The Zero-Dimensional Model of The Scavenging Process in The Opposed-Piston Two-Stroke Aircraft Diesel Engine
The Zero-Dimensional Model of The Scavenging Process in The Opposed-Piston Two-Stroke Aircraft Diesel Engine
http://ppr.buaa.edu.cn/
w w w. s c i e n c e d i r e c t . c o m
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
KEYWORDS Abstract The analysis of the scavenging process in two-stroke engines is important in terms
of achieved performance and emission of toxic substances. The amount of mass of air used for
Two-stroke engine;
Diesel engine; the scavenging process and the amount mass of gas retained in the cylinder affect engine effi-
Opposed-piston engine; ciency. When designing two-stroke engines, the most efficient charge exchange process defined
Scavenging; by the scavenging efficiency parameter is desirable. The process of charge exchange in a two-
Supercharger stroke opposed-piston aircraft diesel engine based on the assumed scavenging model was
analyzed in this work. The charge exchange process was performed by a mechanical centrifugal
compressor. A zero-dimensional engine model created in the AVL BOOST program was used
for the research. The simulation tests were performed for the selected operating conditions, i.e.
maximum continuous power. The analysis of the charge exchange process was accompanied by
obtaining the basic engine operating parameters from the simulation calculations.
ª 2019 Beihang University. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi. This is an open
access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
1. Introduction
*Corresponding author.
E-mail address: pawel.karpinski@pollub.edu.pl (P. Karpinski). The light aircraft is generally driven by four-stroke spark-
Peer review under responsibility of Beihang University. ignition engines but two-stroke compression-ignition en-
gines can also be applied. The use of reciprocating engines
instead of turbine engines in light aircraft is justified due to
Production and Hosting by Elsevier on behalf of KeAi low flight speeds and long routes, which has a beneficial
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jppr.2019.11.003
2212-540X/ª 2019 Beihang University. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. on behalf of KeAi. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND
license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/).
The zero-dimensional model of the scavenging process 301
combination of two turbochargers makes engine perfor- system. A more detailed analysis of the charge exchange
mance (lower brake specific fuel consumption, BSFC) better process in the tested engine using the CFD method is dis-
than a combination of a mechanical supercharger and a cussed in the paper [22]. This research was conducted
turbocharger. simultaneously with the research on the entire engine model
Filling is much impacted, apart from a compressor used, and enabled the analysis of charge exchange to optimize the
by geometries of inlet and outlet ports. These geometries geometry of this system.
have an impact on the following charge exchange parame- This work aims at creating a zero-dimensional model of
ters: delivery ratio, trapping ratio, scavenging efficiency. an opposed-piston two-stroke diesel aircraft engine with a
The work in Ref. [13] shows the function to optimize the mechanical centrifugal compressor, Rotrex C30-64. This
parameters of scavenging in the opposed-piston two-stroke model enables a steady-state simulation. The examined pa-
engine with directly injected gasoline. These parameters rameters of the modelled engine are: filling, scavenging,
include heights of inlet and outlet ports, the port circum- performance, efficiency. We examined what portion of the
ference ratio, the discrepancy in piston motion phases. It is power generated by the engine is consumed by the
found that the height of the inlet port is a key factor behind compressor. Finally, a Sankey diagram is created to show
the delivery ratio, whereas the height of the exhaust port has the mass flow in the cylinder in the model of this research
an impact on the trapping ratio, scavenging efficiency and engine.
thermal efficiency.
Engine performance is impacted, apart from filling, by 2. Scavenging process
combustion. A correctly optimized combustion in the two-
stroke engine results in achieving higher indicated mean A single working cycle in the two-stroke engine proceeds
effective pressure (IMEP) and reduced brake specific fuel during a single revolution of the crankshaft so charge ex-
consumption (BSFC) than in the four-stroke engine of an change should be done with an external device such as a
identical capacity, which is claimed in Ref. [14]. blower, a mechanical supercharger or a turbocharger. In the
The optimizations of the performance of a two-stroke uniflow-scavenged engine, the quality of scavenging is
diesel aircraft engine described in Refs. [15,16] led to the impacted by the geometry of ports, and more specifically the
conclusion that the air-to-fuel ratio (AFR) and compression number of inlet and outlet ports, their shape and position on
pressure have the greatest impact on engine power and the cylinder liner. Scavenging is described by a number of
break specific fuel consumption (BSFC). Furthermore, it is parameters such as: delivery ratio, trapping efficiency,
found that engine performance is impacted much by scavenging efficiency and charging efficiency.
compression, the number of inlet ports, opening and closing The delivery ratio (DR) is the correlation between the
angles of exhaust and inlet ports. mass of a scavenging gas supplied in the scavenging process
Scavenging efficiency depends on the delivery ratio. The and its reference mass. Its reference mass is defined as the
scavenging efficiency vs. delivery ratio correlation in product of the scavenged volume and ambient air density.
Ref. [17] results from the simulation performed on a one-
dimensional model of an opposed-piston two-stroke diesel ms
DR Z ð1Þ
engine. The simulation results overlap with the test bench mref
results. The range of the optimal values of the delivery ratio
for the opposed-piston two-stroke (OP2S) engine is The trapping efficiency (TE ) is expressed as the corre-
achieved. lation of the mass of a scavenging gas trapped in the cyl-
The researchers in Ref. [18] show that using a special inder to the mass of a scavenging gas supplied in the
piston crown with a non-uniform chamber scavenge system scavenging process.
is the best solution to achieve a correct tumble ratio, kinetic
mt
energy and intensity of turbulence which are fundamental TE Z ð2Þ
for air motion. A flat piston crown with a longitudinal type ms
of scavenging results in a higher swirl ratio and a lower
The scavenging efficiency (SE ) is expressed as the
tumble ratio, which leads to an improved scavenging, i.e.
correlation between the mass of a scavenging gas trapped in
improved scavenging efficiency and delivery ratio.
the cylinder and its total mass inside the cylinder (mass of a
The project on a two-stroke aircraft diesel engine with a
fresh charge, mass of exhaust gas and mass of a charge
rotary valve to control inlet port flow is described in
unburned in the previous cycle).
Ref. [19]. Scavenging is done with an external pump made
out of a side cylinder piston which is connected to a mt
crankshaft. The design of the engine makes it possible to SE Z ð3Þ
mo
adapt the gasoline direct injection (GDI) in it [20]. It was
decided to use backflow scavenging based on the compu- The charging efficiency (CE ) is expressed as the corre-
tational fluid dynamics (CFD) analysis performed in the lation between the mass of a scavenging gas trapped in the
paper [21]. This engine model is zero-dimensional and cylinder and its mass which could fill the entire cylinder
generally characterizes the operation of the charge exchange volume with the ambient air.
The zero-dimensional model of the scavenging process 303
Table 1 Basic geometric parameters of the engine. Table 2 Parameters for the combustion model.
cylinders, enabled us to read the given thermodynamic pa- Figure 11 Rate of heat release and mass fraction burned vs. crank
rameters, i.e. pressure or mass flow. angle.
Figure 10 Characteristics of the scavenging efficiency vs. the de- Figure 12 Inlet, outlet and cylinder pressures vs. crank angle in
livery ratio. cylinder no 1 at the maximum continuous power.
The zero-dimensional model of the scavenging process 307
Figure 13 Inlet and exhaust mass flows vs. crank angle in cylinder Figure 14 Aspirated, trapped and in-cylinder masses vs. crank angle
no 1 at the maximum continuous power. in cylinder no 1 at the maximum continuous power.
in the cylinder and the share of fresh air mass in relation to [4] Ł. Grabowski, Z. Czy_z, K. Kruszczynski, Numerical analysis of
the mass of residual exhaust gases remaining in the cylinder. cooling effects of a cylinders in aircraft SI engine, SAE Technical
Paper, 2014-01-2883, 2014.
Other factors that are significantly responsible for scav- [5] M. Gęca, Z. Czy_z, M. Suøek, Diesel engine for aircraft propulsion
enging are the way fresh air is supplied to the cylinder, system, Combust. Engines 169 (2) (2017) 7e13.
engine speed and ambient conditions. Efficient scavenging [6] R. Herold, M. Wahl, G. Regner, J. Lemke, D. Foster, Thermodynamic
guarantees not only that exhaust gases are efficiently benefits of opposed-piston two-stroke engines, SAE Technical Paper,
replaced by fresh air, but also that fuel is well mixed with air 2011-01-2216, 2011.
[7] S. Naik, D. Johnson, J. Koszewnik, L. Fromm, F. Redon, G. Regner,
due to high turbulence. K. Fuqua, Practical applications of opposed-piston engine technology
The mass of air flowing through the cylinder over one to reduce fuel consumption and emissions, SAE Technical Paper,
engine operation cycle is 232 mg, which is about 28% of the 2013-01-2754, 2013.
total mass of air supplied by the compressor to one cylinder [8] E. Sher, Scavenging the two-stroke engine, Prog. Energy Combust.
(831 mg). The rest of the air is closed in the cylinder. A part is Sci. 16 (2) (1990) 95e124.
[9] P. Schweitzer, Scavenging of Two-Stroke Cycle Diesel Engines,
used to burn the fuel-air mixture (395 mg, 48%), while a part Macmillan Co., 1949.
(250 mg, 30%) is an excess of air. The mass of residual [10] K. Pietrykowski, M. Wendeker, J. Czarnigowski, P. Jaklinski,
combustion products (41 mg, 5%) and the mass of residual A. Nazarewicz, M. Gęca, Analysis of radial engine induction -
gas (68 mg, 8%) constantly circulates in the cylinder in each CFD simulation, PTNSS CONGRESS SC2-151 (2007) 258e271.
cycle of the engine's operation. Our results show that the air [11] J. Heywood, Internal Combustion Engine Fundamentals, McGraw-
Hill, 1988.
used in the combustion is almost half of the mass reaching the [12] A. Carlucci, A. Ficarella, D. Laforgia, A. Renna, Supercharging
cylinder. The mass of gases circulating inside the cylinder is a system behavior for high altitude operation of an aircraft 2-stroke
small share (13%) and, theoretically, strongly depends on the diesel engine, Energy Convers. Manag. 101 (2015) 470e480.
characteristics of inlet and outlet ports (see Figure 9). [13] F.K. Ma, J. Wang, Y.N. Feng, Y.G. Zhang, T.X. Su, Y. Zhang,
The port geometry also influences the occurrence of Y.H. Liu, Parameter optimization on the uniflow scavenging system of
an OP2S-GDI engine based on indicated mean effective pressure
reverse flows in inlet and outlet channels. In the tested en- (IMEP), Energies 10 (3) (2017) 368e387.
gine, the reverse flow occurs in the inlet channel just after [14] E. Mattarelli, G. Cantore, C. Rinaldini, T. Savioli, Combustion system
the opening of the intake ports. development of an opposed piston 2-stroke diesel engine, Energy
Our analysis enabled a quantitative study of the scav- Procedia 126 (2017) 1003e1010.
enging in the two-stroke opposed-piston diesel engine. The [15] A. Carlucci, A. Ficarella, G. Trullo, Performance optimization of a
two-stroke supercharged diesel engine for aircraft propulsion, Energy
results give us the data to understand the charge exchange Convers. Manag. 122 (2016) 279e289.
process in this type of engine and to further optimize the [16] A. Carlucci, A. Ficarella, D. Laforgia, G. Trullo, Multiobjective
process. The values from the simulation calculations are optimization of the breathing system of an aircraft two stroke super-
particularly important because an experimental measure- charged diesel engine, Energy Procedia 82 (2015) 31e37.
ment of mass of individual components of air and exhaust [17] Y.H. Liu, F.J. Zhang, Z.F. Zhao, Y.F. Dong, F.K. Ma, S.L. Zhang,
Study on the synthetic scavenging model validation method of
gas in an uniflow scavenging is very difficult. opposed-piston two-stroke diesel engine, Appl. Therm. Eng. 104
In the future, it is possible to compare the results of (2016) 184e192.
simulation calculations with the results of experimental tests [18] F.K. Ma, C.L. Zhao, F.J. Zhang, Z.F. Zhao, S.L. Zhang, P. Stewart,
carried out on the test engine. C. Bingham, Effects of scavenging system configuration on in-
cylinder air flow organization of an opposed-piston two-stroke en-
gine, Energies 8 (6) (2015) 5866e5884.
Acknowledgements [19] G. Cantore, E. Mattarelli, C. Rinaldini, A new design concept for
2-stroke aircraft diesel engines, Energy Procedia 45 (2014)
739e748.
This work has been realized in the cooperation with The
[20] T. Tulwin, R. Sochaczewski, The dual-fuel CFD combustion model
Construction Office of WSK "PZL-KALISZ" S.A. and is with direct and indirect CNG injection, ITM Web Conf. 15 (2017)
part of Grant Agreement No. POIR.01.02.00-00-0002/15 07016.
financed by the Polish National Center for Research and [21] C. Rinaldini, E. Mattarelli, V. Golovitchev, CFD analyses on 2-stroke
Development. high speed diesel engines, SAE Int. J. of Engines 4 (2) (2011)
2240e2256.
[22] Z. Czy_z, K. Siadkowska, R. Sochaczewski, CFD analysis of charge
References exchange in an aircraft opposed-piston diesel engine, MATEC Web
Conf. 252 (2019) 04002.
[1] Z. Czy_z, P. Magryta, Analysis of the operating load of foil-air bearings [23] AVL BOOST User Guide, 2013.
in the gas generator of the turbine engine during the acceleration and [24] J.P. Pirault, M. Flint, Opposed Piston Engines: Evolution, Use, and
deceleration maneuver, Eksploatacja i Niezawodnosc - Mainten. Future Applications, SAE International, 2010.
Reliab. 18 (4) (2016) 507e513. [25] K. Patton, R. Nitschke, J. Heywood, Development and evaluation of a
[2] M. Wendeker, Z. Czy_z, Analysis of the bearing nodes loads of turbine friction model for spark-ignition engines, SAE Technical Paper,
engine at an unmanned helicopter during a jump up and jump down 890836, 1989.
maneuver, Eksploatacja i Niezawodnosc - Mainten. Reliab. 18 (1) [26] K. Pietrykowski, T. Tulwin, Aircraft radial engine CFD cooling
(2016) 89e97. model, SAE Int. J. of Engines 8 (1) (2015) 82e88.
[3] Z. Czy_z, Ł. Grabowski, K. Pietrykowski, J. Czarnigowski, M. Porzak, [27] T. Tulwin, A coupled numerical heat transfer in the transient
Measurement of flight parameters in terms of toxic emissions of the multicycle CFD aircraft engine model, Procedia Eng. 157 (2016)
aircraft radial engine ASz62-IR, Measurement 113 (2018) 46e52. 255e263.
The zero-dimensional model of the scavenging process 309
[28] N. Abani, N. Nagar, R. Zermeno, M. Chiang, I. Thomas, G. Regner, [29] G. Blair, Design and Simulation of Two-Stroke Engines, SAE Inter-
Developing a 55% BTE commercial heavy-duty opposed-piston en- national, 1996.
gine without a waste heat recovery system, SAE Technical Paper, [30] T. Tulwin, M. Klimek, P. Piech, Open-end tube dynamic flow model
2017-01-0638, 2017. with an oscillatory extortion, ITM Web Conf. 15 (2017) 07010.