All About Mud
All About Mud
All About Mud
Written By
Mohamed Bakry
HYDRODYNAMICS:
Viscosity of Fluids:
All fluids exhibit a certain resistance to flow, In general terms, a fluid is often described as being thick or thin.
A thick fluid crude oil has a high viscosity than thin fluid such as water.
In general viscosity is defined as the relationship between the shear stress (flow pressure) and the shear rate
(flow rate), shear stress and shear rate cause deformation of mud matter and thus affect the flow property of the
drilling fluid.
1. Shear stress:
It can b defined as the force required to overcome the fluid resistance to flow divided by the area that force
acting on.
Shear stress (t) =force applied (dynes) / A (cm
2
)
= dunes / cm
2
Where: A is the surface area subjected to stress.
2. Shear rate:
It can be defined as the relative viscosity of the fluid layers, or elements divided by their normal separation
distance.
Shear rate (y) = V (cm/sec) / H (cm) = sec
-1
FIGURE
Assume that two flat plates are placed parallel too each other, at 1 cm apart the top plat is free to move, while
the bottom plat is fixed , the space between the two plates is filled with fluid . So if a force is then applied to
the top plate, so that it moves with a constant velocity of 1 cm /sec, that force will be transmitted to the fluid,
thus causing the layers within to move also but with different rates. The layers that is close to the moving plate
will move approximately with the same velocity of the plat, while the movement of the force that is transmitted
through the layers diminishes until the movement at the fixed plat is nearly equal zero.
Thus viscosity can be defined as a measure of the resistance of a fluid to flow.
Viscosity = shear stress / shear rate.
Drill Fluid Rheology:
Rheology can be defined as the science of the deformation of the flow of matter.
It as usually described by viscosity and gel strength.
Types of flow regimes:
Laminar flow.
Turbulent flow.
N.B. The type of flow is usually depending on the flow rate (SPM * POP), the flow pressure and the relative of
the flow channel.
Laminar flow:
Is generally associated with low flow rate, low fluid velocities and with fluid movement in uniform layers. In
laminar flow the force (pressure) required to induce flow increases as the fluid velocity increase.
CURVE
In laminar flow, the fluid particles tend to move in straight lines parallel to direction of flow. The layers near the
wall of the flow channel tend to move at a lower velocity than that exists in the center of the flow channel, thus
the flow profile of the fluid in case of laminar flow when move a cylindrical pipe will be in a sort of concentric
cylinder.
FIGURE
Turbulent flow:
In generally occurs at high flow rates, high fluid velocities, and is characterized by an erratic, random
movement of the drilling fluid particles.
A flowing fluid is generally considered to be an either laminar or turbulent flow.
There is a very critical period called transitional period between two regimes when the movement of fluid
particles is no longer complete laminar, nor has it yet become complete random .
I.e.: If the flow pressure is reduced slightly, the fluid particles will return to the laminar movement. Conversely,
if the flow pressure is increased sufficiently the fluid particles will assume the random flow patterns associated
with the turbulent flow.
This transition occurs at some critical velocity, which is generally governed by the ratio of the fluids internal
forces to its viscous forces this ratio is called Reynolds number (N
re
)
N
re
= [diameter of the flow channel *average flow velocity * fluid density]/ fluid viscosity
CURVE
N.B.
Shear stress and shear rate data, allows accurate determinations of the fluid behavior under varying flow
conditions.
This data then provides the basis for further calculations used to determine several important aspects related to
the drilling fluids parameters.
I.e.: proper understanding and application of rheological principles can be valuable aid in determination of
dynamic performance of drilling fluid in order to establish and maintain the most effective properties for
efficient and economical drilling fluid performance.
These further calculations are:
1. Fluid velocity.
2. Calculation of the system pressure losses.
3. Calculation of surge and swab pressures.
4. Bit and jet nozzle hydraulics.
5. Relative hole cleaning efficiency.
6. Equivalent circulating density.
7. Estimation of the relative extent of hole erosion.
Reynolds Number:
a. In pipe Nr = 15.46 dvw / PV.
b. In annulus Nr = 15.46(dh-dp) vw / PV.
Fluid velocity (ft/min):
a. In pipe V = 24.51 GPM / d
2
.
b. In annulus V = 24.51 GPM / (dh
2
dp
2
) OR = POP (bbl/min)/ Ann. Vol. (bbl/ft).
Critical Velocity (ft/min):
a. In pipe V = 64.57 PV + 64.57 [(PV)
2
+ 12.3 d
2
YP W] / wd.
b. In annulus V = 64.57 PV+ 64.57 [(PV)
2
+9.26(dh dp)
2
YP W] /w(dh dp).
Slip Velocity Vs (ft/min):
a. Laminar Flow = 3210 (Wc W) D
2
V / 339 YP (dh dp) + PV V.
b. Turbulent Flow = 60 [D(Wc W) /W] .
I.e.: Slip Velocity is that velocity of desendigration of cuttings, according to its specific gravity, cutting size and
hole size, which acts against fluid velocity, carrying capacity and viscosity of mud.
WHERE :
V = fluid velocity (ft/min).
GPM = gallons per min. d = hole diameter.(in) Dp = pipe diameter (in)
D = cutting diameter(in).
Wc = cutting density (PPG).
L = section length (ft).
W = mud weight (PPG).
Vc = critical velocity(ft/min).
PV = plastic viscosity (cp).
YP = yield point.(lbs./100sq ft).
TVD = true vertical depth(ft).
Pressure drop = [Mwt in Mwt out] * 0.0519 * TVD.
MUD FACTS AND PRINCIPLES
PLASTIC VISCOSITY (PV)
=======================================
The friction to resist moving of mud layers against each other in dynamic state
In other words
Is the resistance of the fluid particles to move against each other in dynamic state, which is caused primary by the friction between the
suspended particles and the viscosity of the continuous liquid phase.
NB: PV is a function of solids
I.e.: plastic viscosity depends on the concentration of solids, also size and shape of solids.
PV is affected by the following:
1- Size and distribution of solids
2- Shape and concentration of solids.
3- Fluids phase viscosity
NB:
* The finer the solids, the higher the PV due to the increase of surface area which surrounded by more Volume of water.
*PV may be called (bit viscosity) which is equivalent to the viscosity of mud coming out of the bit, because PV has to be measured at
high shear rate.
*PV = 600 reading 300 reading
CAUSES OF PLASTIC VISCOSITY (PV) INCREASE:
1- Increases of solids concentration
a- drilled solids
b- commercial solids
1- Barite
2- Bentonite
2-Increases of solids surface area.
Non dispersed solids Dispersed solids
less surface area * more surface area
less quantity of adsorbed water * more quantity of adsorbed water
CAUTION
!S T O P
IN GENERAL: PV gives an
indication about the nature of solids in mud
more available free water *low available free water
low PV *high PV
low YP *high YP
low GEL *high GEL
low viscosity *high viscosity
* High capability to removed *low capability to be removed
thin fluids * thick fluids
thin rigid cake *thick cake
NB: Increase of PV direct related with increases of YP, also with increases of annular
pressure losses and with increases of ECD value, and decreases of ROP value.
METHODS OF DECREASING PV:
=================================
1- DILUTION:
a- with water in case of water base mud.
b- With diesel in case of oil base mud.
c- With clean premixed mud.
2-REMOVAL OF SOLIDS BY:
a- solids control equipments
b- settling
Natural settling: is effective because some of solids are colloidal and suspended.
(NB: settling does not take place by stopping agitation.)
c- adding Flocculants:
This is done by flocculate solids and decrease surface area of solids.
Flocculants are chemicals added to collect the solids together to decrease surface area of solids and thus can easily
remove solids out of mud.
NB: treating by dilution is more effective than chemical treatment.
YIELD POINT (YP ) :
ITS THE ELECTRO CHEMICALS ATTRACTION BETWEEN SOLIDS OR MUD COMPONENTS
IN OTHER WORDS:
ITS THE FORCE REQUIRED TO SLIDE ONE LAYER OF THE MUD OVER ANOTHER
These forces are a result of the +ve and ve charges located on the surface of fluids layers.
YP is the measurement of these forces and its effect on fluids under flowing condition of drilling fluid.
NB: YP is the measure of Flocculation
In general YP gives some indication of hole cleaning ability of the fluid, when the fluid is in
motion
CAUSES OF (YP) INCREASE: (CAUSES OF FLOCCULATION)
=============================================================
1- FLOCCULATION DUE TO TEMPERATURE :
====================================
THIS TAKE PLACE BY
A- CHEMICAL DEGRADATION
B- CLAY MOVEMENT
C- DEHYDRATION
**Over 150 F the space between clay particles increases causes over hydration on the clay particles, so Water is no longer
available in the system to keep mud flows, thats why mud become more thicker
**Over 350F a chemical degradation to clay particles occurs, causes an increase in activating ions and by term an increase in
Electro-chemicals attraction occurs, so Flocculation occurs accompanied by increase in YP.
TO DECREASE (YP ) DUE TO TEMPERATURE: (TEMP FLOCCULATION )
A- Dilute with water or fresh mud
B- Reduce clay as possible
C- Add high temp Deflocculant
2- FLOCCULATION CAUSED BY SOLIDS CROWDING:
REASONS:
A- Weighting up of mud ( water should be added to wet barite)
B- Poor solid control equipment
C- Reactive formations
D- Dehydration.
TO DECREASE (YP) CAUSED BY SOLID CROWDING:
A- Dilute with water or fresh mud.
B- Use high efficiency solid control equipment
3- FLOCCULATION CAUSED BY ALKALINITY CHANGES:
REASONS:
A- PH increases or decreases due to cement contamination.
B- Lime addition.
C- Acid gas influx (CO2 , H2S )
D- Carbonate
E- Incorrect Pm/Pf ratio (lime mud )
NB: High PH causes flocculation due to increases of attraction forces between particles.
TO DECREASE (YP) CAUSED BY ALKALINITY CHANGES:
A- Increases of PH by adding caustic soda or caustic potash.
B- Decreases of PH by dilution or adding organic acid such as Lignite (3.8 PH) or lignosulfonate (4.2 PH).
C- Adjusting Pm/Pf ratio by adding lime or caustic soda.
4- FLOCCULATION CAUSED BY COMMERCIAL ADDITIVES ( BENTONITE & POLYMERS):
A- Overdoses of polymers (such as viscosifiers, flocculants, water loss reducer )
B- Excess of bentonite.
TO DECREASE (YP) CAUSED BY COMMERCIAL ADDITIVES:
A- Dilute with water
B- Adding deflocculants.
5- FLOCCULATION CAUSED BY CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION:
A- Salt/salt water
B- Calcium
C- Carbonates
D- Cement
E- H2S/CO2
F- Anhydrite/Gypsum.
TO DECREASE (YP) CAUSED BY CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION:
A- Add deflocculant
B- Chemically remove the contaminate
C- Dilute
RELATION BETWEEN (PV) AND (YP):
1- If both (PV) and (YP) increases: ( solid content problem)
TREATMENT:
A- Dilution
B- Maintain solid control equipment.
NB: Dont add thinner otherwise (YP) will dramatically decreased and (PV) still high and
this will causes barite settling.
2- If (PV) is steady and (YP) increases : ( chemical contamination problem-YP problem)
TREATMENT:
A- Dilution
B- Add Deflocculants
NB: In low saline mud and as a result of presence of CL ions (at a certain limit) the (YP) increases with no
effect on (PV) value, this take place due to increases of Electro-chemical attraction between ions in mud, so if
same salinity required, add deflocculants, And if we need to reduce salinity we had to dilute with water.
3- If (PV) and (YP) decreased : (in case of high saline mud)
TREATMENT:
A- Add Flocculants
B- Add Viscosifiers
C- Add Water reducers.
NB: In high saline mud, the % of free CL ions will increase in the mud and thus will retrieve water from
bentonite plates back to the system, so both PV and YP will decreases. That besides increasing of frees H2O
and thus increases of water loss.
GENERAL NOTES:
1- PV = 600 READING - 300 READING
2- YP = 300 READING - PV
3- YP IS A MEASUREMENT OF THE CHARGES ON THE SOLID.
4- ALWAYS KEEP PV LOWEST AS POSSIBLE.
5- PV IS A FUNCTION OF SOLIDS.
6- IF PV INCREASES, YP MUST BE INCREASE DUE TO CROWDING EFFECT OF FINE SOLIDS.
THESE FINE SOLIDS PUSHES THE CHARGES TO EACH OTHER, SO THE ELECTRO-
CHEMICAL ATTRACTION BETWEEN MUD COMPONENTS INCREASES, CAUSING YP
INCREASE.
7- CHEMICAL CONTAMINATION Ca, Mg AND SALT, WILL INCREASE YP WITH NO EFFECT ON
PV.
SO: IF PV INCREASED, YP MUST BE INCREASED TOO.
BUT YP INCREASING DOES NOT AFFECT THE PV VALUE.
GEL STRENGTH:
Is the measurement of chemical attraction forces between mud particles under static conditions. GEL Strength is
an indicator for low shear rate rheology at 3 rpm reading ( V.G meter)
Gel strength importance:
A- Low gel strength : causes
1- settling of cutting and barite in statics conditions
2- building up of cuttings beds in deviated wells
B- High gel strength : causes
1- increasing pressure in break circulation to break down gel( may break down formation and
causes mud losses )
2- Increasing applied pressure to the formation while running in hole.
(Might break down formation, causes mud losses)
3- Swabbing while pull out of hole.
4- Poor cement jobs( as gel are hard to break, so that causes channeling of cement)
TYPES OF GEL:
1- Fragile or flat Gel:
Gel strength of 10 minute is slightly higher than 10 seconds gel even if 10 seconds gel reading
is high.
This gel can be easily broken by low pump pressure.
This type of gel has low swab and surge pressure.
2- Progressive or elevated Gel:
Gel strength increases significantly after 10 minute, even if 10 seconds gel is low.
Causes of Progressive Gel:
1- Reactive formation resulting in high percentage of reactive solids.
2- Solids crowding.
3- In sufficient deflocculation.
4- Carbonate contamination (CO3& HCO3).
NB: Relation between Gel,YP, and Viscosity, Cake and pore hole diameter:---
The increases of viscosity causes increase in YP & Gel, where too much increase of viscosity causes removed
of filter cake and may causes wash in bore hole diameter.
FILTRATION:
Is the rate of water loss of mud into formations
There are two aspects of the filtration phenomenon:
1- The quantity of filtrate which is the volume of filtrate that invades the formation.
(Anyhow lowering the water loss helps in hole stability)
2- The quality of filtrate, which gives an idea about the type and concentration of materials dissolved in
filtrate.
This gives an idea about the extend of stability of mud resulting from chemical interaction forces
between mud components, also gives an idea about the amount of contaminants dissolved in mud (LGS,
SALT and Chemical contaminants) that
Contributes this stability.
NB: 5ppb water loss reducer ==== water loss = +/- 3.0
FILTER CAKE:
IS THE MEASUREMENT OF THE RELATIVE AMOUNT OF MUD SHEETS DEPOSITED ON
THE PORE HOLE FORMATION SURFACE
Evaluation of filter cake depends mainly on two items:
1- QUALITY:
A- Impermeable
B- Non Porous
This much affected by:
percentage of solid in mud
shape and size of solids
chemical contaminant in mud
2- QUALITY: (THIN OR THICK)
Cake must be thin to minimize well sticking and reduce friction forces between drill string and pore hole
wall.
This is much affected by:
Quantity of water loss.
Solid content in mud
Chemical contaminant
RELATION BETWEEN WATER LOSS AND FILTER CAKE.
Isolating the formation from the drilling fluids will minimize the potentially detrimental interaction between
Filtrate and exposed formation and thus control the hole stability, this is complied by controlling:
Water loss
Quality and quantity of filter cake.
In other word minimize water loss by mean of water loss reducers together with getting rid of colloidal
Materials (LGS) off mud and chemical treatment of chemical contaminants .
SOLIDS:
TYPES OF SOLIDS:
A- High gravity solids (Ca CO3 +Barite)
B- Low gravity solids (drilled solids + bentonite)
Increases of drilled solids effect:
1- increase of mud weight
2- increase of viscosity
3- increase of Gel = may leads to gellation
NB: Gel must be obtained from bentonite or polymers not from drilled solids (to keep cutting suspended in mud
in static case not to be settled)
4- Increase of water loss.
5- Increase of PV & YP
6- Increase cake thickness and porosity.
NB: Increase of high gravity solids in mud leads to increases in mud weight only, when low gravity solids
Increase in mud leads to all pervious effects and may causes flocculation in mud.
7- Severe cut to PH =which may leads to bicarbonate problem.
Removing solids off mud produces the following benefits:
1- Improve filter cake quality (less coarse drilled solids) results in a less permeable and less porous cake.
Improving cake quality (thinner and tougher) minimize wall sticking and pore hole wall
And thus reducing pipes corrosion and minimizes pressure produced on formation resulting from those friction
forces (surge ) and thus reducing fluid losses.
2- A decrease in concentration of drilled solids contributes to improve and maintain rheological and other mud
properties and thus reduce mud maintenance cost.
Increase of solids in mud can be detected by:
1- Weighting mud
2- Evaporating and condensing mud fluid in a cylinder, leaving solid residual behind.
3- Increase of PV
BENEFITS OF OBTAINING LOW PERCENTAGE OF LOW GRAVITY SOLIDS (LGS ) IN
MUD :
1- Better hole condition
2- Reduce torque and drag
3- Reduce swab and surge pressure
4- Reduce tendency for differential stuck.
5- Fewer possibility of stuck of logging tool.
6- Improve bit run
7- Reduce bit and stabilizer balling
8- Better hole stability
NB: As increase of LGS % in mud causes an increase in mud weight and thus increases the hydrostatic head of
mud column and by turn ECD.
In other words increase the imposed pressure on formation which may exceed fracture pressure of the formation
leading to a loss of circulation.
9- Keep PV low and thus obtaining higher penetration rate.
10- Low abrasive LGS in mud reduces equipment wear and repair
11- Low abrasive LGS in mud minimize pipe washout.
12- Better cement jobs.
13- Better condition drilling fluid, thus low rate of dilution and mud treatment, which
Reduces mud cost.
Effect of solid size on ROP:
Particles less than 1.0 micron decrease rate of penetration 12 times more than that which is higher than 1.0
micron because:
1- PV increase
2- Surface area of adsorption of water increases
NB: 6-8 % colloidal solids adsorb 50% of water
3- Since percentage of adsorbed water increases, the mud will become thicker which may lead to flocculation
of mud.
Solid analysis determines:
% LGS and HGS
Mass balance calculation methods
Salinity corrections
Percentage of reactive solids
Percentage of bentonite and drilled solids
Cation exchange capacity (CEC) of bentonite and shale.
Remove solids by:
1- dump and dilution
2- mechanical removal (solid control equipment)
3- Settling.
NB: Some times diesel acts like solids, making what is known as (mechanical solids) causing increase in PV,YP
and Viscosity, this take place as a diesel in retort make a sort of droplets which dont condense and thus gives
slightly increase in solid percentage.
NB: NEVER INCREASE MUD WEIGHT WITH DRILLED SOLIDS ( LGS).
I.e.: never to put off solid control equipment to increase mud weight
Example:
To increase mud weight 0.1 PPG with drilled solids, that means ==0.1 X 2.6 X 42 = 10.92 ppb of low gravity
solids which is too high and will cause a lot of solid problems as mentioned before.
SOLID CONTROL EQUIPMENT
Solid Control Depending on:
1. Screening.
2. Centrifugal force.
3. Combination of both.
A. Screen Device:
This depends on:
Screening area and number of mesh.
Pump out put.
Solids load or penetration rate.
Mud viscosity.
Factors Affecting Shaker Efficiency and Solid Removal:
1. Screen selection:
Selecting the right screen for shakers recommended to remove the maximum amount of solids of mud, and
limits solids returning to mud system.
Screen selection depends on:
Amount and shape of solids to be removed.
Circulating rate.
Viscosity.
Screen life expectancy.
NB:
1. You will normally remove some finer solids than the mesh size due to piggy backing .
2. Changing wire diameter will change the cut point although mesh is the same.
3. Fine screen anticipating losing mesh water due to increase of surface area on smaller solids which are
removed.
Screen Types:
a. Sandwich:
If its a 40 mesh I.E.: it is accurately 80 mesh.
Advantages: never plugged with sand.
Disadvantages : plugged with gumbo shales.
b. Rectangular opening.
c. Plain weave.
d. Conventional.
Advantages: resist more than sandwich.
Disadvantages: plugged with sand faster than sandwich.
e. Oblong:
The best square mesh screens.
f. Pyramidal:
Advantages: never plugged with sand.
Disadvantages: plugged with gumbo shales.
What does screen mesh means?
Mesh means the linear measurements of number of openings per square inch.
I.E: Mesh counts opening per square inch.
EG: 80 mesh 80 openings per square inch.
One mesh includes width of one opening plus width of one wire.
Mesh count only tells the number of openings per linear inch in each direction.
Changing wire diameter without changing mesh will change the cut point although mesh is the same.
Size openings depend on mesh count and wire size.
NB: If screens are cutted at the same point several times you have to change the support cushion(Page6-10).
Type of Motion:
A. Circular.
B. Elliptical.
C. Longitudinal.
Circular and elliptical damage faster than longitudinal.
But elliptical is better than circular where the solids are exposed to more surface area at the screen.
Angle of Deck:
Horizontal decks
Have a higher liquid handling capacity than the sloped deck shakers, since the liquid has no tendency to run off
the end of the shakers.
Sloped decks shakers:
Have a higher solid handling capacity because the deck angle tends to make solids fall off the unit as it vibrates.
NB: Screen motion and deck angle controls:
1) Rate of travel of cuttings along screen.
2) Solid capacity .
Distribution of fluid carrying solids on screens.
3) Fluid capacity.
Flow Capacity:
a. As PV increases flow capacity decreases.
b. As mesh screens increase flow capacity increase.
c. % screen covered increase flow capacity increase.
d. Plugging effect increase flow capacity increase.
PS: Screens have a viscosity and solids limit.
Precautions;
Wash down screens before trips.
Keep screens clean and you will reduce blinding and plugging effect.
Amplitude or Stroke Length:
Shakers are available with stroke lengths from 0.025 to 0.5 inches. The greater the stroke length , the higher
solid removal because of the greater the unit the unit handling capacity.
Long strokes that forces thick fluids through the screen openings, also tend to force solids into the screens
openings which cause blinding or partially blinding that particularly while handling sticky solids.
Speed of Rotation:
The general vibration frequency for shakers is 1100 to 3300 RPM.
Shale shaker (G) Force:
The common expression for the amount force generated by a shaker is G force.
PS:
Cut point of shaker means that all cuttings above that size of mesh screens will be separated on the shaker,
below that size will pass from mesh screens of shaker back to system until removed with other solid control
equipments.
Cut point Millimicrons.
In General the Optimum Shale Shaker Operation Depends on:
Mounting and Leveling:
Shakers must be leveled according to GPM not too much to the front so as not to lose mud. Or not too much up
so as cuttings do not accumulate on the back sides of screens which by turn will cause too much load on that
part of screens and thus may cause screen cut and by turn solids will escape into system.
Provide required voltage and frequency .
Vibrator should rotate in proper direction.
Install proper screens and proper support cushions.
Proper and screen size is recommended so as not to have too narrow mesh and thus solids may plug screens and
thus lose mud at shakers OR too wide and thus allow cuttings to pass into system and thus increase solids
percentage in mud.
Also make sure that sealing rubber (support cushions) of screens is proper and not small or cutted otherwise the
solids will escape into system through cutted points.
Tension screens properly.
Size of mesh screens so as mud to cover 75 80 % of length.
Use water hose to wash down screens on trips.
You need partial plugging of mesh screens to aid in flow capacity and cutting removal.
Make sure that the bypath of shakers is not leaking. Otherwise solids will escape to system.
The volume of fluid lost on shale shakers per unit time depends on
1. Shaker design.
2. Screen mesh and type.
3. Drilling fluid properties.
4. Solid loading.
PS:
If only 50 % or less of the screen area is covered with mud, finer mesh screens is recommend.
Inspite that without changing screens, the operating ones can become partially blocked with time by cuttings
wedge in the open screens (blinded) or by sediments/ residue/ mud dried on the wire cloth(coated).
B. Centrifugal Device:
Depends on separating solids based on size and specific gravity of solids.
The centrifugal separator mechanically subjects the fluid to increased G forces and thus increases the settling
rate of particles by mean of this method both heavy coarse and light fine fractions are separated of mud.
Desired fractions of solids are then selected and return to the system. This recharging works well with both low
density(low gravity solids), and high gravity fluids.
FIGURE
Hydrocyclones Performance Depend on:
Fluid viscosity.
Mechanical condition of cones.
Head at cone manifold(Feed pressure = 30 40 psi.
Solid load.
Hydrocyclones Instillation & Maintenance:
Flow capacity should exceed rig circulating rate by 10 20 %.
Eliminate mud guns and use mechanical agitators.
Recommended individual centrifugal pump for each set of Hydrocyclones.
Pumps properly sized to give recommended head at Hydrocyclones (35 psi).
Lines properly sized and short as possible.
Suction out of one compartment, and discharge down stream in next
Replace only worn cones or nozzles.
Do not bypath shakers, as bypassing shakers causes most plugged cones.
Run as fine shale shaker screens as possible.
Operate in spray discharge for higher efficiency.
Periodically unplug (clean).
NB: If keeping the previous percussion you will get the best solid separation.
Also separation depends on:
1. specific gravity of solids (separation).
2. Size of particles (separation).
3. Centrifugal force (separation).
4. Liquid phase viscosity (separation).
5. Solid load (separation).
6. Feed pressure optimum (separation).
7. Mechanical condition (separation).
NB1:
As centrifugal forces increases the cut point decreases (I.E. decrease the size of separated particles).
NB2:
As viscosity increases the cut point increases (I.E. increase the size of separated particles).
PS:
Under Flow GPM (equipment) = 1.25 X GPM (rig).
How heavy should cone underflow be?
Depends on size and nature of solids in feed.
Cone should be in spray discharge.
Cone underflow should be heavier than feed.
Desander underflow should be heavier than desilter underflow.
Hydrocyclones Optimistic Cut Point
Centrifugal force increase
Size D 50 microns
12 (Desander) 65 - 70
6 (desilter+M.C) 25 32
4 (desilter+M.C) 16 18
3 (desilter+M.C) 12
2 (desilter+M.C) 7 -10
Effect of PV 0n separation 4 cone
Mud PV (cp.) D 50 microns
1 16
10 18
23 29
The higher the viscosity and PV the lower the efficiency of the equipment.
Effects of solids 0n separation 4 cone
PV = 7 YP = 1 solids %
Solids % D 50 microns
1.2 18
2.05 22.5
2.37 19
3.9 27
Hydrocyclones Rope Versus spray discharge
Discharge Wt(PPG) Solids Lb./hour lb./day
Rope 4 GPM 14.5 46% 2392 57403
spray 3 GPM 13 35% 3640 87360
NB:
1. Cones processes 125 150 % of the flow line GPM.
2. Optimum pressure on the solid control equipment = M.wt X (distance between pumps of solid control
equipments 75ft and the equipment itself) X 0.0519.
GPM of Solid Control Equipment:
a. Measure how much time needed to fill a viscosity cup to the mark from one cone.
Convert seconds to minutes.
NB: viscosity cup = gallon.
Say in 8 min.
0.25 gallon was filled in 8 min.
0.25/8 = 0.03125 GPM for one cone.
b. Multiply by number of cones to get GPM of equipment.
a. Multiply by 60 minutes to get gallon / hour.
b. Multiply by 42 minutes to get bbl / hour.
NB:
On calculating equipment losses always try to match the GPM of equipment with equipment losses.
PS:
Never measure M.wt with drilled solids.
I.E: Never to put off solid control equipments to increase mud weight.
EG:
To increase M.wt 0.1 PPG with drilled solids that means:
0.1 X 2.6 = 0.26 (ppb LGS).
2.6 = specific gravity of LGS.
I.E: 0.26 X 42 = 10.92 (ppb of pure LGS). Which is too high and will cause a lot of solid problems as
mentioned before.
See pages 6-13, 6-14, 6-15, and 6-16.
1. Desander / Desilter Operation Tips:
A. Equipment is fed by a centrifugal pump maintaining a manifold pressure of 35-40 psi.
Excessive pressure contributes to a bladder wear and effects cut point.
Excessive pressure may be due to :
Feed lines are plugged.
Distance between equipment pumps and equipment itself is not correct.
If pressure is less than 30 psi mean that there is a leak somewhere or equipment is not working.
In both high and low pressures the efficiency of solid separation is not ok.
B. Proper discharge from the cones is in the form of a conical pressurized spray. Roping may occur when the
fluids to be processed has an excessive amount of solids present in the mud .
Cones discharge may be adjusted by turning the adjustment at the cone apex.
If discharge coming out of the cone is like a stream (like that causing out of a tap of H
2
O). this means that
cones are highly wearied which will not give a chance for good centrifuging and separating of excess solids.
C. Cones may become plugged from time to time and should be cleaned by opening the adjustment and
inserting a welding rod or equivalent from the bottom to dislodge the solids blocking the discharge.
D. Continual plugging of cones may be due to the failure of up stream solid control equipment, which should
be checked to insure that its functional.
OR
Plugging of cones may be due to incorrect shale shaker mesh screens which allows larger amount of solids to
pass into system.(use finer mesh screen after unplugging cones to solve this problem).
OR
Plugging of cones may be due to those guns in tank before unit is on (stop guns immediately and use normal
agitation).
E. Weight of discharge must be high as an indication of getting rid of excess solids.
If discharge weight is nearly the same or higher a little bit than feed in mud . this means that equipment is
not working.
Also you can feel the discharge by your hand if it is mud or solids.
NB: Cones processes 125-150 % of the flow line GPM.
2. Mud Cleaner:
The hydrocyclone / screen combination consists of a bank of desilters which are mounted over a fine mesh
vibrating screen. The discard from desilter is processed by the fine screens.
Particles are removed by the screen and discarded while the fluid processed through the screen is returned to the
active system.
Mud cleaner is a fine screen shaker, its primary function is to remove that portion of sand size or larger that
passes through rig shaker.
NB:
Ideally a 200 mesh screen would be desirable on mud cleaner , however 140-150 mesh screens is generally
necessary to minimize barite losses.
3. Degasses:
By mean of centrifugal action separates gas + foam from mud.
Hydrocyclones ID is ranging from 6-12.
It process mud immediately from below the sand trap not from the sand trap.
4. Centrifuge:
Last defend for solids. Can remove solids below 4-6 microns that will not be separated at shakers and pass
to the system.
These very fine particles have a greater effect on rheology than the coarser particles.
Centrifuging will not however eliminate the need for water. But dilution rates will be reduced and a fluid
maintenance cost reduction will be expected.
Trend of PV can give an indication of how fast solids concentration is increasing the MBT and solid content
and solid content can also be an assistance guide in this determination.
Each type of centrifuge have its own optimum RPM (normal RPM from 1900 to 2200).
Has to be used carefully in weighted mud otherwise will separate barite and affect M.wt.
The reference to make sure that centrifuge is working ok is the discharge weight and weight of flow of
processing mud coming out of centrifuge to system.
I.E: Must have good flow . processing mud weight must be less than operating mud weight.
Charging optimum RPM range of any centrifuge affects the unit efficiency.
SOLID CALCULATION:
CALCULATION USED IN SOLID CONTROL EVALUATION
The following equation is based on the fact that the specific gravity (sg) of the mud is Equal to
the sum of the specific gravity times the volume fraction of each component.
In this simplified equation, the mud will consist of three basic components: liquid, low-gravity
Solids, and high-gravity solids.
Sm = VwSw + VlgSlg + VhgShg
NB: Volume of salt water corrected (Vwc) and specific gravity of water (Sw) is obtained from appropriate salt
table.
CALCULATE OF LOW GRAVITY SOLIDS AND HIGH GRAVITY SOLIDS VOLUME
SOLIDS ANALYSIS:
Calculation of low-gravity solids and high-gravity solids from a retort analysis. Correct the
retort values and the specific gravity of the water phase by using the salt tables.
EQUATION TO GET VOLUME OF LOW GRAVITY SOLIDS
[{ Vw}{Pf}+ {Vss}{Pb} + {Vo}{Po}] 100{Pm}
Vlg =
{Pb Plg}
EQUATION TO GET VOLUME OF HIGH GRAVITY SOLIDS
100{Pm} - [{ Vw}{Pf}+ {Vss}{Plg} + {Vo}{Po}]
Vb =
{Pb Plg}
WHERE:
- Vlg = volume of low gravity solids
- Vss = volume % of suspended solids
- Vb = volume of high gravity solids
- Vw = water fraction corrected for presence of dissolved salt
- Po = density of oil
- Pm = density of mud (spgr)
- Plg = density of low gravity solids (LGS) = 2.6
- Pf = density of water phase corrected for dissolved salts
EXAMPLES OF SOLID CALCULATIONS:
IF : M .WT = 14.0 PPG = 1.88 sp .gr
Density of weighted material (Pb)== barite = 4.2 & hematite = 5.0
From retort:
Vs (volume of solids ) = 28 %
Vo (volume of oil) = 8 %
Vwr(volume of water) = 64 %
CL = 100,000 mg/l (Na CL)
1. Correct retort value for soluble salts from Na CL table
Pf = density of water phase corrected for dissolved salt = 1.111
Volume increase factor = 1.059
Vw ( water fraction corrected for presence of dissolved salt )
= Vwr X volume increase factor
= 64 X 1.059
= 67.8 %
Vss (volume percentage of suspended solids)
= 100 Vw Vo
= 100 67.8 - 8
= 24.2 %
One bbl of mud = 14 PPG X 42
= 588 ppb
Weight of water = 67.8/100 X PPG of brine water(water of 100,000 mg/l Na CL salt table) X 42
= 67.8/100 X 9.27 X42
= 263 ppb
Weight of oil = 8/100 X 7.0 X 42
= 23 ppb
Calculated weight of solids = weight of mud weight of water (corrected) weight of oil
= 588 263 - 23
= 302 ppb
2. Substitute in equation to get volume of low- gravity solids and high-gravity solids.
[{Vw){Pf}+{Vss}{Pb}+{Vo}{Po}]-100{Pm}
Vg = ---------------------------------------------------------
{Pb Plg}
[{67.8}{1.111}+{24.2}{4.2}+{8}{0.84}] 100{1.8}
= ---------------------------------------------------------------
{4.2- 2.6}
= 2.3 % LGS
100{Pm}-[{Vw){Pf}+{Vss}{Plg}+{Vo}{Po}]
Vb = -----------------------------------------------------------
{Pb Plg}
100{1.8}-[{67.8}{1.111}+{24.2}{2.6}+{8}{0.84}
= --------------------------------------------------------------
{ 4.2-2.6}
= 21.9 % HGS (Barite)
Percentage of low-gravity solids to total solids
2.3
= ------ X 100 = 9.5 %
24.2
Percentage of high-gravity solids to total solids
21.9
= ------ X 100 = 90.5 %
24.2
Weight of low-gravity solids .
9.5
= ------ X {2.6 x8.33}X [{24.2/100}X42]
100
= 20 pounds
Weight of high-gravity solids
90.5
= ------ X {2.4 x8.33}X [{24.2/100}X42]
100
= 322 pounds
Fluids concentration
TYPE SP.GR PPG (SP .GR X 8.34 ) PPB(PPG X 42)
WATER 1.0 8.34 350.28
BARITE 4.2 35.028 1471.176
LGS 2.6 21.684 910.728
CARBONATE 2.7 22.518 945.756
Examples:
1 -fluid with 3% LGS, how much concentrate in ppb.
{3/100} X{910.728} = 27.3 ppb
2 Fluid with 54.6 ppb LGS, how much concentrate in percentage
{54.6}/{910.728} X 100 = 6.0 %
3 Fluid weight 9.2 PPG, how much ppb of LGS in un-weighted mud (LGS % = 7.5%)
for unweighted mud:
solids = solids % X [Mud weight weight of water (8.34)]
LGS % = 7.5 (% solids of retort) X ( 9.2 8.34 )
= 6.45 % ( % of corrected solids)
LGS ppb = [{6.45}/{100 }}X 910.728
= 58.7 ppb
4 On adding 5.5% solids to one bbl of mud free of solids, calculate volume increase
Volume increase = {5.5}/{100} + 1
= 1.055 bbl
5 - If water = 86 % , oil = 10 % , solids = 4 %, MBT = 18 ppb
Calculate:
% of solids corresponding to one bbl
corrected MBT
corrected solids
total solids in fluid
volume increase by 1 bbl = {4/100} + 1 = 1.04 bbl
corrected solid % in one bbl = {4.0}/{1.04} = 3.85 %
weight of solids = {3.85}/{100}X 910.728 = 35 PPB (of solids}
corrected MBT in one bbl = {18.0}/{1.04} = 17.3 ppb
total corrected drilled solids in ppb (LGS)
LGS in ppb = 17.3 + 35 = 52.3 ppb
total LGS % = [{52.3}/{910.728}] X 100
= 5.75 %
Mixing liquids of different densities
Mass balance equation :
1 -Two phase equation:
{Vt}{Wt} = {V1}{W1} + {V2}{W2}
Example: If Vt = 1890 bbl, Mwt (Wt) = 8.8 PPG ,calculate volume of water for 100 bbls.
V1 = volume of water
W1= weight of water (8.34 PPG)
V2= volume of LGS
W2= weight of LGS
100 X 8.8 = V1 X (8.34) + V2 X 21.7
100 X 8.8 = V1 X (8.34) + {100-V1} X 21.7
1290 = 13.36 V1
V1= 96.6 %
V2 = 3.4 %
OR: calculate for total volume:
1890 X 8.8 = 8.34 V1 + {1890 V1} X 21.7
13.36 V1 = 24471
V1 = 1831.66
V1 % = {1831.66} / {1890 } X 100 = 96.9 %
V2 (LGS) = 3.1 %
2 THREE PHASE EQUATION:
Vt Wt = V1W1(H2O) + V2W2(LGS) + V3W3(HGS)
EXAMPLE:
Vt = 100 bbl
Wt = 12.5 PPG
V1 = 84 ( % or bbl because Vt = 100 )
Solution:
V2 + V3 = 16 %
V2 = {16 V3}
W2(LGS) = 21.7 PPG
W3(HGS) =35 PPG
100 X 12.5 = {84 X 8.34} + {16 V3} X 21.7 (wt of LGS) X {V3 X 35(wt of barite)}
13.3 V3 + 1047.76 = 1250
V3 = 202.24
V3 = 15.2 %
V2 (LGS) = 16 15.2 = 0.8 %
3 -FOUR PHASE EQUATION:
Vt Wt = V1W1( WATER) + V2W2( LGS) + V3W3( HGS) + V4W4 (DIESEL)
EXAMPLE:
IF Vt = 100
Mwt = 12.8 PPG
V1 = 72 (retort value)
V4 = 10 (retort value)
Solution:
V2 + V3 = 100 {72 +10}
= 18
V2 = {18 V3}
W2(LGS) = 21.7 PPG
W3(HGS) =35 PPG
W4(DIESEL) = 7 PPG
100 X 12.8 = 72 X 8.34 + {18 V3}21.7 + V3 X 35 + 10 X 7
V3 (HGS) = 16.46 %
V2 (LGS) = 1.54 %
THREE PHASE MUD WITH SALT:
EXAMPLE:
Mwt = 12.1 PPG
Water = 80 %
Solids = 20 %
CL = 141,000
Solution:
From Na CL salt table, salinity of 141.0 k, volume increase = 1.087
Brine volume = 80 X 1.087 = 86.9 %
Corrected solids = 100 86.9 = 13.1 %
From NaCL salt table, adjust density of water corresponding to 141.0 k of CL = 9.6 PPG
100 X 12.1 = {86.9 X 9.6} + { 13.1 V3 }X 21.7 + 35 X V3
V3 = 6.9 %
V2 = 13.1 (Total corrected solids) 6.9
V2 = 6.2 %
ALKALINITY AND PH :
ALKALINITY IS DEFINED AS THE AVAILABILITY OF H+ IN SOLUTION
PH IS A FUNCTION OF DISSOCIATION OF WATER
PH NUMBER ARE A FUNCTION OF H+ IONS CONCENTRATION IN GRAM
IONIC WEIGHT PER LITER OF MUD.
ALKALINITY PROPORTIONAL WITH 1/H+
PH = 16 PH = 7.0 PH = 814
ACIDIC NEUTRAL ALKALINE
IN GENERAL ALKALINE MEDIA IS THE BEST ENVIRONMENT FOR ALL CHEMICAL
PRODUCTS TO PERFORM GOOD WHILE DRILLING
PH EXPRESSED AS LOG SCALE (BASE 10)
Example: PH OF 9.0 indicates an alkalinity ten times as greater as that of PH of 8.0 .
PH value depending on the concentration of OH group and or CO3 , HCO3 and CO2 in mud As:
IF
PH =12.0 or higher ======= Mud contaminate with OH group
PH =10.0 ======= Mud contaminate with OH & CO3
PH =9.0 10.0 ======= Mud contaminate with CO3 group only
PH =9.3 - 8.3 ======= Mud contaminate with CO3 & HCO3
PH =8.3 6.0 ======= Mud contaminate with HCO3 only
PH = 6.0 4.3 ======= Mud contaminate with HCO3 & CO2
PH = 4.3 or lower ======= Mud contaminate with CO2 only.
NB: Using PhPh indicator to test PH value
As follows:
No color ========= PH less than 8.3
Light pink color ==== PH 7.5==8.5
Pink color ======= PH 9.0 =10.0
Violet color ======= PH more than 10.0
NB: PhPh end point is at PH = 8.3
ALKALINITY OF MUD TEST : (Pm )
Prepare 1 ml of mud + 5 ml distilled water + 3 drop PhPh (red pink color)
Titrate with H2SO4 acid (N/50)===== end point == colorless indication
Pm = Volume of H2SO4 used.
ALKALINITY OF FILTRATE : ( Pf & Mf test)
Prepare 1 ml of filtrate + 2 drop PhPh (red pink color)
Titrate with H2SO4 acid (N/50)===== end point == colorless indication
Pf = Volume of H2SO4 used
Add 2 drops of methyl orange indicator (yellowish orange color)
Continue titrate with H2SO4 (N/50)===end point ==pale red color
Mf = total volume of H2SO4 used.
RELATION BETWEEN Pf & Mf:
1. If Mf = Pf or little higher :
That means mud contaminate with OH ions only
Expected to get Ca++ ions contaminate in mud , whenever no CO3 group to precipitate Ca++.
2. If Mf less than twice of Pf:
Most of ions CO3 and OH.
3. If MF = TWICE Pf:
Most of ions are CO3
High pH related to CO3 not OH which may causes a problem in lignosulphonate mud Leads no
response for rheological properties.
4. If Mf higher than twice of Pf:
Most of ions are CO3 and HCO3.
5. If Pf = 0 and Mf very high:
Most of ions are HCO3 only.
NB:
Mf is a matter of measuring CO3, HCO3 & CO2
Pf is a matter of measuring CO3 & OH group.
Pf end point is at PH = 8.3
Mf end point is at PH = 4.3
Example:
If PH = 9.0 Pf = 0.8 Mf = 1.6
That means high consumption of H+ ions of H2SO4 acid, take the same quantity of Pf to utilize the filtrate
to reach PH = 4.3, So all alkalinity in Pf was from CO3 group.
Total carbonate = 1220 (Mf Pf )
Treatment of carbonate contaminate in mud depending on total carbonate value (Mf & Pf ) and type of
carbonate .
Carbonate contamination treated by adding Lime, or Lime +NaOH or Lime +Gypsum
Carbonate contamination treated as follows:
- HCO3 value X 0.00021 == PPB of Lime (treatment value)
- CO3 value X 0.00043 == PPB of Lime
- HCO3 value X 0.002 ==== PPB of NaOH
- CO3 value X 0.001==== PPB of Gypsum
Rule of thumb:
CO2 AND H2S are acidic gases
At high PH you have free OH ions in mud
At high PH we minimize bacterial degradation
Dont treat carbonate to zero so as to have some carbonate to react w/ excess Ca ions in mud
Accepted carbonate in mud is between 500 2000 mg/l
A solids problem may look like a CO3 problem.
In case of CO2 treat with lime C<2O + Ca<2OH =(CaCO3 + H2O
In lime mud the influx of CO2& H2S, which are acidic gases gives incorrect Pm/Pf ratio
Solubility of Ca increase with low pH, causing flocculation of mud
Clay or shale becomes highly sensitive to mud in highly pH over 9.0, causing flocculation of mud as the
attraction forces between ions increases
Mf value sometimes tend to be higher than actual (false value),this is because some chemicals added to mud
(such as ,lignosulphonates , unical , resinex), buffer the pH of the fluid (fix it) ,so it takes more amount of
H2SO4 to reach pH 4.3.
High pH more than 11.0 may deactivate some polymers, best media pH is between 8.5(10.0.
Low pH less than 7.0 causes breakdown (burn) of polymers
Ligosulphonate becomes less affective and may cause sever foaming at pH below 8.0,so add caustic
Soda to adjust PH
In lime mud or excess lime Pm becomes higher than Pf as lime increases.
To adjust Pm/Pf ratio add lime or caustic soda .
Contaminants :
Na Cl :
Source :
1. salt domes .
2. rock salt beds .
3. evaporite formations .
4. salt H
2
O flow .
5. salty make up water.
Effects :
1. Increase apparent viscosity .
2. Increase yield point .
3. Decrease pH .
4. Cl
-
ion will increase in filtration and will decrease P
f
.
5. Flocculation followed by aggregation of mud .
6. Wash of hole .
7. Chemical foam .
Treatment :
1. Dilution .
2. Add thinner to reduce apparent viscosity, YP, Gel strength .
3. Add caustic soda (Na OH) to increase and adjust pH .
4. Add organic thinner to reduce filtration .
5. Analyze salty make up water before adding to system otherwise it will act as if we get a salt water flow .
6. To make sure that there is no increase in mud weight .
7. To convert to salt saturated mud .
8. Any treatment should be done as soon as possible otherwise getting a hole wash or untreated mud may cause loose control which
might result in moving in salt body into hole getting a pipe stuck .
9. In case of foams, add defoamer (aluminum stearate defoamer) .
Ca SO
4
:
Source :
1. Gypsum (Ca SO
4
2H
2
O)
2. Anhydrite (Ca SO
4
) .
3. Cap rock of a salt dome .
4. Make up water .
Effects :
1. Cause flocculation and aggregation .
2. Increase apparent viscosity .
3. Increase YP & gel strength .
4. Increase filtrate .
5. Increase Ca
++
ion in mud which cause flocculation . also increase SO
4