Power System Protection Fundamentals
Power System Protection Fundamentals
By
Engr. M. Hafeez ur Rahman
Objectives
•Security: the certainty that a protection system will not operate when it is not
required
•Selectivity: ability of a relay to determine what part of the power system is under
fault
•Speed: ability of relay to sense and clear the fault as fast as possible
Continued
Protective System Characteristics
• Functionality: monitor the current and/or
voltage of the power system to detect:
Circuit Breakers
Instrument Transformers:
Current Transformers
Voltage Transformers
DC Supply
Control Cables
Instrument Transformers
Current Transformer (CT)
A device which transforms the current of the
power system from large primary values to
safe secondary values (usually 5A or 1A)
8
GE Consumer & Industrial
Multilin
A Bad Day in System Protection……
9
GE Consumer & Industrial
Multilin
What is an Electrical Fault?
• Electrical fault is an abnormal condition, caused by
failures in electrical equipment such as transformers,
motor, cable and busbar etc. Theses faults cause
interruption to electric flows, equipment damages and
even cause death of humans, birds and animals
15
GE Consumer & Industrial
Multilin
Another analytical classification of faults in the electrical
power system is symmetrical and unsymmetrical faults.
Symmetrical faults:
•A symmetrical fault is also called as balanced fault.
•It produces symmetrical fault currents that are
displaced by 120 degree each other. Since fault currents
are balanced, so system remains balanced, but results in
severe damage to the electrical system components.
•Included are:
all three phases simultaneously short circuited
all three phases short circuited and earthed
Symmetrical Faults
L−L−L−G and L−L−L
Only 2-5 percent of system faults are symmetrical faults.
Analysis of these faults is easy and is required for selecting
relays, settings, rupturing capacity of the circuit breakers and rating
of the protective switchgear.
Unsymmetrical or unbalanced faults
Unsymmetrical Faults
• These are very common and less severe than symmetrical
faults.
• These are also called unbalanced faults since their
occurrence causes unbalance in the system. Unbalance of
the system means that that impedance values are different
in each phase causing unbalance current to flow in the
phases. These currents have different magnitudes with
unequal phase displacement
• These faults include:
• All single and two phase open circuit faults
• All single and double line short circuits or short circuits to
ground
Unsymmetrical faults (continued)
110
GE Consumer & Industrial
Multilin
Causes of Electrical Faults
• Weather conditions: It includes lighting strokes, heavy rains, heavy
winds, salt deposition on overhead lines and conductors, snow and ice
accumulation on transmission lines, etc. These environmental conditions
interrupt the power supply and also damage electrical installations.
• Human errors: Electrical faults are also caused due to human errors such as
inadequate design, selecting improper rating of equipment or devices,
forgetting metallic or electrical conducting parts after servicing or
maintenance, switching the circuit while it is under servicing, etc.
Class C fires involve flammable gases, such as propane, butane and methane.
Class E is sometimes given to fires involving electrical circuits or electrical and electronic
equipment (symbol not yet approved by any international standards organization)
Fire Extinguishers Types
Water Fire Extinguishers
•Filled with ordinary tap water.
•Suitable for Class-A fires
•Red in colour
On the night of May 17, an intense fire erupted in Kohat Grid Station of Peshawar
Electricity Supply Company (PESCO), which burnt it to ashes.
One power transformer was completely destroyed and the adjacent one was severely damaged along
with associated cables and installations. Consequently, cities of Kohat and Hangu as well as the
surrounding areas were plunged into darkness for many hours. The profusely dense blaze and flames
were visible from miles away. Fire brigade reached on site and started controlling the fire; fortunately it
was mainly quenched by heavy rainfall.
As a matter of fact, fire is always an effect of some deliberate cause. If the possibilities of such a cause
are reduced through adoption of proper preventive techniques, there will be obviously no effect.
However, it appears that no fire prevention measures exist in Kohat to nip the evil in the bud. In the first
instance, cause of this huge fire could be attributed to excessive heating of the transformers because of
their abnormal overloading. The cooling system of transformers could be either non-functional or
ineffective due to many reasons including lack of maintenance or gross overlooking of the operational
staff.
Nevertheless, the real cause could be ascertained through an impartial enquiry of the accident, which
must be conducted by PESCO or PEPCO to fix the responsibility of the huge loss as a result of this fire,
which has to be ultimately sustained by tax-payers of the country for no fault of theirs.
Furthermore, being an ex-employee of PEPCO, I can safely predict that the grid station could be devoid
of proper fire fighting apparatus, which includes installation of firstly, water sprinklers around the
transformers, circuit breakers and all major electrical equipment and secondly, automatic as well as
manual fire extinguishers at appropriate points in the station yard.
These devices are initiated through an automatic fire detection and alarm system, which senses even a
minor inception of fire and becomes functional in no time. Thus the fire is controlled at an initial stage
and its ill effects are aptly reduced to bare minimum.
In fact, all of PEPCO grid stations seldom have adequate fire prevention system,
which could drastically eliminate potential fire hazards. And if it is luckily installed
anywhere then it is hardly maintained by PEPCO staff, thus making it inoperable.
PEPCO grid operation and maintenance staff does not possess essential know
how of the latest fire safety procedures and ways to tackle any fire incident.
During 2010, I visited some grid stations under Gujranwala Power Company
(GEPCO) and specifically noted gross negligence of concerned staff in proper
maintenance of grid stations as a whole. Yards of many of these grid stations were
having heaps of dried grass and wooden planks, which were quite susceptible to
fire. I saw some oil drums near the live electrical installations, which was a serious
safety hazard but remained unnoticed by all concerned. Some of these grid stations
were having manual fire extinguishers, but these were least attended and never
filled after expiry. No fire drill was ever conducted therein due to which the staff on
duty was unable to operate them in case of any impending emergency.
This sad situation seems to be prevalent everywhere in PEPCO. That’s why we are
witnessing accidents like that of Kohat. PEPCO management needs to install latest
loss prevention gadgets in all of its critical facilities as well as cultivate a culture of
safety perception and awareness in its staff.
M. HAFEEZUR RAHMAN
Jubail, KSA
Fire Extinguishers Types (continued)
Dry Powder Fire Extinguishers
• Excellent all-rounder fire extinguishers suitable for Class-A, Class-B and Class-C fires.
• Safe for use on fires involving electrical equipment. In that case must have electrical safety
pictogram
Parameter Rating
Sensitivity Poor
Selectivity Poor
Speed Depends
Simplicity Best
Cost Economical
Directional Overcurrent Relay
(Device No. 67)
Characteristics:
Determines that current is flowing in the
forward direction
Detects current above normal and trips
Will not respond to reverse faults
More selective
How do we determine direction?
Which way it goes? Because AC current
reverses direction every half cycle!
Solution:
• We need a reference called a Polarizing
Quantity
• Phase angle of current with respect to
voltage for example
Phase angle of current with respect to voltage is taken as a
reference point for Direction O/C relays
Directional Overcurrent Relays Performance
Parameter Rating
Sensitivity Depends
Selectivity Good
Speed Good
Simplicity Moderate
Cost Higher
Earth Fault Protection
(Device No. 50N, 51N)
Earth fault is the unintended fault between the live
conductor and the earth. It also occurs, because of the
insulation breakdown. When this fault occurs the short-
circuit currents flow through the system to the earth.
These fault currents damage the equipment of the power
system and also interrupts the continuity of the supply.
Prominent earth fault protections are:
• Restricted earth fault (REF)
• Sensitive earth fault
• Standby earth fault
Restricted earth fault (REF)
During an earth fault, the fault current flows depending
on the voltage level at point of fault. If a fault occurs at
a location where voltage to ground is less, the chances
of such earth fault getting detected are very less, and
thus the fault may aggravate. The REF scheme is a
solution to that. In this scheme, four CTs are connected
n each phase and in ground.
When there is an earth fault within the range of the 4
CTs, even at a low potential, the relay senses and trips.
Sensitive earth fault protection
The relay monitors continuously the line current I through CT and the bus
voltage V through PT and operates when the V/I ratio decline below the set
value.
Parameter Rating
Sensitivity Good
Selectivity Better
Speed Better
Simplicity Poor
Cost Higher
Differential Relays
ANSI Code 87
Simple concept:
• Measure current in vs. current out
• If they are not equal, then trips
• Operates on the difference in current – not
the total current
• Sensitivity is good
Types of Differential Relays
• Differential Overcurrent:
Operates on magnitude of difference
• Percent Differential:
Difference must be a percentage of the total
current
Parameter Rating
Sensitivity Best
Selectivity Best
Speed Best
Simplicity Moderate
Cost Depends
Transformer Protection
Power Transformer is the most vital part of a power
system. It is normal practice to install two units at a
substation to provide continuity of supply. However:
Thermal Protection
Overcurrent Protection
Differential Protection
(A simple scheme is shown next)
Buchholz Protection
(for conservator fitted units)
Differential Protection for Transformer
• The power transformer is star connected on one side and delta connected
on the other side.
• The CTs on the star connected side are delta-connected and those on
delta-connected side are star-connected.
• This is done to compensate for phase differences on each side of the
Power Transformer. Thus, the resultant phase that is seen by the relay is
effectively Zero
• The neutral of the current transformer star connection and power
transformer star connections are grounded.
• The restraining coil is connected between the secondary winding of the
CTs.
• Restraining coils controls the sensitive activity of the system.
• The operating coil is placed between the tapping point of the restraining
coil and the star point of the current transformer secondary windings.
Working of Differential Protection System
Normally, the operating coil carries no current as the
current are balanced on both the side of the power
transformers. When the internal fault occurs in the
power transformer windings the balanced is disturbed
and the operating coils of the differential relay carry
current corresponding to the difference of the current
among the two sides of the transformers.Thus, the relay
trip the main circuit breakers on both sides of the power
transformers.
Problem Associated with Differenctial Protection System
When the transformer is energized, the transient inrush of magnetizing current
flows in the transformer. This current is as large as 10 times full load current
.This magnetizing current flows in the primary winding of the power
transformer due to which it causes a difference in current transformer output
and it makes the differential protection of the transformer to operate falsely.
To overcome this problem the kick fuse is placed across the relay coil. These
fuses are of the time-limit type with an inverse characteristic and do not
operate in short duration of the surge. When the fault occurs the fuses blow out
and the fault current flows through the relay coils and operate the protection
system. This problem can also be overcome by using a relay with an inverse
and definite minimum type characteristic instead of an instantaneous type.
A working example:
• Notice that in both cases, the current that the Bias Coils in the relay see is 1A at
both ends. Any deviation of this 1A will causes an imbalance within the relay, which
will consequently cause protection to operate and isolate the Transformer.
BUCHHOLZ RELAY