Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                
Religious Studies Review • VOLUME 40 us with a rounded methodological approach to researching the subject of astrology as well as a clear and concise consideration of its forms and functions. This volume is highly recommended. Beth Singler The University of Cambridge • NUMBER 4 • DECEMBER 2014 Tibet; Europe and Islam; and modernity—which explore specific religious and cultural representations and connections of subtle bodies. Each section includes a short introduction, followed by three to five essays. Topics include Daoist qi, Indian chakras and nadis in tantric practice, Bon and Tibetan soul and energy channel representations, ancient Greek notions of the body related to athletics, Neoplatonic soul concepts, Sufi subtle centers, and modern subtle body concepts in neo-shamanism, scientific, esoteric, poststructuralist, feminist, and ethnic discourses. The last chapter by Samuel is the most theoretical, attempting to approach the subtle body in nonreductionist ways, focusing on practices and historical frameworks. Although not fully successful due to self-imposed limitations, Samuel’s theoretical essay nevertheless continues an important conversation about nonreductionism. Overall, this book is a fine collection that will interest East–West comparativists, those in body studies and embodiment, Asian religions, and those theorizing about nonreductionist approaches to studying religion. John L. Crow Florida State University ERANOS: AN ALTERNATIVE INTELLECTUAL HISTORY OF THE TWENTIETH CENTURY. By Hans Thomas Hakl. Translated by Christopher McIntosh. Montreal, Canada: McGill-Queen’s University Press, 2013. Pp. xvi + 440. Paper, $34.95. Initially published in 2001 as Der verborgene Geist von Eranos, Hakl’s extensive history of the Eranos conferences has at last been updated and translated into English. Hakl divides the history of these annual events into three eras as defined by dominant personalities: 1933–1950, with Jung; the “heyday” from 1950 through the mid-1970s, with Corbin, Scholem, and Eliade; and the mid-1970s onward, under archetypal psychologist James Hillman. En route, Hakl develops vivid biographical portraits of both the famous scholars and those lesser known, such as Jakob Hauer and David Miller. Regarding the misgivings toward Eranos scholars voiced by S. Wasserstrom and others, notably the attribution of sympathy for violent forms of fascism to some of the participants, Hakl provides an abundance of archival documentation in each individual case that allows readers to make their own determination. Wasserstrom’s critique of Eranos as “mystocentric,” by contrast, is cautiously embraced. Scholars like Jung, Corbin, and Durand had obvious esoteric interests, but for Hakl their scholarship is best understood as part of the German Idealist tradition that employs both reason and imagination, mythos and logos, and is not itself part of their effort for salvation. Amply documented and clearly written, this book is recommended to scholars in comparative religions, seeking to better understand the development of their discipline in the twentieth century. Matthew J. Dillon Rice University RELIGIOUS AND SPIRITUAL EXPERIENCES. By Wesley J. Wildman. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014, Pp. xvi + 303. $28.95. Wesley Wildman presents and defends a religious naturalist interpretation of religious and spiritual experiences (RSEs). As such, his approach involves a rejection of supernaturalism (the belief in disembodied agency) and supranaturalism (the belief that ultimate reality is essentially personal). Nonetheless, over and against antireligious forms of naturalism, he aims to preserve and develop the spiritual value of RSEs. To this end, he critically examines both practical and theoretical issues connected with the phenomena of RSEs and their academic exploration. Four theoretical issues are explored in detail: 1) the psychological, social, and evolutionary origins of RSEs; 2) the effects of RSEs; 3) the epistemology of RSEs; and 4) the ultimate spiritual significance of RSEs. In this way, Wildman engages the topic with a breadth that is sometimes missing from more narrowly focused critical examinations. The result is an empirically, philosophically, and historically informed discussion with discussionadvancing insights. Among the latter is Wildman’s dipolar monistic form of naturalistic ontology in which the physical and mental are aspects of the same thing, as well as his “neural mediation thesis,” according to which the brain exhaustively mediates mental phenomena. As Wildman argues, although RSEs may plausibly be interpreted within the framework of either dualism or dipolar monism, a good account of RSEs must incorporate the neural mediation thesis. Michael Sudduth San Francisco State University RELIGION AND THE SUBTLE BODY IN ASIA AND THE WEST: BETWEEN MIND AND BODY. Edited by Geoffrey Samuel and Jay Johnson. Routledge Studies in Asian Religion and Philosophy. New York: Routledge, 2013. Pp. xiv + 275. $155.00. Theosophical thought has dominated the West’s thinking about the subtle body, according to Samuel and Johnson. But this dominance has obscured other ways subtle bodies have been conceptualized. In response, this diverse and interesting anthology surveys Asian and Euro-American subtle body concepts and practices. In addition to a general introduction, there are four sections—China and India; 196