Theories and Level of Disease Occurence Final
Theories and Level of Disease Occurence Final
Theories and Level of Disease Occurence Final
occurrence
Ashenafi Shumye (BSc.PH, MPH)
Lecturer in Public Health Department
College of Health Sciences
Mekelle University
1
1. Introduction
• Communicable diseases continue to account for
a major proportion of disease burden
2
2. Components of Infectious
Disease Process
• Infectious diseases result from the interaction
between the infectious agent, host/reservoir and
environment.
Host
Agent Environment
3
Cont…
• Agent: An agent is a factor whose presence or
absence, excess or deficit is necessary for a
particular disease or injury to occur
• An infectious micro-organism depends on:
– Pathogenicity, is the ability of a pathogen to produce
an infectious disease in an organism.
– infectivity, the ability of a pathogen to establish an infection
– infective dose,
– immunogenicity, is the ability of a particular substance, such as
an antigen or epitope, to provoke an immune response in the body
of a human or animal.
– Virulence
4
• Host: Related to human factors.
– Influences individual’s exposure, susceptibility or
response to a causative agent, and it depends on:
• Age, - gender,
• race, - habits,
• sexual activities, - immunization,
• contraception, - diet,
• nutrition, -etc.
5
Cont….
6
3. Causal Concepts of Disease
• Not all associations between exposure and
disease are causal.
7
Casual …
• In past times
– There were an assumption of one-to-one
correspondence between the observed cause and
the effect.
– One factor is necessary and sufficient
• At present
– The understanding is that the cause of any effect
must consist a constellation of components that
act in concert.
– There is necessary and sufficient causes
8
Con…
• If disease does not develop without the
factor, then the causative factor is
“necessary”.
• Necessary cause is a factor that is necessary
(or with out which) the disease does not
occur or exist
• No specific factor is sufficient to produce a
disease.
9
Cont….
• A “sufficient cause” : which means a
complete casual mechanism
– defined as a set of minimal conditions and
events that inevitably produce disease;
• For example,
Tobacco smoking is a cause of lung cancer, but by
itself it is not a sufficient cause.
10
Cont…
• If a single factor alone become sufficient to
develop the disease, then we term the
causative factor as both “Necessary” and
“sufficient”.
• Example:
– Tubercle bacilli is a necessary factor for TB
13
1. Epidemiologic triangle and
triad (balance beam).
Host Environment
Environment
Epidemiologic triangle Balance beam
14
Cont…
• From the perspectives of epidemiological
triad, the host, agent, and environment can
coexist harmoniously.
• Disease and injury occur only when there is
interaction or altered equilibrium between
them.
• Disruption of any link can also prevent
disease
15
2 Multi-causality of Diseases
• Web casual model= Spider's web
• Developed in response to the idea that an infectious
agent is a unique and sufficient cause of a disease.
16
Cont….
• In this approach, the causes of disease are
considered to be agents, exposures, or risk
factors.
17
Con….
• An agent is considered to be necessary but not
sufficient causes of a disease b/s the conditions of the
host and the environment must be optimal for a
disease to develop.
U U U
A B A E B E
Host Agent
Genetic
Agent
core
Physical
(Humans) environment
Biologic
environment Agent
21
Host factors
• Influences
– Exposure
– Susceptibility
– Response to agents
• Includes
– Genetic factor
– Physiologic factor (pregnancy, puberty, stress )
– Immunologic factor,
– Human behaviour, Hygienic….
• Host factor results from the interaction of genetic
endowment with environment. 22
Environmental factors
• It is extrinsic factor which affect the agent and
the agent for exposure
• Influence the existence
– Exposure
– Agent
– susceptibility
• Includes
– Biological event (agent, reservoir, vector)
– Social environment (socioeconomic, poletical)
– Physical environment
23
• Generally we can classify cause of a disease in
to two
1. Primary cause or etiologic agent (necessary)
2. Risk factor (aggravating, predisposing factors or
contributing factors)
24
Risk factors
• Risk factor is any factor associated with an
increased or decreased occurrence of a
disease.
• It could be
– Factor related to the agent (strain difference…)
– Factor related to the human host (immunity….)
– Factors related to the environment (over
crowding, lack of ventilation….)
25
Risk factors
• may be classified as
– 1. Factors susceptible to change
• Smoking habit, alcohol drinking habit,
• It is a factor epidemiology is interested in
– 2. Factors not amenable to change
• Age, sex, family history
26
Association vs. Causation
27
Association vs. Causation
• Association in simply an identifiable relationship
between an exposure an exposure and disease
e.g. Coronavirus is isolated more frequently from individuals
with diarrhea than those without
• Implies that exposure might cause disease
• Exposures associated with a difference in disease risk
are often called “risk factors
28
Association vs. Causation
Causation implies that there is a true mechanism
that leads from exposure to disease
– e.g., long-term heavy smoking causes myocardial
infarction
Finding an association does not make it causal
– e.g., hospital stays are associated with an increased
mortality rate, but this does not mean they cause death
29
Bradford-Hill Criteria (1968)
1. Strength of association
2. Consistency
3. Specificity
4. Temporality
5. Biological gradient (dose response)
6. Plausibility
7. Coherence
8. Experimental evidence
9. Analogy
30
Strength of association
Strong associations are more likely to be causal
than weak ones.
31
Strength of Association
1.1-1.3 Weak
1.4-1.7 Modest
1.8-3.0 Moderate
3-8 Strong
8-16 Very strong
16-40 Dramatic
40+ Overwhelming 32
Consistency of Effect
• Relationships that are demonstrated in
multiple studies are more likely to be causal,
i.e., consistent results are found
– In different populations,
– In different circumstances, and
– With different study designs.
33
Consistency
• Smoking and lung cancer
> 100 studies over last 30 years demonstrate increased
risk
• Lack of consistency does not rule out causality
blood transfusion not always a risk for HIV: virus must be
present
• Consistency may only be apparent when all
relevant details of cause are understood
34
Specificity
One cause leads to one effect, not multiple
effects.
35
Temporality
Exposure must precede disease.
36
Does the cock crowing make the sun rise?
thanks to
Tom Grein
37
cont..
• Strong temporality observed in some cases
• Does this mean causation?
38
Biological gradient (dose response)
Risk of outcome increases with increasing
exposure to the suspected risk factor
Changes in exposure are related to a trend in
relative risk
39
Biological Gradient..
Linear relationship not always causal: Downs
syndrome and birth rank
40
Plausibility and coherence
Consistency with current biological
knowledge about the disease.
41
Experimental evidence
• human experiments
• animal experiments
• does removing exposure
lead to fall in outcome?
42
Analogy
Existence of other cause-effect relationships
analogous to the one studied supports a causal
interpretation.
43
Summary of Bradford-Hill criteria
44
Causal Inference: Cautions
• No single study is sufficient for causal inference
• Causal inference is not a simple process
– Consider “weight of evidence”, using Bradford Hill’s
criteria
– Always requires judgment and interpretation, no
cookbook method
– Some consider causal inference to be in the public policy
domain, rather than the scientific domain
• No way to prove causal associations
45
Key points
46
Chapter two
47
2. Natural history of a disease
• The progression of a disease process in an
individual over time, in the absence of
intervention.
Stage of Stage of
Stage of Stage of Recovery,
Subclinical Clinical Disease
susceptibility Disability, or Death
Disease
Differ
•Duration
Outcome •Severity
Recovery •Outcome
Clinical
51
Rabies in Humans
First Death occurs
First Onset
Exposure neurological or recovery
Symptom Coma
signs begins
Acute
Incubation Neurological
Period Prodome phase Coma Recovery
52
2.2. Chain of Infection
• Infection: implies that the agent has
achieved entry and begun to multiply in the
host and leads to disease.
Causative
agent
Reservoir
Susceptible
host
Portal of
exit
Portal of
entry Mode of
transmission
54
a. Agent
• Host agent interaction (outcome) is characterized
by
– infectivity, the ability of a pathogen to establish an
infection
– Pathogenicity, is the ability of a pathogen to produce
an infectious disease in an organism.
– immunogenicity, is the ability of a particular substance, such
as an antigen or epitope, to provoke an immune response in the
body of a human or animal.
– Virulence: the proportion of clinical cases resulting in severe
clinical disease (disability, fatality)
– These depends on environmental condition, route of
infection, infective dose, host factor (age, sex, nutritional status)
55
b. reservoir
• Reservoir: The habitat of an infectious agent
where it normally lives, grows and multiplies
(can be animal, environment, People)
– Eg dog for rabies, - Cattle for anthrax
59
e. Susceptible human host
• The susceptible human host is the final link in
the infectious process.
• Host susceptibility or resistance can be seen at
the individual and at the community level.
• Host resistance at the community (population)
level is called herd immunity.
60
Susceptible host…
61
Herd immunity….
• Example - If 90 % of the children are
vaccinated for measles, the remaining 10 % of
the children who are not vaccinated might not
become infected with measles because most
of the children (90 %) are vaccinated.
• That means transmission from infected person
to other susceptible children will not be
easier.
62
Herd immunity cont…
Conditions under which herd immunity best functions
1)Single reservoir (the human host): If there is other
source of infection it can transmit the infection to
susceptible hosts.
2)Direct transmission (direct contact or direct
projection): Herd immunity is less effective for diseases
with efficient airborne transmission.
3)Total immunity: Partially immune hosts may continue
to shed the agent, and hence increase the likelihood of
bringing the infection to susceptible hosts.
Herd immunity cont…
4) No shedding of agents by immune hosts (no carrier
state).
5) Uniform distribution of immunes: Unfortunately,
susceptibles usually happen to live in clusters or
pockets because of socioeconomic, religious, or
geographic factors.
6) No overcrowding: Overcrowding also increases the
likelihood of contact between reservoirs and
susceptible hosts.
• However, these conditions for the operation of
herd immunity are seldom fulfilled.
2.3. Time course of an infectious
disease
• Pre-patent Period: The time interval between
biological onset and the time of first shedding of the
agent.
• Incubation Period: Interval between infection
( biological onset) and the first clinical
manifestations of disease (clinical onset).
• Communicable Period: The time interval during
which the agent is shed by the host.
• Latent Period: The interval between recovery and
the occurrence of relapse or recrudescence in
clinical disease.
65
Generation time
• With person-to-person spread, the interval between cases
is determined by the generation time
• It is the time between the receipt of infection by a host
and maximal communicability of that host.
66
Fig 9. Time course of a disease in relation to
its clinical expression and communicability
Clinical case
Symptomatic
Co
Clinical
nv
Threshold
ale
er
sc
r ri
en
ca
tc
Asymptomatic
y
ar
r
to
rie
a
ub
r
c
In
TIME
Time of infection Agent starts 1 manifestation of Recovery Agent stops Relaps
st
68
Mode of Transmission…..
• Is the various mechanisms by which agents are conveyed
to a susceptible host.
1. Direct transmission
1.1 Direct contact: The contact of skin, mucosa, or conjunctiva
with infectious agents directly from person or vertebrate
animal, via touching, kissing, biting, passage through the
birth canal, or during sexual intercourse.
Example: HIV, rabies, gonorrhea
1.2 Direct projection: projection of saliva droplets by coughing,
sneezing, singing, spitting or talking.
Example: common cold
1.3Transplacental: Transmission from mother to fetus.
Example: syphilis
69
Mode of Transmission cont…
2. Indirect transmission
2.1 Vehicle-borne:
• A vehicle is any non-living substance or object by
which an infectious agent can be transported and
introduced in to a host through a suitable portal
of entry.
• Transmission occurs through indirect contact
with inanimate objects (fomites): bedding, toys,
or surgical instruments; as well as through
contaminated food, water, IV fluids etc.
70
Mode of Transmission cont…
2.2 Vector-borne:
A vector is an organism (usually an arthropod)
which transports an infectious agent to a
susceptible host or to a suitable vehicle.
Biological vector:
• A period of multiplication and/or development of the
agent in the vector is required before transmission
to the host can occur (extrinsic incubation period).
• Transmission occurs while the vector is feeding on its
host.
71
Mode of Transmission cont…
• two ways of transmission by biological vector: salivarian and
stercorarian
– Salivarian - Infective saliva is directly injected in to the
host.
Example: Malaria by the anopheles mosquito
– Stercorarian- Infective fecal or regurgitated material is
deposited near the bite wound .
-The host then auto-inoculates the infective material by
scratching the itching bite. Example: flea borne or louse
borne typhus.
-Alternatively, infective material from a crushed louse can be
rubbed into the bite wound or into a skin abrasion
72
Mode of Transmission cont…
Mechanical vector:
– agent is directly infective to the host, without having to go
through a period of multiplication or development.
– agent is transported (carried) on the leg or mouth parts of
the vector,
– or passes through its gastrointestinal tract and is excreted
or regurgitated onto the host or vehicle.
– Introduction of the agent into the host is either:
– by bite (e.g rift valley fever by blood sucking flies),
– by vector-host contact (e.g- Trachoma by flies), or
– through contamination of a vehicle (e.g contamination
of food by flies or cockroaches).
73
Mode of Transmission cont…
2.3 Airborne: which may occur by dust or
droplet nuclei (dried residue of aerosols)
Example: Tuberculosis
2.4 Non vector intermediate host: hosts not
playing an active role in transporting the
agent to humans.
Example: Aquatic snails in the transmission of
schistosomiasis.
74
Cont…
• Direct transmission • Indirect transmission
Touching Airborne
Kissing
Vehicle-borne
Biting
Vector-borne
Direct projection
Non-vector
Blood transfusion
intermediate host
Parenteral injections
75
2.5. Levels of Disease Prevention
76
Cont….
There are several stages during the course of a disease
at which we can intervene in order to control the
disease.
I. Primary prevention
The objectives here are to promote health,
prevent exposure, and prevent disease.
The aim is preventing health people from becoming
sick
77
Cont…
A. Health promotion (Primordial):
• This consists of general non-specific interventions
that enhance health and the body’s ability to resist
disease – including:
78
Cont…
B. Prevention of exposure:
– Immunization
• Active (antigens)
• passive (ready made antibody, commonly
after exposure)
• Both types of immunization are after
exposure has taken place.
80
– Some times it may be difficult to differentiate
interventions in what form of prevention they
involved
81
Cont…
II. Secondary prevention
– Interventions that act after the biological onset of
disease, but before permanent damage sets in.
82
Cont…
III. Tertiary prevention
• Intervention that acts after permanent damage has
set in, and
• The objective of tertiary prevention is to
– Treatment to prevent further disability or death
– limit the impact of that damage.
• The impact can be physical, psychological, social
(social stigma or avoidance by others), and
financial.
• Strategy at this stage in general is rehabilitative.
• Rehabilitation is the retaining of the remaining
functions for maximum effectiveness.
83
2.6. Levels of Disease Occurrence
84
Levels of Disease
Epidemic
Endemic
Sporadic
85
Levels of Disease Occurrence…
Diseases occur in a community
1. by difference in level of disease at a point in time
87
2.7. Disease Classification
88
2.8. Infection and Disease Outcome
Disease
Exposure Infection Disease
outcome
90
Cont…
• The progress of an infectious agent and disease
outcome can be quantified as follows:
91
Cont…
2. From infection to disease
92
Cont….
3. From disease to disease outcome
Mild Severe
In apparent Death
disease Disease
infection
No signs
Clinical illness with symptoms
or
symptoms
or Recovery
No sine or
inapparent infection
symptom
• Severity of an illness
In apparent
Mild Moderate Severe Fatal
Likely to be seen by doctor, but not usually
recorded
Likely to be hospitalized and
recorded which tells us case
severity
95
Important Terms in Infectious
Disease Epidemiology
• Incidence: It refers to the number of new cases
in a given time period
• Prevalence: It refers to the number of cases at a
given time expressed as a percent at a given.
• Case Fatality: It refers to the proportion of
infected individuals who die of the infection.
96
• Factors Affecting Infectivity of an Infectious
Disease/Agent
– Dose and route
– Immunity of host
97
Epidemiology of Vaccination
98
• Vaccine efficacy is assessed by comparing
incidence of a particular disease among
vaccinated and unvaccinated people.
• Vaccine Efficacy (%) = (Iu-Iv)/Iu X 100%
• Where,
– Iu – Disease incidence in the unvaccinated
– Iv – Disease incidence in the vaccinated
99
Types of immunity
A. Natural
– (i) Active: Infection by an agent stimulates the host to
produce antibodies
– (ii) Passive: Antibodies produced by the mother cross the
placenta into the blood stream of the fetus i.e. maternal
antibodies
B. Artificial
– (1) Active: Host is stimulated to produce antibodies by the
injection of an attenuated pathogen (an antigen)
• i) Killed vaccine
• ii) Modified live vaccine
– (2) Passive: Host receives antibodies produced elsewhere
100
Some Basic Concepts
• What is health?
101
Clinical Versus Community
Medicine
• Clinical medicine is concerned with
– Diagnosing and treating diseases
– In individual patients,
• While
• Community medicine is concerned with
diagnosing the health problems of a community,
and with planning and managing community
health services.
102
• Public health
– a science, an art and a profession of
• preventing disease,
• prolonging life, and
• promoting health and efficiency through organized
community effort (for sanitation, control of
communicable disease, health education, etc.)
a set criterion.
• Criteria for priority setting
– Magnitude: (amount or frequency) of the problem
– Severity: (to what extent is the problem disabling, fatal)
– Feasibility: (availability of financial and material resource,
effective control method and acceptance by the community)
– Community concern: (whether it is a felt problem of the
community)
– Government concern: (policy support, political commitment)
105
Disease, Illness and Sickness
• Disease is literally the opposite of ease. It is
physiological or psychological dysfunction.
107
• Thank you!!!
108