Chapter 08
Chapter 08
Chapter 08
Reduced Mass
m1
r
r1
CM
R
m2
r2
O
r1 = r2 + r ⟹ r = r1 - r2
m 1 r 1 + m2 r 2
R= ⟹ m1 r1 + m2 r2 = (m1 + m2 ) R
m 1 + m2
F = - ∇ U (r) = f (r) r
central force
U r1 , r2 U (r)
1
1
L= m1 (r1 )2 + m2 (r2 )2 - U (r)
2 2
?
First Task : 2 - body problem 1 - body problem
Let ' s write r 1 , r2 in terms of r , R
m1 r1 + m2 r2 = (m1 + m2 ) R
m 2 r 1 - m2 r 2 = m 2 r
(m1 + m2 ) r1 = (m1 + m2 ) R + m2 r
(m1 + m2 ) m2 m2 m2
r1 = R+ r = R+ r = R+ r
(m1 + m2 ) (m1 + m2 ) (m1 + m2 ) M
m2 m1
r1 = R + r, similarly, r 2 = R - r
M M
M = m1 + m2 = total mass
2 CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb
1
m2
m1
2 1 2
L= m1 R + r + m2 R - r - U (r)
2 M 2 M
m1 m2
m1 m2
since, R r-R r=0
M M
1 1 m2 m1
2 1 1 2
L = m1 (R)2 + m1 r + m2 (R)2 + m2 r - U (r)
2 2 M 2 2 M
1
1 m1 m2
L = (m1 + m2 ) (R)2 + (m1 + m2 ) (r)2 - U (r)
2 2 M 2
1
1 m1 m2
L= M (R)2 + (r)2 - U (r)
2 2 M
m1 m2
μ= = reduced mass
M
1
1
L= M (R)2 + μ (r)2 - U (r)
2 2
As R = cyclic ignorable coordinate
d ∂L ∂L d ∂L ..
= =0 ⟹ = 0, R = 0 ⟹ R = constant
dt ∂ Ri ∂ Ri dt ∂ Ri
1
⟹ M (R)2 = Constant = L0
2
1
L = L0 + μ (r)2 - U (r)
2
In CM - frame, L0 = 0
1
L= μ (r)2 - U (r)
2
This Lagraingain describes the motion of
single particle of mass μ under central force F = f (r) r
..
..
μ
L = μ r × r + r × μ r = r × μ r = r × F = r × f (r) r = 0
M
∴ L = r × μ r = constant
1
E= μ (r)2 + U (r) =? constant
2
..
1 ..
..
E = μ r · r + r · r + r · ∇ U (r) = μ r · r - r · F = F · r - r · F = 0
2
1
∴ E = μ (r)2 + U (r) = constant
2
π
We choose this plane to be the xy - plane with θ =
2
(r, θ, ϕ) ⟶ (r, ϕ)
1 2
L= μ r2 + r2 ϕ - U (r)
2
As ϕ = cyclic coordinate
∂L 2 l
pϕ = = μ r ϕ = constant = l, ϕ=
∂ϕ μ r2
1
dA = r×dr
2
r = r cosϕ x + sinϕ y, d r = r dr + r - sinϕ x + cosϕ y dϕ,
r × d r = r cosϕ x + sinϕ y × r - sinϕ x + cosϕ y dϕ
1 1
d A = r × d r = r2 dϕ z
2 2
4 CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb
1 dA 1 dϕ 1 1 l
dA = r2 dϕ, = r2 = r2 ϕ = r2
2 dt 2 dt 2 2 μ r2
dA l
= = constant
dt 2μ
"Areal velocity is constant in time" [Kepler ' s second law]
(r, θ, ϕ) ⟶ (r, ϕ)
1 2 l
L= μ r2 + r2 ϕ - U (r), ϕ=
2 μ r2
1 l2
L= μ r2 + - U (r)
2 μ2 r2
dr 2 (E - V (r))
r= =±
dt μ
dϕ dϕ dt ϕ l ±1
= = =
dr dt dr r μ r2
2 (E-V (r))
μ
CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb 5
l dr
ϕ (r) = ±
μ r2
2 (E-V (r))
μ
2 l2 E
-k ± k2 + μ
r=
2E
2 l2 E
-k + k2 + μ
If E > 0 [Hyperbola] : r=
2E
2 l2 E 1/2 2 l2 E
-k + k 1 + μk2
-k + k 1 + 2 μk2
+ (E2 )
If E = 0 [Parabola] : r = =
2E 2E
l2
If E = 0 [Parabola] : r=
2 μk
2 l2 E
k∓ k2 - μ
If E < 0 [Ellipse], let' s E = - E , r=
2 E
2
2 l2 E
As, k > k - , there will be two roots
μ
2 l2 E 2 l2 E
k- k2 - μ
k+ k2 - μ
rmin = , rmax =
2 E 2 E
μ k2
E = = Vmin [Circle]
2 l2
2 l2 E μ k2
When k2 - =0⟹ E = = Vmin ,
μ 2 l2
k k l2
then rmin = rmax = = = =? r0
2
2 E 2 μ k2 μk
2l
l2 k l2 k l2
V (r) = - , V' (r) = - + = 0 ⟹ r0 =
2 μ r2 r μ r3 r2 μk
3 l2 2k 1 3 l2 k
V'' (r0 ) = - = -2k = > 0 [V (r0 ) = Vmin ]
μ r0 4 r0 3 r0 3 μ r0 r0 3
CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb 7
l2 k μ k2 μk2 μ k2
Vmin = V (r0 ) = - = - =-
l 2 2 l2 2 l2 l2 2 l2
2 μ μk μk
μ k2
Vmin = -
2 l2
l2 k
V (r) = 2
-
2μr r
r>>r0 k r>>r0 r <<r0 l2 r <<r0
V (r) - 0 & V (r) ∞
r 2 μ r2
1 2
μ r = E - V (r) ≥ 0 ⟹ E ≥ V (r) ≥ V (r3) = Vmin
2
E1 ≥ 0, 1 - turning point at r1 , [unbounded motion]
With initial condition, r(t=0) = R, r(t=0) = 0
1 l2 k 1 k
E= μ r2 + - = μ v2 -
2 2 μ r2 r 2 r
1 k 2k
E=0 ⟹ μ v2esc = ⟹ vesc =
2 R μR
dE (R) μ vorb2 k k
=0 ⟹ = 2 ⟹ vorb =
dR R R μR
mM
In M >>> m limit with k = GM & μ = →m
m+M
8 CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb
m vorb2 GmM GM
= 2 ⟹ vorb =
R R R
1 GmM 2 GM
m vesc2 = ⟹ vesc =
2 R R
Summary-I
v = vorb, Circular orbit [E = Vmin]
vorb < v < vesc, Ellipse orbit [Vmin < E < 0]
v = vesc, parabola orbit [E = 0]
v > vesc, hyperpola orbit [E > 0]
μ 2 2
L= r + r2 ϕ - U (r)
2
d ∂L ∂L ∂L 2 ∂U
= , = μr ϕ -
dt ∂ r ∂r ∂r ∂r
CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb 9
d ∂L .. 2 ∂U
= μ r = μr ϕ -
dt ∂ r ∂r
.. 2 ∂U
μ r = μr ϕ -
∂r
1
Let' s define, u =
r
l
ϕ=
μ r2
du du dr dt 1 r r l
= = - 2 = -μ ϕ =
dϕ dr dt dϕ r ϕ l μr2
d2 u d du d r dt d r
= = -μ = -μ
dϕ2 dϕ dϕ dϕ l dϕ dt l
2.. ..
r 2 2 r r
= -μ = -μ
lϕ l2
.. 1 l2 d2 u l2 2 d2 u l l 2
r =- 2 2 2
=- 2
u 2
, ϕ= 2
= u ,
μ r dθ μ dθ μr μ
k ∂U k
U (r) = - = -k u, = 2 = k u2
r ∂r r
.. 2 ∂U l2 d2 u l2 ∂U
r =rϕ - ⟹ - u2 = u3 -
∂r μ2 dϕ2 μ2 ∂r
d2 u μ2∂U
= - u+
dϕ2 l2 u2 ∂r
d2 u μ F[u]
2
+u = - [orbital equation]
dϕ l2 u2
Important to note that for inverse square law force,
r2 r2 k μk
-μ F[r] = μ = = constant
l2 l2 r2 l2
d2 u k
+u = μ
dϕ2 l2
k d2 w d2 u
Define, w = u - μ , =
l2 dϕ2 dϕ2
10 CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb
d2 u k d2 w
+ u-μ =0 ⟹ +w=0
dϕ2 l2 dϕ2
w = A cos (ϕ - ϕ0 ), ϕ0 = 0, w = A cosϕ
μk 1 1
u = A cosϕ + = , r=
l2 r A cosϕ + μk
l2
l2 l2
μk μk
r= =
A
cosϕ + 1 Al2
μk 1+ μk
cosϕ
l2
α Al2 l2
r= , ε= , α=
1 + ε cosϕ μk μk
This is the equation of conic section which is formed by the intersection of a plane and a cone.
α α
a= [aphelion], b = [perihelion]
1 - ε2
1 - ε2
α α 2ε αε
2d= - =α ⟹ d= =aε
1-ε 1+ε 1- ε2 1 - ε2
k l2 k αk k
E=- α
+ =- α
+ = ε2 - 1
1+ε 2μ α
1+ε 2 1+ε 2 α
1+ε 2 2α
2Eα l2
ε= 1+ , α=
k μk
Summary-II
2Eα
ε= 1+
k
k
ε = 0, Circular orbit E = Vmin = -
2α
0 < ε < 1, Elliptic orbit [Vmin < E < 0]
ε = 1, Parabolic orbit [E = 0]
ε > 1, Hyperpolic orbit [E > 0]
∂2 V
Stability requires >0
∂r2 r=R
∂V l2 k (1 - n) l2 l2
=- + R-n = - + k R-n = 0 ⟹ k R-n-1 =
∂r r=R μ R3 (1 - n) μ R3 μ R4
μk
Rn-3 =
l2
∂2 V 3 l2 3 l2 nl2 l2
= - n k R-n-1 = - = (3 - n) >0
∂r2 r=R μ R4 μ R4 μ R4 μ R4
General Treatment
.. 2 ∂U
μ r - r ϕ = - = F (r) = -μ g (r)
∂r
CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb 15
.. l2
r- = - g (r), put r = R + x, x << R
μ2 r 3
.. l2
x- (R + x)-3 = - g (R + x)
μ2
.. l2 x -3
x- 1 + = - g (R + x)
μ2 R 3 R
.. l2 3x dg
x- 1- = - g (R) - x
μ2 R 3 R dr r=R
l2
- = - g (R)
μ2 R 3
.. 3x dg
x - g (R) 1 - = - g (R) - x
R dr r=R
.. 3x dg
x - g (R) + g (R) = - g (R) - x
R dr r=R
.. 3 dg
x = - g (R) + x = -ω2 x
R dr r=R
.. 3 dg
x = -ω2 x, ω2 = g (R) + >0
R dr r=R
3 dg
dr r=R 3 dF
dr r=R
+ >0 ⇔ + >0
R g (R) R F (R)
k 3 -n k R-n-1
F (R) = - ⇔ + >0
Rn R k R-n
3 n (3 - n)
- = >0 ⟹ n<3
R R R
k
k 3 -
R2 ?
F (R) = - ⇔ + >0
R R k
R
3 1 2
- = > 0 [therefore, circular orbits are stable in this case]
R R R
R
1 1 -
R dF (R) 2k 1 -
R k k e- a
F (R) = -k + e a, =- - - e a - + -
R2 aR dR R3 a R2 R2 aR a
dF (R) 2k 2k k R 1 1 R
= + + e- a , F (R) = -k + e- a
dR R3 a R2 a2 R R2 aR
R
-
3 2 3k + 2k
+ k
e a
R a R2 a2 R
- >0
R
R -
k2 + k
e a
R aR
R R2
2 + 2 +
a a2
3- >0
1 + R
a
R R2 R R
2+2 + < 3 1+ = 3+3
a a2 a a
R 2 R a 2 a
- - 1 < 0, + -1 > 0
a a R R
a 2 a a -1 ± 1+4 -1 ± 5
+ - 1 = 0, = =
R R R 2 2
a 5 -1
= = 0.618
R 2
CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb 17
a 5 -1
q= > = 0.618 [for the stability of circular orbits]
R 2
a 5 -1
q= > = 0.618
R 2
3
q2 +q-1
-1
0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0
q
l= μ
1.0
0.8
0.6
V(r)
0.4
0.2
0.0
-0.2
0 1 2 3 4 5
r/R
18 CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb
μ c2 GM l2 GM l2
V[r] = ϵ -ϵ + -
2 r 2 μ r2 r3 μc2
ϵ = 0 for light and ϵ = 1 for massive particles
d2 u k
+u = μ [Orbital eqn. in Newtonian Gravity]
dϕ2 l2
CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb 19
d2 u GM
+u= + 3 GM u2 [Orbital eqn. in GR]
dϕ2 l2
mM M>>m
μ= m
m+M
1 k m GmM GM GM
[u] = = μ = = ⟹ = L0
L l2 m2 v2 r2 (v r)2 v2 r
G MSun
v << c ⟹ << r
c2
Dimensions with c = 1, [GM] = [L], m = 1;
d2 u GM
+u = [Orbital eqn. in Newtonian Gravity]
dϕ2 l2
d2 u GM
+u= + 3 GM u2 [Orbital eqn. in GR]
dϕ2 l2
1
[l] = [L]⟹ [β] = & [δ] = [L]0
L
3 (GM)2
GM 3 (GM)2 δ l2
β= , δ= << 1, = = 3 GM
l2 l2 β GM
l2
GM
u0 = β + A cosϕ = + A cosϕ
l2
nπ
ϕn = ≃ n π (1 + δ),
(1 - δ)
Therefore, successive perihelia in u occur at the interval of
ϕ2 - ϕ1 = 2 π (1 + δ) instead of 2 π
22 CM-I-Lec-Jan-01-2021.nb
where l2 = a 1 - ε2 GM,
m3
a = 5.8 × 1010 m, ε = 0.2056, MSun = 2 × 1030 kg, G = 6.67430 × 10-11
kg - s
1
* 100
0.2408
415.282
0.103614
Remember that a second of arc, arcsecond (arcsec) denoted by the symbol { ''} is
1
of a degree
3600
43.0289
Orbital Dynamics
Hohmann Transfer
"Path of minimum total energy expenditure"
k
E=- [for circular & elliptical orbits]
2a
For a circular orbit with radius r1 around Sun,
k 1 k k 1
E1 = - = T+U = mv21 - ⟹ = mv21
2 r1 2 r1 2 r1 2
k
v1 =
m r1
k k 1 k
Et = - =- = m v2t1 - [At prehelion of transfer - oribit]
2 at r1 + r 2 2 r1
1 k k r2 k
m v2t1 = - + =
2 r1 + r 2 r1 (r1 + r2 ) r1
2 CM-I-Lec-Jan-22-25-2021.nb
2k r2
vt1 =
mr1 r1 + r 2
Δv1 = vt1 - v1
For a circular orbit with radius r2 around Sun
k 1 k k
E2 = - = T+U = mv22 - ⟹ v2 =
2 r2 2 r2 m r2
k 1 k
Et = - = m v2t2 - [At Aphelion of transfer - oribit]
r1 + r 2 2 r2
2k r1
vt2 =
mr2 (r1 + r2 )
Δv = Δv1 + Δv2
Delta - v budget
Transfer time
4 π2 μ
τ2 = a3 [Kepler ' s Third Law]
k
CM-I-Lec-Jan-22-25-2021.nb 3
τt m
Tt = =π a3/2
t
2 k
Bi - elliptic transfer
The bi - elliptic transfer is an orbital maneuver that moves a spacecraft from one orbit to another and
may, in certain situations, require less delta - v than a Hohmann transfer maneuver.
4 CM-I-Lec-Jan-22-25-2021.nb
Round - Trip
Although the Hohmann transfer path represents the least energy expenditure,
it does not represent the shortest time
M1 R 1 + M 2 R 2
R= = 0 ⟹ M1 R1 = -M2 R2 ⟹ MS RS = ME RE
M1 + M 2
12 CM-I-Lec-Jan-22-25-2021.nb
CM-I-Lec-Jan-22-25-2021.nb 13
Calculations of L4 & L5
14 CM-I-Lec-Jan-22-25-2021.nb
CM-I-Lec-Jan-22-25-2021.nb 15
16 CM-I-Lec-Jan-22-25-2021.nb