Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                
Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 116 views

    Possible Counterclaim

    Uploaded by

    Keyaru Healer
    While dogs are often seen as more easily trainable and able to perform tasks, the document argues that cats should not be underestimated in their intelligence and abilities. Both cats and dogs can form strong bonds with humans, though they show affection differently, and both can offer a sense of protection and entertainment to their owners. The document counters common claims about the superiority of dogs by pointing out cats' problem-solving skills, independence, hunting abilities, and capacity for developing deep relationships with humans.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Possible Counterclaim

    Uploaded by

    Keyaru Healer
    116 views4 pages
    While dogs are often seen as more easily trainable and able to perform tasks, the document argues that cats should not be underestimated in their intelligence and abilities. Both cats and dogs can form strong bonds with humans, though they show affection differently, and both can offer a sense of protection and entertainment to their owners. The document counters common claims about the superiority of dogs by pointing out cats' problem-solving skills, independence, hunting abilities, and capacity for developing deep relationships with humans.

    Original Description:

    Counter claim

    Original Title

    Possible counterclaim

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    While dogs are often seen as more easily trainable and able to perform tasks, the document argues that cats should not be underestimated in their intelligence and abilities. Both cats and dogs can form strong bonds with humans, though they show affection differently, and both can offer a sense of protection and entertainment to their owners. The document counters common claims about the superiority of dogs by pointing out cats' problem-solving skills, independence, hunting abilities, and capacity for developing deep relationships with humans.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    116 views4 pages

    Possible Counterclaim

    Uploaded by

    Keyaru Healer
    While dogs are often seen as more easily trainable and able to perform tasks, the document argues that cats should not be underestimated in their intelligence and abilities. Both cats and dogs can form strong bonds with humans, though they show affection differently, and both can offer a sense of protection and entertainment to their owners. The document counters common claims about the superiority of dogs by pointing out cats' problem-solving skills, independence, hunting abilities, and capacity for developing deep relationships with humans.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 4

    DOGS V.

    S CATS

    Based on “Best Pet Boarding Delhi Gurgaon, dog daycare service, pet bathing &
    grooming. (2023, September 21). https://www.anotherhome.in/blog/10-
    reasons-dogs-are-better-than-cats”. These are the possible claims of why are
    dogs are the best

    Statement 1: Dogs Help You To Stay Active And Fit


    Counterclaim 1: It's crucial to remember that cats can also support a healthy
    lifestyle, even while dogs are undoubtedly active animals and can inspire their
    owners to exercise. Cats are inherently lively, and interactive playtime with toys
    may keep both the cats and their owners engaged. To make sure their feline
    companions get outside exercise, some cat owners even lead and harness their
    feline companions on walks.

    Statement 2: Dogs Adapt Better to Atmosphere


    Counterclaim 2: Cats may adapt to new circumstances with time and
    consideration, while dogs may seem to do so more rapidly. Cats are
    renowned for their independence, which enables them to feel confident in
    a variety of living situations and get comfortable there. For people who
    cherish their independence, they might initially take a little longer to get
    used to, although this does not necessarily make them less acceptable as
    pets.

    Statement 3: Dogs Are Easy to Train


    Counterclaim 3:Because of their inherent desire to please their humans,
    dogs are frequently easier to train than cats. Cats may, however, be
    trained to perform tricks and comply with orders, particularly when the
    process is patiently carried out and rewarding. Cats can be just as
    enjoyable to train as dogs, even though it may take more time and effort.
    Statement 4: Dogs are Human’s Best Friend
    Counterclaim 4: Science has finally proven that cats are just as competent
    as their canine counterparts to position themselves as man’s best friends.
    Cats’ enigmatic personalities have unfairly led to assumptions that their
    aloofness demonstrates an inability to connect and bond with humans.
    But researchers at Oregon State University found that cats are able to —
    and do — form strong bonds with humans much the same way dogs do. In a
    study published in Cell Press, the lead author Kristyn Vitale said cats
    “share social traits once attributed to dogs and humans.” Scientists
    conducted tests on more than 100 cats to measure how strongly they
    connected with humans after short absences. Similar tests had been done
    on dogs and primates. Their findings? Much like apes and dogs, cats form
    secure and insecure bonds with their human caretakers. "Like dogs, cats
    display social flexibility in regard to their attachments with humans,"
    Vitale said in a statement. "The majority of cats are securely attached to
    their owners and use them as a source of security in a novel environment…
    Your cat is depending on you to feel secure when they are stressed out.”
    Another scientific study conducted in 2011 and reported in TIME also
    concluded that cats and their human caretakers “form strong social bonds
    and a mutual understanding based on affection—and maybe just a little
    indulgence.” The report further stated, “The study showed that the
    dynamics underlying the relationship between mutually adoring cats and
    their humans are nearly identical to human-to-human bonds.” So move
    over Fido! Cats have equal rights to be considered as man’s best friend.

    REFERENCE: Kurghinyan, A. (2019). Science proves cats are man’s best


    friends. Modkat. https://modkat.com/blogs/modkat-purrr/study-concludes-
    cats-have-what-it-takes-to-be-man-s-best-friend

    It's crucial to understand that although cats can also develop close
    relationships with their owners. Cats can express their affection in a variety of
    ways, like as headbutting, purring, and cuddling up next to their owners. The
    emotional bond between cats and their owners can be equally as strong and
    significant as it is with dogs, despite the differences in how they display their
    love.
    Statement 5: Dogs act as a medium of safety and protection
    Counterclaim 5: Cats are often stereotyped as standoffish and aloof, even to
    the people who love them most, but the truth is that cats can be just as
    protective of their people as dogs are of theirs. Put simply, cats love their
    family and their family loves them right back. In a groundbreaking study
    published in 2011, researchers showed for the first time that "cat-human
    relationships are nearly identical to human-only bonds," according to NBC
    News.

    You might not realize how closely your cat pays attention to where you are and
    what you're doing. Petful highlights a cat who protected a child from a dog
    attack as well as numerous cats who alerted their humans to medical
    emergencies, including cancer and carbon monoxide poisoning. Kitties use their
    razor-sharp hearing and smelling abilities to keep their pet parents safe.

    More frequently, cats try to protect their pet parents from people they
    consider to be dangerous. Although cats are fierce predators, humans can seem
    big and scary to some cats. It's instinctual for a cat to defend their territory and
    yours.

    REFERENCE: Colgate. (2022). Are cats protective of their humans? Hill’s


    Pet Nutrition. https://www.hillspet.com/cat-care/behavior-appearance/are-
    cats-protective-of-humans?lightboxfired=true#

    Cats can also give a sense of security, but dogs are frequently thought of as
    protective creatures and may bark or act aggressively in response to potential
    threats. Because of their propensity for attentiveness, cats can serve as a
    deterrent to pests like rats. When they perceive danger, certain cats may
    vocalize or hide, which can act as an early warning system for their owners.
    Statement 6: Dogs are a medium of laughing & Entertainment
    Counterclaim 6: A cat has the ability to both calm your nervous system and
    provide an immediate outlet for fun and play. Although cats are independent
    animals who like to scavenge and explore on their own terms, they are also very
    affectionate with their owners and people they trust. One of the great benefits
    of owning a cat is that you don’t need much space to play and have fun
    together. Unlike large animals who need plenty of space to play fetch or run
    around, all you need with a cat is your living room and a little imagination.
    Beyond a ball of yarn, there are plenty of other ways to entertain and bond with
    a cat.
    Play hide and seek. An old childhood sleepover favorite can now become you
    and your fluff ball’s favorite pastime. Just hide a toy or an object that
    interests them under a blanket, and watch your cat scavenge.
    Use an app. iPhone and Android applications offer games to keep your cat
    entertained, including catching fish or bugs as they appear on screen. See
    the Get more help section below for more information.

    REFERENCE: Segal, R., MA. (2023). The joys of owning a cat. HelpGuide.org.
    https://www.helpguide.org/articles/healthy-living/joys-of-owning-a-
    cat.htm#:~:text=A%20cat%20has%20the%20ability,owners%20and%20people%
    20they%20trust.

    Cats can playfully misbehave by chasing laser pointers or pounce on feather


    toys, for example. Additionally, many cat owners find pleasure and satisfaction
    in the calming influence of a cat's presence, as they watch them cuddle up on
    their lap or purr happily.

    Statement 7: Dogs are Cleaver and Smarter


    Counterclaim 7: Cats are generally considered smarter than dogs, just because
    of their more independent nature and ability to solve problems on their own.
    But dogs are known as more trainable, able to learn a wide variety of tricks, and
    even perform jobs like search and rescue. But what does it mean to be smart?
    Comparing animal intelligence is challenging because intelligence is hard to
    define, and different species have different types of intelligence. For example, a
    bird may be fantastic at navigating large distances but unable to solve a basic
    puzzle.
    So, what does intelligence mean for dogs and cats? Can we compare cat IQ vs
    dog IQ? Not exactly. There’s cognitive intelligence, which includes problem-
    solving, memory, and emotional intelligence, but there is also practical
    intelligence, which refers to an animal’s ability to survive and thrive in the wild.
    In this regard, cats are better hunters than dogs, but dogs are more emotionally
    intelligent, having adapted over time to understand humans.

    REFERENCE: Cats vs. Dogs: Exploring Feline Intelligence and Canine IQ.
    (n.d.).https://www.thewildest.com/pet-behavior/are-cats-smarter-than
    dogs#:~:text=Are%20cats%20really%20smarter%20than,jobs%20like%20search
    %20and%20rescue.

    Cats, however, possess a distinct brain and set of instincts. They are skilled
    hunters and thinkers of solutions. They have proven useful in reducing insect
    populations, which can be crucial in some circumstances, because to their
    excellent senses and hunting skills.

    You might also like