CE132 Module
CE132 Module
More than 90% of this recorded fatal road crashes occur in low-and middle-
income countries. More so, 2019 statistics showed that the leading cause of death for
children and young-adults aged 5 to 29 years is road traffic injuries (WHO). The
organization tackles road safety through Decade of Action for Road Safety 2011-2020.
In the Philippines, as of 2018 data, there are a total of 116,906 incidents of road traffic
crashes in Metro Manila alone. On average there were 334 reported accidents per day
with one resulting in fatality, 56 being non-fatal and 276 leading to damages to
property (topgear.com). This leads to the Philippine Road Safety Action Plan 2017-
2022, a program developed by the Department of Transportation adopting a vision of
zero road traffic death, with an interim target to reduce road death rate by at least 20%
by 2022. The interventions are organized according to the Action Plan of the Decade of
Action for Road Safety 2011-2020, focusing on the following: (1) road safety
management, (2) safe roads and mobility; (3) safe vehicles; (4) safe road users; and (5)
post-crash care.
1. Vehicles
Four general classes of design vehicles are (1) passenger cars, (2) buses, (3) trucks, and
(4) recreational vehicles. In the design of any highway facility, the designer should
consider the largest design vehicle that is likely to use that facility with considerable
frequency or a design vehicle with special characteristics appropriate to a particular
location in determining the design of such critical features as radii at intersections and
radii of turning roadways (refer to Table 2.3.1 and Table 2.3.2). As a general rule;
● A passenger car may be selected when the main traffic generator is a parking lot.
● A two-axle single unit truck may be used for intersection design of residential
streets and park roads.
● A three-axle single-unit truck may be used for the design of
collector streets and other facilities where larger single-unit trucks
are likely.
● A bus may be used in the design of highway intersections that are
designated bus routes and that have relatively few large trucks
using them.
Table 2.3.1. Design Vehicle Dimension
Table 2.3.2. Minimum Turning Radii of Design Vehicles
2. Traffic Characteristics
The design of a highway and its features should explicitly cover traffic volumes and
traffic characteristics. Traffic volumes obtained from field studies (such as hourly and
daily traffic volumes, type and weight of vehicles and traffic trends) can indicate the
need for improvement and directly influence the selection of geometric design features,
such as number of lanes, widths, alignments and grades. Relevant studies include
average daily traffic (ADT), peak hour traffic, directional distribution, composition of
traffic, projection of future traffic demands, speed and traffic flow relationships
characterized by the volume flow rate in vehicles per hour, the average speed in
kilometers per hour, and the traffic density in vehicles per kilometer.
3. Physical Elements
These elements include highway capacity, access control and management,
pedestrians, bicycle facilities, safety and environment.
Knowledge of highway capacity is essential to properly fit a planned highway to traffic
demands. Access control to manage interference with through traffic is achieved
through the regulation of public access rights to and from properties abutting the
highway facilities, and can comprise full control, partial control, access management or
driveway/entrance regulations.
Pedestrian facilities including sidewalks, crosswalks, traffic control features, curb cuts,
ramps, bus stops, loading areas, stairs, escalators and elevators warrant due attention in
both rural and urban areas.
Existing streets and highways provide most of the network used by bicycle travel,
making bicycle traffic an important element for consideration in highway design.
Because the number of crashes increases with the number of decisions that need to be
made by the driver, it is in the interest of safety that roadways should be designed to
reduce the need for driver decisions and to reduce unexpected situations.
4. Economic Factors
Highway economics is concerned with the cost of a proposed improvement and the
benefits resulting from it.
On minor, low volume roads, average daily traffic (ADT) normally is sufficient. On
most highways a DHV equal to the 30th highest hourly volume (abbreviated as ‘30
HV’) is usually used for design. On highways with unusual or highly seasonal
fluctuation in traffic flow, it may be necessary to use a design hourly volume other than
the 30 HV.
1. Character of Traffic
All roads should be designed to accommodate trucks, buses, passenger vehicles,
handcarts, cyclists and pedestrians with safety and convenience. A thorough
knowledge of the design vehicle’s weight, dimensions, mobility and other
characteristics is essential for good design.
The vehicle which should be used in design for normal operation is the largest one
which represents a significant percentage of the traffic for the design year. For design
of most highways accommodating truck traffic, one of the design semitrailer
combinations should be used – refer to Table 2.3.1 and Table 2.3.2. A design check
should be made for the largest vehicle expected to ensure that such a vehicle can
negotiate the designated turns, particularly if pavements are curbed. This is done using
a swept path analysis using either turning circle templates or software.
Knowing the predominant character of traffic to use the highway, the required width of
lane could be determined. The total width of a highway is the sum of the widths of
traffic lanes required, dividing islands, curbs and gutter, shoulders and/or walkways,
ditches or gutters, drains and other special features.
2. Design Speed
The design speed is the speed determined for design and correlation of the physical
features of a highway that influence vehicle operation. It is the maximum safe speed
that can be maintained over a specified section of the highway when conditions are so
favorable that the design features of the highway govern. The choice of design is
influenced principally by the character of terrain, the extent of man-made features and
economic considerations. Once selected, it sets the limits for curvature, sight distance
and other geometric features. In the design of a substantial length of highway it is
desirable, although it may not be feasible, to assume a constant design speed on certain
sections. Changes in terrain and other physical controls may dictate a change in design
speed on certain sections. If so, the introduction of a lower or higher design speed
should not be affected abruptly but over a sufficient distance to permit drivers to
change speed gradually before reaching the section of highway with the different
design speed.
When available funds are limited, it is impractical to reduce design speed just to save
construction cost; rather the savings should be on other features.
1. Highway Capacity
Roadway conditions include geometric and other elements. In some cases, these
influence the capacity of a road; in others, they can affect a performance measure such
as speed, but not the capacity or maximum flow rate of the facility.
The horizontal and vertical alignment of a highway depends on the design speed
and the topography of the land on which it is constructed.
In general, the severity of the terrain reduces capacity and service flow rates. This is
significant for two-lane rural highways, where the severity of terrain not only can affect
the operating capabilities of individual vehicles in the traffic stream, but also can
restrict opportunities for passing slow-moving vehicles.
2. Classification of Highway
Certain characteristics distinguish multilane suburban and rural highways from
expressways. For example, vehicles may enter or leave multilane highways at
intersections and driveways, and they can encounter traffic signals.
Design standards for multilane highways tend to be lower than those for expressways,
although a multilane highway approaches expressway conditions as its access points
and turning volumes approach zero. Moreover, the visual setting and the developed
frontage along multilane highways have a greater impact on drivers than they do along
expressways.
The multilane highway is similar to urban streets in many respects, although it lacks
the regularity of traffic signals and tends to have greater control on the number of
access points per kilometer. Also, its design standards are generally higher than those
for urban streets. The speed limits on multilane highways are often 10 to 20 kph higher
than speed limits on urban streets. Pedestrian activity, as well as parking, is minimal,
unlike on urban streets.
Multilane highways differ substantially from two-lane highways, principally because a
driver on a multilane highway is able to pass slower-moving vehicles without using
lanes designated for oncoming traffic. Multilane highways also tend to be located near
urban areas and often connect urban areas; they usually have better design features than
two-lane highways, including horizontal and vertical curvature.
1. Accident information
On all proposed projects, the accident history should be analyzed and potentially
hazardous features and locations identified to determine appropriate safety enhancement.
A study of accidents by location, type, severity, contributing circumstances,
environmental conditions, and time periods may suggest possible safety deficiencies.
Table 2.3.3 and Table 2.3.4 contain the minimum design standards for Philippine
highways and for tourism roads respectively.
Introduction
Geometric design of highways talks about the design of its visible dimensions of
components like horizontal and vertical alignments, cross sections, junctions or
intersections, super elevations, and earthworks. These basic elements are common to all
linear facilities, such as roadways, railways. The primary goal of geometric design is to
create a roadway that is safe, efficient, and cost-effective to operate while maintaining a
high level of aesthetic and environmental quality. Vehicle, driver, and traffic factors all
have an impact on geometric design. The geometric design is a dynamic discipline where
design rules are changed on a regular basis to produce better results for a reason that
these characteristics changes over time.
Geometric design of Railways refers to the importance of tracks to have a proper
geometric design in order to maximize the safety and smooth running of trains at
maximum allowable speed carrying the heaviest load of the axle. The speed and axle load
of the train is important and sometimes included as parameters to be considered while
arriving at the geometric design of railway. This chapter focuses on the fundamentals of
geometric design of highways and railways, and presents standards and examples from
different modes. The order of presentation of material in this chapter is to consider
geometric design of highway first, then geometric design of railway, cross-sections,
vertical alignment, horizontal alignment, super elevation, earthworks, and other design
details. Design guidelines take into account speed, vehicle type, road grade (slope), view
obstructions, and stopping distance. With proper application of guidelines, along with
good engineering judgement, an engineer can design a roadway that is comfortable, safe,
and appealing to the eye.
1. Geometric Design
1.1 Highway Geometric Design
The geometric design of roads is the branch of highway engineering concerned
with the positioning of the physical elements of the roadway according to standards and
constraints. The basic objectives in geometric design are to optimize efficiency and
safety while minimizing cost and environmental damage. Geometric design also affects
an emerging fifth objective called "liveability," which is defined as designing roads to
foster broader community goals, including providing access to employment, schools,
businesses and residences, accommodate a range of travel modes such as walking,
bicycling, transit, and automobiles, and minimizing fuel use, emissions and
environmental damage. Geometric roadway design can be broken into three main parts:
alignment, profile, and cross-section. Combined, they provide a three- dimensional layout
for a roadway.
The alignment is the route of the road, defined as a series of horizontal tangents and
curves.
The profile is the vertical aspect of the road, including crest and sag curves, and the
straight grade lines connecting them.
The cross section shows the position and number of vehicle and bicycle lanes and
sidewalks, along with their cross slope or banking. Cross sections also show drainage
features, pavement structure and other items outside the category of geometric design.
To meet the objective of fitting the highway to site topography and yet satisfy the
safety, service and performance standards, the following considerations have to be
properly addressed in the design process.
Design speed
Design traffic volume
Number of lanes
Level of service (LOS)
Sight distance
Alignment, super-elevation and grades
Cross section
Lane width
Horizontal and vertical clearance
1.1.1 Design Elements Design Speed
The design speed is defined as a selected rate of travel used to determine the
various geometric features of the roadway. The basic purpose in using the design speed
concept is to achieve consistency in the various design elements that influence vehicle
operations. Since many critical design features are predicated upon design speed, the
selection of the proper value is essential to allow for the safe design of a safe street or
highway. The selection of an appropriate design speed is dependent on the predicted
driver behavior and is, therefore, rather complex. This selection of design speed should
receive considerable preliminary investigation and thought so safety will be realized from
the design. The primary basis for selecting the design speed should be a rational
prediction of the probable maximum operating speed (by approximately 90 percent of the
vehicles) on the street or highway. The "average running speed" is not acceptable as a
design speed.
In selecting design speeds, consideration should also be given to pedestrians and
bicycle usage and to the present and future adjacent land use. Recommended minimum
values for design speed are given in the table below. These values should be considered
as general guidelines only.
The maximum normal operating speed is dependent on many variables including
topography, general roadway geometry, frequency of traffic signals or other traffic
control devices, posted speed limit and the degree of enforcement and others.
Design Vehicles
Sight Distance
Sight distance is the roadway ahead that is visible to the driver. Various sight
distance criteria exist in highway geometric design to provide drivers with sufficient
warning of potential obstacle or conflict ahead. Future obstruction to sight distance that
may develop or be constructed should be taken into consideration in the initial design.
Areas outside of the highway right of way that are not under the highway agency's
jurisdiction should be considered as points of obstruction.
Stopping sight distance is the distance ahead that a motorist should be able to see
so that the vehicle can be brought safely to a stop short of an obstruction or foreign object
on the road. This distance will include the driver’s reaction or perception distance and the
distance traveled while the brakes are being applied. The total distance traveled varies
with the initial speed, the brake reaction time, and the coefficient of friction for wet
pavements and average tires. Safe stopping sight distances shall be provided continuously
on all streets and highways. The factors, which determine the minimum distance required
to stop, include:
Vehicle speed
Driver's total reaction time
Characteristics and conditions of the vehicle
Friction capabilities between the tires and the roadway surface
Vertical and horizontal alignment of the roadway
Types of gradients
1. Ruling gradient
The steepest gradient allowed on the track section. It determines the max load that
the locomotive can haul that section. The steep gradient needs more powerful
locomotives, smaller train loads, lower speed, resulting in costly hauling.
2. Momentum Gradient
The gradient on a section which are steeper than the ruling gradient acquire
sufficient momentum to negotiate them are known as momentum gradient.
3. Pusher gradient
As stated above a ruling gradient limits the maximum weight of a train which can
be hauled over the section by a locomotive. If the ruling gradient is so severe on a section
that it needs the help of extra engine to pull the same load than this gradient is known as
pusher of helper gradient. In Darjeeling Railways 1 in 37 pusher gradient is used on
Western Ghats BG Track.
4. Gradient at stations
At stations gradient are provided sufficient low due to following reason:
To prevent movement of standing vehicle
To prevent additional resistance due to grade.
On Indian railways, maximum gradient permitted is 1 in 400 in station yards.
Grade compensation on curves
If a curve is provided on a track with ruling gradient, the resistance of the track
will be increased this curve. In order to avoid resistance beyond the allowable limits, the
gradients are reduced on curves. The reduction in gradient is known as grade
compensation for curves.
1. Cross Sections
The AASHTO “Green Book” defines a roadway cross-section as “a vertical
section of the ground and roadway at right angles to the centreline of the roadway,
including all elements of a highway or street from right-of-way line”. Along with the
vertical alignment (grades and vertical curves) and horizontal alignment (tangents and
curves), the roadway cross-section helps to present a three-dimensional roadway
model. The principal elements of a highway cross section consist of the travel
lanes, shoulders, and medians (for some multilane highways). Marginal elements
include median and roadside barriers, curbs, gutters, guard rails, sidewalks, cross slope
and side slopes. The primary consideration in the design of geometric cross sections for
highways, runways, and taxiways is drainage. Details vary depending on the type of
facility and agency.
Travel Lanes or Traffic Lanes
Travel lane is “the portion of the roadway for the movement of vehicles, exclusive
of shoulders and bicycle lanes”. This area usually contains two or more lanes for roadway
traffic. Travel lanes have a great influence on driving comfort, operational characteristics,
crash probability and level of service. The predominant travel lane on freeways and land
service highways is 12 feet. Drivers typically increase their speeds with wider travel
lanes. Therefore, it may be appropriate to use narrower lane widths that are compatible
with the alignment and intended speed at locations with low design speeds and restricted
alignments. Using a typical lane width of 12 feet reduces maintenance costs and provides
adequate clearance between heavy vehicles on two-lane, two-way rural highways with
high commercial vehicle traffic.
Shoulders
A shoulder is the portion of the roadway contiguous with the travelled way for
accommodation of stopped vehicles, for emergency use, and for lateral support of sub
base, base and surface courses. Some of the more important advantages of providing
shoulders are:
Space for the motorist to pull completely off the roadway for emergencies.
An escape zone to allow motorists to avoid potential accidents or reduce accident
severity.
An aid to driver comforts by creating a sense of openness; improves highway capacity.
An improvement in sight distance in cut sections.\
A provision to enhance lateral clearance for the placement of signs, guide rails, or
other roadside appurtenances.
Space for pedestrians where there is no sidewalk and for bicycle usage
Shoulder surfaces range in width from 2 ft. on minor roads to 12 ft. on major
arterials. Shoulders are also used to laterally support the pavement structure. The
shoulder width is known as either graded or usable, depending on the section of the
shoulder being considered. The graded shoulder width is the whole width of the shoulder
measured from the edge of the travel lane to the intersection of the shoulder slope and the
plane of the side slope. The usable shoulder width is that part of the graded shoulder that
can be used to accommodate parked vehicles. The usable width is the same as the graded
width when the side slope is equal to or flatter than 4:1 (horizontal: vertical), as the
shoulder break is usually rounded to a width between 4 ft. and 6 ft., thereby increasing
the usable width.
Medians
A median is the section of a divided highway that separates the lanes in opposing
directions. This area is located between the edges of opposing travel lanes (including any
left shoulders). Median width and design characteristics are among the most important
safety features of high-speed highways in both urban and rural areas. The principal
functions of a median are to:
Median widths are dependent on the roadway type and location. Any proposed median
widths should be evaluated for potential barrier needs. Ideally, median widths (typically 4
to 80 feet) should be sufficient so that no barrier is needed, when practical. The wider
medians are safer but more costly, requiring more right-of-way, construction and
maintenance. Medians can either be raised, flush, or depressed. Raised medians are
frequently used in urban arterial streets because they facilitate the control of left-turn
traffic at intersections by using part of the median width for left-turn-only lanes. Flush
medians are commonly used on urban arterials. They can also be used on freeways, but
with a median barrier. Depressed medians are generally used on freeways and are more
effective in draining surface water.
Guard Rails
Guard rails are longitudinal barriers placed on the outside of sharp curves and at
sections with high fills. Their main function is to restrain and redirect errant vehicles and
prevent them from leaving the roadway. They are installed at embankments higher than 8
ft. and when shoulder slopes are greater than 4:1. Shapes commonly used include the W
beam and the box beam. The weak post system provides for the post to collapse on
impact, with the rail deflecting and absorbing the energy due to impact.
Sidewalks
Sidewalks are usually provided on roads in urban areas, but are uncommon in
rural areas. Nevertheless, the provision of sidewalks in rural areas should be evaluated
during the planning process to determine sections of the road where they are required.
Generally, sidewalks should be provided when pedestrian traffic is high along main or
high-speed roads in either rural or urban areas. When shoulders are not provided on
arterials, sidewalks are necessary even when pedestrian traffic is low. In urban areas,
sidewalks should also be provided along both sides of collector streets that serve as
pedestrian access to schools, parks, shopping centers, and transit stops, and along
collector streets in commercial areas. Sidewalks should have a minimum clear width of
4 ft. in residential areas and a range of 4 to 8 ft. in commercial areas. To encourage
pedestrians to use sidewalks, they should have all- weather surfaces since pedestrians will
tend to use traffic lanes rather than unpaved sidewalks.
Cross Slope
Pavements on straight sections of two-lane and multilane highways without
medians are sloped from the middle downward to both sides of the highway, resulting in
a transverse or cross slope, with a cross section shape that can be curved, plane or a
combination of the two.
Plane: Slope break at crown line, Uniform slope on each side
Rounded: Parabolic cross-section, Rounded surface at crown line Increasing slope toward edges
The rounded section is beneficial for roadway drainage due to its steepening cross
slope toward the edge of travelled way. However, disadvantages include: difficult
construction; excessive outer lane cross slopes; and pavement transitions at intersection
areas.
Side slopes
Side slopes adjoin the roadway shoulder and are located between the edge of the
shoulder and the right-of-way boundary. Any side slope design needs to improve road
stability and provide adequate recovery space for errant vehicles. Side slopes are also
provided on embankments and fills to provide stability for earthworks. When being
considered as a safety feature, the important sections of the cross slope are the hinge
point, the fore slope, and the toe of the slope. The hinge point should be rounded since it
is potentially hazardous and may cause vehicles to become airborne while crossing it,
resulting in loss of control of the vehicle. The fore slope serves principally as a recovery
area, where vehicle speeds can be reduced and other recovery manoeuvres taken to
regain control of the vehicle. The Toe of Slope is the intersection of fore slope with level
ground or back slope and usually within clear zone and impacted by vehicle.
Figure 2.3 - Divided highway cross section, depressed median, with ditches.
Figure 2.4 - Divided highway cross section, raised median, curbed
High fills or elevated structures. The lack of surrounding objects reduces the driver's
perception of the roadway alignment.
At or near a crest in grade
At or near a low point in a sag or grade
At the end of long tangents
At or near intersections, transit stops, or points of ingress or egress
At or near other decision points
The "broken back" arrangement of curves (short tangent between two curves in
the same direction) should be avoided. This is acceptable only at design speeds of 30 mph
or less. This arrangement produces an unexpected and hazardous situation.
Design Speed
The design speed is the main factor in which geometric design elements depends.
The design speed of roads depends upon the class of the road and the terrain.
Horizontal Curve
A horizontal highway curve is a curve in plan to provide change in direction to
the central line of a road.The centrifugal frorce on a vehicle negotiating a horizontal
curve has two factors:
a. An automobile has a rigis wheel base and only the front wheels can be turned, when this
vehicle takes turn to negotiate a horizontal curve, the rear wheel do not follow the same
path as that of the front wheels. This phenomenon is called off tracking.
b. While two vehicles cross or overtake at horizontal curve there is psychological tendency
to maintain a greater clearance between the vehicle for safety.
c. For greater visibility at curve, the driver have tendency not to follow the central path of
the lane, but to use the outer side at the beginning of the curve.
d. At higher speed superelevation and lateral friction cannot counteract centrifugal force
and skidding may occur.
1. Vehicle speed
2. Acceleration and deceleration
3. Sight distance
4. vehicle operation cost
5. Comfort while travelling at hight speed
Tangent Grades
Tangent grades are designated according to their slopes or grades. Maximum
grades vary, depending on the type of facility, and usually do not constitute an absolute
standard. The effect of a steep grade is to slow down the heavier vehicles and increase
operating costs. Furthermore, the extent to which any vehicle is slowed depends on both
the steepness and length of the grade. The effect of the slowing of the heavier vehicles
depends on the situation, and is often more a matter of traffic analysis than simple
geometric design. Chapter 10, for instance, discusses the effects of slow-moving vehicles
on highway capacity and level of service. As a result, the maximum grade for a given
facility is a matter of judgment, with the tradeoffs usually being cost of construction
versus speed. In the case of railroads, on the other hand, the tradeoff is an economic one,
involving travel time, construction cost, and minimum power/weight ratios for trains on
various grades
Vertical Curves
Changes in grade should be connected by a parabolic curve (the vertical offset
being proportional to the square of the horizontal distance). Vertical curves are required
when the algebraic difference of intersecting grades exceeds the values of maximum
change in grade. Vertical curves used in highway may be classified in to two categories:
Summit curves or crest curves Length of summit curve:
- while designing the length the parabolic summit curves, it is necessary to
consider ssd and osd separately.
- length of summit curve for stopping sight distance (ssd):
The valley curve and its length are designed as a transition curve to fulfil two criteria:
1. Allowable rate of change of centrifugal acceleration or comfort conditions
2. Required head light sight distance for night driving
3. Super- elevation
In the design of highway curves, it is necessary to establish a proper relationship
between curvature of the roadway and design speed. The use of superelevation (rotation
of the roadway about its axis) is employed to counteract centrifugal force and allow
drivers to comfortably and safely travel through curves at the design speed. Advantages
of providing Super elevation:
Super elevation is provided to achieve the higher speed of vehicles.
It increases the stability of fast-moving vehicles when they pass through a horizontal
curve, and it also decreases the stresses on the foundation.
In the absence of super elevation on the road along curves, potholes are likely to occur at
the outer edge of the road.
The Indian Road Congress (IRC) has prescribed the max value of Super Elevation is 1 in
15.
Maximum Super-elevation:
Indian Roads Congress (IRC) had fixed the maximum limit of Superelevation in plan and
rolling terrains and is snow bound areas as 7.0%
On hill roads not bound by snow a maximum Super elevation up to 10% is recommended.
On urban road stretches with frequent intersections, it may be necessary to limit the
maximum super elevation to 4.0%
Minimum Super-elevation:
From drainage consideration it is necessary to have a minimum cross slope to drain off
the surface water. If the calculated super elevation is equal to or less than the camber
of the
road surface, then the minimum super elevation to be provided on horizontal curve may
be limited to the camber of the surface.
Although superelevation is advantageous for traffic operations, various factors
combine to make its use impractical in many built-up areas. Such factors include:
Wide pavement areas
Need to meet grade of adjacent property
Surface drainage considerations
Frequency of cross streets, alleys, and driveway
5. Earthworks
Earthworks are engineering works created through the moving and/or processing
of massive quantities of soil or unformed rock. Earthwork is done to reconfigure the
topography of a site to achieve the design levels. Earthwork involves cutting and filling
to achieve the required topography.
Cutting: Cutting is the process of excavating earth material from a work location to
achieve the desired topography.
Filling: Filling is the process of moving the excavated material or additional earth
material to a work location to achieve the desired topography.
Applications of Earthwork Typically, earthwork is done in the following projects:
Road works
Railways
Irrigation project such as canals and dams
Other common earthwork applications are land grading to reconfigure the topography of
a site, or to stabilize slopes.
References:
https://theconstructor.org/transportation/geometric-design-of-highways-factors/20897/ -
What is Geometric Design of Highways and Factors Affecting it? - The Constructor
https://www.slideshare.net/manivelkln-railway-engineering-geometric-design-of-track-
Railway Engineering - Geometric design of track (slideshare.net)
https://www.slideshare.net/namdeoshashank-geometric-design-76549173Geometric
design (slideshare.net)
https://www.vssut.ac.in/lecture_notes/lecture1423182729.pdf
https://www.accessengineeringlibrary.com/content/book/9780071800129/back-
matter/appendix9
MODULE 5: STRUCTURAL DESIGN OF RAILWAYS AND PAVEMENTS
Bridge Deck- portion of a railway bridge that supplies a means of carrying the
track rails.
STRUCTURAL DESIGN
Ballasted Bridge
A structural design project may be divided into three phases, i.e. planning,
design and construction.
Planning: This phase involves consideration of the various requirements and
factors affecting the general layout and dimensions of the structure and results
in the choice of one or perhaps several alternative types of structure, which
offer the best general solution.
Design: This phase involves a detailed consideration of the alternative solutions
defined in the planning phase and results in the determination of the most
suitable proportions, dimensions and details of the structural elements and
connections for constructing each alternative structural arrangement being
considered.
Construction: This phase involves mobilization of personnel; procurement of
materials and equipment, including their transportation to the site, and actual
on-site erection.
The geometric design of a railway track includes all those parameters which
determine or affect the geometry of the track. These parameters are as
follows.
Gradients are provided to negotiate the rise or fall in the level of the railway
track.
∙ A rising gradient is one in which the track rises in the direction of the movement
of traffic and a down or falling gradient is one in which the track loses
elevation in the direction of the movement of traffic.
∙ A gradient is normally represented by the distance travelled for a rise or fall of
one unit.
∙ Sometimes the gradient is indicated as per cent rise or fall. For example, if there
is a rise of 1 m in 400 m, the gradient is 1 in 400 or 0.25%.
Gradients are provided to meet the following objectives.
(b) Pusher or helper gradient - When the gradient of the ensuing section is
so steep as to necessitate the use of an extra engine for pushing the train, it is
known as a pusher or helper gradient.
(c) Momentum gradient - is steeper than the ruling gradient and can be
overcome by a train because of the momentum it gathers while running on the
section.
(d) Gradients in station yards - are quite flat due to the following reasons.
∙ To prevent standing vehicles from rolling and moving away from the yard
due to the combined effect of gravity and strong winds.
∙ To reduce the additional resistive forces required to start a locomotive to the
extent possible.
Example: Find the steepest gradient on a 2° curve for a BG line with a ruling
gradient of 1 in 200.
Solution
I. SOIL CHARACTERISTICS
2. Surface Texture
∙ fine-textured soils-soils consisting mainly of silts and clays with very small
particle sizes.
∙ coarse-textured soils-soils consisting mainly of sands and gravel with much
larger particles.
II. PROPERTIES OF SOILS-influence their behavior when subjected to external loads
1. Phase Relations-Soil is considered 3 phase system consist of air, water, and solids.
A. Porosity-the ratio of the volume of voids to the total volume of the soil.
Types of pavements:
1. Flexible pavements
2. Rigid pavements
Flexible pavement- will transmit wheel load stresses to the lower layers by
grain-to-grain transfer through the
points of contact in the granular structure (see Figure 1).
Load
• Conventional layered flexible pavement- are layered systems with high
quality expensive materials are placed in the top where stresses are high, and
low quality cheap materials are placed in lower layers.
• Full - depth asphalt pavement- are constructed by placing bituminous layers
directly on the soil sub-grade. This is more suitable when there is high traffic and
local materials are not available.
• Contained rock asphalt mat (CRAM)- are constructed by placing dense/open
graded aggregate layers in between two asphalt layers. Modified dense
graded asphalt concrete is placed above the sub-grade will significantly
reduce the vertical compressive strain on soil sub-grade and protect from
surface water.
Typical layers of a flexible pavement:
• Seal coat- is a thin surface treatment used to water-proof the surface and
to provide skid resistance.
• Tack coat- is a very light application of asphalt, usually asphalt emulsion
diluted with water. It provides proper bonding between two layer of binder
course and must be thin, uniformly cover the entire surface, and set very fast.
• Prime coat- is an application of low viscous cutback bitumen to an absorbent
surface like granular bases on which binder layer is placed. It provides
bonding between two layers. Unlike tack coat, prime coat penetrates into the
layer below, plugs the voids, and forms a water tight surface.
• Surface course- is the layer directly in contact with traffic loads and generally
contains superior quality materials.
• Binder course- This layer provides the bulk of the asphalt concrete
structure. Its chief purpose is to distribute load to the base course.
• Base course- is the layer of material immediately beneath the surface of
binder course and it provides additional load distribution and contributes to
the sub-surface drainage.
• Sub-base course- is the layer of material beneath the base course and the
primary functions are to provide structural support, improve drainage, and
reduce the intrusion of fines from the sub-grade in the pavement structure.
• Top soil or sub-grade- is a layer of natural soil prepared to receive the stresses from
the layers above. It is essential that at no time soil sub-grade is
overstressed.
Design Considerations
The factors considered in the AASHTO procedure for the design of flexible
pavement as presented in the 1993 guide are:
• Pavement performance
• Traffic
• Materials of construction
• Environment
• Drainage
• Reliability
A general equation for the accumulated ESAL for each category of axle load
is obtained as
ESALi = fd X Grn X AADTi X 365 × Ni X FE
ESALi = equivalent accumulated 18,000lb (80 kN) single-axle load for the axle
category i fd = design lane factor
Grn = growth factor for a given growth rate r and design period n AADTi = first
year annual average daily traffic for axle category i Ni = number of axles on
each vehicle in category i
FEi = load equivalency factor for axle category i
Structural Design
3. Learning Outcome
Explain Highway Maintenance and Traffic Safety Management
4. Learning Content
Maintenance calls for periodic and immediate correction of unfavorable conditions. It involves making
the facilities as near the newly constructed or reconstructed conditions a s possible. The utilization of
manpower is what makes the maintenance very costly. Cost could be reduced substantially, if maintenance
operations are done by the use of equipment. Unfortunately, instead of using modern equipment as a
product of modern technology, highway Management return to the use of primitive tools like of traditional
pick, shovels, hoe, scythe, axe or machete.
One particular example is the community Employment Development program (CEDP) with man
objective of giving employment to the people of the rural areas. Large
amount of money was spent for the purchase of traditional primitive tools and for manpower payroll
disturbing several millions for northing except for political gimmicks.
The project was summarily sacrificed when 50% of the appropriation was spent for labor payroll
without accomplishment.
Maintenance of Roadside
The type and kind of roadside maintenance depends upon the following conditions:
1. If the roadside is full of grass, mowing closer to the shoulder is the answer. If necessary, grass at the
roadside be fertilized or treated with lime. In some areas, re-seeding maybe required.
2. If the roadside has dry grass considered as fire hazard, burning or plowing is the solution.
3. If brushes cover the black-slope, trimming is necessary to maintain clearance and sight distance.
Drainage Maintenance
1. Cleaning of ditches, culvert, drop inlets and catch basins to accommodate free flow of water.
2. Removal of sediments, braches and other debris gathered at trash racks, culvert and structures
entrances.
3. Repair of eroded channels and dikes.
4. Riprap and bank protection to prevent recurrence.
Bridge Maintenance
1. For steel bridge structure, the routine maintenance calls for cleaning by sandblasting, flame or other
means of re-painting.
2. Cleaning and re-sealing of deck joints that are extruded or filled with dirt.
3. Repair of drainage handrails.
4. Re-surfacing of rough or slicky deck surface.
5. Correct serious scour around the pier and abutments.
6. Most bridges maintenance is considered specialized work.
Traveling crews exclusively for bridges work alone is a function of the maintenance operations.
7. Concrete bridge decks normally deteriorate due to deicing salts. The problem starts when the sat
penetrates and corrodes the reinforcing steel that spall-off the overlaying concrete.
8. Correction is to remove the concrete, clean the steal and apply new material such as polymer concrete.
9. Sometimes seal-out or overlay of asphalt materials are used as protective covering.
10. Check the bridge deck deterioration by:
a. Applying waterproof membranes.
b. Applying latex modified concrete.
c. Impregnating the deck with polymers.
d. Passing electric current through reinforcing steel.
11. If decks are dismantled, an epoxy coated reinforcing steel may be used.
Traffic Service
Before, maintenance is regarded as secondary functions of the Highway agency. The personnel of
the maintenance sections.
Often felt that they are regarded as secondary class employees of the Highway agency. Indeed, the
spoil system exist wherein the maintenance positions are used to pay political favors or buy patronage
support.
Today, maintenance and its management are considered the most intricate and ever-changing highway
and technology. Maintenance is now regarded as one of the most important part of the Highway
maintenance program.
Continuous studies have been going focused on the best management, time utilization, productivity,
methods, and management of maintenance.
Studies showed the need for improvement on the following field.
1. Education is management technique for maintenance Engineers foreman including its field personnel.
2. More detailed and careful planning and scheduling of work and establishing standards for the level of
maintenance.
3. Major improvement of maintenance tools and equipment.
4. Providing a better and efficient communications.
5. Establishing lines of authority and responsibilities.
6. For the maintenance organization to succeed, staffing with permanent trained and dedicated personnel is the
solution.
7. Effective management system requires efficient, accurate and fair budgeting and reporting procedures. But
how to implement these, is next to impossible, because it is difficult to overcome varied
administration, and behavioral problems.
1. The use of better equipment could accomplish mowing from 3 to 6 times as much area compared to the use of
poor and antiquated tools.
2. Two mowers working side by side accomplish less than when they work separately. Conversation time eats
most of the working time.
3. Not less than one and one half of two hours a day is spent unproductively for the preparatory operation and
travel of the mower to the job site.
There is no specific number of mowing the road shoulder per year but normally, from one to four
times depending upon the physical condition of the shoulder. Grass by the nature grows faster during
rainy days than on summertime.
1. To stabilize the standard level of the maintenance by setting performance standards for workers crew and
maintenance units. This requires Methods Time Management (MTM) expected output for
operations that are pre-determined.
2. To develop an accurate monitoring and fair reporting system and to compare actual work with the
expected production.
3. To develop a management system that will give the efficient work scheduling assignment.
4. To develop effective procedures, methods and machinery or organization to carry individual
maintenance operations.
Effective maintenance management could be achieved by gaining the enthusiastic support of the personnel
educating them with the new methods plus acknowledgement of their efforts through personal
recognition and by financial reward for there is a saying that we cannot live by the love alone.
The roadway to the development in maintenance is still far. While the others have already gone for
advanced, we are just about to begin.
Effective maintenance personal activities are measured under the following criteria.
1. Personnel who are devoted to the maintenance work are not those who just kill the time and collect their
salaries.
2. Personnel responsibility for keeping the roadway open to traffic moving under all conditions.
3. Personnel rescue operation in assisting stranded motorists during bad weather, heavy rain, removal of fallen
trees, flood, erosion, etc.
4. Maintenance personnel are exposed to accidents, hazards during their maintenance or rehabilitation
work.
On some instances, Highway agency is legally held responsible for injury to person or damages to property
resulted from poor highway maintenance. Unfortunately, employees and supervisors are even charged in court,
condemned, and crucified by the media people prior the hearing of the case.
9-3 Rehabilitation
Pavement rehabilitation is an activity primarily to provide god riding and skid resistance or to
improve the structural effectiveness of the pavement.
= Resurfacing, restoration and rehabilitation work, restoring to the original safe usable condition without
addition to the original capacity.=
1. Sufficiency ratings.
2. Accident data.
3. Skid tests.
4. Maintenance report.
5. Public comments and suggestions.
Resurfacing
Resurfacing is the addition pavement layer over the existing roadway or bridge deck surface to
provide additional capacity. The additional re-surface pavement should not be less than 20 mm in thickness.
Reconstruction refers to the removal of existing pavement and replacing them with a new
pavement and under course.
Overlays could be either by Portland cement or Asphalt concrete laid on an existing pavement.
Recycling means the repeated use of existing materials working on asphalt materials, Portland cement
or lime.
1. Surface Recycling consists of reworking about the top surface of asphalt pavement. It is applied for the
treatment of raveling, wheel truck rutting, flushing and corrugations. The work includes the use of
heater-planer, heater-scarifier, cold planners and cold milling. The disadvantage of their use is the are the
presence of noise, heat, and air pollution.
2. In place Surface and Base Recycling. This procedure involves pulverizing all existing pavement,
followed by re-shaping, and compacting. Before relaying, the materials are upgraded with lime, Portland
cement or chemicals. This method is used for both asphalt and Portland cement concrete pavement. One
advantage of this method is the ability to increase the load carrying capacity of the pavement without
major changes in the grade.
3. Central Plant Recycling is the removal materials from the roadway, crushing them, mixing in the plant
then laid and compacted with conventional equipment.
Both asphalt and Portland cement concrete are reprocessed to make aggregate materials for
stabilization of the base course. The recycled materials when used as base course is blended with
additives without heat such as Portland cement, Lime of Cutback or Emulsified asphalt. For surfacing, it
is heated and then blended with new asphalt cement or recycling agents and sometimes with new
aggregates.
Disadvantages:
1. Quality control not as good as from the central plant.
2. Traffic disruption.
3. Pulverizing equipment repair requirement.
4. Higher in cost.
Maintenance and Rehabilitation programs are based on different types of collected data that includes:
1. Surface roughness
2. Surface distress
3. Surface deflection
4. Surface friction or skid resistance
Definition of Terms
Surface Roughness is defined as the irregularities in the pavement surface that adversely affect
the riding quality.
Surface Distress is defined as any indication of unfavorable pavement performance or signs
of impending failure, or any unsatisfactory performance is sort of failure.
Any type of distress that may be observed includes any one of the following:
a) Fracture associated with load and non-load cracking.
b) Distortion is a permanent deformation of faulting.
c) Disintegration such as spalling, raveling and other failure of the pavement.
For each Distress Type, the corresponding damage, severity and locations are specified. All data
are gathered and indicated in the survey form as a guide
In case of Surface Deflection, measurement of the changes in pavement surface level between the loaded
and unloaded segment is the basis for rehabilitation design strategies. The design strategy is to determine
the structural adequacy or the ability of the pavement to resist traffic load without developing undesirable
distress.
Distress observations could be of static deflection, steady state of deflection or by the impact
load response as determined by the Dynaflect and Falling Weight Deflection respectively.
Surface Friction is determined by gathered data identifying a pavement section having low coefficient
of friction. There is equipment available to determine the skid number. It is measured using a locked
wheel trailer (ASTM Method E-274) or by the Yaw Mode trailer where the wheels are skewed in
accordance with the direction of travel.
Maintenance decision are based on pavement condition data gathered from project to project
basis. From these gathered data, it is determined which project calls for maintenance or rehabilitation
including the decisions required to correct pavement deficiencies. Decisions however, are made on a yearly
basis.
Considering the increasing length of the roadways, the management on the basis of field
observations alone is becoming difficult hence the objective method of evaluation was introduced:
1. Those project that need immediate maintenance or rehabilitations are listed on the priority projects.
2. The type and kind of maintenance or rehabilitation required is specified.
3. What strategy of maintenance or rehabilitation would be adopted now and in the future to minimize life
cycle costs or maximized the net benefits.
Mud Jacking
Mud Jacking is a maintenance method adopted to restore the sub-grade support under pumping
pavement and to level uneven slabs. The liquid filler is injected under the slab through drilled holes. The mud-
or slurry, filled all the voids that if continuously injected applying hydraulic pressure will force the slab
upward. Slurry for mud jacking consists of a mixture of fine grain aggregate, portland cement and water
or an addition of small amount of asphalt. A mixture of one part cement, and three to four parts of ground
limestone, could be used as slurry for mud jacking.
The mixture must pass through the pump without gumming. It must flow readily under the pavement to the
smallest voids. The mixture must harden rapidly without excessive shrinkage and not becoming hard and
brittle.
Take note that the spacing of the holes through the concrete should be palnned carefully when the slab is to
be lifted by pumping slurry into several holes. Frequent movement of the nozzle is necessary so that the
lifting will be in small increment.
Under sealing
Under sealing is an alternative for mud jacking. Heated asphalt is sometimes used. The advantage of
under sealing is the formation of the asphalt as seal against the penetration of surface water into the
subgrade.
Early road was patterned after the railroad of the same period. The principle behind the construction of
early road is to construct the cheapest roadway that would serve the traffic under all conditions of
weather without regard to its environment.
Roadside development was not included in the program. Shoulders and the right of way are narrow or no-
existing at all. Side slopes were too steep, drainage and ditches, channels and structures were designed to
protect the roadbed without regard to erosion outside the roadway limit.
These crude practices in road building have brought unslightly conditions and high maintenance cost
until such time that the design standard were gradually modified.and improved. The later development and
improvement of roadways has incorporated the following features:
1. Pleasing views and surroundings were developed sacrificing a little costs or distances to
enhance driving pleasure.
2. Long sweeping horizontal curves are acceptable than short curve connected by long tangents.
3. Choppy or broken back grade line were not only flattened but smoothened.
4. In rough areas, the depth of cuts and fill heights were lowered to reduce scare and slope erosion
to a minimum level.
5. Retaining walls are sometimes helpful and improve the attractiveness of the roadway.
6. Modem highway now provides wide roadbeds, shallow wide gutter and ditches, flat back
slope and cuts, and flat side slope on fill.
7. Top of the cut banks and toes of fills are rounded to blend with the original ground.
These features of the roadway give safer roadbed and a pleasing approach. Erosion occurs more
slowly or prevented on flatter slopes. The result is less expense for cleaning gutters and
ditches. Mowing could be done using power equipment that substantially reduces maintenance costs. Wider
right of way has become a necessity in roadside development by the following reasons:
1. It allows blending of the road into the natural landscape.
2. It provides space to plant screening in front of unsightly and objectionable areas and
other undesirable objects.
3. It isolated the highway visually from its surroundings and freeing the roadside of hazards.
Roadside is the entire right of way except the travelled way. In planning roadside development,
planners were conscious of the cost maintenance including the cost of mowing, trimming
and cleaning. Roadside development is sometimes referred to as roadside beautification made after the road
construction is completed. Roadside development without question provides a more pleasing
environment for travelers, less maintenance cost and safer highways. The roadside development is
under the carc of the Highway agency, although there re-adjacent property home-owners who
sometimes contribute to the beautification of their surroundings including the roadside itself for aesthetic
consideration that they themselves enjoyed.
1. Good location
2. Good design
3. Construction
4. Maintenance Outdoor Advertising
The control and removal of outdoor advertising had long been controversial in the beautification of
highways A court ruling on these aspects states that:
<The concept of public welfare, for the purpose of which the legislative may exercise police power, is
broad and exclusive and the value it represents is spiritual and aesthetic as well as physical and
monetary.=
For public interest, the government should extend full assistance to control the use of the areas
adjustment to the highway by regulating the erection and maintenance of outdoor advertisement signs,
display or other devices within a reasonable distance from the edge of the right of way but still visible
from the main traveled way.
1. The government recognizes the impact of man9s activities in relation to all components of the
natural environment more particularly:
a) The influence of population growth
b) The high density urbanization
c) Industrial expansion
d) Resource exploration:
e) The expanding technological advances
f) Restoration and maintenance of environmental quality to the welfare and development of man.
2. The present generation must fulfill the responsibility as trustees of the environment
for. the succeeding generations.
3, To assure all Filipino people of a safe, healthful, productive and aesthetically and culturally pleasing
surroundings.
4.To provide the widest beneficial use of the environment 8without degradation and risk to health or
other undesirable consequences.
5. To preserve some important pre historic, cultural and natural aspect of our natural heritage
and whenever possible an environment which uphold diversity and variety of individual choice.
6. To maintain a balanced distribution of population and use of resources that will give high
standard of living and wide sharing of life's amenities
7. To impart that all person has the responsibility to contribute to the preservation and
enhancement of the environment.
The main objections of community complaint on environmental effects of transportations are as follows:
1. Air and noise problem
2. Traffic induced vibration
3. Accidents
4. Annoyance caused by water pollution, dust and dirt.
Motor vehicles are mainly the contributor to both forms of pollutants estimated at 70% carbon dioxide,
50% hydrocarbon, and 30% of nitric oxide. The area condition is acceptably worst when temperature
inversions trap pollutants near the ground surface when there is little wind or no wind at all.
Concentration becomes extremely high affecting human life and even some vegetation are killed,
stunted or the foliage is burned.
Various approaches to reduce area pollutants were planned and employed including future approaches such as:
1. By Land Use Control. One example is the limitation and control of industrial-commercial
development where their construction and land use would contribute to pollution
2. To Lower the Emission. This is by lowering the emission of pollutant from existing machineries.
3. Modification of the fixed existing facilities such as substituting low sulfur coal to reduce the
release of sulfur di-oxide.
4. Lowering pollution coming from motor vehicles that falls under the following categories:
a) Reducing the output of pollutants by making them fuel efficient and controlling pollutant out- put.
b) Limiting vehicle travel by shifting travelers to other mode using electric current.
c) Cutting fuel consumption and pollutant output by improving traffic flow.
d) A set of standard to be met by new vehicles.
Noise Control
Noise is defined as unwanted sound. Noise is measured in decibels with a common unit dBA. This single
unit combine sound intensities from all frequencies above 100 per second and
strongly react in the human ear. Sound at 1dBA level could be hardly detected by human
ears, but an increase of 10 on the decibel scale means tenfold increase in intensity. In a quite
residential area at night, the ambient noise is measured from 32 to 43 dBA. The urban residential
district at daytime limit is about 41 to 53 dBA. In industrial areas the range is 48 to 66 dBA, and in
downtown commercial areas with heavy traffic is 62 to 73 dBA.
In terms of conversation or communication. these sound level means that at 65 dBA a conversation is
difficult at a distance of 1.00 meter and at 75 dBA an ear has to be plugged by a finger in order to hear a
telephone conversation.
At the time of grading operations, topsoil should be preserved for future landscaping. Likewise, trees
outside the distance limit from the travelled way, should be protected from damages caused by man and
equipment. Removing of soil or fills from along the right of way called side borrow should be
avoided, and borrow fills out of sight from the roadway is preferable.
Objects of interest like rocks, outcrops in cut slope or trees at toes of fill should be preserved for
pleasant view. Rugged slope in borrow areas and along roadside are dressed to encourage the return of
native plants and shrubs.
Ground cover is defined as low growing herbaceous or woody plants more than one meter at Both low
shrubs and vines are included.
Ground cover is an altemative to grass in controlling erosion by wind and water. It also serves as
insulation that reduces sloughing caused by freezing and thawing. Mat forming plantsare considered best
ground cover for protecting slopes and other roadside areas. There are those that root from
decumbent branches and those that spread from suckers and shoots.
1. Bushy dense foliage plants, and those producing litter with great water holding
capacity are considered good vegetation to protect the roadside against erosion.
2. The rapid growing species with inconspicuous flowers to prevent distraction and
vandalism are preferred.
3. Fire resistant plants with the ability to sprout after burning are much desirable. The cogon
grass is one example.
4. Plants that are subject to disease and insect damage, poisonous or irritating to the skin or
that may become agricultural pest should be rejected.
For median strips and islands, erosion control is but one of the functions of ground covers. Properly
selected plants prevent headlight glare without affecting distance and provide a contrasting background that
also guide traffic directions.
Parking turnout to accommodate stopping off the traveled way is an important adjunct to major rural
highways. Wayside rest areas are necessary facilities of the highway wherein motor-ist stops, relaxes and
use sanitary facilities.
Wayside rest areas should be located on those with natural features that make the area:
1. More attractive.
2Those that are accessible and safely located.
3Those with sufficient area and with existing shades.
Locations where public use will create fire hazard or others wise affect adjoining property should be
avoided.
Likewise, location closer to cities and towns are not advisable, because it will just be monopolized by the
town people. The site must have adequate driveways and parking space separated from the traveled
way with bumper rails or curbs to confine vehicles, and if possible, provided with fence.
Without questions, highway rest areas are worthwhile, but highway officials and maintenance personnel object
to their establishment because motorist users are untidy and are some-
times vandals making maintenance difficult and very expensive. #
5. Teaching and Learning Activities Essay
In an essay form,
9. References
Max B. Fajardo, Jr.-Elements of Roads and Highways Garber, Nicholas J, Traffic and Highway Engineering
, 2020
Besavilla, Venancio I., Jr. Basic Fundamentals of Transportation, Highway Engineering and Surveying ,
2016