Diversity Management The Challenges & Opportunities
Diversity Management The Challenges & Opportunities
Diversity Management The Challenges & Opportunities
(iii) Third Country National(TCN): They are the citizens of one country employed by a company
from another country who worked in a third country.
• Example: when a Bangladeshi firm recruits employee from India for their Canada branch.
Hiring Parent Country Nationalist
If MNCs' managers decide to employ PCNs (which in literature are commonly
called expatriates) for key positions in entities abroad, their transfer to the
subsidiaries abroad can be basically motivated by various reasons
• (a) filling positions in the subsidiaries abroad because the local staff is not
qualified enough,
• (b) development of expatriate managers who will gain international
experience and be prepared for future important tasks in subsidiaries
abroad or in the parent company, and
• (c) organizational development, where transfers enable development of
strategic coordination and control, as well as the development of
communication channels in the MNCs.
• The selection of PCNs for the key positions in the entities abroad is associated with a
number of advantages.
• First of all, such people are typically familiar with the objectives, policies and
procedures of the parent company and there is an assumption that this fact will
positively affect the subsidiaries to be in the course of strategic goals of the company.
• Also, sending PCNs facilitates communication with the top managers of the MNCs. On
the contrary, communication with the members of other nationalities and cultures can
be difficult because of the different styles of verbal and nonverbal communication.
• Besides that, the problem with different language may also arise. Having that in mind,
managers from the headquarters of MNCs usually prefer to have some managers from
the home country in the entities abroad
Hiring Host Country Nationalists
• Hiring HCNs also has its good and bad sides.
• First, by their engagement the problem of adapting to the new socio-
economic, political and cultural environment is avoided, as well as the
necessity of learning the business practices of the host country.
• Second, the costs of their employment usually are lower comparing
to the costs of the expatriates. In addition, opportunities for
promotion and advancement of local staff can have a positive effect
on their motivation.
• However, the decision on the employment of HCNs for the key
positions in entities abroad may lead to serious problems. In fact,
some MNCs that are deployed persons from the host country and
persons from the third-country in key positions in the subsidiaries
abroad, have faced the problem of losing control of such subsidiaries.
• Also, they have increased their dependence on managers who do not
come from the company's headquarters and its managers have
limited opportunity to gain global experience .
Third Country Nationalist
• MNCs engage persons from the third-countries (TCNs) for the key positions in entities abroad.
• In this way a special kind of compromise between the need of providing technical and
managerial expertise and the ability to adapt to foreign socio-economic and cultural
environment should be made.
• This is possible since the third-country nationals usually have some experience in the process
of adapting to foreign environment. Also, studies indicate that TCNs typically cost less than the
members of the home country.
• In addition, in some cases it is confirmed that TCNs are more familiar with the situation in the
host country than the PCNs.
• From the above mentioned follows that any decision on the selection of international staff has
both good and bad sides, which indicates that the problem of international staffing is very
complex and that in the process of deciding on this issue companies should take into account
numerous variables.
Some statistics
• From the above mentioned follows that any decision on the selection of
international staff has both good and bad sides, which indicates that the problem
of international staffing is very complex and that in the process of deciding on
this issue companies should take into account numerous variables.
• MNCs whose headquarters are placed in Scandinavian region have the lowest
percentage of PCNs at the key positions in the subsidaries abroad, while the
largest percentage of PCNs have Japanese MNCs, 76.5%. This can be explained by
the fact that a HRM in Japan has some specifics comparing to the Western
countries.
• Characteristics of Japanese HRM system that have an impact on the choice of
PCNs are: lifetime employment, extensive use of the practices such as transfer of
employees, salary based on seniority, total quality control, JIT procedures, etc.
THE KEY FACTORS OF
INTERNATIONAL STAFFING POLICY
• In order to recruit and select the staff for the subsidiaries and
affiliates abroad, MNCs must analyze the effects of three groups of
factors:
• factors related to the specificity of the host country,
• factors related to the specificity of the companies and
• the so-called hybrid factors.
Selection of the optimal alternative in the international staffing will be
the resultant of the effects of all three groups of factors and their
mutual causality in the case of a specific company.
Contextual factors of the host country
• Institutional characteristics of the host country : “the bigger the
institutional distance is, the greater the likelihood that the orientation
in international staffing policy will be toward PCNs”.
• Economic factors : The level of the economic development of the
country, the purchasing power of its citizens, as well as the prospects
for its future prosperity, are also important issues for MNCs when
they decide about filling management positions in entities abroad
Political risk : Political risk in the host country may also influence the
decision on the composition of the staff in the subsidiaries.
• Generally speaking, political risk can have different causes. So, there
are firms specific risks, which is also known as
• micro risk,
• country-specific risks, also known as macro risk,
• and global specific risks (global risks) [22].
• The most common cause of micro risk arises from a conflict between the goals and
objectives of certain MNC and those of the host government. This type of risk does
not reflect on all foreign companies, but only on some. Therefore, this type of risk
is called micro risk.
• The macro risk is associated with a risk of the specific country. The two most
common macro risks are cultural and regulatory risks, and they come from the
ownership structure, religious norms, nepotism, protectionism, intellectual
property rights in a particular country, etc.
• Global risk is the one that affects MNCs in a specific country but its origin is on the
global level. It can be, for example, terrorism, anti-globalization movement,
concerns for environmental protection, etc. If the company estimates that any kind
of risk is high, it is more likely to opt for ethnocentric orientation in the staffing
policy.
Company's specific features
• Orientation in the business strategy : Orientations in business strategy
concerning internationalization can be ethnocentric, polycentric,
regiocentric or geocentric.
• Stage in the life cycle of the company : Some authors point out that
the choices in the international staffing policy could be affected by the
phase of the life cycle in which the company decided to enter the
international market. Thus, companies that implement a phased
approach in internationalization of the business and international
activities usually apply the so-called EPRG orientation.
• Industry : Some studies have shown that a proportionately higher
percentage of ethnocentric orientation in the provision of managerial
staff is identified in the financial sector, while a smaller percentage is
identified in the advertising industry, food production, computer
industry, etc.
• This can be explained by the fact that in the banking sector the issue
of control is very important, which causes that in this sector an
ethnocentric orientation is dominant, while in others, such as services
sector, possessing knowledge of the local market is more important.
Therefore, in such sectors of the economy, the polycentric or
regiocentric orientations are prevalent.
• Characteristics of the subsidiaries : Characteristics of the subsidiaries
influence the approach in staffing policy in a way that when it is about a
newly formed subsidiary, ethnocentric orientation is more likely.
• On the other hand, if the subsidiary has a longer history of operations, a
polycentric or regiocentric orientations are more likely to be implemented.
• In addition, when the subsidiary is relatively new, difficulty in recruiting staff
from the local labor market goes in favour of the ethnocentric orientation.
• These problems, however, almost do not exist if the subsidiary has a long
history of successful business. A polycentric approach is more likely in a
situation when the knowledge of local market is very important and the
subsidiary is new.
Hybrid factors
• This group of factors comprehends transaction costs related to
employing staff. Namely, when it comes to making such decisions,
these costs should be compared in terms of what is their amount in
the host country and what is their amount in the home country.
• Transaction costs that affect the policy of international staffing consist
of two main categories, namely: (a) the amount of salary for
personnel performing tasks in entities abroad, and (b) staffing costs.
• Staffing costs, however, include the costs of recruitment, selection,
and costs caused by the need for controlling and monitoring the
employees' behavior.
• Researches generally confirm that the level of the expatriates' salary
is usually higher than the salary of local population [29], as well as
that their salary is not lower than the earnings they would have in the
home country. In some countries, it is found that expatriates earn
between 20 and 50 times higher salary than the local population .