EEG and Epilepsy Monitoring.10
EEG and Epilepsy Monitoring.10
EEG and Epilepsy Monitoring.10
KEY POINTS
h Yield of an outpatient For many years, EEGs were re- Sensitivity and Specificity
EEG may be low even in corded with analog recordings that The sensitivity of EEG in various stud-
patients with known then were charted on paper. The ies had ranged from 29% to 55%, with
epilepsy. amplifiers and the frequency response studies showing an average of one-third
h Repeat EEGs over time of the EEG pens limited the ability to of initial EEGs being abnormal.12,13
or sleep deprivation may record higher-frequency activity. More However, the sensitivity improves to
increase the yield. recently, recordings have been digital about 80% to 90% if EEGs are re-
h With an epileptiform
and able to display high frequencies peated over time.14 Timing of EEG is
abnormality on EEG,
when digitized at a high enough rate important, with studies showing 51%
chances of recurrence (at least twice as high as the frequency of EEGs being abnormal if done within
of seizures are high, and that one is interested in). Using a fast 24 hours of a seizure compared to
treatment decisions may sampling rate (2000 Hz) has defined 34% demonstrating abnormalities in
be made even after activity known as fast ripples that occur later EEGs.10
first-time seizures. in the 250- to 600-Hz frequency range Specificity of EEG for diagnosis of
and are more clearly defined when re- epilepsy is fairly high in most studies.
corded intracranially. High-frequency Interictal epileptiform discharges are
oscillations appear to be a biomarker seen rarely in normal adults or chil-
for epileptogenic tissue and in the fu- dren (0.2% to 3%).15 Occipital spikes
ture may be useful to define areas to re- have been reported in normal blind
sect in patients with intractable epilepsy.5 people, and generalized spikes have
been reported in first-degree relatives
USE OF ROUTINE OUTPATIENT of patients with idiopathic generalized
EEG IN DIAGNOSIS OF EPILEPSY epilepsies. Moreover, patients with
EEG is an important diagnostic tool in epilepsies may have normal EEGs.
epilepsy. While clinical history generally Even in those with epileptiform ab-
provides adequate information regard- normalities, localization on an EEG
ing the diagnosis of epilepsy, history may not accurately denote the epi-
may not always aid in establishing an lepsy syndrome. Examples of this are
epilepsy syndrome. Outpatient EEG is the presence of generalized spike-
an important tool along with imaging wave discharges in a small proportion
studies that aid in establishing an of children with benign epilepsy with
epilepsy syndrome.6 Both American centrotemporal spikes, and the pres-
Academy of Neurology and Interna- ence of focal epileptiform discharges
tional League Against Epilepsy guide- (fragmented generalized spike-wave)
lines recommend EEG in diagnosing among patients with generalized epi-
epilepsy in adults and children, with lepsy (Figure 2-2). These findings may
inclusion of photic stimulation, hyper- lead to erroneous diagnosis as far as
ventilation, and sleep deprivation in the epilepsy syndrome is concerned.
adults as part of the protocol.7,8 An Interictal spikes or epileptiform ab-
epileptiform pattern seen on EEG af- normalities may be seen as a result of
ter a first-time seizure often predicts drugs such as cefepime, bupropion,
recurrence of seizures based on stud- lithium, tramadol, and clozapine. Fo-
ies in both adults and children, with cal, multifocal, and diffuse epilepti-
recurrence rates that range from 30% form abnormalities have also been
to 70% in the first year.9Y11 Therefore, reported in metabolic disorders such
when the EEG is epileptiform after a as uremia and thyrotoxicosis and in
first-time seizure, treatment may be con- autoimmune encephalopathies such
sidered even before a diagnosis of epi- as Hashimoto encephalopathy. There-
lepsy is established. fore, the presence of an ‘‘epileptiform
600 www.ContinuumJournal.com June 2013
abnormality’’ does not always mean are most often seen in generalized
epilepsy, and EEG findings should be epilepsiesVespecially childhood ab-
interpreted in the clinical context, sence epilepsy with or without eyelid
albeit with caution. myoclonia, juvenile absence, and myo-
clonic epilepsyVand very rarely in pa-
Photic Stimulation and tients without epilepsy.17
Hyperventilation Hyperventilation is another pro-
Photic stimulation is a useful method cedure that can activate epileptiform
of activating epileptiform discharges abnormalities. Typically, absence sei-
primarily in patients with idiopathic zures are activated with hyperventila-
generalized epilepsy, but also those tion, although epileptiform discharges
with partial epilepsy. Photic driving of in focal epilepsies may be activated
a posterior rhythm is a normal re- as well.18
sponse, and a photomyogenic response
that consists of brief repetitive muscle Sleep Deprivation
activity such as eye blinks seen in Sleep deprivation is an important tool
anterior electrodes that increase in when EEGs are unyielding in provid-
amplitude with flash frequency and ing diagnostic information. In a review
cease when stimulation stops is a of all earlier studies, Ellingson and
normal variant. A photoparoxysmal re- colleagues19 concluded that sleep
sponse (Figure 2-3) that consists of deprivation increases the chances of
generalized spike-wave or polyspike- finding interictal epileptiform dis-
and-wave discharges, which may be charges on an EEG in 30% to 70% of
anterior or posterior dominant, and cases. Similarly, Fountain and col-
that may or may not be associated leagues20 reported an activation rate
with loss of awareness or myoclonic of 52% with sleep deprivation when
jerks, is an abnormal response often baseline EEGs are normal. Further-
associated with epilepsy, especially if it more, activation by sleep deprivation
outlasts duration of the photic stimu- is more common in younger patients
lation, and is often termed photocon- and those with primary generalized
vulsive.16 Photoparoxysmal responses epilepsy syndromes.16,21
FIGURE 2-3 EEG of photoparoxysmal response. Note that the patient is undergoing photic stimulation at 15 Hz (denoted by
Ph at the bottom of the page), during which the patient is initially noted to have a posterior driving response
(higher amplitude beta range activity at the beginning of the page) followed by a generalized spike-wave discharge
that is anteriorly dominant.
FIGURE 2-4 EEG showing frontal intermittent rhythmic delta activity in a 70-year-old patient admitted with mental status
changes. Note the rhythmic high-amplitude delta that waxes and wanes.
FIGURE 2-5 EEG showing triphasic waves in a 48-year-old patient with renal failure and obtundation. Note that the EEG shows
triphasic waveforms that have maximal amplitude anteriorly and an anteroposterior lag.
Case 2-1
A 38-year-old, right-handed man presented with a history of generalized tonic-clonic seizures since
age 12. The seizures occurred relatively rarely, but frequently enough (every 3 to 6 months) to
make it difficult for the patient to obtain a driver’s license; they occurred more often in the context
of sleep deprivation or alcohol use. In addition, the patient described brief episodes of impaired
thought or concentration associated with twitching of one or both sides of his mouth. In some cases
he had a cluster of these before having a generalized tonic-clonic seizure. He used diazepam as
needed to try to abort them and the generalized tonic-clonic seizures. These smaller seizures and
his tonic-clonic seizures had not been controlled despite trials of phenobarbital, phenytoin,
carbamazepine, lamotrigine, valproate, and levetiracetam. It was unclear whether he had frontal
lobe seizures with generalization or a primary generalized epilepsy.
At the time of evaluation, his family history was negative for epilepsy, and a prior EEG had shown
an isolated left frontal sharp wave.
The brief seizures with facial twitching were fairly common and often occurred at night before
sleep or early in the morning.
He was evaluated with continuous video-EEG monitoring and several of his typical smaller
seizures were captured. They were associated with brief (4- to 5-second) episodes of generalized
spike-and-wave discharges occurring at 4 to 5 Hz associated with subtle upper lip twitching
(Figure 2-7). This was diagnostic of absence seizures with perioral myoclonia. He was started on
FIGURE 2-7 EEG recording from the patient described in Case 2-1. The patient felt a brief lapse and twitch
of his jaw. The EEG correlate demonstrated generalized spike-wave activity occurring at 3 to
4 Hz. Note that the patient pushes an event button that identifies he had a seizure.
delays, often last longer than typical EEG in epileptic encephalopa- KEY POINT
absences with gradual onset and offset, thies. EEG patterns seen in epileptic h Many normal variants
and may be associated with atonia, encephalopathies that deserve special can lead to erroneous
diagnosis of epilepsy,
with EEG showing diffuse background mention include hypsarrhythmia seen
such as wicket spikes,
slowing and 2- to 2.5-Hz generalized in West syndrome, slow spike and
small sharp spikes, and
spikes, unlike the 3-Hz spikes seen in wave and paroxysmal fast activity seen 14 and 6 positive spikes.
typical absence epilepsy. Fragments of in Lennox-Gastaut syndrome, continuous
generalized spikes may appear focally spike and wave during slow-wave sleep
within the same record showing gener- seen in Landau-Kleffner syndrome,
alized spikes16 (Figure 2-2). The 3-Hz burst-suppression seen in Ohtahara
spike-wave discharges of childhood ab- syndrome, and polyspike-and-wave
sence epilepsy can be associated with discharges of 3 to 6 Hz with slow
occipital intermittent rhythmic delta background and photosensitivity seen
activity (OIRDA). in progressive myoclonic epilepsies
Slow spike and wave. These patterns (Table 2-2).
are seen in more catastrophic epilepsies
with multiple seizure types and cog- Normal Variants or Benign
nitive dysfunction (eg, Lennox-Gastaut Patterns That May Confuse
syndrome). Slow spike-and-wave dis- the Diagnosis
charges typically occur at 1.5 to 2.5 Hz There are many normal variants that
and are distributed in a generalized can be confused with epileptiform ac-
fashion but can have focal features. tivity and lead to an erroneous diagno-
The background EEG activity is typi- sis (Table 2-3, Figure 2-9). Therefore,
cally slow in these patients, and slow being familiar with these patterns is
spike and wave is associated with atyp- important for a practicing neurologist
ical absence. who reads outpatient EEGs routinely.
Rhythmic temporal delta. Rhythmic Rhythmic midtemporal theta and wick-
temporal delta activity can be encoun- et spikes are the most frequent normal
tered in records of patients with tem- variants on the EEG that can lead to the
poral lobe epilepsy (Figure 2-8). It is erroneous diagnosis of epilepsy.25 In a
rarely encountered in normal popula- study of 35,249 EEGs, benign variants
tion and has a high specificity and were identified in 3.4% of the record-
positive predictive value for temporal ings, with the most common being
lobe epilepsy.24 small sharp spikes (1.85%); others were
FIGURE 2-8 EEG of rhythmic temporal delta activity seen best in the right temporal leads during an abdominal sensation in a
patient with right hippocampal sclerosis. This activity appeared as an ictal pattern but also occurred at other times
without any clinical symptoms. The patient is seizure free after a right anterior temporal lobectomy.
KEY POINT rhythmic midtemporal theta of drows- in the intensive care unit. A patient
h EEG in status epilepticus iness (0.12%), subclinical rhythmic elec- may begin with convulsive status epi-
can show progressive trographic discharges of adults (SREDA) lepticus, and if it is untreated or does
changes.
(0.07%), wicket spikes (0.03%), 6-Hz not respond to treatment, it may
spike and wave (1.02%), and 14 and 6 convert into a nonconvulsive status
positive spikes (0.52%).26 epilepticus.
In humans and animal models, there
EEG PATTERNS IN STATUS is a predictable sequence of EEG pat-
EPILEPTICUS terns in convulsive status epilepticus,
Status epilepticus is rarely encountered and EEG findings vary on an EEG de-
in routine EEGs or in patients with no pending on which stage is captured.27
preexisting epilepsy. The patterns They are the following:
seen on EEG during status epilepticus
depend on the type of status epilep- 1. Discrete seizures
ticus, convulsive versus nonconvulsive; 2. Merging of discrete seizures
the latter can be subdivided into par- 3. Continuous ictal discharges
tial complex status epilepticus, absence 4. Continuous ictal discharges with flat
status epilepticus, or nonconvulsive periods
status epilepticus in a comatose patient 5. Periodic epileptiform discharges
Age
Syndrome Predisposition Clinical Phenotype EEG Pattern
Ohtahara syndrome First 3 mo of life Tonic spasms Burst suppression
West syndrome 4 to 8 mo Epileptic spasms Hypsarrhythmia or modified
hypsarrhythmia
Dravet syndrome 1 to 3 y of age Infantile febrile convulsions Progressive background slowing,
followed by myoclonic jerks, generalized spike-wave and
atypical absences, and focal multifocal spike-wave discharges,
seizures with impaired photosensitivity
awareness
Lennox-Gastaut Peaks at 3 to Tonic, atonic, and atypical Generalized slow spike-and-wave
syndrome 5 y of age absence seizures discharges and paroxysms of
fast activity
Landau-Kleffner Peaks at 5 to Acquired aphasia, cognitive Multifocal spikes or posterior
syndrome 7 y of age and behavioral abnormalities, temporal spikes facilitated
clinical seizures infrequent markedly by sleep, seen
continuously in slow-wave sleep
Progressive myoclonic Age of onset 5 to Progressive myoclonus, 3Y6 Hz polyspike-wave discharges
epilepsies 20 y of age cognitive impairment, ataxia and photosensitivity
TABLE 2-3 Benign Variants Commonly Encountered on EEG but Confused With
Epileptiform Patterns
FIGURE 2-9 Normal variants or benign patterns. A, EEG of psychomotor variant or rhythmic
midtemporal theta of drowsiness (RMTD). Note the theta range activity seen
bilaterally but maximally in the temporal leads as the patient is becoming
drowsy. B, EEG of small sharp spikes. Note the low-amplitude spikes of 50 2V or less in the
temporal leads and note that the patient is also in light sleep.
Continued on next page
FIGURE 2-9 (Continued from page 611) Normal variants or benign patterns. E, EEG of 14 and 6 positive bursts. Note the
1-second burst of right-sided activity with spike components but occurring at 14 Hz in trains during drowsiness.
F, EEG of subclinical rhythmic electrographic discharges of adults (SREDA). This EEG is from a 60-year-old patient
during awake state where bilateral, sharply contoured theta activity is seen but does not alter the baseline alpha range activity
posteriorly and almost looks like an ictal discharge, but patients generally do not have change in awareness. It has abrupt onset
and offset and can be seen in wakefulness or during sleep.
In comatose patients, rhythmic or GPDs have been divided into periodic KEY POINTS
periodic patterns often do not clearly short-interval diffuse discharges and pe- h Several periodic EEG
fall into ‘‘ictal’’ or ‘‘nonictal’’ cate- riodic long-interval diffuse discharges. patterns are seen in
comatose patients in the
gories, and there is some controversy With increased use of the EEG in criti-
intensive care unit,
in the literature regarding which pat- cally ill patients, it has become apparent
many of which are
terns represent or indicate status epi- that some ‘‘epileptiform’’ patterns may indicative of status
lepticus and which do not. Moreover, not be specific for seizures, and the epilepticus, although
different patterns may be seen within guidelines for prolonged intensive care some are controversial
the same patient at different time unit (ICU) monitoring now refrain from (such as triphasic
points during the continuous EEG rec- using the term epileptiform.29 waves).
ording. The commonly seen periodic h Continuous EEG
patterns include rhythmic delta activity; USE OF CONTINUOUS EEG monitoring should be
generalized triphasic waves; periodic MONITORING IN THE INTENSIVE considered in any
lateralizing discharges (PLDs); general- CARE UNIT critically ill patient with
ized periodic discharges (GPDs); bilat- Continuous EEG (cEEG) monitoring is unexplained mental
erally independent periodic lateralizing performed over hours or days to obtain status changes,
discharges (BIPLDs); and stimulus- information about cerebral function especially those with
induced, rhythmic, periodic, or ictal among patients who are critically ill acute neurologic injury,
discharges (SIRPIDs). PLDs have been and have limited neurologic examina- as nonconvulsive
seizures may be
further divided by some authors into tion; it is often indicated among pa-
underrecognized.
‘‘PLDs proper’’ and ‘‘PLDs-plus,’’ and tients in a medical or neurologic ICU
Continuum (Minneap Minn) 2013;19(3):598–622 www.ContinuumJournal.com 613
FIGURE 2-10 Periodic EEG patterns. A, EEG of periodic lateralized discharges. Note that the EEG shows
periodic sharp-wave discharges phase reversing in the right temporal leads. B, EEG of
bilateral periodic discharges. Note the periodic discharges phase reversing in the frontal
leads bilaterally and sometimes occurring asynchronously.
Continued on next page
Case 2-2
A 23-year-old woman had a several-year history of spells characterized by sudden loss of consciousness
associated with a fall preceded by lightheadedness. Some of these spells had been triggered by blood
draw. She had eight of these episodes over the past 2 years and may have had some posturing and
shaking involved. She also described episodes characterized by an aura of déjà vu followed by staring
and oral automatisms and at times speech arrest, which occurred twice a week. Both types of spells
continued despite two anticonvulsant medication trials either independently or in combination. Her
MRI results were normal, as were Holter monitoring and ECG as an outpatient. Routine outpatient EEG
findings were normal as well. The patient was then admitted for video-EEG monitoring.
Comment. The case posed a diagnostic challenge in that the patient had a history of episodes twice
a week of what sound like focal seizures with loss of awareness and automatic behavior suggestive of a
temporal lobe semiology, whereas the episodes of loss of consciousness preceded by lightheadedness
sounded like syncope. However, it is possible that these may represent generalized tonic-clonic seizures
as well.
When admitted to the epilepsy monitoring unit, the patient had a blood draw for labs shortly after
which she reported feeling dizzy and then lost consciousness; this was followed by a brief tonic
posturing, followed by brief tonic-clonic activity. At the end of the event she had no postictal state and
reported to the nurses that she had ‘‘passed out.’’ ECG during the event showed severe bradycardia
when the patient reported dizziness, followed by asystole for 15 seconds with gradual return to normal
sinus rhythm. EEG during the bradycardia showed loss of amplitude diffusely followed by flattening,
FIGURE 2-11 EEG from the patient described in Case 2-2. A, Note the normal awake
pattern while patient is undergoing phlebotomy. B, Note the bilateral
high amplitude slowing followed by flattening of EEG associated
with muscle artifact that coincided with patient losing consciousness and having some
tonic posturing.
FIGURE 2-11 (Continued from page 616) EEG from the patient described in Case 2-2. C, Note
that the EEG remains flat along with muscle artifact with poorly discernible electrocerebral
activity likely due to hypoperfusion during the period of asystole. D, Note resumption
of EEG activity that coincided with the patient having a few clonic jerks and that
followed resumption of ECG rhythm.
Continued on page 618
FIGURE 2-11 (Continued from page 617) EEG from the patient described in Case 2-2. E, Note the recovery of normal
alpha activity that coincided with patient recovery of normal consciousness where she started answering
questions.
who are comatose where subclinical Among comatose patients in the ICU,
seizures or nonconvulsive status epilep- rates of status epilepticus have been
ticus is suspected. It is also utilized reported to vary from 8% to 37%31,32 on
among patients with acute neurologic cEEG monitoring. Similarly, noncon-
injury to monitor function, during treat- vulsive status epilepticus was found in
ment of status epilepticus to monitor up to 20% of patients with traumatic
treatment response, among patients brain injury and 6% of patients with
with subarachnoid hemorrhage to stroke or intracranial hemorrhage.33 In
monitor for vasospasm, and among many institutions across the United
patients with raised intracranial pres- States, cEEG monitoring is now per-
sure after traumatic brain injury.29,30 formed routinely in patients with
are placed surgically through burr holes 3. Devinsky O, Sato S, Kufta CV, et al.
Electroencephalographic studies of simple
either in the temporal lobes alone partial seizures with subdural electrode
(tangentially or longitudinally) or as an recordings. Neurology 1989;39(4):527Y533.
array in the temporal and frontal lobes 4. McCormick DA, Contreras D. On the cellular
bilaterally. and network bases of epileptic seizures.
Subdural grid electrodes are placed Ann Rev Physiol 2001;63:815Y846.
surgically when seizure-onset zone is 5. Jacobs J, Staba R, Asano E, et al. High
felt to be close to an eloquent area. frequency oscillations (HFOs) in clinical
epilepsy. Prog Neurobiol 2012;98(3):
Subdural grids offer the advantage of 302Y315.
mapping of eloquent cortex, such that
6. King MA, Newton MR, Jackson GD, et al.
seizure-onset zone can be separated Epileptology of the first-seizure presentation:
clearly so as to prevent postoperative a clinical, electroencephalographic, and
12. Pillai J, Sperling MR. Interictal EEG and 25. Benbadis SR, Lin K. Errors in EEG
the diagnosis of epilepsy. Epilepsia 2006; interpretation and misdiagnosis of epilepsy.
47(suppl 1):14Y22. Which patterns are overread? Eur Neurol
2008;59(5):267Y271.
13. Bozorg AM, Lacayo JC, Benbadis SR.
The yield of routine outpatient 26. Santoshkumar B, Chong JJ, Blume WT, et al.
electroencephalogram in the veteran Prevalence of benign epileptiform variants.
population. J Clin Neurophysiol 2010;27(3): Clin Neurophysiol. 2009;120(5):856Y861.
191Y192. 27. Treiman DM, Walton NY, Kendrick C.
14. Salinsky M, Kanter R, Dasheiff RM. A progressive sequence of
electroencephalographic changes during
Effectiveness of multiple EEGs in supporting
the diagnosis of epilepsy: an operational generalized convulsive status epilepticus.
curve. Epilepsia 1987;28(4):331Y334. Epilepsy Res 1990;5(1):49Y60.
28. Wang NC, Good LB, Marsh ST, Treiman DM.
15. Cavazzuti GB, Cappella L, Nalin A.
EEG stages predict treatment response in
Longitudinal study of epileptiform EEG
experimental status epilepticus. Epilepsia
patterns in normal children. Epilepsia 1980;
2009;50(4):949Y952.
21(1):43Y55.
29. Hirsch LJ, Brenner RP, Drislane FW, et al.
16. Seneviratne U, Cook M, D’Souza W. The
The ACNS subcommittee on research
electroencephalogram of idiopathic
terminology for continuous EEG monitoring:
generalized epilepsy. Epilepsia 2012;53(2):
proposed standard terminology for
234Y248.
rhythmic periodic patterns encountered in
17. Kasteleijn-Nolst Trenite DG, Guerrini R, critically ill patients. J Clin Neurophysiol
Binnie CD, Genton P. Visual sensitivity 2005;22(2):128Y135.
30. Sutter R, Fuhr P, Grize L, et al. Continuous 36. Wirrell E, Kozlik S, Tellez J, et al. Ambulatory
video-EEG monitoring increases detection electroencephalography (EEG) in children:
rate of nonconvulsive status epilepticus in diagnostic yield and tolerability. J Child
the ICU. Epilepsia 2011;52(3):453Y457. Neurol 2008;23(6):655Y662.
31. Oddo M, Carrera E, Claassen J, et al. 37. Benbadis SR, Agrawal V, Tatum WO 4th.
Continuous electroencephalography in the How many patients with psychogenic
medical intensive care unit. Crit Care Med nonepileptic events also have epilepsy?
2009;37(6):2051Y2056. Neurology 2001;57(5):915Y917.
32. Towne AR, Waterhouse EJ, Boggs JG, 38. Lobello K, Morgenlander JC, Radtke RA,
et al. Prevalence of nonconvulsive status et al. Video EEG monitoring in the
epilepticus in comatose patients. Neurology evaluation of paroxysmal behavioral events.
2000;54(2):340Y345 Epilepsy Behav 2006;8(1):261Y266.
33. Vespa PM, O’Phelan K, Shah M, et al. Acute 39. Salinsky M, Spencer D, Boudreau E, et al.
seizures after intracerebral hemorrhage: Psychogenic nonepileptic seizures in
a factor in progressive midline shift and US veterans. Neurology 2011;77(10):
outcome. Neurology 2003;60(9):1441Y1446. 945Y950.
34. Faulkner HJ, Arima H, Mohamed A. The 40. Chung SS, Gerber P, Kirlin KA. Ictal eye
utility of prolonged outpatient ambulatory closure is a reliable indicator of psychogenic
EEG. Seizure 2012;21(7):491Y495. nonepileptic seizures. Neurology 2006;
66(11):1730Y1731.
35. Tatum WO 4th, Winters L, Gieron M, et al.
Outpatient seizure identification: results 41. Elgavish RA, Cabaniss WW. What is the
of 502 patients using computer-assisted diagnostic value of repeating a
ambulatory EEG. J Clin Neurophysiol non-diagnostic video-EEG study. J Clin
2001;18(1):14Y19. Neurophysiol 2011;28(3):311Y313.