EEX 107.03 Evaluating Applied-Potential Tests
EEX 107.03 Evaluating Applied-Potential Tests
EEX 107.03 Evaluating Applied-Potential Tests
Note: The source of the technical material in this volume is the Professional
Engineering Development Program (PEDP) of Engineering Services.
Warning: The material contained in this document was developed for Saudi
Aramco and is intended for the exclusive use of Saudi Aramco’s employees.
Any material contained in this document which is not already in the public
domain may not be copied, reproduced, sold, given, or disclosed to third
parties, or otherwise used in whole, or in part, without the written permission
of the Vice President, Engineering Services, Saudi Aramco.
INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................. 5
AC AND DC APPLIED-POTENTIAL TEST SETS ........................................................... 6
Operational Principle ............................................................................................ 6
Constructions........................................................................................................ 8
EVALUATING AC APPLIED-POTENTIAL TESTS ........................................................ 12
AC Applied-Potential Tests: Applications and Methods ...................................... 12
Applications ............................................................................................. 12
Basic Methods ......................................................................................... 13
Evaluation Factors.............................................................................................. 15
Close Clearance ...................................................................................... 15
Time......................................................................................................... 16
Charging Current ..................................................................................... 16
Avalanche Breakdown ............................................................................. 16
EVALUATING DC APPLIED-POTENTIAL TESTS........................................................ 17
DC Applied-Potential Tests: Applications and Basic Methods ........................... 17
Applications ............................................................................................. 17
Basic Methods ......................................................................................... 18
Incipient Breakdown Detection Factor ................................................................ 21
Dielectric Absorption Factor................................................................................ 23
EVALUATIng INSULATING FLUID DIELECTRIC TESTS ............................................ 24
Insulating Fluid Dielectric Tests: Applications and Methods .............................. 24
Applications ............................................................................................. 24
Methods ................................................................................................... 24
Effects of Water Contamination .......................................................................... 26
Effects of Temperature ....................................................................................... 27
WORK AID 1: RESOURCES USED TO EVALUATE AN AC APPLIED-
POTENTIAL TEST ........................................................................................................ 28
Work Aid 1A: Non-Mandatory Test Form P-008, Medium-Voltage Circuit
Breakers (Handout 8).................................................................... 28
Work Aid 1B: Non-Mandatory Test Form P-014, Metal-Enclosed Bus Duct
(Handout 9) ................................................................................... 28
Work Aid 1C: Manufacturer’s Literature.............................................................. 28
Work Aid 1D Applicable Procedural Steps.......................................................... 30
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF TABLES
INTRODUCTION
The subject of this Module is the evaluation of applied-potential
tests. Applied-potential tests are also called high-potential tests,
hi-pot tests, or high-voltage withstand tests. Applied-potential
tests include AC applied-potential tests, DC applied-potential
tests, and insulating fluid dielectric tests. As background
information, the operational principles and constructions of AC
and DC applied-potential test sets are explained. The
applications and basic methods of applied-potential tests are
also explained. To gain practical experience, the Participant will
perform three Exercises to evaluate the test data taken from
three applied-potential tests.
Applied-potential tests are performed for one or both of two
purposes:
• As a proof test in which significantly more than normal
voltage is applied to an insulation system or an insulation
component for a brief period of time in order to discover any
gross defect.
• To obtain measurements of insulation current that can be
analyzed to evaluate the general condition of an insulation
system or an insulation component.
Proof tests are performed using AC applied-potential test sets
and DC applied-potential test sets. Measurements of insulation
current are made using DC test sets.
Measuring insulation current with a DC applied-potential test
has the same basic purpose as performing an insulation-
resistance test or an insulation power-factor test. DC applied-
potential tests can, however, be conducted at significantly
greater voltages than insulation-resistance or insulation power-
factor tests.
Operational Principle
An applied-potential test set receives a 120 or 240-volt AC
input, and it produces an adjustable high-voltage output.
Figure 1 is a schematic representation of the circuits of a typical
applied-potential test set.
• AC input is connected and disconnected by the input power
switch.
• The variable autotransformer produces a zero to 120-volt
output. This autotransformer is the basic component of the
raise-voltage control shown in Figure 3.
• The circuit breaker CB remains closed throughout a test.
The primary function of this circuit breaker is to trip open if a
fault develops in the insulation system of the equipment
under test.
• Contactor K1 connects and disconnects the high-voltage
transformer under control of the HV-OFF pushbutton, the
HV-ON pushbutton, the remote interlock device, the zero-
start ZS microswitch, and the OL overload relay. A second
test set operator (person) is required to activate the electrical
contact of the remote interlock device. The ZS microswitch is
closed whenever the autotransformer is set at zero-output
adjustment. Relay OL will cause the K1 contactor to open if
an overload current is detected.
• The high-voltage transformer generates the output voltage.
The magnitude of this output voltage is indicated by the
kilovoltmeter VM.
• Divider resistors R1 and R2 reduce the output voltage to a
level that is safe for a panel meter.
• The milliammeter A indicates the magnitude of current
returning from the equipment under test.
• Built-in spark gaps protect the kilovoltmeter and the
milliammeter from damage that might be caused by a
transient overvoltage.
Input
Engineering Encyclopedia
R1
Power Variable
Switch Auto Transformer
R2
H.V. H.V.
Off On
OL
ZS K1 OL
K1 Spark
Remote CB = Circuit Breaker A Gap
Interlock K1 = Output Contactor
Device OL = Overload and Insulation Fault Detector
ZS = Zero-Start Interlock Switch
Return
7
Engineering Encyclopedia Electrical Equipment Testing
Constructions
Applied-potential test sets have two basic construction types:
• AC applied-potential test sets.
• DC applied-potential test sets.
The differences in construction between AC and DC test sets
are in their high-voltage transformer circuits. Figure 2a shows
the high-voltage circuit of an AC test set. Figure 2b shows the
high-voltage circuit of a DC test set. A DC test set has four
additional components:
• A high-voltage rectifier that changes the AC output of the
high-voltage transformer into a DC output.
• A discharge solenoid whose main contact dissipates a
capacitive charge a brief time after the output contactor
opens.
• An extra return-current terminal called the guard terminal.
Any current flowing into the guard terminal will not be sensed
in the microammeter.
• An output filter capacitor that changes the half-wave output
of the rectifier into a ripple-free direct voltage.
Note: Some DC applied-potential test sets do not have an
output filter capacitor. In these test sets, the distributed
capacitance of the insulation system under test smoothes the
wave form. The advantage of this arrangement is that less
energy is discharged into an insulation system after an
insulation breakdown occurs.
K1
K1 D
Q R1
Engineering Encyclopedia
R1
OL OL
D = Discharge Solenoid
C = Output Filter Capacitor *
Guard
Q = High-Voltage Rectifier
A
A Ground (Chassis)
Return Link
Return
(a) (b)
9
Engineering Encyclopedia Electrical Equipment Testing
20 Return
20 30 5
10 10 0 dc
0
15
80
5 dc 4 Ground uA
Raise Voltage
Voltage Range Current Range
Med 40 50 60 X10 X100
Low High
30 70 X1 X1K
20 80
AC Power High Voltage
Zero 10 90
On 5A Start On Off
0 100
11
Engineering Encyclopedia Electrical Equipment Testing
Basic Methods
Power Cord
with Ground-
Return Conductor T1 T4
H.V. T2 T5
Terminal
T3 T6
Spark-Gap
Temporary
Voltmeter
Jumpers
Bonding
Return Terminal
Test Set Connection
Chassis
Connection
(a)
T1 T4
T2 T5
T3 T6
Spark-Gap
Voltmeter
Return Terminal
(b)
Evaluation Factors
The basic evaluation criterion of an AC applied-potential test is
the ability of the insulation system to successfully withstand the
pre-determined voltage for the pre-determined period of time.
The following factors relate to the evaluation of an AC applied-
potential test.
Close Clearance
Time
Charging Current
Avalanche Breakdown
Basic Methods
Cable Connection
Compartment High-Voltage
of Switchgear Bus Bars
Shield
Conductors
Movable
Link
Figure 6. Connection Diagram for DC Applied-Potential Tests that Use the Guard
Terminal
Proof Tests -- The method for conducting a DC proof test is
sometimes the same as the method for conducting an AC proof
test. The more usual method of conducting a DC test is a step-
voltage test. A step-voltage test provides some warning of an
incipient insulation failure. Note: A more detailed description of
the method of a step-voltage test is given later in this
Information Sheet.
Measurement of Leakage Current -- A measurement of leakage
current is usually made at a level of voltage less than the level
of a proof test. The method of measuring leakage current is to
first choose a level of voltage that will be applied, typically equal
to or greater than the insulation system’s rated voltage but less
than the proof test level. The test set is connected, and the pre-
determined voltage is applied for sixty seconds. At the end of
this time period, the microammeter is read, and the value of
microamperes is recorded.
Plot of Current
Current (mA)
Voltage (kV)
Plot of Current
= Data points read from
Microammeter at end of
each one-minute period
Leakage
35 140 and
Displacement Absorption
and Absorption Final
30 120 Currents
Currents Voltage
25 100
20 80
15 60
10 40
5 20
0 0
1 2 3 4 5 6
Discharge
Time (minutes) Solenoid Activated
30
20
Microamperes
15
10
9
8
7
6
5
4
2
.25 .50 .75 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 15
Methods
60
VDE
ASTM
40
Breakdown Voltage, kV, RMS
30
20
10
0 10 20 30 40 50 60
Water Content, Parts Per Million
Figure 9. Plot of Breakdown Voltage Versus Water Content
Effects of Temperature
The result of an insulating fluid dielectric test is affected by the
temperature of the fluid. Dielectric breakdown voltage is lower
when the insulating fluid temperature is higher. A sample of
dielectric fluid should be allowed to stabilize at a temperature of
20°C before it is tested.
After the high potential is removed, discharge any electrical charge that
may be retained, particularly from the center shield of the vacuum
interrupters. To avoid any ambiguity in the ac high potential test due to
leakage or displacement (capacitive) current, the test unit should have
sufficient volt-ampere capacity. It is recommended that the equipment be
capable of delivering 25 milliamperes for one minute.
6.7 INSULATION INTEGRITY CHECK
PRIMARY CIRCUIT:
The integrity of primary circuit insulation may be checked by the AC high
potential test. The test voltage depends upon the maximum rated voltage of
the breaker. For breakers rated 4.76 kV, 8.25 kV, 15 kV and 27 kV, the test
voltages are 15 kV, 27 kV, 27 kV and 45 kV, 60 Hz respectively. Conduct the
test as follows:
Close the breaker. Connect the high potential lead of the test machine to
one of the poles of the breaker. Connect the remaining poles and breaker
frame to ground. Start the machine with output potential at zero and increase
to test voltage. Maintain the voltage for one minute. Repeat for the remaining
poles. Successful withstand indicates satisfactory insulation strength of the
primary circuit.
1. Verify from test report data that the insulation system has the minimum insulation
resistance required for conducting an applied-potential test. The minimum
insulation resistance in megohms is required to be greater than the nominal
voltage rating of the equipment in kilovolts but not less than 1 megohm.
2. Verify from test report data that the correct voltage was applied for the correct
period of time according to the equipment manufacturer’s instructional literature,
or the recommendations of the test forms of the Saudi Aramco Project
Acceptance Committee.
Refer to
Table 1 (Work Aid 1C) and Table 2 (Work Aid 1C) as representative examples of
applicable manufacturer’s instructional literature.
3. Determine from test report data whether the insulation successfully withstood the
applied voltage without breakdown. If the insulation broke down during the test,
bypass the procedure described in step 4.
4. If the insulation successfully withstood the recommended voltage applied for the
recommended time, the evaluation of the test ends at this step.
5. Determine from test report data the magnitude of insulation current read from the
test set’s milliammeter before the test set’s overload relay terminated the test.
VArated
• mA rated =
kVrated
Work Aid 2E: Associated Research Inc. Form #5-25.1, Cable Test
Graph Paper (Handout 12)
For the contents of Form #5-25.1, refer to Handout 12.
8. Calculate factor B:
• B = (i1.0 + i10.0 )− (2 × i3.16 )
A
• ia1.0 = (i1.0) -
B
A
• ia10.0 = (i10.0) -
B
ia10.
• Absorption Ratio =
ia10.0
12. Evaluate the absorption ratio. If this dielectric absorption test is combined with a
step-voltage test, the dielectric absorption ratio is expected to be 2.0 or greater. If
the dielectric absorption ratio is less than 2.0, the test is terminated without
continuing the step-voltage test. If the dielectric absorption test is conducted
alone, the values of Table 4 are used to evaluate the result:
13. If the test data represents a step voltage test, verify that the correct final voltage
was applied according to the equipment manufacturer’s instructional literature, or
the recommendations of the test report forms of the Saudi Aramco Project
Acceptance Committee.
Table 3 (Work Aid 2C) is a representative example of a recommendation from
manufacturer’s instructional literature. The recommendations of this work aid
should be used when evaluating tests performed on rotating machinery
manufactured by Westinghouse Electric Corporation. Other manufacturers
publish recommendations that might have different values but that have the
same general form.
When cable insulation is tested, the last step of voltage is maintained for a
maximum of 15 minutes on EPR cable. The last step of voltage is maintained for
a maximum of 15 minutes on XLPE cable.
18. Plot insulation current versus time on a linear grid. The test set operator makes a
similar plot during the test, and checks whether each new point is on a straight
line with all of the other previously plotted points. A nearly straight-line
relationship is expected for insulation that has no defects. Figure 10 is an
example of a data plot of a step-voltage test for a rotating machine insulation that
has no defects. Figure 11 is an example of a data plot of a step-voltage test for
insulation that developed a corona discharge when higher voltage steps were
applied during testing.
19. Verify any justification given for terminating the test before reaching final voltage.
In the time interval between plotting data points, the test set operator makes an
observation of the exponential decay of insulation current (refer to Figure 7 in the
Information Sheet). If the operator observes at any time that insulation current is
increasing during a period when voltage is constant, he will terminate the test.
Note: Although this exponential decay of current is not represented in the data of
the test report form, the operator will make a written comment when rising current
is the reason for ending the test.
If the operator’s decision to terminate the test is judged to be appropriate, the
insulation components of the equipment will require other electrical tests or
physical inspections to determine the reason for disproportionate insulation
current. Other electrical tests might include an insulation power-factor test,
dielectric loss test, capacitance measurement, partial-discharge test, or insulation
resistance test.
21
48
20
45
19
42
18
39
DC Test Voltage, kV
Minutes (I vs. Time)
17
36
16
33
15
30
14
27
13
24
12
21
11
18
10
15
60
45
30
15
Microamps
21
48
20
45
19
42
18
39
DC Test Voltage, kV
Minutes (I vs. Time)
17
36
16
33
15
30
14
27
13
24
12
21
11
18
10
15
60
45
30
15
Microamps
If the operator’s decision to terminate the test is judged to be not appropriate, the
step-voltage test should be repeated. Note: The decision to re-apply
overpotential voltage to an insulation system having a suspected weakness is
highly subjective. This decision is made only after consultation with all interested
parties. Factors that affect this decision are the risk of returning equipment to
service without resolving an ambiguous test result, the consequences of an
unexpected failure, and the expense involved in replacing or repairing the
insulation components that are suspicious.
20. If the insulation did not break down during the step-voltage test, the evaluation of
the test ends at this step.
21. If the insulation broke down during the step-voltage test, the most likely cause is
an avalanche breakdown of solid insulation material. Avalanche breakdown
indicates deteriorated insulation or damaged insulation. Note: Identifying the
cause of an avalanche breakdown usually requires physical inspection of
insulation components. The physical location of the breakdown is sometimes
identified by re-applying test voltage, watching, and listening for the electrical
discharge.
6. If the oil sample was drawn from the main or auxiliary tank of a new transformer
that was delivered full of oil and that is 34.5 kV class or less, the minimum
acceptable dielectric breakdown voltage is 30 kV (D877 method).
7. If the oil sample was drawn from the main tank of a new transformer that was
delivered full of oil and that is 34.5 kV class or greater, the minimum acceptable
dielectric breakdown voltage is 30 kV (D877 method).
8. If the oil sample was drawn from the main or auxiliary tank of an in-service
transformer for a maintenance test, evaluate the minimum acceptable value
according to the table in
9. Table 7.
GLOSSARY