The 8th International Conference for Informatics and Information Technology (CIIT 2011)
E-learning in Higher Education through E-learning center
Zoran Zdravev MSc 1, Gorgi Dimov MSc 1, Silvana Krsteva 1
1
E-Learning Centre, Goce Delchev University
Stip, Republic of Macedonia
Abstract
Today E-learning has become the key to a profound
revolution in learning. This is because E-learning can offer
the most flexible and effective learning approach. The
university "Goce Delchev" - Stip is a leading institution in the
implementation of new technologies in education in
Macedonia. In order to gain an understanding of the current
situation in Macedonian universities, this paper highlights the
broad spectrum of E- learning practice and activity occurring
today at University "Goce Delchev" in Stip. All activities are
conducted through the E-learning center, which directs,
supports and coordinates all of these activities. The key
benefits, derived from the successful integration of E-learning
within the wider learning practices of a university, are
explored, too. The paper concludes by outlining the
challenges and opportunities for E-learning, and raises the
issue of how collaborative action could benefit the
universities in Macedonia.
Introduction
The presence of informational communicational technology
in education has brought significant changes in the learning –
teaching process. E-learning is attaining significance in this
Internet world due to the obvious advantages of anywhere
anytime learning, to reach the unreachable. Nowadays, most
of the effort in the area of e-learning are directed towards the
educational use of ICT at all levels in the Educations system.
In the last two decades, the constant imperative of teachers
and professors was to introduce the use of ICT in the
educational process. For this purpose, at all levels of
education various projects are implemented to integrate ICT
in teaching. In the Republic of Macedonia, this process is
especially emphasized in the last 5-6 years, through the
implementation of several projects of national interest. These
projects are funded by USAID, European Council and
Ministry of Education and Science of Republic of Macedonia.
Some of these projects were implemented through the Faculty
of Pedagogy in Stip, and from 2007 through the University
"Goce Delchev"-Stip (University "Goce Delchev" was
founded in 2007 and the Faculty of Pedagogy was joined at
the University since the date of its establishment).
Also an important point to single out with the foundation of
the University “Goce Delchev” is the preferential role that
ICT won at the beginning of its work. The project
"Implementation of LMS in teaching was organized as a part
of the ICT implementation activities at the University, which
was partly supported by the European Commission (through
TEMPUS project) and Fulbright Foundation.
As a result of this project in September 2008 the E-learning
center has been established in order to introduce modern
forms of learning at the university, new technologies
(interactive whiteboards, graphic whiteboards, multimedia
software and hardware, audio-visual equipment), as well as
training for teachers and students from universities and
schools in Macedonia and abroad. The realization of these
projects through the E-Learning Center at the University
"Goce Delchev" made it a leading institution in our region in
the implementation of new technologies in education.
Conditions for equipment and application of ICT in
Higher Educations
It is evident that a wide access to learning through E-Learning
is gaining significance and becomes essential for the survival
in this new, continually changing world in any profession and
in any discipline. Information communicational technology
(ICT) has a main role in maintaining the quality in Higher
Education in Macedonia and it will be a basis for competitive
advantages of the universities in the future.
In the past period (2000 – 2005) all universities in Macedonia
were very modestly equipped with ICT. As an example, is
taken the Faculty of Pedagogy in Stip. In 2005 there was a
laboratory with 12 PCs of type 486 (the current type Pentium
4 "), acquired in 1996. In each cabinet, 2 or 3 teachers had a
"Pentium 3" computer and several laser printers for the entire
faculty. The best computers were installed in the accounting
and student services. There was no organized maintenance of
computers. There was no laptop computer and there was only
one LCD projector that was used accidentally. Teachers were
not happy with this situation and they constantly looked for
ways to improve it. Generally, known problems that emerged
here were: a lack of equipment, insufficient training for using
of the equipment, a lack of digital resources for using in
education and so on. At present, most of these problems are
solved and with the implementation of the projects this
situation is dramatically changed.
The project "Creative Teaching and Learning" lasted from
October 2002 to December 2009 and it was implemented in
three phases, with a total budget of about 3.5 million dollars
provided by USAID.
In the second phase (from July 2005 to September 2008) 11
teachers from the state pedagogical Faculties in the Republic
of Macedonia were included, 5 of which were from our
University. The following activities were realized as part of
this important project:
Two ten-day intensive trainings "Teaching and Learning
with Technology", with instructors from George Mason
1
The 8th International Conference for Informatics and Information Technology (CIIT 2011)
University, Washington, the USA (Tetovo and Ohrid in
August 2005, January 2006)
A study visit to London, the UK, workshops involving
visits to schools and universities that have shown positive
results in the use of ICT in the teaching process
(November 2005)
Reconstruction and providing laboratories and
classrooms with suitable equipment ($ 70,000 spent,
Summer 2006)
Dissemination of experience gained through mandatory
workshops, each teacher at the Faculty of Pedagogy
(Sept-Oct 2006)
In the second part of the second phase of this project all
teachers from the pedagogical Faculties during 2007 and 2008
were included, and more workshops and training sessions
were organized, which were not directly related to the
integration of ICT in teaching process.
The second project, titled "Integrating E-Learning across the
Teacher Curriculum" was within the TEMPUS program of
the European Commission. It was launched in October 2006
and lasted until September 2009. The value of the project was
about 480,000.00 Euro. The holder of the project was the
Faculty of Pedagogy, Stip, and the project included two other
state Faculties of Pedagogy from Skopje and Bitola, as well
as teachers from the Teacher’s Faculty from SEE University
in Tetovo. The EU Partners of the project were from the
University of Groningen, University of Edinburgh and
Catholic University of Leuven. Important activities
implemented within this project were:
A study visit in Groningen and Leuven, organized as
short courses and visiting schools that are advanced in
the use of ICT in the teaching process (February 2007).
The goal of this visit was to get a perspective of the
equipment and software tools used to deliver the teaching
process in the Netherlands and Belgium.
A series of workshops implemented at the Pedagogical
Faculty in Stip (2007-2009)
connecting buildings and campuses with optical connection
are provided. In September 2008, the e-learning center has
been established and Learning Management System (Moodle)
has been implemented.
The E-learning Center uses Moodle platform, which aims to
ensure proper development of skills and competencies
necessary for the 21st century and especially to ensure digital
literacy for students that is essential for their future profession
or career. Also, this software package provides increased and
improved access of students to the created courses. By using a
multimedia software, interactive panels and audiovisual
equipment, the center meets all the needs of a modern and
educational space.
Until now (February 2011) the Moodle platform has 9205
members, 225 of which are teachers, assistants and lab
technicians, and others are students of the University "Goce
Delchev" - Stip.
Currently, the total number of created active courses on
Moodle platform is 835, and administrators run regular and
constant review of its courses for content, activities and
students belong to them. In the table 1 are given recent data
that define the use of Moodle platform.
Table 1. Use of Moodle platform
Courses:
Users:
Assignments of roles:
Lecture:
Posts:
Questions:
Resources:
In the period from November 2009 to December 2010, the E
– learning center implemented a number of activities,
according to the intended work program. In continuity is
given a chronological overview of implemented activities:
A study visit in Groningen, Leuven and Edinburgh
(January 2008), retraining teachers, 12 for the application
of ICT in the teaching process (for everyone in their area
of interest).
A purchase of equipment and software to equip the ELearning Center that fits the newly established University
"Goce Delcev" (110,000.00 Euros were spent, from
March to August 2008). The goal of the establishment of
this Center was to provide continuous support to teachers
and monitors, and to develop and implement new
technologies in the field of electronic learning.
In the second half of 2007, with the foundation of the
University Goce Delcev (UGD), it established a policy that
would be organized with a high degree of usage of ICT in all
segments of business and administration and teaching. Thus,
by the end of 2008, computers were provided for each
employee at the UGD, more new classrooms and computer
labs with interactive boards were provided, a modern network
Total:
835
9205
51690
225
17430
1575
9176
In the period from November 2009 to January 2010 at the
E-Learning Center (ELC), initial courses were held for
the use of „Moodle platform“ for teachers and
collaborators from all 13 faculties within the University
"Goce Delchev".
In the period from February to March 2010, and a new
look for the Moodle platform with its own logo on the
center was created, with menus and links to useful sites.
On 03/05/2010, the officially launched the first issue of
the weekly e-info, which is continuously published
weekly, except the period during summer vacations..
From March 31 to April 30, 2010, the second part of the
courses for the use of ”Moodle platform” for teachers
and collaborators from all 13 faculties within the
University "Goce Delchev" was held.
In the period from April to May, in regions of the
Workers' University in Strumica,a course for the „Life
2
Thee 8th Internationnal Conference for Informaticss and Informatioon Technology (CIIT 2011)
long learninng in every home“ was held, as weell as
conducted trraining coursees for IT resou
urces.
In the periood from Mayy 31 to June 30,
3 2010, in tthe ELearning Ceenter (ELC) thhe courses forr IT - Resourcces for
new employyees of the University
U
"Go
oce Delchev" were
held.
ormation Com
mputer
Additional ccourses for thhe use of Info
Technologyy - ICT in teacching and ressearch processs took
place duringg the period (223.08 – 20.09
9.2010 year). G
Guide
for using M
Moodle platform was deveeloped. Duringg this
period at thee high school “Dobri Dask
kalov” in Kavaadarci
the course " Use of IT toools for E-learn
ning " was helld.
The project "Im
mplementationn of LMS in teaching
t
orgaanized
by the UGD’s E
E-Learning Center
C
(ELC),, began in Jaanuary
200
09 and is still in progress, and
a it is plann
ned to finish inn July
2010. It is partlyy funded by the
t Fulbright program, andd most
of the assets aree covered by the
t UGD. As part of this pproject
thee following is realized:
First part off the training for
f trainers for the applicatiion of
LMS in unniversities (tw
wo from each
h faculty), 15 days
workshop w
with instructoors from the USA,
U
provideed by
Fulbright, Jaanuary 2009
A part of thhe training forr trainers for of
o the applicatiion of
LMS in unniversities (tw
wo from each
h faculty), 15 days
workshop w
with instructors from the US
SA, provided bby the
Fulbright, Juuly 2009
Mandatory one-day initiial training on
n the use of LMS,
for each teaacher at UGD
D, with instrucctors from thee ELC
implemented from Octobber 2009 to Deecember 2009
b noted thatt since October 2009, when
w
Heree it should be
comp
pulsory coursses began too use the LM
MS, its use has
increeased several times.
t
If you ccompare Apriil 2009 and April
A
2010
0 you will see three timess more activiity than in April
A
2010
0.
Of course
c
this haas influencedd by the use of LMS by the
studeents. Accordin
ng to the survveys carried in
n March 2009 and
Marcch 2010 a total of 632 stuudent replies in
i 2009, i.e. 731
studeent replies in 2010
2
(table 1)):
-
-
The num
mber of studen
ents who have a computerr at
home is up nearly tto 5%, i.e. from
f
79.60%
% to
85.12%
The numb
ber of student
nts who have internet
i
accesss at
home has increased bby more than
n 10% i.e. from
fr
59.82% to
o 70.77%
Tab
ble 1. Studentts questionnairre
Students
S
questionnaire
2009
2010
Ow
wn PC
779,60%
84,12%
Internet access
559,82%
70,77%
632
731
Year
An
nswers
Th
he obtained ressults from tabl
ble 1 are shown
n with diagram
m
(figurre 2)
100,00%
Mandatory training (connsultations) on
o the spot aat the
university’ss faculties with visiting in
nstructors from
m the
ELC, Januarry 2010
80,00%
Mandatory two days’ traaining for using the LMS
S, for
each teacherr at UGD, witth instructors from
f
the Centter for
e-learning im
mplemented from
f
April 2010 to June 20110
40,00%
4
60,00%
2009
2010
20,00%
0,00%
Own PC
Preesent situatioon results ach
hieved (May 2010)
2
As a result of alll these activitties, the situattion with the uuse of
ICT
T is much im
mproved. Everry employee of
o UGD dailyy uses
com
mputers for ccommunicationn and work, while teacherrs use
mo
ore LMS as it is shown in thhe following picture:
p
Internet access
Fig
gure 2: Graf - students whoo have a homee computer annd
Internet aaccess
The lack of digital content and resources thaat should be used
u
in teeaching occurrs as a shortccoming in this situation. The
proceess of creatin
ng digital conntent is time consuming and
requiires more effo
ort in their creeation. This diirectly affects the
qualiity of teaching
g.
Figure 1: Graf showingg the usage off the LMS at U
UGD
In this
t
period all the efffort are directed
d
towaards
impleementation and
a
integratition of Moodle E-learnning
platfo
form. Our nex
xt activities w
will be to crreate content for
learn
ning and creatiing a repositorry for contentt of learning.
Concclusion
3
The 8th International Conference for Informatics and Information Technology (CIIT 2011)
The process of implementation of ICT in daily work in
teaching is not easy. It takes great effort, dedication and
perseverance.
Before we began this process the lack of equipment and lack
of skills in using the equipment were identified as the main
problems. Yet another issue was neglected at the beginning:
the human factor - motivation and willingness to use ICT.
This was frustrating - they were leaders with their support the
computerization, but when they began to use computers, they
avoided training and kept low level of skills in using ICT.
Unfortunately it is a fact that became a word for fellow aged
between 30 and 40 years. A solution to this is found in several
"unpopular" measures: mandatory training for anyone
recording the attendance and examination, instructions for
mandatory use of ICT and regulate the entire process with
regulations.
The key benefits of e-learning solutions are:
Increased quality and value of learning achieved through
greater student access and combination of appropriate
supporting content, learners’ cooperation and interaction,
and on-line support Decreased cost of learning delivery,
and reduced travel, subsistence costs and time away from
the job.
Increased flexibility and ability to respond to evolving
business requirements with rapid roll-out of new and
organizational-specific learning to a distributed audience.
Often an E-learning programme will involve
development by a number of people simultaneously.
Therefore design and development of standards need to
be put in place to ensure consistency and transferability
of skills.
Students are also far less forgiving in terms of
inconsistency of user interface and ease of use than with
classroom material.
Increased reach and flexibility enabling learners to
engage in the learning process anytime, anyplace and on
a just-in-time basis
From all the above said in our success story, we found that
key factors for success are:
E-Learning Center (ELC), which is necessary for
realizing and coordination of all activities.
Advanced ICT equipment and resources
Permanent training for upgrading skills to use ICT
equipment and resources
Organizing a specific centers which will be tasked to
monitor compliance with the ICT (safety, maintenance,
lapse, use) and which will provide continuous training to
users
Looking for a way of motivating users through the
rewards, orders, decrees, etc.
Organizing a repository of reusable digital content and
learning materials.
4