Chapter 13 Answers
Chapter 13 Answers
Chapter 13 Answers
SM-Ch13-5e - Answers
13
Planning and Budgeting
13-1.
Next period’s budget has more detail because it is closer in time than the longer-range
forecasts. The budget plan is a blueprint for operations in the coming period. It must be
sufficiently detailed so that it provides adequate direction to the various people
responsible for operations.
13-2.
Cash receipts and disbursements often take place in different time periods from when
items are recognized in the income statement and balance sheet. Thus, a company
needs to prepare a cash budget to ensure that cash needs will be met.
13-3.
Answers will vary, but examples include:
a. Econometric methods—using economic data to forecast using statistical models;
b. Delphi technique—collecting and synthesizing the opinion of experts;
c. Estimates from salespeople and other knowledgeable personnel;
d. Trend analysis—statistical analysis of historical data;
e. Market research—collecting information on the macroeconomic trends in the
industry and in the local markets.
13-4.
13-4.
The master budget links long-term objectives and short-term, tactical plans.
Organization goals are broad-based statements of purpose. Strategic plans take the
broad-based statements and expresses them in terms of detailed steps needed to attain
those goals. Budgets are the short-term plans used to implement the steps included in
the strategic plans.
For example, a company might have a goal of "Becoming the number 1 company in the
industry." The strategic plans would include such statements as: "Increase sales volume
by 20% per year." The master budget would state the number of units that are needed
to be produced and sold in the coming period to meet the 20% volume increase as well
as the production and marketing costs necessary to attain that objective. The master
budget would also include estimates of the levels of cash, accounts receivable,
inventories, and fixed assets needed to support the budgeted level of activity.
13-5.
Because middle management has better knowledge about operations at lower levels in
the organization, and because budgets are usually used to evaluate performance or
compute bonuses for middle management, middle management might have a tendency
to underestimate revenues and overestimate costs. This bias arises because if the
biased plans are adopted, middle management will find it easier to meet targets and to
achieve bonus awards. Of course, if upper management always "tightens" the budget
plans suggested by middle management, gaming might result. The disadvantage of this
gaming is that the planning effectiveness might be reduced.
13-6.
Budgeting aids in coordination in a number of ways. By relating sales forecasts to
production activities it is possible to reduce the likelihood of over- or under-production. It
coordinates production so that plants making subassemblies are making the appropriate
number at the right time as needed by the plant making the final assemblies. In addition,
the budget process is used to make certain that adequate cash is on hand to finance
company activities for the coming period. Guidelines are set for administrative and
selling departments so that their costs are commensurate with the company’s income
and output goals.
13-7.
Participative budgeting is a process that uses inputs from lower- or middle-management
employees. The advantages include enhanced motivation, acceptance of goals,
increased information. The primary disadvantage is the time taken away from other
activities.
13-8.
Required Budgete Ending Beginning
production = d sales + inventor – inventory
(units) (units) y (units) (units)
13-9.
It is often more difficult to create the marketing and administration budget, because the
managers have more discretion about both the amount and timing of the spending.
13-10.
“Use it or lose it” in the context of budgeting refers to the incentive managers have to
spend any unused funds prior to the end of the budget year. If they fail to do this, they
will lose the money and, possibly, see reduced budgets in the future.
13-11.
The strategic plan provides broad, long-range goals for the company. The budget
provides more detail for how to work toward achieving those goals on an annual (or
quarterly, or monthly) basis.
13-12.
Answers will vary. Two possible reasons are (1) smaller firms have less of a “cushion”
and therefore require better estimates of cash and (2) smaller firms might have more
difficulty (might need to pay higher rates) borrowing money.
13-13.
The earlier the budgeting process is started, the earlier the company will understand
some of the problems it must address. In addition, an early start allows managers to
work on the budget, step back and think about it, and then revise it. A later start avoids
some of the costs of developing budgets only to have them revised as more current
data become available.
13-14.
Because inventories would be eliminated, the timing of purchases would be closer to
the time of production. This would minimize the differences between the timing of cash
outflows for materials purchases, work in process and finished goods, and the time
when the related costs are recognized in the production budget.
13-15.
The purpose of tying spending to budgets is to ensure that the wishes of the legislature
are carried out. The problem is that managers cannot take advantage of funds in one
budget to use in another area, even if that means lower overall costs to the government.
13-16.
Planning communicates the goals of the organization and can be used to coordinate the
activities of different units in the organization. The control purpose of the budget is to
provide a mechanism to influence managers, either by limiting resources available or by
providing a performance evaluation benchmark.
Problems can arise when the manager who is most knowledgeable, and, therefore the
best source of information for planning, will be evaluated at the end of the period.
Knowing that the information he or she submits for planning purposes will be used to
evaluate performance can affect the manager’s actions when providing information
needed for preparing the budget.
©The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc., 2017
610 Fundamentals of Cost Accounting
13-17.
It is common to start the budgeting process with a sales forecast because sales are
most out of control of managers. However, if raw materials were difficult to obtain and a
ready market existed for output, especially if prices were regulated, a company might
start with a forecast of production. Electricity production might be an example.
13-18.
In organizations where spending is literally tied to the budget, managers often spend
what remains in the budget as the year ends to avoid losing the funds and potentially
leading to lower budgets in the future.
13-19.
A positive balance at the end of the budgeting period does not ensure that there is
always cash available. An example is when all bills are due on the first of the month and
receipts are collected at the end of the month. The net cash flows can be positive even
though, during the month, there is a negative cash balance.
13-20.
Answers will vary. Many people will submit a budget in excess of their best guess. Part
of this is natural conservatism. Part of this is concern over their performance evaluation.
Other people might submit a number below their best guess, because they fear that
management will cancel the project if the estimated cost is too high.
13-21.
Answers will vary. Some basic factors are the nature of the product and the nature of
the market. For products that are well established (mature), there might be enough data
available to make trend analysis and econometric techniques reliable. In other cases,
the product might be so new, that the data that are available are not representative. In
that case, market researchers and Delphi techniques might be preferred. Similarly, if
market conditions are stable over time, trend analysis and econometric models might be
helpful. If market conditions are changing or unstable, trend analysis and econometric
models based on historical data might not be useful.
Solutions to Exercises
.80 = market volume in the coming year (as a percent of last year)
.95 = number of sales in the coming year (as a percent of last year)
1.10 = average commission per trade in the coming year (as a percent of last year)
900,000 trades x $5 per sale x .80 x .95 x 1.10 = $3,762,000.
Note: This is not the same as a 25 percent reduction (20% + 5%) because the volume
would not have been 5 percent of last year’s volume but 5 percent of the reduced
volume of 720,000 sales (= 900,000 x 80%).
Flex-Tite
Sales Budget
For the Year Ended December 31
(in units)
Expected sales......................................................................... 900,000 units
Plus: Desired ending inventory (1/12 x 900,000 x 130%)........ 97,500 units
Subtract: Planned production................................................... 930,000 units
Beginning inventory.................................................................. 67,500 units
b. The main issue is that the required production (712,500 units) is greater than plant
capacity (700,000 units).
(2 months ÷ 12 months)
x 160,000 x 6...................................
160,000
aEstimated sales for following three months: 45,200 = 17,800 (February) + 13,200
(March) + 14,200 (April)
Note: Once the process reaches equilibrium, the estimated purchases (in units) are
equal to the budgeted sales three months in the future.
a. Lakeside Components
Merchandise Purchase Budget
For the Period Ended July 31
(in units)
June July
Estimated sales...................................................
12,900 10,500
Add: Estimated ending inventory........................ 10,500 11,100
Total merchandise needs.................................... 23,400 21,600
Less: Beginning inventory...................................12,000 10,500
Merchandise to be purchased............................. 11,400 11,100
Total Cash
Cash Receipts in Month of: Receipts
May June July August for Period
March sales.........................................................
$ 2,304a $2,304
April sales............................................................
30,240b $ 4,032 34,272
May sales............................................................
50,400c 100,800 $13,440 164,640
June sales...........................................................
96,000 192,000 $ 25,600 313,600
July sales............................................................. 115,200 230,400 345,600
August sales........................................................
_________ ________ ________ 86,400 86,400
Total cash collections......................................
$82,944 $200,832 $320,640 $342,400 $946,816
a $2,304 = 8% x $28,800
b $30,240 = 60% x $50,400
c $50,400 = 30% x $168,000
This pattern is repeated for subsequent months.
13-42. (15 min.) Budgeting in a Service Organization: Solving for Unknown: Jolly
Cleaners.
The contribution margin for a residential client is:
$100 = $300 – (10 hours x $15 per hour) – (10 hours x $5 per hour).
The contribution margin for a commercial client is:
$400 = $1,400 – 50 hours x $15 per hour – 50 hours x $5 per hour.
Fixed costs are $32,000 per month.
Budgeted profit with commercial clients only is:
$($12,000) = (50 x $400) – $32,000.
If the total budgeted profit is $5,000, the contribution margin from residential customers
is:
$17,000 = $5,000 – ($12,000).
The number of residential clients, therefore, must be budgeted to be:
170 clients = $17,000 ÷ $100 per client.
To check:
Jolly Cleaners
Budgeted Income Statement
July
July
Revenues:
Commercial (50 @ $1,400)...................................... $70,000 (a)
Residential (170 @ $300)........................................ 51,000 (b)
Total revenue...................................................... $121,000
Expenses:
Cleaner compensation (4,200 hours @ $15)........... $ 63,000 (c)
Supplies (4,200 hours @ $5)................................... 21,000 (c)
SG&A........................................................................ 30,000 (d)
Other expenses........................................................ 2,000 (d)
Total expenses.................................................... $116,000
Income........................................................................... $ 5,000
The following is an Excel screenshot of the spreadsheet. In typing the formulas, shown
in row 2, do not enter the opening quote (“). Replace the “#” in the formula with the
specific row number. For example, to enter the formula for gross margin for unit gross
margin of $2 and 15,000 customers, place the cursor in cell c6 and type everything
between, not including, the following quotation marks: “=a6*b6”.
Notice the range of incomes is quite large, from a loss of $5,900 to a profit of $90,500.
The following is an Excel screenshot of the spreadsheet. In typing the formulas, shown
in row 2, do not enter the opening quote (“). Replace the “#” in the formula with the
specific row number. For example, to enter the formula for gross margin for unit gross
margin of $15 and 4,500 customers, place the cursor in cell c6 and type everything
between, not including, the following quotation marks: “=a6*b6”.
Notice the range of incomes is quite large, from a loss of $14,250 to a profit of
$280,500.
Solutions to Problems
Cash from operations would equal revenues less cash costs, which excludes
depreciation.
Calculations
Sales revenue.....................................................
$2,781,000 $2,500,000 x 1.08 x 1.03
Manufacturing costs:
Materials..........................................................
$ 457,920 $400,000 x 1.08 x 1.06
Variable cash costs.......................................... 559,170 $545,000 x 1.08 x 0.95
Fixed cash costs.............................................. 196,560 $216,000 x 0.91
Depreciation (fixed) ........................................ 279,900 $267,000 – $29,100 + $42,000
Total manufacturing costs................................... $1,493,550
Marketing and administrative costs:
Marketing (variable, cash) .............................. $ 307,800 $285,000 x 1.08
Marketing depreciation.................................... 67,800 $67,800 (unchanged)
Administrative (fixed, cash) ............................ 297,330 $270,300 x 1.10
Administrative depreciation............................. 25,200 $25,200 unchanged
Total marketing and administrative costs............ $ 698,130
Total costs...........................................................
$2,191,680
Operating profits..................................................
$589,320
Cash from operations would equal revenues less cash costs, which excludes
depreciation.
Alternative method:
First, compute the estimated production:
P = Sales + EB – BB
P = Sales + (210,000 – 120,000)
= 540,000 + 90,000
= 630,000 units
Next estimate the costs:
Direct materials
Cotton 630,000 x 1 yard x $4.00 x 1.20.............. $3,024,000
Canvas 630,000 x 0.2 yards x $12.00................ 1,512,000
Total direct materials....................................... $4,536,000
Direct labor:
630,000 x 0.5 hr. x $18.................................... $5,670,000
Overhead:
Indirect labor........................................................
630,000 x $0.60 $ 378,000
Indirect materials.................................................
630,000 x $0.20 126,000
Power..................................................................
630,000 x $0.40 252,000
Equipment costs..................................................
600,000 x $1.30 780,000
Building occupancy.............................................
600,000 x $0.90 540,000
Total overhead............................................... $2,076,000
Total budgeted manufacturing costs...................$12,282,000
Alternative method:
First, compute the estimated production:
P = Sales + EB – BB
P = Sales + (10,000 – 20,000)
= 210,000 – 10,000
= 200,000 units
Next estimate the costs:
Direct materials
Steel 200,000 x 3 pounds x $0.50 x 0.90............ $270,000
Alloy 200,000 x 0.5 pounds x $2.00.................... 200,000
Total direct materials....................................... $470,000
Direct labor:
200,000 x 0.02 hr. x $25 x 1.04....................... $104,000
Overhead:
Indirect materials.................................................
200,000 x $0.60 $ 120,000
Indirect labor........................................................
200,000 x $0.70 140,000
Utilities.................................................................
200,000 x $0.50 100,000
Plant and equipment depreciation......................250,000 x $0.90 x 1.06 238,500
Miscellaneous......................................................
250,000 x $0.70 175,000
Total overhead............................................... $773,500
Total budgeted manufacturing costs................... $1,347,500
Budgeted
Item January Adjustments Typical Month
Sales commissions..............................................
$364,500 x 1.14 x 0.90 = $373,977
Sales staff salaries..............................................
86,400 x 1.06 = 91,584
Telephone & mailing............................................
43,000 x 1.14 x 1.05 = 51,471
Building lease payment.......................................
54,000 (unchanged) = 54,000
Utilities.................................................................
11,100 x 1.03 = 11,433
Packaging & delivery...........................................
74,000 x 1.14 = 84,360
Depreciation........................................................
33,750 + ($53,040 ÷ 120 months) = 34,192
Marketing consultants.........................................
–0– + $64,500 = 64,500
Total budgeted costs.. $765,517
a. $113,000
BB + P = Sales + EB
(120% x 11,900) + P = 11,900 + (120% x 11,400)
14,280 + P = 11,900 + 13,680
P = 11,900 + 13,680 – 14,280
= 11,300 units
11,300 x $10 = $113,000
b. $121,200
BB + P = Sales + EB
(120% x 11,400) + P = 11,400 + (120% x 12,000)
13,680 = 11,400 + 14,400
P = 11,400 + 14,400 – 13,680
= 12,120 units
12,120 x $10 = $121,200
c. $691,896
70% x $726,000 x 98% = $498,036
15% x $726,000 = 108,900
12% x $708,000 = 84,960
$691,896
13-54. (continued)
e. 49,040
BB + P = Sales + EB
(120% x 12,000) + P = 12,000 + (120% x 12,200)
P = 12,000 + 14,640 – 14,400
= 12,240 units
It is useful to calculate some variable costs per night and property in Year 1:
Average food and beverage revenue per night = $25 (= $19,162,500 ÷ 766,500)
Average food and beverage cost per night = $18 (= $13,797,000 ÷ 766,500)
13-55. (continued)
a. Under the “High Price” strategy, the number of nights will be:
13-56. (continued)
a. Under the “High Occupancy” strategy, the number of nights will be:
13-56. (continued)
c. Based on the budget, the High Price Strategy is expected to earn more profit than
the High Occupancy strategy ($20,778,800 versus $19,990,400). However, neither
strategy appears as profitable as the current one with an estimated profit of
$22,092,800.
a. (1)
Brighton, Inc.
Schedule Computing Production
Budget (Units)
For April, May, and June
April May June
Budgeted sales—Units........................................ 600,000 450,000 600,000
Inventory required at end of montha................... 90,000 120,000 120,000
Total to be accounted for.................................... 690,000 570,000 720,000
Less inventory on hand at beginning of month... 120,000 90,000 120,000
Budgeted production—Units............................... 570,000 480,000 600,000
(2)
Schedule Computing Raw Materials Inventory
Purchase Budget (Pounds)
For April and May
April May
Budgeted production—Pounds (1/4 lb. per Unit) a...... 142,500 120,000
Inventory required at end of monthb........................... 48,000 60,000
Total to be accounted for............................................ 190,500 180,000
Less inventory on hand at beginning of month.......... 57,000 102,000c
Balance required by purchase.................................... 133,500 78,000
Budgeted purchases—Pounds
(Based on Minimum Shipments of 62,500 lbs. each) 187,500 125,000
13-57. (continued)
b.
Brighton, Inc.
Projected Income Statement
For the Month of May
Sales revenue (450,000 Units at $4) ........................................ $1,800,000
Less: Cash discounts on Sales................................................. $ 18,000
Estimated bad debts (1/2 percent of gross sales) ................... 9,000 27,000
Net Sales................................................................................... $1,773,000
Cost of Sales:
$1,100,000
Variable cost per unit (= x 450,000 Units) ................................................
$990,000
500,000
Fixed Cost............................................................................... 400,000 1,390,000
Gross profit on sales................................................................... $ 383,000
Expenses:
Selling (10 percent of gross sales) .........................................$180,000
Administrative ($165,000 per month) ..................................... 165,000
Interest expense (.01 x $500,000) ......................................... 5,000 350,000
Operating profit........................................................................... $ 33,000
13-58. (continued)
Panther Corporation
Budgeted Balance Sheet
(in thousands)
Budgeted
December 31,
Year 2
Current Assets
Cash................................................................. $ 4,800
Accounts receivable........................................ 320,000
Inventory.......................................................... 459,000a
Income tax receivable...................................... 10,400b
Total current assets..................................... $794,200
Plant and equipment........................................... 520,000
Less: Accumulated depreciation..................... 164,000 356,000
Total assets.................................................. $1,150,200
Current liabilities
Accounts payable............................................ $180,000
Accrued payable.............................................. 93,000
Notes payable.................................................. 200,000
Total current liabilities.................................. $473,000
Shareholders’ equity
Common stock................................................. 280,000
Retained earnings............................................ 397,200c
Total shareholders’ equity............................ 677,200
Total liabilities and shareholders’ equity...... $1,150,200
Notes on the next page:
13-58. (continued)
a Inventory
Units:
$1,440,000
Beginning inventory $192,000 = 40,000 units
300,000
Added to inventory 450,000 – 400,000............... = 50,000 units
Ending inventory.................................................. 90,000 units
Cost:
Manufacturing costs........................................$2,295,000
Units manufactured.......................................... 450,000
Cost per unit ($2,295,000 450,000) ............. $5.10
Ending units..................................................... x 90,000
Cost of ending inventory.................................. $459,000
b Income tax:
Sales & other income.......................................... $2,436,000
Cost of goods sold............................................... $2,028,000
Selling expense................................................... 324,000
General & administrative expense...................... 110,000
Total cost......................................................... $2,462,000
Tax loss............................................................... $ (26,000)
Tax rate............................................................... 40%
Tax receivable..................................................... $ 10,400
c Ending retained earnings = Expected beginning balance plus net income – Dividends
= $432,800 – 15,600 – $20,000.
13-59. (40 min.) Prepare Cash Budget for Service Organization: Cortez Beach
Yacht Club.
The income statement is on a cash basis, hence we start with a budgeted income
statement.
a. Cortez Beach Yacht Club
Budgeted Statement of Income (Cash Basis)
For the Year 10
Cash revenue
Annual membership fees....................................
$710,000 x 1.1 x 1.03 ..............................................................
$804,430
Lesson and class fees ....................................
(468,000 ÷ 360,000) x $468,000) $608,400
Miscellaneous .................................................
(4,000 ÷ 3,000) x $4,000) 5,333 613,733
Total cash received ......................................................................................................................
$1,418,163
Cash costs
Manager’s salary and benefits ($72,000 x 1.15) ..................................... $ 82,800
Regular employees’ wages and benefits ($380,000 x 1.15) ................... 437,000
Lesson and class employee wages and benefits (given)......................... 604,650
Supplies ($32,000 x 1.25) ........................................................................ 40,000
Utilities (heat and light) ($44,000 x 1.25) ................................................. 55,000
Mortgage interest ($720,000 x .06)a......................................................... 43,200
Miscellaneous ($4,000 x 1.25) ................................................................. 5,000
Total cash expenses............................................................................. $1,267,650
Cash income................................................................................................. $ 150,513
Additional Cash Flows
Cash payments:
Mortgage payment.................................................................................... $ 60,000
Accounts payable balance at 10/31/Year 9.............................................. 5,000
Accounts payable on equipment at 10/31/Year 9..................................... 30,000
Planned new equipment purchase........................................................... 50,000
Total cash payments............................................................................. $ 145,000
Cash inflows from income statement........................................................... 150,513
Beginning cash balance (including petty cash)............................................ 14,600
Cash available for working capital and to acquire property.......................... $ 20,113
aOn November 1, Year 9, the unpaid balance after annual payment is $720,000,
computed as follows: Balances after the $60,000 annual payment November 1, Year 6
= $900,000; November 1, Year 7 = $840,000; November 1, Year 8 = $780,000;
November 1, Year 9 = $720,000 and as given in the problem.
13-59. (continued)
b. Operating problems that Cortez Beach Yacht Club could experience in Year 10
include:
The lessons and classes contribution to cash decreased because the projected
wage increase for lesson and class employees is not made up by the increased
volume of lessons and classes.
Operating costs are increasing faster than revenues from membership fees.
CBYC seems to have a cash management problem. Although there appears to
be enough cash generated for the club to meet its obligations, there are past-due
amounts on equipment and regular accounts. Perhaps the cash balance might
not be large enough for day-to-day operating purposes.
c. The manager’s concern with regard to the Board’s expansion goals is justified. The
Year 10 budget projections show only a minimal increase in the cash balance. The
total cash available is well short of the cash needed for the land purchase over and
above the club’s working capital needs. However, it appears that the new equipment
purchases can be made on an annual basis. If the Board desires to purchase the
adjoining property, it is going to have to consider significant increases in fees or
other methods of financing such as membership bonds, or additional mortgage debt.