Handbook On Chemicals Hazardous Waste Management Handling in India CEERANLSIU

Hand Book on Chemical Waste
HANDBOOK ON
CHEMICALS AND HAZARDOUS WASTE

MANAGEMENT AND HANDLING
IN INDIA
Jointly published by:
CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL LAW, EDUCATION,

RESEARCH AND ADVOCACY
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY
MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT, FOREST AND

CLIMATE CHANGE, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA
NLSIU
Copyright @ NLSIU, 2019
All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or utilised in any form of by any means electronic
and mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage or otherwise, without
permission in writing from NLSIU.
ISBN : 978-93-83363-79-7
Price : INR 500/-
©National Law School of India University, Bengaluru.

www.nlspub.ac.in
Published By :
CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL LAW, EDUCATION, RESEARCH AND
ADVOCACY
NATIONAL LAW SCHOOL OF INDIA UNIVERSITY
P O Box 7201,
Nagarbhavi, Bengaluru-560 0242
Printed by:
Sri Vidya Printers
Bengaluru Ph: 9986659590, 9035142247
ii
NLSIU
Table of Contents
Page No.
Acknowledgment ................................................................................................................... vii

Preface .......................................................................................................................................ix
List of Abbreviations .......................................................................................................... xiv
CHAPTER 1
CHEMICALS AND HAZARDOUS WASTE - OVERVIEW AND
DEFINITIONS .................................................................................................. 1
1.1 Understanding Chemical Substances ............................................................... 1
1.2 Chemical and Physical properties of Chemical Substances ........................ 3
1.3 Hazardous properties of Chemical Substances ............................................. 5
1.4 Globally Harmonized System for Classification and
Labelling of Chemicals (GHS) ....................................................................... 11
CHAPTER 2
INTERVENTIONS OF INTERNATIONAL ORGANISATIONS IN THE
FIELD OF CHEMICAL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT . 26
2.1 Introduction ....................................................................................................... 26
2.2 Organizations Working in the Field of Chemicals and
Hazardous Waste Management at the International Level ........................ 28
2.3 Organizations working in the field of Chemicals and
Hazardous Waste Management at the Regional Level ............................... 46
2.4 Definitions of hazardous waste adopted by International and
Regional Organizations .................................................................................... 55
2.5 Definitions of Hazardous Waste within the Indian Legal Framework.... 60
2.6 Comparative Analysis of the Definitions of Hazardous Waste
adopted by International and Regional Organizations and
the Indian Legislations ..................................................................................... 62
iii
NLSIU
CHAPTER 3
INTERNATIONAL INSTRUMENTS ON CHEMICAL AND
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENTAND INDIA ............................... 65
3.1 Background for International Regulation in Chemical and Hazardous Waste
Management ....................................................................................................... 65
3.2 Quick factsheet of the Conventions ............................................................. 66
3.3 Basel Convention on the Transboundary Movement of Hazardous Wastes
and their Disposal (1989). ............................................................................... 67
3.4 Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain
Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade, 1998......... 71
3.5 Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants (2001) ............ 75
3.6 Strategic Approach to
International Chemicals Management (SAICM) (2006) ............................. 78
3.7 Minamata Convention on Mercury (2017) ................................................... 80
3.8 Indian Response and Compliance to the Conventions............................... 82
3.9 Matrix of International Law on Management of Hazardous Wastes
and Chemicals.................................................................................................. 104
CHAPTER 4
OVERVIEW OF THE CHEMICAL SECTOR IN INDIA .......................... 131

4.1 Background ...................................................................................................... 131
4.2 Role of the Chemical Sector as a contributor to Indian Economy ........ 132
4.3 Key drivers for growth of the Chemical Sector ........................................ 135
4.4 The functioning of the Chemical Sector ................................................... 140
4.5 Challenges faced in the Disposal, Storage and
Transportation of Hazardous Waste............................................................ 147
4.6 Bhopal Gas Tragedy- A Case of Inefficient Waste Disposal ................... 149
iv
NLSIU
4.7 Global outlook on the need for effective

Chemical Waste Management ....................................................................... 152
4.8 The Need for Regulation of the Chemical Sector in India ...................... 155
4.9 International Trade in Chemicals and the Indian Position....................... 160
4.10 Indian Regulation ............................................................................................ 169
CHAPTER 5
INDIAN REGULATIONS ON CHEMICAL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE
MANAGEMENT ........................................................................................... 177
5.1 Background ...................................................................................................... 177
5.2 The Legal Framework on Chemical and Hazardous Waste in India ...... 180
CHAPTER 6
LAW ON EMERGENCY, REMEDIAL AND PENAL ACTION IN RELATION
TO HAZARDS CAUSED BY CHEMICAL WASTE .................................... 281
6.1. Introduction to Chemical Accidents and Disasters: An Overview ....... 281
6.2 Chemical and Hazardous Substance Accidents and Disasters:
an overview of Environmental Consequences ......................................... 284
6.3 Chemical Accidents around the World:
Impact on the State of Environment .......................................................... 285
6.4 Chemical Accidents in India: Shortcomings of the Legal Regulations . 291
6.5 Reflecting on the Legal Framework: Which Laws were applicable?.... 295
6.6 Issues and Challenges in Production, Storage and Transport of
Chemicals in India: ......................................................................................... 297
6.7 The Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, (MSIHC)
1989 & Chemical Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness and
Response) Rules, (CAEPR) 1996; A Critical Appraisal........................... 300
******
v
NLSIU
vi
NLSIU
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The Handbook on Chemicals and Hazardous Waste Management and Handling in India
is a result of the research undertaken by the Centre for Environmental Law, Education,
Research and Advocacy (CEERA), National Law School of India University, Bengaluru.
CEERA expresses its gratitude to the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change (MoEF&CC), Government of India for granting the Three – Year project on
“Collaborative Engagement for Research, Training and Development in Handling of Chemical and
Hazardous Waste”. We express our sincere thanks to Mr. Manoj Kumar Gangeya,
Director, MoEF & CC, and to Mr. Dinesh Runiwal, Scientist-D at MoEF & CC’s
Office of Hazardous Substances Management, for guiding us in this project and coming
up with this Handbook.
CEERA would like to express earnest gratitude to our Vice Chancellor Prof. (Dr.) Sudhir
Krishnaswamy, for his encouragement in bringing forth our first publication under this
project. We are thankful to Prof. (Dr.) M.K. Ramesh, our mentor and guide, for providing
his rich insights and for his relentless support to CEERA and the entire team.
This handbook has been a result of the contributions from Ms. Madhubanti Sadhya
and Mr. Rohith Kamath, who are the lead authors and other notable contributions
from Ms. Raagya P. Zadu, Mr. Raghav Parthasarathy, Mr. Vikas Gahlot and
Ms. Geethanjali K.V, for putting in their efforts in bringing this publication.
Prof. (Dr.) Sairam Bhat

Coordinator, CEERA
Professor of Law, NLSIU
vii
NLSIU
viii
NLSIU
PREFACE
In the present times, the use of chemicals is crucial for the growth of any economy,
bearing in mind its application in almost all spheres of human activity. It is the mainstay
of several sections of the economy and contributes largely for the growth of the industrial
and agricultural sector by providing raw materials to a number of industries, including
textile, paper, paint, soap and detergent, pharmaceutical, bulk drugs and formulations,
agrochemicals. It also has extensive domestic application. Besides use of imported
chemicals in different industries, the chemical sector is an industry in its own right
producing a wide array of products such as inorganic chemicals, synthetic organic
chemicals like drugs and pharmaceuticals, dyes and intermediates, pigments, fine and
specialty chemicals, chlor-alkali, pesticides, colorants and alcohol based chemicals. India
ranks sixth in the world in the production of chemicals and fourth in the production of
agro-chemicals. India accounts for 16 per cent of the dye stuff and dye intermediaries
and is a global supplier of dyes. Excluding pharmaceutical products, the chemical industry
in India ranks 14th in global exports, employs more than 2 million people and its value is
expected to rise to 304 billion dollars by 2025.
While the use and importance of the chemical sector as one of the drivers of the economy
cannot be denied, the harmful effects that some chemical substances and the hazardous
waste generated through their use pose must not be disregarded. Chemical substances
and hazardous waste by their very nature and physical characteristics often lead to
significant hazards. Directly or indirectly, they pose major threats to human health and
the environment if not managed or utilised cautiously. The hazardous nature of chemical
substances and waste and the sheer magnitude of the Indian chemical industry, the wide
spectrum of products manufactured and the impact that the industry has on the safety
and livelihood of the persons engaged with the sector, makes it incumbent on the state
to devise a regulatory mechanism for the chemical industry. In keeping with the
requirements of the industry and the challenges it can pose, especially in terms of
environmental and health risk, the country has devised a comprehensive legislative
framework for the management of chemicals.
ix
NLSIU
The Handbook on Chemicals and Hazardous Waste Management and Handling in India
endeavours to give a broad overview of the legislative and regulatory framework governing
the chemical sector in India. Designed to serve as a ready reckoner for stakeholders
working in the field of chemicals and hazardous waste, such as members and officers of
the Pollution Control Boards, allied institutions of the Ministry of Environment, Forest
and Climate Change, other regulatory authorities, officials and employees of hazardous
waste management companies and chemical industries, importers and exporters of
chemicals and waste, the Handbook outlines the core objectives of the different Acts,
Rules and Regulations that regulate different aspects of chemicals and hazardous waste.
Much of the legislative framework in India that governs chemicals and hazardous waste
owes its origin to different Multilateral Environmental Agreements on hazardous waste,
to which India is a signatory. The Handbook also delineates the core principles of five
major Conventions on hazardous waste and the obligations that the country has to fulfil
in furtherance of their objectives. Spread across six chapters, the Handbook presents to
its readers a holistic picture of the chemical sector in India and attempts to apprise them
about the fundamental concepts that influence and govern chemical and hazardous waste
management and handling in the country.
Understanding the properties of chemical substances and hazardous wasteis pertinent,

since it enables persons dealing with these substances to identify their nature and gauge
how the substances could react under different conditions. The First Chapter, ‘Chemicals
and Hazardous Waste: Overview and Definition’ gives an overview of chemicals and
hazardous wastes and delineates the physical, chemical and hazardous properties of
chemical substances and hazardous waste that aids in their identification. The chapter
also discusses the Globally Harmonized System for Classification and Labelling of
Chemicals, the internationally harmonized system of organizing and labelling chemicals
and the criteria adopted by GHS for classifying chemical substances and mixtures
according to their health, environmental and physical hazards.
The Second Chapter, sheds light on the interventions of the international and regional
organisations in the field of chemical and hazardous waste management. Initiatives taken
x
NLSIU
up by international organizations to the likes of United Nations Environment Programme

(UNEP), Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), Global
Environment Facility (GEF), International Maritime Organisation, Inter-Organisation
Programme for the Sound Management of Chemicals and regional organizations like the
European Union, the African Union, and the North American Agreement on
Environmental Cooperation are delineated. The chapter presents the definition of
hazardous waste adopted by the different organizations and a comparison is made between
the definition of ‘hazardous waste’ in the legislative framework in India in contrast to
the ones adopted by international and regional organizations, to trace the genesis of the
definitions adopted in India and to gauge how far are they attuned to the international
standards and descriptions.
The Third Chapter, gives a brief summary of the five international instruments on chemical
and hazardous waste, namely the Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary
Movement of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal, the Rotterdam Convention on the
Prior Informed Consent Procedure for certain Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in
International Trade, the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants, the
Minamata Convention on Mercury and the Strategic Approach on International Chemicals
Management. The chapter presents salient features of the Conventions aided by illustrative
descriptions. The country’s obligations under each of the Conventions, steps taken towards
domestic application and its status of compliance are also presented in the chapter.
The Fourth Chapter, gives an overview of the chemical sector in India. The chapter focusses
on the role of the chemical sector as a contributor to the Indian economy, the functioning
of the chemical sector and the categories of chemical manufacturing industries, the
regulatory framework governing production and consumption of major chemicals,
chemical waste disposal and treatment facilities and their availability and coverage across
the states. The major challenges faced in the storage, disposal and transportation of
hazardous waste and the need for regulation of the chemical sector is also delineated.
The chapter presents a brief outline of the international trade in chemicals and the
Indian position regarding the same, the arguments for and against international trade in
xi
NLSIU
chemical and waste and the international and Indian regulations governing international
trade.
The Fifth Chapter, discusses the Indian regulations on chemical and hazardous waste
management. A detailed analysis of the Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous
Chemical Rules, 1989 [as amended in 2000], the Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation
and Control) Rules, 2000 [as amended in 2014] the Hazardous and Other Waste
(Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016 [as amended in 2019], the
E-Waste Management Rules, 2016, [as amended in 2018], the Plastic Waste Management
Rules, 2016 [as amended in 2018] and the Batteries (Management and Handling) Rules,
2001 [as amended in 2010]. The chapter presents the scope of application of these
Rules, criteria identified for the classification of waste, identified stakeholders and their
responsibilities and the different mechanisms identified for the treatment, storage, disposal,
labelling and transport of waste and the liabilities and penalties prescribed for their
contravention in a simple and reader friendly format. Some best practices adopted by
different countries in regulating and managing hazardous waste are discussed. A tabular
representation of the measures adopted by all Indian states in the management of
hazardous waste has been added in this chapter.
The Sixth Chapter, lays down the law on emergency, remedial and penal action in relation
to hazards caused by chemicals and hazardous waste. The effects of various disasters
and accidents in the chemical industry which have happened in the past, across the
world and their environmental consequences have been succinctly described. This chapter
also presents a critical appraisal of the Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous
Chemical Rules, 1989 and Chemical Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness and
Response) Rules, (CAEPR) 1996. The shortcomings of the existing provisions with
reference to the management of the accidents and emergency preparedness in the country
are also discussed.
This Handbook prepared and published as the first in a series of publications under the
Three-Year Project of the Ministry of Environment Forest and Climate Change on
xii
NLSIU
Collaborative Engagement for Research, Training and Development in Handling of

Chemical and Hazardous Waste, is designed to serve as a reference guide to the concerned
stakeholders to aid their understanding of the chemical industry, the chemical and
hazardous waste generated and the legislative and regulatory mechanism governing every
aspect of handling and managing chemicals and hazardous substances in India.
The team acknowledges the contributions made by Ms. Shyama Kuriakose, Independent
Consultant, Ms. Lianne D’Souza, Ms. Harita Ramachandran, Ms. Priyadarshini Venkatesh,
and Ms. Nayana J. M, Students from School of Law, Christ Deemed to be University in
the preparation of the Handbook.
Prof. (Dr.) M.K. Ramesh Prof. (Dr.) Sairam Bhat

Madhubanti Sadhya Rohith Kamath Raagya Zadu
Geethanjali K V Raghav Parthasarathy Vikas Gahlot
******
xiii
NLSIU
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
AU African Union
BRICS Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa
CCC Carriage of Cargoes and Containers
CiP Chemicals in Products
CPCB Central Pollution Control Board
CRC Convention and the Chemical Review Committee
EIA Environment Impact Assessment
ELV End of Life Vehicles
EPA Environment Protection Agency
ESM Environmentally Sound Management
EU European Union
FAO Food and Agriculture Organisation
FDI Foreign Direct Investment
GATT General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade
GDP Gross Domestic Product
GEF Global Environment Facility
GHS Globally Harmonized System for Classification and Labelling of Chemicals
GoI Government of India
GVA Gross Value Added
HEAL Health and Environmental Alliance
ICCM International Conference on Chemicals Management
IGCS Indo-German Centre for Sustainability
ILO International Labour Organization
IMCO Inter-Governmental Maritime Consultative Organisation
xiv
NLSIU
IMDG International Maritime Dangerous Goods

IMO International Maritime Organization
IOMC Inter-Organization Programme for the Sound Management of Chemicals
IPEN International POPs Elimination Network
IPM Integrated Pest Management
IVM Integrated Vector Management
LDCs Least Developed Countries
MAH Major Accident Hazard
MEA Multilateral Environment Agreements
MoEF&CC Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change
MTA Metric Tonnes/Annum
NAFTA North American Free Trade Agreement
ODP Ozone Depleting Potential
ODS Ozone Depleting Substances
OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development
PCPIRs Petroleum, Chemical and Petrochemical Investment Regions
POPs Persistent Organic Pollutants
SAICM Strategic Approach to International Chemicals Management
SDGs Sustainable Development Goals
SLF Secured Landfills
SPCB State Pollution Control Board
SPREP Secretariat of the Pacific Region Environment Programme
TEPA Trade and Economic Partnership Agreement
TSDFs Treatment, Storage & Disposal Facilities
UN United Nations
xv
NLSIU
UNCED United Nations Conference on Environment and Development

UNDP United Nations Development Programme
UNEA United Nations Environment Assembly
UNEP United Nations Environment Programme
UNIDO United Nations Industrial Development Organization
WEEE Waste of Electronic or Electrical Equipment
WHO World Health Organisation
3Rs Reduce, Reuse and Recycle
xvi
NLSIU
Hand Book on Chemicals and Hazardous Waste Management and Handling in India
1
CHEMICALS AND HAZARDOUS WASTE -
OVERVIEW AND DEFINITIONS
1.1 UNDERSTANDING CHEMICAL SUBSTANCES:
The Oxford Dictionary defines a chemical as “a distinct compound or substance, especially

one which has been artificially prepared or purified”.1 Any substance consisting of matter
which may be in the form of solids, liquids or gases is a chemical. The most naturally
occurring chemical in the gaseous form is oxygen. Minerals such as copper and zinc are
chemicals in the solid form that are found naturally. A chemical substance is any material
that has a definite chemical composition. The Compendium on Chemical Terminology
compiled by A. D. McNaught and A. Wilkinson defines a chemical substance as a “matter
of constant composition best characterized by the entities (molecules, formula units,
atoms) it is composed of. Physical properties such as density, refractive index, electric
conductivity, melting point etc. characterize the chemical substance.”2 Like chemicals,
chemical substances may take the form of solids, liquids or gases and may change from
one form to the other when exposed to changes in temperature or pressure. A chemical
substance may be an element such as iron, zinc or gold or a compound made up of
elements of more than one chemical such as sucrose or sugar that is made up of the
elements carbon, hydrogen and oxygen. Chemical substances may occur naturally, such
as water that is the most naturally occurring liquid chemical substance made up of
hydrogen and oxygen or be artificially made. Artificial or man-made chemical compounds
1 The Oxford Learner’s Dictionary, Available at: https://www.oxford learners dictionaries.com/definition/

english/chemical_1?q=chemical (Last accessed on October 10, 2019).
2 IUPAC. Compendium of Chemical Terminology, 2nd ed. (The “gold book”) Compiled by A. D.
Mcnaught and A. Wilkinson. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford (1997). Online Version (2019-)
Created by S. J. Chalk. ISBN 0-9678550-9-8. https://doi.org/10.1351/goldbook.
1
NLSIU
Chemicals and Hazardous Waste - Overview and Definitions
comprising of elements of different chemicals have revolutionized several sectors. Ethyl

glycol used as antifreeze, aspirin the famous pain relieving drug, aspartame used as an
artificial sweetener and teflon used as coating in non-stick cookware are some of the
well-known examples of man-made chemical substances.
In the present times, chemicals have become an indispensable part of our lives. Chemical
substances are used to sustain life in several ways and are used in food and household
products, agricultural products, pharmaceuticals etc. Humans are exposed to chemicals
everyday through multiple routes which include but are not limited to ingestion (eating
or swallowing), inhalation, skin contact and via the umbilical cord to the unborn child. It
can be clearly stated that not all chemical substances are harmful and a number of them
are used by individuals and families across the globe on a daily basis with little or no side-
effects, some of which include common salt (sodium chloride), baking powder (sodium
bicarbonate), detergent (sodium sulphate), mouthwash (hydrogen peroxide), aspirin (acetyl
salicylic acid). However, there are some other chemicals and chemical substances that
people get exposed to in their day to day lives that can be highly hazardous and pose
negative effects to our health and the environment when improperly managed. Some
conventional examples of such chemical substances are arsenic that could result in chronic
arsenic poisoning that passes on to humans through groundwater containing naturally
high levels of inorganic arsenic, food prepared with this water, and food crops irrigated
with high arsenic water sources; formaldehyde, a carcinogen used in the production of
plywood, building insulation, paper napkins, towels and tissues; mercury that has different
toxic effects on the nervous, digestive and immune systems, lungs, kidneys, skin and
eyes and reaches humans through air pollution, industrial waste, consumption of some
varieties of fish that accumulate higher concentrations of the chemical; and lead that one
gets exposed to through lead based paint and lead contaminated dust that can have
multiple ill effects including the neurologic, hematologic, gastrointestinal, cardiovascular,
and renal system failure, stunted growth and delayed development in children.3 There are
several other chemicals that affect the environment and human health in more ways than
one.
3 See generally, Ten Chemicals of Major Public Health Concern. World Health Organization,
Available at: https://www.who.int/ipcs/features/10chemicals_en.pdf ?ua=1. (Last accessed on 16,
November 2019).
2
NLSIU
Data released by the World Health Organization reflects that nearly 1.6 million lives and
45 million disability-adjusted life-years were lost in 2016 due to exposures to selected
chemicals. This however, accounts for data available with regard to a relatively small
number of chemical exposures, when in fact people are exposed to many more chemicals
every day. Approximately 1 million deaths across the globe result from unintentional
chemical poisoning, of which 78,000 can be considered preventable.4
Besides the adverse effects of chemical substances on human health, the environment
and ecosystem may also be deeply impacted through the long-term exposure of certain
chemicals or short term exposure of highly lethal and toxic chemicals released into water,
air and land. However, it is important to understand that chemical substances usually
pose a threat to the environment when it is released in large quantities, is toxic, persists
in the ecosystem is one form or the other or is transformed into a more toxic material and
targets living organisms whether plants, animals or humans.5
Irrespective of the effect that a chemical substance has on the human body, environment
or the ecology, whether good or bad it is a given that chemical substances are here to
stay, especially if we consider the diverse uses to which they are put starting from domestic,
agricultural, medicinal to industrial. Hence, it is important to understand some of the
basic properties of chemical substances. Understanding the properties of chemical
substances becomes pertinent, since it enables one to identify the nature of the substance
and to gauge how the substances could react and behave under different conditions. This
brings one to the properties of chemical substances.
1.2 CHEMICAL AND PHYSICAL PROPERTIES OF CHEMICAL

SUBSTANCES:
The characteristics that distinguish one substance from another are the physical and
chemical properties. The difference between physical and chemical properties of a chemical
4 See generally, Public Health Impact of Chemicals: Knowns and Unknowns, World Health Organization,
Available at: https://www.who.int/ipcs/publications/chemicals-public-health-impact/en/ (Last
accessed on 16, November 2019).
5 Donald R. Miller, ‘Chemicals In The Environment,’ In ‘Effects of Pollutants At The Ecosystem Level’,
(John Wiley & Sons Ltd, 1984).
3
NLSIU
substance is a very basic one. It is easier to witness the physical properties than the
chemical ones. The physical properties of a substance are the ones that can be witnessed
with the naked eye in the form of colour, smell, freezing point, boiling point, melting
point, viscosity, density etc. whereas chemical properties are those properties or behaviour
that a chemical substance exhibits when it undergoes a chemical change or reaction, for
instance; heat of combustion, reactivity with water and other substances, flammability,
stability under specific conditions, toxicity, corrosivity, etc.6 While physical properties of
a chemical substance in most cases help in the identification of the substance by
observation through the naked eye or by measurement and are not associated with change
in the chemical composition, there must be a chemical change or reaction for the chemical
property of a substance to be observed. Unlike physical properties, a chemical reaction
or change must occur for one to observe a chemical property of a chemical substance.7
An example of this could be the oxidation of iron to form rust. The fact that iron when
exposed to oxygen in the presence of water or moisture in the air turns into rust, is a
chemical property of iron, that would not be readily apparent when the physical properties
of iron are plainly studied. Since chemical properties of a chemical substance are not
obvious, they are included in labels for chemical containers.
Some of the common physical and chemical properties of chemical substances are physical
state - which may take the solid, liquid or gaseous form; colour; odor, or the property of
a substance that stimulates or is perceived by a sense of smell; vapour pressure; solubility;
density; gravity; evaporation rate; specific gravity; decomposition temperature; sensitivity
to shock or friction; boiling point; freezing point etc.8 These properties help in classification
of chemical substances and in managing them. Certain substances (mostly chemical)
require special care in their storage, both during and after use. Hence, proper knowledge
of care and management of each substance is mandatory so that it is not dangerous for
anyone handling these substances.
6 Cavallini S., et al., “Handbook on Chemical and Biological Waste Management”, 94 (2014).
7 Anne Marie Helmenstine, Chemical Property-definition and Example, Available at: https:
//www.thoughtco.com/definition-of-chemical-property-and-examples-604908, (Last accessed on
5, October 2019).
8 Supra note at 6, at 95-97.
4
NLSIU
In addition to the general dangers and hazards that chemical substances pose, maintaining
safety while dealing with chemicals is not merely dependent on its chemical and physical
properties and is inherently linked to other safety issues which include but are not limited
to engineering controls, laboratory procedures to which the chemical substances are
exposed, personal protective gear and equipment used by persons handling such
substances, electrical safety, fire safety; means and methods of hazardous waste disposal.
Besides the general physical and chemical properties of chemical substance, another set
of properties that deserves a mention are the hazardous properties of chemical substances,
especially when the subject being deliberated upon is chemical and waste management.
Many chemicals have properties that make them hazardous. For instance, the chemicals
may pose physical hazards if they result in fire or explosion, especially when they are
highly inflammable, and/or cause health hazards owing to their toxicity or carcinogenic
property or result in chemical burns etc. Many such chemical substances are categorized
as hazardous chemical waste. It is therefore important to have some understanding about
the hazardous properties of chemical substances. It is important to clarify at the outset
that there is considerable overlap between chemical and hazardous properties of chemical
substances. Most hazardous properties of a chemical substance are their chemical
properties as well.
1.3 HAZARDOUS PROPERTIES OF CHEMICAL SUBSTANCES
Hazardous properties, as the name suggests, are those properties which can cause harm
to our person or the surroundings. These properties generally come to the fore if the
chemical substance possessing such a property is not handled with due care and caution
or is exposed to any substance to which it is reactive. For example, exposure to specific
chemicals in relatively low concentrations over a period may result in chronic effects. On
the other hand, at higher concentrations, the effects may be acute. For some chemicals
damage is caused at the point of their contact or as soon as they enter into the body,
whereas for other chemicals they need to be transported to different organs of the body
before their adverse effects become apparent.9
9 Phillip Carson and Clive Mumford, Hazardous Chemicals Handbook, 94 (2nd ed. Butterworth
Heinemann 2012).
5
NLSIU
In simple words hazardous properties are those properties that help in the assessment of
the adverse impact or danger that a substance can pose. The evaluation of the hazardous
properties of a chemical substance help in the identification of both physical hazards
such as flammability, reactivity or health hazards such as carcinogenicity, toxicity or
sensitization etc. It also helps in the determination of environmental hazards that the
substance can pose. Besides, assisting in the assessment of their hazardous properties
and the impact that these substances have on the health and environment, hazard
assessment helps to train employees and persons engaged in the handling of these
substances and also in the labelling of these substances for proper identification. Akin to
chemical substances, often chemical waste is categorized as ‘hazardous’ owing to their
chemical reactivity, toxicity, explosiveness, corrosiveness, radioactivity or other
characteristics, that constitute a risk to human health or the environment.
There are different parameters suggested by different frameworks and directives under
different Conventions, international and regional organizations and national legislations
and regulations that provide a framework for the classification of chemicals and chemical
waste as hazardous. When a chemical or chemical waste exhibits or fulfils one or more
parameters or properties it is referred to as hazardous. Of the different parameters and
properties, there are four hazardous properties that are usually associated with chemical
substances and wastes which have been briefly explained below:
1.3.1 EXPLOSIVITY
Explosivity is the property of an explosive substance which could either be a solid or

liquid substance (or mixture of substances) which is in itself capable by chemical reaction
of producing gas at such a temperature and pressure and at such a speed as to cause
damage to the surroundings.10 Due to this property, the chemical substances are triggered
by heat, shock, friction or other impulses to a rapid chemical reaction, decomposition or
combustion which leads to rapid generation of heat and gases with a combined volume
10 Definition of Explosives, International Labour Organisation, Available at: https:

//Www.ilo.org/legacy/english/protection/safework/ghs/ghsfinal/ghsc1528.pdf. (Last accessed on
October 11, 2019).
6
NLSIU
much larger than the original substance.11 Two common parameters to judge the explosivity
of a substance are defined as Upper Explosive Limit and Lower Explosive Limit.
1.3.2 FLAMMABILITY
The ability of a chemical substance to burn or ignite, causing fire or combustion is known
as its flammability. Usually materials are rated as highly flammable, flammable and non-
flammable. 12 Flammability of a substance usually refers to its self-sustained combustion
or ability to burn. Heat generated when the substance gets oxidised (combine chemically
with oxygen) must be adequate to make up for the heat lost or dissipated and to heat up
the substance to its ignition temperature. This however, depends upon several factors
including the environment in which the substance is placed. For instance some substances
are flammable only in fresh air, while other substances burn only when they are in the
environment of fresh oxygen. Flammability is measured by certain parameters which
include Lower Flammability Limit and Upper Flammability Limit usually associated with
flammability of gases. Lower Flammability Limit or the Lower Explosive Limit refers to
the lower limit of fuel concentration below which the gas does not allow self-sustained
burning. On the other hand, Upper Flammability Limit refers to the highest concentration
of the gas in the air, to the extent that the concentration of air is decreased to such as
point where burning again cannot be sustained. For liquids, flammability is measured on
the basis of flash point or the temperature necessary for the liquid to ignite. It is the lowest
temperature at which vapour given off by a liquid pool form an ignitable mixture with
air. Another parameter in relation of liquid substances and their flammability is dependent
on what is known as the fire point. The liquid temperature required to produce sufficient
vapour to ensure that the fire that has started is sustained by the heat generated from the
flames is termed as the fire point.13 Auto-ignition temperature is another parameter used
11 Explosives, Ilpi, Available at: http://www.ilpi.com/msds/ref/explosive.html, (Last accessed on

October 11, 2019).
12 Flammability, Chemsafetypro, Available at: https://www.chemsafetypro.com/topics/cra/
flammability.html (Last accessed on October 11, 2019).
13 C.J. Fry, ‘Flammability’, Thermopedia, Available at http://www.thermopedia.com/content/767/
(Last accessed on October 11, 2019); See also SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineering, National
Fire Protection Association Quincy, Massachusetts, (3rd ed. 2002).
7
NLSIU
to gauge the flammability of chemical substances. As a flammable property it is defined

as the lowest temperature at which a gas or vapour spontaneously ignites without the
presence of any ignition source. Flammability as a hazardous property is generally
dependent on more than one factor such as pressure, temperature, environment, the
vessel in which the chemical is being carried etc.14
1.3.3 TOXICITY
Toxicity can be defined as the property of a substance of being toxic or poisonous. In

other words it is the property of a substance to cause injury once it is inside the body of
human or animals or both. Some of the primary modes through which toxic chemicals
can enter the body is by way of inhalation, ingestion and absorption through the skin.
Hazardous chemicals in the form of gases, vapours, mists, dusts, fumes and aerosols are
often inhaled or come in contact with the skin and affect the skin, eyes and mucous
membranes. Although ingestion is rare, it may be possible to accidentally consume some
hazardous chemicals as a result of poor personal hygiene, subconscious hand-to-mouth
contact, or accidents. While the skin may not show any immediate effect of contact with
a hazardous substance, it provides a route for substances to enter the body owing to its
permeable feature.15 If the effect that a hazardous substance with toxic properties has on
the human body is to be judged, it could be categorised under three heads: acute toxicity
in which the harmful effects of the hazardous substance on an organism becomes known
or apparent after a single or short term exposure; sub-chronic toxicity refers to the ability
of the hazardous substance to affect the exposed organism for more than a year but less
than its lifetime. Lastly, chronic toxicity arises when harmful effects are caused to the
exposed organism over an extended period of time which may extend up to its lifetime;
usually due to repeated or continuous exposure of the harmful substance on the organism.16
14 Ann Marie Fauske, “Flammability Testing: Flash Point Versus Auto-ignition Temperature”, Available
at: https://www.fauske.com/blog/do-you-know-your-flash-point-from-your-ait-test-in-flammability-
testing. (Last accessed on October 12, 2019).
15 Phillip Carson and Clive Mumford, Hazardous Chemicals Handbook, 67(2 nd ed. Butterworth
Heinemann 2012).
16 National Research Council, Pesticides in the Diets of Infants and Children, 127-158 (Washington,
Dc: The National Academies, 1993). Available at https://doi.org/10.17226/2126. (Last accessed on
October 12, 2019).
8
NLSIU
In so far as the assessment of toxic parameters of hazardous substances are concerned,

there are a number of indicators that are usually employed, but the most common are the
LD50 and the LC50. Apart from these indicators there are a wide range of techniques for
assessment of skin and eye irritation, skin sensitization, mutagenicity, acute and chronic
dermal and inhalation toxicity, reproductive toxicology, carcinogenicity, neurotoxicity,
endocrine disruptors, genotoxicity etc.17 LD stands for ‘lethal dose’ and LD50 is the
statistically derived single dosage of a substance that can be expected to cause death in
50% of the sample population of the animal/organism on which it is tested. It therefore
indicates acute toxicity or short term poisoning potential of an organism. The affect that
a toxic substance would have on an organism is also dependent on the species, sex, age,
etc. LC50 also used to measure acute toxicity of chemicals through the air breathed or in
water is the ‘lethal concentration’ of a chemical or chemical substance (e.g. in air or
water) that will cause the death of 50% of the sample population of the animals/
organisms on which it is tested. Toxic substances are tested on animals and their toxicity
rating may range between extremely toxic, highly toxic, moderately toxic, slightly toxic,
non-toxic or harmless.18
While tests to determine toxicity are conducted on animals, primarily rats and mice in
general, if the immediate toxicity is similar in all of the different animals tested, the
degree of immediate toxicity is likely to be similar for humans. When the LD50 values of
a particular toxic substance is different for animal species, approximations and assumptions
have to be made to estimate the probable lethal dose of the substance on man. The
toxicity of hazardous substances that are gauged on the basis of LD50 and LC50 for humans
may range from 1 grain, 1 teaspoon, 1 pint to 1 quart of the substance to form a lethal
dose for humans depending upon their weight, age etc. Different chemical substances
may affect different organs of the human body, but it is difficult to measure with certainty
which of these chemicals are more harmful. Thus, to compare the toxic potency of
different chemical or hazardous substances, the lethality test is carried out using these
17 Toxicity Testing Overview, Alttox.org, Available at: http: //alttox.org/mapp/toxicity-testing-overview/

(Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
18 Phillip Carson and Clive Mumford, Hazardous Chemicals Handbook, 81(2 nd ed. Butterworth
Heinemann 2012).
9
NLSIU
two parameters since it measures how much of a chemical is needed to cause the same
effect or in this case, death of the sample population of animals tested.19 Other parameters
for measuring toxicity includes TLV or threshold limit value 20 and OEL or occupational exposure
limit, percutaneous absorption etc.
1.3.4 CORROSIVITY
The property of a hazardous substance or chemical to eat away, erode or corrode is

known as its corrosivity. It is derived from the word ‘corrosion’ which literally means
wearing away or deterioration of a material or its properties due to chemical or electro-
chemical reaction with components of its environment.21 It normally occurs when a
chemical substance in the gaseous or liquid form chemically attacks an exposed surface
and its effect on the surface attacked could be accelerated due to temperature, pressure
or the environment in which the substance reacts to the substance attacked.22 A hazardous
substance or chemical that exhibits this property has the ability to damage or destroy
other substances when they come into contact and can severely attack a number of
materials, including organic compounds and metals. In addition to metals and other
chemical substances with which a corrosive substance reacts, living tissues can also be
greatly affected by the corrosivity of a substance. The effect of corrosive substances on
living and non-living substances is quite distinct.23
The U.S. Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), a federal government
agency of the Department of Labour defines corrosives “...a chemical that produces
destruction of skin tissue, namely, visible necrosis through the epidermis and into the
dermis, in at least 1 of 3 tested animals after exposure up to a 4-hour duration. Corrosive
19 What is Ld50 And Lc50?, Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety, Available at: https://
www.ccohs.ca/oshanswers/chemicals/Ld50.html (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
20 This represents the concentration of a substance in the air to which a person can be exposed or which
can be inhaled day after day without causing any adverse health effects.
21 Vivekanand Kain, In S. Bannerjee and A.k. Tyagi, Functional Materials: Preparation, Processing and Application,
507 (Elsevier, 2012).
22 Corrosion., Brittanica, Available at: https://www.britannica.com/science/corrosion. (Last accessed on
November 16, 2019).
23 Corrosivity, Corrosionpedia, Available at: https://www.corrosionpedia.com/definition/339/corrosivity
10
NLSIU
reactions are typified by ulcers, bleeding, bloody scabs and, by the end of observation at
14 days, by discoloration due to blanching of the skin, complete areas of alopecia and
scars…..”24 Hazardous substances with corrosive property pose immediate danger to
skin, tissues, eyes and other parts of the body. In so far as the effect of corrosives on
human tissue is concerned, a distinction can be drawn between non-penetrating corrosive
substances that form a protective layer after reacting with the human tissue and limits
the extent of damage. Penetrating corrosives on the other hand enter the eyes and skin
deeply and require greater efforts for flushing them out. Rust and electrochemical oxidation
is forms of corrosion that affect metals.25
Besides the aforementioned properties, there are other properties that a substance or
chemical may exhibit to be deemed hazardous such as radioactivity and carcinogenicity.
In the present time and age, when the use of chemicals and the consequent release of
chemical waste, a sizeable portion of which can be deemed to be hazardous has become
indispensable, understanding the properties that make them hazardous and adopting
precautions while handling and disposing of them can ensure that minimum damage is
caused to the persons handling them and eventually the environment.
1.4 GLOBALLY HARMONIZED SYSTEM FOR CLASSIFICATION AND

LABELLING OF CHEMICALS (GHS)
Chemical substances by their very nature and physical characteristics often lead to
significant hazards in various aspects. Directly or indirectly, they pose a major threat to
human health and the environment if not managed or utilised cautiously. In preventing
or minimising the dangers arising from chemical substances, it is imperative to classify
them on the basis of their chemically reactive nature, identity the kinds of hazards they
pose to health and environment. Such classification not only aids in identifying the possible
hazards caused by different types of chemicals but also help to undertake necessary
preventive measure to reduce such hazards.
24 Health Hazard Criteria (Mandatory), Appendix A to the Hazard Communication Standard, 29 Cfr
1910.1200. Available at: http://www.ilpi.com/msds/osha/1910_1200_app_a.html#a.2.2.1.1.
( Last accessed on October 11, 2019).
25 Corrosive, ILPI, Available at: http://www.ilpi.com/msds/ref/corrosive.html (Last accessed on
October 11, 2019).
11
NLSIU
The first time when the question of having a system for the classification of chemicals
was raised was at the UN Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro in 1992 and further at the
World Summit on Sustainable Development in 2002 in Johannesburg.26At the Earth
Summit in1992, the International Labour Organization (ILO), the Organisation for
Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), various governments and other
stakeholders agreed upon the need of developing a globally harmonized hazard
classification and compatible labeling system. The United Nations Organisation adopted
the Globally Harmonized System for Classification and Labelling of Chemicals in the
wake of the growing international market of chemical mixtures and substances, to
facilitate trade and also to save people from the hazards which can be caused by chemicals.
Most countries and organizations have developed regulations for the labelling of chemicals
that identifies the chemicals and the hazards they pose and the protective measures to be
implemented. But the differences in the existing laws and regulations have resulted in
differences in labelling for same chemicals that come from different countries. Hence,
some chemical that is labelled flammable in one country may not be considered flammable
in another country. Acknowledging the extent of international trade in chemicals and the
importance of a uniform labelling framework and the need for national rules that
ensure safety in the use, transport and disposal of chemicals, it was recognized that an
internationally harmonized system of labelling and classifying chemicals would
be imperative.27
So, given the gravity of the situation, GHS was recognised as an approach that was
harmonized internationally to organise and label chemical substances. Its aim is to ensure
that all the information on toxicity and hazards from chemical substances must be made
available and accessible so that the protection of both, the health of humans and that of
the environment during the management, transport and use of such substances, can be
26 Background: Globally Harmonised System, Health and Safety Executive (UK), Available at: http://
www.hse.gov.uk/chemical-classification/legal/background-directives-ghs.htm( Last accessed on October
11, 2019).
27 Globally Harmonized System for Classification and Labelling of Chemicals (GHS), Ch.1.1.1.1.2
(8th ed. 2019) Available at: http://www.unece.org/trans/danger/publi/ghs/ghs_rev08/08files_ e.html
12
NLSIU
done efficiently.28 GHS was adopted in 2002 by the UN and published for the first time
in 2003. Since then, it has been revised and enhanced eight times, the latest revision
being in the year 2019.29 The scope of GHS includes the following30:
 A harmonized criteria for classifying chemical substances and mixtures

according to their health, environmental and physical hazards;
 A harmonized system for the communication of hazard elements;(for instance

pictograms and labels; symbol such a flame, gas cylinder etc, signal word
such as ‘danger’; ‘warning’; and hazard statement such as “Chemical under
pressure: May explode if heated), including requirements for labelling and
safety data sheets.
This classification is done by way of types of hazard and is aimed at making available all
information on hazards (such as acute toxicity, non-flammable etc.) from chemicals in
order to enhance the protection of human health and the environment during the handling,
transport and use of these chemicals. Furthermore, the GHS provides a basis for
harmonization of rules and regulations on chemicals at national, regional and worldwide
level and a systematic compliance framework for industries dealing with chemical
substances.31
(8th ed. 2019) Available at: http://www.unece.org/trans/danger/publi/ghs/ghs_rev08/08files_e.html
31 Cavallini S., et al., “Handbook on Chemical and Biological Waste Management”, 100 (2014).
13
NLSIU
Enhancing the protection of human

health and the environment by
providing an internationally
comprehensible system for hazard
communication.
Providing a recognized framework

for those countries without an
existing system.
Reducing the need for testing and

evaluation of chemicals.
Facilitating international
trade in chemicals whose
hazards have been properly
assessed and identified on
an international basis.
NEED FOR HARMONISED SYSTEM OF LABELLING AS PER GHS
The GHS also mandates guidance for the preparation of safety data sheets. An SDS is a
detailed and all-inclusive report containing information about a substance for use in
regulatory framework. It is used by both workers and employers as a source of information
about hazards, including the environmental ones, and also provides data on safety
precautions.32 Besides the GHS, the International Hazard Communication Standard (HCS)
requires chemical manufacturers to communicate a chemical’s hazard information to
chemical handlers by providing a Safety Data Sheet. All information required such as
chemical properties, health and environmental hazards, protective measures, as well as
safety precautions for storing, handling, and transporting chemicals are reflected in Safety
Data Sheets.33 The GHS Eight Revised edition is divided into four parts; each part
33 Safety Data Sheet, Chemical Safety, Available at: https://chemicalsafety.com/sds-search/(Last accessed
on November 16, 2019).
14
NLSIU
corresponding to a particular kind of hazard - physical, health and environmental and 11

Annexes.
Chemical substances and mixtures fall under three heads: Hazard Group; Hazard Class
and Hazard Category. The different types of hazards comprised within a hazard group
are called hazard class. For instance gases under pressure and self-reactive substances
and mixtures fall under the ‘physical’ hazard group. The sub-categories under a hazard
class are termed as hazard categories. For instance flammable liquids a hazard class under
the Physical Hazard group are classified into 4 categories based on their flash point and
initial boiling point.
Each Hazard Category has rules or criteria to determine what chemicals are assigned to
that category. Each Category has numbers (or letters) with category 1 (or A) being the
most hazardous. Taking the example of the Group Health Hazard; carcinogenicity would
be a Hazard Class and Carcinogenicity 1A would be a Hazard category.
Many questions may arise as to the applicability of GHS. In this regard certain parameters
have been set. GHS covers all chemicals that are hazardous and its target audiences
include consumers, workers, transport workers and emergency responders. However,
hazard communication elements of the GHS such as labels and safety data sheets vary
according to the product category or stage in the life cycle.34 Apart from containing a
harmonized classification criteria for chemicals labelling norms, the GHS document also
provides assistance and guidance to countries and organizations in developing tools for
implementation of the GHS. The GHS is designed in a way to allow self-classification
and the uniform development of national policies on classification of chemicals. It also
provides flexibility to accommodate any special requirements that a nation may have to
meet.35
35 Ibid, Ch. 1.1.4.
15
NLSIU
To put it succinctly, it can be said that GHS aims to deliver certain benefits such as
facilitating trade, promoting efficiency in regulation, and the most important issues of
safe handling, transport and use of chemicals. GHS provides harmonized criteria for
classifying chemical substances and mixtures according to their health, environmental
and physical hazards. The following section deals with each of these categories and the
chemical substances that are enlisted under each of the three heads.
1.4.1 PHYSICAL HAZARDS
In terms of the physical hazards, the chemical substances have been categorised by the
GHS as follows36:
NO. OF
HAZARD CLASS GHS SYMBOL
CATEGORIES
Explosives: An explosive substance (or mixture) Unstable
has been defined as a solid or liquid substance (or
Explosives – 1
mixture of substances) which is in itself capable
by chemical reaction of producing gas at such a Explosives
temperature and pressure and at such a speed as
Division 1.1-1.6
to cause damage to the surroundings. Pyrotechnic
substances are included even when they do not
evolve gases. Pyrotechnic substance (or mixture)
has been defined as a substance or mixture designed
to produce an effect by light, sound, gas, smoke
or a combination of these as a result of non-
detonating, self-sustaining exothermic chemical
reactions. All explosive substance, mixture or
article37 other than unstable explosives are assigned
one out of six divisions depending on the type of
hazard they present which could range from mass
explosion, a fire hazard or a minor blast etc.
36 Ibid, Part 2.
37 An explosive article is an article containing one or more explosive substances.
16
NLSIU
Flammable gases: A gas having a flammable Three categories -

range with air at 20 °C and a standard pressure of 1A, 1B and 2
101.3 kPa. They are differentiated from pyrophoric
gases and chemically unstable gases. A pyrophoric
gas is a flammable gas that is liable to ignite
spontaneously in air at a temperature of 54 degree
Celsius or below. Whereas, a chemically unstable
gas is a flammable gas that is able to react
explosively even in the absence of air or oxygen.
Aerosols: Aerosols are non-refillable receptacle Three categories:

made of metal, glass or plastics and containing 1, 2 and 3
gas compressed, liquefied or dissolved under
pressure, with or without a liquid, paste or powder
and fitted with a release device allowing the
contents to be ejected as solid or liquid particles in
suspension in a gas, as a foam, paste or powder or
in a liquid state or a gaseous state. However, they
do not include gases under pressure. Aerosols
should be considered for classification as
flammable if they contain any component which
is classified as flammable according to the GHS
criteria, i.e., flammable liquids; flammable gases and
flammable solids.
Oxidising Gases: An oxidising gas is classified One Category

under a single category, and is any gas which may,
generally by providing oxygen contribute to the
combustion of other material more than air.
Gases under pressure: Gases which are contained Four Categories:

in a receptacle at a pressure not less than 200 kPa Compressed gases,
at 20 °C or as a refrigerated liquid. They comprise Liquefied gases,
of, depending on their physical state when Dissolved gases and
packaged. Refrigerated
liquefied gases.
17
NLSIU
Flammable liquids: Flammable liquid is a liquid Four categories: 1,

having a flash point of not more than 93°C. 2, 3 and 4 based on
Flammable liquids are classified into 4 categories flash point and
based on their flash point and initial boiling point. initial boiling point.
Flammable solids are solids which are readily Two categories:

combustible, or may cause or contribute to fire 1 and 2 based on
through friction. Readily combustible solids are burning rate test
powdered, granular, or pasty substances which are and burning time
dangerous if they can be easily ignited by brief
contact with an ignition source, such as a burning
match, and if the flame spreads rapidly. They are
put under two categories.
Self-reactive substances and mixtures: These Seven categories:

include thermally unstable liquid or solid substances Types A – G
or mixtures liable to undergo a strongly exothermic divided on the basis
decomposition even without participation of of principles under
oxygen (air). This definition excludes substances and Chapter 2.8
mixtures classified under the GHS as explosives,
organic peroxides or as oxidizing. A self-reactive
substance or mixture is regarded as possessing
explosive properties when in laboratory testing the
formulation is liable to detonate, to deflagrate
rapidly or to show violent effect when heated under
confinement.
Pyrophoric liquids are liquids which, even in small One Category

quantities, can ignite within five minutes after
coming into contact with air.
Pyrophoric solids are solids that even in small One Category

quantities, can ignite within five minutes after
coming into contact with air.
18
NLSIU
Self-heating substances and mixtures: A self- Two Categories: 1

heating substance or mixture is a solid or liquid and 2 classified in
substance or mixture, other than a pyrophoric liquid accordance with
or solid, which, by reaction with air and without test N.4 under
energy supply, is liable to self-heat. It differs from GHS
a pyrophoric liquid or solid in that it will ignite only
when in large amounts (kilograms) and after long
periods of time (hours or days).
Substances and mixtures which, in contact with Three Categories: 1,

water, emit flammable gases are substances or 2 and 3 classified in
mixtures which, by interaction with water, are liable accordance with
to become spontaneously flammable or to give off test N.5 under
flammable gases in dangerous quantities. GHS
Oxidizing liquid: A liquid which, while in itself Three Categories: 1,

not necessarily combustible, may, generally by 2 and 3 classified in
yielding oxygen, cause, or contribute to, the accordance with
combustion of other material. test O.2 under
GHS
Oxidizing solids: A solid which, while in itself is Three Categories: 1,

not necessarily combustible, may, generally by 2 and 3 classified in
yielding oxygen, cause, or contribute to, the accordance with
combustion of other material. test O.1 and O.3
under GHS
Organic peroxides: Liquid or solid organic Seven categories:

substances which contain the bivalent -0-0 structure Types A – G
and may be considered derivatives of hydrogen divided on the basis
peroxide, where one or both of the hydrogen of principles under
atoms have been replaced by organic radicals. The Chapter 2.15
term also includes organic peroxide formulations
(mixtures). Organic peroxides are thermally unstable
substances or mixtures, which may undergo
exothermic self-accelerating decomposition. In
addition, they may have one or more of the
following properties: (a) be liable to explosive
19
NLSIU
decomposition; (b) burn rapidly; (c) be sensitive

to impact or friction; (d) react dangerously with
other substances.
Corrosive to metals: A substance or a mixture One Category

that is corrosive to metal is a substance or a
mixture which by chemical action will materially
damage, or even destroy, metals.
Desensitized Explosive: They are solid or liquid Four categories: 1,

explosive substances or mixtures which are 2, 3 and 4 based
rendered less sensitive to suppress their explosive on ‘burning rate
properties in such a manner that they do not mass test’
explode or do not burn too rapidly and therefore
are exempted from the hazard class of
‘explosives’.
1.4.2 HEALTH HAZARDS
In terms of the health hazards, the chemical substances have been categorised by the
GHS as follows:38
NO. OF
CATEGORIES
Acute Toxicity: Acute toxicity refers to serious Five categories :
adverse effects or lethality after oral, dermal or 1,2,3,4 and 5
inhalation (of gases, vapours, dusts or mist)
exposure of a substance or mixture. Measured on
the basis of Acute Toxicity Estimates or LD50
(oral/dermal) and LC50 (inhalation).
38 Ibid, Part 3.
20
NLSIU
Skin corrosion/irritation - Skin Corrosion is the Three categories:

production of irreversible damage to the skin; Category 1 further
namely, visible necrosis through the epidermis and sub-divided into
into the dermis, following the application of a test categories 1A, 1B
substance for up to 4 hours. Skin Irritation is the and 1C to be used
production of reversible damage to the skin by authorities
following the application of a test substance for up requiring more than
to 4 hours. one category;
Category 2 (skin
irritation) and
Category 3 (mild
skin irritation).
Serious Eye Damage and Irritation – Serious Two categories:

eye damage is the production of tissue damage in category 1 (serious
the eye, or serious physical decay of vision, not fully eye damage) and
reversible that occurs after exposure of the eye to category 2(eye
any substance or mixture. Eye irritation is the irritation)
production of changes in the eye, occurring after
exposure to any substance or mixture which is fully
reversible.
Respiratory or skin sensitization- A respiratory Two categories:

sensitizer is a substance that will induce Category 1
hypersensitivity of the airways following inhalation (Respiratory
of the substance. A skin sensitizer is a substance that sensitizers) -may be
will induce an allergic response following skin further sub-divided
contact. into 1A and 1B and
Category 2 (Skin
sensitizers) – may be
further sub-divided
into 2A and 2B
21
NLSIU
Germ cell mutagenicity- Chemicals the exposure Two categories

to which may cause mutations in the germ cells of
humans that can be transmitted to the progeny,
including chromosome aberrations.
Carcinogenicity - A chemical substance or a Two categories:

mixture of chemical substances which induce Category 1(known
cancer or increase its incidence. Substances which or presumed human
have induced benign and malignant tumours in well carcinogens further
performed experimental studies on animals are sub-divided into
considered also to be presumed or suspected categories 1A and
human carcinogens unless there is strong evidence 1B) and category 2
that the mechanism of tumour formation is not (suspected human
relevant for humans. carcinogens)
Reproductive toxicity refers to adverse effects Two categories:

on sexual function and fertility in adults and; Category 1(known
developmental toxicity in the offspring after or presumed human
exposure to a substance or mixture. reproductive toxicant
further sub-divided
into categories 1A
and 1B) and category
2 (suspected human
reproductive toxicant)
Specific target organ systemic toxicity - single Three categories:

exposure refers to specific, non-lethal toxic effects category 1(presumed
on target organs occurring after a single exposure to produce
to a substance or mixture. significant toxicity in
humans; category 2
(presumed to be
harmful to human
health) and category
3 (transient target
organ effects)
22
NLSIU
Specific target organ systemic toxicity - Two categories:

repeated exposure refers to specific, non-lethal category 1 (presumed
toxic effects on target organs occurring after to produce significant
repeated exposure to a substance or mixture. toxicity in humans)
and category 2
(presumed to be
harmful to human
health)
Aspiration hazard - refers to severe acute effects Two categories:

such as chemical pneumonia, varying degrees of category 1 (chemicals
pulmonary injury or death following aspiration of known to cause
a substance or mixture. human aspiration
toxicity hazard) and
category 2 (chemicals
presumed to cause
human aspiration
toxicity hazard)
1.4.3 ENVIRONMENT HAZARDS
In addition to physical and health hazards, the GHS identifies certain properties exhibited
by chemical substances that are hazardous to the environment. Under environmental
hazards, chemical substances and mixtures have been categorised under different heads
depending upon the part of the environment that they effect such as the aquatic
environment, the ozone layer. Under environment hazards, the chemical substances have
been categorised by the GHS as follows39
39 Ibid, Ch. 4.
23
NLSIU
NO. OF
CATEGORIES
Hazardous to the Aquatic Environment
Acute aquatic toxicity is the intrinsic property Short term (acute)
of a substance to be injurious to an organism in a hazard are out under
short-term exposure to that substance. three categories:
Acute 1, Acute 2 and
Chronic aquatic toxicity - potential or actual Acute 3. Long term
properties of a substance to cause adverse effects (chronic) hazard are
to aquatic organisms during exposures which are further classified
determined in relation to the life-cycle of the based on the
organism. availability of
adequate toxicity
data.
Hazardous to the Ozone Layer

Ozone Depleting Potential is an integrative One Category based
quantity, distinct for each halocarbon source species, on the Montreal
that represents the extent of ozone depletion in the Protocol.
stratosphere expected from the halocarbon on a
mass-for-mass relative to CFC-11.
An overview of this hazard classification reflects that it is necessary to categorize chemical

substances in order to understand the dangers that may emanate from them. At this
juncture it is noteworthy that the regime in India does not imbibe this classification by
the UNECE in toto. However, there have been positive actions to adopt this pattern of
categorizing chemical substances. In July 2011, the Ministry of Environment and Forests
published a draft document called Hazardous Substances (Classification, Packaging and
Labelling) Rules, 2011.40 Though these rules have not been officially adopted, they are
in tandem with the UN GHS. Furthermore, in May 2017, the Ministry of Environment,
Forest, and Climate Change formed the National Coordination Committee to prepare a
40 GHS India SDs Requirement, Chemsafetypro, Available at: https: //www.chemsafetypro.com/topics/

india/ghs_india_sds_requirements.html (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
24
NLSIU
National Action Plan for Chemicals for India. This National Action Plan is said to be a
positive step in revising the existing legislations and tuning them in line of the GHS.
While India is yet to adopt the GHS for classification of chemicals, India has certain
Safety Data Sheet requirements enlisted under Schedule 9 of the Manufacture, Storage
and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989 which to a great extent is compliant
with the GHS safety data sheet.
******
25
NLSIU
2
INTERVENTIONS OF INTERNATIONAL
ORGANISATIONS IN THE FIELD OF CHEMICAL AND
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT
2.1 INTRODUCTION
Hazardous waste and its proper management has been a major concern the world over
because of its wide ramifications. Hazardous waste not only causes grievous harm to the
environment, wildlife and human health, both immediate and long term, but it is also
lethal to all living things. The impact of hazardous waste transcends boundaries and
generations and while the immediate or first point of contact and impact may be the
environment or human and animal health, in the long run it has the potential of disrupting
communities, affecting populations placed close to sites of disposal or spillage and
devaluing property, thereby exhibiting social and economic effects.1
Hazardous waste has increased substantially over the years which further necessitate
strong systems and mechanism for their proper handling and disposal. Hazardous waste
definitions differ from one country to another. A generic definition might depend on
wastes or combinations of wastes that pose a substantial present or potential future
threat to the environment or human life. There are a multiplicity of reasons, that makes
hazardous waste unsafe. They are not readily degradable, they are pertinacious in the
environment and their effects can be felt over a long period of time, they are detrimental
to human and animal health and natural resources. Hazardous waste can arise from
various sources which range from industrial manufacturing process wastes to batteries2,
1 Michael R. Greenberg, Richard F. Anderson, and Kirk Rosenberger, Social and Economic Effects of
Hazardous Waste Management Sites, Hazardous Waste, Vol.1, No.3. Available at: https://
www.liebertpub.com/doi/abs/10.1089/hzw.1984.1.387. (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
2 Basics of Hazardous Waste, United Nations Environmental Protection Agency, Available at: https://
www.epa.gov/hw/learn-basics-hazardous-waste (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
26
NLSIU
agricultural land and agro-industries, domestic, mines and mineral processing sites,
healthcare facilities, industrial waste sources, institutional waste sources, commercial
waste, solid waste disposal sites, contaminated sites, building materials, etc. Hazardous
wastes may also emerge from waste oil and fuel; solvents and thinners; acids and bases/
alkaline; toxic or flammable paint wastes; chlorinated solvents, heavy metals, peroxides;
abandoned or used pesticides; and wastewater treatment sludge.3
Due to the wide range of harmful effects that hazardous waste poses, over many years,
different international and regional organizations across the globe have taken initiatives
to set up frameworks for the proper management, handling and disposal of such waste.
Right from 1865 when the first international intergovernmental organization – the
International Telecommunication Union was founded, international organizations have
aided in the setting up of international agendas to counter the problems plaguing the
world, in steering the attention of the member states to the issues that needed immediate
attention, in providing a platform for inter-state deliberation, coordination and cooperation.
Thus, international organizations have always played a pivotal role in addressing the
social, political, cultural and economic issues, and addressing environmental issues are
no exception. While some international organizations have been set up with the sole
objective of safeguarding the interests of the environment, there are others that take up
the cause of environment in addition to their central mandate. Even in the sphere of
Chemical and Hazardous Waste Management, numerous international organisations and
their agencies have contributed to the widespread awareness of handling and disposal of
chemical and hazardous wastes.
The following section briefly discusses some of the interventions made by organizations
and institutions set up in the international and regional level in the field of chemical and
hazardous waste management.
3 D. Grasso, D. Kahn, M. E. Kaseva, and S. E. Mbuligwe , Hazardous Waste Management – Hazardous Waste.
Available at: http://www.eolss.net/ebooks/sample%20chapters/C09/E1-08-00-00.pdf (Last accessed
27
NLSIU
Interventions of International Organisations in the Field of Chemical and
Hazardous Waste Management
2.2 ORGANIZATIONS WORKING IN THE FIELD OF CHEMICALS AND

HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AT THE INTERNATIONAL
LEVEL
2.2.1 UNITED NATIONS ENVIRONMENT PROGRAMME (UNEP)
The United Nations Environment Programme is one of the leading international

organizations working in the realm of environment protection. UNEP is vested with the
duty of coordinating the environmental activities of the United Nations and in assisting
the State actors in the implementation of sustainable policies and practices that benefit
the environment. It provides guidance to its member states to help them effectuate
environmentally safe and sound policies. UNEP headquartered at Nairobi, Kenya, carries
an operation of facilitating leadership and invigorating nations of the world to enter into
partnerships, thereby engaging them towards protection and care of the environment.
Founded in June 1972, as a result of the United Nations Conference on the Human
Environment (Stockholm Conference), UNEP has the overall responsibility and
accountability for environmental problems among the United Nations agencies.4
UNEP categorizes its work into seven broad thematic areas: climate change, disasters
and conflicts, ecosystem management, environmental governance, chemicals and wastes,
resource efficiency and environment under review. With regard to management of
hazardous waste, UNEP came up with a unique sub-programme called the Harmful
Substances and Hazardous Waste. In order to control the use of chemical substances
and wastes that have the potential to pose threat to the environment and human health,
UNEP intends to support countries and regions in managing the life cycles of such
substances. It puts special efforts to minimize the risks from substances like mercury,
heavy metals, pesticides, persistent organic pollutants (POPs) and other chemicals of
global interest. This sub-programme is built on more than 30 years of work in the field
and is a driving force behind the sound management of chemicals and hazardous waste.
UNEP’s Harmful Substances and Hazardous Waste sub-programme has four key goals5:
4 UN Environment, Available at: https: //www.unenvironment.org/about-un-environment (Last accessed

5 Harmful Substances and Hazardous Waste, United Nations Environment Programme, Available at:
http: //wedocs.unep.org/handle/20.500.11822/7939 (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
28
NLSIU
 Global assessment of policies and trends in use & release of chemicals and waste products to
provide policy and science-based guidance to decision makers.
Scientific
 Raising awareness about the potential adverse affects of chemicals and hazardous waste.
Assessments
 UNEP hosts SAICM secretariat and plays a key role in its implementation.
 Supports evolution & development of internationally agreed chemical management regimes;
Legal assists countries, secretariats and other stakeholders in their efforts.
Instruments  Helps States to strengthen their legal and regulatory regimes.
 Popularizes performance of best practices, by helping the states to oversee, evaluate and notify
Monitoring on the successful implementation of their national programmes.
and
Evaluation
 Develops tools for sound managament of chemicals and assists states to adapt them to their needs.
 Provides incentives & trade policies for integrating the sound management of harmful substances
National & hazardous wastes.
Implementation  Capacity development of national governments.
UNEP undertakes efforts to reduce risks from harmful substances including Mercury,
Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs), E-wastes, Bio-Medical wastes, Carcinogens or
Mutagens, and other chemicals and hazardous wastes. The UNEP under its aegis initiated
the signing of several international treaties on waste and hazardous waste including
chemical waste and hosts the Secretariats of Basel Convention, Rotterdam Convention,
Stockholm Convention and Global Programme of Action for the Protection of the Marine
Environment from Land-based Activities.
One of the major ongoing activities at UNEP is the Chemicals in Products (CiP)
Programme initiated in 2008. It is based on the realistic features of information access
about the chemical content in everyday products. In order to facilitate the manufacturers
to properly handle the products and the chemical content in them, the activities of the
programme aim at expanding the availability and access to the information actors need,
throughout the whole process of creating a product. The SAICM administrative body
29
NLSIU
welcomed the CiP Programme in 2015 at ICCM4, which was a result of broad research
and stakeholder consultations, as the mechanism for all stakeholders to proceed on this
compound issue.6
The UNEP has formed a voluntary partnership with World Health Organisation for the
purpose of preventing exposure to lead, which is known as the Global Alliance to
Eliminate Lead Paint. It mainly aims at popularizing the termination of paints containing
lead, to prevent exposure to lead, and promoting the phase-out of paints containing lead.
An advisory group guides the Lead Paint Alliance, which is chaired by the United States
of America through the Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA). It comprises of
Government representatives from Colombia, Republic of Moldova, Kenya, Thailand,
IPEN International POPs Elimination Network (IPEN), Health and Environmental
Alliance (HEAL), International Paint and Print Ink Council (IPPIC), Akzo Nobel (a
paint company), United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO).7
For the purpose of advocating sound management of pesticides, including Integrated

Vector Management (IVM) and Integrated Pest Management (IPM), the UN Environment
Chemicals and Health Branch indulges in partnerships and collaborations with various
organisations at international level, regional level, intergovernmental organisations and
Multilateral Environment Agreements (MEA) Secretariats. As covered under the
Stockholm Convention, both IPM and IVM are suggested in the elimination of persistent
organic pollutant (POP) pesticides. IPM and IVM approaches urge using pesticides as
last resort building on several control options. Well within the mandate of Strategic
Approach to International Chemicals Management (SAICM), the UN Chemicals and
Health Branch intensively popularizes sound management of chemicals. Due to SAICM
the overall progress has substantially expedited and coordination with other agencies has
6 Chemicals in Products, United Nations Environment Programme, Available at: https://

www.unenvironment.org/explore-topics/chemicals-waste/what-we-do/emerging-issues/chemicals-
products (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
7 Global Alliance to Eliminate Lead Paint, United Nations Environment Programme, Available at: Https:/
/www.unenvironment.org/explore-topics/chemicals-waste/what-we-do/emerging-issues/global-
alliance-eliminate-lead-paint (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
30
NLSIU
intensified. The international community has probably progressed most in the area of
pesticides.8
Sustainable chemistry as a concept has attained recognition at an international level. At

the fourth session of United Nations Environment Assembly (UNEA) in 2019, resolution
4/8 gave attention to the value of creating a better understanding of sustainable chemistry.
The resolution laid emphasis on the analysis given by UNEP on ideal practices in
sustainable chemistry and requested the UNEP to amalgamate it into manuals on
sustainable green chemistry. It urged consultation with relevant stakeholders, by the
time the fifth UNEA is held. Further, the resolution asked the UNEP to take into
consideration both the gravity of sustainable management of chemicals as well as the
possible boons arising from these chemicals for sustainable development, and thereby
asked it to continue to work on developing a holistic approach for the sustainable
management of chemicals and wastes in the long run. A report has been made accessible
as information document for UNEA4. It is entitled “Analysis of Stakeholder Submissions
on Sustainable Chemistry Pursuant to UNEA Resolution 2/7” which requires stakeholders
to look at sustainable chemistry as an essential component so that the sound management
of chemicals and waste is attained.9
2.2.2 ORGANIZATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND

DEVELOPMENT (OECD)
The Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development is an intergovernmental

economic organisation with 36 member countries10, headquartered in Paris, France. It
was founded in 1961 to stimulate economic development and world trade. OECD has
8 Pesticides, United Nations Environment Programme, Available at: https://www.unenvironment.org/

explore-topics/chemicals-waste/what-we-do/emerging-issues/pesticides (Last accessed on November
16, 2019).
9 Sustainable Chemistry, United Nations Environment Programme, Available at: https://
www.unenvironment.org/explore-topics/chemicals-waste/what-we-do/policy-and-governance/
sustainable-chemistry (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
10 The Member Countries of OECD are Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada, Chile Czech Republic,
Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Iceland, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Japan,
Korea, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Mexico, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal,
Slovak Republic, Slovenia, Span, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, United Kingdom and United States.
31
NLSIU
also taken some specific actions for management of hazardous waste. On 9 June 2004,
the OECD Council brought in force a Recommendation on the Environmentally
Sound Management of Waste. Initially, there were problems faced and certain drawbacks
in the Environmentally Sound Management of Waste were identified, which were as
follows:
 The level and purview of ESM substantially varies from one member state to
another.
 There is absence of a standard and clear definition and unanimous understanding
of the term ESM, which has evidently led to obstacles and challenges for the
functional and practical implementation of ESM instruments.
 In certain member nations, there are less binding and less forceful environmental
controls, human health standards and safety levels observed.
 There is an opportunity created for exporters, importers or waste managers to
redirect shipments of wastes, which were intended for recovery, into OECD
countries. Furthermore, waste management facilities have lowered waste
management standards.11
For the above mentioned reasons, the member states initiated their work towards
international ESM Guidelines for waste recovery facilities, in 1999. The aspects that
were ventured into by member countries were:
 Considering relevant experience on ESM in OECD and non-OECD countries

 Elucidating the elements of ESM
 Deliberating and discussing voluntary and regulatory approaches to ESM
 Providing guidance to the future OECD work on ESM
11 Environmentally Sound Management of Waste, OECD, Available at: https://www.oecd.org/env/

waste/environmentallysoundmanagement ofwaste. Htm#targettext=e nvironmentally% 20sound%
20management %20(esm)%20of, principles% 20of%20waste% 20management% 20policies. (Last
accessed on November 16, 2019).
32
NLSIU
After considering the aforesaid points, the solutions devised included the following12:
Providing facilities with common basic provisions for ESM in order to improve
their environmental performance, if necessary.
Achieving a more level playing field among facilities within the OECD area, to help
ensure that competitiveness of facilities which have invested in environmentally
sound technologies is maintained.
Implementation of these “guidelines” to help countries have greater confidence that

their waste shipments within the OECD were being sent to environmentally sound
management facilities.
2.2.3 GLOBAL ENVIRONMENT FACILITY (GEF)
The Global Environment Facility was established on the eve of 1992 Rio Earth Summit,
with the aim to handle Earth’s most pressing environmental issues. Today, the GEF is an
international partnership of 183 countries, civil society organisations, international
institutions and private sector organisations that looks into global environmental problems
with its headquarters in Washington D.C. The GEF has facilitated numerous notable
achievements in the field of environment protection, some of which include setting up
of protected areas, sustainable landscape and seascape aimed towards the protection of
biodiversity, sustainable forest and land management, integrated water resource
management, among others.13 In the field of hazardous waste management, the GEF has
12 Ibid.
13 The Sixth Environment Action Programme of the European Community, European Union, Available
at: https://ec.europa.eu/environment/archives/action-programme/intro.htm#targettext=the%
206th%20 eap%20is% 20a, be% 20taken %20to%20achieve %20them. &Amp; targettext= environment
%20and % 20health, natural%20resources%20and%20waste%20 (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
33
NLSIU
engaged itself in the safe disposal of hazardous chemicals. The efforts in this area have
resulted in the phase out of 29,000 ODP (Ozone Depleting Potential) and have led to
the sound disposal of more than 200,000 tonnes of POPs legacy in developing countries.14
Certain harmful chemicals are covered by the Stockholm Convention on Persistent

Organic Pollutants, the Minamata Convention on Mercury, and the Montreal Protocol
on Substances that deplete the Ozone Layer. The GEF has been given the responsibility
of shutting out these harmful chemicals. By way of providing assistance and support to
the Strategic Approach to International Chemicals Management (SAICM), the structure
set up by the United Nations to propagate chemical safety around the world, the GEF
fuels the accomplishment of broader safe and sound management of chemicals and
wastes.
The Global Environment Facility promotes two key strategic goals, which are as
follows15:
TWO STRATEGIC
GOALS OF GEF
Materialize the necessary Minimize the frequent generation

equipment, conditions and of hazardous waste and
environment for the sound chemicals and to uphold the
management of hazardous execution of clean substitutive
wastes and chemicals. substances or technologies
14 Global Environment Facility, Available at: https://www.thegef.org/about-us (Last accessed on November

16, 2019).
15 Ibid.
34
NLSIU
Implementation assistance is provided by GEF to the Parties of the aforementioned

Conventions to ensure that the Parties are able to fulfil their commitments under the
Conventions. In order to use and manufacture chemicals without suffering their dangerous
impacts, the Parties are allowed to use the entry point of these Conventions to reconstruct
their management of chemicals accordingly. The work of GEF on harmful chemicals
and wastes management emphasizes on four eminent programs in GEF-7 (seventh
replenishment of resources of the GEF Trust Fund), which are as follows:
THE
INDUSTRIAL
CHEMICALS
PROGRAMME
THE
THE ENABLING
ACTIVITIES
GEF AGRICULTURAL
CHEMICALS
PROGRAMME
7 PROGRAMME
THE LEAST
DEVELOPED
COUNTRIES
AND SMALL
ISLAND
DEVELOPING
STATES
PROGRAMME
35
NLSIU
 The Industrial Chemicals Program: This program aims to freeze out or

substantially minimize chemicals that fall under the international conventions by
advancing support to programs that address the following: chemicals and the
waste generated at the end of the life of the chemical; chemicals used in processes
or emitted as a result of processes and products, and management of wastes
containing these chemicals.
 The Agricultural Chemicals Program: It is responsible for looking into the

agricultural chemicals that are listed under the Stockholm Convention as persistent
organic pollutants, as well as those agricultural chemicals that contain mercury
or its compounds. In conditions where the use of such chemicals becomes
inevitable and necessary, the GEF puts in efforts to bring forth alternatives.
 The Least Developed Countries and Small Islands Developing States

Program: By way of uplifting the capacity of sub-national, national, and regional
institutions and by empowering the enabling policy and structure of rules and
regulations in these countries, the GEF addresses the issue of sound management
of chemicals and wastes.
 The Enabling Activities Program: Under Stockholm Convention and Minamata

Convention, it empowers the enabling activities. It also renders assistance to the
global monitoring of chemicals.16
For the replenishment of GEF-7, in order to rid the world of the most harmful
chemicals through GEF’s chemical and waste program, the donors pledged US$600
million approximately, which accounted for 15% of the total replenishment commitment.
Right from its adoption in 2001, the GEF has cumulatively invested US$1.2 billion in
those projects which support the Stockholm Convention, as of June 30, 2018. Due to
this GEF investment, approximately US$4.8 billion has been leveraged in co-financing,
and the cumulative value of GEF POPs portfolio has been brought up to over US $6
billion.17
16 Ibid.
17 Results, Global Environment Facility, Available at: https://www.thegef.org/topics/chemicals-and-waste
36
NLSIU
2.2.4 INTERNATIONAL MARITIME ORGANIZATION (IMO)
The International Maritime Organization earlier known as the Inter-Governmental

Maritime Consultative Organisation (IMCO) is the United Nations specialized agency
which is responsible for the safety and security of shipping and the prevention of marine
and atmospheric pollution by ships. IMO’s work supports the UN Sustainable
Development Goals. The IMO was established following an agreement at a UN Conference
held in 1948 at Geneva. It came into existence in 1959, ten years later. Headquartered in
London, United Kingdom, the IMO currently has 174 member states and three associate
members.18
Being a specialized agency of the United Nations, IMO has the authority to set global
standards and rules for the security, safety and favourable environmental performance in
the process of international shipping. Its main objective is to create a structure of rules
and regulations that is effective, fair, just, universally adopted and implemented. In simple
words, the IMO brings forth a level playing-field, ensuring fair treatment, so that ship
operators do not get an opportunity to fulfil their financial needs by way of malpractices,
cutting corners and compromising on safety, security and environmental performance.
Through this innovation and efficiency is encouraged.19
The International Maritime Organization (IMO) has the responsibility of maintaining

and updating the International Maritime Dangerous Goods Code (IMDG Code). It
administers the wide majority of shipments of hazardous materials by water. The intention
of IMDG Code is to facilitate the safe transportation of hazardous materials by vessel,
to protect crew members and to prevent marine pollution. Essentially the code finds its
basis in the UN Model Regulations, but certain items which are found to be necessary for
the safe and sound transportation of hazardous materials by water have been included in
the code though they do not come under the UN Model Regulations, like: requirements
for the shipboard safety and protection of the marine environment, stowage and
18 Introduction to IMO, International Maritime Organization, Available at: http:// www.imo.org/en/

about/pages/default.aspx (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
19 Ibid.
37
NLSIU
segregation, procedure for loading freight containers, requirements for marine pollutants,
etc.20
IMO’s Carriage of Cargoes and Containers (CCC) Sub-Committee is responsible for

maintaining and updating the IMDG Code. It was earlier known as Dangerous Goods,
Solid Cargoes and Containers Sub-Committee. The International Convention for the
Safety of Life at Sea (SOLAS) and the International Convention for the Prevention of
Pollution from Ships (MARPOL) bring an obligation upon IMO for the implementation
of the IMDG Code. Today, more than 98% of the world’s gross tonnage, coming from
the combined merchants fleets of at least 150 countries, makes use of the IMDG Code
for the purpose of maintaining favourable sea transport of hazardous materials. The
IMO updates the IMDG Code every two years. Amendment 38 was effective from January
1, 2018. A twelve month transitional period has been suggested by the IMO’s Marine
Safety Committee, in order to help the users to become familiar with the new updated
format.21
2.2.5 INTER-ORGANIZATION PROGRAMME FOR THE SOUND

MANAGEMENT OF CHEMICALS (IOMC)
The objectives of Inter-Organizational Programme for the Sound Management of

Chemicals are mainly to empower the international co-operation in the area of chemicals,
to strengthen co-ordination of its policies and activities, pursued jointly or separately, to
heighten the impact of the organization’s international chemicals programmes, to
accomplish the safe and sound management of chemicals and hazardous materials with
relation to human health and the environment.
The IOMC was established in 1995 following the recommendations of the 1992 UN
Conference on Environment and Development (UNCED), specifically those in Chapter
19 of Agenda 21 about toxic chemicals.
20 Sub-committee on Carriage of Cargoes and Containers, International Maritime Organization, Available
at: http://www.imo.org/en/media centre/meeting summaries/ccc/pages/default. Aspx (Last accessed
21 International Maritime Organization, Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration, Available
at: https://www.phmsa.dot.gov/international-program/international-maritime-organization (Last
38
NLSIU
The IOMC brings together the following nine intergovernmental organisations:
FOOD AND
AGRICULTURE
ORGANISATION
OF THE UNITED
NATIONS (FAO)
UNITED NATIONS
ENVIRONMENT
PROGRAMME
(UNEP)
UNITED
INTERNATIONAL NATIONS
LABOUR DEVELOPMENT
ORGANIZATION PROGRAMME
(ILO) (UNDP)
WORLD HEALTH
ORGANIZATION WORLD BANK
(WHO)
UNITED UNITED
ORGANIZATION NATIONS NATIONS
FOR ECONOMIC INSTITUTE FOR INDUSTRIAL
COOPERATION AND TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT
DEVELOPMENT RESEARCH ORGANIZATION
(OECD) (UNITAR) (UNIDO)
39
NLSIU
Through the works of Inter Organization on Programme of the Sound Management of

Chemicals (IOMC), a sustainable future is created through coordinated global actions
with the purpose of achieving the sound lifecycle management of chemicals and waste
for the betterment of human health and the environment. The IOMC participating
organizations have helped most of the developing nations to strengthen their capacity
for achieving the purpose of mainstreaming the safe and sound management of chemicals
and wastes, all of which is a result of the commitment of IOMC towards promoting
coordination of its policies and activities. For the purpose of promoting the sound
management of chemicals and wastes, the IOMC shows utmost dedication towards
facilitating a comprehensive set of technical and scientific tools. It also has immense
opportunities which provide for green jobs.22
2.2.6 UNITED NATIONS DEVELOPMENT PROGRAMME (UNDP)
The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) is the development network of

the United Nation which operates at a global level. Its activities include sponsoring and
advocating change and uniting and interlinking countries to “knowledge, experience and
resources” with the purpose of assisting people in building a better life . UNDP offers and
provides “expert advice, training and monetary grants” assistance to developing countries,
with special emphasis on providing support to the least developed countries (LDCs). It’s
activities also include promotion of “technical and investment cooperation” among countries.
UNDP has its headquarters in the city of New York. The present legal statues of UNDP
within the United Nations framework is of an executive board within the United Nations
General Assembly.
The sound management of chemicals and wastes is an important component of UNDP’s

efforts to achieve sustainable, inclusive and resilient human development and the
Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). UNDP advocates for integrating chemicals
management priorities into national environmental and poverty reduction planning
frameworks, helps countries access financial and technical resources, and provides
22 Chemicals and Waste Management, United Nations Development Programme, Available at: https://
www.undp.org/content/undp/en/home/2030-agenda-for-sustainable-development/planet/
environment-and-natural-capital/chemicals-and-waste-management.html (Last accessed on November
16, 2019).
40
NLSIU
technical assistance and implementation support to improve the holistic management of

chemicals and waste at national, regional and global levels. UNDP’s expertise covers
management of chemicals harmful to human and environmental health, including
Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs), Ozone Depleting Substances (ODS), Mercury,
Lead, and other heavy metals. UNDP helps countries strengthen their waste management
systems, including waste prevention, reuse or recycling, treatment and disposal. Safe and
effective treatment of hazardous medical waste through innovative technologies is also
one of its initiatives. UNDP activities on chemicals and waste management are carried
out in cooperation with the Global Environment Facility (GEF), the Multilateral Fund
for the Implementation of the Montreal Protocol (MLF),the Inter-Organization
Programme for the Sound Management of Chemicals (IOMC), Secretariat of the
Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants, Secretariat of the Minamata
Convention on Mercury, and a broad range of bilateral, private sector and civil society
partners.23
2.2.7 UNITED NATIONS INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENT

ORGANIZATION (UNIDO)
The United Nations Industrial Development Organization (UNIDO), is a specialized

agency in the UN Framework. It is headquartered in Vienna, Austria. The mandate of
UNIDO, as prescribed in the Lima Declaration, is the promotion and acceleration of
“Inclusive and Sustainable Industrial Development” (ISID) in the member states. It is also a
member of the United Nations Development Group.24 The 2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development and the associated Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) recognised
the importance of ISID as an integrated approach to all of the three pillars of sustainable
development. UNIDO’s mandate is fully recognized in SDG-9, which calls to “Build
resilient infrastructure, promote inclusive and sustainable industrialization and foster
innovation”. Accordingly, the Organization’s programmatic focus is structured, as detailed
23 Ibid.
24 United Nations Industrial Development Organization, Available at: https: //www.unido.org/who-
we-are/unido-brief (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
41
NLSIU
CREATING ADVANCING
SHARED ECONOMIC
PROSPERITY COMPETITIVENESS
SAFEGUARDING STRENGTHENING
THE KNOWLEDGE AND
ENVIRONMENT INSTITUTIONS
Responding to the urgent need of phasing out the production and consumption of ODSs,
which lead to the continuing degradation of human health and the natural environment,
as enunciated in the Vienna Convention and the Montreal Protocol the UNIDO assists
governments of developing countries that are signatories to the Montreal Protocol to
comply with its requirements through transferring non-ODS-(Ozone Depleting Substances)
based technologies to Article 5 countries and supports them to meet the set targets in
terms of tonnages of ODS to be eliminated. There is a commitment on the part of
governments that are parties to the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants
(POPs) to implement legal, organizational and environmental management measures,
25 Ibid.
42
NLSIU
including substantive technological changes, in order to comply with the requirements

of the Convention. UNIDO also assists countries in reaching compliance with the
Stockholm Convention and develops capacities in developing countries to protect their
populations and their environmental resources from POPs-related pollution. UNIDO
also supports countries in addressing the commitments under the Minamata Convention
on Mercury.26
The UNIDO-GEF project, “Strengthening of National Initiatives and Enhancement of

Regional Cooperation for the Environmentally Sound Management of POPs in Waste of
Electronic or Electrical Equipment (WEEE)” approved in the year 2014 assists 13 Latin
American countries both technically and financially, advising on e-waste policies and
regulations, suitable management technologies, business models, capacity-building and
awareness-raising. At the national level, the project seeks to strengthen policies and train
technical staff and government officials. At the regional level, the project seeks to
harmonize key aspects of e-waste policies and strengthen regional cooperation and
knowledge exchange. Through this project, recycling services and high-quality recyclable
materials would be provided, generating significant numbers of direct decent jobs and
work opportunities. This project also seeks to develop a circular economy approach that
would go a long way in protecting the environment from hazardous wastes, chemicals
and emissions, recover raw materials and provide affordable refurbished products.27
2.2.8 UNITED NATIONS INSTITUTE FOR TRAINING AND RESEARCH

(UNITAR)
The United Nations Institute for Training and Research (UNITAR) set up in 1963 is a
dedicated training arm of the United Nations system. UNITAR provides training and
capacity development activities to assist mainly developing countries with special attention
to Least Developed Countries (LDCs), Small Island Developing States (SIDS) and other
26 Safeguarding the Environment, United Nations Industrial Development Organization, Available

at: https://www.unido.org/our-focus/safeguarding-environment (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
27 Regional Co-operation on E-waste Management in Latin American Countries, UNIDO, Available at:
https: //www.unido.org/ewastelac (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
43
NLSIU
groups and communities who are most vulnerable, including those in conflict situations.
It is headquartered at Geneva, Switzerland. UNEP’s International Environmental
Technology Centre (UNEP IETC) and UNITAR have prepared “Guidelines for National
Waste Management Strategies: Moving from Challenges to Opportunities”. These
guidelines serve to respond to calls for UNEP (through UNEP Governing Council
resolutions 25/8 and 26/3) to support national implementation of integrated waste
management and to the Rio+20 call for development of comprehensive national waste
management strategies (paragraph 218 of the outcome document, “The Future We Want”).
The strategy guidelines are intended to foster an overarching approach to national waste
management planning. They build upon the already existing material previously developed
to provide technical support for management of individual waste streams or parts of the
waste life-cycle, and to support planning in related fields such as chemicals management.
The strategy guidelines also take account of recent policy emphases relating, for example,
to “green economy” objectives, connections between waste management and climate
change, and the potential for greater resource recovery from waste.28
The UNITAR has launched a new module on Gender, Chemicals and Waste that was
launched at the side event “Integrating Gender into Sound Management of Chemicals
and Waste”, held on 9 May 2019, in Geneva, Switzerland, during the 2019 meetings of
the Conferences of the Parties (COPs) to the Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm (BRS)
Conventions. This online module has as its audience, specialists, development
practitioners and policy-makers working on chemicals and waste management and
primarily focuses on describing the relationship between gender, chemicals and waste,
identifying key international commitments on gender equality and sound management
of chemicals and waste, explaining how gender equality contributes to sound management
of chemicals and waste and providing examples of gender-responsive initiatives on
chemicals and waste safety.29
28 Waste Management, United Nations Institute for Training and Research, Available at: https://
www.unitar.org/sustainable-development-goals/planet/our-portfolio/waste-management (Last accessed
29 New Module on Gender, Chemicals and Waste, UNITAR, Available at: https://unitar.org/about/
news-stories/news/new-module-gender-chemicals-and-waste-available-online (Last accessed on November
16, 2019).
44
NLSIU
2.2.9 WORLD BANK
The World Bank created at the 1944 Bretton Woods Conference, provides financial and
technical assistance to developing countries around the world. The World Bank Group
comprises five institutions managed by their member countries which include the
following:30
INTERNATIONAL BANK INTERNATIONAL INTERNATIONAL

FOR RECONSTRUCTION DEVELOPMENT FINANCE
AND ASSOCIATION (IDA) CORPORATION (IFC)
DEVELOPMENT (IBRD)
INTERNATIONAL
MULTILATERAL INVEST-
CENTRE FOR SETTLEMENT
MENT GUARANTEE
OF INVESTMENT
AGENCY (MIGA)
DISPUTES (ICSID)
The World Bank, World Health Organization, and United Nations Environment
Programme have cooperated in the preparation and issuance of a manual on the Safe
Disposal of Hazardous Wastes. This three-volume manual is intended for administrators
and technical staff, primarily in developing countries, who have responsibilities for waste
management, public health and environmental protection. The manual includes
information on the classification of hazardous waste, its effects on health and the
environment, the planning and implementation of programs in hazardous waste
management, hazardous waste treatment, and disposal technologies, including economic
and institutional considerations. The manual primarily emphasises on the management
aspects and on the technologies that may be appropriate for implementing a region-wide
hazardous waste management program. Practical illustrations in the form of case studies
from developing countries have been incorporated. Sufficient information is provided in
30 World Bank, Available at: https://www.worldbank.org/en/about/what-we-do (Last accessed on

November 16, 2019).
45
NLSIU
the manual for conducting at least a pre-feasibility assessment of various options for a
hazardous waste management program. A particularly useful section of this manual
includes the examples of various operating systems for hazardous waste tracking and
disposal, waste survey questionnaires and techniques, and landfill design and management
practices.31 Since 2000, the World Bank has committed over $4.7 billion to more than
340 solid waste management programs in all six regions of World Bank engagement.32
2.3 ORGANIZATIONS WORKING IN THE FIELD OF CHEMICALS

AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AT THE REGIONAL
LEVEL
2.3.1 EUROPEAN UNION
Headquartered at Brussels, Belgium, the European Union (EU), a political and economic
union of 28 member states of Europe came into force on November 1, 1993. Drawing
up of a waste management plan, by all Member states of EU is a requisite as per Article
28 of the Waste Framework Directive (WFD). The entire geographical territories of all
member states should be covered in the plans, so drafted, and it should be in accordance
with the provisions of Article 1 WFD, Article 4 WFD, Article 13 WFD, Article 14 WFD
and Article 16 WFD.33 The 7th Environmental Action Programme, which would guide
European environment policy until 2020; recently extended up to 2050, sets out a number
of pertinent objectives for waste policy in EU which include the following:
 To reduce the amount of waste generated;

 To maximise recycling and re-use;
 To limit incineration to non-recyclable materials;
31 The Safe Disposal of Hazardous Waste, World Bank Technical Paper Number 93, Available at: http://
documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/695131468764392542/pdf/multi-page.pdf (Last accessed on
November 16, 2019).
32 Solid Waste Management, The World Bank, Available at: https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/
urbandevelopment/brief/solid-waste-management (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
33 Waste Management Planning, European Union, Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/
plans/index.htm (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
46
NLSIU
 To phase out landfilling to non-recyclable and non-recoverable waste;

 To ensure full implementation of the waste policy targets in all Member States.34
An emphasis is laid on the following areas to ensure that the objectives set are achieved:
34 7th EAP—The New General Union Environment Action Programme to 2020, Available at:
https://ec.europa.eu/environment/pubs/pdf/factsheets/7eap/en.pdf (Last accessed on
November 16, 2019).
47
NLSIU
Some recent initiatives have been taken by the EU in the field of hazardous waste
management. The European Commission, the Executive Branch of the EU responsible
for the proposing legislation, upholding EU treaties and managing the day to day business
of EU has adopted the report on the implementation and on the impact on the
environment and the functioning of the internal market of the Batteries Directive (2006/
66/EC) on the 9th of April 2019.35 The report evaluated the implementation of the
Battery Directive36 which has been the only EU legislation on batteries. The environmental
impact of the batteries in so far as the hazardous components that they contain are
addressed by the directive. It further directs reducing the hazardous components in
batteries and establishing measures to ensure the proper management of waste batteries.
In so far as the level of recycling, of the waste generated from batteries are concerned
the information provided by Member states reflected that, the vast majority of waste
batteries collected in the EU are recycled as required by the Directive and most Member
States met the Directive’s recycling efficiencies targets. Lead-acid batteries accounted
for the maximum recycling efficiency in almost all Member States. Data gaps are more
frequent for nickel-cadmium and ‘other’ batteries, although the targets for these were
also met.37
In January 2018, the EU adopted the European Strategy for Plastics in a Circular Economy.
In December 2015, the Commission while adopting the EU Action Plan for a circular
economy, identified plastics as a key priority and committed itself to ‘prepare a strategy
35 Report from the Commission to the European Parliament, the Council, the European Economic and
Social Committee and the Committee of the Regions on the Implementation and the Impact on the
Environment and the Functioning of the Internal Market of Directive 2006/66/Ec of the European
Parliament and of the Council of 6 September 2006 on Batteries and Accumulators and Waste Batteries
and Accumulators and Repealing Directive 91/157/Eec, Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/environment/
waste/batteries/pdf/report_ implementation_ batteries_ directive.pdf (Last accessed on November 16,
2019).
36 Directive 2006/66/Ec of the European Parliament and of the Council of 6 September 2006 on Batteries
and Accumulators and Waste Batteries and Accumulators and Repealing Directive 91/157/Eec Oj L 266,
26.9.2006, P. 1, as Amended.
37 Commission Staff Working Document on the Evaluation of the Directive 2006/66/Ec on Batteries and
Accumulators and Waste Batteries and Accumulators and Repealing Directive 91/157/Eec, 9th April, 2019.
Available at: Https://ec.europa.eu/environment/waste/batteries/pdf/evaluation_report_batteries_
directive. Pdf (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
48
NLSIU
addressing the challenges posed by plastics throughout the value chain and taking into
account their entire lifecycle’. To move towards achieving the SDGs and reduce the
pollution caused by plastics, the Commission vowed to focus on plastic production and
use and work towards the goal of ensuring that all plastic packaging is recyclable by
2030.38 This step seemed to be a necessary intervention bearing in mind the amount of
plastic generated in EU to meet the demands of the economy. As per 2015 estimates,
EU requires 49 million tonnes of plastic to meet its packaging, building and construction,
automotive and other needs. It generated around 25.8 million tonnes of plastic every
year. To counter the ill effects of plastics, the Strategy proposes to improve the economics
and quality of plastic recycling by investing on recyclable designs, boosting demand for
recycled products, designing harmonized collection and sorting mechanisms for plastics.
The strategy also proposes to curb plastic waste and littering in sea and land, establish a
clear regulatory framework for plastics with biodegradable properties, boost investment
by financing the development of smarter and more recyclable plastics materials, making
recycling processes more efficient and tracing and removing hazardous substances and
contaminants from recycled plastics.39
2.3.2 AFRICAN UNION (AU)
The African Union (AU) is a continental body comprising of fifty-five member states/
parties which constitute the nations of African Continent, headquartered at Addis Ababa,
Ethiopia. It was authoritatively inaugurated in July 2002 in Durban, South Africa,
followed by an accord made by its preceding body, the Organisation of African Unity
(OAU, 1963- 1999) in September of 1999, with the aim of creating an advanced
continental organisation to continue its work and build on it.40 The African Union has
taken certain activities towards safe, legitimate and sound management of waste. One
of the major acts of AU, regarding management of hazardous waste, is the Bamako
38 A European Strategy for Plastics in a Circular Economy. Communication from the Commission to the
European Parliament, the Council, The European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee
of the Regions, Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/resource.html?uri= cellar: 2df5d1d2fac7-11e7-
b8f5-01aa75ed71a1.0001.02/doc_1&format=pdf (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
39 A European Strategy for Plastics in a Circular Economy, Available at: https://ec.europa.eu/environment/
circular-economy/pdf/plastics-strategy-brochure.pdf (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
40 African Union, Available at: https://au.int/en/overview (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
49
NLSIU
Convention on the ban of the Import into Africa and the Control of Transboundary
Movement of Hazardous Wastes within Africa, which came into force in 1998. The
Bamako Convention emerged as a reaction to the Basel Convention which urges members/
parties to go into bilateral, multilateral and regional agreements for deciding on Hazardous
Waste, in order to be able to accomplish the goals of the Convention.41
Prohibiting import of all

hazardous & radioactive
wastes in African conti-
nent, for any reason
Minimizing and
controlling the
Establishing the transboundary
precautionary movements of
principle. hazardous wastes
within the African
continent.
Promoting cleaner
production over the
Constraining the
quest for a permissible
dumping into ocean
emissions approach,
and inland water or
dependent on
incineration of
assimilative capacity
hazardous wastes.
assumptions.
Using “environmentally
sound” methods for the
disposal of wastes.
41 The Bamako Convention, United Nations Environment Programme, Available at https://

www.unenvironment.org/explore-topics/environmental-rights-and-governance/what-we-do/meeting-
international-environmental (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
50
NLSIU
For a State to be a party to the Bamako

Convention, it had to be a member of
Organisation of African Union(OAU)
There will be an obligation upon all parties to

prohibit the import of all hazardous wastes, for
any reason, from non-contracting parties into
Africa.
2.3.3 SECRETARIAT OF THE PACIFIC REGION ENVIRONMENT

PROGRAMME (SPREP)
The Governments and Administrations of the Pacific region were delegated with the
responsibility of preserving and looking after the natural resources and environment of
the Pacific. They set up a regional organisation called the Secretariat of the Pacific
Region Environment Programme, which is headquartered in Apria, Samoa with about
100 staff. The organisation was established in 1982.42
CLIMATE
CHANGE
RESILIENCE
EFFECTIVE
WASTE
MANAGEMENT
AND
POLLUTION
CONTROL
ISLAND AND
OCEAN ENVIRONMENT
ECOSY STEM GOVERNANCE
FOUR CORE PRIORITIES OF SPREP
42 SPREP, Pacific Environment, Available at: https: //www.sprep.org/about-us, (Last accessed on

November 16, 2019).
51
NLSIU
The third priority of SPREP deals with the ‘Effective Waste Management and Pollution
Control.’ The most relevant action taken with regards to the same is Waigani Convention
of 2001. The Convention to Ban the importation into Forum Island Countries of
Hazardous and Radioactive Wastes and to Control the Transboundary Movement of
Hazardous wastes within the South Pacific Region, popularly known as Waigani
Convention, commenced on the 21st October 2001. The basic purpose of this Convention
involves minimizing and eradicating the transboundary movements of hazardous and
radioactive wastes, limiting the creation of hazardous and toxic wastes in the Pacific
region and making sure that disposal of wastes in the Convention area is accomplished
in an environmentally safe way.
The Waigani Convention is moulded on certain eminent conventions like the Basel
Convention, Rotterdam Convention and the Stockholm Convention.43 It basically
establishes the regional operation of the international hazardous waste control
system. Severe controls of the Basel Convention are applied in this Convention to the
South Pacific area, and also it is made certain that any Pacific country or Antarctica
is not affected by the hazardous waste travelling there from New Zealand or Australia.
The Waigani Convention is considered essential for the region, due to the following
reasons:
 The turning of South Pacific into an international waste dump by waste traders
can be prevented by keeping in place an effective protective mechanism;
 The Pacific will no longer be used as a highway by ships for hazardous waste; and
 The hazardous and radioactive wastes in the region can be cleansed by the bringing
forth of a regional apparatus.44
43 Waigani Convention, SPREP Pacific Environment, Available at: https: //www.sprep.org/convention-

secretariat/waigani-convention (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
44 Description/Achievement of Initiative, Waigani Convention, Available at: https: //sustainable
development.un.org/partnership/?P=7456 (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
52
NLSIU
2.3.4 NORTH AMERICAN COMMISSION ON ENVIRONMENTAL

COOPERATION (CEC)
The North American Agreement on Environmental Cooperation (NAAEC) was formed

in 1994 through the collaborations of Canada, Mexico and United States for protecting
the environment of North America. It was around the same time as the North American
Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) came into force and marked a commitment that
liberalization of trade and economic growth in North America would go hand in hand
with effective cooperation between the countries in the environmental protection of the
area. To fulfil its objectives towards environment protection, NAAEC established an
intergovernmental organization - the Commission for Environmental Cooperation (CEC)
– to facilitate cooperation among the NAFTA partners in addressing environmental issues
and environmental challenges. The CEC Secretariat is headquartered in Montreal.45
45 Commission for Environmental Cooperation, Available at: http: //www.cec.org/about-us/about-cec

53
NLSIU
The CEC involves itself in several environmental initiatives including climate change,
green economy, ecosystems etc. In the area of pollutants it tracks the release of pollutants
and supports chemicals management across North America. While it has undertaken
several projects in this field, it is presently monitoring three ongoing projects
 Action Plan to Enhance the Comparability of Pollutant Release and

Transfer Registers (PRTRs) in North America: A Pollutant Release and
Transfer Register (PRTR) provides annual data on the pollutants released by
facilities on site to the air, water and land, or for disposal or underground injection;
and transferred off site for recycling, treatment or disposal. The North American
PRTR comparability was adopted by a Resolution of the Commission in 1997.
In 2002 the CEC Secretariat published the first Action Plan, with a status of the
comparability of the North American PRTRs. It has been subsequently updated
in 2014. The CEC’s North American PRTR (NAPRTR) initiative promotes public
access to PRTR data to improve understanding of the sources and management
of pollutants of common concern. The data used in Taking Stock Report are reported
by facilities to the three national PRTRs: Canada’s National Pollutant Release
Inventory (NPRI), Mexico’s Registro de Emisiones y Transferencia de
Contaminantes (RETC), and the United States’ Toxics Release Inventory (TRI).
Efforts are focused on adding value to the data through their integration, analysis
and dissemination.46
 Modernizing data exchange system for hazardous waste transfers: In

compliance with the requirements of the Basel Convention on the Control of
Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal, the CEC
has developed a Notice and Consent Electronic Data Exchange (NCEDE). This
provides a seamless communication system that allows Canada, Mexico and the
United States to efficiently transmit and respond to notices and consents that
facilitates legal and environmentally-sound cross-border transport and
46 Action Plan to Enhance the Comparability of Pollutant Release and Transfer Registers (PRTRs) In
North America, Commission for Environmental Cooperation, Available at: http://www3.cec.org/
islandora/en/item/11583-action-plan-enhance-comparability-pollutant-release-and-transfer-registers-
prtrs-en.pdf (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
54
NLSIU
environmentally sound management of hazardous waste. As and when

amendments are made to the domestic or international regulations, the NCEDE
is updated to support efficient data exchanges and accommodate future needs.47
With the integration of the three countries, a trilateral electronic system is in
place which supports paper-less information-sharing; extensive reduction in
processing delays; and efficient decision making. The NCEDE also has significant
economic impact on recycling and waste management companies. In the realm
of international trade, the effective management of waste aids in the creation of
jobs in the three countries, since each country moves towards the development
of better technology and processes to manage waste and recyclables.48
2.4 DEFINITIONS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE ADOPTED BY

INTERNATIONAL AND REGIONAL ORGANIZATIONS
ORGANIZATION DEFINITION OF CHEMICAL AND HAZARDOUS

WASTE
United Nations Follows the definition adopted by the Basel Convention 49
Environment
Hazardous Waste: (a) Wastes that belong to any category contained
Programme (UNEP)
in Annex I, unless they do not possess any of the characteristics
contained in Annex III (b) Wastes that are not covered under
paragraph (a) but are defined as, or are considered to be, hazardous
wastes by the domestic legislation of the Party of export, import or
transit.
47 Modernizing the data exchange system for hazardous waste transfers, commission for environmental
cooperation, Available at: http://www.cec.org/our-work/projects/modernizing-data-exchange-system-
hazardous-waste-transfers (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
48 Commission for Environmental Cooperation Operational Plan 2019–2020, Commission For
Environmental Cooperation, Available at: http://www.cec.org/sites/default/files/documents/
operational_plans/operational-plan_19-20.pdf (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
49 Article 1, Basel Convention Controlling Trans Boundary Movements of Hazardous Disposal of Waste,
1989 Annex I (Page 46) Annex iii (Page 50), Available at: https://www.basel.int/portals/4/
basel%20convention/docs/text/baselconventiontext-e.pdf (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
55
NLSIU
Annex I provides for the categories of wastes to be controlled which

are of two categories. The first one is Waste Streams which includes
waste generated in stages of production, preparation and formulation
in various industries like clinical wastes from medical care in hospitals,
waste pharmaceuticals, waste from heat treatment, waste tarry residues,
waste from use of latex, etc. The second category includes waste having
as constituents 27 types of chemicals and its compounds like Mercury
and its compounds, Inorganic and Organic cyanides, Metal carbonyls,
Halogenated organic solvents, Tellurium and its compounds, etc.
Annex III provides for the list of hazardous characteristics which consists
of 14 characteristics of hazardous wastes like explosive, flammable
liquids and solids, oxidizing, organic peroxides, corrosive, toxic, etc.
Organization for Hazardous wastes are wastes that, owing to their toxic, infectious,
Economic Co- radioactive or flammable properties pose a substantial actual or
Operation and potential hazard to the health of humans and other living organisms
Development and the environment.50
(OECD)
Global Environment Has not separately defined chemical and hazardous waste.
Facility (GEF) The GEF is charged with eliminating the most harmful chemicals, which
are covered by the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic
Pollutants, the Minamata Convention on Mercury, and the Montreal
Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer.51
International International Maritime Organization works in tandem with the Basel

Maritime Convention.52 The IMO Guidelines on Ship Recycling provides for a
Organization List of Hazardous Wastes and Substances that are relevant to ship
(IMO) recycling in Appendix 1.53 This includes wastes and substances that
50 Glossary of Statistical Terms, OECD, Available at: https://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?id=1206

51 Chemicals And Waste, Global Environment Facility, Available at: https://www. thegef.org/topics/
chemicals-and-waste (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
52 Application of Basel Conventions to Ships, Basel Convention, Available at: http://www.basel.int/
implementation/legalmatters/ships/overview/tabid/7560/default.aspx (Last accessed on November
16, 2019).
53 IMO Guidelines on Ship Recycling, Appendix 1, Page 26, Basel Convention, Available at: http://
www.basel.int/portals/4/basel%20convention/docs/ships/imo-guidelines-2003.pdf (Last accessed on
November 16, 2019).
56
NLSIU
may be inherent in the ship structure, wastes and substances that may
be on board the ship, and waste components that are relevant to ship
recycling and which are not included in List A in the Basel
Convention.Follows the definition adopted by the Basel Convention.
Inter-Organization Follows the definition adopted by the Basel Convention.54
Programme for the
Sound Management
of Chemicals
(IOMC)
International A hazard can be defined as the set of inherent properties of a chemical,

Programme on mixture of chemicals or a process that, under production, usage or
Chemical Safety disposal conditions, has the potential to adversely affect the environment
(IPCS) or the organisms it contains. In other words, it is a source of danger.55
United Nations Follows the definition adopted by the Basel Convention.

Development
Programme (UNDP)
United Nations
Follows the definition adopted by the Basel Convention.56
Industrial
Development
Organization
(UNIDO)
54 UNDP Guide for Integrating the Sound Management of Chemicals into Development Planning, UNDP,
Available at: https://www.undp.org/content/dam/aplaws/publication/en/publications/environment-
energy/www-ee-library/chemicals-management/integrating-sound-management-of-chemicals-into-
mdg-based-development-planning/integrating%20sound%20management %20in%20chemicals%
20final%20r2.pdf (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
55 User’s Manual for the IPCS Health and Safety Guides, INCHEM, Available at: http://www.inchem.org/
documents/hsg/hsg/hsgguide.htm (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
56 UNIDO Calls on Manufacturers Design for Recycling, UNIDO, Available at: https://www.unido.org/
news/unido-calls-manufacturers-design-recycling (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
57
NLSIU
United Nations A hazard is the inherent property of a substance which makes it

Institute for capable of causing adverse effects to people or the environment
Training and under conditions of exposure.57
Research (UNITAR)
European Union 'Hazardous waste' means waste which displays one or more of the
(EU) hazardous properties listed in Annex III.58 Annex III provides for
the properties of Waste which renders it hazardous which consists
of 15 properties like explosive, oxidizing, corrosive, toxic, irritant,
carcinogenic, etc.
African Union (AU) Relies heavily on definition adopted by the Basel Convention.
As per the Bamako Convention the following substances are deemed
“hazardous wastes” -(a) Wastes that belong to any category contained
in Annex I of the Convention; (b) Wastes that are not covered under
paragraph (a) but are defined as, or are considered to be, hazardous
wastes by the domestic legislation of the State of export, import or
transit; (c) Wastes which possess any of the characteristics contained
in Annex II of the Convention; (d) Hazardous substances which have
been banned, cancelled or refused registration by government
regulatory action, or voluntarily withdrawn from registration in the
country of manufacture, for human health or environmental reasons.59
Hazardous wastes also include waste which as a result of being
radioactive are subject to any international control systems, including
international instruments, applying specifically to radioactive materials.
The Convention specifically excludes wastes derived from the normal
operations of a ship, the discharge of which is covered under other
international instruments.
57 Key Elements of a National Programme for Chemicals Management and Safety, UNITAR, Available at:
http://cwm.unitar.org/publications/publications/cw/inp/key_elements.pdf (Last accessed on
November 16, 2019).
58 Directive 2008/98/Ec of the European Parliament and of the Council on Waste and Repealing Certain
Directives Page L 312/9. Annex iii (Page L 312/25), Available at: https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/
en/txt/pdf/?uri=celex:32008 l0098 &from=en, (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
59 Article 2, Bamako Convention on the Ban of the Import Into Africa and the Control of Transboundary
Movement and Management of Hazardous Wastes, 1991, Available at: https://au.int/sites/default/
files/treaties/7774-treaty-0015_-_bamako_ convention_ on_hazardous_ wastes_e.pdf (Last accessed
58
NLSIU
Annex I formulates the categories of waste which are hazardous

wastes which are waste streams like clinical wastes from medical care
in hospitals, waste pharmaceuticals, waste from heat treatment, waste
tarry residues, waste from use of latex, etc., and Waste Having as
Constituents Mercury and its compounds, Inorganic and Organic
cyanides, Metal carbonyls, Halogenated organic solvents, Tellurium
and its compounds, etc. Annex II provides for the list of hazardous
characteristics like explosive, flammable liquids and solids, oxidizing,
organic peroxides, corrosive, toxic, etc.
Secretariat of the Follows the definition of hazardous waste in the Waigani Convention,
Pacific Region 1995, which also relies on the definition of hazardous waste under
Environment the Basel Convention.
Programme (SPREP) Hazardous Waste includes (a) Wastes that belong to any category
contained in Annex I of the Waigani Convention, unless they do not
possess any of the characteristics contained in Annex II; (b) Wastes
that are not covered under sub-paragraph (a), but which are defined
as, or are considered to be, hazardous wastes by the national legislation
of the exporting, importing or transit Party to, from or through which
such wastes are to be sent.60
Annex I formulates the categories of waste which are hazardous
wastes which are waste streams like clinical wastes from medical care
in hospitals, waste pharmaceuticals, waste from heat treatment, waste
tarry residues, waste from use of latex, etc., and Waste Having as
Constituents Mercury and its compounds, Inorganic and Organic
cyanides, Metal carbonyls, Halogenated organic solvents, Tellurium
and its compounds, etc. Annex II provides for the list of hazardous
characteristics like explosive, flammable liquids and solids, oxidizing,
organic peroxides, corrosive, toxic, etc.
60 Convention to Ban the Importation into Forum Island Countries of Hazardous and Radioactive
Wastes and to Control the Transboundary Movement and Management of Hazardous Wastes within
The South Pacific Region Article 2, Waigani Convention, 1995 Annex I (page 28) and Annex II (page 31),
Available at: https://www.sprep.org/att/publication/000129_waigani_pdf.pdf (Last accessed on
November 16, 2019).
59
NLSIU
United Nations Follows the definition adopted by the Basel Convention.

Economic
Commission For
Europe (UNECE)
North American Hazardous wastes are industrial waste streams that may contain more
Commission on than a single chemical or substance. They are typically defied
Environmental by characteristics such as ignitability, reactivity, corrosiveness and
Cooperation (CEC) toxicity.61
2.5 DEFINITIONS OF HAZARDOUS WASTE WITHIN THE INDIAN

LEGAL FRAMEWORK
Legislation Definition of Chemical and Hazardous Waste
Hazardous and Other Rule 3 sub-rule (17) of the Act defines “hazardous waste” as any waste
Wastes (Management which by reason of characteristics such as physical, chemical, biological,
and Transboundary reactive, toxic, flammable, explosive or corrosive, causes danger or is
Movement) Rules, likely to cause danger to health or environment, whether alone or in
2016 as amended in contact with other wastes or substances, and shall include –
2019
1. waste specified under column (3) of Schedule I;
2. waste having equal to or more than the concentration limits
specified for the constituents in class A and class B of Schedule II
or any of the characteristics as specified in class C of Schedule II;
and
3. wastes specified in Part A of Schedule III in respect of import
or export of such wastes or the wastes not specified in Part A
but exhibit hazardous characteristics specified in Part C of
Schedule III;
61 Crossing the Border Opportunities to Improve Sound Management of Transboundary Hazardous

Waste Shipments in North America, Available at: http://www3.cec.org/islandora/en/item/10158-
crossing-border-opportunities-improve-sound-management-transboundary-hazardous-en.pdf (Last
60
NLSIU
The Batteries Although there is no specific definition of hazardous waste, Rule 9

(Management and sub-rule (2) of the Rules provides that-
Handling) Rules, 2001
9(2) The Joint Secretary, Ministry of Environment and Forests or any
as amended in 2010
officer designated by the Ministry or an agency designated by it shall
ensure that the recyclers possess appropriate facilities, technical
capabilities, and equipment to recycle used batteries and dispose of
hazardous waste generated.
Moreover, Form VI that contains the particulars to be submitted for
registration of facilities possessing environmentally sound management
practice for recycling of used lead acid batteries requires authorization
under rule 5 of the Hazardous Wastes (Management and Handling)
Rules, 1989 and details of hazardous waste management, including
analysis report of characterization of hazardous waste generated.
Bio-Medical Waste No specific definition of hazardous waste.

(Management and
Schedule I that lays down details of biomedical wastes categories and
Handling) Rules,
their segregation, collection, treatment, processing and disposal options
2016 as amended in
provides that expired or discarded medicines which includes
2018
pharmaceutical waste like antibiotics, cytotoxic drugs including all items
contaminated with cytotoxic drugs along with glass or plastic ampoules,
vials etc. shall be sent to common bio-medical waste treatment facility
or hazardous waste treatment, storage and disposal facility for incineration.
The Schedule further provides that chemicals used in production of
biological and used or discarded disinfectants shall be disposed of by
incineration or Plasma Pyrolysis or Encapsulation in hazardous waste
treatment, storage and disposal facility.
Part 2 of Schedule I provides that ash from incineration of biomedical
waste shall be disposed of through hazardous waste treatment, storage
and disposal facility, if toxic or hazardous constituents are present
beyond the prescribed limits as given in the Hazardous Waste
(Management, Handling and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2008
or as revised from time to time. It also provides that residual or discarded
chemical wastes, used or discarded disinfectants and chemical sludge
can be disposed at hazardous waste treatment, storage and disposal
facility.
61
NLSIU
E-Waste Management No specific definition of hazardous waste. But several provisions under
Rules, 2016 as the Rules make mention of hazardous wastes such as the following:
amended in 2018
Under Rule 13(3), any dismantler or recycler of e-waste seeking renewal
of authorization from the State Pollution Control Board must file a
certificate of compliance of effluent and emission standards, treatment
and disposal of hazardous wastes as applicable from the concerned State
Pollution Control Board or any other agency designated for this purpose.
Rule 16 requires every producer of electrical and electronic equipment
and their components or consumables or parts or spares to reduce
the use of hazardous substances in the production. Every producer
of applications listed in Schedule II must ensure that the limits of
hazardous substances as given in Schedule II are to be complied.
Moreover, the Central Pollution Control Board shall conduct random
sampling of electrical and electronic equipment placed on the market
to monitor and verify the compliance of Reduction of Hazardous
Substances provisions and the cost for sample and testing shall be
borne by the Producer.
With regard to transportation of e-waste, Rule 19 provides that
transportation of waste generated from manufacturing or recycling
destined for final disposal to a treatment, storage and disposal facility
shall follow the provisions under Hazardous Wastes (Management,
Handling and Transboundary Movement) Rules.
2.6 COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS OF THE DEFINITIONS OF HAZARDOUS

WASTE ADOPTED BY INTERNATIONAL AND REGIONAL
ORGANIZATIONS AND THE INDIAN LEGISLATIONS
If a comparison is made between the definition of ‘hazardous waste’ in the legislative

framework in India in contrast to the ones adopted by international and regional
organizations working in the realm of chemicals and hazardous waste management, it
would be evident that most international and regional organizations have either adopted
or rely upon the Basel Convention definition of ‘hazardous wastes’. The Hazardous and
Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016 (hereinafter
referred to as HWM Rules) as amended in 2019 was brought into effect owing to the
domestic obligations of India subsequent to the ratification of the Basel Convention.
62
NLSIU
These Rules have adopted a definition which is similar to the definition of ‘hazardous
waste’ under the Basel Convention. On a bare perusal of the definitions in the Indian
legal framework, it is apparent that the understanding of the scope of hazardous wastes
is in a rather nascent stage as there is a lack of definitional clarity as to what constitutes
hazardous wastes apart from the HWM Rules. The Environment Protection Act, 1986
which is considered to be umbrella legislation does not contain a definition of hazardous
or chemical waste. With respect to hazardous substances the Act empowers the Central
Government to make Rules under Sections 6, 8 and 25 which again focuses on the safe
handling of the hazardous substances and procedures regarding and does not explicitly
refer to hazardous waste disposal. But, several Rules have been drafted that deal with
the disposal of wastes, many of which could be categorized as hazardous.
With regard to the Batteries (Management and Handling) Rules, 2001, Rule 9 Sub-rule 2,
this rule can be understood in the sense that the recycling of used batteries will generate
hazardous waste. As a result of which, they have to be disposed in the manner in which
hazardous waste is disposed. Moreover, Form VI that contains the particulars to be
submitted for registration of facilities possessing environmentally sound management
practice for recycling of used lead acid batteries requires authorization under rule 5 of
the Hazardous Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules, 1989 and details of hazardous
waste management, including analysis report of characterization of hazardous waste
generated. Therefore, by implication that recycling of used batteries falls within the
ambit of hazardous waste. The Bio-Medical Waste (Management and Handling) Rules,
2016, in Schedule I provides that expired or discarded medicines, ash from incineration
of biomedical waste and residual or discarded chemical wastes, used or discarded
disinfectants and chemical sludge can be disposed at hazardous waste treatment, storage
and disposal facility. This is essence means that certain categories of bio-medical waste
fall within the ambit of ‘hazardous wastes’. Similar provisions have been incorporated
under the E-Waste Rules. While there is no specific definition of hazardous waste under
the aforementioned Rules, apart from the HWM Rules, e-waste, bio-medical waste and
waste generated in the production of batteries are brought within the ambit of hazardous
wastes by implication, if the Rules are read in whole.
63
NLSIU
While most of these Rules deal with chemicals and it is understood by implication that
most of the hazardous waste generated contains chemicals that are harmful and hazardous,
in the absence of definition of ‘chemical wastes’, there seems to be a gap as to what
chemical wastes would form a part of hazardous wastes. Merely classifying chemical
wastes as hazardous wastes would just be solving one half of the problem. Moreover,
there are other wastes generated through the use of chemicals which although not covered
under any of the aforementioned Rules may require specific disposal mechanisms owing
to their specific characteristics. This calls for a legislative frame work in India specifically
to deal with chemical waste management.
******
64
NLSIU
3
INTERNATIONAL INSTRUMENTS ON CHEMICAL
AND
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT AND INDIA
3.1 BACKGROUND FOR INTERNATIONAL REGULATION IN

CHEMICAL AND HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT
Lack of International rules and principles, catastrophic international incidents like the
Khian Sea Waste Disposal incident (1986), the Bajze Rail Station Incident in Albania (1991), the
Atari Video game burial case (1983), the Ivory Coast Toxic Waste Dump (2006), the Minamata
Disease Case in Japan(1956) coupled with the rapidly growing chemical industry around
the world, the amenability of developing countries to the economic exploitation by the
developed countries initiated a series of steps by the global community to seek regulation
of the chemical sector at the international level. Among them, first was the development
of a global response to hazardous waste trade and dumping, which began in 1982, when
UNEP identified hazardous waste as one of the key areas in need of global regulation.1
In 1982, UNEP convened a working group of experts to develop principles on the
management of hazardous wastes. The group developed the Cairo Guidelines for the
Environmentally Sound Management of Hazardous Wastes that contained a number of
principles to regulate the transboundary movement of hazardous wastes; which were
meant to assist governments in arriving at their own waste policies. Because of the
importance of the issue, the UNEP Governing Council authorized a working group to
prepare a convention on the transboundary movement of wastes. The working group
drafted the Basel Convention, which was adopted by 116 countries and the European
1 Jennifer R. Kitt, Waste Exports io the Developing World: A Global Response, 7 Geo. Int’l Env. L. Rev. 485
(1995).
65
NLSIU
International Instruments on Chemical and Hazardous Waste Management and India
Community in March of 1989. Many other important international conventions followed

this historic development.
The five conventions namely: the Basel Convention, the Rotterdam Convention, the
Stockholm Convention, SAICM and the Minamata Convention have contributed to the
development of a global regulatory framework in the management and disposal of
hazardous wastes. The following section briefly discusses the important provisions of
these conventions followed by the Indian response to these Conventions..
3.2 QUICK FACTSHEET OF THE CONVENTIONS

Convention Basel Rotterdam Stockholm Minamata SAICM
Date of 22 March 10 September 22 May 2001 10 October 6 February

Adoption 1989 1998 2013 2006
Date of 5 May 24 February 17 May 2004 16 August 2017 N.A.
entering 1992 2004
into Force
No of 53 72 152 128 N.A

Signatories
No of 187 161 183 114 175+
Parties Governments
and 85+ NGOs
Subject Transboundary Prior Persistent Organic Mercury Chemical
Matter movement Informed Pollutants (POPs) Management
of hazardous Consent
wastes Procedure
Last 14 (14th COP 9 (9th COP was 9 (9th COP was 2 (2nd COP was 4 (ICCM4 was
Conference was held in held from 29 held in Geneva, held in November held from 28
of Parties Geneva April -10 May Switzerland from 2018)2 September-2
Switzerland 2019 in 29 April- 10 May October 2015, 7th
from April Geneva, 2019 ) ICCM5 Bureau
29 - May 10, Switzerland) was held on
2019) 9-10th July, 2019)
2 The Third Meeting of COP under the Minamata Convention is scheduled to be held from 25-29 November,
2019 in Geneva. Available at: http://www.mercuryconvention.org/convention/conferenceoftheparties/
tabid/6337/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 8 November, 2019).
66
NLSIU
Indian Signed on: India was not Signed on:14/05/ Signed on: 30/ Acceded to
Position 15/03/1990 among the 2002 09/2014 SAICM in
original February 2006
Ratified on: Ratified on 13/ Ratified on 18/
signatory to the
24/06/1992 01/2006 06/2018
Rotterdam but
Entered accessioned to Became binding
into force it on 24/05/ on India on 13/
for India 2005 04/2006
on: 22/09/
The convention
1992
became binding
on India on
22/08/2005
3.3 BASEL CONVENTION ON THE TRANSBOUNDARY MOVEMENT

OF HAZARDOUS WASTES AND THEIR DISPOSAL (1989)
The Basel Convention of 1989 was the international community’s first attempt at dealing
with the problem of toxic trade at a global level.3 Officially titled The Basel Convention
on the Control of Trans-boundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal4
was adopted on 22nd March 1989 and entered into force on 5th May 1992. The management
of hazardous wastes had been on the UN’s agenda ever since the first Montevideo
Programme on Environmental Law in 19815. The process to develop and implement
guidelines regulating the movement of hazardous wastes across countries was accelerated
after the discovery in the mid-1980s that several countries in the developing world,
especially in Africa had become the dumping ground for the hazardous wastes of the
developed world. Subsequent to this, work on developing the Basel Convention began in
1987 with the approval of the Cairo Guidelines, an instrument that was designed to help
governments across the world in developing their own national policies regarding hazardous
wastes. In the same meeting, the Executive Director of the UNEP (United Nations
Environmental Programme) was mandated to create a group that would work on making
a global convention about the transboundary movement and trade of hazardous wastes.
3 Jennifer R. Kitt, Supra note 1.

4 Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal,
1 J Env Law 255–277 (1989).
67
NLSIU
This became the Basel Convention in 1989 with a Conference of Plenipotentiaries,

representing 116 countries, finally ratifying the convention.
As it currently stands, the Basel Convention has 187 parties, with Vanuatu being the last
entrant in 2019. The Convention has also been amended several times, with a new
amendment being proposed by Norway in 2018 that aims to minimise marine pollution
by restricting illegal dumping of plastic waste6. The amendment seeks to move plastic
waste from Annexure IX of the Convention to Annexure II, which would require countries
exporting plastic waste to get the informed consent of the importing country. Further, it
would create stringent requirements for plastic waste to be considered non-hazardous7.
This proposed amendment has been cautioned against by the FEAD (European Federation
of Waste Management and Environmental Services), which says that the amendment is
unlikely to achieve its stated objective, but will rather only serve to disrupt the growing
market for plastic waste, especially in the EU8.
The Basel Convention has been subject to criticism regarding its ineffectiveness in
achieving its stated objectives. It has been empirically found that international waste
trade has actually increased since the Basel Convention came into force. The Convention
has seemingly done more to legitimise international waste trade rather than reduce it.
The Ban Amendment, introduced in 1995 sought to address these concerns by banning
waste trade between countries mentioned in Annexure VII of the Convention and
countries not mentioned thereof. However, this amendment has been easy to circumvent
for countries worldwide. While international waste trade has increased, the newer parties
to the convention have exhibited low levels of waste export. Some attribute this to the
5 Montevideo Programme I, Available at: http://wedocs.unep.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.11822/20587/

montevideo-programme-i.pdf ?sequence=1&isallowed=y (Last accessed on May 8, 2019).
6 Proposed Amendments, Available at: http://www.basel.int/theconvention/amendments/proposed
amendments/tabid/7906/default.aspx (Last accessed on May 8, 2019).
7 Corrs Chambers Westgarth-Christine Covington & Tahnee De Souza, Murky Waters: Proposed
Amendments to Basel Convention on Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Waste | Lexology,
Available at: https://www.lexology.com/library/detail.aspx?g=1c9bf2b0-8b2b-44dc-9d48-8ff636a5711c
(Last accessed on May 8, 2019).
8 Fead Slaps Down Norway’s Basel Convention Amendment on Plastic Waste, (2018), Available at: https:/
/waste-management-world.com/A/Fead-slaps-down-norways-basel-convention-amendment-on-plastic-
waste (Last accessed on May 8, 2019).
68
NLSIU
success of the Convention, but the reality is that these countries have lower levels of
waste exports simply because they are smaller countries. So, while the average waste
export of the parties to the convention has decreased since it was introduced, it would
be incorrect to classify this as being any sort of effect of the Convention9.
Parties must take appropriate legal /

administrative action to implement
provisions of the Convention,
Illegal traffic of waste is a criminal act
including sanctions imposed to punish
contraventions
Parties must draft and

introduce national
legislations in order to
deal with illegal traffic
If illegal traffic is fault of exporting country, If responsibility cannot be traced back to

the country will take back exported waste, either exporting /importing country,
or if this is impractical, ensure that wastes parties concerned must dispose of waste
are disposed of in accordance with the in an environmentally sound manner
convention within 30 days of it coming to
the knowledge of that country
SALIENT PROVISIONS OF THE BASEL CONVENTION
E-waste has been a primary concern of the Basel Convention since 2002, when the
MPPI (Mobile Phone Partnership Initiative) was formed at the sixth Conference of Parties
(CoP) to the Basel Convention. The MPPI aims to promote the environmentally sound
management of end-of-life mobile telephones. In order to achieve this, a guidance
document10 was prepared and was finally adopted at the eleventh Conference of Parties
9 Derek Kellenberg & Arik Levinson, Waste of Effort? International Environmental Agreements 47.
10 MPPI Guidance Document, Available at: Http://www.basel.int/implementation/technicalassistance/
partnerships/MPPI/mppiguidancedocument/tabid/3250/default.aspx (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
69
NLSIU
in 201111. At the eighth meeting of the Conference in 2006, the Nairobi Declaration on
the Environmentally Sound Management of Electrical and Electronic Waste12 was
adopted, giving the Secretariat of the Basel Convention a formal framework within which
to operate on the development of a work plan to manage e-waste in an environmentally
sound manner. In pursuance of this, the ninth Conference developed a plan that aimed
to – 1) set up programmes for environmentally sound e-waste management in Africa and
the Asia-Pacific. 2) Set up the Partnership for Action on Computing Equipment (PACE).
3) Prepare technical guidelines on the trans-boundary movement of e-waste. Consequently,
PACE was established in 2008 as a multi-stakeholder entity that aimed to bring together
computer manufacturers, recyclers, trade associations, and any other concerned party in
order to tackle the issue of environmentally sound management of end-of-life computers
and accessories13.
The Cartagena Declaration14 was adopted at the tenth Conference of Parties (CoP) to
the Basel Convention in order to put forth a strong commitment by the Parties to promote
the prevention and minimisation of the generation of hazardous and other wastes. This
declaration was the culmination of the parties’ realisation that the Basel Convention’s
provisions had proven inadequate to deal with the issues posed by the accumulation of
waste, despite having been in force for over 20 years. The volume of hazardous waste
and its trans-boundary movement had only been increasing globally since the introduction
of the Basel Convention. This declaration aimed to actively promote and implement
strategies for prevention and minimisation of waste generation, take measures to delink
economic growth from environmental impact, and encourage greater co-operation between
parties so as to ensure that there are comprehensive global and regional efforts to
11 Mobile Phone Partnership Initiative, Available at: http://www.basel.int/implementation/technical

assistance/partnerships/mppi/overview/tabid/3268/default.aspx (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
12 Nairobi Declaration on the Environmentally Sound Management of Electrical and Electronic Waste,
Available at: Http://www.basel.int/portals/4/basel%20convention/docs/meetings/cop/cop8/nairobi
declaration.pdf (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
13 Partnership for Action on Computing Equipment, Available at: http://www.basel.int/implementation/
technicalassistance/partnerships/pace/overview/tabid/3243/default.aspx (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
14 Cartagena Declaration on the Prevention, Minimization and Recovery of Hazardous Wastes and Other
Wastes, Available at: Http://www.basel.int/portals/4/basel%20convention/docs/meetings/cop/cop10/
cartagenadeclaration.pdf. (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
70
NLSIU
improve access to cleaner production processes through capacity building and technology
transfers.
Further, the parties directed the Open Ended Working Group (OEWG) to look at the
progress that the parties had made in implementing the Declaration and to prepare a plan
of action for the future. At the OEWG’s ninth meeting, a road map15 was presented that
formulated guidelines and mandated certain action for the effective implementation of
the Declaration. At the twelfth CoP, the parties adopted the road map and further directed
the Expert Working Group (EWG) on Environmentally Sound Management (ESM) to
develop more guidelines that would assist parties in developing efficient strategies in
order to prevent and minimise the generation of waste as a part of its regular work
programme dealing with the ESM Framework. At its sixth meeting, the EWG submitted
a draft guidance document16 that was to be presented at the thirteenth CoP for its
consideration.
As it stands, the Cartagena Declaration continues to be an invaluable guidance document
that the CoP continues to update regularly. At the most recent, fourteenth CoP, the
parties agreed to continue the implementation of the Declaration through the adoption
of a new and updated plan of action.
3.4 ROTTERDAM CONVENTION ON THE PRIOR INFORMED

CONSENT PROCEDURE FOR CERTAIN HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS
AND PESTICIDES IN INTERNATIONAL TRADE, 1998
The Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain
Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade (hereinafter Rotterdam
Convention) is an international multilateral treaty with the aim of promotion of “shared
responsibilities” in the matter of import and export of hazardous chemicals. The Convention
15 Road Map for Action on the Implementation of the Cartagena Declaration, Available at: http://basel.int/
theconvention/openendedworkinggroup(oewg)/reportsanddecisions/tabid/3413/ctl/download/mid/
14072/default.aspx?id=5&objid=13568. (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
16 Draft Guidance to Assist Parties in Developing Efficient Strategies for Achieving the Prevention and
Minimization of the Generation of Hazardous and other Wastes and their Disposal, Available at: Http:/
/www.basel.int/implementation/country ledinitiative/meetings/ewg6onesm/overview/tabid/5356/ctl/
download/mid/16415/default.aspx?id=1&objid=15788. (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
71
NLSIU
advocates and prescribes “open exchange of information” and requires exporters of hazardous
chemicals to apply proper labelling and provide directions on safe handling, and provide
informationto the purchasers of any known restrictions or bans. Signatory nations of the
convention can take decision on the matter of import i.e. “whether to allow or ban the
importation of chemicals which are listed in the annex of the treaty”. To further that goal, the
convention casts and obligation on the exporting countries to make sure that their
producers comply with the requirement standards.17
The text of the Convention was adopted on 10
Primary objective of the
September 1998 in Rotterdam, Netherlands and the
Convention is to “Promote shared
Convention entered into force on 24 February 2004
responsibility and cooperative efforts among
parties in the international trade of certain and became legally binding for its parties.18 The ninth
hazardous chemicals in order to protect meeting of the Rotterdam Conference was held in
human health and the environment from the city of Geneva, Switzerland from 29 April - 10
potential harm and to contribute to their May 2019.19 The Convention comprises of 30 Articles
environmentally sound use, by facilitating and VI Annexures.20 21
information exchange about their
characteristics, by providing for a national The Convention applies to banned or severely
decision-making process on their import and restricted chemicals; and severely hazardous pesticide
export and by disseminating these decisions for mulations. 22 However, narcotic dr ugs and
to parties” psychotropic substance, radioactive materials, wastes,
chemical weapons, pharmaceuticals, food additives,
17 Text of the Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain Hazardous
Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade, Available at: http://www.pic.int/portals/5/
download.aspx?d=unep-fao-rc-convtext-2017.english.pdf (Last accessed on 24 October, 2019).
18 History of Rotterdam Convention, Available at http://www.pic.int/theconvention/overview/history/
overview/tabid/1360/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on October 24, 2019).
19 Available at http://www.brsmeas.org/2019cops/overview/tabid/7523/language/en-us/default.aspx/
(Last accessed on October 24, 2019).
20 Text of the Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain Hazardous
Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade, Available at: http://www.pic.int/portals/5/
download.aspx?d=unep-fao-rc-convtext-2017.english.pdf (Last accessed on 24 October, 2019).
21 Ibid, Article 1.
22 Ibid, Article 3. [For the Definition of the Term Chemicals, Banned Chemicals, Severely Restricted Chemicals
And Severely Hazardous Pesticide Formulation See Article 2 of the Convention].
23 Ibid Article 3(2).
72
NLSIU
food are not covered under the scope of the convention.23 The Convention also does not
cover chemicals in quantities which is not likely to affect human health or the environment
with the condition that they are imported for the purpose of research and analysis or by
an individual for his or her own personal use in quantities which is reasonable for such
use.24
Article 4 of the Convention mandates each party to

designate national authorities for the performance
of administrative functions required by the
Convention.

Article 5 mandates each party to notify the Secretariat
in writing of the final regulatory action regarding
banned or severally restricted chemicals, that they
have adopted in the form contained in Annexure.
Annexure III is one of the most important annexures to the Convention as it lists the
chemicals which are subject to the Prior Informed Consent Procedure. Annexure II and
IV of the Convention lays down the criteria for listing banned or severely restricted
chemicals; and severely hazardous pesticide formulations, respectively, in Annexure III.
Annexure V and VI contain the information requirements for export notification25 and
procedure for settlements of disputes,26 respectively.
To achieve the objectives of the Convention the two key mechanisms established are
Prior Informed Consent Procedure and Information Exchange (Article 14). Two key
players involved in this process are parties to the Convention, their Designated National
Authorities (DNA) (under Article 4), Conference of Parties (CoP) (under Article 18),
24 Ibid.
25 See Article 12.
26 See Article 20.
73
NLSIU
Chemical Review Committee (CRC) (under Article 18(6)) and the Secretariat (under
Article 19).
Prior Informed Consent Procedure:27 The Prior Informed Consent Procedure is one
of the mechanisms established under the convention. One of the key purpose of the
PIC mechanism is the formal acquisition and dissemination of the decisions taken by the
importing parties pertaining to the matter that “whether they wish to receive future shipments of
those chemicals listed in Annex III of the Convention”. The other key function of the PIC
mechanism is to ensure compliance with these decisions by the exporting parties. A
Decision Guidance Document (DGD) is the starting point of the PIC procedure. It is
prepared for each and every chemical which is listed under Annex III and which is subject
to the PIC procedure. After preparation, the DGD is sent to all the parties. The purpose
behind the DGD is to help governments in assessing the risks that are associated with
the “handling and use of the chemical” so that they can make more informed decisions about
future import and use of the chemical, considering their local conditions. Based on the
DGD, all the parties are required to take decision as to whether or not they will allow
future import of each of the chemicals listed under Annex III of the Convention. These
decisions are known as import responses. These import responses are then circulated by
the Secretariat to all the DNAs periodically every six months via a PIC Circular and they
are also available on the Convention’s official website. All the exporting parties are then
under an obligation to ensure that exportation of chemicals which subject to the PIC
procedure do not occur in a contrary manner to the decision of the importing party. They
should also ensure that the import responses in the PIC Circular are communicated to
their exporters, industry and other relevant authorities such as Department of
Customs etc.28
27 For an in depth working of the PIC Procedure: See Frequently Asked Questions About the Rotterdam
Convention on the Official Rotterdam Convention Website, Available at: http://www.pic.int/
theconvention/overview/frequentlyaskedquestions/tabid/1062/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last
accessed on October 28, 2019).
28 The Prior Informed Consent Procedure, Available at: http://www.pic.int/theconvention/overview/
howitworks/tabid/1046/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on October 28, 2019).
74
NLSIU
Information Exchange: Information Exchange is another important requirement of

the Convention and it takes place in accordance with Article 14 of the Convention. The
Information exchange takes place under the convention by each party notifying the
Secretariat when a domestic regulatory action to ban or severely restrict a chemical is
taken. The summaries of these notifications and proposals are received by all the parties
on a regular basis via the PIC Circular. When a banned or severely restricted chemical is
exported by a party from its territory, then that party must notify each and every individual
party which is importing that chemical before the first shipment and thereafter on an
annual basis. The exports are also required to be appropriately labelled and accompanied
by basic health and safety information in the form of a safety data sheet.29
3.5 STOCKHOLM CONVENTION ON PERSISTENT ORGANIC

POLLUTANTS (2001)
The Stockholm Convention, formally called the Stockholm Convention on Persistent

Organic Pollutants, is a globally binding international treaty that aims to eliminate or
restrict the production, use, storage, trade of Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs). POPs
are organic compounds that are resistant to environmental degradation through chemical,
biological and photolytic processes, they bioaccumulate and are transported through air,
water and migratory species, across international boundaries and are deposited far from
their place of release, where they accumulate in terrestrial and aquatic ecosystems.30
They possess toxic properties and are hazardous for human health (especially in developing
countries in particular to women). The biomagnification of POPs pose particular risks to
the Arctic ecosystems and indigenous communities as they contaminate their traditional
food supply.31 Because of long-range transport of POPs, the international community
had been calling for global action to reduce and eliminate release of these chemicals
which resulted in the Stockholm Convention, an important step towards minimizing
29 Information Exchange Available at: http://www.pic.int/theconvention/overview/howitworks/tabid/

1046/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on October 28, 2019).
30 Recitals to the Stockholm Convention; See Text of the Stockholm Convention, Infra note 38.
31 Ibid.
75
NLSIU
risks from the impact of POPs.32 The objective of the Convention is to protect human
health and the environment from Persistent Organic Pollutants.33
 30 Articles
Text of the  6 Annexes A-G
Convention
 Mandates prohibition and/or elimination of the production & usage including import & export
of intentionally produced POPs that are listed in Annex A & B.
 Specific exemptions can be sought by the parties and for that purpose a Register has to be
Article 3 maintained as mandated by Article 4.
 Mandates measure that are to be taken by each party to reduce or eliminate releases from
intentional production of the chemicals listed in Annex C.
Article 5  Development of an action plan and implementation plan.
 Ensuring safe and environmentally sound management of stockpiles and waste containing POPs.
 Stockpiles and wastes containing POPs are transported across international boundaries considering
relevant international rules, standards and obligations.
Article 6
 Capacity development of national governments.
3.5.1 LISTING OF CHEMICALS UNDER THE CONVENTION:
Initially the Convention contained 12 POPs called as “Dirty Dozen”.34 However since
its adoption the list of POPs has constantly expanded. Article 8 of the Convention
provides the detailed procedure for the listing of new POPs in Annexes A, B and/or C.
A party tothe Convention may submit a proposal to the Secretariat for listing a chemical
in Annexes A, B and/or C.35 The proposal shall contain the information specified in
32 See Importance of Stockholm Convention at Toxic Links, Available at: http://www.toxicslink.org?

q=content/stockholm-convention (Last accessed on 4 November, 2019).
33 Stockholm Convention Article 1. The Text of the Convention is Available at: http://www.pops.int/
theconvention/overview/textoftheconvention/tabid/2232/default.aspx (Last accessed on 2 November,
2019).
34 Listing of Chemicals Under the Stockholm Convention by Toxic Links, Available at: http://
www.toxicslink.org/?q=content/stockholm-convention (Last accessed on 3 November, 2019).
35 Article 8(1).
76
NLSIU
Annex D (This is verified by the Secretariat). Upon the verification by the Secretariat the
proposal is forwarded to the Persistent Organic Pollutants Review Committee (POPRC)36.
The committee shall examine the proposal and apply the screening criteria specified in
Annex D in a flexible and transparent way as per Article 8(3). If the Committee is not
satisfied the proposal is set aside after informing the parties and observers.37 But if satisfied
the Committee shall make the proposal and its evaluation available to all the parties and
observers and invite them to submit the information specified in Annex E.38 Following
this the Committee shall further review the proposal, taking into account any relevant
additional information received, and shall prepare a draft risk profile in accordance with
Annex E which shall go through the Secretariat, make the draft available to all parties
and observers, collect technical comments from them and, takin those comments into
account, complete the risk profile. Pursuant to that the Committee shall prepare a Risk
Management Evaluation under provision of Article 8(7)(a).39 Based on risk profile and
risk management evaluation, the Committee shall recommend whether the chemical
should be considered by the Conference of the Parties for listing. Finally, the Conference
of the Parties shall decide whether to list the chemical and specify its related control
measures in Annexes A, B, and/or C.
Other key provisions of the Convention are: the development of implementation plans40,
Information exchange 41 public information, awareness and education 42 research
development and monitoring43 Technical Assistance (Article 12), Financial resources
36 See Article 19(6). [POPRC is a subsidiary body formed under the convention by the Conference of the
Parties].
37 However, an option of resubmission of the proposal is also provided for under Article 8(5).
38 Article 8(4).
39 However, after the risk profile conducted under Article 8(6) if the Committee decides that the proposal
shall not proceed it can set aside the same under Article 8(7)(B).
40 Article 7.
41 Article 9.
42 Article 10.
43 Article 11.
77
NLSIU
and mechanisms 44 Reporting Mechanism 45, Effectiveness evaluation 46 and non-

compliance47.
3.6 STRATEGIC APPROACH TO INTERNATIONAL CHEMICALS

MANAGEMENT (SAICM) (2006)
SAICM (Strategic Approach to Chemical Management) is a global policy framework and

strategy with the aim of promotion of chemical safety throughout the world.48 It was
adopted by the Governments and stakeholders in the First International Chemical
Conference on Chemical Management (ICCM-1).49 It was adopted in order to protect
human health and ecosystem from the harmful effects which are caused by exposure to
toxic chemical substances. The scope of the SAICM includes environmental, economic,
social, health and labour aspects of chemical safety; It also covers agricultural and industrial
chemicals. The ultimate goal of SAICM is the promotion of sustainable development
and its coverage encompasses chemicals at all stages of their life-cycle, including end
products.50 However if the health and environment safety concerns of the products and
chemicals are regulated by a domestic food or pharmaceutical authority or arrangement,
then to that extent they are not covered under SAICM.51 The overall objective of SAICM
is the achievement of sound management of chemicals throughout their life-cycle so
that, by 2020, the production and usage of chemicals take place in ways which lead to
the minimization of adverse effects on human health and the environment.52 The primary
objectives of SAICM are categorized under five themes, namely: Risk reduction,
44 Article 13.
45 Article 15.
46 Article 16.
47 Article 17.
48 SAICM Overview Available at: http://www.saicm.org/about/saicmoverview/tabid/5522/language/
en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 8 November 2019).
49 Ibid.
50 See the Text of SAICM Available at: http://www.saicm.org/portals/12/documents/saicmtexts/saicm-
publication-en.pdf (Last accessed on 8 November, 2019).
51 See footnote to Article 3 of SAICM Text, Ibid.
52 Article 13 of Saicam Text, Supra note 50.
78
NLSIU
Knowledge and Information, Governance, Capacity-building and technical cooperation;

and Illegal international traffic.53 The primary instrument to achieve these objectives is
the set of activities mentioned in the Global Plan of Action.
Highly hazardous Chemicals in

pesticides Products
Per-f luorinated Hazardous substances

chemicals and the within the life cycle of
transition to safer electrical and
alternatives electronic products
Environmentally Nanotechnology and

persistent manufactured
phar maceutical nanomaterials
pollutants
Endocrine
Lead in paint disrupting
chemicals
EMERGING POLICY ISSUES ADOPTED BY SAICM
These resolutions adopted recognize the policy imperatives to address identified

concerns, agree on the actions needed and appeal to the specific stakeholders to consider
undertaking certain actions.54
53 See SAICM Overview Available at: http://www.saicm.org/about/saicmoverview/tabid/5522/

language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 8 November, 2019).
54 Available at: http://www.saicm.org/implementation/emergingpolicyissues/tabid/5524/language/
en-us/default.aspx. (Last accessed on11 November, 2019).
79
NLSIU
3.7 MINAMATA CONVENTION ON MERCURY (2017)
The Minamata Convention on Mercury is a global treaty with the aim of protection of
human health and the environment from the harmful effects of mercury.55 It was agreed
upon at the fifth session of the Intergovernmental Negotiation Committee on mercury in
Geneva, Switzerland on January 19th, 2013 the convention was adopted on October 10,
2013 at a Diplomatic Conference held in Kumamoto, Japan.56 The Convention entered
into force on 16th August 2017 i.e. on the 90th day after the date of deposit of 50th
instrument of ratification, acceptance, approval or accession.57
It is noteworthy that, Minamata Convention is perhaps the only international treaty that
with a focal point on a single pollutant i.e. mercury which is a global and ubiquitous
metal. It occurs naturally and has multiple uses in objects of day to day life. It is released
into the environment (air, soil and water) from a wide range of sources. Mercury is a
highly toxic metal and metabolizes into methyl mercury naturally which is fatal for the
human environment.58 One of the key objectives of the Convention is to control the
anthropogenic releases of mercury into the environment. The Convention addresses
mercury throughout its life cycle including mining, manufacture, production, storage,
emissions, releases, wastes and disposal. The Convention is named after the catastrophic
pollution which was caused by industrial releases of methyl mercury in Minamata, Japan
which caused the epidemic known as Minamata disease in the 1950s and onwards.59
The text of the Convention comprises of 35 Articles and 6 Annexures. As per Article 1,
the objective of the Convention is to protect the human health and the environment
55 Available at: http://www.mercuryconvention.org/convention/text (Last accessed on 5 November 2019).

56 Ibid.
57 Ibid. [See also Article 31.1 of the Minamata Convention which prescribes that the Convention shall enter
into force on the Ninetieth Day after the date of deposit of the Fiftieth Instrument of Ratification,
Acceptance, Approval or Accession.].
58 Jamima K Yeptho, The Minamata Convention on Mercury and India: A Legal Review, 4 International Journal
of Legal Developments and Allied Issues 381 (2018).
59 Ibid.
80
NLSIU
from anthropogenic emissions and releases of mercury and mercury compounds.60 It applies
to mercury, mercury compounds and mercury added products.61 The primary focus of
treaty is on: controlling and regulating mercury trade, reducing supply and usage control,
lessening mercury emissions and releases, ensuring mercury emissions and releases,
ensuring mercury waste handling in sage and environmentally sound manner.62
Link between Basel and Minamata Convention: Elemental mercury, or mercury

containing or contaminated wastes, are categorised as hazardous wastes under Annex I
of the Basel Convention63. The Convention has also found it prudent to develop and
adopt technical guidelines regarding the environmentally sound management of mercury
wastes. The first set of technical guidelines64 were adopted at the 10th Conference of
Parties. A committee was constituted at the 11th COP to update these guidelines under
the leadership of Japan. The results of this update were unveiled at the 12th COP where
the revised technical guidelines were adopted65. The revised guidelines included among
other things, provisions dealing with the Minamata Convention on Mercury66 which was
60 Article 1, Minamata Convention on Mercury.

61 Article 2(d) defines Mercury as Elemental Mercury (Hg(0), Cas No. 7439-97-6); Article 2(e) defines
mercury compounds as any substance consisting of atoms of mercury and one or more atoms of
other chemical elements that can be separated into different components only by chemical reactions;
and article 2(f) defines mercury added product as a product or product component that contains
mercury or mercury compound that was intentionally added.
62 Toxic links, Mercury Free India – Right Choices, Available at: http://toxicslink.org/docs/mercury-
free-india.pdf (Last accessed on 6 November, 2019).
63 Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their
Disposal, 1 J Env Law 255–277 (1989).
64 Technical Guidelines for the Environmentally Sound Management of Wastes Consisting of Elemental
Mercury and Wastes Containing or Contaminated with Mercury (2011), Available at: http://
www.basel.int/portals/4/basel%20convention/docs/pub/techguid/mercury/06a2r1e.pdf (Last
accessed on May 13, 2019).
65 Technical Guidelines for the Environmentally Sound Management of Wastes Consisting of Elemental
Mercury and Wastes Containing or Contaminated with Mercury (2015), Available at: http://
www.basel.int/portals/4/download.aspx?d=unep-chw.12-5-add.8-rev.1.english.pdf (Last accessed on
May 13, 2019).
66 Minamata Convention on Mercury, Available at: http://www.mercuryconvention.org/portals/11/
documents/booklets/cop1%20version/minamata-convention-booklet-eng-full.pdf (Last accessed on
May 13, 2019).
81
NLSIU
adopted in 2013. The Minamata Convention aims to protect human and environmental
health against the emission of mercury. There has been a growing tendency in recent
years to move away from mercury added products, which will result in a situation where
the global supply of mercury will far outstrip its demand. This excess of mercury would
pose major threats to environmental stability at the scale of the Minamata disaster in the
1950s in Japan67, if not handled and managed properly. In addition to this, the Basel
Convention has forged partnerships with private and public organisations such as the
UNEP Global Mercury Partnership 68. The Basel Convention assists the Mercury
Partnership by providing expertise in the areas of mercury waste management; mercury
supply and storage; and mercury reduction in products.
3.8 INDIAN RESPONSE AND COMPLIANCE TO THE CONVENTIONS
3.8.1 INDIA AND THE BASEL CONVENTION
India was one of the initial countries to sign and ratify the Basel Convention; having
ratified the Convention on 22nd September 1992, just over four months after it had come
into force. However, considering the inadequacy of the Convention’s initial provisions
to tackle the problem of hazardous waste movement effectively, this did not have much
of an effect on India. Being a developing country, India had become a dumping ground
for the waste materials of the developed countries and was one of the leading importers
of waste materials in the world. The ratification of the Basel Convention had done little
to change that. In an attempt to improve their situation, India and a few other developing
nations came together at the first Conference of Parties to the Basel Convention and
stated that developed nations had to keep their own waste rather than attempting to
dump it on a developing country. India continued to maintain this stance at the second
Conference as well, sowing the seeds for the introduction of the Ban Amendment to the
Basel Convention, which would ban countries which were part of the OECD, i.e.
developed countries from moving their wastes to non-OECD, i.e. developing countries.
However, in the next Conference, India changed its stance. At the ninth Conference,
India went a step further, stating that they viewed hazardous waste as recyclable material.
This transition, from being staunchly opposed to the international trade of hazardous
82
NLSIU
waste to welcoming such trade with open arms has seen India continue to be one of the
largest importers of hazardous waste. The Ban Amendment, of which India was one of
the early proponents has still not been ratified by the country, and has also not come into
effect anywhere else nearly 25 years after it was first introduced as its fate has now fallen
into the hands of the developed countries, who would much rather never see the Ban
Amendment coming into force69.Thus, it is evident that the provisions of the Basel
Convention have not been able to gain significant ground in the Indian context, especially
when it comes to the Ban Amendment, which continues to remain unratified. The
ineffectiveness of the Basel Convention has to be rectified by trying to move away from
defining the hazardous waste trade in economic terms and moving towards defining it in
environmental terms.
Following the introduction of the Basel Convention, India brought in a national legislation
in order to deal with hazardous wastes, the Hazardous Waste (Management & Handling)
Rules, 1989 under the provisions of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. This
legislation was found to be lacking in terms of covering the provisions of the Basel
Convention and hence was amended several times throughout the years until it was
finally repealed and replaced by the Hazardous Waste (Management & Handling) Rules,
2008.70 This new legislation too was amended four times before it was replaced by the
Hazardous Waste (Management & Handling) Rules, 2016 which has been recently
amended in 2019.71 India also brought out a National Hazardous Waste Management
Strategy in 2017.72
67 M. Harada, Minamata Disease: Methylmercury Poisoning in Japan Caused by Environmental Pollution, 25 Crit.
Rev. Toxicol. 1–24 (1995).
68 Global Mercury Partnership, Available at: https: //web.unep.org/globalmercurypartnership/ (Last
69 Mayank Aggarwal, Environment Ministry Seeks Suggestions on Global Meets on Hazardous Waste,
Pollutants (2017), Available at: https: //www.livemint.com/politics/li6p64jypj4ier0vwp0zri/
environment-ministry-seeks-suggestions-on-global-meets-on-ha.html (Last accessed on May 8, 2019).
70 Hazardous Waste (Management & Handling) Rules,, 2008, Available at: http: //mpcb.gov.in/
hazardous/pdf/hwrulesfinalnoti240908.pdf (Last accessed on May 9, 2019).
71 Ibid.
72 National Hazardous Waste Management Strategy, Available at: https://www.informea.org/en/National-
hazardous-waste-management-strategy (Last accessed on May 9, 2019).
83
NLSIU
Alongside these frequent legislative measures taken up by the Environment Ministry,

there has also been some judicial action. The most significant of these judicial tussles
has to be Research Foundation for Science, Technology & National Resource Policy v. Union of
India. This petitioner (along with many others) has filed several petitions over the years
beginning in 1997,73 regarding the scrapping of a ship involved in an oil spill in India, and
extending all the way to 2018,74 where the Supreme Court transferred the case to the
National Green Tribunal. The gist of the various petitions filed is that the petitioners felt
that the legislations brought out by the ministry were inadequate in dealing with the
problem of hazardous waste, and also that they were a far cry from the provisions laid
down in the Basel Convention, which they sought to emulate. There were also claims
that the current policy of the government regarding hazardous waste violated several
fundamental rights of the citizens.
Through its judgments in these matters, the Supreme Court established itself as a protector
of the environmental rights of the citizens. In a 2012 judgment75, the Supreme Court
directed the government to ban the import of all hazardous waste as identified under the
Basel Convention, and also directed it to amend the Hazardous Waste (Management &
Handling) Rules and bring it in line with the Basel Convention and Articles 21, 47 and
48-A of the Constitution.
India, being a party to the Basel Convention, deals with illegal traffic of waste under the
Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016.76
Under paragraph 15 of Chapter III of these Rules, illegal traffic of hazardous waste is
defined. In essence, illegal traffic under this Rule is constituted by any trade of hazardous
waste that is in contravention to the provisions of Chapter III. These provisions talk
about the prior informed consent required, the approval of the Ministry of Environment,
73 Research Foundation for Science vs. Union of India, (1999) 1 SCC 223.
74 Research Foundation for Science vs. Union of India, Writ Petition (Civil) No.(s) 657 of 1995.
75 Research Foundation for Science vs. Union of India, (2012) 7 SCC 769.
76 Hazardous and other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016, Available at:
http://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id= ahdtzc 9iv01 funvs zxnfm jaxni5wzgy=. (Last accessed on
May 10, 2019).
84
NLSIU
and also the various other licenses and permissions required before a party can engage in
either import or export of hazardous waste. If these conditions are contravened, the
legislation provides for sanctions that are similar to the ones enumerated by the Basel
Convention. In cases of illegal import, the importer is liable to re-export the hazardous
wastes within 90 days of its arrival to India, and if the importer is not traceable, the
customs authority is free to sell the waste to anyone who is authorised under the rules to
handle them, or send it to the State Pollution Control Board. As can be seen, the rules
brought into force by India conform to the guidelines that have been laid down in the
Basel Convention, with a few minor changes like the time period requirement.
However, the enforcement of these rules is proving to be a problem as they do not have
any penal provisions with which to punish the illegal traders. The maximum amount of
damage that can be caused to these traders is to force them to re-export the wastes at
their own cost. While this could result in some financial difficulty for smaller traders, the
bigger traders would face no significant problem, and would not be effectively deterred
from continuing such operations. In the case of P.P. Electronics vs. New Delhi (Import &
General)77, an electronics store owner imported some Colour Picture Tubes and declared
them to be new. But on inspection it was found that the tubes were old and used. An
expert certified these tubes as constituting hazardous waste. The court directed the
importer to re-export the goods under the Hazardous Waste Management Rules within
90 days. As has already been mentioned, this decision of the court could be seen as being
detrimental to the interests of a smaller entity like the one in this case and act as an
effective deterrent; however such sanctions would make no difference to the operations
of a larger firm.
Thus, we can see that India has taken several steps to ensure that its waste policy
framework is in accordance with the guidelines of the Basel Convention; however more
needs to be done in order to ensure that these guidelines do not just remain guiding
principles, but are also enforced and implemented effectively.
77 P.P. Electronics vs. New Delhi (Import & General), Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal,
2018.
85
NLSIU
3.8.2 E-WASTE AND INDIA
The management of e-wastes in India used to be for a long time governed by the Hazardous
Waste Management Rules under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. However, in
2011, the E-Waste (Management and Handling) Rules78 were enacted and came into
effect on 1st May, 2012. This Rule allowed for the recycling of e-wastes in order to save
usable materials that would have otherwise been sent directly for disposal for classifying
as hazardous waste. These Rules also brought in the concept of Extended Producer
Responsibility (EPR), which made the manufacturers of electronic goods liable for the
safe disposal of any waste arising from such production, and also for the safe disposal of
any post-consumption products. The Rules were replaced by the E-Waste (Management)
Rules, 201679 which came into effect on 1st October, 2016.
A significant change that the E-Waste Rules have brought in was the proposal of a buy-
back scheme in order to augment the EPR policy, wherein producers would have to buy
products back from the consumer at the time of disposal. This gave the consumers an
incentive to hand in their disposable electronics to the producer rather than disposing
them off by themselves in an environmentally harmful manner. Further, there was an
attempt to formalise the informal sector of e-waste disposal, which accounted for handling
over 90% of the e-waste generated in the country80. The new Rules also ushered in the
concept of Producer Responsibility Organisations (PROs), further enhancing the viability
of EPR. These organisations essentially take over the responsibility of e-waste
management from producers for a certain price and ensure that the e-waste is recycled or
disposed of in an efficient and environmentally responsible manner.
78 E-waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 2011, Availabale at: https://www.citehr.com/attachments/

113546-e-waste-management-handling-rules-2011-pdf-e-waste-mgmt-handling-rules-2011.pdf (Last
79 E-waste (Management) Rules, 2016, Availabale at: http://www.invironmentportal.org.in/files/file/
ewm%20rules%202016.pdf (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
80 Dr Lakshmi Raghupathy et al., E-waste Recycling in India – Bridging the Gap Between the Informal and Formal
Sector. Availabale at: Https://www.iswa.org/uploads/tx_iswaknowledgebase/krueger.pdf. See also
miles park, electronic waste is recycled in appalling conditions in india,the conversation, http://
theconversation.com/electronic-waste-is-recycled-in-appalling-conditions-in-india-110363 (Last accessed
on May 10, 2019).
86
NLSIU
The Rules were amended in 2018 with the introduction of the E-Waste (Management)
Amendment Rules81. The most important change that this amendment brought in was
the revision of the EPR e-waste collection targets for producers. These collection targets
mandate that the producers collect a certain percentage of the e-waste that has been
produced as a consequence of the use of their products. Under the 2016 Rules, these
targets began at 30% of the total waste generated during the first two years of the
implementation of the rules, and increased by 10% every two years until after seven
years, where the target would become 70% of the total quantity82, Under the amended
Rules, these targets were brought down to 10% in the first year, 20% in the second year,
and so on till the seventh year where the target would be 70%. These targets were lowered
because firms were simply not conforming to them, resulting in the Central Pollution
Control Board (CPCB) having to send notices to over 200 companies for not complying
with collection norms83. There was also a new category introduced for firms that had just
begun operations, wherein their targets would begin at 5% and reach 20% after seven years.
This was done in order to ensure that newer firms are not put at a disadvantage where
their profitability is affected by the demands of the collection targets. Another change
brought in by the amendment was that PROs are now needed to register themselves with
the CPCB, thus allowing the CPCB to monitor and supervise the activities of these PROs.
There has not been much judicial action or judiciary driven policy changes in the context
of e-waste in India, with most cases either dealing with the non-implementation of the
provisions of the legislations enacted84, i.e. the E-Waste Management Rules, or the
penalising of illegal imports of e-waste (banned by the Hazardous Waste Management
Act) by the imposition of fines and mandated re-export of the goods85.
81 E- Waste (Managment) Amendment Rules, 2018, Availabale at: http://www.indiaenvironment

portal.org.in/files/file/e-%20waste%20 (managment)%20amendment %20%2 0rules, %202018.pdf
82 Supra note 94.
83 Jacob Koshy, What is India Doing with its 2 Million Tonnes of E-waste Every Year?,The Hindu, January 13,
2018, Availabale at: https://www.thehindu.com/eci-tech/energy-and-environment/Indias-toxic-eiffel-
towers-we-produce-2-million-tonnes-of-e-waste-every-year-and-the-new-regulations-arent-helping-
deal-with-it/article22429947.ece (Last accessed on May 10, 2019).
84 Nagrikupbhokta & Ors. vs. State of M.P. & 10 Ors., National Green Tribunal, 2017.
85 P. P. Electronics vs. New Delhi (Import & General), Customs, Excise & Service Tax Appellate Tribunal,
2018.
87
NLSIU
India currently ranks fifth in terms of e-waste production in the world, producing
around 2 million tonnes a year86. It is now clear that while there are several provisions
and legislations that govern the disposal of e-wastes in India; their implementation still
leaves a lot to be desired. Implementation and enforcement of the enacted Rules has to
become the government’s main priority when it comes to managing the e-waste situation
in India.
Needs and Gaps in Indian Compliance under the Basel Convention
NEEDS AND GAPS STATUS OF COMPLIANCE
1. Need for National Definition India has complied to the requirement of the
reporting of national definition.
2. Need for Prior consent before There is no data available as to whether India did
exporting the waste. give any consent to the import of waste in the
recent years.
3. Designation of competent India has complied to it.

authorities and focal point
4. National inventory should No data available in national inventory about

maintain about the illegal illegal traffic.
traffic either through export
and import
86 Jaideep Shenoy, India among the Top Five Countries in E-waste Generation: Assocham-nec Study |
India News – The Times of India, Availaable at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/india-
among-the-top-five-countries-in-e-waste-generation-assocham-nec-study/articleshow/64448208.cms
88
NLSIU
and import
5. Checklist for the Legislator It is helpful for the preparation of the national
inventory which would in turn help for annual
national reporting of a country.
6. Strategic framework for the No reports on India’s stand on Indonesian-Swiss

years 2012-2020 country-led initiative and also there is a need for
the data on how India would be effected by the
Ban Amendment if ratified by our country.
7. Technical guidelines for e- India has enacted the rules and guidelines in
waste, cement kilns, etc., furtherance of the Basel Convention.
8. Accident Reporting India has Chemical Accident Information

Reporting System and Accident Reporting
Procedure.
3.8.3 INDIA AND ROTTERDAM CONVENTION
To perform its obligations under Article 4 of the Convention India needed to identify
departments and institutions as Designated National Authorities (DNAs) which can act
on its behalf to perform the various administrative functions required under the
Convention.87 India has designated Department of Chemicals and Petrochemicals, Ministry
of Chemicals and Fertilizers, and Department of Agriculture, Cooperation and Farmers
Welfare, Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers’ Welfare as the National Authorities under
the Rotterdam Convention.88 The Official Contact Points (OCPs) are designated in Ministry
of Environment, Forests and Climate Change (MoEF&CC).
In 2017, India opposed the listing of Chrysotile asbestos as a hazardous substance under
the Rotterdam Convention at the 8th CoP that was conducted in Geneva.89
87 Article 4 of the Rotterdam Convention.

88 Available at: http://www.pic.int/countries/countrycontacts/tabid/3282/language/enus/default.aspx
(Last accessed on October 24, 2019).
89 Available at : https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/chrysotile-asbestos-not-hazardous-says-
india-under-rotterdam-convention/storyqfmw glmary hboh4e4atspo.html. (Last accessed on October
24, 2019).
89
NLSIU
Some of the policy initiatives taken for ensuring chemical safety in the country, as well
as for implementing the Convention are as follows:
Comprehensive National Chemical Profile assessing the existing

institutional, administrative, technical and legal infrastructure
vis-a-vis the requirements of safe handling of chemicals in the
country is being prepared.
1729 Major Accident Hazard Units (MAH) in 22 States / UTs.

1569 on-site Plans and 137 Off-site plans have been prepared.
GIS based Emergency Planning and Response System developed

in Gujarat, Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh Delhi,
Assam, Haryana, West Bengal, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar Pradesh,
Karnataka, Punjab, Rajasthan and Kerala.
Out of 270 districts having MAH Units, 180 have hazard prone
industrial pockets. Hazard Analysis studies have been initiated for
107 districts.
Inventorization study on “Isolated Storages” carried out during

2001-02 has identified 347 Isolated Storages in the country.
As per CoP 9 of the Rotterdam Convention two new chemicals

(Phorate and HBCD) were added in the list for mandatory PIC
procedure in international trade.
90
NLSIU
3.8.4 INDIA AND THE STOCKHOLM CONVENTION
India became a full party to the Stockholm Convention in 2006 and issued a National
Implementation Plan (NIP) in 201190, in accordance with Article 7 of the Convention
stipulating that every party must issue an NIP. However, for a very long time India had
refused to list any new POPs that the Stockholm Convention had brought in, choosing
instead to stick with the original 12 chemicals that were on the list. Usually, if any new
chemical is banned under the Convention, the ban also automatically applies to most
parties, unless they make a special request to the Secretariat saying that they cannot
accept it. India on the other hand, is a part of a select group of countries that automatically
rejects a new listing unless they write to the Secretariat explicitly accepting it91. India
took full advantage of this rule, choosing to do nothing with regard to the new listings
for over 12 years. Even the NIP introduced in 2011, failed to take any note of the newly
banned substances.92 Finally in 2018, the government introduced the Regulation of
Persistent Organic Pollutants Rules93 which imposed bans on 7 of the 14 (at the time)
newly listed substances.
As can be seen, India while being a full party to the Stockholm Convention has not come
into full conformity of its guidelines yet. The legislation on matters of POPs wastes is
particularly weak in the country, with the first targeted legislation dealing with the matter
only being brought in last year. Further, the Rules brought in last year appear only to be
a half-baked attempt at complying with the norms of the Stockholm Convention, especially
considering its reluctance to ban all the chemical substances listed in the Convention.
90 National Implementation Plan, Available at: http://www.pops.int/implementation/national

implementation plans/niptransmission/tabid/253/ctl/download/mid/13657/default.aspx?id=79&
objid=11745. (Last accessed on May 14, 2019).
91 India All Set to Accept New Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs)? | Toxicswatch, Journal of Earth,
Science, Economy and Justice, Available at: http://www.toxicswatch.org/2017/01/India-all-set-to-
accept-new-persistent.html (Last accessed on May 14, 2019).
92 Girija Bharat, Persistent Organic Pollutants In Indian Environment: A Wake-up Call for Concerted Action,
Available at: https://www.teriin.org/sites/default/files/2018-02/policy%20brief%20on% 20pop.pdf
93 Regulation of Persistent Organic Pollutants Rules, 2018, Available at: https://www.kspcb.gov.in/
regualtion% 20of%20persistent%20organic_07072018.pdf (Last accessed on May 14, 2019).
91
NLSIU
Also, the enforcement of the bans actually imposed is in themselves lax. The use of
pesticides for agricultural use has been banned in India since 1983, but these substances
have found new life as insecticides and continue to be produced to this day, despite
being banned under both the Stockholm Convention and national legislations. Thus,
there needs to be a concerted attempt to rework the current legislative framework
regarding POPs, in order to bring it in full compliance with the demands of the Stockholm
Convention, and by extension the Basel Convention as well.
India through Global Environment
Facility (GEF) funding. has developed a
National Implementation Plan (NIP) to
demonstrate how its obligations to the
Convention would be implemented
Ministry of Environment, Designated national

Forests and Climate authorities are in Ministry of
Change serves as the Focal Agriculture and Cooperation
Point for GEF and and Ministry of Chemicals
Stockholm Convention in and Petrochemicals
the countr
India has ratified 12 initially listed

Chemicals
3.8.5 INDIA AND SAICM
India was among the initial countries to accede to SAICM in February 2006. Initial
undertakings under the SAICM framework included:
 Development or updating of national chemicals profiles
 Strengthening of Institutions
 Mainstreaming sound management of chemicals in national strategies
92
NLSIU
To achieve these targets, India introduced the following steps:
 Preparation of the National Chemicals Management Profile to assess its

infrastructure and capacity for management of chemicals. The Profile was
prepared by Ministry of Environment & Forests (MoEF) and Central Pollution
Control Board (CPCB) with assistance from United Nations Institute for
training and Research, (UNITAR), Geneva under the auspices of Canada-
India Environmental Institutional Strengthening Project, Canada.94
 India also notified the E-Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 2011 for
the management of electronic waste.95
 In line of Globally Harmonized System, India finalised the draft Dangerous

Goods (Classification, Packaging, and Labelling), Rules, 2013.96 Globally
Harmonized System of Classification and Labelling of Chemicals (GHS) is a
system for the classification and labelling of chemicals as per their intrinsic
hazardous properties and is a cornerstone of sound chemical management.97
However, as of 2017 India has not implemented the GHS.98
 MoEF also initiated studies of inventorisation of lead, cadmium, mercury

and arsenic in paints, distemper and pigments in the country.
 Discussions with leading national laboratories.
94 The Text of the National Chemical Management Profile is Available at: Http://164.100.107.13/upload/
newitems/newitem_112_ nationalchemical mgmtprofilefor india.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November,
2019).
95 Available at http://toxicslink.org/docs/rulesansregulation/e-waste-rule-guidelines.pdf (Last accessed
on 11 November, 2019).
96 The Rules are known as Hazardous Substances (Classification, Packaging and Labelling) Rules, 2011.
Available at: http://www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/so523_e_new.pdf (Last accessed
97 Linn Persson Et Al, The Globally Harmonized System of Classification and Labelling of Chemicals – Explaining
The Legal Implementation Gap, 9 Sustainability 2176 (2017).
98 Ibid.
93
NLSIU
India and Emerging Policy Issues under SAICM
1. Lead in Paint: Lead is a heavy and highly toxic metal. From a historical
perspective, the adding of lead compounds to oil-based decorative and industrial
paints etc is done for enhancement of colour, reduction in corrosion on metal
surfaces and reduction in the time it takes the paint to dry.99 After the lead paint
is applied, the release of lead particles into dust and soil occurs due to the process
of weathering, peeling or chipping of the paint.100 The use of such paints in
home, schools, playgrounds and other locations exposes the children to lead
exposure and is one of the main source of such exposure.101 The exposure to lead
can lower Children’s IQ102 and can cause permanent damage to the brain and
nervous system and increased behavioural problems. Hypertension, kidney
damage, impaired reproductive system are other health risks which are caused by
lead paint exposure.103 Global Alliance to Eliminate Lead Paint (Lead in Paint) is
a joint initiative by the UNEP and World Health Organization (WHO) with the
aim to prevent children’s exposure to lead from paints. Regulation of lead paint
with the ultimate objective of phasing out Lead use in paints is one of the
components of SAICM Global Environmental Facility Project.104
India and Lead Paint: As per a study conducted by Centre for Science and
Environment (CSE) in 2008 and 2009 the quantity of lead, in most of the popular
brands of paints in India, was very high. (more than 1000ppm)105 The standards
99 See UNEP, Update on the Global Status of Legal Limits on Lead in Paint September 2019, Available at:
https://wedocs.unep.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.11822/30110/2019_global_ update.pdf ?
Sequence=1&isallowed=y (Last accessed on14 November, 2019). [The Global Update is provided annually
by the UNEP and Global Alliance to eliminate Lead Paint (Lead Paint Alliance)]
100 Ibid.
101 Ibid.
102 Infra note CSE India Study.
103 Supra note UNEP Global Status Update.
104 Available at http://www.saicm.org/implementation/emergingpolicyissues/leadinpaint/
saicmgefprojectleadinpaintcomponent/tabid/7801/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 14
November 2019).
105 Available at: https://www.cseindia.org/paints-in-india-have-unaceptable-levels-of-toxic-lead-7536 (Last
accessed on 14 November, 2019).
94
NLSIU
of lead in paint in India are determined by Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS)106,

which replaced the erstwhile Indian Standards Institution(ISI) which was
determining the Indian standards since 1947.107 Since 1950 till 2004, the standard
for lead in paints in India were set at 1000 ppm.108 However, vide IS 133: 2013,
BIS revised the standards to 90 ppm109, a limit accepted by the other developed
countries including USA, Canada and China.110 However, the BIS Standard is of
voluntary nature unlike certification, the paint manufactures are not bound to
meet the BIS Standard.111 Thus, the Indian paint industry remains virtually
unregulated for the lead content. And as per the Reports published by Toxics
Link in the year 2009 and 2011, high concentration of Lead was detected in
some of the leading paint manufacturers in India.112
To meet the SAICM objectives, the Government of India notified the

“Regulation on Lead contents in Household and Decorative Paints Rules,
2016” on 1st November, 2016 which came into force from 1st November, 2017.113
This initiative by the Union Government will hopefully pave the way for lead
free paints in India.
106 BIS was established under the Bureau of Indian Standards Act, 2016 which revised the earlier Bureau
of Indian Standards Act, 1986. It replaced the erstwhile Indian Standards Institution[ISI].
107 Available at: https: //bis.gov.in/index.php/standards/ (Last accessed on14 November, 2019).
108 Available at: http: //toxicslink.org/?q=content/bureau-indian-standards-bis-notifies-lead-standards-
paints-90-ppm (Last accessed on 14 November, 2019).
109 Ibid.
110 See Supra note UNEP, Update on the Global Status of Legal Limits on Lead in Paint September 2019.
111 See CSE, Lead in Paints Report (August 2009) PML/PR-34/2009, Available at: http:
//indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/lead_paints.pdf (Last accessed on 14 November, 2009).
112 Supra note, Toxic Links Available at: http://toxicslink.org/?q=content/bureau-indian-standards-bis-
notifies-lead-standards-paints-90-ppm (Last accessed on 14 November, 2019).
113 Available at: https: //www.cpcb.nic.in/openpdffile.php?id= tmv3c0zpbgvzlzu 3xze0otu0n dcyodbfb
wvkawfwag90bzm5ntkumdm=.
95
NLSIU
2. Chemical in Products: Chemical in products (CiP) is another emerging policy

issue on which resolutions have been adopted. The Fourth Session of
International Conference on Chemicals Management (ICCM4) in 2015 launched
the Chemicals in Products Programme which is a voluntary framework for all
SAICM Stakeholders.114 It is a global initiative which is aimed at management
of chemicals in products with the ultimate objective of reducing the risk to the
human health and the environment posed by hazardous chemicals in products.115
CiP is recognized by SAICM as fundamental in the achievement of SAICM
2020 goals.116 The three key objectives to achieve this goal are:
a. Exchange of Information and Knowledge within the supply chains

on chemicals in products, associated hazards and sound management
practices.
b. Disclosure of relevant information to stakeholders outside the supply

chain to enable informed decision making and actions about chemicals
in products.
c. to ensure that information is accurate, current and accessible, through

due diligence.117
SAICM CiP Programme operates with the central principle that “All Stakeholders
should have access to relevant and reliable information to make informed decisions about
chemicals in products”118 The striking feature about the SAICM CiP Programme is
that it addresses chemicals in production throughout the entire supply chain
114 Available at: http://www.saicm.org/implementation/emergingpolicyissues/chemicalsinproducts/

tabid/5473/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 14 November, 2019).
115 Available at: https://www.unenvironment.org/resources/toolkits-manuals-and-guides/welcome-
saicm-chemicals-products-programme (Last accessed on 14 November, 2019).
116 Ibid.
117 Saicm Chemicals in Products Programme, Available at https://wedocs.unep.org/bitstream/handle/
20.500.11822/27791/cip_ background_ brief_english. Pdf ? Sequence =1&isallowed=y (Last accessed
118 Ibid.
96
NLSIU
starting with basic chemicals suppliers to the ultimate recyclers. This life cycle
includes chemical product formulators, raw materials manufacturers, component
manufacturers, end product manufacturers, distributors, retailers, consumers,
waste managers, governments and NGO’s.119 Thus the CiP Programme envisages
the flow of information to coincide with product flow.120
India and CiP: India formulated its Draft National Action Plan for chemicals (NAPC).121
This is proposed to take place within the aegis of World Bank under the capacity building
project for industrial pollution management. The project is aided by the World
Bank.122Embracing of green and sustainable chemistry is another major area looked under
SAICM and India, through the Ministry of Education is piloting a programme under
which all chemists are mandated to take a one-year course in green chemistry.123 To
support such efforts at primary, secondary, tertiary and professional levels green and
sustainable chemistry tools and materials are being provided.124
3. Hazardous Substances within the life cycle of electrical and electronic

products: The work on Hazardous Substances within the life cycle of Electrical
and Electronic Products (HSLEEP) is led by the United National Industrial
Development Organization (UNIDO).125 UNIDO has been working with the
secretariats of the Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm Conventions and UNEP
119 The Flow Chart of the CiP Information Flow or Request is Available at: http://www.saicm.org/
portals/12/documents/epi/guidance% 20for% 20 stake holder %20in%20exchanging% 20cip%
20information_october2015.pdf (Last accessed on 14 November, 2019).
120 Ibid.
121 Available at: https://chemicalwatch.com/60306/india-to-have-a-national-action-plan-for-chemicals-
by-2018 (Last accessed on14 November 2019).
122 Available at: https://chemicalwatch.com/60306/india-to-have-a-national-action-plan-for-chemicals-by-
2018 (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
123 Global Chemicals Outlook Synthesis Report: From Legacies to Innovative Solutions – Implementing
the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development, Available at: http://www.saicm.org/portals/12/
documents/meetings/oewg3/inf/oewg3-inf-19-gcoii-summary.pdf (Last accessed on 14 November,
2019).
124 Ibid.
125 Available at: http://www.saicm.org/implementation/emergingpolicyissues/hazardouselectricals/
tabid/5474/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
97
NLSIU
International Environmental Technology Centre on this issue.126 Global Action

Plan on HSLEEP was endorsed by ICCM3 and it included areas such as e-products
green design, environmentally sound manufacturing of e-products and aware-
raising.127 The parties at ICCM3 also agreed to continue the work of identification,
compilation and creation of an international set of best practice resources in this
area.128 An International Workshop on HSLEEP was held in Vienna from 29 to
31 March 2011 and the stakeholders at ICCM4 were encouraged to disseminate
the Report of this workshop 129 and were also encouraged to consider the
recommendations and key messages emerging from the workshop.130 HSLEEP
substances included lead, mercury, cadmium, zinc, yttrium, chromium, beryllium,
nickel, brominated flame-retardants, antimony trioxide, halogenated flame-
retardants, tin, polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and phthalates.131
India and HSLEEP: As per a toxic link Report India’s rate of personal computers
obsolescence is rising very dangerously.132 As per the Report, the major sources
of e-waste are departments of government, the public and private sectors, retailers,
individual households, foreign embassies, PC manufacturing units, the secondary
market and imported scrap.133 To tackle the issue and implement HSLEEP India
introduced the E-Waste (management) Rules 2016 which replaced the earlier E-
Waste (Management) and Handling Rules, 2011.134
126 Ibid.
127 Ibid.
128 Ibid.
129 The Report of the Workshop is Available at: http://www.saicm.org/portals/12/documents/epi/
report%20e-waste%20workshop_vienna.pdf (Last accessed on 14 November, 2019).
130 The recommendations and key messages of the workshop are carefully listed in detail in the report, Ibid.
See the report of the workshopfor the list of recommendations and key messages emerging from the
workshop.
131 Available at: http://addis.unep.org/projectdatabases/01571/project_general_info (Last accessed on
14 November 2019).
132 Toxic Links, E-waste in India- System Failure imminent -Take Action Now! Available at: http://
toxicslink.org/docs/06040_repsumry.pdf (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
133 Ibid.
134 Available at: https://www.downtoearth.org.in/blog/waste/e-waste-day-82-of-india-s-e-waste-is-
personal-devices-61880 (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
98
NLSIU
4. Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals: Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals (EDCs)

are chemicals or mixtures of chemicals that interfere with normal hormonal action
and cause adverse effects.135 They include a number of PoPs such as PCB and
DDT. They can cause disorders such as infertility and growth related disorders in
both human and animals.136 Under SAICM, EDCs are listed as one of the 8
emerging issue137 and the ICCM has recognised their adverse effects on human
and environment both.138 Since 2012 the actions in this area are led by the OECD,
UNEP and WHO.139 The WHO and UNEP Report titled State of the Science of
Endocrine Disrupting Chemicals 2012140 as part of their collaboration seeks to
addresses the concerns about the potential adverse effects of anthropogenic
chemicals and is referred by the SAICM to all the stakeholders.
India and EDCs: There is no specific policy and regulation dealing of EDCs in
India. However, a team of Indian Scientists have developed a comprehensive
database of EDCs.141 The database is a comprehensive catalogue of research
that focused on the impact of these chemicals on health. This database will not
only help to raise public awareness but will also the regulatory agencies, health
authorities and industry to tackle the menace of EDCs.142 India also prepared a
discussion paper on the Uniform Risk Management approach to address the issue
135 Available at:http://addis.unep.org/projectdatabases/01571/project_general_info (Last accessed on

14 November, 2019).
136 Ibid.
137 Available at:http://www.saicm.org/implementation/emergingpolicyissues (Last accessed on 14
November, 2019).
138 Ibid.
139 Ibid.
140 This Report is available at:http://wedocs.unep.org/bitstream/handle/20.500.11822/12223/
state%20of%20the% 20science%20of% 20edcs%20summary% 20report%202012.pdf? sequence=
1&isallowed=y (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
141 Available at: https://vigyanprasar.gov.in/isw/indian-scientists-develop-database-of-everyday-chemicals-
harmful-to-human-health.html (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
142 Ibid.
99
NLSIU
of Endocrine Disrupting chemicals in Food143 at the 50th Session of Joint FAO/

WHO Food Standards Programme Codex Committee on Pesticide Residue with
the objective to develop internationally acceptable definition of EDCs in the
context of food safety and to develop risk based guidelines to deal with their
presence in food products.144
5. Environmentally Persistent Pharmaceutical Pollutants: Environmentally

persistent pharmaceutical pollutant were adopted as an emerging policy issue
under SAICM during the ICCM4.145 Relevancy and need of information
dissemination and awareness-raising on EPPPs was highlighted and improvement
in the availability and access to this information was made a priority at ICCM4.146
EPPPs and India: India is known as the pharmacy of the world due to its
vibrant generic pharma industry. Thus, making it highly vulnerable to extreme
example of drug pollution. One such case was found in India in 2009 in an area
where pharmaceutical manufacturing activity is concentrated. It was found that
The water quality monitoring for the year 1995-2009 which is regularly conducted
by the Central Pollution Control Board indicated that organic, inorganic and
bacterial contamination was critical in the water bodies of India. The main cause
of water contamination was determined to be the mixing of domestic and
industrial wastewater in the environment. This release of wastewater in the
environment was done without passing the same through treatment plants.147
Further, a research conducted found very high concentration of pharmaceutical
143 The discussion paper is available at: http: //www.fao.org/fao-who-codexalimentarius/sh-proxy/

en?lnk= 1&url=h ttps%253a%252f%252 fworkspace.fao.org% 252fsites%252fcodex% 252fmeetings%
252fcx-718-50%252fcrds%252fpr 50_crd18x.pdf (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
144 Ibid.
145 Available at:http://www.saicm.org/implementation/emergingpolicyissues/pharmaceuticalpollutants/
tabid/5477/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
146 Ibid.
147 Available at: https://www.omicsonline.org/pharmaceutical-substances-in-india-are-a-point-of-great-
concern-2157-7587.1000e103.php?aid=9042 (Last accessed on 14 November 2019).
100
NLSIU
drugs in drains, sewerages and rivers.148 Taking into account, and also the objective
of SAICAM regulatory agencies (Central Drugs Standard Control Organization
(CDSCO) and National Pharmaceutical Pricing Authority (NPPA) and Water
Act) in India need to frame stringent regulations to tackles the issue.
3.8.6 INDIA & MERCURY
India does not mine mercury but procures it through imports for meetings its requirements.
India is called a Mercury hotspot as it is one of the biggest consumers of mercury across
the globe.149 The imported mercury is utilized in various industrial activities, it is however
primarily used in thermometers and other measuring devices, electronics, dentistry,
batteries, lighting equipment, thermostat switches fungicides, paints, cosmetics, drugs,
pharmaceutical products, traditional uses in Ayurveda and siddha medicine and
chlor-alkali industry. 150 Thus, even though mining of mercury does not occur
domestically, India still consumes mercury in significant quantities through imports.
This consumption results in generation of mercury laden waste and mercury emissions
into the environment. Besides that, Indian emission of mercury also occurs through coal
fired thermal power plants.151
In India, mercury wastes are dealt with under the Hazardous Waste Management Rules,
2016152, in accordance with the provisions of the Basel Convention. At present, India
does not have any specific legislation to deal with management of mercury wastes. However
there are technical guidelines developed by the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB)
148 Ibid.
149 Nidhi Jamwal, India a Mercury Hotspot, Available at: https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/india-a-
mercury-hotspot-13770 (Last accessed on 6 November, 2019).
150 Technical Background Report to the Global Atmospheric Mercury Assessment, AMAP & UNEP, 2008 (As cited
in JaminaKYepto, supra).
151 Ibid.; See also Mercury Free India by Toxic Links, for a detailed study of mercury in India and Minamata
Convention and its application in India.
152 Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016, Available at:
http://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id=ahdtzc9iv01funvszxnfmjaxni5wzgy= (Last accessed on May 11,
2019).
101
NLSIU
in order to deal with mercury wastes generated by health-care facilities153. A draft of

these guidelines was prepared in 2010 and they were finally adopted in 2012. These
guidelines aim to reduce the risk posed by mercury wastes disposed by hospitals and
other health care providers by mandating certain norms for their safe and responsible
disposal. They also aim to reduce the dependence of health-care providers on devices
and instruments that include mercury as one of their main constituents.
However, as already mentioned, other than these guidelines, the legislations for specifically
dealing with mercury wastes in India are almost non-existent. This is in stark contrast to
the situation in several European and even Asian countries, where the use of mercury in
most regular activities that pose the greatest danger to the general public has been
totally banned. For instance, in China, there is a complete ban on the use of mercury in
the production or as a constituent of household products, with no such corollary
existing in India. Thus, the enforcement of rules regarding mercury pollution in India is
relatively weak. This situation must be improved by the introduction of specific
legislations that deal with mercury waste in different circumstances, so as to improve
implementation by reducing the vagueness and inconsequentiality of the current legislative
scheme.154
IMMI (Improvement of Mercury Management in India) is a project being

implemented by UNDP for the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate change,
and funded by the Global Environment Facility (GEF). The aim of the project is to
develop a national mercury profile by undertaking a comprehensive inventory of mercury
including significant sources of emissions and releases. It also included assessment of
legal, policy, regulatory, technical and financial needs and gaps that need to be addressed
by India to meet the obligations of the Minamata Convention on Mercury. It also conducts
awareness workshops for various stakeholders on impacts of mercury on human health
153 Environmentally Sound Management of Mercury Waste Generated from the Health Care Facilities,
http://cpcb.nic.in/uploads/hwmd/guidelines_for_ esm_ mercuryw_ fromhcfs.pdf (Last accessed on
May 13, 2019).
154 R. C. Srivastava, Guidance and Awareness Raising Materials under New UNEPMercury Programs (Indian Scenario),
Available at: http://www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/india-submission.pdf (Last accessed
on May 13, 2019).
102
NLSIU
and the environment.155 India approved ratification of Minamata convention along

with the flexibility for continued use of mercury-based products and processes involving
mercury compounds till 2025.
CPCB, State
Pollution
Control Boards
Minstr y of
Ministr y of Environment,
Power Forest and
Climate Change
Ministr y of Ministr y of
Consumer Health
Affairs
ORGANIZATIONS CRITICAL FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF THE MINAMATA

CONVENTION IN INDIA
Major Consumers of Mercury in India
Mercury Amount (estimated through
Consumers
Consumers primary study) (tons/annum)
Elemental Mercury Clinical thermometer 21.82

Blood pressure
Elemental Mercury/ Dental amalgams 65
Mercury Oxides Compact fluorescent lamps 8.5
Mercury Chlor-alkali industries in 2013 2.96
Total 98.28
155 Available at: https://www.in.undp.org/content/india/en/home/climate-and-disaster-reslience/

successstories/press-release—two-day-workshop-on-minamata-convention-and-inven.html (Last
103
NLSIU
3.9 MATRIX OF INTERNATIONAL LAW ON MANAGEMENT OF

HAZARDOUS WASTES AND CHEMICALS
Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of
Hazardous Wastes and Their Disposal, 1992
Summary The Basel Convention was adopted in response to the realization in
the eighties that many least developed countries had become a
dumping site for hazardous wastes imported from developed
countries. The Convention was opened for signature on 22 March
1989, and entered into force on 5 May 1992. As of October 2018,
186 states and the European Union are parties to the Convention.
In its Preamble, the Convention sets forth that reduction of
hazardous waste generation and the promotion of environmentally
sound management of hazardous wastes are of utmost priority.
Having said that, wherever there is no option but to carry out
transboundary movement of such wastes, the same should be done
according to the regulatory system established in this Convention.
There is a duty imposed on the waste generator to be responsible for
transportation and disposal of hazardous wastes and the State of
import has the sovereign right to ban such entry or disposal in its
territory.156 The Convention also talks about establishing proper
measures for exchange of information on and control of the
transboundary movement of hazardous wastes and the Secretariat
under the Convention is designated to be Clearing House for this
purpose.157 Signatory Parties to this Convention have to designate
competent authority158 and focal point159 of this Convention.
Cooperation between parties is mandated160, ranging from exchange
156 Available at: https://www.basel.int/portals/4/basel%20convention/docs/text/baselconventiontext-

e.pdf (Last accessed on November 10, 2019).
157 Article 16, Basel Convention.
158 Ibid Article 6.
159 Ibid Article 5.
160 Ibid Articles 10 & 13.
104
NLSIU
of information on issues relevant to Convention to technical

assistance, particularly to developing countries. Regional or sub-
regional centres for training and technology transfers regarding the
management of hazardous wastes and the minimization of their
generation shall be set up.161According to this Convention, hazardous
and other wastes are those covered under Annex I, II and III of the
Convention and those considered as hazardous under domestic
legislation of the Party of export, import or transit. Radioactive
waste and waste generated during the normal operation of a ship
are exempted from this Convention, since there are separate
conventions on the same. Based on the concept of prior informed
consent, it requires that, before an export may take place, State of
export authorities notify the prospective States of import and transit
authorities, providing them with detailed information on the
intended movement. The movement may only proceed if and when
all States concerned have given their written consent.162 Pursuant to
the coming of the Convention, a Protocol on Liability and
Compensation for Damage resulting from Transboundary
Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal, has also been
introduced. In the event that the contract for a transboundary
movement of hazardous wastes could not be carried out for some
reason or is coming within the meaning of illegal traffic, Convention
attributes responsibility to one or more of the States involved, and
imposes the duty to ensure re-import163.Parties may enter into bilateral
or multilateral agreements on hazardous waste management with
other parties or with non-parties, provided that such agreements
are “no less environmentally sound” than this Convention.164
161 Ibid Article 14.

105
NLSIU
A protocol setting out appropriate rules and procedures in the case

of liability and compensation for damage resulting from
transboundary movement and disposal of hazardous wastes, to be
put in place by parties.165After the initial adoption of the Convention,
some least developed countries and environmental organizations
were concerned that all kinds of wastes could be exported to least
developed countries under the guise of recycling which can only
be avoided through a complete ban. This led to the adoption of an
amendment to the convention in 1995 termed the Basel Ban
Amendment which prohibits the export of hazardous waste from a
list of developed (mostly OECD) countries to developing countries.
The amendment has been accepted by 95 countries166 and the
European Union, but has not entered into force as that requires
ratification by 3/4 of the member states to the Convention. As per
Art. 12, the Basel Protocol on Liability and Compensation for
Damage Resulting from Transboundary Movements of Hazardous
Wastes and their Disposal Basel was introduced on 10th December,
1999 which has been signed by 13 parties.
Indian India signed the Convention on 15th March, 1990, ratified the same
ratification on 24th June, 1992 and it finally came into force in India on 22nd
status/ treaty September, 1992. It has not ratified the Basel Ban or the 1999
obligations Protocol till now. According to Article 4, India as a Party has the
following obligations:
- Minimum generation of hazardous wastes and other wastes;
- Availability of environmentally sound disposal facilities at
place of disposal;

166 Primary data, Available at: http://www.basel.int/countries/statusofratifications/banamendment/tabid/
1344/default.aspx (Last accessed on November, 2019).
106
NLSIU
- Persons involved in hazardous waste management prevent

pollution and its consequences;
- Transboundary movement of hazardous wastes is reduced
to a minimum;
- To not allow export of hazardous waste into developing
countries that have prohibited such imports;
- Information about proposed transboundary movement of
such wastes to be provided to States concerned;
- Prevent import if wastes in question will not be managed in
an environmentally sound manner;
- Co-operate in activities with other Parties and interested
organizations, directly and through the Secretariat;
- Consideration that illegal traffic in hazardous wastes is
criminal;
- Appropriate legal, administrative and other measures to
implement and enforce provisions of this Convention
including punishment for contravention;
- No export or import deals between a Party and a non-Party;
- No export for disposal within the area south of 60° South
latitude;
- Prohibit unauthorised transport or disposal of such wastes
within its national jurisdiction;
- Such wastes to be packaged, labelled and transported in
conformity with international rules and standards and best
practices; and
- Wastes to be accompanied by a movement document from
the commencement point of transboundary movement
 Transboundary movement to be allowed only if;
 State of export does not have the technical capacity or
facilities for disposal;
107
NLSIU
 State of import requires such waste for recycling or

recovery industries;
 Movement is in accordance with criteria set by Parties;
India is also actively involved in the work relating to preparation of
technical guidelines for environmentally sound management of
shipbreaking along with Norway and the Netherlands under this
convention.
Domestic First comprehensive rules on hazardous waste management were
application brought about in July 1989 through the Hazardous Waste
(Management and Handling) Rules 1989 but these rules suffered
from some limitations. After becoming a party to the Basel
Convention, the Rules were amended in 2000, 2003 and a final
notification of the Hazardous Waste (Management, Handling and
Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2008 in supersession of former
notification was brought about. These Rules were again superseded
by Rules of 2016. The Rules lay down corresponding duties of
various authorities such as Ministry of Environment, Forests and
Climate Change (MoEF&CC), Central Pollution Control Board
(CPCB), State/Union Territory governments, State Pollution Control
Boards (SPCB)/Pollution Control Committees (PCC), Directorate
General of Foreign Trade (DGFT), Port Authority and Custom
Authority while SPCBs/ PCCs have been designated with wider
responsibilities touching across almost every aspect of Hazardous
wastes generation, handing and their disposal.
'Hazardous waste' is defined as any waste which by virtue of its

physical or other characteristics (described as chemical, toxic,
inflammable, reactive, explosive, etc.) causes or can cause danger to
health or environment, either standalone or in combination with other
substances.167 A list of processes generating hazardous waste is
167 Rule 3 (1) (17), Hazardous Waste Management Rules, 2016.
108
NLSIU
identified which inter-alia includes industries engaged in petro-

chemicals, oil & gas, petroleum, mines and minerals, zinc, copper,
lead based production, textiles, steel, asbestos, electronic, tannery,
etc.168 Every occupier of a factory is required to obtain authorization
from SPCB, and will be responsible for safe and environmentally
sound handling of hazardous wastes generated in the establishment.
As such it is mandated that every occupier must (i) sell hazardous
waste only to an authorised actual user, (ii) transport such waste in
the manner prescribed, (iii) provide specific information on safe
storage and disposal, and (iv) prevent accidents and increase
awareness.169 Further, the occupier has to file annual returns and
maintain records regarding generation of hazardous waste in
prescribed forms. There is also a checklist in place for occupiers to
follow, for the import/export of hazardous and other wastes. These
wastes include lead scrap/batteries scrap, waste tyres/rubber scraps,
electrical and electronic assemblies for repair/renting/ testing
purpose/ projects/ R&D/ re-use of medical equipment/ refurbished
spare parts or components, used oil or any other wastes excluding
those listed above.
Hazardous Substances Management Division (HSMD) is the nodal

point for the Basel Convention. Following policy initiatives have
been started by this Division:
- A project on GIS Based National Hazardous Waste

Information System which is a web based system, developed
to provide status of hazardous waste management in the Country.
The database available on the web is required to be regularly
updated by all State Pollution Control Boards to ensure updated
status at all times. Through NHWIS till now survey of 33,000
168 Ibid Schedule I.

169 Ibid Rule 4.
109
NLSIU
hazardous waste industries and MIS date entry of about 27,500

hazardous waste industries has been completed.
- By preparing a National Inventory of Hazardous Wastes:
As per information provided by the Central Pollution Control
Board (CPCB), there are about 41,523 industries in the country
generating about 7.90 million tonnes of hazardous waste annually,
out of which landfillable waste is about 3.32 million tonnes
(42.02%), incinerable waste is about 0.60 million tonnes (7.60%)
and recyclable hazardous waste is about 3.98 million tonnes
(50.38%).170
- At present, Treatment, Storage and Disposal Facilities (TSDFs)
for hazardous wastes including Integrated TSDF, 13 Exclusive
Common Secure Landfills and Exclusive Common Incinerators
are available in 10,9 and 4 States/UT respectively.
- In Basel Convention COP 14, 2019, two important issues were
discussed and decided, i.e. technical guidelines on e-waste and
inclusion of plastic waste in the PIC procedure.
- Opened negotiations and corrections in the interim technical
guidelines on e-waste and strengthened India's global commitment
towards phasing out single use plastic.171
Apart from the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and
Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016, the Batteries (Management
and Handling) Rules, 2001, E-waste (Management and Handling)
Rules, 2016 and Plastic Waste (Management and Handling) Rules,
2016 have also been promulgated to handle management and disposal
of batteries, e-waste and plastic waste, respectively. There are also
the Guidelines for Environmentally Sound Management of E-Waste.
170 Available at: http://moef.gov.in/environment/waste-management/ (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).

171 Available at: https://pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=190019 (Last accessed on November
19, 2019).
110
NLSIU
Rotterdam Convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for

Certain Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade, 2004
Summary There has been a growing concern amidst increased production of

chemicals and potential risks posed by hazardous chemicals and
pesticides. Consequently the Food and Agricultural Cooperation and
United Nations Environment program introduced the Convention
on Prior Informed Consent Procedure for Certain Hazardous
Chemicals in International Trade for signature in 1998 and the
Convention came into force in 2004. There are 161 parties to this
Convention as of 2018.172
Its two main objectives are as follows:
- to promote shared responsibility and cooperative efforts
among Parties in the international trade of certain hazardous
chemicals in order to protect human health and the
environment from potential harm;
- to contribute to the environmentally sound use of those
hazardous chemicals, by facilitating information exchange
about their characteristics, by providing for a national
decision-making process on their import and export and by
disseminating these decisions to Parties.
Convention begins with defining the various kinds of categories of
chemicals such as 'banned chemical', 'severely restricted chemical'
and 'severely hazardous chemical formulation'.173 The procedures to
include such chemicals within the requirements of prior informed
consent (PIC) are prescribed as well.174
172 Available at: http://www.pic.int/countries/statusofratifications/tabid/1072/language/en-us/

default.aspx (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
173 Article 2, Rotterdam Convention.
174 Ibid Articles 5-9.
111
NLSIU
Each Party needs to have a designated national authority (DNA)

responsible for implementation of this Convention. Other key
agencies here are the Chemical Review Committee (CRC) and
Conference of the Parties (COP). The CRC reviews notifications of
final regulatory actions and proposals from Parties and makes
recommendations to COP on the addition of chemicals to Annex
III.
Parties are empowered to make informed decisions about the
chemicals they wish to import and those that they refuse to. The PIC
procedure is the mechanism for formally obtaining and disseminating
the decisions of importing Parties, as to whether they wish to receive
future shipments of those chemicals listed in Annex III of the
Convention and for ensuring compliance with these decisions by
exporting Parties. As of now, a total of 50 chemicals are listed in
Annex III, 34 pesticides (including 3 severely hazardous pesticide
formulations), 15 industrial chemicals, and 1 chemical in both the
pesticide and the industrial chemical categories.175
Annexes under the Convention include information requirements
for notifications made pursuant to Article 5; criteria for listing banned
or severely restricted chemicals in Annex III; chemicals subject to
the PIC procedure; information and criteria for listing severely
hazardous pesticide formulations in Annex III; information
requirements for export notification; procedure for settlement of
disputes.
At its 7th COP, CRC decided to recommend the following chemicals
to be added in Annex III to the Convention:
- Chrysotile asbestos
175 Available at: http://www.pic.int/theconvention/chemicals/annexiiichemicals/tabid/1132/language/

en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
112
NLSIU
- Fenthion (ultra low volume (ULV) formulations at or above

640 g active ingredient/L)
- Liquid formulations (emulsifiable concentrate and soluble
concentrate) containing paraquat dichloride at or above 276
g/L, corresponding to paraquat ion at or above 200 g/L
- Trichlorfon
Indian India ratified the Convention on 24thMay, 2005 and it came into
ratification force in India from 22nd August, 2005. It's obligations are as follows:
status/treaty
- Power to decide whether to allow or ban the importation of
obligations
chemicals listed in the treaty.
- In case of exports, it should make sure that producers within
their jurisdiction comply.
In 2017, India opposed the listing of Chrysotile asbestos as a
hazardous substance under the Rotterdam convention at the 8th COP
that was conducted in Geneva.176
India is also the member of CRC for the period of 2016- 2020.
Domestic HSMD is the nodal point for the Rotterdam Convention with the
application primary objective of safe management and use of hazardous
substances including hazardous chemicals, in order to avoid damage
to health and environment. DNAs include Department of Chemicals
and Petrochemicals and Department of Agriculture, Cooperation
and Farmers' Welfare.
Broadly production, use, import and export, packing, storage,
transportation of pesticides and Industrial Chemicals and Chemicals
176 Available at: https://www.hindustantimes.com/india-news/chrysotile-asbestos-not-hazardous-says-

india-under-rotterdam-convention/story-qfmwglmaryhboh4e4atspo.html (Last accessed on November
19, 2019).
113
NLSIU
Wastes are regulated and managed in India under the following Acts/
Rules:
- The Insecticides Act, 1968, The Insecticides Rules, 1971,
The Manufacture Storage and Import of Hazardous
Chemicals Rules, 1989, The Water Act, 1974, The Air Act,
1981, The Environment (Protection ) Act,1986, The Chemical
Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness and Response)
Rules, 1996, The Public Liability Insurance Act, 1991, The
Public Liability Insurance Rules, 1991, The Environmental
Impact Assessment Notifications, 2006 and The Hazardous
Wastes (Management, Handling and Transboundary
Movement) Rules, 2016.
Some of the policy initiatives taken for ensuring chemical safety in
the country, as well as for implementing the Convention are as
follows:
- A comprehensive National Chemical Profile assessing the
existing institutional, administrative, technical and legal
infrastructure vis-a-vis the requirements of safe handling of
chemicals in the country is being prepared.
- As on date, there is 1729 Major Accident Hazard Units
(MAH) in 22 States / UTs (19 states and 3 UTs). As per the
latest information, 1569 on-site Plans and 137 Off-site plans
have been prepared. All the states except Bihar and Jammu
& Kashmir have constituted State Level Crisis Groups.
- A GIS based Emergency Planning and Response System has
been developed for 20 districts clusters in Gujarat,
Maharashtra, Tamil Nadu and Andhra Pradesh and extended
to cover another 22 districts in the 10 states of NCT- Delhi,
Assam, Haryana, West Bengal, Madhya Pradesh, Uttar
Pradesh, Karnataka, Punjab, Rajasthan and Kerala.
114
NLSIU
- Out of 270 districts having MAH Units, 180 have hazard

prone industrial pockets. Hazard Analysis studies have been
initiated for 107 districts
- An inventorization study on "Isolated Storages" carried out
during 2001-02 has identified 347 Isolated Storages in the
country.
- As per COP 9, under the Rotterdam Convention, two new
chemicals (Phorate and HBCD) were added in the list for
mandatory PIC procedure in international trade.
Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants, 2004
Summary Exposure to Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs) which remain intact
in the environment for long periods and over large geographical areas,
can lead to serious health effects including certain cancers, birth
defects, dysfunctional immune and reproductive systems, greater
susceptibility to disease and damages to the central and peripheral
nervous systems. Realising the global scale at which such pollutants
spread, the UNEP called for global action to be taken on POPs.
Convention was introduced in 22nd May 2001 and came into force
on 17th May, 2004, with 182 parties so far.
The Convention seeks an initial twelve chemicals for restriction or
elimination of the production and releases which include
organochlorine pesticides, (aldrin, chlordane, DDT, dieldrin, endrin,
heptachlor, hexachlorobenzene (HCB), mirex, toxaphene,) industrial
chemicals (polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and hexachlorobenzene
(HCB)) and unintentionally produced chemicals (polychlorinated
dibenzo dioxins/ polychlorinated dibenzo furans (PCDD/PCDF),
PCBs and HCBs)).
Under the Convention, the chemicals can be listed for complete
elimination from production, use, export and import (Annex-A),
restriction in use and production for specific purpose only
115
NLSIU
(Annex-B) or unintentional production (Annex-C). The

implementation of the Convention requires the parties to take
measures to eliminate or reduce the release of these POPs into the
environment. Till date, 26 chemicals are listed as POPs under the
Stockholm Convention. Other Annexes include information
requirement and screening criteria; information requirement for the
risk profile; information on socio-economic considerations; and
arbitration and conciliation procedures for settlement of disputes.
Other provisions of the Convention relate to the development of
implementation plans177 , information exchange,178 public information,
awareness and education179 (Article 10)181, research, development and
monitoring, 180 technical assistance 181, financial resources and
mechanisms182, reporting183, effectiveness evaluation184 and non-
compliance185.
Persistent Organic Pollutants Review Committee (POPRC) was
established in 2005 to identify additional POPs and the criteria to
be considered in doing so.
Indian India actively participated in the International Negotiation

ratification Committee (INC) meetings leading to the drafting and acceptance
status/ treaty of the Stockholm Convention and it ratified the same on 13th
obligations January, 2006.
177 Article 7, Stockholm Convention.

178 Ibid Article 9.
116
NLSIU
India's obligations under this Convention include:

- Prohibit and/or eliminate the production and use, as well
as the import and export, of the intentionally produced
POPs that are listed in Annex A to the Convention.186
- Restrict the production and use, as well as the import and
export, of the intentionally produced POPs that are listed
in Annex B to the Convention.187
- Reduce or eliminate releases from unintentionally produced
POPs that are listed in Annex C to the Convention.188
- Ensure that stockpiles and wastes consisting of, containing
or contaminated with POPs are managed safely and in an
environmentally sound manner.189
- To target additional POPs.190
India has membership of POPRC from 2018-2022.
Domestic HSMD is the nodal point for the Stockholm Convention. Designated
application national authorities are in Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperation
and Ministry of Chemicals and Petrochemicals.
Broadly production, use, import and export, packing, storage,
transportation of pesticides and Industrial Chemicals and Chemicals
Wastes related to POP chemicals are regulated and managed in India
under the following Acts/ Rules:
- Explosives Act, 1884, Indian Ports Act, 1908, Petroleum
Act, 1934, Factories Act, 1948, Mines Act, 1952, Merchant
186 Ibid Article 3.

187 Ibid.
188 Article 5, Stockholm Convention.
189 Ibid Article 6.
190 Ibid Article 8.
117
NLSIU
Shipping Act, 1958, Customs Act, 1962, Insecticides Act,

1968, Insecticides Rules, 1971, Water (Prevention and
Control of Pollution) Act, 1974, Air (Prevention and Control
of Pollution) Act,1981, Static and Mobile Pressure Vessels
(Unfired) Rules,1981, Fertilizer (Control) Order,1985 under
the Essential Commodities Act, 1955, Calcium Carbide
Rules, 1987, Manufacture Storage and Import of Hazardous
Chemicals Rules, 1989, Central Motor Vehicles Rules, 1989,
Environment (Protection ) Act,1986, Public Liability
Insurance Act, 1991, Public Liability Insurance Rules, 1991,
Chemical Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness and
Response)Rules, 1996, Ozone Depleting Substances
(Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000, Gas Cylinder Rules,
2004, Environmental Impact Assessment Notifications,
2006 and Hazardous Wastes (Management , Handling and
Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016.
The NIP for India has been developed through Global Environment
Facility (GEF) funding. MoEF&CC serves as the focal point for
GEF and Stockholm Convention in the country. For the development
of the NIP, the MoEF worked closely with the CPCB, Ministry of
Agriculture (MoA), Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers (MoCF),
Ministry of Power, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare
(MoH&FW) and Ministry of Science & Technology (MST).In
accordance with the Convention requirements, India would review
and update the NIP according to the timeframe given by the COP.
Indian government has the following strategies for implementation
of the NIP:
- Environmentally Sound Management and Final Disposal
of PCB
- Environmentally Sound Management of Medical Wastes
118
NLSIU
- Development and promotion of non POPs alternatives to

DDT
- Implementation of the Best Available Technology (BAT)/
Best Environmental Practices (BEP) strategies for
elimination / reduction of unintentional POPs emissions
of the priority industry sectors identified in the NIP of
India
- Management of PVC plastic waste to avoid incineration /
dumping the landfill for preventing releases of Dioxins and
Furans due to burning
- Capacity building, demonstration of production and
promotion of bio-botanical neem derived bio-pesticides as
viable, eco-friendly, bio-degradable alternatives to POPs
pesticides
- Identification of sites contaminated by POPs chemicals
and of remediation process at the potential hotspots
- POPs and pesticides management in India
- Inventorization of newly listed POPs
- National POPs monitoring India program and
- Strengthening institutions and capacity building for effective
and efficient implementation of the NIP in India.
- Under the Stockholm Convention the COP14, 2019
decided to list “Dicofol” in Annex A without any exemption.
The “PFOA” was also listed with some exemptions in the
Annex A of the Stockholm Convention.
India has ratified the 12 initially listed chemicals.
119
NLSIU
Minamata Convention on Mercury, 2017

Summary The toxicity of mercury and mercury compounds and their adverse
effect on human health and the environment have been known for
a long time. However, the enormous public health crises which were
cause due to mercury poisoning, such as Minamata disease and
Niigata Minamata disease, brought the issue to the limelight. In
February 2009, the Governing Council of UNEP called for the
development of a global legally binding instrument on mercury. On
10th October, 2013, the Minamata Convention on Mercury, a global
treaty to protect human health and the environment from the adverse
effects of mercury, was formally adopted and opened for signature
by States and regional economic integration organizations. The
Convention has 101 parties and entered into force on 16th August,
2017.
Apart from referring to mercury as a chemical of global concern and
wide spread diseases such as the Minamata disease, Preamble to the
Convention talks about the importance of financial, technical, and
technological and capacity building support, particularly for
developing countries and countries with economies in transition and
the role that multilateral agencies and agreements have in this respect.
Operational part of the Convention discusses phasing out of primary
mercury mining, restrictions on import or export of mercury without
written consent, discouraging new mercury-added products, unless
there are environmental or human health benefits, restricting
manufacturing processes in which mercury or mercury compounds
are used and eliminate use of mercury in artisanal and small-scale
gold mining. Any State or regional economic integration organization
may register for an exemption, provided that there is a statement
providing reasons for the same.191 Articles 8 and 9 prescribe maximum
191 Article 6, Minamata Convention.
120
NLSIU
permissible limits on mercury emissions and release of such

compounds to land and water.
Financial support to Parties in implementing the Convention would
be provided through GEF and through a specific international
programme (SiP) which will support “capacity building and technical
assistance.”192 Information and awareness sharing provisions include
health aspects, information exchange, public information, awareness
and education, research, development and monitoring,
implementation plans, reporting and effectiveness evaluation.193
Annexures include lists of mercury-added products, manufacturing
processes in which mercury or mercury compounds are used, detailed
strategy to handle artisanal and small-scale gold mining, list of point
sources of emissions of mercury and mercury compounds to the
atmosphere and arbitration and conciliation procedures.
Indian India signed the Convention on 30th September 2014 and ratified
ratification on 18th June, 2018 becoming the 93rd member of the Convention.
status/ treaty The ratification entails flexibility for continued use of mercury-based
obligations products and processes involving mercury.
India's obligations under the Convention:
- Not grant permission for fresh projects on primary mercury
mining after the coming into force of this Convention and
allow existing projects to continue for only a period of 15
years from the date of Convention.
- Mercury from such mining to be used only in manufacturing
of mercury-added products,194 in manufacturing processes195

193 Ibid Articles 16-22.
194 Ibid Article 4.
195 Ibid Article 5.
121
NLSIU
and disposed only using operations which do not lead to

recovery, recycling, reclamation, direct re-use or alternative
uses.196
- Identify individual stocks of mercury or mercury compounds
exceeding 50 metric tons, as well as sources of mercury
supply generating stocks exceeding 10 metric tons per year.
- Ensure that, where the Party determines that excess mercury
from the decommissioning of chlor-alkali facilities is
available, such mercury is disposed of in accordance with
Article 11.
- Allow export of mercury only after written consent from
country of import provided that it's for a use allowed under
this Convention or is to be stored on an interim basis in an
environmentally sound manner
- Setting out measures which will either phase out or will
restrict such existing manufacturing processes as are referred
to, in Article 5.
- Initiating steps that will lead to reduction in the usage of
mercury and its compounds in activities such as gold mining
and processing, and wherever feasible eliminating the usage
of mercury and its compounds in mining and processing
activities, and also the environmental emissions and releases
of mercury from the aforementioned activities.197
- Develop and implement national action plan
- Identification of the relevant “point source categories” of
mercurial releases into land and water within a time line of

197 Ibid Article 7.
122
NLSIU
three years after of date of entry into force of the

Convention.198
- Develop appropriate strategies for identifying and assessing
sites contaminated by mercury or mercury compounds.199
Parties are also encouraged to:
- Identify and protect populations at risk
- Promote education and prevention programmes
- Promote appropriate health care services
- Establish and strengthen Institutional and health professional
capacities
India has registered exemption under Article 6 from application of
Convention provisions to items mentioned below due to lack of
information on mercury use and dearth of techno-economic feasible
alternative: 200
- Batteries, except for button zinc silver oxide batteries with
a mercury content < 2% and button zinc air batteries with a
mercury content<2%
- Switches and relays, high frequency radio frequency switches
and
- Compact fluorescent lamps (CFLs) for general lighting
purpose less than 30 watts
- Linear fluorescent lamps (LFLs) for general lighting purpose
198 Ibid Article 9.

200 Available at: http: //www.mercuryconvention.org/portals/11/documents/notifications/
india%20exemptions.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
123
NLSIU
- High pressure mercury vapour lamps for general lighting

purpose
- Mercury in cold cathode fluorescent lamps and external
electrode fluorescent lamps (CCFL and EEFL) for electronic
displays
- Cosmetics (with mercury content above Ippm)
- Pesticides, biocides and topical antiseptics
- Non-electronic measuring devices such as barometers,
hygrometers, manometers, ther mometers and
sphygmomanometers
Domestic The National Focal Point of India to the Minamata Convention is

application the HSMD.201
The country currently has no policy to regulate and control mercury
emissions.
The MoEF&CC and the UNDP, under the GEF project on
Improvement of Mercury Management in India, organized a
Workshop on “Two-day Workshop on “Minamata Convention and
Inventorisation of Mercury in India” in Indian Institute of Technology
(IIT) Madras during December 4-5, 2018. The workshop deliberated
on sources of mercury, environmentally sound management of
mercury, regulatory and industry concerns in mercury management;
challenges and opportunities in meeting the obligations of the
Minamata Convention; approaches for conducting a national
inventory of mercury as well as case studies of mercury
contamination in India.202
201 Available at: http://www.mercuryconvention.org/portals/11/documents/notifications/india%

20nfp.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
202 Available at: http: //www.in.undp.org/content/india/en/home/climate-and-disaster-reslience/
successstories/press-release—two-day-workshop-on-minamata-convention-and-inven.html (Last
124
NLSIU
Strategic Approach to International Chemicals Management, 2006

Summary Acknowledgement of the essential economic role of chemicals and
their contribution to improved living standards needs to be balanced
with recognition of potential costs. These include the chemical
industry's heavy use of water and energy and the potential adverse
impacts of chemicals on the environment and human health. The
diversity and potential severity of such impacts makes sound
chemicals management a key cross-cutting issue for sustainable
development. In February 2006, over 190 countries including India
acceded to the Strategic Approach to International Chemicals
Management (SAICM), an international policy framework to guide
efforts to achieve the Johannesburg Plan of Implementation goal
that, by 2020, chemicals will be produced and used in ways that
minimize significant adverse impacts on the environment and human
health. It maybe noted that SAICM is a voluntary initiative which is
not legally binding.203
SAICM comprises the Dubai Declaration on International Chemicals
Management and an Overarching Policy Strategy (OPS) which sets
out its scope, needs, objectives, financial considerations underlying
principles and approaches, and implementation and review
arrangements. The Declaration and Strategy are accompanied by a
Global Plan of Action (GPA) that serves as a working tool and
guidance document to support implementation of SAICM.
The Declaration refers to the insufficient progress been made in
international chemicals management through the implementation
of chapter 19 of Agenda 21, International Labour Organization
Conventions No. 170 on Safety in the Use of Chemicals at Work
and No. 174 on the Prevention of Major Industrial Accidents, Bahia
203 Available at: http://www.saicm.org/portals/12/documents/saicmtexts/saicm-publication-en.pdf (Last

125
NLSIU
Declaration on Chemical Safety, 2005 World Summit Outcome,

Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm Conventions and the adoption of
the Globally Harmonized System for the Classification and Labelling
of Chemicals. It acknowledges the efforts being made by private
sector, non-governmental public health and environmental
organizations, trade unions and other civil society organizations
towards this end.205
Parties to the Declaration aim to work towards addressing the
discrepancies between developed and developing countries with
respect to achieving sustainable chemicals management by:206
- strengthening of capacities for sound management of
chemicals;
- development of safer alternative products and processes,
including non-chemical alternatives, through partnerships,
technical support and financial assistance;
- ensuring effective and efficient governance of chemicals
management by means of transparency, public participation
and accountability;
- partnerships with all stakeholders;
- making available data and information on health and
environmental benefits and risks of chemicals;
- ensuring that published information does not violate the
confidentiality of commercial and industrial information
wherever applicable;
204 Article 2, Dubai Declaration.

205 Articles 4 & 5, Dubai Declaration.
206 Text of Dubai Declaration.
126
NLSIU
- prevent illegal traffic in toxic, hazardous, banned and severely

restricted chemicals and chemical products and wastes;
- promote the sound management of chemicals and
hazardouswaste as a priority in national, regional and
international policy frameworks;
- integrate SAICM into the work programmes of all relevant
United Nations organizations, specialized agencies, funds and
programmes.
The OPS has the main objectives of risk reduction, knowledge
creation and information dissemination, governance, capacity-
building and technical cooperation and curbs on illegal international
traffic.207 Its scope includes environmental, economic, social, health
and labour aspects of chemical safety.208 There are several strategies
prescribed under each of these objectives within this document209
such as:
- Adherence to precautionary principle;
- Obtaining scientific understanding for effective risk
management;
- Phasing out unmanageable chemicals by 2020;
- Reduction of generation of hazardous waste;
- Availability of objective scientific information;
- Accelerated pace of scientific research on safer alternatives;
- Strengthened enforcement of national legislations;
- Promotion of codes of conduct; and
207 Article 1, OPS.

208 Ibid Article 3.
209 Ibid Articles 14, 15, 16, 17 & 18.
127
NLSIU
- Adaption of chemicals management models from developed

countries, among others.
Strategies for obtaining financial resources are provided within the
OPS document as well, especially for economies in transition.210
Institutional arrangements to support implementation and taking
stock of progress on the SAICM will include national coordination
and, as appropriate, regional processes and, at the international level,
aperiodic review process facilitated by the International Conference
on Chemicals Management (ICCM).211 The ICCM shall convene
triennially. There shall also be Bureau setup for the Conference and
the Open-ended Working Group (OEWG).
Within the GPA possible work areas and their associated activities,
actors, targets and timeframes, indicators of progress and
implementation aspects are grouped according to five categories of
objectives contained in the OPS.212
The Quick Start Programme (QSP) under SAICM is programme aimed
to support and assist in enabling capacity building and implementation
activities during the initial stages in the developing countries, least
developed countries, small island developing States and countries
with economies in transition.213
Resolutions adopted by the ICCM , inter alia, are on the following
issues:
- Emerging policy issues, including adopting a new area of
work on environmentally persistent pharmaceutical
pollutants;

211 Ibid Articles 21, 24 & 28.
212 Article 2, GPA.
213 Article 19(e), OPS.
128
NLSIU
- Addressing highly hazardous pesticides;

- SAICM and sound management of chemicals and waste
beyond 2020;
- Activities and budget of the SAICM secretariat.
Emerging policy issues identified by SAICM:
- Lead in Paint;
- Chemicals in Products;
- Hazardous substance within the life cycle of electrical;
and electronic products;
- Nanotechnology and manufactured nanomaterials;
- Endocrine-disrupting chemicals;
- Environmentally Persistent Pharmaceutical Pollutants;
- Perfluorinated chemicals.
- Highly Hazardous Pesticides.
Indian Being a signatory to SAICM, India needs to take the following steps214:
ratification - Inventorisation of chemical manufacturers (and storage
status/treaty facilities);
obligations
- Inventorisation of Chemical substances in use, including
relevant physical, chemical, ecological and toxicological
data about them;
- Legislation for Classification, Labelling and Packaging;
- Legislation on Registration, Evaluation and Approval of
toxic or dangerous chemicals;
- Draft Chemical Policy to be finalised;
214 Available at: http://www.moef.nic.in/division/introduction-12 (Last accessed on November 19,

2019).
129
NLSIU
- National Centre for Chemicals to be setup to be a

repository for all related data.
An Indian representative is one of the Vice Presidents in the Bureau
setup for the fifth session of the Conference.
Domestic HSMD is the nodal point in the MoEF & CC for SAICM. Ministry of
application Chemicals and Fertilisers is also involved in the activities herein.
India has proactively participated in all SAICM meetings and
conferences. The India Government continues to integrate SAICM
into relevant programmes and plans pertaining to chemicals and
sustainable development. While developing these programmes and
plans, the government tries to ensure relevant stakeholder
participation. The government is in the process of establishing
arrangements for implementing SAICM on an inter-ministerial and
inter-institutional basis so that all concerned stakeholder interests
are represented and all relevant substantive areas are addressed.
India initiated the preparation of the National Chemicals Management
Profile to assess India's infrastructure and capacity for management
of chemicals. Other actions taken by the Ministry are:
- Initiated studies of inventorisation of lead, cadmium,
mercury and arsenic in paints, distemper and pigments in
the country
- Initiated discussions with leading national laboratories
- Notified the E-Waste (Management and Handling) Rules,
2016 for the management of electronic waste
- Came out with the draft Dangerous Goods (Classification,
Packaging and Labelling) Rules, 2013 in line with Globally
Harmonized System.
******
130
NLSIU
4
OVERVIEW OF THE CHEMICAL SECTOR IN INDIA
4.1 BACKGROUND
Over the past few decades, India as a developing country has witnessed rampant industrial
reforms whereby it has progressively metamorphosized from an agro-based economy
into an industry-based economy. This economic transformation has much to owe to the
pivotal role that the chemical sector has played in the economic growth of the country.
In India, more often than not the chemical sector is commonly misconceived to encompass
the production of pharmaceutical products. However, to view the chemical sector as
merely constituting pharmaceuticals would be a misnomer because it would involve
construing the magnitude of the sector narrowly. The sector covers a broad spectrum of
industries producing various kinds of chemicals which include bulk chemicals, specialty
chemicals and organic chemicals. Not only does it yield a significant boost to the
development of the agricultural and industrial sectors, but the sector also serves as a key
enabler for other sectors by providing building blocks for other downstream markets.
The chemical industry is undoubtedly a key manufacturing sector in an industrialised
economy.1 Constituting a highly diversified industry covering over 80,000 commercial
products, the Indian chemical sector accounts for 3% of the global chemical market.2
In the year 2017-18, the chemical manufacturing sector alone contributed a total of
2.1% towards the nation’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) and also accounted for a
total 15.95% of India’s manufacturing sector.3 Furthermore, according to the Annual
1 Neil Gunningham, Environmental Management Systems and Community Participation: Rethinking

Chemical Industry Regulation, 319 16 UCLAJ. Envtl. L. &Policy 319 (1997).
2 “FICCI”, India Chem 2018, Available at: http://ficci.in/spdocument/23036/knowledge%20paper-
india%20chem%202018-ficci.pdf. (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
3 Available at: http://www.makeinindia.com/article/-/v/make-in-india-sector-survey-chemicals (Last
131
NLSIU
Overview of the Chemical Sector in India
Report 2018-19 of the Ministry of Chemicals and Petrochemicals, the Index of Industrial
Production (IIP) for the Chemicals and Chemical products for the month of March 2019
stands at 128.40 which is 1.18% higher as compared to the levels in the previous year.4
These numbers bear testimony to the fact that the chemical industry has built an impressive
and consistent track record in the overall development of the economy.
This chapter maps the contribution of the chemical sector to the Indian economy as a
whole. It delves into the myriad aspects pertaining the growth and significance of this
sector. Furthermore, with a focus on the chemical waste management systems in place,
the chapter inquiries into the various challenges and issues that wrought this sector in
terms of chemical waste management, treatment and disposal.
4.2 ROLE OF THE CHEMICAL SECTOR AS A CONTRIBUTOR TO

INDIAN ECONOMY
The chemical sector plays an instrumental role in boosting the economy by virtue of its
nature as a knowledge based and human resource-intensive industry. It has also emerged
as a major contributor to the global chemical sector’s economic footprint. According to
the data provided by Oxford Economics, out of the global contribution of 5.7 $ Trillion,
Indian chemical sector features as a major stakeholder among other developing nations.5
A cursory look into the performance and economic contribution of 4 major developing
countries, as indicated below, shows that India has taken a leap in anchoring its position
in the global chemical sector.
4 Annual Report, Ministry of Chemicals and Petrochemicals, 2018-19.

5 The Global Chemical Industry: Catalysing Growth and Addressing Our World’s Sustainability
Challenges Report for ICCA, page 10, Available at: iccachem.org/wpcontent/uploads/2019/03/
icca_economicanalysis_report_030819.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
132
NLSIU
FIGURE 1: Source - ICCA Report: The Global Chemical Industry: Catalyzing Growth and
Addressing Our World’s Sustainability Challenges
Apart from the global contribution made, the sector has made immense contribution to
the growth of the domestic economy which is evidenced by the following indicators-
4.2.1 CONTRIBUTION TO GROSS DOMESTIC PRODUCT (GDP)
According to the data provided by the World Bank, India has been maintaining an average
GDP of around 7.42% over the past decade.6 The steady growth rate of the chemical
sector has contributed to this consistent average. From 2014-15 to 2018- 19, the average
annual growth rate of Chemicals and Chemicals Products calculated on the basis of IIP
stands at 2.13% within the total manufacturing sector which amounts to 3.83%.7
Furthermore, with respect to the sectoral growth of the chemical sector alone, the IIP in
2018-19 shows a significant increase by 2.15% in the production levels when compared
to the previous year.8
6 Available at: https: //data.worldbank.org/indicator/ny.gdp.mktp.kd.zg? end=2018&locations=

in&start=2008 (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
7 Department of Chemicals and Petrochemicals Annual Report 2018-19, page 8.
8 Available at: http: //mospi.nic.in/iip (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
133
NLSIU
4.2.2 CONTRIBUTION TO GROSS VALUE ADDED (GVA)
GDP and GVA are primary indicators that highlight the demand and supply of products
and services respectively. They bring about the efficiency of economic activity in a
particular industry. In the year 2018-19, the manufacturing industry accounted for 29.6%
of the GVA to the domestic production.9 Within this the chemical and chemical products
sector accounted for 1.41% of the GVA for all economic activities according to the
CSO’s National Accounts Statistics 2018.10 This improvement brings to light the
flourishing and profit-generating nature of the sector.
4.2.3 EMPLOYMENT GENERATION
Employment generation, according to Goal 8 of the Sustainable Development Goals, is

an aspect which lays emphasis on decent work and economic growth.11 Owing to its
human resource-intensive nature, the chemical sector employs more than over a million
people.12 The Economic Survey of 2018-19 identifies the chemical sector as one having
a pre-dominantly high employment elasticity. 13 This brings to light the highly
accommodative capacity of the sector as it requires both skilled and unskilled labour.
Additionally, the current policy initiatives such as setting up of Petroleum Chemicals
and Petrochemicals Investment Regions (PCPIR’s) and plastic parks further act as catalysts
to boost employment generation.14
9 Available at: https://www.prsindia.org/report-summaries/economic-survey-2018-19 (Last accessed

10 Department of Chemicals and Petrochemicals Annual Report 2018-19 page 5.
11 Available at: https://www.undp.org/content/undp/en/home/sustainable-development-goals/goal-
8-decent-work-and-economic-growth.html (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
12 Planning Commission Working Group on Indian Chemical Industry page 12, Available at: http://
planningcommission.nic.in/aboutus/committee/wrkgrp11/wg11_chemical.pdf (Last accessed on
November 19, 2019).
13 Economic Survey 2018-19 Vol 1 page 76, Available at: https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/
economicsurvey/doc/echapter.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
134
NLSIU
4.2.4 FACILITATES FOREIGN INVESTMENTS
The chemical sector fosters a conducive platform for Foreign Direct Investment (FDI).
According to the FDI policy, the chemical sector is open to 100% FDI except in case of
hazardous chemicals.15 This liberalised approach has reflected a positive upward trend in
the receipt of FDI equity inflows to a sum of 2.2 USD Billion between the years 2014-
16 as compared to 1.1 USD Billion during the preceding two year period. 16 The emergence
of India as a major manufacturing destination for chemical products has further enhanced
the foreign investments into the economy.
4.2.5 CREATES A VIBRANT MARKET FOR IMPORT AND EXPORT
Globally, the chemical sector is estimated at USD 4.7 Trillion as it is also driven by
demand from end-use industries. While these numbers appear to be staggeringly high,
the Indian chemical sector is estimated to be valued at USD 163 Billion. It ranks 14th in
exports and 8th in imports of chemicals (excluding pharmaceutical products) globally.17
As per the import figures for the year 2018-19, the Import of Chemicals and Petrochemical
products (excluding Pharmaceutical Products and Fertilizers) contributed 11% to the
total imports in 2018-19. The exports on the other hand, contributed 12.3% to the total
exports in the year 2018-19. This significant rise in the quantity of chemicals being
imported into the country throws light on the rising quantum of chemicals being consumed
as primary products as well as used by industries in other downstream markets.
Furthermore, trends in international trade also highlight an increased consumption and
use of chemicals and chemical products in India.
4.3 KEY DRIVERS FOR GROWTH OF THE CHEMICAL SECTOR
Chemicals form the primary raw material for many manufacturing industries like agro-
chemicals, synthetic rubbers, pharmaceutical sectors, consumer products and other
15 Available at: https: //makeinindia.com/sector/chemicals (Last accesses on November 19, 2019).

16 Chemicals and Petrochemicals Sector Achievement Report page 3 (Department of Chemicals and
Petrochemicals) Available at: drive.google.com/file/d/0b-tv7_upckanekpqm2nhyndkqw8/view (Last
17 FICCI Knowledge Paper, Infra note 26.
135
NLSIU
ancillary industries.18 The very nature of chemicals makes it indispensable in facilitating

miscellaneous industrial applications. Thus, the sector primarily thrives owing to the
dependency of the other downstream markets. In addition to this, certain developing
country requirements also have a bearing on the Chemical sector. An amalgamation of
such varied factors provides the necessary impetus for the growth of the chemical sector
in India as illustrated below.
FIGURE 2: Interplay between the key drivers of growth of Chemical sector
The key areas which has influenced the growth of the Chemical industry are-
(a) Robust demand for products and Voluminous Consumption rates
The growth of the Chemical sector is supported by the robust demand for these products
owing to the huge consumption base of the ever-increasing population. The country is
ranked the third largest on the basis of its Purchasing Power Parity (PPP). These
18 Indian Chemical Industry Challenges and Opportunities- the Associated Chambers of Commerce
and Industry of India, Available at:https://www.resurgentindia.com/pro_bfloors/services_img/
pdf_teders/2093224542challenges-and-opportunities-report-f.pdf (Last accessed on November 19,
2019);IMFWorld Economic Outlook (april-2019),Available at: https://www.imf.org/external/pubs/
ft/weo/2019/01/weodata/weorept.aspx?pr.x=34 &pr.y=5&sy=2019& ey=2024&ssd= 1&sort=
country&ds=. &br=1&c= 534&s=ngdpd% 2cpppgdp&grp=0&a= (Last accessed on November 19,
2019).
136
NLSIU
consumption rates have fuelled a robust demand for these products thereby creating a
profitable domestic market alongside a lucrative investment opportunity for foreign
players. The shift in the consumption pattern of chemical products over the past decade
is indicated as below-
FIGURE 3 - Source: India Stats(Annual Report)
(b) Availability of cheap labour
Chemical Industry in India provides abundance of employment opportunities owing to

the diversification of its business activities and the magnitude of its operation. The
share of wages paid in the chemical sector in India is less owing the abundance of
availability of cheap labour which shows a declining trend towards providing wages in
this Sector.19 This provides sufficient incentives for foreign and domestic chemical industry
manufacturers to set up bases and establish production units within India.
FIGURE 4
19 Available at: lo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/—asia/—ro-bangkok/—sronew_delhi/documents/

publication/wcms_614777.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
137
NLSIU
(c) Ease of doing business and conducive policy initiatives
In the pursuit of securing a profitable market for foreign investments, the conduciveness
of the business environment is an essential pre-requisite. There has been a consistent
improvement in the ease of doing business index rankings of India. With the latest World
Bank’s Ease of Doing Business Report 2019, India is ranked at the 77th position.20 This
significant improvement has paved way to open up the economy in this era of globalisation.
FIGURE 5 - Source: World Bank’s Report on ease of Doing Business
The ease of doing business is largely fuelled by a couple of policy initiatives with its
prime focus on strengthening the Chemical Sector in India-
(a) “Make in India” initiative – The identification of chemical sector among 25

other sectors to be a part of the Make in India initiative led by the Department
of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP) and Ministry of Commerce and
Industry is reflective of the government initiative to focus and strengthen the
sector.21 The initiative fosters research into emerging areas such as specialty
chemicals and agro-chemicals by promoting investment into the sector and thereby
anchoring the position of the chemical sector as a major contributor to the
manufacturing industries.22
20 Available at: https://www.doingbusiness.org/content/dam/doingbusiness/media/annual-reports/

english/db2019-report_web-version.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
21 Available at: https://www.ibef.org/economy/make-in-india (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
138
NLSIU
(b) Proposal for establishing Petroleum, Chemicals and Petrochemical

Investment Regions (PCPIRs)- The PCPIR’s are proposed to be set up in
designated notified areas in 4 regions of the country. This is done to provide
infrastructure-intensive logistical support to make the country a suitable
investment destination. This comes at a time when India is perceived as an
emerging global leader in the chemical sector. The proposed implementation of
Petroleum, Chemical and Petrochemical Investment Regions (PCPIRs) is said to
be a major source of employment generation apart from its numerous other
benefits. The amount of prospective employment generation envisaged by the
proposal for setting up these PCPIR’s is around 33.96 Lakh persons.23
(c) Strong Intellectual Policy regime which encourages R&D initiatives- The
IP regime supported by a strong legal framework incentivises manufacturers to
innovate in the realm of chemical products. These factors especially are relevant
in the pharmaceutical sector to ensure sufficient legal protection to pharmaceutical
companies who invest an exorbitant amount in Research and Development and
clinical trials.
(d) Revamping of the tax regime- The consolidation of the indirect taxes into the
unifying Goods and Services Tax(GST) regime has borne positive results especially
with respect to the pharmaceutical sector. The previous tax systems adopted
created a cascading effect thereby increasing the price of the end product. With
the elimination of taxes on multiple levels, chemical products and pharmaceutical
products in particular, have become more viable from a consumers’ perspective.
The impact that the GST regime has therefore been positive and the same can be
understood from the diagram 24 below:
22 Chemicals and Petrochemicals Sector achievement Report(Department of Chemicals and Petrochemicals)

drive.google.com/file/d/0b-tv7_upckanekpqm2nhyndkqw8/view (Last accessed on November 19,
2019).
23 Available at: https://pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=181238 (Last accessed on November
19, 2019).
24 Available at: https: //pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=184756 (Last accessed on November
19, 2019).
139
NLSIU
FIGURE 6 - Source: Press Information Bureau
4.4 THE FUNCTIONING OF THE CHEMICAL SECTOR
The chemical industry in India is a mix of public sector undertakings along with private
players in the market. The Public Sector Undertakings (PSU’s) majorly constitute 3 major
stakeholders- Hindustan Organic Chemicals Ltd. (HOCL), HIL (India) Limited and
Hindustan Fluorocarbons Limited (HFL).25 It has been established that the chemical
sector is broad and multifarious consisting of multiple industries producing diverse
categories of chemicals and chemical products. The list is indefinite. But for the purpose
of specific industrial demarcation, the Department of Chemicals and Petrochemicals
has segregated these chemicals on the basis of their composition and use. The categories
of chemical manufacturing industries have been devised and segmented as follows:
 Alkali Chemicals
 Inorganic Chemicals
 Organic Chemicals
 Pesticides
 Dyes & Pigments
140
NLSIU
 Basic Major Chemicals

 Synthetic Fibres
 Polymers
 Elastomers (S. Rubber) Synth.
 Detergent Intermediates
 Performance Plastics
These industries have been identified as key players that contribute to the revenue
generation in the economy. Though they do not represent an exhaustive list of chemicals
produced, they are a categorical reflection of major chemical producing industries in the
sector.
The nature of the sector is such that it requires regulation at multiple levels- Production,
consumption by ancillary industries, disposal and treatment of chemical waste.
(a) Production and Consumption of Major Chemicals
As per the IIP, the total quantum of chemicals and chemical products manufactured
and produced by the domestic industries stands at 27,847 million tonnes.
Furthermore, the volume of production in each of these chemicals have been
accounted for as follows.
FIGURE 7 - Source: Annual Report 2018-19, Department of Chemicals and

Petrochemicals
141
NLSIU
The Indian chemical industry comprises of a wide range of small scale as well as large
scale units that cater to the increasing demand and consumption of such chemicals.
Furthermore, the current per capita consumption of chemical products in India is about
1/10th of the world average and the demand is said to increase by an average of 9% per
annum.26 (Refer to Figure 3)
(b) Discharge of Chemical Waste
A cursory glance of the production patterns in the chemical industry suggests that the
quantum of chemicals and chemical based products are being produced at a staggering
rate. With this rapid rise in the production of chemicals, it is only natural to that the
amount of chemical waste emitted from such industrial activity also increases. Thus, the
chemical industry acts as a major source for environmental pollution. According to the
report of the Central Pollution Control Board, the numbers hazardous waste generating
industries authorized to generate hazardous waste in the year 2016-17 was approximately
56,350. The quantum of hazardous waste generated by these industries was further found
to be 25.46 million Metric Tonnes(MT) which included a major portion of toxic chemical
waste. 27 Furthermore, as per the annual return submitted by the occupiers the quantum
of hazardous waste generated was around 7.17 Million MT.
(c) Treatment of chemical waste
As it is pointed out that the chemical sector is responsible for generating industrial waste
which is toxic in nature. In the absence of safe-handling of chemical waste through
effective disposal and treatment measures, it can be lethal to health and environment.
Although chemical waste and the treatment thereof is not specifically regulated as a
separate category, it has been included within the ambit of ‘hazardous waste’. According
to Rule 3(1)(17) of the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary
Movement) Rules, 2016 28 (Waste Management Rules) “hazardous waste” is defined to
26 "FICCI”, India Chem 2018, Available at: http://ficci.in/spdocument/23036/knowledge%20paper-

india%20chem%202018-ficci.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
27 CPCB Report - National Inventory Report on Hazardous Waste Generation and Its Management
(2016-17).
28 Rule 3(1)(17) of the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement)
Rules, 2016.
142
NLSIU
mean any waste which by reason of characteristics such as physical, chemical, biological,
reactive, toxic, flammable, explosive or corrosive, causes danger or is likely to cause
danger to health or environment. Therefore, chemical waste falls within the ambit of
hazardous waste.
Schedule III of the Waste Management Rules of 2016 categorizes hazardous waste on
the basis of the nature as the following:
1. Explosive and Flammable
An explosive waste is a liquid or solid substance which in itself can cause damage
to the surrounding due to a chemical reaction of producing gas at a specific
temperature and pressure and a specific speed. It also includes substances that
give off flammable vapour and can combust in an instant.
2. Oxidising Waste
These are wastes which may contribute to combustion by exposing itself to oxygen
while they aren’t inherently combustible in nature.
3. Organic Peroxides
Organic substances or wastes which contain the bivalent-o-o-structure are

thermally unstable substances which may undergo exothermic self-accelerating
decomposition.
4. Poisons (acute)
Substances or wastes liable either to cause death or serious injury or to harm

human health if swallowed or inhaled or by skin contact.
5. Infectious substances
Substances or wastes containing viable micro-organisms or their toxins which are

known or suspected to cause disease in animals or humans.
143
NLSIU
6. Corrosives
Substances or wastes which, by chemical action, will cause severe damage when
in contact with living tissue, or, in the case of leakage, will materially damage, or
even destroy, other goods or the means of transport; they may also cause other
hazards
7. Toxic (delayed or chronic)
Substances or wastes which, if they are inhaled or ingested or if they penetrate

the skin, may involve delayed or chronic effects, including carcinogenicity).
8. Eco-toxic
Substances or wastes which if released present or may present immediate or

delayed adverse impacts to the environment by means of bioaccumulation or
toxic effects upon biotic systems or both.
From the aforementioned categorisation, it is clear that the nature of these chemicals
require the establishment of an efficient system of treatment and disposal facilities to
ensure minimal harm to health and environment. In order to facilitate the same, the
Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) acts a regulator. The CPCB has tabulated a list
of treatment, storage and disposal facilities with respect to the management of hazardous
waste. Accordingly, the total number of Common Integrated Treatment, Storage &
Disposal Facilities (TSDFs), Common Incinerators & Secured Landfills:29
Integrated TSDFs (with both SLF and Incinerator): 17
TSDFs with only Common Incinerators: 9
TSDFs with only Common Secured Landfills: 15
Furthermore, the number of facilities available in every state and union territory is as
follows:
29 Available at: http://cpcbenvis.nic.in/tsdf.html (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
144
NLSIU
Sl.No. Name of the State / UT Number of Common TSDFs in

operation
1. Andhra Pradesh No of TSDFs - 1
2. Arunachal Pradesh Nil
3. Assam Nil
4. Bihar Proposed, near Bojpur, Patna district EC
under progress
5. Chhattisgarh Proposed
6. Delhi Nil
7. Goa Proposed at Dharbandora, Sanguem,
8. Gujarat No of TSDFs - 11
TSDFs Integrated – 4
TSDFs with common SLFs - 5
TSDFs with only Common Incinerator – 2
9. Haryana No of TSDFs - 01
TSDF integrated – 1
10. Himachal Pradesh No of TSDFs - 01
TSDF with only common SLF – 01
11. Jammu & Kashmir Proposed, EC under progress
12. Jharkhand Proposed, EC under progress
13. Karnataka No of TSDFs - 07
TSDF with only common SLF - 2
TSDF with only common Incinerators – 5
14. Kerala No of TSDFs - 1
TSDF with only common SLF – 1
15. Madhya Pradesh No of TSDFs - 1
TSDF Integrated – 1
145
NLSIU
16. Maharashtra Total TSDFs - 4

(Proposed TSDFs – 1 at Mahad)
TSDFs Integrated – 3
TSDFs with only common SLFs– 1.
17. Manipur Nil
18. Meghalaya Nil
19. Mizoram Nil
20 Nagaland Nil
21. Odisha No of TSDFs – 1
22. Punjab No of TSDFs – 1
23. Rajasthan No of TSDFs – 3
TSDF with only common Incinerator – 1
24. Sikkim Nil
25. Tamil Nadu No of TSDFs – 1TSDF Integrated – 1
26. Telangana No of TSDFs - 1TSDFs integrated – 1
27. Tripura Nil
28. Uttar Pradesh No of TSDFs – 4
TSDFs Integrated - 2
TSDFs with only common SLF - 1
TSDFs with only common Incinerator – 1
29. Uttarakhand No of TSDFs – 1TSDFs Integrated – 1
30. West Bengal No of TSDFs – 1TSDFs Integrated – 1
31. Andaman & Nicobar Islands Nil
32. Chandigarh Nil
33. Daman, Diu, Dadra & Nagar No of TSDFs – 1
Haveli TSDFs Integrated – 1
146
NLSIU
34. Lakshadweep Nil
35. Puducherry Nil
An important point to be noted from the statistics provided above is that 13 states and
union territories do not have efficiently function to dispose TSDFs at all. Therefore, in
such states, the question remains as to how the waste generated is being treated.
Furthermore, in 6 states, the facilities are proposed to be set up. In the absence of adequate
TSDF’s for a sector of this magnitude, it is of paramount importance to take positive
steps in this regard.
4.5 CHALLENGES FACED IN THE DISPOSAL, STORAGE AND

TRANSPORTATION OF HAZARDOUS WASTE
(a) The dangers of improper and unregulated disposal
Untreated waste is disposed into water bodies like rivers, lakes and streams creates water
pollution which makes the water bodies unfit for drinking and agricultural purposes. this
also affects the animals and plants who depend on this water for survival. The risk of
contamination of groundwater supplies due to leachates from landfills depends on several
factors: toxicity and volume of the contaminant generated at each site, the nature of the
geologic medium underlying the site, and the hydrologic conditions dominant in the
area.30
Additionally, the poorest members of the global community face higher risks. In urban
areas, low-income or minority populations are often exposed to hazardous chemicals and
associated wastes in their jobs or because they reside in polluted areas.31 Further, the
progressive decline in the standard of services in collection and disposal of waste, and
the lack of awareness in doing the same, has left a huge amount of solid waste unattended
in urban areas. This leads to an increase in morbidity due to microbial and parasitic
infections especially in the densely populated slums in urban areas because of the rise in
30 Report of High Power Committee on Urban Solid Waste Management in India, Planning Commission
of India 1995.
31 Available at: https://www.undp.org/content/undp/en/home/2030-agenda-for-sustainable-
development/planet/environment-and-natural-capital/chemicals-and-waste-management.html(Last
147
NLSIU
unsanitary conditions.32 In rural areas, most chemical exposure and environmental pollution
is linked to the misuse of agricultural chemicals and pollution brought by waterways,
impacting the natural resources upon which these communities depend. 33
Small, medium and large scale industries generate hazardous waste on the basis of which
these industries are classified. In terms of regulation the identification of large and medium
scale industries as contributors to the chemical sector have been acknowledged. But the
problem arises in the regulation of the small scale industries which are widespread and in
abundance. This makes it hard to identify and monitor in order to regulate the generation
and disposal of waste. Figure 8 showcases the hazardous waste generated by small scale
industries which ought to be regulated but are not being done efficiently.34
FIGURE 835
of India 1995.
33 Available at: https://www.undp.org/content/undp/en/home/2030-agenda-for-sustainable-
development/planet/environment-and-natural-capital/chemicals-and-waste-management.html (Last
of India 1995.
35 Ibid.
148
NLSIU
(b) Inefficient storage and transportation of hazardous waste
The storage of industrial solid waste is often one of the most neglected areas of operation
of an industry. Very little attention is paid to proper storage and heaps of mixed waste
piled against a wall or on open ground are common sights in many factories. Concrete
bays or disused drums are also often used for storage. Sledges originating from holding
tanks or interceptors do not present storage problems; no separate sludge storage is
required, because the sludge is retained in the tank until sufficient quantities are collected.36
Transportation of industrial wastes in metropolitan areas of developing countries is

generally not by purpose-built vehicles such as skip-carrying Lorries, but by open trucks.
The wastes are not covered during transportation. It is rare for special arrangements to
be made for hazardous wastes; they are usually collected together with the other wastes.
Contractors who carry hazardous waste do not need to be licensed, and consequently,
there is little control over either the types of firms engaged in carrying hazardous waste
or the vehicles used to transport such waste.
4.6 BHOPAL GAS TRAGEDY- A CASE OF INEFFICIENT WASTE

DISPOSAL
The fatal night of 2nd December 1984, while the workers of the then Union Carbide
Corporation (UCC) were washing the pipes clogged with solid hazardous wastes an
exothermic reaction was set off while the water seeped through the valves of two tanks
storing Methyl Isocyanate (MIC), thereby causing its discharge into the atmosphere
causing immediate death and injury of thousands of people who came in contact with
the gaseous mixture.
It is pertinent to note that UCC established its plant in Bhopal, and the factory was
constructed approximately within a 2 km radius from the railway station and adjacent to
a residential locality. Proposals for installation of a waste liquid incinerator facility for
the disposal of waste but these proposals were not implemented. Even with the enactment
of the Air and Water Act prior to the disaster, UCC and UCIL had not abide by the
regulations. There was contamination within the factory premises itself.
36 Ibid.
149
NLSIU
The Effluent Treatment Plants (ETP) to minimise the pollution of water bodies not
being installed to support the evaporation ponds which had the possibility of
contaminating the surrounding areas due to overflow.37 The non-compliance with the
regulatory standards under the pre-existing regime led to the disaster which could have
been prevented had UCC and UCIL abided by the Rules.
In 1989, UCC approved the ‘Site Rehabilitation Project- Bhopal Plant’ to decontaminate
and dispose the hazardous waste generated from the disaster which included high quantities
of Sevin and Napthol tarry residues. National Environmental Engineering Research
Institute (NEERI) took up the task of submitting a report on the examination of the soil
in 1990 where it stated that there was no contamination of groundwater in and around
the site of the MIC plant. But UCC itself doubted the legitimacy of the report stating
that the area contained quantities of Sevin and Napthol far more than the permitted
levels by Indian Statistical Institute for inland disposal.38 This highlights that the
Government did not have the expertise to take adequate measures to foresee the effect
that the waste would have on the land in and around the plant. But even though this
rehabilitation project was proposed, the implementation of the same fell back.
In 2001, Dow Chemicals took over Union Carbide however, refusing to accept the liability
of the disaster, and the disposal of the waste even though the Polluter Pays Principle
was imposed on them.39 Apathy lies in the fact that several tonnes of hazardous substance
left in the factory for over 2 decades after the disaster, had subsumed to become Waste
and concerns of the accumulated waste was addressed by the Jabalpur High Court in
2007, while ordering the Madhya Pradesh Pollution Control Board (MPPCB) and the
Central Pollution Control Board to take action on the waste in the UCC plant area. It was
alarming that the Boards were conflicted on deciding a suitable location to bury or
37 Available at: http://toxicslink.org/docs/06036_bhopal_report.pdf (Last accessed on November 19,

2019).
38 Available at: http://www.ielrc.org/content/w0405.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
39 Available at: https://corporate.dow.com/en-us/about/legal/issues/bhopal/tragedy.html (Last accessed
150
NLSIU
incinerate the waste.40 This portrayed the inefficiency of the laws enacted in India to
facilitate the disposal of toxic wastes in India.
However, the MPPCB, in successive consecutive failures of performed the following

four methodologies for disposal of the waste:
 Land Filling at Pithampur, Indore:
First, they decided to dispose the waste within the State at Pithampur near Indore.
After 40 tonnes had already been buried, the actions of the Board came to the
awareness of the people living there which led to the resistance of this action
and the people succeeded in diverting the waste from being dumped.
 Incineration at Ankleshwar, Gujarat:
Secondly, the CPCB took up the initiative to incinerate the waste in Ankleshwar,
Gujarat. But this plan failed as well because the incinerator caught fire and the
local people raised objections against the same.
 Incineration at DRDO Facility, Nagpur:
Thirdly, the Board decided to incinerate the waste in the Defence Research and
Development Organization facility around 30 kms from Nagpur in Maharashtra.
The people from a neighbouring village called Ruikhairi objected this act by going
to the Court because incineration of the waste which contained chlorinated
chemicals and heavy metals would expose deadly toxins in the air. Thus, the plan
failed.
 Disposal at Taloja, Mumbai
Lastly, which is the most recent plan, was to dispose the waste in a facility near
Taloja in Navi Mumbai. This plan also failed in implementation because it is not
possible to transport tonnes of waste for around 600 kms from Bhopal. It would
40 Available at: https: //www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/41419808.pdf ?ab_segments=0%2fbasic_syc-

4222%2ftest&re freqid=search %3a5b058b19c1dc4363b6242e55ed9c7db1 (Last accessed on November
19, 2019).
151
NLSIU
also breach the rules controlling disposal of hazardous waste which states that
the wastes must be managed closer to the plant to prevent further hazards during
transportation.41
In 2015, there was a proposal from Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (GIZ)
to airlift the waste to Germany and incinerate it. But the German public and activists
opposed this proposal. Further the representatives of India and Germany were not able
to negotiate on certain clauses of the agreement with respect to the liability of the transport
and incineration. The disposal of the waste was proposed to take place in the incinerator
in Hamburg which would have cost India about 3.4 million42 and there was a dilemma as
to whether the burden of the costs would be taken up by the Government of India or
Dow Chemicals. Thus, Germany retracted their proposal to incinerate the waste. Despite
all these failed mechanisms, the government remains lackadaisical about enacting stringent
and clear guidelines for disposal of toxic waste and the pile of waste in the Bhopal Plant
remains untouched. The effects of the disaster still felt by the people who live in the
vicinity of the plant. Despite having wreaked havoc which continues to affect the
environment and human health, there is a need for adequate measures to be taken up to
resolve this dire situation.
4.7 GLOBAL OUTLOOK ON THE NEED FOR EFFECTIVE CHEMICAL

WASTE MANAGEMENT
The universal impediment to effective chemical waste management happens to be

insufficient measures to ensure effective chemical treatment plants and safe handling of
chemicals. Sound chemical waste management by virtue of its impact becomes imperative
in light of achieving the Sustainable Development Goals owing to its inherent connection
it shares with the collective goals.43 This flows as a necessary corollary to the global
41 Bhopal’s Toxic Legacy,Available at: https://www.jstor.org/stable/pdf/41419808.pdf ? ab_segments=

0%2fbasic_syc-4222%2ftest&re freqid=search% 3a5b058b19c1dc4363b6242e55ed9c7db1 (Last accessed
42 Available at:https://www.dw.com/en/germans-back-out-of-bhopal-cleanup/a-16250333 (Last accessed
43 Chemicals and Waste Management: Essential to Achieving the Sustainable Development Goals
(SDGs),Available at: https://www.who.int/iomc/chemicalsandsdgs_interactive_feb2018_new.pdf
152
NLSIU
chemical output generated by the developed and the developing countries emphasising
the need for an effective system of chemical waste management. The global chemical
output has grown by a staggering 84% between the years 2000 and 2010 and with emerging
developing economies almost accounting for 65% of the increase.44
FIGURE 9 Source: UNEP Chemicals Outlook 2013
This clearly indicates that developing countries being primary contributories to the Global
Chemical Output, there is a need for an effective system of chemical waste management.
It is often important to analyse the collaboration of the BRICS nations from an
environmental standpoint as these developing countries are largely dependent on their
industries for the growth of the economy. With the environmental concerns constantly
being at loggerheads with developmental activities, the amount of investment made
with respect to environmental protection becomes imperative to understand.
44 UNEP Global Chemicals Outlook 2013.
153
NLSIU
FIGURE-10 Source: BRICS Statistical Publication 2016
The above graphical representation clearly indicates that the amount of expenditure
made on Environment Protection by India has been rather meagre in comparison to
other BRICS nations that have been compared above.45 The question of effective
chemical waste management looms large if we construe out of this meagre expenditure
on environment protection how much would be actually allocated for the cause of
chemical waste management.
This does not mean that efforts and initiatives are not underway to ensure sustainability
in terms of effective chemical waste management. The BRICS Nations have signed a
MoU in 2018 for approach on matters such as waste management in pursuance of the
SDG’s and the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.46
45 BRICS Statistical Publication 2016, page 95-97, Available at: http://mospi.nic.in/sites/default/files/

publication_reports/brics_jsp_2016.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
46 BRICS Environment Ministers sign Memorandum of Understanding (MoU), 26 July 2018, Department
of Environmental Affairs, Republic of South Africa, Available at: https://www.environment.gov.za/
mediarelease/brics2015_ environmentministers_sign_mou (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
154
NLSIU
Table I The status of generation of hazardous waste in the country as of 2001,

2009 and 2016
Description Million tonnes Million tonnes Million tonnes per

per annum (as per annum (as annum (as of
of 2000)47 of 2009)48 2016)49
No. of industries 12, 584 nos. 36,165 43,938 nos.
generating hazardous
wastes
Total generation of 7.243 6.232507 7.467
hazardous waste
Lanfillable Hazardous 5.250 2.728 3.416
waste
Incinerable waste 0.118 0.415 0.695
Recyclable waste 1.4292 0.3088 3.356
With respect to the BRICS countries, measures have been adopted to ensure hazardous
waste management in terms of management facilities, yet there needs to be a lot done
with regard to ensuring sufficiency of these measure to tackle the problem of hazardous
waste management owing to the fact that these are largely industry-oriented economies.50
4.8 THE NEED FOR REGULATION OF THE CHEMICAL SECTOR IN

INDIA
An overview of the chemical sector as provided above portrays that there is a robust
system in place to regulate the sector as a whole. This is not to say that the regulatory
47 Report of MoEF 2000.
48 National Inventory of Hazardous Wastes Generating Industries and Hazardous Waste Management
in India, CPCB 2009.
49 CPCB Bulletin Vol. I, July 2016, Govt. of India.
50 Global Waste Management Outlook, UNEP and ISWA, page 284,Available at: https://www.uncclearn.
org/sites/default/files/inventory/unep23092015.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
155
NLSIU
regime in place is devoid of loopholes. There are certain industry-specific requirements

which have not been adequately catered to in the existing framework. These ambiguities
and lacunae pose certain challenges in the effective regulation of the sector. The possible
hurdles in the effective regulation of the chemical sector are summarised as below.
 Nascent legal framework-
The legal framework for the regulation of the Sector is yet to encapsulate the essence of
the peculiar nature of the Industry which requires regulation at multiple levels.
(i) Ambiguity in definitions- The Environment Protection Act, 1986 which is an

umbrella legislation with regard to the aspects of environmental regulation does
not define what constitutes “chemical waste” nor does it define what a “chemical
substance”. It goes on to define the term “hazardous substance” under Section
2(e) in which there is no cogent understanding of the amount of importance
given to the chemical industry and dealing with the nuances of chemicals as a
category which requires separate focus owing to its nature.
(ii) Absence of a specific legislation to specifically cater to needs to the

Chemical sector in India- With respect to the Chemical sector, currently there
is only a policy framework in the nature of a National Chemical Policy which has
not yet come to force. All the matters under the Chemical Industry currently are
being dealt under the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and
Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016 with the Central Pollution Control Board
as a regulator in this regard. This leaves a huge legislative vacuum for chemicals
which are not hazardous by nature but owing to the lack of standards to ensure
its safety turns harmful. In the absence of the requisite legislative infrastructure,
it poses a serious problem for the chemical products manufactured in India to be
compliant with European Union’s REACH(Registration, Evaluation,
Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals).
(iii) Need for a penal provision centric-approach for non-compliance- Rule 19

of the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement)
Rules, 2016 provides for serving of an improvement notice by the concerned
authority for contravention for any of the obligations under the Act. This does
156
NLSIU
not provide for penal sanctions in case of non-compliance. Incorporation of

penal sanctions in terms of revocation or suspension of licenses will ensure
maximum compliance by chemical manufacturing companies.
 Need for collation of Independent and Updated Statistics
In order to ensure regulation of a particular sector, it requires the understanding of the

deep and profound impact it creates on the country. With respect to statistics related to
the chemical sector in particular, the information pertaining to numerous indicators are
based on reports prepared by corporate giants. This raises questions as to the accuracy of
these reports. The lack of enforceability of the National Chemical Policy coupled with
the inadequacy of independent updated statistics calls for a need to collate sufficient
data with requisite indicators to ensure the comprehensive understanding of the industry
as a whole.
 Lack of adequate hazardous waste treatment and management facilities
Though there was scanty awareness about the consequences of hazardous industrial
waste, it took a series of devastating incidents for the nation to finally wake up from its
slumber and take an awakening interest in this problem. India faces significant
environmental challenges associated with the proper treatment and management of waste.
The subject of industrial/chemical waste particularly has reached a place of highest
importance when it boils down to waste management and sanitary regulation. The fact
that many States do not have a TSDF’s put in place signifies the need for positive steps
to be taken to handle hazardous wastes.
 Inefficiency of Statutory bodies
The Central as well as the State Pollution Control Boards have faced challenges in
implementing their policies and protocols. There are no standard inspection and sampling
procedures prescribed in the Water Act, Air Act or EPA, or other regulations and the
CPCB and SPCBs have not issued uniform guidelines.51 The Environmental Impact
51 Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD). Environmental Compliance

and Enforcement in India: Rapid Assessment. 2006 , 9 [OECD].
157
NLSIU
Assessment is one such protocol that is used as a device to determine environmental,

social and economic impacts of a project prior to taking a decision on its implementation
and mitigation of harmful impacts and maximizes the beneficial effects. The EIA process
involves many steps such as Screening, Preliminary Assessment, Scoping, and the final
assessment of public hearing and appraisal. But there is an absence of an independent
Institutional setup to conduct and monitor EIAs and management plan implementation,
absence of cumulative EIA provisions in the law, absence of effective quality control of
EIA process.
Additionally, SPCBs have no deterrent mechanisms such as fines or penalties that could
be imposed on non-complying industries.52 Chapter 3, the Wastes Management Rules do
in fact allow SPCBs to impose civil fines on occupiers and operators if they violate
provisions of the Hazardous Wastes Rules. An SPCB must, however, get approval from
the CPCB before it imposes the fine. This approval process can be difficult and time
consuming, which may be the reason that one study found that few SPCBs use this
provision.
 Lack of demarcation of landfills for treatment facilities-
The Waste Management Rules 2016 relies on a compliance-based approach to regulate

demarcation of land for the purpose of landfills and the onus is upon the occupier to
ensure the treatment of chemical wastes. The absence of governmental intervention
leaves this matter solely to the prerogative of the Occupier who may or may not ensure
effective waste management.
The Reduce, Re-use and Recycle Paradigm
The concept of Reduce, Re-use and Recycle or 3Rs is an efficient mechanism to

minimize the drastic environmental impact of pollution caused by waste. In the realm
of chemical and hazardous waste management, practices incorporating the essence of
this ‘Triple R’ regime will facilitate waste minimization.53 It will ensure sustainable
52 Centre for Science and Environment, Rurnaround: Reform Agenda for India’s Environmental
Regulators, New Delhi: CSE, 2009 [Turnaround].
53 Handbook on Chemical and Biological Waste Management, Centres of Excellence, United Nations
Interregional Crime and Justice Research Institute, 2014 page 168.
158
NLSIU
production and consumption patterns. The ‘Reduce’ aspect implies a reduction in the
amount of waste generated by utilizing items with care.54 To reuse means to repeat the
use of items or parts of items which still have usable aspects. Recycling means the use
of waste itself as a resource. It includes the use, reuse or reclamation of waste residuals
or materials of hazardous waste. The reduction in the resources and energy used should
yield to a proportional increase in the recyclable materials. Waste minimization can be
achieved in an efficient way by focusing on the 3Rs in a chronological order. The
waste hierarchy refers to the 3Rs, which classify waste management strategies according
to their desirability and prioritize based on their importance. The aim of the waste
hierarchy is to extract the maximum practical benefits from products and to generate
the minimum amount of waste. This saves fresh resources exploitation and waste
generation quantity. It facilitates economic feasibility by saving fresh resources from
being exploited and is socially acceptable. By implementing measures on both the
production and consumption sides, countries may be able to reduce (per unit of product)
both the quantity of the resource extraction stream and the quantity and environmental
impact of the residual materials flow that ultimately reaches disposal sites.55
In a world entrapped in the snares of accelerating economic development, environmental

degradation is an inevitable and fatal consequence. It is no secret that economies striving
towards a growth-oriented paradigm are likely to become incompatible with the idea of
ecological sustainability simply because a rising industrial sector means more harm to
the environment. The importance that the Industry has assumed over the years in India
in terms of a contributor to the economy shows that it cannot be done away with. At the
same time, the effect that the industry has on the environment in terms of the pollution
54 National 3RStrategy for Waste Management, Department of Environment, Ministry of Environment

and Forests, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, December 2010 page 3, Available at:
http://www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/national_3r_strategy.pdf (Last accessed on
November 19, 2019).
55 Reduce, Reuse and Recycle (the 3Rs) and Resource Efficiency as the Basis for Sustainable Waste
Management, United Nations Centre for Regional Development, 2011, New York page 5, Available at:
https://www.un.org/esa/dsd/csd/csd_pdfs/csd19/learningcentre/presentations/may%209%
20am/1%20-%20learning_centre_ 9may_ppt_mohanty.pdf (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
159
NLSIU
cause by it cannot be ignored. Therefore, devising a regulatory framework for the industry
to meet the needs of its economic growth while keeping the drastic environmental impact
to the minimum calls for a sustainable approach. The constant tussle between environment
and development cannot come in the way of the need for regulation of the use of chemicals
by virtue of the inherent characteristics of chemicals which has the propensity to be
harmful. The sheer magnitude and volume of production and consumption of chemical
products is growing at a pace which calls for regulation in this Sector.
4.9 INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN CHEMICALS AND THE INDIAN

POSITION
The basic economic concept called Trade is of buying and selling of goods and services.
When such trade is undertaken between countries it is termed as international trade.
Chemical waste or hazardous wastes, are wastes which is said to pose a threat to human
health or environment; such wastes would also require special care when being transported,
stored, treated or disposed. Back in 1992 the chief economist of the World Bank, Lawrence
Summers, had written in an internal memo56 questioning as to whether or not it would be
a good decision to dump toxic wastes in low wage and low population density countries.
The inherent meaning behind this request was that such countries would have an increased
degree of tolerance towards environmental hazard as the number of people affected by
such environmental risks would be less, not to mention the low income of the majority
of the population indicating a decreased economic value of human life and health.57
Toxic wastes, as per the law of comparative advantage58, needs to be stored and treated
in a low-income-under-populated country.59
56 Economist, 1992, Let Them Eat Pollution, 8 Feb 1992, 66.

57 Thunen Michael Rauscher, Series of Applied Economic Theory - working paper no. 19: International
Trade in Hazardous Waste.
58 Comparative advantage: when one nation’s opportunity cost of producing an item is less than another
nation’s opportunity cost of producing that item. A good or service with which a nation has the largest
absolute advantage (or smallest absolute disadvantage) is the item for which they have a comparative
advantage, Glossary, Bureau of LaborStatistics, United States Department of Labor, Available at:
https://www.bls.gov/bls/glossary.htm#c (Last accessed on 8 November, 2019).
59 So the number of people affected by an environmental risk of such dumping would be low.
160
NLSIU
Free trade is where countries agree to reduce trade barriers60 and facilitate free
movement of goods and services with little or no government tariffs, quotas, subsidies
etc. therefore it is a voluntary exchange and the benefits to have international division of
labor improves the production factors and increases productive utilization. However,
when it comes to trade in chemical wastes it is often argued that international trade in
hazardous substances would result in an imbalanced economic exchange between Global
North and the Global South,61 in the sense that the industrialized developed countries
would be exporting their domestic wastes and in turn their environmental complications
to a developing non-industrialized country which would have already been facing a
problem in processing and disposal of hazardous substances. So the proponents of this
argument suggest that there needs to be a complete ban on the trade of these chemical
and hazardous wastes which would compel the developed countries into either steer
clear of generation of such wastes completely or evolve environmentally sound means
of disposal.
In actuality, however, international trade in hazardous waste is highly regulated62 and in

some cases restricted.63 An international instrument that is of prime importance in this
regard is the ‘Basel Convention on the Control of Trans-boundary Movements of
Hazardous Waste and its Disposal’64 (Basel Convention). This convention forbids private
transactions in chemical and hazardous waste and also prohibits exports of countries
who are not a party to this convention; further in certain special situations the convention
60 Free Trade – Economics, Encyclopaedia Britannica, Available at: https://www.britannica.com/topic/

free-trade (Last accessed on 8 November 2019).
61 Vincenzo di Nicola, the Global South: an Emergent Epistemology, Available at: https://
www.academia.edu/36591955/the_global_south_ the_global_south_an_emergent_epistemology
(Last accessed on 8 November 2019).
62 Stockholm Convention; Rotterdam Convention; Basel Convention; Minamata Convention.
63 Annex 6. List of chemicals banned or severely restricted to certain uses owing to their effects on health
and the environment in the countries of EU, International Labour Organization, Available at: https:/
/www.ilo.org/legacy/english/protection/safework/cis/products/safetytm/clasann6.htm (Last accessed
on 8 November 2019).
64 Basel Convention &Basel Protocol on Liability and Compensation.
161
NLSIU
suggests that the exported wastes and substances would have to be re-imported into the
country of origin.65
4.9.1 INDUSTRIAL GROWTH AND CLASSFICATION
‘The World Counts’ organization statistics of the tons of hazardous waste thrown out
globally as on 8.11.2019 stands at 343,243,100 and its increasing by the second.66 The
generation of waste has to have a source and this section explores the source for the
generation of the chemical wastes around the world.
The Indian Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEFCC) in 2016
developed a criterion to categorize the industries in India based on the Pollution Index.
The pollution Index, PI, would be any number between 0 and 100 and the closer an
industries PI to 100 the higher the degree of pollution load from it.67 The CPCB, SPCB
and MoEFCC together has classified most of the chemical manufacturing and waste
generating industries in the ‘Red Category’ which indicates that the industries under this
sector has a pollution index of 60 and above.68 To broadly categorize the industries
which produce chemical wastes are:
65 Basel Convention: Article 8: duty to re-import:

[When a trans-boundary movement of hazardous wastes or other wastes to which the consent of the
states concerned has been given, subject to the provisions of this convention, cannot be completed in
accordance with the terms of the contract, the state of export shall ensure that the wastes in question
are taken back into the state of export, by the exporter, if alternative arrangements cannot be made for
their disposal in an environmentally sound manner, within 90 days from the time that the importing
state informed the state of export and the secretariat, or such other period of time as the states
concerned agree. To this end, the state of export and any party of transit shall not oppose, hinder or
prevent the return of those wastes to the state of export.] Available at:: https://www.basel.int/
portals/4/basel%20convention/docs/text/baselconventiontext-e.pdf (Last accessed on: November
19, 2019).
66 Hazardous Waste Statistics, the World Counts, Available at: https: //www.theworldcounts.com/
counters/waste_pollution_facts/hazardous_waste_statistics.(Last accessed on November 19,
2019).
67 Environment Ministry releases new categorisation of industries. (5-march-2016) Press Information
Bureau, GoI, Available at: from: https: //pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=137373 (Last
68 Ibid.
162
NLSIU
 Auto repair shops: with their constant oil changing ritual, paint, engine lubricant
etc;
 Printing industries: with their use of ink and photography equipment;
 Metal-works industry: using acid based chemicals and water based sludge
producing, in some cases, cyanide waste;
 Dye industry: manufacturing to further use in paper, textiles and such other
industries and using copper, chromium, sulfuric acid etc to prepare the dyes;
 Chemical manufacturing industry: making plastics, paints, explosives, dyes,

pharmaceuticals, petrochemicals etc.
 Lead-acid battery industry: making rechargeable batteries and the pile up of

unused batteries making its way to be up-cycled.
Besides these it would only seem discourteous to ignore the plastic manufacturing
industries as one of the producers of chemical waste and it would be appropriate to
assume that most of the industries these days would produce some form of chemical
waste during the process of their manufacture. In India the number of polluting industries
are said to have doubled between 2011 and 2018.69 Lack of statutorily required safety
standards and insufficient training of the workers would result in use of crude methods
to handle toxic waste leading to such toxic wastes contaminating the nearby air and
water resources putting nearly millions of people around such industries at risk.
Interestingly many countries around the world have a registry system for such industries
to obtain a license if they are to deal with any such chemicals.70 India has proposed to
69 Grossly Polluting Industries More than Doubled in 8 years: SOE in Figures, Down to Earth, Available
at:https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/pollution/grossly-polluting-industries-more-than-
doubled-in-8-years-soe-in-figures-64962 (Last accessed on 8 November, 2019).
70 Waste: Guidelines &References, Environmental Protection Department, the Government of Hong
Kong. Available at:https://www.epd.gov.hk/epd/english/environmentinhk/waste/guide_ref/
ref_cw.html (Last accessed on 8 November 2019).
163
NLSIU
have a registry for chemical producing industries through its National Action Plan on
Chemicals.71
4.9.2 ARGUMENTS FOR AND AGAINST INTERNATIONAL TRADE IN

CHEMICAL AND WASTES
International trade in general is considered to be advantageous to all the countries involved.

The simple reason would be that there would not be an agreement to trade in case parties
involved would not be acting in self-interest to benefit from such a trade. However,
expecting free trade especially in the case of chemical and hazardous wastes would be
considered naive. Therefore there will be economic situations where barriers to trade
have been in place and the removal of these barriers would result in loss of welfare of
the parties involved. Therefore, if one has to assume that there are no transport externalities
and pollution spill-overs then this would result in a regulatory deficit in waste disposal
industries of the importing countries and becomes beneficial to the exporters of toxic
waste thereby harming the importers as they lose out on welfare from trade liberalization
resulting in a negative trade in international trade perspective.
The supporters of international trade in chemical wastes view the situation through an
economic and financial lens. They argue that since the liberalization of trade and
introduction of free trade between the countries it would be impractical to criticize trade
in chemical waste as free trade is based on voluntary exchange between countries and
that they would not be tying themselves together if it were not beneficial to the parties
involved. Further the international division of labor results in increased ability to allocate
as it facilitates the production factors to a most productive utilization of resources.
Therefore they conclude that that international trade in chemical waste would be beneficial.
This stand supporting profit maximization was demonstrated through an article published
in Cato Journal in 200772 which argues that there is small evidence of the fact that death
71 Sunny Lee, India Draft Chemical Plan Possible Early 2019, Chemical Watch – Global Risk and Regulation
News. Available at: https://chemicalwatch.com/72436/india-draft-chemical-plan-possible-early-
2019#overlay-strip (Last accessed on 8 November, 2019).
72 Jay Johnson, GrayPecquet & Leon Taylor, Potential Gains from Trade in Dirty Industries: Revisiting
Lawrence Summers’ Memo, Available at: https://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/cato-
journal/2007/11/cj27n3-6.pdf (Last accessed on 8 November 2019).
164
NLSIU
rates in developing countries has increased due to such trade and that developing countries
and its people weigh the increased opportunities to business and productivity more than
the hazards created by the pollutants due to trade in chemical wastes. Increase in the
economic development and profits of the developing countries and that of the global
south seems to be the central focus of the arguments for the international trade in chemical
wastes.
On the other hand the critiques of this trade feel that as ideated by Lawrence Summers,
the current trend in the world trade has resulted in ‘Toxicomania colonialism’.73 The term
coined in 1992 by Jim Puckett of Greenpeace referring to the dumping of industrial
wastes of the Global North countries into that of the Global South.74 This, it is argued,
is a result of the lack of regulation and weak policies turning the countries of the global
south into toxic dumping yards of the countries of the global north. It is pointed out that
the producers of these chemical wastes rarely suffer the negative health effects from
having to had to deal with disposing them and that the burden has been passed on to the
workers and individuals of the poorer countries. In one of his research papers Professor
Reed argues75 that the western cultures has always viewed the developing and indigenous
land as underdeveloped and less civilized and therefore forge to transfer their harmful
wastes into those lands drawing a correlation between actual colonialism and that of
toxic colonialism.
4.9.3 INTERNATIONAL INSTRUMENTS REGULATING TRADE IN

CHEMICAL WASTE
The international conventions and the Indian national stand with regard to trade in
chemical wastes is not that of a blanket ban on the import and export of these substances,
but to restrict in international trade of select category of hazardous wastes and setting
73 Laura A. Pratt, Decreasing Dirty Dumping? aRe-evaluation of Toxic Waste Colonialism and the Global
Management of Transboundary Hazardous Waste, 35 WM. &Mary Envtl. L. &Pol’yRev. 581
(2011)Available at:https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/wmelpr/vol35/iss2/5 (Last accessed on 8
November, 2019).
74 Tam Dalyell, Thistle Diary: Toxic Wastes and Other Ethical Issues - Comment from Westminster,
News Scientist (4 July 1992), Available at:https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg13518285-900-
thistle-diary-toxic-wastes-and-other-ethical-issues-comment-from-westminster-by-tam-dalyell/(Last
accessed on 8 November 2019).
165
NLSIU
up a precondition permitting of such import and export of wastes after securing that
such wastes would be handled in a safe environment and in an environmentally viable
means and methods of treatment and disposal.
International trade, in more situations, take place through the sea route and this has been
the practice since the times of the first voyage through sea.76 These trade practices involve
the usage of ships and ships would often indulge in dumping77, spillage and oil pollution78.
To keep this in check the International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from
Ships came into being in 1973 which was later modified into a Protocol i.e. MARPOL
73/78.79 This protocol had the nations, through their national ship registry of such ships
at sail, responsible for their actions regardless of where they set sail. This in a way gave
the countries an authorization to monitor as to how, what and where the cargo of the
ships would be carried and their fate.
In 1986 a cargo ship named Khian Sea was carrying 14,000 tons of waste incinerator ash
to be shipped out of its origin territory. After being repeatedly refused by many countries
to accept the consignment of this ship, the crew dumped the same in the sea in 1988
despite the fact that MARPOL was already in existence; this incident lead to the Basel
75 T.V. Reed, Toxic Colonialism, Environmental Justice, and Native Resistance in Silko’s ‘Almanac of the
Dead’MELUS vol. 34, no. 2, Ethnicity and Ecocriticism pages. 25-42 (2009).
76 Peter. N. Stearns; William L. Langer, the Encyclopaedia of World History: Ancient, Medical, and Modern,
Chronologically Arranged. Houghton Mifflin Company (2001).
77 Inventory of Radioactive Waste Disposal at Sea, International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), Available
at: https://www-pub.iaea.org/mtcd/publications/pdf/te_1105_prn.pdf (Last accessed on 10
November, 2019).
78 Bella Bathurst, the Wreckers: a Story of Killing Seas and Plundered Shipwrecks, from the 18thCentury
to the Present Day, page 140, Available at: https://books.google.co.in/books? id=2cwsxl3adpkc
&printsec=frontcover&vq=%2 2shipwrecks+of+the+isles+ of+scilly% 22&source =gbs_citations_
module_r&cad =6#v=onepage&q= %22shipwrecks%20of% 20the%20isles%20of%20scilly% 22&f=
false (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
79 International Convention for the Prevention of Pollution from Ships (MARPOL), International
Maritime Organization, Available at: http://www.imo.org/en/about/conventions/listofconventions/
pages/international-convention-for-the-prevention-of-pollution-from-ships-(marpol).aspx (Last
166
NLSIU
convention coming into existence.80 This convention created the opportunity for the
countries of the world to ideate and conceive an international instrument on
trans-boundary movement of hazardous waste i.e. Basel convention which came into
effect in 1992.
Subsequent to Basel convention a multilateral treaty, in 1998, which checked the

responsibilities of the countries with respect to importation of hazardous chemicals was
entered into i.e. the Rotterdam convention on the Prior Informed Consent Procedure for
Certain Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade.81 This convention
needed the exporters to suitably and adequately label the hazardous materials that are
being exported.82 Rotterdam convention majorly contains the list of substances that
requires to be labelled in case of international trade in them. Meanwhile the Stockholm
Convention on persistent organic pollutants came into being in 200483 which aimed at
eliminating or restricting production and use of persistent organic pollutants. This
convention not only listed substances that it aims to eliminate or restrict but it also
provided for financial support from the developed countries to eliminate or restrict the
use of listed chemical and effectively manage their disposal.84 The above mentioned
three conventions namely, Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm, later had joint managerial
functions for their Secretaries.85
80 William P. Cunningham & Mary Ann Cunningham, Principles of Environmental Science, McGraw-
Hill GurtherEducation, chapter 13: Further Case Studies, Available at:http://highered.
mheducation.com/sites/0072919833/student_view0/chapter13/additional_case_ studies.html (Last
81 The Rotterdam Convention, Available at: http://www.pic.int/theconvention/overview/
textoftheconvention/tabid/1048/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
82 Article 13: Information to Accompany Exported Chemicals, Rotterdam Convention on the Prior
Informed Consent Procedure for Certain Hazardous Chemicals and Pesticides in International Trade,
Texts and Annexes (revised in 2017) United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) and Food and
Agriculture Organization of UN (FAO).
83 Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutants, Available at: http://www.pops.int/
theconvention/overview/textoftheconvention/tabid/2232/default.aspx (Last accessed on 10
November, 2019).
84 Article 13: Financial Resources and Mechanisms, Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic Pollutant,
Texts and Annexes (revised in 2017) (UNEP).
85 Synergies Among the Basel, Rotterdam and Stockholm Conventions, Available at: http://
www.brsmeas.org/home/tabid/813/language/en-us/default.aspx (Last accessed on 10 November,
2019).
167
NLSIU
As part of the Indo-German Bilateral agreement and Indo-German Cooperation in Science

and Technology86 there has been a project on strengthening of Central and State Pollution
Control Boards. Under this bilateral agreement an Indo-German centre for sustainability
(IGCS) has been established at IIT Madras along with German universities which, along
with other things, also work towards sustainable waste management. Under the said
project there had to identification and categorization of the hazardous wastes and to
develop a national framework to dispose such wastes thereby developing guidelines to
issue license to such facilities and to establish cooperation between different waste
management authorities in India.
Having a sound and conscious trade begins with a robust legislation and to support this
in 2015 the UNEP i.e. the United Nations Environment Program has come with a UN
Environment Guidance on the Development of Legal and Institutional Infrastructures
and Measures for Recovering Costs of National Administration for Sound Management
of Chemicals; this in short are called the LIRA Guidance. These guidelines aim at providing
support for nations in framing legislations and for institutional set-ups to have sound
management of chemicals. This was followed by ‘Guidance on chemical control
contributing to national progress and safety’ in 2015 to assist governments in implementing
the LIRA guidelines.
Bamako convention, an African Union convention, came into being as a response to

Article 11 of the Basel Convention87. This convention aims at protecting the African
countries against the exports of the toxic wastes from the developed nations. Including
this there are 9 other conventions that have been entered into by various countries.88
86 Brief on Indo-Ger man Cooperation in Science & Technology, Available at: https://
www.indianembassyberlin.gov.in/pdf/indo-german%20brief%20for%20january%202019.pdf (Last
87 Freedom to Parties of the Basel Convention to Enter into Regional Agreements.
88 Bilateral, Multilateral and Regional Agreements and Arrangements, Basel Convention on the Control
of Trans-boundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal, Available at: http://
archive.basel.int/article11/multi.html (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
168
NLSIU
4.10 INDIAN REGULATIONS
One of the focuses of the Indian Foreign Trade Policy (2015-2020), among others, is to
support chemical markets with a concentration to strengthen the South Asian community.89
Further the policy states that India along with negotiating with the Trade and Economic
Partnership Agreement (TEPA) and the EFTA countries i.e. Iceland, Norway, Switzerland
and Liechtenstein, has plans to engage with Turkey and Visegrad-490 and other non-EU
countries to encourage trade in organic chemicals among other things.91 The policy also
looks at improving trade connectivity amongst the SAARC countries and trade in chemicals
is one among the focused industries.92 On the impact analysis the policy mentions that
the preferential imports of intermediate goods into India through Foreign Trade
Agreements (FTA) has benefited through an increase in manufacturing activities. The
prime function of the Directorate General of Foreign Trade constituted under the Foreign
Trade (Development and Regulation) Act, 1992 is to implement the Exim or the Foreign
Trade Policy93 and therefore becomes the authority to implement the above mentioned
Foreign Trade Policy regulations on Chemicals and their trade between India and other
countries.
The other Indian legislation that majorly concerns with trade in chemical wastes is the
Hazardous and other Wastes (Management and Trans-boundary Movement) Rules, 2016.
The core objectives of these rules are to recycle, reprocess and reuse of hazardous wastes
by setting up Treatment Storage and Disposal Facility (TSDF). The Import of wastes
under these Rules are only permitted for reuse or recycle or reprocessing with prior
permission of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change and/or Directorate
General of Foreign Trade.94 These Rules, for the first time, distinguished between
89 Foreign Trade Policy (2015-2020) Available at: https://dgft.gov.in/foreigns-trade-policy-2015-20- (Last

90 Czech Republic, Hungary, Slovak Republic, Poland.
91 Supra note 89 at 35.
92 Ibid.
93 About the Directorate General of Foreign Trade, Available at: https://dgft.gov.in/about-us/about-
dgft (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
94 Environment Ministry Notifies Hazardous Waste Management Rules, 2016, Press Information Bureau,
Government of India, Available at : https: //pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=138521 (Last
169
NLSIU
Hazardous Waste and other wastes along with simplifying the procedure by merging the
approvals into a single window clearance to set up waste disposal facilities. The new
rules have also streamlined and simplified the document based process to import-export
of waste; the rules have also given out the list of waste regulated for import and export.
Further the HW Rules has prohibited the import of chemical wastes particularly the ones
in the solvent form.95
With a reference made to Annexure 8 of the Basel Convention, Part A of Schedule 3

mentioned under Rules 3, 12, 13, 14, 17(3) of the HW Rules, 2016 mentions about the
list of hazardous wastes that can be imported into India only upon prior consent; whereas
Part B of the said Schedule lists those wastes trading in which would not require a prior
consent. Part C – list of hazardous characteristics, Part D List of wastes the trade of
which would not require permission from the Environment Ministry. Schedule 6 as
mentioned under Rules 12 and 14 contain the list of hazardous and other wastes that are
prohibited from import into India. And the list of documents that are to be verified by
the Customs authorities for import of wastes is given under Schedule 8 as mentioned
under Rule 13(2) &(4). Schedule 7 under Rule 13(6)96 and Rule 2197 of the HW Rules,
2016 mentions the authorities who are concerned with the management of Hazardous
and other wastes. Accordingly,
 Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change under the Environment

(Protection) Act, 1986 are the authorities who issue permission to exporters and
importers of wastes.
 State pollution control boards or the Pollution Control Committees constituted

under the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 are the authorities
95 Ibid.
96 Rule 13(6): The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change shall forward a copy of the
permission to the concerned Portand Customsauthorities, Central Pollution Control Boardand the
concerned State Pollution Control Board for ensuring compliance with respect to their respective
functions given in Schedule VII.
97 Rule 21: Responsibility of Authorities.-the authority specified in column (2)of Schedule VII shall
perform the duties as specified in column (3) of the said schedule subject to the provisions of these
rules.
170
NLSIU
who examine the applications for imports submitted by the importers and
forwarding the same to the above said Ministry.
 The Directorate General of Foreign Trade constituted under the Foreign Trade
(Development and Regulation) Act, 1992 are the authorities who grant licenses
for the import of hazardous and other wastes; And to refuse license for such
wastes whose import and export has been prohibited.
Besides these, Rule 10 of the Ozone Depleting substances (Regulation) Rules, 2000
prohibits the import and export of any products which are made or are likely to contain
ozone depleting substances unless such importer or exporter obtains license from the
authorities and such product is properly labelled.
Indian regulations are required to be followed by the traders engaging in Exim trade in
India. The traders considering these regulations as hindering or delaying their trade in
chemical wastes to and from India have an international instrument in place. In so far as
barriers to international trade in chemical wastes are concerned, the anti-dumping duty
imposed by the domestic government on the imports from a foreign country secures a
prime position. The reason for imposition of an anti-dumping duty is to curtail the exporting
company from selling a product at a lower price than that of the same products in the
importing country thereby hampering the domestic market. The World Trade Organization
‘Anti-dumping Agreement’98 is one such international agreement which focuses on directing
as to how a country should or should not react to a dumping activity. Article 6 of GATT99
also provided for anti-dumping measures. India has taken this prudent measure several
times in the past and continues to take them in the interest of domestic trade. The
procedure of imposing such duties can be done in two ways:
98 Agreement on Implementation of Article VI of the General Agreement on Tariffs and

trade 1994,Uruguay Round Agreement, World Trade Organization, Available at: https://www.wto.org/
english/docs_e/legal_e/19-adp_01_e.htm (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
99 Ibid.
171
NLSIU
 One, where the government takes a suo moto decision to impose such duty;
 Second, after investigating an application filed by a company so affected by such

unfair competition.
Such anti-dumping measure related to chemicals has been imposed in the past few years
as follows:
 In 2017 the Directorate General of Trade Remedies (earlier known as Directorate

General of Anti-dumping and Allied Duties) under the Department of Commerce,
Ministry of Commerce and Industry, had imposed an anti-dumping duty of 60.35
$ per tonne for five years to protect domestic players from dumping of ‘ammonium
nitrate’ from Russia, Indonesia, Georgia and Iran.
 In November, 2018, the Ministry of Commerce recommended the continuation

of anti-dumping duty on import of ‘Methylene Chloride’, a chemical used in
pharmaceutical and agricultural industries, from the United States of America
and the European Union countries. This duty was initially imposed in 2014 and
on upon investigation from January-December, 2017, it was found that the
domestic market still suffers from the dumping of these chemicals into India.100
As a forward looking strategy the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change
has formed a National Coordination committee to draw up a National Action Plan for
Chemicals as part of the World Bank-aided Capacity Building for Industrial Pollution
Management Project.101 This action plan would address the production, import and
consumption of chemicals in terms of a policy framework for registration of chemicals,
to stop chemicals which pose a threat to human health and the environment, developing
infrastructure for analysis of chemicals and their effects on users, revising current and
100 Notification no.38/2018-customs (Add), Available at: http://www.cbic.gov.in/resources//htdocs-

cbec/customs/cs-act/notifications/notfns-2018/cs-add2018/csadd38-2018.pdf; jsessionid=
9c41b0f9071c8e94f26975ca0267fc6a (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
101 India Draft Chemical Plan Possible Early 2019, Chemical Watch Global Risk and Regulation News,
Available at: https://chemicalwatch.com/72436/india-draft-chemical-plan-possible-early-2019#overlay-
strip (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
172
NLSIU
existing legislation, involving India in more international programs and agreements. This
draft National Action Plan for Chemicals was said to set up a REACH like database102 for
India and is said to have been published for public comment in the first quarter of 2019.
It would be benefitting India immensely in the sense that which is said to follow the
Globally Harmonized System of classifying, labelling and packaging standards by setting
up new Hazardous Chemical Management Rules which has been draft law since 2011;
this Action plan seeing the light of the day would boost India a step ahead in developing
on par with the global standards by having to maintain its own national inventory of
chemicals which would facilitate easy management and regulation of chemicals and wastes
in the country.
Despite these conventions and legislations being in place there has been several instances
where countries have dumped hazardous substances into the borders of another country
in the pretext of international trade. The scenarios are discussed below.
The case of Italy and Nigeria
Africa has always been considered as the poorest of the countries with its feeble regulations
and implementation and a strong reputation of being exploited by the developed countries
from centuries together. Therefore the continent and its countries becoming victims of
‘toxic colonialism’ was not a surprise. An Italian company on one occasion dumped 4000
tons of toxic waste containing over a 100 tons of polychlorinated biphenyls into a Nigerian
village by falsely labelling the package as fertilizer; thereby resulting in the death of a
number of those villagers due to consumption of rice grown from the water contaminated
by those chemicals which made its way into a nearby flowing river. However, this situation
was said to have been remedied by the coming together of the environmental non-
governmental organizations (NGOs) with that of the State players in the 1980s were
successful in bringing about a ban on waste trade to a certain extent between Organization
for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries and non-OECD
countries.103
102 Registration, Evaluation, Authorisation and Restriction of Chemicals (REACH) established European
Chemicals Agency.
103 Jennifer Clapp, African, NGOs, and the International Toxic Waste Trade, the Journal of Environment
& Development (Vol 3, Issue 2, 1994) page 17-46.
173
NLSIU
Ship-breaking industry
The global south has been a hot-spot for ship-breaking. Ship-breaking refers to a way to
dispose it off the old and word out ships by way of demolition by breaking it up into
parts and thereby selling or utilizing the same for different industrial application and in
some cases to recycle them.104 Asian countries particularly Bangladesh, India, China,
Pakistan, Turkey etc have been the top choices among the developing countries to engage
in these activities. This activity dates back to the 80s when the British ships were scrapped
after years of service and continues till date.105 The trend majorly has been that the
industrialized countries wanting to get rid of an old ship looking to pass on the burden to
not deal with the effects of such process would sell those ships to developing countries;
in the garb of good business, the traders of the developing countries usually accept the
deal despite the old ships containing harmful substance and chemicals like asbestos,
mercury, arsenic etc and providing suitable gear to the workers who are involved in such
ship breaking is another cause of concern. A Supreme Court of India judgment in the
Clemenceau ship breaking case106 would more accurately demonstrate this situation.
Alang in Gujarat which has been reputed to be one of the world’s largest ship-breaking
yards107 has constantly been in the news for its controversial choice of dismantling ships
that pose a threat to the environment and the workers there. In 2005 despite the Dutch
Environment Ministers writing to the then Minister, A Raja, to deny permission to
dismantle a Dutch fugitive ship it is said that the request was denied.108 Following this in
104 Ship-Breaking: a Hazardous Work. International Labor Organization, Available at: https://
www.ilo.org/safework/areasofwork/hazardous-work/wcms_110335/lang—en/index.htm (Last
105 World War 1 at Sea,the British Shipbreaking Industry in Outline, Available at: http://www.naval-
history.net/ww1navybritish-shipbreak.htm (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
106 Research Foundation for Science, Technology and Natural Resource Policy vs. Union of India & Ors,
Dt:6/7/2012 (W.P. no. 657 of 1995).
107 10 Largest Ship Graveyards in the World, Available at: https://www.marineinsight.com/category/
environment/amp/ (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
108 Surabh Yadav, a Toxic Ship Comes Ashore, (2018), Available at: https://
www.thehindubusinessline.com/blink/know/a-toxic-ship-comes-ashore/article8309858.ece# (Last
174
NLSIU
2006 the Supreme Court of India appointed a High-Powered Committee109 to make

recommendations regarding the hazards associated with the ship breaking industry; the
committee’s recommendations were on the line of the international conventions like
Basel and Rotterdam and also directed that the Government of India formulate a Code
to incorporate the recommendations of the Committee. Further the court in the said
case decided to deny permission to a French aircraft carrier ship Clemenceau as it
contained huge amounts of asbestos in it and Alang did not have sufficient infrastructure
and does not follow safety measures while handling these harmful substance.110 This was
followed by the French Supreme Court recalling the ship.111 This was again facilitated by
the join work of various NGOs around the world and in India. Despite the Supreme
Court of India Judgment and the monitoring committee in place there has been ships
coming in since 2006 (SS Blue Lady),112 2010 (SS Platinum II).113 However, following this
several ships have been denied permission to enter Indian coasts like the Oriental Nicety
and Exxon Valdez.
With all these regulations in place one of the reasons as to why recyclers import waste
would be that they do not get enough waste in the country, which would be hard to
believe with the amount of garbage generated by Indian cities. As on 2015 the Ministry
of Environment, Forests and Climate Change has detected 5 cases of import of hazardous
waste114 of which the recent ones being the customs officials seizing containers carrying
around 500 tonnes of municipal wastes along with chemical wastes such as batteries etc
109 Supra note 106.

110 Ibid.
111 Ibid at 54.
112 Toxic Ship Blue Lady to be Allowed into Indian Waters, the Maritime Executive, Available at: https:/
/www.maritime-executive.com/article/2006-06-14toxic-ship-blue-lady-to-be-allowed-int (Last accessed
113 Central Team Begin Inspection of Ship Platinum II Near Alang, The Hindu. Available at https:
//www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/central-team-begin-inspection-of-ship-platinum-ii-near-alang/
article16887636.ece (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
114 See also https: //commerce.gov.in/writereaddata/uploadedfile/moc_635975494541653787_
ls20151214.pdf. (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
175
NLSIU
labelled as paper consignment. The importer was never the less penalized.115 The customs
are highly understaffed and under equipped to check thousands of containers that arrive
regularly across the ports in India. Ultimately the issue involves both law and environment
and also the essence of protecting a countries domestic market and its players or forging
for a bigger market share for their countries products and substances outside their
boundaries. The conduct of the countries and its traders towards the rules and regulations
would determine the equity between the countries and maintain harmony between trade
and environment.
******
115 See also https://www.downtoearth.org.in/coverage/single-window-dumpyard-328. (Last accessed

176
NLSIU
5
INDIAN REGULATIONS ON CHEMICAL AND
HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT
5.1 BACKGROUND
In the present times, the use of chemicals is indispensible for the growth of any economy
since it impacts almost all spheres of human activity. It is the mainstay of several sections
of the economy and contributes largely for the growth of the industrial and agricultural
sector by providing raw materials for a number of industries, including textile, paper,
paint, soap and detergent, pharmaceutical, bulk drugs and formulations, agrochemicals
such as insecticides, pesticides, fertilisers etc. Besides use of imported chemicals in
different industries, the chemical sector is an industry in its own right producing a wide
range of products such as inorganic chemicals, synthetic organic chemicals like drugs
and pharmaceuticals, dyes and intermediates, pigments, fine and specialty chemicals,
chlor-alkali, pesticides, colorants and alcohol based chemicals, etc. India ranks sixth in
the world in the production of chemicals and fourth in the production of agro-chemicals.
India accounts for 16 per cent of the dye stuff and dye intermediaries and is a global
supplier of dyes. Excluding pharmaceutical products, the chemical industry ranks 14th
in global exports, employs more than 2 million people and its value is expected to rise to
304 billion dollars by 2025.1
The sheer magnitude of the Indian chemical industry, the wide spectrum of products
manufactured, the allied and dependent sectors using chemicals, the emergence of new
chemical products with each passing day and the impact that the industry has on the
safety and livelihood of the persons employed in the sector and those working in close
contact with chemicals, and its potential to generate hazardous waste makes it incumbent
on the state to devise a regulatory mechanism for the chemical industry and the waste
1 Chemicals, Available at: https://www.investindia.gov.in/sector/chemicals (Last accessed on November

19, 2019).
177
NLSIU
Indian Regulations on Chemical and Hazardous Waste Management
the chemical industry or other allied industries using chemicals generates. In keeping
with the requirements of the industry and the challenges it can pose, especially in terms
of environmental and health risks, India has a comprehensive legislative framework for
the management of chemicals and hazardous chemical waste. Regulations have been
enacted for the entire life cycle of chemicals, starting from manufacture, storage, use,
handling, transportation, import and export, recycling, disposal and waste management,
consumer interest for using chemicals and the protection of the environment and public
health.
In addition to the chemical industry, there are a number of other sectors that generate
hazardous waste, in most of which chemicals are used in one form or the other. As a
result of industrialisation, technology picked pace and started controlling the industries.
Growth of software, supported by the hardware i.e., the physical device to use the
technology, had to be made out of components which is easy to use and at the same time
durable. Metals, plastic, glass and silicon-based materials were most suitable for such
products. Discarding these products after use has led to generating several tonnes of
wastes everyday worldwide. However, increased dependence on plastic and other non-
degradable substances has put the planet under peril. Indiscriminate disposal of these
plastic and other waste materials surrounded as landfills, littered in lakes, rivers and
oceans are slowly turning out to be a ticking time-bomb. Post the commencement of
technological era, focus has shifted from waste disposal to waste handling and management.
Classification of these waste substances into Hazardous, Chemical, E-waste, Plastic
wastes and Bio-medical wastes has laid down special emphasis on handling and
management of these specialised waste substances.
Different ministries are involved in regulating the implementation of the different Acts,
Rules and Regulations that govern different aspects of chemical and hazardous waste
management and handling. The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 acts as an umbrella
legislation under which most regulations on chemical wastes are framed. Moreover, this
legislation links the different multilateral environmental agreements on chemical and
waste such as the Basel Convention by formulating rules in pursuance of the obligations
that a signatory state has to abide by. The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change is the nodal Ministry responsible for the implementation of the Environment
178
NLSIU
(Protection) Act and consequently the Ministry that coordinates with the other ministries
for the management of chemicals, especially from the perspective of environmental
laws. The Hazardous Substances Management Division of the Ministry of Environment,
Forest and Climate Change is the nodal agency that is responsible for the management of
hazardous substances to ensure that minimal damage is done to health and environment.
The activities of the division are carried out under different thrust areas which include
chemical safety in the manufacture, storage and import of chemicals, chemical accidents
with special reference to emergency planning, preparedness and response, hazardous
waste management, solid waste management, bio-medical waste management, municipal
solid waste amongst other measures. The Division is also the coordinating body for the
five multilateral environmental agreements to which India is a party namely; the Basel
Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movement of Hazardous Waste and their
disposal; Rotterdam Convention on Prior Informed Consent Procedure for certain
Chemicals and Pesticides in International trade; Stockholm Convention on Persistent
Organic Pollutants, the Minamata Convention on Mercury and Strategic Approach to
International Chemicals Management.2
Some of the other important ministries and departments that regulate chemicals and in
one way or the other include the Ministry of Commerce and Industry that oversees the
export and import of chemicals and the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion
under the Ministry of Commerce and Industry that frames rules on explosives, the Ministry
of Labour that is concerned with the occupational health and safety of workers engaged
in chemical industries and the Department of Chemicals and Petrochemicals under the
aegis of the Ministry of Chemicals and Fertilizers that works as the nodal department for
the formulation and implementation of policies and programmes for the overall growth
and development of the chemical and petrochemical sector in the country. Other important
Ministries and bodies include the Ministry of Agriculture, Ministry of Petroleum and
Natural Gas and the Central Pollution Control Board and the State Pollution Control
Boards and the National Disaster Management Authority.
2 Waste Management - Hazardous Substance Management System, Available at: http: //moef.gov.in/
environment/waste-management/ (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
179
NLSIU
With the expanse of the chemical sector, one can only roughly estimate the amount of
hazardous waste that is generated in the country. The Ministry maintains an online web
based portal - the National Hazardous Waste Information System3 (NHWIS) that gives
an overview of the waste management in the country. The NHWIS project developed by
Environment and Forest Informatics division of National Informatics Centre (NIC) in
consultation with the Hazardous Substance Management Division (HSMD) of the
Ministry of Environment & Forests maintains a database that is regularly updated by all
the State Pollution Control Boards. The NHWIS built with the objective of maintaining
an online database that targets more than 32 thousand waste generating industries contains
records of such waste generating units, besides providing information on the status of
their compliance to environmental regulations.4 As per the information provided by the
Central Pollution Control Board, about 7.90 million tonnes of hazardous wastes are
annually generated by about 41,523 industries in the country, of which only 3.32 million
tonnes is land fillable waste, 0.60 million tonnes is incinerable waste and about 3.98
million tonnes is recyclable hazardous waste.5 With the magnitude of waste generated, it
becomes imperatives for the state to devise appropriate regulations for the management,
handling and disposal of hazardous wastes. While there are a number of regulations and
legislations that deal with different stages of the production and use of chemicals, the
scope of this chapter shall be confined to the Indian rules and regulations that deal with
the handling and management of chemicals and hazardous waste.
5.2 THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK ON CHEMICAL AND HAZARDOUS

WASTE IN INDIA
5.2.1 MANUFACTURE, STORAGE AND IMPORT OF HAZARDOUS

CHEMICAL RULES, 1989
The Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989 was one of
the first rules on hazardous chemicals to be formulated in India under the aegis of the
3 National Hazardous Waste Information System, Available at: http: //nhwis.nic.in/auth/industry/
home.aspx (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
4 NHWIS - an Integrated Web Based Solution, Available at: http: //nhwis.nic.in/spages/aboutus.aspx
5 Waste Management, Available at: http: //moef.gov.in/environment/waste-management/. (Last accessed
180
NLSIU
Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. These Rules have been subsequently amended in
1994 and 2000 and as the title suggests regulate the manufacture, storage and import of
hazardous chemicals in India.6 The Rules apply to hazardous chemicals defined under
Section 2(e) of the Rules which includes any chemical which satisfies any of the criteria
laid down in the Schedules appended to the Rules. It includes chemicals which fulfill the
norms stipulated in Part I of Schedule I or listed in Column 2 of Part II of the Schedule;
any chemical listed in Column 2 of Schedule II; and any chemical listed in Column 2 of
Schedule III of the Rules.
Classification of Hazardous Chemicals
Part I of Schedule I categorizes chemicals under the heads of toxic chemicals, flammable
chemicals and explosives and lays down the criteria, physical or chemical properties that
a chemical must exhibit to be categorized under any one of the three heads. Toxic chemicals
are further subdivided under extremely toxic, highly toxic and toxic. Flammable chemicals
are categorized as flammable gases and flammable liquids and flammable liquids are
further classified as extremely flammable, very highly flammable, highly flammable and
flammable liquids. Part II of Schedule I enlists 684 hazardous and toxic chemicals. Thus,
as far as Schedule I of the Rules are concerned, a chemical would be considered ‘hazardous’
if it either matches the criteria laid down under Part I or is enlisted under Part II of the
Schedule.
Schedule 2 enlists 30 chemicals with two sets of threshold quantities for the applicability
of different Rules that relate to isolated storage at installations or group of installations
belonging to the same occupier where the distance between installation is not sufficient
to avoid, in foreseeable circumstances, any aggravation of major accident hazards.
Similarly, Schedule 3 enlists 179 chemicals in Part I and 6 categories of chemicals under
Part II clubbed under two groups of ‘toxic substances’, and three groups of ‘highly reactive
substances, explosive substances and flammable substances’ respectively with threshold
and quantity earmarked for the applicability of different rules. When any isolated storage
6 The principal rules were published in the Gazette of India vide number S.O. 966(e), dated 27.11.1989
and subsequently amended vide: s.o.115 (e), dated 05.02.1990; GSR 584, dated 09.09.1990; S.O.2882,
dated 03.10.1994; and S.O. 57(e), dated 19.01.2000.
181
NLSIU
and industrial activity of any occupier handles hazardous chemicals equal to or in excess
of the threshold quantity7 specified in schedule 2 and 3 respectively, they are considered
major accident hazards.8
Sites where hazardous chemicals are dealt with: Important terms and definitions
Most activities that involve hazardous chemicals are carried out in certain locations and
hence defining the limits of such an area becomes pertinent for the far reaching implications
that it can have, especially with regard to the applicability of rules and regulations
formulated. Defining the locational boundaries of a facility handling hazardous chemicals
becomes important even when one views it from the perspective of safety and the need
for containment of emergency situations. The Manufacture, Storage and Import of
Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989 defines ‘site’ to mean any location where hazardous
chemicals are manufactured or processed, stored, handled, used, disposed of and includes
the whole of an area under the control of an occupier and includes pier, jetty or similar
structure whether floating or not.9
The 1989 Rules, also defines ‘índustrial activity’ to mean any operation or process carried
out in any of the industrial installations referred to in Schedule 410 which involves or is
7 As per Section 2(n) the threshold quantity means, -

(i)in the case of a hazardous chemical specified in column 2 of Schedule 2, the quantity of that chemical
specified in the corresponding entry in columns 3 and 4 ;
(ii) in the case of a hazardous chemical specified in column 2 of part I of Schedule 3, the quantity of that
chemical specified in the corresponding entry in columns 3 & 4 of that part;
(iii) in the case of substances of a class specified in column 2 of part II of Schedule 3, the total quantity of
all substances of that class specified in the corresponding entry in columns 3 and 4 of that part.
8 Rule 2(ja), Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989.
9 Ibid Rule 2(m).
10 Schedule 4 of the Rules enlists installations that are set up for different purposes such as installation for
the production, processing or treatment of organic or inorganic chemicals using for this purpose,
among others; Alkylation, amination by ammonolysis, carbonylation, condensation, dehydrogenation
etc., hydrogenation, Hydrolysis, oxidation etc; installation for distillation, refining or other processing
of petroleum or petroleum products, installations for the total or partial disposal of solid or liquid
substances by incineration or chemical decomposition, installations for production, processing, useor
treatment of energy gases, for example, LPG, LNG, SNG, installation for the dry distillation of coal or
lignite; installations for the production of metals or non-metals by a wet process or by means of
electrical energy.
182
NLSIU
likely to involve one or more hazardous chemicals and includes on-site storage or on-site
transport associated with that operation or process.11 As per the definition, industrial
activity also includes an isolated storage; or a pipeline.12 When hazardous chemicals are
kept in storages other than the storage associated with an installation on the same site
enlisted under Schedule 4 where that storage involves atleast quantities of that chemical
set out in Schedule 2, such storages are defined as isolated storages.13 ‘Pipeline’ has been
defined to mean a pipe (together with any apparatus and works associated) or system of
pipes (together with any apparatus and work associated) for the conveyance of a hazardous
chemical other than a flammable gas as set out in Column 2 of Part II of Schedule 3 at a
pressure of less than 8 bars absolute. Inter-state pipelines have also been included in the
definition of pipeline.14
Application of the Rules : Implementation Scheme of the Rules
The Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989 applies to
occupiers of different sites where industrial activity is carried out. However, it is
interesting to note that different rules apply for different industrial activities based upon
the hazardous chemicals they deal with and the quantity of these chemicals stipulated in
the Schedules appended to the Rules. Thus, the applicability of these Rules on industrial
activity and consequently on the occupiers of industrial activity depends on their type of
hazardous chemicals they deal with, their threshold quantity and other criteria and
particulars laid down in the Schedules.
Duty of Occupier of Industrial Activity and Isolated Storage
Rule 4 of the Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989
applies to any industrial activity in which a hazardous chemical is involved or may be
involved; and any isolated storage of a hazardous chemical listed in Schedule 2 in a
11 Supra note 8, Rule 2 (h)(i).

12 Ibid Rule 2 (h)(ii) and 2(h)(iii).
13 Ibid Rule 2 (i).
14 Ibid Rule 2 (k).
183
NLSIU
quantity equal to or more than the threshold quantity specified in Column 3.15 An occupier
of an industrial activity which contains hazardous chemicals that satisfies the requirements
laid down under the Rules is enjoined with certain responsibilities. The occupier must
provide evidence to show that he has identified major accident hazards and has taken
adequate steps to prevent such accidents and to limit their impact on people and the
environment. The Rules also makes the occupier responsible for the safety of persons
working on the site. The persons working on the site must be provided with adequate
information, training and equipment including antidotes to ensure their safety on site
from chemical hazards.16
Approval of concerned authority:
Some occupiers of industrial activity and isolated storage that fulfill the criteria laid
down under Rule 6; that is; deal with quantities of hazardous chemicals as stipulated
under Rule 6 must take prior approval from the concerned authority before industrial
activity is commenced.17
RULE 6 - CRITERIA FOR INDUSTRIAL AND ISOLATED STORAGE FOR

APPLICABILITY OF RULES 7-15
KIND OF ACTIVITY CRITERIA FOR APPLICABILITY
Industrial activity Quantity of hazardous chemical listed in Schedule

3 Column 2 which is equal to or more than the
quantity specified in the entry for that chemical in
Column 3 & 4.Illustration: If the industrial activity
involves the usage of Arsenic pentoxide, Arsenic
15 Ibid Rule 4.
16 Ibid Rule 4(2).
17 Ibid Rule 7.
184
NLSIU
(V) acids and salts (listed under Column 2 of

Schedule 3), it must use at least 500kg (listed under
Column 3) or more of the chemical for the
application of Rules 5, 7-9 and 13-15For the
applicability of Rules 10-12 quantity specified in the
entry Column 4 shall apply)Illustration: If the
industrial activity involves the usage of Methyl
isocynate (listed under Column 2 of Schedule 3), it
must use at least 150kg (listed under Column 4) or
more of the chemical for the application of Rules
10-12
Isolated storage Quantity of a hazardous chemical listed in Schedule

2 Column 2 which is equal to or more than the
quantity specified in the entry for that chemical in
Column 3 & 4. Illustration: If the isolated storage
involves the usage of Ammonia (listed under Column
2 of Schedule 2), it must use at least 60 tonnes (listed
under Column 3) or more of the chemical for the
application of Rules 5, 7-9 and 13-15For the
applicability of Rules 10-12 quantity specified in the
entry Column 4 shall apply)Illustration: If the isolated
storage involves the usage of Ammonia (listed under
Column 2 of Schedule 2), it must use at least 600
tonnes (listed under Column 4) or more of the
chemical for the application of Rules 10-12.
Before undertaking any industrial activity, the sites have to be notified before the authority
concerned and the occupier has to submit a written report before the authority with all
the particulars enlisted under Schedule 7 of the Rules. As per Rule 7, the particulars to
be included in the notification of a site include:
185
NLSIU
 The name and address of the employer making the notification.
 The details of the site where the notifiable industrial activity will be carried on,
including full postal address, area of the site covered by the notification and of any
adjacent site; map of the site and its surrounding area to a scale large enough to show any
features that may be significant in the assessment of the hazard or risk associated with
the site; the location and quantities of all significant inventories of the hazardous
chemicals; description of the process or storage involving the hazardous chemicals; the
maximum number of persons likely to be present on site.
 Anticipated date of commencement of the industrial activity
 Name and maximum quantity of each dangerous substance which is likely to be

handled in the site
 Organizational diagram of the proposed industrial activity and the set up for
ensuring safety and health.
 Information on probable major accidents that may occur including conditions

and circumstances that could bring about an accident and the measures taken to
avert an accident.
 The arrangement for training of workers and equipment necessary to ensure their
safety.
If the industrial activity to be notified is a pipeline, similar information as indicated

above must be notified before the concerned authority besides full postal address of the
place from which the pipeline activity is controlled, addresses of the places where the
pipeline starts and finishes and a map showing the pipeline route drawn to a scale of not
less than 1:400000.The notification must also reflect the total length of the pipeline, its
diameter and normal operating pressure and the name and maximum quantity of each
hazardous chemical that it is likely to carry.18
18 Ibid Schedule 7.
186
NLSIU
The aforesaid information must be made available to the concerned authority three
months before the activity is commenced or before such shorter time as the concerned
authority may agree. If the occupier wishes to subsequently undertake any activity which
involves threshold quantity or more of an additional hazardous chemical then such activity
would be deemed to be a different activity and shall be notified separately by the occupier.19
A similar stipulation has been imposed on the occupier under Rule 8 which requires the
occupier to furnish a further report to the Authority, if any change is made to the site
including an increase or decrease in the maximum threshold quantity of a hazardous
chemical which is or is liable to be at the site or in the pipeline or at the time of cessation
of the activity.
The concerned authority shall take a maximum period of 60 days to look into the written
report submitted by the occupier. If the authority is of the opinion that contravention of
the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 or the Rules has taken place, it will serve an
improvement notice on the occupier under Rule 19. On receipt of the improvement
notice, the occupier has to remedy the contravention within a period of 45 days20 and the
notice served shall clearly specify the measures to be taken by the occupier in remedying
the contraventions under the Rules and Act.21
Submission of Safety Reports and Safety Audit Reports by Occupier
Rules 10-12 of the Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules,
1989 that apply to occupiers of industrial activities and isolated storages handling
hazardous chemicals that fulfil the threshold quantities enlisted under Column 4 of
Schedules 2 and 3 of the Rules respectively, vest certain responsibilities on them. Owing
to the magnitude of hazardous chemicals that these sites handle, the Rules require the
Occupiers to fulfil certain obligations over and above the need for approval and notification
to the concerned authority before an industrial activity is undertaken. The Rules require
the Occupiers to prepare and submit a safety report and a safety Audit report to the
concerned Authority.
19 Ibid Rule 7(1).

20 Ibid Rule 19(1).
21 Ibid Rule 19(2).
187
NLSIU
No occupier of an industrial activity and isolated storage with hazardous chemicals listed
under Schedule 2 and 3 that fulfills the threshold quantity under Column 4 of the
Schedules shall undertake any industrial activity, unless a safety report on that industrial
activity with the information specified in Schedule 8 has been prepared and a soft copy
of the same has been sent to the concerned authority at least ninety days before
commencing that activity.22 Along with a safety report, the Manufacture, Storage and
Import of Hazardous Chemicals (Amendment) Rules, 1994, has introduced the need for
filing a safety audit report on the basis of an independent safety audit carried out by an
expert, not associated with the industrial activities.23 which should be forwarded by the
occupier along with the comments of the auditor to the concerned Authority within 30
days after the completion of such Audit.24 The safety audit report has to be updated by
the occupier once a year by getting a fresh audit conducted by an independent auditor
which also has to be submitted to the concerned Authority within 30 days to the concerned
Authority along with the comments of the auditor.25 After perusing the safety audit reports,
if the concerned Authority so deems fit, he may issue an improvement notice to the
occupier within within 45 days of the submission of the said report.26
INFORMATION TO BE FURNISHED IN A SAFETY REPORT

SUBMITTED BY AN OCCUPIER BEFORE THE CONCERNED
AUTHORITY
1. The name and address of the person furnishing the information.

2. Description of the industrial activity, namely-
(a) site,
(b) construction design,
(c) protection zones explosion protection, separation distances,
(d) accessibility of plant,
22 Ibid Rule 10(1).

23 Ibid Rule 10(4).
24 Ibid Rule 10(5).
25 Ibid Rule 10(6).
26 Ibid Rule 10(7).
188
NLSIU
(e) maximum number of persons working on the site and particularly of those
persons exposed to the hazard.
3. Description of the processes, namely -
(a) technical purpose of the industrial activity,
(b) basic principles of the technological process,
(c) process and safety -related data for the individual process stages,
(d) process description,
(e) Safety-related types of utilities.
4. Description of the hazardous chemicals, namely -
(a) chemicals (quantities, substance data, safety-related data, toxicological data
and threshold values),
(b) the form in which the chemical may occur on or into which they may be
transformed in the event of abnormal conditions,
(c) the degree of purity of the hazardous chemical.
5. Information on the preliminary hazard analysis, namely-
(a) types of accident
(b) system elements or events that can lead to a major accident,
(c) hazards,
(d) safety-relevant components.
6. Description of safety -relevant units, among others;
(a) special design criteria,
(b) controls and alarms,
(c) special relief systems,
(d) quick-acting valves,
(e) collecting tanks/dump tank,
189
NLSIU
(f) sprinkler system,

(g) fire fighting etc.
7. Information on the hazards assessment, namely-
(a) identification of hazards ,
(b) the cause of major accidents,
(c) assessment of hazards according to their occurrence frequency,
(d) assessment of accident consequences,
(e) safety systems, (f) known accident history.
8. Description of information or organizational systems used to carry on the industrial
activity safety, namely-
(a) maintenance and inspection schedules,
(b) guidelines for the training of personnel,
(c) allocation and delegation of responsibility for plant safety,(d) implementation
of safety procedure
9. Information on assessment of the consequences of major accidents, namely
(a) assessment of the possible release of hazardous chemicals or of energy,
(b) possible dispersion of released chemical,
(c) assessment of the effects of the releases (size of the affected area, health
effects, property damage)
10. Information on the mitigation of major accidents, namely -
(a) fire brigade,
(b) alarm systems,
(c) emergency plan containing system of organisation used to fight the emergency,
the alarm and the communication rules guidelines for fighting the emergency,
information about hazardous chemicals, examples of possible accident
sequences,
190
NLSIU
(d) coordination with the District Emergency authority and its offsite emergency
plan,
(e) notification of the nature and scope of the hazard in the event of an accident,
(f) antidotes in the event of a release of a hazardous chemical.
Once a safety audit report has been submitted to the concerned Authority by an occupier,
no modification to the industrial activity must be made which materially affects the
particulars of the report, unless the concerned Authority has been apprised of the same
and a report detailing the modifications carried out on the industrial activity has been
sent to the Authority 90 days prior to the making of those modifications.27 The
Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989 have taken into
account the technical advancement that takes place over the years in all fields, especially
in the field of science and has made an occupier responsible for keeping up with the
safety requirements and hazards associated with an industrial activity by taking into
account the new technical knowledge that can affect them. This must be done within
three years of the submission of the first safety report.28
Preparation of On-site Emergency Plan by the Occupier
The occupier of an Industrial Activity and Isolated Storage dealing with hazardous
chemicals that are equal to or more than the threshold quantities enlisted under Column
3 of Schedules 2 and 3 of the Rules respectively are required to prepare an on-site
emergency plan for the sites they handle. The responsibility of the occupier does not end
merely with the preparation of the on-site emergency plan that details how the major
accidents shall be dealt with, but it must be updated at regular intervals. The plan must
include the name of the person responsible for on-site safety and the names of persons
authorized to take action in accordance with the plan in case of any emergency.29 While
preparing and keeping the emergency plan up to date the occupier shall take into account
any modifications made in the industrial activity that needs to be taken note of. The
27 Ibid Rule 11(1).

28 Ibid Rule 11(2).
29 Ibid Rule 13(1).
191
NLSIU
occupier is also responsible for ensuring that all persons working on the site who may be
affected if a chemical hazard or accident takes place is apprised of the relevant provisions
of the emergency plan.30
DETAILS TO BE FURNISHED IN ON-SITE EMERGENCY PLAN BY THE

OCCUPIER
1. Name and address of the person furnishing the information.

2. Key personnel of the organization and responsibilities assigned to them in case of
an emergency
3. Outside organization if involved in assisting during onsite emergency:
(a) Type of accidents
(b) Responsibility assigned
4. Details of liaison arrangements between the organizations.
5. Information on the preliminary hazard analysis:
(a) Type of accidents
(b) System elements or events that can lead to a major accident
(c) Hazards
(d) Safety relevant components
6. Details about the site:
(a) Location of dangerous substances
(b) Seat of key personnel
(c) Emergency control room
7. Description of hazardous chemicals at plant site:
(a) Chemicals (Quantities and toxicological data)
30. Ibid Rule 13(2).
192
NLSIU
(b) Transformation if any, which could occur.

(c) Purity of hazardous chemicals.
8. Likely dangers to the plant.
9. Enumerate effects of:
(i) Stress and strain caused during normal operation:
(ii) Fire and explosion inside the plant and effect if any, of fire and explosion outside.
10. Details regarding:
(i) Warning, alarm and safety and security systems.
(ii) Alarm and hazard control plans in line with disaster control and hazard
controlplanning, ensuring the necessary technical and organizational
precautions;
(iii) Reliable measuring instruments, control units and servicing of such
equipment.
(iv) Precautions in designing of the foundation and load bearing parts of the
building.
(v) Continuous surveillance of operations.
(vi) Maintenance and repair work according to the generally recognized rules of
good engineering practices.
11. Details of communication facilities available during emergency and those required
for an off-site emergency.
12. Details of fire fighting and other facilities available and those required for an
off-site Emergency.
13. Details of first aid and hospital services available and its adequacy.
In addition to the persons on site, the occupier of an industrial activity handling hazardous
chemicals has been made responsible for the safety of persons outside the site. The
occupier has the duty of informing persons outside the site who are likely to be in an
area, which may be affected by a major accident, about the nature of the major accident
193
NLSIU
hazard, the safety measures to be adopted and the Do’s and Don’t which should be
adopted in the event of a major accident.31 Besides the Occupier, the Rules require the
Authorities identified under the Rules to develop off-site emergency plans to deal with
emergencies that may arise if a possible major accidents takes place on the site. In preparing
the off-site emergency plan the Authority must consult the occupier and such other
persons as it may deem necessary. Apart from information on the industrial activity, the
Authority may seek information on the nature, extent and likely effects off-site of possible
major accidents from the occupier.32 In addition to the particulars and information
contained in the on-site emergency plan prepared by the occupier, the off-site emergency
plan prepared by the Authority must contain details on and make provisions for facilities
and transport routes, contact for further advice e.g. meteorological information, transport,
temporary food and accommodation, water and agricultural authorities, special equipment
including fire fighting materials, damage control and repair items, details of emergency
response procedure, evacuation arrangements, and arrangements for dealing with the
press and other media interests.33A mock drill of the on-site emergency plan must be
conducted every 6 months and a rehearsal of the off-site emergency plan must be
conducted once a year by the Occupier and the concerned Authority respectively.34
Preparation of Safety Data Sheet
Taking cognizance of the harm that a hazardous chemical if not handled carefully can
result in, the Rules require the occupiers of industrial activities to keep information
about the chemicals ready in the form of a safety data sheet. All occupiers of industrial
activities that deal with hazardous chemicals that satisfy any of the criteria laid down in
part I of Schedule 1 or listed in Column 2 of Part II of Schedule 1, that is industrial
activities dealing with toxic chemicals, flammable chemicals, explosives and hazardous
chemicals are required to prepare a safety data sheet. Information on the chemicals must
be recorded accurately and must reflect the scientific evidence used in making the hazard
31 Ibid Rule 15.

32 Ibid Rule 14.
33 Ibid Schedule 12.
34 Ibid Rules 13 & 14.
194
NLSIU
determination.35 The safety data sheet should reflect the chemical identity of the
hazardous chemical such as name, chemical classification, hazardous ingredients etc; the
physical and chemical properties such as physical state, appearance, melting point, boiling
point etc; fire and explosion hazard data such as flammability, auto ignition temperature
etc; reactivity data such as chemical stability, incompatibility with other chemical etc.;
health hazard data which reflects the routes of entry into the human body, effects of
exposure, permissible limits of exposure, emergency treatment etc. The safety data must
also contain information about the contact details of the manufacturer or supplier. The
safety data sheet must be made available on request for reference. 36
Apart from the safety data sheet that is to be made available on request, the occupier
must ensure that every container of a hazardous chemical is clearly labelled or marked to
identify -
(a) the contents of the container ;

(b) the name and address of the manufacturer or importer of the hazardous
chemical;
(c) the physical, chemical and toxicological data.37
Import of Hazardous Chemicals
The Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemicals Rules, 1989 was one of
the first rules on chemical management that prescribed certain requirements that an
importer of toxic chemicals, flammable chemicals, explosives and hazardous chemicals
had to comply. These Rules primarily aim to ensure that no mishap occurs within the
country that are triggered by the imported hazardous chemicals and no harm is caused to
the environment because of such imports. In this regard the Rules have laid down certain
duties and obligations that have to be fulfilled by the importer and the concerned Authority
of the state of import.
35 Ibid Rule 17.

36 Ibid Schedule 9.
37 Ibid Rule 17(4).
195
NLSIU
Duties of Importer
The primary duty enunciated under the Rules for any importer of hazardous chemicals in
India is to provide adequate information about the chemicals to the designated authorities
identified under the Rules before the same is imported into India. Any person importing
hazardous chemicals into the country has to provide the concerned Authority the following
information:
1) the name and address of the person receiving the consignment in India;
2) the port of entry in India;
3) mode of transport from the exporting country to India;
4) the quantity of chemical (s) being imported; and
5) complete product safety information.
The aforementioned list of information must be provided to the Authority before 30

days or as reasonably possible but not later than the date of import. 38 Records of hazardous
chemicals being imported have to be maintained by the importer in the manner prescribed
under Schedule 10 and shall be open for inspection by the concerned authority at the
State or the Ministry of Environment and Forests or any officer appointed by them in
this behalf.39
FORMAT FOR MAINTAINING RECORDS OF HAZARDOUS

CHEMICALSIMPORTED
1. Name and address of the Importer:

2. Date and reference number of issuance of permission to import hazardous
Chemicals:
38 Ibid Rule 18(2).

39 Ibid Rule 18(5).
196
NLSIU
3. Description of hazardous chemicals:

(a) Physical form:
(b) Chemical form:
(c) Total volume and weight (in kilogram’s/Tones)
4. Description of purpose of Import:
5. Description of storage of hazardous chemicals:

(a) Date:
(b) Method of storage
Duties of Authorities
The Authorities have been entrusted with the responsibility to ensure that the chemicals
imported do not cause major accidents and if the Authority of the concerned state where
the imported hazardous chemical will be kept is satisfied that the chemical may cause
major accidents, it may direct the importer to take safety measures to avert any such
major accident.40 The concerned Authority at the State must also simultaneously intimate
the Port authorities at the port of entry to safely handle, and store hazardous chemicals
at the time when the consignment is off-loaded.41 The concerned Authority of the State
has been provided wide powers under the Rules including the right to stop the import of
chemicals if it is of the opinion that the chemical should not be imported into the country
based on safety and environmental considerations.42
Monitoring Mechanism under the Rules
Different authorities have been identified under the Rules to monitor the implementation
of the Rules, notification of hazardous chemicals, issuance of orders and directions with
respect to chemical management, handling and import of hazardous chemicals,
preparation of off-site emergency plans and the enforcement of directions and procedures
40 Ibid Rule 18(3).

41 Ibid Rule 18(4).
42 Ibid Rule 18(3a).
197
NLSIU
for different industrial establishments and storages. Some of the duties entrusted on the
authorities by the Rules include:
 Analysis and Reporting on Major Accidents: Where a major accident occurs in

any site or pipeline, the occupier of the concerned authority has to report about
the accident to the Concerned Authority and the Authority must report the
same within 90 days to the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change.43
 Preparation and keeping up to date off-site emergency plan.44
 Serving of improvement notice to occupier of any site to remedy any

contravention made to the Rules.45
The following table enlists the different Authorities identified under the Rules and their
respective responsibilities. A perusal of the list makes it evident that the handling, storage,
import of chemicals and the prevention and containment of any accident that results
from chemicals requires a multi-pronged and multi-sectoral approach.
SI.NO AUTHORITIES DUTIES AND CORRESPONDING RULE

1. Ministry of Notification of hazardous chemicals under the
Environment,Forests Rules
and Climate Change
under Environment
(Protection) Act,
1986.
43 Ibid Rule 5.
44 Ibid Rule 14.
45 Ibid Rule 19.
198
NLSIU
2. Chief Controller of Import of hazardous chemicals

Imports &Exports
under Import &
Exports (Control)
Act, 1947
3. Central Pollution (1) Enforcement of directions and proceduresin
Control Boardor State respect of isolated storage of hazardous
Pollution Control chemicals, regarding-
Board or any assigned
(i) Notification of major accidents
Committee
underEnvironment (ii) Notification of sites
(Protection) Act,1986 (iii) Safety reports in respect of isolated storages
as the case may be (iv) Preparation of on-site emergency plans
(2) Import of hazardous Chemicals and

enforcement of directions and procedures
onimport of hazardous chemicals.
4. Chief Inspector of Enforcement of directions and procedures inrespect

Factoriesappointed of industrial installations and isolatedstorages
under the covered under the Factories Act, 1948,dealing with
FactoriesAct, 1948 hazardous chemicals and pipelinesincluding inter-
state pipelines regarding-

(ii) Notification of sites
(iii) Safety reports.
(iv) Preparation of on-site emergency
plans.Preparation of off-site emergency plans
inconsultation with District Collector or
DistrictEmergency Authority
199
NLSIU
5. Chief Inspector of Same as above vis-a-vis industrial installations and

Dock Safetyappointed isolated storages dealing with hazardous chemicals
under the DockWorkers and pipelines inside a port covered under theDock
(Safety, Health Workers (Safety, Health and Welfare)Act, 1986.
andWelfare) Act, 1986
6. Chief Inspector of Same as above vis-a vis mines

Minesappointed under
the Mines Act,1952
7. Atomic Energy Enforcement of directions and procedures regarding:

RegulatoryBoard
appointed under
theAtomic Energy Act, (ii) Approval and Notification of Sites
1972 (iii) Safety report and safety audit
(iv) Acceptance of On-site Emergency plans
(v) Assisting the District Collector in the
preparation of Off-Site emergency plans
8. Chief Controller of Enforcement of directions and procedures asper the

Explosivesappointed provisions of
under the
(i) The Explosives Act, 1884 and Rules, namely;
IndianExplosive Act
and Rules, 1983 (a) The Gas Cylinders Rules, 1981;
(b) The Static and Mobile Pressure Vessel
(Unified) Rules, 1981;
(c) The Explosive Rules, 1984
(ii) The Petroleum Act, 1934 and Rules, namely;
(a) The Petroleum Rules, 1976;
(b) The Calcium Carbide Rules, 1987and in
respect of industrial installation andisolated
storages dealing with hazardouschemicals and
200
NLSIU
pipelines including inter-state pipelines

regarding
(c) Notification of major accident
(d) Approval and notification of sites
(e) Safety report and safety audit reports
(f) Acceptance of On-site Emergency plans
(g) Assisting the District Collector in the
preparation of Off-Site emergency plans
9. District Collector or Preparation of off-site emergency plans
District Emergency
Authority designated
by the State
Government
10. Centre for Enforcement of directions and procedures

Environment and inrespect of laboratories, industrial
Explosive Safety, establishmentand isolated storages dealing with
Defence Research & hazardouschemicals in the Ministry of Defence
Development
Organisation (DRDO),
Ministry of Defence
(MoD)
5.2.2 OZONE DEPLETING SUBSTANCES (REGULATION AND

CONTROL) RULES, 2000 AS AMENDED UPTO 2014
Ozone Depleting Substances include Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs)

Hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) and Hydrobromofluorocarbons (HBFCs) which are
used in India in various industries including air conditioning, refrigeration, foams, aerosol,
fire fighting equipment, sterilants and solvents. As the name suggests Ozone Depleting
Substances are chemicals that destroy the earth’s protective ozone layer that acts as a
201
NLSIU
shield to filter the earth from the harmful ultraviolet radiation from the sun. The history
of India’s involvement in addressing the ill effects caused by the use of ozone depleting
substances dates back to the years 1991 when India became a party to the Vienna
Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer on 18th March and the year 1992
when it acceded to the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer
on 19th June, 1992.46 India has also ratified all the amendments to the Montreal Protocol
including London amendment in 1992, Copenhagen and Beijing amendments in 2003.
A Country Programme for India under the Montreal Protocol along with a National Strategy
and Action Plan for controlling the use of Ozone Depleting Substances and phasing out
the use of such substances was finalized with the assistance of United Nations
Development Programme (UNDP), The Energy and Resources Institute (TERI) and
representatives of various ministries, industries and scientific institutions which was
approved in 1993. Considerable progress was made and 46,582 Ozone Depleting Potential
(ODP) tonnes was phased out until 2010 when the accelerated Phase-out Management
Plans (HPMP) were introduced under the Montreal Protocol.47
India is classified as a Party operating under Paragraph 1, Article 5 of the Montreal

Protocol and is qualified to receive technical and financial assistance from the Multilateral
Fund (MLF), established as the financial mechanism of the Montreal Protocol and is
committed to phase-out Ozone Depleting Substances (ODSs) including
Hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) in 2030 in accordance with the accelerated phase
out schedule of the Montreal Protocol.48 Annex C Group I of the Montreal Protocol
classifies Hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) as controlled substances. These HCFCs
are subject to the adjusted control schedule for Article-5 countries. The countries that
46 The Montreal Protocol: India’s Success Story, Ozone Cell, Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change, 2018 at page15.
47 HCFC Phase-out Management Plan (HPMP Stage-I) for Compliance with the 2013 and 2015 Control
Targets for Consumption of Annex-C Group-I Substances, Ozone Cell, Ministry of Environment &
Forests, Government of India,United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) at page 7.
Available at: https: //www.undp.org/content/dam/india/docs/hpmp-productdocument.pdf (Last
48 HCFC Phase-out Management Plan Stage-II, Ozone Cell Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change, Government of India, March 2017 at page 1.
202
NLSIU
fall under Article 5 including India are expected to freeze the consumption of ODSs
at baseline levels from 2013 and reduction of 10% from baseline levels from 2015 and
subsequent reduction steps leading to 97.5% phase-out by 2030 and complete phase-out
by 2040.49
The calculated HCFC consumption baseline for India is 1,608.2 Ozone Depleting Potential
(ODP) tonnes, being the average of HCFC consumption for 2009 and 2010.50 While the
usage of CFCs and HCFCs in the country had reached a staggering amount, before the
phase out programmes had been initiated, the country was rather slow in adopting these
chemicals when compared to the developed countries where large scale usage of the
chemicals was prevalent since the 1930s. The first sector to use CFCs and HCFCs in
India was the Refrigeration and Air Conditioning sector which can be traced back to the
1960s and the chemicals required were primarily imported. The use of CFCs and HCFCs
in other industries such as foam manufacturing industry, aerosol industry etc., started
gaining ground in the 1980s. India is the second largest producer and consumer of ODS
after China, but owing to India’s obligations under the international conventions and the
national regulatory mechanism in place, India has already implemented HCFC Phase-out
Management Plan (HPMP) Stage-I to meet the freeze target of 2013 and 10 % phase-out
targets of HCFCs in 2015. As per the report released by the Ozone Cell, the production
and consumption of CFCs, CTC and halons as of 1st January, 2010 (except use of
pharmaceutical grade CFCs in manufacturing of Metered Dose Inhalers (MDIs) for Asthma
and Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Diseases (COPD) patients has been phased out.
The production and consumption of Methyl Chloroform and Methyl Bromide have also
been phased out.51 The country is presently implementing the HCFC Phase-out
Management Plan (HPMP) Stage-II for the period 2016 to 2023 with special focus on
the MSME sector in foam manufacturing and its successful implementation will phase
out 769.49 ODP tons of HCFCs.52
49 Supra note 47 at page 2.

203
NLSIU
HCFC PHASE-OUT LIMITS FOR INDIA53
Montreal Protocol Maximum Allowable Consumption Limit (ODP - Ozone

Consumption of Levels ofAnnex C Group Depleting Potential tons)
1 Substances
Baseline (2009-2010 average) 1608.20
2013- Freeze on baseline levels 1608.20
2015- 90% of the baseline 1447.38
2020- 65% of the baseline 1045.33
2025- 32.5% of the baseline 522.67
2030- 2.5% of the baseline 40.21
2040- No consumption 0
The Government of India has entrusted the work relating to ozone layer protection and
implementation of the Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer
to the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC). An Ozone
Cell has been set up by the MoEF&CC to act the National Ozone Unit (NOU) to assist
and effectively supervise the timely implementation of the Protocol and its ODS phaseout
program in India. An Empowered Steering Committee (ESC) has also been constituted
by the MoEF&CC which is supported by two Standing Committees, namely the
Technology and Finance Standing Committee (TFSC) and the Standing Committee on
Monitoring. The Executive Standing Committee, chaired by the Secretary of the
MoEF&CC oversees the implementation of the Montreal Protocol provisions. It also
reviews policies adopted in this sphere and monitors the implementation of projects/
plans. 54

54 Supra note 46 at page15.
204
NLSIU
Besides the setting of targets for the phase out of Ozone Depleting Substances and
meeting those targets, the other important contribution of the Montreal Protocol has
been the adoption of a National Strategy and Action Plan that has led to the enactment
of the Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Rules, which were notified
in 200055 under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and subsequently amended in
2001, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006 and 2007. The latest amendments to the Rules have been
made in 2014 to align them with the accelerated phase-out of HCFCs. Spread over 15
Rules and 12 Schedules, the Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control)
Rules, regulate the production, consumption, manufacture export and import of Ozone
Depleting Substances. The Rules define “ozone depleting substance” to mean the
substances specified in column (2) of Schedule I, whether existing by itself or in a mixture.
The definition however excludes any such substance or mixture (blend) which is in a
manufactured product other than a container used for the transportation or storage of
such substance.56 Schedule I lists 96 such substances. The Schedule provides the names
of the chemicals, their chemical composition along with their Ozone Depleting Potential.
All the chemicals are classified under nine different groups.
Regulation of production and consumption of ozone depleting substances:
The Rules regulate the production and consumption of HCFCs as per the accelerated
phase-out schedule for HCFCs. Under the Rules, production of any ozone depleting
substance after the date specified in column (5) of Schedule V is prohibited unless the
person concerned is registered with the authorities identified under the Act.57 Thus, any
producer of ODSs must have registered with an officer not below the rank of a Deputy
Secretary in the Ministry of Environment, Forests and Climate Change within three
months of the commencement of these Rules in order to continue production of ODSs.58
Interestingly, the Rules provide meanings for the terms ‘production’ and ‘consumption’
with reference to ozone depleting substances that differ from their literal meanings to
55 Vide Notification S.O. 670 (e) dated 17 July, 2000, Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government
of India.
56 Rule 2(1), Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000.
57 Ibid Rule 3(1).
58 Ibid Schedule V.
205
NLSIU
align with the objective of regulating and phasing out the use of ODSs. The term
“production” in relation to any ozone depleting substance has been defined to mean the
manufacture of an ozone depleting substance from any raw material or feedstock chemicals.
The definition has however excluded the manufacture of a substance that is used and
entirely consumed (except for trace quantity) in the manufacture of other chemicals; or
quantities that are incidentally produced while manufacturing other chemical substances
or quantities which are recycled or reused; or quantities destroyed by technologies as
specified by the Central Government.59 “Consumption” with respect to any ozone
depleting substance has been defined to mean the amount of that substance produced in
India in addition to the amount imported, less the amount exported.60 These definitions
are aligned with definitions of the terms under the Montreal Protocol.
Keeping with the need for phasing out of the production and use of CFCs, the Rules
prohibits the consumption of several ODSs in the manufacture of several products by
prescribing specific phase out dates. From the date of commencement of the Ozone
Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Amendment Rules, 2014, the production
and consumption of ozone depleting substances specified in Schedule I barring those
under Group VI have been prohibited for all applications. However, this prohibition
does not apply to substances which are for use as feedstock in the manufacture of other
chemicals, with negligible emissions.61 Feedstock refers to those ozone depleting
substances that are used as chemical building blocks or raw materials for other chemicals.
After the latest amendment to the Rules, production and consumption of substances
under Group VIII of Schedule I which includes the chemical substance Methyl Bromide
has been prohibited. After 2014 and till further amendments are made to the Rules,
Methyl Bromide may only be used in quarantine and pre-shipment applications.62
For some of the ozone depleting substances specific time limits have been prescribed
during which the production and consumption of the substances have to be regulated to
59 Ibid Rule 2(l).

60 Ibid Rule 2(d).
61 Ibid Rule 3(2).
62 Ibid Rule 3(2a).
206
NLSIU
match the percentages prescribed under the Rules. No person is permitted to produce
ozone depleting substances specified that fall under Group VI of Schedule I such as
HCFC-21 - Dichlorofluoromethane (CHFCl2) or HCFC-31 - Chlorofluoromethane
(CH2FCl) and other chemicals under the Group from the date of commencement of the
Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Amendment Rules, 2014 to the
1st January, 2040 in excess of the corresponding percentages of the baseline specified in
Schedule II. Similarly only such percentages of the chemicals can be consumed in India
that does not exceed the amount stipulated under Schedule II.63 The Ozone Cell of the
Ministry also reserves the right to issue orders regarding quotas that must be adhered to
with respect to domestic market quantities of different CFCs. Producers dealing with
Group VI substances are not to supply to the domestic market quantities in excess of the
quota orders issued by the Ozone Cell, to cater to the needs of the domestic market of
HCFC-22 for non-feedstock application. If there is a shortfall, the Central Government
may allow for the import of HCFC-22 within the consumption control quantity as per
the market requirements.64 This new monitoring and reporting system by introducing the
system of quotas for all feedstock applications including use of Carbontetrachloride
have been introduced by the 2014 Amendment to the Rules in order to comply with
phase-out targets of the production and consumption of Group VI substances (HCFCs).
For instance, use of CFCs for the manufacture of Aerosol products or pressurized
dispensers (excluding metered dose inhalers for medicinal purposes), use of CFCs for
the manufacture of foam products including foam part of Domestic Refrigerator and for
the manufacture of Polyol for foam products was prohibited beyond 1.1.2003. Similarly,
the use of methyl bromide except for pre-shipment and quarantine purposes was
permitted only up till 1.1.2015.65 Phase out date for the use of ozone depleting substances
in servicing of refrigeration and air-conditioning equipment or products and servicing of
fire extinguishers and fire extinguishing systems has been set at 1.1.2040. To ensure that
industries and persons engaged in industrial activities that use ODSs do not go out of
business, the Montreal Protocol as implemented by the Rules, makes provisions for
63 Ibid Rule 3(2b).

64 Ibid Rule 3(2c).
65 Ibid Schedule IV.
207
NLSIU
financial assistance to persons and enterprises for switching over to non ozone depleting
substance technology or to establish or to expand new capacity with non ozone depleting
technology and the phase out dates prescribed under the Rules are the dates by which
the conversion must be completed.66 Since Hydrochlorofluorocarbons (HCFCs) are
chemicals that have a low Ozone Depleting Potential and are also used in the manufacture
of substances as interim substitutes to replace CFCs, their use have been allowed upto
1.1.2030 in accordance with the Montreal Protocol accelerated phase-out schedule.67
Export and Import of Ozone Depleting Substances
The Rules have enlisted countries that are party to the Montreal Protocol of 1987 under
Schedule VI. Acknowledging the importance of regulating the use and consumption of
ozone depleting substances on an international scale to thwart their ill effects on the
environment, the Rules prohibit the import or export of any ozone depleting substance
from any country not specified in Schedule VI after the commencement of these rules.68
The Rules have adhered to the Harmonized classification of commodity codes, consistent
with international system to regulate import and exports. Export or import of products
made with or containing Ozone Depleting Substances and Ozone Depleting Substances
including blends and mixtures of such substances from a country that is a party to the
Montreal Protocol would require a licence issued by the authority identified under Schedule
V - that is the Director General of Foreign Trade.69 The licensing system was introduced
in the country in 1996 based on the recommendation of the Meeting of the Parties
(MOP) at Vienna in 1995. All imports require licences issued by the Directorate General
of Foreign Trade (DGFT), Ministry of Commerce and Industry, Government of India,
based upon the recommendations of the Ozone Cell, MoEF&CC. However, the import
and export of ozone depleting substances is subject to certain restrictions, some of which
have been introduced by the Amendment Rules of 2014.
66 Ibid Schedule IV.

68 Rule 4, Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000.
69 Ibid Rule 5(1).
208
NLSIU
 The 2014 Rules have placed a bar on the issuance of import and export licence
for ozone depleting substances specified under Group I, Group II, Group III,
Group IV and blends containing ozone depleting substances including Group
VI substances enlisted under Schedule I from the date of commencement of
the Amendment Rules, 2014. This ban however does not apply to ozone
depleting substances that have been recovered, recycled and reclaimed or used
for destruction or for feedstock applications or have been certified by an essential
use panel as essential use nominations, if any.70
 Restrictions have also been placed for the export of HCFC22 in Group VI for
which export licences shall be issued from the commencement of the Ozone
Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Amendment Rules, 2014 until
the 1st January, 2040, to export only such quantity which is the difference
between the production and domestic supply volumes.71
 Aircraft, mobile or automobile, boat, train and truck air conditioning units
(whether incorporated in vehicle or not), refrigerators, freezers, dehumidifiers,
water coolers, ice machines, air conditioning and heat pump units, compressors,
aerosol products, expect medical aerosols, portable fire extinguishers/ system
cylinder enlisted under Schedule VII of the Rules that contain ozone depleting
substances can be imported provided an import licence is obtained from the
Director General of Foreign Trade within six months from the date of
notification of the latest amended rules.72
 All exporters of products mentioned aforementioned must affix a label

specifying whether or not the product has been made with or contains ODSs.73
 Import of air-conditioning and refrigeration equipment and other products

containing Group VI substances have been prohibited from the 1st July, 2015.74
70 Ibid Rule 5(2).

71 Ibid Rule 5(2).
72 Ibid Rule 10(1).
73 Ibid Rule 10(2).
74 Ibid Rule 10(1a).
209
NLSIU
Sale and Purchase and Use of Ozone Depleting Substances
The Rules also regulate the sale and purchase of Ozone Depleting Substances. For any
person to sell any ozone depleting substance registration with the concerned authority is
compulsory. As per the latest amendment in 2014, all traders/dealers/ wholesaler/sellers
of ozone depleting substances, must get themselves registered with an officer not below
the rank of Deputy Secretary in the Ministry of Environment and Forests. The last date
of registration is also prescribed under the Rules and only for substances in Group VI
time up to 31st December, 2039 has been allowed for registration.75
Before any ozone depleting substances that are used for the manufacture of other
substances enlisted under Schedule IV such as Aerosol products or pressurised dispensers,
foam products including foam part of Domestic Refrigerator, Fire Extinguishers or Fire
Extinguishing Systems are purchased from a person dealing with the different ODSs
used for making such substances, the person purchasing ODS must give a declaration to
the seller giving the details of the end use to which the ODS would be put within the
period stipulated under Schedule V.76 The declaration must clearly reflect inter alia the
name of the ODS, the purpose for which it is being purchased (eg. Manufacture of
aerosols, Foam products, Refrigerations & Air Conditioning products, metered dose
inhalers for medicinal purposes etc,) and the quantity of the ODS being purchased77
The Rules also prohibit engagement in any activity that deals with the manufacture of
products with the use of ODS till the persons/ enterprises are registered with the concerned
authorities identified under the Rules. Any person or enterprise engaged in the manufacture
of products that use ODS whose capital investment is less than Rs. 1 crore must have
registered with Officer-in-charge of the office Small Industries Services Institute in
respective jurisdiction under Small Industries Development Organisation under the
Ministry of Small Scale, Agro and Rural Industries within one year of the commencement
of the Rules and any enterprise whose capital investment was more than Rs.1 crore,
75 Ibid Rule 6 and Schedule V.

76 Ibid Rule 7 and schedule V.
77 Ibid Schedule XII.
210
NLSIU
must have registered with an officer not below the rank of a Deputy Secretary in the
Ministry of Environment and Forests. All products produced with the use of ODS must
be labeled to indicate the ozone depleting substances they contain.78
To be in compliance with the HCFC Phase-out Management Plans, adopted by the country,
individuals who have received technical and financial assistance from the Multilateral
Fund in accordance with the Montreal Protocol are expected to not engage in any activity
that involves the use of ODSs after the phase out periods or after the submission of
completion report to change from ozone depleting substance technology to non ozone
depleting substance technology. 79 Besides the above restrictions, the Rules also
prohibits any new investment in any manufacturing facility for production of any ozone
depleting substance after the phase out dates.80
Monitoring and Reporting
The Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000 prescribe
extensive monitoring and reporting mechanisms for persons producing, importing,
exporting or selling ODS or stocking or purchasing ODSs for manufacture of other
products, or someone who has received technical or financial assistance from any
international organization. All such persons are expected to maintain records and file
reports as stipulated under Schedule X with the designated authority under the Ministry
of Environment, Forest and Climate Change.81
In Indian Council for Enviro-Legal Action (ICELA) v. MoEF & Ors.82 a case was brought
before the Principal Bench of the National Green Tribunal directing its attention to the
ill effects of HFC-23 which was being produced as a by-product by companies
manufacturing HCFC-22 and that it had serious climatic impacts, particularly, air pollution.
Five companies producing HCFC-22 in their refrigerant production units were impleaded

80 Ibid Rule 9.
81 Ibid Rule 14.
82 Original Application No. 170 of 2014 decided on 10 December, 2015.
211
NLSIU
as respondents in this case. The petitioner, a registered voluntary organisation working

in protection of environment, rivers and lakes had prayed before the National Green
Tribunal to direct companies producing HCFC22 to immediately stop venting of HFC-
23 and incinerate/destroy the gas under the supervision of the Ministry of Environment,
Forest and Climate Change, the Central Pollution Control Board and independent experts/
body as deemed fit and proper by the NGT and to direct the Ministry and the Central
Pollution Control Board to be directed to inspect the companies manufacturing HCFC-
22 and thereby producing HFC-23 by product and file a status report of production,
storing/ venting.
Concerned with the ill-effects of the emission of HFC-23 which being a greenhouse gas
has a global warming potential 14,800 times more than carbon dioxide, with a great
ozone depletion potential, the petitioner had filed this case. The National Green Tribunal
in its decision acknowledged the fact that this matter was being internationally governed
by the UNFCC with reference to the Montreal and Kyoto Protocol and the Ministry of
Environment, Forest and Climate Change was executing the obligations of the country
under the Protocols by implementing the phase out targets for the different ODSs. HFC
23 forms a part of the basket of greenhouse gases that adversely affects the ozone layer
and contributes to global warming. The NGT also took note of the fact that there is no
domestic law in place to regulate the HFC-23 in the country, even though the country
plans to phase out the use of HCFC-22 by 2030 under the HCFC Phase-out Management
Plans. The NGT noted that although the regulation of HFC 23 was a matter of global
policy and directions from the international conventions was pertinent to take action in
this field till legislation was enacted in the country, the ill effects of the gas is indisputable.
However, since this concern is a part of the policy of the Indian Government at the
global level and poses concerns that transcend environmental considerations, the NGT
was of the opinion that it was necessary to create some regulatory regime and issue some
guidelines to fill the legislative gap.
The NGT directed the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change and the
Central Pollution Control Board along with other concerned Ministries or expert bodies
to carry out a study of all industrial units manufacturing HCFC-22 that leads to the
generation of the by-product HFC-23 and create a comprehensive database. The NGT
212
NLSIU
further directed that the study should reflect the mechanism of storage, handling
incinerators and emission standards of HFC-23 and must examine the impact of the gas
as a pollutant and the extent to which it is affecting global warming. The bodies were
also directed to issue appropriate interim and long term measures under Section 3 of the
Environment Protection Act of 1986.
5.2.3 HAZARDOUS AND OTHER WASTES (MANAGEMENT AND

TRANSBOUNDARY MOVEMENT) RULES, 2016 AS AMENDED UPTO
2019
In order to regulate the hazardous wastes generated, the Hazardous Wastes (Management
and handling) Rules, 1989 were notified by the Central Government. The Rules of 1989
was enacted to ensure safe handling and management of hazardous wastes in an
environmentally benign manner. However, these Rules were repealed and a new set of
Rules came into place. The new rules focussed on hazardous waste and their transboundary
movement. The Rules titled Hazardous Wastes (Management, Handling and
Transboundary Movement) Rules, 200883, were more specifically designed to align it
with the objectives enshrined in the Basel Convention on Control of Transboundary
Movements of Hazardous Wastes and its disposal84. Thereafter, the Central Government
framed the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement)
Rules of 2016, which were recently amended in 201985.
APPLICATION
The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, under Section 886 explicitly bars any person
from handling hazardous substances except in accordance with such procedure and
83 Guidelines on Implementing Liabilities for Environmental Damages Due to Handling and Disposal
of Hazardous Waste and Penalty, Central Pollution Control Board, January 2016, Ministry of
Environment, Forest & Climate Change, Government of India.
84 Supra note 1.
85 The Amended Rules were notified on 1stMarch, 2019, Available at: https://kspcb.gov.in/
hazardous%20and%20other%20wastes%20amendment%20rules,%202019_25-03-2019.pdf (Last
accessed on 24 October 2019).
86 Section 8 - persons handling hazardous substances to comply with procedural safeguards.- no person
shall handle or cause to be handled any hazardous substance except in accordance with such procedure
and after complying with such safeguards as may be prescribed.
213
NLSIU
subsequent to compliance of such safeguards as may be prescribed. This provision is to

be read along with Rule 13 of the Environment (Protection) Rules, 1986. The Central
Government in the year 2016 notified the new Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management
and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016 (‘2016 Rules’ for short), by replacing the
older Rules framed in 2008. The term hazardous waste87means any waste which by reason of
any of its physical, chemical, reactive, toxic, flammable, explosive or corrosive characteristics cause
danger or is likely to cause danger to health or environment, whether alone or when in contact with other
wastes or substances and includes those as listed in Schedule-I. Furthermore, wastes have been
classified as Class-A, B and C under Schedule - II based on the concentration limits as
specified under respective class. A separate classification for the imported or exported
wastes has been provided Schedule - III. Overarching powers to make rules has been
provided to the Central Government under Section 6 and Section 25 of the EPA. The
Central Government invoking the powers vested under EPA has delegated88 certain powers
to the State Governments to issue certain directions in writing to any person, officer or
any authority, which has to be mandatorily complied with. Authorities established under
the different pollution control laws viz., Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) and
State Pollution Control Board (SPCB) have been assigned with the task of implementing
and enforcing the provisions made under these laws.
The 2016 Rules lay down comprehensive definitions of the termsused. The term ‘other
wastes89’ has also been included in the present framework. It is interesting to note that
present Rules make provision forprevention, minimisation, reuse, recycling, recovery,
co-processing and safe disposal in a sequential order.90 That is to say, each of these
processes have to be followed in a sequence. The Rules have also included within their
87 Rule 17 of the Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016.
88 Powers under Section 5 of EPA has been delegated to the State Governments vide Notification no, S.O.
152 (e) dated 10-2-88 published in the Official Gazette no. 54 of the same date, Available at: https:
//indiacode.nic.in/bitstream/123456789/4316/1/ep_act_1986.pdf (Last accessed on 22 October 2019).
89 Rule 23 of 2016 Rules “other wastes” means wastes specified in Part B and Part D of Schedule III for
import or export and includes all such waste generated indigenously within the country.
90 New Hazardous Waste Rules will ensure resource recovery and disposal of hazardous waste in
environmentally sound manner: Javadekar, Available at: https: //pib.gov.in/newsite/
printrelease.aspx?relid=138521 (Last accessed on 25 October, 2019).
214
NLSIU
ambit other types of waste like waste tyre, paper waste, metal scrap and other electronic
items. The 2016 Rules contain six chapters and as many as 24 Rules.
The primary concern of the Rules is with regard to the procedure for the management of
hazardous and other wastes as has been laid down under Chapter II. Rule 4 of the 2016
Rules lays down certain obligations on the Occupier for management of hazardous wastes.
The occupier must follow the steps in the same order to prevent, minimize, reuse, recycle,
recovery, utilisation including co-processing and finally safe disposal. The Occupier has
been made responsible for safe and environmentally sound management of hazardous
and other wastes in order to prevent accidents, contain contaminants and limit the
consequences on humans and environment91. Provision for authorised disposal facility
has been incorporated to ensure safe disposal of hazardous and other wastes. A duty has
been cast upon the State Government to ensure that hazardous and other wastes are
managed in environmentally sound manner by assigning a specific department vested
with the authority to earmark space in the industrial areas or sheds for recycling, pre-
processing of wastes in existing or upcoming industrial parks, estates and industrial
clusters92. The duty of the State Government is not just limited to earmarking space but
it also extends to the recognising and registration of workers involved in the recycling,
pre-processing and other activities, assisting in formation of groups of such workers,
undertaking industrial skill development activities and to conduct annual monitoring to
ensure safety and health of workers involved in these activities.
Even though the Rules lay down and impose restrictions on importing and exporting of
wastes, it is not completely prohibited. As per the Rules, any activity of importing may
happen only for recycling, recovery, reuse and utilisation including co-processing93. As
per the Notification issued by the Customs Department, Government of India, certain
compliances have to be followed before importing or exporting any kind of hazardous
wastes. The procedure has been enumerated as per Rules 12, 13, 14 and 15, as specified
under Chapter IIIof the 2016 Rules. Movement of these hazardous wastes to different
91 Rule 4(6) of 2016 Rules.

92 Rule 5 of 2016 Rules.
93 Rule 12(2) of 2016 Rules.
215
NLSIU
nations may happen with the Prior Informed Consent of the exporting nation and also
with the permission of the MoEF&CC. Earlier, the hazardous waste had aregulated
market. But, post the amendment in 2019, Government of India has banned import of
any kind of solid waste including the plastic waste/scrap. Post the amendment, no
importing of solid plastic waste is permitted as on 1st March, 2019. The primary objective
of bringing in the amendment was to reduce the waste generation and recycling capacity
in the country, gradually moving towards the phasing out of single use plastic waste by 202294.
The Government’s move to completely prohibit the plastic waste from getting
imported was due to insufficient recycling capacity in the country. Huge amounts
of hazardous wastes remain without reaching the proper disposal centres for
recycling. This has led to the increase in pollutants in the atmosphere. Based on
the data available Class I cities account for total of 80% of the country’s waste
generation and considering the amount of waste generated, it is estimated that
around 88 Sq.km., of precious land would be required to dump the waste by the
year 2050.
Classification of Wastes
The main focus of the 2016 Rules is not restricted

to the hazardous wastes, but it also focuses on
other wastes which cannot be classified as per se
hazardous. It is pertinent to note that any solid
waste with properties that make it dangerous or
capable of having harmful impact on health of
Figure – 1 Pie Chart depicting hazardous
waste by method of Disposal. Source – Waste
Management in India – Shifting Gears, March
2017, ASSOCHAM – PWC Report.
94 Govt Puts Complete Ban on Import of Solid Plastic Waste, Available at: https://
economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/environment/pollution/govt-puts-complete-ban-on-import-of-
solid-plastic-waste/articleshow/68293186.cms?from=mdr (Last accessed on 31October, 2019).
216
NLSIU
humans or animals and environment in general are hazardous wastes. In order to classify
what constitutes hazardous wastes, it is fundamental to identify it first. As per the study
undertaken by ASSOCHAM and PWC95, it is estimated that around 43,936 industries
are operating throughout the country and generating about 7.46 mn metric tonnes of
hazardous waste. The disposal methods of these hazardous wastes are by way of landfills,
recycled and incinerations. Hazardous industrial wastes have been classified mainly into
two broad categories96;
A. Hazardous industrial wastes produced in India;
B. Hazardous industrial wastes brought into India for recycling and re-processing.
The 2016 Rules has also laid down procedure for obtaining the approvals. The process
has been simplified to the extent that it is now based on the single window
clearance system. The system has been set up for granting clearances to establishing the
hazardous waste disposal facility. The newly set system acquires prominence as there is
an impetus to process and recycle the wastes rather consuming the virgin resources of
the country.
95 Waste Management in India – Shifting Gears, March 2017, ASSOCHAM – PWC, Available at: https:
//www.pwc.in/assets/pdfs/publications/2017/waste-management-in-india-shifting-gears.pdf
(Last accessed on 29 October, 2019).
96 Ibid.
217
NLSIU
Responsibility of Authorities under the Rules
Several duties and responsibilities have been assigned to various authorities including
the MoEF&CC to identify hazardous and other wastes, granting permissions for export/
import/transit, promotion of environmentally sound management if hazardous and other
wastes and training programs; Central Pollution Control Board to coordinate training
activities, conduct training, specifying standards, annual report review or any other
functions as specified; State Government/ Union Territory Government/ Administration
to identify and approve sites and other related activities; State Pollution Control Boards
to inventorisation of hazardous and other wastes, grant and renewal of authorisation,
monitoring, examining and to take actions for violations of provisions of Rules; Directorate
General of Foreign Trade to grant or refusal of license for import of hazardous and other
wastes; Customs and Ports Authority for verifying documents, intimation to MoEF&CC,
taking necessary actions against importer/exporter under relevant laws.97
Powers and Functions of Agencies under EPA and HWM Rules
Agencies Powers and Functions

Central 1. Laying down procedures and safeguards for handling of
Government hazardous substances (Section 3 (2) (vii)), Environment
represented Protection Act, 1986 (EPA))
by Ministry of
Environment, 2. Make rules to regulate environmental pollutants (Section 6,
Forest and EPA)
Climate 3. Make rules for providing the procedure in accordance with and
Change safeguards in compliance with which hazardous substances shall
(MoEF&CC) be handled or cause to be handled by persons handling the same
(Section 25 (2) (b), EPA)
4. To deal with import and export of hazardous and other wastes
(Section 11, Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management
97 Schedule VII, corresponding Rules 13(6) and 21 of 2016 Rules.
218
NLSIU
and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016 (HWM

Rules))
5. Duties under Schedule VII, HWM Rules read with Rules
13 (6) and 21, HWM Rules
- Identification of hazardous and other wastes
- Permission to exporters of hazardous and other wastes
- Permission to importer of hazardous and other wastes
- Permission for transit of hazardous and other wastes through
India.
- Promote environmentally sound management of hazardous and
other waste.
- Sponsoring of training and awareness programme on Hazardous
and Other Waste Management related activities.
Directorate Duties under Schedule VII, HWM Rules read with Rules 13 (6) and
General of 21, HWM Rules-
Foreign Trade Grant of licence for import of hazardous and other wastes-
constituted Refusal of licence for hazardous and other wastes prohibited for
under the imports and export
Foreign Trade
(Development
and
Regulation)
Act, 1992
Central 1. Issue guidelines or standard operating procedures for
Pollution environmentally sound management of hazardous and other
Control Board wastes (Section 10, HWM Rules)
(CPCB
2. Issue guidelines for treatment, storage and disposal facility for
hazardous and other wastes (Section 16 (2), HWM Rules)
3. Issue guidelines for Packaging and Labelling (Section 17, HWM
Rules)
219
NLSIU
4. Issue guidelines for transportation of hazardous and other wastes

(Section 18, HWM Rules)
5. Prepare the consolidated review report on management of
hazardous and other wastes and forward it to the MoEF&CC,
along with its recommendations before the 30th day of December
once in every year (Section 20 (4), HWM Rules)
6. Duties under Schedule VII, HWM Rules read with Rules 13 (6)
and 21, HWM Rules:
- Co-ordination of activities of SPCBs
- Conduct training courses for authorities dealing with management
of hazardous and other wastes
- Recommend standards and specifications for treatment and
disposal of wastes and leachates, recommend procedures for
characterisation of hazardous wastes.
- Inspection of facilities handling hazardous waste as and when
necessary.
- Sector specific documentation to identify waste for inclusion in
these rules.
- Prepare and update guidelines to prevent or minimise the
generation and handling of hazardous and other wastes.
- Prepare and update guidelines/ Standard Operating Procedures
(SoPs) for recycling, utilization, pre-processing, co-processing
of hazardous and other wastes.
- To prepare annual review report on management of hazardous
waste.
- Any other function assigned by MoEF&CC, from time to time
7. Accordingly, guidelines for the following aspects have been
prepared by the CPCB98:
- Revised Guidelines for Pre-Processing and Co-Processing of
Hazardous and Other Wastes in Cement Plant as per H&OW(M
& TBM) Rules, 2016
98 Available at: http: //cpcb.nic.in/technical-guidelines/ (Last accessed on 29 October, 2019).
220
NLSIU
- Guidelines on Implementing Liabilities for Environmental

Damages due to Handling & Disposal of Hazardous Waste and
Penalty
- Guidelines for Common Hazardous Waste Incineration-
Criteria for Hazardous Waste Landfills
- Guidelines for Management, Handling, Utilisation and Disposal
of Phosphogypsum Generated from Phosphoric Acid Plants
- Protocol for performance Evaluation and Monitoring of the
Common Hazardous Waste Treatment Storage and Disposal
Facilities including Common Hazardous Waste Incinerators
- Guidelines for Setting up of Operating Facility: Hazardous Waste
Management
- Guidelines for Proper Functioning and Upkeep of Disposal Sites
- Guidelines for Environmental Sound Recycling of Hazardous
Waste as per Schedule-V of Hazardous Waste (Management
Handling and Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2008
- Guidelines for the Selection of Site for Landfilling
- Guidelines for Transportation of Hazardous Wastes
- Guidelines for Storage of Incinerable Hazardous Wastes by the
Operators of Common Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage
and Disposal Facilities and Captive HW Incinerators
- Guidelines for Conducting Environmental Impact Assessment
: Site Selection for Common Hazardous Waste Management
Facility
- Manual for ‘Sampling, Analysis and Characterization of
Hazardous Wastes’
8. A National Inventory of Hazardous Wastes Generating
Industries & Hazardous Wastes Management in India has been
prepared along with state-wise status.99
99 Available at: http: //cpcb.nic.in/inventory/ (Last accessed on 29 October 2019).
221
NLSIU
9. A project on “Remediation of hazardous waste contaminated

dumpsites” in the country with CPCB as anexecuting agency
under the National Clean Energy Fund has been initiated.100
8 contaminated areas coming under this project include101:
-
Mercury Contaminated sites at Gunjam, Orissa
-
Chromium Contaminated area, Orichem, Talcher, Orissa
Chromium Contaminated area at Rania, Kanpur Dehat, Uttar
Pradesh
- Pesticide contaminated site near Deva Road, Lucknow, Uttar
Pradesh
- Chromium Contaminated Area at Ranipet, Tamil Nadu
- H-Acid Contaminated Sites near Ratlam, Madhya Pradesh
- Chromium and heavy Metal contaminated Area at Nibra,
Howrah, WB
- Pesticides Contaminated land and creeks near Eloor-Edayar,
Kerala
State Department of Industry/Labour in the State or any other government
Government agency authorised in this regard by the State Government (Section
5, HWM Rules):
- to ensure earmarking or allocation of industrial space or shed
for recycling, pre-processing and other utilisation of hazardous
or other waste in the existing and upcoming industrial park,
estate and industrial clusters;
- to ensure recognition and registration of workers involved in
recycling, pre-processing and other utilisation activities;
- to assist formation of groups of such workers to facilitate
setting up such facilities;
- to undertake industrial skill development activities for the
workers involved in recycling, pre-processing and other
utilisation;
100 Available at: http://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id= ahdtzc9oq0vgx1byb 2vqy3rfqmfja
2dyb3vuzc5wzgy= (Last accessed on 29 October 2019).
101 Available at: http://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id= ahdtzc9oq0vgx1byb2ply 3rfu3rhdhvzx1nlchqymde
0lnbkzg== (Last accessed on 29 October, 2019).
Filing Returns 222

NLSIU
- to undertake annual monitoring and to ensure safety and health

of workers involved in recycling, pre-processing and other
utilisation.
- State Government to prepare integrated plan for effective
implementation of provisions on hazardous waste management
and to submit annual report to the MoEF&CC
Port authority Duties under Schedule VII, HWM Rules read with Rules 13 (6) and
under Indian 21, HWM Rules
Ports Act, 1908 - Verify the documents
and Customs
- Inform the MoEF&CC of any illegal traffic
Authority
under the - Analyse wastes permitted for imports and exports, wherever
Customs Act, required.
1962 - Train officials on the provisions of these rules and in the analysis
of hazardous and other wastes
- Take action against exporter or importer for violations under
the Indian Ports Act, 1908 or Customs Act, 1962
State Pollution 1. To grant authorisation for managing hazardous and other wastes
Control Board to occupiers of facility who are engaged in handling, generation,
(SPCB) and collection, storage, packaging, transportation, use, treatment,
Pollution processing, recycling, recovery, pre-processing, co-processing,
Control utilisation, offering for sale, transfer or disposal of the
Committees hazardous and other wastes. (Section 6, HWM Rules)
(PCC) 2. Power to suspend or cancel an authorisation to holder of such
an authorization after giving reasonable opportunity of being
heard (Section 7, HWM Rules)
3. Providing authorization for utilisation of hazardous and other
wastes as a resource or after pre-processing either for co-
processing or for any other use (Section 9, HWM Rules)
4. Monitor the setting up and operation of the common or captive
treatment, storage and disposal facility (Section 16 (3), HWM
Rules)
223
NLSIU
5. Provide ‘No Objection Certificate’ to persons transporting

hazardous and other wastes within India (Section 18 (3),
HWM Rules)
6. Provide necessary authorisation for transport to either sender
or receivers of hazardous and other wastes within India
(Section 18 (6), HWM Rules)
7. Based on annual returns received from occupiers and operators
of the facilities for disposal of hazardous and other wastes,
SPCB shall prepare an annual inventory of the waste generated;
waste recycled, recovered, utilised including co-processed;
waste re-exported and waste disposed and submit to the CPCB
by the 30th day of September every year. (Section 20 (3),
HWM Rules)
8. prepare inventory of hazardous waste generators, actual users,
and common and captive disposal facilities and submit
information to CPCB every two years (Section 20 (3), HWM
Rules)
9. Duties under Schedule VII, HWM Rules read with Rules 13
(6) and 21, HWM Rules
- Inventorisation of hazardous and other wastes-Grant and
renewal of authorisation
- Monitoring of compliance of various provisions and conditions
of permissions including conditions of permission issued by
MoEF&CC for exports and imports
- Examining the applications for imports submitted by the
importers and forwarding the same to MoEF&CC
- Implementation of programmes to prevent or reduce or
minimise the generation of hazardous and other wastes.
- Action against violations of these rules.
- Any other function under these Rules assigned by MoEF&CC
from time to time.
224
NLSIU
Filing Returns
The 2016 Rules have specified procedure for filing returns and maintenance of records.
Any person being the occupier or operator of handling hazardous or other wastes shall
maintain records as has been specified under Form 3102. State Pollution Control Boards
have a duty to collect and maintain such annual returns that have been filed by the
occupier handling hazardous and other wastes containing the particulars specified under
Form 4.103 Furthermore, the State Pollution Control Boards, have a duty to file to the
Central Pollution Control Board a report to be submitted by the 30th day of September
every year containing the following;
- Annual returns received from occupiers and operators of facilities for disposal
of hazardous and other wastes;
- Annual inventory of waste generated, waste recycled, recovered, utilised
including co-processed, waste re-exported and waste disposed;
- Annual inventory of hazardous waste generators, actual used, and common
and captive disposal facilities
In case of any accidents at the facility of the occupier handling or operating while
undertaking any activities related to hazardous or other wastes, it shall be reported to the
State Pollution Control Board.
Liability and Penalties

In order to address the issue of importing or exporting of wastes from or to other countries
for various reasons, without having sufficient capacity to handle or manage such wastes
a serious cause of concern has arisen. In this regard, the Government of India decided to
ban such import or export activity of chemicals and wastes to reduce the dumping in the
country. Accordingly, a set of procedures including obtaining permission from the Central
Government has become mandatory. Insertion of the provision on illegal traffic104 clearly
lays down several conditions under which export and import of hazardous or other wastes
from and into India shall be deemed to be illegal.
102 Rule 20(1) of 2016 Rules.

103 Rule 20(2) of 2016 Rules.
104 Rule 15 of 2016 Rules.
225
NLSIU
In case the importer of such hazardous wastes is not traceable, then the waste can either
be sold by the Customs Authority to any user having authorisation under these rules or
can be sent to authorised treatment, storage and disposal facility.105
Penalty for any violations of the provisions of 2016 Rules, are supplemented with the
provisions contained in the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986. Rule 23(2) of the 2016
Rules, lays down liability on occupier and operator of facility to financial penalties levied
by the State Pollution Control Boards with the prior approval from the Central Pollution
Control Board. Failure to comply or contravention of any provisions of the Act or Rules,
will attract imprisonment for a term extending to 5 years with fine of Rupees one lakh
and Rupees five thousand per day for continued contravention106. The Karnataka State
Pollution Control Board recently has issued a direction to all the concerned officers for
filing complete information consisting of evidences, returns etc. Failure to send complete
information resulting in non-enforcement of penalties and filing cases against defaulting
industries/organisation, the concerned officers will be held liable personally.107
5.2.3.1 HAZARDOUS WASTE MANAGEMENT IN UNITED STATES OF

AMERICA
Environment Protection Agency (EPA) of the United States of America has developed
a regulatory definition and process that identifies specific substances known as hazardous
wastes. This is not clearly exhaustive as it encompasses an objective criterion to include
such other wastes within the purview of hazardous waste. Waste generation, more
specifically hazardous waste is generated from industries using chemicals, batteries and
other forms of liquid and gases108. The EPA has laid down certain guidelines for
identification of solid and hazardous wastes. A separate legislation titled Resource
Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA)109 and regulations have been implemented to
105 Rule 15(3) of 2016 Rules.

106 Section 15 - Penalty for contravention of the provisions of the act and the rules, order and direction,
Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
107 Circular No.pcb/wmc/3243/circular/2019-20, dated 04.06.2019 issued by the Karnataka State Pollution
Control Board.
108 Learn the Basics of Hazardous Waste, United States Environmental Protection Agency, Available at:
https: //www.epa.gov/hw/learn-basics-hazardous-waste (Last accessed on 29 October2019).
226
NLSIU
create a framework for proper management of

hazardous and non-hazardous solid waste. As
per the system in United States, the hazardous
waste identification process follows the model
as prescribed by RCRA. The issue of solid
waste management has been persisting since
the mid twentieth century. Evolution of solid
waste from being mere waste to hazardous
waste has only aggravated the issue of waste
handling and management. Cost escalation,
identification of new sites for disposal and
handling waste much less the hazardous waste, Figure – 2 Hazardous Waste Identification
shrinking capacity of disposal, long process. Source - Learn the basics of
hazardous waste, United States
decomposition time among other issues has
Environmental Protection Agency.
only added to the woes. This has led to
discovery and evolution of new mechanism for handling wastes. RCRA has developed a
new framework to manage the hazardous waste safely from “cradle to grave”110. The concept
of cradle to grave means, from the time waste is created, while it is transported, treated
and stored, and until it is disposed.
Hazardous Waste identification process in US prescribed by RCRA
Contravention or violations of the provisions of the RCRA could result in both civil and
criminal actions against the contravener or violator. A stringent enforcement mechanism
has been put in place to check illegal treatment, storage, or disposal or hazardous wastes
without any permit. It is apposite to note that the permission of the appropriate authority
is necessary even before the hazardous wastes are exported and violation of which may
result in serious consequence. The provision also specifically mentions that if any person
knowingly exports hazardous waste without consent of receiving country or in violation
109 Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA) laws and regulations, Available at:https:
//www.epa.gov/rcra (Last accessed on 29 October 2019).
110 EPA’s Cradle-to-Grave Hazardous Waste Management Program, Available at: https: //www.epa.gov/
hw/learn-basics-hazardous-waste#cradle (Last accessed on 31October 2019).
227
NLSIU
of an international agreement between the receiving country, it amounts to illegal export

of hazardous wastes111. Specific provisions for transportation of unpermitted facility,
making false statement,wilful alteration, destruction or concealment of records, wilful
endangerment or illegal export of hazardous wastes are considered as offences.
Figure -3 RCRA Framework on Cradle to grave Waste Management System. Source -

Hazardous Waste Violations: Beware! EPA Fines have Increased, MCF Environmental Services.
However, as a civil remedy, any violations of the provisions of law attract hefty amounts
of fine which may extend to $70,117 per violation, per day. The laws in USA are stringent
and fines imposed are massive. The rate of fines was revised in mid- 2016. Under various
legislations like the Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act and other environment related
legislations the fines have been nearly doubled thereby effectively keeping a check on
any violations.112
111 42 USC 6928(d)(6).

112 Hazardous Waste Violations: Beware! EPA Fines have Increased, MCF Environmental Services,
Available at:https://mcfenvironmental.com/hazardous-waste-violations-beware-epa-fines-have-
increased/ (Last accessed on 5 November, 2019).
228
NLSIU
5.2.4 E-WASTE (MANAGEMENT) RULES, 2016
Consumerism coupled with accessibility and development in technology has spiked the
need for electrical and electronic equipment (EEE). The pace at which these gadgets are
being introduced in the market is a manifestation of research and development in the
sector. These devices have great utility and are user friendly. India, being one of the most
populous countries in the world is witnessing escalated demands for these products.
Despite there being huge demands for electrical and electronic gadgets, the supply has
never been lowered. Rather the supply has always been in abundance. Mobile phones
and chipsets, iron box, television sets, computers, printers, wires and connectors are few
of the examples of electronic and electrical gadgets. The life span of these devices is not
fixed, however due to the demand for continuous upgradation or usage, the physical
devices get obsolete. Planned obsolescence has been alleged against the manufacturers
of several of these devices.
A recent study has stated that the Electronic product life spans are getting shorter in
addition to the consumers’ desire to replace old models of devices with the new ones
even though 60% of them were functioning perfectly113. It is a matter of great concern
that the inefficient use of resources in nations across the world has led to depletion and
degradation. The United Nations has warned that the world maybe soon hit by tsunami
of e-waste114. Nations across the world have taken note of the issue and there are
legislations and rules that are introduced to reduce, recycle and reuse the waste.
Issue of e-waste in the countries of European Union has been addressed by taking
necessary policy initiatives and by adopting scientific methods for recycling and disposal.
European Union defines the new stream of waste as Waste Electrical and Electronic
Equipment (WEEE). Some of the developed countries even though had found out
113 Lifespan of Consumer Electronics is Getting Shorter, Study Finds. Guardian Environment Network,
Susanna Ala – Kurikkafor Ends Europe, Available at: https: //www.theguardian.com/environment/
2015/mar/03/lifespan-of-consumer-electronics-is-getting-shorter-study-finds (Last accessed on 5
November, 2019).
114 Tsunami of E-waste’ to Hit the World Soon, Warns Wew UNReport, Available at: https://
www.downtoearth.org.in/news/waste/-tsunami-of-e-waste-to-hit-the-world-soon-warns-new-un-
report-62958 (Last accessed on 10 November, 2019).
229
NLSIU
solutions to manage and handle the issue of E-waste, they were exporting their wastes to
India, China, Vietnam, Mexico, Brazil, and other developing nations who were receiving
the bulk of e-waste from North America, Japan, South Korea and Australia. The export
of electronic waste is regulated under the Basel Convention on the Control of
Transboundary Movement of Hazardous Wastes and its Disposal. Based on the
international treaties and commitments, India had to introduce a proper legal framework
to deal with the electronic waste.
The legal framework for India is robust to deal with the issue of electronic waste and
several doctrines and principles have been enshrined in the Rules to ensure responsibility
and fix liability on the defaulters.
5.2.4.1 LEGAL FRMAEWORK GOVERNING THE E-WASTE IN INDIA
The management of electronic waste came to the fore sometime only in the early 2000s.
During this time the electronic waste was considered to be one of the hazardous wastes
to be handled under the erstwhile hazardous waste management Rules, prevailing then.
There was discussion and debate among the government organisations, environmentalist
groups and private parties. Supreme Court of India vide its order115 dated 14th October,
2003 directed the Union Government and accordingly, states notified set of hazardous
waste laws. This also led to the construction of numerous hazardous waste disposal
facilities. However, the issue was taken note of by the Government and Parliament on
23rd December, 2005, when a Private Member’s Bill on the Electronic Waste (Handling
and Disposal) Bill, 2005 came up for discussion in Rajya Sabha. The Bill had several
important features for consideration with regard to disposal of electronic waste along
with the Municipal waste. The Bill did not pass through and ultimately it lapsed sometime
in July 2010 with the expiry of the term of the member in Rajya Sabha.116
115 Research Foundation for Science, Technology And Natural Resource Policy vs. Union of India & Others
in W.P. (civil) no.657/1995.
116 E-Waste in India, Research Unit (Larrdis) Rajya Sabha Secretariat, New Delhi, June, 2011, Available at:
https://rajyasabha.nic.in/rsnew/publication_electronic/e-waste_in_india.pdf (Last accessed on 10
November, 2019).
230
NLSIU
Guidelines for Environmentally Sound Management of E-Waste, 2008
The regulatory regime for E-waste commenced with the Hazardous Waste (Management
and Handling) Rules, 1989 as amended up to 2003 and subsequent changes relating to
the Hazardous wastes in India. The growing concern however, did not stop the
Government of India and the Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) to prepare and
publish the Guidelines for Environmentally Sound Management of E-Waste117 in March
2008. The primary objective of these guidelines was to provide guidance for identification
of various sources of waste electrical and electronic equipments and prescribe procedures
for handling of e-waste in an environmentally sound manner. The guidelines were a pilot
effort by the Government which succeeded in making a law. The guidelines were applicable
to all those who handle e-waste including the generators, collectors, transporters,
dismantlers, recyclers and stakeholders of e-waste without any embargo on the scale of
their operation. It followed some of the concepts which were already in place in the existing
Hazardous Waste Rules. Guidelines have been formulated with the objective of providing
guidance for identification of various sources of e-waste and methods for its handling.
E-waste composition and recycling potential of items of economic value, identification
for possibility of hazardous contents in e-waste, recovery, re-use and recycling options,
treatment and disposal options and environmentally sound treatment technology.
Guidelines also emphasised on placing the liability on the producer for the entire life
cycle of product which included taking back, recycling and to ultimately dispose the
product. The principle behind this is termed as Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR).
5.2.4.2 E-WASTE (MANAGEMENT AND HANDLING) RULES, 2011
The new Rules were notified in May, 2012. Some of the fundamental principles as laid
down in the guidelines preceding the Rules of 2011 have been incorporated. The producers
are responsible for making the consumers aware about the hazardous components present
in the product. The mandatory instructions for consumers handling the gadget after the
use along certain do’s and don’ts have been provided. The Rules laid down responsibility
not just on the producers, but also on the collection centres, consumer or bulk consumer,
dismantlers and recyclers.
117 As approved vide MoEFLetter no.23-23/2007-hsmd d. March 12,2008).
231
NLSIU
a. Symbol to prevent E-waste from being dropped in garbage bins

Producers118 - The principle of Extended Producer Responsibility
(EPR)119 found its mentionin the Rules. Producer was to ensure that
the e-wastes are channelised to registered dismantler or recycler.The
duty is also extended to setting up of collection centres or taking
back systems either individually or collectively.Creating awareness
among the consumers about the disposal mechanism had been one
of the highlighting features of the Rules.
b. Collection Centres120 - Furthermore, the collection centres Figure – 4 Symbol
also had the responsibility ofobtaining authorisation from their to prevent E-waste
respective Pollution Control Boards by duly giving all the details from being dropped
as mandated. Collection centres had to ensure that the waste in garbage bins.
collected by them is stored in a secured manner till it is sent to the Source - E-waste
dismantlers or recyclers. Towards the environment, they had to (Management and
ensure that no damage is caused while storage or transportation of Handling) Rules, 2011.
e-waste.To file annual returns and maintenance of records in the
format as prescribed was another responsibility vested on them.
c. Consumer or Bulk consumer121 – Waste had to be challenised to authorised
collection centres or registered dismantlers or recyclers or returned to pick-up or take
back services. The bulk consumers on the other hand were required to maintain records
of e-waste generated by them and produce to SPCB for scrutiny.
d. Dismantler122 – Dismantlers had to get themselves registered with the concerned
Pollution Control Board. Ensuring safety of the environment, and ensuring that health is
not adversely affected during the dismantling process, and sending of dismantled wastes
to recycling facilities for recovery of materials were their other responsibilities.
e. Recycler 123 - Primary responsibility was to obtain registration from the
jurisdictional Pollution Control Board for operation and to dispose of the residue in a
hazardous waste treatment storage disposal facility.
118 Rule 4 of the E-waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 2011.
119 Ibid Rule 4(2).
120 Ibid Rule 5.
121 Ibid Rule 6.
122 Ibid Rule 7.
123 Ibid Rule 8
232
NLSIU
The other important provisions of the 2011 Rules included the power of the Pollution
Control Board to cancel authorisation of the different stakeholders for non-compliances.
It also laid down the procedure for storage of wastes. The Rules contained and classified
certain categories of electrical and electronic equipment including the consumer durables
like televisions, washing machines, air conditions. However, these provisions were not
sufficient to tackle the issue of e-waste and the loopholes had to be plugged by appropriate
mechanism. Hence, the E-waste (Management) Rules, 2016 came into effect.
5.2.4.3 E-WASTE (MANAGEMENT) RULES, 2016
Notified on 23rd March, 2016, the 2016 Rules came into effect in supersession of the
E-waste Rules of 2011. The Rules have been drastically changed when compared to the
2011 Rules. However, certain key features have been retained in the present Rules.
Application
The Rules of 2016 has been made applicable to every manufacturer, producer, consumer,
bulk consumer, collection centres, dealers, e-retailers, refurbisher, dismantler and recycler
involved in manufacture, sale, transfer, purchase, collection, storage and processing of
electronic waste or electrical and electronic equipment as has been listed in the Schedule
I. It includes the components, consumables, parts and spares which make the product
operational. The Rules have been made applicable to the components, consumables,
spares and parts of EEE. Lamps containing mercury and other chemicals like the Compact
Fluorescent bulbs have been brought under the Rules.
Earlier framework provided for responsibility of producer, whereas, the present Rules
has incorporated the responsibilities of manufacturer124. The manufacturer has the
responsibility to collect the e-waste generated during the manufacture of any electrical
and electronic equipment and channelize it for recycling or disposal. A general duty as to
124 Producer as per the old Rules also included manufacturer. In the present Rules, manufacturer means a
person or an entity or a company as defined in the Companies Act, 2013 (18 of 2013) or a factory as
defined in the Factories Act, 1948 (63 of 1948) or Small and Medium Enterprises as defined in Micro,
Small and Medium Enterprises Development Act, 2006 (27 of 2006), which has facilities for
manufacture of electrical and electronic equipment;
233
NLSIU
the protection of environment has been made to ensure that during transportation and
storage, environment is not damaged.
Under the Rules, authorisation125 has been mandated for generation, handling, collection,
reception, storage, transportation, refurbishing, dismantling, recycling, treatment and
disposal of e-waste to be granted to the manufacturer, dismantler, refurbisher and recycler.
Accordingly, the producer of e-waste under the principle of Extended Producer
Responsibility has to establish his own collection centre, implement take back system, or
the producers may also tie up with the Producer Responsibility Organisation or with the
E-waste exchange.The authorisation framework for producer has been introduced as
follows;
Extended Producer Responsibility126 -Authorisation should comprise of general
scheme for collection of waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment from the Electrical
and Electronic Equipment placed on the market earlier, such as through dealer, collection
centres, Producer Responsibility Organisation, through buy-back arrangement, exchange
scheme, Deposit Refund System, etc. whether directly or through any authorised agency
and channelising the items so collected to authorised recyclers;
Provision for import of electrical and electronic equipment has been allowed for those
producers who have the authorisation for EPR127. Furthermore, operation without the
EPR authorisation by any producer has been considered as causing damage to the
environment. A presumption has been drawn towards the defaulter for being non-
compliant.
Responsibilities of collection centres as provided under the 2011 Rules have been retained.
The Rules have introduced a new stakeholder - the dealers128 and their responsibilities.
Dealers have been given the responsibility of collecting on behalf of producer, and the
procedure for such collection has been prescribed. The dealer or the retailer shall refund
125 Supra note 118, Rule 3(b).

126 Ibid Rule 5(1)(d).
127 Ibid Rule 5(3).
128 Ibid Rule 3 definitions - ‘dealer’ means any individual or firm that buys or receives electrical and
electronic equipment as listed in schedule I of these rules and their components or consumables or parts
or spares from producers for sale.
234
NLSIU
the amount as per the take back system or deposit refund scheme of producer of
e-waste.
Refurbisher means the ones who are engaged in the activity of refurbishment of used
electrical and electronic equipment. They have the responsibility of collecting the
e-waste during refurbishing activity and to channelize it to the licensed dismantler or
recycler. Duties of the bulk consumer, dismantler and recycler have been made more
robust compared to the previous Rules.
Additionally, the State Government has been assigned the responsibility of environmentally
sound management of E-waste. Sufficient area has to be earmarked in industrial space
or shed for dismantling and recycling e-waste in the already existing parks and also in the
upcoming ones. Moreover, the State Government also has to ensure and maintain the
rolls of works and ensure that they are registered and recognised. Setting up of workers
group to facilitate dismantling is one among other duties of the State Government.
Rule 13 of the Rules, specifically deals with the procedure for seeking and grant of
authorisation including the EPR Authorisation of producers, authorisation of
manufacturer, authorisation of refurbisher from the concerned State Pollution Control
Boards. The authorisation is not a mere procedural formality but it is to ensure that the
authorised agencies are brought under a uniform mechanism and the duties imposed on
them are strictly enforced.
Other objective of the Rule is to ensure that there is reduction in the use of hazardous
substances in the manufacture of electrical and electronic equipment and their components
or the consumables or parts and spares. Chemicals like lead, mercury, cadmium, hexavalent
chromium, polybrominated biphenyls and polybrominated diphenyl ethers are not to be
found in concentration value of more than 0.1% by weight in homogeneous materials for
lead and mercury and other chemicals.
Municipality has been assigned with the duty of ensuring that the e-waste of orphan
products is collected and channelized to authorised dismantler129. Orphaned products
refer to non-branded or assembled EEE as specified under Schedule I or those products
129 Rule 24 of the E-waste (Management) Rules, 2016.
235
NLSIU
produced by the company, which has closed its operations130. Liability on the manufacturer,
producer, importer, transporter, refurbisher, dismantler and recycler has been fixed and
any default may lead to levying of financial penalties..
What’s new in the 2016 Rules?
Buy Back - The 2016 Rules has provided for buying back of the EEE which means that
the producers can buy the products back for safe recycling. An incentive has also been
introduced to encourage the consumers to also help recycle the electronic waste. This
principle forms a part of the EPR as the reverse chain mechanism has been incorporated
and mandated imposing a liability on the producers.
Consumers, Bulk Consumers, Refurbisher and Dismantlers–Roles of refurbishers

and dismantlers who are mostly in the informal sector, has been aligned within the new
Rules. This system will allow for formalising the informal sector and the workers will be
trained to handle the electronic waste rather than resorting to the damaging practices like
burning and landfilling. The segregation of precious metals or other chemicals from these
products would allow for reusing the chemicals rather than opting for fresh procurement.
The consumers and bulk consumers also have been imposed with a responsibility of
ensuringthat the waste materials are channelized and it reaches the hands of recyclers for
efficient disposal. The bulk consumers have a role to collect the items and hand it over
to the authorised recyclers and the responsibility will be on the one’s buying them.
Amendment of 2018– The 2016 Rules was amended in 2018. The concept of registration
of Producer Responsibility Organisation (PRO) has been incorporated by the amendment.
Prior to the amendment, there were no targets fixed for EPR authorisation, but for the
provision of Rules to be made more effective, E-waste collection target has been
introduced. CPCB has been empowered to issue guidelines for compliance under
Rule 23 of the present Rules.
130 Ibid Rule 3(1)(aa).
236
NLSIU
A recent study undertaken by Toxics Link has identified that major electric and electronic
companies have been placed in the poor category for poor implementation of EPR131.
The present Rules are framed under the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and the
penalty and punishment for non-compliance shall be as has been prescribed under the
Act. Apart from the financial penalties, of Rs. 1 lakh, there will be imprisonment term
for a period extending up to five years.
5.2.4.4 ELECTRONIC WASTE MANAGEMENT IN EUROPEAN UNION
The European Union policy and regulations on E-waste has

been quite effective in terms of handling and management.
The member nations have had their respective national
legislations since over 2 decades. The first effort from the
European Union came in the year 2003 which was in the form
of a directive i.e., WEEE (Waste for Electrical and Electronic
Equipment) Directive. They had identified the nature of waste
being both hazardous (chemicals impacting human health)
and valuable(precious metals and other items) fundamentally Figure - 5 Symbol for
due to the nature of waste. EPR, has been mandated in India Restriction of Hazardous
recently, whereas, the EU had conceived it initially and the Substances. Source - ROHS
Guide.
implementation was more stringent.
As per the prevailing mechanism, the legislation requires heavy metals like lead, mercury
and others to be substituted by safer alternatives. There is complete prohibition on dumping
of EEE in landfill sites. The continuous increase in the targets for collection of E-waste
has been a major highlight which is very similar to the system that was introduced in
India in 2018. The concept of recycling has been reiterated even for those shops selling
products like mobile phones to accept small e-waste components from customers, even
if the customers do not intend on buying. Responsibility is placed on the manufacturers
131 Time to Reboot III, E-waste Rules: Assessing EPRCompliance. February, 2019 by Toxics Link.
237
NLSIU
for recycling the big items like washing machines, etc. The primary objective of this
legislation is to reduce, reuse and recover as much waste as
possible.
Directive in the year 2002132 focussing on the Restriction of

Hazardous Substances as a standard was introduced for the first
time. As per this Directive, several substances are banned
including Lead, Mercury, Cadmium, Hexavalent Chromium,
Polybrominated Biphenyls and Polybrominated diphenyls. The Figure – 6 Conformité
‘Européene’ means
reason for banning these chemicals was because they were European Conformity.
hazardous to the environment and polluted landfills. They were Source - CE marking is a
also considered to be dangerous in terms of occupational exposure certification mark that
indicates conformity with
during manufacturing and disposal. The RoHS compliant health, safety and
standards and certification is essentially meant for manufacturing environmental protection
facility. Since the first directive, there have been additions to it standards.
and improvements. The second directive133 was published in 2011
known as RoHS – Recast or RoHS 2134. This directive mandated compliance of CE135
marking directive for those products which require the CE marking of products. As on
date, RoHS 3136 is in force which has added additional four substances to the list of six.
5.2.5 PLASTIC WASTE MANAGEMENT RULES, 2016
In today’s era one of the major global environmental concerns has been posed by he
increasing use of plastic. Plastic has been in use for over six decades and its utility is only
growing day by day. Plastic and allied industries have been one of the major drivers of
economic growth in the late 20th and 21st century. Plastic is a synthetic material made
from polymers, which are long molecules built around chains of carbon atoms, typically
with hydrogen and other compounds. It is commonly used to refer to wide range of
132 Directive 2002/95/ec.

133 Directive 2011/65/eu.
134 ROHS Guide, Available at:https://www.rohsguide.com/ (Last accessed on 12 November, 2019).
135 CE marking is a certification mark that indicates conformity with health, safety and environmental
protection standards.
136 Directive 2015/863.
238
NLSIU
synthetic or semi-synthetic materials used for various purposes. Plastics are found in
various forms and nylon, thermoplastics and tarpaulins would be some of its forms to
name a few. More specifically there are seven137 types of plastic that exist;
a. Polyethylene Terephthalate (PET or PETE or Polyester) – used for making

drinking bottles that are to be crushed and disposed after use;
b. High-Density Polyethylene (HDPE) – Thick and strong variant commonly used

to mSince has been one of the major drivers of economic growth in the late 20th
and 21st century and are used to make opaque milk bottles, juice containers,
shampoo bottles and medicine bottles;
c. Polyvinyl Chloride (PVC) – Strong and durable variant for making blood bags,
medical tubing, plumbing equipment like pipes, toys etc.;
d. Low-Density Polyethylene (LDPE) – used to make grocery bags, frozen food

bags, garbage bags, wrappers, and used as covers for bottles, wires and as cable
covers;
e. Polypropylene (PP) – The durability is somewhere between LDPE and HDPE,

used to make thermal vests, Car parts. It is also included in disposal diapers and
sanitary pad liners;
f. Polystyrene (PS) – In other words known as Styrofoam used for packing

containers, bike helmets, food containers etc;
g. Others - Includes bio-plastics, Polycarbonate - used in making baby bottles,

sippy cups, water bottles, metal food liners, dental sealants etc.
Plastic is in use at almost every stage of our day to day activities in every sector. Some
countries have imbibed it in their economy in the form of plastic currency notes like
Australia, Maldives amongst others. Even though it is massively popular in every part of
the world for its utility, there are undesirable and adverse impacts that has already been
researched and published.
137 7 Types of Plastic That You Need to know. Waste 4 Change, Availalble at:https: //waste4change.com/
7-types-plastic-need-know/ (Last accessed on 13 November, 2019).
239
NLSIU
The seven types of plastics referred to in the foregoing paragraph are harmful in their
own way and have been identified to have adversely impacted the health of users over a
substantial period of time. That apart, plastics are infamous for being non-biodegradable.
Irrespective of the quality of plastic, it is expected to last a minimum of 100 years on
this planet before it disintegrates. Its presence in the marine ecosystem has proved fatal
for many animals. Though there are replacements available in the form of cloth bags,
corn starch bags, a stronger political will is required to replace the use of plastic with
alternatives that are more environmentally benign.
The Government of India recently announced its intention to ban single use plastic bags
in the country, however, due to the economic impact that such a move will have, the
decision was not implemented. Nevertheless, the country is not bereft of any regulatory
mechanism and specific rules have been implemented to handle and manage the plastic
and the resultant waste in several countries.
5.2.5.1 RECYCLED PLASTICS MANUFACTURE AND USAGE RULES, 1999
Since the commencement of Environment (Protection) Act, 1986, the Government of

India has made constant and consistent efforts to mitigate the adverse impact on the
environment. Accordingly, in the year 1999, Central Government notified Recycled
Plastics Manufacture and Usage Rules138. The primary objective of this was to regulate
the manufacture, sale, use and recycling of plastic bags. A basic minimum criterion of
thickness was fixed at 20 microns. It further laid down that the food products shall not be
packed with recycled plastic or carry bags which was a specification under the Bureau of
India Standards (BIS).
Powers under the Rules were delegated to the State Pollution Control Boards and Pollution
Control Committees for taking action for violation of Rules or provisions of the Act.
The Rules were amended in the year 2003.
138 Manufacture and Usage of Plastic Goods, Available at: https://pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.

aspx?relid=74888#:~: targettext=the%20central%20government%20had% 20notified,and%
20recycling%20of%20plastic%20bags (Last accessed on 12 November, 2019).
240
NLSIU
5.2.5.2 PLASTIC WASTE (MANAGEMENT AND HANDLING) RULES, 2011
Salient features of the Rules were that it imposed a ban on use of plastic materials in
sachets for storing, packing or selling gutkha, tobacco and pan masala, and no food stuff
wasto be packed in the plastic which is recycled or compostable. It also specified that
recycled carry bags must be BIS compliant as regards the colour and thickness was
increased to 40 microns. The waste pickers were given explicit recognition and municipal
authorities were mandated to constructively engage agencies or groups working in the
waste management including the waste pickers. Urban local bodies were made responsible
for setting up, operationalise and coordinate the waste management system for performing
associated functions. This system was introduced in order to ensure safe collection, storage,
segregation, transportation, processing and disposal of plastic waste without causing any
damage to the environment during the whole process. It disallowed the open burning of
plastic waste and also created awareness amongst all the stakeholders.
5.2.5.3 PLASTIC WASTE MANAGEMENT RULES, 2016
For the better implementation of the Rules and to give emphasis on plastic waste
minimization, source segregation, recycling involving waste pickers, recyclers and waste
processors in collection of plastic waste from households or any other source of its
generation or intermediate material recovery facility and to adopt polluter’s pay principle
for the sustainability of the waste management, a review of the 2011 Rules was effected.
The Central Government notified the Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016 on 18th
March 2016. The Rules have brought in several changes and the most prominent being
the change in minimum thickness of plastic carry bags being increased from 40 to 50
microns139. The data provided by the Minister of Environment, Forest and Climate Change
stated that 15,000 tonnes of plastic waste is generated everyday out of which 9000
tonnes is collected and processed and around 6000 tonnes of plastic waste is not being
collected. Earlier the jurisdiction of theRules were restricted only up to the municipal
areas, but now it has been extended to rural areas too.
139 Government Notifies Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016, ‘Minimum Thickness of Plastic Bags
Increased from 40 To 50 Microns’, Available at: https: //pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?
relid=138144 (Last accessed on 12 November, 2019).
241
NLSIU
Applicability
The definition of Plastic140 as per the 2016 Rules means material which contains as an
essential ingredient a high polymer such a polyethylene terephthalate, high density
polyethylene, Vinyl, low densitypolyethylene, polypropylene, polystyrene resins, multi-
materials like acrylonitrile butadiene styrene, polyphenylene oxide, polycarbonate,
Polybutylene terephthalate. Certain other definitions of terms like plastic sheet141, plastic
waste142, compostable plastics143 have also been included.
Applicability of these Rules shall be to every waste generator, local body, gram panchayat,
manufacturer, importers and producer. The Rules has specifically excluded Export
Oriented Units or Units in Special Economic Zone, notified by the Central Government
manufacturing their products against an order for export. However Rule 2(2) clearly
specifies that this exemption shall not apply to units engaged in the packaging gutkha,
tobacco and pan masala and also to any surplus or rejects, left over products and related
ones.
Any kind of usage of plastic including the manufacturing, importing, stocking,

distribution, sale and use of carry bags, plastic sheets, packing covers, multi-layered
packaging are now subjected to the conditions as specified under Rule 4. The Rule
encompassed within it the guidelines as has been prescribed by the Indian Standard : IS
9833:1981 titled “List of pigments and colorants for use in plastics in contact with
foodstuffs, pharmaceuticals and drinking water”.
As per the conditions laid down in the Rule, carry bags made of recycled plastic or
products made of recycled plastic shall not be used for storing, carrying, dispensing or
packaging ready to eat or drink food items. The impact of this would be most on the
140 Rule 3(o) of the Plastic Waste Management Rules, 2016.

141 Ibid Rule 3(p) “plastic sheet”meansplastic sheet is the sheet made of plastic.
142 Ibid Rule 3 (q)”plastic waste”means any plastic discardedafter use or after their intended use is over.
143 Ibid Rule 3(e)”compostable plastics” mean plastic that undergoes degradation by biological processes
during composting to yield co2, water, inorganic compounds and biomass at a rate consistent with other
known compostable materials, excluding conventional petro-based plastics,and does not leave visible,
distinguishable or toxic residue.
242
NLSIU
small sector who are heavily reliant on the plastic much less the recycled plastic bags.
The mandate of 50 microns thickness for carry bags made of virgin or recycled plastic
has seen a shift from 20 microns to 40 microns to 50 microns as on date. The Rules also
expressly bar the gutkha, tobacco and pan masala industries from using plastic material
for storing, packing and selling. The provision of thickness is not applicable to the
compostable bags made from compostable plastic and shall conform to the Indian
Standard: IS 17088:2008 titled as Specifications for Compostable Plastics.
The Urban Local bodies have been assigned the role of managing the Plastic waste.
Several initiatives have been provided expressly under the Rules wherein, the Local bodies
may recycle and channelize the plastic waste recycler and recycling in conformity with
the Indian Standards. Usage of plastic in the construction of roads as mentioned in the
guidelines or energy recovery or waste to oil etc. It may be undertaken in compliance of
all the pollution control laws. Municipal and Gram Panchayath have also been assigned
the duty to develop and set up infrastructure for segregation, collection, storage,
transportation, processing and disposal of the plastic waste. The activity may be done on
its own or by engaging agencies or producers. A separate provision for framing bye-laws
for imposing of user fee or chargehas been made under the Rules.
The Rules also place responsibility on every person

or group of persons, institutions, residential and
commercial establishments including the Indian
Railways, Airport, Port and Harbour and defense
establishments generating plastic wastes that have
been classified as Waste Generators. Minimising
generation, segregation of plastic waste at source
according to the Solid Waste Management Rules,
2000 has been mandated. A provision for littering Figure - 7 PET-Polyethylene terephthalate,
has been retained to ensure segregated storage of HDPE-Highdensit polyethylene, V-Vinyl
waste at source or to handover the wastes to local (PVC), LDPE-Low density polyethylene, PP-
Polypropylene, PS-Polystyrene and Other
authorities. Certain responsibility has also imposed means all other resins and multi-materials like
on the producers, importers and brand owners. Any ABS, PPO, PC, PBT. Source – Plastic Waste
person conducting any public event like marriages, (Management and Handling) Rules, 2011.
243
NLSIU
public meetings, held in open spaces, are held responsible as waste generators. Rules144
also prescribe for the marking and labelling of each plastic carry bag and multi-layered
packaging in with the details as has been specified in the figure.
Producers or brand owners generating waste have been made responsible for collecting
waste that was generated through their products. Previously collection of waste by
producers and brand owners depended on their discretion, but presently, it has been
made mandatory. The local body shall be the authority responsible for assisting them in
formulation of a plan or framework. The street vendors or shopkeepers have been assigned
with the responsibility of procuring license and levying charges for the plastic bags that
they give as a part of the purchase.
The 2016 Rules were amended in 2018. Some new directives issued by the amended
Rules as follows;
a. To gradually phase out Multi-layered Plastics (MLP) which are non-recyclable,

non-energy recoverable or have no alternate use.
b. Registration process for producer, importer or brand owner is now based on central
registration system. This has been done keeping in mind the ease of doing business.
The CPCB shall be handling the central registration system.
c. Explicit pricing of carry bags has been removed from the amendment.
Consumption of plastic in India has risen over the decades. It is estimated that around
12.8 million tonnes of plastic per annum is consumed in India145. Even though the Rules
are stringent on paper, their implementation needs to be evaluated.
144 Ibid Rule 11.

145 Plastic Infrastructure report, 2017.
244
NLSIU
Penalties for breach of provisions of these Rules are as specified under the Environment
(Protection) Act, 1986. That apart, the local bodies have also been empowered to impose
fines on those who store, supply and transport or sell the items. The Government of
Tamil Nadu has notified the bye-laws and empowered the Municipalities to impose and
collect fines.
Government of Maharashtra in the year 2018 notified the plastic ban throughout the
state with an objective to curb the usage of plastic and to fight the pollution that it
causes. The notification banned manufacturing, use, sale, distribution and storage of
plastic materials as bags, plates, spoons and other disposal items. Thermocol has also
been included in the ban. Maharashtra State Pollution Control Board has been authorised
to implement the ban, with certain responsibilities on the district and local authorities to
ensure implementation. The penalty for first time offenders is Rs.5000, for second time
offenders is Rs.10,000. Third time offenders attract a penalty of Rs.25,000 and
imprisonment of three months.
Government of Bihar has also notified the Bihar Plastic Waste Management Byelaws,
2018 and its violations which can attract penalties ranging from Rs.100 to Rs.5000.
Different state governments have taken measures to reduce plastic and its usage within
their territories.
PLASTIC WASTE RELATED LAWS IN AFRICA
The African nations have taken a step ahead in banning the plastic carry bags.
More than 30 countries in Africa have already implemented the ban. The plastic
ban has been gaining momentum in the African continent and most of the under-
developed countries in African continent has come forward to implement the ban.
TANZANIA
The Plastics Carrier Bags Regulations 2019 has been implemented in Tanzania
which prevents import, export, manufacturing, sale, storage, supply and use of
245
NLSIU
plastic carry bags irrespective of its thickness in the country. As per the notification
published by the Government, selling commodities wrapped in plastics unless the
nature of such commodities requires plastic wrapping is prohibited.
Exceptions for usage of plastic have been made in specific sectors like medical,
industrial, construction, agricultural and waste management packaging. Zanzibar,
an autonomous region of Tanzania has already enforced ban on plastic bags for
more than a decade. The fines for violating the provisions of the regulations are
fixed up to 20 million Tanzanian Shillings. The principle of take back or buy back
has been recognised and a duty has been imposed on the manufacturer or supplier
of products containing plastic to setup, operate or participate in take back system
in collecting their plastic water bottles for recycling purposes without any service
charge. The Government has also notified to the travellers about the prohibition
on bringing carrier bags into the country as of June, 2019. Authorities will confiscate
the plastic bags and the Ziploc bags have been exempted to be carried for use. The
move has been appreciated by several countries all over the world.
KENYA
The efforts to reduce the plastic commenced in 2017. Handing out of plastic bags
in Kenya was rampant and due to this the country was plagued with plastic pollution
which has led to increase in number of cases of malaria as the plastic bags clogged
the drains and water flowing areas resulting in breeding space for mosquitos. Because
of this, the Government has made a decision to impose plastic ban on manufacturing,
sale and distribution of plastic carrier bags in the country. Those found to be
manufacturing, importing or selling plastic bag will be considered to have violated
and could be fined up to $40,000 or face sentence up to Four years. Any violation
of the law, the fines range between $500 and $1500 and jail term for over up to a
year. Penalties imposed by the Government have been considered to highest in the
world. The efforts to reduce the plastic bags from circulation within the country
are notable and laudable
246
NLSIU
5.2.6 BATTERIES (MANAGEMENT AND HANDLING) RULES, 2001.
Pursuant to sections 6,8 and 25 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 (29 of 1986),
the Central Government notified the Batteries (Management and Handling) Rules, 2001.
Persons covered under these rules
These Rules exhaustively cover the activities of Manufacture, Purchase, Sale, Processing
and Usage in relation to Batteries.
247
NLSIU
Responsibilities of Manufacturers, Importers, Assemblers and Re-conditioners
All Manufacturers, Importers, Assemblers and Re-Conditioners of Lead Acid Batteries

are required pursuant to Rule 4 of the Batteries (Management and Handling) Rules,
2001 to ensure the following:
a. Collection of Used Batteries:
(i) They are required to collect back used batteries against new batteries sold
excluding those sold to original equipment manufacturer and bulk
consumer(s) and ensure that used batteries collected back are of similar type
and specifications as that of the new batteries sold in the manner provided
below:
248
NLSIU
Sl.No. Year Percentage of Collection
(i) During first year of implementation of rules 50% of new batteries sold
(ii) During second year of implementation of rules 75% of new batteries sold
(iii) After second year of implementation of rules 90% of new batteries sold
(ii) They are required to set up collection centres either individually or jointly -at
various places for collection of used batteries from consumers or dealers.
(Recyclers and Assemblers are exempted from this condition).
(iii) They shall ensure that used
Rule 6 provides that all imports by the Reporter
batteries collected are sent only
shall be contingent upon
to the registered recyclers.
 Valid registration with the Reserve Bank
b. Filing of Retur ns and of India (with Importer’s Code
Number);
Reporting:
 One-Time mandatory Registration
Half-yearly return of their sales under Rule 5 with the Ministry of
and buy-back to the State Board Environment and Forests or an agency
in Form- I shall be latest by 3rd designated by it by submitting details in
Form-I, for a period of five years.
June and 30th December of each
 Submission of Undertaking in Form-
year. They are also bestowed with III along with a copy of the latest half-
the duty to bring to the notice of yearly return in Form-IV
the State Board or the Ministry Where an Importer fails to collect the required
of Environment and Forests any number of used batteries as per the said rules
violation by the dealers. or in case of non-submission of timely half
yearly returns, the Registration may be cancelled
c. Safety of Transportation: thereof; and renewal of the registration shall be
as per the compliance status. An appeal shall lie
(i) They shall ensure that against any order of suspensionor cancellation
necessary arrangements are or refusal of registration passed bythe Member-
made with dealers for safe Secretary of the State Pollution Control Board
transportation from collection or any other officer designated by the State.
centres to the premises of
registered recyclers.
249
NLSIU
(ii) They shall also ensure that no damage to the environment occurs during
transportation. (Recyclers and Assemblers are exempted from this
condition)
d. Creation of Public Awareness:
(i) They shall create public awareness through advertisements, publications, posters
or by other means with regard to the following
 hazards of lead;
 responsibility of consumers to return their used batteries only to the dealers

or deliver at designated collection centres; and Addresses of dealers and
designated collection centres.
e. Sale/Purchase of New/Used Batteries and Recycled Lead:
(i) It shall be ensured that the new batteries sha1l be sold only to the registered
dealers
(ii) They shall use the international recycling sign on the Batteries(Recyclers and
Assemblers are exempted from this condition);
(iii) They shall buy recycled lead only from registered recyclers. (Recyclers and
Assemblers are exempted from this condition)
RESPONSIBILITIES OF DEALER
Rule 7 of the Batteries (Handling and Management) Rules

‘Recycler’-refers to an
2001; stipulate the following duties to every dealer of
occupier who processes
Batteries. used lead acid batteries or
a. Collection of Used Batteries: components thereof for
recovering lead.
(i) The Dealer shall ensure that the used batteries
are collected back as against new batteries sold in the manner provided herein
below:
250
NLSIU
Sl.No. Year Percentage of Collection
(i) During first year of implementation of rules 50% of new batteries sold
(ii) During second year of implementation of rules 75% of new batteries sold
(iii) After second year of implementation of rules 90% of new batteries sold
b. Filing of Returns and Reporting:
File half-yearly returns of the sale of new batteries and buy-back of old batteries
to the manufacturer in Form V by 31st May and 30th November of each year.
c. Provision of Appropriate Discounts:
The Dealer shall provide appropriate discount for every used battery returned by
the consumer.
d. Safety in Storage & Transportation of Used Batteries collected:
RESPONSIBILITIES OF RECYCLERS
Rule 8 of the Batteries (Handling and Management) Rules 2001, provides for the recycler
to perform various duties.
a. Mandatory Registration of Recyclers:
Any person carrying out at the time of these Rules, or intending to carry the
function of a recycler shall apply for registration to the Ministry of Environment
and Forests or an agency designated by it if not applied already, by submitting
information in Form VI and shall ensure strict compliance of the terms and
conditions of registration; however, those already registered with the Ministry of
Environment and Forests or all agency designated by it for reprocessing used
batteries would be bound by the terms and conditions of such registration, who
shall within 90 days of receipt of application form with complete details. The
registration granted under this rule shall be in force for a period of two years
from the date of issue or from the date of renewal unless suspended or cancelled
251
NLSIU
earlier. The Registration may be refused after giving reasonable opportunity to

the applicant of being heard, refuse to grant
registration. Prescribed Authority for ensuring
compliance of the provisions of
An application for the renewal of registration these rules shall be the State
shall be made in Form VI at least six months Board. And, it shall file an annual
before its expiry. compliance status report to the
Central Pollution Control Board
b. Submission of Annual Returns and by 30th April of every year.
Reporting:
Every Recycler shall file Annual Returns is Form VII to the State Board describing,
inter alia the Total number of used battery scrap purchased from / sent for
processing in such Year. The Recycler shall make available all records relating to
receipt of used batteries, sources, quantities and metal yield to be submitted to
the State Pollution Control Board for inspection to the State Board for inspection.
c. Marking of Recycled Lead:
Every Recycler shall mark ‘Recycled’ on lead recovered by reprocessing of the

Used Batteries.
f. Creation of Public Awareness:

“Bulk consumer” means a
(i) Every Recycler shall also create public consumer such as the
awareness through advertisements, Departments of Central
publications, posters or others with regard Government like Railway;
to the following: Defence, Telecom, Posts and
Telegraph, the Departments
 Hazards of lead; and of State Government, the
Undertakings, Boards and
 Obligation of consumers to return used other agencies or companies
batteries only to the registered dealers or who purchase hundred or
deliver at the designated collection more than hundred batteries
centres. per annum;”.
252
NLSIU
Responsibilities of Consumer or Bulk Consumer
Pursuant to Rule 10 of the Batteries (Handling and Management) Rules, 2001, every
consumer shall ensure that used batteries are not disposed of in any manner other than
depositing with the dealer, manufacturer, importer, assembler, registered recycler,
reconditioner or at the designated collection centres.
Bulk Consumers shall have the following duties:
a. Non-Disposal of Used Batteries in otherwise than prescribed manner:
The Bulk Consumer shall ensure that used batteries are not disposed of in any
manner other than by depositing with the dealer/manufacturer/registered
recycler/importer/ reconditioner or at the designated collection centres,- and
b. Filing of Returns:
The Bulk Consumer shall file half-yearly return in Form VIII to the State Board,
by 30th June (for the period October-March) and 31st December (for the period
April-September) each year.
c. Resale of Used Batteries:
Bulk consumers to their user units may auction used batteries to registered recyclers
only.
Responsibilities of Auctioneer
Rule 11 of the Batteries (Handling and Management) Rules provides that all the
auctioneers shall ensure the following duties are duly performed:
a. Resale of Used Batteries:
Auctioneers shall ensure that the used batteries to registered recyclers only.
b. Filing of Returns:
Half-yearly returns of auctions to the State Boards in Form-IX, shall be submitted

by the auctioneer to State Board by 30th June and 31st December of each year;
253
NLSIU
and The Auctioneers shall maintain a record of such auctions and make these
records available to the State Board for inspection.
The Batteries (Handling and Management) Rules, 2001 have been suitably amended
from time to time, and the Central Pollution Control Board has compiled and published
the data received every year from the State Boards to ensure the review of compliance
of the rules periodically to improve the collection and recycling of used lead batteries
and appraise the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India.
5.2.7 STRATEGIES FOR HAZARDOUS AND OTHER WASTES

MANAGEMENT AT THE CENTRAL LEVEL
National Hazardous Waste Management Strategy

Objectives:
 Effective management of hazardous waste, so as to avoid environmental
pollution and adverse health effects;
 To provide guidance to regulatory bodies, generators of hazardous waste,
recyclers and operators of treatment, storage and disposal facilities to minimize,
recycle, treat aand dispose of left over hazardous waste in an environmentally
sound manner;
 To facilitate implementation of the action plan in the “National Environmental
Policy, 2006” in respect of management of hazardous waste;
 To fulfil obligations under the Basel Convention; and
 To promote use of cleaner technologies.
Actions:
 Inventory of hazardous waste generation by CPCB, SPCB and PCCs including
end of life consumer products which have potential to generate hazardous
wastes;
 MoEF&CC has developed a GIS based National Hazardous Waste
Inventorization System (NHWIS), which needs to be updated on a regular basis
by SPCBs/PCCs;
254
NLSIU
 Waste avoidance and waste minimization in the production process with the
CPCB playing a lead role in promoting technological options;
 Reuse, recover and recycling through waste exchange banks/centers;
treatment, storage, disposal and recycling facilities set up by Center or State;
promotion of Extended Producer Responsibility as incorporated within E-
Waste (Management and Handling) Rules, 2016; use of hazardous wastes as
supplementary fuel/raw materials in cement industry, thermal power plants,
iron and steel plants; and public awareness regarding safe disposal methods
amongst stakeholders including general public;
 Safe and environmentally sound disposal methods for those wastes which
cannot be recycled or reused through setting up of common, treatment, storage
and disposal facilities (TSDF) preferably located within industrial estates;
and financial support to such facilities to deal with setting up as well as post
closure monitoring and liability arising due to mishaps, calamities, etc;
 Development of online tracking system by SPCB/PCC for interstate
movement of hazardous waste from generation to the disposal/recovery/
recycle stage.
 Stepping up of surveillance to take care of illegal dump sites and remediation
through MoEF&CC’s National Programme for Rehabilitation of Polluted Sites
which will undertake inventorization of polluted sites, establishing best
practice solutions and engaging multiple stakeholders in the implementation,
including cost recovery mechanisms with focus on ‘Polluter Pays Principle’;
building technical capacities of select SPCBs; and creation of a dedicated
fund by MoEF&CC/SPCB for remediation in cases where polluters are not
traceable;
 Strengthening of infrastructure of regulatory bodies such as SPCB/PCCs in
terms of manpower, equipment and other such facilities as well as providing
adequate funding, training and awareness programs;
 In order to control illegal imports of hazardous wastes, harmonization of
EXIM regulations with HWM Rules; training of Custom department personnel
in inspection and sampling; and Up-gradation of Custom Department
Laboratories;
255
NLSIU
 Disposal of date-expired drugs and pesticides using TSDFs and following

India’s mandate under the Stockholm Convention on Persistent Organic
Pollutants with regard to destruction of banned chemicals; and
 Handling and management of hazardous waste during ship dismantling by
ensuring zero generation of persistent organic pollutants; complete
containment of all gaseous, liquid and solid residues; addressing health and
safety of workers at ship breaking yard; adopting adequate safety systems
during ship dismantling; and enforcement of recommendations by Supreme
Court in ship dismantling by SPCBs/State Maritime Boards.
5.2.8 MEASURES ADOPTED BY INDIAN STATES IN HAZARDOUS
WASTE MANAGEMENT
Andhra  As of 2016-17, the quantity of hazardous waste generated in Andhra

Pradesh & Pradesh and Telangana was 282266.4 MTA and 277078.5 MTA
Telangana respectively.146
 Telangana has 2642 number of hazardous waste generating units in
Telangana as of 2017-18.147
 With respect to Andhra Pradesh, the APPCB has inventorised 1739 units
to be hazardous waste generating units which is covered within the ambit
of Hazardous Waste Management Rules, 2003.148
 Following steps have been taken by the Andhra Pradesh Pollution Control
Board (APPCB) towards management of hazardous and other wastes149:
 APPCB is issuing Consent for Operation (CFO) and Hazardous Waste
Authorization (HWA) together. The occupier of industry/activity/project
uploads the application along with prescribed fee and required documents
online through the “Single Desk Portal” – www.apindustries.gov.in.
146 State-Wise Hazardous Waste Generation (2016-17), Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate
Change, Government of India. Lok Sabha UnstarredQuestion no. 4553 Answered on 19.07.2019 by
Minister of State in the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Available at: http://
www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/generation%20of%20waste.pdf (Last accessed on 11
November, 2019).
147 Available at: http: //tspcb.cgg.gov.in/cbipmp/hw%20annual%20inventory%202017-18.pdf (Last
148 Available at: https: //pcb.ap.gov.in/achievements.html (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
149 Available at: https: //pcb.ap.gov.in/hazardous-waste-management.html (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
256
NLSIU
 In case of HWA renewal, the applications made in Form-I along with the
following documents are to be verified –
 CFE compliance for fresh HWA application.
 Compliance of HWA conditions in case of renewal
 Annual returns as applicable.
 TSDF membership.
 These documents are verified and examined at field level for specific
compliance status on case to case basis by the Regional Office / Board
Officials.
 Every person desirous of recycling or reprocessing the hazardous waste
specified in Schedule- IV of HWM Rules has to obtain registration as
recycler employing Environmentally Sound Technologies (EST). The RO
verifies the application and submits report to Head Office for issue /
reject the registration.
 Every trader desirous of import of Metal scrap, paper waste and
other wastes as listed in Schedule III (Part D) may make an application in
Form - 16 to the SPCB.
 In order to ensure scientific disposal of Hazardous Wastes in the State, one
TSDF has been established in the name of M/s. Coastal Waste Management
Project with incinerator and land fill at J.N. Pharmacity, Parawada,
Visakhapatnam.
 Common TSDF located in Andhra Pradesh is having surplus capacities to
handle the present quantities of land disposable waste.The TSDF situated
in Dindigal, Rangareddy district has been commissioned in 2006 to
incenirate hazardous waste. Further this TSDF has been functioning as a
common hazardous waste incinerator for disposal of hazardous hazardous
waste generated in Northern Coastal Districts of Andhra Pradesh.
 By opting Cleaner Production technologies, the high calorific value of
Hazardous waste generated from Bulk Drugs & Pharmaceuticals industries
are effectively disposed off through cement kiln being operated at 1400
degree centigrade.
 APPCB in line with the guidelines of CPCB on co-processing, is encouraging
cement plants with rotary kilns to establish facilities for co-processing of
hazardous wastes.
 APPCB is putting the responsibility of transportation of the Hazardous
wastes either with generators of the hazardous wastes or with the cement
257
NLSIU
plants to avoid transportation problems. The authorised cement plants

have been directed to obtain regular permission from CPCB for co-
processing as and when required.
 Visakhapatnam and Bollaram Patancheru industrial areas in Andhra Pradesh
have been identified as Critically Pollution Areas by Central Pollution Control
Board in 1990. A.P. Pollution Control Board constituted “Monitoring
Committees” in these two areas to monitor and review the status of
pollution by the industries. With constant persuasion, APPCB in consultation
with the industries in the Critically Polluted Areas prepared industry specific
Action Plans for implementation of various mitigation measures for further
reduction of pollution load and for the effective treatment and disposal
of the effluents and solid wastes by the industries.
 The SPCB of Andhra Pradesh as well as Telangana maintains a Hazardous
waste inventory prepared annually which consists of industrial Hazardous
waste generated in the State. This inventory is compiled by monitoring the
district-wise contribution to the total generation of hazardous wastes.
Assam  As of 2016-17, the quantity of hazardous waste generated in Assam was

29434.64.150
 The West Boragaon Treatment plant is undergoing certain changes in order
to adopt the novel methods of waste treatment. A new provision for
treatment of hazardous and electronic waste is also underway at the plant site.
 All the major sector industries in Assam have been directed to constitute a
Hazardous Waste Management Committee to be headed by the top
management as head of the Committee for formulation of action plan &
implementation of HWM Rules. They are to meet once in a month to review
the situation.
 Secondly, Board also make it mandatory to organize health checkup camp
for the people residing within a radius of 5 km distance from major
hazardous Waste generating units at an interval of every six months with
regular submission of the report to the Board along with photographs.
Minister of State in the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change,Available at: http://
November, 2019).
258
NLSIU
 In addition to this, Board has taken various steps for construction of

common TSDF as per direction of the Supreme Court Monitoring
Committee (SCMC) vide letter No. 23-8/2004-HSMD (Vol.-II), dtd.
21/8/2006. Accordingly, Board has requested the state Govt. for allotment
of 60 (sixty) across of land for proposed construction of CTSDF in the
Central Assam area preferably near M/s. ONGCL, Jorhat and M/s.
ONGCL, Sivasagar area. The Hon’ble Minister of Revenue, and Chief
Secretary, Govt. of Assam is also requested for their intervention regarding
allotment of land for proposed construction of common TSDF. Once
the land is available, the other formalities will be observed as fast as to
pave the way for construction of common TSDF.
Bihar  As of 2016-17, the quantity of hazardous waste generated in Bihar was

7629 MTA.151
 It has 144 number of hazardous waste generating units in the State.152
 Bihar Environment Conservation Board has completed the inventorization
of hazardous wastes generating units.
 Board has granted authorization to these units for collection, reception,
treatment, transport, storage and disposal. etc.
Chandigarh  It has 237 number of hazardous waste generating units as of 2009. 153 As
of 2016-17, the total quantity of hazardous waste generated was 2846.892
MTA154.
 Chandigarh PCC has tied up with Punjab Pollution Control Board and
the hazardous waste generated in U.T., Chandigarh will be disposed of
to TSDF at Derabassi (Punjab). The units have been asked to sign an
agreement with M/s Ramky Enviro Engineers Ltd., (Operator of the
facility) and M/s Nimbuan Green field Punjab Ltd., (NGPL-Developer
of the facility).
151 Ibid.
152 Available at: http: //bhocmms.nic.in/ (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
153 Available at: http: //chandigarhenvis.gov.in/beta/htm/research/cpcc/final_hw_report.pdf (Last
Change, Government of India. Lok Sabha Unstarred Question no. 4553 Answered on 19.07.2019 by
November, 2019).
259
NLSIU
 A list of authorised parties responsible for the collection and transportation

of hazardous waste from Chandigarh has also been approved by the
Chandigarh PCC.155
Chhattisgarh  As of 2016-17, the total quantity of hazardous waste generated in

Chattisgarh was 65186.14 MTA.
 Chhattisgarh Environment Conservation Board has completed the
inventorzation of hazardous wastes generating unit as per Hazardous and
Other Wastes (Management and Transboundary Movement) Rules,
2016.CECB has issued total 359 nos. of authorization to hazardous waste
generating units as on 20-04-2019. Board has granted authorization to
these units for Generation, Collection, Storage, Transportation, Reception,
Reuse, Recycling, Recovery, Co-Processing, Utilisation, Treatment, Disposal.
As per third party inventorization report total waste quantity is about 3,14,903
MT (Three Lakhs fourteen thousand nine hundred three MT).
 TSDF proposed to be set up.
Daman,
 It has 1937 number of hazardous waste generating units as of 2009.156
Diu, Dadra
 There are 4 individual incineration facilities.
& Nagar
Haveli
Delhi  As of 2016-17, the total quantity of hazardous waste generated in Delhi

was 4197.36 MTA.157
 The stand of the NCT Delhi is that 1,100 hazardous waste generating
units are operating as on 23rd March, 2018158
155 Available at: http://chandigarhenvis.gov.in/beta/departments/cpcc/hwrecyclers.pdf (Last accessed on

11 November 2019).
156 Available at: http://www.ciiwasteexchange.org/wasteinventory/inventory_hw%20in%20india.pdf (Last
November, 2019).
158 Available at: https ://www.dpcc.delhigovt.nic.in/ngt_order_15.05.2019.pdf (Last accessed on 11
November, 2019).
260
NLSIU
 A common TSDF is proposed to be developed at Khanjhawala Village

or Gummanhera Village of Delhi.159
 About 2267 number of Hazardous Waste Authorizations Granted under
the HWM rules.
 An amount of Rs 45.02 Crore has been paid to DSIDC for 50 acres of
land to be developed for TSDF.
Goa  Hazardous waste generating industries –North Goa – 674 , South

Goa – 766.
As of 2009, the quantity of hazardous waste generated in Goa was 26648
MTA.160
Gujarat  It has 7751 number of hazardous waste generating units as of 2009.As

of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was
2811925.3 MTA.161
Following activities have been undertaken by Gujarat SPCB:162
 There are 7 operational TSDFs for the disposal of land disposable
hazardous waste. There 6 common hazardous incineration facilities.163
 GPCB has taken various initiatives for adopting the co-processing concept
under ‘Utilisation of Waste’ so far till March 2019@ 207 Lakh MT
hazardous waste and non-hazardous waste disposed properly by co-
processing of waste at cement industries.
159 Ibid.
160 Available at: https://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id= ahdtzc9ozxdjdgvtxze 0nv9od19pbnzlbnrvcn
lfzmluywxfcmvwb3j0xziwmdkucgrm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
November, 2019).
162 Available at: https://gpcb.gujarat.gov.in/uploads/ar_2018_19_english.pdf (Last accessed on 11
November, 2019).
163 Available at: https://gpcb.gov.in/hazardous-wastes-facilities-in-gujarat.htm (Last accessed on 11
November, 2019).
261
NLSIU
 To boost up the concept of co-processing of waste in cement plants, a

regulatory forum (RF) under the Chairmanship of Member Secretary,
GPCB and Member Secretaries of SPCBs of Andra Pradesh, Rajasthan,
Orissa, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka along with representative of MoEF&CC,
CPCB, CMA and IIP have been constituted.
 The Central Laboratory at Gandhinagar provides facilities for analysis
of hazardous waste samples apart from its regional laboratories located
across the state.
 A Committee has been constituted for finalization of the Registration as
recyclers with environmentally sound management facilities under the
HWM Rules and a committee to finalize the permission for co-processing
of Hazardous Waste and other waste in Cement kiln/Thermal Power
Plants/Steel plants is also in place.
 Identification of site for the disposal of hazardous wastes.
 Processing and finalisation of Consolidated Consents and/ Authorisation
applications under the Water Act, the Air Act and the HWM Rules.
 On 21st May 2014, RO, Gujarat SPCB, Bhuj organised Environmental
Clinic for storage terminals - storage of chemicals & petrochemical,
edible& non edible oil units of Kutch region and cement manufacturing
units of Kutch & Saurashtra region for co-processing & Hazardous
Chemicals Rules including bulk liquid storage of chemicals, petro chemicals
& edible and non-edible oil terminals facing issues of handled/ storage
of hazardous chemicals and petrochemicals areas.
 Online tracking system is developed for movement of hazardous waste.
Haryana  As of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was

58829.43 MTA.164 List of Units authorized by the Haryana State Pollution
Control Board as Reprocessor /Refiner/Recycler of Hazardous Waste
covered under Schedule IV of Hazardous & Other Wastes (Management
& Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016 – 119 in number.
Minister of State in the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, Available at: http:
//www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/generation%20of%20waste.pdf (Last accessed on
11 November, 2019).
262
NLSIU
 Annual Inventory of Hazardous Waste year-wise under HWM Rules is

available for 2016-2017.
 List and detail of Units Registered/Authorized with Haryana SPCB for
Recycling of Hazardous Waste and those units for utilization of Hazardous
and Other Waste as a resource or after pre-processing either for co-
processing or for any other use under HWM Rules are available.165
 A comprehensive procedure for authorization under HWM Rules of
2016 has been prepared and issued on 02.11.2018.166
Himachal  As per 2016-17, the total hazardous waste generated was 29029.38
Pradesh MTA.167 As per Annual Report 2018-19168
 Total Number of HW generating Industries – 2508 ( Note 1033 of
them closed during 2018-19)
 Total Number of HW processing units – 1808.
Jammu &  As of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was
Kashmir169 1043.21 MTA.170
 As per the inventory report of Hazardous wastes 2016-17 prepared by
the Jammu and Kashmir Pollution Control Board, about 1043.21 metric
165 Available at: http: //hspcb.gov.in/cp_menu_hwm.html (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).

166 Available at: http: //hspcb.gov.in/procedurehazardouswaste.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
November, 2019).
168 Available at: https: //hppcb.nic.in/ (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
169 Available at: http: //jkenvis.org/waste_hazardous_jammu_2012.html (Last accessed on 11 November,
2019).
November, 2019).
263
NLSIU
tonnes of hazardous wastes is being generated by 213 hazardous waste

generating units.171
 The hazardous waste generated by the units is being stored, within the
unit premises, in the absence of a TSDF. In specific cases, permission for
transportation of hazardous waste to a TSDF outside the state is granted.
The authorization in some cases is also granted for recycling, reuse and
reprocessing of hazardous waste.
 J&K State Industrial Corporation (SIDCO) has notified 80 kanals of
land for setting up of an Integrated Common Hazardous Waste Treatment,
Storage, Disposal and Recycling facility (ICHWTSDRF) at Phase-II,
Industrial Growth centre (IGC), Samba in village Mandhera, Tehsil and
District Samba. Environmental Clearance has been granted by the
MoEF&CC.
Jharkhand  As of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was

578788.6 MTA.172
 List of Authorized recyclers/ utilizers/ co- processors of hazardous waste
in Jharkhand is 9.173 There is 1 individual incineration facility. Till date no
common TSDF has been developed. There is one common TSDF plant.
Karnataka  As of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was

336791.6 MTA.174
171 Available at: https://www.cpcb.nic.in/openpdffile.php?id=uhvibg ljyxrpb25gawxllze5mjvfmtuyotu

4mjg3nl9tzwrpyxbob3rvmti1os5wzgy= (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
November, 2019).
173 Available at: https: //jspcb.nic.in/ (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
Minister of State in the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change,Available at: http:
//www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/generation%20of%20waste.pdf (Last accessed on 11
November, 2019).
264
NLSIU
 The Karnataka Pollution Control Board has identified 3134 hazardous

waste generating industries in Karnataka and issued authorization.175
 There are 2 TSDF facilities in the State.
 Treatment, Storage, Disposal Facility (TSDF) is established at Dabaspet,
Nelamangala Taluk, Bengaluru Rural District by Ramky Enviro Engineers
on BOOT model basis and same is in operation since 2008.
 One more Treatment, Storage, Disposal Facility (TSDF) is established at
Harohalli Industrial area, Kanakapura Taluk, Ramanagar District by Mother
Earth Environ Tech Pvt Ltd.
 The Board has issued authorization to Six common incineration facilities
in the State.
 The Board has accorded authorization for co-processing of incinerable
hazardous waste in Cement plant. Nine cement plants have established
facilities for handling the incinerable hazardous waste.
Kerala  As of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was

38466.20 MTA.176
 The number of HW waste generating industries is 1215. (Annual report
2017-18)177. Authorisation under HWM Rules is required by generators/
handlers/disposers of hazardous wastes for collection, reception,
treatment, transport, storage and/or disposal of hazardous wastes.
Application for Authorisation is to be submitted to the Regional/District
offices of the Board. The application is available free of cost from all
offices of the Board or can be downloaded from this web site. The
application is to be submitted along with the application for the Integrated
Clearance.
175 Available at: https: //kspcb.gov.in/annual_report_eng_17-18.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).

www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/generation%20of%20waste.pdf (Last accessed on
11 November, 2019).
177 Available at: https: //www.keralapcb.nic.in/ (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
265
NLSIU
 The generators of waste oil/used oil, lead acid batteries, non-ferrous

metals can dispose their waste only by sale/transfer to pre-processors
who have authorisation from the Board and registration with MoEF&CC.
Application form for Registration is available at all offices of the Board
and the Ministry and can also be downloaded from this web site.178
 List of the units in Kerala registered with MoEF/CPCB/SPCB as
recyclers/reprocesses is available in the inventory mentioned above.179
 There is 1 common and 1 individual incineration facilities.180
 The Government of Kerala identified 50 acre of land, meeting the
specifications of the CPCB, in the premises of the FACT, Ambalamedu,
Ernakulam for common TSDF. The construction activities have been
started at the site and are progressing in full swing. Now temporary storage
building, laboratory building and fencing are being provided with priority.
The work is also commenced for the first cell of the land fill facility. For
collection and transportation of wastes, order for sample container has
been placed and is expected to be delivered soon.181
Madhya  As of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was

Pradesh 125880.7 MTA.182
 The number of hazardous waste generation industries in Madhya Pradesh
in 2017-18 amounts to 2564 industries.183
178 Available at: https: //www.keralapcb.nic.in/# (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).

179 Available at: https: //www.keralapcb.nic.in/cmsadmin/fileuploads/inventory_of_ hazardous%
20wastes-ernakulam_up_29-09-2018.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
180 Available at: http://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id= ahdtzc9ozxdjdgvtxze 0nv9od19pbnzlbnrvcnl
fzmluywxfcmvwb3j0xziwmdkucgrm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
181 Available at: https: //www.keralapcb.nic.in/cmsadmin/fileuploads/inventory_of_hazardous%20
wastes-ernakulam_up_29-09-2018.pdf (last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
//www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/generation%20of%20waste.pdf (Last accessed on
11 November, 2019).
183 Available at: http: //www.mppcb.nic.in/proc/final%20report%20-%20hz%20 inventory%202017-
18annual%20reports.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
266
NLSIU
 A separate cell established for this purpose named as “Hazardous Substance

Management Division” (HSMD) at Head Office level. The head office is
supported with a network of Regional Offices across the State for regular
vigil on the Industries. Head office issues Authorization/ renewal to Large
and Medium scale industries while authorizations to small-scale industries
are issued by Regional offices.
 A laboratory developed for characterization of hazardous wastes at its
Research Center, Bhopal. This laboratory has been recognized under EPA
and is carrying out the analysis of Hazardous Wastes Samples.
 Common TSDF located in Madhya Pradesh is having surplus capacities
to handle the present quantities of land disposable waste. It became
operational from November 2006 and has following facilities:
o Temporary storage of wastes.
o Solidification/stabilization.
o Incineration.
o Secured Land Fill.
o ETP for leachates.
o Lab for analytical purposes.
 There are 12 individual incineration facilities.
 Madhya Pradesh SPCB has identified 4 hazardous waste dump sites in
Ratlam and Maksi area.
 10 units in the state have their own Captive Secured land Fill Facility.
 MPSIDC has also identified a site-admeasuring about 50 Acres located in
Pithampur for the said purpose and have called for tenders. Following a
tendering process, RamkyEnviro Engineers Limited has been selected to
take up the job on a BOOT basis, which has been developed in the
name of ‘Madhya Pradesh Waste Management Project’ a division of
RamkyEnviro Engineers Limited. M/s. M.P. Waste Management Facility
(RamkyEnviro Engineers Ltd.,) has been granted consent to establish under
Waster & Air Act (on 05-09-2005 ) as well as Authorization under the
Hazardous Waste (M&H) Rules (on 04-10-2006) for Common TSDF by
MPPCB at Plot No. 104, Industrial Area No. II, Pithampur, Dist. Dhar.184
184 Available at: http: //www.mppcb.nic.in/ctsdfhn.htm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
267
NLSIU
Maharashtra  In Maharashtra, the HSM Division under Maharashtra SPCB deals with
implementation of the policies with regard to hazardous waste man As
of 2009, the total quantity of waste generated was 1568368 MTA.185
 A total of 6353 authorizations were granted to Hazardous Waste
generating units in Maharashtra State. the highest number of authorizations
granted to HW generating units were in Pune Region – 1311 (21%)
followed closely by Kalyan Region – 905 (14%). The lowest number of
authorizations granted was seen to be in Amravati Region – 80 (1%)186
 Activities undertaken by Maharashtra SPCB are as follows:
- It has taken various steps for its proper treatment and disposal by
way of issuing notices and levy of fine.
- Regional officer (HQ) was representative from the Board for
preparation of Guidelines for storage of incinerable Hazardous
Waste by the operator of CHWTSDF and captive hazardous waste
incinerator.
- Regional Officer (HQ) is also committee member for finalization
of amount needed toward maintenance of Esrow/Corpus fund/
Contingency fund/ Insurance policies etc., for post monitoring of
CHWTSDF.
- Regional Officer (HQ) has prepared circular for disposal of date
expired/discarded medicines and drugs. Also prepared circular for
industry generating spent solvents and its reprocess.
- Board is carrying out Environmental Audit with respect to licence
quantity for manufacturing and waste generated out of it.
- Board has developed software for keeping track on hazardous waste
generating units in Maharashtra.
- Installation of GPS for tracking of vehicles transporting hazardous
waste is activated.
- The Board has taken keen interest to implement rules under the
Manufacturing Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules,
1989 wherein it is obligatory for importers of Hazardous Chemical
to inform Board prior to receiving the consignment at port. After
receiving the letter with documents from importers, the Board would
185 Available at: https://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id= ahdtzc9ozxdjdgvtxze 0nv9od 19pbnzlbnrvcnlf

zmluywxfcmvwb3j0xziwmdkucgrm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
186 Available at: http: //www.mpcb.gov.in/node (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
268
NLSIU
inform the Customs to clear the consignment. Board has prepared

proposals to start issuing NOC to such importers.
- Maharashtra SPCB in association with CPCB has organized various
one day seminars for awareness among public and stake holders
for better implementation of Battery (Management & Handling)
Rules 2001.187
- Lists of authorized hazardous waste transporters, reprocessors /
recyclers granted registration for environmental sound management
of hazardous waste and industries authorized by Board for
distillation of Spent Solvents are available.188
- Common facilities for management of Hazardous Waste have been
set up at Taloja, Mahape, Ranjangaon and Butibori.189
- There are 4 Common Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage &
Disposal Facilities (CHWTSDF) installed and operating successfully
in the State of Maharashtra. 2 facilities namely Mumbai Waste
Management (MWM), Taloja and Trans Thane Waste Management
Association (TTCWMA), Mahape, are located under Navi Mumbai
Region; 1 facility namely Maharashtra Enviro Power Ltd (MEPL),
Ranjangaon is located in Pune Region and Vidharbha Enviro
Protection Ltd. (VEPL), Butibori Industrial Area is located in
Nagpur Region. Presently 6353 industries are members of these 4
facilities and are disposing their hazardous waste.
Manipur  As of 2009, the total quantity of waste generated was 252 MTA.190
 It has 264 number of hazardous waste generating units as of 2010.191
However, its contribution towards waste generation of this kind is
considered to be negligible. The last inventory it submitted to the CPCB
was in 2008.192
187 Available at: http: //mpcb.gov.in/images/pdf/hwachievements1011.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).

188 Available at: http: //mpcb.gov.in/hazardous/hazardousmgt.php (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
189 Available at: http: //www.mpcb.gov.in/sites/default/files/about-us/annual-report/mpcb_ar_2017-
18_english_final_01032019.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
190 Available at: https://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id= ahdtzc9ozxdjdgvtxze 0nv9od19
pbnzlbnrvcnlfzmluywxfcmvwb3j0xziwmdkucgrm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
191 Available at: http://environmentclearance.nic.in/writereaddata/form1a/homelinks/tgm_comman%
20hazardous%20waste%20treatment_010910_nk.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
192 Available at: http://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id=ahdtzc 9ozxdjdgvtxze0nv9od 19pbnzlbnrvcnlfzm
luywxfcmvwb3j0xziwmdkucgrm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
269
NLSIU
 There is presently no more information available on the status of hazardous

waste management in the State.
Meghalaya  As per 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was
75.8 MTA.193 Total quantity of Hazardous Wastes generated amounts to
447.435 MT.194 There is a proposal for the development of Common
Hazardous Waste Treatment Storage & Disposal Facility. There is no
treatment process is being followed for hazardous wastes generated by
the units. Since, a centralized hazardous waste management facility is not
in existence in the State of Meghalaya or the neighbouring State, the units
store their landfillable waste within their own premises in a concrete
lined pit. The recyclable wastes are sold to registered recyclers for recycling.
 Government of Meghalaya is in the process of identification of suitable
common landfill site in the vicinity of the Export Promotion Industrial
Park. The Meghalaya SPCB is also exploring the possibility of sharing
the common facilities to be established in the neighbouring state of Assam
in co-ordination with the Assam SPCB.195
Mizoram  The total number of Hazardous wastes generating units is 28.196

 There is presently no more information available on the status of
hazardous waste management in the state.
Nagaland  It has 2 number of hazardous waste generating units as per the inventory
report of hazardous wastes for 2015-2016 submitted by Nagaland
November, 2019).
194 Available at: http://megspcb.gov.in/form/revised%20inventory%20of%20hazardous%20waste-
2017.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
195 Available at: http://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id=ahdtzc9o zxdjdgvtxze0nv 9od19pbnzlbnrvcnl
196 Available at: https://www.indiastat.com/table/environment-and-pollution-data/11/solid-waste/261/
1234223/data.aspx (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
270
NLSIU
SPCB.197 As of 2016-17, the total quantity of waste generated was 10

MTA.198
 A common TSDF for the North East States is to be set up in Assam for
which the Assam PCB is taking the initiative.
Orissa  There are five nos. of Hazardous Waste Generating Units operating in
the City. As of 2016-17, the total quantity of hazardous waste generated
was 595697.8 MTA.199 These units generate Battery Waste, ETP Sludge,
Used Oil, Used Battery and Chemical Residue type of Hazardous Waste.200
 Lists of actual users (processor/recyclers) inside and outside Odisha and
list of Industrial Units/Mines having valid authorization of SPCB are
available.201
 A common TSDF has been commissioned in 2010 by M/s Ramky
Environ Engineer Ltd.202
Pondicherry  It has 127 number of hazardous waste generating units as of 2016-17.203

 Requests were sent to Tamil Nadu SPCB, Chennai, and Andhra Pradesh
SPCB to permit Pondicherry PCC to share the TSDF of these states for
disposal of land fillable Hazardous waste generated in U.T. of Puducherry
until a suitable site is identified by Government of Puducherry. Both the
Boards have informed their inability to share the TSDF available in their
States as well as for Transboundary Movement of Hazardous wastes.
Thus, it was decided to have its own arrangements like installation of
197 Available at: http: //cpcb.nic.in/openpdffile.php?id=uhvibgljyxrpb 25gawxllze5mzjfmtuyotu4mzi1nf

9tzwrpyxbob3rvmtc2ndcucgrm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
November, 2019).
199 Ibid.
200 Available at: http: //orienvis.nic.in/index1.aspx?lid=31&mid=1&langid=1&linkid=29 (Last accessed
201 Available at: http://ospcboard.org/divisions/waste-management-division/hazardous-waste-
management/ (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
202 Available at: http://ospcboard.org/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/annexure-iv-1.pdf (Last accessed
271
NLSIU
incinerator / Secured Land filling as per the CPCB guidelines. A meeting

with the Hazardous waste generators was conducted to evolve of
hazardous waste.
Punjab204  As of 2016, 3136 industries generating Hazardous Waste in Punjab. As

of 2016-17, the total hazardous waste generated was 115490.1 MTA.205
 Common Hazardous Waste disposal facility Installed at Vill. Nimbuan,
Dera Bassi in an area of 21 acres.206
 The PPCB is responsible for collecting data and inspecting and ensuring
proper storage/disposal of hazardous waste in the state. All major
hazardous waste units in the state have installed captive incinerators in
their premises. Now a Common Treatment, Storage and Disposal Facility
(TSDF) has been set up at village Nimbuan, District Mohali. The entire
industrial hazardous waste from Punjab is being stored/disposed at this
facility. The PPCB is also currently laying emphasis on promotion of
clean and no-waste industrial technologies/processes in the state and
organizing awareness programs.
Rajasthan  According to Annual report 2014-15 number of hazardous waste

producing industries is 464 industries. 207 As of 2016-17, the total quantity
of hazardous waste generated was 724663.2 MTA.208
203 Available at: http://www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/files/file/annualenvtsurveyreport2011-

2012.pdf (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
204 Available at: http://punenvis.nic.in/index2.aspx?slid=294&sublinkid=1135&langid=1&mid=1 (Last
November, 2019).
206 Available at:http://punenvis.nic.in/index2.aspx?slid=294&sublinkid=1135&langid=1&mid=1 (Last
1234223/data.aspx (Last accessed 11 November, 2019).
November, 2019).
272
NLSIU
 A TSDF set up for the disposal of land disposable hazardous waste in

2007. There are 5 individual incineration facilities.
 Common TSDF located in Rajasthan does not have adequate capacities
to accommodate the present quantities of land disposable hazardous
waste.209
Sikkim  As of 2016-17, the total number of hazardous wastes generated was

785.472 MTA.210
 CAG Report for Sikkim for the year 2015 reports the following211:
 1,721.16 MT of hazardous wastes were generated against which only
619.04 MT was disposed of at TSDF at Haldia in West Bengal and the
remaining 1,102.12 MT of untreated hazardous waste were not
transported through TSDF. No records available with the Sikkim SPCB
as well as with industries as to how these wastes were disposed of.
 It was seen that Sikkim SPCB had not compiled such inventory using the
annual returns furnished by the occupiers/operators as on date of audit
(July 2015).
 While doing physical inspection (15-16 July 2015) of industries it was
seen that most of these industries kept huge quantity of hazardous waste/
sludge which had accumulated for more than ninety days, that was neither
disposed of in time nor any extension of time was sought from the
Board.· There is presently no more information available on the status
of hazardous waste management in the state.
209 Available at: http: //cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id= ahdtzc9ozxdjdgvtxze 0nv9od19pbnzlbnrvcnl

November, 2019).
211 Available at: https: //cag.gov.in/sites/default/files/audit_report_files/chapter_5_general_sector.pdf
(Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
273
NLSIU
Tamil Nadu  As of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was
383189.2 MTA.212 TNPCB has identified 3,545 units generating hazardous
wastes and issued authorization under the rules. In Tamil Nadu about
6.91 lakhs tons of hazardous waste is annually generated in which 2.97
lakhs tones is landfillable, 3.42 lakhs tones is recyclable and 0.52 lakhs.
tones is incinerable. As of 2009, the total quantity of waste generated
was 258647 MTA.213
 The following activities are undertaken by TNPCB-214
 The Board is taking effective steps in handling and management of
hazardous wastes, its treatment and disposal in an environmentally
safe manner. One common hazardous waste Treatment Storage and
Disposal Facility (TSDF) has been established at SIPCOT Industrial
Estate, Gummidipoondi and another TSDF at Unduorumikidakulam
village in Virudhunagar district is in operation.
 TNPCB has taken pioneering efforts to utilize the hazardous waste
generated from Common Effluent Treatment Plants (CETPs) of
textile processing units as fuel/raw material for co-processing in the
cement factories. So far, about 50,000 Tonnes of ETP sludge have
been disposed to various Cement industries for co-processing. Similar
trails are being taken-up for using hazardous waste generated from
tannery CETPs in co-processing in the cement factories. A common
facility for pre-processing of hazardous waste has been established
in Ranipet. The facility pre-processes the hazardous waste so as to
use the same for co-incineration in cement kiln.
Minister of State in the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change,Available at: http:
November, 2019).
213 Available at: https: //cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id=ahdtzc9ozxdjdgvtxze 0nv9od19pbnzlbnrvcnl
214 Available at: https://www.tnpcb.gov.in/hazardous-waste-managment.php (Last accessed on 11
November, 2019).
274
NLSIU
Tripura  As of 2016-17, the total quantum of hazardous waste generated was

270.19 MTA.215 Most of the production units in Tripura are small-scale
in nature and most of them do not available the Material Safety Data
Sheet (MSDS). Therefore, inventorisation of hazardous waste for this
state can only be done on the basis of medium-scale and large-scale
industrial units. Based on the available information an inventory of
hazardous waste generating units has been prepared by the National
Productivity Council in 2001.216 The total quantum of hazardous waste
generated amounts to 1847.694 MT/year excluding the latex industries
as of 2001.
 Following are the different industrial sectors storing and using hazardous
chemicals in Tripura:217
 Gas gathering stations
 Drug intermediate (Diosgene) producing unit
 Latex processing unit
 LPG bottling plant
 Bottling plant of alcoholic beverages
 Gas distribution pipelines
Uttar  As of 2016-17, the number of hazardous waste generating industries was
Pradesh 2334.218 As of 2009, the total quantity of waste generated was 169294
MTA.219
 Activities taken up by the Uttar Pradesh SPCB220
November, 2019).
216 Available at:https://tspcb.tripura.gov.in/wman.htm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
217 Available at: http://orienvis.nic.in/files/state%20of%20environment%20report%20-%20tripura.pdf
(Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
1234223/data.aspx (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019).
219 Available at: https://cpcb.nic.in/displaypdf.php?id=ahdtzc9ozxdjdgvtxze 0nv9od19pbnzl
bnrvcnlfzmluywxfcmvwb3j0xziwmdkucgrm (Last accessed on 11 November, 2019)
220 Available at: http://upenvis.nic.in/database/household_wastes_829.aspx (Last accessed on 11
November, 2019).
275
NLSIU
- Closure of 45 units operating without any authorization or in

violation of authorization issued under HWM Rules
- Hazardous waste generating units have been directed to display
relevant information through public notices and through conditions
of authorization.
- Out of total inventoried 2159 units, 442 units are reported to be
closed for more than 03 months & 12 units are dismantled. Thus,
1705 units are operational out of which 1705 units have installed
display boards.
- 5 illegal dumping sites were identified in various parts of the State.
- ITRC, Lucknow was short listed for risk assessment/ EIA/
remediation plan for illegal dump sites. ITRC has submitted
preliminary report which has been submitted to CPCB.
- Directions have been given through public notices that hazardous
waste shall in no case be disposed in open and/ or illegal dumping
sites.
- Pesticide waste lying in the old brick kiln at Deva Road, Barabanki
has been shifted to TSDF, Kumbhi, Kanpur Dehat by the responsible
Industry and the site is being used as new car parking area by private
firm.
- Now by the introduction of clean energy fund, CPCB is now to
make DPR for cleaning up the waste and ground water remediation
at three illegal dumpsites i.e. Khanchandpur, Juhi Baburia Kanpur
and Deva Road Barabanki.
- Lohianagar Ghaziabad areas ground water has been found to be
contaminated with Cr+6 although there is no hazardous waste lying
anywhere now. The Lohianagar ground water is being remediated
for Cr+6 by industries as per directions given by UPPCB. The
same has been informed and is first of its kind in India.
- A Nodal cell for the Management of Hazardous Wastes has been
constituted at the Board’s Head Office which looks after Hazardous
waste management along with other assigned routine works.
276
NLSIU
- Common TSDFs for Hazardous Waste disposal are operational/

being developed/ capacity exhausted at 4 sites in Uttar Pradesh.
- Apart from common TSDFs, three industries have their own
captive secured land fills.
- A Booklet printed on Hazardous Waste Management in Uttar
Pradesh in 2007, along with Industrial Hazardous Waste Inventory
and sent to MOEF and CPCB.
- Inventory of Hazardous Waste generating units published in 2007
and revised in April 2010 has been put up on Website
www.uppcb.com and published.
- 281 number of identified Hazardous industries, either recycle
or reuse their waste, therefore, they are not required to take the
membership of any TSDF.
Uttaranchal  As of 2016-17, the amount of industries generating hazardous wastes

are 3671.221
 Uttaranchal has maintained an Inventory of Hazardous Waste
Management for which data until 2016-2017 is available.222
West Bengal  At present there are more than nine hundred (900) nos. hazardous waste
generating units in the State.
 As of 2016-17, the total quantity of waste generated was 85848.74 MTA.223
The activities undertaken by the West Bengal Pollution Control Board are as
follows:224

1234223/data.aspx (Last accessed on November 11, 2019).
222 Available at: http://ueppcb.uk.gov.in/files/industry-wise-annual-inventory-hazardous-waste-2016-
2017-all-district-combined-final_(3).pdf (Last accessed on November 11, 2019).
November, 2019).
224 Available at: https://www.wbpcb.gov.in/hazardous-waste-management (Last accessed on 11 November,
2019).
277
NLSIU
- There is one(1) no. Common Hazardous Waste Treatment, Storage and

Disposal Facility (CHWTSDF) located at Purba Srikrishnapur, Haldia,
Purba Medinipur that caters to all units in the state.
- The CHWTSDF, named M/s West Bengal Waste Management Ltd., was
developed jointly by the Haldia Development Authority (HDA) and
M/s Ramky Enviro Engineers Ltd., a Hyderabad based company under
a Public Private Partnership (PPP). The development was facilitated by
the Department of Environment, Govt. of West Bengal and MoEF, Govt.
of India through financial assistance of Rs. 2 crores each.
5.9 HANDLING AND MANAGEMENT OF HAZARDOUS CHEMICALS IN

STEEL SCRAP UNDER THE STEEL SCRAP RECYCLING POLICY, 2019
5.2.9.1. INTRODUCTION
The Ministry of Steel, Government of India, recently passed the Steel Scrap Recycling
Policy, 2019 which promotes the establishment of metal scrapping centers in India and
facilitates recycling of ferrous, non-ferrous and other non-metallic scraps. The policy
lays down a standard framework and guidelines for collection, dismantling and shredding
activities in an environmentally sound manner. The proposed policy imposes certain
compliances like increased registration charges for private vehicles and increased fitness
certification charges for transport vehicles to de-incentivize such vehicles.225 The
objectives of the Steel Scrap Recycling Policy, 2019 are:
a) To promote circular economy in the steel sector;
b) To promote a formal and scientific collection, dismantling and processing activities

for end of life products that are sources of recyclable (ferrous, non-ferrous and
other non-metallic) scraps which will lead to resource conservation and energy
savings and setting up of an environmentally sound management system for
handling ferrous scrap;
225 Vehicle Scrappage Policy May Bring in Stricter Fitness Norms for Pre-2005 Built Vehicles, The Economic
Times, Available at: http: //economictimes.indiatimes.com/articleshow/71358745.cms? from=mdr&utm_
source= contentofinterest&utm_ medium= text&utm_campaign=cppst. (Last accessed on November 19, 2019).
278
NLSIU
c) Processing and recycling of products in an organized, safe and environment

friendly manner;
d) To evolve a responsive ecosystem by involving all stakeholders;
e) To promote 6R’s principles of Reduce, Reuse, Recycle, Recover, Redesign and
Remanufacture through scientific handling, processing and disposal of all types
of recyclable scraps including nonferrous scraps, through authorized centers/
facility; and
f) To create a mechanism for treating waste streams and residues produced from
dismantling and shredding facilities in compliance to Hazardous & Other Wastes
(Management & Transboundary Movement) Rules, 2016 issued by MoEF & CC.226
The endeavor is to develop a globally competitive market and at the same time to adopt
a state of art environmentally benign technologies for disposal of scrap wastes.
System of Shared Responsibility - The prime feature of policy is the system of shared
responsibility, which would enable the development of appropriate ecosystem in terms
of setting up of Collection, Dismantling centers and Scrap processing centers, either by
independent entrepreneurs or through Joint Ventures between Corporate entities and/or
PSUs. The responsibility is shared among five stakeholders.
Dismantling & Scrap Processing Centers (SCs) - The scrapping centre may develop
facilities, to segregate the processed scrap, based on its composition or chemical analysis,
which would facilitate the downstream industries with quality scraps.
Manufacturers and Extended Producer Responsibility - The Ministry of Road

Transport and Highways (MoRTH) and Department of Heavy Industry (DHI) work
towards “Extended Producer Responsibility” by requiring the vehicle manufacturers to
incentivize the owners of ELVs to voluntarily give their vehicles for scrapping in exchange
for price discounts for purchase of new vehicles. This will also provide for the required
feed to the scrapping centres. The collection and dismantling center and scrap processing
center must issue a Certificate of Destruction (COD) / Proof of scrappage to the owner
226 The Scrap Policy 2019, The Gazette of India, Available at: https: //steel.gov.in/sites/default/files/213770.pdf.
279
NLSIU
of the End of Life Vehicle. The engine parts arising out of the end of life vehicles
should be defaced, or drilled with 6" hole, by the scrapping centres, such that the same
may not be reused in the secondary market.
5.2.9.2. USE AND TREATMENT OF HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCES AND

WASTE
One of the primary objectives of the Policy is to ensure that the waste streams and
residues which is produced from the dismantling and shredding facilities is treated in
compliance with the Hazardous & Other Wastes (Management & Transboundary
Movement) Rules of 2016 and relevant health and safety regulations. The responsibility
to reduce the use of hazardous substances and treatment of waste generated is two-fold.
The responsibility of the Centers should promote a zero discharge system with a
depollution system for processing the end of life goods and scraps. It shall also have
storage for hazardous substances like batteries and condensers. In case they don’t have
adequate facilities to recycle hazardous waste, it should be sold to authorized recyclers
who have adequate capability through a government authorized e-commerce/auction
portal. The responsibility of the automobile manufacturers is to ensure that the use of
lead, mercury, cadmium and other hazardous materials and substances of concern should
be avoided as they do not become a part of the residue and cause air and water pollution.
Thus, the use of recycled materials in the new products should be promoted to keeping
in mind the recyclability of the end of life vehicle. Manufacturers should also undertake
responsibility to make adequate provisions relating to the classification, packaging, labeling
and color scheme for dangerous substances. The centers deal with ferrous and nonferrous
scraps, and ELVs which should produce hazardous waste impacting the environment.
Thus, the Policy provides for the adoption of state-of-the-art environmentally friendly
technologies. The centers should strictly adhere to the statutes and rules issued by the
Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change like Environment (Protection)
Act, 1986, Water and Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Acts, Guidelines for
environmentally sound management of ELVs, 2016 laid down by Central Pollution
Control Board (CPCB)- AIS 219, Waste regulations notified by the Ministry of
Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC), as applicable for the management
and recycling of ELVs, etc.
******
280
NLSIU
6
LAW ON EMERGENCY, REMEDIAL AND PENAL
ACTION IN RELATION TO HAZARDS CAUSED
BY CHEMICAL WASTE
6.1 INTRODUCTION TO CHEMICAL ACCIDENTS AND DISASTERS: AN

OVERVIEW
Rapid industrialization which has seemed to engulf the country also has significantly
increased the risk of vulnerability of the environment, both human and natural. With the
number of factories and industries coming up, the nature of the industrial age is also
evolving. The change and evolution of technology has a seminal role to play in it. It is
but natural that when development happens too quickly in a very short span of time, the
risk of accidents and mishaps increases a lot more. While the industrial units are increasing
in size as well as number, to ease the process and method of setting up and doing business
is getting simpler. Lesser compliance procedures and simpler setting up processes is making
this industry thrive and grow. Common causes of chemical accidents are deficiencies in
safety management, human errors, sabotage and even natural disasters and calamities.
These accidents result in fire endangering life and property, release of toxic gases and
fumes or leakage of chemicals into the surrounding atmosphere and ground highly toxic
and uninhabitable for life. Every time such an event occurs, big or on a small scale, it has
a detrimental effect on human and natural life and thus, certain criterion must be met in
terms of reporting such an occurrence.
At various levels, a number of bodies and authorities are involved which need to take
action for ensuring that the damage as caused is not enhanced and the safety of the plant
has to be assessed to determine whether or not the chemical facility is fit to stay in
operation. Ever since the accident in the Union Carbide Factory in Bhopal and the
disastrous effect it had on the residents then and for years to come, the mechanism of
281
NLSIU
Law on Emergency, Remedial and Penal Action in Relation to Hazards Caused by Chemical Waste
making the chemical industries and factories safe for the people working in them, the
surroundings and making their operations environmentally benign, set stringent measures
have been laid down under various laws, rules and regulations. Similarly, the transport
and handling of chemical and hazardous substances, their storage, its use and eventually
disposal, is all governed by laws and regulations. In the event of any mishap, incident or
untoward accident, the occupier of the chemical facility, whether private or publicly
owned, has liability to compensate for the damage caused, document in detail about the
cause of the incident and submit all reports within a given period of time to all requisite
authorities. Only after a scrutiny is when the defaulted facility granted permission to
start operations again.
Moving ahead, it is to note that the chemical industries are spread over a couple of
States and the ones involving the import and export of chemical and hazardous substances,
are mostly found in the states of Gujarat, Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu,
Karnataka, West Bengal and some fertilizer and pesticide industries in Punjab and
Haryana. The initiatives taken in these particular states must be studied with respect to
hazardous waste management and the preparedness and plan in case of an untoward
accident or incident. The industry being highly polluting and having high potential of
causing permanent damage to nearby environment, the norms and regulations for
environmental safety are strict, along with the regular checks and inspections from
appropriate authorities. The most likely effects are contamination of the soil, groundwater,
water bodies, toxicity which lasts for decades, mutations of the human and plant genetic
structures, chemical residue in food, fire resulting in loss of life and property etc.
occupational health, transport, storage and disposal are main thrust areas which require
proper risk assessment and studies and plans to reduce these risks. The absence in one
place, of a detailed database, which tracks the same, is a gap and a shortcoming which
must be filled expediently, in order to make risk assessment and reduction possible on a
priority basis.
With a diverse spectrum of the chemical industry which is thriving in the country, there
are a host of regulations and laws which are laid down, governing each and every aspect
of the management of chemicals and hazardous substances. On a Central as well as on
the State level, there are functional authorities who have been tasked to regulate, monitor
282
NLSIU
and abate the risks as possessed by this industry. There even are detailed rules on the
action which ought to be taken, in case of an accident, and how best to be prepared for
one, which has been discussed in the earlier chapters; however, we shall be looking into
more of a critique of the same, thus finding some suggestions to better the same. As
brought together by a National Chemical Management Profile for India1 the Environment
(Protection) Act, 1986 serves as an umbrella Act and can link other Acts in one way or
another, without interfering with the autonomy of any other Acts / Rules. Various
Ministries at Central and State level with their regulatory agencies are responsible for
implementing the respective laws. The Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 links the
multilateral environmental agreements through various rules such as Hazardous Waste
(Management and Handling) Rules, 1989 amended in 2000 and 2003 with the Basel
Convention and Ozone Depleting Substances (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000 with
Montreal Protocol- in addition, it serves as an umbrella Act and can link other Acts in
one way or another, without interfering with the autonomy of any other Acts / Rules.
Since the Ministry of Environment & Forests is the nodal ministry for enforcement of
the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and thereby the co-ordinating ministry for
management of chemicals. The Ministries of Commerce and Finance take care of import
and export. The Ministry of Health and Ministry of Agriculture with their concerned
laws handle consumer interest. Ministry of Surface Transport and Ministry of Shipping
ensure implementation of transportation laws. Labour Ministry is concerned with safety
and occupational health and the Industry Ministry is concerned with use of explosives.
This brings us to the question that despite having many regulations in place, why challenges
and issues still exist, such as inspection, vigilance and public awareness about the dangers
and abatement processes of chemical and hazardous substances. Another issue which is
pertinent is that despite the numerous regulations prompting to the number of reports to
be submitted in the event of an accident, about the causal factor, the method in which
the issue was handled and the laws of public insurance liability as followed are all
consolidated in one place and made public documents. This aide’s transparency and
boosts public confidence in the institutional framework. There is also a multitude of
bodies which have been constituted to look into the affairs of the dealing with chemicals
1 Prepared by Ministry of Environment Forests and Climate Change & the Central Pollution Control
Board, with assistance from United Nations Institute for Training and Research.
283
NLSIU
and hazardous substances when there has been an accident, for instance, the Central
Crisis Group which has been setup under the 1989 Rules, to look into the management
of the chemical accidents, the committees constituted in consultation with NGOs and
Industry associations to look into occupational health and safety, under the Factories
Act, to ensure that prior information has been given out in case of hazardous factories
etc.. Maintaining an inventory of hazardous substances is also very scattered as the same
is maintained under the various lists and annexures as provided under the various
International Conventions.
6.2 CHEMICAL AND HAZARDOUS SUBSTANCE ACCIDENTS AND

DISASTERS: AN OVERVIEW OF ENVIRONMENTAL
CONSEQUENCES
The World Health Organisation describes a chemical incident as an unexpected and an

uncontrolled release of a chemical from its containment. More specifically, a chemical
incident which affects the health of the public at large, where two or more people are at
risk of being exposed or are exposed to a chemical. This release is understood as ‘acute’
if the exposure dose is rising rapidly and is understood as ‘chronic’ when the dose is not
rising rapidly and emergency health measures need not be carried out rapidly. However,
it does not mean that the latter does not pose threat of fatality or illness to the exposed
public. These chemical incidents and accidents have affected the people and the
environment in many ways, such as causing an explosion and the effects of the resultant
fire, toxicity of the chemicals and the reaction of these chemicals with human and animal
life, causing poisoning, burning and irritation of the skin and eyes, respiratory disorders
and even instant death. It poisons and contaminates the soil wherever the chemicals
seeps into the ground, thus altering the composition of the soil, pollutes the air by affecting
hundreds of people at once and carries the risk of being spread to other neighbouring
towns and cities as well, thus causing a vast number of people to be at risk from the
chemical leak. While some chemical accidents and leaks cause immediate effect of causing
respiratory and skin issues, some more deadly chemicals cause the human and animal
gene pool to be affected and thus the health issues which are potentially fatal to start
surfacing months and even years after the exposure. The leak in Chernobyl and the leak
in the Union Carbide Factory were such examples where not only did people die instantly,
284
NLSIU
but many generations in the coming years were affected. The state of the environment as
well suffers in the process as with the soil contaminated, there are high chances of the
chemical entering into the food chain and never leaving the plant. Similarly, chemicals in
the gaseous form such as Benzene, Amonium Nitrate etc, cause acid rain and contaminate
large patches of land and pollute even the water bodies.
Following are some of the worst cases of chemical accidents around the world, which
have had a consequence on the human and the natural environment over the years.
6.3 CHEMICAL ACCIDENTS AROUND THE WORLD: IMPACT ON THE

STATE OF ENVIRONMENT
6.3.1 ICMESA, CHEMICAL MANUFACTURING PLANT: THE SEVESO

DISASTER IN 1976
This incident took place in Italy, just outside the city of Milan, where a small chemical
manufacturing plant suffered a mishap and resulted in the exposure of the highest amount
of tetrachloridebenzo-p-dioxin (TCDD) in a residential population. The owner of the
plant was the company ICMESA (Industrie Chimiche Meda Societa ‘Azionaria) which is a
subsidiary of Givaudan, which was further a subsidiary of Hoffmann-La Roche. During
the production of this chemical, it was an exothermic reaction which led to a
mismanagement of the heat and failure of adequately cooling the same. The chemical-
release accident was triggered by an interruption in a batch process before the final step
in the process could be completed i.e. removal of ethylene glycol from the reaction
mixture by distillation. This interruption occurred to show conformity with an Italian
law which required shutdown of plant operations over the weekend. Other parts of the
site had already begun the process of closing down as the processing of other batches
was completed. This led to reduction in power consumption throughout the plant, which
caused a dramatic drop in the load on the turbine. This increased the temperature of the
exhaust steam to 300 °C approx. This steam was much hotter than the regular steam. It
heated the portion of the metal wall of the accident reactor above the level of the liquid
within it and brought it to the same temperature. The operators did not have a steam
temperature reading among their instruments. They were unaware of this additional
heating, so they stopped the batch in a normal manner i.e. by isolating the steam and
285
NLSIU
turning off the stirrer in the reactor vessel2. This led to the heating of the adjacent
reaction mixture by this abnormally-hot upper region of the reactor jacket. The stirrer
was not operating and thus the heating was highly localised. It was primarily confined to
the portion of the upper layers of reaction mixture which were next to the reactor wall.
The local temperature was increased to the point of critical temperature for the exothermic
side reaction as seen during testing phase. But later, the critical temperature was discovered
and proved to be 50 °C lower than that was believed. At such lower critical temperature,
a slow runaway decomposition began which released more amount of heat and led to
beginning of a fast runaway reaction when the temperature climbed to 230°C seven
hours later.3
The reactor valve erupted and caused the release of tonnes of chemicals which then
spread settled over the nearby area. Within a couple of days, many dead animals, especially
poultry and rabbits were discovered. Fearing the chemical would enter the food chain,
many thousands of animals were slaughtered. Numerous children were hospitalised with
skin inflammation and according to reports4 447 people were found to be suffering from
skin diseases like Chloracne. Fourteen years after the accident, a report in 19915 proved
that the most evident health effects was the skin disease and the earliest symptoms was
peripheral neuropathy due to the exposure to the dioxin. A 2001 study6 confirmed in
victims of the disaster, that dioxin is carcinogenic to humans and corroborate its
association with cardiovascular- and endocrine-related effects. In 2009, an update
including 5 more years (up to 1996) found an increase breast cancer. As an effort to
clean-up after this accident, large scale medical monitoring was undertaken where the
Italian government raised the value of compensation and the cases were settled out of
court, the compensation amount was a total of 20 billion lire. Further, five former
employees of ICMESA were sentenced to prison, the sentence ranged from 2.5-5 years.
2 Trevor A. Kletz, Learning from Accidents103–109 (3 ed. Oxford U.K.: gulf professional) (2001).
3 Trevor A. Kletz, What Went Wrong? Case Histories of Process Plant Disasters (1998).
4 Ibid.
5 Bertazzi, Pier Alberto, Long-Term Effects of Chemical Disasters. Lessons and Results from Seveso, the
Science of the Total Environment. 106 (1–2): 5–20 (1991).
6 Bertazzi, et al, Health Effects of Dioxin Exposure: a 20-year Mortality Study, American Journal of
Epidemiology, 153 (11): 1031–1044, (2001).
286
NLSIU
However, where the Court of Appeal in Milan found three of the five, not guilty. But
Finally, sentence against the remaining defendants was confirmed by the Supreme Court
in Rome.
The protection operations handled with the combined efforts of the administrators of
the company and local government have been nicely coordinated. However the incident
was not disclosed publicly and at least a week elapsed before it caught public attention
that dioxin emissions had occurred and evacuation commenced much later then it should
have. As a result, the local populace was caught unaware when the accident happened
and they were unprepared to tackle the spread of an invisible poison. The Industrial
Safety Regulations as passed in European Community in 1982 were called the Seveso
Directive. The Directive imposes very stringent regulations.
Towards the natural environment, the chemical substance TCDD, as per World Health
Organisation7 are detailed as Persistent Environmental Pollutants (POPs) and their
maximum detrimental effect is found on human beings. Though present in the environment
in minute quantities, chemical releases of this TCDD is largely known to cause multiple
organs and system failure in animals and human beings and long term exposure of humans
to high levels of dioxins is linked to the impairment of immune system, nervous system,
endocrine and reproductive systems.
6.3.2 S.S GRANDCAMP: AMMONIUM NITRATE FIRE (1947):
It is known as the deadliest and the most unfortunate accidents in the entire American
history. This accident has been one with the highest number of human life loss. The
accident took place on a French-registered vessel called SS Grandcamp and the cargo it
was carrying, 2,100 metric tons of ammonium nitrate, which caught fire. A series of
unfortunate events followed as this fire triggered many other fires and explosions in the
nearby ships and oil-storage facilities, killing 581 people.8 This accident instituted the
first of its kind lawsuit against the United States Government. The suit was instituted
under the Federal Tort Claims Act, on behalf of the 8,485 victims.
7 Available at: https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/dioxins-and-their-effects-on-

humanhealth (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
8 Hugh W Stephens, the Texas City Disaster, 1947, University of Texas Press, 100 (1997).
287
NLSIU
The district court found the United States responsible for a litany of negligent acts of
omission and commission by 168 named agencies and their representatives in the
manufacture, packaging, and labelling of ammonium nitrate, further compounded by
errors in transport, storage, loading, fire prevention, and fire suppression, all of which
led to the explosions and the subsequent carnage. The Dalehite decision was eventually
“appealed” to the Congress, which granted relief by means of legislation.9 The lesson as
learnt from this accident was the proper labelling and transport precaution that must at
all times be practised while carrying chemicals which are explosive in nature and can
cause an inexhaustible fire.
6.3.3. THIOKOL-WOODBINE EXPLOSION, 1971:
The accident happened in Georgia, where the group of factories which were engaged in
the manufacturing of tripflares for the purpose of use in the Vietnam war. The primary
compound used to make these flares is Magnesium which when burnt, produces a flame
at very high temperatures which is not extinguishable by normal means. Water combines
to create hydrogen gas, which is also highly inflammable gas and the use of carbon
dioxide also in not helpful in extinguishing it. If burned in closed environment, there is a
potentially high risk of building up of heat and pressure which may then detonate in an
uncontrolled fashion causing a large amount of damage.
Once a small fire was observed, they were extinguished and no panic was created,
however, when a conveyor belt caught fire, it was spread across the production line and
reached to the storage room which contained five tons of processed materials and more
than fifty thousand assembled flares.10 Dozens of employees were either killed,
dismembered, or injured by the explosion and the resulting fire. Bodies were hurled to a
height of about 400 feet11 and debris was found more than four thousand feet from
building M-132, which was levelled. Three other surrounding buildings were severely
9 Ibid.
10 Gordon Jackson, Memories Still Shake Florida Times-Union, February 4, 2001, Available at: https:
//www.jacksonville.com/tu-online/stories/020401/met_5309104.html. (Last accessed on November
16, 2019).
288
NLSIU
damaged, and the fire engulfed nearby pine trees, which started a forest fire that eventually
scorched hundreds of acres
Twenty-four people were killed in the blast or died soon after. Five others later died from
their injuries, primarily burns, for a total of 29 deaths. At least 50 individuals suffered
debilitating injuries, including burns and limbs severed by the explosion. Thiokol and the
Government were found to have contributed to the disaster through a series of
communications failures, managerial mistakes and negligence that began long before the
day of the accident.
A 1977 Federal court decision found both the Government and Thiokol liable for damages
arising from the 1971 explosion. Under Georgia workers’ compensation laws, however,
Thiokol’s exposure was limited to $17,000 for each person killed and a lesser amount for
those injured. The Government has been forced to pay the bulk of the damages awarded
so far, more than $7 million.12 Local officials had participated in no disaster planning, and
the scale of the accident overwhelmed the only hospital in the county, a small facility
more than 20 miles from the plant. For the victims of the explosion and for their families,
the disaster uncovered the deficiencies in state workers’ compensation benefits and the
weaknesses of the legal system in resolving conflicts between poor people and the Federal
Government.
6.3.4. PHILIPS DISASTER, 1989:
A factory manufacturing highly flammable materials, suffered a terrible fate, when 23

workers were killed and 314 others gravely injured due to a number of explosions which
occurred in this factory, located in Pasadena, Texas. The mishap occurred during the
process of manufacturing where flammable gases were released from the facility, which
was later discovered, to be a ‘common practice’ at this factory. After the accident took
place, it was found that the safety valves, one for closing and other for opening were
dysfunctional, which was a huge occupational safety risk. These flammable gases, instead
of being released outside the factory, accumulated inside and came into contact with a
11 Ibid.
12 Available at:https: //www.nytimes.com/1986/07/20/business/a-tragedy-in-south-georgia.html (Last
289
NLSIU
point of ignition, which resulted in a number of explosions. The strength of these explosions
was measured 3.5 on the Richter Scale or equivalent to the explosion of 2.5 tons of TNT
inside the plant.13
Upon investigation by the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, it was found
that the plant was in grave violation of a number of safety regulations and codes. An
excerpt from the OSHA report14"…At the conclusion of the investigation (April 19, 1990),
OSHA issued 566 wilful and 9 serious violations with a combined total proposed penalty of
$5,666,200 to Phillips 66 Company and 181 wilful and 12 serious violations with a combined total
proposed penalty of $729,600 to Fish Engineering and Construction, Inc., a maintenance contractor
on the site.”
Despite the ruthlessness of the Phillips Disaster of 1989, the Phillips plant was revived
after upkeeps were made. Today, it employs hundreds of entities and still makes the
same types of plastic compounds. Since the 1989 explosion, there have been three other
major accidents, two of which resulted in loss of life.
6.3.5. WILLIAMS OLEFINS PLANT EXPLOSION, 2013:
A detailed case study15 as published by the United States Chemical Safety and Hazard
Investigation Board, the disaster which occurred in this chemical plant at Louisiana has
been described as catastrophic. Even though it killed two employees, the accident is a
tough reminder about how the safety management of high-risk plants and factories must
not be taken lightly at any given point of time. The incident occurred during a non-
routine operational activity when the heat exchanger was offline which created pressure.
The reboiler shell catastrophically ruptured, causing boiling liquid expanding vapour
explosion and fire. Chemicals released were benzene and propane which are not
environmentally benign. It also released 30,000 pounds of flammable petrochemical
13 A Look Back at the Phillips Disaster of 1989, the Daspite Law Firm, 2014. Available at: https://
www.daspitlaw.com/personal-injury-blog/2014/february/a-look-back-at-the-phillips-disaster-of-1989/
14 Available at:http: //envrionment.blogspot.com/2009/01/phillips-disaster.html (Last accessed on
November 16, 2019).
15 Available at:https: //www.csb.gov/williams-olefins-plant-explosion-and-fire-/(Last accessed on
November 16, 2019).
290
NLSIU
products and by-products into the air that day. According to the report, the facility released
31,187 pounds of volatile organic carbon material, including 23,090 pounds of propylene;
2,398 pounds of ethylene; 5,621 pounds of other volatile organic carbon materials,
including propane; and 48 pounds of benzene. Also released were 85 pounds of soot and
particulate matter.16
6.4 CHEMICAL ACCIDENTS IN INDIA: SHORTCOMINGS OF THE

LEGAL REGULATIONS
6.4.1. CHASNALA MINING DISASTER
On 27 December 1975, a disaster struck the Chasnala colliery, near Dhanbad where a
coal dust explosion in the deep mine led to a blast that damaged the roof barrier with a
huge water body sitting above it. Owing to the formidable flooding of water into the
mine, around 372 lives were lost. The explosion was said to be caused by sparks from
equipment igniting a pocket of methane gas that is produced abundantly in coal mines. 17
While it was tragic that the explosion resulted in the loss of many lives, the environmental
aftermath caused by the emission of methane into the atmosphere has been drastic.
Methane being a short-lived greenhouse gas, traps energy quickly leading to a rise in the
temperature. Upon mine explosions, large quantum of methane trapped underground is
released into the atmosphere thereby deteriorating the air quality and increasing the
atmospheric temperature.
According to a World Bank expert, the disaster was one which could have been avoided
if the mine had not been built within sixty meters of the barrier.18 Under the Mines Act,
1952, coal mine owners are responsible for implementing provisions of safety laid down
by the DGMS (Directorate General of Mines Safety) which was not abided by in this
16 Available at: https: //www.nola.com/news/environment/article_f6c3672e-1a62-533e-a7d6-77e7ef8ff

5b7.html (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
17 Available at: https: //www.nsenergybusiness.com/features/worst-coal-mining-disasters/ (Last accessed
18 Indian Coal Mines: Graveyard of Miners, K. V. Subrahmanyam, Economic and Political Weekly vol. 12,
no. 32 (Aug. 6, 1977). 1252-1254.
291
NLSIU
situation. When the incident took place, there was no particular law that provided for the
reporting and management of chemical disasters. As such, no action was taken and the
colliery was forced to shut down. However, in connection with this disaster, two former
Indian Iron and Steel Company (IISCO) officials were awarded imprisonment on a later
date for their negligence in maintaining the mining site.19
6.4.2 GACL VADODARA
On 5 September, 2002, a major accident took place in a chemical unit in Nandesari,

Vadodara when a tanker in the Gujarat Alkalies Chemicals Limited (GACL) premises
exploded while filling chlorine. It was found out that the said explosion took place owing
to the reaction of the chlorine with moncholoroacetic acid traces in the container.20 This
incident took a death toll of 4 and injured 20 persons.21
The relevant laws that were applicable to prevent this disaster were under the Factories
Act 1948. Section 41B (1) provides for the compulsory disclosure of dangers of a
hazardous process. Furthermore according to sub section (4) the occupier is required to
draw up an On-Site Emergency Plan & Disaster Control Measures for his factory. Further
Rule 4 of the MSHIC (The Manufacture, Storage and Import of Hazardous Chemical
Rules) 1989, requires notification of a major accident. These instances point the need of
effective chemical management which has the propensity of being harmful and fatal.
6.4.3. CHEMICAL FACTORY DOMBIVILI, MUMBAI
The chemical factory blast in Dombilivilli in 2016 resulted in the release of hexane and
is known to be one of the major industrial accidents in India. The legal framework in
19 Available at: http: //www.sankalpindia.net/blog/chasnala-story-betrayal-independence (Last accessed

20 Available at: https: //www.icis.com/explore/resources/news/2002/09/09/180402/chemical-explosion-
at-india-s-gacl-kills-3-injures-17/ (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
21 Available at: http: //moef.gov.in/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/offiste-emergecy-plan-guidelines.pdf
22 Press Information Bureau, Disasters and Accidents in Chemical Industries, 26-August-2010, Available
at: https: //pib.gov.in/newsite/printrelease.aspx?relid=65303 (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
292
NLSIU
order to deal with the chemical industrial accidents were the Manufacture, Storage and
Import of Hazardous Chemical Rules, 1989 as amended in 2000 and the Chemical
Accidents (Emergency Planning, Preparedness and Response) Rules, 1996 and the
Factories Act, 1948 (Amended) 1987.22 Although this incident has not been reported,
there were subsequent instances of chemical factories resulting in fire and causing harmful
effects. This incident brings to light the nature of the chemical industry being susceptible
to fire hazards. The blast occurred in 2016, within the chemical manufacturing industry
Probace Chemical factory in MIDC, Domblivali which resulted in massive fire which
eventually damaged neighbouring factories within the MIDC.23 Currently, there is an
identification of Major Accident Hazard Units by the National Disaster Management
Authority however a need is felt to revamp the legal framework with regard to chemical
accidents.
6.4.4. MATRIX LABORATORY INCIDENT
The chemical accident which occurred in Matrix Laboratory Ltd. in Andhra Pradesh in
2005 caused casualties resulting in the death of 8 persons.24 This accident throws light
on the harmful nature of sodium hydride which caused the accident. Though there is no
reporting of the incident except by recognising it as a chemical accident by the National
Disaster Management Authority, it is clear that the widespread use of sodium hydride in
the synthetic chemical industry without paying sufficient attention to the safety hazards
poses a significant issue in safe handling of these chemicals.25 The nature of sodium
hydride is witnessed by its mixture with certain solvents which has a deeply combustive
reaction which more often than not leads to an explosion.26
23 PTI, Number of Deaths in Dombivli Factory Blast Near Mumbai Rises to 12, May 28, 2016, Available at:
https: //www.ndtv.com/mumbai-news/number-of-deaths-in-dombivli-factory-blast-near-mumbai-
rises-to-121412951 (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
24 National Disaster Management Guidelines- Chemical Disasters, 2007 Available at: https: //nidm.gov.in/
pdf/guidelines/new/chemicaldisaster.pdf, (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
25 Craig Tucker et. Al, Explosion Hazards of Sodium Hydride in Dimethyl Sulfoxide, N,N-
Dimethylformamide, And N,N-Dimethylacetamide, Org. Process Res. Dev. 2019, 23, 10, 2210-2217,
Available at: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.oprd.9b00276 (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
26 Bethany Halford, Chemists Continue to Forget Safety Concerns about Sodium Hydride, Available at:
https: //cen.acs.org/safety/lab-safety/chemists-continue-forget-safety-concerns-about-sodium-hydride/
97/web/2019/08 (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
293
NLSIU
With respect to the legal framework, currently there is a Chemical Laboratories- Code of
Safety published by the Bureau of Indian Standards (IS 4209 : 2013) with respect to the
safety measures to be adopted by laboratories. 27 This incident brings to light the need for
safe handling of chemicals as their use can turn to be hazardous and in the absence of
adequate lab safety practices can prove to be a threat to the safety and health of the
workers in the synthetic chemical industry.
6.4.5. MAYAPURI RADIOLOGICAL INCIDENT
The incident took place in the scrap market of the Mayapuri Industrial Area in Delhi in
2010 as a result of exposure to radioactive emissions which proved fatal to one and
caused injuries to six workers. The radioactive contamination of the imported steel scraps
has said to be the cause of the mishap.28 The exposure of the workers to the acute
radiations emitting from the radioactive isotope Cobalt-60 caused the fatalities. Posing
significant threat as occupational hazards for the safety of the workers coupled with a
need to provide social security measures to the workers affected, an acute radiation of
this sort has far-reaching consequences. The constant exposure to radioactive emissions
in the absence of efficient radioactive emission management has the propensity to cause
substantial harm in the form of health hazards to the workers who have adjacent dwellings
in the industrial area. Subsequently,with the liability fixed on the Delhi University
Chemistry Department, a NGT panel was set up to prevent the reoccurrence of such an
incident and to review the steps taken by the government in this regard. 29 The accident
garnered attention with respect to the effective radioactive emission management and
cast a cloud of doubt on the role of Atomic Energy Regulatory Board (AERB) as an
effective regulator of radiological safety in the country.
27 Indian Standard Chemical Laboratories — Code of Safety (Second Revision), Bureau of Indian
Standards, 2013, Available at:https: //law.resource.org/pub/in/bis/s02/is.4209.1987.pdf (Last accessed
28 R. Ramachandran, Radiation Shock, Available at: https://frontline.thehindu.com/static/html/fl2710/
stories/20100521271002500.htm (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
29 PTI, National Green Tribunal Sets Up Panel to Inspect Mayapuri Scrap Market, Apr 05, 2013, Available
at: https: //economictimes.indiatimes.com/national-green-tribunal-sets-up-panel-to-inspect-mayapuri-
scrap-market/articleshow/19396293.cms?from=mdr (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
294
NLSIU
6.4.6. UNION CARBIDE INDIA LIMITED, 1984
At 11.00 PM on December 2 1984, while the greater part of the one million inhabitants
of Bhopal dozed, an administrator at the plant saw a little hole of methyl isocyanate
(MIC) gas and expanding pressure inside a capacity tank. The vent-gas scrubber, a security
gadget planner to kill poisonous release from the MIC framework, had been killed three
weeks earlier. Obviously a defective valve had permitted one ton of water for cleaning
inside channels to blend in with forty tons of MIC. A 30 ton refrigeration unit that
regularly filled in as a wellbeing segment to cool the MIC stockpiling tank had been
depleted of its coolant for use in another part of the plant. Weight and warmth from the
energetic exothermic response in the tank kept on building. The gas flare security
framework was out of activity and had been for a quarter of a year. At around 1.00 AM,
December 3, uproarious thundering resonated around the plant as a wellbeing valve gave
way sending a crest of MIC gas into the early morning air. Inside hours, the roads of
Bhopal were covered with human cadavers and the corpses of bison, dairy animals,
canines and winged creatures. An expected 3,800 individuals kicked the bucket promptly,
for the most part in the poor ghetto settlement adjoining the UCC plant. Neighbourhood
emergency clinics were before long overpowered with the harmed, an emergency further
intensified by an absence of information on precisely what gas was included and what its
belongings were. It got one of the most exceedingly terrible synthetic fiascos in history
and the name Bhopal got synonymous with modern calamity.
6.5 REFLECTING ON THE LEGAL FRAMEWORK: WHICH LAWS WERE

APPLICABLE ?
The cause of these accidents in one way or the other has been caused by the direct and
inevitable effect of the hazardous nature of the chemicals involved. From the Chasnala
incident, it is quite evident that the legal framework prevalent at that time, i.e the Mines
Act, 1952 did not effectively provide safeguards against the possible occupational hazards
that emerge out of mining activities. The release of methane as a result of mining is
something that ought to be anticipated owing to its highly combustible nature. Although
the said legislation provided for the Occupier to take necessary measures in providing
295
NLSIU
for the safety of the miners in the event of any mining disaster, it did not cover in any
aspect the foreseeable harm which is engendered with the nature of the chemical gases
associated with the mining activity. Furthermore, the absence of any other legislation to
deal with the intricacies of chemical accidents and the subsequent liability/responsibility
upon person responsible for such accidents highlights the absolute inadequacy of the
law to address such issues at that time. The Bhopal Gas Tragedy of 1984 created a sense
of legal consciousness regarding the need for a specific legal framework to deal with the
challenges posed by the ever-expanding growth of the Chemical sector in India. This
being said, the post 1984 legal regime focussed on a rather compensatory approach which
was ex-ante in nature and not on a preventive approach. While this change in the legal
regime was a positive step, it proved ineffective to curb the occurrence of chemical
accidents. From the incidents which took place in GACL, Matrix Laboratory and the
Probace Chemical factory in MIDC, it is evident that the aspects of safe handling of
chemicals were pressing issues which were required to be specifically addressed. The
chemicals being hazardous in nature require a comprehensive regulatory framework with
respect to their use, manufacture and handling. The very fact that these incidents have
not been reported by the respective State governments in itself shows that the magnitude
of these incidents was not truly comprehended and was significantly undermined in
terms of the propensity of damage caused. This calls for a more stringent monitoring
and compliance regime in terms of reporting of chemical accidents. Further, there is a
need for regulating the safe handling procedures in not only chemical laboratories and
chemical manufacturing industries, but also in other industries which use chemicals as
part of their production processes. In the Mayapuri incident, the effective radioactive
emission management in the country was called into question. These emissions are almost
similar to nuclear radiations in terms of their impact and long lasting effects it can cause
on nearby inhabitants. With respect to the nuclear accident in particular, the Civil Nuclear
Liability Bill had not come into effect at that time to deal with fixing of liability upon the
operators. Despite the presence of two alternate legislations focussing on the workers
welfare namely- the Unorganised Sector Worker’s Social Security Act, 2008 and the
National Policy on Safety, Health and Environment at Workplace, 2009, the nascence of
the legal framework was evident as there was no comprehensive legal protection to the
296
NLSIU
workers in terms of compensation and dealing with the niche aspects of a radioactive
emission accident response.30
6.6 ISSUES AND CHALLENGES IN PRODUCTION, STORAGE AND

TRANSPORT OF CHEMICALS IN INDIA:
The first and foremost point to state here is the indomitable difference between chemical
accidents in factories and incidents due to accumulation of chemical waste. Both these
events are results of two different reasons and have different cause and effects. Even the
laws, regarding the same, are different. While one is related more towards harming the
environment and human life for a period of generations, accidents due to chemical
processes cause explosions, fires and leaks which lead to instantaneous destruction of
property, loss of life and also percolate into the natural environment.
Storage and disposal of hazardous waste, is dealt with extensively under various rules
and regulations formulated under the Environment Protection Act, which state the
procedure in which they must be disposed off without causing pollution and harm. The
chemicals being used actively in the industries are regulated and monitored by numerous
statutes and not just the environmental laws, and are scattered all over the legal system.
They are governed under the Factories Act, Disaster Management Act, Environmental
Protection Act and Rules therein, and others. The principle of polluter pays applies
largely and the concept of strict liability is exercised in the case of any leak of hazardous
waste, during its handling and disposal. Whereas, heavy penalty and criminal liability is
placed on the responsible person/s and companies, in case of a negligent act and/or
omission causes an accident in a chemical factory, while the manufacturing process is
underway. It is observed, under the laws governing the same, that a strict and stringent
procedure describing the standard operating procedure in the case of an accident, and
how it must be reported to all local authorities, the fire department, the disaster management
team, state government, police and the state pollution control board and the reports
30 Babu P Remesh & C P Vinod, Radiation Incident in Mayapuri: Disquieting Signals to Labour, Economic
& Political Weekly, July 24, 2010 Vol XLVNo 30, Available at: http: //www.indiaenvironmentportal.org.in/
files/radiation%20incident%20in%20mayapuri.pdf (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
297
NLSIU
which need to be submitted. States which have designated Major Accident Hazards31
have a special duty towards formulating such plans which detail about the handling of
the situation, in case of an accident or incident. Up until recently, such reports have been
made and carried out after the accidents have taking place in Maharashtra, Andhra Pradesh,
Madhya Pradesh etc. but those reports, being voluminous in nature and submitted to
numerous different bodies, are tough to locate. The industries however, keep a strict and
detailed record of the chemicals they use, manufacture, import and export.
With the Government of India’s long term plans of ‘Make in India’, ‘Ease of Doing
Business’, developing Special Economic Zones and Exclusive Economic Zones, the
industry dealing with chemicals is now largely becoming self-dependant and producing
chemicals indigenously, therefore, considering a ban on such products does not seem to
be a viable solution. It is however suggested that the records of industries carrying out
the labelling, marking, observing the procedures and not indulging in flouting of the
norms, along with the overall monitoring mechanism of the chemical industry, must be
regulated and brought under one designated authority. This would greatly better the
situation as the accountability, transparency and ease of channelling liability in case of
any breach would become less tedious.
As can be understood from the accidents that have taken place, the biggest fall-out was
the UCIL factory leak in Bhopal which caused tremendous loss of life and loss of faith
among the citizens of India, whether the country’s regulators are capable of handling the
safety of the people. The company was in obvious breach of all safety parameters with
the storage and handling of the chemicals and the infrastructure of the factory was
obsolete, thus making the accident, a reality. However, in the past couple of years, there
have been minor leaks and fire breakouts in the compounds of gas factories, chemical
storage facilities, but the same have been contained and were not allowed to become
major accidents. This shows the fact that the infrastructure and technology have come a
long way in the developmental sense and it is possible to ensure safety of the workers as
well as the inhabitants around the city. The challenge still happens to be within the
regulatory mechanism, where information about the reports as filed, which department
31 Schedule 2 and 3 under the MSHIC Rules, state that when a site handles more than the threshold limit
and amount of chemicals, the site is regarded as an MAH and is subject to reporting, safety audits and
contingency plan requirements.
298
NLSIU
to spearhead in case of an accident, the channelling of liability (as most facilities are
owned and run by the government) remains unclear.
Noting some of the most common challenges as expressed by the industries in the chemical
sector32 is the absence of adequate infrastructure including common facilities for
scientific disposal of hazardous waste. The main reason for issues arising from pollution
in states such as Gujarat, Maharashtra etc which are hubs for the chemical industries, is
the lack of these facilities. Secondly, the issue is lack of financial resources, shortage
of staff and skilled managerial support, and a lack of standardized protocols and
authority. The Hazardous and Other Wastes (Management and Trans-boundary
Movement) Rules 2016 provides that owners of hazardous waste disposal facilities are
liable to pay financial penalties if the rules of transportation, storage, and recycling of
such waste are not complied with, and may even be imprisoned due to negligence. The
rules also specifically direct the state governments to identify locations for the construction
of hazardous waste treatment facilities. However, no new sites have been built since the
new rules came into effect. Many states like Karnataka, Kerala, Punjab, and Orissa do
not have hazardous waste treatment facilities.33 Through government schemes like the
Swach Bharat Abhiyaan the centre stage seems to have been taken by plastic waste
management and solid waste management, thus, giving lesser impetus to hazardous and
chemical waste management. Lack of collated data with the Central and State
Pollution Control Boards about the quantity of hazardous waste and chemicals is
another issue, as owing to the rapid growth in the industry, the use of chemicals and thus
the rise in the existing hazardous waste, goes unnoticed. The nature of the chemicals and
the very scientific nature of the rules governing them pose a challenge to the existing
regulators such as SPCB, CPCB and NGT to understand and enforce them in the manner
intended.
32 Available at: https: //www.smeventure.com/chemical-manufacturing-industry-india-challenges-

opportunities/ and at <exportersindia.com/blog/opportunities-and-challenges-for-the-indian-chemical-
industry.htm (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
33 The Associated Chambers of Commerce of India (ASSOCHAM) And Price Waterhouse Coopers (PWC).
India Would Need to Bring 88 km2 Land Under Waste Disposal by 2050: Study. 2017. Available at: http:
//www.assocham.org/newsdetail.php?id=6350 (Last accessed on November 16, 2019).
299
NLSIU
6.7 THE MANUFACTURE, STORAGE AND IMPORT OF HAZARDOUS

CHEMICAL RULES, (MSIHC) 1989 AND CHEMICAL ACCIDENTS
(EMERGENCY PLANNING, PREPAREDNESS AND RESPONSE)
RULES, (CAEPR) 1996: A CRITICAL APPRAISAL
It is not only under these rules that a system has been formulated to setup guidelines
about chemicals in the country, but also under other laws, chiefly, the National Disaster
Management Law as well. Various organisations and institutions in the private and not-
for-profit sector as well have published the do’s and dont’s. It was however, under the
MSIHC rules that sites such as the MAH were established only to highlight the places
where maximum amounts of chemicals and hazardous substances were present, so that
those areas could be monitored more closely. The chief inspector of factories, under the
factories act has to closely inspect and monitor the upkeep of these units and ensure that
there are no violations with respect to the factory as well as in the safety of the workers.
State provides for the necessary training programmes, workshops and capacity building
programmes, to keep the management at these facilities up to date with the recent advances
in safety. Various risk response systems and centres have been setup across the country
to serve as a link between the District Crisis Group, as formulated under the CAEPR
Rules, and the industry during an emergency. An inventory of ‘isolated storages’ with
chemicals and their quantities in the country has been undertaken, the data of which is
available on most state’s pollution control websites, and the website of the Ministry of
Chemicals and Fertilizers, the only issue is the regular updating and the authenticity of
the data as provided. Some of the challenges as posed despite the enactment of these
two rules, in the event of an accident are listed as follows:
1. Multiplicity of Rules, Regulations and Protocols: From NDMA (2005) to

Factories Act (1947), Environmental Protection Act and rules, Labour Laws,
Mining Laws etc, each statute has a prescribed format of reporting a mishap
and due to which, there is excessive paperwork and management protocols which
need to be followed. There is a dire requirement of a harmonized approach and
incorporation of a single-window system in tackling the chemical industry.
2. National Level Risk Assessment: No one body assigned specifically for

assessing and identifying the risks associated with the chemical industry, specially,
300
NLSIU
the manner of emergency response, collated data on storage extent of chemicals

etc. and therefore, no insight into the forthcoming risks of the same.
3. Publication of Reports: Even though the regulations and statutes provide the
making of and maintaining of the reports containing all important information
with respect to the manufacture, import, export, storage of and the data regarding
accidents and mishaps in chemical facilities, these reports are not made available
to the public at large, easily. All that is available is the out-dated on-site emergency
plans of industries and the off-site emergency preparedness of the factories
which are not updated annually. Details of the safety audits done in the various
kinds of chemical plants and factories are also not addressing the required safety
requirements, and leaves most to individual discretion.
4. Updated Information on Education, Training and Capacity Development:

It sure is not fair, that the industry today is growing in leaps and bounds, with
technologically advanced patents and practices coming into the industry and
more research and development happening to update the chemical industry while
the capacity building as provided in the regulations remains the same and stays
outdated. The infrastructural facilities in the installations need an upheaval.
5. Medical Preparedness and Response: The regulation, CAEPR, must contain

some basic provision for medical preparedness as well. Ensuring by law, that
trained medical professionals with required expertise shall be the first responders
in event of a crisis situation. With too many levels of groups, it would only add
on to the shifting of responsibility as to who shall be responsible for providing
medical attention. It is in the report prepared by the National Disaster
Management Authority where it states that the standard operating procedure at
the incident site is not laid down. A specific medical preparedness plan is
missing.34
6. Overall Implementation Strategy for Existing Regulations and Procedures:

Upon the observation of the precedent examples of the accidents, there is no
clear information available as to which authority or body has taken the initiative
34 National Disaster Management Guidelines, Chemical Disasters, 2007, page 18.
301
NLSIU
to prosecute the body liable for these accidents and what action was taken to
prevent such accidents in the future. They do get reported, however, the eventual
action as taken and the change in safety procedures do not find mention.
With most focus on the amount of compensation as received and the channelling of the
liability, what loses focus and importance is the need for continuous improvement in the
safety and security aspects. Keeping in mind, the role of the civil society, private players
and the important role of the regulator, certain very strong steps on developing a
strengthened institutional framework for this industry is a must. The CAEPR Rules need
immediate amendment and addition of up to date factors for the collaborative effort of
numerous bodies need to be put together. It is only then, that a wholesome and complete
structure of monitoring, regulation and attempt at mitigating risks arising out of the
handling and managing of the chemicals and hazardous substances would have been
achieved.
******
302
NLSIU

Handbook On Chemicals Hazardous Waste Management Handling in India CEERANLSIU

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Handbook On Chemicals Hazardous Waste Management Handling in India CEERANLSIU

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Handbook On Chemicals Hazardous Waste Management Handling in India CEERANLSIU

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Hand Book on Chemical Waste

CHEMICALS AND HAZARDOUS WASTE

Jointly published by:

CENTRE FOR ENVIRONMENTAL LAW, EDUCATION,

MINISTRY OF ENVIRONMENT, FOREST AND

Copyright @ NLSIU, 2019

Price : INR 500/-

©National Law School of India University, Bengaluru.

Acknowledgment ................................................................................................................... vii

OVERVIEW OF THE CHEMICAL SECTOR IN INDIA .......................... 131

4.7 Global outlook on the need for effective

Prof. (Dr.) Sairam Bhat

Understanding the properties of chemical substances and hazardous wasteis pertinent,

up by international organizations to the likes of United Nations Environment Programme

Collaborative Engagement for Research, Training and Development in Handling of

Prof. (Dr.) M.K. Ramesh Prof. (Dr.) Sairam Bhat

IMDG International Maritime Dangerous Goods

UNCED United Nations Conference on Environment and Development

1.1 UNDERSTANDING CHEMICAL SUBSTANCES:

The Oxford Dictionary defines a chemical as “a distinct compound or substance, especially

1 The Oxford Learner’s Dictionary, Available at: https://www.oxford learners dictionaries.com/definition/

comprising of elements of different chemicals have revolutionized several sectors. Ethyl

1.2 CHEMICAL AND PHYSICAL PROPERTIES OF CHEMICAL

1.3 HAZARDOUS PROPERTIES OF CHEMICAL SUBSTANCES

Explosivity is the property of an explosive substance which could either be a solid or

10 Definition of Explosives, International Labour Organisation, Available at: https:

11 Explosives, Ilpi, Available at: http://www.ilpi.com/msds/ref/explosive.html, (Last accessed on

to gauge the flammability of chemical substances. As a flammable property it is defined

Toxicity can be defined as the property of a substance of being toxic or poisonous. In

In so far as the assessment of toxic parameters of hazardous substances are concerned,

17 Toxicity Testing Overview, Alttox.org, Available at: http: //alttox.org/mapp/toxicity-testing-overview/

The property of a hazardous substance or chemical to eat away, erode or corrode is

1.4 GLOBALLY HARMONIZED SYSTEM FOR CLASSIFICATION AND

 A harmonized criteria for classifying chemical substances and mixtures

 A harmonized system for the communication of hazard elements;(for instance

Enhancing the protection of human

Providing a recognized framework

Reducing the need for testing and

NEED FOR HARMONISED SYSTEM OF LABELLING AS PER GHS

corresponding to a particular kind of hazard - physical, health and environmental and 11

1.4.1 PHYSICAL HAZARDS

Flammable gases: A gas having a flammable Three categories -

Aerosols: Aerosols are non-refillable receptacle Three categories:

Oxidising Gases: An oxidising gas is classified One Category

Gases under pressure: Gases which are contained Four Categories:

Flammable liquids: Flammable liquid is a liquid Four categories: 1,

Flammable solids are solids which are readily Two categories:

Self-reactive substances and mixtures: These Seven categories:

Pyrophoric liquids are liquids which, even in small One Category

Pyrophoric solids are solids that even in small One Category

Self-heating substances and mixtures: A self- Two Categories: 1

Substances and mixtures which, in contact with Three Categories: 1,

Oxidizing liquid: A liquid which, while in itself Three Categories: 1,

Oxidizing solids: A solid which, while in itself is Three Categories: 1,

Organic peroxides: Liquid or solid organic Seven categories:

decomposition; (b) burn rapidly; (c) be sensitive

Corrosive to metals: A substance or a mixture One Category

Desensitized Explosive: They are solid or liquid Four categories: 1,

1.4.2 HEALTH HAZARDS