-
SurgicaL-CD: Generating Surgical Images via Unpaired Image Translation with Latent Consistency Diffusion Models
Authors:
Danush Kumar Venkatesh,
Dominik Rivoir,
Micha Pfeiffer,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Computer-assisted surgery (CAS) systems are designed to assist surgeons during procedures, thereby reducing complications and enhancing patient care. Training machine learning models for these systems requires a large corpus of annotated datasets, which is challenging to obtain in the surgical domain due to patient privacy concerns and the significant labeling effort required from doctors. Previou…
▽ More
Computer-assisted surgery (CAS) systems are designed to assist surgeons during procedures, thereby reducing complications and enhancing patient care. Training machine learning models for these systems requires a large corpus of annotated datasets, which is challenging to obtain in the surgical domain due to patient privacy concerns and the significant labeling effort required from doctors. Previous methods have explored unpaired image translation using generative models to create realistic surgical images from simulations. However, these approaches have struggled to produce high-quality, diverse surgical images. In this work, we introduce \emph{SurgicaL-CD}, a consistency-distilled diffusion method to generate realistic surgical images with only a few sampling steps without paired data. We evaluate our approach on three datasets, assessing the generated images in terms of quality and utility as downstream training datasets. Our results demonstrate that our method outperforms GANs and diffusion-based approaches. Our code is available at https://gitlab.com/nct_tso_public/gan2diffusion.
△ Less
Submitted 23 August, 2024; v1 submitted 19 August, 2024;
originally announced August 2024.
-
Using Fiber Optic Bundles to Miniaturize Vision-Based Tactile Sensors
Authors:
Julia Di,
Zdravko Dugonjic,
Will Fu,
Tingfan Wu,
Romeo Mercado,
Kevin Sawyer,
Victoria Rose Most,
Gregg Kammerer,
Stefanie Speidel,
Richard E. Fan,
Geoffrey Sonn,
Mark R. Cutkosky,
Mike Lambeta,
Roberto Calandra
Abstract:
Vision-based tactile sensors have recently become popular due to their combination of low cost, very high spatial resolution, and ease of integration using widely available miniature cameras. The associated field of view and focal length, however, are difficult to package in a human-sized finger. In this paper we employ optical fiber bundles to achieve a form factor that, at 15 mm diameter, is sma…
▽ More
Vision-based tactile sensors have recently become popular due to their combination of low cost, very high spatial resolution, and ease of integration using widely available miniature cameras. The associated field of view and focal length, however, are difficult to package in a human-sized finger. In this paper we employ optical fiber bundles to achieve a form factor that, at 15 mm diameter, is smaller than an average human fingertip. The electronics and camera are also located remotely, further reducing package size. The sensor achieves a spatial resolution of 0.22 mm and a minimum force resolution 5 mN for normal and shear contact forces. With these attributes, the DIGIT Pinki sensor is suitable for applications such as robotic and teleoperated digital palpation. We demonstrate its utility for palpation of the prostate gland and show that it can achieve clinically relevant discrimination of prostate stiffness for phantom and ex vivo tissue.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2024; v1 submitted 8 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
One model to use them all: Training a segmentation model with complementary datasets
Authors:
Alexander C. Jenke,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Fiona R. Kolbinger,
Marius Distler,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Understanding a surgical scene is crucial for computer-assisted surgery systems to provide any intelligent assistance functionality. One way of achieving this scene understanding is via scene segmentation, where every pixel of a frame is classified and therefore identifies the visible structures and tissues. Progress on fully segmenting surgical scenes has been made using machine learning. However…
▽ More
Understanding a surgical scene is crucial for computer-assisted surgery systems to provide any intelligent assistance functionality. One way of achieving this scene understanding is via scene segmentation, where every pixel of a frame is classified and therefore identifies the visible structures and tissues. Progress on fully segmenting surgical scenes has been made using machine learning. However, such models require large amounts of annotated training data, containing examples of all relevant object classes. Such fully annotated datasets are hard to create, as every pixel in a frame needs to be annotated by medical experts and, therefore, are rarely available. In this work, we propose a method to combine multiple partially annotated datasets, which provide complementary annotations, into one model, enabling better scene segmentation and the use of multiple readily available datasets. Our method aims to combine available data with complementary labels by leveraging mutual exclusive properties to maximize information. Specifically, we propose to use positive annotations of other classes as negative samples and to exclude background pixels of binary annotations, as we cannot tell if they contain a class not annotated but predicted by the model. We evaluate our method by training a DeepLabV3 on the publicly available Dresden Surgical Anatomy Dataset, which provides multiple subsets of binary segmented anatomical structures. Our approach successfully combines 6 classes into one model, increasing the overall Dice Score by 4.4% compared to an ensemble of models trained on the classes individually. By including information on multiple classes, we were able to reduce confusion between stomach and colon by 24%. Our results demonstrate the feasibility of training a model on multiple datasets. This paves the way for future work further alleviating the need for one large, fully segmented datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 5 April, 2024; v1 submitted 29 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Graph data modelling for outcome prediction in oropharyngeal cancer patients
Authors:
Nithya Bhasker,
Stefan Leger,
Alexander Zwanenburg,
Chethan Babu Reddy,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Steffen Löck,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Graph neural networks (GNNs) are becoming increasingly popular in the medical domain for the tasks of disease classification and outcome prediction. Since patient data is not readily available as a graph, most existing methods either manually define a patient graph, or learn a latent graph based on pairwise similarities between the patients. There are also hypergraph neural network (HGNN)-based me…
▽ More
Graph neural networks (GNNs) are becoming increasingly popular in the medical domain for the tasks of disease classification and outcome prediction. Since patient data is not readily available as a graph, most existing methods either manually define a patient graph, or learn a latent graph based on pairwise similarities between the patients. There are also hypergraph neural network (HGNN)-based methods that were introduced recently to exploit potential higher order associations between the patients by representing them as a hypergraph. In this work, we propose a patient hypergraph network (PHGN), which has been investigated in an inductive learning setup for binary outcome prediction in oropharyngeal cancer (OPC) patients using computed tomography (CT)-based radiomic features for the first time. Additionally, the proposed model was extended to perform time-to-event analyses, and compared with GNN and baseline linear models.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Exploring Semantic Consistency in Unpaired Image Translation to Generate Data for Surgical Applications
Authors:
Danush Kumar Venkatesh,
Dominik Rivoir,
Micha Pfeiffer,
Fiona Kolbinger,
Marius Distler,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
In surgical computer vision applications, obtaining labeled training data is challenging due to data-privacy concerns and the need for expert annotation. Unpaired image-to-image translation techniques have been explored to automatically generate large annotated datasets by translating synthetic images to the realistic domain. However, preserving the structure and semantic consistency between the i…
▽ More
In surgical computer vision applications, obtaining labeled training data is challenging due to data-privacy concerns and the need for expert annotation. Unpaired image-to-image translation techniques have been explored to automatically generate large annotated datasets by translating synthetic images to the realistic domain. However, preserving the structure and semantic consistency between the input and translated images presents significant challenges, mainly when there is a distributional mismatch in the semantic characteristics of the domains. This study empirically investigates unpaired image translation methods for generating suitable data in surgical applications, explicitly focusing on semantic consistency. We extensively evaluate various state-of-the-art image translation models on two challenging surgical datasets and downstream semantic segmentation tasks. We find that a simple combination of structural-similarity loss and contrastive learning yields the most promising results. Quantitatively, we show that the data generated with this approach yields higher semantic consistency and can be used more effectively as training data.The code is available at https://gitlab.com/nct_tso_public/constructs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2024; v1 submitted 6 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
TUNeS: A Temporal U-Net with Self-Attention for Video-based Surgical Phase Recognition
Authors:
Isabel Funke,
Dominik Rivoir,
Stefanie Krell,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
To enable context-aware computer assistance in the operating room of the future, cognitive systems need to understand automatically which surgical phase is being performed by the medical team. The primary source of information for surgical phase recognition is typically video, which presents two challenges: extracting meaningful features from the video stream and effectively modeling temporal info…
▽ More
To enable context-aware computer assistance in the operating room of the future, cognitive systems need to understand automatically which surgical phase is being performed by the medical team. The primary source of information for surgical phase recognition is typically video, which presents two challenges: extracting meaningful features from the video stream and effectively modeling temporal information in the sequence of visual features. For temporal modeling, attention mechanisms have gained popularity due to their ability to capture long-range dependencies. In this paper, we explore design choices for attention in existing temporal models for surgical phase recognition and propose a novel approach that uses attention more effectively and does not require hand-crafted constraints: TUNeS, an efficient and simple temporal model that incorporates self-attention at the core of a convolutional U-Net structure. In addition, we propose to train the feature extractor, a standard CNN, together with an LSTM on preferably long video segments, i.e., with long temporal context. In our experiments, almost all temporal models performed better on top of feature extractors that were trained with longer temporal context. On these contextualized features, TUNeS achieves state-of-the-art results on the Cholec80 dataset. This study offers new insights on how to use attention mechanisms to build accurate and efficient temporal models for surgical phase recognition. Implementing automatic surgical phase recognition is essential to automate the analysis and optimization of surgical workflows and to enable context-aware computer assistance during surgery, thus ultimately improving patient care.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2024; v1 submitted 19 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Metrics Matter in Surgical Phase Recognition
Authors:
Isabel Funke,
Dominik Rivoir,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Surgical phase recognition is a basic component for different context-aware applications in computer- and robot-assisted surgery. In recent years, several methods for automatic surgical phase recognition have been proposed, showing promising results. However, a meaningful comparison of these methods is difficult due to differences in the evaluation process and incomplete reporting of evaluation de…
▽ More
Surgical phase recognition is a basic component for different context-aware applications in computer- and robot-assisted surgery. In recent years, several methods for automatic surgical phase recognition have been proposed, showing promising results. However, a meaningful comparison of these methods is difficult due to differences in the evaluation process and incomplete reporting of evaluation details. In particular, the details of metric computation can vary widely between different studies. To raise awareness of potential inconsistencies, this paper summarizes common deviations in the evaluation of phase recognition algorithms on the Cholec80 benchmark. In addition, a structured overview of previously reported evaluation results on Cholec80 is provided, taking known differences in evaluation protocols into account. Greater attention to evaluation details could help achieve more consistent and comparable results on the surgical phase recognition task, leading to more reliable conclusions about advancements in the field and, finally, translation into clinical practice.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Surgical tool classification and localization: results and methods from the MICCAI 2022 SurgToolLoc challenge
Authors:
Aneeq Zia,
Kiran Bhattacharyya,
Xi Liu,
Max Berniker,
Ziheng Wang,
Rogerio Nespolo,
Satoshi Kondo,
Satoshi Kasai,
Kousuke Hirasawa,
Bo Liu,
David Austin,
Yiheng Wang,
Michal Futrega,
Jean-Francois Puget,
Zhenqiang Li,
Yoichi Sato,
Ryo Fujii,
Ryo Hachiuma,
Mana Masuda,
Hideo Saito,
An Wang,
Mengya Xu,
Mobarakol Islam,
Long Bai,
Winnie Pang
, et al. (46 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The ability to automatically detect and track surgical instruments in endoscopic videos can enable transformational interventions. Assessing surgical performance and efficiency, identifying skilled tool use and choreography, and planning operational and logistical aspects of OR resources are just a few of the applications that could benefit. Unfortunately, obtaining the annotations needed to train…
▽ More
The ability to automatically detect and track surgical instruments in endoscopic videos can enable transformational interventions. Assessing surgical performance and efficiency, identifying skilled tool use and choreography, and planning operational and logistical aspects of OR resources are just a few of the applications that could benefit. Unfortunately, obtaining the annotations needed to train machine learning models to identify and localize surgical tools is a difficult task. Annotating bounding boxes frame-by-frame is tedious and time-consuming, yet large amounts of data with a wide variety of surgical tools and surgeries must be captured for robust training. Moreover, ongoing annotator training is needed to stay up to date with surgical instrument innovation. In robotic-assisted surgery, however, potentially informative data like timestamps of instrument installation and removal can be programmatically harvested. The ability to rely on tool installation data alone would significantly reduce the workload to train robust tool-tracking models. With this motivation in mind we invited the surgical data science community to participate in the challenge, SurgToolLoc 2022. The goal was to leverage tool presence data as weak labels for machine learning models trained to detect tools and localize them in video frames with bounding boxes. We present the results of this challenge along with many of the team's efforts. We conclude by discussing these results in the broader context of machine learning and surgical data science. The training data used for this challenge consisting of 24,695 video clips with tool presence labels is also being released publicly and can be accessed at https://console.cloud.google.com/storage/browser/isi-surgtoolloc-2022.
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2023; v1 submitted 11 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Non-rigid Point Cloud Registration for Middle Ear Diagnostics with Endoscopic Optical Coherence Tomography
Authors:
Peng Liu,
Jonas Golde,
Joseph Morgenstern,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Chenpan Li,
Yujia Hu,
Zhaoyu Chen,
Edmund Koch,
Marcus Neudert,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Purpose: Middle ear infection is the most prevalent inflammatory disease, especially among the pediatric population. Current diagnostic methods are subjective and depend on visual cues from an otoscope, which is limited for otologists to identify pathology. To address this shortcoming, endoscopic optical coherence tomography (OCT) provides both morphological and functional in-vivo measurements of…
▽ More
Purpose: Middle ear infection is the most prevalent inflammatory disease, especially among the pediatric population. Current diagnostic methods are subjective and depend on visual cues from an otoscope, which is limited for otologists to identify pathology. To address this shortcoming, endoscopic optical coherence tomography (OCT) provides both morphological and functional in-vivo measurements of the middle ear. However, due to the shadow of prior structures, interpretation of OCT images is challenging and time-consuming. To facilitate fast diagnosis and measurement, improvement in the readability of OCT data is achieved by merging morphological knowledge from ex-vivo middle ear models with OCT volumetric data, so that OCT applications can be further promoted in daily clinical settings. Methods: We propose C2P-Net: a two-staged non-rigid registration pipeline for complete to partial point clouds, which are sampled from ex-vivo and in-vivo OCT models, respectively. To overcome the lack of labeled training data, a fast and effective generation pipeline in Blender3D is designed to simulate middle ear shapes and extract in-vivo noisy and partial point clouds. Results: We evaluate the performance of C2P-Net through experiments on both synthetic and real OCT datasets. The results demonstrate that C2P-Net is generalized to unseen middle ear point clouds and capable of handling realistic noise and incompleteness in synthetic and real OCT data. Conclusion: In this work, we aim to enable diagnosis of middle ear structures with the assistance of OCT images. We propose C2P-Net: a two-staged non-rigid registration pipeline for point clouds to support the interpretation of in-vivo noisy and partial OCT images for the first time. Code is available at: https://gitlab.com/nct\_tso\_public/c2p-net.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Why is the winner the best?
Authors:
Matthias Eisenmann,
Annika Reinke,
Vivienn Weru,
Minu Dietlinde Tizabi,
Fabian Isensee,
Tim J. Adler,
Sharib Ali,
Vincent Andrearczyk,
Marc Aubreville,
Ujjwal Baid,
Spyridon Bakas,
Niranjan Balu,
Sophia Bano,
Jorge Bernal,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Alessandro Casella,
Veronika Cheplygina,
Marie Daum,
Marleen de Bruijne,
Adrien Depeursinge,
Reuben Dorent,
Jan Egger,
David G. Ellis,
Sandy Engelhardt,
Melanie Ganz
, et al. (100 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
International benchmarking competitions have become fundamental for the comparative performance assessment of image analysis methods. However, little attention has been given to investigating what can be learnt from these competitions. Do they really generate scientific progress? What are common and successful participation strategies? What makes a solution superior to a competing method? To addre…
▽ More
International benchmarking competitions have become fundamental for the comparative performance assessment of image analysis methods. However, little attention has been given to investigating what can be learnt from these competitions. Do they really generate scientific progress? What are common and successful participation strategies? What makes a solution superior to a competing method? To address this gap in the literature, we performed a multi-center study with all 80 competitions that were conducted in the scope of IEEE ISBI 2021 and MICCAI 2021. Statistical analyses performed based on comprehensive descriptions of the submitted algorithms linked to their rank as well as the underlying participation strategies revealed common characteristics of winning solutions. These typically include the use of multi-task learning (63%) and/or multi-stage pipelines (61%), and a focus on augmentation (100%), image preprocessing (97%), data curation (79%), and postprocessing (66%). The "typical" lead of a winning team is a computer scientist with a doctoral degree, five years of experience in biomedical image analysis, and four years of experience in deep learning. Two core general development strategies stood out for highly-ranked teams: the reflection of the metrics in the method design and the focus on analyzing and handling failure cases. According to the organizers, 43% of the winning algorithms exceeded the state of the art but only 11% completely solved the respective domain problem. The insights of our study could help researchers (1) improve algorithm development strategies when approaching new problems, and (2) focus on open research questions revealed by this work.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Objective Surgical Skills Assessment and Tool Localization: Results from the MICCAI 2021 SimSurgSkill Challenge
Authors:
Aneeq Zia,
Kiran Bhattacharyya,
Xi Liu,
Ziheng Wang,
Max Berniker,
Satoshi Kondo,
Emanuele Colleoni,
Dimitris Psychogyios,
Yueming Jin,
Jinfan Zhou,
Evangelos Mazomenos,
Lena Maier-Hein,
Danail Stoyanov,
Stefanie Speidel,
Anthony Jarc
Abstract:
Timely and effective feedback within surgical training plays a critical role in developing the skills required to perform safe and efficient surgery. Feedback from expert surgeons, while especially valuable in this regard, is challenging to acquire due to their typically busy schedules, and may be subject to biases. Formal assessment procedures like OSATS and GEARS attempt to provide objective mea…
▽ More
Timely and effective feedback within surgical training plays a critical role in developing the skills required to perform safe and efficient surgery. Feedback from expert surgeons, while especially valuable in this regard, is challenging to acquire due to their typically busy schedules, and may be subject to biases. Formal assessment procedures like OSATS and GEARS attempt to provide objective measures of skill, but remain time-consuming. With advances in machine learning there is an opportunity for fast and objective automated feedback on technical skills. The SimSurgSkill 2021 challenge (hosted as a sub-challenge of EndoVis at MICCAI 2021) aimed to promote and foster work in this endeavor. Using virtual reality (VR) surgical tasks, competitors were tasked with localizing instruments and predicting surgical skill. Here we summarize the winning approaches and how they performed. Using this publicly available dataset and results as a springboard, future work may enable more efficient training of surgeons with advances in surgical data science. The dataset can be accessed from https://console.cloud.google.com/storage/browser/isi-simsurgskill-2021.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
On the Pitfalls of Batch Normalization for End-to-End Video Learning: A Study on Surgical Workflow Analysis
Authors:
Dominik Rivoir,
Isabel Funke,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Batch Normalization's (BN) unique property of depending on other samples in a batch is known to cause problems in several tasks, including sequence modeling. Yet, BN-related issues are hardly studied for long video understanding, despite the ubiquitous use of BN in CNNs (Convolutional Neural Networks) for feature extraction. Especially in surgical workflow analysis, where the lack of pretrained fe…
▽ More
Batch Normalization's (BN) unique property of depending on other samples in a batch is known to cause problems in several tasks, including sequence modeling. Yet, BN-related issues are hardly studied for long video understanding, despite the ubiquitous use of BN in CNNs (Convolutional Neural Networks) for feature extraction. Especially in surgical workflow analysis, where the lack of pretrained feature extractors has led to complex, multi-stage training pipelines, limited awareness of BN issues may have hidden the benefits of training CNNs and temporal models end to end. In this paper, we analyze pitfalls of BN in video learning, including issues specific to online tasks such as a 'cheating' effect in anticipation. We observe that BN's properties create major obstacles for end-to-end learning. However, using BN-free backbones, even simple CNN-LSTMs beat the state of the art {\color{\colorrevtwo}on three surgical workflow benchmarks} by utilizing adequate end-to-end training strategies which maximize temporal context. We conclude that awareness of BN's pitfalls is crucial for effective end-to-end learning in surgical tasks. By reproducing results on natural-video datasets, we hope our insights will benefit other areas of video learning as well. Code is available at: \url{https://gitlab.com/nct_tso_public/pitfalls_bn}
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2024; v1 submitted 15 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Comparative Validation of Machine Learning Algorithms for Surgical Workflow and Skill Analysis with the HeiChole Benchmark
Authors:
Martin Wagner,
Beat-Peter Müller-Stich,
Anna Kisilenko,
Duc Tran,
Patrick Heger,
Lars Mündermann,
David M Lubotsky,
Benjamin Müller,
Tornike Davitashvili,
Manuela Capek,
Annika Reinke,
Tong Yu,
Armine Vardazaryan,
Chinedu Innocent Nwoye,
Nicolas Padoy,
Xinyang Liu,
Eung-Joo Lee,
Constantin Disch,
Hans Meine,
Tong Xia,
Fucang Jia,
Satoshi Kondo,
Wolfgang Reiter,
Yueming Jin,
Yonghao Long
, et al. (16 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
PURPOSE: Surgical workflow and skill analysis are key technologies for the next generation of cognitive surgical assistance systems. These systems could increase the safety of the operation through context-sensitive warnings and semi-autonomous robotic assistance or improve training of surgeons via data-driven feedback. In surgical workflow analysis up to 91% average precision has been reported fo…
▽ More
PURPOSE: Surgical workflow and skill analysis are key technologies for the next generation of cognitive surgical assistance systems. These systems could increase the safety of the operation through context-sensitive warnings and semi-autonomous robotic assistance or improve training of surgeons via data-driven feedback. In surgical workflow analysis up to 91% average precision has been reported for phase recognition on an open data single-center dataset. In this work we investigated the generalizability of phase recognition algorithms in a multi-center setting including more difficult recognition tasks such as surgical action and surgical skill. METHODS: To achieve this goal, a dataset with 33 laparoscopic cholecystectomy videos from three surgical centers with a total operation time of 22 hours was created. Labels included annotation of seven surgical phases with 250 phase transitions, 5514 occurences of four surgical actions, 6980 occurences of 21 surgical instruments from seven instrument categories and 495 skill classifications in five skill dimensions. The dataset was used in the 2019 Endoscopic Vision challenge, sub-challenge for surgical workflow and skill analysis. Here, 12 teams submitted their machine learning algorithms for recognition of phase, action, instrument and/or skill assessment. RESULTS: F1-scores were achieved for phase recognition between 23.9% and 67.7% (n=9 teams), for instrument presence detection between 38.5% and 63.8% (n=8 teams), but for action recognition only between 21.8% and 23.3% (n=5 teams). The average absolute error for skill assessment was 0.78 (n=1 team). CONCLUSION: Surgical workflow and skill analysis are promising technologies to support the surgical team, but are not solved yet, as shown by our comparison of algorithms. This novel benchmark can be used for comparable evaluation and validation of future work.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Long-Term Temporally Consistent Unpaired Video Translation from Simulated Surgical 3D Data
Authors:
Dominik Rivoir,
Micha Pfeiffer,
Reuben Docea,
Fiona Kolbinger,
Carina Riediger,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Research in unpaired video translation has mainly focused on short-term temporal consistency by conditioning on neighboring frames. However for transfer from simulated to photorealistic sequences, available information on the underlying geometry offers potential for achieving global consistency across views. We propose a novel approach which combines unpaired image translation with neural renderin…
▽ More
Research in unpaired video translation has mainly focused on short-term temporal consistency by conditioning on neighboring frames. However for transfer from simulated to photorealistic sequences, available information on the underlying geometry offers potential for achieving global consistency across views. We propose a novel approach which combines unpaired image translation with neural rendering to transfer simulated to photorealistic surgical abdominal scenes. By introducing global learnable textures and a lighting-invariant view-consistency loss, our method produces consistent translations of arbitrary views and thus enables long-term consistent video synthesis. We design and test our model to generate video sequences from minimally-invasive surgical abdominal scenes. Because labeled data is often limited in this domain, photorealistic data where ground truth information from the simulated domain is preserved is especially relevant. By extending existing image-based methods to view-consistent videos, we aim to impact the applicability of simulated training and evaluation environments for surgical applications. Code and data: http://opencas.dkfz.de/video-sim2real.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2021; v1 submitted 31 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Surgical Visual Domain Adaptation: Results from the MICCAI 2020 SurgVisDom Challenge
Authors:
Aneeq Zia,
Kiran Bhattacharyya,
Xi Liu,
Ziheng Wang,
Satoshi Kondo,
Emanuele Colleoni,
Beatrice van Amsterdam,
Razeen Hussain,
Raabid Hussain,
Lena Maier-Hein,
Danail Stoyanov,
Stefanie Speidel,
Anthony Jarc
Abstract:
Surgical data science is revolutionizing minimally invasive surgery by enabling context-aware applications. However, many challenges exist around surgical data (and health data, more generally) needed to develop context-aware models. This work - presented as part of the Endoscopic Vision (EndoVis) challenge at the Medical Image Computing and Computer Assisted Intervention (MICCAI) 2020 conference…
▽ More
Surgical data science is revolutionizing minimally invasive surgery by enabling context-aware applications. However, many challenges exist around surgical data (and health data, more generally) needed to develop context-aware models. This work - presented as part of the Endoscopic Vision (EndoVis) challenge at the Medical Image Computing and Computer Assisted Intervention (MICCAI) 2020 conference - seeks to explore the potential for visual domain adaptation in surgery to overcome data privacy concerns. In particular, we propose to use video from virtual reality (VR) simulations of surgical exercises in robotic-assisted surgery to develop algorithms to recognize tasks in a clinical-like setting. We present the performance of the different approaches to solve visual domain adaptation developed by challenge participants. Our analysis shows that the presented models were unable to learn meaningful motion based features form VR data alone, but did significantly better when small amount of clinical-like data was also made available. Based on these results, we discuss promising methods and further work to address the problem of visual domain adaptation in surgical data science. We also release the challenge dataset publicly at https://www.synapse.org/surgvisdom2020.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Stereo Correspondence and Reconstruction of Endoscopic Data Challenge
Authors:
Max Allan,
Jonathan Mcleod,
Congcong Wang,
Jean Claude Rosenthal,
Zhenglei Hu,
Niklas Gard,
Peter Eisert,
Ke Xue Fu,
Trevor Zeffiro,
Wenyao Xia,
Zhanshi Zhu,
Huoling Luo,
Fucang Jia,
Xiran Zhang,
Xiaohong Li,
Lalith Sharan,
Tom Kurmann,
Sebastian Schmid,
Raphael Sznitman,
Dimitris Psychogyios,
Mahdi Azizian,
Danail Stoyanov,
Lena Maier-Hein,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
The stereo correspondence and reconstruction of endoscopic data sub-challenge was organized during the Endovis challenge at MICCAI 2019 in Shenzhen, China. The task was to perform dense depth estimation using 7 training datasets and 2 test sets of structured light data captured using porcine cadavers. These were provided by a team at Intuitive Surgical. 10 teams participated in the challenge day.…
▽ More
The stereo correspondence and reconstruction of endoscopic data sub-challenge was organized during the Endovis challenge at MICCAI 2019 in Shenzhen, China. The task was to perform dense depth estimation using 7 training datasets and 2 test sets of structured light data captured using porcine cadavers. These were provided by a team at Intuitive Surgical. 10 teams participated in the challenge day. This paper contains 3 additional methods which were submitted after the challenge finished as well as a supplemental section from these teams on issues they found with the dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 28 January, 2021; v1 submitted 4 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
SERV-CT: A disparity dataset from CT for validation of endoscopic 3D reconstruction
Authors:
P. J. "Eddie'' Edwards,
Dimitris Psychogyios,
Stefanie Speidel,
Lena Maier-Hein,
Danail Stoyanov
Abstract:
In computer vision, reference datasets have been highly successful in promoting algorithmic development in stereo reconstruction. Surgical scenes gives rise to specific problems, including the lack of clear corner features, highly specular surfaces and the presence of blood and smoke. Publicly available datasets have been produced using CT and either phantom images or biological tissue samples cov…
▽ More
In computer vision, reference datasets have been highly successful in promoting algorithmic development in stereo reconstruction. Surgical scenes gives rise to specific problems, including the lack of clear corner features, highly specular surfaces and the presence of blood and smoke. Publicly available datasets have been produced using CT and either phantom images or biological tissue samples covering a relatively small region of the endoscope field-of-view. We present a stereo-endoscopic reconstruction validation dataset based on CT (SERV-CT). Two {\it ex vivo} small porcine full torso cadavers were placed within the view of the endoscope with both the endoscope and target anatomy visible in the CT scan. Orientation of the endoscope was manually aligned to the stereoscopic view. Reference disparities and occlusions were calculated for 8 stereo pairs from each sample. For the second sample an RGB surface was acquired to aid alignment of smooth, featureless surfaces. Repeated manual alignments showed an RMS disparity accuracy of ~2 pixels and a depth accuracy of ~2mm. The reference dataset includes endoscope image pairs with corresponding calibration, disparities, depths and occlusions covering the majority of the endoscopic image and a range of tissue types. Smooth specular surfaces and images with significant variation of depth are included. We assessed the performance of various stereo algorithms from online available repositories. There is a significant variation between algorithms, highlighting some of the challenges of surgical endoscopic images. The SERV-CT dataset provides an easy to use stereoscopic validation for surgical applications with smooth reference disparities and depths with coverage over the majority of the endoscopic images. This complements existing resources well and we hope will aid the development of surgical endoscopic anatomical reconstruction algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Surgical Data Science -- from Concepts toward Clinical Translation
Authors:
Lena Maier-Hein,
Matthias Eisenmann,
Duygu Sarikaya,
Keno März,
Toby Collins,
Anand Malpani,
Johannes Fallert,
Hubertus Feussner,
Stamatia Giannarou,
Pietro Mascagni,
Hirenkumar Nakawala,
Adrian Park,
Carla Pugh,
Danail Stoyanov,
Swaroop S. Vedula,
Kevin Cleary,
Gabor Fichtinger,
Germain Forestier,
Bernard Gibaud,
Teodor Grantcharov,
Makoto Hashizume,
Doreen Heckmann-Nötzel,
Hannes G. Kenngott,
Ron Kikinis,
Lars Mündermann
, et al. (25 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Recent developments in data science in general and machine learning in particular have transformed the way experts envision the future of surgery. Surgical Data Science (SDS) is a new research field that aims to improve the quality of interventional healthcare through the capture, organization, analysis and modeling of data. While an increasing number of data-driven approaches and clinical applica…
▽ More
Recent developments in data science in general and machine learning in particular have transformed the way experts envision the future of surgery. Surgical Data Science (SDS) is a new research field that aims to improve the quality of interventional healthcare through the capture, organization, analysis and modeling of data. While an increasing number of data-driven approaches and clinical applications have been studied in the fields of radiological and clinical data science, translational success stories are still lacking in surgery. In this publication, we shed light on the underlying reasons and provide a roadmap for future advances in the field. Based on an international workshop involving leading researchers in the field of SDS, we review current practice, key achievements and initiatives as well as available standards and tools for a number of topics relevant to the field, namely (1) infrastructure for data acquisition, storage and access in the presence of regulatory constraints, (2) data annotation and sharing and (3) data analytics. We further complement this technical perspective with (4) a review of currently available SDS products and the translational progress from academia and (5) a roadmap for faster clinical translation and exploitation of the full potential of SDS, based on an international multi-round Delphi process.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2021; v1 submitted 30 October, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Rethinking Anticipation Tasks: Uncertainty-aware Anticipation of Sparse Surgical Instrument Usage for Context-aware Assistance
Authors:
Dominik Rivoir,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Isabel Funke,
Felix von Bechtolsheim,
Marius Distler,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Intra-operative anticipation of instrument usage is a necessary component for context-aware assistance in surgery, e.g. for instrument preparation or semi-automation of robotic tasks. However, the sparsity of instrument occurrences in long videos poses a challenge. Current approaches are limited as they assume knowledge on the timing of future actions or require dense temporal segmentations during…
▽ More
Intra-operative anticipation of instrument usage is a necessary component for context-aware assistance in surgery, e.g. for instrument preparation or semi-automation of robotic tasks. However, the sparsity of instrument occurrences in long videos poses a challenge. Current approaches are limited as they assume knowledge on the timing of future actions or require dense temporal segmentations during training and inference. We propose a novel learning task for anticipation of instrument usage in laparoscopic videos that overcomes these limitations. During training, only sparse instrument annotations are required and inference is done solely on image data. We train a probabilistic model to address the uncertainty associated with future events. Our approach outperforms several baselines and is competitive to a variant using richer annotations. We demonstrate the model's ability to quantify task-relevant uncertainties. To the best of our knowledge, we are the first to propose a method for anticipating instruments in surgery.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2022; v1 submitted 1 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Non-Rigid Volume to Surface Registration using a Data-Driven Biomechanical Model
Authors:
Micha Pfeiffer,
Carina Riediger,
Stefan Leger,
Jens-Peter Kühn,
Danilo Seppelt,
Ralf-Thorsten Hoffmann,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Non-rigid registration is a key component in soft-tissue navigation. We focus on laparoscopic liver surgery, where we register the organ model obtained from a preoperative CT scan to the intraoperative partial organ surface, reconstructed from the laparoscopic video. This is a challenging task due to sparse and noisy intraoperative data, real-time requirements and many unknowns - such as tissue pr…
▽ More
Non-rigid registration is a key component in soft-tissue navigation. We focus on laparoscopic liver surgery, where we register the organ model obtained from a preoperative CT scan to the intraoperative partial organ surface, reconstructed from the laparoscopic video. This is a challenging task due to sparse and noisy intraoperative data, real-time requirements and many unknowns - such as tissue properties and boundary conditions. Furthermore, establishing correspondences between pre- and intraoperative data can be extremely difficult since the liver usually lacks distinct surface features and the used imaging modalities suffer from very different types of noise. In this work, we train a convolutional neural network to perform both the search for surface correspondences as well as the non-rigid registration in one step. The network is trained on physically accurate biomechanical simulations of randomly generated, deforming organ-like structures. This enables the network to immediately generalize to a new patient organ without the need to re-train. We add various amounts of noise to the intraoperative surfaces during training, making the network robust to noisy intraoperative data. During inference, the network outputs the displacement field which matches the preoperative volume to the partial intraoperative surface. In multiple experiments, we show that the network translates well to real data while maintaining a high inference speed. Our code is made available online.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Heidelberg Colorectal Data Set for Surgical Data Science in the Sensor Operating Room
Authors:
Lena Maier-Hein,
Martin Wagner,
Tobias Ross,
Annika Reinke,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Peter M. Full,
Hellena Hempe,
Diana Mindroc-Filimon,
Patrick Scholz,
Thuy Nuong Tran,
Pierangela Bruno,
Anna Kisilenko,
Benjamin Müller,
Tornike Davitashvili,
Manuela Capek,
Minu Tizabi,
Matthias Eisenmann,
Tim J. Adler,
Janek Gröhl,
Melanie Schellenberg,
Silvia Seidlitz,
T. Y. Emmy Lai,
Bünyamin Pekdemir,
Veith Roethlingshoefer,
Fabian Both
, et al. (8 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Image-based tracking of medical instruments is an integral part of surgical data science applications. Previous research has addressed the tasks of detecting, segmenting and tracking medical instruments based on laparoscopic video data. However, the proposed methods still tend to fail when applied to challenging images and do not generalize well to data they have not been trained on. This paper in…
▽ More
Image-based tracking of medical instruments is an integral part of surgical data science applications. Previous research has addressed the tasks of detecting, segmenting and tracking medical instruments based on laparoscopic video data. However, the proposed methods still tend to fail when applied to challenging images and do not generalize well to data they have not been trained on. This paper introduces the Heidelberg Colorectal (HeiCo) data set - the first publicly available data set enabling comprehensive benchmarking of medical instrument detection and segmentation algorithms with a specific emphasis on method robustness and generalization capabilities. Our data set comprises 30 laparoscopic videos and corresponding sensor data from medical devices in the operating room for three different types of laparoscopic surgery. Annotations include surgical phase labels for all video frames as well as information on instrument presence and corresponding instance-wise segmentation masks for surgical instruments (if any) in more than 10,000 individual frames. The data has successfully been used to organize international competitions within the Endoscopic Vision Challenges 2017 and 2019.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2021; v1 submitted 7 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Robust Medical Instrument Segmentation Challenge 2019
Authors:
Tobias Ross,
Annika Reinke,
Peter M. Full,
Martin Wagner,
Hannes Kenngott,
Martin Apitz,
Hellena Hempe,
Diana Mindroc Filimon,
Patrick Scholz,
Thuy Nuong Tran,
Pierangela Bruno,
Pablo Arbeláez,
Gui-Bin Bian,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Jon Lindström Bolmgren,
Laura Bravo-Sánchez,
Hua-Bin Chen,
Cristina González,
Dong Guo,
Pål Halvorsen,
Pheng-Ann Heng,
Enes Hosgor,
Zeng-Guang Hou,
Fabian Isensee,
Debesh Jha
, et al. (25 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Intraoperative tracking of laparoscopic instruments is often a prerequisite for computer and robotic-assisted interventions. While numerous methods for detecting, segmenting and tracking of medical instruments based on endoscopic video images have been proposed in the literature, key limitations remain to be addressed: Firstly, robustness, that is, the reliable performance of state-of-the-art meth…
▽ More
Intraoperative tracking of laparoscopic instruments is often a prerequisite for computer and robotic-assisted interventions. While numerous methods for detecting, segmenting and tracking of medical instruments based on endoscopic video images have been proposed in the literature, key limitations remain to be addressed: Firstly, robustness, that is, the reliable performance of state-of-the-art methods when run on challenging images (e.g. in the presence of blood, smoke or motion artifacts). Secondly, generalization; algorithms trained for a specific intervention in a specific hospital should generalize to other interventions or institutions.
In an effort to promote solutions for these limitations, we organized the Robust Medical Instrument Segmentation (ROBUST-MIS) challenge as an international benchmarking competition with a specific focus on the robustness and generalization capabilities of algorithms. For the first time in the field of endoscopic image processing, our challenge included a task on binary segmentation and also addressed multi-instance detection and segmentation. The challenge was based on a surgical data set comprising 10,040 annotated images acquired from a total of 30 surgical procedures from three different types of surgery. The validation of the competing methods for the three tasks (binary segmentation, multi-instance detection and multi-instance segmentation) was performed in three different stages with an increasing domain gap between the training and the test data. The results confirm the initial hypothesis, namely that algorithm performance degrades with an increasing domain gap. While the average detection and segmentation quality of the best-performing algorithms is high, future research should concentrate on detection and segmentation of small, crossing, moving and transparent instrument(s) (parts).
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2020; v1 submitted 23 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Unsupervised Temporal Video Segmentation as an Auxiliary Task for Predicting the Remaining Surgery Duration
Authors:
Dominik Rivoir,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Felix von Bechtolsheim,
Marius Distler,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Estimating the remaining surgery duration (RSD) during surgical procedures can be useful for OR planning and anesthesia dose estimation. With the recent success of deep learning-based methods in computer vision, several neural network approaches have been proposed for fully automatic RSD prediction based solely on visual data from the endoscopic camera. We investigate whether RSD prediction can be…
▽ More
Estimating the remaining surgery duration (RSD) during surgical procedures can be useful for OR planning and anesthesia dose estimation. With the recent success of deep learning-based methods in computer vision, several neural network approaches have been proposed for fully automatic RSD prediction based solely on visual data from the endoscopic camera. We investigate whether RSD prediction can be improved using unsupervised temporal video segmentation as an auxiliary learning task. As opposed to previous work, which presented supervised surgical phase recognition as auxiliary task, we avoid the need for manual annotations by proposing a similar but unsupervised learning objective which clusters video sequences into temporally coherent segments. In multiple experimental setups, results obtained by learning the auxiliary task are incorporated into a deep RSD model through feature extraction, pretraining or regularization. Further, we propose a novel loss function for RSD training which attempts to counteract unfavorable characteristics of the RSD ground truth. Using our unsupervised method as an auxiliary task for RSD training, we outperform other self-supervised methods and are comparable to the supervised state-of-the-art. Combined with the novel RSD loss, we slightly outperform the supervised approach.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
2018 Robotic Scene Segmentation Challenge
Authors:
Max Allan,
Satoshi Kondo,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Stefan Leger,
Rahim Kadkhodamohammadi,
Imanol Luengo,
Felix Fuentes,
Evangello Flouty,
Ahmed Mohammed,
Marius Pedersen,
Avinash Kori,
Varghese Alex,
Ganapathy Krishnamurthi,
David Rauber,
Robert Mendel,
Christoph Palm,
Sophia Bano,
Guinther Saibro,
Chi-Sheng Shih,
Hsun-An Chiang,
Juntang Zhuang,
Junlin Yang,
Vladimir Iglovikov,
Anton Dobrenkii,
Madhu Reddiboina
, et al. (16 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In 2015 we began a sub-challenge at the EndoVis workshop at MICCAI in Munich using endoscope images of ex-vivo tissue with automatically generated annotations from robot forward kinematics and instrument CAD models. However, the limited background variation and simple motion rendered the dataset uninformative in learning about which techniques would be suitable for segmentation in real surgery. In…
▽ More
In 2015 we began a sub-challenge at the EndoVis workshop at MICCAI in Munich using endoscope images of ex-vivo tissue with automatically generated annotations from robot forward kinematics and instrument CAD models. However, the limited background variation and simple motion rendered the dataset uninformative in learning about which techniques would be suitable for segmentation in real surgery. In 2017, at the same workshop in Quebec we introduced the robotic instrument segmentation dataset with 10 teams participating in the challenge to perform binary, articulating parts and type segmentation of da Vinci instruments. This challenge included realistic instrument motion and more complex porcine tissue as background and was widely addressed with modifications on U-Nets and other popular CNN architectures. In 2018 we added to the complexity by introducing a set of anatomical objects and medical devices to the segmented classes. To avoid over-complicating the challenge, we continued with porcine data which is dramatically simpler than human tissue due to the lack of fatty tissue occluding many organs.
△ Less
Submitted 2 August, 2020; v1 submitted 30 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Using 3D Convolutional Neural Networks to Learn Spatiotemporal Features for Automatic Surgical Gesture Recognition in Video
Authors:
Isabel Funke,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Florian Oehme,
Felix von Bechtolsheim,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Automatically recognizing surgical gestures is a crucial step towards a thorough understanding of surgical skill. Possible areas of application include automatic skill assessment, intra-operative monitoring of critical surgical steps, and semi-automation of surgical tasks. Solutions that rely only on the laparoscopic video and do not require additional sensor hardware are especially attractive as…
▽ More
Automatically recognizing surgical gestures is a crucial step towards a thorough understanding of surgical skill. Possible areas of application include automatic skill assessment, intra-operative monitoring of critical surgical steps, and semi-automation of surgical tasks. Solutions that rely only on the laparoscopic video and do not require additional sensor hardware are especially attractive as they can be implemented at low cost in many scenarios. However, surgical gesture recognition based only on video is a challenging problem that requires effective means to extract both visual and temporal information from the video. Previous approaches mainly rely on frame-wise feature extractors, either handcrafted or learned, which fail to capture the dynamics in surgical video. To address this issue, we propose to use a 3D Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) to learn spatiotemporal features from consecutive video frames. We evaluate our approach on recordings of robot-assisted suturing on a bench-top model, which are taken from the publicly available JIGSAWS dataset. Our approach achieves high frame-wise surgical gesture recognition accuracies of more than 84%, outperforming comparable models that either extract only spatial features or model spatial and low-level temporal information separately. For the first time, these results demonstrate the benefit of spatiotemporal CNNs for video-based surgical gesture recognition.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Generating large labeled data sets for laparoscopic image processing tasks using unpaired image-to-image translation
Authors:
Micha Pfeiffer,
Isabel Funke,
Maria R. Robu,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Leon Strenger,
Sandy Engelhardt,
Tobias Roß,
Matthew J. Clarkson,
Kurinchi Gurusamy,
Brian R. Davidson,
Lena Maier-Hein,
Carina Riediger,
Thilo Welsch,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
In the medical domain, the lack of large training data sets and benchmarks is often a limiting factor for training deep neural networks. In contrast to expensive manual labeling, computer simulations can generate large and fully labeled data sets with a minimum of manual effort. However, models that are trained on simulated data usually do not translate well to real scenarios. To bridge the domain…
▽ More
In the medical domain, the lack of large training data sets and benchmarks is often a limiting factor for training deep neural networks. In contrast to expensive manual labeling, computer simulations can generate large and fully labeled data sets with a minimum of manual effort. However, models that are trained on simulated data usually do not translate well to real scenarios. To bridge the domain gap between simulated and real laparoscopic images, we exploit recent advances in unpaired image-to-image translation. We extent an image-to-image translation method to generate a diverse multitude of realistically looking synthetic images based on images from a simple laparoscopy simulation. By incorporating means to ensure that the image content is preserved during the translation process, we ensure that the labels given for the simulated images remain valid for their realistically looking translations. This way, we are able to generate a large, fully labeled synthetic data set of laparoscopic images with realistic appearance. We show that this data set can be used to train models for the task of liver segmentation of laparoscopic images. We achieve average dice scores of up to 0.89 in some patients without manually labeling a single laparoscopic image and show that using our synthetic data to pre-train models can greatly improve their performance. The synthetic data set will be made publicly available, fully labeled with segmentation maps, depth maps, normal maps, and positions of tools and camera (http://opencas.dkfz.de/image2image).
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Learning Soft Tissue Behavior of Organs for Surgical Navigation with Convolutional Neural Networks
Authors:
Micha Pfeiffer,
Carina Riediger,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Purpose: In surgical navigation, pre-operative organ models are presented to surgeons during the intervention to help them in efficiently finding their target. In the case of soft tissue, these models need to be deformed and adapted to the current situation by using intra-operative sensor data. A promising method to realize this are real-time capable biomechanical models.
Methods: We train a ful…
▽ More
Purpose: In surgical navigation, pre-operative organ models are presented to surgeons during the intervention to help them in efficiently finding their target. In the case of soft tissue, these models need to be deformed and adapted to the current situation by using intra-operative sensor data. A promising method to realize this are real-time capable biomechanical models.
Methods: We train a fully convolutional neural network to estimate a displacement field of all points inside an organ when given only the displacement of a part of the organ's surface. The network trains on entirely synthetic data of random organ-like meshes, which allows us to generate much more data than is otherwise available. The input and output data is discretized into a regular grid, allowing us to fully utilize the capabilities of convolutional operators and to train and infer in a highly parallelized manner.
Results: The system is evaluated on in-silico liver models, phantom liver data and human in-vivo breathing data. We test the performance with varying material parameters, organ shapes and amount of visible surface. Even though the network is only trained on synthetic data, it adapts well to the various cases and gives a good estimation of the internal organ displacement. The inference runs at over 50 frames per second.
Conclusions: We present a novel method for training a data-driven, real-time capable deformation model. The accuracy is comparable to other registration methods, it adapts very well to previously unseen organs and does not need to be re-trained for every patient. The high inferring speed makes this method useful for many applications such as surgical navigation and real-time simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Video-based surgical skill assessment using 3D convolutional neural networks
Authors:
Isabel Funke,
Sören Torge Mees,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Purpose: A profound education of novice surgeons is crucial to ensure that surgical interventions are effective and safe. One important aspect is the teaching of technical skills for minimally invasive or robot-assisted procedures. This includes the objective and preferably automatic assessment of surgical skill. Recent studies presented good results for automatic, objective skill evaluation by co…
▽ More
Purpose: A profound education of novice surgeons is crucial to ensure that surgical interventions are effective and safe. One important aspect is the teaching of technical skills for minimally invasive or robot-assisted procedures. This includes the objective and preferably automatic assessment of surgical skill. Recent studies presented good results for automatic, objective skill evaluation by collecting and analyzing motion data such as trajectories of surgical instruments. However, obtaining the motion data generally requires additional equipment for instrument tracking or the availability of a robotic surgery system to capture kinematic data. In contrast, we investigate a method for automatic, objective skill assessment that requires video data only. This has the advantage that video can be collected effortlessly during minimally invasive and robot-assisted training scenarios.
Methods: Our method builds on recent advances in deep learning-based video classification. Specifically, we propose to use an inflated 3D ConvNet to classify snippets, i.e., stacks of a few consecutive frames, extracted from surgical video. The network is extended into a Temporal Segment Network during training.
Results: We evaluate the method on the publicly available JIGSAWS dataset, which consists of recordings of basic robot-assisted surgery tasks performed on a dry lab bench-top model. Our approach achieves high skill classification accuracies ranging from 95.1% to 100.0%.
Conclusions: Our results demonstrate the feasibility of deep learning-based assessment of technical skill from surgical video. Notably, the 3D ConvNet is able to learn meaningful patterns directly from the data, alleviating the need for manual feature engineering. Further evaluation will require more annotated data for training and testing.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2019; v1 submitted 6 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
2017 Robotic Instrument Segmentation Challenge
Authors:
Max Allan,
Alex Shvets,
Thomas Kurmann,
Zichen Zhang,
Rahul Duggal,
Yun-Hsuan Su,
Nicola Rieke,
Iro Laina,
Niveditha Kalavakonda,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Luis Herrera,
Wenqi Li,
Vladimir Iglovikov,
Huoling Luo,
Jian Yang,
Danail Stoyanov,
Lena Maier-Hein,
Stefanie Speidel,
Mahdi Azizian
Abstract:
In mainstream computer vision and machine learning, public datasets such as ImageNet, COCO and KITTI have helped drive enormous improvements by enabling researchers to understand the strengths and limitations of different algorithms via performance comparison. However, this type of approach has had limited translation to problems in robotic assisted surgery as this field has never established the…
▽ More
In mainstream computer vision and machine learning, public datasets such as ImageNet, COCO and KITTI have helped drive enormous improvements by enabling researchers to understand the strengths and limitations of different algorithms via performance comparison. However, this type of approach has had limited translation to problems in robotic assisted surgery as this field has never established the same level of common datasets and benchmarking methods. In 2015 a sub-challenge was introduced at the EndoVis workshop where a set of robotic images were provided with automatically generated annotations from robot forward kinematics. However, there were issues with this dataset due to the limited background variation, lack of complex motion and inaccuracies in the annotation. In this work we present the results of the 2017 challenge on robotic instrument segmentation which involved 10 teams participating in binary, parts and type based segmentation of articulated da Vinci robotic instruments.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2019; v1 submitted 18 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Prediction of laparoscopic procedure duration using unlabeled, multimodal sensor data
Authors:
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Martin Wagner,
Lars Mündermann,
Hannes Kenngott,
Beat Müller-Stich,
Michael Breucha,
Sören Torge Mees,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Purpose The course of surgical procedures is often unpredictable, making it difficult to estimate the duration of procedures beforehand. A context-aware method that analyses the workflow of an intervention online and automatically predicts the remaining duration would alleviate these problems. As basis for such an estimate, information regarding the current state of the intervention is required. M…
▽ More
Purpose The course of surgical procedures is often unpredictable, making it difficult to estimate the duration of procedures beforehand. A context-aware method that analyses the workflow of an intervention online and automatically predicts the remaining duration would alleviate these problems. As basis for such an estimate, information regarding the current state of the intervention is required. Methods Today, the operating room contains a diverse range of sensors. During laparoscopic interventions, the endoscopic video stream is an ideal source of such information. Extracting quantitative information from the video is challenging though, due to its high dimensionality. Other surgical devices (e.g. insufflator, lights, etc.) provide data streams which are, in contrast to the video stream, more compact and easier to quantify. Though whether such streams offer sufficient information for estimating the duration of surgery is uncertain. Here, we propose and compare methods, based on convolutional neural networks, for continuously predicting the duration of laparoscopic interventions based on unlabeled data, such as from endoscopic images and surgical device streams. Results The methods are evaluated on 80 laparoscopic interventions of various types, for which surgical device data and the endoscopic video are available. Here the combined method performs best with an overall average error of 37% and an average halftime error of 28%. Conclusion In this paper, we present, to our knowledge, the first approach for online procedure duration prediction using unlabeled endoscopic video data and surgical device data in a laparoscopic setting. We also show that a method incorporating both vision and device data performs better than methods based only on vision, while methods only based on tool usage and surgical device data perform poorly, showing the importance of the visual channel.
△ Less
Submitted 3 April, 2019; v1 submitted 8 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Active Learning using Deep Bayesian Networks for Surgical Workflow Analysis
Authors:
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Dominik Rivoir,
Alexander Jenke,
Martin Wagner,
Michael Breucha,
Beat Müller-Stich,
Sören Torge Mees,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
For many applications in the field of computer assisted surgery, such as providing the position of a tumor, specifying the most probable tool required next by the surgeon or determining the remaining duration of surgery, methods for surgical workflow analysis are a prerequisite. Often machine learning based approaches serve as basis for surgical workflow analysis. In general machine learning algor…
▽ More
For many applications in the field of computer assisted surgery, such as providing the position of a tumor, specifying the most probable tool required next by the surgeon or determining the remaining duration of surgery, methods for surgical workflow analysis are a prerequisite. Often machine learning based approaches serve as basis for surgical workflow analysis. In general machine learning algorithms, such as convolutional neural networks (CNN), require large amounts of labeled data. While data is often available in abundance, many tasks in surgical workflow analysis need data annotated by domain experts, making it difficult to obtain a sufficient amount of annotations.
The aim of using active learning to train a machine learning model is to reduce the annotation effort. Active learning methods determine which unlabeled data points would provide the most information according to some metric, such as prediction uncertainty. Experts will then be asked to only annotate these data points. The model is then retrained with the new data and used to select further data for annotation. Recently, active learning has been applied to CNN by means of Deep Bayesian Networks (DBN). These networks make it possible to assign uncertainties to predictions.
In this paper, we present a DBN-based active learning approach adapted for image-based surgical workflow analysis task. Furthermore, by using a recurrent architecture, we extend this network to video-based surgical workflow analysis. We evaluate these approaches on the Cholec80 dataset by performing instrument presence detection and surgical phase segmentation. Here we are able to show that using a DBN-based active learning approach for selecting what data points to annotate next outperforms a baseline based on randomly selecting data points.
△ Less
Submitted 2 April, 2019; v1 submitted 8 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
Real-time image-based instrument classification for laparoscopic surgery
Authors:
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Antonia Ohnemus,
Darko Katic,
Anna-Laura Wekerle,
Martin Wagner,
Hannes Kenngott,
Beat Müller-Stich,
Rüdiger Dillmann,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
During laparoscopic surgery, context-aware assistance systems aim to alleviate some of the difficulties the surgeon faces. To ensure that the right information is provided at the right time, the current phase of the intervention has to be known. Real-time locating and classification the surgical tools currently in use are key components of both an activity-based phase recognition and assistance ge…
▽ More
During laparoscopic surgery, context-aware assistance systems aim to alleviate some of the difficulties the surgeon faces. To ensure that the right information is provided at the right time, the current phase of the intervention has to be known. Real-time locating and classification the surgical tools currently in use are key components of both an activity-based phase recognition and assistance generation.
In this paper, we present an image-based approach that detects and classifies tools during laparoscopic interventions in real-time. First, potential instrument bounding boxes are detected using a pixel-wise random forest segmentation. Each of these bounding boxes is then classified using a cascade of random forest. For this, multiple features, such as histograms over hue and saturation, gradients and SURF feature, are extracted from each detected bounding box.
We evaluated our approach on five different videos from two different types of procedures. We distinguished between the four most common classes of instruments (LigaSure, atraumatic grasper, aspirator, clip applier) and background. Our method succesfully located up to 86% of all instruments respectively. On manually provided bounding boxes, we achieve a instrument type recognition rate of up to 58% and on automatically detected bounding boxes up to 49%.
To our knowledge, this is the first approach that allows an image-based classification of surgical tools in a laparoscopic setting in real-time.
△ Less
Submitted 1 August, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
Temporal coherence-based self-supervised learning for laparoscopic workflow analysis
Authors:
Isabel Funke,
Alexander Jenke,
Sören Torge Mees,
Jürgen Weitz,
Stefanie Speidel,
Sebastian Bodenstedt
Abstract:
In order to provide the right type of assistance at the right time, computer-assisted surgery systems need context awareness. To achieve this, methods for surgical workflow analysis are crucial. Currently, convolutional neural networks provide the best performance for video-based workflow analysis tasks. For training such networks, large amounts of annotated data are necessary. However, collecting…
▽ More
In order to provide the right type of assistance at the right time, computer-assisted surgery systems need context awareness. To achieve this, methods for surgical workflow analysis are crucial. Currently, convolutional neural networks provide the best performance for video-based workflow analysis tasks. For training such networks, large amounts of annotated data are necessary. However, collecting a sufficient amount of data is often costly, time-consuming, and not always feasible. In this paper, we address this problem by presenting and comparing different approaches for self-supervised pretraining of neural networks on unlabeled laparoscopic videos using temporal coherence. We evaluate our pretrained networks on Cholec80, a publicly available dataset for surgical phase segmentation, on which a maximum F1 score of 84.6 was reached. Furthermore, we were able to achieve an increase of the F1 score of up to 10 points when compared to a non-pretrained neural network.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2018; v1 submitted 18 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Why rankings of biomedical image analysis competitions should be interpreted with care
Authors:
Lena Maier-Hein,
Matthias Eisenmann,
Annika Reinke,
Sinan Onogur,
Marko Stankovic,
Patrick Scholz,
Tal Arbel,
Hrvoje Bogunovic,
Andrew P. Bradley,
Aaron Carass,
Carolin Feldmann,
Alejandro F. Frangi,
Peter M. Full,
Bram van Ginneken,
Allan Hanbury,
Katrin Honauer,
Michal Kozubek,
Bennett A. Landman,
Keno März,
Oskar Maier,
Klaus Maier-Hein,
Bjoern H. Menze,
Henning Müller,
Peter F. Neher,
Wiro Niessen
, et al. (13 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
International challenges have become the standard for validation of biomedical image analysis methods. Given their scientific impact, it is surprising that a critical analysis of common practices related to the organization of challenges has not yet been performed. In this paper, we present a comprehensive analysis of biomedical image analysis challenges conducted up to now. We demonstrate the imp…
▽ More
International challenges have become the standard for validation of biomedical image analysis methods. Given their scientific impact, it is surprising that a critical analysis of common practices related to the organization of challenges has not yet been performed. In this paper, we present a comprehensive analysis of biomedical image analysis challenges conducted up to now. We demonstrate the importance of challenges and show that the lack of quality control has critical consequences. First, reproducibility and interpretation of the results is often hampered as only a fraction of relevant information is typically provided. Second, the rank of an algorithm is generally not robust to a number of variables such as the test data used for validation, the ranking scheme applied and the observers that make the reference annotations. To overcome these problems, we recommend best practice guidelines and define open research questions to be addressed in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2019; v1 submitted 6 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Comparative evaluation of instrument segmentation and tracking methods in minimally invasive surgery
Authors:
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Max Allan,
Anthony Agustinos,
Xiaofei Du,
Luis Garcia-Peraza-Herrera,
Hannes Kenngott,
Thomas Kurmann,
Beat Müller-Stich,
Sebastien Ourselin,
Daniil Pakhomov,
Raphael Sznitman,
Marvin Teichmann,
Martin Thoma,
Tom Vercauteren,
Sandrine Voros,
Martin Wagner,
Pamela Wochner,
Lena Maier-Hein,
Danail Stoyanov,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Intraoperative segmentation and tracking of minimally invasive instruments is a prerequisite for computer- and robotic-assisted surgery. Since additional hardware like tracking systems or the robot encoders are cumbersome and lack accuracy, surgical vision is evolving as promising techniques to segment and track the instruments using only the endoscopic images. However, what is missing so far are…
▽ More
Intraoperative segmentation and tracking of minimally invasive instruments is a prerequisite for computer- and robotic-assisted surgery. Since additional hardware like tracking systems or the robot encoders are cumbersome and lack accuracy, surgical vision is evolving as promising techniques to segment and track the instruments using only the endoscopic images. However, what is missing so far are common image data sets for consistent evaluation and benchmarking of algorithms against each other. The paper presents a comparative validation study of different vision-based methods for instrument segmentation and tracking in the context of robotic as well as conventional laparoscopic surgery. The contribution of the paper is twofold: we introduce a comprehensive validation data set that was provided to the study participants and present the results of the comparative validation study. Based on the results of the validation study, we arrive at the conclusion that modern deep learning approaches outperform other methods in instrument segmentation tasks, but the results are still not perfect. Furthermore, we show that merging results from different methods actually significantly increases accuracy in comparison to the best stand-alone method. On the other hand, the results of the instrument tracking task show that this is still an open challenge, especially during challenging scenarios in conventional laparoscopic surgery.
△ Less
Submitted 7 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
IMHOTEP - Virtual Reality Framework for Surgical Applications
Authors:
Micha Pfeiffer,
Hannes Kenngott,
Anas Preukschas,
Matthias Huber,
Lisa Bettscheider,
Beat Müller-Stich,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Purpose: The data which is available to surgeons before, during and after surgery is steadily increasing in quantity as well as diversity. When planning a patient's treatment, this large amount of information can be difficult to interpret. To aid in processing the information, new methods need to be found to present multi-modal patient data, ideally combining textual, imagery, temporal and 3D data…
▽ More
Purpose: The data which is available to surgeons before, during and after surgery is steadily increasing in quantity as well as diversity. When planning a patient's treatment, this large amount of information can be difficult to interpret. To aid in processing the information, new methods need to be found to present multi-modal patient data, ideally combining textual, imagery, temporal and 3D data in a holistic and context-aware system. Methods: We present an open-source framework which allows handling of patient data in a virtual reality (VR) environment. By using VR technology, the workspace available to the surgeon is maximized and 3D patient data is rendered in stereo, which increases depth perception. The framework organizes the data into workspaces and contains tools which allow users to control, manipulate and enhance the data. Due to the framework's modular design, it can easily be adapted and extended for various clinical applications. Results: The framework was evaluated by clinical personnel (77 participants). The majority of the group stated that a complex surgical situation is easier to comprehend by using the framework, and that it is very well suited for education. Furthermore, the application to various clinical scenarios - including the simulation of excitation-propagation in the human atrium - demonstrated the framework's adaptability. As a feasibility study, the framework was used during the planning phase of the surgical removal of a large central carcinoma from a patient's liver. Conclusion: The clinical evaluation showed a large potential and high acceptance for the VR environment in a medical context. The various applications confirmed that the framework is easily extended and can be used in real-time simulation as well as for the manipulation of complex anatomical structures.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Exploiting the potential of unlabeled endoscopic video data with self-supervised learning
Authors:
Tobias Ross,
David Zimmerer,
Anant Vemuri,
Fabian Isensee,
Manuel Wiesenfarth,
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Fabian Both,
Philip Kessler,
Martin Wagner,
Beat Müller,
Hannes Kenngott,
Stefanie Speidel,
Annette Kopp-Schneider,
Klaus Maier-Hein,
Lena Maier-Hein
Abstract:
Surgical data science is a new research field that aims to observe all aspects of the patient treatment process in order to provide the right assistance at the right time. Due to the breakthrough successes of deep learning-based solutions for automatic image annotation, the availability of reference annotations for algorithm training is becoming a major bottleneck in the field. The purpose of this…
▽ More
Surgical data science is a new research field that aims to observe all aspects of the patient treatment process in order to provide the right assistance at the right time. Due to the breakthrough successes of deep learning-based solutions for automatic image annotation, the availability of reference annotations for algorithm training is becoming a major bottleneck in the field. The purpose of this paper was to investigate the concept of self-supervised learning to address this issue.
Our approach is guided by the hypothesis that unlabeled video data can be used to learn a representation of the target domain that boosts the performance of state-of-the-art machine learning algorithms when used for pre-training. Core of the method is an auxiliary task based on raw endoscopic video data of the target domain that is used to initialize the convolutional neural network (CNN) for the target task. In this paper, we propose the re-colorization of medical images with a generative adversarial network (GAN)-based architecture as auxiliary task. A variant of the method involves a second pre-training step based on labeled data for the target task from a related domain. We validate both variants using medical instrument segmentation as target task.
The proposed approach can be used to radically reduce the manual annotation effort involved in training CNNs. Compared to the baseline approach of generating annotated data from scratch, our method decreases exploratively the number of labeled images by up to 75% without sacrificing performance. Our method also outperforms alternative methods for CNN pre-training, such as pre-training on publicly available non-medical or medical data using the target task (in this instance: segmentation).
As it makes efficient use of available (non-)public and (un-)labeled data, the approach has the potential to become a valuable tool for CNN (pre-)training.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2018; v1 submitted 27 November, 2017;
originally announced November 2017.
-
What does it all mean? Capturing Semantics of Surgical Data and Algorithms with Ontologies
Authors:
Darko Katić,
Maria Maleshkova,
Sandy Engelhardt,
Ivo Wolf,
Keno März,
Lena Maier-Hein,
Marco Nolden,
Martin Wagner,
Hannes Kenngott,
Beat Peter Müller-Stich,
Rüdiger Dillmann,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Every year approximately 234 million major surgeries are performed, leading to plentiful, highly diverse data. This is accompanied by a matching number of novel algorithms for the surgical domain. To garner all benefits of surgical data science it is necessary to have an unambiguous, shared understanding of algorithms and data. This includes inputs and outputs of algorithms and thus their function…
▽ More
Every year approximately 234 million major surgeries are performed, leading to plentiful, highly diverse data. This is accompanied by a matching number of novel algorithms for the surgical domain. To garner all benefits of surgical data science it is necessary to have an unambiguous, shared understanding of algorithms and data. This includes inputs and outputs of algorithms and thus their function, but also the semantic content, i.e. meaning of data such as patient parameters. We therefore propose the establishment of a new ontology for data and algorithms in surgical data science. Such an ontology can be used to provide common data sets for the community, encouraging sharing of knowledge and comparison of algorithms on common data. We hold that this is a necessary foundation towards new methods for applications such as semantic-based content retrieval and similarity measures and that it is overall vital for the future of surgical data science.
△ Less
Submitted 22 May, 2017;
originally announced May 2017.
-
Unsupervised temporal context learning using convolutional neural networks for laparoscopic workflow analysis
Authors:
Sebastian Bodenstedt,
Martin Wagner,
Darko Katić,
Patrick Mietkowski,
Benjamin Mayer,
Hannes Kenngott,
Beat Müller-Stich,
Rüdiger Dillmann,
Stefanie Speidel
Abstract:
Computer-assisted surgery (CAS) aims to provide the surgeon with the right type of assistance at the right moment. Such assistance systems are especially relevant in laparoscopic surgery, where CAS can alleviate some of the drawbacks that surgeons incur. For many assistance functions, e.g. displaying the location of a tumor at the appropriate time or suggesting what instruments to prepare next, an…
▽ More
Computer-assisted surgery (CAS) aims to provide the surgeon with the right type of assistance at the right moment. Such assistance systems are especially relevant in laparoscopic surgery, where CAS can alleviate some of the drawbacks that surgeons incur. For many assistance functions, e.g. displaying the location of a tumor at the appropriate time or suggesting what instruments to prepare next, analyzing the surgical workflow is a prerequisite. Since laparoscopic interventions are performed via endoscope, the video signal is an obvious sensor modality to rely on for workflow analysis.
Image-based workflow analysis tasks in laparoscopy, such as phase recognition, skill assessment, video indexing or automatic annotation, require a temporal distinction between video frames. Generally computer vision based methods that generalize from previously seen data are used. For training such methods, large amounts of annotated data are necessary. Annotating surgical data requires expert knowledge, therefore collecting a sufficient amount of data is difficult, time-consuming and not always feasible.
In this paper, we address this problem by presenting an unsupervised method for training a convolutional neural network (CNN) to differentiate between laparoscopic video frames on a temporal basis. We extract video frames at regular intervals from 324 unlabeled laparoscopic interventions, resulting in a dataset of approximately 2.2 million images. From this dataset, we extract image pairs from the same video and train a CNN to determine their temporal order. To solve this problem, the CNN has to extract features that are relevant for comprehending laparoscopic workflow.
Furthermore, we demonstrate that such a CNN can be adapted for surgical workflow segmentation. We performed image-based workflow segmentation on a publicly available dataset of 7 cholecystectomies and 9 colorectal interventions.
△ Less
Submitted 13 February, 2017;
originally announced February 2017.
-
Surgical Data Science: Enabling Next-Generation Surgery
Authors:
Lena Maier-Hein,
Swaroop Vedula,
Stefanie Speidel,
Nassir Navab,
Ron Kikinis,
Adrian Park,
Matthias Eisenmann,
Hubertus Feussner,
Germain Forestier,
Stamatia Giannarou,
Makoto Hashizume,
Darko Katic,
Hannes Kenngott,
Michael Kranzfelder,
Anand Malpani,
Keno März,
Thomas Neumuth,
Nicolas Padoy,
Carla Pugh,
Nicolai Schoch,
Danail Stoyanov,
Russell Taylor,
Martin Wagner,
Gregory D. Hager,
Pierre Jannin
Abstract:
This paper introduces Surgical Data Science as an emerging scientific discipline. Key perspectives are based on discussions during an intensive two-day international interactive workshop that brought together leading researchers working in the related field of computer and robot assisted interventions. Our consensus opinion is that increasing access to large amounts of complex data, at scale, thro…
▽ More
This paper introduces Surgical Data Science as an emerging scientific discipline. Key perspectives are based on discussions during an intensive two-day international interactive workshop that brought together leading researchers working in the related field of computer and robot assisted interventions. Our consensus opinion is that increasing access to large amounts of complex data, at scale, throughout the patient care process, complemented by advances in data science and machine learning techniques, has set the stage for a new generation of analytics that will support decision-making and quality improvement in interventional medicine. In this article, we provide a consensus definition for Surgical Data Science, identify associated challenges and opportunities and provide a roadmap for advancing the field.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2017; v1 submitted 23 January, 2017;
originally announced January 2017.