Funding and Profitability of Cyber Crime
Funding and Profitability of Cyber Crime
Funding and Profitability of Cyber Crime
6708205H8.:61YH>=940>:9/2
z{Q|^}I~
uPJK_JNQ̀JKQvMOwU`x_a_UTQOyQRTxLMQRM_VL
,-./01234015670819::95;0821980143:.<9:0=176195:.<.241381>9:.3>9/1.>:0802:?1:-0149.>1=8.<0813@156708158.401.21A83B:97./.:6C1D>1:-.21/0223>?1E0F//10G94.>019
@0E140:-3=213@1-3E156708158.4.>9/2149;019>=1H201:-0.8143>06C
IJKLMNMOPJKQLROSTSULV
W-01B82:10/040>:1:-9:1.21<.:9/1:31:-0156708158.401053>3461.2191:-8.<.>X1.>:08>9:.3>9/1498;0:A/950149=01HA13@1-H>=80=213@1@38H42?1A/9:@3842?19>=
262:042C1,.:-.>1:-.21498;0:10><.83>40>:?158.4.>9/217H619>=120//1=9:9?1.=0>:.:.02?19>=1:33/21:3149;01A83B:C1Y3810G94A/0?191<086153443>1980913@1.>:0802:
.2143>061/9H>=08.>XC1Z-3H/=156708158.4.>9/212:09/12340143>061@834191<.5:.4?1:-061>00=1:31-9<019140:-3=1:3149;01:-012:3/0>143>061H297/019>=1.=09//6
H>:895097/0C1W-06159>1=31:-.21761H2.>X191[8=1A98:612A05.9/.2:1.>19>13H:23H85.>X\/.;0149>>08C
].;0191:89=.:.3>9/1053>346?12A05.9/.241=8.<0210@B5.0>5.0219>=19//3E2158.4.>9/21:31@35H213>1E-9:1:-061095-1=31702:C
^J_U_`aQR`SbQ_JcLRU_OJ
Z3?1E.:-191498;0:A/950120:1HA?1-3E1=3158.4.>9/21X0:143>06d1e0/3E19801:-8001X0>089/140:-3=21761E-.5-1:-06159>195-.0<01:-.2Cf
ghijkl tW-01432:1=.805:140:-3=1.2158.4.>9/219::04A:.>X1:312:09/143>061@8341:-0.81:98X0:0=1<.5:.4C
mnio t,-./01:-.2159>1701=3>01:-83HX-1534A834.2.>X179>;.>X1262:0421381534A834.2.>X19553H>:2?1:-01432:
pqrhqo 53443>149>>081.21:-83HX-1@89H=1381=050A:.3>C
tW-020125942198013@:0>1:-01s:05-12HAA38:12594s13813:-0812.4./981:8.5;21.>:0>=0=1:31A082H9=0191<.5:.4
:31X.<01:-0158.4.>9/191B>9>5.9/170>0B:12H5-1921X.<.>X19E96179>;1=0:9./219>=1A0823>9/1.>@3849:.3>C
0012312424 567898 96 8
,-./.012 f89:;<=:;>?@A=:=BCD>?9EE;A?<F;=A?>;AG=@;>?<9?@CAAH?9I<?=DD;JCD?<C>K>?<9?A;JIDCA?L;9LD;?CBM
34-56.-7 9AJCB=NC<=9B>O
fPF=>?=>?@9::9BDH?M9B;?I>=BJ?C?M;B=CD?9E?>;AG=@;?QR98S?C<<C@K?<FC<?C<<;:L<>?<9?9G;AD9CM?K;H?LCA<>?9E?C
>;AG=@;O?T9A?=B><CB@;U?C?@A=:=BCD?:CH?9EE;A?<F;?CV=D=<H?E9A?CB?9AJCB=NC<=9B?9A?=BM=G=MICD?<9?M=>CVD;?C
@9:L;<=<9A?9A?A=GCDOW
fXB?<F=>?:9M;DU?<F;?@A=:=BCD?M9;>?B9<?<CK;?:9B;H?EA9:?<F;?G=@<=:O?XB><;CMU?<F;?@A=:=BCD?J;<>?LC=M?VH
<F;?9AJCB=NC<=9B?9A?=BM=G=MICDOW
fYB9<F;A?;ZC:LD;?9E?<F=>?=>?@9:LI<;A?:=>I>;?=B?C?:;A@;BCAH?><HD;O?X:CJ=B;?C?L;A>9B?F=A=BJ?C?@A=:=BCD
<9?><;CD?C?@9:L;<=<9A[>?K;H?=B<;DD;@<ICD?LA9L;A<H?9A?M;><A9H?C?A=GCD\>?MC<CVC>;>O
]^_4-_7` fXB?<F=>?:9M;DU?<F;?@A=:=BCD?JC=B>?<F;?CV=D=<H?<9?M=>AIL<?C?G=@<=:?VH?M=>CVD=BJ?K;H?>H><;:>?9A
3-4/ <FA;C<;B=BJ?<9?M=GIDJ;?>;B>=<=G;?MC<COW
a.b_./ fXB?A;@;B<?H;CA>?<F=>?FC>?V;@9:;?L9LIDCA?c=<F?<F;?CMG;B<?9E?ACB>9:cCA;O?XB?C?ACB>9:cCA;?C<<C@KU?C
G=@<=:\>?K;H?>H><;:>?CBM?dD;>?CA;?;B@AHL<;M?=B?>I@F?C?:CBB;A?<FC<?A;BM;A>?<F;:?=B9L;ACVD;O?P9
A;><9A;?<F;?>H><;:>?CBM?dD;>U?<F;?G=@<=:?=>?C>K;M?<9?LCH?<F;?@A=:=BCD?C?ACB>9:?<9?A;@;=G;?<F;
M;@AHL<=9B?K;HOW
fe<F;A?;Z<9A<=9B?<F;:;M?CLLA9C@F;>?@CB?=B@DIM;?<FA;C<;B=BJ?<9?M=GIDJ;?9AJCB=NC<=9B?9A?@I><9:;A
MC<C?>I@F?C>?;:VCAAC>>=BJ?;Z;@I<=G;?;:C=D>?9A?@I><9:;A?MC<CVC>;>O
W
ghijklmnhhopmiq
eG;A?<F;?DC><?E;c?H;CA>U?<F;A;?FC>?V;;B?C?ACL=M?=B@A;C>;?=B?@AHL<9JACLF=@CDDH?@9B<A9DD;M?@IAA;B@=;>?@CDD;M?mhijklmnhhopmrosO?PF;?9A=J=BCD?@AHL<9@IAA;B@HU
trkmlrpuvwkkjsxyyzrkmlrp{lh|yopy}U?LA9L9>;M?C?B;c?:;<F9M?E9A?:9B;<CAH?;Z@FCBJ;?VC>;M?9B?C?>FCA;M?D;MJ;A?@CDD;M?C?~D9@K@FC=BO?PF=>?@9B@;L<?FC>?V;;B
VI=D<?IL9B?VH?>IV>;I;B<?B;c?@IAA;B@=;>?<FC<?FCG;?V;;B?VI=D<?=B?A;@;B<?H;CA>O
F;B?I>=BJ?CB?CB9BH:9I>?D;MJ;A?9I<>=M;?9E?J9G;AB:;B<?@9B<A9DU?LCH:;B<>?CA;?M;>=JB;M?<9?V;?B;CA?=:L9>>=VD;?<9?A;JIDC<;?9A?VD9@KO?PF=>?:CK;>
@AHL<9@IAA;B@=;>?IBV;D=;GCVDH?I>;EID?E9A?:9B;H?DCIBM;A=BJ?9A?E9A?9<F;A?@A=:=BCD?:CAK;<LDC@;?C@<=G=<=;>O
]C/^?./_:61/612A./09/1?./̀08:-.;/=-F04F.6/2/5:=B=-24/A2-A/<:0@85=-A/2/<=.5./09/B24>2:./>?=5?/:.50:@6
G.;61:0G.6/2-@/65:..-/6?016CJ
aC/^?./B24>2:./281?0:6/38;/2/4=61/09/G-0>-/.B2=4/2@@:.66.6/9:0B/2-01?.:/<2:1;/2-@/6.-@/081/1?./B24>2:./26
2-/.B2=4/21125?B.-1C/^?./03.̀51=F./=6/90:/1?./B24>2:./10/>0:G/0-/1?./F=51=B6Z/B25?=-.6/60/1?.=:/32-G=-A
@.12=46/2-@/01?.:/<266>0:@6/52-/3./6104.-/2-@/6.-1/10/1?./B24>2:./281?0:6CJ/b1/1?=6/<0=-1E/1?.=:/>0:G/=6
@0-.C/^?.;/?2F./2/4=61/09/<266>0:@6/2-@/32-G=-A/40A=-6CJ
cC/I0>E/1?./B24>2:./281?0:/B2;/211.B<1/10/d526?/081d/1?.B6.4F.6/0:/6.44/1?./@.12=46/10/2-01?.:/A2-A/10
_-=6?/1?./<:05.66CJ
eC/^?./5:=B=-24/A2-A/52-/211.B<1/10/40A=-/86=-A/1?./5:.@.-1=246/2-@/B2G./1:2-69.:6/10/B0-.;/B84.6/1?.;
?2F./>0:G.@/>=1?/<:.F=0864;C/D-/1?=6/526.E/1?./B84.6/2:./1;<=5244;/A844=34./0:/@.6<.:21./=-@=F=@8246/>?0
?2F./2A:..@/10/2440>/2/61:.2B/09/B0-.;/1?:08A?/1?.=:/25508-16/=-/.f5?2-A./90:/<2;B.-1C
gC/^0/_-=6?/1?./<:05.66E/1?./5:=B=-24/A2-A/5084@/90:5./1?./B84.6/10/38;/2-@/1:2-69.:/5:;<1058::.-5=.6/10
25508-16/50-1:044.@/3;/1?./A2-ACJb6/600-/26/1?=6/@0-.E/1?./52B<2=A-/=6/50B<4.1.C/h?084@/42>/.-90:5.B.-1
=-F.61=A21./1?./5:=B.E/1?./1:2=4/091.-/.-@6/>=1?/0-4;/1?./B0-.;/B84./3.=-A/1:25.234.C
,