Physiognomonica
Physiognomonica
Physiognomonica
BY
T.
LOVEDAY
AND
E. S.
FORSTER
PREFACE
THIS work, as \ve have it, is evidently a compilation of two treatises, the second beginning with Chapter IV.
Neither
is
Aristotle s
both
may
be Peripatetic.
Prantl
text (Teubner, 1881) has been used, but a great many emendations have been taken from Forster s text and
very
notes in his Scriptores Physiognomonici (1893), vol. i. On J. B. Forster s excellent work we have chiefly relied has also proved Porta s De humana physiognomonia (1650) useful. We have, as before, to thank Mr. W. D. Ross
;
and suggestions.
we decided
,
clumsy
the
.
forms
more accurate
in place of
T. L.
E. S. F.
CONTENTS
CHAP. 1. Methods.
2. 3.
4.
5.
Body and
soul.
Method
again.
Typical animals.
Inferences, chiefly from animals.
6.
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
I
not independent of and unaffected 805* but is conditioned by the state of by bodily processes, and contrariwise the body is sympathetically the body influenced by affections of the soul. 1 The former of these propositions is well exemplified by drunkenness and sick ness, where altered bodily conditions produce obvious 5 mental modifications, and the second by the emotions of
character
is
;
MENTAL
love and fear, and by states of pleasure and pain. 2 still better instances of the fundamental connexion of
But
body
10
and soul and their very extensive interaction may be found normal products of nature. 3 There never was an animal w ith the form of one kind and the mental character of another the soul and body appropriate to the same kind always go together, and this shows that a specific body involves a specific mental character. Moreover, experts on the lower animals are always able to judge of character it is thus that a horseman chooses his by bodily form
in the
r
: :
15
be true (and
it
always
is
true),
practicable.
Three methods have been essayed in the past, each having had its special adherents. i. The first method took as the basis for physiognomic
inferences the various genera of animals, positing for each
20
genus a peculiar animal form, and consequently upon this a peculiar mental character, and then assuming that if a man resembles such and such a genus in form he will
resemble
1
it
also in soul. 4
8o5
*
&>5
2, 3.
a
805"
8o5
xav
(})v<Tioyi><t>fjLovov<ri,
Read Kivr^f^v, rouro SjjXov (as in Stobaeus, Anthol. i. 47 b ). Place re after \virat, as Forster suggests. i.e. in animals. 8. Read with Wachsmuth of /ueV yap eV TWI/ yev&v 2l,22. Km did TidffMvoi Kud eKao-rov yevos dSos n
7.
q>ov
TO
TUVT<J>
(T<*p.<i
[or
keep rw
Kttl
8os
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
Those who adopted the second method proceeded in the same way, except that they did not draw their inferences from all kinds of animals but confined themselves
2.
25
to
human
(e. g.
beings they distinguished various races of men Egyptian, Thracian, Scythian) by differences of appear
:
ance and of character, and drew their signs of character from these races just as others did from animal genera.
3.
The
third
method took
which
as
its
facial
expressions
are
observed
accompany
fear,
such as anger,
erotic
excitement, and all the other passions. the All these methods are possible, and others as well selection of signs may be made in diverse ways. The last:
mentioned method by itself, however, is defective in more than one respect. For one thing, the same facial expression may belong to different characters the brave and the
:
impudent,
5
person will assume a cheerful countenance, whilst a naturally cheerful man, if he be distressed, will change his expression accord And, thirdly, the number of inferences that can ingly.
though their characters may at times wear an for instance, a morose now and again spend an enjoyable day and
:
be drawn from
10
is
small.
arguments from beasts, the selection of signs is made on wrong principles. Suppose you have passed in review one by one the forms of all the different kinds of animals, you still have no right to assert that a man who
to
As
15
resembles a given kind in body will resemble it in soul In the first place, speaking broadly, you will never also. 1 More find this complete likeness, but only a resemblance.
20
very few signs are peculiar to individual genera most of them are common to more than one kind, and of what use is resemblance in a common attribute ? A man will resemble a lion, let us say, neither more nor less than a deer. (For we have a right to suppose that common signs indicate common mental characters and peculiar
over,
;
8o5
is
b
15.
jue r rt
a
,
but
Hayduck
(v TI
attractive.
CHAPTER
signs peculiar characters).
8os
will
not get any clear evidence from common signs. 1 But is he any better off if he takes every genus by itself and
selects signs that are peculiar to
each
cannot
tell
signs
of peculiar characteristics,
that there are any mental characteristics peculiar to the different kinds of animals that we examine in physiognomy.
found in many 25 nor timidity to the hare, but it shares this quality with numberless other creatures. Thus it is equally fruitless to select the common and the peculiar features, and we must abandon the attempt to proceed by an examination of every kind of animal singly. Rather, we ought to select our signs from all animals that have some 3 mental affection in common. 2 For instance, when investi gating the external marks of courage, we ought to collect all brave animals, and then to inquire what sort of affections are natural to all of them but absent in all other animals. For if we were to select this or that as the signs of courage 8o6 a
Courage
is
lion,
but
is
other creatures
in
way
as not to exclude
the possibility of the presence in all these animals of some other mental affection, 3 we should not be able to tell
of
courage
ful
5
Two
conditions
must be
therefore
we choose our
signs
must be
as
numerous as
possible,
have any mental affection in common except that one of which we are investigating the signs. Permanent bodily signs will indicate permanent mental qualities, but what about those that come and go ? How
can they be true signs
also
1
if
come and go
No doubt
ro
Read with Forster duio-afyjijeit on the evidence of the Latin version by Earth. Messanius. 2 b 8o5 29. The Latin version of Earth. Mess, supports amivrcav in place of avdpunatv. Otherwise uvopoluv would seem more likely to have given rise to the error. 3 8o6 a 1-3. Inserting wore before pi]. Wachsmuth proposed to omit rnvTi errrt TCI rrrj/jLf ia avUpeias. 4 a 8o6 9. Omitting with Hayduck.
i
b 8o5 2i.
8o6 a
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
might be true once in a way, but still it would be worthless because it would not be a con stant concomitant of a particular state of soul. 1
it
sign to be permanent,
Then again there are affections of soul whose occurrence produces no change in the bodily marks on which the physiognomist relies, and they will not provide his art with
recognizable signs.
for the fact of
2
Thus
having acquired a piece of knowledge will not have produced any alteration in the bodily signs on
relies.
which physiognomy
20
special province of physio- 2 the range of its application is limited), and gnomy (for the sources from which its various kinds of data are drawn,
WE
and then we may proceed to a detailed exposition more convincing among its conclusions.
of the
25
for its province, as the name implies, natural affections of mental content, and also such acquired affections as on their occurrence modify the
Physiognomy has
all
I will signs which physiognomists interpret. later \vhat kinds of acquired characters are meant, explain
external
but now I will give a list a complete list of the sources from which physiognomic signs are drawn. They are
these
:
30 tcristic facial
movements, gestures of the body, colour, characexpression, the growth of the hair, the smooth
of the body,
is
ness of the skin, the voice, condition of the flesh, the parts and the build of the body as a whole. Such
the
list
in
r,5
that physiognomists always give of the sources their signs. Had this list been obscure
or insignificant, 4 there would have been no use in my going any further but, as things are, it may be worth while 8o6 b to give a more detailed description of the more convincing 5
;
draw from
7rp<iy/*<m.
their material,
and
8d6 a 8o6 a
a
4>
12.
1
F. reads
-rradfjfiaTi
for
5.
recognizable by
3
(u6um)m,
4
8o6 a
The text seems to be corrupt. F. suggests TU trrjuela rwr KrA. F. reads evaaff)^- r) /j.t] n<Trj^.os. 358o6 a 37. Read (mtfjavfVTfpa F.
o6 25.
ru>v.
The
may
lie
in
CHAPTER
to state
*
8o6
what
to
supposed
be found, so far as
brilliant
whilst
parts,
when
Soft hair indicates cowardice, and coarse hair courage. This inference is based on observation of the whole animal
The most timid of animals are deer, hares, and whilst the lion and they have the softest coats sheep, and wild-boar are bravest and have the coarsest coats. Precisely the same holds good of birds, for it is the rule that birds with coarse plumage are brave and those with soft plumage timid, particular instances being the cock and the And again, among the different races of mankind quail.
kingdom.
;
10
the
same combination
of qualities
may
be observed, the
15
inhabitants of the north being brave and coarse-haired, whilst southern peoples are cowardly and have soft hair.
about -the belly signifies loquacity, whole tribe of birds, for the one is 2 a bodily and the other a mental property peculiar to birds. When the flesh is hard and constitutionally firm, it in
thick growth on the evidence
of hair of the
20
dicates
dullness
of
sense
when smooth,
it
indicates
naturally good parts combined with instability of character, except when smooth flesh goes with a strong frame and
powerful extremities.
Lethargic movements are a sign of a soft character, rapid
25
movements of a fervid temper. As to the voice, when deep and full it is a sign when high-pitched and languid, of cowardice.
Gesture
of courage;
and the
their
preted by
instance,
varieties of facial expression are inter for 30 if, affinity to different emotions
:
when
is
man
takes
on
an angry person,
signified.
re
8o6 b
I.
Omitting
with F.
;
of birds in the sense that they do not occur lower animals but they may occur in men, for other wise no physiognomic conclusions could be drawn from them. 3 806^ 30-31. Reading orav yap mitrx?) TI, d TOIOVTOV TI yiverni olov
These
qualities are
ifiia
vrjp.f iov.
tippfii
KT\.
8o6 b
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
Males are bigger and stronger than females
kind, and their extremities are stronger firmer and capable of more perfect
of the same and sleeker and
performance
of
all
3?
functions.
But
inferences
of the
body
8o7
a
is
of character
are less secure than those based on facial expression 1 and movements and gesture. In general it silly to rely on a single sign you will have more reason
:
your conclusions when you find several signs all pointing one way. Here I may mention a possible method of physiognomy which has never yet been tried. Suppose, e.g., that irasci2 bility and morose sulkiness necessarily involve an envious disposition, and that the physiognomist could, without any bodily signs of the last character, deduce its presence from the presence of the other characters, we should then have a method peculiarly appropriate to masters of philosophy,
,
for confidence in
10
since
when
is, we suppose, the peculiar mark of philosophy, certain premises are given, to know the necessary conclusion. 3 But this method which considers the inter
it
relations of
empirical observation
4 Take the voice, for example. By contrary conclusions. the former method you might feel bound 5 to connect a shrill voice with a fierce temper, because in vexation and 15
anger
one
voice tends to
shrill,
whilst placid
people speak in tones at once languid and deep. But as against this, if you observe beasts, you find that a deep voice goes with courage and a shrill voice with
timidity,
bull,
of lion
and
the
20
hound s bay, and the deep-noted crow of high-spirited and on the other, the high-pitched tones of deer and
1
cocks,
hares.
8o6 b 36. Omitting eV rols with three MSS. Cf. 805* 28. a 8o7 5. Reading mKpo with Sylburg. a 8o7 ip. Reading TO avaynalov (I8(vm. Schneider reads Snep
i/
fl8fvai.
4
807*^11,
TiovTiu
T<U
12.
Kara ra
In this very corrupt passage F. reads fvriv ore eWeo-Ti S 6Ye seems Trdffr] (f)V(noyva>p.nv?iv TO Kara TU
f<5n.
necessary to^ avoid undue abruptness. The abruptness of the next sentence irepi (jxavijs is suspicious. The sense is Kara TU fcoa, olov rrein
OVI]S
6
KOTO
(Ji(l>
KrA.
8e"iv
807*
14.
Read with L a
in place of 8velv
eVe/cei/.
CHAPTER
2
to connect
voice,
8o7
Yet perhaps even in these cases it is better not courage and cowardice with the pitch of the
rather with
its
1 intensity, so that
but
it is
marks the brave and a languid and feeble voice the coward. It is safest, however, to refrain from all positive assertion when you find that your signs are inconsistent and contrary to one another in detail, unless they belong to classes, some of which you have determined to be more trustworthy than
others.
25
Above
all it is
upon
it is
concerned
for in
physiognomy we try
of of
from bodily signs the character or that particular person, and not the characters this the whole human race.
to infer
of
?>0
SIGNS
of the
ities
;
Courage
;
are-
coarse hair
an upright carriage
and strength of bones, sides and extrem body the belly broad and flat shoulder-blades broad and
size
;
neither too closely nor too loosely knit 35 a sturdy neck, not very fleshy a chest well covered with flat hips flesh and broad the thickness of the calf low 8o7 b down the leg 2 gleaming eyes, neither wide and staring
set well apart,
;
;
;
slits,
3
the
body
of a
a forehead straight and lean, not large, and neither quite smooth nor yet a mass of wrinkles. Signs of Cowardice are a small growth of soft hair the figure
hue
stooping
and lacking in quickness the thickness of the calf high up the leg a sallow complexion weak blinking weak extremities little legs, and hands long and eyes delicate loins small and weak a rigid gesture of the
; ;
ro
with undecided, deprecating, scared movements, body and a shifty downcast look. Good natural parts are indicated by rather moist and
;
8o7 23.
,
fv eppaneirii
orTf
(fi<avi]v.
!
8o7
vfl^, d
F. thinks that there is a lacuna between f v rw and and suggests that the last of the missing word s may be But it is more likely that there is an anacoluthon.
TI]I>
I.
807"
2, 3
&c. 807
IO.
Read with Schneider Karecrn-uo-^ai. Read (Tvppvov, avx^porepov TO ... ov ptrumov 4 b 8o7 5. Read ro5 o-w/zm-t avyKKa6fiKa>s. Read TO o-co/ua (Tvirovov, ev TOIS Kivrjcrecriv owe ira/io?. F.
cra>/j.aTOS
Soy
tender
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
flesh, not exactly firm nor yet extremely fat by leanness of the shoulders, neck, face, and neighbouring regions; by shoulder-blades closely knit and the parts
;
below slack
a somewhat gaunt back by supple sides a small a thin skin a clear pinkish hue over the body and of hair, neither very coarse nor very black growth
1
; ; ;
20
Dullness of sense is indicated when the back of the neck and the legs are fleshy and stiffly the shoulderthe hip-joint round fitted and knitted
moist, gleaming eyes.
;
;
blades high-set
25
the the forehead big, round, and fleshy and vacant the legs thick and fleshy and round eyes pale at the ankles; the jaws big and fleshy; loins fleshy;
; ; ;
legs long
neck thick-set
of
The manner
of the dull
movement, gesture, and facial expression 2 man, you may take it, are analogous to his
character.
jo
Impudence is signified by small, bright, wide-open eyes, with heavy blood-shot lids slightly bulging 3 high shouldera carriage of the body not erect, but crouched blades
;
slightly forwards
and high
35
chest.
;
Signs
of
a slow gait
a slow
;
and weak
voice
speaking with a breath-like small eyes, black but not lustrous, not
way
of
slits
Good Spirits are indicated by a good-sized forehead, fleshy a rather the region of the eyes rather low and smooth
;
drowsy-looking countenance, neither keen nor reflective. The gait, we may suppose, will be slow and languid, the and facial expression those of a good but not
gesture a quick man.
;
brows
1
8c>7
lean and wrinkled Signs of Low Spirits are enfeebled eyes (but you should notice that weak
2
:!
b i6. b 28.
Read uvfipiva. Schneider. Read ava\a^ave (F.) on evidence of Barth. Mess. Read Traced, p.iKpbv eyKvpra. Read d<r0(^s. F. (I a has aadivts according to Bekker).
de physiogn.
liber,
Cp. Anon,
107
Vocem
infirmi
spiritus
CHAPTER
eyes
8o8 a
10
and low
spirits)
his head weak-eyed and knock-kneed hangs on his right shoulder his hands are carried upturned and flabbily and as he walks he either wags his loins or else holds them rigid and he casts a furtive by an effort for all the world like Dionysius the gaze around, Sophist.
is
; ;
The Pathic
i5
Sulkiness
is
indicated
by a
;
and by straight
20
Men
of Fierce
ribs
about the
Temper bear themselves erect, are broad and move with an easy gait their bodies
;
;
are of a reddish hue, 2 their shoulder-blades set well apart, their extremities large and powerful large and broad they are smooth about the chest and groin they have great beards, and the hair of the head starts low down with a
;
;
vigorous growth. Those of a Gentle disposition are robust-looking, well covered with plenty of moist flesh well-sized men and
;
25
well-proportioned
back
than
carrying themselves with head thrown and their hair starts rather higher up on the head
;
is
usual.
his eyes,
is fat about the face, with wrinkles round and he wears a drowsy expression. The Small-Minded have small limbs and small, delicate, lean bodies, small eyes and small faces, just like a Corin
30
thian or Leucadian.
Men
like weasels.
Railers have
3
projecting,
and
The Compassionate are delicate, pale, and lustrous-eyed the top of their nostrils is furrowed with lines, and they are always weeping. Such men are fond of women and
:
35
beget
.
.
TU n*v
M.
I
efy\v,
TU Of
SoS<*
20.
.
Read
r
1
8cS- 33.
845-8
Read
Schneider.
8o8 a
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
female children, and in character they arc erotic and mindful of the past, with good natural parts and a fervid temper. of these qualities have already been mentioned. The
signs
8o8 b Compassion goes with wisdom, with cowardice, and with with stupidity and good moral character, hardness of heart
effrontery.
navel to Gluttony is indicated when the distance from chest is greater than that from chest to neck. Lasciviousness is indicated by a pale complexion, a heavy
a growth of straight, thick, black hair over the body, heavy of straight hair on the temples, and small, lustrous, growth lewd eyes. In the Somnolent the upper parts are disproportionately 1 such men are bulky and hot, and their flesh is firm. large
:
indicated by disproportionate size of the a thick growth upper parts, with a round delicate build, and of hair about the belly. when the upper parts are is A Good
2
Loquacity
is
Memory
signified
10
are delicate and tolerably disproportionately small, and covered with flesh. well
SOUL and body, as it seems to me, are affected symon the one hand, an alteration pathetically by one another
:
15
produces an alteration in the form and contrariwise an alteration in bodily form of the body, Grief and joy, soul. produces an alteration in the state of the soul, and every one to take an instance, are states of knows that grief involves a gloomy and joy a cheerful countenance. Now if it were the case that the external rid of these expression persisted after the soul had got 3 we might still say that soul and body are in emotions, not be sympathy, but their sympathetic changes would
concomitant.
20 entirely
As a matter
of fact,
however,
it is
obvious that
1
every modification
of
Read oyxwSeis with Rose. Read exovrft. AuXoi* ol TO livm KT\. F. following Schneider and Rose. 8o8 b 17, 8. The passage is corrupt and
2
1
8o8 b 7. 8o8 b 8.
/ieia>
t^wrfs
KUI
fiivtiv is
supported
CHAPTER
modification of the other.
to be
4
best instance of this
it
is
808"
The
is
Mania, insanity. generally a condition of the soul, yet doctors cure it partly by administering purgative drugs to the body, partly by prescribing, besides these, certain courses of diet. Thus the
allowed,
is
found
in
manic
result of proper
is
and that too simultaneously, not only in altering the physical condition, but also in curing the soul of mania and the fact that the changes are simultaneous proves that the sympathetic modifications of body and soul are
;
25
thoroughly concomitant.
equally indisputable that differences in the soul s capacities are represented by corresponding physical traits, so that all the resemblances 2 in animals are indicative of
It is
some
identity.
30
Again, if we consider the behaviour of animals, we find that some affections of the soul are peculiar to particular
genera, whilst others are common to several, and that the peculiar activities are accompanied by peculiar, the
physical traits. Examples of common characters are insolence, which is found in all animals with bushy tails, and violent sexual excitability, 3 which is
common by common,
35
found alike
railing
is
in asses
and
in
dogs
4
:
hand
a character peculiar to dogs, and insensibility to a pain is peculiar to the ass. I have already explained how 8og common and peculiar characters are to be distinguished.
At the same time it is only by long and wide experience that one can hope for oneself to attain detailed and expert understanding of these matters. For not only are visible
characteristics of the
as
body
drawn partly from animals, from modes of action, but there are other external partly traits which depend on the varying proportions of bodily
are told, to analogies
we
Read yeW. F. Read anavrn (ra) o/uoui. Siebeck (Gesch. Psycli. I. 2. 263) takes this to mean that alle Erscheinungen am lebendigen Wesen nur die Erscheinungsformen eines und desselben Princips seien and but it probably means merely that speaks of organische Einheit wherever you find similarity of external traits, you can reckon on some 3 8o8 b 34. Read identity of character. Sylburg. 8o8 b 36. Read for ITVMV, as F. suggests.
2
<uv)
</.
eK<rruu-ir.
Kw5>r
E 2
8og
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
heat and cold
traits are
;
and
to
add
alike
to the difficulty,
some
of these
very
much
distinctive
10
with the paleness that results names, as is the case e.g. 1 Now when from terror and the paleness due to fatigue. can hardly be discerned except the difference is so slight, it
by those
the taught to appreciate with different shades of expression congruity of different from congruity of mind, and so the argument conditions
whom
practice has
15
2 and soundest conclusions, and enables It is a method us to distinguish minute differences. in the selection of physio and particularly generally useful, with the signs selected must be congruous signs, for gnomic 3 what they stand for. of signs, ,o Deduction also should be used in the selection 4 we attach whenever possible. In the deductive procedure them. For instance, if to our data known attributes of 5 and we have it given that a man is an impudent blackguard we can add that he will be a thief and a miser,
25
penurious, the other as the one as a consequence of his effrontery, In all such cases we a consequence of his penuriousness. in our procedure. to include the deductive method
ought
I
they are or timorous, upright, or dishonest. respectively brave the whole animal kingdom for this purpose have to divide and to show into two physical types, male and female, are congruous with each of these what mental attributes 6 the female is In all beasts that we try to breed ,o types. than the male, less power tamer and gentler in disposition reared and more manageable. One may ful, more easily a less spirited temper, conclude from this that the female has
if
WILL now first attempt to make a division are bound to differ by the marks in which they
of
animals
We
35
and
think
we
when
7
we are mastered by a fit of temper we become more and and totally intractable; we grow headstrong
a 8o9 10. a 2
1
obstinate
violent
3
* 5
8oo 14. a 8o9 18. a 8o9 20. 8oo a 2l. a So9 30. a 8o9 35,
Read Read
xdi al OTTO.
F.
6.
apio-ros (rpon-os)
F.
passage corrupt, perhaps beyond Omit and TI. F. Read TIS for re. F.
36.
CHAPTER
the female
in
5
Further,
is, my opinion, more mischievous than the h Every one can 8og male, and (though feebler) more reckless. see that this is so in women and in domesticated animals, and according to the unanimous evidence of herdsmen and
hunters
it is
it is
no
less true of
field.
Moreover,
5
of the beyond dispute that in every genus the head female is smaller than that of the male, her visage narrower, her neck thinner, her chest weaker, her sides of smaller
build,
and
fuller,
she
inclines to be knock-kneed, the lower parts of her legs are in short, less stout, and her feet more delicately made l rather than to the eye the build of her body is pleasing
ic
comparison feeble and tender, and 2 The male is the opposite of all this the braver and more upright nature, whilst the female
is
in
the more timid and less upright. This being so, the lion manifestly exhibits the male type He has a good-sized mouth his in its most perfect form.
:
15
level with visage is square and not too bony, the upper jaw his nose you would call, the lower and not protruding his gleaming eyes are deep-set, if anything, rather thick and neither absolutely round nor unduly long, and of 20
:
:
moderate size 3 his brow is of the right size, his forehead square and slightly hollowed from the centre, and over its lower part, towards the eyebrows and nose, there hangs a sort of cloud, and from the top of his forehead down to 4 his his nose there runs a ridge of hairs sloping outwards head is of moderate size his neck of due length and broad in proportion, with a tawny mane upon it, which is neither
: : :
stiff
and
About the
:
25
his supple and not too tightly articulated shoulders are stalwart, his chest powerful, his trunk broad, there is no superfluity of with sides and back to match
clavicles
he
is
flesh
1
and
30
809
2
8<X)
3
4
jj8uu KOI (i^aXfoTe pnj/ 77 with F. from Adamantius. F. rightly marks a lacuna after evavrin, to be filled by TOU Sppams or the like. 809 20. Read ^frpiovs, as F. suggests. b b 8o9 23, 24. Read aro<nX\6p. Sylburg. Cp. 8l2 34.
Perhaps
b i2.
/j,ei>
8og
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
sinewy, his gait vigorous, his \vholc frame well-knit and he moves slowly sinewy and neither too stiff nor too soft
:
with a large
is
35 liberal,
Such generous and and ambitious, yet gentle and just and proud
stride, rolling his shoulders as
he goes.
and
in soul
he
is
The panther, on the other hand, of all animals accounted brave, approximates more closely to the feminine type, save
8io
a
uses to perform any feat of strength. 2 For its face is small, its mouth large, its eyes small and white, its forehead set in a hollow, but rather flat in themselves
in its legs,
which
it
too long and tends to be curved rather than flat near its chest narrow its neck too long and thin the ears
is
:
haunches and thighs fleshy flanks and and its whole abdomen rather flat its colour blotchy body ill-articulated and ill-proportioned. Such is its bodily aspect, and in soul it is mean and thievish, and in a word,
and
its
back long
10
a beast of low cunning. I have now described the more notable examples of the male and the female types of body to be found among
animals accounted brave, and the characterization of the remainder will present no difficulty. I will next proceed
to explain in a chapter on selection of signs
what marks
derived from animals the student of physiognomies should take into consideration.
of
the
semeiotics
of
human 6
15
large and shapely foot, well-articulated and sinewy, is For evidence we arc held to signify a strong character.
A small, narrow, illreferred to the male sex in general. articulated foot, pretty but weak, signifies a soft character,
ao
and
Curved toes are a sign of impudence, so are curved nails, on the evidence of birds with curved claws, whilst toes that are not properly divided indicate
b 8o9 34. Read f Xeu& piof. Gesner. 809 38. Read evf^yel, as F. suggests. 8lo a 23, 24. Read opuffca TOVS crTfyavonoftas.
Gesner.
CHAPTER
Ankles
8io a
2?
sinewy and well-articulated mark a strong on the evidence of the male sex fleshy and illcharacter, a soft character, on the evidence of the articulated ankles,
;
female sex.
When
:
is
at once well-articulated
and sinewy
and stalwart, it signifies a strong character, as in the male 30 when it is thin and sinewy it signifies loquacity, 1 as sex
in birds.
When
it is full
it
signifies
by congruity blatant effrontery. Knock-knees are a sign of the pathic, by congruity. Thighs bony and sinewy indicate a strong character, as
in the
35
male sex
full,
a soft character,
of
as in females.
Buttocks pointed
character,
as
in
fleshy buttocks character, as in females, whilst lean buttocks which look as if they had been rubbed bare, are indicative of a mis
males
fat
chievous disposition, as in apes. A narrow waist 2 marks the hunter, as in the lion, 3 and you will find that the best hunting dogs also are narrow in
the waist.
loose build round about the belly indicates strength of character, as in the male sex, whilst the opposite is by
congruity indicative of a soft character. A well-sized and sturdy back marks strength, and a narrow
feeble
10
back softness
of character, as in
4 When the sides signify aimless loquacity, as in frogs. distance from navel to infra-sternal notch exceeds that from
it
is
mark
of
gluttony and of
Read XuXot, as F. suggests. The correction of favoi Barth. translates bene lumbosi But Porta seems right in into tvfavoi dates from Gesner and Porta. saying potius succinctos, et graciles, quam lumbosos interpretandum if one looks at actual specimens. 3 8io b 5. Omit Km raits nrvas as F. suggests. Cp. 8ii a 21, 8l2 a 10, where the author is evidently adding instances from dogs to the accepted
31.
4.
2
. ,
8io a 8iob
Omit
TOVS /3of?
r)
tm with
F. as a variant
on
fiarpaxovs.
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
dullness of sense,
of
20 a receptacle of food,
and
1 the senses is correspondingly confined and compressed by the receptacle of food, so that the senses have become stupefied by repletion of the stomach rather than, as is 2 usual, by inanition.
When the upper part of the back is large and well covered with flesh and well-knit, the character is strong, as in males
:
when
soft,
it
is
feeble
ill-knit,
the character
is
as in females.
fall in
When
it
is
very
it is
the
shoulders
30 to signify
argued by congruity
of the
a mischievous disposition, since the front parts body, which ought to stand clear to view, become
invisible.
When
it is
curved backwards,
it
signifies
vanity
and lack of intelligence, as in the horse. So it must not be either convex or concave and something intermediate between these extremes, therefore, should be looked for as
;
marking a man
35
When
good natural parts. the shoulders and the back of the neck are wellof
articulated, they signify a strong character, whilst weak and ill-articulated shoulders signify a soft character, the
8n a
reference being to the sexes, as I explained when speaking of feet and thighs. Supple shoulders signify liberality of
the argument being based on the external appear with which liberality seems to be congruous. On the ance, other hand, stiff, clumsy shoulders indicate an illiberal dissoul,
5 position,
also
by
congruity.
Suppleness of the clavicles signifies quickness of percep tion, for when the collar-bone is supple, stimulation of the
senses
10
rendered easy. 4
stiff
it
collar-bone
difficult to
is
Read (rvveuxr^fvov. F. Read (//aXXoi/) fv8dns. F. 8ii a 2. Read Aev&ptoi. F. 4 811*5-10. With a supple collar-bone it is easy, with a stiff one difficult, to move the head and so adjust the facial sense-organs to
2
rj
stimuli.
CHAPTER
A
6
:
8n a
thick neck indicates a strong character, as in males a thin neck, weakness, as in females a neck thick and full, fierce temper, as in bulls * a well-sized neck, not too thick, a proud soul, as in lions a long, thin neck, cowardice, as
:
:
15
in
deer
as in wolves.
that part
corners,
Lips thin and pendulous at their points of junction, such 2 of the upper lip overhangs the lower at the
is
20
given
of
soul.
The
reference
generally
you may
see the
well in large
and powerful breeds of dogs. hard with a prominence about the eye-teeth are a sign of base breeding, 3 on the evidence of swine. Thick lips, with
25
the upper overhanging the lower, and the ape. Projecting upper
railer,
mean
lip
folly, as in
the ass
A
but
dullness of sense, as in 30 tip, if the swine is pointed, irascibility, as in whilst tip dogs a round, blunt tip indicates pride, as in lions. Men with a nose thin at the tip have the characteristics of birds.
if
; ;
means
such a nose curves slightly right away from the forebut when it head, it indicates impudence, as in ravens is strongly aquiline and demarcated from the forehead by
:
When
35
in
it is
the forehead rounded and the curve rising upwards, it 5 A snub nose means signifies lasciviousness, as in cocks.
lasciviousness,
fierce
as in deer. Open nostrils are a sign of for they enter into the facial expression of temper,
8n b
temper.
1
2
3
811*23.
4 5
Omit %ioeiSer?. F. Read wore n for eVi. Read dy ewfis. Bonitz. Read TrXaTeZay.
u>s
F.
Like Porta
gallos consuluimus
F. reads Trpos TO utranrov and suggests Karn^epf} for Porta translates Tifpifapr), But this does not much improve the sense. incavus nasus ante frontem, rotundus, et supereminens [i.e. the comb] rotundum which, as his illustration shows, gives a sense not far from the actual appearance, if it could be got from the text. Either the text is corrupt, or the author had not kept poultry.
ignoraremus.
b
8"
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
The
if
face,
when
fleshy,
10
1 gaunt, assiduity, and if bony, cowardice, on the analogy of asses and deer. A small face marks a small soul, as in the cat and the ape: a large face means lethargy, as in asses and cattle. So the face must be neither nor
large
little
an intermediate size
is
therefore best.
mean-
15
looking face signifies by congruity an illiberal spirit. As to the eyes, when the lower lids are pendulous and baggy, you may know a bibulous fellow, for heavy drink
20
produces bagginess below the eyes but when the upper lids arc baggy and hang over the eyes, 3 that signifies somnolence, for on first waking from sleep our upper lids hang heavily. Small eyes mean a small soul, by congruity and on the evidence of the ape as
ing
:
in cattle.
In a
man
of
Hollow eyes eyes will be neither large nor small. as in the ape villainy, protruding eyes,
:
imbecility,
mean by con-
25
gruity and as in the ass. The eyes, therefore, must neither recede nor protrude an intermediate position is best.
:
When
soul, as in lions:
and when a
little
deeper
4
still,
gentleness,
as in cattle.
30
A small forehead means stupidity, as in swine too large a forehead, lethargy, as in cattle. A round forehead means dullness of sense, as in the ass a somewhat long and flat
:
:
forehead,
35
quickness
of sense, 5 as in
the dog.
square
8i2 a
and well-proportioned forehead 6 is a sign of a proud soul, as in the lion. A cloudy brow signifies self-will, as in the lion and the bull a taut brow is taken from observation to mark the flatterer, and you may notice how a dog s brow smooths out when he fawns upon you. 7 So, a cloudy brow indicating self-will and a smooth brow obsequiousness,
: 1
2 3
Read as F. suggests (cp. Ps. Pol. 179). Read e juTreTTttKoou. Schneider. Read Kva-nBff. (ot? 8e ra eVi TO IS o^daX/jinls olov
o<rra><5;?
(<}>((TTT]Ka(Ti.
8ii b 27.
.
F. after Taube. Or, better, ols TO KT\., to match But not unduly deep. Or read with Kekule,
<$
1.
13.
flat
8li b 32.
"
8u b
cSu
3-5.
37.
fvoicr&pot. TO
ot
F. reads
alcrdrjriKni
cp.
8l2 a
6.
^eYa>7roi>.
Warhsmuth.
KiW.
F.
CHAPTER
8ia
the proper condition must be intermediate between these A scowling brow means a morose disposition, extremes.
for
we observe
that vexation
is
as
A
A
of sense,
means quickness and a small head dullness of the dog and the ass respectively. peaked head means impudence, as in those birds which
large head
on the evidence
have curved claws. Men with small ears have the disposition of monkeys, those with large ears the disposition of asses, and you may notice that the best breeds of dogs have ears of moderate
size.
10
Too black a hue marks the coward, as witness Egyptians and Ethiopians, 1 and so does also too white a complexion, So the hue that makes for as you may see from women. must be intermediate between these extremes. courage A tawny colour indicates a bold spirit, as in lions but too
:
15
ruddy a hue marks a rogue, as in the case of the fox. A pale mottled hue signifies cowardice, for that is the colour one The honey-pale are cold, and coldness turns in terror. means immobility, and an immobile body means slowness. A red hue indicates hastiness, for all parts of the body on
flaming skin, however, indicates mania, for it results from an overheated body, and extreme bodily heat is likely to mean mania.
being heated by
20
movement
turn red.
25
fiery colour
on the chest
it
is
part of the expression of the onset of anger. Swollen veins on the neck and temples also signify irascibility, being part A face that reddens easily of the expression of anger.
30
marks a bashful man, for blushing is an expression of But when the jowl goes red, you have a bashfulness. for a red jowl is an expression of heavy drinking drunkard,
:
whilst eyes that flush red indicate uncontrollable temper, for in a wild outburst of temper the eyes flush red. If the
35
eyes are too black, they signify cowardice, for we that this is the signification of too black a hue
:
saw above
8ia b
if they are not too black, but inclining to chestnut, they indicate a bold
1
8l2 a
12.
Read Alymriavs
(*<"}
klffioiras,
Frnnz.
8ia b
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
spirit.
for
we saw
:
the signification of a white hue but if they arc gleaming rather than grey, they mean a bold Goatish 1 eyes mean lustfulspirit, as in lions and eagles.
ness, as in goats fiery eyes, impudence, as in dogs eyes pale and mottled, cowardice, for in terror the eyes go pale with splotches of colour glistening eyes, lasciviousness,
:
10
Hairy legs mean lasciviousness, as in goats. Too much hair on breast and belly means lack of persistence, as argued from birds, in which this bodily characteristic is most
developed
;
of hair indicate
im
20
pudence, as in women. So both extremes are bad, and an intermediate condition must be best. Hairy shoulders
mean much
lack of persistence, on the analogy of birds too hair on the back, impudence, as in wild beasts. Hair on the nape of the neck indicates liberality, as in lions
: :
dogs. Eyebrows that meet signify moroseness, by 3 congruity eyebrows that droop on the nasal and rise on the temporal side, silliness, as is seen in swine. When the
:
30
up stiff, it signifies cowardice, by congruity, for fright, as well as cowardly disposition, makes the hair stand on end and very woolly hair also signifies as may be seen in Ethiopians. Thus extremely cowardice,
:
bristly and extremely woolly hair alike signify and so hair gently curling at the end will make
35 of spirit, as is to
cowardice,
5
for boldness
ridge of hair on the upper part of the forehead indicates a liberal disposition, as in the lion but a growth of hair on the forehead down by
be seen
in lions.
8i3
the nose 6 indicates illiberality, the argument being from con gruity, because such a growth presents a servile appearance.
8i2 b 6, 7. Read nlyatiroi. Gesner, &c. But no reading suggested very satisfactory. 2 8i2 b 24- Clearly the meaning must, as Porta points out, concern hair. Porta suggests naKpoyeveioi, but it is doubtful whether this could mean with a long beard nor have most dogs long beards. The passage remains uncertain, but it does not mean with a long chin 3 8i2 b 26. Read TT/JOS Schneider. plvn. 4 8l2 b 32. Read e^nivova-i. F. 5 b 8i2 34, 35. Read fiiwriXAor But the whole sentence is corrupt. 6 See F. s note. 8i2 b 36. Omit F. rtjt Ktfa&rfs.
1
is
n}i>
CHAPTER
A
8i3
slow to begin, but long and slow step indicates a mind when started, for the length of the stride shows persistent A short determination, but its slowness procrastination. tardiness without persistence, for shortness slow step means and slowness do not indicate determination. A long quick
step means enterprise indicates enterprise and
Identical
1
and
persistence,
for
its
speed
short
its
2 length determination.
are
made about
s
10 gesture of hand,
stiff
4
To hold one
:
as one walks signifies a vainglorious spirit, on 5 the analogy of the horse but to roll the shoulders if one a little forwards means a proud soul, as in the lion.
and
roll
them
stoops
To walk with
bending
7
feet
and
is
legs
15
as being a characteristic of
women.
To keep
turning and
a sign of obsequiousness, for that To walk with a stoop to the is the gesture of the flatterer. held to argue a pathic. right is by congruity of appearance
the
body
Mobile eyes signify keenness and rapacity, as in hawks the eyes. blinking eyes, cowardice, for flight begins with
:
20
of Sidelong leering glances are held to be characteristic a fop, 8 and so are drooping movements of one lid half over a motionless eye, and an upward roll of the eyes under the upper lids 9 10 with a tender gaze and drooping
>
25
eyelids,
and in general all tender melting glances we argue these partly from congruity, partly from the fact that of the A slow movement looks are common in women. eyes which allows a tinge of white to show all the time, so
;
11
3
4
6 7
a Si3 7. Omit OVK. Willich. a 8i3 8. Read eVitfmKoj for TeXeo-TiKoi and omit OIK. F. a 8l3 IO, II. Read dt/a<popai for di/a0epoyTm. 813* 12. Read yavponXa^ovfs. Sylburg. a 8i3 13. Read eTno-aXeiWres with the Cod. Ambros. 813*15. Read tyXets. 813* 1 6. Read fyK^ivdptvoi for eyrpt/Sopcpot. F. 813*21. Read 01 /mXXaiVoj>res (Hemsterhuis), or KaTiXXuimu
,
I
b>pa(0rai<
j3Xc 8i3 23. Read vrro T 10 813* 24. Read ttyeu. Sylburg. 11 l 8i3 29. Read, perhaps, oxr/rep seems to be corruptava>
(pap<(.
F.
COTJJKU TI.
8ia
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
when
big,
30 for
the
mind
is
absorbed
in reflection,
are motionless.
the ass
voice which, starting low, rises to a high pitch, indicates despondency and querulousness, the argument being partly
35
from
tones
cattle
Shrill, soft,
broken
8i3
the speech of the pathic, for such a voice is found in women and is congruous with the pathic s nature. A deep, hollow, simple voice signifies a noble soul, 1 as in the
stronger breeds of dogs, and also A soft, languid voice congruity.
mark
sheep
a
of
shrill,
Men
shrieking voice, lewdness, as in goats. abnormally small stature are hasty, for the flow
of their blood having but a small area to cover, its move ments are too rapidly propagated to the organ of intel 2 Men of abnormally large stature, on the other ligence.
10
hand, are slow, for the flow of the blood has to cover a large
and its movements are therefore propagated to the organ of intelligence slowly. Small men with dry tissues, or of the hue that heat produces in the body, have not
area,
for their persistence enough to effect their purposes blood flowing in a confined space, and at the same time,
;
15
consequence of the fiery condition of the body, flowing rapidly, their thought never keeps to a single topic, but is always passing to something new before being done with the old. 3 Again, big men with moist tissues or of the hue
in
that results from cold, also lack persistence for their blood over a large area, and slowly, on account of the flowing
;
20 to
cold condition of the body, its movement does not manage reach the organ of intelligence entire. 4 On the other
<pa>vov<ri
2. Read ftapv noiXuv rrenXfyfJifvov, and mark a lacuna after ntn\fy^vov. F. following Gesncr. 2 b 8i3 9- Sc. the heart. F. refers to Empedocles in Theophr. De Senstt, 10, as confirming the view that TO (fipovovv is the blood. But if TO (ppovovv is the blood, then al KiMjaeis are not of the blood. Yet Moreover, virepxwpovai in Kivfjo-fws in 1. 22 must refer to the blood. 1. 33 becomes almost unintelligible, unless indeed a distinction is drawn between blood near the heart as the seat of intelligence and other blood as stimulating it. If, however, TO (ppovovv is the heart, m Kiv^arfis are movements of the blood occasioned by stimuli, or at any rate con
fj,f)
8i3
16.
Read
F.
TO ntpwv.
F.
inserts
nfyiKv-jvptvi],
(F. also
KtVf;criy
before
uv.)
CHAPTER
hand, small
results
8i 3
tissues
and
of the
;
hue that
from
cold,
do
effect their
moving
its
purposes mobile
3
constituent in
eifectiveness.
of the
composition produces a proportion which conduces to 4 And again, big men with dry tissues, and
also persistent, of tissue
hue that results from heat, 5 arc for the warmth are keen of sense
;
25
plexion counteracts the excessive size, so that a proportion conducive to effectiveness is attained. Such, then, are the conditions under which opposite extremes of stature tend
and now to ineffectiveness. But a stature intermediate between these extremes confers upon its possessors the greatest acuity of sense and the greatest
now
to effective activity,
general effectiveness, for on the one hand, movements of the blood, not having a long distance to travel, easily reach the reason, while on the other hand, not being con
fined in too small a space, they do not pass beyond their mark. 6 Thus the greatest tenacity of purpose and the
An ill-proportioned body indicates a rogue, the argument 814* being partly from congruity and partly from the female 7 sex. But, if bad proportions mean villainy, a well-propor
characteristic of upright men and the standard of the right proportions must [only, be sought in the good training and good breeding of the body, and not in the male type, as determined at the begin-
tioned frame
must be
brave
advisable, in elucidating all the signs I have men tioned, to take into consideration both their congruity with
It is
8l3 2I. Readxpw/*a(TU>, (a) Sia x/^poVr/ra yiVon-cu, eVireXeoTiKot. F. b 8l3 22. sc. cold. 3 b 8i3 23. sc. between size of body and speed of movement of blood, as in 1. 26 not between constituents of the blood. 813 23. Read Trpos TO for TO TTpwTor. F.
2
; 1
8l3 24, 25. Read xptt/uxeru , (a) yivovrut, eVriTfXeo-TiKot b 8l3 33. Insert ov% with F., but retain vrrefjxfopovtnv. 7 814* I. Read 5e for yap. Sylburg. * a 8l4 3-5. This passage is in complete contradiction to Chapter V and to the next paragraph. It must be regarded as an interpolation. It may be noted that only here in the Physiognoiiwiuni is used with
. .
(i
8i 4
PHYSIOGNOMONICA
various characters and the distinction of the sexes, which is, as I showed, the most complete distinction, the male
being more upright and courageous and, in short, altogether It will be found, moreover, in better than the female.
8i4
b
every selection of signs that some signs are better adapted than others to indicate the mental character behind them.
The
indications are given by signs in certain suitable parts of the body. The most suitable particularly part of all is the region of the eyes and forehead, head and next to it comes the region of the chest and shoulders, face
clearest
;
and next again, that of l the legs and feet whilst the belly and neighbouring parts are of least service to physioIn a word, the clearest signs are derived from gnomics. those parts in which intelligence is most manifest. 2
;
F. 8i4 6. Read eVeira ntpl. b 8l4 8. Read emfjuivfia, which gives a better sense than eVt/rpeVeia. Earth. Mess, translates in quibus et sapientiae plurimae superappais his term for eVic^m^ and rentia fit and, as superapparens his MS. must have read fjrt<pdveta. fTn<paiv6p.fvos,
1
1j
()