A Study On Strength Properties of Concrete With Alccofine and Nano Silica As Partial Replacement of Cement
A Study On Strength Properties of Concrete With Alccofine and Nano Silica As Partial Replacement of Cement
A Study On Strength Properties of Concrete With Alccofine and Nano Silica As Partial Replacement of Cement
A Dissertation
Submitted
in partial fulfillment of the requirement for the award of the degree of
MASTER OF TECHNOLOGY IN
STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING
By
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the dissertation work entitled “A STUDY ON STRENGTH PROPERTIES
OF CONCRETE WITH ALCCOFINE AND NANO SILICA AS PARTIAL REPLACEMENT
OF CEMENT” that is being submitted by AAKARAPU SAI PRATHIK, HT No: 15011P0110
in partial fulfillment for the award of Master of Technology in “Structural Engineering” to the
Department of Civil Engineering, JNTUH College of Engineering, KUKATPALLY, Hyderabad, is a
record of bonafide work carried out by him under my guidance and supervision.
The material contained in this report has not been submitted to any university or
Institution for the award of any degree or diploma.
I AAKARAPU SAI PRATHIK, HT. No: 15011P0110 hereby declare that the research
embodied in the present dissertation entitled “A STUDY ON STRENGTH PROPERTIES OF
CONCRETE WITH ALCCOFINE AND NANO SILICA AS PARTIAL REPLACEMENT OF
CEMENT”, which is being submitted to the JNTUH College of Engineering, Kukatpally,
Hyderabad in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the award of the Degree of Master of
Technology in Structural Engineering, Department of Civil Engineering, is a bonafide report of
the work carried out by me.
The material contained in this report has not been submitted to any university or
Institution for the award of any degree or diploma.
3
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
My profound thanks to Dr. P. SRAVANA, Professor and Head of the Department of the
Civil Engineering, JNTUH College of Engineering for her valuable suggestions and help is
carryout this dissertation work.
I express my thankfulness to all lab technicians and lab assistants who have helped me
out in making my project successful.
4
ABSTRACT
Concrete is the world’s second most produced material. With increase in demand for
construction materials the need for concrete has increased exponentially. Mechanical
properties of concrete can be improved by introducing supplementary cementitious material
5
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page No.
CERTIFICATE i
DECLARATION OF CANDIDATE ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT iii
ABSTRACT iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS v
LIST OF TABLES 6
ACRONYMS 6
6
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION 1-6
1.1 General 1
1.2 Alcoffine 1
3.1 General 12
3.2.1 Cement 12
3.2.2 Aggregates 12
3.2.3 Water 14
3.2.5 Alccofine 16
7
3.2.6 Conplast SP430 DIS 16
3.4.1 Mixing 26
4.1 Cement 30
8
4.6 Flexural Strength of AFNS concrete 33
concrete 34
Concrete 35
concrete 36
4.11 Graphs 37
9
CHAPTER 8 PHOTOGRAPHS 53-58
10
LIST OF TABLES
Concrete 31
concrete 31
12
LIST OF GRAPHS
different grades 37
different grades 37
grades 38
grades 38
different grades 39
different grades 39
13
concrete of grade M50 42
14
LIST OF PHOTOGRAPHS
Photograph 2 Alccofine 52
ACRONYMS
15
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1 GENERAL
Concrete is a very strong and versatile construction material which can withstand great
compressive loads. Concrete is mixture of Cement, aggregates and water. Cement is the
mostly used binding material which plays a key role in setting and hardening of concrete. In
modern era, the requirements of concrete cannot be fulfilled by using only Ordinary Portland
cement.
Most of the constructions like high rise buildings, high way bridges where the application
of loads is high demand concrete with high mechanical and durability properties which
cannot be fulfilled by use of ordinary Portland cement.
Strength of concrete can be improved by reducing water cement ratio, changing type of
aggregates or by addition of mineral admixture. Use of supplementary cementitious materials
to enhance performance of concrete are being explored. Production of cement results in
emission of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases which have a negative impact on
environment. Use of supplementary cementitious material produce greener concrete.
Most of recent studies in concrete are inclined towards use of nano materials in concrete.
Nanomaterials are materials whose size varies from 1 to 100nm. Nano materials like nano
silica, Nano clay, Nano alumina, Carbon nano tubes can be used in concrete. Each nano
material acts differently when added to concrete, based on requirements Nano material to be
used is selected.
1.2 ALCCOFINE
ALCCOFINE 1203 is a specially processed product based on slag of high glass content
with high reactivity obtained through the process of controlled granulation. It is also known
as Ultrafine GGBS and Ultrafine slag. Alccofine is a supplementary cementitious material
first produced in India by Ambuja cements which is finer than micro silica and cement. The
main component of Alccofine is Low calcium silicates. The mean particle size is around 4-
6µm. The fineness of Alccofine is due to the proper processed granulation of required
ingredients. Highly sophisticated equipment is used to obtain the uniform particle size
distribution of Alccofine.
16
1.3 EFFECTS OF ALCCOFINE IN CONCRETE
17
1.5 APPLICATIONS OF ALCCOFINE
Concrete with Alccofine can be used as a construction material in special structures like
RCC commercial and residential buildings
Tall structures like High rise buildings
High strength and high performance with low water cement ratio
Shotcrete with increased cohesion and early strength gain
Tunnels in sea beds
Precast concrete structure like hollow core slabs, bridge elements, segemental
construction units
Off-shore piers and platforms
Jetties and ports
Roads and air ports
Alccofine was in Nagpur for construction of its first cable stayed bridge.
Kochi metro in Kerala Alccofine 1203 is being used.
For metro project in Chennai, Alccofine 1101 was used as micro fine cement
grout.
Nano technology deals with applications of nano particles whose size is in scale of
500nm or less. With increase in technology the study of nano particles through SEM analysis
and XRD has been made possible. Over the years, the requirement of high strength has been
increasing. In past years, Concrete of lower grade were sufficient. In modern times, For
constructions beyond the limits of strength of ordinary concrete, use of mineral admixtures
are adopted. High strength cannot be produced just by use of cement, aggregates and water
without any additional mineral admixture. Usually Materials like Silica fume are used to gain
high strength.
Many studies are being conducted over the past years exploring the effects of using
different nano materials in concrete. Nano silica, Nano alumina, Carbon nano tube (CNT),
Polycarboxylates, Titanium oxide, Nano kaolin and Nano clay are some of the widely known
18
nano materials used in concrete industry.
Nano particles when added to concrete can enhance strength in a molecular level. As
the pore volume of concrete increases the strength of concrete decreases. With incorporation
of nano particles, even the smallest of voids between the cement particles are filled producing
dense and compact concrete. Nano particles manipulate or alter the cement matrix system to
provide a new nano scale structure by acting as good filler.
The particle size distribution of nano materials depends on the production. Nano
particles should be manufactured in such a way that it should not alter any chemical
properties or purity of parent materials. Nano particles can be produced in two methods. They
are top to bottom approach and bottom to top approach. Top to bottom approach involves use
of techniques like milling and mechanical attrition. Top to bottom approach is also called as
Nano fabrication. In this method, large size particles are fractured into nano size particles
without influencing any chemical composition. One of the most used technique for top to
bottom approach of production is milling as it requires only milling machine and doesn’t
require any additional equipment for any alterations. Milling not only breaks materials into
nano size particles but also fuses and forms new compound when different particles are used.
The top to bottom approach is mostly utilized in the largescale production of nano materials.
Though the process is economical, it doesn’t ensure quality and homogeneity.
Another method of production of Nano materials is bottom to top approach which is
recognized as molecular Nano technology. In this method Nano particles are formed by
piecing molecular and atomic particles together through chemical formulation. The nano
materials of required size and composition can be obtained through chemical synthesis
technique. Molecular manufacturing is more efficient than nano fabrication. Due to proper
size reduction, uniformity and order, the nano materials produced from chemical synthesis
will have more specific surface area and wide range of applications. Bottom to top approach
is relatively costlier than top to bottom approach. The important techniques for synthesis of
nano materials through bottom to top approach are
Electro-deposition Methods
Sol-Gel
Sono-chemical Methods
Solution Deposition
19
20
1.9 NANO SILICA
21
Improves resistance to abrasion by forming a strong exterior surface due to
improvement of structure in the transition zone of concrete.
Alkali silica reaction is prevented.
Compared to other mineral admixtures, the price of nano silica is high. Due to this
reason, Nano Silica is only used in the self-compacting, high performance and Ultra-
high performance concrete.
Some explorative applications of NS in high performance well cementing slurries,
specialized mortars for rock-matching grouting and gypsum particle board can be
found, but Nano-Silica is not used in practice yet.
Nano-Silica is used mainly as an anti-bleeding agent in HPC and SCC concrete.
Nano-Silica is applied as additive in tiles and eco-concrete mixtures.
Particulate Nano-Silica is applied in oil well cementing slurries in two specific ranges
of particles sizes, i.e., 5 to 50nm and 5 to 30nm.
Normal concrete made with Portland cement undergo several disadvantages. Attempts
to over-come these deficiencies have resulted in the development of special concretes. High
strength concretes have been produced industrially by using superplasticizers or water
reducing admixtures, pozzolonas etc. Over the past 20 years the use of supplementary
cementitious materials in concrete has become very common due to their technological,
economic and environmental benefits. In present study, Alccofine is used as supplementary
cementitious materials. Nano materials can also be incorporated into concrete to enhance
mechanical properties. Nano silica is the most used Nano material in field of concrete
technology. In this present study, use of Nano silica is adopted. The Aim of present research
is to determine the compressive strength, flexural strength and tensile strength at 28,90 and
180 days for M40, M50 and M60 grades of concrete with optimum percentage of alccofine
and Nano silica.
22
CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
In this Study, Nano materials such as nano silica, Cu-Zn ferrite and Ni ferrite were
added to the concrete so as to determine the change in the compressive strength, splitting
tensile strength, flexural strength and modulus of elasticity of concrete. One to five
percentages of nano silica, Cu-Zn ferrite and Ni ferrite were added with respect to the weight
of cementitious materials. Results obtained from experiments conducted were compared with
that of convectional mix and Concrete with silica fumes. The X-ray powder diffraction
(XRD) data for nano materials used in this research were collected using Graphics X-ray
Powder Diffractometer. Structures of nano particles were shown using X-ray diffraction
pattern.
Based on the results obtained from this experimental, it was observed that the
optimum percentage of nano silica to be used is 3%. There was 21%, 44% and 23% increase
in compressive strength, Split tensile strength and flexural strength upon on addition of Nano
silica. It also concludes that use of nano silica significantly reduced workability and high
range water reducer should be used to attain workability.
This research studied the effects of concrete with nano silica and silica fume at high
temperatures. Studies were also done on compressive, tensile strengths, spalling and mass
loss of high strength concrete (HSC) obtained with addition of Nano-Silica at high
temperatures. Different percentages of Nano silica and Silica fume were used in eight
different concrete mixes and Experiments were conducted on samples at different
temperatures at an increase of 20 0C/min. The results obtained concluded that presence of
nano silica in High strength concrete improved mechanical properties even at high
temperatures. Efficient use of nano silica increased tensile strength to prevent loss of strength
and formation of cracks.
23
It was observed from the Compressive strengths obtained from specimen with nano
silica and with silica fume that concrete with nano silica had higher strength than that of
concrete with silica fumes. The maximum compressive strength was obtained when 3% of
nano silica was used.
In this research, Nano materials were added to the concrete to determine the effects of
use of nano materials on compressive strength and flexural strength. The nano materials used
in this research were Nano silica and Nano clay. 24 different mixes of Different proportions
of nano silica and nano clay varying from 0% to 10% were used to cast specimen required to
determine compressive and flexural strength for 7, 28 and 90 days.
The results concluded that use of nano silica and nano clay in either dry or wet condition
enhanced mechanical properties. However, increase in compressive strength due to use of
nano silica was more than that of nano clay. Similarly Increase in flexural strength was
observed on addition of nano silica.
[4] X.F. Wang, Y.J. Huang, G.Y. Wu, C. Fang, D.W. Li, N.X. Han, F. Xing
In this study, experiments were done on light weight aggregate concrete by inclusion
of nano silica. 1%,2% and 3% of nano silica by weight of cement are added to light weight
aggregates to concrete and compared with convectional light weight aggregates to investigate
the effects on nano silica on the compressive strength, early cracking sensitivity and
shrinkage.
The results concluded that there was a significant increase in compressive strength of light
weight aggregate concrete upon addition of 3% of nano silica. With increase in percentage of
nano silica from 1% to 3% the compressive strength also increased. It was observed from the
scanning electronic microscopic images of light weight aggregate with nano silica and
without nano silica that the concrete with 3% nano silica was more compact than the
convectional LWAC.
24
[5] Byung-Wan Jo, Chang-Hyun Kim, Ghi-ho Tae, Jong-Bin Park
[7] Ehsan Ghafaria, Hugo Costab, Eduardo Julio, Antonio Portugalc, Luisa
Duraes
Influence of addition of nano silica and silica fume to the concrete on Strength,
flowability and other properties were studied. The concrete tested consists of mixes with
3%,6%,9% of nano silica as replacement of cement. SEM analysis was done on concrete with
nano silica and without nano silica. Based on the SEM micrographs for different concrete
with percentages, it was noticed that with increase in nano silica content there is decrease in
capillary pore volume which further concludes that the density of concrete increases upon
inclusion of nano silica. The peak percentage of increase in strength was seen when cement is
replaced by 3% of nano silica.
25
[8] M. Pradeep Kumar, K.M. Mini, Murali Rangarajan
Conducted experimental investigations on ordinary Portland cement with inclusion of
ultrafine slag. Cubes and cylinders with different percentage of alccofine were cast to
determine compressive strength, bond strength and resistance to corrosion. SEM analysis and
X ray diffraction analysis were performed on control concrete and concrete with ultrafine
slag. It was noted that addition of alccofine to OPC increased compressive strength as well as
bond strength but reduced workability. Further data obtained from XRD and SEM analysis
revealed that there was change in composition of mixture due to addition of Alccofine and
this is due to alccofine being ultrafine and has higher surface area of particles.
This research was done to report the improvements of strength properties and
durability properties on self compacting concrete which uses Alccofine and Silica fume as
supplementary cementitious materials. The experiments were done on concrete which were
cast with use of varying percentages of silica fumes and alccofine. Seven mixes were
obtained which include control mix, mixes with silica fumes 5%,10% and 15% of cement by
weight and mixes with alccofine 5%,10% and 15% of cement by weight. The experimental
results obtained conclude that use of both silica fume and alccofine i.e, ultrafine GGBS
showed significant increase in compressive and split tensile strength. Based on this research,
replacement of cement with 5,10 and 15% with supplementary cementitious material Strength
properties obtained were greater that of control mixes.
This study presented the influence of GGBS and alccofine on compressive strength
when it replaces cement. Initially concrete were cast by replacing different percentages of
cement with GGBS and the optimum percentage of GGBS is determined. Based on the
results obtained, 20% of cement was replaced with GGBS and further experiments were
conducted to obtain optimum percentage of Alccofine to be used as supplementary
cementitious material. The results concluded that use of both GGBS and ultrafine GGBS
showed less compressive strength than control concrete.
26
[11]Shamshad Ahmad, Mohammad Shakeel, Sirajuddin Ahmed
This study dealt with use of Alccofine as supplementary cementitious materials and
investigates effects of alccofine on compressive strength and durability properties of concrete
made with pozzolanic Portland cement. Five mixes of concrete were produced using 5%,10%
15% and 20% of cement being replaced by alccofine. Compressive strength tests were
conducted for all mixes at 3,7 and 28 days. It was observed that replacement of cement
alccofine gave better early compressive strength. With increase in percentage of alccofine
replaced, the compressive strength was also increased. 28 days strength obtained was highest
for 20% replacement and concrete with alccofine showed better resistance to acid attacks. It
was proved that with the use of alccofine, the increase in strength is due to denser pore
structure & better particle packing.
Described the review of how the supplementary cementitious material alccofine alters the
strength properties of concrete of different water and binder ratios. The percentage of cement
replaced by ultrafine slag is 25% by weight. 0.45,0.4 and 0.38 were water binder ratios used
in this research. Compressive strength, modulus of rupture and split tensile strength were
determined for all mixes after 7 and 28 days of curing and XRD analysis and
thermogravimetric analysis were performed on specimen. Results proved that alccofine can
acts as a feasible supplementary cementitious material.
27
CHAPTER 3
EXPERIMENTAL INVESTIGATION
3.1 GENERAL
In the present study, various experimental investigations are carried out to study the
strength parameters such as compressive strength, flexure strength and split tensile strength
of the concrete. Concrete specimen for these mechanical properties of different grades were
casted with partial replacement of cement with alccofine and nano silica.
3.2.1 CEMENT
In mixing of concrete binding material plays a key role in setting and hardening of
concrete. Cement is the mostly used binding material which sets, hardens and adhere to the
aggregates and binds them together. Generally, cement of different grades is used as per
requirements. Grade of cement usually indicates strength of the cement for a standard cube
after 28 days of curing. 33,43 and 53 are different grades of cement that are available.
In this project, KPC cement of grade 53 is used. The cement has been tested as per IS:
4031-1998 and found to be conforming to all required specifications of IS 12269-2013. The
cement used for this experimental investigation has been taken from a single source without
any lumps and stored in a place free from humidity and atmospheric exposure.
The properties of ordinary Portland cement used for the research are shown in table 4.1.
28
3.2.2 AGGREGATES
Aggregates which can pass through 4.75mm and retained on 150µ are termed as fine
aggregates. Fine aggregate usually consists of Quartz sand, Crushed stone sand and Crushed
gravel sand. Fine aggregates are classified into Grading zone I, Grading zone II, Grading
zone-III, and Grading zone IV. Grading zone can be found by using fineness modulus by
referring to table 4 from IS 383:1970.
Locally available sand is employed as fine aggregate in the present investigation. The
Fine aggregates used in this investigation are tested for various properties and are shown in
the table 4.2.
Aggregates which retain on 4.75mm sieve are termed as coarse aggregates. Coarse
aggregates are larger size materials which acts as inert filler material for concrete in
construction. Coarse aggregates like irregular broken stone or naturally-occurring rounded
gravel, Uncrushed gravel or stone which results from natural disintegration of rock, Crushed
gravel or stone when it results from crushing of gravel or hard stone and partially crushed
gravel or stone are usually used as coarse aggregates.
To determine the physical properties such as gradation, fineness modulus, specific
gravity and bulk density of the coarse aggregate used in this project are tested and results are
shown in table 4.3.
29
3.2.3 WATER
Potable Tap water available was used in this entire experimental investigation. Water
used for concrete mix should be clear and pH should be in range of 6 to 8.
Nano silica is one of the prominent nano materials which can be used as mineral
admixture. Addition of nano silica will enhance strength of the concrete because of its pore
filling effect.
The Nano silica used in this research is procured from Astrra chemicals suppliers in
Chennai, Tamilnadu.
30
3.2.5 ALCCOFINE 1203
ALCCOFINE 1203 is a specially processed product based on slag of high glass
content with high reactivity obtained through the process of controlled granulation. In this
project, Alccofine 1203 used in this research is manufactured by Counto Microfine Products
Pvt. Ltd. Which is a joint venture enterprise of Ambuja Cements Ltd
The physical and chemical properties of alccofine are shown in table below.
Chemical Properties
CaO 32-34 %
SiO2 33-35 %
Al2O3 18-20 %
Fe2O3 1.8-2 %
MgO 8-10 %
SO3 0.3-0.7 %
31
3.2.6 CONPLAST SP430 DIS
Properties
Specific Gravity 1.2±0.02
Chloride content Nil (As per BS 5075 part I)
Air entrainment As per IS 9103
The concrete mix with 15% Alccofine and 3% Nano silica is referred as AFNS mix.
The mix proportions which are adopted to conduct this experimental study designed as per IS
10262:2019 guidelines.
32
3.3.1 DESIGN PROCEDURE FOR M40 CONCRETE
STIPULATIONS FOR PROPORTIONING
f’ck = fck+1.65 S
or f’ck = fck + X whichever is higher.
where f’ck = Target average compressive strength at 28 days,
fck = Characteristic compressive strength at 28 days,
S = Standard deviation (taken from table 1 of IS 10262: 2019)
X = factor based on grade of concrete. (taken from table 2 of IS 10262: 2019)
Target strength is calculated as follows
From table 3 of IS 10262: 2019, For 20 mm nominal maximum size of aggregate, the
amount of entrapped air to be expected in normal concrete is 1.0 percent
The free water-cement ratio required for the target strength of 48.25 N/mm 2 is 0.4 for
OPC 53 grade curve. This is lower than the maximum value prescribed for ‘Moderate’
exposure for reinforced concrete as per Table 5 of IS 456.
From Table 4,
water content = 186 kg (for 50 mm slump) for 20 mm aggregate.
33
Estimated water content for 125 mm slump (increasing at the rate of 3 percent for every 25
mm slump)
Water content = 186+ 9 x (186/100) = 202.74 kg
Due to use of superplasticizer, the water content will be reduced.
23 percent of water content is reduced considering use of superplasticizer at the rate 0.45
percent by weight of cement.
The arrived water content = 160 kg.
From Table 5 of IS 10262: 2019, For 20 mm coarse aggregates and fine aggregate
(Zone II), volume of coarse aggregate for water-cement ratio of 0.50 = 0.62.
And for every ± 0.05 change in water cement ratio, the proportion volume of coarse
aggregate changes at rate of ∓0.01.
For water cement ratio of 0.4, the proportion volume of coarse aggregate should be 0.64.
Volume of fine aggregate content = 1 – 0.64 = 0.36 m3
MIX CALCULATIONS
34
e) Volume of chemical admixture (superplasticizer)
(@ 0.45 percent by mass of cementitious material)
= (Mass of chemical admixture/Specific gravity of admixture) × 1/1000
= 1.8/1.2 ×1/1000 = 0.0015 m3
f) Volume of all in aggregate = 1- (Volume of cement + Volume of water + Volume of
Admixture) - Volume of Entrapped air
= 1- (0.127+0.160+0.0015)-0.01
= 0.70
g) Mass of coarse aggregate = g × volume of coarse aggregate × Specific gravity of
coarse aggregate × 1 000 = 0.70 × 0.64 × 2.79 × 1000 ≈1248 kg.
h) Mass of fine aggregate = g × Volume of fine aggregate × Specific gravity of fine
aggregate × 1 000 = 0.70 × 0.36 × 2.65 × 1000 = 667 kg.
MIX PROPORTIONS
35
APPROXIMATE AIR CONTENT:
From table 3 of IS 10262: 2019, For 20 mm nominal maximum size of aggregate, the amount
of entrapped air to be expected in normal concrete is 1.0 percent.
The free water-cement ratio required for the target strength of 58.25 N/mm 2 is 0.36 for OPC
53 grade curve. This is lower than the maximum value prescribed for ‘Moderate’ exposure
for reinforced concrete as per Table 5 of IS 456.
From Table 5 of IS 10262: 2019, For 20 mm coarse aggregates and fine aggregate (Zone II),
volume of coarse aggregate for water-cement ratio of 0.50 = 0.62.
And for every ± 0.05 change in water cement ratio, the proportion volume of coarse
aggregate changes at rate of ∓0.01.
For water cement ratio of 0.36, the proportion volume of coarse aggregate should be 0.648.
Volume of fine aggregate content = 1 – 0.648 = 0.352 m3
36
MIX CALCULATIONS
MIX PROPORTIONS
37
3.3.3 DESIGN PROCEDURE FOR M60 CONCRETE
STIPULATIONS FOR PROPORTIONING
From table 3 of IS 10262: 2019, For 20 mm nominal maximum size of aggregate, the amount
of entrapped air to be expected in normal concrete is 1.0 percent.
The free water-cement ratio required for the target strength of 68.25 N/mm 2 is 0.3 for OPC 53
grade curve. This is lower than the maximum value prescribed for ‘Moderate’ exposure for
reinforced concrete as per Table 5 of IS 456.
38
PROPORTION OF VOLUME OF COARSE AGGREGATE AND FINE
AGGRAGETE CONTENT
From Table 5 of IS 10262: 2019, For 20 mm coarse aggregates and fine aggregate (Zone II),
volume of coarse aggregate for water-cement ratio of 0.50 = 0.62.
And for every ± 0.05 change in water cement ratio, the proportion volume of coarse
aggregate changes at rate of ∓0.01.
For water cement ratio of 0.3, the proportion volume of coarse aggregate should be 0.66.
Volume of fine aggregate content = 1 – 0.66 = 0.34 m3
MIX CALCULATIONS
39
MIX PROPORTIONS
The optimum percentages of alccofine and nano silica for replacement of cement to enhance
strength are to be considered for this experimental investigation. Based on experimental
investigations conducted by fellow researcher and from literature It was observed that
replacement of cement with 15% of alccofine, there is significant increase in compressive
strength, flexure strength and split tensile strength. Similarly based on studies conducted by
replacing cement with nano silica, it was observed that 3% is the optimum percentage of nano
silica that improve mechanical behavior of concrete.
Mix proportions are calculated for concrete by partial replacement of cement with 15%
of alccofine and 3% nano silica.
As there is replacement of cement with ultrafine and nano material, to attain workability,
the admixture percentage is increased to 2%.
Note : Concrete mix with 15% of alccofine and 3% nano silica as replacement of cement
is referred as AFNS concrete.
40
Chemical admixture = 8 kg/m3
MIX PROPORTIONS FOR M50 WITH 15%AF AND 3%NS REPLACEMENT
41
3.4 PREPARATION OF TEST SPECIMENS
3.4.1 MIXING
Materials required are weighed according to the obtained proportions. Percentage of loss
should also be included in weighs. The mixing is performed in a rotating drum. In case of
control mix, initially coarse aggregates, fine aggregates, cement are added followed by
gradual addition of water with admixture. In case of AFNS mix, initially coarse aggregates,
fine aggregates, cement, alccofine and nano silica are added and mixed thoroughly with
gradual addition of water. Care should be taken while adding and mixing of nano silica as it
is nano material, it may be dispersed in air.
Immediately after mix the workability tests should be conducted on all concrete mixes.
Abram’s slump cone test is conducted on all concrete mixes to determine consistency of
the mixes. The slump of upper diameter 100 mm, lower diameter of 100 mm and height of
300 mm is used for this workability test. This test must be conducted immediately after mix
is done. The apparatus especially the internal surface of the cone should be cleaned
thoroughly and should be free from moisture. oil should be applied on internal surface for
smooth movement of mix.
The cone should be held rigidly on a level surface and concrete should be added in four
layers followed by twenty-five strokes of tamping rod. After filling of cone, the top surface
should be levelled and cone should be lifted vertically. The slump of the mix is then
determined by difference of height of mould and height of concrete.
The slump obtained for control mix is around 100-125mm. The slump obtained for mix
with Nano silica and Alccofine was around 0-10mm. Trails were done by increasing dosage
of admixture from 0.5% to 2%. Even though the admixture dosage was 2% of cement
content, the slump obtained was still same. This is due to presence of Nano silica. Nano silica
and Alccofine have a large specific surface area which promote them to absorb water
molecules and make the mix dry. Further increase in admixture leads to overdose of
admixture which results in significant increase of setting time, however strength will not be
impaired.
This indicates that the addition of Alccofine and nano silica greatly increases the water
demand of concrete mixes.
42
3.4.3 CASTING OF SPECIMEN
Concrete specimen required for compressive strength, flexural strength and split
tensile strength are to be casted. The dimensions specimen casted are as follows:
Cubes of dimension 150 x 150 x 150 mm
Beams of dimension 100 x 100 x 500 mm
Cylinders of dimension 150 Ø x 300 mm
Before casting, the internal surface of the mould should be cleaned and rinsed with
oil. The mix is added into moulds in three layer and is compacted with needle vibrator. AFNS
mix should be compacted properly and longer when compared with that of control mix as it is
zero mix. After filling the moulds the top should be levelled with a trowel. The filling should
be done on a levelled surface. The moulds should be kept undisturbed for 24 hrs and then
demoulding can be done.
In this project, tests are to be conducted after 28,90 and 180 days of curing. After
demoulding the specimen should be marked with date and grade and immersed in curing tank
with fresh water for 28,90 and 180 days.
Tests must be done at scheduled time. The specimen taken from curing taken should
be dried and cleaned in such a way that there should be no moisture on surface of specimen
while testing.
43
3.5 EXPERIMENTS CONDUCTED
The testing apparatus is equipped with a gauge to mounted on top of the rollers. The
load applied when first crack shows up is noted and distance between nearest support and
crack is determined. Flexural strength of concrete is calculated as follows
44
F = PL/bD² for a > 133mm
F = 3Pa/bD² for 133mm > a > 110mm
Spilt tensile strength test is the most commonly used test to determine tensile strength
of concrete specimen. The test is conducted on compression testing machine of capacity
2000KN after 28,90 and 180 days of curing period. The cylinders taken out from curing are
dried and cleaned and tested as per Indian standards. The specimens are placed in
compression testing machine and the plywood strip is placed above the specimen and is
arranged in such a way that the upper plate of CTM is in touch with the plywood strip.
Load is applied gradually without any shock and load at fracture is noted. This
procedure is repeated for other two samples. Split tensile strength of concrete is calculated as
follows
T = 2P/(πDL)
Where T = Split tensile strength of concrete
P = Failure load
D = Diameter of the cylinder
L = Length of Cylinder.
45
CHAPTER 4
EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
4.1 CEMENT
S. No Property Results
3 Soundness 1mm
46
4.3 PROPERTIES OF COARSE AGGREGATES
47
Table 4.4.3 MIX PROPORTIONS OF AFNS CONCRETE (15% AF AND 3% NS)
48
4.6 FLEXURAL STRENGTH OF AFNS CONCRETE AND CONTROL
CONCRETE
Flexural Strength(N/mm2)
Grade Mix
28 days 90 days 180days
CC 4.56 5.18 5.76
M40
AFNS 6.30 6.60 7.01
CC 5.13 5.67 6.20
M50
AFNS 6.91 7.29 7.58
CC 5.85 6.52 7.24
M60
AFNS 7.74 8.12 8.70
49
4.8 PERCENTAGE INCREASE OF COMPRESSIVE STRENGTH OF AFNS
CONCRETE
50
4.9 PERCENTAGE INCREASE OF FLEXURAL STRENGTH OF AFNS
CONCRETE
Age of concrete Flexural strength for Flexural strength for Percentage increase
CC mix (N/mm2) AFNS mix (N/mm2) in Flexural strength
(%)
28 days 5.13 6.91 34.7
90 days 5.67 7.29 28.6
180 days 6.20 7.58 22.26
Age of concrete Flexural strength for Flexural strength for Percentage increase
CC mix AFNS mix (N/mm2) in Flexural strength
(N/mm2) (%)
28 days 5.85 7.74 32.3
90 days 6.52 8.12 24.5
180 days 7.24 8.70 20.17
51
4.10 PERCENTAGE INCREASE OF SPLIT TENSILE STRENGTH OF AFNS
CONCRETE
52
4.11 GRAPHS
53
Variation of Flexural strength
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
Graph 4.3 Shows Variation of Flexural strength of Control concrete of different grades
with respect to Age
Graph 4.4 Shows Variation of Flexural strength of AFNS concrete of different grades
with respect to Age
54
Variation of Split Tensile strength
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
Graph 4.5 Shows Split tensile strength of Control concrete of different grades with
respect to Age
55
Variation of Compressive strength
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
CC AFNS
CC AFNS
56
Variation of Split tensile Strength
7
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
CC AFNS
Graph 4.9 Shows Variation of Split tensile strength of AFNS concrete vs Control
concrete of grade M40 with respect to Age
CC AFNS
57
Variation of Flexural Strength
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
CC AFNS
CC AFNS
58
Variation of Compressive strength
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
CC AFNS
CC AFNS
59
Variation of Split tensile Strength
9
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
CC AFNS
30
25
20
15
10
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
60
Percentage Increase in Flexural strength
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
28 DAYS 90 DAYS 180 DAYS
61
CHAPTER 5
DISCUSSIONS
Cubes of 150 x 150 x 150 mm are casted by replacing 15% of cement with Alccofine
and 3% with Nano silica. Three different grades of specimen were casted and cured for 28,90
and 180 days.
Table 4.5 shows compressive strength of concrete with alccofine and nano silica as
partial replacement of cement for M40, M50 and M60 grades of concrete for 28, 90 and 180
days.
Table 4.8.1 shows comparison of compressive strength of AFNS concrete and control
concrete of grade M40.
Table 4.8.1 shows increase in percentage of compressive strength of AFNS concrete
with respect to control concrete of grade M40 for 28,90 and 180 days as 28.9%, 22.2% and
19.67% respectively.
Table 4.8.2 shows comparison of compressive strength of AFNS concrete and control
concrete of grade M50.
Table 4.8.2 shows increase in percentage of compressive strength of AFNS concrete
with respect to control concrete of grade M50 for 28,90 and 180 days as 20.4%, 15.1% and
13.56% respectively.
Table 4.8.3 shows comparison of compressive strength of AFNS concrete and control
concrete of grade M60.
Table 4.8.3 shows increase in percentage of compressive strength of AFNS concrete
with respect to control concrete of grade M60 for 28,90 and 180 days as 20.7%, 13.5% and
12.28% respectively.
62
For three grades of concrete there is improvement in compressive strength upon replacement
of cement with Alccofine and Nano silica.
Beams of 100 x 100 x 500 mm are casted by replacing 15% of cement with Alccofine
and 3% with Nano silica. Three different grades of specimen were casted and cured for 28,90
and 180 days.
Table 4.6 shows Flexural strength of concrete with alccofine and nano silica as partial
replacement of cement for M40, M50 and M60 grades of concrete for 28, 90 and 180 days.
Table 4.9.1 shows comparison of Flexural strength of AFNS concrete and control concrete of
grade M40.
Table 4.9.1 shows increase in percentage of Flexural strength of AFNS concrete with respect
to control concrete of grade M40 for 28,90 and 180 days as 38.2%, 27.4% and 21.7%
respectively.
Table 4.9.2 shows comparison of Flexural strength of AFNS concrete and control concrete of
grade M50.
Table 4.9.2 shows increase in percentage of Flexural strength of AFNS concrete with respect
to control concrete of grade M50 for 28,90 and 180 days as 34.7 %, 28.6% and 22.26%
respectively.
Table 4.9.3 shows comparison of Flexural strength of AFNS concrete and control concrete of
grade M60.
Table 4.9.3 shows increase in percentage of Flexural strength of AFNS concrete with respect
to control concrete of grade M60 for 28,90 and 180 days as 32.3%, 24.5% and 20.17%
respectively.
For three grades of concrete there is improvement in Flexural strength upon
replacement of cement with Alccofine and Nano silica.
63
5.3 STUDIES ON SPLIT TENSILE STRENGTH OF CONCRETE WITH
ALCCOFINE AND NANO SILICA AS PARTIAL REPLACEMENT OF CEMENT:
Cylinders of 150 Ø x 300 mm are casted by replacing 15% of cement with Alccofine
and 3% with Nano silica. Three different grades of specimen were casted and cured for 28,90
and 180 days.
Table 4.7 shows Split tensile strength of concrete with alccofine and nano silica as partial
replacement of cement for M40, M50 and M60 grades of concrete for 28, 90 and 180 days.
Table 4.10.1 shows comparison of Split tensile strength of AFNS concrete and control
concrete of grade M40.
Table 4.10.1 shows increase in percentage of Split tensile strength of AFNS concrete with
respect to control concrete of grade M40 for 28,90 and 180 days as 35.2%, 24.2% and
19.96% respectively.
Table 4.10.2 shows comparison of Split tensile strength of AFNS concrete and control
concrete of grade M50.
Table 4.10.2 shows increase in percentage of Split tensile strength of AFNS concrete with
respect to control concrete of grade M50 for 28,90 and 180 days as 31 %, 25.8% and 20.37%
respectively.
Table 4.10.3 shows comparison of Split tensile strength of AFNS concrete and control
concrete of grade M60.
Table 4.10.3 shows increase in percentage of Split tensile strength of AFNS concrete with
respect to control concrete of grade M60 for 28,90 and 180 days as 26.2%, 20.5% and
19.02% respectively.
For three grades of concrete there is improvement in split tensile strength upon replacement
of cement with Alccofine and Nano silica.
The combined action of nano silica and alccofine i.e. nucleation and pozzolanic
reaction of nano silica and alccofine results in development of dense microstructure and
increases compactness which enhances strength. The percentage increase in strength is
highest for 28 days. This is due to the pozzolanic reaction which occurs in initial seven days.
The further increase in strength after seven days is only due to filling action.
64
CHAPTER 6
CONCLUSIONS
Based on the experimental investigation conducted and results obtained from tests conducted
in this project. The following conclusions can be drawn
1. Partial replacement of cement with Alccofine and Nano silica significantly improved
the mechanical properties of concrete.
2. The increase in percentage of compressive strength of concrete upon partial
replacement of concrete with 15% Alccofine and 3% Nano silica of grade M40
observed for 28,90 and 180 days are 28.9%, 22.2% and 19.67% respectively.
3. The increase in percentage of Flexural strength of concrete upon partial replacement
of concrete with 15% Alccofine and 3% Nano silica grade M40 observed for 28,90
and 180 days are 38.2%, 27.4% and 21.7% respectively
4. The increase in percentage of Split tensile strength of concrete upon partial
replacement of concrete with 15% Alccofine and 3% Nano silica grade M40 observed
for 28,90 and 180 days are 35.2%, 24.2% and 19.96% respectively.
5. The percentage increase of compressive strength of grade M50 upon replacement of
cement with 15% Alccofine and 3% nano silica was observed to be 20.4%, 15.1% and
13.56% for 28,90 and 180 days respectively.
6. The percentage increase of Flexural strength of grade M50 upon replacement of
cement with 15% Alccofine and 3% nano silica was observed to be 34.7 %, 28.6%
and 22.26% for 28,90 and 180 days respectively.
7. The percentage increase of Split tensile strength of grade M50 upon replacement of
cement with 15% Alccofine and 3% nano silica was observed to be 31 %, 25.8% and
20.37% for 28,90 and 180 days respectively.
8. For M60 grade, it is observed that there is 20.7%, 13.5% and 12.28% increase in
compressive strength on replacement of cement with 15% Alccofine and 3% Nano
silica for 28,90 and 180 days respectively.
9. For M60 grade, it is observed that there is 32.3%, 24.5% and 20.17% increase in
Flexural strength on replacement of cement with 15% Alccofine and 3% Nano silica
for 28,90 and 180 days respectively.
10. For M60 grade, it is observed that there is 26.2%, 20.5% and 19.02% increase in Split
tensile strength on replacement of cement with 15% Alccofine and 3% Nano silica for
28,90 and 180 days respectively.
65
11. The combined action of nano silica and alccofine i.e. nucleation and pozzolanic
reaction of nano silica and alccofine results in development of dense microstructure
and increases compactness which enhances strength.
66
CHAPTER 7
Further study can be carried out on durability properties of concrete with alccofine and
Nano silica.
Further study can be carried out on Concrete with Alccofine and Nano silica by varying
the type of admixtures and their composition to attain workability and strength.
Further study can be carried out on temperature effects on alccofine nano silica concrete.
67
CHAPTER 8
PHOTOGRAPHS
68
Photograph 3 shows Mixing of materials in rotating drum of AFNS concrete Mix
69
Photograph 5 shows Slump of AFNS mix
70
Photograph 7 shows beam specimen of AFNS concrete of Grade M50
71
Photograph 9 shows Compressive strength specimen of AFNS Concrete
72
Photograph 11 shows Split tensile strength specimen of AFNS Concrete
73
CHAPTER 9
REFERENCES
1. Mohamed Amin, Khaled Abu el-hassan “Effect of using different types of nano
materials on mechanical properties of high strength concrete” Elsevier, Construction
and Building Materials.
4. X.F. Wang, Y.J. Huang, G.Y. Wu, C. Fang, D.W. Li, N.X. Han, F. Xing “Effect of
nano-SiO2 on strength, shrinkage and cracking sensitivity of lightweight aggregate
concrete” Construction and Building Materials 175 (2018) 115–125 ScienceDirect.
7. Ehsan Ghafari, Hugo Costa, Eduardo J ´ulio, Antonio Portugal, Luisa Dur ˜ “ The
effect of nanosilica addition on flowability, strength and transport properties of ultra
high performance concrete” Materials and Design 59 (2014) 1–9 ScienceDirect
8. M. Pradeep Kumar, K.M. Mini, Murali Rangarajan “Ultrafine GGBS and calcium
nitrate as concrete admixtures for improved mechanical properties and corrosion
resistance” Construction and Building Materials 182 (2018) 249–257, ScienceDirect.
9. Ardra Mohan, K.M. Mini “Strength and durability studies of SCC incorporating
silica fume and ultrafine GGBS” Construction and Building Materials 171 (2018)
919,ScienceDirect
74
ISSN (Online): 2319-7064 Index Copernicus Value (2013): 6.14 | Impact Factor
(2015): 6.391 Volume 5 Issue 10.
13. Javed Ahmed Naqash, Panga Narasimha Reddy “Properties of Concrete Modified
with Ultra-Fine Slag” Karbala International journal of Modern Science.
14. Saurav, Ashok kumar gupta (2014) “Experimental study of strength relationship of
concrete cube and concrete cylinder using ultrafine slag alccofine” international
journal of scientific & engineering research, volume 5, issue 5.
15. Yatin H patel, P.J.Patel, prof. Jignesh M patel, Dr. H S patel “Study on durability
of high performance concrete with alccofine and fly ash” international journal of
advanced engineering research and studies.
20. Luo Ting, Wang Qiang, Zhuang Shiyu “Effects of ultra-fine ground granulated
blast-furnace slag on initial setting time, fluidity and rheological properties of cement
pastes ” Powder Technology 345 (2019) Elsevier ScienceDirect Powder Technology
22. Susanto Teng, Tze Yang Darren Lim, Bahador Sabet Divsholi “Durability and
mechanical properties of high strength concrete incorporating ultrafine Ground
Granulated Blast-furnace Slag” Construction and Building Materials 40 (2013) 875–
881 ScienceDirect.
75
23. Parveen, Dhirendra Singhal, M. Talha Junaid, Bharat Bhushan Jindal , Ankur
Mehta “Mechanical and microstructural properties of fly ash based geopolymer
concrete incorporating alccofine at ambient curing” Construction and Building
Materials 180 (2018) 298–307 ScienceDirect.
24. S.K. Saxena, Mukesh Kumar, N.B. Singh “Effect of Alccofine powder on the
properties of Pond fly ash based Geopolymer mortar under different conditions” s.
Environmental Technology & Innovation (2018).
25. Abdulkadir Cüneyt Aydına, Vahid Jalilzadian Nasla, Türkay Kotan “The
synergic influence of nano-silica and carbon nano tube on self-compacting concrete”
Journal of Building Engineering, Science direct.
26. Saber Fallah, Mahdi Nematzadeh “Mechanical properties and durability of high-
strength concrete containing macro-polymeric and polypropylene fibers with nano-
silica and silica fume” Science direct.
27. Farid Hasan-Nattaj, Mahdi Nematzadeh “The effect of forta-ferro and steel fibers
on mechanical properties of high-strength concrete with and without silica fume and
nano-silica” ScienceDirect, Construction and Building Materials.
30. M.S. Muhd Norhasri, M.S. Hamidah, A. Mohd Fadzil “Applications of using nano
material in concrete: A review” ScienceDirect, Construction and Building Materials.
76
List of referred code books:
77