Charting Ethical Tensions in Multispecies Technology Research through Beneficiary-Epistemology Space
Authors:
Steve Benford,
Clara Mancini,
Alan Chamberlain,
Eike Schneiders,
Simon Castle-Green,
Joel Fischer,
Ayse Kucukyilmaz,
Guido Salimbeni,
Victor Ngo,
Pepita Barnard,
Matt Adams,
Nick Tandavanitj,
Ju Row Farr
Abstract:
While ethical challenges are widely discussed in HCI, far less is reported about the ethical processes that researchers routinely navigate. We reflect on a multispecies project that negotiated an especially complex ethical approval process. Cat Royale was an artist-led exploration of creating an artwork to engage audiences in exploring trust in autonomous systems. The artwork took the form of a ro…
▽ More
While ethical challenges are widely discussed in HCI, far less is reported about the ethical processes that researchers routinely navigate. We reflect on a multispecies project that negotiated an especially complex ethical approval process. Cat Royale was an artist-led exploration of creating an artwork to engage audiences in exploring trust in autonomous systems. The artwork took the form of a robot that played with three cats. Gaining ethical approval required an extensive dialogue with three Institutional Review Boards (IRBs) covering computer science, veterinary science and animal welfare, raising tensions around the welfare of the cats, perceived benefits and appropriate methods, and reputational risk to the University. To reveal these tensions we introduce beneficiary-epistemology space, that makes explicit who benefits from research (humans or animals) and underlying epistemologies. Positioning projects and IRBs in this space can help clarify tensions and highlight opportunities to recruit additional expertise.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
Designing Multispecies Worlds for Robots, Cats, and Humans
Authors:
Eike Schneiders,
Steve Benford,
Alan Chamberlain,
Clara Mancini,
Simon Castle-Green,
Victor Ngo,
Ju Row Farr,
Matt Adams,
Nick Tandavanitj,
Joel Fischer
Abstract:
We reflect on the design of a multispecies world centred around a bespoke enclosure in which three cats and a robot arm coexist for six hours a day during a twelve-day installation as part of an artist-led project. In this paper, we present the project's design process, encompassing various interconnected components, including the cats, the robot and its autonomous systems, the custom end-effector…
▽ More
We reflect on the design of a multispecies world centred around a bespoke enclosure in which three cats and a robot arm coexist for six hours a day during a twelve-day installation as part of an artist-led project. In this paper, we present the project's design process, encompassing various interconnected components, including the cats, the robot and its autonomous systems, the custom end-effectors and robot attachments, the diverse roles of the humans-in-the-loop, and the custom-designed enclosure. Subsequently, we provide a detailed account of key moments during the deployment and discuss the design implications for future multispecies systems. Specifically, we argue that designing the technology and its interactions is not sufficient, but that it is equally important to consider the design of the `world' in which the technology operates. Finally, we highlight the necessity of human involvement in areas such as breakdown recovery, animal welfare, and their role as audience.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
