INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SATELLITE COMMUNICATIONS AND NETWORKING
Int. J. Satell. Commun. Network. 2007; 25:551–558
Published online in Wiley InterScience (www.interscience.wiley.com). DOI: 10.1002/sat.890
Interworking between MANET and satellite systems for
emergency applications
Michele Luglio1,*,y, Cristiano Monti2, Cesare Roseti1, Antonio Saitto2
and Michael Segal3
1
Department of Electronics Engineering of University of Rome ‘Tor Vergata’, Rome 00133, Italy
2
Telespazio, Rome 00156, Italy
3
Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Beer-Sheva, Israel
SUMMARY
This paper presents the main achievements of a project, focused on the design of an integrated
system composed of a satellite segment and a MANET to provide telecommunication services in
emergency scenarios, in terms of network design, focusing in particular on the development of the
interface between the two systems and showing the results of field trials. Copyright # 2007 John Wiley &
Sons, Ltd.
Accepted 23 June 2007
KEY WORDS:
MANET; emergency; satellite; interoperability
1. INTRODUCTION
During emergency events, operators working in difficult and complex environments primarily
require both voice and data services (including pictures and moving images).
MANET (Mobile ad hoc Networks) and satellite technologies are complementary because
MANETs are characterized by very small, low-power consumption, limited capacity terminals
and work in a very limited coverage range, while satellite systems work with medium/large
dimension, medium/high-power user terminals and cover very wide areas. Moreover, MANETs
are very suitable to work also in indoor environments where signals from satellite systems
usually do not penetrate.
*Correspondence to: Michele Luglio, Department of Electronics Engineering of University of Rome ‘Tor Vergata’,
Rome 00133, Italy.
y
E-mail: luglio@uniroma2.it
Contract/grant sponsor: Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs
Contract/grant sponsor: Ministry of Industry of Israel
Copyright # 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
552
M. LUGLIO ET AL.
User requirements can be satisfied guaranteeing two features [1]:
*
*
Interconnectivity among team members and among different teams involved in the
emergency activity achieved without using additional frequency bands, both for existing
radios and for the new generation ones,
Interconnectivity between teams in the field and remote users (typically high and medium
level managers not present in the emergency area).
Due to the combined use of ‘ad hoc networks’ for local connectivity and easy deployable
satellite stations for remote connectivity, the network configuration satisfies the typical
needs of emergency communications: easy transportability and setting up, low weight
and power consumption, limited maintenance and basic network centric operation
functionality.
However, many ad hoc networks recently designed and proposed have two major drawbacks
which limit their use for emergency rescue teams: the first is the difficulty of using a data
network for voice, the second is the low efficiency of the connectivity protocols, mostly due to IP
architecture, not optimized for the radio communication channel. In addition, the link to the
remote center may be unreliable due to channel conditions or to not full compatibility between
protocols of different networks.
To improve on this, the system presented in this paper consists of a cost-effective solution to
create a module based on two basic features:
*
*
A new ‘ad hoc network’ architecture that uses a protocol optimized for voice (peer to peer
and common channel) and allowing data and image communications via self-configured
relay terminals to overcome the lack of line of sight.
A simple interface with narrowband or broadband satellite terminals.
2. REFERENCE SCENARIO
On the basis of the requirements of fire fighters of Trento (Italy), and assuming that the users are
uniformly distributed in a bi-dimensional plane, three different ranges of distances have been
considered:
*
*
*
R1 (outdoor areas without obstacles), maximum single-hop distance 500 m,
R2 (outdoor areas with only a few obstacles), maximum distance 300 m,
R3 (indoor areas with many obstacles), maximum distance 50 m:
In the identified scenario a team or several teams, each composed of a dozen of units, are
deployed in a potentially wide area. We refer to the scenarios where a certain number of teams,
belonging to the same command or independently coordinated (i.e. military forces, police, fire
fighters, rescue teams, etc.), cooperate in the same mission and have the following requirements
in terms of connectivity: between units of the same team, between units belonging to different
teams using different systems or technology or equipment, with a remote station. Such
objectives are achieved through a wireless ad hoc network with access to satellite communication
networks at a very low cost and high reliability [2] (Figure 1 shows the conceptual architecture
while Figure 2 shows the test-bed configuration).
Copyright # 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Int. J. Satell. Commun. Network.2007; 25:551–558
DOI: 10.1002/sat
INTERWORKING BETWEEN MANET AND SATELLITE SYSTEMS
553
Figure 1. Reference scenario.
Satellite Modem
Satellite Modem
Satellite IP Network
VVFF Radio
Fixed GW
IP Net.
PMR Radio
IP Net.
Professional Station
A&C Station
IP phone SAVION group
Mobile GW
SAVION GW
PC
Figure 2. Test-bed configuration.
Copyright # 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Int. J. Satell. Commun. Network.2007; 25:551–558
DOI: 10.1002/sat
554
M. LUGLIO ET AL.
3. THE SAVION DYNAMIC MESH NETWORK
Mobile unit works in the 2.4-GHz band and the modulation technique used are spread
spectrum. It uses a standard short-distance transceiver with an advanced algorithm and voice
compression system. The system is capable of receiving and transmitting data and voice up to
1.6 km using no more than 10 hops. Due to the system mesh networking capabilities, it operates
in very harsh environments and conditions where regular radio transmission fails. Parallel and
simultaneous voice and data communications are also allowed. The nodes movements result in
local updates of node table that are carried out in constant time. The mobile unit survives up to
100 users, uniformly spread over 2 km2 (outdoor), all using the same frequency, allowing
extreme bandwidth efficiency. Both data (asynchronous) and voice (synchronous) communications with a total bandwidth of 1 Mbit/s are supported. The unit can work as stand-alone with
voice and data capabilities or be connected to another device. The Generic Radio Control unit
allows remote access of the network and parameters selection.
Two typical operation modes can occur: Unit Network Discovery or Request of
Transmission. In the former case after a group of units have been activated, the network
takes at most 5 s to be ready for any type of communication. In the latter case any transmission
request will be forwarded with a Push-to-Talk mode (for voice) and data user interface (for
data) implying a communication activation request. This request will command the network to
create a communication path for the connection type requested (like Broadcast, P2P, grouping,
etc). The network will handle and serve more than one voice/data request simultaneously.
4. MANET–SATELLITE INTERCONNECTION
Three different communication segments are involved in the SAVION system:
*
*
*
A MANET.
A satellite segment that in turn can be assumed as narrowband segment or broadband.
A MANET–satellite interface.
The system can be configured depending on both the operational needs and the requested
services. To build up interconnection between the ad hoc terminal, set as gateway, and the
satellite terminal two satellite solutions have been identified: Globalstar (Telit SAT 600
terminal) and a Ku-band satellite of the Eutelsat fleet (e-bird 338 East) with the ground segment
from Hughes Network Systems (DW7000 terminal).
4.1. Interface MANET–narrowband satellite system
The TELIT SAT 600 mobile phone (Figure 3) can be directly connected to the SAVION
gateway unit through the data transmission module DT 600 included in the Telit data kit pack
[3]. Such a module allows the SAVION gateway unit to use TELIT SAT 600 as an external
modem by installing an appropriate driver.
4.2. Interface MANET–broadband satellite system
The conversion of both the analogue voice signal and digital data, coming from the
SAVION gateway unit, into IP datagrams to forward to the IP broadband satellite terminal
Copyright # 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Int. J. Satell. Commun. Network.2007; 25:551–558
DOI: 10.1002/sat
INTERWORKING BETWEEN MANET AND SATELLITE SYSTEMS
555
Figure 3. MANET–Globalstar connection.
MULTIMEDIA IP GATEWAY
SAVION GW
SATELLITE TERMINAL
18-pin connector
Figure 4. MANET–VSAT interconnection.
is performed through an IP multimedia gateway able to interface radio systems to IP networks
(Figure 4).
5. ACHIEVEMENTS
The tests have been oriented to highlight the properties of the ad hoc mesh network and to
demonstrate the interconnection to the satellite segment, both through a broadband modem and
a narrowband terminal. The last set of trials was performed at Telespazio premises.
5.1. Ad hoc mesh network tests
A set of tests has involved six SAVION terminals (Figure 5) to provide simultaneously private
calls, group calls, broadcast calls, and data transfers. The tests were performed in different
environments: indoor environment (fire fighter’s base and exhibition pavilion), tunnels, outdoor.
Table I summarizes the results for both voice and data applications.
5.2. Voice service through broadband satellite terminal
The architecture of the test bed is shown in Figure 2. Each SAVION terminal belonging
to a group has been connected (for both voice and data communication) via a satellite IP
network to the following remote systems/terminals: fire fighter’s radio (VVFF radio),
Copyright # 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Int. J. Satell. Commun. Network.2007; 25:551–558
DOI: 10.1002/sat
556
M. LUGLIO ET AL.
Figure 5. Ad hoc mesh network.
Table I. Trial achievements.
Test id
Single-hop distance (m)
Overall coverage ðm2 Þ
10
200
200
320
200
8000
}
}
Indoor (base)
Indoor (pavilion)
Tunnel
Outdoor
Figure 6. Test bed in Trento.
a generic private mobile radio (PMR radio), an IP phone, a PC. As far as the interface elements
is concerned:
*
*
The Fixed GW is a station used to interconnect the VHF radio to the IP satellite modem,
The Mobile GW is a station used to interconnect the SAVION GW to the IP satellite
modem (through an USB interface),
Copyright # 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Int. J. Satell. Commun. Network.2007; 25:551–558
DOI: 10.1002/sat
INTERWORKING BETWEEN MANET AND SATELLITE SYSTEMS
*
*
557
The Professional Station manages the communications,
The A & C Station is the control center that manages and controls all the tasks performed
in the fixed/mobile GW.
Figure 6 shows the picture of the test bed deployed in Trento.
5.3. Data transfers through Globalstar terminal
The test bed included two Telit DT600 terminals connected to two PCs, running Windows XP
operating system, through a RS232-USB adapter. Both a data channel (non-TCP/IP) and a
TCP/IP connection have been successfully set up and used for chatting and file transfers.
6. CONCLUSION
This paper presents the characteristics of the SAVION network designed for emergency
communication. In particular, it concerns the definition and the implementation of an
integrated satellite-ad hoc network architecture.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The work performed in the SAVION project was funded by the Italian Ministry of Foreign Affairs in
cooperation with the Ministry of Industry of Israel. Thanks to the volunteer Fire Brigades of Trento for
their irreplaceable support and hospitality.
REFERENCES
1. Luglio M, Monti C, Saitto A, Segal M. Interfacing satellite systems and ad hoc networks for emergency applications. Third Advanced Satellite Mobile Systems Conference, Herrsching am Ammersee, Germany, 29–31 May 2006;
396–401.
2. Luglio M, Nicolai G, Splendorini L, Vatalaro F, Zuliani L. Combined use of Italsat and Globalstar for monitoring
and disaster recovery purposes. Seventh Ka Band Utilization Conference, Santa Margherita Ligure, Italy, 26–28
September 2001; 77–84.
3. http://www.elsacom.it
AUTHORS’ BIOGRAPHIES
Michele Luglio received the Laurea degree in Electronic Engineering at University of Rome ‘Tor Vergata’.
He received the PhD degree in telecommunications in 1994. From August to December 1992 he worked, as
visiting Staff Engineering at Microwave Technology and Systems Division of Comsat Laboratories
(Clarksburg, Maryland, USA). From 1995 to 2004 he was research and teaching assistant at University of
Rome ‘Tor Vergata’. At present he is associate professor of telecommunication at the same university. He
works on designing satellite systems for multimedia services both mobile and fixed. In 2001 and 2002 he
was visiting Professor at the Computer Science department of University of California Los Angeles
(UCLA) to teach Satellite Networks class. He taught Signal Theory and collaborated in teaching Digital
Signal Processing and Elements of Telecommunications. Now he teaches Satellite Telecommunications and
Signals and Transmission.
Copyright # 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Int. J. Satell. Commun. Network.2007; 25:551–558
DOI: 10.1002/sat
558
M. LUGLIO ET AL.
Cristiano Monti received the Electronical Engineering degree, the MBA and the PhD degree in
Telecommunications and Microelectronic Engineering, in 2000, 2002, and 2007, respectively, all from the
University of Rome Tor Vergata, Rome, Italy. Since 2001 he was involved in several national TLC
research projects. His main research interests include analysis of interoperability, security and coexistence
issues on wireless and Satellites systems. Since 2006, he’s involved in research projects regarding safety and
security issues for Innovation Department of Telespazio. He’s author of many papers for international
reviews.
Cesare Roseti graduated cum laude in 2003 in Electronic Engineering at University of Rome ‘Tor Vergata’.
In 2003 and 2004 he was a visiting student at Computer Science Department of University of California,
Los Angeles (UCLA). From August to December 2005 he worked at the TEC-SWS division of the
European Space Agency (Noordwijk, The Netherlands). He received the PhD degree in ‘Space systems and
technologies’ in 2007. Collaborator in the ‘Satellite Telecommunications’ class at the University of Rome
‘Tor Vergata’ His research interests include satellites communications and protocol design, cross-layer
interactions, implementation and performance analysis in wired/wireless networks.
Antonio Saitto received the master degree in Electronic Engineering at the University of Rome ‘La
Sapienza’. He was at Selenia as Antenna System Designer from 1972 to 1980, at European Space Agency
(Noordwjik, Holland) as Senior Scientist between 1980 and 1983, Ground Segment Division Technical
Director at Alenia Spazio from 1985 and 1992, at Alenia-Marconi Communications (Pomezia) as
Technical Director between 1993 and 1995, at Marconi Services as Marketing Director of Southern Europe
from 2001 to 2003. At present he is responsible for the Innovation Strategy and Research Development &
Coordination at Telespazio. He is Member of il Quadrato della Radio, Member of IEEE, Member of
AEIT. He teached Radio technologies, Communications Theory, Statistical Theory of Communications in
different Italian universities. Currently he teaches Radio Mobile Transmissions at university of Rome ‘Tor
Vergata’.
Michael Segal finished BSc, MSc and PhD degrees in computer science from Ben-Gurion University of the
Negev in 1994, 1997, and 1999, respectively. During a period of 1999–2000 Dr Michael Segal held a
MITACS National Centre of Excellence Postdoctoral Fellow position in University of British Columbia,
Canada. Dr Segal joined the Department of Communication Systems Engineering, Ben-Gurion University,
Israel in 2000 where he currently serves as department’s Chairman. He has over 60 publications in scientific
journals and conferences. His primary research is algorithms (sequential and distributed), data structures
with applications to optimization problems, mobile wireless networks, communications and security.
Copyright # 2007 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Int. J. Satell. Commun. Network.2007; 25:551–558
DOI: 10.1002/sat