Location via proxy:   [ UP ]  
[Report a bug]   [Manage cookies]                
Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • 58 views

    Cost Effectiveness of Different Canal Lining Materials: Mr. Amrut Sangale, Dr. S. S. Valunjkar

    Uploaded by

    erpublication
    This document compares the cost effectiveness of different materials for canal lining. It discusses 10 different rigid lining systems including concrete, brick, stone masonry, and geomembranes. The key lining materials analyzed are cement concrete, stone masonry, and burnt clay tiles. Estimates for excavation, dressing, lining construction, and total costs per 100 meters are provided for each. Concrete lining has the lowest total and annual cost, while burnt clay tiles have the highest costs but shortest lifespan.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Cost Effectiveness of Different Canal Lining Materials: Mr. Amrut Sangale, Dr. S. S. Valunjkar

    Uploaded by

    erpublication
    58 views3 pages
    This document compares the cost effectiveness of different materials for canal lining. It discusses 10 different rigid lining systems including concrete, brick, stone masonry, and geomembranes. The key lining materials analyzed are cement concrete, stone masonry, and burnt clay tiles. Estimates for excavation, dressing, lining construction, and total costs per 100 meters are provided for each. Concrete lining has the lowest total and annual cost, while burnt clay tiles have the highest costs but shortest lifespan.

    Original Description:

    .

    Original Title

    IJETR032103

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    This document compares the cost effectiveness of different materials for canal lining. It discusses 10 different rigid lining systems including concrete, brick, stone masonry, and geomembranes. The key lining materials analyzed are cement concrete, stone masonry, and burnt clay tiles. Estimates for excavation, dressing, lining construction, and total costs per 100 meters are provided for each. Concrete lining has the lowest total and annual cost, while burnt clay tiles have the highest costs but shortest lifespan.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    58 views3 pages

    Cost Effectiveness of Different Canal Lining Materials: Mr. Amrut Sangale, Dr. S. S. Valunjkar

    Uploaded by

    erpublication
    This document compares the cost effectiveness of different materials for canal lining. It discusses 10 different rigid lining systems including concrete, brick, stone masonry, and geomembranes. The key lining materials analyzed are cement concrete, stone masonry, and burnt clay tiles. Estimates for excavation, dressing, lining construction, and total costs per 100 meters are provided for each. Concrete lining has the lowest total and annual cost, while burnt clay tiles have the highest costs but shortest lifespan.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Download as pdf or txt
    of 3

    International Journal of Engineering and Technical Research (IJETR)

    ISSN: 2321-0869, Volume-3, Issue-5, May 2015

    Cost Effectiveness of Different Canal Lining


    Materials
    Mr. Amrut Sangale, Dr. S. S. Valunjkar

    5. Cement concrete tile lining,


    AbstractThe purpose of this study is to produce a
    comparative study of irrigation canal lining by the use of 6. In situ cement /lime concrete lining,
    existing materials. This study reveals why irrigation canal lining 7. Stone masonry lining,
    and describes a number of various lining and there analysis.
    There are variable materials which are adopting concrete lining, 8. Soil cement lining,
    brick lining, stone masonry lining, and polyethylene film with
    concrete cover and geo membranes lining. However in our 9. Shotcrete lining
    country as per environmental condition mostly cement concrete
    10. Ferrocement lining.
    lining is popular. Cost of each lining is different than others
    b) Geomembrane lining
    Index Terms Reduce cost, cost comparison, saving in
    water, lining materials, lining cost, canal lining. High Density Polyethylene (HDPE), Polyvinyl Chloride
    (PVC), Low Density Polyethylene (LDPE) with cover
    I. INTRODUCTION comprising layer of betonies with adequate earth/burnt clay
    tile brick or pulverized fuel ash-lime brick or burnt clay fly
    The irrigation has been from the time immemorial and so
    ash building brick/precast cement concrete.
    has been building of irrigation canals, but is not only since last
    century that canals have been designed on more or less Functions of Lining
    scientific substructure. A canal may be rigid boundary or a
    The function of lining are:
    mobile boundary canal .Irrigation system should be built in
    such a way that they operate in maximum efficiency. The 1. Seepage control,
    efficiency of the conveyance and distribution system, that is
    2. Prevention of water logging,
    convey of water at minimum cost and with minimum seepage
    and evaporation loss, essentially affects the economy of an 3. Increased hydraulic efficiency,
    irrigation project. Now many irrigation project constructed in
    4. Increased resistance to erosion,
    Maharashtra, especially in West Maharashtra including
    Satara, Sangli, Kolhapupur, Pune. 5. Reduction in cross section area,
    The many canal constructed in this area are unlined canal,
    concrete canal, stone masonry canal. Design of canals are 6. Low operation and maintenance cost.
    being carried out in accordance with Circular No MIS 1094/ Fig. 1 shows the various linings used in India so far.
    (156/94) MP (A), dated 18-2-1995 by Irrigation Department,
    Government of Maharashtra. For this paper case study of
    concrete canal lining no-6 of Khatav canal, Urmodi Dam
    Division, Satara. Regional Schedule of Rates of Pune Region
    used for the estimation of canal lining.

    II. DIFFERENT CANAL LINING


    Lining Systems
    As per IS 10430:2000 CRITERIA FOR DESIGN OF
    LINED CANAKS AND GUIDANCE FOR CULL OF TYPE
    OF LINING following are different lining systems.
    a) Rigid Lining
    1. Stone pitched lining,
    2. Brick lining,
    3. Pulverized fuel ash-lime bricks lining,
    4. Precast cement concrete /stone slab lining, FIG. 1 LINING TYPES UTILIZED IN INDIA.

    Mr. Amrut Namdev Sangale, M.E.II (Civil - CM) Dept. Of Civil III. DESIGN & MEASUREMENT OF CANAL LINING
    Engineering, Government College of Engineering, Karad, Maharashtra,
    India, 9595964194.
    Dr. S. S. Valunjkar, Professor& Head of Dept. Of Civil Engineering, The basic parameter to design the canal is discharge, and as
    Government College of Engineering, Karad, Maharashtra, India. per case study the discharge is 20 cumecs.

    1 www.erpublication.org
    Cost Effectiveness of Different Canal Lining Materials

    As per Circular no. MIS 1094/ (156/94) Excavation of 4174.4 m3 (rate 51.45 Rs per m3) Cost =
    214772 Rs.
    Slope of ground is 1:5000
    Dressing of side slope area 1874 m2 (rate 1.85 Rs per m2)
    Side slope 1 V: 1.5 H
    Cost = 3467 Rs.
    B/d ratio 1.5 to 2
    Cost of 15 mm thick 1:3 CM = 301343 Rs.
    Assume that canal cross section is totally in cutting & strata
    Cost of 230 mm thick UCR = 459388
    is hard murum.
    As per RSR Pune 2013-14,
    A) Cement Concrete Lining
    Total design cost per 100 m = 978970 Rs.
    As per IS code3873:1993 design of C.C lining
    Velocity = 0.9 m/s,
    C)Brick /Burnt Clay Tiles Lining
    Area req. = (20/0.9) =22.22 m2
    Excavation of 3670 m3 (rate 51.45 Rs per m3) Cost =
    Provide, B = 4m,
    188841 Rs.
    d =3.65 m (with 0.9 m extra free board)
    Dressing of side slope area 1760.8 m2 (rate 1.85 Rs per m2)
    As per design provide 10 cm thick concrete bed & 8 cm Cost = 3257 Rs.
    side wall.
    Cost of 10 mm CM (1:5) = 156348 Rs.
    B) Stone Masonry Lining
    Cost of two 50mm thick brick coat = 394394 Rs.
    As per IS code 11809:1994 for Stone Masonry
    Cost of plaster (1:3) = 391175 Rs.
    Velocity = 0.8 m/s,
    As per RSR Pune 2013-14,
    Area raq. = 25 m2 ,
    Total design cost per 100 m = 993298 Rs.
    Provide B = 4.2 m,
    d = 3.80 m (with 0.9 m extra free board) V. RESULT AND DISCUSSION OF CANAL LINING
    Comparison of the three different comparing estimated
    As per design provide 0.23 m thick stone masonry with 15
    annual costs of types of lining cost show in the table 1.
    mm CM on prepared sub-grade.
    The following work illustrates calculate and compare
    C)Brick/ Burnt Clay Tile Lining annual costs and additionally in graphical form show in fig 2.
    As per IS code 9698:1995 design of C.C lining
    Table.1 Comparing Estimated Annual Cost of Lining
    Velocity = 0.9 m/s,
    Sr. Type of work Cost of Lined canal Per 100 m
    Area req. = (20/0.9) =22.22 m2 No
    .
    Provide, B = 4m, Cement Stone Burnt
    Concrete Masonry Clay Tile
    d =3.65 m (with 0.9 m extra free board) 1 Total cost 717579 978970 993298
    As per design provide 10 mm thick CM on sub-grade, then 2 Life 50 50 30
    provide two 50 mm thick coat of burnt clay tiles with 3 Salvage 179394 244742 148994
    separated by 15 mm sandwich plaster & 5 mm thick mortar. value
    4 T. D. D L. 538184 734227 844303
    IV ESTIMATION OF CANAL LINING
    5 10763 14684 28143
    A. D. C.
    Estimation is carried by using Regional Schedule of Rates
    (RSR) Pune region 2013-14. 6 A. I. C. 22424 30592 28557
    7 A. M. C. 4981 4843 8009
    A) Cement Concrete Lining 8 Total Annual 38168 50119 64709
    cost:5+6+7
    Excavation of 3958.56 m3 (rate 51.45 Rs per m3) Cost =
    200860.8
    Nomenclature:
    Dressing of side slope area 1835.14 m2 (rate 1.85 Rs per T. D. D. L. = Total depreciation during life,
    2
    m ) Cost = 3395 Rs. A. D. C. = Annual depreciating charge,
    A. I. C. = Annual interest charge,
    Cost Preparation of sub-grade = 40051.3 Rs.
    A. M. C. = Annual maintenance charge.
    Cost of M 15 concrete for bed & side lining =473272 Rs. B = Canal bed width.
    D = Total height including free board.
    As per RSR Pune 2013-14,
    Total design cost per 100 m = 717579.12 Rs. In this study concrete lining, stone masonry lining & burnt
    brick clay lining are commonly utilized in Maharashtra and
    B) Stone Masonry Lining

    2 www.erpublication.org
    International Journal of Engineering and Technical Research (IJETR)
    ISSN: 2321-0869, Volume-3, Issue-5, May 2015
    discussed fairly and a compression with deference to Maharashtra, India. One paper published on the topic Cost Effectiveness of
    Different Canal Lining Materials on IJERT.
    durability and economically.

    Dr. S. S. Valunjkar Professor& Head of Dept. Of Civil


    Engineering, Government College of Engineering, Karad, Maharashtra,
    India.

    Fig. 2 Comparison of Annual Cost

    VI. CONCLUSION

    In this study mainly fixate on the detail of construction cost of


    variant of lining and its durability. Compare cement concrete,
    Stone masonry and Burnt clay tile lining. According to
    analysis of this topic cement concrete lining is more felicitous
    then other two types of lining. Cost analysis of the topic
    cement concrete lining more cost efficacious then other types
    of lining method.

    ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
    I would relish to express my deep and sincere gratitude to
    my guide Dr. S. S. Valujkar Head of Department of Civil
    Engineering, for guiding me to accomplish this paper work. I
    am very thankful to Mr. Ruju Mulani, Asst. engineer at
    Urmodi Dam Division, Satara (Krishna Irrigation Project) for
    providing all the obligatory data to carry out my work.

    REFERANCES
    [1] M. El-Kady, h. Wahby, Lining of Egyptian Canals Techniques and
    Economic Analysis,April1984.
    [2] Pradeep Shau, The Use of Canal Lining Avilable Material And Its
    Comparative Study e-ISSN: 2278,p-ISSN: 2320-334X, Volume 11,
    Issue 3 Ver. . IV (May-June 2014).
    [3] Government of Maharashtra Irrigation Department circular No. MIS
    1094/(156/94) MP (A) Dated: 18-2-1995.
    [4] IS 3873: 1993, Laying Cement Concrete/ Stone Slab Lining Of
    Canal-Code Of Practice .
    [5] IS 3872:2002, Lining Of Canals With Burnt Clay Tiles- Code of
    Practice.
    [6] IS 11809;1994, Lining For Canals By Stone Masonry- Code of
    Practice.
    [7] Regional Schedule of Rates Pune Region (Under The Juridiction
    MKVDC) 2013-14.

    Mr. Amrut Namdev Sangale M.E.II (Civil - CM)


    Dept. Of Civil Engineering, Government College of Engineering, Karad,

    3 www.erpublication.org

    You might also like