14
Book
of modern neuroanatomy and capturing a glimpse of the
complex eloquent man who carried the banner for
neuroanatomical investigation in our times.
P.S. Goldman-Rakic
Section Neurobiology
Yale University School of Medicine
333 Cedar Street, Room C-303
New Haven, CT 06520-8001, USA
.
Alzkmer
Disense: Therapeutic Strategies
Ezio Giacobini
and Robert Becker (Editors).
Birkh&ser, Boston, 1994, ISBN O-8176-3757-5 or
3-7643-3757-5
This book is the latest of three in a series entitled ‘Advances in Alzheimer Disease Therapy’. It is based on
presentations given at the ‘International Springfield
Symposium on Advances in Alzheimer Therapy.’ The
volume comprises of seventeen parts each containing between two to thirteen chapters. Moreover, the introduction contains two chapters, the first of which (by
Giacobini) is an overview of the compounds that are
discussed in the three volumes. Although I share the optimism of Dr. Giacobini that significant improvement
will be made in the cholinomimetic therapy, I doubt that
these improvements will come within two to three years.
In the second chapter, Amaducci and Fratiglioni deal
with the epidemiology of Alxheimers Disease (AD) and
its impact on the treatment.
The following XVII parts consist of single or
multiauthored chapters. The first part is devoted to the
neuropathologic and genetic basis of AD treatment. The
amyloid cascade hypothesis implies that deposition of
the amyloid B-protein is the causative agent of AD
pathology and that neurofibrillary pathology, cell loss
and dementia follow. Wisniewski and Wegiel indicate
that study of the cells that are engaged in amyloid fibril
formation (microglia, perivascular cells and myocytes)
should be of highest priority in the development of therapeutic strategies to prevent and treat AD. In this respect, they emphasize that drugs affecting &protein
amyloidogenesis and b-protein Iibrillogenesis are two
areas that should be of high priority in research and development of treatment of AD. Hardy and Duff review
the recent advances in understanding the disease and
point out some of the problems and deficiences with the
cascade hypothesis. The mechanism of Alzheimer
neurofibrillary degeneration and a strategy to inhibit
this type of degeneration is described by Iqbal and
Grundke Iqbal. Olfactory function is severely compromised in the early stages of Alzheimers disease. Struble et al. suggest that using olfactory testing for
diagnostic aid in AD may identify early changes.
Miklossy describe the presence of spirochetes in the
reviews
blood, cerebrospinal fluid and brain of 14 AD cases.
The characterization of spirochetes found in AD is important since it would enable one to develop serological
tests for early detection of the infection. An implication
of the observation of Miklossy would be that an appropriate antibiotic treatment could stop the progress of
dementia or prevent it.
Therapeutic strategies to arrest production and processing of amyloid are discussed in part II. Although no
drugs are presented that arrest production and processing of amyloid, several suggestions to study amyloid
precursor protein (APP) biogenesis and turnover as well
as &A4 production and aggregation in cell free systems
and cell culture models are presented.
In part III, the choline&z system of human brain is
discussed. Mesulam describes the localization as well as
the source of butyryl cholinesterase (BChE) in human
brain. He suggests that the high density of BChE positive glia in AD brains may play a permissive or causative
role in the neuropathology of AD. Soreq et al. establish
transgenic models for overexpressing human cholinesterases in cholinergic synapses of Xenopus laevis tadpoles and mice in order to study the role of choline@
neurotransmission in regulating synaptic structure and
function. Sihnan et al. describe elegantly the structurefunction relationships in the binding of reversible inhibitors in the active-site gorge of acetylcholinesterase.
Taken together, these studies indicate that acetycholinesterase inhibition by eptastigmine is associated with
cognitive and clinical improvement. Hupenine-A, a
novel anticholinesterase inhibitor, is suggested as a promising candidate for clinical development as a second
generation of anticholinesterase in the treatment of AD
by Tang et al. From in vitro and in vivo studies in animals, Emmerling et al. predict that CI-1002, a novel inhibitor of acetyl cholinesterase and muscarinic receptors
will produce fewer peripheral side effects than other anticholinesterases and should improve patient compliance with treatment. In the next six chapters, the
preclinical and/or clinical effects of several anticholinesterases including SDZ ENA 713, MDL 713,
745, galanthamine, velnacrine and tacrine are discussed
by several authors. Part IV concludes with two chapters
on the preclinical and clinical aspects of second and
third generation cholinesterase inhibitors by Giacobini
and Caudra, and Becker et al. The first authors have
confirmed that central AChE inhibition and ACh levels
are not necessarily correlated and report that individual
inhibitors affect aminergic systems in different ways.
The last authors describe the pharmacology and clinical
efficacy of metrifonate. They emphasize the importance
of monitoring patients for side effects which might be
apparent after months of treatment during long clinical
trials. Moreover, they plead to all who are investigating
these drugs to undertake a thorough characterization of
any patient who shows idiosyncratic responses to these
drugs.
Book
In part V, the role of nicotinic systemin the cognitive
disorderof Alzheimerdiseaseis presented.Moreover,
nicotinic agonists are proposed as drugs for AD
treatment.
Muscarmicagonistsare suggestedin part VI, from
preclinicaland clinical studies,to havetherapeuticpotentialin AD. Preclinicalstudieswith AF 102B (Fisher
et al.), PD 142505(Schwarxet al.), and xanomeline
(Shannonet al.) showthat thesemuscarinicagonistsare
Ml selective.Clinical trials with AF 102 B show
favorableresultsin AD patients.Xanomeline shows
favorabletolerability profdein clinical trials. Theseresultsencouragefurther clinical trials to evahtateif Ml
agonistsmay be useful in a choline@ replacement
treatmentand also in delayingthe progressionof AD.
Farber et al. discusscholine metabolismand membranephospholipidin relation to AD, whereasZacxek
et al. suggestthepossibilityof a multiple neurotransmitter releaseby linopirdine@UP 996)as an AD therapy
in part VII.
The threechaptersin part VIII deal with preclinical
and clinical aspectsof nootropicdrugs.It is suggested
that thesedrugsmight havetherapeuticvalue in AD.
However,in my opinion severalprechnical studies
shouldbe doneto understandthe mechanismof action
of nootropics.Multicenter clinical studiesindicatinga
largh populationof patientsare also requiredto confirm i&e preliminarydata.
In the fast of the two chaptersof part IX, Cue110
reviewsthe experimental,clinical and histologicaldata
of loss of synapsesin AD and proposestrophic factor
inducedsynaptogensis
in AD. In the secondchapter,
Svennerhohnand Toffano describeexperimentaland
clinical data of gangliosidesin AD.
In part X, the first chapterby OlneyandFarberdeals
with excitatorytransmitterneurotoxicityand AD. The
secondchapter,by Miller et al., dealswith freeintracellular calciumin agingand AD. The last chapterin this
part by Sugayaand MC Kinney dealswith nitric oxide
synthase(NOS) in a lesion model of AD. They
hypothesizethat certainNOS negativecholine@ neurons may be vulnerablein AD and that part of the
neurodegeneration
may be causedby induction of
cytokineinduciblein the activatedmicroglia in AD.
In part XI, two chapters,one by Burlakovaand the
otherby Richardsonet al., dealwith antioxidantdrugs.
Theseauthorspresentin vitro evidencefor the useof
antioxidantsin AD. Burlakovapresentsdata on a hybrid moleculewhich has both anticholinesterase
and
antioxidantactivity andsuggests
that successful
application of antioxidantsasneuroprotectors
will be achieved
by creatinghybrid moleculesand studyingantioxidant
action at ultra low doses.Another two chaptersdeal
with the immunemechanismin senileplaqueformation
(McGeer et al.) and inflammatory pathology in AD
(Websterand Rogers).Both chapterssuggestinterven-
reviews
75
tion with anti-inflammatoryagents.In a chapterby
McLachlanet al., theuseof aluminumchelatorssuchas
desferrioxamineto lower brain aluminum concentrations is suggested
as therapeutictools in AD.
The first two chaptersin part XII deal with behavioural disturbances.In the first, Schneiderreviewsthe
managementof agitationand depressionin dementia.
Treatmentwith serotonergicdrugsof emotionaldisturbancesin patientswith dementiadisordersis discussed
in the secondchapterby Gottfries.The third chapterin
this part by Francis et al, deals with glutamate&
hypoactivityin AD. Disturbancesof gait in patients
with dementiais reviewedby Elble.
In part XIII, the first chapterby Hanin reviewsthe
centrallycholinodeftcientanimalas a modelof AD. He
emphasizes
that the advantagesof the availability of a
centrallycholinodeficientanimalmodelareseveralfold.
In the secondchapter, Neve and Koxlowski show
elegantlythe role of the carboxyterminus@APP-ClOO)
of the Alxheimer amyloid protein precursorin AD
neurodegeneration.
They suggestthat the degeneration
of the neuronscomesabout by the binding of &APPCl00 to a newlyidentifiedmoleculelocatedon the surfaceof nervecells.However,morework remainsto be
doneto characterixethe detailedmechanismby which
flAPP-ClOOkills neuronsin or&r to developa potential
therapyfor AD. Anothertransgenicmice model,transgeniefor the human 751amino acid form of the /3amyloidprecursor protein,is discussedby Higginsand
Cordell. The histological featuresof the @APP751
transgenicmousebrain most closelyresemblesthoseof
early AD. Taken together,the studies of Neve and
Koxolwski,andHigginsand Cordellshouldprovideincreasedconfidencein transgenesis
asa meansto testadditional geneticand environmentalfactorswhich may
play a role in thedevelopmentof AD. Takedaet al., in
the third chapter,review neurofilamentpathology in
animalmodelsfor AD. Usingdifferentkinds of animal
models(fluid percussionrat model, cyclosporinA administeredrat model,Alxheimerbt@ coat inoculation
model)which weredesignedto representeachspecific
aspectof pathogenicprocessof AD, they discussthe
aberrationof cytoskeletalproteinsin thesemodels.They
speculatethat phosphorylationof neurofdamentprotein
inhibits axonal transport and eventuallyleadsto the
cytoskeletalpathologyof AD. In anothermodel,Oron
et al. studythe role of antineurofdamentantibodiesin
neurodegeneration
in AD. Their animalmodel (experimental autoimmunedementia)studiesshow that anti
NF-H IgG similar to thoseof AD patientsinducespecific neuronalandbehaviouralderangements.
In the only
chapterdealingwith primatemodels,Walker describes
the useof agednon-humanprimatesas modelsof /3amyloidoses.
Their studyindicatesthat non-humanprimatesareadvantageous
modelsfor studyingthe pathogenesisof senileplaquesand cerebrovascular
amyloid
16
Book
and for testing strategies for the diagnosis and treatment
of 8-amyloidoses. The ditTerent animal models described in this part (XIII) will be valuable in determining
disease mechanisms and in assessing potential therapeutics.
Part XIV deals with the use of imaging techniques to
monitor the effect of drugs in AD treatment. The first
two chapters by Nordberg and Tavitian et al. deal with
positron emission tomography (PET). The studies by
Nordberg indicate that functional changes can be traced
in brain after months of tacrine treatment in AD patients with mild dementia. Moreover, patients receiving
intraventricular infusion of NGF for three months have
consistently shown improvements of [ “C]-nicotine
binding in cortical brain regions as well as changes in
CBF and glucose metabolism. The studies by Tavitian et
al. describe the synthesis and application of two new
PET ligands to non-human primates’ brain imaging and
suggmt that [ “Cl-methyltacrine appear to bind to the
same cerebral sites as tacrine and [“C]-physostigmine
shows a distribution highly compatible with that of
acetykholinesterase. Taken together, the studies of
Nordberg and Tavitian et al. indicate that PET will be
important for examining a site of mechanism of action
of a certain drug as well as for evaluation of long-term
treatments in AD and to select responders to a certain
therapy. In a subsequent chapter, Robert et al. discuss
the use of single photon emission tomography (SPECT)
in early diagnosis and to monitor the effect of drugs
in AD.
Part XV deals with the clinical testing of efficacy of
new drugs in AD. The chapters deal with minimal efficacy criteria, instruments for measuring the efficacy of
treatments, psychometric strengths and weaknesses of
the AD assessment scale in clinical testing, and validation of informant based cognitive assessment for use in
autopsy.
In part XVI, the socioeconomic aspects in the treatment of AD is discussed. The costs of treatment and
care in general of AD patients is evaluated.
Part XVII deals with the future of Alxheimer treat-
reviews
ment. The first chapter by Whitehouse deals with the
biological approaches, international harmonization and
ethical issues. Whahmd et al. discuss the use of trophic
factors and reducing &amyloid deposition in the second
chapter. In the final chapter, Cacabelos discusses new
strategies for AD treatment and suggests multifactorial
strategies and compounds with pleiotropic activity.
Although there has been disappointment with the
cholinergic approaches, the fact that the only approved
treatment for AD is a cholinesterase inhibitor, and the
development of second and third generation choline&erase inhibitors, new selective muscat-ink and nicotinic compounds which are being tested in the clinic indicates that in the last decade tremendous progress has
been made in the field of cholinergic therapy. Tharapies
to slow the progression of the disease by preventing cell
death are now in the early stages of clinical trial, including drugs that act on mitochondrial metabolism,
calcium metabolism, free radicals, and neuronal viability. Considerable optimism has been placed on slowing
the progression of AD using approaches directed
towards the amyloid cascade. However, development of
more effective treatments to cure or even prevent the
disease depends on an understanding of AD pathogenesis. To summa&e, several chapters include well illustrated and well presented original material, together
with excellent summaries of previous work, others only
review old work; and, finally, some chapters fall
defiitely outside the main objective. However, on balance, the editors of this book have been quite successful.
It is certainly a volume that should be accessible to all
preclinical and clinical researchers interested in therapeutic strategies of AD.
A. A&m
Department of Geriatric Medicine
Karolinska Institutet
Huddinge University Hospital
S-141 86 Huddinge
Sweden