I. Gross Estate Vis-À-Vis Net Estate
I. Gross Estate Vis-À-Vis Net Estate
I. Gross Estate Vis-À-Vis Net Estate
Gross Estate vis-à-vis Net Estate intangible personal property of citizens of the
Gross Estate Philippines not residing in that foreign country; or
- Total value of all property, real or personal, tangible or intangible, the o Partial Exemption
actual and beneficial ownership of which was in the decedent at the § The laws of the foreign country of which the decedent
time of his death was a resident citizen at the time of his death allow a
similar exemption from estate tax, in respect of
Net Estate intangible property owned by citizens of the
- Value of the estate after all the deductions have been made against Philippines not residing in that foreign country
the gross estate;
Intangible Asset
Main distinction: Gross estate is the totality of all the properties in which the - Identifiable nonmonetary asset without physical substance
decedent had an interest existing at the time of his death while net estate is - Rule: situs of intangible personal property is the domicile of the owner
what remains after subtracting from the gross estate the allowable deductions. (Mobilia Sequntur Personam)
Gross estate is not subject to tax while the net estate is the basis for imposing o Not applicable if the intangible property has acquired a
the estate tax. business situs in another jurisdiction
o Should not be based on the domicile of the owner but the
II. Determination of Gross and Net Estate place where such franchise is exercised
Value of the Gross Estate - Within the Philippines:
- Including all the value at the time of his death of all property, real or o Franchise which must be exercised in the Philippines
personal, tangible or intangible, wherever situated o Shares, obligations or bonds issued by any corporation or
- In case of a nonresident: If at the time of his death was not a citizen of sociedad anonima organized or constituted in the Philippines
the Philippines, only that part of the gross estate which is situated in in accordance with its laws
the Philippines shall be included in his taxable estate o Shares, obligations or bonds issued by any foreign corporation,
85% if the business of which is located in the Philippines
o Shares, obligations or bonds issued by any foreign corporation
Composition of Gross Estate
if such shares, obligations or bonds have acquired a business
Decedent Gross Estate
situs in the Philippines
• Citizen 1. Property (Real or Personal)
o Shares or rights in any partnership, business or industry
• Resident Alien wherever situated
established in the Philippines
2. Intangible personal
property wherever situated
Situs of Tangible and Intangible Property
• Nonresident Alien 1. Real property situated in the
Property Situs
Philippines
• Real Property and Tangible Location of the property
2. Tangible personal property
Personal Property
situated in the Philippines
• Shares, franchise, copyright Where the intangible property is
3. Intangible personal
exercised regardless of where the
property with situs in the
corresponding certificate is stored
Philippines, unless excluded
on the basis of reciprocity • Receivables Residence of the debtor
• Bank Deposits Location of the depositary bank
Reciprocity Clause
- Excludes “intangible” personal property with situs in the Philippines Valuation of Gross Estate
from the gross estate of a non-resident alien decedent if there’s - Since succession and accrual of the corresponding estate tax takes
reciprocity effect upon the death, it shall only be fair to appraise the estate at its
- There’s reciprocity if: fair market value at the time of the decedent’s death
o Total Exemption
§ The decedent at the time of his death was a resident • In General Fair Market Value at the time of
citizen of a foreign country which at the time of his death
death did not impose an estate tax in respect of • Real Property Higher between;
- FMV determined by the o Thought of death is the controlling motive which induces the
Commissioner; and disposition of property for the purpose of avoiding the tax
- FMV as shown in the o Included within this concept is donation mortis causa
schedule of values fixed by o Include in the gross estate the value of property transferred by
the provincial and city the decedent during his lifetime in anticipation of his death
assessors such as:
• Personal Property Fair Market Value at the time of i. Transfer of property in favor of another person, but the
death transfer was intended to take effect only upon the
• Shares of Stock Unlisted Common Share transferor’s death
- Book Value Per Share of the ii. Transfer by gift intended to take effect at death, or
issuing corporation after death or under which the donor reserved the
Unlisted Preference Share income or the right to designate the persons who
- Par Value Per Share should enjoy the income
Listed Share o There’s no transfer in contemplation of death when the
- FMV shall be the average transfer of property is a bona fide sale for an adequate and full
between the highest and consideration in money or money’s worth
lowest quotation at the date o It is not the mere transfer that constitutes a transfer in
nearest the date of death, if contemplation of death but the retention of some type of
none is available on the date control over the property transferred
of death itself o Five instances which constitutes transfer in contemplation of
• Units of participation in any The bid price nearest the date of death according to Prof. Thomas Matic
association, recreation or death published in any newspaper § Secondary Life Estate – Retention by the grantor for
amusement club or publication for general circulation life of the right to enjoy the income or the fruits of the
• Right to usufruct, use or In accordance with the latest Basic property transferred in trust constitute what is called
habitation and annuity Standard Mortality Table taking into reservation of a primary life estate. There is no
account the probable life of the question in this case that the property would be
beneficiary, to be approved by the included in the gross estate of the grantor upon his
Secretary of Finance upon death.
recommendation of the Insurance § Interests Analogous to Life Estates – where the
Commissioner decedent had transferred certain shares of stock to
his daughter “subject to your giving me the first
III. Items to be Included in the Gross Estate dividends on these P15,000,” and part of the P15,000
was still unpaid when the decedent died, it was held
A. Property owned by the decedent ACTUALLY AND PHYSICALLY
that the entire value of the securities was properly
PRESENT IN HIS ESTATE at the time of his death
included in the decedent’s gross estate since he had
B. Decedent’s Interest
retained the income for a period which did not in fact
o Refers to the extent of equity or ownership participation of the
end before his death.
decedent on any property physically existing and present in
§ Discharging Legal obligation to transferor – a transfer
the gross estate, whether or not in his possession, control or
with the right retained to have the income used to
dominion.
discharge a legal obligation of the transferor or
o Also refers to the value of any interest in property owned or
otherwise for his pecuniary benefit is equivalent to a
possessed by the decedent at the time of his death (interest
reservation of the right to the income. Thus, where a
having value or capable of being valued or transferred)
man created a trust with the provision that the
C. Property NOT PHYSICALLY IN THE ESTATE (these have already income should be paid to his life for her “support and
been transferred during the lifetime of the decedent but are still maintenance”, remainder to their children, it was held
subject to payment of estate tax) that the property was includible in his gross estate.
But there is no inclusion required if the grantor’s
1.) Transfer in contemplation of death dependent is free to use the income for any purpose
o Disposition of property prompted by the thought of death without restriction, the reason being that inclusion is
required only where the transfer relieves the grantor § The existence of the desire by the decedent of
of his duty to support. avoiding estate taxes by means of making inter vivos
§ Right Retained Alone or with another to designate transfers of property (Estate of Oliver Johnson v.
who shall enjoy property or income therefrom – The Commissioner, 10 T.C. 680)
situation contemplated here usually occurs when the § Concurrent making of will or making a will within a
settlor or grantor designates himself as trustee or co- short time after the transfer (Roces v. Posadas, 58 Phil.
trustee with another. 108).
§ Retention of Power to distribute or accumulate trust
income – where the grantor, either alone as trustee or 2.) Transfer with retention or reservation of certain rights
as co-trustee with others, reserved the power to o Decedent transferred his property during his lifetime, but
accumulate or distribute income and exercised such retained for himself beneficial employment of the thing or the
power by accumulating and adding income to right to receive income from the same
principal and this power he held until the moment of o Doesn’t convey full ownership
his death with respect to both the original principal
as well as the accumulated income, this requires the 3.) Revocable transfers
inclusion in the decedent settlor’s gross estate. o Transfer whereby the terms of enjoyment of the property may
o Motives which negate transfer in contemplation of death be altered, amended, revoked or terminated by:
§ To relieve the donor from the burden of § Decedent alone;
management; § By the decedent in conjunction with any other person
§ To save income taxes or property taxes; without regard to when or from what source the
§ To settle family litigated and unlitigated disputes; decedent acquired such power to alter, amend,
§ To provide independent income for dependents; revoke or terminate; or
§ To see the children enjoy the property while while § Where any such power is relinquished in
the donor is alive; contemplation of the decedent’s death other than a
§ To protect family from hazards of business bona fide sale for an adequate and full consideration
operations; in money or money’s worth.
§ To reward services rendered. o The power to alter, amend or revoke shall be considered to
o Circumstances to be taken into account in determining exist on the date of decedent’s death even though:
whether the transfer is one in contemplation of death § The exercise of the power is subject to a precedent
§ Age of the decedent at the time the transfers were giving of notice; or
made § The alteration, amendment or revocation takes effect
§ Decedent’s health, as he knew it at or before the time only on the expiration of a stated period for the
of the transfers exercise of the power, whether or not on or before the
§ The interval between the transfers and the decedent’s date of the decedent’s death
death • Notice has been given
§ The amount of property transferred in proportion to • The power has been exercised.
the amount of property retained o Revocable transfer is part of the gross estate because the
§ The nature and disposition of the decedent transferor can revoke the transfer any time
§ The existence of a general testamentary scheme of o It is sufficient that the decedent had the power to revoke
which the transfers were a part though he did not exercise the power
§ The relationship of the donee(s) to the decedent o Transfer not revocable, thereby not subject to estate tax when:
§ The existence of a desire on the part of the decedent § The decedent’s power could only be exercised with
to escape the burden of managing property by the consent of all parties having an interest in the
transferring the property to others transferred property and if the power adds nothing to
§ The existence of a long established gift-making policy the rights the parties possess under local law (Lober v.
on the part of the decedent United States, 346 US 335).
§ The existence of a desire on the part of the decedent § When the decedent has been completely divested of
to vicariously enjoy the enjoyment of the donees for the power at the time of his death (ibid.)
the property transferred
§ Where the exercise of the power by the decedent was • The possession, enjoyment or right to income
subject to a contingency beyond the decedent’s from the property; or
control which did not occur before his death (Hurd v. • The right to designate the person who will
Commissioner 160F(2)610). possess or enjoy the property or income
§ The mere right to name trustees. Neither is the therefrom (Sec. 85[D], NIRC).
grantor’s limited power to appoint himself as trustee
under conditions which did not exist at his death (24 5.) Transfer for insufficient consideration
Am Jur. 2d, p 790). o When a sale or transfer was made for a price less than its fair
market value at the time of sale or transfer, the excess of the
4.) Transfers under a general power of appointment fair market value of the transferred property at the time of
o Power of appointment refers to the right to designate the death over the consideration received should be included in
person who will succeed to the property of the prior decedent. the gross estate
o Appointment could be in favor of anybody, including himself, o This is applicable to:
his estate, his creditors, or the creditors of his estate § Transfers in contemplation of death
§ Revocable transfers
General Power of Special Power of § Transfers under general power of appointment
Appointment Appointment o It is also subject to Donor’s Tax if there is no reference to:
As to Nature Donee has the power to Donee appoints the § Revocable transfer
appoint any person he successor to the § Contemplation of death
chooses or enjoy the property who is within a § General power of appointment
property without restriction limited group or class of o Fair Market Values:
person according to the § FMV of the property at the time of sale or transfer
will of the Donor • Determine whether or not the consideration
was full and adequate
• If the consideration received is substantially
As to tax Makes appointed property, Not includable in the the same with the fair market value at the
implications for all intents, the property of gross estate of the done time of transfer, hence not subject to estate
the done; thus, forms part of when he dies tax
the gross estate of the donee § FMV of the property at the time of death
• Used to determine the amount to be
included in the gross estate
• If the consideration received is substantially
As to effects Donee holds the appointed Donee holds the lower or for less than full and adequate
property with all the appointed property in consideration compared to the fair market
attributes of ownership trust value at the time of sale or transfer
o If there was no consideration received at the date of transfer
and such transfer was made “in contemplation of date,” the
fair market value of the property at the date of death, not at
o Properties passing under a GPA is includible as part of a the date of transfer, should be included in the gross estate of
decedent’s estate through the decedent
§ Will o If there was no consideration received at the date of transfer
§ Deed executed in contemplation of death, or and such transfer was not made “in contemplation of death,”
intended to take effect in possession or enjoyment at, such transfer shall be considered inter-vivos subject to donors’
or after his death tax based on the fair market value at the date the donation
§ Deed under which he has retained for his life or for was made
any period not ascertainable without reference to his
death or for any period which does not in fact end Rules on insufficient consideration
before his death: Consideration >/= FMV at the time Bona fide sale; excluded from
of transfer gross estate
Consideration < FMV at the time Insufficient consideration. § Proceeds of a group insurance policy taken out by a
of transfer Include in the gross estate at company for its employees;
the excess of FMV @ the time of § Proceeds of insurance policies issued by the GSIS to
death over the consideration government officials and employees are exempt
received. from all taxes;
Sale was made in the ordinary Bona fide sale regardless of the § Benefits accruing from SSS law;
course of trade amount of consideration § Proceeds of life insurance payable to heirs of
No consideration received Either donation mortis causa deceased members of military personnel.
(subject to estate tax) or
donation inter-vivos (subject to Proceeds of Life Insurance (Taken out by the Decedent)
donor’s tax) Beneficiary Designation Gross Estate
Estate Revocable or Included
6.) Claims against insolvent persons Irrevocable
o Insolvent = properties are not sufficient to satisfy, whether fully Executor Revocable or Included
or partially, his debts Irrevocable
o Judicial declaration of insolvency is not required but the Administrator Revocable or Included
incapacity of the debtor to pay should be proven Irrevocable
o Full amount of the claim should be included in the gross 3rd Party (i.e. wife) Revocable Included
estate 3rd Party (i.e. wife) Irrevocable Not Included
o Portion of the claim which is not collectible should be allowed
as deduction
§ (Assets/Liabilities) x Claim = Collectible o To determine the conjugal or separate character of proceeds,
§ Claim – Collectible = Uncollectible (deductible) the following factors are considered:
§ Policy taken before marriage – Source of funds
7.) Proceeds of life insurance determines ownership of the proceeds of life
o Part of the gross estate to the extent of the amount receivable insurance
when the beneficiary in a life insurance is: § Policy taken during marriage
§ The estate of the decedent, his executor or • Beneficiary is estate of the insured –
administrator taken out by the decedent upon his Proceeds are presumed conjugal; hence,
own life regardless of whether the designation is one-half share of the surviving spouse is not
revocable or irrevocable; OR taxable
§ A third person, other than the decedent’s estate, • Beneficiary is third person – Proceeds are
executor, or administrator provided that the payable to beneficiary even in premiums
designation is not revocable were paid out of the conjugal
o In the absence of an express designation, the presumption is
that the beneficiary is revocable designated. In the event the 8.) Prior Interest
insured does not change the beneficiary during his lifetime, o All transfers, trusts, estates, interests, rights, powers and
the designation shall be deemed irrevocable relinquishment of powers made, created, arising existing,
o Not part of the gross estate when: exercised or relinquished before or after the effectivity of the
§ Proceeds from a life insurance policy is receivable by NIRC
a 3rd person (NOT the decedent’s estate, executor or o Coverage of prior interest
administrator) AND that the said beneficiary is § Transfers in contemplation of death
designated as irrevocable; § Revocable transfers
§ Where the life insurance was not taken by the § Life insurance proceeds to the extent of the amount
decedent upon his own life even though the receivable by the estate of the deceased, executor or
beneficiary is the decedent’s estate, executor, or administrator under policies taken out by the
administrator; decedent upon his own life or to the extent of the
§ Accident insurance proceeds. NIRC specifically amount receivable by any beneficiary not expressly
mentions only life insurance policies; designated as irrevocable
Vanishing Deductions - Standard deduction of
- Share of the surviving spouse is not included in the gross estate; it is 500,000 is now allowed
actually a deduction from the gross estate II. Special Deductions
- Capital = property brought by the husband to the marriage - Standard Deduction III. Share of the Surviving
- Paraphernal = property brought by the wife to the marriage - Family Home Spouse
- RA 4917 (Retirement
IV. Deductions from the Gross Estate Benefits)
- Deductions from the gross estate are classified as ordinary and
special deductions III. Share of the Surviving
Spouse
Allowable Deductions (Prior to TRAIN)
Citizens and Resident Decedents Nonresident Alien Decedents Ordinary Deductions
I. Ordinary Deductions I. Ordinary Deductions A. ELITe (Expenses, Losses, Indebtedness, Taxes, etc.)
Expenses, Losses, Indebtedness, Proportionate Deductions for 1.) Funeral Expenses
Taxes, etc. (ELIT) Expenses, Losses, Indebtedness, o Repealed by TRAIN
- Funeral Expenses Taxes, etc. (ELIT) computed as o Whether paid or unpaid from the date of death up to date of
- Judicial Expenses follows: interment
- Losses - (Gross Estate Phils./Gross o The amount deductible is the lower between:
- Indebtedness/Claims Estate World) x ELIT world § Actual funeral expenses (paid or unpaid); or
against the estate/Mortgage Transfer for Public Use § 5% of the gross estate
payable Vanishing Deductions **But not exceeding 200,000
- Taxes o Any amount in excess of 200,000 are not deductible
- Claims against Insolvent II. Special Deductions § Neither shall the unpaid portion in excess of
Person - Not allowed 200,000 be allowed as deduction under “claims
Transfer for Public Use against the estate”
Vanishing Deduction III. Share of the Survivng o Supporting receipts or invoices
Spouse o Nonresidents:
II. Special Deductions § Lower between:
- Standard Deduction • (Phil GE/World GE) x F.E. World
- Family Home • 5% x Phil GE
- Medical Expenses o Funeral Expenses include:
- RA 4917 (Retirement § Mourning apparel of the surviving spouse and
Benefits) unmarried minor children of the deceased, bought
and used in the occasion of the burial;
III. Share of the Surviving § Expenses of the wake preceding the burial including
Spouse food and drinks;
§ Publication charges for death notices;
Allowable Deductions (TRAIN) § Telecommunication expenses in informing relatives
Citizen and Resident Decedents Nonresident Alien Decedents of the deceased;
I. Ordinary Deductions I. Ordinary Deductions § Cost of burial plot, tombstone monument or
Expenses, Losses, Indebtedness, Losses, Indebtedness, Taxes, claims mausoleum but not their upkeep. In case deceased
Taxes, etc. (ELIT) against insolvent persons owns a family estate or several burial lots, only the
- Losses - (Gross Estate Phils./Gross value corresponding to the plot where he is buried is
- Indebtedness/Claims Estate World) x LIT world deductible;
against the estate Transfer for Public Use § Interment and/or cremation fees and charges;
- Taxes Vanishing Deductions § All other expenses incurred for the performance of
- Claims against insolvent the ritual and ceremonies incident to the interment.
persons II. Special Deductions o Expenses incurred after the interment are not deductible
Transfer for Public Use o If borne by relatives and friends = Not deductible
o Medical expenses as of the last illness will not form part of § Attorney’s fees incident to litigation incurred by the
funeral expense but should be claimed as Medical Expenses heirs in asserting their respective rights (ibid).
Classification of Donation
- As to motive or purpose
o Simple
§ Pure liberality
o Renumeratory
§ Due to past services rendered or future services or
charges or burdens
§ Not really donations in substance
§ Not gratuitous – Not subject to donor’s tax
o Modal
§ Consideration is less than the value of the thing
donated
- As to time of taking effect (Perfection)
o Donation inter-vivos
o Donation mortis-causa