Guidance On Practice For New Pressure Vessels: Document No. Applicability Date
Guidance On Practice For New Pressure Vessels: Document No. Applicability Date
Guidance On Practice For New Pressure Vessels: Document No. Applicability Date
GP 46-01
BP GROUP
ENGINEERING TECHNICAL PRACTICES
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Foreword
This is the first issue of Engineering Technical Practice (ETP) BP GP 46-1. This Guidance on Practice
(GP) is based on parts of heritage documents from the merged BP companies as follows:
British Petroleum
RP 24-1 Fire Protection – Onshore.
RP 24-2 Fire Protection – Offshore.
RP 42-2 Bolting for flanged joints.
RP 46-1 Unfired Pressure Vessels.
RP 5-2-2 Flanges, Gaskets and Bolting
RP 7-4-1 Bolting procedures for flanged connections.
Amoco
A FE-VE-DV1-E Fabricated Equipment—Pressure Vessels—Division 1—Engineering
Specification.
A FE-VE-DV1-G Fabricated Equipment—Pressure Vessels—Division 1—Guide.
A FE-VE-DV1-P Fabricated Equipment—Pressure Vessels—Division 1—Procurement
Specification.
A FE-VE-DV2--E Fabricated Equipment—Pressure Vessels—Division 2—Engineering
Specification.
A FE-VE-DV2-P Fabricated Equipment—Pressure Vessels—Division 2—Procurement
Specification.
A PN-PLT-GASK-E Piping—Plant—Gaskets—Selection Specification.
A PN-PLT-GASK-G Piping—Plant—Gaskets—Guide.
ARCO
Std 40-89 Pressure Vessels.
Std 42-95 General Welding: Fabrication and Inspection for General Refinery
Service.
Copyright © 2006, BP Group. All rights reserved. The information contained in this
document is subject to the terms and conditions of the agreement or contract under which
the document was supplied to the recipient’s organization. None of the information
contained in this document shall be disclosed outside the recipient’s own organization
without the prior written permission of BP Group, unless the terms of such agreement or
contract expressly allow.
Page 2 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Table of Contents
Foreword ........................................................................................................................................ 2
1. Scope .................................................................................................................................... 7
2. Normative references............................................................................................................. 7
3. Definitions.............................................................................................................................. 9
4. Symbols and abbreviations .................................................................................................. 10
5. Introduction, codes, legislation and quality assurance.......................................................... 10
5.1. Introduction ............................................................................................................... 10
5.2. Codes ....................................................................................................................... 11
5.3. Legislation................................................................................................................. 11
5.4. Quality Assurance..................................................................................................... 12
6. Materials selection ............................................................................................................... 12
6.1. Process specific requirements .................................................................................. 12
7. Design ................................................................................................................................. 14
7.1. General..................................................................................................................... 14
7.2. Loadings ................................................................................................................... 16
7.3. Design against corrosion under insulation (CUI) ....................................................... 19
7.4. Design for non-intrusive inspection ........................................................................... 19
7.5. Plate layout and weld design .................................................................................... 20
7.6. Nozzles and manways .............................................................................................. 20
7.7. Flanges, gaskets, and bolts ...................................................................................... 21
7.8. Welds........................................................................................................................ 23
7.9. Internals.................................................................................................................... 23
7.10. Supports ................................................................................................................... 23
7.11. External attachments ................................................................................................ 26
7.12. Spheres .................................................................................................................... 27
7.13. Pig launchers and receivers...................................................................................... 28
8. Fabrication........................................................................................................................... 28
8.1. General..................................................................................................................... 28
9. Inspection and testing .......................................................................................................... 28
9.1. Preparation ............................................................................................................... 28
9.2. Surface examination of welds ................................................................................... 28
9.3. Volumetric examination of welds............................................................................... 28
9.4. Fracture mechanics assessment of weld flaws ......................................................... 28
9.5. Hydrostatic test ......................................................................................................... 29
9.6. Positive materials identification and datum thickness readings ................................. 29
10. Internal non-metallic coating or refractory lining ................................................................... 29
10.1. Non-metallic coating ................................................................................................. 29
10.2. Refractory lining ........................................................................................................ 29
Page 3 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Page 4 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Q.14 Prevention of yielding with low strength bolts, e.g. stainless steel ........................................ 55
Q.15 Measurement of elongation.................................................................................................. 56
Q.15.1 Ultrasonic elongation measurement.......................................................................... 56
Q.15.2 Proprietary bolts with integral load measuring........................................................... 57
Q.16 Safety .................................................................................................................................. 57
Annex AA (Normative) Requirements for vessels to the ASME Code ........................................... 58
AA.1 General................................................................................................................................ 58
AA.6 Materials .............................................................................................................................. 58
AA.7 Design ................................................................................................................................. 58
AA.7.1 General..................................................................................................................... 58
AA.7.2 Division 1 .................................................................................................................. 58
AA.7.3 Division 2 .................................................................................................................. 59
AA.8 Fabrication........................................................................................................................... 59
AA.16 Division 3 .................................................................................................................. 59
Annex BB (Normative) Requirements for vessels to PD 5500 ....................................................... 60
BB.1 General................................................................................................................................ 60
BB.6 Materials .............................................................................................................................. 60
Annex CC (Normative) Requirements for vessels to BS EN 13445............................................... 61
CC.1 General................................................................................................................................ 61
CC.6 Materials .............................................................................................................................. 61
CC.7 Design ................................................................................................................................. 61
CC.7.1 Component design ............................................................................................... 61
CC.7.2 Alternative flange design method ......................................................................... 61
CC.7.3 Pressure relief systems ........................................................................................ 61
Bibliography .................................................................................................................................. 62
List of Tables
List of Figures
Figure 1 - Typical hot box at skirt to head attachment on high temperature vessel........................ 24
Figure 2 - Slotted skirt to head attachment on high temperature vessel under cyclic temperature
loading ................................................................................................................................. 25
Figure C.1 – Legend used in the cladding figures in Annex C ....................................................... 32
Page 5 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Page 6 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
1. Scope
This GP provides guidance on practice in the specification of new pressure vessels, spheres, and pig
launchers/receivers. Its purpose is to brief BP engineers or contractors working on behalf of BP.
2. Normative references
The following normative documents contain requirements that, through reference in this text,
constitute requirements of this technical practice. For dated references, subsequent amendments to, or
revisions of, any of these publications do not apply. However, parties to agreements based on this
technical practice are encouraged to investigate the possibility of applying the most recent editions of
the normative documents indicated below. For undated references, the latest edition of the normative
document referred to applies.
BP
DS 46-010 Data Sheet for Pressure Vessels.
GIS 36-103 Guidance on Industry Standard for Positive Materials Identification
(PMI) for Pressure Vessels, Piping, and other Components.
GIS 46-010 Guidance on Industry Standards for New Pressure Vessels.
GIS 46-020 Guidance on Industry Standard for Pressure Vessel Details.
GIS 46-030 Guidance on Industry Standard for Commercial Vessel Purchasing
Specification.
GP 06-20 Guidance on Practice for Materials for Sour Service.
GP 06-25 Guidance on Practice for Design to Prevent Corrosion under Insulation.
GP 06-60 Guidance on Practice for Coating of Metal Surfaces and Equipment
(A CP-COAT-00-E or BP GS 106-2).
GP 06-63 Guidance on Practice for Internal Coatings.
GP 24-23 Guidance on Practice for Active Fire Protection – Offshore.
GP 24-24 Guidance on Practice for Offshore Passive Fire Protection.
GP 24-10 Guidance on Practice for Fire Protection – Onshore.
Page 7 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Page 8 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Other
UK Health and Safety Executive Guidance Note GS 4, Safety in pressure testing.
UK Health and Safety Executive, Pressure test safety, Contract research report 168/1998.
Website for Upstream separator guidelines
3. Definitions
approval
acceptance by the purchaser.
ASME code
ASME Boiler and Pressure Vessel Code.
BP
BP p.l.c., an associate or subsidiary, or other organization as defined in the Conditions of Contract for
the project.
clad plate
plate that has been purchased by the supplier already clad (by roll or explosion bonding).
cladding re-instatement
the process in which small areas at nozzles and attachments, where the cladding has been removed for
welding of the base material, are re-clad by welding.
purchaser
contractor acting on behalf of BP or BP itself in the case of a direct purchase.
Page 9 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
These mechanisms are: sulphide stress corrosion cracking, soft zone cracking,
hydrogen induced cracking, stepwise cracking, or stress orientated hydrogen
induced cracking.
supplier
the organisation, purchaser or agency which is contracted to provide vessels to BP.
HBW Brinell hardness measured by tungsten carbide ball (also referred to as HB)
Hv10 Vickers hardness measured with a 10 kgf indenter (also referred to as HV)
RT radiographic testing
RF raised face.
UT ultrasonic testing
5.1. Introduction
For ease of reference, the index of GIS 46-010 generally also applies to this GP. However, if a
topic is raised that is not addressed in GIS 46-010, it is entered as an extra paragraph at the end
of the relevant section in this GP. In some cases, a complete annex has been added.
Guidance is given on standard pressure vessel details in GIS 46-020 and on the commercial
aspects of pressure vessel purchase in GIS 46-030.
Page 10 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
5.2. Codes
a. The vessel code shall be approved by the Engineering Authority in the BP Business Unit
for which the vessel is being bought. This should be done before order placement.
b. The code to be used depends mainly on national regulations, precedent, and cost. It may
also depend on the type of vessel being specified, the material, design, and method of
fabrication, and the familiarity of the fabricator with the code proposed. The following are
typical options:
1. A vessel may be supplied to the ASME code and stamped with either the U or U-2
stamps.
2. It may be purchased to the ASME code but not stamped.
3. It may be made to PD 5500 or BS EN 13445.
BS EN 13445 is new but considered to be technically acceptable.
4. It may be made to another internationally recognised code but this would be subject
to the approval of the Engineering Authority.
Component thicknesses to ASME VIII Division 1 are generally larger than those to
PD 5500, BS EN 13445, or ASME VIII Division 2.
The ASME code includes materials such as zirconium and some nickel alloys that
PD 5500 does not.
PD 5500 has well regarded design methods for external pressure, nozzle
compensation, and saddles. It also permits greater use of weld inspection by
ultrasonics in lieu of radiography.
BS EN 13445 is harmonised under the PED and does not therefore require approval
from a Notified Body every time it is used (in Europe). It contains advanced sections
on fatigue, flange and tubesheet design.
The definition of a pressure vessel varies from one design code to another. The
ASME code has a minimum pressure requirement of 1 bar. PD 5500 excludes
vessels in which the calculated stresses are less than 10% of the allowable design
stresses.
5.3. Legislation
5.3.1. In the US
Pressure vessels supplied to BP for use within the US shall be constructed and stamped in
accordance with the ASME code.
ASME code construction and stamping of new pressure vessels is a requirement of
the Occupational Safety and Health Administration.
5.3.2. In Europe
a. Pressure vessels supplied to BP for use within the European Economic Area (i.e. European
Union with other countries including Norway and Switzerland) must be stamped with a CE
mark and supplied with all other necessary certification including a Declaration of
Conformity.
Stamping and certification are provided by the manufacturer when the vessel in
manufactured within the European Economic Area. For vessels imported into the
European Economic Area, they may be provided by the manufacturer if he has the
necessary certification or by an agent acting on his behalf who is certified.
Page 11 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
b. The PED uses the term ‘maximum allowable pressure’ and the vessel design pressure must
equal or exceed maximum allowable pressure of the system in which it is to be installed.
c. For conformity assessment, the manufacturer specifies the module, but in the enquiry the
purchaser should indicate any requirements that he has regarding the module to be used.
Suppliers are required to manufacture to a conformity assessment procedure. For
pressure vessels supplied to BP, this is likely to be either Module G (purchaser
inspection) or Module H1 (full conformity assessment by the manufacturer under the
surveillance of his Notified Body).
d. A material that is specified in a harmonised standard requires no further regulatory
approval and, providing it is cost competitive, is therefore preferred. Other materials shall
be accepted using a Particular Material Appraisal (specific approval by a Notified Body
using) or, in rare cases, by a European Approval of Materials.
The aim of the PED is the removal of barriers to trade of pressure equipment (i.e.
vessels, piping, valves, etc.) within the European Economic Area. It applies to
‘placing on the market’ and ‘putting into service’ of pressure equipment. Hence
manufacturers and operators are both responsible for its implementation.
The PED defines pressure equipment as being designed for maximum allowable
pressures in excess of 0,5 barg. It requires that vendors provide operating
instructions and recommendations for the operating instructions are given in the
draft BS CEN/TS 764-6.
6. Materials selection
6.1.1. General
Nothing.
Page 12 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
This can be of benefit where the base material is a high strength carbon steel. It is
assumed that the cladding prevents corrosion and therefore formation of hydrogen,
hence the main agent for cracking of the base material is absent.
c. Sour water, wet H2S service, or wet sour service shall be determined from NACE MR0103
for refineries.
NACE TM0177 is used by the upstream business and has been used by the refineries
to some extent, though use of the new TM0103 will likely reduce its use.
NACE RP0472 is used by refineries.
NACE MR0103 has an appendix on hardness testing. ASTM E10 on Brinell testing
now requires the use of a tungsten carbide ball, so the hardness reading is referred
to as HBW.
6.1.7. Duties containing Naphthenic acids and a design temp. above 220°C (430°F)
Nothing.
Page 13 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
has to be used with a substantial increase in cost. Nickel steel may be suitable but is
little used for pressure vessels.
The requirements for vessels with minimum design temperatures lower than –60°C (–76°F)
shall be specified by the purchaser.
7. Design
7.1. General
Page 14 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Page 15 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
7.2. Loadings
7.2.1. Static
Page 16 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Page 17 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
7.2.2. Dynamic
a. Vessels or vessel components shall be checked for vibration if there is any likelihood of
flow induced vibration occurring.
Dynamic analysis depends on determining the natural frequency (or frequencies) of
the vessel or component and the frequency of the applied loading. If the two are
close to each other, resonance may occur leading to large amplitude vibration with
a high probability of failure. (It is very easy for a large number of cycles to occur in
a short time, and hence fatigue damage to accumulate quickly).
The solution lies in one of the following:
• Change the natural frequency of the component. It may be possible to alter the
support of a pipe or the mass of a vessel to alter the natural frequency
sufficiently to stop the vibration.
• Change the nature of the loading. With wind induced vibration of distillation
columns, the platforms, ladders, and vertical piping all act as spoilers for the
wind flow. Therefore, by distributing these at different orientations at different
elevations, it may be possible to break up the vortex shedding sufficiently to stop
the vibration. Pressure dampers similarly alter the loading being applied, in this
case the internal flow, so that the effect of the resonance becomes minimal.
• Take the energy out of the resonance, thereby rendering it harmless. This is the
principle behind a snubber or damper on a piping system. However, these can
be expensive and may be impossible to apply with the large energies involved in
pressure vessel vibration.
b. Vessels shall be checked for dynamic effects if the process is likely to apply shock loading
to the vessel.
Because the natural period of most vessel components is long compared with the
duration of the shock wave, a simple, conservative solution is to design the
component for twice the applied pressure of the impulse. However this may not be
economic in some cases and a more detailed analysis may be necessary. The
fundamentals of such design are discussed in UK Health and Safety Executive,
Pressure test safety, Contract research report 168/1998.
7.2.3. Environmental
Page 18 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
1. The allowable stress design method shall be used. When the pressure vessel is
designed using the allowable stress method and the supporting structure or foundation
bolts are designed using the strength design method a check shall be made that there
is no inconsistency between the two design methods.
The strength design or load and resistance factor design method is not normally
used for pressure vessel design but is frequently used for civil engineering design.
2. The equivalent static method design method shall be used. Dynamic analysis shall not
be used unless authorised by BP. If the dynamic analysis method is used, the
competence of the designer should be verified.
The additional effort and complexity of performing a dynamic analysis for pressure
vessels is not normally justified. The equivalent static method is normally slightly
more conservative but is less prone to error.
3. The basic load combinations associated with the allowable stress design method shall
be used.
The load combination factors for the allowable stress and the strength design or
load and resistance factor design are different.
4. Vertical columns may be considered as “cantilevered column systems” provided they
are anchored to a foundation at grade.
Flexibility of the supporting structure may alter the response of a heavy vessel.
5. Seismic design need only be considered for operating conditions. Hydrotest
conditions do not need to be considered.
6. Parameters such as seismic user group and site class shall be defined for each site.
Site class shall be consistent with the factors used for the civil engineering design.
In accordance with table 1604.5 in the International Building Code, process plant is
normally considered as category II, except for facilities that are required for post-
earthquake recovery (e.g. fire fighting facilities) which are considered as
category IV.
Page 19 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
perhaps leading to preparation of a full set of fabrication drawings, may be needed before
materials are ordered. The contract shall be set-up accordingly.
A requirement to design a vessel for non-intrusive inspection may considerably alter
the materials required and the design (mainly to permit external ultrasonic
inspection). Details of the vessel should therefore be agreed with the vendor at a
very early stage.
7.6.4. Manways
a. Manways on towers, regenerators, reactors, fractionators, strippers and vessels where there
are substantial quantities of internals shall be DN 600 (NPS 24).
b. If the tower diameter precludes this, one flanged head is required.
c. Manways shall have a minimum inside diameter of 457 mm (18 in), measured from the
inside surface of the overlay or refractory. Thus, unless the pressure is exceptionally high
or the nozzle is internally clad, it shall be DN 500 (NPS 20).
d. Horizontal drums larger than 70 m3 (2 400 ft3) shall have one manway at each end. Drums
70 m3 (2 400 ft3) and smaller shall have one manway in one end and one DN 150 (NPS 6)
vent, minimum, in shell top at opposite end.
e. Vertical vessels without trays shall have one manway located in bottom section, with one
DN 150 (NPS 6) vent, minimum, in top head of vessel.
f. Fractionating columns shall be provided with manways as follows:
1. One in the base section as low down in the shell as practicable.
2. One above the top tray.
3. One at each reflux tray.
4. One at each feed section.
5. One at each other section that contains internal equipment, other than trays, that is
likely to require inspection or maintenance, e.g. mist eliminator pads or trap-out trays.
6. One spaced at not more than 1 every 6 trays, except that for valve and sieve trays this
may be increased to 10.
g. Access through tray manways both up and down the tower is preferred.
Page 20 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
h. In vessels where quantities of coke or other material may be expected to collect at the
bottom, manways shall be provided at the base of the shell to give ready access for
cleaning.
i. A manway shall be provided in any large division plate to permit access to all parts of the
interior of the vessel. If this is not possible, additional manways shall be provided in the
vessel shell.
j. If access to the interior of a vessel cannot be via manways, a minimum of one DN 150
(NPS 6) or larger inspection opening shall be provided. If approved by BP, a piping nozzle
may be used as an inspection opening if piping can be removed. Inspection openings
should be located such that representative shell joints and critical parts of the interior of the
vessel can be inspected.
k. Manways or inspection openings shall satisfy the statutory requirements at the point of
usage. In the absence of such directions, BS 470 may be followed.
l. Adequate nozzles and/or manways shall be provided to meet venting requirements for gas
freeing vessels and ventilation for mechanical work such as welding.
7.7.1. Flanges
a. Nozzles NPS 1-1/4, 2-1/2, 3-1/2, 5, and 9 shall not be used. Class 400 shall not be used.
b. The use of compact flanges shall be subject to approval.
7.7.2. Gaskets
Page 21 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
b. For flat gaskets, flange faces should be machined to a surface roughness between 3,2 and
12,5 μm (125 – 500 μin) Ra, except where the manufacturer of a selected proprietary
gasket advises otherwise.
Page 22 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
c. Flange facings used with SW gaskets should be machined a surface roughness between 3,2
and 6,3 μm (125 – 250 μin).
7.7.3. Bolts
7.8. Welds
Unless otherwise approved by BP, vessels shall be designed and fabricated with a minimum of
spot radiographic examination.
7.9. Internals
Subject to the agreement of the purchaser, manways in vertical vessels shall be supplemented
with rungs attached to the inside of the vessel shell when other internal fixtures do not afford
suitable safe footing and handholds for persons entering or leaving the vessel.
Guidance on manway rungs is given in GIS 46-020.
7.10. Supports
7.10.1. Skirts
a. Skirts on vessels 2 m (6 ft) or less in diameter shall have at least one access opening. On
vessels with diameters over 2 m (10 ft) and skirt heights over 2,5 m (8 ft), two access
openings may be provided in the skirt.
This allows improved access and ventilation on larger diameter vessels.
b. The minimum access opening shall be 600 mm (24 in) diameter, or 450 mm (18 in) x
900 mm (36 in) obround.
c. Skirts are preferred over lugs.
Skirts provide a more uniform distribution of load to the shell.
d. In essentially non-cyclic service, where the design temperature is in excess of 350°C
(650°F), a hot box shall be provided as shown in Figure 1.
e. In cyclic high temperature services, i.e. where highest temperature in the cycle is greater
than 343°C (650°F), such as coke drums, slots may be used in the vessel skirts to
accommodate thermal expansion. See Figure 2.
Slots relieve some of the thermal stress in the skirt as they permit some flexing.
Page 23 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
1. Stress in portions of the skirt between slots may be analysed by assuming the portions
to be flat plates loaded with a uniform load in the plane of the plate.
There are designs without slots.
Figure 1 - Typical hot box at skirt to head attachment on high temperature vessel
H = 20 x SKIRT THICKNESS,
BUT NO MORE THAN 1/2
SUPPORT CLIPS ON
SKIRT HEIGHT
457mm (18 in) CENTRES
OMIT CLIPS W HEN S <
305m m (12 in)
5mm (3/16 in) FILLET W ELD
(BO TH SIDES)
(CLIPS BY VESSEL VENDOR)
45
7 229mm
(1 8 m m
in ) (9 in)
PLAN VIEW
Page 24 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
TOP OF SKIRT
51mm
(2 in)
R=(1/2)t A
16t
3mm (1/8 in) SLOTS BLEND SMOOTH SKIRT
EQUALLY SPACED ATTACHMENT WELD
AT 15° INTERVALS
RADIALLY AROUND R 5mm A
SKIRT (3/16 in)
m
R 6m n)
4 i
(1/
SECTION A-A
7.10.3. Saddles
Horizontal vessels shall be supported on two saddles only. Slots shall be provided in one saddle
to allow for expansion
Page 25 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
7.11.2. Fireproofing
a. Directions on fireproofing are given in GP 24-10 for Onshore and GP 24-23 and GP 24-24
for Offshore.
b. Exterior surfaces of skirts supporting towers or vertical vessels containing hydrocarbons
and located within a fire exposed envelope of sufficient duration and intensity shall be
fireproofed.
Details of fireproofing of skirts are given in GIS 46-020.
c. Skirt interior surfaces shall be fireproofed if there are flanges or valves within the skirt or
if there are manway openings greater than 600 mm (24 in) diameter. Skirts of vessels less
d. than 760 mm (30 in) diameter need not be protected on the inside.
e. Pipe penetrations and other small openings shall be plugged if possible. Manways in skirts
shall be left clear and, if necessary, additional reinforcement should be provided around the
periphery of the manway. Vent holes at or near the top of vessel skirt shall be kept clear.
f. Anchor bolts shall be fireproofed unless otherwise specified. Particular attention shall be
paid to the detailing around bolts anchored in epoxy resin, if there is a danger of conducted
heat affecting the anchorage.
g. Brackets or lugs used to attach vertical reboilers or heat exchangers to towers or tower
skirts should be fireproofed. The earthing (grounding) lug should be kept clear of the fire
protection.
h. Elevated exposed legs supporting vessels shall be fireproofed to their full load bearing
height.
i. Steel saddles supporting horizontal vessels that have a diameter of 760 mm (30 in) or
greater, and which have a vertical distance between the concrete pier and the shell
exceeding 460 mm (18 in), shall be fireproofed if within a significant fire envelope.
j. The protection of vessel saddles that have provision for sliding on a bedplate should
include covering the bolts in protective paste or tape or equivalent and keeping the
elongated holes free of concrete. It is important to check before commissioning and
periodically thereafter that the appropriate supports are free to slide.
k. The paint system shall be compatible with the fireproofing system. See NACE publications
6H 189 and RP0198 for further information on the prevention of corrosion under
fireproofing.
Page 26 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
l. For vessels up to approximately 2 m (6 ft), a cover may be fitted over the access way to
prevent human entry and ingress of flames. In this case, the inside of the skirt may not
need to be fire proofed.
7.11.3. Nameplates
Nothing.
7.12. Spheres
a. The design calculations for the sphere should be reviewed by the purchaser.
The design of the legs of spheres is outside code rules and mainly proprietary to the
suppliers. The calculations for this in particular should be requested and reviewed.
b. If the sphere is to be subject to PWHT, a full check on the design for PWHT shall be
carried out.
Spheres have successfully been subject to PWHT.
Page 27 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
c. For spherical storage vessels, one manway with a davit shall be provided at the top of the
sphere and one with a hinge at the bottom.
8. Fabrication
8.1. General
a. When environmental attack is not a concern and PWHT is not required, hardness need not
be checked.
b. Suggested maximum values of macro-hardness in parent plate and welds of ferrous
materials in non-sour service are given in Table 3 for information. They apply to vessels
with and without PWHT and are subject to confirmation by the supplier.
Suggested maximum values of macro-hardness for base material and weld metal
C Mn steels 1 ¼ Cr ½ Mo Other Ferrous Materials
Without PWHT 225HBW (Hv10 238) 225HBW 241HBW
With PWHT 200HBW 215HBW 235HBW
For most vessel fabrications, hardness values are not required for non-sour
applications. However, typical values are provided here for those cases in which
hardness is of significance.
9.1. Preparation
Nothing.
Page 28 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
If a crack-like flaw assessment is likely to be required during the life of the vessel,
samples should be made available during manufacture of the vessel from which
fracture mechanics data may be obtained. Accurate fracture toughness and other
data greatly improve the accuracy of flaw assessment calculations. The tests can be
made either during fabrication or at a later date during operation (perhaps when a
flaw assessment is required).
b. Fracture mechanics tests on either welded or unwelded samples should be made to
BS 7448 Parts 1 – 4 or an equivalent standard.
c. Flaw assessment calculations should be made to either BS 7190 or API 579.
Flaw assessment may be made on both actual defects and on postulated ones. With
the latter, it is possible to use the technique to determine allowable flaw sizes and
therefore set levels for NDE. Conversely, given a known accuracy of NDE, it is
possible to determine whether PWHT is or is not needed. (PWHT greatly reduces
the level of residual stress and allows a much larger permissible flaw).
9.6.1. PMI
PMI shall be specified to be in accordance with GIS 36-103.
Background information on PMI for piping systems is given in API RP 578.
Page 29 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
External coating of vessels for corrosion protection shall generally conform to conform to
GP 06-60.
12. Insulation
Thermal insulation of vessels for temperature conservation, personal protection, sound insulation, or
fireproofing shall conform to either GP 52-10.
Nothing.
14. Documentation
Basic design information and options selected shall be documented on a data form such as
DS 46-010.
Information on inspection documentation for metallic materials is given in
BS EN 764-5.
Page 30 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Annex C
(Normative)
Additional requirements for clad vessels
C.1 General
a. Suppliers should be questioned on their choice of supply route in particular in relation to:
1. Method of cladding.
Large, low pressure clad vessels are generally made from roll clad plate. The
disadvantage of this is that it takes time, early in the contract, to clad the plate and
there is always a risk of disbonding during fabrication. For vessels in which the
base material is above 25 mm (1 in) thick, there are major advantages in cost and
delivery time in cladding the vessel by applying weld overlay to the manufactured
cylinders and heads. Explosion cladding is expensive but is used for materials that
cannot be clad by other means, e.g. titanium onto steel, or for flat plates such as
tubesheets that would distort with weld overlay.
2. Depth of cladding, number of layers, and dilution.
3. Thermal stresses during operation.
4. The need for and feasibility of stress relief.
5. Likely service performance of the cladding material.
6. Risk of disbonding.
7. The need for buffer layers; compatibility of cladding with substrate material.
8. Details of cladding re-instatement.
b. Layered vessels may be considered when a corrosion resistant liner is required in a vessel
designed for such a pressure that it is either impossible or uneconomic to make the vessel
in a conventional way by cladding base plate.
Rules for layered vessels are given only in ASME VIII Divisions 1 and 2. There are
numerous additional points in both manufacture and operation to be considered
when specifying layered vessels.
C.7 Design
C.7.1 General
a. The purchaser shall specify which cladding details are acceptable and which are not.
The way a vessel should be clad depends on: the nature of the cladding material, the
likelihood of significant thermal stress in operation and the methods of NDE that
can be applied to the clad vessel when it is new and when it is in service.
The method of cladding nozzles, particularly small bore nozzles, is an important
detail. Loose liners are generally unsatisfactory because, however well machined
the base material and the liner are, settlement occurs that may crack the welds. The
only exception to this is titanium, in which there is little alternative to a machined
shrunk fit liner and, carefully executed, it may provide a satisfactory cladding.
Page 31 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
b. For all cladding materials other than titanium, nozzles shall be made as follows:
1. By weld overlay cladding. See Figure C.2 for the attachment of the nozzle to the
vessel.
2. From roll clad plate. This applies to large nozzles (larger than DN 200 (NPS 8)). See
also Figure C.2 for the attachment of the nozzle to the vessel
3. From solid corrosion resistant material, see Figure C.3. A check should be made of
any thermal stresses that could result from the presence of a solid nozzle in a clad
vessel.
Page 32 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
SOLID ALLOY
NOZZLE
c. Lightly loaded supports may be considered to be those where the average shear stress
across the section does not exceed 25 MPa (3 625 psi). Moderately loaded are those where
it lies between 25 MPa (3 625 psi) and 50 MPa (7 250 psi), and heavily loaded where it
exceeds 50 MPa (7 250 psi). These stress values are approximate and, where custom and
practice indicates otherwise, designs shall follow satisfactory precedent.
d. The design of attachments shall be as follows:
1. Lightly and moderately loaded internal supports may be welded directly to clad plate
where the plate has been clad by weld overlay.
2. Lightly loaded internal supports may be made by welding directly to clad plate as
shown in figures C.4(a), and C.4(b).
Figure C.4(a) - Attachment of a lightly loaded clad bar or ring to a clad vessel
CLAD PLATE
CLAD STRIP
Page 33 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
CLAD PLATE OR
WELD OVERLAID
SOLID STRIP
Page 34 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
CLAD PLATE
CLAD STRIP
STRIP, SHEET OR
WELD OVERLAY
Page 35 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
f. Heavily loaded internals where thermal stress is present shall be integral with the shell.
g. Clad flanges shall be raised face as shown in Figure C.6. Clad ring type joints made as
shown in Figure C.7 are not acceptable because these are vulnerable to cracking at the root
of the groove, particularly if thermal stresses are large.
(1/4 in)
6mm
MACHINING
GRIND FLUSH
BORE LINING
Figure C.7 - Cladding the groove for a ring type joint (not-acceptable)
TYPE
GROOVE
GRIND FLUSH
BORE LINING
Page 36 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
C.8 Fabrication
C.8.2 Welding
C.8.2.5 PWHT
The temperature for PWHT of vessels clad with austenitic stainless steel shall be decided taking
into account:
(a) The effect of thermal stresses on the dissimilar joint, e.g. dimensional stability, buckling,
disbonding of cladding.
(b) The importance of maintaining the required strength of the base metal and corrosion
resistance of the cladding.
(c) The importance of minimising the development of undesirable metallic phases, e.g. sigma
phase or precipitation of intergranular chromium carbide (weld decay).
Page 37 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Annex E
(Normative)
Additional requirements for vessels in duplex stainless steel (DSS)
E.6 Material
Page 38 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Annex F
(Normative)
Additional requirements for vessels in high nickel alloys
F.1 General
a. In services where Type 304H SS is required (e.g. on Fluid Catalytic Cracking service) it is
recommended that the carbon content be controlled between 0,04 – 0,08% C.
b. In oxygen service, only Alloy 400 shall be used.
This is because with all other readily available materials, particles striking them
may cause sparks.
Page 39 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Annex G
(Normative)
Additional requirements for vessels in titanium
G.1 General
Titanium shall not be used where methanol could be present in the process. It shall not be used
in conjunction with cupro-nickel or any other material with which it is not galvanically
compatible.
Page 40 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Annex Q
(Normative)
Requirements for bolt tightening
Q.1 Scope
This annex sets down the requirements to ensure joint integrity assurance is achieved and
maintained throughout the life of the equipment being purchased. The requirements apply to all
joints on new pressure vessels.
Q.2 Objective
ASME PCC-1-2000 Guidelines for Pressure Boundary Bolted Flange Joint Assembly. ISBN
0-7918-2676-7.
NORSOK Standard L-005 – Compact flanged connections. www.norsok.no
UKOOA/IP. Guidelines for the Management of Bolted Pipe Joints. ISBN 1 903003 14 8
If specified by the purchaser, only operatives trained and examined by a competent instructor in
the use of bolt tightening tools shall carry out the controlled tightening of bolted joints. BP may
require proof of competency.
Guidance for the standards required for skilled performance can be obtained from
the Engineering Construction Training Board (ECITB) in the UK. The ECITB can
also advise on locations of approved training and assessment centres.
Page 41 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Q.6.1 General
Before tightening a bolted joint, criticality assessments should be performed.
Allocation of a criticality rating to a joint defines the controls, reviews, and checks
required to minimise the risk of a leak during test, start up, and in service. These are
required to ensure that appropriate levels of resource and materials are allocated to
a joint on the basis of its criticality.
Page 42 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Criteria Rating
Design Temp < 400 F 1
400 F > Temp < 800 F 2
Temp > 800 F 3
Pressure > 750 psig 2
Service Hydrogen or Hydrogen rich 2
Hydrofluoric acid 2
Category D Fluid XX 1
Category M Fluid XX 3
History of leakage 3
Insulated flanges 2
Mechanical Flange diameter ≥ 48” 2
Compact flanges⑴ 3
Clamps 2
Notes:
1. For compact flanges with bolt stress ≥ 70% bolt yield, tightening method shall be
verified.
2. For any body flange where the bolt is larger than 50 mm (2 in), during hydrotesting,
the use of hardened steel washers shall be considered to protect the back of the
flanges from damage.
The objective in tightening bolted gasketed joints is to uniformly compress the gasket to the
correct loading, without rotating the flanges or yielding the bolts. To this end:
a. The supplier shall have responsibility for calculating the correct bolt load for each joint.
Bolt stress relaxation due to temperature can cause the bolts to relax to a load that
results in leakage.
b. The bolt load shall be sufficient to seal both test and design conditions. If appropriate, the
bolt load shall take account of stress relaxation due to the design temperature. In the
absence of alternative data, the following shall be used to estimate the effect of relaxation:
1. The bolt load for operating conditions (i.e. Wm1 in the ASME Code, Section VIII
Division 1, Appendix 2 and PD 5500; Wop in EN 13345 clause 11) shall be calculated
for the design pressure and temperature.
2. An estimate of the initial load required to provide this after stress relaxation shall be
read from Figure Q.1.
Page 43 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
3. The value from Step 2 shall be compared with the bolt load for the ambient test
condition and the higher value used for bolt tightening.
c. For guidance, the target bolt stress for SA-193 B7 and B16 bolts for use on flanges
designed per the Taylor Forge method (i.e. ASME Code, Section VIII Division 1,
Appendix 2, PD 5500 or EN 13345 clause 11) shall not exceed 345 MPa (50 000 psi).
d. Target bolt stresses for other bolting materials shall be determined by the formula given
below:
Where:
Sb – target bolt stress, MPa (psi)
W – larger of the minimum required bolt load for:
- the operating conditions (i.e. Wm1 in the ASME Code, Section VIII Division 1, Appendix 2 and
PD 5500; Wop in EN 13345 clause 11). The larger value of the calculated load for design and
test conditions will be used. N (lbs).
- gasket seating (i.e. Wm2 in the ASME Code, Section VIII Division 1, Appendix 2 and
PD 5500; WA in EN 13345 clause 11) N (lbs).
N – number of bolts.
AR – root area of one bolt, mm2 (in2)
Page 44 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Stress relaxation behavior of various bolting materials showing percentageof initial stress retained at 1000 hours
over a temerature range 0°C to 800°C
Temperature °F
212 392 572 752 932 1112 1292 1472
100
90
80
Residual Stress (% of initial stress)
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800
Temperature °C
Page 45 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
a. It is often possible to identify the coefficient of friction. It is preferred that the value is
identified and a torque value calculated from the known friction factor and required bolt
load.
The coefficient of friction can be a large variable when using torque wrenches.
Lubricant and tightening tool suppliers should provide the data for the coefficient of
friction. BP may wish to specify lubricants (noting the relevant flange and bolt
materials and the design conditions) and state the friction value. Alternatively, the
tightening tool supplier should use lubricant from a manufacturer who has
conducted friction tests to ASTM D271.
b. Unless friction conditions are known accurately, there is no benefit in assuming a complex
relationship between torque and bolt tension.
c. Simplified formulae have been used to generate the predicted torque levels for 345 MPa
(50 000 psi) bolt stress (see Q.6.1.c) shown in Table Q.3. The table tends to be
conservative. Many unknowns including the amount and type of lubrication affect the
torque required to attain a given bolt stress. If bolt elongation measurements indicate that
torque loads given in Table Q.1 are higher or lower than necessary to achieve 345 MPa
(50 000 psi) bolt stress, adjustment should be made.
d. For bolting materials other than SA 193 B7 and B16, final torque values shall be subject to
approval.
Table Q.3 - Bolt torque to develop a bolt stress(1) of 345 MPa (50 000 psi)
a. Proprietary compact flanges are similar in shape to conventional flanges but designed to be
smaller and lighter for a given set of design conditions. Compact flanges achieve their
compactness by either metal-to-metal flange facing or a pressure energized sealing ring.
See Figure Q.2.
Page 46 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Page 47 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Note: the left hand side shows the flanges before tightening; the right hand side shows the tightened flanges with contact at the
outside edge.
b. Both types of flange shall be tightened using the procedures laid down in this annex.
c. Mating surfaces should be protected until immediately before inserting the seal rings and
flange closure.
d. Alignment of flange faces shall be within the manufacturer’s specification, particularly
with large flanges as permissible misalignment tolerances tend to zero.
Compact flanges are less robust than conventional ASME/ANSI flanges. The flange
surfaces affecting the seal need to be maintained and protected. Surface scuff marks
or worse, indentations, almost certainly lead to leaks.
e. Before tightening it is necessary to verify that the bolt load will be achieved.
Pressure energized flanges require moderate bolt stress typically 200 MPa
(30 000 psi) to seal successfully. As the internal pressure increases the gasket
sealing load increases thereby maintaining the seal.
Metal-to-metal faced flanges require high bolt stresses typically 500 MPa
(70 000 psi) to retain a seal on the gasket. The high load reflects the use of smaller
bolting on a reduced pitch circle diameter. Achieving the high bolt stress is crucial
to a successful seal.
Page 48 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Page 49 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
3. Bolts shall conform to specification and be of correct material, size, and length. They shall
be clean and without burrs. Nuts shall be free running on the bolts.
4. The surface of the flanges where contact is made with the nuts shall be clean, flat, parallel
with the gasket face and completely free from rust or burrs.
This is essential with compact flanges.
5. Gaskets shall conform to specification and be of the correct size. They shall be clean and
metal gaskets shall have grease, rust, and burrs completely removed. Gaskets shall be fitted
against each flange gasket-seating surface to check alignment with the surface.
6. If nuts are to be torqued, only the specified lubricant shall be used and applied evenly to
both the underside nut face (and washers where fitted) and the threads in the portion where
the nut rotates when tightened.
Using the specified and approved lubricant greatly contributes to the accuracy of
the final bolt load achieved.
7. Two bolts shall be installed diametrically opposite each other at 12 and 6 o’clock positions.
A third bolt shall be inserted at a 9 o’clock position midway between the two installed
bolts for retaining the gasket. The nuts shall then be engaged.
8. The gasket shall be inserted, and centred between the flanges. Nuts shall be hand tightened
to hold the gasket in place. If flanged joints are in the vertical plane, gaskets without
centring devices such as ring joint gaskets shall be lowered to the bolts for retention and
then raised into position.
9. Gaskets shall not be held in place with tape during flange alignment. A heavy grease or
gasket cement may be used, if necessary.
Page 50 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
10. Alignment tolerances for flange faces prior to bolt-up shall be checked and conform to
suppliers’ requirements.
This is essential with compact flanges.
11. Flanged joints shall be drawn up squarely so that the entire flange face bears uniformly on
the gasket. Four pointing and eight pointing procedures are acceptable for the initial
alignment of joints, provided torque values less than 1/3rd of the final torque value are
used.
12. If the bolts are to be torqued at least two full threads shall protrude above the upper nut
face. If bolts are to be tensioned at least on full diameter of thread length shall protrude
above the upper nut face. Bolts for tensioning shall be arranged to ensure the tools fit.
13. Measurements of the gap between flanges shall be taken around the circumference to
assure that the flanges are being brought evenly together.
14. When assembling large vessels and exchangers, removable covers, channels, or flanges
shall be adequately supported. The pressure bolting shall not be used for this purpose. It
shall be possible to close up the cover or flange unhindered.
Q.11.2 Clamps
Before tightening, the following checks shall be made.
1. Sealing surfaces of the hubs shall be perfectly clean and completely free from scratches,
rust, burrs, corrosion, and other damage before assembly. Scratches or indications shall be
removed by methods subject to approval.
Clamp connectors are particularly sensitive to cleanliness.
2. The seal ring shall be new and conform to specification. All seal ring surfaces shall be
clean and free of defects.
3. A visual inspection shall be made of the seal ring to confirm it has been manufactured by
the same company as the hub parts.
Seal rings from other manufacturers should never be substituted for the original
design as seal rings are not always interchangeable.
4. Before assembly the seal ring shall be placed in the mating hub seat to check the specified
stand off between the ring rib and hub face has been achieved. If no stand off is present the
hub measurement shall be measured. Any deviation shall be rectified after consultation
with the manufacturer.
5. Bolts shall conform to specification and be of correct material, diameter, and length. They
shall be clean and without burrs. Nuts shall be free running on the bolts.
6. Seal rings shall be cleaned before installation using a non-abrasive material. Lubrication
shall be in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions.
Most seal rings have a coating or plating (cadmium, PTFE or MoS2) which acts as a
lubricant during make up. In some applications where uncoated or unplated seal
rings are used, a light film of clean lubricant will be recommended.
7. The hubs shall be aligned to allow engagement of the seal ring to the hub sealing faces to
ensure correct engagement of the hub and clamp segments.
a. Any misalignment shall be removed by applying external loads to the mating
pipework only after consultation and approval.
b. Removal of misalignment shall not be attempted through use of the clamping force.
c. If external jacks or lifting equipment are used to correct misalignment they shall not
be removed before the clamp is fully assembled and tightened.
Page 51 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
8. Only the specified lubricant shall be used and applied evenly to both the underside nut face
and the threads in the portion where the nut rotates when tightened.
Using the specified and approved lubricant greatly contributes to the accuracy of
the final bolt load achieved.
9. Insert the bolts into the clamp lugs. Thread the nuts on ensuring the spherical face of each
nut is located in the spherical seating provided in the lug face.
10. Two full threads shall protrude above each upper nut face.
Q 12.1 Flanges
The sequence for tightening shall follow the criss-cross tightening sequence irrespective of the
torque tool being used. This sequence is described below.
1. The use of hand torque wrenches is approved for torque values of 1 000 N-m (600 ft-lb),
and less. One inch diameter bolts and smaller should be hand torqued whenever possible.
2. The manual or hydraulic torque wrench and pump unit (in particular the gauge) shall each
have a valid calibration certificate for the date of the task. If any of the certificates are
invalid, the wrench or pump unit shall be either be re-calibrated or exchanged.
3. If the joint is to be tightened using controlled torque, tightening shall not begin before a
final torque value is known.
4. If using hydraulic torque wrenches, the size of cassette or square drive shall be suitable for
the required final torque. The selection of the reaction points shall be chosen to prevent
damage to the flange or any local accessories.
5. The correct tightening sequence shall be marked on the studs in a clockwise direction with
chalk or other safe marker according to the number of bolts in the flange. For reference,
this is shown for an eight bolt flange in Figure Q.5(a). Correct numbering of bolts results
in odd numbered bolts around one side of the flange and even numbered bolts around the
other side.
4 Bolt Flange 1-3-2-4
8 Bolt Flange 1-5-3-7-2-6-4-8
12 Bolt Flange 1-5-9-3-7-11-2-6-10-4-8-12
16 Bolt Flange 1-9-5-13-3-11-7-15-2-10-6-14-4-12-8-16
20 Bolt Flange 1-13-5-17-9-3-15-7-19-11-2-14-6-18-10-4-16-8-20-12
28 Bolt Flange 1-13-21-5-17-9-25-3-15-23-7-19-11-27-2-14-22-6-18-10-26-4-16-24-8-
20-12-28
32 Bolt Flange 1-17-9-25-5-21-13-25-3-19-11-31-7-29-15-27-2-18-10-30-6-22-14-26-4-
20-12-32- 8-24-16-28
Page 52 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
6. Bolts shall be first torqued to 1/3rd the final torque value, using the tightening sequence
specified above. This includes the bolts that were tightened initially in the pre-assembly
procedure. Stud bolts of 5/8 inch and 3/4 inch diameter shall be torqued to 1/2 of the final
torque values on the first pass.
7. The flanges shall never be drawn up tight on one or two bolts only.
This causes local gasket crushing or pinching, which results in leaks.
Flanges shall always be tightened up gradually, using the “criss-cross” pattern shown in
Figure Q.5(b). After each round of tightening, the alignment may be checked, by
measuring the distance between the flange faces.
8. For the second or intermediate pass tightening, all bolts, except 5/8 inch and 3/4 inch bolts
shall be torqued to 2/3rds the final torqued value using the sequence specified.
9. For final pass tightening, two passes shall be made at the final torque setting for all bolts.
This is the 2nd and 3rd pass for bolts 5/8 inch and 3/4 inch in diameter and the 3rd and 4th
pass for larger bolts.
10. Additional passes may be required to ensure the final torque value is achieved in all bolts.
These passes can be made by tightening adjacent bolts in a rotary sequence. See
Figure Q.5(c).
Several passes may be required particularly if an RTJ gasket is fitted.
Q.12.2 Clamps
The sequence for tightening shall follow the criss-cross sequence, see Figure Q.5(b),
irrespective of the torque tool being used.
1. The use of hand torque wrenches is approved for torque values 1 000 N-m (600 ft-lb) and
less. One inch diameter bolts and smaller should be hand torqued whenever possible.
2. The manual or hydraulic torque wrench and pump unit (in particular the gauge) shall each
have a valid calibration certificate for the date of the task. If any of the certificates are
invalid the wrench or pump unit shall be either be re-calibrated or exchanged.
3. If the joint is to be tightened using controlled torque, tightening shall not begin before a
final torque value is known.
This value is usually provided by the manufacturer.
Page 53 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
4. If using hydraulic torque wrenches, the size of cassette or square drive shall be suitable for
the required final torque. The selection of the reaction points shall be chosen to prevent
any damage to the clamp or hubs.
5. The bolts shall be tightened in a criss-cross manner using the final torque value. The
position of the clamp segments shall be monitored to ensure that the segments are pulled
up evenly until the final torque value has been applied.
6. The clamp shall be jarred using a soft faced hammer by administering a blow to the back
of each clamp segment. Each bolt should be re-torqued and the process repeated until
applying the final torque load does not rotate any of the nuts further.
7. The hub faces shall be checked to ensure the faces are flush against the seal ring rib and
the gaps between both of the clamp lugs are equal on both sides.
This check confirms the clamp has been correctly installed and that any excess bolt
load has not damaged any of the clamp components.
Bolt tensioners hydraulically stretch a bolt to a pre-defined strain, allowing the nut to be
manually rotated onto the flange face. The pressure is then released retaining a known and
calculable bolt load.
a. The contractor used for the work and procedures and pump pressures shall be subject to
approval.
b. The bolts shall be specified to ensure a minimum engagement of at least 80% thread
length. This requires the bolts to be at least one diameter longer than the equivalent bolts if
torque is used.
c. The hydraulic pump unit (in particular the gauge) shall have a valid calibration certificate
for the date of the task. If the certificates are invalid the pump unit shall be either be re-
calibrated or exchanged.
d. The tensioners shall be hydraulically connected together and pressurised using one pump.
1. Ideally, all bolts in the flange shall be tensioned simultaneously.
2. The next alternative is to tension half the bolts in the flange at one time. This is
usually the most commercially acceptable option often referred to as ‘50%
tensioning’. The procedure outlined below is based on this option.
3. In no case shall less than four tensioners be used simultaneously.
4. Whatever the quantity of tensioners used they shall always be equally spaced around
the flange.
e. Unless all the bolts are to be tensioned simultaneously, two different pressure settings are
required.
1. The first pass is generally performed at a pressure (often known as ‘Pressure A’)
designed to over-tension the bolts in recognition that some further bolt load is lost as
adjacent bolts are tensioned.
2. Subsequent passes are conducted at a lower pressure (often referred to as
‘Pressure B’), calculated to produce the required minimum residual bolt stress when
the joint is tight.
3. Additional passes should be performed at this lower pressure until the nuts remain
tight when this pressure is applied to the tensioning equipment.
Specialist contractors may provide further guidance in order to minimise the
number of passes required.
Page 54 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
f. The tensioner shall be attached in the following manner. Dependent on the orientation,
additional support or lifting equipment may be required to attach the tools safely.
Several variants of tensioner exist. The procedure outlined below is based on the
most common variant which is usually available for hire as well as purchase.
1. The tensioner socket is positioned over the nut.
2. The tensioner body and bridge are lowered over the stud and nut assembly.
3. Lower the tensioner until the base rests squarely on the flange surface.
4. The puller bar is threaded onto the stud bolt until it “bottoms out” on the tensioner
piston.
5. The above is repeated until all the tensioners have been attached.
g. The hydraulic harness is connected so that each tensioner is included and a ring main is
formed which in turn is connected to a hydraulic pump.
h. The bolts are then tensioned in the following manner:
1. Pressurise the tensioners to the higher pressure (Pressure A).
Throughout this and all pressurisations care should be taken to ensure the maximum
stroke of any of the tensioners is not exceeded.
2. Whilst retaining the pressure in the harness, all the sockets are rotated using a tommy
bar until all the nuts are seated on the flange face. The pressure is released.
3. The pressurisation is repeated twice more. Each time the nuts should rotate a little
further.
This ensures most of the nut flange face embedment losses are removed.
4. The tensioners are removed and attached to the next set of bolts, hydraulically
connected to the pump and pressurised using the lower pressure (Pressure B).
5. Whilst retaining the pressure in the harness, all the sockets are rotated using a tommy
bar until all the nuts are seated on the flange face. The pressure is released.
6. The pressurisation and nut rotation are repeated twice more. The tensioners are
removed.
i. Each bolt has now been tensioned, but bolt load has been lost in the first set of bolts
tensioned as a result of tensioning the second set.
1. To check that sufficient load has been retained a tensioner is attached to one of the
bolts tensioned in item h.1. and the tool pressurised until the nut can be rotated off the
flange face. If the pressure recorded is below the ‘Pressure B’ value then both sets of
bolts shall be re-tensioned using the ‘Pressure B’ value and a further pressure load
check carried out.
The number of tool passes required reflects the gasket fitted. Hard gaskets, e.g.
SWG with rings fitted, tension with few passes while soft gaskets, such as RTJs, can
require several passes. Maximising the safe differential between the two pressures
also reduces the number of passes.
2. This process shall continue until the pressure load check gives a pressure equal to or
in excess of ‘Pressure B’. Once this is satisfied the joint is complete.
Q.14 Prevention of yielding with low strength bolts, e.g. stainless steel
Most equipment requires a bolt stress of c. 25 000 psi (i.e. 83% yield.) so the risk of
yielding if not using controlled bolt tightening is high. If a leak develops, the natural
Page 55 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
tendency is to increase the bolt load and at this point that the bolts may be taken
into yield. Suggestions to avoid the bolt yielding are:
• Always specify Class 2 bolting - this gives a benefit up to 1 ½ on bolts.
• Consider using slave bolting (BP have done this in the past.) In this procedure
lubricated B7 bolts are used to tighten the joint, usually with bolt tensioners.
Thereafter each bolt is removed, one at a time, and the B8 bolt torqued in to
replace it. The torque value used is determined using the torque setting required
to break each B7 bolt out.
• Calibrate the tightening method - in a similar way to that recommended in Q.9.d
for compact flanges.
• For large bolts consider using ASTM A453 Grade 660B.
Where:
D = Elongation of the stud
E = Modulus of elasticity
σ = Target Bolt Stress
LE = Effective bolt length
b. To calculate LE, determine lengths L and H as shown in Figure Q.6. Then, LE = L + 2/3 x
H.
c. Elongation is determined by measuring the length of the stud before and after the tensile
load is applied to the stud.
d. A log of measurements taken for initial lengths and any subsequent elongations shall be
recorded and provided to the purchaser.
e. For the second to last torquing/ tensioning setting, elongation shall be checked to
determine if the final torque or tension setting is appropriate. Adjustments to the final
setting may be required depending on the elongations measured.
Page 56 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
f. A minimum of 25% of the bolts shall be checked after final loading for each joint that is to
be ultrasonically controlled. If only a sampling (25%) of the bolts is measured, sample
bolts shall be chosen from the same quadrant on the flange.
g. The acceptance criteria for final elongation measurements shall be ± 15% of the targeted
elongation, unless otherwise specified. If the average measured value is close to the
targeted value but the scatter is not within the ±15% limit, additional passes are required at
the same load setting.
h. Measurements from the bolt gauge shall be repeatable. A number of readings shall be
taken showing consistent values before entering them on to the Data Sheet. Bolt gauges
shall be calibrated before each new application by an experienced operator.
Q.16 Safety
Page 57 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Annex AA
(Normative)
Requirements for vessels to the ASME Code
AA.1 General
The ASME U and U-2 stamps are quality assurance schemes comparable to ISO 9000. The
supplier is regularly audited and, providing his systems pass the audit, he is permitted to
manufacture without the attendance of an outside inspector. Some countries, states, or operating
sites require the system to be applied on major vessels but otherwise it is optional.
The ASME code is not harmonised and for compliance to the PED, a Notified Body
must confirm that it meets the Essential Requirements of the PED.
AA.6 Materials
a. MDMT shall be the lowest expected metal temperature at the operating location.
1. In determining MDMT, start-up, shutdown, and upset temperatures shall be taken into
account. If these conditions apply, the operating manual for the unit shall specifically
address these procedures.
2. Typically, the MDMT can be set at a temperature so that the coincident pressure
during the start-up and shut-down conditions is equal to or less than 25% of the
design pressure.
b. The MDMT can be determined by computation or by measurement from equipment in
service under equivalent operating conditions.
c. If controlled start-up and shut-down procedures do not determine MDMT and the process
design conditions do not result in special coding effects, the MDMT shall be set to the
lowest expected metal temperature for the site.
d. When specifying MDMT, the pressure coincident with the MDMT shall be specified.
UCS-65 through UCS-68 of ASME BPVC, Section VIII, Division 1, shall be used to
determine the coincident MDMT at pressure.
e. For vessels constructed to Division 1, the MDMT stamped on the vessel nameplate shall be
established as the minimum permissible value based upon the selected material
specification and furnished thickness. The ratio of required thickness to furnished
thickness less corrosion allowance as given in paragraph UCS-66(b) of this Code shall be
1,0 for the design condition that governs the vessel wall thickness calculation.
AA.7 Design
AA.7.1 General
Maximum allowable working pressure (MAWP) shall be calculated by the supplier and shown
on the drawings.
AA.7.2 Division 1
Intermediate heads shall be installed with 3 mm (1/8 in) additional corrosion allowance for fillet
seal weld per paragraph UW-13(b). Liquid service for this type vessel shall be avoided and shall
be used only if approved by BP. Intermediate heads, attached by fillet welds, shall have the
welds magnetic particle or liquid penetrant examined.
Page 58 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
AA.7.3 Division 2
Whether or not fatigue calculations have to be made is determined by rules given in AD-160.
AA.8 Fabrication
AA.16 Division 3
a. Division 3 applies to vessels designed for 70 MPa (10 000 psi) or above. It is limited to
certain materials and therefore the purchaser shall thoroughly review proposed materials.
b. Design by analysis predominates. Advanced methods of design and design methods based
on fracture mechanics are included. The results of such analyses shall be critically
reviewed by the purchaser. Article KD-3 contains an extensive fatigue design method.
Page 59 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Annex BB
(Normative)
Requirements for vessels to PD 5500
BB.1 General
PD 5500 is not a harmonised standard and a Notified Body must confirm that it meets the
Essential Requirements of the PED. Guidance on where PD 5500 conforms to the PED is given
in Annex Z of PD 5500.
BB.6 Materials
Page 60 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Annex CC
(Normative)
Requirements for vessels to BS EN 13445
CC.1 General
BS EN 13445 is a harmonised standard and presumed to have conformity with the PED, without
particular approval by a Notified Body.
CC.6 Materials
The method in Annex D for autorefrigeration provides allowable minimum temperatures for
stress levels of F, 2/3F, and 50 MPa. Therefore a graph may be plotted showing the envelope of
acceptable pressure and temperature. The design shall lie within this envelope.
CC.7 Design
Page 61 of 62
18 December 2006 GP 46-01
Guidance on Practice for New Pressure Vessels
Bibliography
[1] BP Corrosion and Materials Guidelines 2001: Report No. S/UTG/309/01, Corrosion Under Insulation,
A Guide to the Prevention and Detection of Corrosion Beneath Thermal Insulation.
[2] BS DD CEN/TS 764:2004 Pressure equipment Part 6: Structure and content of operating instructions
(draft).
[5] ASTM D271, Standard Test Method for Calibration and Operation of a block-on-ring testing machine.
Page 62 of 62