Worldwide, governments, the private sector, and non-government organizations face the challenge of balancing wetland conservation with promotion of wise use of resources and appropriate associated economic development. Similar challenges...
moreWorldwide, governments, the private sector, and non-government organizations face the challenge of balancing wetland conservation with promotion of wise use of resources and appropriate associated economic development. Similar challenges exist in Alberta. Over the span of a few decades the province has evolved from no wetland policy to a leader on no-net-loss policy and practice. However, as a revised policy is poised to be announced, Alberta may now become a province with potentially diminished wetland protection if replacement of lost wetlands is not considered. As growth continues in the province, Albertans are becoming increasingly concerned about environmental issues, as are those elsewhere in the world. At this juncture, Alberta has the unique opportunity to continue the leadership charge on wetland policy and practice, and can set the precedent for effective and balanced wetland conservation and management in Canada, and elsewhere.
Wetlands are Alberta’s keystone ecosystem and resource. Keystone ecosystems are those that are particularly important from the perspective of ecology or management, and whose influence and significance is greater than their geographic presence. In Alberta, wetlands are found in all biomes and are inextricably linked to the province’s aquatic and terrestrial ecosystems. Alberta’s wetlands provide a wide range of functions and values. This keystone ecosystem will become progressively more important with increased development and climate change. The state of Alberta’s wetlands is a bellwether for the condition of the province’s aquatic resources and, ultimately, the quality of life for Albertans.
In Alberta there are two primary wetland types in two geographic regions that require two different management strategies. Most of the province’s wetlands are peatlands (bogs, fens, conifer swamps) in the Peatland Zone. This region coincides with, but is larger than, the green area (78% vs. 61%). Here wetland loss is generally unknown but likely relatively smaller compared to the south. Current and planned developments, however, will likely lead to significant wetland losses here. The remaining wetlands in Alberta are mineral soil wetlands (marshes, shallow water wetlands, and shrub swamps) found primarily in the province’s Mineral Soil Wetland Zone. The zone is similar to, but smaller than, the white area (22% vs. 39%). Here wetland loss approaches 65% and it is critical to preserve what remains, restore what has been impacted, and construct new wetlands to add value.
The Peatland and Mineral Soil Wetland regions differ significantly by wetland type, area, land ownership, population, land use pressure, and authority to set regulations. Herein lays the opportunity for Alberta to lead the development of two novel policies and practices that will address the different requirements of both zones. Examples of wetland policy and practice exist in other provinces and countries that can be used as models. In Alberta, policy for wetlands in the Mineral Soil Wetland Zone, where the highest loss has occurred, would benefit from a no-net-loss and a mitigation sequence of 1) avoid impacts, 2) mitigate or minimize impacts, and 3) compensate for irreducible impacts. The established 3:1 compensation ratio with a sliding scale for distance from original wetland is a useful replacement for lost wetland function and value until a standardized wetland evaluation system can be developed for this zone. Application of the mitigation sequence concept in Alberta has recently been identified as disfavouring avoidance of wetlands with resulting wetland loss. However, with some adjustment, no-net-loss and wetland compensation can remain proven concepts that enhance wetland conservation in Alberta.
Mineral Soil Wetland Zone policy is the low-hanging fruit in Alberta. Policy development in the Peatland Zone is more challenging and will require extensive consultation, resources, funding, and research. Here, time is of the essence. Nothing less should be acceptable given that the province’s most ambitious development plans are in the region with the most wetlands. In the interim, priority should be given to conserving wetlands in the region until the creative solutions can be explored and a Peatland Zone policy developed.
Both wetland policies would be enhanced with support from the following programs and products: a validation program for qualified wetland workers and agencies; a provincial wetland inventory; a made-in-Alberta wetland classification, and; individual evaluation systems for the Peatland and Mineral Soil Wetland Zones using holistic broad-based indicators including hydrological, biological, social, rarity, and other aspects. Care must be taken when determining function and placing values on wetlands. Wetland rarity is independent of function and value as much as function is independent of value. Rarity or importance must not be used at the cost of the lost function and value in ‘common’ wetland types that are deemed nonessential. There is an important temporal aspect of value. Value judgements made on wetlands today may not reflect future values, the same way that past value judgements have not served us in the present. Wetlands must remain a legacy.
The province, industry, and academic institutions can support a research centre of excellence for applied wetland science in western Canada. Scientists have been conducting wetland research in Alberta for over 30 years. The research continues to grow and there is excellent expertise and top-rate research facilities. Through consolidation of expertise and resources, Alberta can become an international exporter of wetland knowledge, technology, and innovation. Current climate change models are forecasting an overall movement of development northwards into peatland-rich areas of Canada and Alberta is uniquely placed to develop progressive techniques for wetland construction, restoration, and mitigation.
Wetlands in Alberta are at a crossroads. They are the province’s keystone resource. The challenge is to balance conservation of our wetland legacy with wise use of resources and appropriate economic development. Alberta now has the opportunity to be among those jurisdictions that play a key leadership role in the development of novel and effective wetland policy, practice, research, and technology.