8.06
89 2624.87 1.201 4.12 104 2.41 104 0.10 1.46 104 498.22 22.53
90 312.90 0.067 3.99 105 2.59 105 1.22 1.83 103 21.33 3.88
91 1293.79 0.663 2.86 104 2.29 104 1.11 1.57 103 226.17 30.25
92 7198.49 5.097 2.27 103 1.55 104 0.60 7.51 104 1461.03 74.64
93 476.02 0.295 3.43 105 6.00 104 3.44 4.37 103 34.00 132.83
94 3749.41 0.069 3.24 105 1.39 104 11.02 1.14 102 45.12 374,414.07
95 860.66 0.065 1.99 105 2.68 105 2.46 2.48 103 9.44 98,727.09
96 387.57 0.000 3.17 107 2.78 106 1.19 1.21 103 3.01 52,764.44
97 40.90 0.062 2.84 106 2.00 104 0.27 5.48 104 0.86 3.73
98 65.30 0.002 4.13 106 3.36 105 0.40 6.11 104 1.96 5.24
99 902.14 0.031 4.74 106 8.00 105 2.59 2.52 103 0.81 103,437.48
100 2766.57 0.054 8.54 106 8.46 105 7.92 7.68 103 3.01 327,864.36
101 551.60 0.281 4.77 105 6.35 104 2.91 3.81 103 3.79 12.88
102 334.39 0.044 1.49 105 4.95 105 1.18 1.25 103 6.75 39,319.98
103 8621.92 0.019 2.17 105 2.28 104 28.04 2.97 102 48.90 949,369.22
104 425.91 0.056 1.89 106 2.17 104 1.26 1.22 103 9.59 61,284.65
105 76.07 0.038 1.10 105 5.30 105 0.26 2.77 104 0.43 36.77
106 0.16 0.201 6.48 105 2.67 105 1.20 1.18 103 78.68 51,364.38
107 5.17 0.046 1.06 105 1.26 105 0.31 3.39 104 14.06 0.60
108 677.14 0.104 1.55 105 2.35 104 1.65 1.54 103 7.87 82,605.10
109 915.94 0.016 3.56 106 1.17 104 2.83 2.94 103 5.88 94,980.76
110 1663.48 0.211 5.86 105 1.22 104 5.99 6.14 103 48.99 190,361.87
111 288.61 0.040 2.79 105 1.50 104 0.31 2.32 104 38.92 14.73
112 13,211.97 0.034 1.98 106 1.31 104 41.69 4.38 102 2.97 1,390,552.83
113 3716.29 0.134 4.82 105 1.37 104 11.07 1.13 102 20.92 394,533.29
114 194.12 0.006 1.38 107 6.99 105 0.52 6.85 104 15.69 0.17
115 434.95 0.004 3.54 105 2.46 104 1.53 1.94 103 25.13 2.49
116 160.03 0.048 2.34 105 2.49 105 1.15 1.73 103 9.81 48.21
117 195.60 7.771 2.08 103 1.36 103 104.33 1.62 101 3225.35 4.15
118 127.43 0.021 9.84 107 8.65 105 0.77 1.13 103 1.23 3.22
119 980.73 0.137 1.67 104 1.48 103 4.86 1.04 102 276.44 2.50
120 41.32 0.018 1.92 106 4.23 105 0.50 8.82 104 3.08 1.55
121 1936.35 0.101 2.90 105 5.30 105 6.44 6.69 103 20.54 204,158.22
122 0.97 0.071 3.74 105 8.39 105 0.65 1.02 103 24.95 1.66
123 48.07 0.033 1.03 105 1.79 105 0.28 3.53 104 5.04 0.94
124 2999.33 0.053 2.60 105 5.89 105 9.47 9.67 103 18.88 330,889.01
125 407.18 0.008 2.20 106 1.37 105 1.18 1.12 103 0.70 41,782.09
126 1452.11 0.004 1.72 106 4.59 106 4.46 4.53 103 1.03 161,529.34
127 1609.02 0.021 8.32 106 5.68 106 4.87 4.93 103 2.69 178,903.05
128 10.68 0.013 2.88 106 2.54 105 0.14 3.60 104 3.43 1.12
129 249.41 0.019 1.79 105 4.63 105 1.12 1.67 103 11.04 1.74
130 5601.28 0.029 6.06 106 9.34 105 16.72 1.66 102 2.06 625,762.42
131 1943.21 0.015 5.00 106 4.98 105 6.14 6.38 103 4.35 215,444.10
132 1973.71 0.072 1.95 105 1.05 104 6.08 5.97 103 12.18 228,276.88
133 2087.93 1.249 3.60 104 4.06 104 0.93 1.02 103 439.09 21.03
134 25.36 0.006 1.14 106 1.30 105 0.10 1.51 104 0.58 1.44
135 433.52 0.069 4.48 105 2.43 104 1.36 2.03 103 45.50 3.74
136 1476.05 0.108 2.31 105 2.02 104 4.18 4.20 103 10.03 164,342.67
137 49.11 0.187 4.62 105 1.93 104 0.99 1.16 103 33.99 3.39
138 124.36 0.017 4.46 106 8.00 105 0.27 2.10 104 7.25 7.88
139 161.27 0.013 7.31 106 3.18 105 0.37 2.63 104 0.71 18,861.41
No. a0 a1 a2 a3 a4 a5 a6 a7
140 439.34 0.013 1.26 106 5.72 105 1.43 1.55 103 1.92 45,085.94
141 1837.59 0.007 5.92 106 5.63 105 5.85 6.26 103 6.70 187,579.63
142 964.63 0.050 9.53 106 1.01 104 2.86 2.97 103 5.23 101,856.34
143 154.02 0.059 2.34 105 2.10 105 0.49 8.21 104 19.17 5.30
144 61.04 0.060 1.33 105 7.55 105 0.19 2.95 104 15.81 0.34
145 91.13 0.010 1.53 106 3.05 105 0.30 3.54 104 2.70 1.25
146 2044.48 0.067 1.48 105 1.41 104 5.85 5.69 103 3.98 233,327.78
147 384.04 0.019 5.06 106 4.45 105 1.22 1.24 103 0.80 44,257.62
148 10.31 0.079 1.93 105 1.40 104 0.30 3.69 104 7.80 1.62
149 79.29 0.052 1.24 105 6.04 105 0.01 3.90 105 12.95 1.50
150 13.36 0.069 1.49 105 1.09 104 0.38 5.65 104 104 12.48 3.63
151 77.13 0.024 8.64 106 2.73 105 0.16 1.76 104 6.26 0.45
152 186.97 0.257 2.02 105 1.06 103 0.45 1.71 103 33.22 3.37
153 0.34 0.003 5.40 105 4.32 104 1.84 3.62 103 41.42 1.20
154 32.81 0.016 3.91 106 1.36 105 0.01 1.89 104 0.04 2.69
155 3.39 0.017 5.48 106 8.53 106 0.13 3.20 104 0.94 1.02
156 249.26 0.078 9.95 106 1.58 104 1.46 2.01 103 5.99 1.82
157 9.69 0.037 3.71 106 9.18 105 0.17 2.25 104 5.57 2.35
158 1835.62 0.845 2.97 104 1.29 104 0.71 8.42 104 329.42 11.27
159 0.31 0.049 3.71 106 1.24 104 0.18 5.30 104 1.42 1.50
160 44.26 0.081 1.29 105 2.07 104 0.28 2.97 104 1.10 2.75
161 94.41 0.024 1.21 105 4.80 106 0.31 4.18 104 6.19 0.93
162 12.30 0.079 2.34 105 5.22 105 0.18 9.26 105 11.59 16.92
163 1429.40 0.016 5.10 107 8.54 105 4.41 4.54 103 3.38 152,612.74
164 36.56 0.021 4.22 106 1.76 105 0.16 1.78 104 1.57 2.21
165 69.00 0.056 1.37 105 5.96 105 0.18 2.93 104 16.86 8.38
166 5830.12 0.206 5.82 105 1.24 104 19.23 1.99 102 63.96 658,885.28
167 0.99 0.013 4.42 106 5.06 106 0.24 4.69 104 4.59 1.05
168 2923.03 0.098 3.07 105 7.40 105 8.53 8.70 103 24.20 305,416.57
169 112.44 0.040 1.13 105 8.74 105 0.77 1.17 103 1.00 3.11
170 106.56 0.105 2.97 105 7.50 105 0.15 4.01 104 23.36 3.67
171 13,659.77 0.031 2.01 105 1.97 104 43.02 4.46 102 39.27 1,487,919.98
172 18.24 0.011 1.87 106 2.54 105 0.00 2.29 105 1.31 4.05
173 42.82 0.044 1.03 105 5.78 105 0.20 1.71 104 4.44 3.12
174 32.24 0.016 4.67 106 2.82 105 0.00 3.89 105 3.71 1.83
175 100.38 0.058 3.57 105 7.10 107 0.05 1.74 105 14.02 0.55
176 2.14 0.086 3.24 105 1.38 104 0.38 5.56 104 8.87 1.92
177 1346.38 0.098 2.06 105 2.00 104 4.41 4.60 103 6.60 141,805.22
178 23.81 0.022 6.93 106 9.39 106 0.15 3.36 104 5.20 0.23
179 160.90 0.147 3.83 105 2.34 104 0.50 8.99 104 17.55 2.76
180 11.19 0.008 9.67 106 4.01 105 0.49 9.44 104 10.36 0.69
181 184.93 0.095 1.65 105 1.87 104 0.68 1.16 103 13.21 44.17
182 78.04 0.005 5.66 106 2.25 105 0.23 2.75 104 4.42 1.27
183 0.94 0.034 8.40 106 3.84 105 0.03 1.21 104 3.12 0.20
184 16.28 0.065 3.08 105 3.83 105 0.57 8.45 104 19.31 11.93
185 50.56 0.037 5.90 106 8.97 105 0.49 7.47 104 3.63 0.36
186 1572.06 0.028 8.59 106 1.77 105 5.10 5.30 103 12.28 170,879.91
187 472.29 0.045 1.67 105 6.58 106 1.35 1.42 103 9.97 49,967.76
188 35.35 0.044 9.82 106 5.59 105 0.23 3.75 104 11.37 0.70
189 0.04 0.045 1.20 105 3.13 105 0.13 7.83 105 9.23 0.14
190 1016.15 0.041 1.71 105 3.20 105 3.20 3.22 103 11.13 113,622.34
191 9888.68 0.148 5.24 105 8.59 105 32.16 3.36 102 68.81 1,082,525.80
192 1468.07 0.055 2.61 105 1.18 104 4.82 4.76 103 30.13 175,156.62
193 415.39 0.122 4.34 105 1.38 105 1.04 1.53 103 43.61 20.11
194 2.14 0.071 4.37 105 9.66 105 0.55 8.69 104 22.63 2.17
195 0.06 0.022 2.85 105 1.67 104 0.45 7.23 104 18.02 0.04
196 11.47 0.070 1.73 105 1.34 104 0.32 4.28 104 6.92 0.70
197 18.14 0.011 3.92 106 9.96 106 0.11 3.03 104 3.19 6.16
198 303.35 0.184 6.24 105 6.66 105 0.16 2.57 104 53.32 4.75
199 141.35 0.248 6.43 105 2.52 104 0.53 5.40 104 50.60 0.51
200 1602.81 0.520 1.86 104 9.83 105 3.36 5.11 103 203.24 11.97
201 718.88 0.018 8.52 106 1.12 106 4.84 7.68 103 7.37 6.19
202 38.32 0.006 2.87 106 5.73 105 0.17 2.20 104 2.08 1.94
203 44.52 0.123 3.11 105 1.02 104 0.88 1.17 103 26.52 3.52
204 127.08 0.009 1.63 106 6.44 105 0.23 2.16 104 10.89 0.53
205 1.50 0.105 2.81 105 9.46 105 0.34 3.21 104 18.43 0.20
206 44.33 0.134 2.24 105 2.29 104 0.97 1.28 103 24.08 5.17
207 1972.88 0.128 2.30 105 1.91 104 8.10 1.00 102 15.63 145,287.58
208 22.21 0.031 3.99 106 8.16 105 0.03 2.56 105 2.85 2.61
209 605.76 0.371 1.06 104 6.44 106 0.95 1.28 103 152.58 6.90
210 170.01 0.005 9.12 106 8.17 105 0.57 7.11 104 8.98 0.19
Table 4
AARD (%) for 210 compounds calculated for each of the 22 studied correlations.
No. (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24) (25) (26) (27) (28) (29) (30) (32)
1 21.08 9.99 21.08 28.65 21.05 17.35 23.18 13.73 12.96 6.20 21.14 14.74 18.42 12.89 9.85 13.77 10.08 13.880 15.31 11.69 8.62 6.34
2 19.34 10.70 19.34 11.80 19.09 10.47 18.59 18.47 8.40 10.63 19.31 10.64 12.17 11.41 6.70 12.55 7.00 12.007 11.83 9.56 8.67 6.64
3 24.35 9.48 24.35 13.96 20.21 9.41 19.53 21.08 12.55 9.02 24.36 9.46 12.24 9.59 8.49 12.17 9.18 9.76 9.45 8.91 7.45 7.58
4 5.38 2.37 5.38 4.07 7.00 0.78 6.83 4.94 3.60 2.37 5.38 3.70 3.91 3.90 1.57 3.40 6.95 3.973 4.02 1.66 1.16 1.17
5 46.65 43.30 46.65 44.95 43.95 45.80 43.09 46.42 43.37 40.90 46.53 43.46 45.40 43.38 41.59 45.89 38.06 43.202 46.76 44.81 42.94 39.98
6 13.30 7.74 13.30 8.79 10.28 14.13 9.92 12.43 7.37 7.28 13.26 7.83 10.70 7.67 5.98 11.16 6.33 8.229 9.45 8.40 7.67 5.84
7 17.12 12.78 17.12 13.50 14.95 17.37 13.76 16.23 10.77 9.52 17.03 12.00 15.00 12.96 11.21 16.31 9.73 12.797 14.98 13.57 11.41 9.56
8 9.44 3.61 9.44 3.62 10.74 7.42 9.47 7.46 3.27 3.46 9.40 3.43 5.31 3.59 2.91 5.20 2.86 4.137 5.53 3.66 3.39 2.99
9 9.16 9.09 9.16 9.02 8.53 9.09 9.05 8.42 3.21 3.14 9.02 3.29 8.48 8.56 3.26 4.08 6.57 9.078 3.51 8.09 7.56 3.06
10 6.23 6.00 6.23 7.14 7.00 5.98 7.38 5.96 4.56 5.78 6.21 5.99 5.75 7.09 5.08 6.04 4.70 7.070 6.16 5.22 4.13 4.30
11 12.34 8.80 12.34 10.59 10.62 9.87 9.96 9.97 7.69 8.89 12.38 9.32 12.25 10.48 9.01 9.71 9.07 9.946 10.70 8.87 8.60 7.99
12 3.63 3.39 3.63 10.81 10.42 11.89 11.72 3.19 5.68 3.18 3.64 3.38 3.38 9.74 3.21 3.08 3.38 11.115 10.82 3.20 4.78 3.11
13 33.35 24.00 33.36 26.70 31.12 27.31 29.58 29.76 26.67 23.99 33.27 24.19 26.97 27.31 24.03 26.37 24.35 27.200 27.99 23.98 23.66 18.10
14 18.40 13.51 18.40 14.35 18.03 11.59 17.54 18.54 12.46 13.22 18.46 14.10 16.85 14.36 11.61 17.06 12.18 15.412 15.28 11.78 10.86 11.62
15 3.54 2.87 3.54 3.78 6.63 12.40 6.60 3.54 4.37 2.99 3.51 2.88 2.79 3.57 2.60 3.03 3.06 3.618 2.95 3.14 2.75 2.59
A. Belghait et al. / C. R. Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513

16 6.46 4.29 6.46 6.21 8.06 13.41 6.69 5.34 4.87 4.22 6.47 5.32 6.40 4.80 4.20 5.38 9.94 4.438 5.85 4.96 3.90 3.41
17 31.91 23.55 31.91 30.98 32.82 13.29 33.22 28.66 21.32 15.01 31.89 17.11 22.95 25.64 17.55 22.68 26.03 24.541 23.81 23.87 21.66 14.21
18 13.15 9.39 13.15 9.67 19.06 15.30 18.39 11.97 8.45 7.18 13.16 7.96 12.00 9.34 7.28 11.21 9.09 9.800 10.16 9.28 8.66 7.37
19 7.59 5.13 7.59 14.31 10.38 17.59 10.44 7.22 8.41 4.40 7.58 5.77 7.00 10.49 5.93 7.31 4.78 10.628 8.51 6.15 5.10 4.27
20 14.68 9.67 14.68 9.75 13.99 8.46 14.61 14.89 5.56 10.44 14.67 10.21 7.65 9.06 5.32 5.93 5.48 10.179 7.65 7.74 4.94 4.55
21 5.95 2.65 5.95 2.61 10.03 6.58 9.67 4.33 4.60 2.22 5.95 2.22 3.84 2.66 1.97 3.30 6.91 2.928 3.02 2.69 2.74 2.16
22 3.57 3.10 3.57 13.79 11.49 14.18 13.10 2.32 6.04 2.91 3.60 3.05 3.20 12.01 2.44 2.37 3.11 13.865 11.00 2.53 3.14 2.38
23 19.92 12.88 19.92 32.29 25.32 31.29 26.39 19.48 17.78 6.57 19.90 6.66 14.94 21.43 6.13 15.83 10.44 20.850 16.39 8.03 7.34 6.26
24 9.60 6.33 9.60 17.43 11.42 18.02 12.33 8.84 7.13 6.38 9.59 7.44 7.49 9.86 7.62 7.59 7.95 10.196 8.84 7.82 6.73 6.65
25 3.56 2.42 3.56 4.93 4.79 11.21 3.94 2.39 4.15 1.56 3.50 1.66 1.88 2.78 1.73 2.26 6.66 2.702 3.53 2.29 1.92 1.58
26 21.92 23.69 21.92 26.60 24.19 31.63 23.60 21.97 23.17 24.04 21.89 23.79 22.51 25.77 21.47 24.01 17.43 25.408 24.15 21.94 22.05 21.59
27 6.50 3.52 6.50 6.82 8.07 16.53 7.47 4.17 7.70 2.53 6.46 4.91 4.32 6.56 3.40 4.18 7.40 6.431 5.54 3.39 1.89 1.99
28 16.62 15.18 16.62 20.01 23.99 11.48 23.96 16.59 8.53 7.20 16.58 10.25 16.15 18.87 10.96 16.08 10.61 19.112 15.73 15.68 14.90 7.23
29 8.72 8.22 8.72 8.52 9.02 5.20 8.76 8.20 6.74 5.27 8.70 6.04 8.01 8.80 5.76 7.69 6.90 8.767 8.17 7.83 6.72 4.53
30 8.62 2.66 8.62 4.97 8.63 3.88 8.13 7.02 2.52 2.37 8.61 4.19 4.65 2.99 4.31 3.19 2.70 2.924 4.03 4.28 2.56 2.25
31 12.96 12.79 12.96 14.01 16.13 14.39 16.23 12.46 15.34 11.50 13.02 11.72 13.97 13.67 12.33 12.46 11.83 14.157 13.12 12.47 12.43 8.95
32 24.87 24.48 24.87 26.19 25.29 19.68 26.95 24.29 20.28 24.56 24.76 23.97 23.77 25.98 22.99 24.59 23.39 28.374 23.55 23.86 24.05 17.03
33 7.58 5.81 7.58 12.65 9.90 27.24 9.85 7.11 11.42 5.34 7.65 6.08 7.23 9.71 6.04 6.80 11.18 9.742 5.03 6.85 6.53 4.89
34 9.17 7.10 9.17 10.69 11.01 14.08 11.00 8.14 9.78 6.63 9.19 8.44 8.95 10.55 8.26 8.12 9.29 10.612 8.58 8.30 7.81 6.20
35 10.07 5.43 10.07 6.39 12.74 9.15 11.47 3.60 5.60 5.31 10.06 6.15 7.11 5.51 2.81 3.53 5.52 5.240 5.74 3.83 4.02 2.83
36 36.64 36.42 36.64 39.79 49.29 17.36 50.08 36.54 15.69 36.42 36.59 36.61 25.89 32.06 36.41 20.92 44.94 34.397 31.29 36.42 37.04 35.88
37 11.01 7.22 11.02 9.51 7.25 17.26 6.73 9.81 10.15 6.25 10.83 7.38 8.85 6.62 7.41 9.26 7.05 6.721 10.06 7.65 6.97 4.49
38 5.74 3.93 5.74 5.57 9.10 12.38 7.99 4.58 4.45 3.45 5.73 3.87 4.98 3.87 4.08 4.49 9.00 3.603 5.25 4.30 3.43 3.49
39 8.12 6.15 8.12 16.68 10.65 17.63 11.22 8.04 6.91 6.02 8.09 6.01 6.11 9.73 5.50 6.03 9.44 9.591 8.76 5.55 5.77 5.31
40 5.15 3.00 5.14 5.66 5.57 5.82 5.16 5.35 5.65 2.63 5.19 4.71 5.98 4.92 4.45 5.39 6.21 5.151 5.44 4.65 3.31 2.28
41 18.88 17.66 18.87 17.56 18.28 16.45 19.90 18.04 19.45 16.95 19.02 16.98 20.41 17.55 15.38 16.68 14.44 18.975 16.80 15.18 16.24 12.56
42 12.97 4.04 12.97 10.58 3.71 30.56 8.64 10.70 11.94 3.98 12.86 5.90 10.13 3.64 5.44 9.09 4.62 6.655 10.64 5.51 3.84 3.89
43 4.59 2.67 4.59 5.05 8.53 10.27 8.03 3.88 5.25 2.68 4.60 3.36 3.26 4.39 3.43 2.60 7.72 4.441 3.70 3.43 3.05 2.88
44 24.28 21.51 24.28 22.44 24.73 27.82 24.75 24.57 17.69 21.54 24.28 21.86 18.35 22.43 19.82 16.81 27.25 22.989 15.80 20.22 17.04 16.82
45 2.17 1.16 2.17 3.30 11.92 9.69 11.33 0.69 5.77 1.16 2.17 1.95 2.00 2.53 0.32 0.74 0.39 2.347 1.51 0.59 0.70 0.17
46 15.88 10.61 15.88 15.10 17.15 7.67 17.17 15.89 9.85 8.43 15.87 11.12 11.87 12.98 9.93 10.98 13.86 12.945 10.53 12.34 10.16 7.01
47 100.92 35.72 100.92 95.23 96.50 111.05 98.32 118.98 92.93 36.51 100.88 93.44 98.71 85.47 81.82 93.80 111.90 84.770 95.83 96.76 35.20 35.02
48 13.82 5.48 13.82 8.09 15.35 6.31 14.00 6.24 4.32 5.57 13.82 5.45 9.33 5.84 2.90 5.93 10.42 5.510 3.65 3.98 4.61 2.36
503
504
No. (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24) (25) (26) (27) (28) (29) (30) (32)
49 12.57 5.54 12.57 6.99 11.68 7.30 10.61 8.38 5.28 5.03 12.55 5.25 8.16 6.33 4.69 7.25 14.31 6.174 7.92 5.74 5.32 4.75
50 11.82 11.99 11.82 15.31 12.22 15.15 13.10 12.00 8.33 11.17 11.69 11.13 10.68 12.22 6.26 11.05 6.35 13.225 12.55 11.16 9.67 4.87
51 6.52 5.55 6.52 10.55 6.44 10.26 6.70 6.53 4.36 4.79 6.49 5.15 4.66 5.50 4.77 3.87 4.78 4.412 6.13 4.76 2.80 3.10
52 15.97 10.85 15.97 12.52 14.31 10.68 13.82 15.94 7.17 9.99 15.87 12.23 12.82 12.44 6.10 12.96 6.58 13.404 15.06 11.02 9.16 6.60
53 12.57 10.11 12.57 12.35 14.16 8.05 14.07 12.50 8.55 9.80 12.55 12.07 9.42 10.33 11.86 8.69 13.00 10.45 10.04 12.29 9.83 9.39
54 4.95 3.43 4.96 3.45 5.66 3.39 3.55 3.20 2.88 2.92 4.71 2.95 3.07 3.44 2.86 3.20 2.90 3.05 5.42 3.24 2.90 2.85
55 31.41 26.99 31.40 31.71 32.63 6.06 32.72 23.29 24.87 6.02 31.42 8.78 32.46 32.11 11.83 21.95 5.94 31.92 31.62 23.33 19.87 4.96
56 10.49 5.87 10.49 9.66 8.59 11.53 10.38 11.66 11.71 5.68 10.64 9.09 12.66 8.88 8.56 11.07 19.58 10.45 11.44 8.57 6.95 5.44
57 19.56 13.08 19.56 16.21 19.34 16.06 18.91 19.39 15.04 12.22 19.42 15.83 16.95 17.17 15.43 17.63 22.47 17.04 18.02 15.78 11.85 12.10
58 58.53 42.33 58.52 54.43 60.78 35.86 59.69 50.96 40.29 38.15 58.69 41.07 49.80 39.18 40.35 46.92 38.70 38.55 43.57 45.19 42.90 33.70
59 2.39 2.33 2.39 2.37 3.66 0.64 3.46 2.38 3.01 0.70 2.40 0.70 2.88 2.36 0.61 2.11 0.76 2.39 1.81 1.95 2.22 0.61
60 2.26 2.25 2.26 5.08 2.29 6.21 2.17 2.18 2.87 1.80 2.19 1.80 1.76 2.29 1.44 1.75 1.33 1.95 2.93 1.74 1.42 1.35
61 7.42 5.36 7.42 7.64 5.09 14.90 6.41 6.21 8.12 4.17 7.06 5.00 5.57 5.07 4.62 5.84 29.17 4.79 11.18 5.43 4.11 4.21
62 5.79 4.12 5.79 7.75 3.93 16.12 5.22 5.61 4.76 4.10 5.75 5.14 5.47 3.94 4.79 5.61 17.12 4.54 7.34 4.97 4.13 4.15
63 23.98 15.71 23.98 18.58 19.11 20.99 19.69 23.46 19.45 16.63 23.97 19.19 21.87 17.93 17.76 21.77 21.70 18.89 19.06 17.61 14.48 14.89
64 9.19 8.83 9.18 8.68 9.76 7.55 10.46 9.08 12.85 6.71 9.52 6.62 11.71 8.83 6.08 6.91 7.27 9.67 6.51 6.54 7.35 6.29
65 7.10 4.97 7.10 7.91 6.14 19.74 6.50 6.78 4.91 5.12 7.09 5.28 5.38 5.43 4.22 4.74 5.63 6.04 5.23 4.41 4.45 4.34

66 12.13 7.19 12.13 10.78 9.09 32.55 9.96 11.91 4.72 7.09 12.16 8.99 10.65 8.16 5.38 9.09 4.89 9.54 9.44 6.87 6.31 4.54
67 6.80 6.13 6.80 8.55 6.93 10.44 6.88 6.74 8.46 6.19 6.84 6.49 6.39 6.97 5.79 6.22 5.72 6.71 6.66 5.83 5.94 5.81
68 6.61 5.86 6.61 8.66 6.85 18.69 7.62 6.62 4.73 5.17 6.70 4.76 7.07 6.44 5.06 6.57 7.24 7.45 6.07 5.84 6.53 5.50
69 6.80 5.35 6.81 7.54 5.84 8.21 5.97 5.93 4.80 4.75 6.65 5.89 6.22 5.85 5.97 5.63 13.69 5.29 8.35 6.04 4.12 3.88
70 5.25 4.14 5.25 8.20 4.06 11.64 3.54 5.27 3.72 3.31 5.22 3.83 3.18 4.07 3.37 2.83 5.96 2.75 5.51 3.37 2.39 2.30
71 21.26 14.38 21.26 15.69 20.57 10.75 20.05 21.43 12.02 14.61 21.23 15.82 15.35 15.92 9.59 14.80 10.89 17.58 16.71 12.48 10.95 8.92
72 5.31 4.99 5.31 8.69 5.49 16.45 4.78 5.08 6.76 5.01 5.30 5.32 5.17 5.41 5.18 4.97 9.32 5.18 5.99 5.04 4.80 4.92
73 47.16 35.81 47.16 54.07 83.43 20.59 82.08 47.18 24.08 35.73 47.21 36.68 37.84 38.63 21.36 34.77 28.08 38.95 33.40 23.66 26.87 19.63
74 8.54 2.83 8.54 11.47 2.81 26.76 7.01 7.38 8.63 2.71 8.47 4.76 7.55 2.90 4.58 7.03 25.41 5.50 8.34 4.54 3.71 2.65
75 28.28 24.09 28.28 24.29 25.64 18.14 26.23 30.72 17.77 24.02 28.30 24.82 25.43 25.79 17.13 22.72 38.34 27.77 25.86 18.75 15.02 18.06
76 17.91 12.67 17.91 12.15 17.59 11.61 16.55 15.85 10.69 12.72 17.87 12.26 13.69 12.63 10.72 14.28 24.64 13.03 13.31 12.43 12.68 12.26
77 92.28 60.85 92.28 714.91 630.01 454.94 855.59 113.30 56.47 56.82 92.49 76.48 66.92 356.62 102.86 89.85 85.24 669.08 69.05 116.94 71.36 81.99
78 29.60 14.46 29.60 24.80 29.58 13.35 29.60 24.66 23.84 12.14 29.33 17.32 26.71 21.87 12.71 21.66 12.70 21.23 37.53 21.31 15.40 10.73
79 10.30 7.23 10.30 8.56 9.00 9.01 9.92 10.45 6.93 7.19 10.28 8.46 10.19 8.44 7.60 8.90 24.79 9.91 9.93 7.51 7.10 7.11
80 27.71 11.04 27.71 18.48 27.52 4.53 26.32 24.26 10.25 10.24 27.73 10.69 10.24 11.88 7.67 10.32 18.19 12.31 9.70 8.62 5.55 4.49
81 13.84 8.22 13.85 9.91 8.13 16.12 8.19 11.45 5.82 6.98 13.68 7.64 9.44 7.39 5.79 9.88 5.68 8.28 12.39 8.72 7.90 5.62
82 8.85 7.72 8.85 8.44 16.91 5.73 16.77 8.85 4.39 7.73 8.85 8.29 6.72 8.21 7.50 6.48 8.46 8.21 5.89 7.53 7.42 7.00
83 16.66 7.47 16.66 10.85 19.32 3.85 18.30 14.79 5.00 7.40 16.66 7.54 8.00 9.14 3.42 7.93 19.14 9.44 8.11 4.58 3.53 2.96
84 21.90 20.29 21.90 27.97 30.70 23.74 31.65 14.74 16.51 21.24 21.89 21.13 21.99 28.17 9.32 15.12 14.57 29.85 24.19 17.93 10.56 12.75
85 9.54 6.60 9.54 7.46 9.68 20.26 10.17 9.56 13.19 5.40 9.61 5.31 8.11 6.70 4.22 5.81 4.29 8.61 5.84 4.24 5.01 4.06
86 19.74 12.47 19.74 14.09 17.02 11.60 17.09 19.48 10.05 13.02 19.73 13.29 15.49 14.25 10.60 15.54 25.14 14.50 14.52 11.20 11.05 9.87
87 3.70 3.57 3.70 4.61 4.63 8.75 5.38 3.69 3.77 3.69 3.69 3.80 3.70 4.62 3.64 3.72 3.69 4.72 3.72 3.62 3.54 3.68
88 6.68 6.07 6.68 7.17 7.05 9.38 7.36 6.70 6.27 6.31 6.69 6.45 6.41 7.40 4.46 6.18 4.21 7.53 6.29 5.51 5.78 4.52
89 6.57 3.93 6.57 7.26 6.77 3.48 7.43 5.48 5.59 3.33 6.56 3.51 6.61 6.24 3.46 5.47 3.56 7.54 4.24 3.67 2.68 2.55
90 7.56 7.55 7.56 7.75 8.03 6.52 8.15 7.53 1.38 1.47 7.64 1.45 7.99 7.27 1.45 2.37 2.21 7.12 3.21 7.57 7.95 1.22
91 4.83 4.73 4.83 5.57 5.11 3.57 5.54 4.92 1.60 2.40 4.73 2.80 3.42 4.46 2.69 3.39 3.43 5.56 3.29 4.17 3.89 2.11
92 8.13 4.45 8.13 8.49 8.50 5.11 8.68 8.16 8.23 3.87 8.14 6.70 8.21 8.61 6.33 7.78 6.08 8.71 8.07 6.95 4.63 3.54
93 112.31 86.65 112.31 122.17 114.93 119.25 114.57 99.13 106.46 87.74 112.31 87.10 108.04 114.74 71.76 97.92 40.72 115.27 119.79 87.11 87.27 79.83
94 8.45 6.14 8.46 8.47 8.64 6.10 7.90 8.47 6.34 5.91 8.39 8.34 8.61 8.09 6.40 8.33 6.70 8.18 9.09 7.63 5.83 5.48
95 11.23 3.98 11.23 14.03 5.78 34.24 11.52 10.70 10.80 4.08 11.28 7.23 11.15 5.45 6.72 10.01 6.14 8.58 10.26 6.94 5.05 3.92
96 0.93 0.93 0.93 6.89 3.43 6.24 5.09 0.95 7.02 0.92 0.92 0.94 4.62 3.07 0.93 0.95 1.79 4.38 0.88 0.95 2.00 0.85
97 7.19 6.94 7.19 7.99 7.61 5.56 8.10 6.86 3.49 6.13 7.20 6.03 6.35 7.34 2.42 3.82 2.80 8.16 4.97 2.45 2.48 2.43
98 6.26 5.28 6.26 8.70 12.05 17.46 11.36 6.39 5.89 5.05 6.26 6.06 6.43 4.94 5.38 6.43 4.97 5.50 6.43 5.53 4.55 4.62
99 14.16 13.44 14.16 13.53 17.91 4.87 19.82 12.56 6.41 13.26 14.17 13.02 8.32 10.68 6.15 6.41 5.83 10.77 10.89 6.86 6.75 4.96
100 22.53 18.16 22.52 18.71 20.44 22.87 21.89 22.28 26.38 10.75 22.84 10.85 26.11 18.80 10.16 19.91 27.67 21.13 17.71 17.05 20.60 8.63
101 69.54 45.50 69.54 81.04 122.67 26.85 120.77 69.53 30.19 45.44 69.61 49.06 52.66 54.45 25.66 47.18 38.49 55.05 47.63 28.27 32.74 24.10
102 10.45 4.93 10.45 11.32 13.94 7.76 14.62 10.79 6.34 4.59 10.43 9.48 6.29 11.60 6.96 6.39 7.90 13.04 7.89 9.61 2.85 2.72
103 31.20 31.38 31.21 31.64 62.67 6.83 61.67 29.35 7.36 28.20 31.12 28.89 16.48 12.27 27.72 16.69 28.02 12.19 11.84 27.72 27.73 26.54
104 24.37 16.43 24.37 21.02 25.97 14.83 25.63 24.56 15.28 16.35 24.37 18.85 20.90 20.85 12.01 19.00 23.94 21.36 21.22 13.14 11.57 12.03
105 10.96 8.60 10.96 23.98 16.13 36.60 17.06 10.55 9.67 8.18 10.93 7.89 9.16 13.43 7.88 9.16 7.91 13.36 10.86 7.89 7.81 8.37
106 10.58 9.67 10.57 10.89 11.34 13.29 11.24 10.56 13.63 9.15 10.61 10.24 11.31 10.79 10.13 10.45 10.50 11.10 9.48 10.45 9.82 9.14
107 10.25 5.15 10.26 6.76 12.94 7.61 11.89 7.45 5.85 5.16 10.24 5.39 6.89 5.77 5.36 6.19 11.32 5.81 5.97 5.40 5.23 5.16
108 19.86 19.77 19.86 21.76 20.09 21.04 21.23 20.63 13.39 19.77 19.83 19.65 19.33 19.95 13.11 15.90 15.32 21.41 18.84 17.54 15.63 12.57
109 15.78 8.28 15.78 9.89 10.81 13.97 11.65 15.32 6.87 8.13 15.73 10.09 12.04 9.45 4.40 11.42 4.00 11.32 12.19 6.28 3.71 3.02
110 10.80 10.31 10.80 13.20 10.66 15.76 11.13 10.54 11.77 10.21 10.79 10.82 10.65 10.73 10.49 10.19 16.30 10.18 12.58 10.45 9.61 9.27
111 17.53 10.67 17.53 27.73 21.57 30.23 22.84 16.31 15.42 11.57 17.50 11.79 13.85 18.38 11.11 13.98 9.31 18.38 16.48 10.86 11.35 11.39
112 16.34 8.06 16.34 9.50 14.27 11.62 13.55 13.50 12.06 8.19 16.32 8.59 12.97 9.39 8.02 11.63 8.28 9.20 12.16 8.60 8.13 7.73
113 25.92 8.73 25.92 20.24 27.14 8.08 25.93 20.49 7.77 8.67 25.90 16.31 9.04 8.85 15.37 8.99 9.74 8.84 9.35 16.50 7.36 6.49
114 8.97 4.32 8.97 11.26 5.97 12.23 6.04 8.85 5.97 4.29 8.97 4.30 4.48 5.54 3.21 4.28 3.83 5.00 3.54 3.59 3.82 3.00
115 53.13 40.69 53.13 66.36 74.04 46.84 86.95 51.94 40.31 34.35 53.22 52.96 52.86 55.87 48.58 49.34 28.23 59.17 55.67 52.74 44.26 20.88
116 10.81 8.40 10.81 22.37 11.84 52.86 13.36 11.21 11.35 8.53 10.81 11.90 10.43 9.67 11.69 10.63 10.47 10.64 9.73 11.86 6.22 8.09
117 17.61 12.95 17.61 17.63 17.37 7.25 17.39 17.54 7.20 12.95 17.61 12.99 9.41 16.82 11.36 7.37 17.51 16.56 7.64 8.15 7.67 7.68
118 7.11 6.30 7.11 6.60 10.06 10.31 10.29 6.94 5.85 5.10 7.09 6.30 6.68 6.53 2.69 6.39 5.42 6.86 6.41 6.01 5.51 3.46

119 8.65 8.33 8.65 8.35 8.80 5.73 8.59 6.71 6.51 6.91 8.63 6.89 8.24 8.30 5.21 5.70 6.88 8.21 6.73 5.53 5.37 5.29
120 6.89 6.69 6.89 15.60 6.85 35.96 7.30 4.93 7.18 4.45 6.81 4.57 6.45 6.93 4.80 4.51 4.22 7.40 7.98 4.61 4.08 3.96
121 20.95 9.32 20.94 13.26 13.24 22.36 14.38 19.79 18.40 7.61 21.13 11.91 21.99 12.59 11.53 18.89 43.60 14.10 14.67 12.68 12.20 6.54
122 10.95 8.49 10.95 15.87 11.53 23.71 13.82 8.97 6.20 8.35 10.95 10.84 10.92 10.38 8.38 9.31 7.99 12.51 9.86 8.38 6.18 6.25
123 58.09 2.97 58.09 37.83 68.61 10.90 68.50 47.77 7.32 3.42 58.09 11.68 30.73 20.30 6.60 24.60 42.77 20.37 23.47 10.79 4.31 2.98
124 19.38 14.86 19.38 21.50 16.44 20.91 19.11 19.25 18.75 15.23 19.51 19.87 22.06 16.34 18.27 19.84 17.07 18.49 19.50 18.33 13.96 13.53
125 15.00 9.64 15.00 11.26 17.96 12.72 16.60 11.62 11.02 10.03 14.98 9.99 10.68 9.60 10.08 9.51 14.95 9.58 10.52 9.65 9.54 9.98
126 114.23 19.48 114.23 98.66 131.35 16.82 131.24 55.55 16.75 19.82 114.22 24.37 40.16 25.30 22.69 36.90 67.19 25.26 19.92 22.54 18.75 19.27
127 5.33 4.08 5.33 9.66 4.46 12.18 5.50 5.05 7.90 4.02 5.40 4.95 6.32 4.54 4.82 4.88 4.81 5.50 4.25 4.95 4.29 3.22
128 18.77 3.90 18.77 4.73 8.30 9.75 7.19 13.22 4.49 3.41 18.76 3.58 10.18 4.62 3.36 7.57 36.50 4.80 7.75 4.11 3.56 3.18
129 8.43 4.78 8.43 7.94 10.21 8.29 10.54 7.94 4.04 2.37 8.44 6.18 4.70 7.48 6.29 4.82 9.90 8.13 4.97 7.12 3.97 2.29
130 35.00 24.13 35.00 27.37 33.87 24.05 32.08 33.06 26.21 25.74 34.95 25.69 25.05 24.58 22.49 27.77 44.13 24.87 26.21 24.97 23.64 21.68
131 6.91 3.61 6.91 3.89 5.33 10.63 4.43 5.42 5.96 3.74 6.74 3.82 3.85 3.55 3.49 3.89 18.98 4.27 6.98 3.62 3.42 3.37
132 24.60 22.38 24.60 22.23 26.02 24.61 25.68 24.51 23.88 19.62 24.73 20.04 21.81 22.40 20.80 19.99 19.07 23.06 18.96 21.31 21.10 19.39
133 5.73 4.29 5.73 5.98 6.45 5.84 6.22 5.72 4.95 4.20 5.72 5.71 5.35 5.98 5.73 4.89 5.39 6.06 5.74 5.78 3.20 2.93
134 1.51 1.32 1.51 1.29 11.81 1.52 11.65 1.53 1.15 0.75 1.51 0.77 1.39 1.29 0.83 1.00 0.67 1.41 1.35 22.59 0.60 0.56
135 27.10 22.96 27.10 22.26 27.89 13.81 27.14 25.60 11.68 23.69 27.05 23.93 20.98 20.05 25.57 22.18 45.20 21.39 19.93 12.24 22.89 25.49
136 18.98 14.05 18.98 13.74 18.62 11.33 18.03 18.88 9.08 14.28 18.96 14.12 13.89 13.82 10.10 12.43 10.34 15.11 13.49 4.21 9.46 8.99
137 5.58 4.01 5.58 4.79 5.56 9.60 4.47 4.30 5.96 4.02 5.58 4.36 4.96 4.09 4.12 4.28 10.54 3.79 5.13 6.42 3.82 2.96
138 11.24 8.17 11.24 12.20 9.98 42.34 9.02 6.70 16.23 8.21 11.25 8.15 9.73 9.11 6.38 6.00 13.77 8.80 7.63 12.27 4.92 6.19
139 28.77 16.45 28.77 18.75 15.79 15.75 12.01 23.59 27.08 14.11 28.61 14.42 26.35 13.94 11.74 10.96 18.31 12.55 17.52 5.84 11.69 10.17
140 11.74 5.85 11.75 6.79 13.63 6.14 12.35 8.93 5.02 5.10 11.67 5.15 7.14 6.33 3.72 7.24 13.25 6.38 7.47 14.85 5.21 3.82
141 20.88 15.55 20.89 16.13 17.73 14.07 16.05 15.17 14.43 9.30 20.63 9.96 15.56 16.13 9.62 14.80 10.40 15.28 19.48 7.18 12.86 8.07
142 12.01 11.06 12.01 11.43 14.14 12.16 14.45 12.12 9.22 10.30 12.06 10.23 11.43 10.91 7.18 8.03 7.04 12.74 11.25 5.35 6.49 6.54
143 8.37 4.57 8.37 5.66 8.86 4.03 7.91 6.88 5.06 3.09 8.34 4.51 6.56 5.69 4.14 6.37 9.90 5.47 7.44 3.82 3.85 3.19
144 10.72 2.89 10.72 23.79 17.61 21.18 19.54 6.20 9.02 2.94 10.71 3.72 7.11 10.81 3.47 5.59 10.08 10.85 5.68 3.74 1.75 1.39
145 6.53 3.83 6.53 4.21 5.43 10.72 5.31 5.45 4.94 3.81 6.54 4.08 5.45 4.25 3.67 3.84 3.46 4.14 4.34 34.97 3.77 3.52
146 67.44 67.50 67.44 87.83 114.14 29.99 135.37 36.18 44.09 66.29 67.57 65.40 56.40 53.50 24.31 27.56 45.49 48.56 77.13 19.37 25.23 27.36
147 27.60 21.41 27.60 21.50 31.60 15.00 35.25 25.39 16.02 21.16 27.60 21.28 17.57 19.01 14.11 18.83 19.62 19.61 26.28 14.49 17.68 15.24
148 19.07 16.11 19.07 17.08 18.34 11.54 21.47 19.14 10.00 16.36 19.07 16.36 13.97 17.70 11.15 13.15 11.77 19.97 17.14 1.05 12.16 10.69
149 2.60 1.91 2.60 4.45 2.87 2.52 4.46 1.17 3.21 1.18 2.83 1.17 4.67 2.75 1.04 0.93 0.87 4.34 1.87 7.68 0.86 0.86
150 9.30 7.38 9.30 18.77 14.67 18.23 16.55 7.32 8.45 7.38 9.28 8.08 8.92 14.11 6.48 6.65 7.29 15.69 10.14 8.70 4.80 5.00
151 9.18 7.79 9.18 19.47 18.88 24.73 20.80 9.03 9.11 7.67 9.17 9.38 8.27 18.17 8.44 7.55 9.21 20.02 9.68 13.59 8.25 6.67
152 33.28 29.32 33.28 33.06 37.41 13.02 37.79 29.97 13.42 29.66 33.29 31.33 29.22 32.50 12.87 19.66 34.82 32.84 27.33 9.00 14.93 11.62
505
506
No. (10) (11) (12) (13) (14) (15) (16) (17) (18) (19) (20) (21) (22) (23) (24) (25) (26) (27) (28) (29) (30) (32)
153 15.09 8.85 15.09 13.41 23.31 6.29 23.11 11.94 10.50 8.83 15.09 9.17 11.01 8.76 8.43 7.80 12.63 8.92 8.42 3.77 6.64 4.99
154 5.92 3.66 5.92 6.62 5.11 16.06 4.71 4.32 6.06 2.85 5.86 3.07 4.07 3.32 3.52 4.10 11.77 3.71 5.23 3.58 3.12 2.89
155 3.99 3.40 3.99 5.97 4.96 11.37 4.03 3.54 5.02 2.85 3.95 2.94 3.19 3.38 3.12 3.55 6.40 3.35 4.35 7.24 2.97 2.90
156 9.93 7.31 9.93 7.80 12.68 4.84 12.17 8.33 5.28 6.19 9.93 6.39 8.42 7.23 6.02 8.09 6.77 7.27 4.81 3.00 7.59 5.61
157 5.23 3.83 5.23 8.82 4.28 8.25 5.68 3.08 3.87 3.83 5.24 3.74 4.50 3.36 2.54 2.92 2.52 3.73 3.79 10.85 2.83 2.59
158 18.71 8.63 18.71 18.50 22.24 9.03 28.83 12.67 9.30 8.65 18.70 12.13 17.16 9.21 7.92 11.04 11.78 9.89 10.08 2.41 8.47 8.07
159 7.35 3.68 7.35 4.25 15.08 8.93 14.18 2.97 5.43 3.70 7.35 4.23 5.47 4.02 2.13 3.12 4.86 3.81 2.71 16.32 2.80 2.05
160 38.88 23.00 38.88 28.68 41.27 14.40 40.33 36.82 11.04 22.30 38.88 22.63 24.42 22.43 16.49 24.05 38.49 22.76 19.19 9.11 15.57 15.95
161 10.61 3.76 10.61 10.73 16.78 13.28 17.60 10.58 5.42 3.69 10.61 9.07 6.98 9.80 9.13 7.10 8.80 10.15 8.30 6.05 4.97 3.67
162 6.14 5.69 6.15 10.10 6.19 15.75 6.98 6.09 6.54 5.70 6.11 5.99 5.90 5.99 6.04 5.75 12.96 5.95 6.61 7.55 5.61 5.54
163 16.38 7.43 16.38 8.75 14.21 10.25 13.21 14.30 7.20 7.42 16.34 8.31 10.92 8.78 6.59 11.08 25.15 9.32 10.89 6.14 6.67 6.56
164 18.98 5.20 18.98 5.81 6.09 15.70 6.76 15.79 11.90 5.23 18.97 5.90 12.73 5.24 5.88 10.34 7.63 5.99 8.17 4.63 6.23 5.38
165 11.00 2.99 11.00 27.12 20.55 23.61 22.81 6.83 8.87 3.05 11.00 4.44 7.17 12.22 3.76 6.11 3.37 11.88 6.81 11.67 2.63 2.39
166 12.12 10.81 12.13 11.60 13.21 13.16 12.32 11.66 13.14 10.75 12.07 11.35 11.00 11.77 11.20 11.25 11.39 11.74 11.57 1.95 10.41 9.51
167 2.03 1.16 2.03 4.78 10.81 10.33 10.21 2.04 5.47 1.17 2.03 1.98 2.00 3.15 1.18 2.03 1.69 3.21 1.85 13.85 1.19 1.10
168 15.85 10.71 15.85 13.11 19.36 21.44 18.88 15.76 12.21 10.85 15.84 13.89 10.13 13.04 13.71 11.31 20.50 14.27 11.93 8.85 9.19 10.18
169 33.62 8.64 33.62 24.01 44.64 10.93 43.77 24.97 14.08 8.38 33.61 8.21 18.09 12.49 9.19 16.36 31.38 12.45 13.76 3.97 7.67 7.32

170 5.27 4.27 5.27 4.58 6.78 5.34 5.71 3.94 3.37 3.05 5.20 3.23 4.59 4.44 3.24 3.66 4.25 4.04 5.28 13.60 2.75 2.54
171 17.81 16.03 17.81 16.36 17.30 15.33 18.09 17.80 15.17 14.30 17.95 14.04 16.81 16.50 13.60 14.42 14.14 17.84 14.40 2.87 13.86 11.27
172 4.29 4.03 4.29 5.65 11.05 6.61 11.37 3.78 3.32 3.79 4.30 4.05 3.72 5.63 2.73 2.91 3.02 6.25 3.76 3.40 3.09 2.84
173 3.95 3.49 3.95 5.48 5.73 8.03 4.51 3.31 3.38 3.66 3.95 3.68 4.03 3.36 3.42 3.27 6.57 3.32 4.10 4.48 3.42 3.13
174 8.95 4.59 8.95 4.87 12.15 11.51 10.61 7.54 6.25 4.52 8.94 4.49 5.23 4.71 3.83 5.16 15.15 5.43 5.58 30.38 3.78 3.73
175 57.18 19.60 57.18 38.28 44.13 22.26 38.11 42.74 38.04 17.97 56.83 29.75 51.81 36.26 25.26 29.66 12.30 31.40 55.77 35.29 19.03 19.18
176 66.45 27.04 66.46 37.02 42.47 29.87 43.70 55.15 36.81 26.64 65.86 33.86 39.76 31.61 24.71 22.91 19.81 28.48 48.31 13.22 21.04 17.40
177 24.89 15.83 24.89 17.44 24.38 9.53 23.10 23.16 7.47 15.82 24.84 15.74 14.51 16.31 10.73 14.05 28.99 17.27 15.17 4.19 11.29 9.58
178 11.82 3.41 11.82 4.12 7.23 9.59 5.62 7.53 4.59 2.88 11.80 3.93 7.23 3.88 4.26 5.41 19.62 3.69 6.95 26.29 3.15 2.99
179 41.24 30.40 41.24 45.08 51.88 30.97 53.76 30.36 30.19 28.59 41.25 39.95 31.23 41.83 23.80 20.32 32.06 44.29 31.38 13.99 14.18 17.33
180 17.49 13.54 17.49 17.69 16.20 44.08 15.61 14.39 14.34 12.11 17.44 13.12 13.55 15.54 12.64 13.63 22.67 15.13 14.82 14.36 14.24 11.81
181 20.47 19.84 20.46 26.37 22.66 40.32 25.47 20.39 16.85 20.38 20.51 19.07 19.47 22.69 14.48 17.55 14.91 25.80 19.08 4.08 11.60 14.44
182 4.09 3.05 4.09 10.98 11.23 15.91 11.89 3.95 4.55 3.10 4.09 4.19 3.95 9.00 3.82 3.80 3.89 9.26 6.04 7.44 4.91 2.42
183 12.17 6.58 12.17 9.13 5.85 14.53 5.72 10.44 10.34 6.45 12.17 8.34 11.15 5.86 7.14 9.94 8.70 5.72 8.52 11.19 6.57 6.48
184 12.01 9.50 12.01 12.62 10.72 14.08 11.11 12.09 11.43 9.06 12.00 11.26 11.96 10.72 11.09 12.12 11.10 11.08 12.02 4.05 9.28 8.87
185 6.80 4.05 6.80 5.52 8.62 12.88 8.00 6.22 3.25 3.91 6.79 3.92 4.31 4.89 3.02 4.63 14.08 5.45 4.76 5.12 3.65 2.73
186 23.81 3.59 23.81 17.02 35.83 2.72 35.32 15.27 5.69 4.05 23.80 5.55 12.72 5.77 5.11 11.99 20.26 5.82 3.65 7.00 3.42 3.77
187 8.65 3.71 8.65 9.73 3.86 18.77 5.24 9.12 7.69 3.18 8.68 7.20 8.89 3.97 6.92 8.84 6.36 5.03 9.83 3.57 3.82 3.44
188 7.72 2.75 7.72 16.63 11.35 16.40 12.71 5.40 7.69 2.69 7.71 3.55 6.05 9.07 3.43 5.01 2.74 9.25 4.31 3.61 1.78 1.95
189 5.19 3.61 5.19 3.64 6.72 5.77 6.45 4.31 3.70 3.61 5.19 3.64 3.86 3.64 3.41 3.83 6.15 3.69 3.87 9.59 3.63 3.67
190 11.80 6.57 11.80 12.76 6.34 23.06 9.13 11.31 9.38 6.38 11.71 9.73 11.11 6.37 8.98 11.29 7.62 8.27 12.95 8.41 5.92 5.98
191 13.38 12.01 13.37 13.50 13.79 7.19 14.80 11.84 20.04 8.39 13.53 9.84 18.79 13.36 7.61 11.41 9.88 14.19 13.75 9.22 9.68 5.35
192 9.74 8.44 9.75 10.83 8.54 12.75 9.32 9.70 12.69 7.42 9.52 8.84 9.19 8.55 6.74 9.46 13.11 8.42 10.97 19.76 6.70 6.40
193 24.44 12.03 24.44 74.07 48.02 152.92 54.07 19.17 27.74 12.24 24.47 19.67 22.12 31.72 20.54 19.43 18.01 35.35 18.24 78.67 12.24 10.86
194 183.64 33.67 183.64 96.44 113.46 32.24 114.62 170.72 22.28 39.08 183.64 79.50 132.34 78.27 41.57 132.97 297.07 78.44 86.67 46.87 14.28 28.91
195 159.80 21.42 159.80 80.71 97.17 18.82 96.91 145.81 21.72 24.47 159.80 55.34 103.14 55.58 21.28 103.87 236.23 55.86 54.32 33.44 13.39 16.15
196 34.91 31.72 34.91 54.25 62.02 23.77 77.21 33.75 23.15 30.81 34.75 35.01 30.01 49.45 23.50 25.11 28.38 53.18 43.96 3.37 24.35 20.97
197 3.60 2.90 3.60 5.52 8.38 8.33 8.81 3.59 10.54 2.30 3.59 2.74 2.03 5.01 2.83 2.99 1.59 5.41 2.90 4.61 3.63 2.13
198 6.75 4.48 6.75 6.04 8.98 3.47 8.22 6.18 4.41 3.75 6.75 4.43 4.87 3.50 4.43 3.83 4.08 3.54 3.28 5.26 3.17 3.21
199 5.33 5.34 5.33 5.39 5.88 4.55 5.71 5.27 4.19 5.32 5.33 5.33 5.44 5.36 4.24 4.82 4.71 5.53 5.09 23.63 4.61 3.28
200 27.21 23.02 27.21 26.99 28.23 12.17 28.24 27.23 22.89 13.88 27.24 14.59 23.31 24.52 14.50 22.41 21.17 25.55 22.11 18.35 22.88 12.94
201 18.54 18.36 18.54 20.19 19.67 30.84 19.68 18.55 17.30 12.75 18.51 13.15 18.10 18.90 17.93 18.22 14.33 18.71 18.15 3.70 18.23 12.73
202 5.41 4.53 5.41 6.12 6.66 11.23 6.57 5.40 7.91 4.48 5.42 4.71 5.10 4.50 3.70 4.31 3.68 5.14 4.81 5.34 3.60 3.58
203 7.18 5.83 7.18 6.48 8.95 12.15 7.06 5.37 3.56 5.82 7.19 5.88 6.83 5.78 4.71 5.17 4.79 5.44 6.05 9.44 5.15 3.94
Z SCF ¼ ZðT; P; y2 Þ (6)
81.99
8.88
9.28
5.27
3.44
7.86
5.96
3.77
4.24
0.17
Eqs. 5 and 6 are the basis for calculating the solubility of
44.55
11.92
87.27
10.39
a solid solute in an SCF by an EoS. The quality of predictions
9.22
5.60
4.76
5.61
5.77
0.60 or correlations depends on the EoS and mixing rules to be
116.94 used. Calculations are very sensitive to the accuracy of the
44.53
10.98
12.56
5.64
5.03
5.96
0.83
5.48
0.59
required solute properties [3,4,38].

Taking the logarithm of Eq. 4 gives
119.79
11.81
44.25
14.53
6.25
6.47
7.94
7.75
7.26
0.88
V2s P V2s P2sub 1

ln y2 ¼ ln P2sub ln P ln fSCF
2 þ (7)
R T R T
669.08
10.86
14.68
52.40
13.72
18.90
5.74
4.24
7.90
1.41
The volumetric properties of the solvent are governed

by the equation of state of a real gas:
297.07
12.40
15.37
P ¼ ZRT r1
6.27
9.47
5.27
4.37
4.52
6.27
0.39
(8)
The solubility of the solute at a given T and P can be
132.97
10.01
44.97
10.63
13.52
5.40
5.29
8.40
5.45
0.74
related to the density and the coefficient of compressibility

of the pure solvent by replacing the pressure in Eq. 7:
102.86
10.67
4.90
9.07
5.35
3.43
7.61
4.56
5.28
0.32
V2s P2sub 1
ln y2 ¼ ln P2sub lnðZRT r1 Þ ln fSCF
2 þ V2 Z r1
s
(9)
R T
356.62
13.83
51.16
12.52
16.11
5.87
4.06
9.30
8.12
1.29
All of the density-based models that have been pro-

posed can be considered as a simple empirical approxi-
132.34
10.40
53.50
14.15
15.02
mation to the right-hand side of Eq. 9, which generally does

6.10
5.82
9.99
6.54
1.39
not require any solute property. The next section presents a

brief review of density-based model for correlation of solid
10.15
93.44
12.69
9.10
5.86
4.77
8.73
4.51
6.56
0.70
solubility data.
183.64
11.30
50.63
13.87
13.04
18.79
5.82
6.81
6.71
0.92
2.1. Density-based model for correlation of solid solubility

data
10.44
87.74
10.87
8.86
5.81
4.52
9.40
3.73
5.95
0.70
In a recent article [57], we have presented an extensive

106.46
review of density-based empirical models. Chronologies of

12.17
55.91
13.44
12.63
2.56
6.71
8.26
5.32
1.15
their development, the experimental findings, and theo-

retical explanations of some of the model parameters have
170.72
10.73
47.57
13.33
10.93
16.96
been presented. Table 1 shows semiempirical models used

5.78
5.15
5.45
0.69
to correlate the experimental solubility data that have

been proposed by different authors in the last four de-
855.59
15.10
53.05
19.09
13.68
10.14
25.79
5.76
5.12
2.17
cades with the aim of improving the quality of correlation

of new experimental data. Models that require solute
454.94
properties, which are not readily available for compounds

23.19
11.36
10.34
26.14
13.03
19.94
3.40
5.01
0.64
of interest such as pharmaceuticals and dyes, have not

been considered in this study. In Table 1, y2 is the solu-
630.01
bility of the solid solute in mole fraction, r1 is the density

13.91
51.58
18.22
12.90
10.62
23.74
6.20
4.38
2.29
of the SCF (in kilograms per cubic meter), T is the tem-

perature (in Kelvin), P is the pressure (in bar), ai repre-
714.91
18.87
51.16
13.38
22.27
8.85
8.28
9.31
9.05
1.29
sents the characteristic parameters determined by fitting

experimental data of the solute/solvent considered. For
183.64
11.30
50.21
13.85
12.80
18.80
the Sparks et al. [73] model, solubility is expressed in a

5.75
6.80
6.71
0.93
dimensionless form, whereas in the Bain et al. [64] model

the solute solubility, c2, is in kilograms per cubic meter. In
49.86
11.03
86.65
11.94
8.95
5.39
4.63
9.40
5.96
0.93
both models c2 is related to y2 by Eq. 24a, in which Mw1

and Mw2 are the molecular weights of the solvent and the
183.64
11.30
50.21
13.85
12.81
18.80
solute, respectively. It is worth mentioning that some of

5.75
6.80
6.71
0.93
the models do not relate the solubility explicitly to the

density of the SCF solvent. The model proposed in our
Overall AARD
previous work [57] is based on the following facts: (1)

models that relate the solubility of the solid solute to
Max.
Min.
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
temperature, pressure, and the density of the SCF violate

the phase rule, because the volumetric properties (P, T, and
r1) of scCO2 are governed by the phase rule, hence only

two variables need to be fixed; (2) just as the density 100 X
N
yexp ycal
AARDð%Þ ¼ 2
exp
2
(33)
expansion of the virial EoS is more accurate than the N i¼1 y2
pressure expansion at increased pressures [80], relating
the solubility to density at isothermal condition instead of Initial approximations of model parameters are first
pressure would lead, a priori, to better correlation. obtained by genetic algorithm function (ga MATLAB func-
tion) through several runs to avoid convergence to local
minimum. These approximations are then used as initial
guess for least-square fitting with LevenbergeMarquardt
2.2. Proposed model algorithm as minimization option (lsqcurvefit MATLAB
function).
On the basis of the two arguments mentioned by Si- Table 3 shows the results of parameter estimation (ai) of
Moussa et al. [57], the proposed model is derived first by the model proposed in this work (Eq. 32) for the 210 sys-
a modification of Gordillo et al. [70] model where the tems considered. Parameters of the other models can be
pressure is replaced by the density of the solvent, which accessed in the Supplementary material.
leads to the following equation: The AARDs (%) of each model equation with each solid
compound are shown in Table 4 where the minimal AARD
ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 r1 þ a2 r21 þ a3 r1 T þ a4 T þ a5 T 2 (31) for the correlation of the solubility data of each binary
system is shown in bold. It is clear that empirical models,
As the linear relationship between ln(y2) and ln r1 in considered in this study, as a whole correlate quite satis-
isothermal conditions, as well as the inverse of tempera- factorily the data set with a minimal AARD (0.17%) obtained
ture effect on ln(y2), has been considered in many models by the proposed model (Eq. 32) for component 45 (azo-
that demonstrated acceptable correlation performance in benzene) and a maximum AARD (56.47%) obtained by
previous comparative studies [57e64], these two terms Jouyban et al. model (Eq. 18) for component 77 (corosolic
ða6 ln r1 þ a7 =TÞ are added to Eq. 31. The proposed model is acid). The average of minimal AARDs is 6.87%. Therefore,
therefore 0.17% represents the minimum of minimums and 56.47%
represents the maximum of minimums and 6.87% repre-
ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 r1 þ a2 r21 þ a3 r1 T þ a4 T þ a5 T 2 þ a6 ln r1
sents the average of the minimums for the data set
þ a7 =T considered. It is worth mentioning that the value of 56.77%
(32) was obtained for corosolic acid for which the experimental
data present presumably a misprint, which results in
The eight parameters a0ea7 are obtained from regres- excessive AARD.
sion of experimental data. The new model was compared with the 21 most
commonly used semiempirical models in terms of AARD
3. Results and discussion (%) and the results are presented in Table 5, in which bold
values represent the best performance for a group of
In the present study, a data set of 210 solid solutes models with the same number of adjustable parameters.
counting 5550 data points of experimental solubility in Among the three parameter models, Garlapati and Madras
scCO2, compiled from the literature published in the last 25 [74] (Eq. 20) and Chrastil [65] (Eq. 10) models were found to
years, is used for comparison of correlation performance of correlate better with an average AARD of 18.79%, whereas
22 empirical models. Table 2 displays the range of experi- Jafari Nedjad et al. [76] model (Eq. 22) was found to be
mental temperature, pressure, solubility, Ni number of better among four parameter models with an average
experimental points, and source of the 210 selected binary AARD of 15.02%. Comparing five parameter models, Adachi
soluteescCO2 systems. and Lu [66] correlation (Eq. 11) gave the best global AARD of
The optimization procedure, for fitting the model pa- 11.94%. For the set of six parameter models, Si-Moussa et al.
rameters, reduces the percentage average absolute relative [57] model (Eq. 30) shows a slight advantage over Sparks
deviation (AARD %) and is defined as et al. [73] (Eq. 19) and Bian et al. [59] (Eq. 24) models and a
Table 5
Comparison of overall AARD according to the number of model parameters.
Number of parameters Model equation Overall AARD % Number of parameters Model equation Overall AARD %
3 (10) 18.80 5 (21) 12.69

3 (13) 22.27 5 (25) 13.52
3 (14) 23.74 5 (28) 14.53
3 (16) 25.79 5 (29) 12.56
3 (20) 18.79 6 (15) 19.94
4 (12) 18.80 6 (18) 12.63
4 (17) 16.96 6 (19) 10.87
4 (22) 15.02 6 (24) 10.67
4 (23) 16.11 6 (30) 10.39
4 (27) 18.90 8 (32) 8.88
5 (11) 11.94 9 (26) 15.37
Fig. 1. The number of systems best correlated by each model equation.
clear superiority over Jouyban et al. [58] (Eq. 18) and Gor- the obtained results, it can be concluded that the proposed
dillo et al. [70] (Eq. 15) models with an average AARD of correlation was able to correlate the solubility of solids in
10.39%. To summarize, it is clear from Table 5 that the more scCO2 with an acceptable deviation.
parameters the model has the more accurate correlation Figs. 3 and 4 show comparisons between calculated and
performance are, except the nine-parameter model of experimental solubility for the best (menadione) and worst
Amooey [60] (Eq. 26) with a global AARD of 15.37%. The (corosolic acid) correlation results.
eight-parameter model proposed in this work shows the
smallest AARD (8.88%) among all of the models considered.
These findings are further illustrated in Fig. 1, which 4. Conclusions
represent the correlations that best correlated 90% of sys-
tems considered. Clearly, the model proposed in this work The comparative study of semiempirical models on a
is superior to the other models as it best correlates 87 (41%) fairly large database carried out in this work shows that the
systems of the 210 considered. The second best is the five-
parameter model of Bian et al. [64] (Eq. 29) with 28 (13%) cal exp
Linear Fit: log(y )=(1)log(y )+(-0.014), R=0.99816
2 2
systems.
0
It should be mentioned that models that include the
Data Points
pressure as variable tend to give a relatively poor correla-
Best Linear Fit
tion. This is well demonstrated by the correlation results of
-2 cal
log(y ) = log(y
exp
)
the same data set of Jouyban et al. [58] model (Eq. 18) 2 2
(12.63%) compared to Si-Moussa et al. [57] model (Eq. 30)

(AARD ¼ 10.39%). A more illustrative example, which -4
supports this evidence, is the comparison of Gordillo et al.
[70] (Eq. 15) and its modification (Eq. 31), not included in
log(y )
the present study, where there is a net difference between

cal
-6
2
the correlation performance of the two equations (AARD of

19.94% and 11.09%, respectively).
Fig. 2 displays the scatter plot of the entire data set of -8
the solid solute solubility calculated using the model pro-
posed in this work (Eq. 32) versus experimental solubility
(5550 experimental points). These plots are generated -10
using the postreg function of MATLAB, trace the calculated
solubility as a function of experimental solubility.
In Fig. 2, the first bisector shows the exact fit between -12
-12 -10 -8 -6 -4 -2 0
the correlated solubilities and experimental data, whereas exp
log(y )
the cross points demonstrated the real correlated solubility 2
data by the proposed correlation versus experimental data.

Fig. 2. Scatter plot of the entire dataset of solid solutes solubility calculated
In detail, the closer the points to the solid line, the more using the model proposed in this work (Eq. 32) versus experimental
accurate correlated solubility data means. On the basis of solubility.
Fig. 3. Mole fraction solubility (log10(y2)) of menadione in scCO2 as a function of carbon dioxide density and temperature.
Fig. 4. Mole fraction solubility (log10(y2)) of corosolic acid in scCO2 as a function of carbon dioxide density and temperature.
solubility data of solid solutes in scCO2 are better correlated best correlating performance with an AARD lying in the
by models that relate the logarithm of the solubility in the range of 0.17e81.99% and an average value of 8.88%. The
mole fraction to the density of solvent and temperature with second best correlation is (Eq. 30) [30] where the AARD
more than five adjustable parameters. The model must ranges in 0.60e87.27% and an average value of 10.39%.
include a term of the logarithm of the density, a polynomial
of the density, and a term that accounts for the effect of
Acknowledgments
temperature. As to the data set considered, semiempirical
models correlate quite satisfactorily the data within the
The authors gratefully acknowledge the Algerian Min-
AARD range of 0.17e56.47% and an average value of 6.87%.
istry of Higher Education and Scientific Research (CNEPRU
However, when comparing the global correlating perfor-
Projects Nos. J0102620110007 and J0102620140015) and
mance of each model, the proposed model has by far the
the University Yahia Fares of Medea.
Appendix A. Supplementary data [43] A. Khazaiepoul, M. Soleimani, S. Salahi, Chinese J. Chem. Eng. 24
(2016) 491.
[44] B. Mehdizadeh, K. Movagharnejad, Fluid Phase Equilib. 303 (2011) 40.
Supplementary data related to this article can be found [45] R. Tabaraki, T. Khayamian, A.A. Ensafi, Dyes Pigm. 73 (2007) 230.
at https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crci.2018.02.006. [46] M. Lashkarbolooki, B. Vaferi, M.R. Rahimpour, Fluid Phase Equilib.
308 (2011) 35.
[47] A. Abdallah el hadj, M. Laidi, C. Si-Moussa, S. Hanini, Neural
Comput. Appl. 28 (2015) 87.
References [48] B. Vaferi, M. Karimi, M. Azizi, H. Esmaeili, J. Supercrit. Fluids 77
(2013) 44.
[1] A.S. Mayo, U.B. Kompella, in: J. Swarbrick (Ed.), Encyclopedia of [49] Y. Bakhbakhi, Expert Syst. Appl. 38 (2011) 11355.
Pharmaceutical Technology, Informa Health Care USA, Inc, 2007, p. [50] F. Gharagheizi, A. Eslamimanesh, A.H. Mohammadi, D. Richon, Ind.
3568. Eng. Res. 50 (2011) 221.
[2] J.A.P. Coelho, R.M. Filipe, G.P. Naydenova, D.S. Yankov, R.P. Stateva, [51] A. Aminian, J. Supercrit. Fluids 125 (2017) 79.
Fluid Phase Equilib. 426 (2016) 37. [52] B. Mehdizadeh, K. Movagharnejad, Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 89 (2011)
[3] P. Coimbra, C.M.M. Duarte, H.C. de Sousa, Fluid Phase Equilib. 139 2420.
(2006) 188. [53] A. Baghban, A. Jalali, A.H. Mohammadi, S. Habibzadeh, J. Supercrit.
[4] J.O. Valderrama, J. Zavaleta, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 44 (2005) 4824. Fluids 133 (2018) 466.
[5] M. Türk, M. Crone, T. Kraska, J. Supercrit. Fluids 55 (2010) 462. [54] M.R. Dadkhah, A. Tatar, A. Mohebbi, A. Barati-Harooni, A. Najafi-
[6] M. Ardjm, M. Mirzajanzadeh, F. Zabihi, Chin. J. Chem. Eng. 22 Marghmaleki, M.M. Ghiasi, A.H. Mohammadi, F. Pourfayaz, J.
(2014) 549. Supercrit. Fluids 120 (2017) 181.
[7] H. Rostamian, M.N. Lotfollahi, Indian J. Sci. Technol. 9 (16) (2016) [55] N. De Zordi, I. Kikic, M. Moneghini, D. Solinas, J. Supercrit. Fluids 66
52344. (2012) 16.
[8] J. Sang, Y. Wang, H. Wang, R. Abro, J. Jin, Fluid Phase Equilib. 432 [56] D. Ziger, C. Eckert, Ind. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev. 22 (1983) 582.
(2017) 54. [57] C. Si-Moussa, A. Belghait, L. Khaouane, S. Hanini, A. Halilali, C. R.
[9] M. Yazdizadeh, A. Eslamimanesh, F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Supercrit. Chim 20 (2017) 559.
Fluids 55 (2011) 861. [58] A. Jouyban, H.-K. Chan, N.R. Foster, J. Supercrit. Fluids 24 (2002) 19.
[10] M. Yazdizadeh, A. Eslamimanesh, F. Esmaeilzadeh, Chem. Eng. Sci. [59] X. Bian, Z. Du, Y. Tang, Thermochim. Acta 519 (2011) 16.
71 (2012) 283. [60] A.A. Amooey, Fluid Phase Equilib. 375 (2014) 332.
[11] M. Türk, B. Stehli, Chem. Ing. Tech. 85 (2013) 1446. [61] M.A. Khansary, F. Amiri, A. Hosseini, A.H. Sani, H. Shahbeig, Chem.
[12] J.-H. Li, Z. Huangb, J.-L. Wei, L. Xu, Fluid Phase Equilib. 344 Eng. Res. Des. 93 (2015) 355.
(2013) 117. [62] A. Tabernero, J.M. del Valle, M.A. Galan, J. Supercrit. Fluids 52
[13] E. Reverchon, G.D. Porta, R. Taddeo, P. Pallado, A. Stassi, Ind. Eng. (2010) 161.
Chem. Res. 34 (1995) 4087. [63] X.Q. Bian, J. Li, J. Chen, M.J. Li, Z.M. Du, Chem. Eng. Res. Des 104
[14] C.C. Huang, M. Tang, W.H. Tao, Y.P. Chen, Fluid Phase Equilib. 179 (2015) 416.
(2001) 67. [64] X.Q. Bian, Q. Zhang, Z.M. Du, J. Chen, J.N. Jaubert, Fluid Phase
[15] F. Esmaeilzadeh, M. Roshanfekr, Fluid Phase Equilib. 239 (2006) Equilib. 411 (2016) 74.
83. [65] J. Chrastil, J. Phys. Chem-US 86 (1982) 3016.
[16] D.S.H. Wong, S.I. Sandler, AICHE J. 38 (1992) 671. [66] Y. Adachi, B.C.Y. Lu, Fluid Phase Equilib. 14 (1983) 147.
[17] M. Bonyadi, F. Esmaeilzadeh, Fluid Phase Equilib. 273 (2008) 31. [67] J.M. del Valle, J.M. Aguilera, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 27 (1988) 1551.
[18] I. Tsivintzelis, I.G. Economou, G.M. Kontogeorgis, J. Phys. Chem. B [68] S.K. Kumar, K.P. Johnston, J. Supercrit. Fluids 1 (1988) 15.
113 (2009) 6446. [69] K.D. Bartle, A.A. Clifford, S.A. Jafar, G.F. Shilstone, J. Phys. Chem.
[19] A. Tihic, G.M. Kontogeorgis, N. Von Solms, M.L. Michelsen, Fluid Ref. Data 20 (1991) 713.
Phase Equilib. 248 (2006) 29. [70] M.D. Gordillo, M.A. Blanco, A. Molero, E.M. de la Ossa, J. Supercrit.
[20] A. Tihic, G.M. Kontogeorgis, N. von Solms, M.L. Michelsen, Fluids 15 (1999) 183.
L. Constantinou, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 47 (2008) 5092. [71] J. Mendez-Santiago, A.S. Teja, Fluid Phase Equilib. 501 (1999) 158.
[21] J.M. Ili
c-Paji
c, M.Z. Stijepovi c, G.R. Ivanis, I.R. Radovi
c, J.T. Staji
c- [72] H.D. Sung, J.J. Shim, J. Chem. Eng. Data 44 (1999) 985.
Trosi
c, M.L. Kijevcanin, J. Serb. Chem. Soc. 82 (2017) 1. [73] D.L. Sparks, R. Hernandez, L.A. Este vez, Chem. Eng. Sci. 63 (2008)

[22] M. Fuenzalida, J. Cuevas-Valenzuela, J.R. Perez-Correa, Fluid Phase 4292.
Equilib. 427 (2016) 308. [74] C. Garlapati, G. Madras, Fluid Phase Equilib. 283 (2009) 97.
[23] S. Tamouza, J. Passarello, P. Tobaly, J. de Hemptinne, Fluid Phase [75] C. Garlapati, G. Madras, Thermochim. Acta 500 (2010) 123.
Equilib. 222 (2004) 36. [76] S. Jafari Nejad, H. Abolghasemi, M.A. Moosavian, M.G. Maragheh,
[24] S. tamouza, J.P. Passarello, P. Tobaly, J.C. Hemptinne, Fluid Phase Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 88 (2010) 893.
Equilib. 228e229 (2005) 409. [77] R. Ch, G. Madras, Thermochim. Acta 99 (2010) 507.
[25] Y. Peng, K.D. Goff, M.C. dos Ramos, C. McCabe, Fluid Phase Equilib. [78] K. Keshmiri, A. Vatanara, Y. Yamini, Fluid Phase Equilib. 363
277 (2009) 131. (2014) 8.
[26] Y. Peng, K.D. Goff, M.C. dos Ramos, C. McCabe, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. [79] S.B. Hozhabr, S.H. Mazloumi, J. Sargolzaei, Chem. Eng. Res. Des. 92
49 (2010) 1378. (2014) 2734.
[27] M.C. dos Ramos, J.D. Haley, J.R. Westwood, C. McCabe, Fluid Phase [80] B.E. Poling, J.M. Prausnitz, J.P. O'Connell, Properties of Gases and
Equilib. 306 (2011) 97. Liquids, 5th ed., McGraw-Hill Education, New York, 2001.
[28] G.M.C. Silva, P. Mogado, J.D. Haley, V.M.T. Montoya, C. McCabe, [81] H. Uchida, I. Usui, A. Fuchita, M. Matsuoka, J. Chem. Eng. Data 49
L.F.G. Martins, E.J.M. Filipe, Fluid Phase Equilib. 425 (2016) 297. (2004) 1560.
[29] J.D. Haley, C. McCabe, Fluid Phase Equilib. 440 (2017) 111. [82] A. Karami, Y. Yamini, A. Ghiasvand, H. Sharghi, M. Shamsipur, J.
[30] J.D. Haley, C. McCabe, Fluid Phase Equilib. 446 (2017) 46. Chem. Eng. Data 46 (2001) 1371.
[31] M.H. Anvari, G. Pazuki, J. Supercrit. Fluids 90 (2014) 73. [83] N. Lamba, R.C. Narayan, J. Modak, G. Madras, J. Supercrit. Fluids 107
[32] J.D. Haley, C. McCabe, Fluid Phase Equilib. 411 (2016) 43. (2016) 384.
[33] A. Lymperiadis, C.S. Adjiman, A. Galindo, G. Jackson, J. Chem. Phys. [84] S.N. Reddy, G. Madras, J. Chem. Eng. Data 56 (2011) 1695.
127 (2007) 234903. [85] M. Shamsipur, A. Karami, Y. Yamini, H. Sharghi, A. Salimi, J. Chem.
[34] V. Papaioannou, C.S. Adjiman, G. Jackson, A. Galindo, Fluid Phase Eng. Data 48 (2003) 1088.
Equilib. 306 (2011) 82. [86] J.-F. Liu, H.-J. Yang, W. Wang, Z. Li, J. Chem. Eng. Data 53
[35] F.A. Perdomo, B.M. Millan, J.L. Aragon, Energy 72 (2014) 274. (2008) 2189.
[36] C. Zhong, H. Yang, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 41 (2002) 4899. [87] I. Medina, J. Bueno, J. Chem. Eng. Data 46 (2001) 1211.
[37] H. Yang, C. Zhong, J. Supercrit. Fluids 33 (2005) 99. [88] M. Shamsipur, M.R. Fat'hi, Y. Yamini, A.R. Ghiasvand, J. Supercrit.
[38] A. Abdallah El Hadj, C. Si-Moussa, S. Hanini, M. Laidi, Chem. Ind. Fluids 23 (2002) 225.
Chem. Eng. Q. 19 (2013) 449. [89] J.W. Chen, F.N. Tsai, Fluid Phase Equilib. 107 (2) (1995) 189.
[39] Y. Shimoyama, Y. Iwai, J. Supercrit. Fluids 50 (2009) 210. [90] Q. Li, Z. Zhang, C. Zhong, Y. Liu, Q. Zhou, Fluid Phase Equilib. 207
[40] L.-H. Wang, S.-T. Lin, J. Supercrit. Fluids 85 (2014) 81. (2003) 183.
[41] L.-H. Wang, C.-M. Hsieh, S.-T. Lin, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 54 (41) [91] D. Suleiman, L. Este vez, J. Pulido, J. Garcı
a, C. Mojica, J. Chem. Eng.
(2015) 10115. Data 50 (2005) 1234.
[42] Y.-S. Ting, C.-M. Hsieh, Fluid Phase Equilib. 431 (2017) 48.
[92] J.P. Coelho, K. Bernotaityte, M.A. Miraldes, A.F. Mendonc, [137] M. Lashkarbolooki, A.Z. Hezave, Y. Rahnama, R. Ozlati, H. Rajaei,
R.P. Stateva, J. Chem. Eng. Data 54 (2009) 2546. F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Supercrit. Fluids 84 (2013) 13.
[93] H. Higashi, Y. Iwai, K. Miyazaki, Y. Ogino, M. Oki, Y. Arai, J. [138] M. Asghari-Khiavi, Y. Yamini, M.A. Farajzadeh, J. Supercrit. Fluids
Supercrit. Fluids 33 (2005) 15. 30 (2004) 111.
[94] B. Agustin, S.-Y. Lin, A. Kurniawan, Y.-H. Ju, F.E. Soetaredjo, [139] C. Tang, Y.-X. Guan, S.-J. Yao, Z.-Q. Zhu, J. Chem. Eng. Data 59 (11)
S. Ismadji, Fluid Phase Equilib. 354 (2013) 127. (2014) 3359.
[95] Y. Li, Y. Ning, J. Jin, Z. Zhang, J. Chem. Eng. Data 58 (2013) 2176. [140] A.G. Reveco-Chilla, A.L. Cabrera, J.C. de la Fuente, F.C. Zacconi,
[96] Y.-M. Chen, Y.-P. Chen, Fluid Phase Equilib. 282 (2009) 82. J.M. del Valle, L.M. Valenzuela, Fluid Phase Equilib. 423 (2016)
[97] J.-S. Jin, X. Fan, H. Zhang, Y.-W. Wang, Z.-T. Zhang, J. Chem. Eng. 84.
Data 59 (2014) 2095. [141] A. Hezave, F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Chem. Eng. Data 57 (2012) 1659.
[98] J.-S. Jin, Y.-W. Wang, H.-F. Zhang, X. Fan, H. Wu, J. Chem. Eng. Data [142] P. Coimbra, D. Fernandes, M. Gil, H. Sousa, J. Chem. Eng. Data 53
59 (2014) 1521. (2008) 1990.
[99] Y. Jing, Y. Hou, W. Wu, W. Liu, B. Zhang, J. Chem. Eng. Data 56 [143] Y. Xie, H.-J. Yang, W. Wang, R. Chen, J. Chem. Eng. Data 54 (2009)
(2011) 298. 102.
[100] Y. Yamini, N. Bahramifar, J. Chem. Eng. Data 45 (2000) 1129. [144] J.-L. Ciou, C.-S. Su, J. Supercrit. Fluids 107 (2016) 753.
[101] S. Kazemi, V. Belandria, N. Janssen, D. Richon, C. Peters, C. Kroon, J. [145] Y. Yamini, P. Kalantarian, M. Hojjati, A. Esrafily, M. Moradi,
Supercrit. Fluids 9 (2012) 1016. A. Vatanara, I. Harrian, J. Chem. Eng. Data 55 (2010) 1056.
[102] A.B.S. Rosa, S. Marceneiro, M.E.M. Braga, A.M.A. Dias, H.C. Sousa, J. [146] F. Edi-Soetaredjo, S. Ismadji, Y.-H. Ju, Fluid Phase Equilib. 340
Supercrit. Fluids 98 (2015) 70. (2013) 7.
[103] E. Sahle-Demessie, U.R. Pillai, S. Junsophonsri, K.L. Levien, J. Chem. [147] S.-H. Cheng, F.-C. Yang, Y.-H. Yang, C.-C. Hu, W.-T. Chang, J. Taiwan
Eng. Data 48 (2003) 541. Inst. Chem. Eng. 44 (2013) 19.
[104] J. Jin, Y. Wang, H. Wu, J. Li, Z. Zhang, Fluid Phase Equilib. 334 [148] C.-y. Jiang, Z.-J. Sun, Q.-M. Pan, J.-B. Pi, J. Chem. Eng. Data 57 (2012)
(2012) 152. 1794.
[105] A. Sabegh, H. Rajaei, A. Hezave, F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Chem. Eng. Data [149] H. Sovova, J. Chem. Eng. Data 46 (2001) 1255.
57 (2012) 2750. [150] L. Barna, J.-M. Blanchard, E. Rauzy, C. Berro, J. Chem. Eng. Data 41
[106] M. Hojjati, A. Vatanara, Y. Yaminia, M. Moradi, A.R. Najafabadi, J. (1996) 1466.
Supercrit. Fluids 50 (2009) 203. [151] A. Hezave, H. Rajaei, M. Lashkarbolooki, F. Esmaeilzadeh, J.
[107] Z. Huang, W.D. Lu, S. Kawi, Y.C. Chiew, J. Chem. Eng. Data 49 (2004) Supercrit. Fluids 73 (2013) 57.
1323. [152] A. Duarte, P. Coimbra, H. Sousa, C. Duarte, J. Chem. Eng. Data 49
[108] M. Hojjati, Y. Yamini, M. Khajeh, A. Vatanara, J. Supercrit. Fluids 41 (2004) 449.
(2007) 187. [153] S.A. Shojaee, A.Z. Hezave, S. Aftab, M. Lashkarbolooki,
[109] Y. Yamini, J. Hassan, S. Haghgo, J. Chem. Eng. Data 46 (2001) 451. F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Supercrit. Fluids 78 (2013) 1.
[110] S. Ismadji, Y.-H. Ju, F.E. Soetaredjo, A. Ayucitra, J. Chem. Eng. Data [154] J. Lim, H. Kim, H.K. Cho, M. Sam Shin, Korean J. Chem. Eng. 28 (12)
56 (2011) 4396. (2011) 2319.
[111] D. Sparks, R. Hernandez, L. Este vez, N. Meyer, T. French, J. Chem. [155] M. Charoenchaitrakool, F. Dehghani, N.R. Foster, Ind. Eng. Chem.
Eng. Data 52 (2007) 1246. Res. 39 (2000) 4794.
[112] S. Maeda, K. Mishima, K. Matsuyama, M. Baba, T. Hirabaru, [156] E. Jara-Morante, D. Suleiman, L.A. Estvez, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 42
H. Ishikawa, K.-I. Hayashi, J. Chem. Eng. Data 46 (2001) 647. (2003) 1821.
[113] A. Vatanara, A.R. Najafabadi, M. Khajeh, Y. Yamini, J. Supercrit. [157] M. Sam Shin, H. Kim, Fluid Phase Equilib. 270 (2008) 45.
Fluids 33 (2005) 21. [158] R. Heryanto, A.E. Chan, M. Hasan, J. Chem. Eng. Data 55 (2010)
[114] J.-S. Jin, J.-B. Wang, Z.-T. Zhang, H.-T. Liu, Thermochim. Acta 527 2306.
(2012) 165. [159] S. Marceneiro, P. Coimbra, M. Braga, A. Dias, H. Sousa, Fluid Phase
[115] A. Garmroodi, J. Hassan, Y. Yamini, J. Chem. Eng. Data 49 (2004) Equilib. 311 (2011) 1.
709. [160] A. Stassi, R. Bettini, A. Gazzaniga, F. Giordano, A. Schiraldi, J. Chem.
[116] K.-W. Cheng, M. Tang, Y.-P. Chen, Fluid Phase Equilib. 201 Eng. Data 45 (2000) 161.
(2002) 79. [161] Y. Yamini, M. Tayyebi, M. Moradi, A. Vatanara, Thermochim. Acta
[117] M. Asghari-Khiavi, Y. Yamini, J. Chem. Eng. Data 48 (2003) 61. 569 (2013) 48.
[118] M. Johannsen, G. Brunner, Fluid Phase Equilib. 95 (1994) 215. [162] J. Fan, Y. Hou, W. Wu, J. Zhang, S. Ren, X. Chen, J. Chem. Eng. Data
[119] H. Perrotin-Brunel, M. Roosmalen, M. Kroon, J. Spronsen, G.- 55 (2010) 2316.
J. Witkamp, C. Peters, J. Chem. Eng. Data 55 (2010) 3704. [163] A. Hezave, M. Khademi, F. Esmaeilzadeh, Fluid Phase Equilib. 313
[120] Y. Yamini, M. Hojjati, P. Kalantarian, M. Moradi, A. Esrafili, (2012) 140.
A. Vatanara, Thermochim. Acta 549 (2012) 95. [164] H. Sousa, M. Sousa Costa, P. Coimbra, A. Matias, C. Duarte, J.
[121] S.A. Shojaee, H. Rajaei, A.Z. Hezave, M. Lashkarbolooki, Supercrit. Fluids 63 (2012) 40.
F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Supercrit. Fluids 81 (2013) 42. [165] Y. Yamini, J. Arab, M. Asghari-khiavi, J. Pharmaceut. Biomed. 32
[122] M. Khamda, M. Hosseini, M. Rezaee, J. Supercrit. Fluids 73 (2003) 181.
(2013) 130. [166] R. Murga, M.T. Sanz, S. Beltran, J.L. Cabezas, J. Supercrit. Fluids 23
[123] C.-C. Tsai, H.-M. Lin, M.-J. Lee, J. Supercrit. Fluids 95 (2014) 17. (2002) 113.
[124] A.Z. Hezave, A. Mowla, F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Supercrit. Fluids 58 [167] S. Ismadji, Chem. Eng. Data 53 (2008) 2207.
(2011) 198. [168] C.-S. Su, Y.-P. Chen, J. Supercrit. Fluids 43 (2008) 438.
[125] C.-A. Lee, M. Tang, S.-L. Ho, Y.-P. Chen, J. Supercrit. Fluids 85 [169] S. Ting, S. Macnaughton, S. Tomasko, S. Foster, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res.
(2014) 11. 32 (1993) 1471.
[126] M. Lashkarbolooki, A.Z. Hezave, Y. Rahnama, H. Rajaei, [170] P. Kotnik, M. Skerget, Z. Knez, J. Chem. Eng. Data 56 (2011) 338.
F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Supercrit. Fluids 84 (2013) 29. [171] Z. Knez, M. Skerget, P. Sencar-Bozic, A. Rizner, J. Chem. Eng. Data
[127] Z. Huang, S. Kawi, Y.C. Chiew, J. Supercrit. Fluids 30 (2004) 25. 40 (1995) 216.
[128] C.-A. Lee, M. Tang, Y.-P. Chen, Fluid Phase Equilib. 367 (2014) [172] S. Zhan, L. Cui, Q. Zhao, L. Chen, J. Wang, S. Chen, S. Ding, J. Solution
182. Chem. 44 (2014) 1.
[129] C.I. Park, M.S. Shin, H. Kim, J. Chem. Thermodyn. 41 (2009) 30. [173] R. Chim, S. Marceneiro, M. Braga, A. Dias, H. Sousa, Fluid Phase
[130] H. Asiabi, Y. Yamini, M. Tayyebi, M. Moradi, A. Vatanara, Equilib. 331 (2012) 6.
K. Keshmiri, J. Supercrit. Fluids 78 (2013) 28. [174] Z. Tang, J.-S. Jin, Z.-T. Zhang, H.-T. Liu, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 51
[131] H. Li, D. Jia, Q. Zhu, B. Shen, Fluid Phase Equilib. 392 (2015) 95. (2012) 5515.
[132] Y.-M. Chen, P.-C. Lin, M. Tang, Y.-P. Chen, J. Supercrit. Fluids 52 [175] J. Jin, Z.-M. Dou, G.-X. Su, Z.-T. Zhang, H.-T. Liu, Fluid Phase Equilib.
(2010) 175. 315 (2012) 9.
[133] Y. Yamini, M. Moradi, J. Chem. Thermodyn. 43 (2011) 1091. [176] B. Su, H. Xing, Y. Yang, Q. Ren, J. Chem. Eng. Data 53 (2008) 1672
[134] M.H. Hosseini, N. Alizadeh, A. Khanchi, J. Supercrit. Fluids 52 e1674.
(2010) 30. [177] M. Ko, V. Shah, P.R. Bienkowski, H.D. Cochran, J. Supercrit. Fluids 4
[135] A.C. Kumoro, J. Chem. Eng. Data 56 (2011) 2181. (1991) 32.
[136] J.R. Dean, M. Kane, S. Khundke, C. Dowle, R.L. Tranter, P. Jones, [178] G. Lez, M. Molina, F. Rodrıguez, F. Mirada, J. Chem. Eng. Data 46
Analyst 120 (1995) 2153. (2001) 918.
[179] H. Rajaei, A.Z. Hezave, M. Lashkarbolooki, F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. [188] J. Ke, C. Mao, M. Zhong, B. Han, H. Yan, J. Supercrit. Fluids 9
Supercrit. Fluids 75 (2013) 181. (1996) 82.
[180] R.D. Weinstein, J.J. Gribbin, K.R. Muske, J. Chem. Eng. Data 50 [189] A.Z. Hezave, S. Shahnazar, H. Rajaei, M. Lashkarbolooki,
(2005) 226. F. Esmaeilzadeh, Fluid Phase Equilib. 355 (2013) 130.
[181] S.A. Shojaee, H. Rajaei, A.Z. Hezave, M. Lashkarbolooki, [190] A. Hezave, S. Aftab, F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Supercrit. Fluids 68
F. Esmaeilzadeh, J. Supercrit. Fluids 80 (2013) 38. (2012) 39.
[182] Z.-T. Zhang, W.-M. Li, J.-S. Jin, G.-H. Tian, J. Chem. Eng. Data 53 [191] R. Murga, M.T. Sanz, S. Beltra n, J.L. Cabezas, J. Chem. Eng. Data 49
(2008) 600. (2004) 779.
[183] J.-S. Jin, Y.-Y. Ning, K. Hu, H. Wu, Z.-T. Zhang, J. Chem. Eng. Data 58 [192] Y. Sun, S. Li, C. Quan, J. Chem. Eng. Data 50 (2005) 1125.
(2013) 1464. [193] S. Milovanovic, M. Stamenic, D. Markovic, M. Radetic, I. Zizovic, J.
[184] J.-S. Jin, Z.-T. Zhang, Q.-S. Li, Y. Li, E.-P. Yu, J. Chem. Eng. Data 50 Supercrit. Fluids 84 (2013) 173.
(2005) 801. [194] T. Liu, S. Li, R. Zhou, D. Jia, S. Tian, J. Chem. Eng.Data 54 (2009)
[185] J. Li, J. Jin, Z.-T. Zhang, X.-M. Pei, J. Chem. Eng. Data 54 (2009) 1913.
1142. [195] R. Zhou, S. Li, T. Liu, J. Chem. Eng. Data 53 (2008) 2679.
[186] Z.-B. Bao, Z.-J. Wei, B.-G. Su, Q.-L. Ren, J. Chem. Eng. Data 51 (2006) [196] D. Kostrzewa, A. Dobrzyn ska-Inger, E. Roj, Fluid Phase Equilib. 360
1731. (2013) 445.
[187] Y. Yamini, M.R. Fat'hi, N. Alizadeh, M. Shamsipur, Fluid Phase
Equilib. 152 (1998) 299.

Belghait May 2018

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Belghait May 2018

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Belghait May 2018

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

C. R.

Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Comptes Rendus Chimie

Semi-empirical correlation of solid solute solubility in

1. Introduction new green biotechnological processes, and so forth [1,2].

Model Equation Equation no. Reference

Jouyban et al. ln y2 ¼ a0 þ a1 P þ a2 P 2 þ a3 PT þ a4 TP þ a5 ln r1 (18) [58]

with c*2 ¼ rc2 ; rr;1 ¼ rr1 ; Tr ¼ T

Garlapati et Madras ln y2 ¼ a0 ln r1 þ aT1 þ a2 (20) [74]

No. Solid solute Mw (g/mol) T (K) P (MPa) y2 104 Ni Reference

1 (S)-Boc-piperazine 285.3900 308.20e328.20 90.10e205.00 13.70e65.20 21 [81]

No. Solid solute Mw (g/mol) T (K) P (MPa) y2 104 Ni Reference

69 Cinnarizine 368.5000 308.15e328.15 139.70e240.00 0.03e2.05 21 [128]

No. Solid solute Mw (g/mol) T (K) P (MPa) y2 104 Ni Reference

140 Methylparaben 152.1473 308.00e348.00 122.00e355.00 1.08e12.13 40 [117]

A. Belghait et al. / C. R. Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513

A. Belghait et al. / C. R. Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513

A. Belghait et al. / C. R. Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513

A. Belghait et al. / C. R. Chimie 21 (2018) 494e513

Z SCF ¼ ZðT; P; y2 Þ (6)

required solute properties [3,4,38].

V2s P V2s P2sub 1

The volumetric properties of the solvent are governed

related to the density and the coefﬁcient of compressibility

All of the density-based models that have been pro-

mation to the right-hand side of Eq. 9, which generally does

not require any solute property. The next section presents a

2.1. Density-based model for correlation of solid solubility

In a recent article [57], we have presented an extensive

review of density-based empirical models. Chronologies of

their development, the experimental ﬁndings, and theo-

been presented. Table 1 shows semiempirical models used

to correlate the experimental solubility data that have

cades with the aim of improving the quality of correlation

properties, which are not readily available for compounds

of interest such as pharmaceuticals and dyes, have not

bility of the solid solute in mole fraction, r1 is the density

of the SCF (in kilograms per cubic meter), T is the tem-

sents the characteristic parameters determined by ﬁtting

the Sparks et al. [73] model, solubility is expressed in a

dimensionless form, whereas in the Bain et al. [64] model

both models c2 is related to y2 by Eq. 24a, in which Mw1

solute, respectively. It is worth mentioning that some of

the models do not relate the solubility explicitly to the

previous work [57] is based on the following facts: (1)

temperature, pressure, and the density of the SCF violate

r1) of scCO2 are governed by the phase rule, hence only

3 (10) 18.80 5 (21) 12.69

Fig. 1. The number of systems best correlated by each model equation.

(12.63%) compared to Si-Moussa et al. [57] model (Eq. 30)

the present study, where there is a net difference between

the correlation performance of the two equations (AARD of

data by the proposed correlation versus experimental data.

You might also like