Design and Analysis of Ic Engine Piston Using Catia and Ansis Software
Design and Analysis of Ic Engine Piston Using Catia and Ansis Software
Design and Analysis of Ic Engine Piston Using Catia and Ansis Software
net/publication/303810676
CITATI READS
ON
33,030
1
1 author:
S . Sathishkumar
Vel Tech - Technical University
40 PUBLICATIONS 20 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
MATERIAL DEVELOPMENT FOR THERMO MECHANICAL STRAINED STRUCTURAL APPLICATION View project
All content following this page was uploaded by S . Sathishkumar on 05 June 2016.
Submitted by
SATHISHKUMAR. S
MASTER OF ENGINEERING
IN
ENGINEERING DESIGN
MAY 2015
1
BONAFIDE CERTIFICATE
Certified that this project report titled Design and Analysis of IC engine piston using CATIA
and ANSYS software is the bonafide work of Mr. SATHISHKUMAR.S
(Reg.No:512214408006) who carried out the research under my supervision. Certified further,
that to the best of my knowledge the work reported herein does not form part of any other project
report or dissertation on the basis of which a degree or award was conferred on an
earlier occasion on this or any other candidate.
SIGNATURE SIGNATURE
Piston is the part of engine which converts heat and pressure energy liberated by fuel combustion
into mechanical works. Engine piston is the most complex component among the automotives.
This paper illustrate design procedure for a piston for 4 stroke petrol engine for hero splendor –
pro bike and its analysis by its comparison with original piston dimensions used in bike. The
design procedure involves determination of various piston dimensions using analytical method
under maximum power condition. In this paper the combined effect of mechanical and load is
taken into consideration while determining various dimensions. The basic data of the engine are
1. INTRODUCTION
1.1 Objectives 02
1.2 major force acting over the piston 03
1.3functions of piston 03
1.4 factor considering for proper functioning the
03 piston
04
1.5 model of piston
3. MODELLING OF PISTON
4 DESIGN ANALYSIS 21
5.1 Conclusion 31
5.2 Further possible work 31
6 REFERENCES 31
LIST OF TABLES
1 INTRODUCTION
Piston is one of n the mechanical component, piston invented in a German
scientist
Nicholas August Otto in year 1866
1. The piston should have enormous strength and heat resistance properties to withstand
gas pressure and inertia forces. They should have minimum weight to minimize
the inertia forces.
2. The material of the piston should have good and quick dissipation of heat from
the crown to the rings and bearing area to the cylinder walls. It should form an effective
gas and oil seal.
3. Material of the piston must possess good wearing qualities, so that the piston is able to
maintain sufficient surface-hardness unto the operating temperatures.
4. Piston should have rigid construction to withstand thermal, mechanical distortion and
sufficient area to prevent undue wear. It has even expansion under thermal loads
so should be free as possible from discontinuities
1.5 Piston Assemble Model
Fig 1.1
Chapter 2
Fig 2.1
2.1.1 Piston Head or Crown
The piston head or crown is designed keeping in view the following two main considerations, i.e.
1. It should have adequate strength to withstand the straining action due to pressure
of explosion inside the engine cylinder, and
2. It should dissipate the heat of combustion to the cylinder walls as quickly as possible. On
the basis of first consideration of straining action, the thickness of the piston head
is determined by treating it as a flat circular plate of uniform thickness, fixed at the outer
edges and subjected to a uniformly distributed load due to the gas pressure over the entire
Cross-section.
2.1.2 Piston Rings
The piston rings are used to impart the necessary radial pressure to maintain the
seal between the piston and the cylinder bore. These are usually made of grey cast iron or alloy
cast iron because of their good wearing properties and also they retain spring characteristics even
at high temperatures.
The piston rings are of the following two types :
1. Compression rings or pressure rings, and
2. Oil control rings or oil scraper.
The compression rings or pressure rings are inserted in the grooves at the top portion of
the piston and may be three to seven in number. These rings also transfer heat from the piston to
the cylinder liner and absorb some part of the piston fluctuation due to the side thrust. The oil
control rings or oil scrapers are provided below the compression rings. These rings
provide proper lubrication to the liner by allowing sufficient oil to move up during upward
stroke and at the same time scrap the lubricating oil from the surface of the liner in order to
minimize the flow of the oil to the combustion chamber.
The compression rings are usually made of rectangular cross-section and the diameter of
the ring is slightly larger than the cylinder bore. A part of the ring is cut- off in order to permit it
to go into the cylinder against the liner wall. The gap between the ends should be sufficiently
large when the ring is put cold so that even at the highest temperature, the ends do not touch each
other when the ring expands, otherwise there might be buckling of the ring.
In designing a piston for I.C. engine, the following points should be taken into
consideration
1. It should have enormous strength to withstand the high gas pressure and inertia forces.
2. It should have minimum mass to minimize the inertia forces.
3. It should form an effective gas and oil sealing of the cylinder.
4. It should provide sufficient bearing area to prevent undue wear.
5. It should disperse the heat of combustion quickly to the cylinder walls.
6. It should have high speed reciprocation without noise.
7. It should be of sufficient rigid construction to withstand thermal and mechanical
distortion.
8. It should have sufficient support for the piston pin.
Table 2.5
The piston above has severe scouring on the exhaust skirt with
the heaviest damage on the clutch side of the piston. All of this
damage was caused from running straight fuel. The lack of lubrication
on the piston has caused it to seize to the cylinder wall. The damage
you see was caused in the moments before the piston "stuck," which
seized the
engine.
Fig 2.2
This kind of piston damage can also be found on a saw that was run with the carburetor set too
lean or one that was run with an air leak. If you didn't know this saw had been run with no oil in
the fuel, how would you know it wasn't a heat seizure To fully understand the cause of
this failure, it is important to look at the rest of the piston. The photo below is of the same piston.
It shows additional damage that's usually only found on a saw engine that had been run
with unmixed
The piston above has been damaged by over-speeding. Look at the piston material between the
ring-lands. You can see a big chunk of it is missing and some has been "squished" thinner,
creating a super-wide ring-land. Look at the top ring (bottom of photo). You can see the edge is
rounded-over, a sure sign the rings were catching in the exhaust port. When this occurs, this sets
off a high frequency vibration, eventually breaking the ring-land.
Fig 2.3
The piston above has been damaged by detonation. Notice the damage on the top and the edges
of the piston. The heat caused by detonation made the piston so hot, the rings stuck and the
piston seized in the cylinder. You can see the seizure marks on the side of the piston. This
damage usually ruins both the cylinder and piston.
Detonation can be caused by a number of things. In this case, changing to higher octane supreme
grade fuel was the answer. See our article on Fuel for more information
Fig 2.4
The piston above shows the most common severe piston damage we see - the exhaust side has
damage caused from excess heat. This damage looks similar to piston damage caused by running
straight gas shown in the first image, but with this piston, conditions under the piston
looked normal.
This kind of damage can be caused by over-revving the saw, running the carburetor adjustment
too lean, by ignoring an air leak in the saw's engine, or a combination of factors. The best way to
avoid a such a seizure is to use good quality fuel and mix oil, avoid over-revving the engine, and
always stop running a saw that shows signs of a potential air leak. This kind of damage can also
be caused by a partially plugged fuel filter, which is another reason fuel filters should be
replaced regularly
The damage on this piston skirt is caused by debris getting through the air filtering
system. Notice the horizontal machine marks have been scrubbed off all across the bottom
indicating extreme wear on the lower part of the skirt. Not shown, but the other side of the piston
looked perfect. This damage was only found only on the intake side of the piston. This is typical
for damage caused by intake debris. The other side of the piston is not exposed to an intake port,
so it isn't affected at early stages.
What damages the intake skirt is debris from a leaking filter wedging between the piston and
cylinder wall causing scuffing on the piston skirt. Since the piston is made of softer material, the
damage is more pronounced on the skirt than on the cylinder bore's hard surface. This wear on
the piston increases the clearance, which allows the piston to "rock" in the cylinder's bore. As the
skirt becomes thinner and weaker, rocking increases. Eventually the piston will break. When it
does, the engine seizes. On a pro saw, the piston skirt performs another important function. Not
only does it guide the piston, the skirt serves as the engine's intake valve. As the piston travels up
and down the cylinder, its base opens and closes the intake port as it passes. For the engine to run
its best, it is important for this valve to function well .
18
Fig 2.7
These fine scratches and "peppering" on the exhaust skirt and lower intake skirt is caused by the
failure of the lower rod bearing or main bearings. Small, but hard pieces of the bearings
and retention cages are breaking loose, causing this piston damage. If you are lucky enough to
catch a piston in this condition, stop running the saw until you find which bearing is
giving up material. If you keep running the saw, eventually the bearing(s) will completely fail.
This usually releases larger pieces of bearing material.
When this occurs, sometimes the crank shaft locks up. But if it keeps running, loose pieces in the
bottom end will travel up through the transfer ports and into the engine. All the parts won't make
the complete trip. Some won't pass through the upper transfer port and when the piston goes by, it
will drive these parts into the cylinder wall, destroying both. To repair this damage, both the
crankshaft assembly and the cylinder and piston must be replace two very
expensive components. We typically see this kind of damage on saw engines that have been over-
revved.
For more information see our section on Rod Bearing Failure.
Fig 2.8
Chapter 3
SPECIFICATIONS (splendor-pro)
Table 3.1
P= �
3
5.6×e =2×3.14×7500×T / 60
T=7.130 N-m
2) Diameter of piston
2
πr h = cc
r = radius
Diameter D = 2×r
D = 2*0.025 m =0.05m=50mm
3
Force =5.6e /8.16 = 686.274N
P = F/A
2 2 -3 2
Area = πr = 3.14 (0.025) = 1.934E M
-3
P=686.27/1.934E =0.34953Mpa (minimum)
Where
P= maximum pressure in N/mm²
D= cylinder bore/outside diameter of the piston in mm.
σt = permissible tensile stress for the material of the piston.
tH = 4.01mm
Where,
D = cylinder bore in mm
Pw= pressure of fuel on cylinder wall in N/mm². Its value is limited from
0.042N/mm². to 0.0667 N/mm² For present material, σt is 152.2Mpa
t1 =1.812mm
t2 = 0.7t1 to t1
t2 = 0.92 1.812
t2 =1.66mm
b1= tH to 1.2 tH
b1=1.2 4.01
𝐛𝟏 =4.81mm
𝐛 = 1.242mm
𝐭� = . � 𝐃 + 𝐛 + �. �𝐦𝐦
b = t1+0.4
b = 1.812+0.4
b = 2.212mm
t3= 0.03 D + 2.212+ 4.5mm
𝐭� = 8.212mm
T open = 2.053mm
T L= 0.055 × D
T L =2.75 mm
Dr = t1 + 0.4
Dr = 1.812 +0.4
Dr = 2.212 mm
LP = 25 + 3× 1.812 + 3 ×2.212
LP = 37.072mm
Pdo = 0.32 50
Pdo = 16mm
Pdi = 12mm
PARAMETERS CALCULATED VALUES
Table 3.2
3.3 MODELING OF PISTON IN CATIA
The 2D sketch of the piston in CATIA sketch window as shown in the fig 1
The 3D modeling of the piston as shown in the fig 3.1, it as done by using CATIA
workbench
DESIGN ANALYSIS
Finite Element Analysis (FEA) was first developed in 1943 by R. Courant, who utilized the Ritz
method of numerical analysis and minimization of variational calculus to obtain approximate
solutions to vibration systems. Shortly thereafter, a paper published in 1956 by M. J. Turner, R.
W. Clough, H. C. Martin, and L. J. Topp established a broader definition of numerical analysis.
The paper centered on the "stiffness and deflection of complex structures". By the early 70's,
FEA was limited to expensive mainframe computers generally owned by the aeronautics,
automotive, defense, and nuclear industries. Since the rapid decline in the cost of computers
and the phenomenal increase in computing power, FEA has been developed to an incredible
precision. Present day supercomputers are now able to produce accurate results for all kinds of
parameters
STRUCTURAL ANALYSIS
Structural analysis is the determination of the effects of loads on physical structures and
their components. Structures subject to this type of analysis include all that must withstand loads,
such as buildings, bridges, vehicles, machinery, furniture, attire, soil strata, prostheses and
biological tissue. Structural analysis incorporates the fields of applied mechanics, materials
science and applied mathematics to compute a structure's deformations,
internal forces, stresses, support reactions, accelerations, and stability. The results of the analysis
are used to verify a structure's fitness for use, often saving physical tests. Structural analysis is
thus a key part of the engineering design of structures.
4.1 MODELLING OF PISTON IN ANSYS SOFTWARE
Single cylinder 4 stroke engine (splendor pro) piston structural analysing in ANSYS software
Fig 4.2
DOF solution for X direction
Fig 4.3
Stress analysis in Z direction
VONMISSES STRESS
Fig 4.4
FACTOR OF SAFETY
10
Ultimate stress = 0.155e
6
Normal stress = 152.2e
𝐭 𝐦 𝐭 𝐭 𝟏�� 𝟏
Factor of safety = 𝐨 𝐦 𝐭 = = 10.157
𝟏� �
finish
/clear WPOFFS,-15,-9,
/title,Piston rectng,0,30,0,18
/prep7 VOFFST,1,-4
ET,1,SOLID45 VSYMM,X,1
YS=71e9 FLST,3,2,6,ORDE,2
PR=0.33 FITEM,3,1
MP,KXX,1,175 FITEM,3,-2
MP,C,1,960 VSBV, 36,P51X
MP,DENS,1,2700 WPOFFS,15,0,
MP,EX,1,YS WPROTA,0,0,90
MP,PRXY,1,PR FLST,2,30,6,ORDE,4
k,1,25.5,0 FITEM,2,3
k,2,28.5,0 FITEM,2,8
k,3,28.5,29.5 FITEM,2,-35
k,4,25.5,29.5 FITEM,2,37
k,5,25.5,30.5 VSBW,P51X
k,6,28.5,30.5 WPOFFS,30,0,
k,7,28.5,31.5 WPROTA,0,0,-90
k,8,25.5,31.5 k,10,28.5,32.5 k,11,28.5,34 k,12,25.5,34
k,9,25.5,32.5 k,13,25.5,35.5 k,14,28.5,35.5
k,15,28.5,41.5 FLST,2,34,6,ORDE,9
k,16,25.5,41.5 FITEM,2,1
k,17,19.5,41.5 FITEM,2,-2
k,18,19.5,40 FITEM,2,4
k,19,0,40 FITEM,2,-7
k,20,0,35.5 FITEM,2,9
k,21,23,35.5 FITEM,2,-32
k,22,23,30.5 FITEM,2,34
k,23,25.5,37 FITEM,2,-36
k,24,18,37 FITEM,2,38
k,25,23,5 VSBW,P51X
k,26,25.5,5 !!delete volumes!!
k,30,23,20 FLST,2,28,6,ORDE,19
k,31,13,20 FITEM,2,1
k,32,13,35.5 FITEM,2,3
l,1,2 FITEM,2,-5
l,2,3 FITEM,2,8
l,3,4 FITEM,2,-11
l,4,5 FITEM,2,13
l,5,6 FITEM,2,-15
l,6,7 FITEM,2,17
FITEM,2,-19
l,7,8
FITEM,2,21
l,8,9
FITEM,2,-23
l,9,10
FITEM,2,25
FITEM,2,-27
FITEM,2,29
FITEM,2,-31
FITEM,2,33
FITEM,2,35
FITEM,2,39
l,10,11 FITEM,2,-41
l,11,12 VDELE,P51X, , ,1
l,12,13
l,13,14 wpro,,,-50.000000
l,14,15 FLST,2,2,6,ORDE,2
l,15,16 FITEM,2,37
l,16,17 FITEM,2,42
l,17,18 VSBW,P51X
l,18,19 !!!!!!!!!!!!!
lfillt,17,18,1.5 FLST,2,1,6,ORDE,1
l,19,20 FITEM,2,34
l,20,32 FLST,3,2,5,ORDE,2
L,32,21 FITEM,3,34
l,21,22 FITEM,3,135
lfillt,21,22,5 VSBA,P51X,P51X,SEPO,KEEP,KEEP
l,22,30 !!!!!!!!
l,30,25 VDELE, 6, , ,1
l,25,26 !!!!!!!!!!!
l,26,1 FLST,2,1,6,ORDE,1
l,22,5 FITEM,2,2
l,24,27 FLST,3,1,5,ORDE,1
L,13,23 FITEM,3,35
L,23,24 VSBA,P51X,P51X,SEPO,KEEP,KEEP
L,24,28 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
l,5,8 FITEM,2,7
FITEM,2,-8
l,9,12
VADD,P51X
l,26,4
FLST,2,2,6,ORDE,2
l,30,31
FITEM,2,2
l,31,32
FITEM,2,34
TYPE,1
MAT,1
AL,1,2,3,35,26 VDELE,P51X
al,22,24,25,35,4,27 !!!!glue!!!!!
al,5,6,7,33 vsel,s,volu,,1,6
al,9,10,11,34 vsel,a,volu,,12
al,33,8,34,12,29,30,31,23,27 vsel,a,volu,,16
al,13,14,15,32,29 vsel,a,volu,,20
AL,30,28,19,16,32 vsel,a,volu,,24
al,28,31,21,20,17,18 vsel,a,volu,,28
al,21,23,22,36,37 vsel,a,volu,,32
Vrotat,1,,,,,,19,20,360 VADD,all
Vrotat,2,,,,,,19,20,360 !*
Vrotat,3,,,,,,19,20,360 TYPE, 1
Vrotat,4,,,,,,19,20,360 MAT, 1
Vrotat,5,,,,,,19,20,360 REAL,
Vrotat,6,,,,,,19,20,360 ESYS, 0
Vrotat,7,,,,,,19,20,360 SECNUM,
Vrotat,8,,,,,,19,20,360 !* ESIZE,0.5,0,
FLST,2,4,6,ORDE,2 MSHAPE,1,3D
FITEM,2,1 MSHKEY,0
FITEM,2,-4 !*
VADD,P51X VSEL, s,volu , ,2
FLST,2,4,6,ORDE,2 CM,_Y1,VOLU
FITEM,2,5 CHKMSH,'VOLU'
FITEM,2,-8 CMSEL,S,_Y
VADD,P51X
!*
!!!!
VMESH,_Y1
WPOFFS,30,-20,0
!*
WPROTA,0,0,90
CMDELE,_Y
CYL4,,,25,180
CMDELE,_Y1
VOFFST,1,-70
CMDELE,_Y2
FLST,2,2,6,ORDE,2 FITEM,2,33
FITEM,2,1 VSBV,P51X, 2
!!!!!! !*
WPOFFS,0,40,- /SOL
7 FLST,2,3,5,ORDE,
CYL4,,,11.5,-180 3
VOFFST,1,-10 FITEM,2,69
VSYMM,X,2 FITEM,2,238
VOFFST,9,11.5, FITEM,2,249
, VSYMM,X,5 DA,P51X,ALL,0
WPOFFS,,,7 !*
CYL4, , ,8.5, , , ,-70 !*
FLST,2,6,6,ORDE,2 asel,s,area,,45
FITEM,2,1 asel,a,area,,60
FITEM,2,-6 asel,a,area,,59
VSBV,P51X, 7 asel,a,area,,15
7
!! CM,top_land,area
CMSEL,S,top_land
SFA,top_land,1,PRES,5.24e
6 allsel
SOLVE
FINISH
From von misses stress analysis the ultimate stress obtained using analytical method yields
10
the value is 0.155e
6
The stress assumed for the design calculation is 152e therefore the design is safe as for the
assumed stress value
Also the parameter of piston (refer table 3.2) are safe as for the assumed condition
5.1. CONCLUSION
The fundamental concepts and design methods concerned with single cylinders petrol engine
have been studied in this paper the results found by the use of this analytical method are nearly
equal to the actual dimensions used now a days. Hence it provides a fast procedure to design a
piston which can be further improved by the use of various software and methods. The most
important part is that very less time is required to design the piston and only a few basic
specification of the engine.
The ANSYS analysis of the model designed on the basis of the dimensions found in this paper
can be done. This will help to get the idea whether the design is safe or not and what further
changes can be made in the design considering into mind the reduction of wt. of the piston i.e
work towards the weight minimization. The analysis can be done with change in material of
piston can be changed for better strength and light weight
6.REFERENCES
[1] Computer Aided Design and Analysis of Piston Mechanism of Four Stroke S.I. Engine.
[2] Mathura M.L., Sharma, A Course in Internal Combustion EngineR.P. Dhanpat Rai
Publication 1997 (i, ii, iii).
[3] Amitabha Ghosh, Ashok Kumar Malik, Theory of Mechanism and Machines, third Edition,
Affiliated press pvt limited New De 1998.
[4] Shigley, Joseph Edward, Theory of Machines and Mechanisms, Tata McGraw Hill, New
York, 2003.
[5] Khurmi, R.S. and Gupta, J.K., A Textbook of Theory of Machine,4th Edition, Eurasia
Publishing House (Pvt.), Ltd, New Delhi, 2003
38