Plant Syst Evol (2018) 304:57–69
https://doi.org/10.1007/s00606-017-1448-1
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Long neglected diversity in the Accursed Mountains
of northern Albania: Cerastium hekuravense is genetically
and morphologically divergent from C. dinaricum
Danka Caković1 · Danijela Stešević1 · Peter Schönswetter2 · Božo Frajman2
Received: 25 April 2017 / Accepted: 17 July 2017 / Published online: 30 August 2017
© The Author(s) 2017. This article is an open access publication
Abstract The Balkan Peninsula is a hotspot of European
biotic diversity. One of its biogeographically most peculiar
but poorly explored regions are the Albanian Alps (Alpet
Shqiptare/Prokletije/Accursed Mountains) on the border
between Albania, Kosovo and Montenegro, characterised
by a high number of endemic species. A poorly known taxon
from the Albanian Alps is Cerastium hekuravense, which
was described from Mt. Maja Hekurave (Albania) in 1921,
but later usually merged with C. dinaricum, a widespread
endemic of the Dinaric Mountains, or connected with the
arctic–alpine C. alpinum. Here, we used amplified fragment
length polymorphisms to explore the phylogenetic position of C. hekuravense and particularly its relationship to
C. dinaricum. Our data show that both species are genetically well differentiated, but their relation to other taxa
remains unclear—they are either closely related to Alpine
species of C. ser. Latifolia or to species co-occurring on the
Balkan Peninsula, such as C. banaticum and C. decalvans.
In addition, multivariate morphometric analyses show that
C. dinaricum and C. hekuravense are morphologically well
differentiated. Also their relative genome sizes, estimated
Handling editor: Christoph Oberprieler.
Electronic supplementary material The online version
of this article (doi:10.1007/s00606-017-1448-1) contains
supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
* Božo Frajman
bozo.frajman@uibk.ac.at
1
Department of Biology, Faculty of Natural Sciences
and Mathematics, University of Montenegro, G. Washington
Street, 81 000 Podgorica, Montenegro
2
Institute of Botany, University of Innsbruck,
Sternwartestrasse 15, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria
using flow cytometry, differ. We propose a taxonomic treatment with lectotype designation for both taxa and provide
descriptions and an identification key. Last but not least,
these cold-adapted species mostly growing on northerly
exposed humid screes are highly threatened due to the
global warming and should be ranked endangered according to IUCN criteria. Cerastium hekuravense known only
from three localities is likely one of the most endangered
mountain plant species of the Balkan Peninsula.
Keywords AFLP · Albanian Alps · Balkan Peninsula ·
Endemism · Genome size · IUCN · Taxonomy
Introduction
The Balkan Peninsula is a centre of plant species diversity
and endemism; it is the floristically richest area in Europe
harbouring about 6500 species, of which more than onethird (c. 2600–2700) are endemic and about 400 are considered to be local endemics (Horvat et al. 1974; Kryštufek
and Reed 2004; Stevanović et al. 2007). These numbers are
likely an underestimate, as only for Greece, including Crete
and the islands, 5752 species, of which 1278 are endemic to
this country, have been reported (Dimopoulos et al. 2013).
In the western Balkan Peninsula, especially the high mountain system of the Dinarides (Dinaric Mountains) is highly
diverse (Horvat et al. 1974; Redžić 2011). It spans from Slovenia in the North to northern Albania in the South, where
the highest peak, Maja Jezercë (2694 m), is situated. This
southernmost part of the Dinarides, which is known as Albanian Alps (Alpet Shqiptare/Bjeshkët e Namuna in Albanian)
or Accursed Mountains (Prokletije in the southern Slavic
languages), includes ca. 40 peaks over 2000 m and 17 peaks
over 2500 m (Rakaj 2009).
13
Vol.:(0123456789)
58
Roughly 20 plant species are endemic to the Albanian
Alps in its broader definition, i.e. including Komovi and
Visitor (Rakaj 2009 and references below). Several of
them bear the specific epithet “bertisceus” (derived from
the Ptolemean “Mons Bertiscus” for the Albanian Alps),
pointing to their origin, e.g. Crepis bertiscea Jáv., Draba
bertiscea D.Lakušić & Stevan., Onobrychis bertiscea
Širj. & Rech.f. and Valeriana bertiscea Pančić. In the last
decade, two new species endemic to this mountain range
have been described, i.e. Androsace komovensis Schönsw.
& Schneew. (Schönswetter and Schneeweiss 2009; Frajman et al. 2014) and Heliosperma oliverae Niketić & Stevan. (Niketić and Stevanović 2007). In addition, several
endemics, including Edraianthus pilosulus (Beck) Surina
& Lakušić (Surina et al. 2009), Heliosperma macranthum Pančić (Frajman and Oxelman 2007; Frajman et al.
2009; see also Frajman et al. 2014) and Wulfenia baldaccii
Degen (Surina et al. 2014) have been analysed phylogenetically, confirming their independent status. In contrast,
Campanula latifolioides F.K.Mey., recently described by
Meyer (2011), is likely a synonym of Asyneuma pichleri
(Vis.) Lakušić & Conti (Pils 2016).
One of the poorly know taxa from the Albanian Alps is
Cerastium hekuravense Jáv., which was described by Jávorka
(1921) based on a specimen collected on Mt. Maja Hekurave in Albania. Despite the fact that Jávorka compared
this species with representatives of C. ser. Latifolia Borza
(C. carinthiacum Vest, C. subtriflorum Dalla Torre &
Sarnth., C. latifolium L.), it was later commonly included in
C. alpinum L. (Jalas 1964; Jalas and Suominen 1983; Jalas
1993; Euro + Med 2006). However, Merxmüller and Strid
(1977) suggested that the species does not belong to the
C. alpinum group and Niketić (1999) proposed that the glandular indumentum of the leaves is the only difference from
C. dinaricum Beck & Szyszył., an endemic species of the
Dinaric Mountains included in C. ser. Latifolia. Moreover,
the C. alpinum group only includes high polyploid species,
from octo- to dodecaploids, whereas the species of C. ser.
Latifolia, including C. dinaricum, are tetraploids (Brysting et al. 2011; Niketić et al. 2013). Niketić (1999) treated
C. hekuravense as C. dinaricum var. hekuravense (Jáv.)
Niketić and later (Niketić 2007) as C. dinaricum f. hekuravense (Jáv.) Niketić, which he suggested to occur scattered
throughout the distribution range of C. dinaricum. However,
a detailed study of C. dinaricum showed no phylogenetic differentiation between glandular and glabrous plants (Kutnjak
et al. 2014). Yet, Kutnjak et al. (2014) did neither include
the population from the locus classicus of C. hekuravense,
Maja Hekurave, nor the only known Albanian population of
C. dinaricum from Maja Kakisë east of Abat (Hayek 1924).
For the sake of simplicity, we refer to the two focal taxa on
the species level and their entirety is denoted as C. dinaricum s.l.
13
D. Caković et al.
Here, we used amplified fragment length polymorphisms
(AFLPs), relative genome size (RGS) measurements and
morphometric analyses to elucidate the relationship between
C. hekuravense from the Albanian Alps and the more widespread C. dinaricum. Specifically, we address the following
questions: (1) Is C. hekuravense from the locus classicus
(type locality) genetically differentiated from C. dinaricum?
(2) If so, do the other known and recently discovered populations from the Albanian Alps cluster with C. dinaricum
or with C. hekuravense? (3) Do eventually detected genetic
groups differ in RGS and are they also morphologically differentiated? (4) Based on our results, we provide a taxonomic treatment of both taxa and evaluate their conservation
status following the IUCN criteria.
Materials and methods
Plant material
Molecular analyses are based on silica gel-dried leaf material. We included four populations of Cerastium dinaricum
previously analysed by Kutnjak et al. (2014), including the
population from the type locality, and additionally sampled four populations from Albania tentatively ascribed to
C. dinaricum s.l., including the population from the type
locality of C. hekuravense (Table 1, Fig. 1). Additionally,
we included all other species (Online Resource 1) classified
within the C. latifolium aggregate (Niketić 2007)—C. carinthiacum (two populations), C. latifolium (two populations)
and C. uniflorum Clairv. (one population), as well as the
species distributed on the Balkan Peninsula, which include
tetraploid populations (Niketić et al. 2013), i.e. C. banaticum
(Rochel) Steud. (six populations), C. decalvans Schloss. &
Vuk. (three populations), C. eriophorum Kit. (four populations) and C. grandiflorum Waldst. & Kit. (two populations), to infer the phylogenetic position of C. dinaricum and
C. hekuravense.
AFLP analyses
Extraction of total genomic DNA was performed following
the modified CTAB-protocol of Tel-Zur et al. (1999). AFLP
fingerprinting was conducted as described by Kutnjak et al.
(2014). Two blanks (DNA replaced by water) were included
to test for contamination, and four samples were used as
replicates between the two PCR batches to test the reproducibility. Numbers of sampled individuals per population are
provided in Table 1.
Electropherograms were analysed with Peak Scanner version 1.0 (Applied Biosystems) using default peak
detection parameters except employing light peak smoothing. The minimum fluorescent threshold was set to 100
59
Cerastium hekuravense is divergent from C. dinaricum
Table 1 Studied populations of Cerastium dinaricum and C. hekuravense
ID Lab ID Taxon
1
C101
2
C018
3
C020
4
C022
5
C466
6
C499
7
C024
8
C477
Sampling locality
HR: Velebit, Mt.
Vaganski vrh
C. dinaricum
BH: Prenj, Vjetrana
brda ridge
C. dinaricum
ME: Durmitor, valley
of Škrčko jezero
C. dinaricum
ME: Komovi, summit
of Mt. Kom Kučki
C. dinaricum
AL: Alpet Shqiptare/
Prokletije, summit
of Maja Jezercë
C. hekuravense AL: Alpet Shqiptare/
Prokletije, Buni
Jezercë
C. hekuravense AL: Alpet Shqiptare/
Prokletije, Maja
Hekurave
C. hekuravense AL: Alpet Shqiptare/
Prokletije, Maja
Kakisë
C. dinaricum
Altitude Longitude (E)/Lati(m a.s.l.) tude (N)
1690
Collectors (col- Voucher
lection number)
NAFLP
ZA-H3
010-Cdin
17.881667/43.54861 PS, BF and DK IB
4
12864
19.03/43.12833
PS, BF and DK IB
5
12909
19.6425/42.678611 PS, BF and DK IB
3
12931
19.811/42.443056
PS, BF and MF IB
5
13780
0.306 (± 0.002)
1850
19.81167/42.45944
DC and DS
14399
IB
7
0.371 (± 0.004)
2019
19.94694/42.3944
PS, BF and DK IB
13000
4
0.374 (± 0.003)
1935
19.82388/42.35944
PS and BF
14009
5
0.361 (± 0.003)
1864
1883
2394
2638
15.50419/44.365471 SB and IR
RGS
IB
0.320 (± 0.005)
0.323 (± 0.004)
0.323 (± 0.003)
0.318 (± 0.002)
ID population identifier used throughout the paper. AL Albania, BH Bosnia and Hercegovina, HR Croatia, ME Montenegro. NAFLP number of
individuals investigated with amplified fragment length polymorphism. RGS relative genome size (mean ± standard deviation). Collectors: BF
B. Frajman, DC D. Caković, DK D. Kutnjak, DS D. Stešević, IR I. Rešetnik, MF M. Falch, PS P. Schönswetter, SB S. Bogdanović
C. dinaricum
C. hekuravense
© Google 2016
Fig. 1 Sampled populations of Cerastium dinaricum and C. hekuravense. Population numbers correspond to Table 1. Smaller symbols
indicate non-sampled localities of C. dinaricum, where the species
certainly occurs (see Kutnjak et al. 2014). The inset in the upper right
corner shows the position of the sampling area in Europe; the rectangle in the main part of the figure indicates the position of the Albanian Alps magnified in the inset in the lower left corner
13
60
relative fluorescence units. Automated binning and scoring of the AFLP fragments were performed using RawGeno 2.0-1 (Arrigo et al. 2009) for R 2.15.2 (R Development Core Team 2012) with the following settings: scoring
range = 150–500 bp, minimum intensity = 100 relative
fluorescence units (rfu), minimum bin width = 1 bp and
maximum bin width = 1.5 bp. Fragments with a reproducibility lower than 85% based on sample–replicate comparisons were eliminated. Fragments present/absent in only one
individual were excluded.
A Neighbour-joining (NJ) analysis based on Nei–Li
genetic distances (Nei and Li 1979) was conducted and bootstrapped (2000 pseudo-replicates) with TREECON v.1.3b
(van de Peer and De Wachter 1997). The tree was rooted
with C. grandiflorum based on an ITS phylogeny (Frajman
B., unpublished). Due to the simple structure in the data, no
further analyses were conducted.
Genome size measurements
Flow cytometry (FCM) of 40,6-diamidino-2-phenylindole
(DAPI)-stained nuclei was used to estimate relative genome
size (RGS) of four newly sampled populations (all populations from Albania) as described by Kutnjak et al. (2014).
The RGS was estimated for three to ten individuals per
population.
Absolute genome size (AGS) was determined using FCM
of propidium iodide (PI)-stained nuclei of two samples of
C. dinaricum and one sample of C. hekuravense (Table 1)
as described by Frajman et al. (2015), with the exception
that Pisum sativum cv. Kleine Rheinländerin (2C = 8.84 pg;
Greilhuber and Ebert 1994) was used as reference standard.
Morphometric analyses
Material for morphometric analyses included vouchers of
all molecularly investigated populations of C. dinaricum
s.l. (Table 1), supplemented with herbarium vouchers
stored in the herbarium of the University of Innsbruck,
IB (Frajman and Schönswetter 14631, 14632, 14633),
totalling 54 individuals. Forty characters were measured
or counted and 15 ratios were calculated (Table 2). Leaf
characters were measured on the uppermost and one welldeveloped mid-stem leaf; the apex angle was measured
only on the mid-stem leaf. Trichome characters were
measured on the upper surface and the margin of a midstem leaf, as well as on the internode below the investigated leaf. Certain characters were missing in a few individuals, e.g. petals or fully developed fruits, and were thus
replaced with mean values calculated for the other studied
populations of the same species. Petal, sepal, bract, leaf
and fruit characters were measured on images taken with a
camera mounted on a Zeiss SteREO Discovery. V12 stereo
13
D. Caković et al.
microscope at 8 × magnification. Characters of trichomes
were measured on magnified images taken with an Olympus UC 30 wide zoom camera mounted on an Olympus
SZX9 stereo microscope with 20 × magnification.
We tested correlation among metric characters employing Pearson or Spearman correlation coefficients dependent on character distribution. After standardization to zero
mean and one unit variance, principal component analysis (PCA) was performed. As Tukey HSD Post hoc test
showed no discriminatory power (p values between 0.33
and 0.98) for twelve characters (1, 2, 11, 12, 18, 19, 24,
30, 48, 49, 53 and 55) and three ratios (33, 36 and 39)
we excluded them from the canonical discriminant analysis (CDA), which was applied to inspect the separation
between C. dinaricum and C. hekuravense and the relative
importance of characters as discriminators between them.
Statistical analyses were performed using the package Statistica 5.1 (StatSoft 1996). Values presented in the species
descriptions and in the identification key correspond to the
10 and 90% quantiles, supplemented by extreme values in
parentheses.
Results
AFLP analyses
We scored 335 AFLP fragments for 96 individuals; 42
bands found in only one individual were excluded. For the
36 individuals of Cerastium dinaricum s.l. we scored 196
fragments, of which 43 found in only one individual were
excluded from further analyses.
The neighbour-joining tree of AFLP profiles (Fig. 2)
resulted in a strongly supported cluster (bootstrap support,
BS 100) containing all species except C. grandiflorum,
which was used for rooting. Within this cluster, three moderately to well-supported groups were resolved; the relationships among them were unresolved. One group included
all accessions of C. dinaricum s.l. with strong support (BS
87), falling in two strongly supported clusters (both with
BS 100). One of them contained accessions of C. dinaricum studied by Kutnjak et al. (2014) including the population from the locus classicus, as well as one newly sampled
population from the summit of Maja Jezercë in Albania. The
other cluster contained the population from Maja Hekurave,
locus classicus of C. hekuravense, as well as the populations from Buni Jezercë and Maja Kakisë. The two remaining major groups contained species of C. ser. Latifolia from
the Alps (C. carinthiacum, C. latifolium, C. uniflorum; BS
91) and Balkan accessions (BS 67) of species belonging
to C. ser. Alpina (C. decalvans and C. eriophorum) and to
C. ser. Cerastium (C. banaticum).
Cerastium hekuravense is divergent from C. dinaricum
61
Table 2 Morphological characters studied
Char. No
Character
Abbreviations
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
Petal length, mm
Petal width, mm
Ratio of petal length and petal width
Distance from petal basis to incision, mm
Ratio of distance from petal basis to incision and petal length
Sepal length, mm
Sepal width, mm
Ratio of sepal length and width
Distance from basis to widest part of sepal, mm
Ratio of distance from basis to widest part of sepal and sepal length
Width of hyaline margin of sepal, mm
Bract length, mm
Bract width, mm
Ratio of bract length and width
Distance from basis to widest part of bract, mm
Ratio of distance from basis to widest part of bract and bract length
Width of the hyaline margin of bracts, mm
Length of uppermost leaves, mm
Width of uppermost leaves, mm
Ratio of length and width of uppermost leaves
Distance from basis to widest part of uppermost leaves, mm
Ratio of distance from basis to widest part of uppermost leaves and their length
Length of mid-stem leaves, mm
Width of mid-stem leaves, mm
Ratio of length and width of mid-stem leaves
Distance from basis to widest part of mid-stem leaves, mm
Ratio of distance from basis to widest part of mid-stem leaves and their length
Angle of the apex of mid-stem leaves, degree
Capsule length, mm
Capsule width, mm
Ratio of capsule length and width
Distance from basis to widest part of capsule, mm
Ratio of distance from basis to widest part of the capsule and capsule length
Capsule teeth length, mm
Capsule teeth width, mm
Ratio of length and width of capsule teeth
Seed length, mm
Seed width, mm
Ratio of seed length and width
Stem length, mm
Number of internodes
Ratio of stem length and number of internodes
Length of internode adjacent to mid-stem leaf pair, mm
Number of flowers per stem
Length of peduncle of terminal flower, mm
Length of inflorescence (from the terminal flower to the top), mm
Number of internodes in the longest inflorescence branch
Number of glandular hairs per mm2 on the upper epidermis of mid-stem leaves, calculated as the average of
two squares with 1 mm2 each
PL
PW
PL/PW
LPBI
LPBI/PL
CLL
CLW
CLL/CLW
CLLMW
CLLMW/CLL
CLHM
BL
BW
BL/BW
BLLMW
BLLMW/BLL
BHM
ULL
ULW
ULL/ULW
ULLMW
ULLMW/ULL
MLL
MLW
MLL/MLW
MLLMW
MLLMW/MLL
ASL
CL
CW
CL/CW
CLMW
CLMW/CL
CTL
CTW
CTL/CTW
SL
SW
SL/SW
SH
IN
SH/IN
IL
FN
PTFL
IFL
IFLIN
GHLS
13
62
D. Caković et al.
Table 2 (continued)
Char. No
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
Character
Abbreviations
2
Number of eglandular hairs per mm on the upper epidermis of mid-stem leaves, calculated as the average of
two squares with 1 mm2 each
Number of glandular hairs on the margin of mid-stem leaves along 1 mm just below the tip of the leaf
Number of eglandular hairs on the margin of mid-stem leaves along 1 mm just below the tip of the leaf
Length of the longest trichome on the margin of mid-stem leaves along 1 mm just below the tip of the leaf
Number of glandular hairs on the stem along 1 mm just below a mid-stem leaf pair
Number of eglandular hairs on the stem along 1 mm just below a mid-stem leaf pair
Length of the longest trichome on the stem along 1 mm just below a mid-stem leaf pair
Genome size of Cerastium dinaricum and C.
hekuravense
Average RGS of C. hekuravense ranged from 0.361 in population 8 to 0.374 in population 7 and was distinctly different from the mean RGS of C. dinaricum, which ranged
from 0.301 to 0.327 (Kutnjak et al. 2014); the average
RGS of the population 5 from Maja Jezercë was 0.318
and thus within this range (Table 1, Fig. 3). The AGS of
C. dinaricum ranged from 2.5674 pg (population 4 from
the locus classicus) to 2.5713 pg (population 2), whereas
the AGS of C. hekuravense (population 7 from the locus
classicus) was 3.0311 pg.
Morphological differentiation between Cerastium
dinaricum and C. hekuravense
The measured and counted values for the characters,
as well as the calculated ratios, are presented in Online
Resource 2. As the correlation coefficients did not exceed
0.9 for any character pair, we included all characters listed
in Table 2 in further analyses.
The PCA (first three axes explaining 15.78, 10.98 and
8.06% of the total variation; Fig. 4a) showed a clear separation between C. dinaricum and C. hekuravense along the first
two axes. The characters contributing most to the separation along the first axis, i.e. those having highest component
scores in the coefficient matrix, describe habit (SH, SH/IN,
IL), shape of the sepals (CLL/CLW), as well as shape of the
middle leaves and bracts (MLL/MLW, BL/BW). Leaf, bract
and trichome characters (ULLMW, MLLMW, MLLMW/
MLL, BLMW, BLMW/BL, GHLM, EHLM) contributed
most to the separation along the second axis. The CDA
(Fig. 4b) showed a clear differentiation between the two
species with the strongest contribution of the sepal characters (CLL/CLW, CLLMW, CLW, CLLMW/CL). Still, even
for characters with high discriminatory power (Tukey HSD
post hoc test, P < 0.001) boxplots (Fig. 5) show overlap in
character states between both taxa.
13
EHLS
GHLM
EHLM
TLM
GHS
EHS
TLS
Discussion
Cerastium hekuravense is a distinct species, which is
genetically and morphologically clearly differentiated
from C. dinaricum (Figs. 2, 4, 6, 7). The two species also
have different genome sizes (Fig. 3) and even where they
occur in relatively close vicinity, such as on the summit
of Maja Jezercë (C. dinaricum) and close to Buni Jezercë
(C. hekuravense) no traces of gene flow have been detected
in the AFLP data. Despite the fact that Niketić (1999, 2007)
treated C. hekuravense as a variety or even as a form of
C. dinaricum, which he suggested to be scattered throughout the distribution range of the latter, our data clearly
show that C. hekuravense is endemic to the Albanian Alps,
thus additionally underlining the importance of this mountain range as an endemic-rich area (Rakaj 2009; see also
Introduction).
In spite of the peculiarity of its rich flora, Albania is one
of the botanically least explored regions of Europe (Markgraf 1932; Frajman et al. 2014). After the last editions of
the national flora (Paparisto et al. 1988; Qosja et al. 1992,
1996; Vangjeli et al. 2000) including 3758 taxa (3250 species) of vascular plants, a multitude of species new for Albania have been published (e.g. Barina and Pifkó 2008; Rakaj
2009; Ball 2011; Meyer 2011; Barina et al. 2013; Frajman
et al. 2014). Even if C. hekuravense was described from the
territory of Albania (Jávorka 1921), it was neglected in all
recent Albanian floras, where only C. dinaricum was listed
(Demiri 1983; Paparisto et al. 1988; Vangjeli 2003). In addition to clarifying the status of the known populations from
Maja Hekurave and Maja Kakisë (the latter was published
as C. dinaricum by Hayek 1924), we discovered an additional population of C. hekuravense close to Buni Jezercë
(an indication of its occurrence there was kindly provided
by M. Niketić; 10.10.2013, personal comm. with B. Frajman) as well as the only known population of C. dinaricum
in Albania, on the western summit crest of Maja Jezercë.
Spatially explicit modelling of viable habitat for C. dinaricum suggested a decrease of about 37% by the year 2050
and 70% by the year 2080 due to global warming, and the
Cerastium hekuravense is divergent from C. dinaricum
63
Fig. 2 Neighbour-joining tree derived from AFLP data. Population identifiers correspond to Table 1, Fig. 1 and Online Resource 1
13
64
D. Caković et al.
Rela e Genome size
0.38
0.36
0.34
0.32
0.30
C. dinaricum
1
5
2
C. hekuravense
3
4
8
6
7
Popula
Fig. 3 Relative genome size of Cerastium dinaricum and C. hekuravense as in Table 1. Population numbers correspond to Table 1 and
Fig. 1. Circles represent mean values and whiskers the standard deviation
predicted habitat loss could result in range-wide extinction
of the species in the very near future (Kutnjak et al. 2014).
Thus, following the criterion B2 of the IUCN (2012) for
endangered species, the following applies for C. dinaricum:
(a) area of occupancy is estimated to be less than 500 km2,
(b) area of occupancy is severely fragmented and (c) continuing decline in the area, extent and/or quality of habitat has
been inferred/projected. Therefore, we deem C. dinaricum
endangered (EN) according to IUCN (2012).
The situation is similar, but likely more severe for C. hekuravense, which has a much narrower distribution and is
currently known from only three localities, where it inhabits
northerly exposed humid screes with extended snow cover.
The ecology of C. hekuravense is thus similar to that of
C. dinaricum, which, however, thrives also in rock crevices
in the summit areas of some mountains (e.g. Kom Kučki in
Montenegro and Maja Jezercë in Albania) and thus has a
broader ecological niche. Field observations further suggest
that C. hekuravense prefers more humid and colder screes
than C. dinaricum (P. Schönswetter and B. Frajman, personal observations). In all three localities the species was
rare, the smallest population being that on Maja Kakisë,
where only a few dozen individuals were found. Although
we do not have climatic niche modelling data for C. hekuravense at hand, extrapolation of the results obtained for
C. dinaricum suggests that the species should be treated at
least as endangered (EN).
The AFLP data are inconclusive regarding the relationships of C. dinaricum and C. hekuravense with other
tetraploid Cerastium species from the Alps and the Balkans (Niketić et al. 2013). It is clear that they do not
belong to the C. latifolium aggregate, in which they were
included in the past (Jávorka 1921; Niketić 2007). The
C. latifolium aggregate thus likely includes only the Alpine
broad-leaved species C. carinthiacum, C. latifolium and
C. uniflorum, which form a separate lineage closely related
to C. dinaricum and C. hekuravense. Another group of
species closely related to our study taxa are C. banaticum,
C. decalvans and C. eriophorum. They are mostly
a
b
30
2
20
Frequency
PCA2 (10.98 %)
1
0
10
-1
-2
0
-2
-1
0
PCA1 (15.78 %)
1
2
-10
-6
-2
2
6
Scores of the discriminant functions
Fig. 4 Morphological differentiation between Cerastium dinaricum (black) and C. hekuravense (grey). a, principal component analysis (PCA)
based on 55 morphological characters, b histogram of canonical discriminant analysis (CDA) based on 40 morphological characters
13
65
Cerastium hekuravense is divergent from C. dinaricum
Fig. 5 Boxplot diagrams of morphological characters discriminating between Cerastium dinaricum and C. hekuravense. Boxes define 25 and 75
percentiles; squares indicate medians; whiskers span the 5–95 percentiles and circles indicate outliers. Characters are explained in Table 2
distributed on the Balkan Peninsula and are all characterised by a more or less persistent indumentum. Even
if they were classified in two different series by Niketić
(2007)—C. banaticum in C. ser. Cerastium, C. decalvans
and C. eriophorum in C. ser. Alpina—they together form a
separate lineage, albeit with only moderate bootstrap support 67% (Fig. 2). Previous phylogenetic studies (Scheen
et al. 2004; Brysting et al. 2007, 2011) mostly concentrated on the arctic-alpine members of Cerastium with
focus on the origin of high polyploid species; several Balkan taxa, including C. dinaricum and C. hekuravense, were
not sampled. Further phylogenetic studies using nuclear
and plastid DNA sequences and broader taxon sampling
are thus needed to finally clarify the phylogenetic position of C. dinaricum and C. hekuravense and to propose a
revised infrageneric classification.
Taxonomic treatment
Cerastium dinaricum G.Beck & Szysz., Rozpr. Akad.
Um. (Mat.-Przyr.) 19: 62. 1889.—TYPE: “Kom Kucki”, I.
Szyszyłowicz, Iter Montenegrinum 1886 (lectotype designated here: PRC 452158!).
= Cerastium dinaricum f. velebiticum Degen & Lengyel,
Magyar Bot. Lapok 6: 126. 1907. ≡ Cerastium dinaricum var.
velebiticum (Degen & Lengyel) Graebner & Corr. in Aschers.
& Graebner, Syn. Mitteleur. Fl. 5(1): 628. 1918.—TYPE:
“Croatia. Velebit. In lapidosis alpinis montis Malovan supra
Raduč, 1500–1700”, 5 Aug 1906, A. de Degen, plantae Hungariae exsiccatae (lectotype designated here: JE 00007505!).
Description: Densely caespitose perennial, with ascending stems (4)7–20(29) mm long and having (4)5–8(11)
13
66
D. Caković et al.
Fig. 6 Cerastium dinaricum (above) and C. hekuravense (below) and their habitats. Photos by B. Frajman and P. Schönswetter
internodes. Leaves sessile, ovate, (9.0)12.5–17.8(20.0) mm
long and (2.1)2.6–5.6(7.2) mm wide, (2.3)2.8–5.2(6.1) times
longer than wide, widest at (0.1)0.3–0.5(0.6) of the length,
apex (17.2)26.4–69.6(91.0)°, upper surface of the leaves
glabrous or with indumentum of 2–11(14) glandular and
1–9(10) eglandular hairs per mm2. Bracts (2.2)2.4–5.3(7.8)
× (0.4)0.7–1.9(3.0) mm, (1.6)2.3–4.3(5.9) times longer than
wide. Flowers (1)2–5(7) per stem. Sepals (2.8)5.0–6.9(7.2)
mm long and (1.6)1.7–2.7(3.2) mm wide, (1.3)2.0–3.6(3.8)
times longer than wide, widest at (0.2)0.3–0.6(0.9) of
13
the length. Petals (6.3)7.0–10.3(10.8) mm long and
(2.7)3.8–6.3(7.0) mm wide, (1.3)1.4–2.2(2.6) times
longer than wide, incision (1.6)2.–3.7(3.9) mm deep,
(0.2)0.3–0.4(0.5) of the total petal length. Capsules (7.1)
8.8–11.7(12.6) × (2.1)2.9–4.8(5.5) mm, (1.7)2.0–3.4(3.9)
times longer than wide, widest at (0.2)0.3–0.5(0.6) of the
length, (1.1)1.4–2.1(3.5) times longer than the sepals. Seeds
(0.1)1.4–1.9(2.0) mm long and (0.5)1.1–1.6(1.8) mm wide,
(0.2)1.0–1.5(1.6) times longer than wide. 2n = 36 + 1
(Niketić et al. 2013).
67
Cerastium hekuravense is divergent from C. dinaricum
c
a
1 mm
1 mm
b
e
f
d
5 mm
g
1 mm
5 mm
h
5 mm
1 mm
5 mm
Fig. 7 Iconography of Cerastium hekuravense (a–d) and C. dinaricum (e–h). a, e whole plant; b, h stem leaf; d, g sepal with indicated hyaline
margin; c, f petal; in g and h the leaf and sepal are divided to indicate that the plant can be glabrous or pubescent. Drawings by M. Magauer
Distribution: Disjunct distribution in the Dinaric Mountains
from Mt. Snežnik in Slovenia over Velebit and Dinara in
Croatia, Prenj and Volujak in Bosnia and Hercegovina, Durmitor, Komovi and Žijevo in Montenegro to Maja Jezercë
in Albania.
Habitat: Usually northerly exposed humid screes and rock
crevices mostly in summit areas; the habitat in Slovenia,
where it grows on the bottom of a karstic doline with temperature and vegetation inversion, is an exception.
Conservation status: Endangered (EN).
Note: In the protologue also a collection from Malovan (Velebit) is given, but the specimen has not been seen.
Cerastium hekuravense Jáv., Bot. Közl. 19: 18. 1921. ≡
Cerastium dinaricum var. hekuravense, (Jáv.) Niketić, Glasn.
Prir. muz., Ser. B 49–50: 48. 1999. ≡ Cerastium dinaricum
f. hekuravense (Jáv.) Niketić, Endem. predst. roda Cerastium JI Evr.: 52. 2007.—TYPE: “Montes Albaniae borealis
versus opp. Djakova extensi: Montes Hekurave. In glareosis
calc. sub rupe Maja Drošks supra pag. Dragobija—alt. ca.
1700 m., ad nivem perpetuam”, 30 Aug 1918, S. Jávorka,
(lectotype designated here: PRM 357775!).
Description: Laxly caespitose perennial, with decumbent stems (10)17–27(30) mm long and having (6)6–8(8)
internodes. Leaves sessile, ovate, (8.8)10.1–15.6(17)
long and (2.4)2.7–5.9(7.0) mm wide, (1.7)2.0–4.0(5.6)
times longer than wide, widest at (0.1)0.2–0.4(0.6) of
the length, apex (23.3)30.4–89.5(97.1)°, upper surface of the leaves glabrous or with indumentum of
1–4 glandular and 1–9(10) eglandular hairs per mm 2 .
Bracts (2.4)2.5–5.6(6.4) × (1.2)1.3–2.4 (2.9) mm,
(1.7)1.8–2.7(3.0) times longer than wide. Flowers
2–5(7) per stem. Sepals (5.3)5.4–7.9(8.0) mm long
and (2.0)2.2–3.1(3.6) mm wide, (2.0)2.1–2.9(3.2)
times longer than wide, widest at (0.2)0.3–0.5(0.6) of
the length. Petals (6.2)8.0–10.4(11.4) mm long and
(3.0)3.5–6.0(6.8) mm wide, (1.3)1.4–2.4(2.7) times
longer than wide, incision (0.8)1.4–3.1(3.6) mm
deep, (0.1)0.1–0.3(0.4) of the total petal length. Capsules (5.3)6.1–11.4(12.1) × (3.1)3.7–4.4 (5.0) mm,
(1.4)1.5–2.7(3.2) times longer than wide, widest at
(1.8)1.9–4.0(5.4) mm distance from the basis, widest at
(0.2)0.3–0.5(0.6) of the length, (0.8)0.9–1.8(1.9) times
longer than the sepals. Seeds (0.4)0.8–1.6(2.2) mm
long and (0.3)0.6–1.3(1.8) mm wide, 1.1–1.4(1.5) times
13
68
D. Caković et al.
longer than wide. Chromosome number unknown, but
based on the relative genome size 2n = 36 is expected.
University of Innsbruck for successfully cultivating our living collection of Cerastium. We thank two anonymous reviewers for valuable
comments and suggestions.
Distribution: Endemic to the Albanian Alps (Alpet Shqiptare), where it is only known from three localities—Buni
Jezercë, Maja Hekurave and Maja Kakisë.
Compliance with ethical standards
Habitat: Northerly exposed humid screes with extended
snow cover.
Conservation status: Endangered (EN).
Key to the species of Cerastium dinaricum s.l
Even if there is a strong overlap in character states between
both species, it is possible to discriminate between them
using a combination of characters given in the key. The
most discriminating character, although not always distinct
on herbarium specimens, is bold. Both species and their
habitats are shown in Figs. 6 and 7.
1a. Densely caespitose perennial with ascending
stems and (4)7–20(29) mm long internodes. Plants
variable in indumentum, from completely glabrous
to densely hairy. Leaves (2.3)2.8–5.2(6.1) times
longer than wide. Sepals (2.8)5.0–6.9(7.2) mm
long and (1.6)1.7–2.7(3.2) mm wide. Capsules
(7.1)8.8–11.7(12.6) × (2.1)2.9–4.8(5.5) mm,
(1.7)2.0–3.4(3.9) times longer than wide. Seeds
(0.1)1.4–1.9(2.0) long and (0.5)1.1–1.6(1.8) wide
…………………………………………… C. dinaricum
1b. Laxly caespitose perennial with decumbent
stems and (10)17–27(30) mm long internodes.
Plants with at least some glandular hairs. Leaves
(1.7)2.0–4.0(5.6) times longer than wide. Sepals
(5.3)5.4–7.9(8.0) mm long and (2.0)2.2–3.1(3.6) mm
wide. Capsules (5.3)6.1–11.4(12.1) × (3.1)3.7–4.4
(5.0) mm, (1.4)1.5–2.7(3.2) times longer than wide.
Seeds (0.4)0.8–1.6(2.2) long and (0.3)0.6–1.3(1.8)
w i d e , ( 1 . 1 ) 1 . 1 – 1 . 4 ( 1 . 5 ) t i m e s l o n ge r t h a n
wide…………………………………… C. hekuravense
Acknowledgements Open access funding provided by University
of Innsbruck and Medical University of Innsbruck. This study was
financed by the Austrian Exchange Service (OeAD) within the program
WTZ and the Montenegrin Ministry of Science (Austria–Montenegro
bilateral Project “ME04/2015-2016” to D. P. and B. F.). M. Niketić
and Z. Barina provided locality data and gave valuable hints to relevant
literature. We thank all collectors listed in Table 1 and Online Resource
1. The curator of the herbarium ZA provided herbarium material for
morphometric analyses and Z. Barina sent us photos of type specimens.
M. Gassner, D. Kutnjak and D. Pirkebner helped with laboratory work
and M. Gassner with production of some figures. M. Magauer produced the iconography of both species. We are grateful to P. Daniel
Schlorhaufer and his colleagues from the Botanical Gardens of the
13
Conflict of interest
of interest.
The authors declare that they have no conflict
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use,
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to
the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made.
Information on Electronic Supplementary Material
Online Resource 1. Voucher information about the outgroup taxa
included in the AFLP analyses. Each population of each species has
its specific population ID.
Online Resource 2. Character states of Cerastium dinaricum and C.
hekuravense from morphometric analyses. For explanation of character
abbreviations see Table 2.
References
Arrigo N, Tuszynski JW, Ehrich D, Gerdes T, Alvarez N (2009)
Evaluating the impact of scoring parameters on the structure
of intra-specific genetic variation using RawGeno, an R package for automating AFLP scoring. BMC Bioinform 10:33.
doi:10.1186/1471-2105-10-33
Ball PW (2011) Source of records for Albania in Flora Europaea,
TRTE Herbarium. University of Toronto, Mississauga. Available at: http://www.erin.utoronto.ca/~trteherb/resources_assets/
Albania_V1.pdf
Barina Z, Pifkó D (2008) Additions and amendments to the flora of
Albania. Willdenowia 38:455–464. doi:10.3372/wi.38.38206
Barina Z, Rakaj M, Pifkó D (2013) Contributions to the flora of
Albania, 4. Willdenowia 43:165–184. doi:10.3372/wi.43.43119
Brysting AK, Oxelman B, Huber KT, Moulton V, Brochmann C (2007) Untangling complex histories of genome
mergings in high polyploids. Syst Biol 56:467–476.
doi:10.1080/10635150701424553
Brysting AK, Mathiesen C, Marcussen T (2011) Challenges in polyploid phylogenetic reconstruction: a case story from the arcticalpine Cerastium alpinum complex. Taxon 60:333–347
Demiri M (1983) Flora eskursioniste e Shqiperise. Shtepia Botuese
e Shqiperise, Tirana
Dimopoulos P, Raus T, Bergmeier E, Constantinidis T, Iatrou G,
Kokkini S, Strid A, Tzanoudakis D (2013) Vascular plants of
Greece: an annotated checklist. Englera 31:1–372
Euro + Med (2006) Euro + Med PlantBase—the information
resource for Euro-Mediterranean plant diversity. Available at:
http://ww2.bgbm.org/EuroPlusMed. Accessed 15 Jan 2017
Frajman B, Oxelman B (2007) Reticulate phylogenetics and phytogeographical structure of Heliosperma (Sileneae, Caryophyllaceae) inferred from chloroplast and nuclear DNA
sequences. Molec Phylogen Evol 43:140–155. doi:10.1016/j.
ympev.2006.11.003
Frajman B, Eggens F, Oxelman B (2009) Hybrid origins and
homoploid reticulate evolution within Heliosperma (Sileneae,
Cerastium hekuravense is divergent from C. dinaricum
Caryophyllaceae)—a multigene phylogenetic approach with relative dating. Syst Biol 58:328–345. doi:10.1093/sysbio/syp030
Frajman B, Pachschwöll C, Schönswetter P (2014) Contributions to
the knowledge of the flora of the Dinarides (Balkan Peninsula).
Phyton 54:27–46. doi:10.12905/0380.phython54(1)2014-0027
Frajman B, Rešetnik I, Weiss-Schneeweiss H, Ehrendorfer F, Schönswetter P (2015) Cytotype diversity and genome size variation
in Knautia (Caprifoliaceae, Dipsacoideae). BMC Evol Biol
15:140. doi:10.1186/s12862-015-0425-y
Greilhuber J, Ebert I (1994) Genome size variation in Pisum sativum.
Genome 37:646–655
Hayek A (1924) Zweiter Beitrag zur Kenntnis der Flora von Albanien.
Denkschr Akad Wiss Wien Math-Naturwiss Kl 99:101–223
Horvat I, Glavač V, Ellenberg H (1974) Vegetation südosteuropas.
Gustav Fischer, Stuttgart
IUCN (2012) IUCN Red list categories and criteria: version 3.1, 2nd
edition. IUCN, Gland. Available at: http://www.iucnredlist.org
Jalas A (1964) Cerastium L. In: Tutin TG, Heywood VH, Burges NA,
Valentine DH, Walters SM, Webb DA (eds) Flora Europaea 4.
Cambridge University Press, London, pp 136–143
Jalas A (1993) Cerastium L. In: Tutin TG, Burges NA, Chater OA,
Edmondson JR, Heywood VH, Moore DM, Valentine DH, Walters SM, Webb DA (eds) Flora Europaea, 2nd edn. Cambridge
University Press, London, pp 164–171
Jalas A, Suominen J (eds) (1983) Atlas Florae Europaeae, distribution of vascular plants 6. In: Committee for mapping the Flora
of Europe. Societas Biologica Fennica Vanamo, Helsinki
Jávorka S (1921) Új adatok Albánia flórájához (Novitates florae
Albanicae). Bot Közlem 19:17–29
Kryštufek B, Reed JM (2004) Pattern and processes in Balkan biodiversity – an overview. In: Griffits HI, Kryštufek B, Reed JM (eds)
Balkan biodiversity: pattern and process in the European hotspot.
Kluwer, Dordrecht, pp 203–217
Kutnjak D, Schönswetter P, Dullinger S, Kuttner M, Niketić M, Frajman B (2014) Escaping to the summits: phylogeography and
predicted range dynamics of Cerastium dinaricum, an endangered high mountain plant endemic to the western Balkan
Peninsula. Molec Phylogen Evol 78:365–374. doi:10.1016/j.
ympev.2014.05.015
Markgraf F (1932) Pf lanzengeographie von Albanien. E.
Schweizerbart’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung, Stuttgart
Merxmüller H, Strid A (1977) A new species in the Cerastium alpinum
group from Mt Olympus, Greece. Bot Notiser 130:469–472
Meyer FK (2011) Beiträge zur Flora von Albanien. Haussknechtia
15:1–220
Nei M, Li WH (1979) Mathematical model for studying genetic variation in terms of restriction endonucleases. Proc Natl Acad Sci
USA 76:5269–5273
Niketić M (1999) Cerastium subsection of the genus Cerastium L.
(Caryophyllaceae) on Balkan Peninsula. Annotated check-list.
Glasn Prir Muz Beogradu Ser B 49–50:39–61
Niketić M (2007) Endemični predstavnici roda Cerastium L.u
jugoistočnoj Evropi – Taksonomija, horologija i ekologija. PhD
Thesis, Universitet u Beogradu, Beograd
Niketić M, Stevanović V (2007) A new species of Heliosperma (Caryophyllaceae) from Serbia and Montenegro. Bot J Linn Soc 154:55–
63. doi:10.1111/j.1095-8339.2007.00643.x
Niketić M, Siljak-Yakovlev S, Frajman B, Lazarević M, Stevanović
B, Tomović G, Stevanović V (2013) Towards resolving the systematics of Cerastium subsect. Cerastium (Caryophyllaceae): a
69
cytogenetic approach. Bot J Linn Soc 172:205–224. doi:10.1111/
boj.12050
Paparisto K, Demiri M, Mitrushi I, Qosja XH (1988) Flora e Shqiperise, vol. 1. Akademia e Shkencave e RPS te Shqiperise, Qendra e
Kerkimeve Biologjike, Tirana
Pils G (2016) Illustrated Flora of Albania. Eigenverlag G. Pils, St.
Stefan
Qosja X, Paparisto K, Demiri M, Vangjeli J (1992) Flora e Shqiperise,
vol. 2. Akademia e Shkencave e RPS te Shqiperise, Qendra e
Kerkimeve Biologjike, Tirana
Qosja X, Paparisto K, Vangjeli J, Ruci B (1996) Flore e Shqiperise,
vol. 3. Akademia e Shkencave e RPS te Shqiperise, Qendra e
Kerkimeve Biologjike, Tirana
Rakaj M (2009) Floristic and chorological news from north Albania.
Bot Serbica 33:177–183
Redžić S (2011) Phytogeographic and syntaxonomic diversity
of high mountain vegetation in Dinaric Alps (Western Balkan, SE Europe). J Mountain Sci 8:767–786. doi:10.1007/
s11629-011-2047-1
Scheen AC, Brochmann C, Brysting AK, Elven R, Morris A, Soltis
DE, Soltis PS, Albert V (2004) Northern hemisphere biogeography of Cerastium (Caryophyllaceae): insights from phylogenetic
analysis of noncoding plastid nucleotide sequences. Amer J Bot
91:943–952
Schönswetter P, Schneeweiss GM (2009) Androsace komovensis sp.
nov., a long mistaken local endemic from the southern Balkan
Peninsula with biogeographic links to the Eastern Alps. Taxon
58:544–549
StatSoft (1996) STATISTICA (data analysis software system), version
5.1. Tulsa: StatSoft Inc. www.statsoft.com
Stevanović V, Kit T, Petrova A (2007) Mapping the endemic flora of
the Balkans—a progress report. Bocconea 21:131–137
Surina B, Rakić T, Stefanović S, Stevanović V, Lakušić D (2009) One
new species of the genus Edraianthus, and a change in taxonomic status for Edraianthus serpyllifolius f. pilosulus (Campanulaceae) from the Balkan Peninsula. Syst Bot 34:602–608.
doi:10.1600/036364409789271236
Surina B, Pfanzelt S, Einzmann HJR, Albach DC (2014) Bridging the
Alps and the Middle East: evolution, phylogeny and systematics
of the genus Wulfenia (Plantaginaceae). Taxon 63:843–858
R Development Core Team (2012) R: A language and environment
for statistical computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing,
Vienna, Austria. Available at: www.R-project.org
Tel-Zur N, Abbo S, Myslabodski D, Mizrahi Y (1999) Modified
CTAB procedure for DNA isolation from epiphytic cacti of genera Hylocereus and Selenicereus (Cactaceae). Pl Molec Biol Rep
17:249–254
van de Peer Y, De Wachter R (1997) Construction of evolutionary distance trees with TREECON for Windows: accounting for variation
in nucleotide substitution rate among sites. CABIOS 13:227–230.
doi:10.1093/bioinformatics/13.3.227
Vangjeli J (2003) Udhëheqës fushor i florës së Sqipërisë. Shkenca,
Tiranë
Vangjeli J, Ruci B, Mullaj A, Paparisto K, Qosja XH (2000) Flora e
Shqiperise, vol. 4. Akademia e Shkencave e Republikes se Shqiperise, Instituti i Kerkimeve Biologjike, Tirane
13