

Barbie Box Office

 Gal Gadot Developing Wonder Woman 3

 AEW All In Main Event

 Loki Season 2 Trailer

 Spy Kids Reboot First Look

 Demon Slayer x K-Pop

 Justice League: Crisis on Infinite Earths Movie

 New Watchmen Movie


 GAMING
o Franchises
o Movies
o TV
o Gaming
o Games
o Systems
o Podcasts
o Video
o Paramount+



 Home
 Gaming

Daggerheart First Impressions: Critical

Role's New TTRPG Blends Crunch and
Narrative Play in Unique Ways
We played Daggerheart, the new TTRPG from Critical Role's Darrington Press, and were
impressed.

By CHRISTIAN HOFFER - August 5, 2023 08:00 am EDT





 0
Daggerheart, the new longform fantasy campaign-style tabletop RPG by Critical
Role's Darrington Press, is a surprising blend of vasty different playstyles that somehow
blend together for a very fun experience. This weekend at Gen Con, ComicBook.com had the
chance to run through basic character creation and a play session with Spenser Starke, the
lead designer of Daggerheart, with Critical Role cast member (and company CEO) Travis
Willingham at the table. When Daggerheart was first announced earlier this year, many
players wondered whether it was intended to be a competitor to Dungeons & Dragons or
could potentially replace D&D as the game used by Critical Role to tell their stories in their
main show. From what we experienced over the four hour game session, Daggerheart may
not be a direct competitor to D&D, but it has a lot of potential to be a major competitor when
its released in the future.

Before diving in too deep into Daggerheart, we will note that it is an original game that
incorporates concepts and mechanics from a number of different tabletop RPGs. The core
system is built from the ground up, but Starke noted during our playthrough that the game
drew inspiration from several sources and existing games. There were elements similar to
mechanics found in at least a half-dozen different games, but it feels unfair to say
that Daggerheart is a rift or a derivative of any of them. Unlike Candela Obscura (and
assumably the Illuminated Worlds game system), Daggerheart isn't a take on or "powered
by" a specific game – it instead uses inspiration from a number of different sources as the
foundation for a new experience.

The heart of Daggerheart is a new 2d12-driven check system. Players make rolls using two
different colored d12s, with one called the "Hope" dice and the other being the "Fear" dice.
When a player makes a check, they call out the result and note whether it's made with Fear or
with Hope, depending on which dice shows a higher number. So, a 9 on the Hope dice and a
7 on the Fear dice is a "16 With Hope," while a 7 on the Hope dice and 9 on the Fear dice is a
"16 With Fear." Advantage and disadvantage were factored in with the use of a d6. A roll
with advantage added the d6 to the result, while disadvantage subtracted the d6. Doubles on
the d12s results in a critical success, which is a success with no negative consequence and
usually a narrative bonus on the result.

Hope and fear drive some of the basic narrative flow of the game. A roll made with hope
typically has a positive consequence, even when the check is a failure. In combat, an attack
roll made with hope means that the players retain initiative and a player character gets to go
next. Additionally, rolls with Hope generate a Hope resource, which can be used to either fuel
various player abilities or aid another player's roll (or their own roll.) A roll with Fear hands
initiative back to the enemy characters and often comes with some sort of narrative
consequence that the Game Master warns players about in advance. For instance, my Rogue
character made an Agility check to run past one enemy to attack a more vulnerable foe. The
roll was made with Fear, so the enemy I ran by was able to attack me as I sprinted. Outside of
combat, Hope and Fear serve as a way to guide the narrative, similar to "Yes And" systems
found in more indie-style TTRPGs.

When creating a character, players have four points to spend across 6 different stats, which
include Strength, Agility, Precision, Presence, Intuition, and Knowledge. Different weapons
and abilities are powered by different resources and players add their corresponding score to
an attack roll or check. For instance, my Rogue had an innate Spellcasting ability that
allowed me to summon a cloud of darkness if I made a successful Agility roll with a pre-set
DC. When asking whether a character could do something or had knowledge about
something, it was up to the GM to decide what ability a player rolled with and what the
results could potentially be. I'll note that player characters often had abilities that gave them
advantage or allowed them to spend Hope or take a point of Stress to gain advantage on
roleplaying and social rolls, which indicated that sessions aren't necessarily driven by
combat.

One of the more intriguing and unique bits of Daggerheart is the card-based system that
players use to choose their character's abilities. Each of the game's classes (which contain a
mix of traditional fantasy classes and new classes like Guardian or Seraph) have certain core
abilities. However, each class has at least two options similar to subclasses that come with an
additional unique ability. Also, each class has two "domains" with different powers
represented via different cards. Players choose two abilities from their class's two domains
when they start the game and choose additional abilities when they level up. A player has no
more than five domain abilities active at once, with other abilities going into a Vault and can
be swapped out during either downtime or some kind of rest. Ancestries and communities are
also represented by cards that are placed on top of a player's character sheet. Each ancestry
and community background also comes with some kind of ability or trait spelled out on the
card, ranging from advantage on certain kinds of checks to a mechanical benefit like extra
armor.

The result of character creation in Daggerheart is a three page character sheet with several
cards placed in different slots and certain pages tucked halfway underneath the "main"
character sheet. However, all of a character's abilities and stats (including spells, weapon
abilities, and more) are represented on the page and there's no need to refer back to a
rulebook for clarity on a specific ability, spell, or rule. Interestingly, Daggerheart seems be
much more geared towards having a physical character sheet in front of players, at least
judging from the use of the cards to inform character creation.

Another interesting system is how HP and armor are used in the game. Players start off with 6
hit points and 5 stress, along with a set of three damage threshold numbers. When a player or
creature successfully makes an attack, they roll damage dice, ranging in size from a d6 to
multiple d20s. If the result of the damage dice roll is below a player's first damage threshold
number, they take a point of stress. If the result is between the first and second damage
threshold, they take minor damage resulting in losing 1 point of HP. Similarly, a result
between the second and third damage threshold results in major damage for 2 points of HP,
while exceeding the third damage threshold results in severe damage for 3 points of HP. Each
player also has an armor score and three armor slots or resources – when they take damage,
they can reduce the damage roll by the number of their armor score. So, if a creatures rolls a
15 on a damage roll, a player with an Armor score of 5 can reduce that damage roll to a 10,
potentially turning a severe damage into a major damage, but at the cost of one of their
Armor resources. (Armor can be repaired as a Short Rest activity.)
Finally, we should mention the Death mechanic of Daggerheart, which is a lot more
meaningful than what we've seen in games like Dungeons & Dragons. When a player runs
out of Hit Points, they have three options – they can choose to die in a blaze in glory with an
automatic critical success on their final action, they can choose to become scarred and
permanently remove one of their hope slots to recover, or they can risk it all by rolling their
hope and fear dice and letting the dice determine their fate. If the hope dice is higher, their
character recovers, but if the fear dice is higher they die. Starke mentioned that there's only
one resurrection spell in Daggerheart that is an one-off ability, so it seems death will have a
higher impact and stakes than in other fantasy TTRPG games.

From a narrative standpoint, Daggerheart seems to be much more of a collaboration between

player and GM than something like Dungeons & Dragons. For our game, Starke went around
the table and asked the players questions about the city we started with, asking us to fill out
the details of the town. We chose the name of the starting town, its defining features, and
what tragedy recently befell it. We also defined the quest we were to go on and what kind of
connections this quest had to each player. This didn't just occur at the beginning of the play
session either, Starke asked us to describe the monsters we were fighting as they arrived on
the battlefield, the major NPCs we interacted with, and even the architecture of the towns.
For our table at least, we were able to riff off of each other's suggestions to organically form
an emerging narrative and story, filled with carapace-armored Horde ruffians and a bearded
wyvern with fire breathe and an earwig-esque pincer tail.

Making the GM and players equal partners in the storytelling seems to be a central ethos
in Daggerheart. Starke mentioned the possibility of providing a blank map with a few
general features to the players, with the players naming the towns and notable points of
interest and letting them build the world that they are about to explore in. There's certainly
room for a traditional D&D-type experience where the GM does all the world building, but
there's also room for something akin to Dungeon World where the game is much more
freeform and concerned with letting the world grow as the story moves. While I think this
kind of collaborative worldbuilding can occasionally result in Mad Libs kinds of
shenanigans, a good party of players who are aligned in what kind of stories they want to tell
will find this narrative structure much more engaging from the get out. A world that the
players help build from the onset is a world where there's no needed buy in from players to
make the game a success - Daggerheart understands that and seems to actively encourage
that.

Obviously, Daggerheart is still in the active playtesting phase and it's clear that the game is
trying to balance and tune a lot of different features before it's ready for sale. However, I
thought it was interesting how the game encourages power gaming (a lot of player abilities
have synergies that can ramp up to do a LOT of damage or provide other awesome moments)
without being too focused on optimal builds and seems to be able to pivot between narrative
freeform and more structured games with built-in rails. More
importantly, Daggerheart seems to be a fully fleshed out game system instead of just a game
built for a specific world, which I think was one of the major concerns of the game when it
was announced.

Although Daggerheart is still a work in progress, I came away very impressed and intrigued
by the new system. I genuinely think that Darrington Press has a hit on their hands. It would
be premature to call Daggerheart a "D&D killer" but I do think it can present a fun
alternative for folks wanting a traditional fantasy TTRPG experience, especially if they don't
want to read a 500-page rulebook to understand the game. There's a really cool balance
between crunch and narrative freedom that Daggerheart offers and the game seemed poised
to make a big splash when it comes out in the next year or so.

0COMMENTS
Related:
 Disney Lorcana Draws Overnight Lines at Gen Con
 Daggerheart Reveals Logo, First Key Art at Gen Con
 Disney Lorcana Will Have Secret Rare Cards
 Welcome to Night Vale TTRPG Announced

Start the Conversation

Daggerheart First Impressions: Critical Role's New TTRPG Blends Crunch and
Narrative Play in Unique Ways
10 Video Games Releasing in August 2023 You Shouldn't Miss
Dungeons & Dragons Responds After Artist Admits to Submitting AI-Enhanced Art for
New Book
Mortal Kombat 1 Gameplay Reveals Johnny Cage's Brutal Fatality
Nintendo Switch Online Users Surprised with New Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom
Freebies

 ENTERTAINMENT
 CELEBRITY
 COMICBOOK
 GAMING
 LIFESTYLE

 ABOUT
  CONTACT
 ADVERTISING
 CAREERS
 PARAMOUNT+

 PRIVACY POLICY
 CALIFORNIA NOTICE
 DMCA
 TERMS OF SERVICE
 MANAGE COOKIES

 REGISTER
 LOGIN

Copyright 2023 ComicBook.com. All rights reserved.


We use cookies and similar technologies to understand how you use our services, improve your experience and
serve you personalized content and advertising as described in our Privacy Policy.
Accept All Reject All
Manage Cookies

UNLOCK THE FULL POWER OF COMICBOOK.COM

Now that we have your attention....

ComicBook covers everything you need to know about

movies, comics, television, games and beyond.

Your browser or blocker is impacting your experience. Click below to access the
full site.
Continue With Ads

Continue without disabling|Need help? Contact support

POWERED BY