Experimental investigation of machined hole and o…
Experimental investigation of machined hole and o…
Experimental investigation of machined hole and o…
Technology
Volume 8, Issue 5, September–October 2019, Pages 4354-4363
Original Article
Show more
Abstract
The electrochemical micromachining in non-conventional machining which suffers from process control
in micro level. In addition, the work material i.e. stainless steel provides high strength, high toughness and
adherence to tool material, hence machining of such material is arduous. However, the use of stainless
steel offers its availability in the field of aerospace fuel injection and orthodontic application, since it
possess superior qualities. In this paper, the optimization of micro drilling process is carried out in
stainless steel by considering certain metrics like feed rate, voltage and duty ratio. The geometric
characteristics to drill the tool depends on response parameters like overcut, removal rate of material and
conicity. Such parameter determines both the geometric and machining characteristics of the drill bit. The
study is evaluated to observe the effect of response and duty ratio parameters such as material removal rate
(MRR), machining time and overcut. Further, the conicity is analyzed using VMS images. Finally, the
proposed work establishes duty cycle in pulsed electrochemical micromachining domain of hard materials
and tests its performance.
Previous Next
Keywords
Micro drilling process; Material removal rate; Stainless steel; Unconventional manufacturing
process
1. Introduction
Unconventional manufacturing process is a process assembly, which eliminates additional material using
mechanical, electrical, thermal, or chemical methods. The utilization of sharp cutting tool is avoided
strictly by the conventional manufacturing or non-traditional machining process.
The reverse process of electrochemical plating is the electro-chemical machining, which is a controlled
anodic electrochemical atomic level dissolution process. The stainless steel work-piece is conductive
electrically using a shape tool, which experiences high current flow using an electrolyte (basic or acidic),
which offers low potential difference. The anodic dissolution inside electrolyte cell is used to remove the
work-piece metal (anode) in a controlled manner using a tool (cathode). The cell passes the current, when
the electrolyte is pumped between the tool through the gap, which dissolves the work-piece metal. The
electrochemical plating is used widely in machining jobs and machining hard materials.
Various electrochemical micromachining studies involving the drilling of hole in titanium grade 2 metal
[1], stainless steel SS-316L and copper alloy CA-173 are removed with closed control loop and high
frequency voltage pulse [2]. Stainless steel [3], [4], die steel [5], Inconel grade 718, titanium grade 2 [6],
titanium grade 5 [7] (Ningsong, 2012), and stainless-steel grade 304 through polydimethylsiloxane mask
(Chen et al., 2015). Other studies involves the use of 3D micro features to produce internal grooved barrel
shaped holes [8], flat electrolyte jet machining process [9], electrode side insulation and pulse on time
diameter size (Park et al., 2008), magnetic field (Shi et al., 2002) using the action of Lorentz force and
electrical field force to form curvilinear motion result in electric current density distribution, ultra-shot
pulse [3] and finally mathematical model [10].
Various parametric influential study involves the use of precision based electrochemical micromachining
(De Silva et al., 1998) to develop narrow inter-gap electrodes. Hocheng et al. [11] proposed precision based
electrochemical machining to erode hundreds of μm on metal surface. Jain et al. [12] proposed
temperature, conductivity and current density based electrochemical machining. Further, electrochemical
micro machining studies on electrolyte flow rate, electrolyte concentration and feed rate [7], wired
electrochemical machining internal channels (Ningsong, 2012) and Taguchi L9 orthogonal array [13]. The
pulsed electrochemical machining involves prediction of minimum machining allowance [14], nickel plates
[15] and nickel based super alloy [16], very short pulses (Hyun et al., 2004), impact of pulse period and
voltage [17].
From the above review, it is found that extensive work is been applied to dissolve stainless-steel grade 2
micro drilling [18]. Further this requires higher amount of work in micro range, which is difficult to
control the electrode gap and it further deviates the machining area distribution [19]. The fabrication
electrodes is another challenge in terms of conicity, overcut, MRR and machining time consumption to
drill micro hole [20], [21]. The most work fails to address the area of variation in duty cycle and drilling of
micro hole using pulse current and this paper address this problem.
This paper involves the investigation of electrochemical micro hole drilling in titanium using parametric
optimization and studying the duty cycle influence. The main aim involves microhole drilling in stainless
steel with tungsten electrode using acidified electrolyte. It involves input parametric optimization to drill
most accurate hole and studying the effect of material removal rate (MRR), conicity, circularity, roughness
of hole surface in the work piece. Further, the duty cycle effect is studied in terms of its machining and
geometric characteristics.
Chromium 18–20
Nickel 8–12
Iron Balance
The electrochemical machining is carried out in the following setup with three subsystems, namely,
electrolytic bath and circulation system, tool feed system and inter electrode gap control system, shown in
Fig. 1.
Download : Download high-res image (199KB) Download : Download full-size image
where DENTRY is the hole entry diameter (μm), DEXIT is the hole exit diameter (μm) and H is the
workpiece thickness.
where WB is the weight before work piece machining, WA is the weight after work piece machining
and t is the machining time.
∘ Overcut is the difference between mean diameter of hole at entry point and the diameter of tool.
3. Observation
Taguchi method is used for experimental design with well-defined guidelines over special set of
orthogonal arrays. This stipulates the conduction of minimal experiments to attain full information
affecting the performance of the parameter. The orthogonal arrays choose the combination level of input
variables for each experiments, where the layout is given in Table 2.
1 1 1 1 P1
2 1 2 2 P2
3 1 3 3 P3
4 2 1 2 P4
5
5 2 2 3 P5
6 2 3 1 P6
7 3 1 3 P7
8 3 2 1 P8
9 3 3 2 P9
A Voltage (V) 16 17 18
The response parameters is measured and shown in Table 4. The average diameter of the hole at entry and
exit places are averaged and shown in Table 5.
Experiment no. Voltage (V) Feed rate (mm/min) Duty ratio MRR (g/min) Overcut (mm)
Diameter at entry (mm) Diameter at exit (mm) Average diameter (mm) Conicity (mm)
Voltage Feed rate (mm/min) Duty ratio TON TOFF Machining time MRR (g/min)
The erosion rate of the material from the workpiece is influenced by the current passage and increasing
linearly with current. This phenomenon is due to the influence of higher current available at frontal gap
between workpiece and electrode. The machining time gets reduced when the voltage increases and this is
due to presence of higher voltage and earlier erosion, which leads to reduced machining time.
Rank 1 2 3
The response table of MRR is shown in Table 9. The mean ratio estimation depends on larger value of
better quality characteristics.
Table 9. Response table for mean for MRR.
Rank 1 2 3
It is seen from Table 9 that the voltage obtains the first rank and has maximum effect on MRR, little effect
on feed rate and least effect on duty ratio (Fig. 9).
Table 10 shows the regression analysis to estimate difference between the level 1, 2 and 3 effects on MRR,
overcut and conicity.
The response table of overcut is shown in Table 11a, Table 11b. The mean ratio estimation depends on
smaller value for better quality characteristic (Fig. 11).
Total 8 404.54
Table 11b. Response table for mean for overcut.
Rank 2 3 1
Table 10 shows the regression analysis to estimate difference between the level 1, 2 and 3 effects on MRR,
overcut and conicity (Table 13).
Table 12a. Statistical regression analysis for overcut vs voltage, feed rate, duty ratio.
Rank 2 3 1
Total 8 11.8073
Rank 2 3 1
The response table of conicity is shown in Table 15. The mean ratio estimation depends on smaller value
of better quality characteristic (Fig. 13).
Rank 2 1 3
Download : Download high-res image (83KB) Download : Download full-size image
Table 16 shows the regression analysis to estimate difference between the level 1, 2 and 3 effects on MRR,
overcut and conicity (Table 17).
Table 16. Statistical regression analysis for Conicity Vs Voltage, Feed Rate, Duty Ratio.
Total 8 187.00
The testing material attains maximum MRR, minimum over rate and reduced conicity, shown in Table 18.
5. Conclusion
In this paper, the micro holes are drilled in pure stainless steel using fuel injector nozzle, which attains
maximum accuracy. Further, optimization of certain electrical parameters is agreed to attain optimization
of micro-hole drilling. The stainless steel work piece attains best MRR and overcut values based on central
feed rate value, duty ratio and high voltage level. The current, duty ratio and voltage response parameters
are influenced by order of independent variables influencing the response parameters is (a) current, (b)
voltage and (c) duty ratio. Further, it is observed that conicity of the micro hole is reduced considerably
from trails 1–9. Increased stability has further leads to fall in conicity and side erosion are prevented using
product accumulation. Further, the impact of duty cycle is evaluated based on response parameters like
MRR, machining time and overcut. It is seen that as the value of duty cycle increases, the machining time
has reduced and MRR remarkably increases with dissolution rate rise. The erosion rate of material
determines the convergent behaviour of tool diameter. In this study, the non-convergence exists as the
erosion increases and overcut roughness of the surface increases further, which is influenced by duty cycle
variation. With increasing erosion, the generation of extreme hydrogen bubbles increases the Ra value. The
lowered duty cycle is found, which provides improved results based on response parameters. Finally, the
pulsed electrochemical micromachining with TOFF component flushes the by-products with better surface
quality and anodic shape control.
Conflicts of interest
The authors declare no conflicts of interest.
Recommended articles
References
[1] S.D. Dhobe, B. Doloi, B. Bhattacharyya
Surface characteristics of ECMed titanium work samples for biomedical applications
Int J Adv Manuf Technol, 55 (1–4) (2011), pp. 177-188
CrossRef View Record in Scopus Google Scholar
[3] B.H. Kim, C.W. Na, Y.S. Lee, D.K. Choi, C.N. Chu
Micro electrochemical machining of 3D micro structure using dilute sulfuric acid
CIRP Ann-Manuf Technol, 54 (1) (2005), pp. 191-194
Article Download PDF View Record in Scopus Google Scholar
[9] T. Sathish
BCC Approach for the paramet ric optimization in machining of nimonic 263 alloy using RSM
Materials Today: Proceedings, 5 (2018), pp. 14416-14422
Article Download PDF View Record in Scopus Google Scholar
[10] T. Sathish
Heat transfer analysis of nano-fluid flow in a converging nozzle with different aspect ratios
J New Materials for Electroch Syst, 20 (4) (2017), pp. 161-167
View Record in Scopus Google Scholar
[11] T. Sathish
Performance measurement on extracted bio-diesel from waste plastic
Journal of Applied Fluid Mechanics 10(SpecialIssue) (2017), pp. 41-50
View Record in Scopus Google Scholar
[21] T. Sathish
GAC-ANN Technique for Prediction of Spring Back Effect in Wipe Bending Process of Sheet Metal
Materials Today: Proceedings, 5 (6) (2018), pp. 14448-14457
Article Download PDF View Record in Scopus Google Scholar
Cited by (121)
Show abstract
Synthesis of new catalyst based on TiO<inf>2</inf> immobilised in steel slag for photocatalytic
degradation of permethrin in aqueous solutions: RSM method
2022, International Journal of Environmental Analytical Chemistry