Sattur
Sattur
Sattur
Final Report
-1-
1
PROJECT OVERVIEW
1.1
ASSIGNMENT BACKGROUND
The World Bank has been a partner in urban reform program of Government of Tamil Nadu
(GoTN) with engagement through Tamil Nadu Urban Development Project (TNUDP) TNUDP-I, TNUDP-II and TNUDP-III (in progress). Towards taking forward the urban reform
agenda, the GoTN is now implementing the TNUDP-III with focus on furthering the reforms
initiated under TNUDP-II.
The Tamil Nadu Urban Infrastructure Financial Services Limited (TNUIFSL), as a financial
intermediary, intends to assist the Commissioner of Municipal Administration (CMA) in
strengthening and improving the financial position of its Municipalities for effective capital
investment management and urban service delivery. These towns possess a good potential
for implementation of such financial reforms for which it is essential to formulate a City
Corporate Cum Business Plan. The CMA has started the process of capacity building in
Municipalities through this process to enhance the vision of the ULBs in growth of their
towns.
The TNUIFSL has appointed M/s.Community Consulting India Private Limited (CCI) to
prepare City Corporate Cum Business Plan (CCBP) for Sattur Municipality.
Final Report
-2-
Situation analysis, with regard to the context i.e., demographic and economic trends, city
governance, service provision & delivery including systems & structures, financial status
of the city government and agencies concerned with service provision including an
analysis of their creditworthiness; and effectiveness and efficiency of the institutional
frameworks;
Perspective and a vision for the city;
Strategy identifying key strategic issues, risks and opportunities facing the city, with
focus on reform and reform priorities; and
City Investment Plan, referring to order of investment needed to implement the
perspective and alternative financing strategies.
A CCP clearly defines how a ULB will a) serve its customers (businesses and citizens), e.g.
how it intends to guarantee basic level of urban services to all citizens, make urban planning
responsive to emerging needs, become responsive to the needs of, and improve its
services, to local businesses; b) run its business, e.g. how it intends to manage public
finance in a modern and transparent way, execute urban planning and governance in line
with an established framework, become more responsive, cost and time efficient through
integrating technology in their governance and service delivery processes; and c) manage
its resources, e.g. how it intends to increase revenues and expand its tax base to allow for
self-sustaining urban service delivery, improve its creditworthiness, but also how it intends to
recruit and retain a skilled workforce.
Context of a City Corporate Plan
Past efforts to produce this kind of broad, integrated approach have been fraught with
coordination problems and multiple implementation agencies, which have lead to confusion
and wasted resources. Moreover, past planning, like city master plans, have been
excessively technical and unresponsive to citizen input and demand. The CCP is different
from master planning as cities are now more open to outside influences in a globalized
economy, and more able to act on opportunities for growth. At the same time,
decentralization is giving cities more scope for action, and democratization is opening the
planning and political process to much greater participation and accountability. A CCP is
geared to respond to these new circumstances.
What does the analysis of towns profile show? Where are the opportunities and where
are the key constraints?
Given the opportunities and constraints, where does the town wishes to move in a
medium-term perspective? While the vision is forward-looking, it is also a realistic
vision, achievable with a given time frame.
What strategic options are available to achieve the vision? What are the costs and
benefits of alternative strategic options? Which of the strategies will help the town
achieve the vision at least cost or maximum impact?
What would be the aggregate investment needed to implement the vision? What are the
options for mobilizing resources for implementing the City Corporate Plan (CCP)?
What reforms other than those embodied in the JNNURM, UIDSSMT & IHSDP are
necessary for effectively implementing the City Corporate Plan (CCP)?
Final Report
-3-
The specific objective of this exercise is to visualize the town in the next 10 years and to
Define the growth directions and service up-gradations in relation to the activity mix /
growth;
Look at the demand for the projects specified by the ULBs, and come out with gap in
services with respect to the vision;
Broadly outline the infrastructure needs;
Define specific rehabilitation and capital improvement needs with regard to priority city
infrastructure in both slums and other areas;
Define revenue enhancement and revenue management improvements required to
sustain the rehabilitation proposed;
Reforms required in local administration and service delivery;
Management changes required at the local level to improve O&M of assets, and
Measures to address common growth and infrastructure issues.
City Assessment & Optional Strategy Formulation Stage: This stage of the
assignment will focus on fact finding and analysis with regards key development
elements of the city and will be based on secondary data and extensive consultation
with relevant stakeholders at the disaggregate level. Following are the components:
Demography, Economic Development & Growth Assessment;
Institutional Arrangements;
Infrastructure - Housing and Urban Basic Services ;
Physical and Environmental Aspects; and
Financial Assessment covering a detailed financial assessment of key stakeholder
agencies and a preliminary Financial Operating Plan and Project Cash Flows
Finalization of City Corporate Plan: This stage would finalize and recommend
strategies to achieve the citys development vision, in consultation with the concerned
stakeholder agencies. The strategies will be supported with specific projects and action
points as relevant, phased over a 10-year horizon, with specific annual action plans for
the first five years, indicating stakeholder roles and responsibilities.
The scope of work specifically covers but not limited to the following:
1. Assess the demand for the projects listed out by these Municipalities and analyze
demand for the next 10 years
2. Financial assessment of the ULBs- an assessment of local finances (past 5 years) in
terms of sources and uses of funds, base and basis of levy, revision history and impacts,
State assignments and transfers- base and basis of transfer and its predictability; uses
of funds outstanding liabilities (loans, power dues, pension etc) and, a review of revenue
and service management arrangements. Levels of service, coverage and quality of
municipal services in both poor and non-poor localities. Staffing and management
arrangements in delivery of services
Final Report
-4-
1.2
Final Report
-5-
1. Framing the Process will provide the essential assessment of the readiness of the ULB
to take forward this process and would identify stakeholders and come to consensus on
how the CCBP preparation process will be managed, agreeing a structured programme
to take forward the process. This phase of the assignment will also draw out initial
conclusions as to the chief concerns of the various stakeholders. This phase of the
assignment would also provide basic inputs for preparing the draft template of the CCBP
addressing key issues on the ULB, governance, service provision & delivery and
finances;
2. CCBP Preparatory Phase would include preparing the CCBP for the select ULB based
on the template and integrate the findings of the phase with a more in-depth participative
analysis of the situation. This will identify the structure and trends in the local economy,
the dimensions of poverty in the city, gaps in infrastructure, the constraints and
obstacles to progress-institutional, financial, environmental and social. This will require
the collation and analysis of previous study findings, and may require some particular
primary research. This phase will focus on coming to a consensus on the strategic
options derived using the CCBP;
3. Strategic Consensus Phase would focus on preparing the CCBP and building capacity
among the officials of the ULBs to prepare CCBPs for their administrative jurisdictions
and deriving strategic options. This phase will also provide inputs for refining the outputs
of the CCBP if required along with identifying the sources of assistance. This will also
address how the local and other national international partners can help the ULB to
achieve its goals;
4. Initiating Implementation Phase would involve providing both onsite and back-office
support to the ULBs for preparing the CCBP and advising these ULBs to generate all
necessary strategic outputs and make use of such outputs in implementation.
1.3
TASKS INVOLVED
The aim of the assignment is to prepare consensus-based city corporate plan indicating
policies, programmes, strategies and funding mechanisms to meet the development
requirements. The corporate plan would be formed as shared vision for the city involving
various stakeholders with a long-term development perspective. The assignment is split into
a number of following defined tasks:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
Final Report
-6-
Final Report
-7-
2
PROFILE OF SATTUR
2.1. REGIONAL SETTING
Sattur, a Grade II Municipal town and a taluk head
quarters town falls under the administrative jurisdiction of
Virudhunagari District. The District Head quarters,
Virudhunagar is 22 km north of Sattur. Sivakasi town,
famous for its Crackers, Matches and Printing industry, is
located at a distance 20 km in north western side of the
town. Rajapalyam town is located on the western side of
the town at a distance 52 kms from the town. Kovilpatti is
located at a distance of 21 kms in the southern side of the
town. The famous "Satturappan Kovil" is located at the
heart of the town and is a well known landmark of this town.
Sattur
Sattur
This town is surrounded in the north by Venkatachalpuram Village Panchayat and in the
south by the Vaypur River and Chathrapatti Village Panchayat. Vaypur River and
Padanthangal Village Panchayat form the physical boundary of Sattur in western direction
and VentankuIam Kanamai boundary along eastern side of the town.
Final Report
-8-
Sattur
The National highway (NH:7) connects the town with Thiruchendur, Tuticorin and Madurai
city and the other district roads connect the town with Aruppukottai, Sivakasi, Kovilpatti
Rameshwaran and Paramakudi. The railway line connecting Madurai Kanyakumari
connects the town with all the parts of the state.
2.3
PHYSICAL CHARACTERISTICS
2.3.1 GEOGRAPHY
Sattur, match industry based town is located on the banks on Vaypur river and forms part of
Virudhunagar District. Sattur lies in the coordinates of 927 N 7746 E and the topography
of the town is almost flat with a mild slope towards the river in the eastern part of the town. It
has an average elevation of 55 mts (183 ft) above MSL. The town is surrounded by large
number of villages based on the Matches making, household industry. Agriculture is done
Final Report
-9-
only at a very small scale in the town. Odai, which runs from the north western part of the
town and drains into the river in the southern side of the town acts as the flood moderator of
the town. The other water bodies such as Mariyan Oorani and Ventakulam tank serve as the
major irrigation requirements of the town.
2.3.2 CLIMATE
Temperature
Precipitation
in inches
The climate prevailing in the town is hot & dry and there is no significant variation between
maximum and minimum temperatures. The temperature is about 340C for most of the
months. The temperature is little above 30 0C during September. Sattur is benefited from
both the North East Monsoon and the South West Monsoon. Sattur receives an annual
rainfall of 250 mm from both North east and south west monsoon.
2.3.3 GEOLOGY
Soil condition in the town is primarily black cotton (Karisal). Cholam and Cotton are grown
where tank or well irrigation is available in the town. Chillies (Sattur sannam s4) and
Cucumber that are grown in this region are very famous and are of export quality.
2.4
Gender Ratio
1047
981
1064
1003
1065
1131
1041
974
1022
985
1120
1089
Final Report
- 10 -
Ward
Total Households
13
267
14
239
15
203
16
260
17
202
18
209
19
190
20
252
21
317
22
270
23
325
24
175
Total
7881
Source: Census of India 2001
Male Population
578
458
425
511
403
462
373
463
580
535
700
328
15439
Female Population
603
653
450
527
400
443
350
473
571
545
664
362
16004
Year
1941
1951
1961
1971
Total Population
1181
1111
875
1038
803
905
723
936
1151
1080
1364
690
31443
Total Population
9,381
13,565
15,759
22,222
1981
27,143
1991
29,216
2001
31,443
Source: Census of India 1961, 71, 81, 91 and 2001
Gender Ratio
1043
1426
1059
1031
993
959
938
1022
984
1019
949
1104
25049
Growth rate in %
Variation
-4,184
2,194
Decadal
-44.601
16.174
Annual
-4.4601
1.6174
6,463
4,921
2,073
2,227
41.011
22.145
7.637
7.623
4.1011
2.2145
0.7637
0.7623
Past census data of the ULB has been obtained from census of India and the ULBs Master
Plan and population growth of the ULB is furnished in Table 2.3.Over the past decades, ULB
has exhibited a increasing growth trend in population. It can be observed that the population
growth rate has been significantly low during the last two decades.
Female
14,271
8165
42.07
Total
29,216
18,840
64.85
Final Report
- 11 -
2001
Population
Literate
% of Literate
Source: Census of India 1991 and 2001.
2.5
15,439
12,410
80.38
16,004
10,831
67.68
31,443
23,241
73.91
POLITICAL WING
In Municipal council, the Political arm of the Town consists of 24 elected councilors each
representing a ward. The Chairperson heads Municipal council which performs its duties as
per the provisions of the District Municipalities Act 1920. The Political wing provides
direction to the Municipality and performs its functions through a set of committees
constituted for different purposes.
EXECUTIVE WING
The Executive wing is responsible for day to day operations of the Municipality and is
headed by the Municipal Commissioner. The Commissioner is the Administrative head of
the Municipality and is supported by different departments in the operations.
FUNCTIONAL DEPARTMENTS
Sattur Municipality consists of Six functional departments. Each department consists of
Head who reports to the Municipal Commissioner and functions as per the responsibilities
prescribed in the Act and as delegated by the Commissioner. Departmental profile and
responsibilities of the various functional departments are explained in brief in the following
Table.
Department
General
Administration/
Personnel
Revenue
Accounts
Planning
Functions/ Duties/
Responsibilities
Establishment, Accounts,
Records, Correspondence,
Treasury
Billing and collection of taxes,
charges and fees
Control of financial matters,
preparation of budgets and
maintenance and management of
accrual based accounting system
of ULB
Preparation of master plan,
maintenance of land-use areas,
licensing of plan approval,
booking of unauthorized
constructions, approval of lay out
in the town limit, controlling and
encroachment removal within
municipal limits.
Headed by
Manager General
Administration
Revenue Inspectors (2 nos.)
Assisted By
(In the Order indicated)
Accountant, Assistant Programmer,
Junior Assistants, Record Clerk and
Office Assistants
Revenue Assistants/ Bill Collectors
(10 nos.) and Office Assistants
Accountant
Town Planning Officer
Final Report
- 12 -
Department
Engineering
Functions/ Duties/
Responsibilities
Planning, Implementation,
Operation and Maintenance of
Urban Infrastructure.
Sectors - Street lights, Roads,
Buildings, Drainage, Parks, Water
Supply and Municipal vehicles.
Public Health
Headed by
Municipal Engineer
Assisted By
(In the Order indicated)
Junior Engineer, D-man, Work
Inspector, Elec. Supdt., Electrician,
Helpers, Office Assistants, Drivers,
Meter, and Fitter
The Organizational structure comprises of six functional departments and is explained in the
following chart
SATTUR
Chairman of Council
GRADE II - MUNICIPALITY
Vice Chairman
Commissioner
Ward
Councilor
Manager
Assistant (1)
Assistant cum
Accountant (1)
Junior
Assistant (4)
Asst.
Programmer
Typist (1)
Revenue
Inspector (1)
Revenue
Assistant (8)
Sanitary
Officer
Sanitary
Inspector (1)
Sanitary
Supervisor
(2)
Sanitary
workers (57)
Town Planning
Inspector
Chainman (1)
Municipal
Engineer
Overseer (1)
Electrician
Work
Inspector (1)
Helper (1)
Junior Asst.
(1)
Fitter (1)
Driver (2)
Mini Lorry
Driver (2)
Record
Clerk (2)
Field Ass.
Office Asst.
(3)
Maternity
Ayah (3)
Watchman
Maternity
Asst. (3)
Meter
Reader (1)
Park
Watchman
Reservoir
Watchman (2)
Helper
(1)
Final Report
- 13 -
3
PROJECTION OF FUTURE POPULATION
3.1
The impact of the above factors was considered while performing the projection. Population
projection has been performed based on CPHEEO guidelines that are generally acceptable
for urban planning and infrastructure development related projects. The base criteria
adopted for the projection of future population are listed below:
Arithmetic Increase
Incremental Increase
Geometric Increase
Graphical Methods
Exponential Series
Power Series
Logarithmic Series
Linear Series
Therefore, design stages essentially reflect the period/duration for which projection is
required to design the replacements, renewals and reconstruction activities. Projection of
future population has been performed for the vision period exceeding 50 years (2008 2061).
Final Report
- 14 -
3.2
A pilot projection was performed to evaluate the past trend of decadal growth, i.e. the
population of 2001 was projected by utilizing available census data from 1961 to 1991.
The projected value (by numerical and graphical methods) was then compared with the
actual census population to identify the method that resulted in the minimum variation
(nominal - +/- 10%);
Projection of future population (2008 - 2061) was then performed by utilizing the
method(s) that resulted in the minimum variation (< 10 percent). In cases where the
variation was found to be significant (> 10 percent), the applicable methods were utilized
for comparison;
Results from the aforementioned methods were compared, average decadal growth
rates estimated and submitted for review and approval by the Review Committee.
Details of the past and present census population as provided by the ULB and verified with
the Department of Census are furnished in Table 3.1.
Year
1961
1971
1981
1991
2001
sq.km.
3.83
3.83
3.83
3.83
3.83
pers.
15,759
22,222
27,143
29,216
31,443
%
-41.01%
22.14%
7.64%
7.62%
Density
pers./sq.km.
4,115
5,802
7,087
7,628
8,210
3.3
Linear
32,860
33,199
33,365
34,881
35,428
36,195
37,244
37,354
38,390
38,963
39,328
Final Report
- 15 -
3.4
APPROVED POPULATION
The projection of future population has been
performed for the Sattur based on the pertinent
factors, potential impacts, related aspects and the
applicable methods.
It can be observed that the projection of future
population by Incremental Increase Method and
Logarithmic Method is optimal projections for the
purposes of planning for urban infrastructure
projects. Since the projections in the logarithmic
method is in negative trend, its recommended to
select the higher projected value of the
aforementioned
methods,
i.e.
Incremental
Increase Method as the design population for the
respective project design stages and vision period.
The recommended projected population is given in
the table:
3.5
Year /
Stage
1961
1971
1981
1991
2001
2008
2010
2011
2021
2025
2031
2040
2041
2051
2057
2061
Final Report
- 16 -
4
AREAS OF DEVELOPMENT NEEDS
4.1
ASSESSMENT OF NEEDS
The earlier submitted RUA Report had dealt with sector-wise description of the existing
situation, analysis/assessment and key issues/problems that the system is confronted with.
The assessment was performed to essentially gain a clear understanding of the town and its
present scenario. The report was reviewed by the Technical Review Committee comprising
pertinent authorities and approved.
The existing system/situation is observed to be far from desirable and the town is in need of
improvement across the identified mission areas and sectors. The need was not only
revealed during the analyses, but was also brought out, by the stakeholders and
beneficiaries during field visits, discussions and consultations conducted by the study team.
Therefore, it is imperative to assess the potential for future development and evolve
strategies to set the ULB on the road to well planned development.
The objective of the Strategic Plan for Sattur is to develop a long term vision and short term
strategic plan covering the priority sectors over the next five years. A City Corporate Plan
(CCP) is the corporate strategy of the ULB that presents both a vision of a desired future
perspective for the town and the ULBs organization, and mission statements on how the
ULB, together with other stakeholders, intends to work towards achieving their long-term
vision in the next five years. Thus, a CCP preparation process is essentially a consultative
process and therefore identification of stakeholders to be involved in the process is of crucial
importance. The Strategic Plan has been developed in partnership with various stakeholders
and interest group dedicated to the towns well being. Areas considered for development in
the future are given below:
Physical Development
Social Development
Slum Improvement
Economic Development
Urban Governance
Finance Improvement
4.2
PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT
The sectors covered under physical development are listed below:
Land Use;
Water Supply;
Sewerage and Sanitation;
Storm Water Drainage;
Final Report
- 17 -
4%
In order to assess the land use breakup of the town a land use survey was
conducted in 1985 and the land use
map was prepared. Review of the land
use break up of the town shows that of
the total area of 384.39 hectares of
land, only 180.05 hectares of land
constitutes the developed area, which
works out to be 47% of the total area.
The undeveloped area accounts to
204.34 hectares which works out to be
53 % of the total area.
SL.NO.
1
2
3
4
5
53%
3%
3%
15%
Residential use
Commercial use
Industrial use
Educational use
Public and Semi Public use
Agriculture use (Wet and Dry) including water bodies
Table No. 4.1: Existing Land use Pattern in Sattur LPA (Year 1995)
LAND USE
AREA IN
% TO THE
HECTARES
DEVELOPED AREA
Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Educational
Public and Semi Public
Total
Undeveloped Area
6
Agriculture use (Wet and Dry) including
water bodies
Total
Source: Master Plan for Sattur, 1995.
% TO THE TOTAL
AREA
83.04
15.88
10.56
12.30
58.27
180.05
46.12
8.32
5.87
6.83
32.36
21.60
4.23
2.57
3.29
15.15
204.34
--
53.16
384.39
100
100
Major part of the LPA is undeveloped and covered by agricultural fields, but scattered
residential developments have occurred in all parts of the Local Planning Area. At present
more than 46 % of the developed area is under the residential use. Recent incidence of
residential developments is found along the Vemmbakottai Road and Bye pass road. New
colonies such as Anna Nagar and Periyar Nagar are found in this are of the town. Details of
existing land-use pattern are shown in Table 6.1 and refer Dwg. No. 6.1 for existing land use
plan for Sattur LPA.
Final Report
- 18 -
35%
16%
9%
3%
12%
Residential use
Commercial use
Industrial use
Educational use
Public and Semi Public use
Agriculture use (Wet and Dry) including water bodies
Table No. 4.2: Proposed Land use Pattern in Sattur LPA (Year 2011)
LAND USE
AREA IN HECTARES
% TO THE TOTAL MASTER
PLAN AREA
Residential
Commercial
Industrial
Educational
Public and Semi Public
Agriculture use (Wet and Dry) including Water Bodies
Total
Source: Master Plan for Sattur, 2011.
136.40
32.88
44.56
12.30
60.27
97.98
384.39
35.48
8.55
11.59
3.20
15.68
25.50
100
Final Report
- 19 -
Railway line runs in the eastern part of the town and also the location of Kanmai on the
eastern part of the town reduces the rate of urban developments in the town. There are
agricultural lands abutting the kanmai and agriculture is done seasonal way. Agriculture is
carried on only during the rainy season of the town. Newer developments are found along
the Vemmbakottai road and Vellakarai road. River Vaippar on the southern part of the town
also inhibits growth along that direction.
POTENTIAL FOR DEVELOPMENT: The matches making and printing press which are unique
to the region is the major economic base of the town. Formation of the industrial estates and
promoting the industries supporting the growth of these industries has to be planned to
support and supplement the economic drive of the town. Also it has better linkages with rest
of the towns through SH and Railway network. Development potential of the region is linked
to its economic and industrial base of the town.
As per Master Plan 1989, nearly 53% of lands are under agriculture (both Wet & Dry) use.
Considering the demand of land for housing, commercial and industrial activities in the
future the vacant lands other than wet agricultural and water bodies can be utilized in
planned manner. DDPs prepared by the Sattur LPA need to be implemented with a view to
attract economic activities in this town.
There is an imminent need to capitalize on the industrial growth potential nodes in the LPA,
through transportation linkages especially to the nearby places of tourist interests and by
preserving heritage monuments of Sattur would increase the spatial growth potential of the
town.
Final Report
- 20 -
Final Report
- 21 -
ADEQUACY OF SERVICES
Table 4.6 shows key service indicators of the existing water supply system
Table No. 4.6: Performance Indicators - Existing Water Supply System
Sl.
Service Indicator
Unit
Current Status
No.
1.
Daily per capita supply (2006/2007)
Litres
78
2.
Roads covered with distribution network
Percent
78.63
3.
Storage capacity with respect to supply
Percent
41
4.
Treatment capacity available with respect to supply
Percent
NA
5.
Property tax assessments covered by service connections
Percent
31
6.
Proportion of non-domestic service connections
percent
3
7.
Slum population per public stand post
persons
20
Source: Sattur; 2008 and Analysis
Normative
Standard
90
> 100
33
100
85
> 5.00
150
KEY ISSUES
Discussions were held with officials and stakeholders of Sattur to assess key issues in the
present water supply system and its scope for improvement and issues identified through
discussions, field visits and service analysis are outlined below:
Rehabilitation of Old system: Old scheme which was commenced during the year 1961
requires immense rehabilitation works (both structural and mechanical) to improve the
source sustainability and to meet growing future demand as the burst in the pumping
mains has become a major problem affecting the distribution of the system; The OHTs
and the distribution lines laid then are old and they are required to be rehabilitated for
better usage.
Low Supply Levels: Even though ULB supplies 78 lpcd some places in the north eastern
fringe experiences low supply levels, because they are extended areas of the town and
do not have a service reservoir in nearby location;
Source Augmentation: The town is provided with Thamirabharani CWSS, water is
pumped for a distance of 75 kms, a reliable source; much closer to the town would
reduce O&M costs for the town.
Inequitable Distribution: While the average rate of water supply in the town appears
satisfactory, the distribution is not equitable at present water is supplied once in two
days which need to be regularized to daily supply;
Lack of a sustainable cost recovery approach to ensure sustainability of the system. At
present service charges for water supply is levied at flat rate basis which need to be
metered;
Non-Revenue Water: The distribution network in the town is old and characterized by
leaks through pipelines, faulty service connections and uncontrolled drawal from public
stand posts.
Treatment Capacity: Sattur town does not have any treatment facility except
chlorination. In view of increasing demand in the future and alternate sources such as
surface water, treatment facilities will have to be implemented;
Inadequate Service Coverage: Only about 31 % of the PTAs are provided with water
supply service connections. Existing demand for water supply has not taken into account
the requirement of water supply to the expansion areas;
Inadequate Summer Storage: Even though town receives moderate rainfall, as most of
the water bodies like Venkatakulam Kanmai are encroached, silted and used as sewage
outfalls; the summer storage capacity has been reduced.
Insufficient D-System: Part of the d-system was laid during 1964 and the lines are of CI
and AC pipes which are to be replaced and also d-system coverage has to be expanded
to the rest of uncovered areas. Although intermittent rehabilitation works have been
carried out based on complaints received, the system needs a comprehensive
rehabilitation measure based on detailed assessment.
Final Report
- 22 -
Heavy O&M Cost: Since the water supply scheme established in the town runs through
pumping from the source to service reservoir. ULB has to bear high electricity charges.
and
Need for Asset Management Action Plan: It is required to maintain an effective O&M
Schedule, for water supply assets, for regular maintenance and energy optimization.
Current Water supply rate is around 78 lpcd which is less than the normative standard of
90 lpcd but additional OHTs are under construction to supply more water to satisfy the
per capita demand
Assured source Thamirabarani CWSS and Vaippar scheme ensures water supply to
Sattur for a year.
Additional source Irunkkangudi plan is under discussion and a separate wing is there in
PWD
Municpal Sewage
Farm
There are about 2120 connections in the existing system and rest of the households in the
town uses septic tank with soak pits for treatment and disposal of sewage. In Sattur, there
are 4877 households with septic tank facility. However, the sullage from kitchen and bathing
are disposed into the road side open drains and conveyed to odai leading to Vaippar River
which is the major primary drain in the town running across southern part of town from west
Final Report
- 23 -
to east. The existing system is not properly functioning due to ageing and the blockages in
the system have resulted in the improper functioning of the system. However, it can be seen
that Sattur Municipality was one of the pioneers to get UGSS even four decades before.As
per the stakeholders discussion the extension areas of the town such as Anna Nagar,
Kamarajnagar, Madura coats, New colony i.e. the wards nos 1,3,14,8,6,7 are to be provided
with under ground sewerage scheme.
Sanitation Facilities: ULB has constructed 20 public toilets each with 8 seats in Sattur.
Also 2 pay and use type toilets with 8 seats each have been constructed within the town
limits. Of these toilets, 9 toilets are connected to the under ground sewerage scheme and
the rest has septic tank facilities. There are about 1400 slum dwellers in Sattur spread
across 6 slums. The present toilet facilities mentioned above will cover partially and rest of
them have no such arrangements.
Table No. 4.8: Key Performance Indicators
Sl. No.
Service Indicator
Unit
Current
Status
Normative
Standard
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
percent
percent
percent
percent
percent
percent
persons
28.88
NA
64
22
44.56
22
9
85
80
85
70
----
8.
percent
4.45
--
KEY ISSUES
Discussions were held with principal stakeholders of Sattur to assess the key issues that
surround the present sewerage system. The issues identified through discussions, field
visits and service analysis are outlined below:
At present there is a partial drainage scheme covering a very limited area of the town.
But it is not functioning efficiently due to aging. Letting the sullage water from houses
into the near by tanks and River cause water pollution. Letting the effluent of flush out
latrines through septic tanks in the nearby ground will ultimately cause contamination of
ground water. Because of the above facts there will be health hazards to the public. The
problem of odour and mosquito breeding is also there. Hence there is paramount
necessity to provide an under ground sewerage scheme to this town. Discharge of
untreated sewage to the river via storm water drains and to other low-lying areas and the
resultant degradation of the environment and health risk was highlighted as a major
hazard.
Inadequate and Ill-Maintained Public Sanitation: There is a high dependency by slum
population on public conveniences, the seat per person is limited and most slum
dwellers resort to open defecation;
Public awareness regarding safe sanitation is very poor.
Sattur town has been provided with partial UGD system which is constructed on 1964.
But is it has to be reconstructed due to damaged condition of the existing line. so it has
to reconstruct in the provided area
For the additional construction to cover the town funds has been allotted
Final Report
- 24 -
ADEQUACY OF SERVICES
Table No.4.10: Key Performance Indicators - Storm Water Drains
Sl.
Service Indicator
Unit
Current Status
No.
1.
Road length covered with storm water drainage
percent
70.74
2.
Pucca Drains (Open & Closed)
percent
27.89
3.
Road length covered with Pucca drains
percent
70.74
Source: Sattur; 2008 and Analysis
Normative
Standard
130
100
130
KEY ISSUES
Discussions were held with principal stakeholders of the Sattur to assess the key issues that
surround the present storm water drainage system and its scope for improvement. The
issues identified through discussions, field visits and service analysis are outlined below:
Inadequate Coverage: Drains cover only 70.74 % of the road length. Besides, the
existing drains are not well defined, thus reducing the meaningful coverage of built up
drains;
Problem Areas: Brick work, Random Rubble Masonry, Plain cement concrete drains
Damaged at many places are common within the town and drains are not properly
networked causing Missing links in many places, Lack of proper disposal system;
Due to faster growth of population and rapid increase in the land prices, habitation has
extended to the low lying areas which do not have proper drainage outlets.
Final Report
- 25 -
Roads in the town have been badly affected and damaged at several locations during
monsoons due to the inadequacy of storm water drainage networks. The monsoons
have been witnessing, year after year, overflow of several secondary and primary drains
as most stretches of these drains are silted and have not undergone desilting operations
for years.
Future population addition is expected to increase the pressure on the drainage system
of the town thereby requiring the ULB to concentrate on the development of road
networks along with that of storm water drains.
Silting and Solid Waste Accumulation: Silting and uncontrolled garbage dumping cause
blockage and stagnate water channels/wastewater runoff. Consequently, drains choke
and overflow into neighboring areas. Tanks around the town, which acted as flood
moderators, have also witnessed silting; and
Underutilized Water Bodies: Area under water bodies within the town limit is not being
put to productive use as summer storage tanks. Presently, the tanks are in dilapidated
condition. Misuse of water bodies is also noticed in terms of uncontrolled solid waste
dumping.
Number
1
1
11
59
72
Final Report
- 26 -
Collection
4.535
4.590
9.125
% Of
Collection
100%
100%
100%
DISPOSAL METHOD: At present the total waste collected form the town is transported in
Lorries and Tractors dumped in the land fill site of 4.49 acres along the in Irrukankudi Road
which is located 3 Kms away from the town. The land fill is only an open site where there is
no systematic dumping (or) scientific method of waste disposal. The existing compost yard is
not provided with adequate infrastructure facilities such as road, Waste Segregation platform
and requires improvement.
ADEQUACY OF SERVICES
Table No. 4.14: Key Performance Indicators - Solid Waste Management
Current
Sl.
Service Indicator
Unit
Status
No.
1.
Estimated waste generation per capita per day
grams
267
2.
Waste collected as estimated by ULB (w.r.t. waste generation)
percent
100
3.
Road length per conservancy staff
metres
646
Source: Sattur; 2008 and Analysis
Normative
Standard
300
100
500
KEY ISSUES
Discussions were held with principal stakeholders of the solid waste management and
officials of the ULB to assess the key issues that surround the present solid waste
management system and its scope for improvement. The issues identified through
discussions, field visits and service analysis are outlined below:
Absence of Effective Primary Collection Mechanism: The absence of the full fledged
door-to-door solid waste collection system in the town is basically leading to unhealthy
conditions in the town. The practice of throwing of the waste onto the streets is
exaggerating the problem. Segregation of waste at source is not being practiced in the
town. Source segregation and primary collection of waste through private participation,
is under active consideration by the ULB;
Inadequate Collection Vehicles & Dumper Bins: Inadequate fleet size of the collection
vehicles, mainly pushcarts and tricycles, is hampering the collection efficiency. Also,
additional dumper bins needs to be located at various locations in the town;
Lack of Scientific Waste Disposal: As the scientific disposal of waste is not followed, the
waste is being disposed through open dumping. The waste is disposed improperly
forming heaps of waste at the site, posing problem to environment and health of the
local people. Though the data pertaining to the ground water quality around the site is
not available, there is a probability of ground water contamination due to open dumping;
and
Occupation Health Hazards: The waste collection, loading and unloading operations
have been done manually. The sanitary workers have not been provided with any
protective equipment posing heath hazards.
Final Report
- 27 -
2.
B.
1
2.
2
Road Typology
Municipal Roads
Surfaced Roads
- Cement Concrete
- Blacktop/Asphalted
- WBM
Sub Total (Surfaced Roads)
Non-Surfaced Roads
- Earthen
Sub Total (Non-Surfaced Roads)
Sub Total (Municipal Roads)
Roads Maintained by Other Departments
National Highways
State Highways
Other Major Roads
Total (All Roads)
Distribution (Percentage)
9.179
22.20
0.43
26.607
24.02
49.71
1.13
2.91
2.91
31.617
7.61
2..00
2.70
2.00
38.217
5.23
7.06
5.23
100.00
Road Network / Traffic Pattern: The travel pattern in the town is guided by the road network
and land use pattern in the town. The national Highway connecting Madurai- Kanyakumari is
the major road, which runs almost in the middle of the town, bisecting the town into two
Final Report
- 28 -
equal halves. Apart from these State highways, various Major District Roads (MDR) & Other
District Roads (ODR) and other local roads maintained by state govt. connect Sattur with
surrounding rural habitations and other parts of the region.
Total road length is approximately 31.617 km within the town
limits. These roads provide the forward and backward linkages
for the transport of the matches making and its allied industries
to the marketing centers within and outside the town. The roads
provide linkages for the industrialists and people from the
neighboring villages and other parts of the State. Almost all the
roads in the core areas of the town are having inadequate
carriage way width. The main roads such as Sattur main road
have to be widened and the traffic has to be streamlined to
improve the road conditions in the town:
Apart from the aforementioned junctions the town experiences traffic congestion in the
market areas, the bus stand area. There is a no designated parking space in the town. Taxi
and autos parked along the main road in front of the Taluk office also causes traffic
congestion. Some of the major limitations noticed in the existing system of roads are
inadequate road width, inadequacy of pedestrian sidewalks, absence of two-wheeler
tracks/service lanes, and absence of parking spaces and bus lay-by.
Sattur Bus stand is situated in the enroute of Madurai Sattur Kanyakumari. The bus
stand was constructed in the year 1975 and upgraded as C class bus stand in 1988. The
bus stand is C class bus stand with 10 bus bays. Nearly 250 Buses are plying from here not
only to local villages in Sattur Taluk, but also to the various urban centers of Tamil Nadu.
ADEQUACY OF SERVICES
Table No. 4.16: Performance of Key Road related Service Indicators in Sattur
Sl.
Service Indicator
Unit
No.
1.
Road density
km/sq. km
2.
Per capita road length
metres
3.
Proportion of surfaced municipal roads
percent
Source: Sattur; 2008 and Analysis
Current
Status
10.81
0.19
90
The density of roads in the town is 4.33 km/sq. km. The per-capita road length maintained
by the ULB is 0.19 m, which is less than the standard of 1.75 m. The conditions of major
roads are good. However, minor roads and roads within individual residential colonies are in
bad condition. Footpaths and parking facilities were found lacking along the streets within
town limits.
KEY ISSUES
Discussions were held with principal stakeholders of the roads, traffic and transportation and
officials of the ULB to assess the key issues that surround the present road, traffic and
transportation system and its scope for improvement. The issues identified through
discussions, field visits and service analysis are outlined below:
Except the highways roads in the town all the other roads in the interiors of the town are
narrow. Due to this, there is tremendous traffic congestion on important roads of the
town, primarily in Sattur Main Road.
Final Report
- 29 -
Heterogeneous traffic Animal carts are commonly used for carrying goods within the
town. This obstructs the traffic flow and causes congestion on major traffic corridors.
The junctions of the town namely the Police Roundana junction, Bus stand Junction, By
pass junction are to be provided with proper road geometrics and improved to reduce
the existing chaos in the town.
Absence of road hierarchy and traffic carrying corridors. Most of the internal town roads
are single lane. Rapid growth in vehicles and population (both permanent as well as
floating) has far exceeded the carrying capacity on the road network.
Presence of blind curves along the major road leads to frequent accidents.
High Density and Congested Lanes: Roads in the central areas and surroundings of bus
stand, markets and the court are narrow and surrounded by heavily built-up areas.
These roads also carry large volumes of traffic that cater to visitors and commercial
trading in the area. These factors make the lanes highly susceptible to air pollution and
delayed travel times;
Except for a few major intersections in the town, the rest lack cohesion with road
geometry, necessitating an integrated traffic and transport system. Lack of lane
separators and unabated parking on the main roads and intersections exacerbate the
problem.
The capacity of many intersections has been saturated. Many areas mainly the core
areas (around temple) of the town are experiencing parking problems, low-speed travel,
and increased congestion.
Encroachment: The margins of roads are encroached upon in several sections of major
roads of the town by small time street vendors, illegal parking and other informal
activities. With no margins left on the roads, the effective carriageway of the road is
reduced drastically leading to congestion and accidents; and
Absence of Street Furniture/Signage: The roads/junctions lack signals, signage, and
footpaths. Improper road sweeping results in most roads being covered with top-soil,
mud and granular particles which further reduces the driving safety.
ADEQUACY OF SERVICES
Table No. 4.17: Performance of Key Street Lighting Service Indicators in Sattur
SERVICE INDICATOR
UNIT
CURRENT
STATUS
1.
Spacing between lamp posts
metres
33
2.
Proportion of fluorescent lamps (tube lights) w.r.t. total fixtures
percent
89
3.
Proportion of high power fixtures w.r.t. total fixtures
percent
11
Source: Sattur; 2008 and Analysis
SL. NO.
NORMATIVE
STANDARDS
30
60
40
Final Report
- 30 -
KEY ISSUES
Key issues in street lighting are shifting of poles along the kerb-side of the road and
inadequate street lighting. Spacing of street lights in this town is maintained as 37 m which
is far more than the standard spacing of 30 m. One of major issues in this sector is absence
high power fixtures (High Mast Light) in major road junction. Hence new street lights in the
newly formed extension areas and major junctions are required.
4.3
This town has better street lighting facility which covers 33 m of individual Spacing
between the lamp posts which is more than 3 m than the standards.
Proportion of fluorescent lamps (tube lights) with respect to total fixtures is 89 percent
which is more than the standards of 60 %
SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT
Final Report
- 31 -
Perumal koil Land abutting the Highway is to be improved as a separate park in the
town. There is also another park near the bypass road water tank, which is to be
improved. Other than the above mentioned there are 2 parks functioning in Vellakarai
road and Periyar Nagar.
Sattur has a slaughter house adjacent to the By pass road, which requires to be
modernized.
KEY ISSUES
The key issues identified through discussions, field visits and service analysis are outlined
below:
Education: In the school within the town, Teacher: student ratio is very high which affects the
quality of education. The basic infrastructure facilities in the schools are very poor and in a
dilapidated condition. Most of the schools lack of sanitation and water supply facilities was
highlighted by the stakeholders. Existing schools are operated in tiled/thatched roof which
requires Upgradation to RCC roof. There is no playground facility available within the town.
There are no adequate higher educational and professional institutions in this region.
Health: Sattur Government Hospital lacks basic infrastructure facilities and number of
doctors available is not sufficient to meet the growing demand. Present facilities are not
even sufficient to handle out patients. Even though sufficient land is available in the hospital
premises number of beds in the hospital is not been increased.
Daily Market: Though the town has a market facility in Ward no:1, the market lacks basic
infrastructural facilities and there is a increased demand for separate Meat and fish market
in the town. The existing market has very narrow roads and also the number of shops is not
adequate, resulting in encroachments along the roads and eventually causes congestion
and other traffic problems in the town.
Burial Ground: There is no burial ground under the municipality control.
4.4
Final Report
- 32 -
Water Supply: The main source of water supply in slums is met through open wells,
hand pumps and public stand posts (PSPs). The ULB has provided 69 units of water
taps covering all the slums. Dependency on the PSPs is nominal, in an average
approximately 20, persons per PSP. In addition to the PSPs the ULB also serves the
slum people with water through Lorries.
Sanitation: Most of the slums do not have access to sanitation facility. Safe sanitation
facilities comprise of public conveniences and ISPs. Public toilets are provided at 20
locations with total seats of 144 nos. Even some people in the slums resort to open
defecation on river banks, which is a cause of serious health concern. Dependency on
public convenience seat and urinals are significant, on an average each public
convenience seat serves approximately 9 persons.
Solid Waste Management: Per discussions held with ULB officials, it was indicated that
there are no designated solid waste collection points or waste bins provided in slums.
Also wastes from this place are collected once in a week. As a result, in most of the
slums, waste is disposed in nearby vacant areas and in open drains creating unhygienic
conditions.
Roads: The ULB has provided about 10.620 km length of surfaced roads within the
slums. The per capita road maintained by the ULB in slums works out to be 0.12 m that
is less than the total roads maintained by the ULB on town level.
Storm Water Drains: Slum settlements in the town are not provided with a proper storm
water drain network. Earthen drains were mostly damaged or clogged due to solid waste
dumping and silting. New formation of drains along existing roads and new roads is
essential.
Streetlights: Overall, streetlight spacing in the town is about 33 m, and in slums is
noticed to be far higher. It is noticed that several road junctions and street stretches are
poorly lit, and some of the slums are devoid of any facilities of street lighting.
Key Indicators and Issues: Following are a set of indicators, for which the current situation
and the desired values are presented. The desired values can be used as benchmarks by
the ULB to check its performance annually/ periodically and set targets for itself to be
achieved in the next financial year. The details of performance indicators are furnished in the
table below.
Table No. 4.18: Performance Indicators for Slums in the Sattur
Sl.
Service Indicators
Unit
Current
No.
Situation
1. Proportion of slum population to total city population (2005/2006)
percent
4.45
2. Household size in slums (per HH)
persons
2.98
3. Distribution network reach (against road length in slums) in slums
percent
30.36
4. Slum population per public stand post
persons
20
5. Slum population per seat of public convenience/ ISP Complex
persons
9
6. Road length (per capita road length)
metres
0.12
Source: Sattur; 2008 and Analysis
Benchmark/
Standards
< 10
-> 100
75
60
0.25 - 0.51
Final Report
- 33 -
KEY ISSUES
Following are some of the key issues pertaining to provision and delivery of services to
urban poor in Sattur Town:
Slums are densely populated and not provided with adequate infrastructure;
Poor water supply and sanitation is a major concern. The slums are not provided with
adequate number of public convenience seats and existing facilities are in dilapidated
conditions. Hence, the slum population resorts to open defecation at a number of
locations; and
Slums are provided with inadequate waste collection bins, thus resulting in dumping of
garbage on road-side and in the drains;
4.5
Slum dwellers and ULB interested in the inclusive development of the town.
Currently slums are not provided with good infrastructures but TamilNadu government
has announced several schemes to develop slum areas.
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Final Report
- 34 -
Sattur town was once very famous for fountain pen Nib manufacturing industries. More than
2000 families were involved in this industry. But during the recent times, usage of fountain
pen has come down to larger extent and hence the industry is in declining trend. This
industry, which was once the bread winning industry of the town have almost, vanished now.
Due to the Proximity to Sivakasi, large number of litho
printing press, offset printing and other allied industries are
also found in the town. Calendars and poster printing is
done at a greater scale in the town. These industries are
scattered all through the town. In spite of the ups and
downs in the industry, Sattur still retains its multifunctional
character with, industrial, commercial and administrative
activities.
Total
Population
% of
Workers
No. of
Workers
% of
Workers
Tertiary Sector
No. of
Workers
% of
Workers
No. of
Workers
% of
Workers
5395
381
49
3
6332
14436
57
97
1991
10992
37
290
2
2001
31443
14922
47
105
1
Source: Census of India 2001 & ULB Master Plan Census Data of 1991
It can be observed that although the ratio of workers to the total population has steadily
increased from nearly 37% in 1991 to 47% in 2001, there has been a palpable shift in the
sector concentration. Essentially, primary sector such as agriculture, livestock, has witnessed
decrease pointing to urbanization. Secondary sector such as Nib manufacturing was in peak
during the last decade and is only 3% in the town due to closing of most of the industries.
The tertiary sector has grown strong in the ULB with the workforce concentration growing to
97% (+40% over 1991). Tertiary sector includes sub-sectors such as Matches making,
Printing press, trade and commerce, transport, storage and communication and related
services which support the spurt in growth trend in the respective sectors in the ULB during
recent years.
Final Report
- 35 -
constructed the temple in guidance of the priest of sastha temple. To the south of the temple
is the shrine of Goddess Alamelmanga, in a sitting posture. In the Northern side, is the
shrine of Goddess Andal, in a standing posture. In addition, to the north side of the temple is
located the shrine of twelve Azhwars, nearer to which the Paramapatha Entrance and the
Yagasala are located. The traditional pipal tree, under which the main idols were unearthed
is also present in the temple. There are also large number of temples in close proximity to
the town. Some of the places of interest are listed below.
Kalugumalai one among the interesting tourist places in Tamil Nadu is located at a
distance of 20kms from the town. This place is famous for the Jain cave temple and jain
architecture. There is also a Murugan Temple called Kalugasalamoorthy Kovil which
belongs to the 18th century. Our Lady of Lourdes, (1906) is very famous church and
popular in Palayamkottai Diocese.
Based on the assessment of the existing situation, the key issues/problems in the existing
system and potential for development, Chapter 7 outlines the sector-specific demand gap
analysis, priority actions, proposals for improvement and augmentation of the sector
including estimated capital investment and the strategy for implementation along with
suggestive timelines.
Final Report
- 36 -
5
STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATIONS
5.1
IDENTIFICATION OF STAKEHOLDERS
Preparation of a City Corporate cum Business Plan (CCBP) is essentially a consultative
process and therefore identification of stakeholders to be involved in the process is of crucial
importance. The identified stakeholders may be broadly categorized as under:
Elected Representatives;
Service Providers/ GoTN Departments; and
NGOs/ CBOs and Resource Persons
The identified stakeholders are involved in a proactive manner through all stages of the
consultative process.
5.2
CONSULTATION PROCESS
5.2.1 GENERAL
Phase 1 of the assignment involved extensive consultations with the Stakeholders at the
ULB and Departmental levels. Pursuant to the Rapid Assessment Report submission, a
workshop was conducted including a wider list of stakeholders comprising non government
and other representatives.
In Phase II stage of this assignment, detailed consultations were also held with the elected
representatives and other non-governmental entities at the ULB level to obtain necessary
feedback and development requirements. In this Phase vision of the town was also
formulated through consultation process. Subsequently, development strategies, proposals,
projects, estimated capital investment plan and scheduling have been formulated and
included in this Interim Report.
The Draft Final Report for the town was submitted under Phase III of the assignment. The
report was submitted subsequent to the meeting with the ULB Council & Client to finalize the
identified projects, their priorities and capital investments. The Draft Final Report submitted
was also reviewed by the Review Committee and accorded the approval to submit Final City
Corporate cum Business Plan for Sattur Municipality. This Final City Corporate cum
Business Plan submitted towards this assignment addresses the findings and
recommendations of the study.
Final Report
- 37 -
The recommendations of Working Group have been consolidated to evolve a vision for the
town. After the meetings held from time to time, working group has come out with various
recommendations in their respective sectors. Minutes of the working group discussion are
enclosed in Annexure - 4.
Final Report
- 38 -
Review Meeting, the study team presented the Draft Final Report and committee raised few
points for clarification.
Subsequently, the study team submitted the Annexure to Draft Final Report by addressing
the review comments and related. Technical Review Committee reviewed the Annexure to
DFR and accorded the approval of Draft Final Report and recommended to submit Final City
Corporate Plan with Council approval.
On approval of the Draft Final Report, the same was then presented to the ULB council and
for finalization of CCBP covering identified investment requirements and the priority &
phasing of the identified projects for the short term and long term periods. In continuation to
the stakeholders meeting, this Final City Corporate cum Business Plan was submitted with
councils resolution.
Minutes of the consultations workshops and review meetings held are enclosed as
Annexure 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9 and 10.
5.3
Broad Objectives
Assess existing standards of service delivery
Determine need for higher standards
Priorities and preferences
Assess willingness to pay for services and
higher standards of service delivery
Assess willingness to associate to self-manage
certain urban services
Bring out inequities across space and across
category of respondents
Aspects/Sectors Covered in Demand
Assessment Surveys
Water supply
Sewerage and drainage
Solid waste management
Road network and transportation
Parking facilities
Street lighting
Social infrastructure / community facilities
Complaint redressal system
Property tax
Public awareness
Public opinion
Willingness to associate
Personal information
Households;
Urban Poor (Slum Dwellers);
Small Commercial Establishments; and
Large Commercial Establishments.
Final Report
- 39 -
Questionnaire was designed to perform the City Opinion Survey. A copy of the above
questionnaire is given as Annexure - 6. The methodology adopted for selection of samples
and sample size for each of the categories is given in the table below:
Table 5.1: Sample Selection Methodology and Sample Size
Sl.
1.
Category
Households
Rationale
2.
Urban Poor
(Slum Dwellers)
3.
4.
Small
Commercial
Establishments
Large
Commercial and
Trading
Establishments
Size (Nos.)
50
100
20
15
15
Note: In all categories, about two-third of total sample size were selected on random basis as per above suggested methodology, while remaining
one-third of the sample size were covered through purposive booster interviews to achieve balance of different types of respondents within each
category.
The surveyors were provided with on-field training for conducting the survey and the
supervisors were made responsible for maintaining the desired level of quality of the survey.
Pilot test was carried out before the commencement of the survey to ascertain: a) whether
the identified/specified respondent is able to answer the questions, b) whether the questions
were properly understood by the respondents and all appropriate responses were listed, and
c) whether any key aspects had been left out of the questionnaire. The pilot tests were
successful.
Final Report
- 40 -
Analysis of the information collected through the City Opinion Survey (COS) on several
aspects of the identified Focus Areas is presented in the following sections:
Final Report
- 41 -
Perception of Public
Priority of Public
Infrastructure
Priority Rank
6
8
Public Facilities
Sector
Park and playfield
Public Transport
School / College
Health related facilities
Community Hall
Recreation
Priority Rank
4
3
6
5
2
1
Sector
River / Lake
Air pollution
Water pollution
Land pollution
Noise pollution
Open drain
Open Space
Floods
Earth quake
Cyclone
Drought
Priority Rank
11
9
10
3
2
8
4
7
6
5
1
11
11
Parking facilities
Parking facilities
22
22
Street Light
Street Light
56
56
78
78
U GS & Sanitation
U GS & Sanitation
89
89
Drinking W ater
Drinking W ater
67
67
Road
Road
0
20
20
40
40
60
60
80
80
100
100
33
33
Community Hall
Community Hall
Health related
Health related
facilities
facilities
82
82
98
98
School / College
School / College
49
49
Public Transport
Public Transport
65
65
20
20
40
40
60
60
80
80
100
100
120
120
Drought
Drought
Cyclone
Cyclone
Earth quake
Earth quake
Floods
Floods
O pen Space
O pen Space
O pen drain
O pen drain
Noise pollution
Noise pollution
Land pollution
Land pollution
Water pollution
Water pollution
Air pollution
Air pollution
River / Lake
River / Lake
0
7
4
5
2
1
3
16
16
Recreation
Recreation
Sector
Road
Drinking Water
Under Ground Drainage &
Sanitation
Storm Water Drainage
Solid Waste Management
Street Light
Parking facilities
Rail/Road Transportation
Environment
33
33
Rail/Road T ransportation
Rail/Road T ransportation
20
20
40
40
60
60
80
80
100
100
120
120
Final Report
- 42 -
6
VISION AND STRATEGIC PLANNING
6.1
Final Report
- 43 -
Focus Areas
Economic and Urban
Development
Infrastructure Development
(Provision & Delivery)
Environment Improvement
Urban Poor and Slum
Upgrading
Urban Management and
Reforms
Urban Governance
5.
6.
The CCP process of Sattur has undergone extensive consultative process with its key
stakeholders in prioritizing the key sectors for development. The list of stakeholders
consulted and the outcome of such consultations are enclosed in Annexures 2 to 10. The
priorities of the central and state governments development goals have been considered in
prioritizing these critical sectors, presented below.
Water Supply
Sewerage
Solid Waste Management
Traffic and Transportation
Storm Water Drainage
Urban Poverty
Selection and formulation of strategies are made on the basis of judgment of outcomes not
on the bases of inputs.
6.2
STRATEGIC PLAN
A strategy is a set of actions, policies and programs/projcts designed to achieve a specific
goal. Strategies provide a direction that takes advantage of the unique conditions that exist
in a location. Thinking strategically creates not only a shared vision for the future, but also a
framework for decision-making and the allocation of limited resources.
The essence of the process of strategic plan for physical development is the involvement
and participation of the target population or the beneficiary. Strategic plan starts from the
conception of the idea of business mechanism in planning to the completion and
maintenance of the plan in a sustainable mode.
The strategic plan also suggests a ten year phasing of the proposals of the plan and it
intends to address the essential need in terms of services, in order of micro level priority,
so that a sound base would be built at the end of ten years as a take-off point, when the
citizens and citizen groups will be prepared to spare their attention without pre-occupation or
reservation from the priority, needs at individual locality level (i.e ward level), to the town
level and consciously involve themselves in the city building process. For this there should
Final Report
- 44 -
be a target or vision at town level to pursue and accordingly channelise the efforts in their
thinking, saying and doing. To arrive the future vision of the town in its perspective few
relevant queries relating to resource generation management, project feasibility with
sustainability and other support pre-requisites will be put across to the concillors and other
stakeholders.
Final Report
- 45 -
The Strategic framework for development has been evolved based on the outcome of the
Rapid Assessments and stakeholders consultations carried for this town earlier. Issues and
Potentials for development have been the main product of such assessment and the same
has been considered for evolving sector specific development objectives, primary and
supporting strategies and appropriate action plan. The following table illustrates the
Strategic Framework evolved for Sattur Municipality.
Final Report
- 46 -
No.
Primary Strategies
PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT
Land use Management
1
To Decongest core area.
1.
2.
To
achieve
Utilization of land
Optimum
1.
To
promote
a
spatial
structure of the town that
caters to the emerging
economic
activities
and
population growth.
1.
1.
2.
3.
2.
1.
2.
3.
Water Supply
1
To provide water supply at
the prescribed rate of supply
1.
2.
1.
1.
To
Minimize
component
1.
NRW
2.
1.
1.
4.
5.
2.
3.
6.
Final Report
No.
5
- 47 -
1.
2.
3.
4.
Primary Strategies
Comprehensive Asset management plan.
Institutional strengthening and capacity building.
Revenue enhancement through collection drives,
metering and tariff rationalization to raise annual
collection.
Establishment of GIS based assessment mechanism.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
1.
2.
1.
2.
1.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Final Report
No.
- 48 -
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Primary Strategies
Expanding sanitation program to low income
communities.
Providing subsidies to poorer communities for setting
LCS facility in slum areas.
Integration of existing and proposed LCS & community
toilets to proposed UGSS.
Identification of water bodies within town limits for
conservation.
Manage and control developmental activities along
water front areas.
Rehabilitation of existing water bodies.
Re-development of area adjoining water bodies for
community use, if available.
Improvements to supply channel / catchment facilities,
water quality maintenance and groundwater recharge
in water bodies.
Inventory measures to control the pollution of water
bodies.
Frequent testing of water samples.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
To
achieve
Management
of
system
efficient
natural
1.
2.
3.
4.
1.
2.
1.
2.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Final Report
No.
- 49 -
Primary Strategies
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
To
ensure
effective
processing of waste through
composting.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
1.
1.
1.
2.
3.
Final Report
No.
- 50 -
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
1.
Primary Strategies
development of parking infrastructure.
Improvement of Pedestrian Facilities.
Traffic streamlining.
Segregation of slow and fast moving vehicular traffic.
Construction of underpass/ over bridges at crossings.
Proper re-alignment of road furniture and utilities
Establishment of regional linkages considering the
future growth potentials.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Street Lighting
1
To ensure adequate street
lighting facility
2
To Reduce/minimize energy
cost
3
To Establish PPP
1.
2.
1.
2.
3.
1.
Exploration of
partnerships.
possibilities
of
public
private
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
SOCIAL DEVELOPMENT
1
1.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
Final Report
No.
- 51 -
Primary Strategies
SLUM IMPROVEMENT
1
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
Security of tenure
Affordable Housing
and
1.
2.
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
1
To
provide
employment
opportunities to all
3.
2
To encourage setting up of IT
and ITES
1.
2.
1.
2.
3.
4.
Final Report
No.
3
- 52 -
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Primary Strategies
Expansion of daily and weekly markets in the town.
Exploring possibilities of promoting commercial
activities.
Active promotion of public- private partnership (PPP)
for development and operation of infrastructure and
utilities.
Initiate collaborative arrangements with other
departments and economic development agencies to
facilitate implementation.
Facilitate assistance for enterprises to improve export
supply chains thereby increasing competitiveness
through enhanced supplier and customer relationships
and reduced operating costs.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
URBAN GOVERNANCE
1
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Efficient urban
management
1.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Final Report
No.
- 53 -
Accountability/
Transparency/ Accessibility
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Primary Strategies
Functional Restructuring.
Proposal to develop the GIS as a tool for development
planning.
Exposure to innovative practices of service delivery
followed across the country.
Establishing a Project Monitoring Unit.
Tax Reforms.
Credit enhancement options other than state
guarantees need to be adopted.
Formation of Standing Co-ordination Committee.
Private Sector Participation.
Specific code of conduct for municipal executives and
elected representatives.
Public education, resource mobilization, good
leadership and transparent processes applied to
municipal finance and development work.
Closer networking with media and their engagement in
creating public awareness and creating demand for
good governance. Cautious engagement of private
sector with continuous monitoring is necessary.
Modern and transparent budgeting, accounting,
financial management system for all urban services
and governance functions.
1.
FINANCIAL IMPROVEMENT
1
Computerization Initiatives.
1.
2.
3.
Reforms.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
Final Report
No.
- 54 -
Privatization Initiatives.
1.
2.
Resource
Initiatives.
1.
Mobilization
2.
Capacity Building
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Primary Strategies
urban governance service delivery through reforms.
Exploring areas of privatization.
Formulation of framework for attracting private
investors.
Collection of arrears through innovative ideas and
approaches using tools for community participation
and fast track litigation methods.
Strengthen the fiscal powers of ULB to fix tax rates, fee
structure and user charges through specific guidelines
and notifications, which should find a place in the
Municipal Rules. Prepare model guidelines for the city
to allow greater flexibility in levying taxes, fees and
user charges, borrowing funds and incurring
expenditures;
Staffing pattern, organizational restructuring and
performance appraisal.
Development of MIS for effective and efficient
management & decision-making.
Publication of newsletters for creating awareness and
participation.
Prepare and conduct capacity building programmes for
elected
representatives,
especially
women
representatives, with a view to enable them to focus on
gender based issues.
Promote the creation of interactive platforms for
sharing municipal innovations, and experiences among
municipal managers.
Better human resources management through
assessment of the training needs of personnel involved
in urban administration to enhance management and
organizational capabilities.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
Final Report
- 55 -
7
INFRASTRUCTURE & FINANCIAL IMPROVEMENT
NEEDS
7.1
INTRODUCTION
This section of the Report pertains to the probable proposed development initiatives and
specific improvements that shall be recommended to upgrade the existing systems in Sattur
to normative standards pertaining to Urban Infrastructure provision, delivery, operation and
maintenance and bringing out the characteristics required for the town.
A City Corporate Cum Business Plan (CCBP) is the corporate strategy of the ULB that
presents both a vision of a desired future perspective for the town and the ULBs
organization, and mission statements on how the ULB, together with other stakeholders,
intends to work towards achieving their long-term vision in the next five years. Thus, a
CCBP preparation process is essentially a consultative process and therefore identification
of stakeholders to be involved in the process is of crucial importance. The identified
stakeholders represented both government and non-government sectors.
The identified stakeholders may be broadly categorized as under:
Elected Representatives;
Service Providers/GoTN Offices;
Business Houses and Associations; and
NGOs/CBOs and Resource Persons
7.2
CONSULTATION PROCESS
The entire CCBP preparation process has been divided into three phases. The outcomes of
each of the phases were based on extensive consultations and consensus emerged
thereon. Phase 1 of the assignment involved extensive consultations with Vision
Stakeholders, while Phase 2 has a wider list of stakeholders comprising representatives
from various walks of life, identified as Mission Stakeholders. Phase 3 of the assignment
involved Action Stakeholders who were identified to participate in implementation of the
CCBP. The study team had specific consultations with these stakeholders and specific roles
and responsibilities were evolved so as to implement the CCBP. Each of the above phases
culminated with a workshop, which endorsed the findings with specific remarks and
suggestions.
Broadly, the consultation process was carried out in the following manner:
Final Report
- 56 -
7.3
MISSION AREAS
An assessment of existing physical infrastructure and various basic urban services (social
infrastructure - education, recreation, community, health facilities, etc.) in the town to be
performed was made. Description and mapping to quantify the condition of basic amenities
and urban services was also made, highlighting the needs and deficiencies sector-wise as
follows:
Water supply;
Sewerage and storm water drainage;
Solid waste management;
Roads, traffic and transportation;
Streetlights;
Other basic urban services and facilities; and
Slum upgrading and housing for the poor;
An assessment of the existing situation covering all the sectors like water supply, sanitation,
drainage, solid waste management, internal roads, bridges, traffic management, public
private transportation and streetlights at the town level was carried out specifically covering
the following illustrative aspects:
Sector-Specific Analytical Instruments:
Sl. No.
1.
Study Component
Water Supply
2.
Sewerage and
Drainage
3.
Solid Waste
Management
4.
Analysis / Coverage
Appraisal of water supply augmentation proposals in conjunction with
existing distribution systems, leak detection and UFW levels,
replacement needed, measures that need to be undertaken to promote
continuous system of water supply, and other requirements for
optimum economic performance. Review of existing status of the
service in terms of sources, storage and distribution, treatment,
alternative supply, connections and tariff, utility maps, nature of
complaints
and
origins.
Metering
system
and
revenue
generation/enhancement.
Appraisal of the sewerage and drainage systems with reference to their
adequacy; augmentation of collection system, sewage treatment
facilities and treated wastewater re-use/disposal systems. Review of
existing status of the system in terms of type, O&M aspects, nature of
complaints and origins, areas prone to flooding, etc. Reviewing of the
environmental procedures and plans, low-cost sanitation and system
integration.
Existing facilities and system management for handling solid waste.
characteristics of solid waste, quantity generated, collection and
transportation system, transfer stations, and waste processing/disposal
facilities
Road Length, Density, Coverage, Types, Connectivity, Linkages,
Congestion, Parking Requirements, capacity utilization, traffic flow,
infrastructure such as bus terminals, O&M aspects and related.,
appraisal of efficiency and equity of urban transport models, including
public and private transportation system, traffic management, etc.
Final Report
Sl. No.
5.
Study Component
Streetlights
6.
Education, Health
and Community
Facilities
Deficiency Analysis
7.
7.4
- 57 -
Analysis / Coverage
Spacing, coverage, capacity utilization, energy efficiency, O&M
aspects and related
Number and location of various education, health, leisure and
community facilities, O&M aspects, coverage, adequacy with respect to
normative standards, catchment, etc.
Identification of criteria for deciding deficiency for various services;
Final Report
- 58 -
7.5
Computerization Initiatives;
Property Tax Reforms;
Privatization Initiatives;
Accounting Reforms; and
Resource Mobilization Initiatives.
The following policy framework and priority actions are required for the sustainable financial
improvement of town.
STRATEGY
Innovations both at policy and project levels to speed up the urban reform process.
Reforms to have in-built mechanism of participation and commitment.
Institutional strengthening and financial capacity building to be an integral part of the
reform measures.
Areas of reform measures include property tax, accounting and auditing and resource
mobilization and revenue enhancement.
Final Report
- 59 -
PROPERTY TAX
Bringing transparency and uniformity in taxation policies.
Tax policy and operational procedures should be simple and clear.
Development of templates for property tax (for self-assessment) to increase tax
collection (without levying fresh taxes), including implementation strategies.
Mapping of properties and developing GIS-enabled property tax management system for
enhancing property tax net/coverage and better administration.
Collection of arrears through innovative ideas and approaches using tools for community
participation and fast track litigation methods.
Property tax base should be de-linked from rental value method and should be linked to
unit area or capital value method.
ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING
Accounting reforms - shifting from single entry cash based accounting system to accrual
based double entry accounting system.
Legislative changes in the accounting systems and reporting requirements.
Designing of accounting procedures.
Accounting manual - chart of accounts, budget codes, forms and formats, etc.
Standardized recognition norms for municipal assets and revenues.
Auditing of accounts should be carried out effectively and regularly to promote
transparency and accountability.
RESOURCE MOBILIZATION AND REVENUE ENHANCEMENT
Increasing revenue through measures for better coverage, assessment, billing,
collection and enforcement.
Controlling growth of expenditure.
Improving the organization and efficiency of the tax administration system.
Augmentation of resource mobilization/revenue generation from properties belonging to
ULB for improving the overall financial health.
Energy audit of fuel and energy consumption by various depts. of ULB to minimize
expenditures on fuel and energy, including energy audit and metering of street lights.
Streamlining and strengthening of revenue base of the ULB:
o
o
o
o
Strengthen the fiscal powers of ULB to fix tax rates, fee structure and user charges
through specific guidelines and notifications, which should find a place in the
Municipal Rules. Prepare model guidelines for the city to allow greater flexibility in
levying taxes, fees and user charges, borrowing funds and incurring expenditures;
The annual report of the ULB shall devote a section highlighting the amounts of
subsidy given to a particular service, how the subsidy was funded, and who were
its beneficiaries;
Implementation of MIS to provide relevant information on accounts, commercial
and operating systems for better decision-making and information dissemination to
citizens; and
Application of e-Governance is equally important for municipal finance.
Apart from the above, following are some of other reform measures which should be
implemented to support the above identified key municipal reforms.
URBAN ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
The costs of maintaining a healthy urban environment need to be recovered through various
municipal taxes and user charges following the polluter pays principle. For this, the
functional role of the ULB as envisaged in Item 8, 12th Schedule of the Constitution has to be
resolved keeping in view the role of the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board, and the
organizational and fiscal strength of the ULB.
Final Report
- 60 -
Final Report
- 61 -
7.6
Final Report
- 62 -
Final Report
- 63 -
8
DEVELOPMENT PROPOSALS
8.1
INTRODUCTION
This section outlines the proposed development initiatives
and specific improvements that are recommended to
upgrade the existing system of Urban Infrastructure
provision, delivery, operation and maintenance to normative
standards and characteristics required for a State Capital.
Rapid assessment performed provides for cognitive
navigation through the analysis and recommendations in
various phases in the preparation of the City Corporate
Plan for the town. The sectors covered in this chapter are
given in the adjacent box.
Sectors covered
Land Use;
Water Supply;
Sewerage and Sanitation;
Storm Water Drains;
Solid Waste Management;
Roads, Traffic and Transportation;
Street Lighting;
Basic Services for the Urban Poor;
Other Amenities;
Environmental Improvement;
Urban Governance; and
Social Amenities
Details of the investment components, capital investment phasing plan based on the above, and discussions with Stakeholders
are enclosed in subsequent sections of the report.
The sector-wise estimated capital investment and investment components required to achieve stated objectives within the
period (2008-2012) is given in this section.
Sectoral investment for proposed interventions across all sectors has been estimated based on the following parameters:
Information available/provided by concerned departments, detailed discussions with pertinent authorities, field/site visits,
techno-economic evaluation/analysis conducted by the consulting team;
Standard Schedule of Rates issued by PWD, Highways, and other engineering boards/organizations, OP rates, prevailing
market rates, and relevant information;
Costs indicated are only estimated costs. Detailed cost estimation shall be performed for each item of work pursuant to
detailed design engineering (during the DPR preparation);
Capital and annual O&M cost of the water and sewage treatment facilities, as applicable, has been estimated considering
the techno-economically most feasible alternative technologies; and
Necessary provision for physical contingencies, cost escalation for implementation period greater than 18 months,
administration/supervision and consultancy charges have been included.
Based on the assessment of the existing situation, projected demand, the prevalent gap and
key issues/problems in the existing system, upcoming section outlines the priority actions,
proposals for improvement, estimated capital investment and the strategy for
implementation along with suggestive timelines.
8.2
LAND USE
The land use structure has been worked out based on Master Plan prepared for the town
and the activity centres present. The structure would help in limiting congestion of certain
areas through a conscious and judicious development of core town and the peripheral
wards, which have the maximum potential to grow in future. Considering the existing
landuse and the potential for development, a growth management policy has been
formulated. The policy is to allow growth of the town for a sustainable future through
dispersal of economic and developmental activities. Accordingly the following strategies
have been evolved.
Final Report
- 64 -
8.2.1 RESIDENTIAL
On the whole the residential land use growth is quite satisfactory, occupying about 46% of
the total land use as is proposed in the master plan. However, certain wards have
experienced tremendous growth resulting in saturation of densities and in such cases; the
proposal is to redistribute the densities in the different wards. Though it is impractical to limit
residential developments, the policies shall be formulated in such a way that a regulated FSI
and non conversion of residential to mixed or commercial land use would relieve the
pressure on residential land uses in future.
The additional population coming into the town over the years shall be accommodated within
sustainable limits of the peripheral areas. Increasing the residential land use beyond the
existing percentage of 35% may not be sustainable and hence the strategy would be to
increase the FAR in peripheral wards. This should also be supplemented through
development control regulations and guidelines that avoid conversion of residential use into
mixed and commercial uses in such residential zones. However, major initiatives shall not
be possible as most of the town as developments in the town are saturated, and the wards
adjoining the transport corridors (i.e. NH 7) have reached saturation. There are other
constraints such as water bodies, slums, ecologically sensitive zones in others leaving only
a few wards offering potential for growth.
8.2.2 COMMERCIAL
The commercial land use is slightly above at 8.32% than the UDPFI norms. One reason
could be the absence of decongestive policies in the past allowing development of a number
of commercial areas within the town. In addition, the town acts as the commercial node for
regional activities which has resulted in concentration of economic activities in the town.
Commercial developments are found in a linear manner along the major corridors of the
town, which in turn defines to the newer land uses in these areas and forms the major
guiding factor for developments along the commercial areas along Kanyakumari to Madurai
trunk Road, Railway Station Road and also along the by pass road. The Core-Town area
has to be retained for specialised commodities to retain the character of the area. With the
town functioning as the node for the region, there is further scope of further commercial
development and shall be mitigated by development of a series of commercial centres as
indicated below:
The town shall promote Local Business Districts and Central
The town shall promote two
Business District as the formal commercial centres in identified
types of formal commercial
areas considering its limiting growth in future. The market
activities
forces and the convenience of the walking distance of 5 min for
the local population will essentially decide the quantum of such
Final Report
- 65 -
Padanthal Road and Kanyakumari to Madurai trunk road are the major commercial stretches
so it can be called as CBD for Sattur. With more than 90% of the total formal commercial
area of the town in this area, it has reached a saturation level and any further increase might
lead to agglomeration diseconomies. Hence, active and sustained decongestion initiatives
shall be adopted by means of certain market friendly development mechanisms.
Areas identified for Formal Commercial Activities: area
extending along the Kanyakumari to Madurai trunk road has a
potential for further commercial development. Although the
master plan would have freezed on the land use, the same
shall be altered to declare these areas as formal commercial so
as to adopt a higher FSI.
Provision of Additional
the CBD. It is pertinent to increase the area under the institutional
Public facilities &
Spaces
component. Such public facilities like community centres,
exhibition grounds, recreation areas, open spaces etc are not available in the town and need
to be provided for a better quality of life.
Open Spaces: Currently, the quantity of open space is very limited excluding the area under
water bodies. Considering a per capita recreational requirement of 4 Sq.mt, the area under
the open spaces shall be to the tune of 6% of the total area.
However, qualitatively the role of open spaces shall be further enhanced taking advantage
of the environmental resources such as natural tanks available in the town. These
environmental resources including, flora and fauna, are valuable to the town in terms of their
resource value and have to be conserved to enhance the sustainability of the same. This
would mean that considerable open-spaces have to be generated for its meaningful role in
conserving the regional natural resources & biodiversity and this would also add value to
recreational activities. In addition, networking of water bodies is being propagated to
rejuvenate these resources and to integrate them with town wide developments.
Transportation: The major issue confronting the town is
integration of land use with the transport system. With inadequate
road space and widths, the town lacks an efficient circulation
pattern. This shall be alleviated by developing a hierarchy of
Final Report
- 66 -
widened road network to decongest the core town and other commercial areas. The current
developments and the analysis on the potential for development indicate the wards on the
periphery of the town towards west are likely to experience a high growth in future. Hence, it
is necessary to provide a sustainable mobility plan for these areas in the form of connecting
links.
8.2.5 STRATEGIES
Decongesting Core Town Area: Decongesting the core
Growth Management Strategies
area shall be taken up in the right earnest. Though,
14
21
22
24
Final Report
- 67 -
Constraint Wards
Due to the presence of municipal sewage farm
development in the 14 ward is becomes less and another
reason for the constraint is social status of the people in
this wards. 8, 21, 22, 24 wards has a physical constraint
of Vaippar river inhibiting further development. The
constraint wards are shown in the figure above.
Constraint Wards
Potential Wards
Ward number 1and 3 has potential for further developments due to the constraint in the
southern direction developments are mainly along the northern and north western side of
the town. Alignment of the bypass road and incidence of the layouts in these areas adds to
the potential of growth in these wards. The new alignment of NH 7 and the potential wards
are shown in the figure above.
Revitalizing Commercial and Mixed Land uses: The assessment with respect to the
current land use indicates that there is still scope for commercial activity but should be
balanced and distributed Accordingly, land use policy shall consider development of formal
commercial structures at places indicated. This will also help to decongest the core town
areas. The specific strategies include:
The policies along with the strategies for growth management within the town are
enumerated in Table 8.1.
Final Report
- 68 -
Width of Road, Plot Size vs Land use Type, FSI, Building Height & Setbacks
Parking Space vs Land use, FSI& Coverage
Since the core town is being proposed as an active CBD with more commercial use, the
building rules and regulations need to support this through more FSI assigned to these
areas. This is also needed since the core areas are already saturated and the additional
population and hence the higher densities would mandate vertical development.
In addition, certain areas along the Vembakkottai road, Venkatachalapuram road and
Final Report
- 69 -
towards Madurai have seen an increase in development activities and hence climb in the
FSI and these areas are also where certain formal commercial areas are being proposed.
Hence limited increase in FSI for the commercial use in these areas is necessary to see that
the land use pattern doesnt turn into mixed uses. Considering the proposed arterial
structure, it is proposed to accommodate higher densities with a medium rise in structure in
these areas.
8.3
WATER SUPPLY
It can be observed from the above table that the existing system requires immediate
augmentation. The system is not capable of meeting the increasing water demand through
its present available sources till the year 2010 (assumed based on projected population).
Hence considering the increasing water demand through its present available sources till the
year 2040 (assumed based on projected population) augmentation measures need to be
identified considering the utilization plan of the existing sources (Thamirabharani River and
Vaippar river). Existing systems should be utilized only to the presently installed capacity
and should not be overloaded because of low supply level in the aforementioned sources
during the summer months (considerable part of the year). Therefore it is felt that additional
scheme can be augmented for meeting the ultimate stage water demand conditions. It is
important that capital investments in the water supply sector are planned to broadly address
the following issues:
Augmentation of installed capacity of existing facilities to meet the growing demand; and
Rehabilitation of existing facilities to avoid higher costs of deferred and inadequate
maintenance.
Therefore, the priority actions identified through discussions with stakeholders and the
proposals planned for the system improvement have been recommended with the intension
of achieving the following objectives:
Optimal utilization of the available strengths of the system through requisite identification
and creation of opportunities for system improvement and sustainability; and
Implementation of remedial measures based on identified weaknesses of the
system/sector to ensure that imminent and potential (future) threats are eliminated and
prevented from recurring.
Non-Revenue Water/ Unaccounted for Water (NRW/UFW) and system losses need to be
mitigated and monitored to ensure that the total losses do not exceed the allowable limits
(15 percent) as specified in the CPHEEO guidelines. Further reduction of the losses through
an effective and continual leak detection and water audit program is highly recommended
and this would prove advantageous in the long-term.
Final Report
- 70 -
Final Report
- 71 -
Water Supply Operation & Maintenance Plan: The plan shall be designed largely by
involving the Private Sector for O & M operations. This may be done through a management
contract with a private agency, which would be solely responsible for the O & M of the
system, based on agreed annual fee, with built-in incentives for improved performance.
Asset Management Plan: To address the condition assessment and the performance of the
water supply assets, it is recommended that a detailed asset management plan be prepared
for the assets of water supply in Sattur town.
Consumer Metering System: The ULB need to initiate metering system in the town. For the
projected population, there shall be about of metered connections in ultimate design year of
2040. It is, therefore important that service connections be provided with metering system
under this project. The metering system is very important as it would provide a platform for
proper accounting of the water production and consumption and help reduce the
unaccounted for water and help in revenue generation.
Tariff Revision: Future capital investments on system up-gradation being imminent, the tariff
structure shall be revised from time to time to enable cost recovery and to service the
additional debt from the capital investments.
Unaccounted for Water: ULB shall implement leak detection studies to ascertain the volume
of unaccounted water. This to an extent, if corrected properly, would help ULB to realize
more water.
Re-cycle & Re-use: Strategy for Use of Recycled water for Non-potable use, based on a
Pilot Study for the ULB.
Mapping & GIS: To address the issue of system rehabilitation, mapping and establishing a
GIS system is pertinent to detail out system location, characteristics, age and condition. This
would enable identifying dilapidated sections of the network and those that require
replacement.
Institutional Strengthening & Capacity Building: The officials need to be trained for Project
Planning, Implementation, and Monitoring and Evaluation programs. It is recommended for
strong Strategic Plan database particularly to decrease the duplication of laying of pipeline
for same distribution as well as for a strong redressal system and minimizing unaccountable
losses & illegal connections.
Water Resource
Development of Distribution network for extended areas
Management
Rainwater Harvesting Measures
Water Supply
Redistribution/Re-zoning of D-system in existing areas
System
Rehabilitation of Existing Service Reservoirs
Final Report
Component
- 72 -
PROPOSALS
The improvement to the water supply system is
designed to ensure that the installed water supply
infrastructure meets the community's needs (water
demand) for adequate and equitable supply at
reasonable charges. The projected demand for the
year 2025 is compared with the optimum supply
available from the existing source, to verify the
adequacy and need to augment the capacity of
certain components.
Table 8.4: Demand, Supply and Required Augmentation of Water Supply System for 2025
Demand
Component
Unit Supply
Status
Current
Short-term
Long-term
Year 2008
Year 2010
Year 2040
Demand
Surplus
Demand
Surplus
Demand
Surplus
(Deficit)
(Deficit)
(Deficit)
Water Intake Pumping
MLD
2.70
4.60
(1.90)
4.70
(2.00)
7.02
(4.30)
Water Treatment Plant
MLD
(if Surface water Used)
0
(4.60)
(4.70)
(7.02)
Service Storage
ML
1.70
4.60
(2.90)
4.70
(3.00)
7.02
(5.32)
Distribution System
Km
24.78
60.40
(35.62)
62.04
(35.63)
91.10
(66.32)
Source: Analysis
As reported by the ULB the average drawl of water from the existing sources is worked out
to be 2.70 MLD. The total requirement of water is calculated as 4.70 MLD for the short-term
period (2010) and 7.02 MLD for the long-term period (2040). Deducting the existing quantum
of water availabilities, the net requirement of water for short-term period is 2.00 MLD and
4.30 MLD for long-term period. Both Service storage facility and Distribution system are not
sufficient to meet the short-term demand. From the above table, it is confirmed that
additional distribution mains of 35.63 km length and service reservoirs of 5.32 ML needs to
be established to fulfill the present demand.
Apart from the aforementioned proposals the following requirements are identified through
Stakeholders consultation:
Even though existing storage capacity is more than 45% of total quantity supplied, some
parts of the town are not provided with sufficient water supply facility. In order to provide
equitable supply to the public the following additional service reservoirs are suggested;
1. Sump with booster station or an OHT is required to supply equitable water to
wards 1, 2, 6 and 19.
2. Existing GLR requires improvement works.
Pumping mains are to be re-laid for more than 10kms to problems pertaining to the
supply in the town.
Replacement of d-system was stressed at certain locations in the town;
New distribution system to an approximate length of 15km is essential;
In order to meet the water demand during summer months local bore well source need
to be established at suitable locations;
All the Booster stations require a DC generator facility, since frequent power problem in
the system lead to a fluctuation in supply; and
Final Report
- 73 -
Irunkkangudi Dam can be utilized to serve the water supply need of the town in longterm period. This dam is located at a distance of 5 kms from the town, at present the
water from the dam is used for irrigation purpose. ULB need to examine the feasibility of
the project in consultation with PWD.
The numbers of house service connections in the town are to be increased.
The following proposals have been identified by the study team based on the reported
evaluations, discussions and priority actions as required and mutually agreed upon by the
Stakeholders:
The above proposals are envisaged to initially cover the problem areas within the town as a
first priority, and then in later stages the concept of design/implementation similar to that
adopted for ULB, can be implemented on a modular/zonal basis in the peripheral areas
consistent with future development.
Final Report
8.4
- 74 -
The demand-gap assessment has been performed for the short-term period, i.e.
intermediate stage (15 years) and for the long-term, i.e. ultimate stage (30 years), and is
presented in the table 7.6 below:
Project SubComponent
Table 8.6: Demand, Supply and Required Augmentation of UGS System for 2040
Unit
Existing
Demand
Status
Base
Intermediate
Ultimate
Year
Year 2010
Year 2025
Year 2040
2008
Demand /
Surplus/
Demand /
Surplus/
Demand /
Surplus/
Generation
(Deficit) Generation (Deficit) Generation (Deficit)
In nos.
34519
35448
43125
52055
MLD
2.10
3.80
4.60
5.60
-
Population
Sewage
Generation
New Infrastructure
Sewage Pumping
Sewage Treatment
Plant
Sewer Network
MLD
MLD
(3.80)
(3.80)
4.60
4.60
(4.60)
(4.60)
5.06
5.60
(5.06)
(5.60)
11.386
62.03
(50.65)
km
Estimate of Requirement of Land for Sewage Treatment Alternatives
Waste Stabilization Acres/
Pond @ 4 acres /
MLD
15.20
(15.20)
MLD
Activated Sludge
Acres/
Process @ 0.25
MLD
0.95
(0.95)
acres / MLD
Source: Analysis
75.46
(64.08)
91.10
(79.72)
18.40
(18.40)
22.40
(22.40)
1.15
(1.15)
1.40
(1.40)
Km
3.80
3.80
Note: Requirement of land has been estimated based on available information on sewage treatment plants of similar scale, process of treatment,
scalability and related issues. The nominal footprint/area required for a specific plant is known to vary based on the degree of treatment required,
configuration of the land available, detailed design of treatment facilities and related factors. Decentralized sewage treatment facilities may result in
a net higher requirement of land. The land requirement indicated in this report is provided only for comparison/reference purposes. Actual land
requirement for the proposed STP(s) in related procurement/acquisition/estimation should be arrived at pursuant to relevant surveys, investigation
and detailed engineering design of the proposed facility.
Final Report
- 75 -
Preferred Treatment Facility: Treatment of collected sewage in accordance with the pollution
control norms and river discharge standards is critical and poses a significant hazard to
public health if not designed, implemented, operated and maintained in a proper manner. A
scientific method of treatment such as Activated Sludge Process (ASP) is the best suitable
treatment method in order to reduce the land requirement and to reduce health nuisance.
Before implementing the UGS scheme, ULB should achieve 100% water supply service
connection (except slum areas) by expanding their coverage and augmenting the water
supply system to ensure an average per capita water supply rate of 135 litres per day for the
efficient operation of the proposed sewer system and willingness of the public to avail UGS
connection by paying deposits and user charges.
Re-Cycle & Re-Use: Another issue that must be dealt with is the re-use of treated
wastewater, which can reduce the overall demand on freshwater. The following uses are
recommended for further evaluation:
Coverage of Low Income Settlements: There are 201 households in slum within the town
limit. All these slum areas are partially provided with the sanitation facility. Therefore it is
proposed to cover this locality by using Pay & Use type / Free / Low Cost Sanitation toilet
facility under GoI & GoTN schemes.
Operation & Maintenance Plan: Adoption of an O&M Plan and Schedule, including options
of using the private sector for O&M (e.g. management contract). The ULB can privatize
O&M of pumping stations and STPs through a service or management contract with the
private sector who would be solely responsible for the O & M of the system, based on an
agreed annual fee, with built-in incentives for improved performance.
Final Report
- 76 -
Mapping & GIS: The O&M shall also include mapping & GIS of the sewer system, for proper
upkeep and maintenance and regular updation. This would enable constant vigilance with
regards to system malfunctions and promote effective maintenance.
Asset Management Plan: To address the condition assessment and the performance of the
Sewerage assets, it is recommended that an asset management plan be prepared for the
UGS Assets in ULB.
Tariff Revision: Future capital investments on system up-gradation being imminent, the tariff
structure shall be revised from time to time to enable cost recovery and to service the
additional debt from the capital investments. It is proposed to introduce a Separate Sewer
Charge to service the debts and sustain O&M, of the new Capital Investments.
Institutional Strengthening and Capacity Building: Recruitment of trained engineering
personnel for management of Sewer works is an important issue confronting the ULB, the
present system is being implemented by TWAD Board and shall be transferred to the ULB
for maintenance of Assets, and as well of more importance is to keep them technically
updated. It is necessary that periodic training be imparted to the operations staff of the ULB.
The aforementioned strategies to a significant extent assist in provision of an efficient
system of sewerage, adequate coverage, treatment and disposal in accordance with
applicable discharge standards and full cost recovery. The master plan shall also focus on
provision of sewerage and sanitation facilities in the newly planned layouts and peripheral
areas to ensure coordinated development.
Activity
Development of Sewerage System for Town
Sewerage Collection,
Provision of Sewage Treatment Plant
Treatment &
Community toilet integration
Management
Recycling Plant & Reuse system
Sanitation Facility
Community toilets
PROPOSALS
The projected demand for 2040 is compared with
Proposed Capital Works - UGSS
Final Report
- 77 -
8.5
A well designed and developed master plan for storm water drainage should be
developed focusing on areas such as projected growth of population and incidental
development of road network, updated rainfall details, low-lying areas, rainwater
harvesting requirements and other relevant parameters.
It is also imperative to conduct awareness programs at the town level to cover all
classes of residents to highlight the function of storm water drains, prevention of
encroachment of storm water drain areas, prevention of dumping of solid waste and
discharge of sewage/sullage from households and other related issues.
Final Report
- 78 -
Drainage Rehabilitation Program: The flood prone areas identified are to be relieved of the
problem in future by undertaking a drainage rehabilitation program. As a part of this
program, the leading/connections between secondary and tertiary drains to primary drains
have to be improved and strengthened. In addition, control of weed growth, limiting the
dumping of solid and construction waste and controlling the growth of encroachments would
be given priority.
Primary Drain Rehabilitation and Improvement Program: The primary drains are inadequate
to handle the flash floods as they are not systematically designed and are not fully
constructed in some sections. Moreover, significant reduction in depth and width are noticed
due to siltation and encroachment of drain bunds. To alleviate these, a rehabilitation and
improvement program is recommended.
Improvement Works and Construction of Tertiary Drains: Construction of tertiary drains
(pucca only) would be taken up on a priority basis as the town comprises of 28 km. of
tertiary drains. It is proposed to construct pucca drains to all the major arterials and
important roads to increase the pucca drain coverage to facilitate proper draining of storm
water into natural drains.
Operation & Maintenance Schedule: Adoption of an O&M Schedule for works varying from
Drain Cleaning to Desilting, including options of using the private sector for O&M (e.g.
Management Contract).
Monitoring and Quality Control: Monitoring of water quality parameters need to be
conducted on a regular basis. ULB need to take up the responsibility of monitoring the
parameters in the water bodies within its jurisdiction and take preventive measures, if the
results are above the permissible limits. The horticulture department of town would devise
pro-active strategies to limit pollution to water bodies within its limits and would co-ordinate
with other agencies for monitoring the parameters in the water bodies.
Principles to Strive for in Storm Water Management
These four principles provide a helpful framework for looking at storm water plans:
Control: Control measures can be broken down into two categories: source control and runoff control.
Source control measures focus on pollution prevention. Their objective is to avoid or limit the generation of
pollutants. Typical source control Measures include proper containment measures; spill prevention and
cleanup, waste reduction, public education, illicit connection control, and reduced use of fertilizers and
pesticides. Runoff control measures focus on minimizing runoff from new developments, and siting
infrastructure to discourage development in environmentally sensitive areas. These controls are costeffective if implemented in the site-planning phase of new development projects. Examples of these controls
at the municipal planning level include zoning ordinances, subdivision regulations, buffers, and setback
requirements. Runoff control measures also include techniques for slowing down runoff.
Collection: Capture and storage of runoff for more timely release is a vital component of most storm water
management systems Retention basins are areas designed to hold the storm water permanently until it
infiltrates into the ground. Detention basins are meant to slow and hold storm water before releasing it.
Conveyance: Conveyance systems are used to drain and direct the flow of runoff generated on a site. This
is often done with catch basins feeding into storm sewers. More natural systems, using vegetated
depressions and swales which look and function much like the natural drainage system, should be used
whenever possible.
Cleansing: Control, conveyance, and collection of runoff mean little without provisions for cleansing.
Cleansing is commonly accomplished through techniques that promote filtration and settling of pollutants
and their natural processing by vegetation and soil. Filtering devices include engineered structures like
sediment basins and porous pavement, but also include natural systems like stream buffers and vegetated
filter strips. Depending on their design, many collection systems like ponds and constructed wetlands also
serve to clean water.
Therefore, the priority actions identified through discussions with stakeholders and the
proposals evolved for improvement are specifically intended to achieve dual objectives, viz.
optimal utilization of the available strengths of the system through requisite identification and
creation of opportunities for system improvement and sustainability, and implementation of
remedial measures based on the identified weaknesses of the system/sector to ensure that
the imminent and potential (future) threats are eliminated and prevented from recurring.
Final Report
- 79 -
Construction of
Formation of new drains along proposed road network
Drains
Treatment and re-use of storm water
Year
4
Year
5
As specified earlier, priority actions identified by the stakeholders, discussed and finalized
pertaining to development of the existing network of storm water major and minor drains
including catchment, surface and area drains in Sattur are furnished below:
PROPOSALS
The ULB should increase the Service levels in
terms of coverage, to achieve coverage of 130
percent of Road Length, through Pucca Built-up
Drains. The ULB is recommended to adopt the
strategy for rejuvenation of water bodies, to be used
as sources for re-charging and as Summer Storage,
and through networking of Water Bodies, to
increase Water Sustainability.
Final Report
- 80 -
Table 8.10: Demand, Supply and Required Augmentation of Drainage System for 2011
Demand
Project Sub-Component
Unit
Existing
Status
Year 2008
Year 2011
Demand
Surplus/
Demand
Surplus/
(Deficit)
(Deficit)
Road Length
Kms
31.617
60.40
62.86
System Rehabilitation
Strengthening of Open Pucca
Kms
27.89
(3.50)
Drains
Strengthening of Closed
Kms
Pucca Drains
Upgradation of Kutcha drains
kms
(0.00)
to Pucca drains
Strengthening of Natural
Kms
2.00
(2.00)
Drains
New Infrastructure
Storm Water Drains Kms
31.617
78.52
(47.03)
81.71
(50.55)
(@130% of road length)
Open Pucca Drains
Kms
27.89
62.82
(34.93)
65.37
(44.43)
Closed Pucca Drains
Kms
20.94
(20.94)
21.79
(21.79)
Kutcha drains
Kms
Source: Analysis
Final Report
- 81 -
8.6
Final Report
- 82 -
Pedestrian Facilities and Safety Measures: Pedestrians are most vulnerable road users in
cities. It is therefore necessary to provide better facilities for pedestrian movement in areas
where pedestrian movement is predominant. Pedestrian facilities in terms of providing
footpaths free of encroachment in all the bus route roads.
Building Pay & Park type Complexes: The phenomenal growth of vehicles has lead to
increased demand for parking. Being an important commercial/market centre of the region
there is a sudden increase of floating population during peak hours. The problem is further
aggravated by the absence of adequate off street parking facility. Pay and Park complexes
are to be built for a better parking and traffic management. Such complexes can be
privatized.
Asset Rehabilitation: Upgrading shall be undertaken to extend, refurbish and enhance the
roads. Plans would be phased so as to optimize the cost and surface condition and shall
include upgrading earthen roads to Bituminous Topped Roads. This phased up-gradation
would considerably reduce the costs on new formations.
The most critical issue is not only planning for such infrastructure, but also ensuring active
and effective coordination across other departments such that development activities across
each front, i.e., installation of sewer mains, water mains, street lights, storm water drains.
Junction Improvements
Customer Satisfaction
Signals
by providing better
Signage and markings
infrastructure
Road divider & Medians
Traffic Island
safety
Foot paths
PROPOSALS
The following proposals have been identified by the
Study Team based on reported evaluations,
discussions and priority actions as required and
mutually agreed upon by the Stakeholders:
Y5
Final Report
- 83 -
The Project demand for Roads for 2011 is compared with the existing Road Infrastructure, to
verify the adequacy and need to augment the capacity of components. The future trend of
road network development is envisaged based on population growth and land use; efficient
system of road network; segregation of traffic; signaling in the junctions and Upgradation,
widening and strengthening of major junctions. Projected road demand, for town roads, for
2011 is indicated in Table 8.13.
The Road Length demand for 2011, based on the road density of approximately 14 km per
sq. km of area and Per Capita Road Length of approximately 1.75 m is approximately 62.03
km, as against 31.617 km for 2008. Service level based on Road Surface type is maintained
at 31 percent for CC Roads, 63 percent for BT Roads and 13 percent for WBM Roads. It is
proposed to convert Earthern to WBM roads through Upgradation
Table 8.13: Demand, Supply and Required Augmentation of Internal Roads (excluding NH, SH, MDRs) for 2011
Existing Status
Demand
Project Sub-Component
Unit
Year 2011
Year 2008
Demand
Surplus/ (Deficit)
Road Length
Kms
31.617
62.03
(30.413)
Concrete Road
Kms
9.907
19.44
(9.533)
BT Road (Approved + Unapproved)
Kms
19.699
40.32
(20.62)
WBM Road
Kms
0.321
2.27
(1.94)
Earthen Road
Kms
1.69
System Rehabilitation Upgradation of Internal Town Roads
Repair of Concrete Roads
Kms
(0.00)
BT Roads to Concrete Roads
Kms
(30.413)
Restoration of BT Roads
Kms
(0.00)
WBM Roads to BT Roads
Kms
(0.321)
Earthen Roads to BT Roads
Kms
(1.690)
New Infrastructure New Roads Formation
Concrete Road
Kms
-(0.00)
BT Road
Kms
-(13.93)
WBM Road
Kms
-(3.49)
Source: Analysis
Final Report
- 84 -
Final Report
- 85 -
Table 8.14: Estimated Sectoral Investment - Roads, Traffic and Transportation (Rs. in Lakhs)
Component
Activity
Investment
Facilities, comfort and Pedestrian Crossings
6.06
safety
Foot paths
63.06
Total
1,890.53
8.7
8.7.1
Provide daily waste collection to all households and establishments for collection of
organic bio-degradable waste from the doorstep by ensuring regular and reliable service
so as to clear such waste within 24 hours of its generation;
Dry and recyclable wastes to be collected on alternative days as these do not decay and
need not be collected daily; and
Domestic hazardous wastes produced occasionally may not be collected from doorstep
but the people should be advised to deposit the same in special designated bins.
Accordingly, one of the key steps to be followed towards implementing the above initiatives
would be to direct the street sanitary workers to collect the wet waste (organic and biodegradable) door-to-door during the street sweeping process on a daily basis. Initially, some
of the well developed residential areas of the town that can readily afford the cost involved
Final Report
- 86 -
may be covered through this process. This service shall gradually be extended to other
areas of the town. ULB can evaluate the option of enhancing promotion of NGOs and SHGs
for collection of dry and recyclable wastes and domestic hazardous wastes from the
doorstep on no payment on either side basis.
STREET CLEANSING
The most important aspect of improving effectiveness of street cleansing operations may be
addressed by improving the working environment of the sanitary workers and fixing norms
for each sanitary worker so that the factor of accountability may be established to review the
performance of each sanitary worker.
Sanitary workers shall sweep the roads and footpaths in the area allotted to them as well as
collect the domestic, trade and institutional wastes in their handcart from all households,
shops and establishments situated along the stretch of road/street allotted. The sweeping
norms mentioned below are for cleaning streets in the first 4 hours of the working day.
Roads/streets, which have a central median or divided section, should be considered as two
roads. In such cases the length of the road allotted for sweeping should be reduced to half
or alternatively separate sanitary worker may be engaged for sweeping two sides of the
road. All above shall include the surface drains abutting the road having width less than 1 m.
the sanitary workers should be assigned fixed individual beats and pinpoint work according
to the density of the area to be swept. Alternatively, the following guidelines may be
considered while prescribing these norms:
High-density area
: 250 to 350 running meters of road length.
Medium-density area : 400 to 600 running meters of road length.
Low-density area
: 650 to 750 running meters of road length.
In order to avoid inconvenience to the citizens by dust generated from street sweeping and
also to facilitate sweepers to perform their duty without interruption from constant vehicular
movement, it is recommended to implement night-sweeping arrangement in the town by
the ULB.
TEMPORARY STORAGE OF WASTES
ULB should ensure that containers are provided at an average distance of 250 meters from
the place of work of the sanitary workers. The average distance between 2 containers
should, therefore, not exceed 500 meters. The distance between the containers shall be
determined on the basis of the load of waste / refuse that is likely to be received at the
container from the area concerned. The containers should be placed on cement concrete or
asphalt flooring having a gradual slope towards the road to keep the site clean. The flooring
should be flush with the border of the road (i.e. drains) to maintain hygienic conditions and
facilitate the transfer of waste from the handcart/tricycle into the container. A catch pit may
be provided close by if storm water drains exist in the town. In areas where placement of
large containers (dumper placer containers) is inconvenient, small containers of 1.00 cu. m
size may be placed on the roads, lanes and by-lanes at short distances of about 300 m.
These containers should also be kept on paved flooring and cleared daily. It is of paramount
importance to ensure compatibility of the containers with the existing and proposed
transportation fleet.
Another option that could be used in such a situation is to avoid placing a container
altogether and instead press into service small waste collection vehicles for direct transfer of
waste from the handcarts/tricycles into such vehicles. Such vehicles can be parked at
suitable locations in the congested areas where sanitary workers can bring the waste easily.
It is suggested to use innocuous agents like bleaching powder and other permitted
insecticides to prevent the menace of breading of flies and mosquitoes at the community
storage points. Further, such an application of innocuous agents would facilitate maintaining
hygienic and odorless environment at the community storage points. It may be noted that
Final Report
- 87 -
the proposed containerization of wastes would prevent littering and spreading of wastes at
the community storage points by stray animals. Further, proposed training of rag pickers by
NGOs would facilitate the rag pickers to collect recyclable wastes at the doorstep avoiding
the necessity to pick-up such wastes from the community waste storage points. The
standards and norms prescribed in the Manual1 pertaining to temporary waste storage
points are based on the total waste generation and the spacing, viz. a) the total capacity of
the temporary waste storage points should be equivalent to at least 1.5 times the total waste
generation, and b) the spacing between two temporary waste storage points should be less
than or equivalent to 500 m.
TRANSPORTATION OF WASTES
Synchronization of collection with the transportation process is one of the key steps to be
initiated by the ULB. The collection of waste needs to be containerized and the proposed
transportation system should be envisaged to be compatible with the collection system. The
synchronization of transportation with that of the collection process should be planned in a
phased manner considering the financial capability and operation and maintenance capacity
of the ULB. The vehicles used for the transportation of waste shall synchronize with that of
the collection system and based on the market surveys and situation analysis and
discussion with the ULB, two types of vehicles are envisaged for the town:
Dumper Placer -Twin Container is proposed to cater to the needs of the fast moving
vehicles. This vehicle would have two containers, each of capacity 3 cu. m with side
loading and unloading facilities using hydraulic system. This vehicle is envisaged to
undertake 3 trips per day with total waste carrying capacity of 9 MT per day, primarily
used for the wider roads within the town; and
Three-Wheeler Auto Cargo is proposed to cater to the needs of the small and congested
lanes of the town especially in the old town areas. These vehicles would have an open
container of capacity 1.4 cu. m with manual loading and rear hydraulic unloading
facilities. This vehicle is envisaged to undertake 5 trips per day with total waste carrying
capacity of 3-4 MT per day.
Final Report
- 88 -
Based on the scale of waste generated in Sattur and viability of the treatment technologies,
aerobic composting is recommended as the techno-economically feasible process for further
detailed investigation and subsequent implementation. However, a detailed study needs to
be made on this alternative prior to finalization.
Operation and Management Schedule: Adoption of an O&M Schedule, including options of
using the private sector for O&M (e.g. management contract). In view of the criticality of the
information on vehicle movement in assessing the collection and disposal efficiency of the
local body, it is recommended that a standard register at the disposal site and transfer
station be maintained. The register should contain information on each of the vehicle trips at
both the locations and the origin of waste collection. The Schedule can be used for periodic
maintenance of vehicles to defer Costs. A summary of this information shall be prepared at
the end of the day, to be verified by the health officer.
Approach for Optimal Manpower Utilization: Since all areas under ULB are proposed to be
brought under privatization, it is considered that there would not be any further requirement
to induct conservancy workers. The existing street sweeping operations in the ULB are
satisfactory and to ensure operational efficiency of the system, the following measures are
suggested, (i) Markets and other areas of the town shall be swept at least twice a day and
sweeping should be done on Sundays and holidays in core areas and denser areas. (ii)
Sweepings shall be collected separately as degradable and non-biodegradable waste and
deposit in containers kept at various locations and de-silting of larger drains may be done by
a separate crew equipped with appropriate implements.
Institutional Strengthening and Capacity Building: Recruitment of trained engineering
personnel for management is an important issue confronting the ULB, and as well of more
importance is to keep them technically updated. It is necessary that periodic training be
imparted to the operations staff of the ULB.
Training & Public Awareness: Training may be given at all levels. NGOs and private sector
be fully involved. IEC activities have their role in SWM but the best approach the general
cleanliness is through imposition of administrative charges on erring citizens. When citizens
do not throw solid waste on roads, the collection of solid waste will become efficient and
easy.
Comprehensive Solid Waste Management Scheme (per the MSW Rules, 2000).
Minimization of generation of Solid Waste.
Source segregation of municipal solid waste.
Augmentation and expansion of primary collection of waste.
Modernization and expansion of existing waste transportation system.
Municipal solid waste treatment and disposal.
Regulation of recyclable waste handling and re-use.
Proper handling and disposal of slaughter house and related wastes.
Final Report
- 89 -
Following table presents priority actions and their implementation plan for solid waste
management during the project period (2008-2012):
Table 8.15: Priority Actions and Implementation Plan - Solid Waste Management
Component
Activity
Y1
Y2
Y3
Providing bins for Door-Door Collection
Containerized Tri-Cycles
Equipment
for
Garbage
Recovery
Personnel
Primary Collection
Equipment for Street Sweeping Personnel
Debris Collection
(1.25 MT Capacity)
Transportation
Mechanical Street Sweepers - Tractor Mounted
Disposal
Scientific Closure of the abandoned dump sites
Electrical Sub-station
Y4
Y5
PROPOSALS
The total Solid Waste Generation in 2008 for a Per
Capita Generation of approximately 270 grams/day is
estimated at 9 MT, indicating a priority need for
Scientific Disposal of Waste. Since, the Population
Density of the ULB is high, the Waste generation has
been considered at 270 grams/day (based on present
generation), with a growth of 2 percent per year, against
the generation and the demand for future is assessed.
The total Solid Waste Generation for 2025 is estimated at 11.64 MT. The Present Disposal
system is Open Waste Dumping, creating potential health and environment hazard
considering the quantity of waste generation, location of disposal site and its environs,
hence further option for Scientific Regional Waste Disposal (i.e. Integrated Facility) can be
explored on priority basis. The details of Service Levels for future are presented in Table
8.16.
Description
Population
Per capita Waste Generation
Collection Type
Collection Demand
Vehicle Capacity Adequacy
Treatment Type
Treatment Demand
Total Solid Waste Generation
Source: Norms
Final Report
- 90 -
Highest priority has to be accorded for segregation & storage at source irrespective of the
area of generation so as to facilitate an organized and environmentally acceptable waste
collection, processing and disposal. Source segregation of Recyclables and bio-degradable
(organic) waste will not only provide an efficient way for resource recovery, but will also
substantially reduce the pressure and pollution in Landfill sites.
Approach for Primary Waste Collection and Street Sweeping: The following measures have
been recommended for improving the primary collection practices of the ULB;
Implementation of Door-to-door collection through 100 percent privatization - In order to
achieve the above objective, a Tow Bin system of Solid Waste Storage at source is being
recommended. As per this system, each of the households shall be directed to keep
separate bins/ containers for biodegradable and non-biodegradable waste generated within
their premises. The segregated waste so stored in these bins will have to be transferred to
the dumper placer provided for each area. Details of Collection system and Specifications of
segregated waste are summarized in Table 8.17 and Table 8.18 respectively.
Table 8.17: Details of Proposed Primary Collection System
Area of collection
Primary collection vehicle
Secondary storage
Mode of
Collection
Door to Door
Large Community
Bin System
Small Community
Bin System
S.
No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
1. Residential colonies of
High and Middle income
group
2. Hotels/ Restaurants
Source
Households
Hotels, Restaurants
Shops, Offices,
Institutions
Market Stalls
Function Halls
Hospitals, Nursing
homes
Construction/
Demolition waste
Garden Waste
Tricycles shall be used for door-to-door collection. The collected wastes are then conveyed
to the dumper bins of capacity 1.25 MT. The available push carts and autos shall be
exclusively earmarked for areas having narrow streets/lanes where dumper placer cannot
enter and where dumper bins cannot be placed. It is recommended to phase out waste
collection through pushcarts and autos. The collected garbage is transported to the waste
processing site by dumper placers of 2.5 MT - 3 MT capacities. Dumper placers have to
collect the dumper bins and unload the wastes at inspection yard. Inspection yard at
dumping site are constructed with tipping platform arrangement to unload the garbage from
the dumper bins to perform screening of wastes.
Final Report
- 91 -
Demolition wastes / debris can be collected through existing Tippers or by lorries. Based on
the recommendations above the following Table 8.19 gives the details of the vehicles and
other infrastructure to be purchased to implement this new approach.
Sl. No.
1
2
3
4
5
6
Particulars
Total Requirement
Number of bins available
To be purchased
Source Segregation and Collection of Commercial Waste, through privatization; and Source
Segregation and Collection of Hotels and Market Waste - Construction waste has to be
stored at the premises of the construction either in skips or suitable containers and has to be
directly emptied to the notified disposal site by the generator. Meat and fish markets should
store waste in non-corrosive bins of maximum 100-liter capacity each and transfer contents
to large container to be kept at the market just before lifting of such large containers.
Slaughterhouses should keep separate containers for animal waste and other wastes. It is
also being recommended that this system of source segregation and storage is encouraged
through community education and awareness campaigns and hence no capital investments
are envisaged in this regard. Introduction of bio-medical waste management facility with
support from Indian Medical Association is also recommended.
Street Sweeping and Mopping on Daily Basis - Since further areas and eventually the entire
town is proposed to be brought under privatization, it is considered that there would not be
any further requirement to induct conservancy workers. The existing street sweeping
operations in Sattur are satisfactory and to ensure operational efficiency of the system, the
following measures are suggested. (a) Markets and other areas of the town shall be swept
at least twice a day and sweeping should be done on Sundays and holidays in core areas
and denser areas; (b) Sweepings shall be collected separately as degradable and nonbiodegradable waste and deposit in containers kept at various locations and a separate
crew equipped with appropriate implements may do de-silting of larger drains.
The factors that are considered in preparing plan for street sweeping in ULB are population
and building density, road surface, pedestrian traffic, sand accumulation, and topography. In
preparing a sweeping plan for ULB, the streets and public spaces are classified as
residential streets, market areas, open spaces, streets having no residential areas or having
less density of habitation. The details of sanitary workers are presented in Table 8.21 after
taking the above factors into consideration.
S.No.
1
Total No. of
Sanitary Workers
8
11
Final Report
S.No.
Classification of Roads
- 92 -
Total No. of
Sanitary Workers
2.5
2.5
1.5
1.5
56
23
1
4
206
21
227
2.0
22.20
9.18
0.43
2.91
In conclusion it is suggested to have good sweeping plan and to cover the entire Sattur area
including lanes, by-lanes and open spaces it is necessary to work out the Beats, after
taking in to consideration the following requirements:
Each sanitary worker has to do the sweeping and the cleaning of the tertiary and road
side drains and transfer the sweepings in to the bins in the sweepers cart and deposit
biodegradable and non-biodegradable separately in the containers/ bins kept at the
intersection of sweeping routes.
Separate crew equipped with appropriate implements may do De-silting of larger drains.
Removal of floating debris and blockages should be the responsibility of sweepers.
Part of the street sweeping can be outsourced to women SHGs or other agencies
through a transparent process
The ULB should publish notification inviting general public to complain and bring it to the
notice of municipality in case their area is not cleared.
Sanitary services should not suffer due to absence of any sanitation worker. In order to
assure this, alternate arrangements must be made to ensure that all sanitary services
are provided even when any sanitary worker is on leave or absent.
Community Participation and Enforcement of By-laws and Waste Collection and Handling
Rules - It is recommended that the community be involved in primary collection through
segregation at household level to minimize the number of waste handling operation. Nonbiodegradable waste shall be collected separately from premises where door to door
collections are organized. Present system of primary collection should be supplemented by
introducing multi-bin carts (Push carts / Tricycles) covering the entire area of the town.It is
envisaged that 100 percent area of the ULB be brought under door-to-door collection and
hence, no additional dust bins are proposed, except for slums and other areas. These are
estimated to be about 20 to 25 percent in 2011. The rest of the 75 to 80 percent shall be
privatized. In this scenario, the ULB shall overlook the collection and transportation
activities.
The existing dust bins shall be phased out in an organized manner according to the
implementation of the system. This is proposed to be achieved by the year 2010-11. Based
on these assumptions, the equipments for primary collection are estimated, to meet the
future Waste Generation.
Approach for Waste Collection and Transportation: The following measures have been
recommended for improving the waste collection and transportation practices of the ULB;
Secondary Collection system - It is recommended to retain all Tippers, for secondary
collection purpose, in places where Dual Loaded Dumper Placers cannot be introduced.
Efficient Transportation System - It is also recommended that Dual Loaded Dumper Placers
(DLDPs) be introduced to improve the collection efficiency and to cover 80 percent area of
the town in phased manner. The introduction of Dual Loaded Dumper Placers shall eliminate
the need of the Secondary Collection Points. Instead of these collection points, in the end,
transfer stations with advanced segregation and recycling facilities may be introduced, in the
future. Presently, the Vehicle Capacity Adequacy Ratio is 30. This indicates an overall
capacity deficiency of 16 tons by 2011 for achieving 100% collection efficiency and a
deficiency of 19 Tons respectively by the year 2025.
Final Report
- 93 -
System Demand: Two Dual Loaded Dumper Placers with 9 numbers of containers will be
required for collection of approximately 7.5 MT of waste generated in Sattur at present.
Table 8.22: System Demand for Solid Waste Management
Sl.No
Required per
Design and
CPHEEO norms
Type
Primary Collection
1
Tri-Cycles
2
Push-carts*
4
Tipper Lorries - Used for Construction/Other Debris Collection
5
Autos*
Secondary Collection & Transportation
1
Dumper Bins for Dual Dumper Placers (1.25 MT capacity)
2
Dual Dumper Placer Vehicles (2.5 to 3 MT cap.)
Waste Processing & Disposal
Sanitary Landfill Complex
1
Front End Loader with Shovel for MSW Landfill - waste spreading
Backhoe Loader (Gen. Purpose) for MSW Landfill - Hydraulic Excavator & Front End Loader
2
Combo - for loading, excavation, embankment construction etc.,
3
Landfill/ Soil Compactor with Pad Foot Shell Arrangement
Tipper Trucks w/ custom built body and Double Ram Hydraulic Tipping Arrangement for Waste
4
Handling (Eicher Model 10-90, Ashok Leyland or Equivalent)
Tractor with Water Tank, Pump, Spray Nozzle with Extender Arm Attachment for Fine Spray
5
Dispensing
Aerobic Composting Complex
1
Compost Turner and Aeration Attachment with Tractor
2
Front End Loaders with Shovel (JCB Model or equiv)
Tractor with Water Tank, Pump, Spray Nozzle with Extender Arm Attachment for Fine Spray
3
Dispensing
Tipper Trucks w/ custom built body and Double Ram Hydraulic Tipping Arrangement for Waste
4
Handling (Eicher Model 10-90, Ashok Leyland or Equivalent)
5
Mini-Loaders (Bobcats or equiv.) with Skid Steering or suitable arrangement
* Existing Fleet would be used in congested streets and lanes
104
0
15
0
9
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
Approach and Design for Disposal of Waste: Based on Generation of Solid Waste it is
recommended to develop a landfill site for safe disposal of Solid Waste of the ULB. Based
on the successful implementation of the door-to-door collection and source segregation
practices in the town, the options of waste to energy and composting projects can be
developed. The disposal strategies for the ULB will do with.
Composting the organic fraction of the waste - Approximately 75% of the waste generated in
Sattur is organic nature. In terms of the quantity, it is expected that approximately 5 tons of
organic waste is to be generated which can be taken up for Composting. The land
requirement for compost facility is estimated at 3 acres, which will accommodate Windrow
Pads, Ancillaries and Circulation area.
Sanitary land filling of inorganic fraction of waste and the compost rejects - Inorganic waste
constitutes approximately 25 percent, quantifying to 1.5 ton, is proposed to be disposed
through Sanitary landfill. The land requirement for Landfill facility is estimated at 2 acres.
The Sanitary landfill is proposed for a volumetric capacity of 1.00 cu.m, with at least Three
Lifts (One Lift below ground and Two Lifts above ground). Landfill facility design is based on
CPHEEO design assumptions for Sanitary Landfills, wherein a landfill height of 5 m and a
bulk density of 0.85 Tons/ m3 are assumed. However, the actual height of landfill depends
on the geological/ geographical conditions of the site and technology of landfill development.
The wastes which are being dumped in the dump yard are recommended to be ceased by
scientific closure through implementation of an engineered landfill facility. The land shall
then be reclaimed by creating green space over the earth cover by forming grass land and
by placing adequate soil cover.
Final Report
- 94 -
The study team suggested the ULB to utilize regional landfill facility (combining
Aruppukkottai, Sattur and Kovilpatti municipalities in a cluster) which is under
preparation by TNUIFSL to dispose inert waste and compost rejects.
The following proposals have been identified by the study team based on reported
evaluations, discussions and priority actions as required and mutually agreed upon by the
Mission Stakeholders:
Activity
Providing bins for Door-Door Collection
Containerized Tri-Cycles
Tri-Cycle / Push Carts
Primary Collection
Equipment for Garbage Recovery Personnel
Equipment for Street Sweeping Personnel
Tipper Lorries - Used for Construction/Other Debris Collection
Container Bins for Residential Areas (1.25 MT Capacity)
Secondary Collection Container Bins for Market, Bus Stand, Commercial, Railway Station
etc., (1.25 MT Capacity)
Transportation
Dual Load Dumper Placer Vehicles
Integrated Waste Treatment
Waste Processing &
Sanitary Landfill Facility
Disposal
Scientific Closure of the abandoned dump sites
Administration Complex Administration and Utilities Complex
Total
(Rs. In Lakhs)
Investment
4.31
13.68
0.30
1.80
3.83
10.53
2.38
1.19
34.56
280.02
15.82
38.73
36.38
443.54
Final Report
8.8
- 95 -
STREET LIGHTING
The principal issue in this sector is the present level of power consumption and measures to
reduce energy charges in the future that is incurred through provision of adequate street
lighting for the town roads.
Following table presents priority actions and their implementation plan for street lighting
during the project period (2008-2012):
Table 8.24: Priority Actions and Implementation Plan - Street Lighting
Activity
Y1
Y2
Proposed SV lamps in uncovered areas
Service
Proposed
Sensor
Lighting
Improvement
Proposed Solar Lights
Component
Y3
Y4
Y5
Proposals
The following proposals have been identified by the
study team based on reported evaluations,
discussions and priority actions as required and
mutually agreed upon by the pertinent Stakeholders:
at major intersections;
Installation of street lighting fixtures at
uncovered areas - poles, bull-head fittings, control systems and solar panels (asapplicable);
Augmentation of transformers/sub-stations (as applicable); and
Installation of capacitors, timers/trip sensors and other operational control equipment at
control nodes.
Implementation of underground cabling along major roads.
Final Report
- 96 -
It is proposed to augment additional quantity, (i) Installation of 1,059 New Light Poles, (ii)
Installation of New High Power Fixtures and Conversion of Tube Lights to High Power
Fixtures, of 256 Nos., (iii) Installation of 544 nos. of Tube light fixtures, and (iv) Installation of
1 high mast light. Based on Discussions and field visits, it is understood that the existing
Street Lights are in good functional condition and do not require any major rehabilitation
measures.
32.74
66.55
21.22
63.06
60.64
30.32
0.06
1.52
0.97
277.09
8.9
8.9.1
GENERAL
Slum upgrading (including rehabilitation) initiatives and improving the quality of life of the
urban poor in general and slum dwellers, in particular, shall be an integral part of the CCP.
With the growth of the town and addition of new areas, migration of people from rural areas
to the town is imminent. However, the strategies under growth management shall arrest the
extent of the migration. In the wake of the new developments being planned in the town, it is
necessary that they are regulated in an integrated manner. Various schemes introduced by
Final Report
- 97 -
the State and Central governments to improve the socio-economic status of slum dwellers
need to be utilized in an effective manner. The ULB needs to supplement the current
initiatives on its part with aggressive strategies to fulfill the requirements of the urban poor.
The best practices and strategies outlined in this chapter shall be at the macro level, specific
to social development, as infrastructure provision and deficiencies are already addressed by
the underlined strategies under each sector in the prior chapter on Infrastructure.
8.9.2
8.9.3
8.9.4
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
Community development needs to be integrated to provide economic and employment
generation activities. The ULB has to strengthen its efforts to identify NGOs, SHGs and
CBOs and encourage them to work specifically for the empowerment of the urban poor in
general, and slum dwellers in particular.
The ULB may concentrate on organizing specific training programs on tailoring,
housekeeping, mechanic work, lathe working, computer operation, coir works, etc. to
guarantee employment/self-employment for the identified beneficiaries. Training needs
assessment, designing the training programs, identification of training institutions and
resource persons to bring in community development also needs to be focused.
Education: Support from various sections for involvement in education and to enhance
opportunities for increased access to literacy development is to be encouraged. There is a
need to develop strong linkages between education, training programs and resources. Value
added services (computer coaching classes, tuition, etc.) may be encouraged. The ULB
shall facilitate school-linked programs and support services.
Final Report
- 98 -
Final Report
8.9.5
- 99 -
PREPARATORY ACTIVITIES
IMPROVEMENT MEASURES
Following table presents priority actions and their implementation plan during the project
period (2008-2012):
Final Report
- 100 -
8.9.6
Activity
I.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
II.
Preparatory Activities
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
III.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Y1
Y2
Y3
Y4
Y5
Final Report
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
- 101 -
Table 8.28: Estimated Sectoral Investment - Slum Upgrading and Urban Poor (Rs. in Lakhs)
Particulars / Capital Investment Components
Investment
Dwelling Units
224.18
Water Supply
22.42
Sewerage and Sanitation
44.84
Solid waste Management
33.63
Roads and Pavements
53.80
Street Lights
5.38
Community Centers
24.26
Open Spaces/Gardens
24.26
Total Capital Cost
432.75
the NH
Service Improvement
Y3
Y4
Y5
Based on the parameters specified in the earlier section, the capital cost has been estimated
for the proposed intervention and are listed below:
Sl. No.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Investment
27.22
4.29
76.23
57.17
38.12
203.03
Final Report
- 102 -
Final Report
- 103 -
NETWORKING OF RESOURCES
As specified in the earlier sections, open spaces along or next to water bodies shall be
identified, rehabilitated and maintained in order to connect recreational and cultural areas.
Restoration shall start simultaneously at various areas by clearing the obstacles and
greening the areas. Special emphasis shall be given to planting trees. The aim is to restore
the green cover to its original glory that was lamentably lost during the earlier devastating
cyclone. The immediate action plan consists of greening areas where new developments
are proposed and areas that are rapidly developing. The integration of natural resources in
the city for recreational and cultural purposes shall be targeted to attract investments,
increase commercial exchanges, and create job opportunities.
LAND USE INTERVENTIONS
Broadly three land uses can be identified for distributing green corridors - residential,
commercial and industrial. It is difficult to define clear-cut strategies to convert them to green
spaces, as each will have a characteristic of its own. However, residential areas seem to be
the easiest to link and make part of a green network. Industrial locations consist partly of
open spaces and land reserves that can be integrated to the green corridors.
The implementation of green corridors might be slow due to access and financial
constraints. A convincing argument for planting trees is the impact of the increase on
property values. Areas which are not available for connection may be given incentives by
the government to form green corridors.
MAINTENANCE OF PARKS & PLAYGROUNDS
The possibility of entrusting resident associations and private agencies with the
responsibility of maintaining parks, playgrounds and the proposed green corridors can be
evaluated. The tasks to be carried out like daily cleaning, watering, weeding, trimming,
raising new plantations, etc. need to be clearly spelled out in a contract document. Resident
associations can contribute minimum amounts towards maintenance, while the balance can
be borne by the ULB.
Improvement of S.R Naidu Park: It is located along Kanyakumari to Madurai trunk road near
Municipal Office. At present park is not fully utilized it requires improvement works like
provision of seating arrangements, lighting facilities, gardening, walkways etc.
Final Report
- 104 -
BOD levels;
Management Plan has been released as a guideline for
Nitrate levels;
Vehicular emissions;
on the health impacts of specific contaminants. The
Final Report
- 105 -
Service Improvement
Beautification of River Front
Y5
Table 8.32: Estimated Sectoral Investment Parks & Greening Development (Rs. in Lakhs)
Sector / Component Description
Rehabilitation and Improvement of Water Bodies
Creation of new park
Beautification of River Front
Greening / Avenue Development
Total Capital Cost (incl. contingencies, supervision, administration and consulting charges)
Investment
532.00
30.06
180.34
10.64
753.03
Final Report
- 106 -
Final Report
- 107 -
Apart from the above, following are some of other reform measures which should be
implemented to support the above identified key municipal reforms.
URBAN ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
The costs of maintaining a healthy urban environment need to be recovered through various
municipal taxes and user charges following the polluter pays principle. For this, the
functional role of the ULB as envisaged in Item 8, 12th Schedule of the Constitution has to be
resolved keeping in view the role of the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board, and the
organizational and fiscal strength of the ULB.
ACCESS OF URBAN SERVICES TO THE POOR
Since ability-to-pay for the cost of environmental infrastructure service provision is an
important criterion, cross-subsidization of tariffs, innovative project structuring and user/
community participation is the means to ensure access of these services to the poor. Again
the functional and financial role of ULB with respect to the Items 10 and 11 of 12th Schedule
vis--vis those of central and state government agencies need to be resolved.
In addition to the above, the GoI has formulated a Reform Agenda under JNNURM.
Adherence to this Reform Agenda and Timeline is mandatory for accessing funds under the
proposed UIDSSMT. Good governance in the municipal context stands on two broad
principles, viz. transparency and civic engagement and capacity building measures.
Following sections highlight key elements of the above two principles of good governance
specific to the ULB.
TRANSPARENCY AND CIVIC ENGAGEMENT IN MUNICIPAL MANAGEMENT
Laws/rules/regulations specific to city/local issues should be employed to facilitate effective
implementation. These should be lucid and easily understood. Participatory mechanisms
should be so structured that they have legal standing and administrative power. Local
bodies should be responsive and innovative and involve community participation in civic
engagement as follows:
Specific code of conduct for municipal executives and elected representatives.
Public education, resource mobilization, good leadership and transparent processes
applied to municipal finance and development work.
Closer networking with media and their engagement in creating public awareness and
creating demand for good governance. Cautious engagement of private sector with
continuous monitoring is necessary.
Setting in place an active and online public Grievances Redressal System, with
automated department-wise complaint loading and monitoring system.
Final Report
- 108 -
Final Report
- 109 -
8.13.1 EDUCATION
Existing school buildings needs to improve the Tiled / Thatched roof to Pucca RCC structure
with improved basic infrastructure facilities like protected water supply, sanitation facility,
lighting facility etc. improvement of facilities in Noon Meal Centres were also highlighted by
the stakeholders during consultation workshop. Apart from the aforementioned basic
amenities, provision of computer facility, furniture / other accessories, sports equipments are
also included in the capital investment estimate for Sattur town.
8.13.2 HEALTH
Government Hospital in the town requires improvement facilities like water supply, sanitation
facility, waiting area / seating arrangements for out patients, lighting facility, modernized
medical care facilities, additional buildings for maternity ward, facilities for in-patients etc.
Investment
212.23
242.55
454.78
Final Report
- 110 -
9
CAPITAL INVESTMENT PLAN & PROJECT
PRIORITIZATION
9.1
9.1.1 PROCESS
The Capital Investment Plan involves the identification of
public capital facilities to cater to the demands of the town
population during different stages (design stages) based on
the requirements of various urban services. The following
process has been adopted in identifying the requirement of
capital investment and in formulating the CIP.
PROJECT IDENTIFICATION
The general criteria used in identifying projects were the goals of the various departments
with regard to efficient service delivery, prompt customer service, environmental
sustainability, strategic implementation of projects, community benefits, infrastructure
maintenance needs, and the growing demand. The stakeholder consultations and focus
group discussions held as part of the CCP preparation process for the town is also another
important aspect in the identification of projects. These consultations brought out
deficiencies at the macro and micro levels and have provided the first platform for the
identification of projects. Infrastructure delivery benchmarks in the form of indicators were
also used to arrive at the demand and the gaps in service delivery, which were further
correlated with the results of the stakeholder consultations to arrive at specific project
proposals.
PROJECT SCREENING, PRIORITIZATION AND PHASING
Projects are prioritized from the identified list of proposals and priority actions, based on the
need and funding options. The prioritization has also considered the various alternatives for
FOP, which is phased based on the sustainability of the ULB with regard to its finances.
Specific importance has also been given to the Stakeholders and opinions/feedback of the
elected representatives for institutionalizing the CIP process. As a final step, project phasing
has been carried out considering investment sustainability for various options of the FOP.
Final Report
- 111 -
9.1.2 STRATEGIES
STRATEGIC CAPITAL INVESTMENT
The town shall use fiscal notes and policy analysis to
Capital Investment Plan - Strategies
assist in making informed capital investment choices to
Facility Siting
provides guidance for capital budgeting and long-term
Decision Making
planning of capital facilities for all departments, for
Program Funding
identifying and balancing competing needs, and for
developing short- and long-term capital finance plans for all capital investments.
This process includes defining desired outcomes of capital investments, evaluating potential
investments at the town level by applying standard criteria for assessing alternative
investments, and making more efficient use of all potential resources. The town shall budget
sufficient funds to perform major and preventive maintenance of existing facilities that is
considered cost effective. The town shall use maintenance plans for capital facilities and a
funding allocation plan for such maintenance, and may revise these plans from time to time.
There is a need for fiscal impact analyses of all major capital projects considered for
funding. Such analyses shall include, but not be limited to, one-time capital costs, life-cycle
operating and maintenance costs, revenues from the project, and costs of not doing the
project. The ULBs shall make major project specific capital decisions through the adoption of
the Town's operating and capital budgets, and the CIP.
FACILITY SITING
Encourage the location of new community-based capital facilities. The town shall consider
providing capital facilities or amenities as an incentive to attract both public and private
investments.
DECISION MAKING AND PLAN FUNDING
Work together with other stakeholders towards coordinated capital investment planning,
including coordinated debt financing strategies to achieve the goals of the CCP. Explore
funding strategies for capital facilities, particularly for those that serve or benefit citizens
throughout the region.
Final Report
- 112 -
9.2
9.3
Final Report
9.4
- 113 -
Requisite cost escalation on materials and labor for 2008-2009 rates of implementation;
Requisite cost escalation for contracts over 18-month implementation period; and
Requisite provision for unforeseen items of work and physical contingencies.
SUMMARY OF INVESTMENTS
The total estimated capital investment required for providing efficient services to the present
population and future population of ULB by the year 2040 is Rs. 10,492.48 lakhs. The
planning horizon for the projects identified in sectors of urban poor slum improvements, land
use development planning and other similar sub-projects for 2011 and accordingly the entire
identified investment is proposed for funding in short term. The planning horizon for core
service sectors of Water Supply, Sewerage are planned for Long-term period of 2040 and
projects under Storm Water Drainage and Solid Waste Management are designed for
immediate and short-term needs of 2011 and 2025 respectively. Hence, mindful of the need
for efficient resource planning, only part of the identified investment is proposed for funding
in short-term. In case of Roads, Traffic and Transport sectors, part of the identified
investment is proposed for funding in short-term considering the immediate need for
improving road network and transport systems in the town. The phasing of the identified
projects and investments would be performed in the next stage in consultation with the
stakeholders based on the following principles:
Priority needs, with already developed areas receiving priority over future
development area.
Inter and intra-service linkages, viz. water supply investments shall be
complemented by corresponding sewerage/ sanitation improvements.
Size and duration of the requirements, including preparation and implementation
period.
Project-linked revenue implications, such as installing house connections where
supply and distribution capacities have been increased.
The scheduling of adequate time to allow pre-feasibility, full feasibility and safeguard
investigations for those large sub-projects which will require such analysis.
Scheduling additional infrastructure requirements to match with the population, and
tourist inflow growth over the plan period.
SL.
NO
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
% TO TOTAL
19.15
21.42
18.02
15.07
2.64
4.23
7.18
1.93
4.33
4.12
1.91
100.00
The above table describes the sector wise capital investment proposed for the infrastructure
development of Sattur town. Among the basic amenities, Underground Sewerage Scheme
sector accounts for 2,247.44 lakhs which is about 21.42 percent of total capital investment
estimate, followed by Water Supply System with 19.15 percent of share and Roads, Traffic
and Transportation with 18.02 percent of improvement measures respectively.
Final Report
- 114 -
Estimated
Estimated Capital
Capital Investment
Investment
25.00%
25.00%
21.42%
21.42%
20.00%
20.00%
19.14%
19.14%
18.02%
18.02%
15.07%
15.07%
15.00%
15.00%
10.00%
10.00%
7.18%
7.18%
2.64%
2.64%
5.00%
5.00%
0.00%
0.00%
Water Supply
Water Supply
Scheme
Scheme
Underground
Underground
Sew erage
Sew erage
Scheme &
Scheme &
Sanitation
Sanitation
Storm Water
Storm Water
Drains
Drains
Street Lighting
Street Lighting
4.23%
4.23%
4.33%
4.33%
4.12%
4.12%
1.94%
1.94%
Solid W aste
Solid W aste
Management
Management
Environment
Environment
Improvement
Improvement
1.91%
1.91%
Urban
Urban
Governance
Governance
Out of all the basic amenities, Underground Sewerage Scheme & Sanitation accounts to
2,247.44 lakhs which is about 24.32 percent of total capital investment estimated. It is then
followed by the Roads, Traffic & Transportation with a share of 19.15%, also closely
followed by Water Supply Scheme with a share of 18.77 percent.
The above identified investments are phased to meet the priorities in the next five years
considering the borrowing and investment capacity of the ULB. The phasing of expenditure
based on demand is given in the following sections of this report.
Final Report
- 115 -
Estimated
Estimated Capital
Capital Investment
Investment by
by -ULB
-ULB
24.32%
24.32%
25.00%
25.00%
20.00%
20.00%
18.77%
18.77%
19.15%
19.15%
13.60%
13.60%
15.00%
15.00%
10.00%
10.00%
3.00%
3.00%
5.00%
5.00%
0.00%
0.00%
4.80%
4.80%
4.92%
4.92%
2.39%
2.39%
WWater
aterSupply
Supply
Scheme
Scheme
Underground
Underground Roads,
Roads,Traffic
Traffic&& Storm
StormWWater
ater
Sewerage
Transportation
Drains
Sewerage
Transportation
Drains
Scheme
Scheme&&
Sanitation
Sanitation
Street
StreetLighting
Lighting
Solid
SolidWWaste
aste
Management
Management
Environment
Environment
Improvement
Improvement
2.20%
2.20%
4.68%
4.68%
2.17%
2.17%
Remunerative
Urban
Remunerative Social
SocialAmenities
AmenitiesSlum
SlumUpgradition
Upgradition
Urban
Proposals
Governance
Proposals
Governance
Final Report
- 116 -
Road improvement is ranked as No. 1 since the town is not provided with proper road
facility lead to congestion in the core area of the town. Improvement of Junctions and
proper linking will ease the considerable traffic in the town
Improvement to the Water Supply and Distribution System is ranked as No.2 since
existing supply rate is less than the normative standard of 135 lpcd.
Further, Vaippar is the only source which supplies protected water to Sattur and further
water supply sources is increased by constructing Check Dam in the Irukkangudi which
is 7 km from the Sattur Town.
Due to continuous exploitation of groundwater, water table has significantly reduced,
resulting in significant reduction in yield. There are no sustainable potential sources of
groundwater in the region which can meet the increasing future demand.
Identification of alternate source, either in the proximity or through long-distance
transmission will have to be evaluated in addition to ensuring that the identified sources
are sustainable as the cost of abstraction, treatment, transmission and storage will
attract a higher investment.
Next to Water Supply, Social Amenities takes the 3rd rank. In consultation with
stakeholders, it was observed that due to the lack of Education Quality and social
facilities in the town.
Remunerative Proposals are Ranked 4th because Sattur municipality almost in a deficit
except one year in the assessment period and in the stakeholders meeting also it is
discussed and ranked
Environment Improvement is placed No. 5 since the town is not provided with safe
environment
Sub-Sectoral priority identified during stakeholders consultation is given in the Table 9.4.
Component
Water Resource
Management
Augmentation of
Water Supply
System
Component
Sewerage
Collection,
Treatment &
Management
Sanitation Facility
Component
Improved Safety,
Service delivery
and Customer
Satisfaction by
providing better
infrastructure
Priority
1
2
3
5
4
1
4
3
2
6
5
7
Priority
1
3
2
6
5
4
Priority
3
5
6
13
4
7
8
Final Report
- 117 -
Signals
Signage and markings
Road divider & Medians
Traffic Island
Parking Lots/ complexes
Bus Stand Improvement
Provision of Bus Shelters
Construction of New Bus Stand at proposed location
Accessibility to the disadvantaged
Improved
Pedestrian
Pedestrian Crossings
Facilities
Foot paths
Storm Water Drains
Component
Activity
Drains
Rehabilitation of Major drains/channels
Rehabilitation Rehabilitation of Storm Water Drains
Provision of storm water along existing roads
Construction of
Formation of new drains along proposed road network
Drains
Treatment and re-use of storm water
Street Lighting
Component
Activity
Proposed SV lamps in uncovered areas
Proposed FL lamps in uncovered areas
Proposed High Mast light in major junctions
Proposed Timers for existing / new lights
Service
Proposed Sensor Lighting
Improvement
Proposed Solar Lights
Proposed Power Saver (Capacitors)
Proposed dedicated sub-station/transformers
Proposed Tri-vector meters
Solid Waste Management
Component
Activity
Providing bins for Door-Door Collection
Containerized Tri-Cycles
Push Carts
Primary Collection
Equipment for Garbage Recovery Personnel
Equipment for Street Sweeping Personnel
Tipper Lorries - Used for Construction/Other Debris Collection
Container Bins for Residential Areas
Secondary
(1.25 MT Capacity)
Collection
Container Bins for Market, Bus Stand, Commercial, Railway Station etc., (1.25 MT
Capacity)
Transportation Dual Load Dumper Placer Vehicles
Integrated Waste Treatment
Waste Processing
Sanitary Landfill Facility
& Disposal
Scientific Closure of the abandoned dump sites
Administration Administration and Utilities Complex including HT Electrical Sub-station
Complex
Environmental Improvement
Component
Activity
Rehabilitation and Improvement of Water Bodies
Service
Creation of new park
Improvement
Beautification of River Front
Greening / Avenue Development
Remunerative Proposals
Component
Activity
Service
Development of park and shopping complex facility at vacant land in Perumal Koil Land
Improvement
along the NH
Construction of modernized Slaughter house near the By pass road
2
11
6
9
10
12
4
1
3
2
1
Priority
3
4
2
1
5
Priority
1
2
3
6
9
5
4
7
8
Priority
3
4
5
6
2
1
2
1
1
2
1
3
1
Priority
2
1
4
3
Priority
1
4
Final Report
Component
Service
Improvement
- 118 -
3
2
5
Priority
4
1
2
3
5
6
8
7
Borrowing Capacity for the ULB is prepared after taking into consideration, the revenue
inflows and outflows from the base scenario, i.e. the income from sewerage and water
charges and O&M on assets is taken. In order to arrive at the sustainability, three different
parameters were used which are,
The least of the above 3 factors was arrived at as the possible annuities payable by the
ULB. With this a conversion factor was worked out to determine the Borrowing Capacity
and the Investment Capacity. The maximum sustainable investments for the next 5 years
are summarized as follows:
Table 9.5: Borrowing & Investment Capacity of ULB
Details
Borrowing Capacity
Investment Capacity
2008-09
2009-10
0.00
0.00
2010-11
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
2011-12
0.00
0.00
(Rs. In lakhs)
2012-13
0.00
0.00
Since the town does not have a borrowing capacity to fund the CCBP identified projects the
study team suggested to implement projects such as projects such as Development of park
and shopping complex facility at vacant land in Perumal Koil Land along the NH,
Construction of modernized Slaughter house near the By pass road, Improvements of the
existing Market complex, Construction of Shopping Complex in the existing office area and
Construction of the first floor above the existing bus stand shops by various funding options
suggested in the section 11.4.
After the successful implementation of the abovementioned projects, the ULB shall
implement the service projects identified in the CCBP through ULB self-generated revenue
or through funding assistance from any FIs.
TE Total Expenditure
TR Total Revenue
4 DS Debt Service
2
3
9.5
Final Report
- 119 -
FINANCIAL RESOURCES
The analysis on financial resources is worked out for the
Innovations in terms of
interventions to be carried out within the ULB area. The
Public-Private-Partnerships
sectors that are not in the domain of the ULB are not taken
Financially Self-supporting
Projects
elaborated in the earlier chapters should be supported with
financial allocations and a co-ordinated mechanism has to
Final Report
- 120 -
Loan
55%
45%
60%
60%
60%
20%
20%
65%
10%
20%
Grant
30%
30%
30%
30%
70%
70%
20%
80%
70%
Own
15%
25%
10%
10%
40%
10%
10%
15%
10%
10%
Total
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
Final Report
- 121 -
10
MUNICIPAL FINANCIAL STATUS
10.1 OVERVIEW
The ULBs normally have their own sources of revenue, collected in the form of taxes and/or
user charges though most of their revenue/ income is in the form of assigned revenue
and/or budgetary revenue grant. Barring the ULBs, all other departments and agencies
provide the services through budgetary support.
10.1.1 GENERAL
Accounts of the ULB are
Table 10.1: Summary of Finances of Sattur
All figures in Rs. Lakhs
maintained on cash basis
Summary
Statement
(single entry accounting
(All figures in Rs. Lakhs)
system) till the FY 2002Sl.
Account Head
2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08
No.
2003. The financial status
Actuals
of each ULB has been
REVENUE ACCOUNT
reviewed for the past six
1
Income
203.91
157.37
210.28
258.64
279.87
353.82
years, commencing from
2
Expenditure
300.48
263.60
341.47
487.40
378.84
413.87
FY 2002-03. Currently
3
Status
(96.58) (106.23) (131.19) (228.76)
(98.97)
(60.06)
(Surplus/Deficit)
ULB in Tamil Nadu
CAPITAL ACCOUNT
maintain three separate
1
Income
467.61
450.21
440.51
378.92
79.36
104.85
funds, namely General
2
Expenditure
45.10
45.81
44.76
21.64
78.45
149.83
Fund, Water & Drainage
3
Status
422.51
404.40
395.75
357.28
0.91
(44.98)
Fund and Education Fund.
(Surplus/Deficit)
All
these
funds
are
OVERALL STATUS
1
managed under two heads
Income
671.52
607.59
650.79
637.56
359.23
458.67
2
namely, Revenue Account
Expenditure
345.58
309.41
386.23
509.04
457.29
563.70
3
Status
and Capital Account. For
325.93
298.18
264.56
128.52
(98.06) (105.04)
(Surplus/Deficit)
the
purpose
of
this
Source: Sattur; 2008
analysis, revenue & capital
account of the ULB is
considered and Education Fund is clubbed with General Fund, because it is predominantly
reimbursement inclined. Key financial indicators have been computed and compared with
the desired benchmark to ascertain strength or weakness inherent to the system and
appropriate remedial measures that can be envisioned.
For the purposes of analysis, all the account items are broadly categorized under the
following major heads:
Revenue Account: All recurring items of income and expenditure are included under this
head. These include taxes, charges, salaries, maintenance expenses, debt servicing,
etc.
Capital Account: Income and expenditure items under this account are primarily nonrecurring in nature. Income items include loans, contributions by GoTN, other agencies
and capital grants under various State and Central Government programmes and
income from sale of assets. Expenditure items include expenses booked under
developmental works and purchase of capital assets.
Advances, Investments and Deposits: Under the municipal accounting system,certain
items are compiled under advances, investments and deposits. These items are
Final Report
- 122 -
temporary in nature and are essentially adjustments for the purpose of recoveries and
payments. Items under this head include income tax deductions, investments/realization,
pension payments, provident fund, payment and recoveries of advances to employees
and contractors, etc.
500
500
400
400
Rs. in Lakhs
Rs. in Lakhs
600
300
300
200
200
100
100
0
0
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
Income
2005-06
Ex penditure
2006-07
2007-08
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
Incom e
Ex penditure
2006-07
2007-08
Capital income comprises loans, grants and contributions in the form of sale proceeds of
assets, and contributions and deposits received. A major share on capital income is in the
form of deposits received on account of capital work assignment. The capital account has
witnessed a deficit-implying utilization of revenue surpluses to fund capital works. During the
assessment period, the ULB has received major capital grant for road improvement projects
from GoI. The following sections present a detailed review of revenue and capital accounts,
primarily aimed at assessing the municipal fiscal status and provide a base for determining
the ability of the ULB to sustain the planned investments.
Final Report
- 123 -
Account Head
REVENUE ACCOUNT
1
Property Tax
2
Other Taxes
a. Profession Tax
b. Others
3
Assigned Revenue
4
Devolution Fund
5
Service Charges and Fees
a. Water Charges
b. Service Charges and Fees
(excluding Water Charges)
6
Sale and Hire Charges
7
Other Income
SECTORAL CONTRIBUTION TO TOTAL REVENUE
1
Property Tax
2
Other Taxes
a. Profession Tax
b. Others
3
Assigned Revenue
4
Devolution Fund
5
Service Charges and Fees
a. Water Charges
b. Service Charges and Fees
(excluding Water Charges)
6
Sale and Hire Charges
7
Other Income
GROWTH TRENDS IN %
1
Property Tax
2
Other Taxes
a. Profession Tax
b. Others
3
Assigned Revenue
4
Devolution Fund
5
Service Charges and Fees
a. Water Charges
b. Service Charges and Fees (excluding Water
Charges)
6
Other Income
Source: Sattur; 2008
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
Budget
Actuals
75.74
75.19
79.82
84.69
85.26
88.80
5.00
0.00
23.80
63.65
6.21
0.00
6.71
26.78
6.99
0.00
13.04
56.51
7.38
0.00
14.01
91.10
8.02
0.00
11.48
92.64
9.04
0.00
10.75
118.12
11.88
11.90
11.65
11.65
11.66
31.73
6.60
7.49
18.64
19.49
43.73
56.78
0.55
16.69
0.00
23.10
0.00
23.63
0.00
30.31
0.00
27.07
0.00
38.60
11.28
12.37
12.26
13.28
23.73
19.36
0.74
0.00
3.54
9.48
1.02
0.00
1.10
4.41
1.07
0.00
2.00
8.68
1.16
0.00
2.20
14.29
2.23
0.00
3.20
25.79
1.97
0.00
2.34
25.75
1.77
1.96
1.79
1.83
3.25
6.92
0.98
1.23
2.86
3.06
12.17
12.38
0.08
2.49
0.00
3.80
0.00
3.63
0.00
4.75
0.00
7.54
0.00
8.42
(0.74)
0.00
24.28
-(71.83)
(57.92)
0.00
0.20
6.16
0.00
12.56
-94.44
111.00
0.00
(2.12)
6.11
0.00
5.61
-7.48
61.21
0.00
0.04
0.67
0.00
8.73
-(18.06)
1.69
0.00
0.08
4.15
0.00
12.63
-(6.36)
27.50
0.00
172.05
13.42
148.87
4.53
124.38
29.85
38.41
2.31
28.25
(10.68)
42.59
Major source of revenue income is in the form of Own tax revenues and Devolutions funds,
which contributes to about half of the revenue income on average. As a whole, revenue
income has registered an annual negative growth of 8.78 percent on average during the
assessment period.
While the growth pattern is a common feature to be
Table 10.3: Tax Contribution
talked about while analyzing the financials, it is
Details
Composition (%)
equally important to analyze the composition of
Own Tax revenues
36.91
income which actually reveals the status of the local
Own Non-tax revenues
25.89
body with respect to the sustainability of revenues; i.e.
Assigned Revenues
5.55
if the share of devolution funds is higher, it means that
Devolution of Funds
28.72
the local bodys dependence on devolutions and
grants are much higher and hence they are need to generate more own revenues. As for the
composition of income of Sattur Municipality, the major contributors are Own tax revenues,
Devolution Fund , and Own Non-Tax revenues which constitutes around 36.91 % , 28.72 %
and 25.89 % respectively to the total income of the Sattur Municipality, The composition of
income during the last six years is graphically represented as follows-
Final Report
- 124 -
Share of Receipts
100%
80%
60%
40%
20%
0%
2002-03
Property T ax
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
a. Professional T ax
Assigned Revenue
Devolution Fund
a. Water Charges
Other Income
2007-08
The analysis indicates that a higher revenue generation is by way of Own tax revenues and
Devolution funds. It is interesting to note that major income under this head comes from the
Own tax revenues. This forms 36.91 % of the total income. It is followed by Devolution
Fund of 28.72 % to total income. This is a very good indicator of the growth of the town.
Sattur, having close proximity to Sivakasi and NH 7 cut across the town has a large potential
in future.
Even though there is a steady income arising out of income from weekly market, consultants
feel that this may not be a sustainable income, as it depends on the occupancy ratio of the
stalls, which is fragile. Income from fees is another head of income which shows a major
income. Upon scrutinizing
Table 10.4: Demand-Collection-Balance (DCB) - Statement for Property Tax (Rs.in lakhs)
the balance sheet it is found
Particulars
2002-03 2003-04 2004-05
2005-06
2006-07 2007-08
that the water charges are
No. of Assessments
11717
11762
11913
12029
12137
13126
categorized as Income from
Growth in
-0.38
1.28
0.97
0.90
8.15
fees, which forms at least
Assessments (%)
60% of income under this
Demand (Rs. in lakhs)
head.
Arrear
23.36
28.63
27.96
34.36
41.51
45.85
Current
42.70
43.92
45.15
47.82
49.19
51.12
5 Property tax belongs to the class of general benefit taxes, primarily indirect user charges for municipal services whose benefits are collective
and not confined to any particular individual / community.
Final Report
- 125 -
The ARV is calculated based on the plinth area, building and land cost. The present tax rate
is 40.00 percent of the ARV, which comprises 18 percent of ARV on General tax, 9 percent
on water tax, 2 percent on latrine/ drainage tax, 3 percent on scavenging tax, 3 percent on
lighting tax and 5 percent for Education Tax. ULB is empowered to revise the property tax at
least once in five years (quinquennial revision).
The property tax demand has increased gradually from Rs. 66.06 lakhs in FY 2002-03 to Rs.
96.97 lakhs in FY 2007-08. This significant increase has been due to the proactive efforts of
the ULB to bring in more assessments into the tax net and improve collection performance
as there was no tax revision earlier during this period. As a whole, the property tax
component has registered an average annual growth rate of 15.38 percent during the
assessment period.
Property tax demand-collection-balance (DCB) statement analysis indicates there is a
gradual growth in the number of property tax assessments during the last six financial years
with an average increase of over 2.34 percent per annum. Average property tax per property
works out to Rs. 662 while average ARV of the property works out to Rs. 1,013 during the
assessment period. Growth trends of the current property tax demand, which has increased
gradually from Rs. 42.70 lakhs in FY 2002-03 to Rs. 51.12 lakhs in FY 2007-08. During the
same assessment period, the arrear demand has increased gradually from Rs.23.36 lakhs
in FY 2002-03 and Rs. 45.85 lakhs in FY 2007-08. The overall collection performance was
about 53.69 percent on average during the assessment period.
Share of Property Tax / Total Incom e
25
85
20
Rs. in lacs
% to T o ta l In c o m e
90
80
75
70
65
15
10
5
0
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
Other Taxes: Other tax revenues are in the form of taxes levied on carriage & carts,
animals, advertisement, professional tax and others. The most important category in own
sources of income is the property tax. Professional tax is the other most important tax and it
contributes about 2.91 percent of the total tax revenue. Professional tax has fluctuated
between the values from 2.24 percent in FY 2002-03 to 3.66 in FY 2003-04 overall the
assessment period. Other than the professional tax no other tax has not contributed in the
other taxes during the assessment period
Assigned Revenues: Assigned revenues include revenues transferred to the ULB by the
GoTN under specific acts. This source of revenue income comprises duty on transfer of
properties, entertainment tax / public resort and other assigned revenues. Income through
assigned revenue contributes to about 5.55 percent of revenue income, the growth of which
however has been inconsistent. Other sources of assigned revenue include duty on transfer
of properties, entertainment tax/public resort, and others and these sources have not
contributed during the last three financial years of the assessment period as indicated. As a
whole, the assigned revenue has shown inconsistent growth rate during the assessment
period.
Devolution: Based on the Second State Finance Commission recommendations, GoTN
transfers 8% of its state revenue to the local governments. It is the one of the single largest
source of revenue to the ULB, it accounts to 28.72 % average of total revenue over the
assessment period.
Final Report
- 126 -
13000
12500
12000
11500
11000
2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08
Growth in PT assessments
13500
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05 2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
40
30
20
10
0
The graph relating to PT assessments show a gentle increase till the FY 2006-07 and there
is a steep increase in the FY 2007-08 from the FY 2006-07 which is indicating a good trend
in the growth of the town as well as the increase in tax base. If the share of property tax to
total income is compared with the increase in PT assessments, from the above graphs we
can see that the share is fluctuating in spite of increase in PT assessments. Hence it is
evident that the collection performance has not been to the scale required.
The collection performance indicated in the graph is self-explanatory and provides the
reason for the decreased share of PT to the Total Income. Breaking this further, the graph
below indicates the arrears and current collection performance:
Final Report
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
No. of PT assessments
2006-07
2007-08
No. of WS assessments
R s . in la c s
- 127 -
50
40
30
20
10
0
Current Demand
Current Collection
Arrears Demand
Arrears Collection
200203
200304
200405
200506
200607
200708
Years
From the above graph, it can be seen that as against the demand raised for water charges,
collection has been an average of 47.03 %. The result of the analysis is that there is
requirement of increasing the water supply connections to the house holds, and as may be
the demand, source needs to be augmented. As part of the CIP, the consultants have
proposed certain measures to augment water sources and also to construct the collection
system for water supply in the town.
The other major source of own income for this town is being raised by Non Own tax
revenues, being the main head. However the major income under this head is service
charges and fees and other income, which forms roughly 15.10 % and 10.74% of the total
Non revenue income. However Project Overhead Appropriation Expenses, Rent on
Shopping are the major contributors in the Non-Own Tax revenues. Other revenues in this
heads are very minimal. The ULB should try to exploit the potential of weekly market and
create more such avenues for raising resources, which also results in infrastructure
development.
Assigned Revenue: This includes Stamp duties and entertainment tax. The major income
under this head is only from duty on transfer of property (stamp duty), and there is no
income from entertainment tax. Assigned revenue constitutes approximately 5.55 % of the
total income. The revenues under this head seem to be steadily decreasing from the FY
Final Report
Trend
TrendininAssigned
AssignedRevenues
Revenues
RRss. . inin lalaccss
25
25
20
20
15
15
10
10
55
00
2002-03
2002-03 2003-04
2003-04 2004-05
2004-05 2005-06
2005-06 2006-07
2006-07 2007-08
2007-08
Years
Years
Assigned
AssignedRevenues
Revenues
- 128 -
100
80
60
40
20
0
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
Revenue Expenditure:
Revenue expenditure of the ULB has been analyzed based on expenditure heads broadly
classified under the following heads:
Personal cost;
Administrative expenses;
Operating expenses;
Interest & finance charges;
Revenue grants, contributions and subsidies; and
Miscellaneous / other expenses.
Application of funds by each sector and head-wise utilization of the revenue expenditure is
presented in the table and charts. It may be observed that the personal cost accounts for
35.27 % accounts total expenditure on average during the assessment period. The other
major sector having higher utilization is the operating expenses, which accounts for about
17.31 percent of the revenue expenditure on average. During the assessment period,
revenue expenditure has indicated an average growth of about 9.40 percent per annum
while the corresponding growth in revenue income was 13.69 percent, indicating a
mismatch. A sector-wise break up of costs is shown graphically. A Detailed analysis of each
head of expense followsPersonnel cost & terminal benefits to employees: This include salaries and other related
payments to employees. The expense has been more or less steadily increasing; it reaches
the maximum of 45.17 % during the FY 2005-06. The growth trend of personnel expenses is
as followsThe personnel cost has been gradually increasing but not in a great pace. The ULB shall try
to outsource certain activities like solid waste management, and street light maintenance.
Many of such activities would help in reducing the personnel cost.
Final Report
- 129 -
Share of Expenditure
100%
Capital Expenditure
80%
a. Interest on Loans
60%
Administrative Expenses
Operating Expenses
40%
T erminal and
Retirement Benefits
20%
Personnel Cost
0%
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
Account Head
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
Actual
EXPENDITURE ACCOUNT
Personnel Cost
Terminal and Retirement Benefits
Operating Expenses
Administrative Expenses
Finance Expenses
a. Interest on Loans
SECTORAL CONTRIBUTION TO TOTAL EXPENDITURE
1
Personnel Cost
2
Terminal and Retirement Benefits
3
Operating Expenses
4
Administrative Expenses
5
Finance Expenses
a. Interest on Loans
GROWTH TRENDS IN %
1
Personnel Cost
2
Terminal and Retirement Benefits
3
Operating Expenses
4
Administrative Expenses
5
Finance Expenses
a. Interest on Loans
Source: Sattur; 2008
136.90
32.99
34.23
25.86
128.07
26.52
40.65
12.91
128.67
16.39
64.75
72.10
138.42
33.28
98.27
164.29
171.13
23.01
108.10
23.90
184.14
35.78
119.08
21.63
30.55
31.90
20.84
16.49
10.70
15.81
39.62
9.55
9.91
7.48
41.39
8.57
13.14
4.17
33.31
4.24
16.77
18.67
27.19
6.54
19.30
32.28
37.42
5.03
23.64
5.23
32.67
6.35
21.12
3.84
8.84
10.31
5.40
3.24
2.34
2.80
-----
(6.45)
(19.62)
18.77
(50.10)
0.47
(38.21)
59.28
458.69
7.58
103.05
51.76
127.87
23.63
(30.85)
10.00
(85.45)
7.60
55.51
10.16
(9.51)
--
4.44
(34.66)
(20.88)
(35.09)
47.70
1
2
3
4
5
80
60
40
20
0
2002-03 2003-04 2004-05
Final Report
- 130 -
From the numbers and the graph, it is seen that power charges consumes the majority
portion. The ULB shall focus its attention on reducing the costs incurred under this head by
privatizing the entire street lighting, to the Energy Service Companies. This is the model
which is being tried by many local bodies. This applies to both street lighting and water
supply. It is to be noted that the above analysis does not include sewerage systems. If
sewerage systems are proposed, the ULB cannot sustain the expenditure in their balance
sheet. Energy efficiency measures can be attempted by the ULB in a small scale.
Power charges as a ratio of total operating expenses
140.00
120.00
R s . in la c s
Rs. in lacs
100.00
80.00
60.00
40.00
20.00
0.00
2002-03
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2003-04
2007-08
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
Rs. in lacs
45
Repairs & Maintenance: This is the major
40
head of expenditure and includes repairs
35
and maintenance of assets like drainage,
30
bridges, roads, etc. The bigger item of
25
20
expenditure under this TWAD board
15
maintenance and light vehicle maintenance
10
with a share of 5.40 and 1.65 percent of the
5
total repairs and maintenance expenses.
0
nd
2002-03 2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08
After a decreases from the 2 FY of the
assessment period then there is a gradual
increases till the FY 2006-07. Cost of other maintenance expenditure constitutes a minor
ratio of around 1%. With proper water supply systems in place, this could be reduced.
Moreover, the ULB shall also do a leak detection study, upon implementation of which the
maintenance costs of water supply could be less. Reportedly, the other major expenditure is
the heavy vehicle maintenance. In absolute terms, it does not appear to be huge.
Final Report
- 131 -
This account also has contributions received in the form of security deposits/EMD from
suppliers, contractors, etc. It is noteworthy that the ULB has received capital grants of
Rs.101.63 lakhs during the FY 2007-08 through Govt schemes.
Table 10.6: Break-up of Capital Receipts/Income
Rs in Lakhs
S.No
Head
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
2007-08
Basic Amenities
M.P L.A.D
M.L.A, L.A.D
D.D.P
Flood Relief
Drought Relief
Solid Waste Management
Other (General Funds)
Total Grants from State Govt. (A).
Grants from Central Government
1
Eleventh/TwFC Central Fin.Commn.
2
National Slum Development Programme
3
SJSRY Wages
4
SJSRY Self Employment
5
VAMBAY Scheme
6
Others
Total Grants from Central Govt.(B)
Total Capital Income (A+B)
Source: Sattur Municipality; 2007
1.87
1.99
11.56
0.00
0.00
24.9
0.00
4.71
45.03
15.00
0.00
9.90
1.66
0.00
26.14
0.00
0.00
52.56
0.00
1.40
13.00
0.00
0.00
24.00
10.09
0.00
48.496
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
5.00
0.00
0.00
5.00
0.00
1.25
22.35
0.00
20.00
0.00
13.49
19.4
76.49
0.00
2.10
23.05
0.00
24.8
7.00
6.8
37.88
101.63
10.24
12.00
0.20
0.11
12
0.00
34.55
79.58
2.50
12.00
0.35
0.09
0.00
1.00
15.94
68.50
5.00
12.00
0.37
0.00
0.00
0.72
18.09
66.58
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
5.00
0.00
0
0.61
2.26
0.00
0.00
2.87
79.36
0.00
0.00
0.85
2.37
0.00
0.00
3.22
104.85
Capital Expenditure: Capital expenditure may be broadly categorized under three broad
heads, viz. a) acquisition/ purchase of fixed assets; b) capital projects; and c) other capital
expenses like refund of deposits, spending from the municipal funds, etc. The ULB has been
spending more on Roads and water supply works of total capital expenses. It is then
followed by the Public Health & Sanitation during the assessment period. The ULB has
spent about Rs.149.83 lakhs during the FY 2007-08 which is the Year this municipality has
received higher capital income and expenditure in the same year.
Table 10.7: Break-up of Capital Expenditure
Particulars
2002-03
Roads
Storm Water Drains
Water Supply
Public Health & Sanitation
Conservancy
Others
Total Capital Expenditure
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
Rs in Lakhs
2007-08
2006-07
9.76
7.96
24.67
6.09
5.4
13.28
25.22
1.89
7.64
14.11
3.47
2.1
53.48
7.85
0.00
71.01
24.71
4.06
2.71
0.00
0.00
45.1
20.34
0.7
0.00
45.81
10.01
0.00
0.00
44.76
1.96
0.00
0.00
21.64
0.00
0.00
17.12
78.45
0.00
3.22
46.83
149.83
Maximum
Average
Unit
A.
11.28
23.73
15.38
percent
0.74
2.23
1.37
percent
3
4
1.10
4.41
3.54
25.79
2.40
14.73
percent
percent
2.75
19.30
8.37
percent
Final Report
- 132 -
0.78
22.86
13.18
percent
7
8
0.00
2.49
0.08
8.42
0.01
5.10
percent
percent
1374.78
Rupees
10
11
3.27
12.76
percent
percent
12
13
14
15
17
18
19
20
B.
1
2
5
6
16
(0.74)
5.61
6.16
24.28
0.00
0.00
0.00
percent
(71.83)
(57.92)
94.44
111.00
1.13
28.70
percent
percent
2.80
77.87
40.32
percent
4.53
148.87
64.21
percent
(92.49)
1487.20
282.02
percent
(100.00)
(10.68)
(100.00)
42.59
(100.00)
20.18
percent
percent
(43.66)
27.68
(4.08)
percent
0.38
1.28
12137
1.18
Nos.
percent
40
percent
1013
Rupees
662
Rupees
a. Arrear Demand
0.00
37.49
26.07
percent
b. Current Demand
c. Total Demand
65.64
48.70
75.36
61.97
70.91
55.34
percent
percent
426
Nos.
(1.76)
5.64
2.43
25
percent
percent
1638
Rupees
C.
2
3
Growth in Assessments
Current Tax Rate
Collection Performance
a. Arrear Demand
7.32
44.21
27.88
percent
b. Current Demand
91.96
100.00
94.40
percent
c. Total Demand
78.55
84.93
81.88
percent
0.00
0.00
3000
0.00
Nos.
percent
22.50
percent
D.
1
2
Collection Performance
a. Arrear Demand
24.65
45.87
35.38
percent
b. Current Demand
49.58
62.33
56.21
percent
c. Total Demand
38.62
52.50
45.79
percent
E.
Expenditure Management
Final Report
1
2
- 133 -
27.19
4.24
41.39
9.55
35.27
6.71
percent
percent
9.91
23.64
17.31
percent
6
7
3.84
2.34
32.28
2.34
11.94
5.49
percent
percent
4.25
4.25
14.57
percent
9
10
(6.45)
23.63
1370.66
6.56
Rupees
percent
11
(38.21)
103.05
13.98
percent
12
10.00
59.28
29.99
percent
15
16
(85.45)
(35.09)
458.69
47.70
88.30
(7.70)
percent
percent
17
(51.65)
262.52
60.23
percent
18
19
2.34
1.25
10.31
1.88
5.49
1.55
percent
Ratio
20
(75.65)
263.98
32.21
percent
21
(10.47)
31.80
11.85
percent
F.
80.19
Rs. Lakhs
b. MUDF/TNUDF
c. Other Financial Institutions
40.50
55.82
Rs. Lakhs
Rs. Lakhs
Total
2
3
4
3.20
21.92
176.51
Rs. Lakhs
529.07
Rupees
3.69
10.81
Ratio
percent
Sl. No.
2002-03
2003-04
2004-05
2005-06
2006-07
(175.20)
1.50
(249.53)
1.69
(361.45)
1.64
(568.38)
1.88
(683.99)
1.35
(765.79)
1.25
17.99
21.92
11.54
6.38
3.82
3.20
Actuals
1
2
3
2007-08
Budget
Final Report
- 134 -
Minimum
Maximum
Average
1.25
1.88
1.55
3.20
21.92
10.81
Desirable
Benchmark
Less than 1.00
Less than 30 percent
Final Report
- 135 -
11
FINANCIAL OPERATING PLAN
11.1 OVERVIEW
The Financial Operating Plan (FOP) is a multi-year forecast of finances of the urban local
body. The FOP can be generated for a short term (5 to 7 yrs) and also for the long-term (20
yrs) period. In the context of this assignment, the FOP is generated for the short term (200809 to 2012-13). The projection has also been extended for the long-term (20 years) to
essentially provide a snapshot of the impact of identified investments on the municipal
finances in the long run.
The objective of this section is to assess the investment sustenance capacity of the ULB vis-vis the projects identified in the CIP as part of the CCBP preparation. FOPs are essentially
a financial forecast, developed on the basis of the growth trends of various components of
income and expenditure, based on time-series data. Accordingly, the financial forecast has
been prepared for the ULB. Broadly, all the sectoral components envisaged for funding are
under the ULB. The FOP is in full consonance with the town's vision & approach to
development and priorities and action plans approved by the stakeholders. Several
assumptions were made while forecasting finances. The study team has adopted necessary
caution to adopt the assumptions based on current growth trends, contribution pattern of
various revenue drivers, and utilization pattern of various expenditure drivers. In addition,
various quantifiable assets and liabilities of the ULB were also taken into account and
phased over a period of time. The following section provides insight into the various
assumptions made, necessary logic and justifications for such assumptions.
Income considerations
Revision of property tax ARV by 35 percent in FY 2007-08 and FY 2012-13 from the
existing previous base (quinquinennial revision);
Revision of about 30 percent in the base tariff for water and sewerage (as
applicable) during FY 2008-09, matching with the commissioning of the proposed
schemes has been proposed. A concurrent increase of 5 percent per annum for
other years as per the prevailing procedure of the GoTN Notification is also taken
into consideration;
Improving arrears tax collection efficiency to at least 75 percent and current
collection efficiency to at least 85 percent;
Growth in other revenue income items based on past performance and/or likely
growth; and
Any additional resources generated as part of proposed investments are taken into
consideration.
Final Report
- 136 -
Expenditure considerations
Establishment expenditure assumed to increase at the rate of 8 percent per annum
(8 percent is considered as there has been a consistent low growth rate over the
past years and also there is a restriction by the GoTN for fresh recruitment);
Repairs & maintenance to grow based on past performance and/or likely growth;
Proposed capital expenditure and phasing based on investments recommended;
Additional O&M for new investments are also taken into account.
2.
3.
4.
5.
B.
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
C.
1.
Final Report
No.
2.
- 137 -
3.
Particulars
Capital Grants - GoTN as
Counterpart Contribution
ULB as Counterpart Contribution
4.
5.
Loans/Borrowings
Investment phasing
Base Case - Optimum Scenario: This scenario assumes the capital investment estimate
and the phasing as per the Optimum Scenario. The FOP has been generated assuming
full CIPs under the Optimum Scenario for ULBs; and
Sustainable Scenario Option: This scenario is envisaged to ascertain a sustainable level
of the ULB for the proposed CIP considering the ULBs capital investment capacity and
its capacity to maintain the new assets.
From the discussion with the CMA and stakeholders of the ULB it was observed that
Underground sewerage system takes the long-term priority of the town taking into
consideration huge capital investment requirements and operation and maintenance
requirements. Hence the study team worked out the implementation and financial operating
plan with and without Underground sewerage project. In short-term period, an interceptor
drains with treatment plant are suggested to control / minimize the sewage and sullage load
which are being disposed into the major water bodies in the town through road side drains.
FOP has been evolved for the following four cases.
Even though scenarios are worked out, there is a possibility of reducing the capital
investment and thus increasing the borrowing / investment capacity of the ULB. Certain
projects have been identified, which can be outsourced or privatized, the list of which and
their costs are given as follows:
S.no.
1
Projects
Roads
Description
Strengthening
existing
roads
Amount
184.94
Upgradation of important
roads
Formation of new roads
259.41
Remarks
Government periodically announces grant
programs for development or upgradation of
roads. This particular project identified can be
posed under these grant projects, in phases,
as JNNURM does not support individual
projects, but takes an integrated approach.
Further, the ULB does not have surplus
financials to meet the expenditure by
themselves
-do-
332.87
-do-
Final Report
- 138 -
Street lighting
Solid
management
Remunerative
Proposals
1256.41
277.09
Waste
443.54
Construction
of
modernized
Slaughter
house near the By pass
road
Improvements of the
existing Market complex
27.22
4.29
76.23
Final Report
- 139 -
Construction of Shopping
Complex in the existing
office area.
Construction of the first
floor above the existing
bus stand shops
57.17
38.12
2008-09
0.00
0.00
2009-10
0.00
0.00
2010-11
0.00
0.00
2011-12
0.00
0.00
2012-13
0.00
0.00
(Rs. In lakhs)
Total
0.00
0.00
From the above table it is found that ULB does not have a borrowing and investment
capacity to fund the projects identified under CCBP. In the judgment of the consultants, the
ULB shall execute the works mentioned in the section 11.4 within a period of 2 years and
then go in for further capital investments.
For executing the above, it is quite obvious that ULBs may not have the capacity to prepare
contract documents or conduct feasibility study. For this purpose, they may engage a bid
process consultant through grant funds available with the CMA, and with the guidance of FIs
who are developing such practices.
Case 2: Capital Investment Considered under the Base Case Optimum Scenario:
This scenario assumes the capital investment estimate and the phasing as per the Optimum
Scenario. The FOP has been generated assuming full CIPs excluding underground
sewerage project under the Optimum Scenario.
Capital Investment Considered for FOP Generation (Case 2: FOP without UGSS): In
order to formulate FOP, projects that are directly implementable and having the impact over
the finance of ULB are considered. In this case UGS scheme to the town is not considered
Final Report
- 140 -
since implementation of this scheme requires heavy capital investment. Also in this case,
projects which are implemented by other departments like Rehabilitation of Vaippar River
and Ventankulam Tank etc are not considered for FOP iteration.
Assumptions:
Table 11.3: Assumptions on Means of Finance
Based on the phasing assumed
Fund Option
2008-09 2009-10
2010-11 2011-12
2012-13
the financials are done with
Loan
60%
60%
60%
60%
60%
certain basic assumptions on the
Grant
30%
30%
30%
30%
30%
means
of
finance.
Loan
Own
10%
10%
10%
10%
10%
assumptions
were
made
Total
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
conservatively, and are an
average of the various grants
Table 11.4: Assumptions on Means of Finance (Rs. In Lakhs)
and loans available. Moratorium
Loan
2008-09
2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13
of 2 years is considered on a
Assumptions
conservative side. The O&M is
Tenure
15
15
15
15
15
assumed based on sectors. The
Rate of Interest
9.00% 9.00%
9.00%
9.00%
9.00%
following table summarizes the
outcome of the FOP under the Base Case - Optimum Scenario against select key
indicators.
1.25
3.20
1.88
21.92
1.55
10.81
3
1.31
6.08
2.26
103.80
1.94
69.60
3
OR (Ratio)
1.31
DSR (%)
(0.00)
Category
Note: 1: Financially Sound; 2: Financially Fragile; 3: Financially Insolvent
2.26
103.80
1.86
50.55
3
Under the above scenario (Base Case - Optimum Scenario), if the full investment of
Rs.7,019.02 Lakhs is assumed for ULB and the FOP is forecast based on the above
assumptions, the ULB will be in a deficit position in all the FYs with an average of Rs.
1,835.46 Lakhs during the Short term Period. Further, in order to meet resource
requirements of its own contribution, the ULB would need to take loan of Rs. 4,211.66 Lakhs
during this period. In order to sustain the proposed capital investment, the ULB may require
grant support from the GoTN and GoI to the extent of at least Rs. 2,807.77 Lakhs during this
period. This is expected capital grant contribution from the GoTN at and GoI at 10 percent
each. In order to meet resource requirements of its own contribution, the ULB dont have the
capacity to transfer from its revenue because of its deficit position in the previous FY. The
summary of results from 2008-09 to 2012-13 (short-term) is provided as follows:
Final Report
- 141 -
Summary Statement
Opening Balance
Revenue Receipts
Revenue Expenditure
Operating Ratio
Debt Servicing Ratio (%)
Operating Deficit/Revenue Grant Requirement
Closing Balance
Capital Grant - GoI
Capital Grant - GoTN
ULB Contribution - Transfers from Revenue Surplus
ULB Contribution - Loan/Borrowings
2008-09
(810.77)
356.71
467.14
1.31
6.08
110.42
(921.20)
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
2009-10
(921.20)
395.86
686.79
1.73
49.71
290.93
(1212.13)
472.06
472.06
0.00
1416.17
2010-11
(1212.13)
435.69
938.28
2.15
89.48
502.59
(1714.72)
520.26
520.26
0.00
1560.79
(Rs. In lakhs)
2011-12
(1714.72)
493.25
1114.77
2.26
103.80
621.52
(2336.24)
329.67
329.67
0.00
989.02
2012-13
(2336.24)
536.17
1192.95
2.22
98.92
656.78
(2993.02)
50.97
50.97
0.00
152.90
It can be observed that there is an operational deficit in all the FY during the short-term
period and also deficit in the closing balance in all the FYs due to higher loan dependency
for the projects identified under CCBP. However, based on assumptions, the capital
components of the assumed investments are the loans (Rs. 4,211.66 Lakhs) and the grants
contributes (Rs. 2,807.77 Lakhs) to be made by the ULBs. The interest portion is taken for
calculation of the revenue surplus; the principal repayment is taken as revenue expenditure.
Debt Service Coverage Ratio during the short-term period is average of 69.60% which is
higher than 30% (permissible limit).
Case 3: Capital Investment Considered under the Base Case Optimum Scenario:
This scenario assumes the capital investment estimate and the phasing as per the Optimum
Scenario. The FOP has been generated assuming full CIPs under the Optimum Scenario.
Capital Investment Considered for FOP Generation (Case 3: FOP with UGSS): In order
to formulate FOP, projects that are directly implementable and having the impact over the
finance of ULB are considered. Under this case, Projects which are implemented by other
departments like Rehabilitation of Vaippar River and Ventankulam Tank, Construction of
ROB, widening of existing bridge, Construction of new by-pass road etc., are not
considered.
Assumptions:
Table 11.6: Assumptions on Means of Finance
Based on the phasing assumed
Fund Option
2008-09 2009-10
2010-11 2011-12
2012-13
the financials are done with
Loan
60%
60%
60%
60%
60%
certain basic assumptions on the
Grant
30%
30%
30%
30%
30%
means
of
finance.
Loan
Own
10%
10%
10%
10%
10%
assumptions
were
made
Total
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
conservatively, and are an
average of the various grants
and loans available. Moratorium
Table 11.7: Assumptions on Means of Finance (Rs. In Lakhs)
of 2 years is considered on a
Loan
2008-09 2009-10 2010-11 2011-12 2012-13
conservative side. The O&M is
Assumptions
assumed based on sectors.
Tenure
15
15
15
15
15
Rate of Interest
9.00% 9.00%
9.00%
9.00%
9.00%
Recent trends on O&M have
been adopted for making these
assumptions. The following table summarizes the outcome of the FOP under the Base
Case - Optimum Scenario against select key indicators.
Final Report
- 142 -
1.25
3.20
1.88
21.92
1.55
10.81
1.31
6.08
2.36
114.20
1.91
72.83
2.36
114.20
1.74
51.47
Under the above scenario (Base Case - Optimum Scenario), if the full investment of Rs.
9,240.41 Lakhs is assumed for ULB and the FOP is forecast based on the above
assumptions, the ULB will be in a deficit of position in all the FY of the short term period as
well as in the long term period
Further, in order to meet resource requirements of its own contribution, the ULB would need
to take loan of Rs. 4,861.26 Lakhs during this period. In order to sustain the proposed
capital investment, the ULB may require grant support from the GoTN and GoI to the extent
of at least Rs. 3,696.17 Lakhs during this period. This is expected capital grant contribution
from the GoTN at and GoI at 10 percent each.
In order to meet resource requirements of its own contribution, the ULB would need to
transfer its revenue surpluses of Rs.11.28 Lakhs during this period. Public contribution in the
form of deposits collected for UGS to the tune of Rs. 671.71 Lakhs need to be mobilized by
the ULB in advance. The summary of results from 2008-09 to 2012-13 (short-term) is
provided as follows:
Table 11.8: Summary of Base Case Optimum Scenario (Under Case 3)
S.No
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Summary Statement
Opening Balance
Revenue Receipts
Revenue Expenditure
Operating Ratio
Debt Servicing Ratio (%)
Operating Deficit/Revenue Grant
Requirement
Closing Balance
Capital Grant - GoI
Capital Grant - GoTN
ULB Contribution - Transfers from Revenue
Surplus
ULB Contribution - Loan/Borrowings
Public Contribution UGS Deposits
(Rs. In lakhs)
2008-09
(810.77)
356.71
467.14
1.31
6.08
110.42
2009-10
(921.20)
395.86
716.35
1.81
57.18
320.49
2010-11
(1241.69)
435.69
977.87
2.24
98.57
542.18
2011-12
(1783.86)
493.25
1166.07
2.36
114.20
672.82
2012-13
(2456.68)
693.25
1273.54
1.84
88.13
580.29
(921.20)
0.00
0.00
0.00
(1241.69)
611.26
611.26
0.00
(1783.86)
658.16
658.16
0.00
(2456.68)
414.30
414.30
0.00
(3036.97)
133.43
133.43
11.28
0.00
0.00
1654.43
179.34
1641.64
332.86
1083.40
159.51
389.02
0.00
It can be observed that there is an operational deficit in all the FYs during the short-term
period and also deficit in closing balance of all the FYs due to higher loan dependency for
the projects identified under CCBP. However, based on assumptions, the capital
components of the assumed investments are the loans (Rs. 4,861.26Lakhs) and the own
Final Report
- 143 -
contributions (Rs. 11.28 Lakhs) to be made by the ULBs. The interest portion is taken for
calculation of the revenue surplus; the principal repayment is taken as revenue expenditure.
Debt Service Coverage Ratio during the short-term period is average of 72.83% which is
higher than 30% (permissible limit). The negative surplus in the closing balance is due to
transfers from revenue account to capital expenditure in order to meet the ULB contribution.
Case 4: Capital Investment Considered under the Sustainable Scenario Zero Grant:
This is a scenario where the investments are sized according to the financial capabilities of
the ULB. This is worked out based on certain assumptions. The method of such workings
and the results thereon are given in the forthcoming sections.
Method and Assumption:
The sustainable scenario is prepared after taking into consideration, the revenue inflows and
outflows from the base scenario, i.e. the income from sewerage and water charges and
O&M on assets is taken. In order to arrive at the sustainability, three different parameters
were used which are,
TE /TR <1
DS /TR <=30%
30% of the operating surplus should be retained as surplus and the balance can only
be leveraged.
The least of the above 3 factors was arrived at as the possible annuities payable by the
ULB. With this a conversion factor was worked out to determine the Borrowing Capacity
and the Investment Capacity. The maximum sustainable investments for the next 5 years
are summarized as follows:
Table 11.9: Borrowing & Investment Capacity of Sustainable Case Scenario
Details
Borrowing Capacity
Investment Capacity
2008-09
0.00
0.00
2009-10
0.00
0.00
2010-11
0.00
0.00
2011-12
0.00
0.00
2012-13
0.00
0.00
(Rs. In lakhs)
Total
0.00
0.00
From the above table it is found that ULB does not have a borrowing and investment
capacity to fund the projects identified under CCBP. In the judgment of the consultants, the
ULB shall execute the works mentioned in the section 11.4 within a period of 2 years and
then go in for further capital investments.
For executing the above, it is quite obvious that ULBs may not have the capacity to prepare
contract documents or conduct feasibility study. For this purpose, they may engage a bid
process consultant through grant funds available with the CMA, and with the guidance of FIs
who are developing such practices.
Suggestions:
As mentioned in the earlier sections, the ULB can go in for BOT projects wherever
possible, in order to reduce initial investments, preferably in remunerative projects,
Sanitary Landfill and Composting Facility and also in traffic and transportation sector.
Energy efficiency measures can be adopted in order to reduce O&M costs in areas of
street lighting, etc.
The ULB contribution can be managed by the leveraging concept. A bridge loan can be
obtained from cheaper sources so that the initial upfront investment of ULB can be avoided
and as a result the negative closing balance can also be avoided. This can be managed as
there is still a revenue surplus available and repayments can be accommodated.
Final Report
- 144 -
Final Report
- 145 -
Final Report
- 146 -
12
PRIORITY ASSET MANAGEMENT PLAN
12.1 OVERVIEW
This section focuses on priority asset management to inform and help, guide policymaking
of city governments. Assets can be used by the city administration to help them achieve
their objectives; yet studies find that municipal assets are often underutilized by the local
governments or improperly transferred or sold. Assets can be put into productive use, or
they can be acquired, sold, transformed or otherwise disposed of to benefit ultimately the
citizenry.
The ultimate purpose of an Asset Management Plan is to ensure that assets are operated
and maintained in a sustainable and cost effective manner, so that they provide the required
level of service for present and future customers.
Final Report
- 147 -
Available Assets
Location of Assets
Age of Assets
Quantity of Assets
Physical Characteristics of Assets
It is starting point and for the determination of the high level strategy and objectives of the
program. The inventory can consist of approximations of the quantity, size, materials, and
age of each category of asset. For the project level decisions more detail is necessary for
condition and performance assessment. This level of inventory detail can require a
commitment to a multi year program of data collection and field verification.
CLASSIFICATION
An useful distinction for the classification of properties is the division between core
properties or assets needed for the basic operation of the municipality and often assigned to
the municipal government by law, and surplus properties or assets that are not necessary
for the normal operations of the municipal government but are still in under public
ownership. Assets needed for the operation of the municipality are sometimes further
differentiated according to use: necessary governmental use or social use. Governmental
use would refer to the assets used in the provision of public goods and services such as
municipal buildings, schools, hospitals, and police and fire stations, where the goal would be
efficient provision of public services. Social use would refer to property used for parks and
recreation.
SOME GUIDELINES FOR MUNICIPAL ASSET INVENTORY PREPARATION
A municipal asset inventory can be set up incrementally, based initially on existing
information, and improved through consultation, campaigns and surveys. The focus should
be on identifying major physical assets and subsequently on making this list publicly
available. The process should be seen as an ongoing effort and should be placed under a
responsible office or unit with appropriate mandate and resources. The basic approach
should be to:
List major municipal assets
Identify properties in use by major function
Examine current development plans and requests for the modification of status of
property
o New uses
o Private sector interest, potential for sale, lease
o Proposal to use the asset by other municipal or government departments
o New public sector projects, might include public assets as well as private
assets in the proposal (e.g. road project)
Identify properties that are vacant or otherwise indicated as surplus
Final Report
- 148 -
By considering the current condition point on an assumed decay curve, the profile can
predict the effective life (time) before failure. This failure time can by physical end of life,
minimum level of acceptable service, or limit of capacity of the asset.
Condition assessment ranks assets on a five step scale as follows:
1. Very Good - Very good condition, where only normal maintenance is required.
2. Good - Minor defects only where minor maintenance is required to approximately 5% of
the asset.
3. Fair - Maintenance required returning to accepted level of service where significant
maintenance is required to 10-20% of the asset.
4. Poor - requires renewal where significant renewal or upgrade is required to 20-40% of
the asset.
5. Very Poor - Assets unserviceable where over 50% of the asset requires replacement.
It is not necessary to assess all assets immediately. It is only necessary to assess those that
are going to be critical in the next 5 years. The extent and repetition of condition assessment
will be influenced by:
The criticality of the assets
The type of assets
The relative age of the assets
The rate of deterioration of the assets
The economic value of the outcomes to the business
Unplanned maintenance history
Generally the older the assets the more frequent the assessment of condition is required. It
is necessary to know whether failure is imminent, and if previous assessments have shown
degradation, at what rate.
Final Report
- 149 -
The financial valuation of properties and different forms of assets on a net present value (or
cost benefit) analysis framework might be appropriate, if the property has a minimum level of
value (defined as percent of total expenditures for the period, say initially 2% and upward)
and depending on the potential use of the asset. For smaller valued items, a more
accessible comparative conversion table could be used as the first approximation, with
automatic indicators adjusted for inflation and depreciation (both physical and technical) in
order to reduce administrative costs but keeping the system transparent. Capital valuation
methods, returns on assets, assessment of values from different perspectives and use of
property, should form part of the administrative tools of asset management.
Quantity (Nos.)
AC pipe 250 mm and 350 mm diameter
1
2.7
18
AC and PVC Pipe 90mm to 200mm diameter
0
0
3436
18
Remarks
40 km
2.40 LL
2.7 LL
2.5 hp pump set
18 km
2,000 litres capacity
Final Report
- 150 -
Sanitation:
Type of Assets
Public Conveniences
VAMBAY
Quantity (Nos.)
10
2
Remarks
75 seats
40 seats
Roads:
Sl. No.
1.
Road Typology
Surfaced Roads
- Cement Concrete
- Blacktop/Asphalted
- WBM
2.
10.55
15.69
-26.14
-0.16
0.16
26.30
Non-Surfaced Roads
- Stone Slab
- Earthen
Description
Length (km)
17.48
28.78
46.65
Description
Quantity (Nos.)
2
8
15
Tipper
Auto
Push Cart
Street Lights:
SL.No.
1.
2.
Type of Fixtures
Fluorescent (Tube Lights)
No.
699
119
818
Area
1
2
Municipal Office
Chairman Room
1
2
3
4
5
6
Centre No.1
Centre No.3
Centre No.2,7
Centre No.4
Centre No.5
Centre No.6
Municipal Office
Perumal Kovil Street
Municipal Office perimises Perumal kovil
street
Municipal Office perimises Perumal kovil
street
Noon Meal Centres
Bye -Pass road Head Water Works Opp.
Vembakottai road
S.R.Park at Vellakarai road
Perumal Kovil East car Street
Sivan Kovil South car Street
Perumal Kovil South car Street
Plinth Area of
Building
Total Area of
Building
-26.60 Sq m
1018.00 Sqm
--
58.00 Sq m
--
70.00 Sq m
112.00 Sqm
175.60 Sqm
78.00 Sqm
70.00 Sqm
61.00 Sqm
-------
Final Report
Sl.No
- 151 -
Area
Plinth Area of
Building
125.00 Sqm
Total Area of
Building
--
---
311.00 Sqm
532.00 Sqm
--
56.35 Sqm
---
54.60 Sqm
61.25 Sqm
Main road
Water Tanks
Bye - Pass Tank (Capacity - 6 Lakhs
Litre)
Macs Tank Main road(Capacity - 6 Lakhs
Litre)
Valavanthal puram (Capacity - 2 Lakhs
Litre)
Vellakarai road Tank (Capacity - 3 Lakhs
Litre)
Pumping Stations
--
828.80 Sqm
--
2781.00 Sqm
--
229.50 Sqm
--
270.00 Sqm
---
2064.00 Sqm
626.40 Sqm
1
2
3
4
86.00 Sqm
77.60 Sqm
47.60 Sqm
52.70 Sqm
-----
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
87.50 Sqm
57.00 Sqm
181.00 Sqm
29.00 Sqm
84.50 Sqm
85.00 Sqm
89.30 Sqm
54.60 Sqm
121.00 Sqm
33.00 Sqm
59.40 Sqm
------------
Centre No.8,9
1
2
1
2
3
1
1
2
3
4
1
2
Operation refers to the procedures and activities involved in the actual delivery of
services, e.g. abstraction, treatment, pumping, transmission and distribution of
drinking-water.
Maintenance refers to activities aimed at keeping existing capital assets in
serviceable condition, e.g. cleaning of open drains, repairing public taps.
Final Report
- 152 -
Under this assignment a review of O&M performance of the Municipality has been
performed through wide range of stakeholders consultation covering core infrastructure
services.
Final Report
- 153 -
Following are the identified O&M impacts and ULB constraints during the stakeholders consultation regarding service provision:
No
1
Sector
Water Supply
Sanitation
Storm Water
Drain
Transmission System
Distribution System
Lowered Revenue
Unauthorized Connections
System Losses - old lines
Component
Liquid Waste
No UGSS System
Solid Waste
Secondary Transportation
Treatment & Disposal of wastes
Public Conveniences
Network Coverage
Road Coverage
Low coverage
Improper Maintenance of Roads
Street Lighting
O&M Impact
Coverage
Final Report
- 154 -
Final Report
- 155 -
Final Report
- 156 -
13
PROJECT RISKS, ENVIRONMENTAL AND
SOCIAL IMPACTS
13.1 PROJECT STRUCTURING OPTIONS AND ASSOCIATED RISKS
Project Structuring is an integral part of managing the lifecycle of major infrastructural
projects. This process has involved the systematic identification, analysis and evaluation of
risks across all fronts. The following figure illustrates the framework adopted for formulation
of project structuring and identification of associated risks in any kind of infrastructure
projects. The following diagram illustrates the determinants of project structuring:
Project Structure
Final Report
- 157 -
Water Supply
Underground Sewerage System
Solid Waste Management (Landfill and Composting)
Roads and Storm Water Drain Improvements
Construction of Bus Stands, Shopping Complex and Marriage Halls.
Depending upon the infrastructure project the impact and measure may vary and are
discussed in the subsequent sections of this report.
A.
Riparian conflicts
Tree cutting
Utility Relocation
Planning
Temporary
Traffic Arrangements
Storage of materials
Action to be taken
All clearances required for Environmental aspects during construction shall be ensured and
made available before start of work.
Regulate extraction of water to reduce the effect of downstream users
Try saving trees by changing the alignment
Provide adequate tree protection (Tree guards)
Identify the number of trees that will be affected with girth size & species type.
Undertake afforestation in the nearby areas
Compensatory re-plantation of trees of at least twice the number of trees cut to be carried out
in the project area.
Identify the common utilities to be affected such as: electric cables, electric poles, telephone
cables, water pipelines, public water taps etc.
Affected utilities shall be relocated with prior approval of the concerned agencies before
commencement of construction activities.
Adequate actions to direct and regulate traffic shall be taken in consultation with the PIA,
Dept. of Police to prevent jamming of roads during construction. While planning alternative
routes, care to be taken to minimize congestion and negative impacts at sensitive receptors
such as schools & hospitals.
The wastewater shall comply with the standards of TNPCB to let out into the
stream/nallah/open land/irrigation purposes, and necessary permission to be obtained from
the concerned department.
Ensure efficient working condition of the treatment plant.
The contractor shall identify the site for temporary use of land for construction sites/storage
of construction materials, etc.
Final Report
- 158 -
Action to be taken
No appreciable change to stream course shall occur due to diversion channel and structures
shall be constructed accordingly.
Ensure the restoring of river bed to its natural shape free from any construction debris that
may obstruct flow.
The top soil to be protected and compacted after completion of work, where pipelines run,
including open lands and agricultural lands.
Laying of pipeline
Adequate precautions should be taken while laying water supply mains to avoid possibility of
cross connection with sewer lines
Water Treatment Plant / Booster Stations
Disposal of Sludge
A suitable site should be identified for the safe disposal of sludge generated at the WTP site
and got approved by the Engineer. Prepare a sludge disposal plan that adheres to the same.
Distribution Network and OHTs
Laying of distribution
Adequate precautions should be taken while laying water supply mains to avoid possibility of
pipelines
cross connection with sewer lines.
B.
These projects involve developing the contour maps, laying of branch and main sewer lines,
conveying mains, pumping stations, treatment plant etc. The following environmental
impacts need to be given attention while undertaking aforementioned activities:
DEVELOPMENT AND DESIGN PHASE
Potential Impacts
Clearances
Disposal of construction
debris and excavated
materials
Tree cutting
Utility Relocation
Planning
Temporary
Traffic Arrangements
Storage of materials
Action to be taken
All clearances required for Environmental aspects during construction shall be ensured and
made available before start of work.
The contractor shall identify the sites for debris disposal and should be finalized prior to the
start of earthwork excavation; taking into account the following:
The dumping does not impact natural drainage courses.
Avoid disposal on productive land
Try saving trees by changing the alignment
Provide adequate tree protection (Tree guards)
Identify the number of trees that will be affected with girth size & species type.
Undertake afforestation in the nearby areas
Compensatory re-plantation of trees of at least twice the number of trees cut to be carried out
in the project area.
Identify the common utilities to be affected such as: electric cables, electric poles, telephone
cables, water pipelines, public water taps etc.
Affected utilities shall be relocated with prior approval of the concerned agencies before
commencement of construction activities.
Adequate actions to direct and regulate traffic shall be taken in consultation with the PIA, Dept.
of Police to prevent jamming of roads during construction. While planning alternative routes,
care to be taken to minimize congestion and negative impacts at sensitive receptors such as
schools & hospitals.
The wastewater shall comply with the standards of TNPCB to let out into the
stream/nallah/open land/irrigation purposes, and necessary permission to be obtained from the
concerned department.
Ensure efficient working condition of the treatment plant.
The contractor shall identify the site for temporary use of land for construction sites/storage of
construction materials, etc.
Final Report
- 159 -
A suitable site should be identified for the safe disposal of silt/ sludge generated at the
Pumping / Lifting station sites, which should be away from the water bodies, residential &
sensitive areas, agricultural areas and etc., and got approved by the Engineer.
Construction of Sewerage Treatment Plant
Contamination of ground
Ground water quality may get contaminated due to leaching of waste water. So, the treated
water quality
water quality shall comply with the standards laid down by the PCB for disposal onto land,
water body or for irrigation use.
Regular monitoring is required for the treated sewage quality and also the ground water
quality in the near by areas and ensure compliance with PCB standards.
Impact on surrounding
To avoid problems of foul smell polluted air, insects, noise pollution and other problems buffer
areas
zones to be provided in the form of Green Belt around the STP site.
Disposal of treated waste
The treated water quality shall comply with the standards of TNPCB before letting out into the
water
stream/nallah/open land/irrigation purposes, and necessary permission to be obtained from
the concerned department.
Prevent the pollution of stream water and other water bodies receiving STP discharge.
Disposal of Sludge
A suitable site should be identified for the safe disposal of sludge generated at the WTP site
and got approved by the Engineer. Prepare a sludge disposal plan that adheres to the same.
C.
These projects may include developing land fill, compost yards with washing facilities,
compound walls, purchase of vehicles for transporting the garbage, etc.,
PUBLIC HEALTH, OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH & SAFETY
Public health may be affected by the project activities by noise and dust pollution during the
construction phase especially during landscaping, provision of access road and site
preparation. The activities that affect public health during operation and its closure are given
below:
Operation phase & Closure Phase
Emission of bio-gas, high noise levels during loading and unloading and high dust level
affect public health, waste dispersion, bad odour and spreading of infectious diseases are
other factors that affect public health during the operation and closure phase of the projects.
SOCIO-ECONOMIC CONDITIONS
The socio-economic impacts of the proposed projects within the local area are given below:
During the Construction phase, employment and visual issues are the two major impacts.
The share of local employment needs to be considered carefully during all construction
activities. The Visual impacts will result from disposal of debris and dispersion of solid waste
generated from the workers.
Impact on the i) Employment and ii) prosperity in Business are the major socio-economic
impacts known to occur during the Operation phase. The locals are concerned about
sharing the job opportunities with others during this phase. This issue should be given more
attention with regard to training. As far as Business prosperity is concerned, the supply of
spare parts and consumable from local market is expected to enhance local life quality.
Final Report
- 160 -
Rehabilitation of landfill, Electricity generation and Treated leachate may be the other
impacts during project closure period. A program for designing a final landscape and site
restoration should be provided as far as rehabilitation of land fill is concerned. The electricity
generated from the biogas will be supplied to the locals. The treated leachate may be
reused for irrigation purpose.
FLORA AND FAUNA
The proposed activities that affect Flora and Fauna species during construction and
operation phase are given below:
During the Construction Phase, Flora and Fauna species may be affected by high dust
pollution and direct damage especially during landscaping, provision of access road, site
preparation and removal of soil cover.
During the Operation Phase, high dust level and dispersion of solid waste affect the flora
and fauna species during the project activities such as construction of new cells, loading,
unloading and transportation of solid waste.
WATER RESOURCES
The proposed activities that affect water resources during construction and operation phase
are given below:
Water resources may be affected due to the demand of water for soil compaction and
pollution of ground water during Construction phase. Ground water may be contaminated
due to the maintenance of machineries and resulting domestic waste water from workers.
Hazardous waste dumping and leachate leakages are the two major activities that affect the
water resources during Operation phase. Leachate treatment unit need to be installed on a
paved area to prevent ground water contamination and also a proper reuse and recycle
mechanism to be considered for the treated leachate.
ARCHEOLOGY
Unseen archeological remains (if any) might be affected during landscaping and site
preparation.
MITIGATION MEASURES AND MONITORING PROGRAM
Following are the mitigation measures that need to be implemented in order to reduce the
potential negative impacts:
Dust level need to be controlled during construction activities and transportation of
materials.
Proper handling of dispersed solid waste during transportation and storage.
Proper handling and taking safety requirements for collection and storage of the
solid waste to prevent odour generation.
Taking restrict control on animals and insects (vector diseases) like dogs, cats, rats
etc.
Applying continuous cover over the cell during the operation to prevent odor impact.
Control the existence of the scavengers at the solid waste landfill site to prevent
firing and dispersion of the wastes.
Noise levels need to be controlled during the construction and operation activities.
Monitoring programs need to be implemented covering monitoring of noise levels
and ambient air quality.
Implementation of safety procedures and availability of safety equipment for
workers.
Final Report
D.
- 161 -
Training and awareness programs for drivers and workers on proper handling of
waste and personal protective equipments. Conducting routine medical exams for
workers.
Training of employees to identify hazardous waste and proper safety procedure on
handling and reporting such items.
The domestic wastewater resulting during construction and operation phases need
to be collected and managed in safe manner.
The endogenous trees or plants should be used when rehabilitant the site.
Restrict activities as much as possible to the project site and allocate track roads for
construction.
Hunting and collection of wildlife, especially residents and migratory raptures should
be strictly forbidden.
ROAD IMPROVEMENTS
Activities
Pre-Construction Stage
Land Acquisition
R&R
Tree Cutting
Utility Relocation
Replacement
of
common amenities
Activities
Construction Stage
Clearance
and
grubbing
The acquisition of land and private properties will be carried out in accordance with the RAP and
entitlement framework for the project.
It should be ensured that all R& R activities are to be completed before the construction activity
starts, on any sub-section of the project.
Trees will be removed from the Corridor of Impact (CoI) and construction sites before
commencement of construction with prior intimation to the Forest Department. Prior permission
will be obtained from the District Collector.
Try saving trees by changing the alignment
Provide adequate tree protection (Tree guards)
Identify the number of trees that will be affected with girth size & species type.
Undertake afforestation in the nearby areas
Compensatory re-plantation of trees of at least twice the number of trees cut to be carried out in
the project area.
Identify the common utilities to be affected such as: electric cables, electric poles, telephone
cables, water pipelines, public water taps etc.
Affected utilities shall be relocated with prior approval of the concerned agencies before
commencement of construction activities.
All common amenities such as community sources of water, bus shelters etc., will be relocated
wherever necessary. The relocation site identification will be in accordance with the choice of the
community and completed before the construction starts
Management Measures
Excavations
Management Measures
Earth fill
Dust
Compaction of soil
Silting, contamination
of water bodies
Vegetation will be removed from the RoW before the commencement of construction and will be
carried out such that the damage or disruption to flora is minimum.
Only ground cover / shrubs that impinge directly on the permanent works or necessary temporary
works will be removed with prior approval from the engineer. The contractors, under any
circumstances will not damage trees (in addition to those already identified and felled with prior
permission from the forest department)
All excavations will be done in such a manner that the suitable materials available from excavation
are satisfactorily utilized.
The excavation shall conform to the lines, grades, side slopes and levels shown in the drawing or
as directed by the Engineer.
The contractor shall take adequate protective measures to see that excavation operations do not
affect or damage adjoining structures and water bodies.
Embankment and other fill areas, unless and other wise permitted by the Engineer, be constructed
evenly over their full width and the contractor will control and direct movement of construction
vehicles and machinery over them.
All earth work will be protected in a manner acceptable to the engineer to minimize generation of
dust
To minimize soil compaction construction vehicles, machinery and equipment will move or be
stationed in designated area (RoW, haul roads as applicable) only
Silt fencing to be provided around the stockpiles at the construction sites close to water bodies.
Construction materials containing fine particles will be stored in an enclosure such that sediment
laden water does not drain into the nearby water courses.
Final Report
Activities
Environmental
Monitoring
E.
- 162 -
Management Measures
The contractor will undertake seasonal monitoring of air, water, noise and soil quality through an
approved monitoring agency.
Activities
Pre-Construction Stage
Land Acquisition
R&R
Tree Cutting
Utility Relocation
Replacement
of
common amenities
Activities
Construction Stage
Clearance
and
grubbing
The acquisition of land and private properties will be carried out in accordance with the RAP and
entitlement framework for the project.
It should be ensured that all R& R activities are to be completed before the construction activity
starts, on any sub-section of the project.
Trees will be removed from the site if arises and construction sites before commencement of
construction with prior intimation to the Forest Department. Prior permission will be obtained from
the District Collector.
Try saving trees by alternatives
Provide adequate tree protection (Tree guards)
Identify the number of trees that will be affected with girth size & species type.
Undertake afforestation in the nearby areas
Compensatory re-plantation of trees of at least twice the number of trees cut to be carried out in
the project area.
Identify the common utilities to be affected such as: electric cables, electric poles, telephone
cables, water pipelines, public water taps etc.
Affected utilities shall be relocated with prior approval of the concerned agencies before
commencement of construction activities.
All common amenities such as community sources of water, bus shelters etc., will be relocated
wherever necessary. The relocation site identification will be in accordance with the choice of the
community and completed before the construction starts
Management Measures
Excavations
Management Measures
Earth fill
Dust
Compaction of soil
Silting, contamination
of water bodies
Environmental
Monitoring
Vegetation will be removed from the site before the commencement of construction and will be
carried out such that the damage or disruption to flora is minimum.
Only ground cover / shrubs that impinge directly on the permanent works or necessary temporary
works will be removed with prior approval from the engineer. The contractors, under any
circumstances will not damage trees (in addition to those already identified and felled with prior
permission from the forest department)
All excavations will be done in such a manner that the suitable materials available from excavation
are satisfactorily utilized.
The excavation shall conform to the lines, grades, side slopes and levels shown in the drawing or
as directed by the Engineer.
The contractor shall take adequate protective measures to see that excavation operations do not
affect or damage adjoining structures and water bodies.
Embankment and other fill areas, unless and other wise permitted by the Engineer, be constructed
evenly over their full width and the contractor will control and direct movement of construction
vehicles and machinery over them.
All earth work will be protected in a manner acceptable to the engineer to minimize generation of
dust
To minimize soil compaction construction vehicles, machinery and equipment will move or be
stationed in designated area (RoW, haul roads as applicable) only
Silt fencing to be provided around the stockpiles at the construction sites close to water bodies.
Construction materials containing fine particles will be stored in an enclosure such that sediment
laden water does not drain into the nearby water courses.
The contractor will undertake seasonal monitoring of air, water, noise and soil quality through an
approved monitoring agency.
Final Report
- 163 -
Final Report
- 164 -
14
POLICY INTERVENTIONS
14.1 INTRODUCTION
Sattur is a town with a projected population of 40,955 in 2021. In addition, it is anticipated
that another 10,000 will form the floating population component in the town. Re-organization
of institution, improvement and capacity building programs are required to meet the needs of
managing Sattur 2021. This chapter discusses the agenda for institutional reforms in town
governance and urban poor. It also reviews the institutional reform initiatives already
undertaken at the ULB level and State Government level to successfully implement and
operate the CCBP projects.
To institute a nodal agency, which could provide effective governance to the ULB;
To ensure that the function and powers of this agency and its constituents, match
their responsibilities and make them fully accountable.
To enable clarity of jurisdiction of various agencies and entrusting pertinent
responsibilities
To structure administration such that it reaches the people and vice versa, to ensure
effective problem solving mechanisms in place
To evolve an effective system of town planning, keeping in view the needs in the
context of Local Planning Area (LPA);
To strengthen and build capacity within the ULB, its constituents and other agencies
entrusted with relevant tasks,; and
To make the primary focus of the system and its constituents, the functional
requirements of management of Sattur;
14.3 REFORMS
The ULBs of Tamil Nadu have been generally found to be proactive in their commitment to
introduce reforms at the ULB level. All these reforms may be broadly categorized under the
following:
Computerization Initiatives;
Property Tax Reforms;
Privatization Initiatives;
Accounting Reforms; and
Resource Mobilization Initiatives.
A brief description on the above reform initiatives and their current stage are given in the
following sections of this report.
Final Report
- 165 -
Final Report
- 166 -
Apart from the above, following are some of other reform measures which should be
implemented to support the above identified key municipal reforms.
URBAN ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT
The costs of maintaining a healthy urban environment need to be recovered through various
municipal taxes and user charges following the polluter pays principle. For this, the
functional role of the ULB as envisaged in Item 8, 12th Schedule of the Constitution has to be
resolved keeping in view the role of the Tamil Nadu Pollution Control Board, and the
organizational and fiscal strength of the ULB.
ACCESS OF URBAN SERVICES TO THE POOR
Since ability-to-pay for the cost of environmental infrastructure service provision is an
important criterion, cross-subsidization of tariffs, innovative project structuring and user/
community participation is the means to ensure access of these services to the poor. Again
the functional and financial role of ULB with respect to the Items 10 and 11 of 12th Schedule
vis--vis those of central and state government agencies need to be resolved.
The ULB shall maintain data to generate indicators as suggested in this document for
evaluating its performance.
Prepare and conduct capacity building programmes for elected representatives,
especially women representatives, with a view to enable them to focus on gender based
issues.
Final Report
- 167 -
Promote the creation of interactive platforms for sharing municipal innovations, and
experiences among municipal managers.
Better human resource management through assessment of the training needs of
personnel involved in urban administration to enhance management and organizational
capabilities.
Assessment of fund requirement and resource persons to tackle the training needs of all
personnel.
Development of training material in the local language and impact and evaluation
studies of the training programmes.
Capacity building to better position the urban local body to employ highly qualified staff
and seek superior quality of out-sourced services.
As specified earlier, priority actions have been discussed and finalized by the stakeholders
for urban governance for the ULB. The following policy framework and priority actions have
been identified by the study team based on reported evaluations, discussions and priority
actions as required and mutually agreed upon by the stakeholders.
TECHNOLOGY INTERVENTIONS THROUGH COMPUTERIZATION
Conduct citizen satisfaction surveys & analysis on annual basis to assess citizen needs
and demands including satisfaction levels.
PR strategies to enhance community participation and create awareness.
Innovative citizen complaint redressal system including e-Governance.
Augment and strengthen new initiatives on citizen interface and orientation.
Regular interface with citizen associations/forum to understand public needs.
The above assignment has to be carried out by the ULB with full support from the GoTN.
The outcome of the above assignment shall provide clear guidelines and impetus to the
towns for good urban governance.
Final Report
- 168 -
Repeal of Urban Land Ceiling and Regulation Act: This Act has been repelled in the
State.
Reform of Rent Control Laws: There is a Rent Control Act in the State.
Rationalization of Stamp Duty to bring it down to no more than 5 percent within the next
seven years: At present the Stamp Duty in the State is revised at 8 percent. Some states
like Maharashtra and Karnataka have already reduced their stamp duty to less than 5
percent. The experience is very positive with stamp duty revenues increasing due to
better compliance. The GoTN may consider reducing the Stamp Duty in a phased
manner.
Associating elected ULBs with City Planning and Civic Service Functions: Suitable
action suggested as under Implementation of decentralization measures as envisaged
in 74th CAA, 1992, of the GoI may be taken.
Final Report
- 169 -
Reform of Property Tax in ULBs: Introduction of objective based property tax system
such as unit area and self-assessment systems will help rationalize the tax base.
Moreover, introduction of MIS and GIS based mapping will help to bring all properties
into the tax system and increase tax collection. Based on the experience of other states
it may be ascertained whether any changes in the Municipal Corporation Act are
needed.
Levy of reasonable user charges by ULBs to recover full cost of operation and
maintenance: At present cost recovery from urban water supply and sewerage services
is relatively low and unsatisfactory when compared with the incurred O&M expenditure.
Low cost recovery is one of the potential causes for poor efficiency of the services. It is
necessary that user charges for these services reflect the actual costs and recover at
least O&M costs.
Provision of basic services to urban poor: Provision of basic services to the urban poor
including security of tenure at affordable prices, improved housing, water supply,
sanitation, while ensuing delivery of other already existing universal services of the
Government such as education, health and social security is required.
Town Planning: Views of the ULBs should be incorporated in town planning and
regulation of land use and building construction. Provisions may be made for obtaining
the views of municipal councils/corporations on development plans. Size of building (by
use) and layout plan will be decided from time to time through a Government Order.
Necessary changes may be made in the Town Planning Act and Rules.
Water Supply and Sewerage: Consequent to the 74th CAA, the ULBs are responsible for
ensuring these services to the citizens. Different options of service management either
by the ULB or by a private operator through a management contract can be explored.
Necessary amendments should be carried out to the applicable Acts and Rules in
accordance with set norms and standards by the GoTN/GoI in this regard.
Reduction in Stamp Duty: Stamp Duty to be reduced to 5 percent from the existing 8
percent over the next seven years at the rate of 0.50 percent per year. The Finance
Department may initiate the necessary action in this regard.
Final Report
- 170 -
Accounting System: Amend the Municipal Act to enable introduction of the accrualbased double entry accounting system. Prepare a State-Level Municipal Accounting
Manual based on NMAM. The new system should be introduced in all municipal
corporations of the State.
Property Tax: The applicable act should be amended to introduce the unit area and selfassessment system for property tax. Rules for introduction of the unit area and selfassessment system for property tax to be prepared under the applicable act.
User Charges: The ULB should prepare an information system that provides data on
O&M for water supply and sewerage services. Pricing of water supply and sewerage
services should reflect actual costs and should cover O&M costs within five years. The
GoTN will provide support to ULBs to implement this reform.
Delivery of Services to Poor: The State Government should continuously support ULBs
to extend basic services to the urban poor. A policy paper on this subject should be
prepared.
Adherence to the above reform agenda and efficient implementation, especially the ULB
level reforms, would go a long way in improving the creditworthiness of the ULB and in
enhancing sustainability of the proposed capital investments. Based on the above, a
suggestive timeline for the reform agenda has been developed during the study process and
is furnished in Table 14.1.
Reforms already implemented by ULB would be discussed in detail during the next stake
holders consultation and also reforms which need to be implemented by the ULB and a time
frame for the implementation of the same would be presented to the stakeholders for further
refinement through consultation.
Final Report
- 171 -
Particulars/Items
A.
A.1
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Year 6
Year 7
A.3
B.
B.1
Final Report
Sl.
- 172 -
Particulars/Items
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Year 6
Year 7
B.3
B.4
ALREADY REPEALED
NOT RELEVANT
B.6
B.7
Associate elected ULBs - City Planning & Civic Services (as part of Reform Initiative
A.2)
C.
C.1
C.2
Final Report
Sl.
- 173 -
Particulars/Items
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Year 6
Year 7
C.4
C.5
Devolution of Functions
City / Town Planning and Building Approvals
Water Supply and Sewerage
Final Report
Sl.
- 174 -
Particulars/Items
D.
D.1
Accrual-based Double Entry Accounting System (as part of Reform Initiative C.2)
D.2
D.3
Reform of Property Tax in Urban Local Bodies (as part of Reform Initiative C.1)
D.4
Levy Reasonable User Charges - recover Full O&M Cost (as part of Reform Initiative
C.3)
D.5
E.
OPTIONAL REFORMS
E.1
E.2
E.3
E.4
E.5
E.6
E.7
E.8
E.9
Structural Reforms
E.10
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
Year 4
Year 5
Year 6
Year 7
ALREADY IN PLACE
Final Report
- 175 -
15
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
15.1 INTRODUCTION
The objective of the Technical Assistance (TA) is to strengthen project management and
institutional capabilities, and improve overall readiness for project implementation by the
ULB. TA shall assist the ULBs, to efficiently and effectively manage, coordinate, implement,
and monitor the Projects identified, including the institutional and financial reform initiatives
under the CCBP. The key outcome of TA shall be (i) identification of key project personnel
and creation of project management and project implementation units; (ii) training for the
executing and implementing agencies to familiarize them with policies and procedures; (iii)
completion of consultants selection and prequalification of contractors; (iv) preparation of
standard bid documents for works and procurement of goods, materials, machinery and
supplies; (v) identification of required land and acquisition notification with disclosure to
affected people issued by the implementation agencies and prepared resettlement
guidelines; and (vi) introduction of institutional and financial reforms. The TA shall assist the
ULBs in conducting public awareness and stakeholder consultations to improve
understanding and acceptance of the Project and build consensus for introducing
institutional and policy reforms outlined in UIDSSMT, whose completion is expected in
March 2012.
Final Report
- 176 -
firming up arrangements for land acquisition and resettlement. TA shall assist the ULB in
learning about TNUDF policies and procedures for procurement, recruitment of consultants,
disbursement, fund management, environmental and social safety guards, corruption
prevention, auditing, reporting, and other key aspects of project operations. Furthermore, the
TA need to help train the ULB personnel in planning, leading, organizing, and coordinating
project activities through participatory workshops and on-the-job involvement in project
management. These activities shall be carried out after an assessment of the training needs
of project states and ULBs.
2. Component B: Institutional and Financial Reforms
The TA consultants need to assist the ULB in carrying out urban management, institutional,
and financial reforms recommended by the GoI/GoTN. This include strengthening of ULB
with severe deficiencies; initiation of water utilities arrangement in ULB; improvement of
urban planning; and improvement of property taxation and user charges for such services as
water supply, sewerage, and solid waste management. The following specific activities have
to be undertaken in the ULB:
(i)
(ii)
(iii)
(iv)
Final Report
- 177 -
16
IMPLEMENTATION FRAMEWORK
16.1 AGENCIES INVOLVED
The ULBs are presently governed by seven Acts, one each for six city Municipal
Corporations and one for Municipalities and Town Panchayats. The Town Panchayats which
were governed by the Tamil Nadu Panchayats Act (1958) were brought under Tamil Nadu
District Municipalities Act (1920) consequent on the historic 74th Constitutional Amendment
Act (74th CAA) and on the basis of conformity legislations adopted by the State Legislature
from 1st June 1994.
The town Administration is vested with the Local body. With the enactment of Tamil Nadu
Urban Local Bodies Act 1998, a full-fledged local body came into function with an elected
Chairperson and Councilors. The ULB discharges various obligatory and discretionary
functions as per the provisions of the TN ULB Act, 1998, and provides various specified civic
services/infrastructure facilities to the citizens of the town. Apart from the ULB, there are
other Government departments and their directorates with development related
responsibilities and functions. The following table provides an insight into the development
related responsibilities and functions of various Government departments/institutions in the
region which have a direct bearing on service provision and delivery:
Table 16.1: Development Related Responsibilities and Functions of Various State Government Departments / Institutions
Sl.
Name of the Department/
Responsibilities and Functions
No.
Institution
1.
Local Planning Authority,
LPA was constituted under the Town & Country Planning Act, 1971.
(LPA)
Responsible for development of Local Planning area.
Preparation of interim, comprehensive and zonal development plans.
Enforcement of the provisions of the development plan, zoning regulations and
planning and building standards by way of issuing permissions for construction of
buildings.
Preparation of development schemes and its implementation.
All Town planning functions, development controls and building / layout sanctions.
Principal objectives of the authority include creation of housing stock, creation of
commercial complexes, improvement of city level infrastructure, environmental
improvement, parks and plantations in colonies, blocks, institutions and roadsides.
2.
Public Works Department
Responsible for construction, repair and maintenance of buildings and other related
(PWD)
structures financed from the state and capital budget allocations of the GoTN.
Also responsible for ensuring that no encroachment or structure, whether
temporary or permanent is erected on the land and property under the control of
PWD. It is also responsible for removal of such encroachments as per the GoTN
rules.
Maintaining a register of land, buildings and properties belonging to the GoTN and
under the administration of PWD.
3.
Highways Department,
Responsible for construction, repair and maintenance of roads, bridges, flyovers
and other related structures financed from the state and capital budget allocations
of the GoTN.
All major arterial roads and link roads that enable links to other parts of the district
and state are under the control of the Highways department.
4.
5.
Water Resources
Organization, (WRO), GoTN
Final Report
- 178 -
Sl.
No.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
Source: Analysis
Following table provides an insight into the institutional responsibilities, including the roles
played by the private sector for various urban infrastructure and services:
Urban Infrastructure
Water Supply
Sewerage
Sanitation
Storm Water Drainage
Major Drains & Canals
Storm Water Drainage & Related
Structures along major
roads/highways
Storm Water Drainage
Minor Drains
Solid Waste Management
Roads (including Flyovers) Major Roads
Municipal Roads (including
Flyovers) - Minor/Internal Roads
Street Lighting
Local Body/TWAD
Local Body/TWAD
Local Body
PWD/WRO
Local Body/TWAD
Local Body/TWAD
Local Body
PWD/WRO
Operation and
Maintenance
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Highways Department
Highways Department
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Highways Department
Highways Department
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Local Body
Source: Analysis
Final Report
- 179 -
A Project Formulation & Design Coordination Committee at the regional level to cover
all the identified ULBs may be instituted which may be composed of senior engineers
from relevant departments, boards and experts who are involved in related engineering,
research and development activities
A central design database shall be developed by the Committee containing the following
information:
Design infrastructure (specifications and drawings) from earlier contracts and on the
existing system.
Design information on the proposed improvements.
Details and data on surveys and field investigations performed (topographical/
geotechnical /traffic volume counts, etc. as applicable).
The aforementioned database shall be upgraded and validated into a Project
Implementation and Commissioning Database, which is explained in the following
section.
The Committee shall also ensure efficient and reliable data sharing between the various
entities that are involved in preparation of the projects for subsequent implementation;
this measure is intended to mitigate and possibly prevent/ significantly reduce future
rework and ensure timely implementation in a cost effective manner.
It is also recommended that the aforementioned Committee be involved in the
implementation stage to ensure that the design intent is conveyed into system
implementation, operation and maintenance.
Final Report
- 180 -
It is also imperative for the Project Management Consultant (PMC) to perform the
aforementioned responsibilities to the highest degree of quality since this database will
be the ultimate record of the project for future upgrades/modifications.
Specific attention needs to be paid to documentation/correspondence files since these
files will provide future insight to the past chronology of events, issues, resolutions and
other relevant information.
The PMC must also facilitate and assist in implementing a system for sequentially and
chronologically appending future modifications to the database, so that all changes
made are accurately reflected and available for future reference.
The PMC should involve the ULB officials in the process so as to take up further such
projects bythemselves.