TEXTURE ANALYSIS OF POLARIMETRIC SAR
Gianfranco De Grandi(1), Richard M. Lucas(2), Attilio Gambardella(3), and Maurizio Migliaccio(3)
(1)
European Commission, DG Joint Research Centre, Via Enrico Fermi, 21027, Ispra (VA), Italy,
frank.de-grandi’at’jrc.it
(2)
Aberystwyth University, Institute of Geography and Earth Sciences, SY23 3DB Aberystwyth, U.K.
rml’at’aber.ac.uk
(3)
Università degli Studi di Napoli Parthenope, Centro Direzionale, Isola C4, 80143 Napoli, Italy,
{attilio.gambardella; maurizio.migliaccio}’at’uniparthenope.it
ABSTRACT
The Wavelet Polarization Signature (WASP) is a
recently introduced formalism for analyzing the
dependences of texture measures, in SAR imagery,
afforded by wavelet frames on scale and polarization
state. Based on a previously published theoretical
approach, two experiments are reported where wavelet
WASP analysis is applied to SAR observations of
natural targets, both in the land and marine domains.
The objective is to assess the potential usefulness of the
technique in different thematic contexts and to validate
experimentally the effects predicted by theory. Analysis
conducted so far indicates that texture measures based
on wavelet frames can be an effective vehicle to
characterize the spatial statistics of SAR observations in
the combined space-scale-polarization domain.
1. INTRODUCTION
Spatial variations of Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR)
backscatter bear information on structural and geometric
properties of natural targets, and therefore can be
potentially useful for deriving biophysical parameters,
or for classification problems. These variations and their
relationships are visually perceived as image texture,
and can be measured by the statistics of some
underlying random process. A method for retrieving
local texture measures in SAR imagery using wavelet
frames was proposed in [1] from the theoretical point of
view. In particular the concept of polarimetric texture
was revisited, by investigating the dependences of these
measures on the antenna polarization states. The method
provides estimates of a two-point statistics (a proxy of
the structure function) in the combined space-scalepolarization domain. To analyze from the observational
standpoint these dependences, suitable analytical tools
are introduced to represent these dependences through
signatures that condense information in graphical form.
In particular, the Wavelet Scaling Signature (WASS) for
single polarization detected data, and the Wavelet
Polarization Signature (WASP) for fully polarimetric
data are used to characterize the textural properties of
extended homogeneous areas of interest. Moreover,
textural separability of two regions is studied by means
of a criterion function of the Fischer discriminant.
Based on this theoretical background, two experiments
are reported where wavelet frame texture measures and
signature analysis are applied to SAR observations of
natural targets, both in the land and marine domains.
The objective is to assess the potential usefulness of the
technique in different thematic contexts and to validate
experimentally the effects predicted by theory. The first
experiment is thematically oriented to tropical forest
mapping in the Congo River floodplain, and illustrates
how spatial properties of the classes of interest (swamp
forest, lowland rain forest and secondary forest) are
reflected in WASP analysis in a mixture of texture
strength and polarimetric diversity. Fully polarimetric
single look complex ALOS PALSAR data are used in
this analysis. The second experiment is in the marine
domain, and concerns the characterization through
WASP analysis of oil spills, look-alikes and sea clutter.
In this case, SIR-C fully polarimetric C-band data, are
considered.
2. TEXTURE MEASURES
The method of retrieving texture measures using
wavelet frames is extensively documented in [1].
Texture measures are afforded by the variance of the
wavelet frame coefficients in a discrete transform,
implemented using an à trous algorithm in the
oversampled version. The variance is estimated locally
at several dyadic scales by convolution with a
smoothing kernel. The considered wavelet frame is the
first derivative of a B-spline of order 3, which acts as a
differential operator [2]. Finally, the following feature
vector is achieved:
� =
[ ]
[ ]
,� =
[ ]
[ ]
,� =
[ ]
[ ]
, (1)
where aj[n] is the discrete image at the output of the à
trous low-pass filter (smooth image), n=(n1, n2) is a
running index of the image and xcj[n] and ycj[n] are the
wavelet coefficients in the row and column directions,
respectively, at scale 2j (output of the à trous high-pass
filters).
_____________________________________________________
Proc. of ‘4th Int. Workshop on Science and Applications of SAR Polarimetry and Polarimetric
Interferometry – PolInSAR 2009’, 26–30 January 2009, Frascati, Italy (ESA SP-668, April 2009)
The wavelet coefficients variance is a proxy of the twopoint spatial statistics, also known in geosciences, as
“structure function”. The structure function is effective
in characterizing the signal regularity in discontinuities,
such as edges and point targets, correlations in
stationary random processes, and the scaling properties
(e.g., fractal dimension) in non-stationary processes
with stationary increments, such as fractional Brownian
motion.
configurations. The LDA finds a linear mapping of two
n-dimensional feature vectors, which maximizes a
measure of separability between the regions. The
separability criterion is given by the ratio of the
“distance” between regions over the overall spread of
the projected data. For each case, a figure of the
sensitivity to the estimator configuration is given. This
analysis is referred to as wavelet separability by Fischer
criterion (WASEF).
3. ANALYSIS TOOLS
3.3. WASP and WASPSEF
For polarimetric data, an extension of the a-trous
algorithm is considered, where polarimetric power
synthesis is performed in the wavelet domain [1]. The
tool is referred to as the wavelet polarimetric signature
(WASP). An area extensive version of the WASP is
used here, which is computationally implemented on the
assumption that fully polarimetric data are in covariance
matrix form. The process is based on the commutativity
of the wavelet and power synthesis operators (both
linear). Each element of the polarimetric covariance
matrix is decomposed in the frame representation. The
wavelet transform of the power image for a given
polarization state is then obtained by applying the
polarimetric synthesis operator to the frame
representation of the covariance matrix. This procedure
results in a fast computation of the wavelet transform of
the power image for a number of polarization states.
The signature consists of a family of graphs, each
mapping the normalized wavelet variance against the
orientation angle at a given dyadic scale.
It is also proposed [3] an extension of the WASEF
class-separability analysis. For fully polarimetric data,
the Fischer criterion is computed for backscatter power
synthesized at a number of polarization states. This
signature gives information on the (eventual)
dependence of the region textural separability on the
polarization state. Accordingly, the signature is dubbed
wavelet signature of polarimetric separability by Fischer
criterion (WASPSEF). The results of this process are
condensed in a family of graphs, which maps the
Fischer separability versus polarization state, and are
parameterized by the decomposition scale. This
signature therefore highlights those polarimetric states
that are optimal with respect to the textural separability
of two regions.
Texture measures afforded by the wavelet variance
depend on a number of parameters, including position in
space, scale, and polarization states. Thus, the
experimental analysis of the wavelet variance therefore
requires a meaningful reduction of the representation
space to provide information that could be readily
linked to some characteristics of the underlying texturegenerating random process. For this purpose, a number
of analytical tools, whose description is extensively
detailed in [3], are introduced to capture these salient
features of the observations and condense them in either
a graphical or numerical form.
3.1. WASS
This wavelet scaling signature (WASS) captures the
scaling behavior of the wavelet variance for power
detected data and for a single polarization state. The
WASS is computed by averaging the normalized
wavelet variance at a number of dyadic scales within an
area of interest identified in the backscatter data set. The
wavelet coefficients corresponding to two orthogonal
directions (rows and columns) of the 2-D filter bank
decomposition are considered. If the data set is in the
radar geometry (slant or ground range), the two
directions correspond to range and cross-range. The
WASS signature is based on a two-point statistics
estimated over an area. In the case of a texturally
homogeneous extended target, this measure provides a
good characterization of the textural properties in the
neighborhood of the region of interest. This signature
highlights the strength of texture and at which scale
texture develops. Moreover, the approach provides clues
about the type of stationary or non-stationary regime if
the underlying random process is scale invariant.
3.2. Measures of Separability
The WASS analysis does not give information on the
separability of two texturally homogeneous regions, a
fact which makes it less suitable for bridging over to a
segmentation or classification problem. Therefore, a
version of the signatures is proposed in [3] where, given
two regions defined using a supervised approach, once
the respective feature vectors, as defined in (1), are
computed for a number of scales and different dilation
factors of the smoothing spline filter, the criterion
function of the Fischer’s linear discriminant analysis
(LDA) [4] is then evaluated for the different
4. EXPERIMENTS
In this section, the spatial statistics relevant to fully
polarimetric SAR data are investigated, by WASP
analysis, for tropical forest and marine domain mapping
purposes.
4.1. The Congo River floodplain
The Congo River floodplain in Central Africa hosts the
world’s largest formations of swamp forests. This
ecosystem is important because occurring biochemical
processes influence emissions of greenhouse gases,
particularly methane [5]. The canopies of the swamp
forests are structurally different from the adjoining
lowland rainforest, and these differences are reflected in
the spatial statistics generated using radar data. In
particular, the upper canopy of the swamp forest, which
can be 45 m in height, is composed of a small number
of species and is structurally homogeneous compared
with the lowland forests.
In this experiment, a fine beam fully polarimetric slantrange ALOS PALSAR data set, provided by JAXA in
the framework of the ALOS principal investigator (PI)
program, is used. The original scattering matrix data set
was converted to covariance matrix representation and
multi-looked by four. Therefore, the spatial sampling in
range and cross-range is approximately 9.36 × 13.47 m.
A Pauli decomposition of the data set over the area of
interest in the Congo floodplain is shown in Fig. 1 as a
color composite, where the green, red, and blue
channels are assigned to volume scattering, double
bounce scattering and single bounce scattering
mechanisms respectively. WASP signatures are
computed for (A) swamp forest, (B) primary RF, (C)
flooded swamp forest, and (D) secondary degraded
forest.
The WASP signatures for the four classes at scale 2 are
shown in Fig. 2. The (blue) swamp forest features a very
homogeneous canopy, which is reflected in low texture
and with no dependence on the polarization state in the
signature. The (red) degraded forest, on the other hand,
presents quite a distinctive signature, with higher texture
and polarimetric textural diversity. It is to be noted that
the absolute maximum is shifted toward the orientation
angle Ψ=45°. We can speculate, based on the model
proposed in [1], that this sensitivity to polarization state
is due to the mixture of different scattering mechanisms
in the fragmented forest and within the estimation
window. The (black) primary forest presents an
intermediate case between the more homogeneous
swamp forest and the rugged secondary forest, in terms
of texture strength and polarimetric diversity. Notice
how the maximum now occurs near Ψ=0° (HV), which
indicates that spatial statistics are dictated primarily by
volume scattering. Finally, the flooded swamp forest
(green) presents a signature similar to the swamp forest
(low texture) but with a more marked dependence on
polarization and maxima tending to HV.
The WASPSEF signature related to the two classes
swamp and primary RFs is shown in Fig. 3. The wavelet
variance was estimated at scales 2 and 4 using a
smoothing filter with dilation factor of 16. The absolute
value of the Fischer discriminant is rather low, an
indication that textural information is weak in this type
of data set, which may be attributed to the steep
incidence angle. However, a clear dependence on the
polarization state is observed, with a maximum near the
orientation angle Ψ=0° (HV) and a minimum at Ψ=45°.
Considering that only the co-polarized channels
contribute to power synthesis at Ψ=45°, the HV
configuration is likely to allow for better discrimination
Figure 1. Pauli decomposition color composite image
of a fully polarimetric PALSAR data set acquired over
the Congo floodplain on March 2007 (courtesy of the
JAXA ALOS PI program).
Figure 2. WASP signatures at scale 2 related to the
areas of interest marked in Fig. 8. (Blue line) swamp
forest area A. (Black line) Primary RF area B. (Red
line) Degraded forest area D. (Green line) swamp
forest area C.
Figure 3. WASPSEF analysis for PALSAR full
polarization data. Fischer criterion for wavelet
coefficients’ (red line) variance at scale 2 and (black
line) filtered wavelet variance.
of the two classes compared with the HH or VV
channels alone.
4.2. Sea clutter and oil spills
In this experiment a set of meaningful experiments
performed using multi-look complex (MLC) C-band
SAR data, in which oil spills and oil look-alikes are
present, are presented and discussed. The data sets were
acquired during the SRL-2 SIR-C/X-SAR mission. The
incidence angle varied between 20-55 degrees and the
SAR swath width on the ground varied between 15 Km
and 90 Km. The noise floor at C-band was -28dB [6].
In Fig. 4 is shown the SAR data acquired on October
08, 1994 in the English Channel (p.n. 49939). This case
concerns a SAR acquisition characterized by low wind
conditions. A typical oil spill pattern due to a ship is
present. No information about the type of oil is reported
in literature [7]. A subset of the total power SAR image
acquired over the area of the experiment is shown in
Fig. 4. WASP analysis has been performed over a three
area corresponding to the oil spill (OIL), a free sea
surface (SEA) and a dark area probably due to an
atmospheric wave (AW). The analysis results for OIL,
SEA and AW are shown in Fig. 5. In detail, a family of
curves corresponding to the wavelet variance of the
intensity in the cross-polarized channel at the first four
dyadic scales is shown (black 21, red 22, green 23, blue
24).
In all cases the scale 2 is the most useful, as a rapid
response damping and insensitivity to polarization at
longer scales is experienced. Signature relevant to both
SEA and AW show a low texture and a weak
dependence on the polarization state. On the contrary,
the OIL presents quite a distinctive signature, with
higher texture and polarimetric textural diversity. It is to
be noted that the absolute maximum is near the
orientation angle Ψ=45°. This is an indication that
unbalance in the correlation properties in the crosspolarized and co-polarized channels come into play and
can be exploited for differentiating a true oil slick. The
underpinning physical mechanism needs still to be
investigated at this stage.
Figure 4. Total power image of the area of interest
relevant to the SIR-C C-band image acquired on
October 08, 1994 in the English Channel (p.n.
49939). WASP analysis was performed for OIL, SEA
and AW transects, respectively (courtesy of the JPL
and USGS).
a
5. CONCLUSIONS
Analysis of the spatial statistics in SAR observations of
forested areas has been performed in a number of
experiments using a method based on a wavelet frame
representation. The analysis served the purpose to
validate, on a purely observational basis, the principles
and the computational aspects of the method, which
were exposed on a theoretical ground in [1].
Analysis conducted so far indicates that texture
measures based on wavelet frames can be an effective
vehicle to characterize the spatial statistics of SAR
observations in the combined space-scale-polarization
domain. In particular, preliminary observations confirm
that polarimetric texture could be potentially useful in
connection with specific thematic contexts such as oil
spill detection, and forest mapping.
b
6. ACKNOLEDGMENT
The authors would like to thank Japan Aerospace
Exploration Agency (JAXA) for providing PALSAR
data through the ALOS PI program, the NASA’s Jet
Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), and United States
Geological Services (USGS) for providing the SIR-C/XSAR data used in this study.
c
Figure 5. WASP signatures at scale 2 related to the
areas of interest marked in Fig. 4. oil spill (OIL),
free sea surface (SEA) and a dark area probably due
to an atmospheric wave (AW).
7. REFERENCES
1. De Grandi G., J.-S. Lee, & D. Schuler, (2007).
Target detection and texture segmentation in
polarimetric SAR images using a wavelet frame:
Theoretical Aspects, IEEE Trans. on Geosci.
and Remote Sensing, vol. 45, no. 11, pp. 34373453.
2. S. Mallat, (1998). A Wavelet Tour of Signal
Processing. London, U.K.:Academic.
3. De Grandi G., R.M. Lucas, & J. Kropacek, (2009).
Analysis by wavelet frames of spatial statistics in
SAR data for characterizing structural properties
of forests, IEEE Trans. on Geosci. and Remote
Sensing, in print.
4. R. O. Duda, P. E. Hart, & D. G. Stork, (2001).
Pattern Classification. New York: Wiley.
5. De Grandi G. F., P. Mayaux, J. P. Malingreau, A.
Rosenqvist, S. Saatchi, & and M. Simard,
(2000). New perspectives on global ecosystems
from wide-area radar mosaics: Flooded forest
mapping in the tropics, Int. J. Remote Sens., vol.
21, no. 6/7, pp. 1235–1250.
6. Gade M., W. Alpers, H. Huhnerfuss, H. Masuko, &
T. Kobayashi, (1998). Imaging of biogenic and
anthropogenic ocean surface films by the
multifrequency/multipolarization SIR-C/X-SAR,
J. Geophys. Res., vol. 103, no. C9, pp. 1885118866.
7. Migliaccio M., A. Gambardella, & M. Tranfaglia,
SAR polarimetry to observe oil spills, (2007).
IEEE Trans. on Geosci. and Remote Sensing,
vol. 45, no. 2, pp. 506–511.