Journal of Rehabilitation Sciences and Research: Journal Home Page: JRSR - Sums.ac - Ir
Journal of Rehabilitation Sciences and Research: Journal Home Page: JRSR - Sums.ac - Ir
Journal of Rehabilitation Sciences and Research: Journal Home Page: JRSR - Sums.ac - Ir
Original Article
Sara Abolahrari Shirazi1, Farahnaz Ghafari Nezhad1, Maryam Ebrahimian1, Elham Nouraddini2,
Azadeh Mansoorian2, Farahnaz Emami1*
1
Center for Human Motion Science Research, Department of Physiotherapy, School of Rehabilitation Sciences, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences,
Shiraz, Iran
2
Student Research Committee, School of Rehabilitation Sciences, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran
in muscle function lead to alterations in ground reaction were included in this research [24]. Another criterion
forces, the progression of degenerative changes and the comprised experiencing pain in the majority of the days
development of pain [10]. Patients with knee OA thus of the week during the 6 months prior to the study. All
have different gait kinematics and kinetics compared to participants provided their written informed consent.
asymptomatic persons [11, 12]. Alterations in gait include Those with any history of low back pain, unilateral
decreased knee excursion and different muscle activity knee OA, trauma to the knee joint, loss of joint play
patterns in lower extremity. Although these alterations in tibiofemoral and patellofemoral articulations, lower
may protect the knee joint from further degeneration they extremity fracture and surgery, neurological deficit or
have numerous adverse effects [13]. movement disorder, and those who were athletes or who
The knee consists of two joints [14]: the patellofemoral had been treated with physiotherapy during the previous
and tibiofemoral joint. The former can be involved in 6 months, were excluded from the study. Initially, age,
biomechanical problems in the young and physically active weight and height were recorded on a data collection form.
population [15, 16]. Various factors such as abnormal All measurements were obtained with a goniometer. The
lower limb biomechanics, insufficient flexibility and goniometry reliability for measuring the range of motion
quadriceps deficit may lead to patellofemoral dysfunction. in limb joints is considered good to excellent [25].
Previous studies have shown that the flexibility of muscles In the present study joint play in knee complex was
around the knee joint was decreased in patellofemoral evaluated at first. If the joint play is found to be normal,
pain syndrome (PFPS) and in athletes with anterior knee the limitation of range of motion is most likely due to
pain [7, 17, 18]. Pone et al. noted that in patients with PFPS, lack of flexibility [26].
decreased flexibility in the quadriceps was greater than To measure hamstring flexibility, passive knee extension
in healthy people [17]. Similar studies have documented tests were done in the supine position, as follows. The
decreased flexibility in the gastrocnemius [18], hamstring pelvis was immobilized, and the leg to be measured was
and quadriceps muscles in patients with PFPS compared positioned in 90-90 degree hip and knee flexion. Then one
to controls [7]. Research on the association between examiner extended the knee joint passively to the point
PFP and lower extremity biomechanics by Ohjeoung et where she felt resistance to movement. A second examiner
al. suggested that less flexibility in the hamstring was placed the center (fulcrum) of a universal goniometer
increased in patients with PFPS compared to healthy on the lateral femoral condyle with the stationary arm
controls [19]. of the goniometer aligned on the lateral malleolus and
In middle-aged and elderly people OA is a relatively the moving arm aligned with the greater trochanter,
common problem that can influence self-efficacy for and recorded the angle as shown in figure 1 [27-32]. All
physical tasks, and that is associated with a risk of falling. measurements performed by the same examiner.
Muscle flexibility is an important characteristic, which
deceases with age. The resulting lack of muscle flexibility
can lead to changes in joint function [20], and may be a
risk factor for injuries during activities that require a full
range of motion [21]. Knee OA-related stiffness can be
observed during walking in patients [22]. According to
Oatis et al., joint stiffness showed a moderate negative
correlation with stride length in patients with knee OA
[23]. Thereby performing regular stretching exercises
increase muscle flexibility, ROM and provide functional
benefits for patients with knee OA and may delay the need
for surgical interventions.
To the authors’ knowledge, no previous studies have
explored the flexibility of muscles around the knee joint Figure 1: The measurement of hamstring flexibility.
in patients with knee OA. We accordingly designed the
present study to compare the flexibility of muscles around To measure quadriceps flexibility the examiner flexed
the knee in patients with OA and healthy asymptomatic the knee joint passively in the prone position. The center
control participants. Our hypothesis was that the amount of of the goniometer was positioned on the femoral lateral
knee joint muscles flexibility in patients with knee OA was condyle with the stationary arm aligned on the thigh and
differs from healthy subjects. Also we hypothesized that the moving arm aligned on the tibia, and the angle was
the muscle flexibility would correlate with pain intensity. recorded after 90% (figure 2) [33, 34].
To measure adductor flexibility in the supine position,
Methods the non-test leg was immobilized at the midline and the
other leg was abducted passively until firm resistance
Twenty-three non-athlete women with OA and 23 was felt. The center of the goniometer was placed on
healthy women between 40 and 60 years of age were the anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS), and the moving
enrolled in this cross-sectional study. According to arm was positioned along the thigh midline while the
Kellgren and Lawrence grading system, each participant stationary arm was placed along the imaginary line
had grades 2 or 3 knee OA in bilateral tibiofemoral connecting the two ASIS (figure 3) [35].
Statistical Analysis
All statistical analyses were done with SPSS v. 16
software and P<0.05 was considered significant. The
normality of our data was examined by using Kolmogorov-
Smirnov. Independent t tests were used to compare
Figure 2: The measurement of quadriceps flexibility. muscle flexibility in patients with knee osteoarthritis
and controls, and Pearson’s correlation coefficient was
calculated to search for correlations between knee muscle
flexibility and pain intensity.
Results
JRSR. 2015;2(3) 49
Abolahrari Shirazi S et al.
Table 1: Baseline characteristics of the women who participated in the patient and control groups
Group Patient (n=23) Healthy (n=23) P value
Variable Mean±SD Mean±SD
Age (years) 3.89±49.6 5.71±48.72 0.590
Weight (kg) 11.07±68.52 8.9±68.04 0.873
Height (cm) 6.23±1.58 6.56±1.61 0.265
Table 2: Comparison of muscle flexibility in patients with knee osteoarthritis and controls
Group Patient Healthy P. value
Muscle Flexibility (degrees) SD±Mean SD±Mean
RT Hamstring 13.83±69.04 13.75±69.6 0.890
LT Hamstring 12.08±69.34 13.71±68.26 0.777
RT Quadriceps 13.14± 26.52 8.97±39.73 0.001*
LT Quadriceps 12.05±27.13 7.64±36.17 0.004*
RT Iliotibial band 7.28±17.47 8.4±20.65 0.120
LT Iliotibial band 6.18 ±17.17 9.07±18.00 0.720
RT Adductor 7.92±32.30 12.31±34.86 0.405
LT Adductor 6.46±28.95 9.96±33.26 0.089
RT Gastrocnemius 9.22 ±35.08 10.93±31.95 0.300
LT Gastrocnemius 8.24 ±30.73 10.39±30.86 0.963
RT, Right; LT, Left, *P. value<0.05
Table 3: Correlation between flexibility of muscles around the knee joint and pain intensity
Correlation r P. value
VAS (cm) × RT Hamstring (P) -0.017 0.911
VAS (cm) × LT Hamstring (P) 0.020 0.894
VAS (cm) × RT Quadriceps (P) -0.458 0.001*
VAS (cm) × LT Quadriceps (P) -0.461 0.001*
VAS (cm) × RT Ilitibial band (P) -0.046 0.759
VAS ( cm) × LT Iliotibial band (P) -0.003 0.986
VAS (cm) × RT Adductor (P) -0.258 0.084
VAS ( cm) × LT Adductor (P) -0.314 0.033*
VAS (cm) × RT Gastrocnemius (P) 0.085 0.575
VAS ( cm) × LT Gastrocnemius (P) -0.054 0.719
RT, Right; LT, Left; VAS, Visual analog scale; *P. value<0.05
words, quadriceps flexibility was lower in patients with ability to voluntary activation of quadriceps impaired
more intense perceived pain. One possible explanation in individuals with knee OA. Muscle activation failure
is that to prevent pain, the patients flex their knee joint can result in abnormal articular afferent inputs being
less than 100 degrees and this behavior leads to a decline sent to α.motor neurons and this may occur due to joint
in quadriceps flexibility, patella alta and recurrent pain degeneration [43].
– all of which create a vicious cycle [41]. In contrast to Our results for iliotibial band flexibility showed no
our results, some researchers have found a relationship significant differences between the two groups. We are
between hamstring tightness and pain in adolescent aware of no previous studies of iliotibial band flexibility
athletes with anterior knee pain [7]. A possible explanation in patients with knee OA. One earlier study found no
for these different findings is that the participants in the differences in flexibility between patients with PFPS and
study by Smith et al. were young athletes with anterior healthy individuals [18]. However, Hudson et al. reported
knee pain due to jumper’s knee, Osgood Schlatter disease, decreased iliotibial band flexibility in these patients [44].
patellofemoral pain or combinations of these whereas We believe this difference with our results may exist
the participants in the present study were middle-aged because all participants in our study had knee OA.
women with tibiofemoral joint OA. Therefore the pattern According to comprehensive approach in dysfunction of
of muscle tightness in athletes and patients with knee OA lumbopelvic-hip, shortening of iliotibial band trends to
may be dissimilar. occur in low back pain patients and necessarily not be
We found no significant differences between groups seen in all of patients with knee OA [45].
in hamstring, iliotibial band, gastrocnemius or adductor Our patients with knee OA did not differ significantly
muscle flexibility. One probable reason is that all from asymptomatic controls in hamstring muscle
participants in both groups were non-athletes and middle– flexibility. A previous study, however, noted that hamstring
aged and therefore probably experienced a similar trend tightness may be one of the contributing factors to PFPS
toward loss of contractile function and flexibility [20, 42]. [27]. The discrepancy between our results and those
Another hypothesis is that the central nervous system’ reported by White et al. may be attributed to differences
in the age ranges of the participants, and differences in 12. Conroy MB, Kwoh CK, Krishnan E, Nevitt MC, Boudreau R,
the pathological mechanisms and differences in gender in Carbone LD, et al. Muscle strength, mass, and quality in older men
and women with knee osteoarthritis. Arthritis care & research.
these two studies. Unlike previous study, the participants 2012;64(1):15-21.
in the present research were women aged 40-60 years and 13. Childs JD, Sparto PJ, Fitzgerald GK, Bizzini M, Irrgang JJ.
had tibiofemoral OA. Alterations in lower extremity movement and muscle activation
A few limitations of this study should be taken into patterns in individuals with knee osteoarthritis. Clinical
biomechanics. 2004;19(1):44-9.
account. First, the participants in this study were women 14. Goldblatt JP, Richmond JC. Anatomy and biomechanics of the
aged 40 and 60 years, so we cannot generalize our results knee. Operative Techniques in Sports Medicine. 2003;11(3):172-86.
to other age groups. We suggest further research in larger 15. Pappas E, Wong-Tom WM. Prospective Predictors of
groups including both genders. A second limitation is that Patellofemoral Pain Syndrome A Systematic Review With
Meta-analysis. Sports Health: A Multidisciplinary Approach.
all goniometric readings were made and recorded by the 2012;4(2):115-20.
same examiners, neither of whom was blinded. 16. Barrios JA, Crenshaw JR, Royer TD, Davis IS. Walking shoes and
laterally wedged orthoses in the clinical management of medial
Conclusion tibiofemoral osteoarthritis: a one-year prospective controlled
trial. The Knee. 2009;16(2):136-42.
17. Pons M, Pasarin A, Garcia J, Viladot B. The role of quadriceps
Quadriceps muscle flexibility was reduced in women tightness in patients with patellar symptoms. Journal of Bone &
with knee OA. Treatments should be designed to take Joint Surgery, British Volume. 2006;88(SUPP I):104
into account the association between pain intensity and 18. Piva SR, Goodnite EA, Childs JD. Strength around the hip
and flexibility of soft tissues in individuals with and without
quadriceps tightness as well as muscle flexibility. patellofemoral pain syndrome. Journal of orthopaedic & sports
physical therapy. 2005;35(12):793-801.
Acknowledgements 19. Kwon O, Yun M, Lee W. Correlation between intrinsic
patellofemoral pain syndrome in young adults and lower extremity
biomechanics. Journal of physical therapy science. 2014;26(7):961.
This study is based on the work done for the thesis by 20. Muyor JM, López-Miñarro PA, Casimiro AJ. Effect of stretching
Elham Nouraddini and Azadeh Mansoorian, both of program in an industrial workplace on hamstring flexibility and
whom were supported by Shiraz University of Medical sagittal spinal posture of adult women workers: a randomized
Sciences, Shiraz, Iran. We thank K. Shashok (AuthorAID controlled trial. Journal of back and musculoskeletal rehabilitation.
2012;25(3):161.
in the Eastern Mediterranean) for improving the use of 21. Mandeep Kaur RP, Sandeep Kumar,Reena Arora, Lalit Arora.
English in the manuscript. A Randomized Controll Trial to Copmared the effectiveness of
static stretching versus PNF streching of Hamstring Muscles
Conflict of Interest: None declared. Following superficial Heat in Athletes. International Journal of
Scientific and Research Publications. 2014;4(7):1-4.
22. Dixon SJ, Hinman RS, Creaby MW, Kemp G, Crossley KM. Knee
References joint stiffness during walking in knee osteoarthritis. Arthritis
care & research. 2010;62(1):38-44.
1. Pollard H, Ward G, Hoskins W, Hardy K. The effect of a manual 23. Oatis CA, Wolff EF, Lockard MA, Michener LA, Robbins SJ.
therapy knee protocol on osteoarthritic knee pain: a randomised Correlations among measures of knee stiffness, gait performance
controlled trial. The Journal of the Canadian Chiropractic and complaints in individuals with knee osteoarthritis. Clinical
Association. 2008;52(4):229. Biomechanics. 2013;28(3):306-11.
2. Bruyère O, Ethgen O, Neuprez A, Zégels B, Gillet P, Huskin 24. Petersson IF, Boegård T, Saxne T, Silman AJ, Svensson B.
J-P, et al. Health-related quality of life after total knee or hip Radiographic osteoarthritis of the knee classified by the Ahlbäck
replacement for osteoarthritis: a 7-year prospective study. and Kellgren & Lawrence systems for the tibiofemoral joint in
Archives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery. 2012;132(11):1583-7. people aged 35–54 years with chronic knee pain. Annals of the
3. McCarthy C, Dieppe P. Taping the patella medially: a new treatment rheumatic diseases. 1997;56(8):493-6.
for osteoarthritis of the knee joint? Bmj. 1994;308(6931):753-5. 25. Sacco I, Alibert S, Queiroz B, Pripas D, Kieling I, Kimura A, et
4. Deyle GD, Henderson NE, Matekel RL, Ryder MG, Garber al. Reliability of photogrammetry in relation to goniometry for
MB, Allison SC. Effectiveness of manual physical therapy and postural lower limb assessment. Brazilian Journal of Physical
exercise in osteoarthritis of the knee: a randomized, controlled Therapy. 2012;11(5):411-7.
trial. Annals of internal medicine. 2000;132(3):173-81. 26. Colby LA, Kisner C. Therapeutic Exercise: Foundations and
5. Zhang Y, Jordan JM. Epidemiology of osteoarthritis. Clinics in Techniques: 6 th ed . Phyladelphyia Lippincott. FA Davis
geriatric medicine. 2010;26(3):355-69. Company; 2007.335-336
6. Kaur M, Paul R, Kumar S, Arora R, Arora L. A Randomized 27. White LC, Dolphin P, Dixon J. Hamstring length in patellofemoral
Controlled Trial to Compare the Effectiveness of Static Stretching pain syndrome. Physiotherapy. 2009;95(1):24-8.
Versus PNF Stretching of Hamstring Muscles Following 28. Engebretsen AH, Myklebust G, Holme I, Engebretsen L, Bahr R.
Superficial Heat in Athletes.2014;7(4);1-4. Intrinsic Risk Factors for Hamstring Injuries Among Male Soccer
7. Smith AD, Stroud L, McQueen C. Flexibility and anterior knee Players A Prospective Cohort Study. The American Journal of
pain in adolescent elite figure skaters. Journal of Pediatric Sports Medicine. 2010;38(6):1147-53.
Orthopaedics. 1991;11(1):77-82. 29. O’Hora J, Cartwright A, Wade CD, Hough AD, Shum GL. Efficacy
8. Page P, Frank C, Lardner R. Assessment and treatment of muscle of static stretching and proprioceptive neuromuscular facilitation
imbalance: the Janda approach: Human Kinetics; 2010: 43-44. stretch on hamstrings length after a single session. The Journal of
9. Hollinger H. The Effect of Stretching and Strengthening on Strength & Conditioning Research. 2011;25(6):1586-91.
Patellofemoral Pain Syndrome. 2014. [Thesis] 30. Papadopoulos K, Noyes J, Jones JG, Thom JM, Stasinopoulos
10. Bennell KL, Hunt MA, Wrigley TV, Lim B-W, Hinman RS. Role D. Clinical tests for differentiating between patients with and
of muscle in the genesis and management of knee osteoarthritis. without patellofemoral pain syndrome. Hong Kong Physiotherapy
Rheumatic Disease Clinics of North America. 2008;34(3):731-54. Journal. 2014;32(1):35-43.
11. Gardner JK, Zhang S, Liu H, Klipple G, Stewart C, Milner CE, 31. Herrington L. The effect of pelvic position on popliteal angle
et al. Effects of toe-in angles on knee biomechanics in cycling of achieved during 90: 90 hamstring length test. J Sport Rehab.
patients with medial knee osteoarthritis. Clinical Biomechanics. 2013;22:254-6.
2015;30(3):276-82. 32. Forman J, Geertsen L, Rogers ME. Effect of deep stripping
JRSR. 2015;2(3) 51
Abolahrari Shirazi S et al.
massage alone or with eccentric resistance on hamstring length Cerulli G. Clinical classification of patellofemoral pain syndrome:
and strength. Journal of bodywork and movement therapies. guidelines for non-operative treatment. Knee Surgery, Sports
2014;18(1):139-44. Traumatology, Arthroscopy. 2005;13(2):122-30.
33. Janda V. Muscle function testing: Elsevier; UK:Butterworths. 40. Waryasz GR, McDermott AY. Patellofemoral pain syndrome
Elsevie.r;2013. (PFPS): a systematic review of anatomy and potential risk factors.
34. Nakase J, Aiba T, Goshima K, Takahashi R, Toratani T, Kosaka Dynamic medicine. 2008;7(1):9.
M, et al. Relationship between the skeletal maturation of the 41. Hertling D, Kessler RM. Management of common musculoskeletal
distal attachment of the patellar tendon and physical features disorders: physical therapy principles and methods: 4th ed.
in preadolescent male football players. Knee surgery, sports Philadelphia Lippincott .Williams & Wilkins; 2006.525-526.
traumatology, arthroscopy. 2014;22(1):195-9. 42. Balagopal P, Rooyackers OE, Adey DB, Ades PA, Nair KS.
35. Reese NB, Bandy WD. Joint range of motion and muscle length Effects of aging on in vivo synthesis of skeletal muscle myosin
testing: Elsevier Health Sciences; 2013.573-574. heavy-chain and sarcoplasmic protein in humans. American
36. Reid D, Burnham R, Saboe L, Kushner S. Lower extremity Journal of Physiology-Endocrinology And Metabolism.
flexibility patterns in classical ballet dancers and their correlation 1997;273(4):E790-E800.
to lateral hip and knee injuries. The American journal of sports 43. Lewek MD, Rudolph KS, Snyder-Mackler L. Quadriceps
medicine. 1987;15(4):347-52. femoris muscle weakness and activation failure in patients
37. Halabchi F, Mazaheri R, Seif-Barghi T. Patellofemoral pain with symptomatic knee osteoarthritis. Journal of Orthopaedic
syndrome and modifiable intrinsic risk factors; how to assess Research. 2004;22(1):110-5.
and address? Asian journal of sports medicine. 2013;4(2):85. 44. Hudson Z, Darthuy E. Iliotibial band tightness and patellofemoral
38. Arab AM, Nourbakhsh MR. The relationship between hip abductor pain syndrome: a case-control study. Manual therapy.
muscle strength and iliotibial band tightness in individuals with 2009;14(2):147-51.
low back pain. Chiropractic & osteopathy. 2010;18(1):1. 45. W.W.W Postural Restoration Institute.
39. Witvrouw E, Werner S, Mikkelsen C, Van Tiggelen D, Berghe LV,