THE DOGON

By
T

MARCEL GRIAULE

and

GERMAINE DIETERLEN

Introduction the present stage of studies of the Dogon, and precisely because these studies seek to penetrate deeply into the mentality of the people, it is not possible to present a brief and clear-cut account of the relationship between their cosmogony and their social organization. The reader is warned from the outset, therefore, that he will not find here an exhaustive presentation of Dogon thought from the point of view with which this book is concerned; only certain institutions and concepts among those for which adequate documentation exists will be selected for discussion. The ideas of the Dogon may perhaps best be understood by considering the forms in which they express them. The basis of their thought concerning the universe and man's place in it is the 'sign', most fully elaborated in the form of a 'table of signs'.' The Dogon hold that a 'sign' or symbol and that which it symbolizes are reversible; that signs, substitutes, and images constitute a vast system of correspondences, in which every term is interlocked within what seem to be specific categories. These categories in their turn, whether linked or opposed, are themselves correlated. Social institutions and, in general, all organized human activities constitute a scheme of representations. By analogy, a parallel scheme of myths reproduces the former, but with persons, places, times, and functions transposed. This second scheme, whether esoteric or not, provides for the natives a system of references and explanations of their social institutions. 'Among the Dogon exoteric myths correspond to a 'superficial knowledge'z common to the greater part of the population; on the other hand, esoteric myths, parallel to these, present other identifications and much wider connexions. Finally, within and beyond this totality of beliefs appears a logical scheme of symbols expressing a system of thought which cannot be described simply as myth. For this conceptual structure, when studied, reveals an internal coherence, a secret wisdom, and an apprehension of ultimate realities equal to that which we Europeans conceive ourselves to have attained. The Dogon, in this system of myths and symbols, are able to express a correspondence between their social organization and the world order as they conceive it. For them social life reflects the working of the universe and, conversely, the world order depends on the proper ordering of society. Furthermore, the social order is projected in the individual, the indiSee M. Griaule and G. Dieterlen, Signes graphiques soudanais, Paris, 1951. For the knowledge possessed by the peoples of the French Sudan see G. Dieterlen, Essai sur la religion bambara, Paris, 1951.

84

AFRICAN WORLDS

visible cell which, on the one hand, is a microcosm of the whole, and, on the other, has a circumscribed function, like a cog in a machine; not only is a person the product of his institutions, he is also their motive power. Lacking any special power in himself, but because he is the representative of the whole, the individual affects the cosmic order which he also displays.

The Myths of the Dogon

In order to understand the Dogon view of their own social organization it is necessary to know their myths of creation, and a brief analytical summary of these will be given below. Their conception of the universe is based, on the one hand, on a principle of vibrations of matter, and on the other, on a general movement of the universe as a whole. The original germ of fife is symbolized by the smallest cultivated seedDigitaria commonly known as fonio and also called by the Dogon kize uzi, 'the little thing'. This seed, quickened by an internal vibration, bursts the enveloping sheath, and emerges to reach the uttermost confines of the universe. At the same time this unfolding matter moves along a path which forms a spiral or helix' (see Fig. 1). Two fundamental notions are thus expressed: on the one hand the perpetual helical movement signifies the conservation of matter; further, FIG. I The first seven vibra- this movement, which is presented diagrammatically as a zigzag line (ozu tonnolo) on the tions of the egg of the world faades of shrines, is held to represent the perpetual alternation of oppositesright and left, high and low, odd and even, male and femalereflecting a principle of twin-ness, which ideally should direct the proliferation of life. These pairs of opposites support each other in an equilibrium which the individual being conserves within itself. On the other hand, the infinite extension of the universe is expressed by the continual progression of matter along this spiral path. These primordial movements are conceived in terms of an ovoid form `the egg of the world' (aduno tal)within which lie, already differentiated, the germs of things ; in consequence of the spiral movement of extension the germs develop first in seven segments of increasing length, representing the seven fundamental seeds of cultivation, which are to be found again in the human body, and which, with the Digitaria, indicate the predominance of the Ogdoad or Divine Octet in this system of thought: the organization of the cosmos, of man, and of society (Fig. 2). At the seventh vibration
.

The circular outward and/or upward motion is represented by a helical or spiral form in Dogon signs (Ed.).

THE DOGON

85

the segment breaks its envelope. This segment is the symbol of the seed which plays a primary role in the life and thought of the Dogonthe emme ya, female sorghum, which represents life, the ideal food, immune from impurity. Having broken its wrapping the creative process emerges to follow the predestined and predetermined movement of being. For inside the first seed, and forming its central core, was an oblong plate divided into four sectors in which lay the signs corresponding to the twenty-two categories into which the universe is classified, each placed under the direction of one of the four elements: air, fire, earth, and water. In the rotatory movement of creation this plate, turning on itself, flings off the signs into space, where they come to rest, each one on the things which it symbolizes and which till then existed only potentially. At their touch every being comes into existence and is automatically placed in the predetermined category. ,All these images seem to relate to an effort of discovery, an attempt to apprehend the infinitely , small at its point of departure towards the immeasurably vast. In fact, the order of the heavens, as it is observed and conceived by the Dogon, is no more than a projection, infinitely expanded, of L fr events and phenomena which occur in the infinitely FIG. z. The prefiguring of small. man in the egg of the world The starting-point of creation is the star which revolves round Sirius and is actually named the 'Digitaria star'; it is regarded by the Dogon as the smallest and the heaviest of all the stars; it contains the germs of all things. Its movement on its own axis and around Sirius upholds all creation in space. We shall see that its orbit determines the calendar. Just as on the vegetal plane seven seeds came out of the first, so in the same way on the astral plane, from the first star came seven others bearing the names of the seven corresponding seeds. But from the moment when beings became conscious of themselves and capable of purposive action, the course of creation developed, in Dogon thought, in a less simple fashion. Personalities appeared who, after the chief person, the Creator God Amma, moved in a world of feeling, resembling man's ideas of himself and his own activities. The preceding events, as already mentioned, took place inside an enormous egg (aduno tal), a world situated in infinite space and containing the appointed model of the creation, Nommo, the son of God. This egg was divided into two twin placenta,i each of which should have contained a pair
1 In ordinary conversation the Dogon constantly use the term me for both the placenta and the amnion. We use 'placenta' here because their symbolic representations are mainly associated with that organ.

86

AFRICAN WORLDS

of twin Nommo, direct emanations and sons of God, according to the Dogon, and prefigurations of man. Like all other creatures these twin beings, living images of the fundamental principle of twin-ness in creation, were each equipped with two spiritual principles of opposite sex; each of them, therefore, was in himself a pair. We shall see how these images dominate the organization of society and of the family. In one placenta, however, the male person, for reasons which are obscure, did not await the usual period of gestation appointed by Amma but emerged prematurely from the egg. Moreover, he tore a fragment from his placenta and with it came down through space outside the egg; this fragment became the earth. This being, Yurugu, brought the fonio with him intending to make a world of his own, modelled on the first but surpassing it. This irregular procedure at the outset disorganized Amma's order of creation; the earth thus constituted was provided with a male soul only, since the being who made it was thus imperfect. From this imperfection arose the notion of impurity: earth and Yurugu were, from the beginning, solitary and impure. Yurugu, realizing that this situation would effectually prevent him from carrying out his task on earth, returned to heaven to try and find the rest of his placenta with his twin soul. But at his revolt, Amma had handed over this twin soul to the remaining pair in the other part of the egg, and had put her in their charge. Yurugu could not retrieve her; and from that time he has been engaged in a perpetual and fruitless search for her. He returned to the dry earth where now there began in the darkness to come into existence single, incomplete beings, offspring of incest ; in fact he procreated in his own placenta, in the earth, that is, with his mother. Here we have the prefiguration of certain kinship ties and sentiments. Seeing this, Amma decided to send to earth the Nommo of the other half of the egg, creators of the sky and the stars. They came down to earth on a gigantic arch, at the centre of which stood the two Nommo of the sky, who had assumed the guise of blacksmiths. At the four cardinal points were four other pairs of Nommo, avatars of the first and the ancestors of man. The four male ancestors were named Amma Seru, Ube Seru, Binu Seru, and Dyongu Seru. The arch constituted a new, undefiled earth ; its descent coincided with the appearance of light in the universe, which till then had been in darkness. Water, in the form of rain, purified and fertilized the soil in which were sown the eight seeds which the mythical ancestors brought with themeach bearing a seed; human beings, animals, and plants forthwith came into existence. The 8 ancestors first gave birth to 12 offspring consisting of 4 pairs of twins-3 of mixed sexes and t male pair as well as 2 males and 2 females. Thus the first 3 mythical generations comprised 22 persons, io of whom were female and r 2 male.' With the aid of the skills taught by Nommo, social life was organized. In this way everything which had been created in the egg was then made manifest. The advent of the arch of Nommo denotes not only the delimitation of
Totemism among the Dogon is closely linked with this descent system.

THE DOGON

87

space but also the measurement of times and seasons: the year was linked to the apparent movement of the sun, avatar of the other portion of the placenta of Yurugu; days alternated with nights and the seasons followed each other. This period of the ordering of creation extended over twenty-two years, during which all social institutions were established. The first four years correspond to the first four seed-times, which today are symbolized by the actions of the totem priests who, at the rituals of sowing, cast the millet seeds to the four cardinal points. These four sowings, which denote the planting of the whole world, were necessary to ensure the perennial resurgence of plant life, that is, symbolically, the procreation of human beings. From the fifth sowing onwards a rite was celebrated of which the name, bulu, indicates its purpose, for its meaning is `to make alive again'. Death made its appearance in consequence of events connected with the position of Yurugu in the new organization. In the myth the dry, uncultivated, uninhabited earth belongs t3 Yurugu, a being of night, whereas Nommo, a being of the day, associated with the sky, water, and fertility, rules the cultivated, habitable land.

Man
Man is the 'seed' of the universe: that is to say, he was prefigured in the seed Digitaria, the vibrations and extensions of which produced the world. This notion is expressed in the interpretation of the first seven segmentary vibrations which occurred in the first envelope. The first and the sixth produced the legs, the second and fifth the arms, the third and fourth the head, the seventh the sex organs of man (see Fig. 2). The first movements of creation were thus the first prefiguration of the being around whom everything was to be organized. But the link between man and the first creative act does not end here. The original seed first produced the image of man; conversely, man in his own person presents the image of the seed; the seven segment-vibrations also represent seven seeds, to which should be added the original Digitaria itself. These eight seeds are to be found in man's clavicles and symbolize his substance as well as his sustenance. We shall see that this notion of a vegetal series, in its various modifications, plays a dominant part in human society. Man is the image not only of creation's first beginning but also of the existing universe. The egg of the world is represented by a diagram in which it is shown filled with germinating cells, one of which extrudes downwards, while a second lies horizontally across the first at its point of exit; these two constitute the setting of the world and establish the four cardinal points. A third cell, pressing on the first, takes its place and forces it to curve on itself, forming an open egg-shape symmetrical in position with the first (Fig. 3).' The Dogon thus produce a diagram which they call 'the life of the world' and which is interpreted not only as the microcosmic
' See also 'Signes graphiques dogon' in Signes graphiques soudanais.

88

AFRICAN WORLDS

man but also as the heavenly placenta (the upper egg-form) and the earthly placenta (the lower egg-form) which are separated by the space represented by the cross. In this diagram there may also be seen a reference to the principle of twin-ness : the two egg-shapes and the two segments form two pairs of twins recalling the four primordial beings each possessing two souls. From this it follows that the supreme expression of the individual's identity with creation, the perfect creation, is a pair of twins. Like these primordial beings, man possesses two souls of opposite sexes, one of which inhabits his body while the other dwells in the sky or in water and links it to him. The vital force (nyama), which flows in his veins with his blood, is associated with the eight seeds which are distributed equally between his two clavicles. These seeds, united in pairs, are the basis of various notions concerning human personality and the changes it undergoes and they also recall the original groups of four pairs of twins (cf. p. 86). The series so constituted, the terms of which may vary from one social group to another, does not occur in the same order for every individual in the same group. Thus, within the same family the order applicable to a man will be inverted in the case of a woman; some seeds are excluded for certain social ranks or functions; they are FIG. 3. The life held to be the chief factors of social differentiation. Since of the world.' The the condition of a person mirrors the condition of the heavenly and earthuniverse, everything which affects the one has reperly placentas cussions on the other; that is to say, in some way all a man's actions and all his circumstances must be conceived as closely connected with the functioning of things in general. The seeds symbolize the food of mankind; they are the pivot on which turns the life of the cultivator, which depends as much on the seasonal renewal of vegetation as on the daily intake of food. They recall also the renewal of human life itself, which vanishes momentarily from its possessor only to be reborn in his descendants. Finally, the regular and appointed series attributed to the seeds is the sign of the universal order established on earth since the descent of Nommo. Disorder among the seeds, which for an individual results especially from the breaking of the rules of life, prefigures the universal disorder which spreads by stages from the individual to his close kinsmen, his family, his clan, his people. But the disorder may be arrested and removed at any stage by appropriate rituals. Exact and complicated, they make it possible both for the individual to be restored and the general order to be preserved. Thus the individual, through his family and the society in which he lives, is linked in his structure and in his evolution with the universe ; and this connexion operates in both directions. A human being in his development manifests the development of Nommo,

THE DOGON

89

symbol of the ordered world. Thus the new-born infant at birth is the head of Nommo; when later he becomes a herd-boy, he is the chest, at betrothal the feet, at marriage the arms, and when fully adult he is the complete Nommo; as an elder and still more as a supreme chief he is both Nommo and the totality of the world and mankind.
The Tribe

According to their own accounts, the Dogon are all derived from one stock.' This they explain by the tradition that the original four pairs of twins gave birth to four tribes, Arou, Dyon, Ono, and Domno, 2 who in theory shared the universe among themselves, and in particular the stellar system. 3 Each tribe originally had its habitation at one of the four cardinal points and was associated with one element. Naturally, also, they divided between them the various social and economic functions. 4 Their distribution is shown in the following table.
Ancestors
Amma Seru

Tribes
Arou

Cardinal Points
East

Elements
Air

Functions
Chieftainship, Medicine, Divination Agriculture Trade and Crafts Trade and Crafts'

Dyongu Seru Binu Seru Lebe Seru

Dyon Ono Domno

South West North

Fire Water Earth

This 'organization of the earth' (ganda yegru) is not only applicable to the whole people ; each tribe and smaller group must display the same divisions, and it is also believed that the system is reproduced in every individual. The Dogon express this idea by saying that in every group warfare is controlled by the male Nommo, whose shrine is placed in the centre; cultivation is under the protection of the female Nommo, whose shrines are built of the stones (sogo) of the fields; the shrines dedicated to divination are scattered over the flat, sandy land surrounding the village. The right conduct of affairs will need, first of all, the use of divination, the domain of Yurugu; then a visit to the shrines of cultivation and of war, the domain of
This refers to the internal organization of the Dogon ; there is also an international system in which the same notions are employed. It should be noted that on one level the Dogon regard three tribes as being superior in status: Arou, Dyo, and Ono. In accordance with their habit of thought it is necessary that even in the numbering of the tribes the numbers 3 and 4, symbolizing male and female, should appear. For the Dogon tribes and their present habitat see G. Dieterlen, Les Ames des Dogons. This study takes into account a fifth group, the Kor, which as far as our present knowledge goes seems to be connected with the Ono and Domno. Thus, for the purpose of making certain calculations bearing on the calendar, the sun is associated with Arou and the moon with Dyon. But through craftiness in juggling for precedence the Arou, who consider themselves the stronger, left the sun to Dyon and took the moon for themselves. This refers to the organization which existed before French occupation and which is, to a considerable extent, still preserved or recalled in certain circumstances. The Domno are coupled with the Ono in regard to functions.

90

AFRICAN WORLDS

the Nommo. Any other procedure, and particularly the omission of any of these stages, will produce disorder. On the other hand, the correct mechanism is so effective that even if it is set in motion by a stranger the results are always beneficial. 'If you wish to organize the country, the first (thing is) to practise divination, (then you must) sacrifice a chicken to Binu, a chicken to Pegu, a chicken to Ube. If you do this (even) if you are a stranger, because of you there will be peace, rain, and ripe millet!'' It should be noted that three chief functions are distributed among the four tribes; here may be seen the numerical expression of twin-ness applied in two different spheres, that of mankind and that of function; mankind as a whole (the four tribes) participates in the femininity from which it issues, and the number of which is 4; functions, which are activities, are male, and their number is 3. The number 7 (sum of the 3 and the 4) symbolizes human personality, which means, in this particular instance, that man organized in society must be active. The hierarchy of the three functions denotes also a theoretical hierarchy of tribes which, however, is the subject of continual dissension on the part of those concerned, because at the same time each group in itself possesses the same powers. This hierarchical principle is projected into the realm of material objects; thus pots, according to their size, are associated with one tribe or another: the largest are assigned to Arou, the smallest to Dyon; but in the interests of precedence and tact, in practice the order is reversed. The same principle may he seen, among other examples, in the mounds built up in the fields at the base of the millet stalks, the largest being made in fact by the Dyon, the smallest by the Arou. 2 This hierarchy is still observed today in the institution of chieftainship; the religious and political chiefs of Dyon, Ono, and Domno recognize the supremacy of the single Hogon of Arou. Thus it may be shown that, in spite of historical upheavals, the social structure of the Dogon and its organization into tribes is still valid and meaningful.
Kinship

The corporate body of kin among the Dogon is an agnatic exogamous, patrilocal and patrilineal group, and totems are inherited in the paternal line. In marriage a widespread exchange is practised and marriage with the daughter of a maternal uncle is preferred. Family relationships are variously conceived according as one is concerned with the reciprocal relationships of uterine and paternal kin, the relations between one married couple, those of the uncle and maternal nephew, or those of the different generations, &c. The original couple formed by the male and female Nommo, the twins in the heavenly placenta, is represented by a brother and sister. Thus it was formerly believed that the ideal marriage was one contracted between
' ganda yegru nammay woye pologo almaya kana binu endue obo pegi endue obo lebe endue obo kokana boye u yerne tyo kana kuwone dyam brbeniose ana di babamose yu ile bebentose.
2

In practice this rule only applies to the first mound to be made.

THE DOGON

a brother and sister. The fact that the father is not actually the mother's brother leads to a complex series of ideas and patterns of behaviour in relation to the family. In order to understand the Dogon conception of their kinship system it will be useful to consider the mythical situation of the members of two consanguineous and uterine families on several different planes. On the simplest level and the one which accounts for the twofold kinship which every individual possesses, all the relatives on the father's side are Amma (God) and all relatives on the mother's side are Nommo (the Universe), thus indicating the first expression of the principle of twin-ness which equates God with his creation. On the other hand, for any given individual, all his uterine kin represent femininity and all paternal kin masculinity. A man calls all women who are uterine kin, whatever their age, mother (na); he calls all adult men of his patrilineal kin father (ba).' In another context, in which is envisaged the individual's situation in relation to the members of his father's and of his mother's family, the Dogon adjust their classification to the mythical personages and to the era of the creation: the two grandfathers are Amma and the individual is the offspring of two pairs of Nommo, like those which, in mythical times, occupied the original placenta. One of these is symbolized by the father and the father's sister, the other by the mother's brother and the mother. This is expressed in the terms by which members of the two pairs are addressed as well as by the behaviour of the individual in relation to them. On a third plane, paternal and uterine kin groups may be considered in isolation. The paternal kin group is mythically connected with the twin Nommo who inhabited one of the two divisions of the world egg, and came down to earth after the adventure of Yurugu. In this line of descent the grandfather will be Nommo; all the sons and daughters will be the octet which includes, as we have seen, four pairs of twins of mixed sex; this justifies one of the principles of the extended family in which all the brothers and sisters are regarded as pairs of twins. Some of the names given to the first four sons are linked with the ordinal numbers which recall the series of male Nommo of the arch (see p. 86). Grandchildren represent the twelve descendants of Nommo (cf. p. 86) within the direct line, and so on. Associated with these representations is patrilineal descent, by which each individual is linked with four direct ancestors, the five generations involved symbolizing the five seed-times which followed the advent of the arch. No ancestor earlier than the great-great-grandfather is thought to affect directly the individual's personal existence. The head of the patrilineal joint family lives in the house of the family (ginna), which is that of the territorial founder of the lineage. In this house are the shrines of the ancestors to which new-born infants are presented. The patrilineal kin group is thus; held to be a reflection of the first mythical family which
' See below, p. 93.

92

AFRICAN WORLDS

emerged from that part of the world egg (see p. 86) in which all events unfold in order, the generations following one another in normal fashion. A person's uterine kin group, on the other hand, reflects the situation in that part of the original egg in which events unfolded in disorderly fashion and where the generations were irregular. Here the maternal grandfather symbolizes Amma; the next generationthat is to say, the mother and her brother (the maternal uncle)are the twin Nommo. The third generation that is, Egois, in relation to the two earlier ones, Yurugu. Just as Yurugu, breaking too soon from the womb and bearing with him a fragment of his placenta, is still, so to speak, a part of his motheris, indeed, his mother, so every individual, even if his birth was perfectly normal, is an integral part of the woman who bore him. That is to say, every individual is identified with his mother to the extent of belonging to her generation rather than his own, as though the child, after leaving the womb, continued to possess its pre-natal character as part of its mother's body, and thus belongs to the older generation. If the child is a male, he is regarded as the brother of his mother. He is therefore, as it were, a substitute for his maternal unclethe ideal husband of his mother. Since, however, the child is in fact born into the generation following that of his mother, a pattern of behaviour develops towards his elders and his collaterals which is regulated by various beliefs. The fate of Yurugu, emerging from the womb before he had attained his proper form, is to belong still to the older generation, from which resulted the incestuous union of the myth. In real life the child, even if born at full term, unconsciously preserves towards its mother the attitude of Yurugu. But since she cannot commit incest, the wife of the maternal uncle replaces the mother. This transference is explained by the fact that the couple who engendered the child must represent the original twin Nommo. That is to say, the genitors should be brother and sister and the child can regard his real father as a stranger and his maternal uncle, whose substitute he feels himself to be, as his ideal genitor. In consequence the child regards the wife of his maternal uncle as a substitute for his own mother; he addresses her as yana mo (my wife) and she calls him mu ige (my husband); he jokes with her and takes liberties (including sexual relations), thus recalling the act committed by Yurugu; on the other hand, he is allowed to plunder and rob his uncle's goods and household as much as he likes. These attitudes may also be explained by the relative situations of the souls of the people concerned regarded as reflecting the situations of the souls of mythical personages. It should be remembered that Yurugu, prematurely born, was alone with the scrap of placenta he had carried away. Moreover, he only had his male soul, for the female soul had remained in the other half of the placenta. He tried to return and possess her, but she had already been placed by Amma in the care of the Nommo in the other half of the egg. Yurugu was unable to recover her and ever since then has been
,

THE DOGON

93

pursuing a fruitless quest (cf. p. 86). The maternal nephew, in his early years, like Yurugu, lacks a wife; just as Yurugu is seeking his female soul, so the nephew is seeking a wife, a search which is concealed under the guise of thefts committed in his mother's brother's house. This situation comes to an end when the maternal uncle, who cannot give his own wife to his nephew, finds him a wife of his own who will be a substitute for the female soul he is seeking. The wife, indeed, should be chosen preferably from among the daughters of the maternal uncle, and this is frequently done. Symbolically the girl is regarded as a substitute for her husband's own mother. Clearly there is a correspondence here between the maternal uncle's daughter, his wife, and his sister, who is the mother of the nephew. The marriage is thus; in some sense, a re-enactment of the mythical incest. It is also, however, regarded as a caricature and is thus a kind of defiance hurled at Yurugu. For the existing order represents the reorganization, under the direction of Nommo, of an original situation characterized by the disorderliness of his enemy. Another consequence of the situation just described is that, in theory, brothers should always marry their sisters. Any member of one generation therefore regards all members of the previous generation as his fathers (among paternal kin) and his mothers (among maternal kin). I Not only is there tension between the individual and certain of his maternal kin, tension operates also between generations. There is rivalry between a son and his father. And, as with all the institutions of the Dogon, one must consider its mythical origin in order to discover the way in which this particular mode of behaviour is understood. We have seen how, in the original seed, there developed seven vibrations symbolized by the emerging segments of increasing size. The seventh segment, which broke the enveloping sheath and set in motion external vibrations, divided itself into two unequal parts, the shorter of which might in some sense be regarded as an eighth vibration (Fig. 2). In another context this short segment is regarded as the tip of the male sexual organ of the being represented by the seed. It is thus the emanation of a human microcosm which is itself conceived as a pair consisting of a male and a female, as is twice indicated in the representation. In fact the ideal couplerepresented by the numbers 4 (female)+ 3 (male) making 7is recalled, on the one hand in the number of the seven segments, on the other by the order (seventh) of the reproductive vibration. According to Dogon ideas, the fragment issuing from the seventh vibration is eighth in order and represents the first of a second series of seven. By virtue of being a beginning, it is incomplete in itself and for this reason is likened to Yurugu, who is essentially an incomplete being. It is to be expected, therefore, that the offspring will make demands on its genitors, and more particularly on the male, since,
' This attitude should be distinguished from that described above in which, in a different context, Ego regards all uterine kin as mothers and all consanguineous kin as fathers.
3019

94

AFRICAN WORLDS

as the symbolism shows, it is the male sex organ which in this particular situation seems to emit a segment detached from itself. This representationat once mythical and metaphysicalof the primordial relationship between father and son enables the instructed to understand existing attitudes. The son bears his father a grudge on account of his initial incompleteness. At the same time he resents his father's part in begetting him, which clearly shows that he is not wholly the product of his mother, that he is not derived entirely from the maternal 'root' (du). It would be some consolation if he could regard himself as the son of his mother and his maternal uncle, that is to say, of two genitors springing from the same 'root'. Even so, he would be hostile to this genitor because the uncle, by begetting other children, would give him brothers like himself. The son, indeed, believes that at the moment of sexual intercourse his father implants in his mother a seed similar to that from which he himself was born; thus it seems to him that his father sets no store by the previous child since he wishes to make him over again. This feeling towards the father has repercussions on the sentiments which brothers feel for one another. Each in fact regards all the others as rivals, both in regard to property and to women.
Territorial Organization Districts, countryside, villages

The country of the Dogon has been organized as far as possible' in accordance with the principle that the world developed in the form of a spiral. In theory the central point of development is formed by three ritual fields, assigned to three of the mythical ancestors and to the three fundamental cults. When laid out they mark out a world in miniature on which the gradual establishment of man takes place. Starting from these three fields, the fields belonging to the various kin groups, and finally individual fields, are sited along the axis of a spiral starting from this central area. The various shrines are similarly distributed according to the same plan and, in theory, sacrifices should be offered in the same order as the shrines, on the line of a spiral starting from the centre. The Dogon even say that, in accordance with the original rule, when land is to be cleared the cultivators must work with their backs to the edge of the last field and the area cleared must be of such a shape that the opposite side is much longer than the side from which they start. Thus each field will be an irregular and, as it were, twisted quadrilateral, two sides of which will form a very wide angle opening towards the fields which will subsequently be cleared. This angle symbolizes the continuous extension of the world. Another form of organization is, moreover, embedded in the foregoing. Every extended family should possess eight fields grouped in pairs and
In most cases the nature of the country, the contours, and the siting of watercourses necessitate compliance with the rule.

THE DOGON

95

facing towards the four cardinal points; each of these pieces of land is associated with one of the eight original seeds. As the theoretical arrangement of fields and the process of clearing the ground reproduce the primitive spiral form, so the method of cultivation recalls the more delicate vibratory movement of the axis of the spiral. This screw-like movement, which is represented on shrines and in caves by a zigzag line, is reproduced in the old method of cultivation which is like the technique of weaving; it consists in starting on the north side, moving

r
a

FIG.

4. Theoretical layout of cultivated land around the

three original fields

from east to west and returning from west to east. Each line of millet planted is eight feet long, and a typical patch of planted land comprises eight lines, recalling the eight ancestors and the eight seeds. Moreover, the cultivator advances along the line changing his hoe from one hand to the other at every pace, like the action of weaving, whereby the thread of the woof is fitted into the warp, which itself symbolizes cultivation and the advance of man's labour in uncultivated land. The purposive repetition of the processes of creation is carried yet farther: the different tribes combine to work their land in accordance with the same detailed symbolism, each one, when cultivating, moving in the opposite direction from the next. That is to say, in theory each tribe observes its own rule in working on its own land so that the country as a whole is cultivated in every possible direction. Just as the original vibration in the first seven segments (see Fig. a) prefigured man, who is placed at the centre of the universe, so at the centre of

96

AFRICAN WORLDS

the territorial organization, embedded in the three fields which constitute the point of departure, is situated the village, itself a symbol of man. The village may be square like the first plot of land cultivated by man, or oval with an opening at one end to represent the world egg broken open by the swelling of the germinating cells. Whatever its shape it is a person' and must lie in a north to south direction; the smithy is the head and certain particular shrines the feet. The huts used by women at their menstrual periods, situated east and west, are the hands; the family homesteads form the chest, and the twin-ness of the whole group is expressed by a foundation shrine in the form of a cone (the male sexual organ) and by a hollowed stone (female organ) on which the fruit of the Lannea acida is ground to express the oil. 2 Not only is the village anthropomorphic but each part or section of it is a complete and separate entity and, so far as possible, must be laid out on the same pattern as the whole. Thus, individual families are fitted into a grouping which itself is a unity. Finally, if such a group of habitations is seen from above or from a height, the fields shining in the sun on the one hand and the shadows cast on the earth on the other resemble hillocks of cultivated land casting their shadows into the hollows. And this is a picture of the little family homestead which bears on its faade eighty incised lines of shadow separated by bright surfaces. Furthermore, this facade is a substitute for the black-andwhite checked blanket which resembles the appearance of cultivated fields and the alternation of light and shadow in the rows of hillocks. Thus the settlement where men dwell close together is a representation both of man himself and of the layout of the fields outside the walls. This is a way of calling to mind the fact that the processes of germination and gestation are of the same kind. In accordance with the principle of twin-ness, villages are built in pairs, one of which is often referred to as Upper and the other as Lower. A pair of villages of this sort is regarded as the heaven and earth (Nommo and Yurugu) united, and also as the representation of man (see Fig. 5). The same pattern is repeated in the layout of the district which, at the present time, often coincides with the administrative unit (canton). This area is divided into two parts, one known as Upper and the other as Lower; it is also marked by an open space or public meeting-place in the village where the Hogon, the district chief, lives. In theory this open space should be round like the sky which it represents. The shrine of Lebe at its centre symbolizes the sun, and around it are various shrines belonging to the Binu of the founders, and representing the most important stars. In fact, in the open space called lebe dala in Upper Ogol of Upper Sanga
' See M. Griaule, Dieu d'eau, Paris, 1948, p. 1 i8. This, in theory, is the position of the male shrine (pegu); out of respect for the female sex, represented by the hollow stone, and for the women of the village, the male shrine is often built outside the walls.
2

THE DOGON

97

there are nine shrines placed in three parallel lines, the central one facing south. The central shrine of Lebe ; which in one sense is the first, also has the number nine which is associated with chieftainship. The other eight are substitutes for the shrines of the family fields, beneath which specimens of the eight original seeds are buried. They are also the eight ancestors of the arch of the world of which the meeting-place itself is a symbol. In a sense it might be said that the place known as lebe data represents the coming down to earth of a new world, borne by the eight ancestors who have now assumed the form of the eight stone altars. The Homestead It is possible to go into yet more detail; the basic structure of the village consists of a group of dwellings, among which may be distinguished the big house (ginu da) of each lineage, the plan of which clearly demonstrates all that has been described above. The big house comprises the dembere or 'room of the belly', that is to say, the central room, around which are placed a kitchen (obolom),. three store-rooms (kana), a stable for goats (ende) and the denna or big room, flanked by the entrance (day) and another stable (bel de). On either side of the entrance and at the angles of one of the rooms are four conical towers surmounted by domes (arsobo). The plan of the building is said to represent, on the one hand, Nommo in his human form, the towers being his limbs; on the other hand, the kitchen and stable are said to be the heavenly placenta and its earthly counterpart, together representing the head and legs of a man lying on his right side, whose other limbs also have their architectural counterparts : the kitchen represents the head, whose eyes are the stones of the hearth;' the trunk is symbolized by the dembere, the belly by the other room, the arms by the two irregular lines of store-rooms, the breasts by two jars of water placed at the entrance to the central room. Finally, the sex organ is the entry which leads by a narrow passage to the work-room, where the jars of water and the grinding-stones are kept. On these, young fresh ears of new corn are crushed, yielding liquid which is associated with the male seminal fluid and is carried to the left-hand end of the entry and poured out on the shrine of the ancestors (Fig. 5). The plan of the house, then, represents a man lying on his right side and procreating. 2 This attitude has a logical consequence: the differences in height of the roofs over the rooms and sheds, whether or not there is more than one story, express the diversity of the beings which issued from the ejected seeds. Each part of the building represents an original being germinating and growing from its genitor. The whole plan is contained in an
The hearth, which is also a symbol of breathing, is often made of two stones placed against the wall at the back of the kitchen. The round cooking-pot rests on the stones and leans against the wall. A dead body is placed in this position in the grave, and the same attitude is adopted by the man on the marriage bed.

98

AFRICAN WORLDS

oval which itself represents the great placenta from which have emerged, in course of time, all space, all living beings, and everything in the world. Procreation is also expressed in the patronage under which the house is placed; while the sirige house, also called tire gingi, 'the house of the ancestors',' belongs to the Fox ( Yurugu), the 'big house' is placed under the sign

**,

incline( 4tones

Tow

FIG. 5. The family homestead and the man

of Nommo the Demiurge, the reorganizer of the world. Thus the thunder stone (andugo) placed on the central terrace may be explained as a materialization of Nommo, who comes down in rain and fire. The stone itself is fire and water, and near it are placed the funerary urns of the ancestors, who are regarded as the human representatives of Nommo through the ages. Thus the same pattern, continually repeated on an ever-expanding scale, leads from man to the cosmos, each stage of the process also representing
' See Dieu d'eau, pp. ios sq.

THE DOGON

99

the whole, while a series of material avatars leads from the world itself to smaller and smaller groupingsdistrict, village, village-section, homestead.' The Hogon The chief of a district among the Dyon, the Ono, and the Domno is given the title of Hogon, and the same designation is applied to the single chief of the Arou. Primarily the Hogon is the representative of his group, which is divided into seven age classes, he himself constituting an eighth. These eight classes symbolize the eight ancestors and are represented in each village by eight elders, who possess the necessary knowledge and who act as a corporate body, having been constituted as such by means of various rituals. Thus, the chief stands for the group as a whole ; but the seven classes and the chief are represented by a chapter of eight notables who, to some extent and in specific situations, act in their name. That is, the chief does not rule alone, but is assisted by a council. Every Hogon is the successor of Ube Seru (see p. 89) and as such is responsible for one of the two seeds of which Ube Seru had charge, to wit the female sorghum (emme ya), which is in some sort a substitute for all cultivated seeds and thus sustains the soul and the vital energy. It is the typical seed and the symbol of the cultivation which purifies the unclean soil of Yurugu. The Hogon is also the head of the totem priests, who represent the other seven principal seeds. The motions of their souls are in harmony with the rhythm of all cultivated plants, and therefore the Hogon is ruler of all land laid out in cultivation and of all the rituals connected with it. But since the seeds are the earthly images of the stars, the Hogon controls the cosmic rhythm, and is thus the personification of the universe and the regent of Nommo on earth. In consequence, all his material attributes and all the prerogatives attaching to his function represent the qualities and movements of the cosmic mechanism. The Clothing of the Hogon The usual dress of the Hogon consists of a tunic, trousers, a head-dress, and sandals. The tunic is made of strips of cotton cloth sewn together to form a long rectangle, which is folded over and sewn along the edges, leaving openings for the arms and a slit in the folded part for the head. This garment, which is the general dress of all the Dogon, resembles the Egyptian calasiris, but those worn by the Hogon and the notables, unlike the common style, have wide sleeves. The white threads of the warp are striped, with the red, white, dark blue and light blue threads of the woof. These colours symbolize the four cardinal points, the elements, and, in general, the world; but the name of the garment, arge bunugu (lit. the tunic which has not
' See M. Griaule, 'L'image du Monde au Soudan,, Journal de la Soc. des Africanistes,
xix, 1949, pp. 8i - 88.

loo

AFRICAN WORLDS

come), indicates that it cannot achieve the size or the diversity of the world owing to its limited dimensions and the small number of colours which compose it. To express the universal character of this garment, all the Arou contribute to the cost of their chief's dress, which is woven by a Dyon. Conversely, the tunic worn by a Hogon of the Dyon is woven by an Arou. The trousers, which are white or dark blue, have on the front and back of the legs four coloured stripes to which the same significance is attached as to the colours in the tunic. The sandals represent the arch of Nommo, the point of the toe being the east. The moon is symbolized by the button which fastens them and the sun by a disk on the heel. This interpretation is valid for the Arou, while for the Dyon it is reversed. The button is ornamented with a cluster of twenty-four cowries, representing the twenty-two categories, with two added for the original Nommo. Finally, the sandal is the image of the Hogon, the point of the toe being regarded as the head, the heel as the feet. The head-dress symbolizes even more clearly the function and the quality of its wearer, particularly in the case of the supreme chief of Arou. It is in the shape of a cylinder, slightly convex at the back, made of basketwork woven from the stalks of the seven sacred plants (millet, sorghum, hibiscus, &c.). The weaving produces a spiral pattern from the centre of the crown to the edge, which symbolizes the path followed by the original seed. Eight Hogons, representing the eight ancestors, share in its making. Not counting the female sorghum (emme ya), which is quite separate, the stalks of the seven other seeds used in the head-dress symbolize the seven colours of the rainbow. In any serious emergency the chiefs assemble round the head-dress of the Hogon of Arou, who then invokes the god Amma and, before all the assembled company, speaks into his head-dress and places it on the ground, as if it were a world turned upside down which had to be restored to order. With this head-dress, whose shape suggests the moon, the chief indicates the position of the planet in its various phases.' So important is the head-dress (in which resides the female soul of the chief) that he may not go out wearing it on his head, for if he did the course of the moon would be disturbed and thereby that of the seasons. At the death of its owner the head-dress is deposited in a granary at his home, which is opened on this occasion only; it is regarded as the shell of the world-egg since it contains all the potency of dead chiefs and all the seeds symbolized by their headdresses.
The Homestead of the Hogon

The house of the Hogon of Arou, paramount chief of the Dogon, is so built as to present a model of the universe. It portrays, either by figures made of millet pulp or in reliefs of puddled earth, the beneficent heavens. On the wall behind the platform or dais on which the Hogon sits are
' See p.

THE DOGON

tot

painted the northern stars to the left, the stars of the south to the right.' This diagram is divided in two by a vertical row of four hemispherical earthen bosses, the topmost of which is level with the ceiling of the room above the platform. Each boss is decorated with a spiral of four coils, representing the descent of the world, and is itself the centre of four rays, with four intercalary rays. Each of the four sections of the three lower bosses on the wall represents a lunar month, while the boss at the ceiling symbolizes the head of the Hogon and the thirteenth month. In another context the four bosses are interpreted as the four seasons which, like the lunar months, serve to sustain the head-dress of the Hogon. Facing the platform, the sun is represented on the wall between the two doors of the east. This egg-shaped relief is painted red and surrounded by twenty-two rays of the same colour symbolizing the twenty-two chieftainships of the Dogon world. 2 The solstices are represented by two smaller ovals placed to right and left of the doors. In the wet season the Hogon's pouch, called 'the pouch of the world', is hung on the left, while his staff, called 'the axis of the world', is placed on the right. In the dry season their respective positions are reversed. The Hogon's platform is made of sun-dried mud, in which are embedded fragments of the dry stalks of eight varieties of millet; eight store-rooms set in the walls also represent these eight cereals. The house is entered by a flight of eight stairs representing the first eight chiefs; thus the Hogon follows in the steps of his predecessors. To the left of the entrance is the Hogon's own but or shelter (toguna) which is also approached by eight steps. Beside it are eight stones, representing the eight mythical predecessors, which serve as seats when the Hogon sits in judgement. The whole arrangement of standing stones reproduces the great constellations, especially Sirius and its cluster. To the right of the entrance is the hearth where beer is brewed; a row of eight stones represents the Hogons of the future. By the side of these a hollow stone serves as altar where the spirits of dead chiefs come to drink. The daily life of the Hogon is thus set against a background which presents the world in miniature, and in reference to which his ceremonial acts and movements symbolize the motive power which animates the whole. At dawn, seated with his face towards the east, he is present at the rising of the sun; he then proceeds to walk through his homestead following the order of the four cardinal points. At the end of the day he takes his seat facing towards the west. His walks abroad are similarly regulated: he may never go outside the homestead during the season of vegetal growth when his two souls are in close communion with the spirit of the corn. The beginning and end of this period are marked by libations of water, one from
' The diagram is here described as facing the observer; actually, for the Dogon left and right are reversed since the symbols are arranged with reference to the chief when seated on the platform facing the assembled company. In theory there are five Ono and five Domno chiefdoms. The Arou and Dyon each have six. In fact there is only one Arou chiefdom, which is, nevertheless, counted as six.

102

AFRICAN WORLDS

the first rains and the other from the last. In the dry season, however, when growth is suspended, the Hogon enjoys greater freedom of movement except at the time of the new moonthat is, when the moon is not yet `out'. Thus the Hogon by his clothing represents the world; by his movements about his home he participates in the universal rhythm of things, and in addition he controls the calendar through his links with the motion of the stars, and particularly the moon.' On the other hand, he is set at the midpoint of time, between two theoretically equal series of predecessors and successors, symbolized by the steps placed before his doorway and his judgement seat.

The Hogon and millet beer

Just as his clothing and his homestead are necessary elements in the exercise of the Hogon's power, and substitutes, in their particular spheres, for the whole universe, so also the large yeast-container belonging to the chiefdom is the image of the world. This vessel, of a different shape from those used for making beer in other cults, consists of a large cap-shaped container made of basket-work with four small tassels hanging from its rim, and represents the sun in the centre of the four cardinal points. When the beer is being brewed, it is dipped in the boiling liquid in which the grains of millet have lost their vitality; this signifies the plunging of the sun, with its rays and the world which depends on it, into a state of death in preparation for the renewal of spring and in order to set in motion again the phases of creation. The baobab fibre of which the vessel is made is a substitute for all vegetation and, in particular, for the original seed; the bubbling of the fermenting beer recalls the movements of living beings struggling to emerge from the enclosing sheath. Finally, the pattern of its weaving resembles the chief's head-dress woven from the stalks of eight grain plants, and signifies the moment when men first obtained possession of seeds. At the sigui ceremony, which is held every sixty years and at which one of the chief ritual actions is the drinking of fermented liquor, the Hogon makes the first brew of beer and reserves a portion of it which is distributed to every family and mixed with their own beer. In this way the chief signifies his control of all brewing, and this has many important consequences which it is impossible to discuss here. 2 It
' Each Hogon, in the territories within his jurisdiction, and with due regard to arrangements in neighbouring areas, fixes the dates of the various rites and ceremonies. So great is his authority in this sphere that he can omit an important feast without anyone daring to remind him of it. Some chiefs often do so intentionally to display their power. Thus the procession of leaf masks in Sanga was not held at all in 1949 and took place very late in 195o. 2 We cannot touch on its connexion with the primordial placentas or with copper or with numerology, nor yet its function in the purification of the earth, in drunkenness, in pregnancy, or the part it plays according to the different kinds of beer used in the various cults, or the influence of the varieties of cereals used, &c.

THE DOGON

103

may be pointed out, however, that everyone must be seated when drinking, because the seated position symbolizes founding and planting and thus to drink while seated is to found villages and set plants in the earth. On the other hand, the liquor purifies the man who drinks so that he becomes, as it were, the scene of a resurrection. The living seeds, which died in the boiling liquid, were restored to life in the process of fermentation and finally live again in man. The drinking of the beer causes the seeds to come in contact with the living grain with which the human clavicles are filled; the beer passes out of the body again in the urine which makes its contribution to the family dunghill. The dung, containing dry straw which once was living, will itself distribute the ferment of life to the fields. The economic functions of the Hogon The Hogon controls all trade. Before the arrival of the French, and until quite recently, this control was exercised through his regulation of markets. Until 1932 the Hogon's drums, on the eve of a market, beat out instructions for the population as to the procedure to be followed on the morrow. But even at that date this was no more than a gesture, the relic of an institution of which the chief ceremony used to be celebrated by the supreme Hogon of Arou. At the time of the first-fruits sacrifice, an assembly of all the chiefs was held on the parade-ground of the court on which was drawn the 'diagram of the world'a human figure whose head lay to the south and whose arms were indicated by a triple row of dots symbolizing cowries. This figure, on which the assembled chiefs stood, represented, among other things, the accounting system required for trading. Thus the three rows of 20 dots forming the arms gave the number 6o, known as the 'Mande reckoning', which was formerly used in the West Sudan.' The circle formed by the head and the open circle of the two legs, symbols of the male and female Nommo, each represented TO, the whole and perfect number. 2 The sum of 20 (that is, sox 2) and 6o gives 8o, the basis of the later system of reckoning in French Sudan. But to the value of each Nommo may be added the unity which it represents; thus, if only the one pair is 22, the number of the taken into account, the result will be ( to+ = original categories in which all things and living beings were classified. This arrangement of numbers on the Hogon's parade-ground was not accidental; in theory the Hogons of Arou formed series of sixty, reckoning by their funerary urns. At the same time the parade-ground is, as it were, the site of a great market square on which are displayed the cowries represented by the sixty dots marked out in millet pulp. But the cowries themselves, on which the assembled chiefs stand, are an avatar of the finger-nails
' For the system of reckoning based on 6o see G. Dieterlen, Essai sur la religion bambara, Paris, p. 27, n. 1. 2 The number to is a repetition of unity. See D. Zahan, 'Apercu sur la pens& theogonique des Dogon', Cahiers internationaux de sociologic., vi, 1949, p. 117; G. Dieterlen, op. cit., p. 213.

104

AFRICAN WORLDS

of one of the cult ancestors which he left in his grave;' they signify, therefore, finger-tips counting out money and handing it over in payment. 7'otemism Totemism among the Dogon emphasizes the fact that men belong to twenty-two categories, and demonstrates the links which bind them to the universe, all the elements of which are similarly classified. In theory, and on one plane, the Dogon believe that the eight original ancestors sprang from eight families each of which ruled an eighth part of the universe (see p. 89). Each family was united in substance with that whole and thus all animals and plants in the corresponding series were taboo to it, while each individual in the family was linked to one specimen of each animal and plant. 'When a man is born, because he is their head, all the tabooed animals are born at the same moment.'z But because this situation was burdensome and man was entangled in too complex a mesh of prohibitions, the rule was applied only to some animals and plants. The cult of Binu, which may be described as totemic, is associated with with that of Lebe, one of whose attributes is the female sorghum (came ya) brought to earth by the monitor of the arch called Lebe Seru, who died and returned to life after cleansing the soil. When the arch arrived on earth, another monitor, Binu Seru, made war on l'urugu, who had stolen the seven seeds intended for man. Twenty-two animals took part in this struggle, seven of which were on the side of the victorious Nommo, Binu Seru. 3 To mark the recovery of the stolen goods, he handed on to his successor Dewa the stone duge, symbol of the seven seeds, and on it the cult of Binu was founded. Dewa, whose name was given to the totem of which he became the priest, divided his goods, his attributes, and his functions among twenty-two original cults, each of which is attached to a particular Binu with its own special name ; this division corresponded to the order of the universe, itself divided into twenty-two categories. The seven animals who had been the allies of Nommo, and the seven plants associated with them, were all taboo for the priests of the twenty-two Binu, acting as substitutes for their groups.
' See M. Griaule, Dieu d'eau, p. 66. It should be noted that here there is another reference to the basic 80. Actually, the ancestor put down 8 cowries with 5 fingers, thus indicating that the first great unity was 8 tens. (According to Dogon thinking, 8 must here be multiplied by 5, giving 4o for each hand and 8o for the 2 hands considered as instruments for counting with.) These two bases of reckoning-6o and 8oare complementary, for Dogon as for various other West Sudanese peoples. Sixty represents 3 times the number of a man's fingers and toes and therefore is male (see p. go); 8o represents 4 times the number of the human person and so is female. Moreover, and this shows how the maximum use is always made of symbols, 6 is twice the number 3 which represents masculinity; 8 is twice 4, the feminine number. These two numbers sum up the primordial situation in the world-egg where two pairs of twins developed simultaneously. 4 M. Griaule, Dieu d'eau, p. 155. ' The fifteen other animals were allies of Yurugu; they became unclean and died and are now portrayed by the first fifteen animal masks.

THE DOGON

105

The division into 22 Binu corresponds to the 22 members of the first 3 mythical generations which comprise, first, the 2 original Nommo; second, the 8 Nommo ancestors of the arch ; third, their 12 human descendants4 pairs of twins and 4 single individuals. But as the families of the Dogon increased in number and expanded territorially, the 22 original Binu divided into as many segments as were necessary, and as they divided their names were changed, the segments often adopting other taboos to distinguish them from the original group ;' all the priests, however, continued to observe the basic double series of seven taboos. Every individual is attached to the Binu of his father and therefore belongs to an exogamous agnatic group wider than his major lineage. 2 This affiliation is indicated by the name of the Binu which is given to him by the priest at his birth. Rules of endogamy and exogamy applied to clans and smaller groups are expressed in terms of the compatibility of the symbolic contents of the clavicles of each group. As we have seen, the clavicles are thought to contain a series of seeds, eight in theory, peculiar to each people. It is also accepted that, as regards the Dogon, each tribe is distinguished from the others by the particular order in which the same series of seeds is placed. It has not yet been possible to study fully the variations in the series of seeds in relation to what might be called the totemic clan. The cult of Binu, integrated as it is with that of Lebe, is primarily aimed at promoting growth in the widest sense of the term ; that is to say, it is concerned to secure the well-being not only of the crops but also of men, the bearers of the seeds and partakers of their substance. During the period between the harvest and the next seed-time, the totemic shrines house the spirit of the corn embodied in ears or clusters gathered under certain specified conditions. The seeds from these are put into circulation again by the priests at the next sowing; during the rains they throw them down from the terrace to be gathered up by the women and mixed with the new seed. As regards men, the Binu guardian of the clan bestows on each the clavicular seeds associated with his two souls. A breach of the Binu taboo deprives the offender of his seeds, which the Binu takes away; the purification ceremony proper to the Binu cult consists in restoring these seeds to the one who has lost them. It thus appears that the Binu dispenses the seeds of the clan, and that he is concerned with the sustenance of its members and with the substance proper to them. It follows that the Binu preserves the special character of each person as member of a particular clan, tribe, and people.
I This is why, though they have different names and different taboos, all the Binu of the Kamme district are derived from one single Binu, which was that of the founders. Cf. Tait, 'An Analytical Commentary on the Social Structure of the Dogon', Africa,

xx, 3, 1 95 0 , PP. 175-99.

to6

AFRICAN WORLDS

Technology Iron-working

Among the Dogon, as among all the peoples of the Western Sudan, ironworking is one of the most important crafts. Iron-workers are, in a sense, a separate race, whose members, in some localities no more than a single family, are found all over the Sudan. Among the Dogon only the dyemnte na (lit. great skinan allusion to the bellows) are regarded as iron-workers by origin; the irin are Dogon who practise the craft by permission of the former and after the requisite initiation. In fact, however, they perform the same functions as if they were craftsmen by origin.' Iron-workers are an endogamous group in relation to the rest of the Dogon, the prohibition of sexual relations being based, as has already been said, on differences in the symbolic contents of the clavicles. In theory these craftsmen own no land nor do they receive any direct payment for the agricultural implements which they make or repair. At harvest-time they are given a portion which constitutes their recompense. The special position occupied by these men, a state of economic and cultural symbiosis, derives, in Dogon belief, from the fact that they are the culture heroes of agriculture who came to earth on the arch. In addition to the clavicular seeds, the original iron-worker had in his hammer eight others intended for men. The violent collision with the earth when he arrived there broke his limbs, providing him with joints enabling him to do his work; at the same time his anvil buried itself in the ground, thereby cleansing the earth and giving itland mencultivable grain. The iron-worker, as a result, suffered a diminution of energy, but this put him on an equality with other men. According to Dogon notions, this enfeeblement constituted a kind of uncleanness, though of a different sort from ordinary impurity. The situation of iron-workers is characterized by a diminution of vital energyz which excludes them from the category of ordinary 'living' men (omo). But this diminution is not comparable to that of death, which also divides them from men who are by destiny 'unclean' (puru). Neither are they to be ranked with 'white' men, such as leatherworkers, witch-doctors, basket-makers, wood-workers, &c. In one sense they are diminished, but in another sense they are increased, because they have given their energy for the common good. Along with this ambivalent position there is a recognition of the unquestioned superiority of the craftsman who, in relation to the exercise of his ritual functions, is thought to possess all the seeds which were his at the time of his arrival on earth.
Weaving

The Dogon make a large range of narrow lengths of cloth, plain-coloured and striped, the most usual colours being indigo, white, and red ; these are used chiefly to make clothing and blankets. Weaving is held to be one of the
3

This is admitted to be a fiction but it is universally accepted. Cf. Dieu d'eau, p. los.

THE DOGON

107

original crafts, and innumerable symbolic images are associated with it. It is said that 'cloth is the centre of the world', that it expresses everything, since the originating signs of all things were traced in it. The Nommo who invented weaving used his jaw-bone for loom and his tongue for shuttle. He wove into the cloth the words which were bringing in a new order.' In another way the weaver imitates the Nommo who, springing from the clavicles of God, forthwith wove together the four elements contained therein and made from them the whole universe. Just as he drew the four elements from the clavicles of God, so the weaver draws his threadsthat is, the four elementsfrom the spindles, the clavicles of the loom. In some sort, textiles form seven 'families' comprising twenty-two principal strips corresponding to the categories of the universe. It seems that the total number must, in theory, be equal to the number of signs inscribed in the original seed (see p. 85). For the strip of cloth is itself a sign and connotes a myth, partial or completea material or spiritual image. To wear a particular cloth, 2 to possess a certain blanket, is therefore to display a symbol which, in practice, corresponds to the physical or moral condition of the wearer, to his social and religious functions and his ordinary activities, which are themselves in harmony with the rhythm of the universe. As among the Bambara, there is a 'science of cloths' which is an account of the mechanism of creation. In the Dogon mind this knowledge is identified with its subject and therefore the possession of the complete number of cloths in the form of a blanket represents the ideal form of wealth, the acme of riches. It is possible to exceed this number, but to acquire twice the ideal number of twenty-two kinds of cloth would be excessive. A man in such a case would surpass the god Amma and draw down disaster on his people. For this reason men are reluctant to display the family heritage of cloths, for this would be to reveal to the common gaze both the supreme expression of wealth and the symbols of cosmic knowledge. These possessions are never shown except at the death of the family head, at a moment when, in theory, the social upheaval would forbid anyone to count the goods or detect hidden motives. To exhibit cloths at a funerary ceremony is evidence that death has 'gathered up' 3 the whole universe under the form of the symbols which also constitute wealth.
Mangu: An International Alliance

The original situation of the ideal coupletwins enclosed in the same eggis also illustrated in a religious and economic relationship maintained between the Dogon and the Bozo which has existed, it is said, from the earliest times. This institution, which flourishes over a wide area, is
' For the myth of the invention of weaving see ibid., pp. 35 sq. It may be simply a piece of cloth inset in a garment made of plain strips. This word may bear the meaning 'to receive for the purpose of hoarding or treasuring' as well as `to sustain the moral burden' of the knowledge represented by the objects.
2

198

AFRICAN WORLDS

known as a 'joking relationship', though the term 'cathartic alliance' has been suggested for it.' A Dogon myth relates that when the reorganization of man first began, Dogon and Bozo, represented by the Nommo spirits, had in their clavicles eight seeds and eight fishes respectively. `The most important thing in the world for the mangu (ritual partner)' say the natives, `is the seeds in his clavicles'. 2 By this means the Bozo are marked out as fishermen and the Dogon as cultivators. When they came down to the newly made world together, they made a pact whereby they became mutually complementary. This solemn act, at once a consecration and a recognition of the contents of their clavicles, took place on the original field in which the iron-worker's anvil was embedded. His hammer was beating out the rhythm of the first operations and, since hammer and anvil participated in the form and nature of the universal systemin this instance regarded as a granarythe pact was bound up with the rhythm of those two symbols. By the oaths which they exchanged the two eponymous ancestors, who were already twins, confirmed their complementary relationship; each, by the words he spoke, penetrated the other, depositing within his partner something of himself. This `bridgehead' formed by energy proceeding from himself enabled each to act effectively and with impunity on the other, more especially in that essential action which directly or indirectly effects purification, and which seems to be one of the chief aims of the alliance. This complementary state is deeply felt and is expressed in two typical instances in the material life of the two peoples. For the Dogon cultivator the double ear of millet, and for the Bozo fisherman the fish izu ya3 represent this relationship of twin-ness. If a cultivator finds in his field an ear of millet (yu) with two tufts, he immediately cuts it, takes it to the family shrine and, at the next sowing, the family head will distribute four grains to each member of the family in order to ensure him an abundant harvest. At the same time one grain is thrown in the direction of Bozo territory, 4 which amounts to giving them half the ear, that is, half the good fortune and the abundance, as one would do for a twin. In the same way, if a Bozo catches an izu ya, he must immediately seek a Dogon to eat it with him. If he cannot find one, he simply puts a piece of the fish in with the catch he is taking to market; if he still fails to meet a Dogon
' See G. Dieterlen, 'Les correspondances cosmo-biologiques chez les Soudanais',Journal de Psychologie normale et pathologique, juill.-sept. 195o ; M. Griaule, 'L'alliance cathartique', Africa, xviii. 4, Oct. 1948, pp. 242-8. aduno magu dye wogo dene inne gozen togodige. ' Lit. female fish ; the species is Gnatonemus Stanleyanus. 4 The grain is in fact thrown towards the Bamba cliffs. The mangu system, based on the Bozo-Dogon alliance, has, for geographical reasons, been transferred by the Dogon within their own society and applied to territorial and kinship groups. Dogon and I3ozo are a considerable distance from one another; the geographical proximity of Dogon groups participating in the mangu relationship (by 'oath, alliance, or blood) enables purification rituals to be carried out without delay and without requiring the parties to make long journeys ; the partners are thought to have, in relation to each other, sixteen seeds in their clavicles. In this way the people of Sanga are linked with those of Ilamba.

109 he tries again at the next market, substituting another fish for the first, and so continues till he has been able to share his find with a Dogon. Only then will he feel that he has discharged the debt he has incurred by catching a fish which symbolizes twin-ness. But it is not only in circumstances such as these that the two groups are under an obligation to provide reciprocal gifts and services; they normally acknowledge a wide range of obligations of all kinds, particularly in regard to food. These relations are characterized by exchanges of insults and jests, often of an obscene nature, which may be easily observed and have often engaged the attention of investigators.' It might be said, indeed, that this is the characteristic method of establishing the relationship; the insult is in fact directed at that part of oneself which resides in the other and which one is trying to recover. It is as if one attempted to detach some of the seeds from the other and appropriate them for oneself. Here, acting in another direction, is a mechanism comparable to that of purification. The relationship is attended by taboos, any breach of which will have most serious consequences: the mangu must never, in any circumstances, shed the blood of a partner; the penalty for transgression is impotence. Murder is thought to entail the death of the murderer. Sexual relations between members of the two groups are forbidden: they would unquestionably be incestuous, and would result in the guilty parties being completely denuded of the sustenance lodged in their clavicles. That is to say, the Dogon would lose his millet, the staple grain which no other transgression can affect, and would be, as it were, emptied of his substance. The benefits of this institution are not confined to relations between the two peoples. Within their own society the Dogon have woven a close web of relationships all of which, in different degrees, recall the Bozo pact, and many examples could be given of alliances between groups of regions, between regions, between villages, and between kin-groups. Traditionally, the oldest of these alliances is that which links Bamba with a number of other regions, and is explained by the story that a Bamba man was travelling through the Sanga region at a very unsettled time. On the way he was set upon by six bandits, whereupon he cried out `Mangu! mangu!' The brigands, disconcerted, put their heads together and asked the advice of an old man, who told them to spare him ; they all thought he was a Bozo since the Bozo were the only people with whom the Dogon had relations, so the man escaped. Later the fraud was discovered, but the precedent became a rule and the alliance between the Bamba and the people of the plateau came to be included in the BozoDogon system of relationships. 'All the mangu here (that is, all the relationships between Dogon)', said the Elder Ongnulu, 'copy the Bozo mangu.' The importance of such an institution is obvious ; those who participate
THE DOGON It is this detail of the whole mechanism which has given rise to the name 'joking relationship'.
E 3014 1

Ito

AFRICAN WORLDS

in it are equals in the sense that each is the product of a totality of forces to which an alien element has been added; they are complementary in the sense that each possesses the part that the other lacks. The two partners are equal ; each finds himself in the other. 'When mangu cleanses a man it is as if he purifies himself."
' Manene godijale ku womo wajalage ginuwo.