Ref24 PDF
Ref24 PDF
1, JANUARY 2009
277
AbstractThis paper presents a control system based on a repetitive controller to compensate for key power-quality disturbances,
namely voltage sags, harmonic voltages, and voltage imbalances,
using a dynamic voltage restorer (DVR). The control scheme deals
with all three disturbances simultaneously within a bandwidth. The
control structure is quite simple and yet very robust; it contains
a feedforward term to improve the transient response and a feedback term to enable zero error in steady state. The well-developed
graphical facilities available in PSCAD/EMTDC are used to carry
out all modeling aspects of the repetitive controller and test system.
Simulation results show that the control approach performs very
effectively and yields excellent voltage regulation.
Index TermsDynamic voltage restorer (DVR), harmonic distortion, power quality (PQ), repetitive control, voltage sag.
I. INTRODUCTION
HE importance of power quality (PQ) has risen very considerably over the last two decades due to a marked increase
in the number of equipment which is sensitive to adverse PQ environments, the disturbances introduced by nonlinear loads, and
the proliferation of renewable energy sources, among others. At
least 50% of all PQ disturbances are of the voltage quality type,
where the interest is the study of any deviation of the voltage
waveform from its ideal form [1]. The best well-known disturbances are voltage sags and swells, harmonic and interharmonic
voltages, and, for three-phase systems, voltage imbalances.
A voltage sag is normally caused by short-circuit faults in
the power network [2], [3] or by the starting up of induction
motors of large rating [4]. The ensuing adverse consequences
are a reduction in the energy transfers of electric motors and the
disconnection of sensitive equipment and industrial processes
brought to a standstill. A comprehensive description of voltage
sags can be found in [5].
Manuscript received June 05, 2007; revised May 26, 2008. Current version published December 24, 2008. This work was supported in part by the
Castilla-La Mancha Council under Research Project PBI-06-0150, in part by
the Fellowship Program of Caja Castilla-La Mancha, and in part by the Consejo
Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnologa de Mxico and Instituto Tecnolgico y de
Estudios Superiores de Monterrey, Mxico. Paper no. TPWRD-00330-2007.
P. Roncero-Snchez and V. Feliu are with the Department of Electrical, Electronic, Control Engineering and Communications, E.T.S. Ingenieros Industriales, Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha, Ciudad Real 13071, Spain (e-mail:
Pedro.Roncero@uclm.es).
E. Acha and J. E. Ortega-Calderon are with the Department of Electronics and
Electrical Engineering of the University of Glasgow, Glasgow G12 8LT, U.K.
A. Garca-Cerrada is with the Department of Electronics and Control Engineering, Universidad Pontificia Comillas de Madrid, Madrid 28045, Spain.
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPWRD.2008.2002967
278
279
(7)
(8)
(9)
In order to calculate the frequency response of (7)(9), the
. It should be noticed that the
variable is substituted by
is always zero whenever
is an
term
(e.g.,
, then
integer multiple of the frequency
). Hence, the frequency response shows that
and
for frequenwith
. Therefore, if the
cies
closed-loop system is stable, the error in steady state is zero for
sinusoidal reference inputs or sinusoidal disturbance inputs of
frequency .
is smaller than the grid-voltage period
Since the delay
, the transfer function
can be chosen
as
(10)
where
(3)
With the substitution of (7)(9) and (10) into the load voltage,
(2) yields
(4)
(5)
Repetitive control is a contemporary control technique that may
be used to cancel out, simultaneously, voltage sags, voltage harmonics, and voltage imbalances, characteristics rarely achieved
with other control techniques, such as PI controllers. As a first
approximation, as described in conventional repetitive-control
can be written as
theory [23], the controller
(11)
Unfortunately, the delay is not exactly known and the closedloop system will not be stable if a controller is used with (6) and
.
(10) designed for an estimated
is proTo tackle this problem, a modified controller
posed as
(12)
(6)
where
is a transfer function chosen so that the closed-loop
is the fundamental frequency
stability is always fulfilled and
at the mains.
280
(16)
in (16) must comply
In order to guarantee stability, the term
with the Nyquist criterion: if the number of unstable poles of the
is equal to zero
, then the
open-loop system
number of counterclokwise encirclements of the point
of the term
must be zero
with
.
Since all of the poles of
are stable, which implies that
, then must be zero to guarantee stability, and a suffican be obtained by making
cient condition for
(17)
which is fulfilled if
(18)
Note that condition (18) is independent of the delay value of
in (12).
the controller
A low-pass filter, which is approximated by a constant time
within its passband, can be designed
delay
being the time delay of the filter. For continuous syswith
tems, Bessel filters can be used because they can be approximated by a constant time delay [28], while for discrete time systems, finite-impulse-response (FIR) filters with a linear phase in
their passband can be used [29]. Therefore, the design parameter
can be chosen to cancel out the filter time delay
;
and under such conditions, the closed-loop-system frequency reand
sponse will satisfy
while the approximation of a constant time delay is valid.
Obviously, the bandwidth of the controller will be limited because the magnitude characteristic of the filter will decrease as
frequency increases.
20-kVA coupling transformer with a unity turns ratio and a starconnected secondary winding. The voltage of the dc storage device is 650 V. The main parameters are summarized in Table I.
Q(s)e
0 1).
281
Fig. 7. Three-phase rms voltage. (a) Across the sensitive load. (b) At the PCC.
A. Controller Parameters
In order to design the parameters of the control system correctly, a nominal value for the expected time delay
must
be chosen. As the controller has been implemented by using
the continuous systems provided by PSCAD/EMTDC, the time
delay is only due to PWM switching. In this paper, a sinusoidal PWM scheme has been used to generate the switching
signals for the power converter, which consists of a three-branch
three-phase voltage-source inverter.
A controller has been designed for each phase by using a
coordinate system. The
reference frame
three-phase
is perhaps the most popular alternative to control load voltages
when operating under unbalanced conditions. Nevertheless, it
should be recalled that the repetitive controller also guarantees
zero-tracking error at zero frequency; the controller can be implerotating synchronously
mented by using a reference frame
with the fundamental frequency since the fundamental harmonic
transforms into a dc component in this reference frame.
The fundamental frequency was chosen as being equal to
50 Hz, while the switching frequency was set at 6.45 kHz in
which
order to obtain a frequency-modulation (FM) index
was large enough and an odd integer multiple of 3
(see [30] for more details). Hence, the estimated time delay was
, with
being the switching frechosen to be
quency. The parameter was set at
.
has been designed whose
A second-order Bessel filter
cutoff frequency is 5 kHz. The filter has a linear phase lag in
its passband, which is equivalent to a constant time delay of
551.33 s. The amplitude of the filter begins to decrease at approximately 1 kHz (about 20 times the fundamental frequency).
Fig. 6 shows the Nyquist diagram of the term
where it can be seen that the
number of counterclockwise encirclements of the point
is zero
. Therefore, recalling that the number of
is
, the
unstable poles of the open-loop system
closed-loop system is stable.
B. Simulation Results
The scenario of the simulation is the one depicted in Fig. 4
where the simulation has been carried out as follows: the nonlinear load and the DVR are connected at
0 s. A two-phase
short-circuit fault is applied at the PCC from
0.2 s to
Fig. 8. Line-to-line voltage. (a) At the PCC. (b) Across the sensitive load. Corresponding to the interval (s): 0
0 2.
t< :
282
Fig. 9. Detail of the spectrum of the line-to-line voltage. (a) At the PCC.
(b) Across the sensitive load.
Fig. 11. Sensitive-load line-to-line voltages. (a) v . (b) v . (c) v . Corresponding to the interval (s) 0:2
t < 0:28.
. (b) v
. (c) v
distortion is due to the harmonic currents drawn by the rectifier, while the total current provided to the sensitive load and
the rectifier causes a voltage drop at the PCC. The Fourier analysis of the line-to-line voltage shows that the rms value at the
fundamental frequency is 385 V (96.25% of the nominal value)
12.52%.
and the total harmonic voltage distortion is
Fig. 8(b) shows the line-to-line voltage across the sensitive load,
whereas Fig. 9(a) and (b) shows the harmonic spectrums of the
line-to-line voltage at the PCC and across the sensitive load,
respectively. The control system guarantees that the DVR not
only counteracts the voltage drop but also cancels out the harmonic voltages caused by the nonlinear load. In this case, the
fundamental harmonic has an rms value of 399.63 V, while the
%. Note that
total harmonic voltage distortion is
this harmonic distortion value is due to the high-frequency harmonics associated with the PWM process.
The results obtained when the two-phase short circuit occurs
are plotted in Figs. 1012. Since the fault causes unbalanced
voltages at the PCC, the three line-to-line voltages have been
283
TABLE II
FUNDAMENTAL HARMONIC RMS VALUE AND VOLTAGE TOTAL HARMONIC
DISTORTION OF THE LINE-TO-LINE VOLTAGE AT THE PCC AND ACROSS
THE SENSITIVE LOAD FOR DIFFERENT INSTANTS
Fig. 12. Control outputs. (a) u . (b) u . (c) u . Corresponding to the interval
t < 0:28.
(s) 0:2
Fig. 13. Line-to-line voltage when the induction motor is connected. (a) At the
PC. (b) Across the sensitive load. Corresponding to the interval (s) 0:4 t <
0:65.
shown in Fig. 13, the DVR once again counteracts the voltage
sag and the low-frequency voltage harmonics, thus protecting
the sensitive load from these disturbances. The total harmonic
distortions for the voltages at the PCC and across the sensitive
load are 8.91% and 3.77%, respectively, while the fundamental
harmonic of the line-to-line voltage across the sensitive load has
an rms value of 400.17 V.
0.65 s, the nonlinear load is disconnected from
At
the system and only the motor and the sensitive load remain
connected. The results obtained show that, as expected, the
% and the
voltage at the PCC is sinusoidal
line-to-line voltage has an rms value of 370 V (92.5% of the
nominal value) due to the voltage drop in the line impedance.
The control system and the DVR once again work properly,
thus compensating the voltage drop in the sensitive load. The
fundamental harmonic of the sensitive-load voltage has an rms
value of 399.78 V and the total harmonic distortion is 3.17%.
The use of dynamic voltage restorers in PQ-related applications is increasing. The most popular application has been on
voltage sags amelioration but other voltage-squality phenomena
may also benefit from its use, provided that more robust control
schemes than the basic PI controller become available. A case
in point is the so called repetitive controller proposed in this
paper, which has a fast transient response and ensures zero error
in steady state for any sinusoidal reference input and for any
sinusoidal disturbance whose frequencies are an integer multiple of the fundamental frequency. To achieve this, the controller has been provided with a feedforward term and feedback
term. The design has been carried out by studying the stability
of the closed-loop system including possible modelling errors,
resulting in a controller which possesses very good transient and
steady-state performances for various kinds of disturbances.
A key feature of this control scheme is its simplicity; only
one controller is required to eliminate three PQ disturbances,
namely, voltage sags, harmonic voltages, and voltage imbalances. The controller can be implemented by using either a
stationary reference frame or a rotating reference frame. In
this paper, the highly developed graphical facilities available in
PSCAD/EMTDC have been used very effectively to carry out
all aspects of the system implementation. Comprehensive simulation results using a simple but realistic test system show that
the repetitive controller and the DVR yield excellent voltage
regulation, thus screening a sensitive load point from upstream
PQ disturbances.
REFERENCES
[1] M. H. J. Bollen, What is power quality?, Elect. Power Syst. Res., vol.
66, no. 1, pp. 514, July 2003.
284
Vicente Feliu (SM08) received the M.S. degree (Hons.) in industrial engineering and the Ph.D. degree from the Polytechnical University of Madrid,
Madrid, Spain, in 1979 and 1982, respectively.
He was with the Electrical Engineering Department, Universidad Nacional de
Educacin a Distancia, Madrid, Spain, from 1980 to 1994. He was Full Professor
in 1990 and was Head of the Department from 1991 to 1994. He is with the
School of Industrial Engineering, Universidad de Castilla-La Mancha, Ciudad
Real, Spain, and was a Fulbright Scholar at the Robotics Institute at Carnegie
Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, from 1987 to 1989. His research interests
include multivariable and digital control systems, and kinematic and dynamic
control of rigid and flexible robots.
Dr. Feliu is a member of the International Federation of Automatic Control
(IFAC).
Aurelio Garca-Cerrada (M91) received the M.Sc. degree from the Universidad Politcnica de Madrid, Madrid, Spain, in 1986 and the Ph.D. degree from
the University of Birmingham, Birmingham, U.K., in 1991.
Currently, he is a Professor with the Electronics and Control Engineering
Department and a member of the Applied Research Institute (IIT) at the Universidad Pontificia Comillas de Madrid. His research interests include power
systems and power-electronics control and its applications to electric energy
systems.